Baines and Barkley in England loss

, BBC Sport , 15 November, 31comments  |  Jump to most recent
England were below par in their Wembley friendly against Chile which Baines started and Barkley came on as a sub in the 77th minute. Jagielka was one of the many subs warming the bench.

Elsewhere, Tim Howard kept a clean sheet for the USA in Scotland.

Quotes or other material sourced from BBC Sport



Reader Comments (31)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Phil Sammon
1 Posted 16/11/2013 at 07:35:44
I put a few quid on Chile to win the World Cup last month. Ok, it's a long shot, but I think they're a great team to watch and in South America I reckon they'll surprise a few people.
Steve Pugh
2 Posted 16/11/2013 at 07:47:00
Ross looked good for the short time he was on. Baines was poor, even more-so than his recent Everton form, short corner straight to opponent.

On a plus note after that performance Jags is definitely the best English centre half playing at the moment.

Steve Pugh
3 Posted 16/11/2013 at 07:47:00
Ross looked good for the short time he was on. Baines was poor, even more-so than his recent Everton form, short corner straight to opponent.

On a plus note after that performance Jags is definitely the best English centre half playing at the moment.

Mike Oates
4 Posted 16/11/2013 at 08:44:11
Let's be honest both Baines and Barkley were poor, in fact Baines had a mare. A shadow of the player he was last year; Baines to me has lost the energy, drive, that allowed him to become one of Europe's top creators.

Barkley looked lost to me: far too advance, back to goal, constantly losing ball, fouling opponents.. he looks out of sorts.

Brian Waring
5 Posted 16/11/2013 at 09:23:07
Baines's defending last night was the reason why Cole will just get the nod for the left back berth. I think, out of the two, Cole's defensive side of the game is better.
Matt Traynor
6 Posted 16/11/2013 at 09:30:22
Brian #327, I think even die-hard Blues have grudgingly accepted Cole is the better defender than Baines. Sadly for Leighton, last night's piss poor performance (which was highlighted repeatedly by pundits on the British Biased Corporation) means he may be fighting with Shaw and Gibbs for the 2nd LB slot come March / April.

Whether that goes into his thinking about January remains to be seen - if he's not guaranteed starting every match with OFM, then it's a bit of a risk. Of course if he's not signing a new contract, BK may force the issue (and even I couldn't really blame him for that).

Sam Hoare
7 Posted 16/11/2013 at 09:32:17
Phil, that looks a decent bet. England were poor but Chile were very impressive. All players including the keeper were supremely comfortable on the ball and able to keep it for long periods with accurate passing and constant moving. If Martinez manages to get us playing like that then I will be very happy!
Drew Shortis
8 Posted 16/11/2013 at 09:35:32
I regret wasting two hours of my life watching that dross last night. Chile played an excellent pressing game as well as keeping possession well when they needed to and counter attacking with pace. I think this is the way Martinez would like to get Everton playing, it is very effective.

Jagielka is definitely the first choice partner for Cahill. Jones and Smalling are useful squad players, but not experienced enough yet. Barkley showed a good bit of endeavour and drive when he first came on but soon faded as he settled into the rest of the teams tempo.

I thought Lallana looked good, but Rodriguez is no international. Townsend must start against Germany.

Trevor Lynes
9 Posted 16/11/2013 at 09:37:56
No answer to Sanchez up front, his pace and close control gave the central defenders nightmares. We were ponderous by comparison and Chile showed how to play out of defence properly. Only Rooney played well and he was virtually on his own in really troubling Chile.
We had no idea how to play against them and they are ranked number three in South America. Sanchez looked as good as Aguero and he would do really well in the English game.

Barkley looked out of his depth and gave away loads of fouls and he was only on for 20 minutes or so. He would be yellow carded every game if he kept that up. He has to stop needless tugging and pulling when he loses the ball.

Baines was not that bad although he was at fault for their opening goal but Sanchez's speed of thought was the main reason, he should be credited rather than our defence berated. His second goal was sublime and the England central defence looked big, clumsy and rather like carthorses. Cahill could well have been red-carded if it had not been a friendly.

Chile used gamesmanship a lot and England became frustrated as they hardly had a proper shot on goal throughout the match.

Brian Hennessy
10 Posted 16/11/2013 at 09:49:46
Coleman and McCarthy were excellent last night for Ireland, what a difference in the playing style under O'Neill and Keane.

This can only be good for Everton; both players should be buzzing ahead of the derby next week...

Phil Sammon
11 Posted 16/11/2013 at 09:52:17
Sampaoli has Chile playing back like they did under Bielsa. Loads of pace and pressure when they haven't got the ball. Cool and calm when they have it, but dynamic when they need to be. Ultimately they will probably be found out defensively – but they're great to watch and should appeal to the neutral.
Jim Bennings
13 Posted 16/11/2013 at 09:48:48
I thought the whole English game/style of play, mentality call it what you like, was totally shown up by Chile. Their confidence on the ball and composure was the complete opposite of England's panic push-and-rush football from the back.

Does any England defender look composed on the ball? If they seriously think they are going to be able to play 100-miles-an-hour football in that heat over in Brazil, they are going to be in for a rude awakening.

On the subject of Baines, I agree he was poor last night, very poor on that first goal especially, but my biggest concern is the fact that, for a while now, he has been poor at what he is so good at. That is delivering set-pieces and getting forward and crossing the ball.

Am I the only one who has noticed his decline in performance since the turn of the year? I think it stems from a little further back than just this season, he has been performing below par since January / February for me. His corner kicks are atrocious, no wonder we never seem to score direct from a corner nowadays. He needs to step it up and pretty fast.

As for Ross Barkley... well, he was not really on the pitch long enough to make a fair assessment. He looked okay at times but still seems a bit of a headless chicken at others and the one thing I need to see him improve on as the season progresses is him actually get that final ball or shot away a bit quicker; he needs to be more decisive and that will make him a better all-round player.

Mikey Waterman
14 Posted 16/11/2013 at 10:47:46
Mike (#319) – I think that is exceedingly harsh on Barkley. He came on with just over 10 mins to go in a game where England were playing shite and never looked like equalising in the second half. That must have been very difficult for the lad, he should have been given 25 mins at the very least. I thought he had a couple of nice touches and was trying to make something happen in a side where nothing was happening at all.
Wayne Smyth
15 Posted 16/11/2013 at 10:53:56
Mike Oates, I think you saw a different Barkley to me.

When he got on the ball his passing was generally crisp, accurate and high tempo. He looked good with a few of his runs that he made, especially the one that took him into Chile's area; pity about his final ball though. When I saw him play, I was convinced he'd have offered more going forward than most of the others out there.

How you can slate him for the 15 or so minutes he was on the pitch is beyond me. You really saw him do nothing worthy of note??? He lost the ball once that I remember and "fouled" on a few occasions against a team that was a goal up, working hard and went down under the slightest of pressure.

One man does not make a team and most of the rest of the players were shite, and Chile were good at running down the last 10 minutes. Not something Barkley can really do anything about.

I think we all agree Baines didn't play well. But for me one who stood out was Wilshire. For all the hype and opportunity he gets, he was completely ineffectual, losing the ball with sloppy passes and gave us virtually nothing going forward. I wouldn't have him in the team but I would keep Lallana in, who really impressed, and I would've liked to have seen Barkley given Wilshires role for at least 45 minutes.

One problem with England is too many players are still picked on reputation. There are probably a few more like Townsend, Lallana and Barkley around who can't get a look-in because a player from one of the fashionable clubs gets their place by default.

Sam, I agree with you about Martinez. When I was watching chile knock it around, I was thinking they look like a far sharper, more dynamic version of what we're trying to play. I think if the fans stick with Martinez and he's given time to bring some of his own players in and work (more) with what we already have, then I'd hope to see us be as effective.

Sharabi Singh
16 Posted 16/11/2013 at 11:15:07
I didn't particularly like the way that wanker Townsend said straight after the first goal that Cashley would have got to that.
Mike Oates
17 Posted 16/11/2013 at 11:10:06
Wayne (#361). Barkley is best when he picks the ball up from deep positions and runs at the opposition, like he did at West Ham, Newcastle, and how he was used in the U21s last year and earlier this. If he is asked to play right up top, he just hasn't got the space, he's got a gorilla up his backside and tends to lose the ball and gets frustrated, like last night.

I do agree that he is one of our best options going forward, or will be in future, but clearly he isn't fitting into the England set up yet, otherwise he would have been on from the outset. To me he's being put into a difficult role, it isn't working and, whilst Rooney is around, will always play at best a cameo role.

He needs time at Everton to get his game in shape, he's been brought in too early into England and will never be given the opportunity to shine in the current phase – up to and including the World Cup. I do believe he will develop into a top top player but Hodgson isn't doing him any favours with his role and 15-min cameo appearances.

Barry Rathbone
18 Posted 16/11/2013 at 11:22:32
Drew Shortis,

Entirely agree this is what RM is aiming for – the English style is dead.

Phil Brown
19 Posted 16/11/2013 at 11:46:36
Let's hope that Roberto recorded that Chile performance and plays it to our squad as an example of how to play modern football - it was excellent albeit against weak opposition.

Our problem area is the distrubution from the back, in particular that from ther goalkeeper: as in our friendly against Real Betis the best passer of a football on the pitch was the opposition goalie - just shows how important good distribution from ther back really is.

Ross did well in his cameo appearance but as stated previously he does get frustrated in that No 10 role, eventually he'll be doing the box-to-box role with McCarthy behind him and perhaps a rejuvenated Rodwell sharing the workload in midfield?

Keep at it Roberto, if we can play anything like Chile did last night then it will be worth it and I noted that some of their players were from Wigan and Notts Forest and didn't look out of place.

Colin Glassar
20 Posted 16/11/2013 at 12:13:08
Beausajour and Jara, Phil. Just goes to show that, if you have the mentality and technical skills to play this type of football, it can succeed.
Wayne Smyth
21 Posted 16/11/2013 at 12:17:19
Mike, to be clear, I'm not arguing where Barkley is best or not, or any of the other points you make. I'm simply saying that your summary of his 15-minute cameo was completely negative.

I actually saw quite a bit of positive, sharp play and some direct running that got him into their box, albeit with no end product; something that was missing from most of the other 80 minutes of play from the other players on the pitch.

I think had he been given a lot more time on the pitch, we'd have seen at least a few good chances created by him and maybe more.

Dennis Stevens
22 Posted 16/11/2013 at 12:47:10
'Notts Forest'? I didn't realise Notts County & Nottingham Forest had merged.
Ross Edwards
23 Posted 16/11/2013 at 13:19:55
Townsend is vastly overrated. What's so special about running past one player and shooting over the bar from 30 yards?

Sums up the mediocrity of Hodgson and England.

Trevor Lynes
24 Posted 16/11/2013 at 13:25:51
If we had the ball control and confidence that the Chilean defenders had on show last night, we would definitely make Europe. Unfortunately, with very few exceptions, it seems ball control is poor amongst English players.

We tend to rely on physicality and pace but our normally reliable defence was torn to tatters and all the big men really struggled against the small, quick-footed Chileans. Sanchez was toying with both centre-backs and beat Baines to the ball by fantastic anticipation, making Baines look to slow to react.

But I would rather credit Sanchez than blame anyone for his goals. He was by far the classiest player on the field and only Rooney played well for England. We were really shown up at home by a South American side and God help us if we meet similar opposition in Brazil!!! I reckon we will do far better against European teams.

Steavey Buckley
25 Posted 16/11/2013 at 14:24:31
These international friendlies come at the wrong time of the season, so are meaningless. With players with one eye on their next league matches as clubs are gearing up to either qualify for the European knock out stages or establishing themselves in the league with a good run of wins.

Injuries are the biggest concern in these meaningless international matches. Everton have already lost Gibson because of playing for the RoI. A great loss and blow to Everton. And how many will return to Everton next week not injured?

Bill Gall
26 Posted 16/11/2013 at 14:20:22
I did not watch the game; I preferred the Portugal v Sweden that meant something.

Reading the comments about Baines, I am beginning to wonder if he has an injury or personal problems as his performances over the last few games have deteriorated rapidly. People say it may be over transfer rumors but I think whatever is going to happen is already agreed and will not affect him when he steps on the pitch.

Paul Andrews
27 Posted 16/11/2013 at 15:33:47
I think Baines is struggling for form this season. He is playing slightly different for us this season compared to previous seasons. I can't quite put my finger on the subtle change in style but it is there.
Harold Matthews
29 Posted 16/11/2013 at 15:59:26
I thought Barkley instantly looked a notch up from the Southampton lads and will definitely be on the plane to Rio. He also looked the only one on the same wavelength as Rooney.
Tom Bowers
30 Posted 16/11/2013 at 16:18:50
Baines looked below par and even looked slow against the quick Chileans. England have no chance in Brazil and even more so if the aging Lampard and Gerrard are starters. England need the quicker younger players like Wilshire and Townsend etc.

Yesterday, the new boys did not look up to snuff given they had a chance to stake a claim which they didn't in my book. Milner is far too much a plodder and Rooney is no longer a front player. Johnston is also past his sell-by date.

Hopefully Hodgson will get things sorted by next year but somehow I doubt it as I cannot see England making it out of the group stage, no matter who they are drawn with.

Tom Bowers
31 Posted 16/11/2013 at 21:09:09
Barkley did okay for the short time he was on and should be used ahead of the likes of Milner these days.

Sadly, I have to say that England may have a hard time making it out of the group in Brazil no matter who they are drawn with. Even with the so-called first team yesterday they may have struggled against the Chileans who were so much quicker. Baines even looked slow at times along with Lampard who just isn't good enough to go to Brazil in my book.

By the time it comes around I feel also that Gerrard may be found wanting despite Hodgson making him captain. The new boys didn't do much to stake a claim either. I would prefer that the Everton lads are left out of the game against Germany.

Michael Kenrick
32 Posted 17/11/2013 at 17:28:48
Who was that Evertonian on 606 around 5:30 Sunday, Nick Entwhistle????
Ray Roche
33 Posted 17/11/2013 at 17:38:21
Paul Andrews @ 404

Paul, he IS struggling for form and I also think that it has had an effect on Pienaar's performances, too. There is less of the inter-passing between them that has been so effective in recent seasons. Maybe they have been found out by other clubs but I also think it's the loss of form on Baines's part that has much to do with our left side being less affective.


Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads