Season › 2013-14 › News
No change to passing style, says Martinez
"For me, it's important that we can play eye to eye against the top four clubs," he told the Liverpool Echo. "It's not good enough to let them take the leading role and simply say we're going to be solid and hard to beat, then we'll take opportunities.
"We're not like that. I want us to be ourselves in any situation against any team and I was pleased we did it in the second half at Crystal Palace."
Quotes or other material sourced from Sky Sports
Reader Comments (104)
Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer
2 Posted 16/11/2013 at 18:54:32
3 Posted 16/11/2013 at 18:55:48
Possession is well and good but, if you don't do anything with the ball, then what's the point? Two shots on target against Palace was it? (The worst team in the league...)
I am expecting a much higher tempo in the derby simply because the adrenalin will be pumping and the players wont (hopefully) be just passing it across the back when in possession...
I don't really like the idea of our CBs having too much of the ball, they should just leave it to the midfield and concentrate on defending.
4 Posted 16/11/2013 at 19:16:58
Pong? - see a wrinkly for explanation.
5 Posted 16/11/2013 at 19:28:08
6 Posted 16/11/2013 at 19:32:34
7 Posted 16/11/2013 at 19:42:49
8 Posted 16/11/2013 at 19:53:22
And if we're not there yet against the likes of Palace, then do we stick to our guns in the possession game against the big lads (and RS)?
Yeh! Let's go all out for it. But a fast game please. Then I don't mind losing next week (and the weeks after). Well, maybe not.
9 Posted 16/11/2013 at 19:57:49
10 Posted 16/11/2013 at 19:59:58
11 Posted 16/11/2013 at 20:04:12
12 Posted 16/11/2013 at 19:58:26
18 long years without a trophy, an abysmal record whenever we come up against good sides, and a horrible recent record against our next opponents.
I could understand if we had an open top bus on standby, or the Liverpool fans weren't singing for our last manager to sign for ten more years, so what's the problem?
If it doesn't work we may finish around 8th place in the League, but at least we have tried a different approach.
It's clear the route Martinez is taking will upset a lot of fans, they actually want to see long balls & kick and chase down the channels - that is the most surprising aspect of all these discussions for me.
Do you really want to pay a manager millions for more of the same? Another 20 years of nothing.
13 Posted 16/11/2013 at 20:14:37
I don't get your negative quotes. On what basis are you judging RM and his football ethos? We are in decent shape at present. So we drew at Palace, big deal. A point away from home isn't the end of the world: Man Utd got slotted at home to West Brom; Arsenal got beat at home by Villa; Spurs have been smashed at home twice already this season; City have been beaten twice already by relegation fodder.
Where is the negativity coming from? Why have you convinced yourself we are doomed when all I see is good things happening??? Very strange...
14 Posted 16/11/2013 at 20:17:14
15 Posted 16/11/2013 at 20:23:31
16 Posted 16/11/2013 at 20:24:47
18 Posted 16/11/2013 at 20:27:59
I also recall the Board persevering with Moyes despite finishing 17th early on in his 11 year run & they were quite right to do so as the next season we finished 4th!
19 Posted 16/11/2013 at 20:12:53
He's going against the odds trying to build SERIOUS challengers to all comers without billions no-one has managed it during the Prem years and the division is the lesser for it.
Man City's transition to cup and title winners has been greeted with virtual apathy considering where they played a few years ago - even by their own.
If he manages this trick we'll be renowned again and for that reason alone deserves all the support Evertonians can muster - it ain't gonna be easy and people need to grow a pair to match his.
20 Posted 16/11/2013 at 20:17:13
Why? I can only assume a lamentable lack of patience and presumably, a belief that they actually know better?
As it has been widely reported that it took him several months to make it click at Swansea, and longer at Wigan, what do people expect at this stage?
This club will be around and has been around for a long long time. To start carping after less than a third of a new manager's first season in charge when we are so high up the table is bewildering.
21 Posted 16/11/2013 at 20:37:18
Mourinho wouldn't have kept Wigan up for longer than Martinez did.
22 Posted 16/11/2013 at 20:26:57
I don't think many (anyone?) would disagree with that.
I don't think anyone would disagree that what RM has in mind, isn't what is being delivered right this minute.
So he'll know it's not working.......YET.
And those prepared to be patient know it isn't working........YET.
Seriously, the level of patience being shown by some at the moment is imo ridiculous
Many are behaving like little kids creaming "I WANT IT NOW!"
Something has been changed, we're trying something new, a little bit different.
It's not something guaranteed to be successful but then nothing is.
It'll take time a season, probably two, a few players out, a few in and ONLY then will we be able to say 'it's better/it's worse/it's the same'.
Grown-ups will give it time and understand what's happening, impatient children won't.
23 Posted 16/11/2013 at 20:23:57
Total possession football is all good and well if you have midfielders and defenders with skill, balance and passing ability, as well as who more importantly are confident and comfortable on the ball. Unfortunately I don't get that warm fuzzy feeling when I see Jags and Distin fannying about with the ball around the 18-yard box. I don't see either of them becoming comfortable on the ball either – imo, that's not something you can learn, especially not in your 30s anyway. You either have it or you don't. So trying to get these two especially to play this new style is, in my view, a little optimistic.
We now have midfielders and forwards with pace, which is a luxury we have not had often in the past, so maybe it's wouldn't hurt to let them use it more by trying to attack a little quicker? – ie, mix it up a bit and not always allow the opposition to get everyone behind the ball before we try to do anything. Earlier this season, we seemed to be passing the ball forward a bit quicker and it (to me anyway) had better results as far as creating chances and scoring is concerned.
I am fully behind the manager and obviously he's doing a great job at the minute but that doesn't mean I have to agree with everything that is currently happening – ie, not being able to create any chances against the worst side in the league, whilst the best striker we've had in at least a decade is starved of meaningful service. Fact is we've failed to create many chances in the last two games, which is a bit of a worry. Many players are out of form, whether this is just bad luck or a function of the system change, who knows.
Hopefully Palace was a one-off; if we play against Liverpool and Arsenal like we did against Palace and the first hour against Spurs, not many Toffees will be too happy over the next few weeks....
Get the ball quicker to the likes of Mirallas, Barkley, Delboy, Lukaku etc and let them do their stuff – rather than play it around the defence for half the game.
My wish anyway for the upcoming games........
24 Posted 16/11/2013 at 20:14:32
I can only think of Wegner's arrival in '96 where a comparative emphasis on possession brought success and that was in a still very British PL.
After some of the draws this season, his card is marked if lower teams want a point or more. Until the squad is improved, or mirrors Martinez's ideal... or learns his philosophy... balancing the possession with a level of effectiveness would make sense.
I don't know if a penniless club like Everton can do a one step back to go two forward. Would a Baines replacement choose Everton if Newcastle or Southampton finished above and were also in for him?
No plan B, one up front, doesn't drop Ossie, dropping points to bottom placed teams. Ooh er!
Good for him though, he doesn't lack self belief and that's good to see.
25 Posted 16/11/2013 at 20:43:52
What , short of huge investment, do you want or expect?I wasn't reading ToffeeWeb when Moyes was appointed but surely he was not being ridiculed after a few games.
26 Posted 16/11/2013 at 20:37:20
One thing I don't get! Robbie is trying to change to his style of play overnight. I have never seen a team change their playing style so dramatically in one instance and not bend in any way or form.
Players need to adapt to such massive changes in style otherwise it will leave us open all kinds of problems.
Yes, change the style of play( great) but please, play to players strengths during the change of play.
27 Posted 16/11/2013 at 21:19:43
"Hopefully Palace was a one-off; if we play against Liverpool and Arsenal like we did against Palace and the first hour against Spurs, not many Toffees will be too happy over the next few weeks...."
We have got an abysmal record against these teams, so what do you expect a new manager to do after a couple of months? It's like slagging off Martinez for not winning a trophy in his first season.
29 Posted 16/11/2013 at 21:23:36
So far, Everton are some way behind the top clubs as they play rather subdued at times without the intensity needed. This, of course, can be down to the personnel they have, plain and simple.
The Derby match coming up may unfortunately show this up as the RedShite always come out with a little more intensity as an offensive team and have the players to put Everton on the back foot early.
A one goal can win any match – and, in the derby, a 1-0 win will do for me – but the Everton rearguard will have to come be totally in sync to keep Ratboy & Co at bay.
We all know what Ratboy did to Mirallas last year but I don't think Everton have anyone mean enough to return the favour on Ratboy this year. If Everton take the casual passing approach then they will make little headway against the RedShite. Everton need to come out totally focused and with an intensity they haven't shown this season, so far.
30 Posted 16/11/2013 at 21:33:09
31 Posted 16/11/2013 at 21:35:24
"No plan B, one up front, doesn't drop Ossie, dropping points to bottom placed teams. Ooh er!"
Moyes has gone why are you talking about him?
In all seriousness the practicalities are RM has to give Moyes players a chance and like it or not has to keep the players onside.
I don't entirely get the dropping of Osman as suggested week in week out who do we have to take his place?
The first opportunity for RM is the Jan transfer window at the moment he's matching Moyes best with inherited players while trying something entirely different.
He has turned games with his subs and is unbeaten in the league – quite brilliant.
32 Posted 16/11/2013 at 21:44:20
How many times under the other ginger tosser did we lose against so called inferior opposition? Have some posters forgotten the diabolical cup exits to lower teams? The total capitulation in Europe? The embarrassing heaviest defeats in our prem history?
I fucking haven't ........
33 Posted 16/11/2013 at 21:51:23
34 Posted 16/11/2013 at 21:53:51
Seb, I can't believe you could be so idiotic as to be so sure of Martinez taking us to relegation. It's sad really how low this site can go at times. MK, surely you would agree that what he said is rubbish.
35 Posted 16/11/2013 at 21:54:41
Some of your charges need to up their work rate and look for space whilst we are fannying about at the back to at least provide forward passing options.
Time to get out of the fecking first gear my old son - in my car I have five and I've noticed if I go up a gear my car seems to go faster and I find myself passing people by. Try it, you might start turning defenders and open up options for us in front of goal.
Go on Roberto - give it a go - it might be fun!
36 Posted 16/11/2013 at 21:57:45
As for Roberto, stick to your principles, I respect that, the style I would to like to see is the School of Science when we have the ball (more tempo, more intensity and less pedestrain in getting forward) and Dogs of War when we don't (no nonsense at the back trying to be Brazil from 1970, solid, tight, no nonsense defending, play the tippy tappy in midfield onwards, if the opposition have the ball in our half, hunt them down with a purpose and don't give them a second to breath on the ball.
Easy on paper / keyboard I know, but it's an ideal we should be aiming for.
We need a speech right up there with Braveheart or Pacino's in Any Given Sunday before the derby, i'd like to see us hunting liverpool down next week like very hungry lions chasing their next dinner. NO MERCY! It's Goodison, they're in our den, rough them up and send them away with their tails between their legs! NO MERCY!
37 Posted 16/11/2013 at 22:19:26
38 Posted 16/11/2013 at 22:04:39
I admit some of what we have seen this season has been disappointing but we have had many similar performances over the past twenty years - from the Dogs of War to Moyes' Boys - Everton have let the fans down far too often. What I'm hoping for is that RM wins his battle of wits with the players and then the fans realise what it was they have actually been missing in the previous couple of decades.
But the real issue lies with the board - they have to find the money to back the manager - if they don't then we can expect an Allardyce or Hughes to come in and then we can continue in the Premier League with good old-fashioned hard-running and hard-work with minimal technical ability.
I'm just enjoying the fact that we as a club are trying something different to what we've become used to and when it does click for an entire game it will be a joy to behold. How often last season did people say we were going to give a good-hiding to somebody due to the chances we created but it never happened.
If we can get enough points before Christmas I think the second-half to the season may prove to be a lot better than some envisage - but football being football you just never know.
39 Posted 16/11/2013 at 22:17:28
I was pleased by the appointment of Martinez, in part because he is a proven trophy winner.... and at the same time, just a little worried because of his inability to prevent Wigan from dropping out of the Premier League. I haven't studied the reasons why that happened (other than the obvious lost games and lack of points!!!) but I guess what concerns me now is even a hint of a glimmer of a trace of the kind of thinking that allowed that to happen form the man whose job it was to keep it from happening.
No doubt Ross Edwards will jump in quickly to correct me, but inflexibility — the inability or downright refusal to change when the results are not going your way — would surely be the first sign of character traits or tendencies that may be more than factors contributing to such a dreadful outcome. And in that light, I don't think Seb's concerns can be quite so simply swept under the carpet of positivsm.
For me, I'd want to hear a candid analysis of how or if Roberto reacted to the impending doom of relegation with Wigan; what he did to prevent it, why that wasn't enough, and what other things he might have done, but didn't want to — change their style of play, perhaps — that might have prevented it....
Makes me just that little bit concerned, I have to admit. Because relegation would be absolutely catastrophic for this club — of that I am 100% convinced. I'm not advocating the cowardly 40-point mantra of the previous operative, but it would be comforting to know that there is more capacity for flexibility with RM than we have seen in the 11 games this far.
41 Posted 16/11/2013 at 22:45:46
42 Posted 16/11/2013 at 22:52:32
43 Posted 16/11/2013 at 22:52:33
He's no Rinus Michels. He's just like any other manager who needs to get results... which to be fair he has. But the honeymoon period is over and results are now reflecting performances.
Three years of philosophy and decline at Wigan and MK asks the right question, what did he do to arrest the slide?
We've been in a position of safety for years now. There were 13 teams who came into this season, like last, with the potential to go down, and when you're in that group there's no real consistency of finishing position.
Where the word relegation doesn't have a place under Martinez, a slip into that group of teams would be a real cause for concern. I'd love to know how long a philosophy takes to implement because then we'd be able to judge if that's time we can afford.
44 Posted 16/11/2013 at 23:13:55
45 Posted 16/11/2013 at 23:18:35
46 Posted 16/11/2013 at 23:18:59
No wait, I think I have it: if you draw games instead of winning, through sticking to you 'plan' — even when it's patently not working (eg, Spurs, Palace...) — and then you go on to lose a few that you should perhaps have drawn.... Well, those dropped points all add up, don't they? And, when you get to the end of the season (ie, not after 11 games) and you don't have enough points, you just might end up relegated.
Isn't that what happened to Wigan? Under Roberto?
[Oh gawd... I'm on the slippery slope to 40 points now!!!]
And Ross (#501), is that the best you can come up with? Other managers do it? Oh, so that makes it okay then?!?
47 Posted 16/11/2013 at 23:01:55
I believe most Blues do welcome this style and support the change, but please, "My way or the highway" is not the way... eg, you can score goals going down the sides and crossing into the box (40% of goals are scored this way). You can also score by shooting from outside the box; also you can score from QUICK (!) counter-attacks to overload the opposition. Also, you can go over them; yes, the ball is not on the floor for two seconds but the end product could be a goal.
48 Posted 16/11/2013 at 23:33:22
Just being Everton rather than Wigan is worth that extra 13% IMO.
As long as he keeps a decent work ethic, and he is sensible in the transfer market, I don't believe he can go wrong if top 8 is the benchmark.
49 Posted 16/11/2013 at 23:57:59
50 Posted 17/11/2013 at 00:00:05
51 Posted 16/11/2013 at 23:52:32
52 Posted 17/11/2013 at 00:08:36
Look, the end product in any game is to score goals and win the game by good game management and also adapting to the opposition game plan if needed.
53 Posted 16/11/2013 at 23:58:27
I think Martinez is on his way towards failing right now. I think our last couple of games are a good indicator of how Baines, our most important attacking point, is failing. It could just be bad form, but I believe the speculation has taken a huge toll on Baines and I think RM was wrong to let it go on like this.
To me, it is clear to see that the players no longer know who to turn to when creating chances. I think the worst thing about RM is his over-positive speaking; for me, he is like a soundtrack on repeat.
I for one would like him to be straight once in a while, I'm getting tired of him talking the talk too much. For once I would like to see him deliver without too much talk. I have not lost faith in him, but I can see that he has some faults he needs to work on.
Another thing, I agree with Michael that his unwillingness to adapt at this point is not constructive. If the players fail to implement his style then he has to have a Plan B, but so far I have not seen an alternative in his playing style.
I think RM has many things to learn to be a top top manager, Moyes seemed willing to learn most of the time, but I am not sure if RM is willing to learn along the way.
I think BK picked him because he stands by his chairman no matter what. Not because he is a top manager, because he is not. He has relegated Wigan which is a big failure, but he won the FA Cup going down.
All-in-all, I do not feel overly confident in RM, but he needs time, just as Brendan Rodgers did, to do right by us.
Personally I think Brendan Rodgers is a better coach then Martinez, and he buys better players than RM. There is still time for our manager to bring in a top player or two and, for the sake of this season, I hope he does.
54 Posted 17/11/2013 at 00:47:47
Wasn't that one of the criticisms levelled at OFM.
55 Posted 16/11/2013 at 23:12:31
Our own play in the final third leaves a lot to be desired but Martinez will be working on it and when he eventually gets it right, we won't need a big guy like Lukaku. It will be all about movement, football intelligence and quickness of thought. It might take a year or two but I'll enjoy seeing it gradually taking shape.
56 Posted 17/11/2013 at 00:45:34
Hi Michael #507. What do you 'have' exactly? If you get more draws than wins by sticking to a philosophy, do you have a worse plan than if you get more draws than losses? Do I make sense here? Where have we gone on to 'lose a few'? I see only one loss, against the richest team in the world....and have they lost too, and more than the once this season? How's their philosophy working under a new manager? How do you think their dropped points will 'add up'? Will, come the end of the season (and not after 11 games), may they not have enough points and be relegated/ isn't that what happened in their history?
Or are you just talking garbage?
Please print.
[I'm on the upward journey, not the slippery slope, but each to their own]
57 Posted 17/11/2013 at 01:00:31
I do agree with many of the posters that whilst the possession game is all very nice, there needs to be more incisive passes forwards. We have players with pace and skill in that area and if they play sensible possession can still be maintained by bringing the ball backwards. This will also help stretch the opponents more, pegging them back and going some way towards preventing their ability to press high up the pitch.
It is early days, and Martinez has without question done a good job so far. The next few matches will be interesting as Liverpool, Utd and Arsenal will all have more possession than palace and be , you would assume, more attacking. This will open up spaces in other areas of the pitch and provided the defence can keep steady allow the passing game to be used to better effect. Newcastle in the first half is the model.
To be honest, he is right to stick to his principles. You train all week a certain way and put faith in your approach. Sometimes it wont work as well as others. That said, it would have been nice to see a change in pace against Palace, or something a bit different up front, not a whole sale change in tactics but a shift of play. I remember an Arsenal game in the snow where we never really looked like scoring as their defence was solid. Moyes brought on Big Vic and he shook them up no end, Johnson managed to bang one in, draw became victory. If Lukaku is being shepherded, someone else needs to either draw players away from him or exploit the spaces that will be created.
58 Posted 17/11/2013 at 01:16:07
Brendan Rodgers is given far more money to buy players.........and some of that money has not been used so wisely..........so far only Sturridge has proved to be a good buy.
And I know Brendan Rodger has not used transfer so wisely, he is still in the market looking for players....when he has already bought quite a few already.
59 Posted 17/11/2013 at 01:21:35
You say 'Martinez on his way to failing right now'. Really? After 11 games?
I ignored the rest of your post after reading that. Are you a manager on one of those fancy computer games? I bet you are top of the League having recreated at least 4 different player formations and playing styles.
60 Posted 17/11/2013 at 01:13:49
No wonder we never win anything with such negativity emanating from the stands; the disappointment when we missed the chance of 2nd place by drawing against one of the fancied title contenders was ridiculous. This may have impacted on our players the next week, maybe a factor in Distin's outburst.
Reality check is needed here, if you can find any footage of Everton in the 1970s, take a long hard look at what we endured home and away for years while the reds were winning everything in sight with flowing attractive football.
I am willing to put up with a few bad results if, in the long term it means our club competing against the top sides for trophies, and playing positive football to boot. Roma wasn't built in a day but if we want a quick fix, I believe Steve Cotterel's looking for work.
61 Posted 17/11/2013 at 01:20:09
Perhaps Brendan buys better players because he has a much bigger budget to work with. Ever thought of that? TBH, I don't know how you can judge Martinez after 1 transfer window anyway. I won't bother commenting on the rest of your ridiculous post, I will be here all day.
ABSOLUTE DRIVEL!
62 Posted 17/11/2013 at 01:28:44
But then there is the rub.
We have Moyes type players, trying to play Martinez type football.
My worry is that we are only doing well because of the Moyes type players and once Martinez buys the players he thinks he needs. (Next transfer window or possibly next summer) then we will start to struggle.
One other point I would like to make is that nobody has realised that we have struggled to play well in the last two games with Barkley out of the team? But when he has come we have gone back to dominating? And similarly it has resulted in a drop in form of Lukaku...
It is plain to see that Barkley is the link between the midfield and Lukaku.
63 Posted 17/11/2013 at 01:26:52
More interesting is as Jimmy says, Rodgers has been given time, and so far it looks to be paying dividends for them. A settled team with players who know the system.
64 Posted 17/11/2013 at 01:46:45
The truth is we played poorly at Palace, we couldn't counter their tactics (Note to Jim: that means Palace were involved in the game!), we couldn't change the way we were playing, the substitutions made no real difference, and we dropped two points to the team who were, yes, bottom of the Premier League.
Avoiding defeat is not exactly the object of the game. "Avoiding defeat" means losing TWO points. "Defeat" means losing ONE additional point.... This mentality of being undefeated and drawing away from home is old school thinking that dates back to the days of two points for a win. These days, dropping points against inferior opposition is a serious business and not something the apologists should be so quick to brush aside as they "move on to the next game" — especially when those twats at Fifa have given an extra week to ponder our misfortunes.
The irony, though is that you do want to see changes — changes that Roberto seems worryingly incapable of implementing, or dead set on NOT implementing, no matter how obvious it might be that "something" needs to change. That's what I find a little worrying, to be honest.
65 Posted 17/11/2013 at 02:02:00
66 Posted 17/11/2013 at 01:58:11
"dropping points to bottom placed teams. Ooh er!"
"I'm sorry, but I think the longer he is given, the deeper the grave he'll be allowed to dig for the club."
"Two shots on target against Palace was it? (The worst team in the league...)"
Michael, Plucked from this very thread alone. Grave digging 5 points off top?
In the grander scheme of things a draw is not the end of the world. Granted on paper it was a game we SHOULD win, but footballs not like that. On paper Chelsea should beat us, same goes for utd, Spurs and Arsenal. But as we are all aware football throws up anomalies. Its not that I don't have criticisms of what is going on. I was against appointing Bobby, more in favour of Rangnik. I for one was disappointed that Moyes left, but still felt frustrations with some of his methods.
If you have ready any of the rest of my post you would see that I didnt agree with the tactics used and advocate changes in the style, not whole sale but maybe with 73% possession he could have dispensed with one of defensive mids, shifted Kev forward and had Del boy on the right
67 Posted 17/11/2013 at 01:46:45
Money; the old perennial... if Moyes had money; well, he has now and, according to some, hasn't used it well; I think his time will run out before the money.
Martinez had to reduce the wage bill at Wigan, but he was given time, if you're Wigan (no offence but) winning the FA Cup and getting relegated isn't the end of the world.
So hopefully Martinez will be given 'some' time and 'some' money; how much of both will be the key.
I say we assess both him, the amount of money he is/was given and what he does/did with it. The next four windows should be enough to see how it is going.
That's time, money and gradual (my version of gradual) covered; inflexibilty... this has always been my worry (it was with the Scottish manager as well) from day one.
I wasn't too bothered about the relegation, I mean (again, no offence, but it's Wigan ffs) I was impressed with the first part (the practical) of his job interview in the Cup game; and he obviously impressed Boys Pen Billy with the theory in the verbal section.
I knew he liked to 'try' to play football, but sometimes Row Z IS the best option, just not all the time.
Again, my position is: If all we get is 'x' more years of a different type of inflexibility, with pretty much the same end product, where do we go from there?
Roberto, enough of the all-or-nothing, throwing the Moyes baby out with the KITAP1 bath water.
Jags and Distin ARE NOT Beckenbauer clones, all that is is square pegs in round holes — the names are different but it's playing Neville in midfield all over again
Oi, you, Bobby, Inflexible Moyes-ism? No!
69 Posted 17/11/2013 at 08:04:24
Yes Martinez will get us relegated with his tippy tappy shite, after all we're in last place in the league and conceded a hatful of goals, much worse than the last feller managed after 11 years of stability to work with. Shall I tell you what the last guys plan B often was? Bring on an extra defender and hold on with grim fear to what we have....no matter who we were playing or what the scoreline.
God forbid if our new manager wants us to go toe to toe with the rich clubs and play without fear and not go out there with an inferiority complex, but play our game. Just like Chile did to England with their "inferior" lower league players playing "tippy tappy shite".
Much of the criticism of RM seems centred on the laboured build up of the team's attacking play and a noted lack of chances created in one game, despite high possession. For me, this has two possibilities as a cause:
1) Martinez told the team to go out, not create many chances and have a really slow build up that required the oppositions 11 men to be in defensive position before working it into the box.
2) Martinez does actually want the players to play with a faster build up, but after 11 games of the season, the players are still trying to adapt.
Personally, I'm going with the latter explanation. As evidenced by the superb football he showed us in the FA Cup with Wigan at Goodison, and in patches this season, such as against Newcastle.
The second criticism often poked his way is that which Derek Thomas alludes to. We were told that we'd concede so many goals from playing around the back. I'll admit to being a bit sceptical and a bit worried myself, but actually how many have we actually conceded from jags and distin losing possession playing it around the back so far? None?
I'm not saying RM deserves no criticism, but people need to get a grip in terms of their expectation and also actually identify the cause before putting the boot in. At the moment, 11 games in, we're ahead of spurs who just spent £100M, we're 5 points off top spot and a couple off 2nd place, playing a new brand of football with half a team of new players, a new backroom staff and having all the upheaval of the transfer window with players heads turned etc.
At times the football has been great, at times its not. This is a transition season. The club don't need our support when they're trouncing teams 5-0 and top of the league. They need our support when things aren't quite going as good as they could be. Give the new manager some time, keep faith in what he's trying to achieve, because in the long run its the only way a club of our means is ever going to compete for european places and win anything.
70 Posted 17/11/2013 at 09:13:35
71 Posted 17/11/2013 at 09:29:52
72 Posted 17/11/2013 at 09:42:24
73 Posted 17/11/2013 at 09:10:21
But seriously, most people are not suggesting should win every game at canter, but some more attacking intent would put as at ease. I think Martinez is right to stick with a passing approach, working the ball not the players, but sometimes a turn of pace, a dribble or a darting run into space can open up options or cut through a defence. Presently our 20 million striker is coming deep to receive the ball, not getting service up top where he belongs. Our swashbuckling attacking full backs are playing contained disciplined roles. Super Kev is anything but super, hugging the line tighter than a baby does its blanket. We are playing 2 defensive mids against teams that offer very little attack threat like palace and Hull (Obviously Spurs offered significant threat). Still, it could be worse......Ask Pellagrini or AVB, what possible excuse could they have?
I am responding to every thread with such frequency and enthusiasm at the moment as I am laid up post foot op and off my bean on Tramadol day and night
74 Posted 17/11/2013 at 09:38:18
As far as Manu are concerned, I suspect they will offer a different challenge but although it's now fashionable to slag Moyes off at every opportunity, he's no mug and has the balance of better players at his disposal.
But even if Roberto wanted to change style for these games it would serve only to confuse his players who already seem confused enough as it is !
Two points from these fixtures is the best we can expect,I fear.
75 Posted 17/11/2013 at 09:50:02
Of course I was a worshipper of OFM but I'd love it, just love it if we stuffed his present team 3-0. No motivation is necessary for the derby – we are better than them, always – and well, Arsenal are just boring old Arsenal.
Nine points are there for the taking!
76 Posted 17/11/2013 at 08:51:28
As for your 523 post - well if you care to look at the league table then you'll see that Palace ARE the worst team in the league, they're bottom ffs! They've lost 9 of their opening 11 league games (read that again)! The fact that the top league in England may or may not be the hardest in the world (a very subjective view I might add, given the same teams win every year...) is not really relevant.
Palace had lost 7 (yes SEVEN) games in a row before they played us and will be relegated this year. They are simply shite and I cannot think of a single one of their players that would get onto our bench, let alone our first team. Simply, this was a game we should have won, its two silly points dropped. However, what you fail to pick up on is that the result is not what most people are worrying about, its the fact that we could not create any chances against the worst team in the league - despite having the ball for 3/4 of the game. The aim of the game is to score goals afterall and if you don't create, you don't score, whether you have the ball for 10% or 100% of the time. You can't score with the ball in your own half (don't need to bring up beckham/wimbledon).
Let us also not forget that although the result was 0-0, we should have actually lost the game. They has a couple of gilt edged chances (having only 27% possession) and it was only a great save and poor finishing from their players that saved us. Had they won, I imagine the reaction of some on here would not be quite so relaxed...
Anyway, hopefully things improve on the creativity front over the coming weeks. We do have a fantastic striker in our team afterall...
Anthony 528 - that fact has not been lost on most people. Before the Palace kick off, a lot (myself included) were very surprised to see the same 3 attacking midfielders who started against spurs, also start against palace. Hopefully young Ross will now be brought back into the team, where he belongs - if only to have someone who is willing to try new things in the final third of the pitch. He certainly can' be worse than the likes of osman, Mirallas and Pienaar at the miniute...
77 Posted 17/11/2013 at 10:04:39
I am well aware of their form, and just like all teams that are struggling they played on the whole deep and protected their goal in numbers. Even the top teams in their pomp struggle to beat teams that pack in defence ahead of the ball. The fact that hey had 3 gilt edge chances and missed them is why they are bottom of the league. Should, could and maybes are pretty much pointless words it football. Everton SHOULD have had a penalty against Cardiff. Soldano SHOULD have been sent off, as SHOULD Barry recently. They didnt score. But you are right, had they won we proably would be more peeved, then again, had they scored we might have scored. Would they have created 3 clear cut chances if the first one had gone in? Would they sit back and protect that lead or go gungho in excitement trying to bag more? No idea, it did happen.
If you read my posts in general they are not in praise of the performances of late. I have many issues with the current model mainly centred around the lack of incisive attacking play and needless passing around at the back.
This up coming month should give us a good measure of where the team is at. 6 points from the next 4 games a good return.
78 Posted 17/11/2013 at 09:29:16
Our placing and points total could have been far worse than it actually is when looking at certain games: Villa away – we could have been three down after 20 mins; Palace missed three gilt-edged chances to score; West Ham, where two free-kicks from Baines masked the fact that, for an hour, we were dire; and how we got a point against Spurs is anybody's guess cos, for an hour, we were so poor.
On another note, at Norwich, a cross-cum-shot set up their equaliser; Cardiff were denied a nailed-on penalty; and at City we had a false scoreline thanks to a shite referee. So, as the saying goes, it evens itself out over a season.
As I read on earlier threads saying that we need a few transfer windows to get in the players that Bobby needs to complete his revolution, I'm not too convinced with his first one as regards to buying Kone and McCarthy for a combined total of £20 million: one who (apart from scoring 13 goals last season) has a shite scoring record overall, is always injured, and is the best part of 30... plus the other one who seems unable to pass the ball forward and get in the opponent's half. Was he not also Alcaraz's manager last season when he played a grand total of 12 games?
On a more positive note, the loan signings, namely Lukaku and Barry, have been a revelation but we need to start providing a better service to the latter. I thought, when Bobby came in, we had got a young, bright and inventive manager, and that would have been reflected in our transfer activities — and that wouldn't have resulted in going back to Wigan for three players and an ex-loanee. I would have thought that, with his connections, we would have got in better value for money than we have... but I will keep supporting him and the team through thick and thin as I have done for the previous 46 years — and hopefully including a Derby win to come next Saturday,
79 Posted 17/11/2013 at 09:33:53
Regarding rm's inflexibility, well that seems to be as much a part of the package as it was with our last manager, so for better or worse we're stuck with it for now.
Personally I'd like to see us being a bit more attacking from midfield, particularly if we're not pushing the full backs forward. I'd also like to see Barkley back in the starting line up. I honestly thought rm would stick with him and I'm disappointed he hasn't. I'm a fan of Osman, but I think Barkley brings more energy to the attack.
I'm not a massive fan of Barry and McCarthy playing together so far, although it could be sensible against the Better sides, I'd like to see us being more adventurous against sides not playing particularly well.
Now whether rm's longer term recruitment policy is success, well that's the million dollar question. I'm not pleased with the age of Kone and the money it cost. McCarthy seems a better bet however, and I just hope we see more young energetic recruits though slightly cheaper if possible:)
80 Posted 17/11/2013 at 10:31:03
Seems to me, given Moyes insults of Everton FC, he gets off light.
Or have you forgotten his insulting piss-taking double bid for Baines and Fellaini?
Or..
"I also know that if I'd been Everton manager and Sir Alex had come asking for Leighton Baines and Marouane Fellaini, I'd have found it very difficult to keep them because I always felt the right thing to do was what was right for the players,"
The man has shown himself to be a disgusting hypocrite who insulted Everton FC and showed us that his only loyalty is to David Moyes Ltd.
HE might not be a mug, but given his two-faced carry on and insults in the summer, I'd suggest any Evertonians still singing his praises, are.
81 Posted 17/11/2013 at 10:58:56
Palace were allowed to defend 'well' because we allowed them to get every man behind the ball whenever we had possession. You could see them growing in confidence as the game went on because they figured out we would just pass it around at the back for ages before trying anything. Add to that the fact that our 3 starting AMs are piss poor at the moment, it completely took the pressure off them and allowed them to play better.
Anyway, am sure things will improve when Ross is back in the team. He, unlike our current other AMs, seems to always want the ball and you know he does have the ability to do something, even though he's not the finished article yet. I much prefer him in the middle to Osman because he has things that Ozzie doesn't (size, pace, shooting). Its all ifs and buts but I can't help feeling that we would have beaten Palace had Barkley been in the starting XI - they really are a very poor side and before us had zero confidence.
On the other hand we were lucky to beat Chelsea so a touch of swings and roundabouts you might say....
Am not going to dwell on the palace game anymore - time to move on. Bigger picture is that we're 6th after 11 games and in touching distance of Europe..
82 Posted 17/11/2013 at 11:02:16
Like Michael #498 puts it, the inflexibility is a concern.
The manager's job (regardless of who it is just to detach from the petty pro- and anti- whoever that sometimes happens) is:
(a) to put out an Everton team to win the match or
(b) change tactics / players during the match to get the best possible result.
Does anyone disagree?
Granted, a passing style is preferred generally to an "industrial" Pulis-style "hoof-twat-shoot" or the default bore-fest that (for me) often characterised the ginger one's reign.
But if we're 1-0 down with 15 mins to go, I don't want EFC players poncing about with tippy-tappy possession crap. I want them to lash it from the half-way line towards the goal if necessary. And if that fails, launch it into the box with elbows sharpened and a "take no prisoners" approach.
I want blood, sweat and points, not compliments for the manner of defeat from no-mark MoTD pundits.
To be honest, I don't give a flying one for how he does it but having a "jelly mould" passing style smacks of pomposity to me - i.e. I'm above "hoof-twat-shoot". Well, sometimes it's necessary and as a paying punter it's what I want to see if we need the points.
This raises the question of what matters most to RM - Everton winning or his "footballing philosophy / media friendly" reputation?
83 Posted 17/11/2013 at 11:25:55
I am also in agreement with Mike. Sometimes it take the kitchen sink to make the break through. Utd at their best battered teams in the last 15 minutes with high tempo attacking play. A
As I say, the next few games will go a long way towards revealing if he has enough in his locker to move this team forwards. The is enough quality already in the squad to at least maintain position.
84 Posted 17/11/2013 at 12:05:21
Hate to say it but across the park Liverpool seem to benifiting from a change of style and a more possession based style.
85 Posted 17/11/2013 at 12:23:35
I have been fortunate to watch Barcelona play a couple of games live and they are a great side, but their warm up routine is something to watch. They have a 5 a side warm up as we do the big difference is their passing is so quick and obviously they must practice this tempo everyday. You would assume that passing at that speed would lead to misplaced passes but that very rarely happened.
So I hope that RM will increase the speed at which we move the ball around the park, and make us a little less pedestrian than we are now.
87 Posted 17/11/2013 at 13:39:25
88 Posted 17/11/2013 at 13:28:36
Did you expect him to say at halftime at Palace, "sorry lads, forget all the passing stuff we've been working on for 3 months; its not worked for us for 45 minutes here. Just lump it up to lukaku and run around like headless chickens trying to feed off knock downs".
The guy has a belief in how to play the game which is centred on Everton retaining the football, and our players passing the ball to each other along the ground.
Anyone think we should let the opposition have the football? Anyone think we should revert to percentage football? Shall we employ Tony Pulis instead? I'm sure we'd get some of the blood & guts that people crave and we'd all have neck ache.
If we're making judgements based on 90 minutes of football, then how about we remove Baines off set piece duty based on his performance in the palace game. Get rid of Jags too, because so far as I recall he was shit, and Mirallas. Come to think of it Lukaku did fuck all too.
Thing is we can all moan, but what do you seriously expect the guy to do? Do you think he wants to play slow sideways football? Do you think he doesn't want the players to be sharper in the final third? Do you think he wants the players to play without passion and create so few chances? Should he ask the team to revert to a long ball game in the last 20 minutes if it isn't working?
In what way to his detractors think he should be flexible?!??
89 Posted 17/11/2013 at 13:38:57
Would you seriously prefer Lukaku to RVP or Mirallas to say, Rooney? And whilst RM outplayed him last season in the Cup, I haven't witnessed much of the tactical genius about him since he moved over here.
For us to win at Old Trafford is to me no more likely now Moyes is their manager than it ever was when he was ours !
90 Posted 17/11/2013 at 13:37:35
Is it acceptable to lose against the RS and others this season if it allows us to develop a system that will dominate them for years to come?
When people suggest playing the way we used to play against the RS, do they mean the way that was so heavily criticised on TW because we lost more often than not?
91 Posted 17/11/2013 at 15:47:54
92 Posted 17/11/2013 at 15:55:09
You write:
"Mike, how can a manager seriously be called "inflexible" based on a handful of mediocre performances?"
To which I reply:
The headline of the article is, "No change to passing style, says Martinez."
Which part of that suggests "flexibility"?
Surely "no change" is a strong clue.
93 Posted 17/11/2013 at 15:56:21
Let's just give the guy a chance.
94 Posted 17/11/2013 at 15:33:08
I dont ever see any of the successful teams hoofing their way to success, but I dont see any of them resorting to this of cowardly anti-football either? Both should be outlawed.
I despair at people clinging to the first-half performance against Newcastle as something to hang onto. NOTHING is going to change... How do I know? Because the manager keeps telling us.
Despite inheriting a squad (everyone of whom has ALWAYS finished above him) which is capable of challenging for CL. Martinez is hellbent on ignoring the strengths of some cracking players.
Give him time ... What for? We already know how he wants to set up; he will always want his defenders and goalie trying to bore the opposition to death. He will always want two holding midfield players. Thats SEVEN players who wont be hurting the opposition for most of our games.
The latter stages of the Palace game reminded me of the infamous Germany v Austria World Cup game when neither team showed any intention of winning.
Martinez has the answer: he can become a Goodison legend by removing the shackles from his two holding midfield players, giving his full backs the freedom to do what they do best, and by putting a stop to this cowardly no-risk purposeless nonsense.... but will he?
Its not a few critical posts on ToffeeWeb that will cut short Robertos honeymoon period — he will do that himself by insulting the matchgoer with claims that what has been served up in our last two games is anything but utter shite.
Give him time??? The ball is in his court...
95 Posted 17/11/2013 at 16:31:59
97 Posted 17/11/2013 at 17:11:20
98 Posted 17/11/2013 at 16:41:00
A brave manager who took a long-term view to develop and nurture a group of players, getting them to play the right way. This is a country where anything but genuine success is frowned on. This long-term strategy has resulted in German clubs dripping with talent and a young, inexperienced national team getting close to winning tournaments while playing great football.
Klinsmann talked at length about how he had to battle against short-term thinking, people who wanted to take short cuts for quick success and winning over players, fans and media with an unfamiliar playing style.
He was brave enough to do it with a set-up that demands success. Our current manager is starting this after 18 years of no success.
I'd have a lot less respect for a manager who loses his nerve after 11 games, one defeat and sixth in the table.
If we're still playing aimless, ponderous shite in two years time, I'll be on here slagging him off.
Talk of relegation to me smacks of people who were so sure of their opinions in the summer that they're ignoring the reality in front of them.
Most teams as hard to beat as we are don't get relegated. We're playing badly and we're sixth. What will happen when they get more confident and speed things up? Unlike a lot of people, I have faith in our highly paid players having the ability to pass a ball to each other and get quicker doing it.
100 Posted 18/11/2013 at 00:50:06
101 Posted 18/11/2013 at 00:53:51
102 Posted 18/11/2013 at 02:36:13
However, when people talk about a Plan B this is merely a tactical switch. It still needs to fit in with the overall strategy. Martinez had some tactical switches, eg, putting Mirallas down the centre, bringing on Delboy. This does not mean a shift to hoofball.
So Martinez both (a) sticks to his principles and (b) has a Plan B that is still consistent with his principles. This is not being inflexible.
103 Posted 18/11/2013 at 05:37:52
It's our only chance of glory even if it is still remote. And like some other posters, I really can't believe the impatience and negativity towards our young progressive manager.
I know what you mean MK, regarding that bit of worry, but Moyes had me terrified about not getting to the magic 40, he won nothing, and was utter, utter shite in derbies, which actually means more to me than it maybe should.
104 Posted 18/11/2013 at 06:32:59
"Moyes was utter shite"
Yeah, a disaster......funny, I must have different memories of how good a position we were in 12 years ago?
Yes he has been an utter prick since leaving, yes he also produced some very low quality (but often effective football), and yes he is a dour bastard, but to completely ignore what he did achieve is ridiculous. Bar finishing 17th once he restored stability to a train wreck of a football club.
Bobby is doing a decent job with the squad the in the main Moyes assembled.
He has gone. Another part of this great clubs history. As a person he has shown himself to be less than we thought, but to ignore what he managed to do during his time at Everton is just plain ignorance.
105 Posted 18/11/2013 at 08:13:42
Given the headline was probably penned by Michael Kenrick, not RM, I'd say it says absolutely nothing about Martinez's (in)flexibility.
What we do know from Martinez's actual quotes is that he wants us to go toe to toe with the big clubs and play them on our terms, not go there with a yellow streak and inferiority complex talking about knives and gunfights.
For me that kind of approach is refreshing. The reason we lose so often to the RS is the players(and some of the fans I fear) think we are inferior. They play them while already being mentally beaten. Hopefully Martinez will attempt to reverse this kind of thinking.
I'd also suggest reading what David Ellis writes in #767; he's spot on with his opinion that strategically Martinez will probably be inflexible, but tactically able to switch things around. For me I'm totally comfortable with this.
If its still not working in a couple of YEARS, then I'll be on here calling for his head. In the meantime i'm more than willing to support my team, manager and players through a transition period. Its hardly fucking painful, 5 points off the top, is it?!?
106 Posted 18/11/2013 at 08:37:08
ELEVEN!
So let me get this straight, HE'S inflexible but you're dead flexible?
And make NO mistake, had RM stated 'Passing isn't working, we need a rethink', those same people would be screaming 'he doesn't know what he's fucking doing, dithering Roberto' etc waffle.
I repeat, those whining about his methods after 11 games (particularly given we're 5 points from top spot) are showing a level of impatience seen only in 6-year-olds (with ADHD).
107 Posted 18/11/2013 at 10:02:51
Everything just happens too slowly in my opinion and there doesn't seem any urgency to score at the moment. I think Mirallas being totally off his game is having a big effect on the team at the moment and would toy with the idea of playing him just behind the striker to see if this livens him up.
It also worries me that our legs only seem to last about an hour when a good number of the team are running on empty (Lukaku, Mirallas, Barkley & Osman). We are also getting very deep in our play thus isolating Lukaku who has had nothing to feed off in the last two games as teams start to work us out.
109 Posted 18/11/2013 at 14:43:07
All educated/ highly qualified coaches will focus on winning the game. Managers will have the opposition watched on a number of occasions for area's/players they can exploit and use in the game.
All managers will have a preferred style of play they believe is right. But, within that style of play if and when needed, they will change, like for like. Bring on totally diff type of player in the same position, eg (Naismith on instead of Kev) that alone will change how we play in that area of the field. Change of formations happen on regular basis- and definitely change or mix up the style of play to get a result from the game.
I just feel we don't get enough flexibility in our game play to change the game around when needed.
Mike, I believe in the style of play Robbie wants. I just wish he was more flexible in his style of play so the opposition can't/ won't read the game plan so easily.
110 Posted 18/11/2013 at 16:35:33
Amen
111 Posted 18/11/2013 at 19:00:12
You make a fair point – but the headline is written as a quote..."says Martinez". I made my own point based on that and stand by it. (I'm not going to go digging for references and video footage to validate a headline.)
Success whether we're talking football or survival of the species is strongly associated with change / adaptation. (Everton in the 80s could mix it up. SAF broke his MUFC team up on several occasions).
The headline – at least to me - suggested inflexibility, ie, 'no change to passing style'. That was my concern. It was a concern not just based on 11 games (because we've done well) but on an apparent quote from a manager whose possible inflexibility may have got him relegated 6 months ago, albeit with inferior players.
We'll have to agree to disagree on this one.
Flexible or not, I hope RM does well with us and wins things – starting on Saturday. I hope he surpasses the achievements of Howard Kendall. But, like everyone else on TW at some point in time (well, those with at least half a brain), that doesn't mean I always agree with the approach, strategy, team selection, substitutions etc regardless of who the manager is.
Thanks. Over and out.
112 Posted 19/11/2013 at 13:49:43
However, it's got one proviso. It's what you do with it once you've got it. You need to be quick, accurate and intelligent with it. And we haven't been lately. Who have we penetrated dangerously and threateningly? It's all been laborious and breaking down. On Saturday, we need some tempo.
Add Your Comments
In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.
Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.
1 Posted 16/11/2013 at 18:38:15
He's to to be prepared to change things if it isn't going your way. This inflexible attitude won't get us anywhere.