Dowd gets derby nod again

, 19 November, 47comments  |  Jump to most recent
Phil Dowd has been charged with the responsibility of officiating the first Merseyside derby of the season at Goodison Park this weekend.

The 40 year-old referee oversaw the reverse fixture at Anfield in March and has been chosen again in a game that has seen a catalog of awful refereeing in the Premier League era, from the likes of Graham Poll, Mark Clattenburg and Martin Atkinson.  



Reader Comments (47)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Bobby Mallon
1 Posted 19/11/2013 at 18:36:44
I just hope we get the rub of the green as we did when ratboy was judged offside.
Ken Farrington
2 Posted 19/11/2013 at 18:38:37
Not forgetting Michael Oliver of course for his baffling decision in disallowing Distin's perfect goal thus denying our soon to be departing manager of his first win at Anfield.

Incidentally, I was talking to a fellow blue in Vienna prior to the friendly in July who stated that he had met Clattenburg at Chester Races and he openly admitted that he felt he was too young and inexperienced to get the derby match where it appeared he took advice from a certain Steven Gerrard.

I think the same could have applied to Michael Oliver last season though he did a good job of Man U v Arsenal a few weeks ago.

As for Dowd, I quite like him but you know what they say about referees? They don't care who wins! and I hope that's the case with him.

Ken Farrington
3 Posted 19/11/2013 at 18:53:26
It was definitely Michael Oliver who refereed the derby at Anfield in March, not Phil Dowd.
Nick Armitage
4 Posted 19/11/2013 at 18:54:27
Referees are like coppers, some of them are alright but most of them aren't.

As for the derby, we won't turn up, they will.

The only times we win derbies are when I am out of the country. This weekend I am in Scotland, does that count?

Richard Farrington
5 Posted 19/11/2013 at 18:57:06
Yes Nick - do us all a favor and hop on a ferry to Ireland or Scandanavia. Bit negative there as well. Come on Everton.
Tony McNulty
6 Posted 19/11/2013 at 19:07:22
Webb makes errors - they all do - but he seems to me to be the best.

So long as we never get Battenburg. That game still annoys me. The assault on Lescott, sendings off ...

Ken Farrington
7 Posted 19/11/2013 at 19:19:02
Interesting that Clattenburg has never reffed us at Goodison since that debacle and nor has Martin Atkinson since he wrongly dismissed Jack Rodwell in November 2011.

Bearing in mind that Chris Foy and Mike Dean cannot referee us due to club allegiances there's not that many officials left.

I am available by the way!

Patrick Murphy
8 Posted 19/11/2013 at 19:24:13
I'm a bit surprised at Dowd's appointment to be honest as I thought that it would be the Liverpool Captain who would officiate the game on Saturday, he usually does it doesn't he?

Dowd has reffed three derbies at Anfield and this will be his first at Goodison, at least he won't have far to travel for his champers and prawn sarnies after the game courtesy of LFC's hospitality. Odds on all Eleven Everton players staying on the pitch for the full 90 will have shortened with this appointment.

Paul Mackie
9 Posted 19/11/2013 at 20:20:52
I'm happy with Phil Dowd. As refs go he's usually alright.
James Lauwervine
11 Posted 19/11/2013 at 20:46:48
Well said Richard 018, what a bag of shite post Nick. I'll probably regret this but I consider Dowd one of the better ones. Wasn't it him who did that immensely amusing measure 10 yards and then turn and book Bellend Ballack a few seasons back?
Mike Jones
12 Posted 19/11/2013 at 21:10:03
When are we going to get Mark Clattenburg at home again? Would've thought this was an ideal match to reintroduce him to Goodison Park.
Carl Sanderson
13 Posted 19/11/2013 at 21:02:35
Just thinking about the Clattenburg derby makes me white with anger. We've been robbed blind during many derby games (Thomas, Robinson, Midgeley, Poll, Atkinson) but that one still rings my fucking bell. Gerrard the dying swan, Kuyt's bit of kung-fu on Neville, Carragher's bit of Greco-Roman wrestling on Lescott... How twat got away with that performance is beyond me.
Mike Jones
14 Posted 19/11/2013 at 21:24:00
Nick (17); i'll leave it to you to argue the issue with James (32) (and vice versa with you James), I assume the issue James has with you Nick is your view of referees rather than coppers, as I've not met a decent copper yet (or did you mean coppers James?). However, I am from Liverpool so that might be why
Kevin Tully
15 Posted 19/11/2013 at 21:21:01
Watching one those 'funniest football' programmes a while back, and it showed the Don Hutchison 'goal' where Westerveld kicked it at him and it went in.

There was Poll being interviewed about it and laughing, saying he bottled it and should have gave the goal.

He was at home, and I shit you not that there was a signed, framed Stevie me shirt above his head on the wall. Still fuming about that one.

Peter Warren
16 Posted 19/11/2013 at 21:29:40
Always thought Dowd was one of the better refs
Ian Burns
17 Posted 19/11/2013 at 22:12:13
0-0 with a last minute pen to the home side please Dowdy.

Just watched England - a wasted 2 hours. I pray Sturridge (utter crap) and Jags (far better for England that EFC so far this season) both give repeat performances on Saturday - that will help!

Brian Waring
18 Posted 19/11/2013 at 22:15:21
Happy with Dowd, he doesn't take any shit.
Tom Bowers
19 Posted 19/11/2013 at 22:10:34
Although we have not had the best of luck with the chosen referees in many derby games, I believe in the end it depends mostly on the discipline and attitude of the Blues that will decide the outcome.

Ratboy has been instrumental in the last two Goodison derbies: firstly, the Rodwell incident... and then the Mirallas incident last season – which cost Everton dearly in some of the subsequent games.

I would hope that, after Ratboy's shenanigans since then, the referees are keeping a closer watch on his antics; we could have done a lot worse than Phil Dowd, who is better than most.

Pat Finegan
20 Posted 19/11/2013 at 22:14:30
Phil Dowd refereed the Anfield derby in 2012. He was the only thing about tht match that was the least bit acceptable. I'm always hesitant to say I'm happy with a referee's appointment but I'm not dissatisfied with this one.
Brian Waring
21 Posted 19/11/2013 at 22:17:19
Saw some of the England game myself Ian, Jags spraying the ball around from the back like Beckenbauer, shame he can't do it for us.
Jamie Crowley
22 Posted 19/11/2013 at 22:15:38
I'm actually happy with Dowd. I think he's one of the better refs.

I also respect the man on some level with his weight loss. He took his profession and necessary fitness seriously, and he did something about it.

He controls a game well and generally commands his decisions well.

I hope I don't eat my words, but I think he's a good ref to have for the derby.

Karl Masters
23 Posted 19/11/2013 at 22:16:22
Last season both home teams got dodgy decisions disallowing what would have been winning goals for the away teams ( Suarez and Distin ) . It seems rare that a tag doesn't drop a clanger somewhere along the line.

Lets just blow the fuckers away!!

Ray Roche
24 Posted 19/11/2013 at 22:34:42
Karl, I wish people would put things regarding Ratboys "goal" into perspective. The little shit should have been red carded for either of his fouls (on Mirallas or Distin), and should not have been on the pitch to score in the first place. Mind you, we would have been denied the sheer pleasure of seeing that DJ twatting, crease headed bastard Gerrad sprinting 80 yards and sliding on his knees towards the retards in the away section before the reality of the situation dawned on him...
Andrew Presly
25 Posted 19/11/2013 at 23:00:31
http://www.zimbio.com/Steven+Gerrard+Phil+Dowd/pictures/pro

The refs catching up earlier this week.

Mike Hughes
26 Posted 19/11/2013 at 23:03:07
Following Andrew#058 DISGUSTING pictures...

I've never been one to throw insults around lightly.
(In fact, in all modesty, I'm probably one of the finest and nicest ToffeeWebers one could hope to meet.)

However, I have to say......

...... never has a player epitomised the words "twat" and "gobshite" quite as well as Gerrard. Low-life, cockroach scum (no offence to cockroaches).

He could run a Gobshite Masterclass.

Even worse than the Tooth Fairy, Whining John Barnes and Robbie Coke Fowler.

One reason I don't give a toss about the World Cup is because - if we won it (cough, splutter) we'd see Gerrard's gobshite face on posters, ads etc for the next 40 years.

Not for me, thanks.

Jamie Sweet
27 Posted 19/11/2013 at 23:31:40
I think some people need to brush up on how the Footballing Gods operate.

They do read ToffeeWeb by the way, and they really like to punish us if we say the wrong thing.

After a post basically filled with us discussing how many we'll put past Palace... of course they were going to give us a 0-0. They are snide bastards like that.

So now we have a thread where more than one person has said "Happy with Phil Dowd... he's one of the better refs..." etc. before the derby against the dark-side.

How do you think the Footballing Gods are going to react to that? Hey?

Are you people completely mad?

Peter Laing
28 Posted 19/11/2013 at 23:39:10
After tonight's performance against Germany's second string and the lesson in football the other night from Chile I think we can safely say Mike Hughes that Bobby Moore has more chance of lifting the World Cup, and Nobby Stiles doing a jig than Gerrard of getting anywhere near the trophy next summer.

The English game is a total shambles, nothing will change anytime soon with Hodgson and Dyke in charge and the continuing obsession with the money being hoovered up in the premier league and the dereliction of grass roots football and coaching in this country. The old saying goes that you reap what you sow and that is why the likes of Germany are twenty years ahead technically.

Nick Entwistle
29 Posted 20/11/2013 at 01:08:48
England - Germany on the big screen... but, by 50 minutes, everyone in the pub was watching the small screen with Sweden - Portugal. Absolute epic.
Bobby Thomas
30 Posted 20/11/2013 at 05:30:20
Football is like anything else in life, it just gets distorted by the hype, scrutiny & the pantomime that is the Prem.

Its natural, its life, human nature, that some refs get star struck by the big players. They want to progress in life, work their way up thd system, become an elite ref. The whole thing is a ladder & like in any walk of life they will want to climb the greasy poll.Cant remember the ref but I was watching Arsenal once on the box. Arsenal had a free kick & I saw the ref say to Henry " Do you wanna take it quick, Thierry?"

Why is Mike Riley the refs main man now? A man who had a questionable impartiality when it came to United. Moyes, not known for usually playing these kind of games, mentioned it before the semi in 2009.

Why has Howard Webb awarded TWENTY ODD PERCENT of his career pens to United? United have worked their way into positions of influence domestically & internationally.

They get star struck and want to work their way up through the system. Ive seen that picture of Dowd with Gerrard. He was probably buzzing.

It takes a strong person not to get swayed by the bullshit trappings of anything in politics, football, look at the Co-Op fella. Some will and some wont. The players must try it on all the time. Dowd seems
more grounded than most.

But its human nature gents. It will always be the same

Craig Fletcher
31 Posted 20/11/2013 at 08:02:54
On another topic, good to see Kev scoring for Belgium in their friendly and even Jelavic had some game time for Croatia.
Mike Green
32 Posted 20/11/2013 at 08:17:19
I could eat my words but all things being equal Dowd is one of the refs who seems to judge the game as he see's it and not be turned by big names or biased towards the Sky 4. If you'd asked me up front who I'd choose to ref it I probably would've said Dowd, so no complaints....yet. :)
Jamie Rowland
33 Posted 20/11/2013 at 09:24:29
Referees will always be influenced by the likes of Gerrard due to his availability and ability to get near to them. If he can sit next to them in a gym it is surely like taking a business associate for a game of golf.

A conflict of interest that is allowed to go unpunished. Do you think they genuinely didn't discuss the derby? Just like Mark Halsey genuinely didn't let charitable donations affect his opinion of Alex Ferguson?

On the other hand, now that the picture is out there for all to see, Mr Dowd could show bias the other way to prove a point and we could end up with the rub of the green?

Tony J Williams
34 Posted 20/11/2013 at 10:28:51
I hope you are all right about Dowd.....I seem to recall a similar situation when we thought we were getting the best ref in the world to watch over our qualifier game.

We all know how that went.

James Lauwervine
35 Posted 20/11/2013 at 11:34:31
Mike 040, it's both. Refs are bastards, Coppers are bent, and vice versa. Absolute bollocks!
Although having seen the pics in the link posted by Andrew 58 I think Gerrard would have to stab someone to even get a yellow.
Sam Higgins
36 Posted 20/11/2013 at 12:45:09
'Cant remember the ref but I was watching Arsenal once on the box. Arsenal had a free kick & I saw the ref say to Henry " Do you wanna take it quick, Thierry?"'

Christ it makes me sick when refs get this pally with the players - it makes a mockery of their supposed role on the field of play. I bet that same ref above wished he'd been in Thierry Henry's bed saying the same thing to him.

Carl Sanderson
37 Posted 20/11/2013 at 13:03:05
Bobby 078,

"Why is Mike Riley the refs main man now? A man who had a questionable impartiality when it came to United."

You're not kidding; one season he refereed 19 games and awarded seven penalties. All of them to Manchester United.

Ste Traverse
38 Posted 20/11/2013 at 13:20:25
I don't mind Dowd as a ref. (probably come to regret saying that come 2.45pm on Saturday)

He certainly isn't afraid of so-called 'big names' having sent off Stevie G and Rooney in the past.

Mike Gaynes
39 Posted 20/11/2013 at 17:28:48
Very pleased to have Dowd on this game. He's the best in England in my opinion, which makes him one of the best in the world. Handles the game with a smile and never looks rattled.

James (095), yes, believe me, refs are bastards. I was one for 15 years. Worked up to the US pro minor leagues. Most of the guys I worked with were pompous, self-inflated asses. Come to think of it, so was I.

Norman Merrill
41 Posted 20/11/2013 at 18:20:06
Carl 109, you've hit the nail on the head, the man in charge was a like having the Luntic in charge of the asylum.
He was a poor referee, & now he is in charge?
Steven Telford
42 Posted 20/11/2013 at 18:28:47
How long before the Panini Albums have "Ref Stickers"
Daniel Starkey
44 Posted 21/11/2013 at 13:39:15
Happy it's Dowd, he won't be taken in by all their ducking and diving. 2-1 to us with Deulofeu coming on to score the winner with a superb solo effort.
Mark Griffiths
45 Posted 21/11/2013 at 16:13:02
Couldn't give a rats arse who refs as long as we win! Just been looking at the head to heads and our last victory was Oct 2010, but I cannot remember the game at all? Cahill and Arteta scored? Anyone fill me in regarding the match to jog my memory?
Daniel Starkey
46 Posted 21/11/2013 at 16:17:31
Mark G,17 October 2010, Sunday early kick off Sky game, the American owners first game, cracking long range goal from Arteta and Cahill scored from close range.
Mark Griffiths
48 Posted 21/11/2013 at 17:58:33
Thanks Daniel. Starting to come back to me now I think about it. I think Cahill's shot was top right hand corner?
Colin Glassar
49 Posted 21/11/2013 at 18:39:57
Phil Dowd is a clown who likes to suck up to the so-called star players. I fully expect gerrard to make the big calls in this one.
Roger Domal
50 Posted 23/11/2013 at 01:47:51
If I remember correctly, Mr. Dowd had that great game where Duncan got the header past Timmy to get us to Europe. He correctly called the foul on CR7 and then later sent off the Sky pundit. I have loved Phil Dowd since that night.
John Keating
51 Posted 23/11/2013 at 03:23:55
I suppose one of the pluses in Carraghers retirement is that Dowd will only have Gerrard to help him run the match.

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads

© ToffeeWeb