Brilliant Martinez confounds expectations

, 21 November, 38comments  |  Jump to most recent
He's already taken Everton to the next level
The Mirror's Daniel Storey provides an effusive analysis in of the impact Roberto Martinez has had since his arrival at Everton. Despite apprehension in some quarters when Martinez was appointed, Storey says that the sceptics have been proven wrong; Martinez has entirely altered preconceptions of his tenure.
Statistics could demonstrate that Everton under Roberto Martinez are startlingly similar to Everton under David Moyes last season. After 11 league games they have identical records: Won 5, Drawn 5, Lost 1. In both campaigns they lost 2-1 away from home in the third round of the Capital One Cup. Their shooting accuracy, shot conversion rate and save percentage rate are all within 1-2% of last season's figures, as are the number of shots on target and and shots faced per game.

However, there is an increased air of optimism surrounding Goodison currently. Despite sitting sixth (they were actually fourth at this stage last season) the Toffees are just five points behind leaders Arsenal. People are looking up, and the future looks bright.

There was a fair deal of concern when Roberto Martinez took over in June. It wasn't necessarily that the club was still on the up under the departed David Moyes, but they had found a plateau, a ceiling on expectations higher than at any point since the late 1980s. The attainment of eight consecutive top-eight finishes prior to his defection to Manchester United was the best at Goodison since the glory years under Howard Kendall, and Moyes had been pitted with relatively sparse resources against comparatively augmented opposition.

Martinez split the Goodison faithful. He had won the FA Cup with Wigan Athletic and taken the club into Europe, a startling achievement, but had also taken the Latics down, thus failing where Steve Bruce and Paul Jewell had succeeded – evidently not a comparison to be viewed in favourable terms.

The reason for apprehension was palpable. The Spaniard would attempt to operate his own brand of attractive, measured football, almost the antithesis of Moyes's direct 'blood and thunder' style of pressing and combative midfield strategy. Due to the lack of financial resources, the Spaniard would be forced to implement his philosophy with Moyes's players, leaving square pegs in round holes. With full-backs licenced to roam forward, Everton would be left exposed at the back – no Premier League side conceded more than Wigan last season. Midtable was widely viewed as Everton's natural home in the short-term, an inevitable regression considering the instigation of a new era at the club.

The sceptics have been proven wrong. Not simply due to Everton's current position (they are one of only two teams to have lost just one PL game), because at this early stage that could still be considered false, but through the ease of transition during his five months in charge. Fears have not just been allayed at Goodison, they have been firmly extinguished.

Martinez has entirely altered our preconceptions of his tenure. Everton have been tighter at the back than under Moyes (it is four years since they conceded at a rate of less than one per game) and have actually scored fewer goals (1.27 per game) than during the last seven years, when Everton finished 11th.

Everton's formation has also been noticeably modified. David Moyes normally went with a rather simple 4-4-2 last season (with two of Victor Anichebe, Nikica Jelavic and Steven Naismith up front), shifting to 4-4-1-1 for the tougher assignments, with Marouane Fellaini in the hole behind a lone forward. Under Martinez, however, Everton have lined up 4-2-3-1 in all 11 games, Romelu Lukaku possibly the Premier League's ideal exponent of the target man role, expertly bringing Barkley, Kevin Mirallas and Leon Osman into play before making the late run into the box.

This shift has been facilitated by the club's transfer business during the summer. Despite gainfully holding out for a big fee for the midfielder, Fellaini was never a Martinez-type option in midfield, providing brawn where the Spaniard wanted brains, beauty or both. Fellaini, Phil Neville and Johnny Heitinga accounted for two positions (66 starts between them) last season, and in replacing the trio with James McCarthy and the on-loan Gareth Barry, Martinez has effectively transformed enforcing midfielders into passing pivots – blockers have become creators.

Such changes in personnel and formation alter a team's approach. Everton's average possession has increased from 52% to 58%, and they are making 80 more passes per game on average, a 20% increase on a year ago as the new manager looks to impose his belief in a measured build-up as a key to the club's attacking success.

One of the most interesting amendments has been to the role of Leighton Baines. Under Moyes, Baines was given free licence to maraud down the left flank, particularly on the quick counter-attack, but under Martinez this necessity has been curbed. Baines is making 35% less crosses, and whereas last season he was creating over three chances a match, for this campaign that figure stands at just 1.27. He is yet to register an assist.

Instead, Baines has made almost 30% more tackles, and should perhaps be thanking his new manager for the adjustment in his duties – Roy Hodgson is unlikely to pick a first-choice left-back based solely on his attacking threat, and this is the opportunity to convince in a more defensive capacity.

There is no doubt that Martinez has had his fair share of fortune thus far. Eight Everton players have started nine or more of the club's 11 PL games, and the entire back five have played every minute of the league season so far, an extraordinary occurrence in late November. Quite how the club are able to fare without Barry or McCarthy, Sylvain Distin or Phil Jagielka remains to be seen, and Everton's squad is still rather thin on the ground.

For the last word on Martinez's initial achievements however, we must again look to offer that balance between figures and feelings. In transforming Everton in his own image, the statistics look impressive for the new manager, but it is crucial to mention the reception of goodwill offered at Goodison to their new manager.

Everton is a club with morals running through its core, a club with community and community spirit interwoven into its very fibre. The behaviour of former manager Moyes in attempting to purchase Fellaini and Baines, the public pursuit so soon after leaving the club, amounted to treachery. Even considering his evident success despite relative financial stringency, this was a former manager effectively burning his bridges. In doing so, he allowed Martinez to build his own.

“I'll get you in the Champions League,” were Roberto Martinez's first words to Bill Kenwright upon being appointed. In just five months, such lofty ambitions look less and less absurd. The Spaniard is quickly laying the foundations for a new era at Goodison Park.

Quotes or other material sourced from The Mirror



Reader Comments (38)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Brian Harrison
1 Posted 21/11/2013 at 14:41:12
Well what a strange article, he says that although Baines is making 35% less crosses that's a good thing because he has become a better defender. Bit like saying to a boxer who is regularly knocking people out look I am going to teach you to box more, even though it is making you less effective. He also says that RM has proved everyone of the doubters wrong by our league position so far, but then says but this all may change.
Mark Tanton
2 Posted 21/11/2013 at 15:03:27
God I hope we win on Saturday - I think it will really do Bobby the world of good. I just hope he's bold and drops a few underperformers, as his perseverence with Osman is very disheartening; and Mirallas wants a rocket up his arse too.

I may not watch tomorrow, I think it might be too painful - but it's very rare we beat them and I'll be gutted if I miss turning them pigs over.

Al Reddish
4 Posted 21/11/2013 at 15:39:37
It's OK Baines providing less crosses if the person in front of him is providing more to compensate. As the player in question is usually Pienaar, then more crosses into the box are unlikely. This is probably one reason we might not miss Baines as much as we think. We have been guilty of over relying on him, and he has been found out. The same could also be aimed at Coleman who has Mirallas in front of him, also not producing enough crosses, which is a shame when you think we have a beast of a player itching to get on the end of something, waiting in the 6 yard box.
Drew Shortis
6 Posted 21/11/2013 at 16:04:35
Definitely an article from an outsider. I'm happy with the direction we are taking under Martinez, but less satisfied with our current form, despite our decent league position. The Palace match was terrible. Perhaps the Derby has come at a good time for us after the international break. If this game doesn't put some fire in their bellies then we have problems. I'm willing to except a lower league finish if it means that we get the team playing the kind of football Martinez aspires to. Just grinding out draws is not what anyone wants to see and I'm sure it's not what Roberto has in mind either.

Paul Andrews
7 Posted 21/11/2013 at 16:21:53
The makings of a top class manager, our Roberto.
Raymond Fox
8 Posted 21/11/2013 at 16:20:17
I think the article is affair assessment of
RMs impact at the club.
Considering all the backroom changes, new players, and a new style etc, we have done well to be so high in the league.

As far as the match on Saturdays concerned,
looking at the past 18 seasons apart from cup games we have won 4 they have won 16, with the rest draws.
Lets hope we get a fortunate bounce or two,
if we can keep nibbler quiet, we have a chance.

James Flynn
9 Posted 21/11/2013 at 16:53:33
Well, we were in with a fair shout at the CL last season. We have a talented Side, 11 games in we’re 5 points off the Top.

Not sure what expectations are being confounded.

Denis Richardson
10 Posted 21/11/2013 at 16:53:13
Raymond - that is not a very uplifting stat. However, I think you should only focus on games at GP to compare like with like. Currently (aaprently) in all competitions we've beaten them at GP 40 times and they've beaten us 39 times - so pretty much dead heat.

Anything can happen in the derby and more often than not shite refereeing decisions have decided the match. I would be utterly depressed if we don't at least come away with a point at home, after ALL the players have put in 110%.

The defence needs to be on its top game againnt suarez, otherwise we've got a first team that is capable of winning. The players need to give it their all - goes without saying.

I just hope Barkely starts behind Lukaku so as to give their defence something to think about from the off A win here would lift the whole club for the next few (tough) games to come.

Aman Kanji
12 Posted 21/11/2013 at 17:31:11
Screw the stats. You can make them read to your point of favour. Let's keep defense tight, sharp mid and sparkling attacking... Not much to ask is it!!! 2-0
Gerson Rodriguez
13 Posted 21/11/2013 at 18:13:28
Everyone wants results right away regardless of form I suppose. "Find a way to win" we say. I for one am optimistic about the future and the new foundation being built under Martinez. Lacking the buying power the EPL elite posses compels me to adopt the long view here and continue to be optimistic regardless of what truly transpires under the guise of immediate results, positive or otherwise.
Barry Rathbone
14 Posted 21/11/2013 at 18:37:56
Good to see the standard of Journalism rising.
Colin Glassar
15 Posted 21/11/2013 at 18:47:32
Very good article. If we beat the RS. even the doubters might give Martinez some slack.
James Martin
17 Posted 21/11/2013 at 19:05:51
Strange article, why is he trying to make out that scoring less goals and curbing Baines is a good thing? I think our start has been so-so; some great moments, some awful ones – like last week (a draw that Moyes would have been absolutely destroyed for).

I don't know on what evidence he's based his assertion that there's been a transformation when all the stats are remarkably similar.... Saturday should reveal a bit more whether there is any transformation occuring here or it's going to be another one of those seasons.

Ian McDowell
18 Posted 21/11/2013 at 19:26:16
I think its been a good start. Roberto has had to come in and express his own philosophy, system and coaching methods on the squad. This is obviously a little different to Moyes so I was expecting a bit of a struggle at first. If you look across the park, Rodgers has been to make his changes quicker due to the large transfer kitty has available.

Swansea also appointed managers after Roberto such as Rodgers, Laudrup who also teach a possession-based game so a change at the top is easier to overcome.

So far for Roberto I would say good start, promising signs, and still a bit to do.

Jamie Sweet
20 Posted 21/11/2013 at 20:04:02
The transition from Moyes to Martinez has probably been as smooth as anyone could have possibly hoped so far.

It's been a good start all things considered, but I think we'll have a much better idea of how we're really doing once we've got through the next four fixtures. Seven points or more from these would see us in a very strong position coming into the hectic Christmas period.

And three points on Saturday would feel like Christmas has come early!

Sam Hoare
21 Posted 21/11/2013 at 20:44:33
Good start by RM but it's a marathon not a sprint and we have some testing games coming up. Hopefully we are in a similar position (a few points of the top 4) in January.
Paul Mackie
22 Posted 21/11/2013 at 22:02:46
Barry, I can only assume that's sarcasm, right?
Gary Poole
23 Posted 21/11/2013 at 22:06:23
That's just the most contradictory article ever and it's basic premise - "he's already taken Everton to the next level", just bollocks.

We're eleven games in and have the same points tally and number of wins, losses and draws from last season - sorry but I'm not sure that I see anything there?

Similar number of shots on target and conceded - hmm, struggling to find the difference.

Wait a minute, Baines now crosses the ball less but makes more tackles - just doesn't sound like the next level to me.

Oh and we're scoring less (and conceding less) - pick the bones out of that.

But we have marginally more possession and pass it more - but it doesn't seem to be making any bleeding difference.....

Gary Poole
24 Posted 21/11/2013 at 22:13:11
And Paul, (346) if I was a betting man I would wager that is deadly serious from Barry....
Barry Rathbone
25 Posted 21/11/2013 at 22:13:35
Paul, you can't have read my posts if you think I'm being sarcastic; a suspicion among some pre-Martinez was he would be a disaster. The defence would collapse shipping in 300 goals per game and we would be most certainly be relegated.

The idea of rectifying the infamous Moyes season starts straight away and indeed matching his best start at his first attempt was predicted by none (myself included). Factor in evaluating what's what while changing the style and only a complete loon would disagree about his impressive start.

Bar the few Moyes moles on here who have dug holes so deep they can't see, the recognition of the OP's view is universal among our fans and those of other clubs.

He has made a cracking difference.

Gary Poole
27 Posted 21/11/2013 at 22:50:11
Barry - can you elaborate on the "cracking difference" that he has made.

I know that you want there to be a cracking difference (as we Evertonions would, wouldn't we) but, just so that I am clear, what is different now that is so...."cracking"

Barry Rathbone
28 Posted 21/11/2013 at 23:23:29
Gary when we go forward we come in from all angles even in the games moaned about we've incised THROUGH teams rather than the default being the diagonal long ball from the back.

When it's clicked we've played stuff hardly seen since the title days the important thing about this is this is to be the DEFAULT not an occasional purple patch when Landon arrives for a few weeks.

It is fundamental and absolutely vital if we are to bin this glass ceiling and choking syndrome.

What some can't/won't grasp is the end game this targets they push this ludicrous notion that "same old same old" will eventually win the games at the infamous grounds, win the derbies gather trophies – all will be well.

The last 11 years say that is bollocks.

Patrick Murphy
29 Posted 21/11/2013 at 23:40:23
I would rather the Journalist had waited for another month or so to write his article – I can't help think he has looked at the next four fixtures and recent history suggests that we shouldn't expect so many points from those matches, and so he has decided to write this piece now rather than later. Like Chairman Mao said of the French Revolution it is still too early to tell .

As it is also written in the Echo's sister paper the Mirror – it sort of builds our neighbours profile if they leave Goodison with all the points – which is what they usually do regardless of how well we play.

He couldn't have watched the Palace or Spurs games either, otherwise he would have realised just how toothless we appeared in both games.

I hope the players don't take this type of article too seriously and that they come out on Saturday with the right attitude and a desire to put right what went wrong in the last two games.

Harold Matthews
30 Posted 21/11/2013 at 23:31:31
I'm strongly in favour of his long-term plan but will definitely chuck in a few moans along the way. Right now I'm hoping we haven't fallen too far back by Feb and Kone makes a good recovery.
Chris Williamson
31 Posted 22/11/2013 at 00:20:27
Baines. It's 35% FEWER crosses, not less. How can I take any correspondent seriously for their opinion if they talk like Tescos?

Geesh.

Jim Harrison
32 Posted 22/11/2013 at 01:22:14
The basis of the piece I agree with. I for one wasnt in favour of his appointment but appreciate what he has achieved in a short spell in maintaining league form whist altering the style, but wouldnt go so far as gushing praise. Obviously there are going to be facets of our play that have yet to meet the levels intended, and obviously we as supporters are going to pick up on this and comment (more so during an international break!!)

I don't understand what he is trying to say about Baines though? His strength is his rampaging attacking play. Watching him last season in some games I just could not believe his energy levels to just keep on bombing forwards. To limit that side of his game for me is an error, why be so insistent on keeping him and clipping his wings? Imagine how many chances Lukaku would have from Baines (and Coleman) crosses? A big hulk of a centre forward should be used as a targetman, not dropping in behind midfields to collect the ball. And we are playin 2 defensive mids that could offer cover in the spaces left by Baines advancing.

That for me is the biggest moan. The approach play and possession is better, but one of the main threats we offered in the past is being negated.

Harold Matthews
33 Posted 22/11/2013 at 03:38:03
Some good points Jim.
Lewis Barclay
34 Posted 22/11/2013 at 13:37:10
Let's see if we feel the same when we're welcoming in the New Year. We have a tough six weeks ahead.
Steven Telford
35 Posted 22/11/2013 at 13:58:24
Talking about being "proven" after a 3rd of 1 season is daft as it comes.
As of yet - NOBODY - has been proven right or wrong.

Pretty decent start is how I would characterise it.

Tony J Williams
36 Posted 22/11/2013 at 14:03:05
Decent start that mirrors last season, nothing worse (apart from goal's scored)

It is good that there hasn't been a fall off period due to the transition of the new manager, however, lets how it stays this way.

Jimmy Kelly
37 Posted 22/11/2013 at 15:36:51
Barry, this is a genuine question because I know you are a dyed in the wool blue, but have you actually watched these games?

To say 'when we go forward we come in from all angles even in the games moaned about we've incised THROUGH teams rather than the default being the diagonal long ball from the back.' is just not true.

The games moaned about would include the last 2, when we haven't gone through the teams at all. We've stayed at arms length in front of them, with absolutely nothing that could ever be accused of being incisive.

I will gave Martinez all the time in the world to perfect things - and I haven't seen a single person suggest that he is under real pressure or indeed should be - but I reserve the right to criticise him when I think he gets it wrong, just as I did with Moyes, just as my mates do with Rodgers, ABV, Wenger, Mourinho etc.

Roy Steel
38 Posted 22/11/2013 at 18:12:42
We only need a fair ref, and a wee bit of good luck for a change...

COYB
Chad Schofield
39 Posted 23/11/2013 at 10:02:47
Well I agree with the article.

There are many improvements away from the cold hard stats... and those stats are direct comparisons rather than cherry picking those that fit to drive home the point being made.

If you want a contradiction then while Martinez's addressing of the press has been a breath of fresh air, if I have one real fear, it's that Roberto is almost too good at talking positively. There's a danger that he could sing things up without actually delivering a song. I hope he has the balance right... and given the sudden changes at half time in games such as Tottenham, I don't think he's just nice guy Bobby.

Ultimately he needs time, but in the short while he's been with us, I'm impressed.

Clive Rogers
41 Posted 23/11/2013 at 10:00:12
Martinez is not the problem, it's the board and their lack of investment and willingness to move aside. The fact is you just can't do it without money any more. Martinez knows he needs new players to fit his style of play. Lets see how much money is made available in January and particularly next summer when some older players and loans will need to be replaced.
Barry Rathbone
42 Posted 23/11/2013 at 11:32:33
Jim Kelly

If we did it non stop we would be Barca"

Yes I did see the highlights and yes we did get through (admittedly only a couple of times) but other games have us playing a creative game of the highest order in part.

This is a generally held premise among neutrals hence the journo's piece, they are not instigators of ideas these fellas mere reflective mirrors (not always right I grant you) but I reckon he's bang on this time.

Nicholas Ryan
45 Posted 26/11/2013 at 17:06:48
One of the signs of a great team, is that they don't lose when they have an off day. So far this season, we've had a few off days, but not lost.....is there something there!!
Ste Jackson
46 Posted 27/11/2013 at 09:39:14
I love our new song for Bobby, I believe Christine to be right, it is from our very own scouse song Alle Alle Oh, the ship sails down the alle oh.

http://m.youtube.com/watch?v=7jXjgRVcifk&desktop_uri=%2Fwatch%3Fv%3D7jXjgRVcifk

Ste Jackson
47 Posted 27/11/2013 at 15:55:13
Sorry, wrong link, That was Hibs fans singing it allez allez allez au a couple of seasons ago.

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads

© ToffeeWeb