Set-piece frailties rob Blues of derby glory

, 23 November, 132comments  |  Jump to most recent
Everton 3 - 3 Liverpool
The concession of a third set-piece goal less than two minutes from the end of the 90 minutes pegged Everton back to 3-3 after Romelu Lukaku's second goal looked to have won a thrilling Merseyside derby.

The Blues had fought their way back from 2-1 down to lead 3-2 after 82 minutes but a sloppy foul by Sylvain Distin outside the penalty area gave Steven Gerrard the chance to find substitute Daniel Sturridge and he glanced past Tim Howard to break Everton hearts at the death.

Liverpool had drawn first blood early when Coutinho was allowed to ghost in at the back post and prod home after just three minutes.

But Everton responded swiftly and impressively, Seamus Coleman flighting in a free kick from midfield which Ross Barkley knocked down and Kevin Mirallas converted at the back post.

That work to regain parity was wasted after 18 minutes, though, when Tim Howard allowed Luis Suarez to exploit a gap in his defensive wall and bend a direct free kick inside the post to make it 2-1.

What had been a frantic but relatively clean all-Merseyside clash turned ugly in the 34th minute, though, when Mirallas, no doubt exacting revenge on Suarez for an unpunished stamp in this game last season, clattered through the Uruguayan's knee with a high boot. Had he seen red he couldn't have complained but referee Phil Dowd opted for restraint and only flashed a yellow card.

After a disappointing remainder of the first half from Everton's perspective, it took the introduction of the mercurial Gerard Deulofeu for the injured Baines five minutes into the second for the game to open up for the Blues in Liverpool's half.

The teenager found Simon Mignolet in inspired form in the Liverpool goal, though, and he was foiled in a one-on-one showdown within five minutes of coming on. Lukaku was also denied by his Belgian teammate on a couple of occasions before he seized on Mirallas' cut-back in the 71st minute and side-footed into the net off the goalkeeper's hand to level things up at 2-2.

11 minutes later, after more quick feet by Deulofeu had won a corner on the Everton left, Lukaku stole in front of Glenn Johnson and buried a powerful header into net to provide the platform for victory but it was not to be.

Quotes or other material sourced from ToffeeWeb Match Reports



Reader Comments (132)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Steavey Buckley
1 Posted 23/11/2013 at 15:55:00
There are 2 aspects of the game that stood out for me, Everton could not defend and could not get past their goalkeeper. So instead of being 3-3 it should have been at least 5-1 for the blues.

Mark Jones
2 Posted 23/11/2013 at 15:54:42
What a game! On the balance of play, the quality of football and chances created, we deserved to win. But when you defend like we did from set pieces you really don't deserve anything.

Almost as bad was the rash tackles we kept putting in to give them so many free kicks around the box. With the quality of Gerrard's delivery we we were asking for trouble.

On the plus side, McCarthy and Barkley were excellent today - I thought McCarthy absolutely ran the show in the second half, in particular. Much improved performance from Mirallas, and bonus points for nailing Suarez.

Lukaku's general contribution wasn't great, but he took his chances brilliantly and that's all that matters. Deulofeu was brilliant. I know he lost the ball a LOT, but look how many times he made things happen too. His is a high risk game, so turning over possession is inevitable from time to time.

I'm over the initial devastation at throwing away the win now. Bottom line is it was a great game and, although it's yet another draw, I feel miles more positive than I did after the draw against Palace. Things are still tight at the top so a win next week will throw us right back in the mix. Plus Southampton and Spurs will probably both lose this weekend.

Paul Thompson
3 Posted 23/11/2013 at 15:55:47
Great game. Plunged heights of joy and despair. We dominated most of the game and our general play was very good. Barkley my man of the match, his creativity shading it over McCarthy's commitment and energy. Pointless fouls and poor box marking cost us the game. Having said that, Liverpool's attacking players - Suarez, Coutinho and latterly Sturridge are going to give most teams trouble this season. Fortunately their midfield and defence (other than the excellent Mignolet) are average. I don't think we are going to see this Everton team playing the underdog in derby games for a while.
Ian Burns
4 Posted 23/11/2013 at 16:05:10
My internet stopped from getting onto TW Live, so frustrated, had to listen to the game on radio!

Flung me lucky, blue stubbly jumper in the bin when Ross put that one into the Gladwys Street stands when we were losing 2-1. Got it out again when we were winning 3-2 and chucked the fecking back in again when they equalised. It can fecking stay there now!

Great game for the neutral; heart stopping if you are a blue; disappointing to lose at the end, particular as it was three set pieces.

Where's the fecking gin

Jim Bennings
5 Posted 23/11/2013 at 16:08:25
This may be a really strange thing to say but if we had Southampton's defence we would be fantastic.
It is becoming a massive concern over the last year at how many set-pieces we concede. I first noticed it when I watched a re-run of last season dvd review a couple of weeks ago, I knew it already but I dint quite know that is happened so often. Every single match we seemed to concede from either a corner or a free kick in a wide area.
This to me MUST be rectified soon, January if possible.
I know some people laud it over Jagielka and Distin but for me I would have Stubbs/Weir ahead of that partnership any day.
Jagielka is too small for a centre half and while Distin has great body strength in one on ones, he seems to have massive problems in dealing with ariel battles.
I don't know what Martinez can do to rectify the problem, would he be able at this stage to bring in John Stones or Alcaraz? I don't know but something needs doing because it is costing us.
It has cost us a fantastic deserved win today, make no mistake I was proud of us today but I feel the players have been letdown by stupid schoolboy errors that just should not being happening.
Linda Morrison
6 Posted 23/11/2013 at 16:15:10
Well, Mark may be right as Southampton are losing against Arsenal.

My heart rate has just about returned to normal. I'm so disappointed as I thought we had won, but we scored 3 goals against a great keeper today, and we are still in the mix.

I heard Roberto being interviewed after the match and he agrees that we need to look at defending set-pieces. Once that's sorted, we should be much harder to break down. Is it my imagination or did the team play better after the shuffle around after Baines went off?

Trevor Powell
7 Posted 23/11/2013 at 16:21:52
Am I naive in thinking that at corners or free kicks close to the corner flag, we should have two defenders inside the posts. This was a real strength in the great days of the eighties!
Jim Bennings
8 Posted 23/11/2013 at 16:26:03
It's basic really Trevor isn't it?
You would think that a centre back duo of Distin and Jagielka who are supposed to have a wealth of experience would be able to somehow organise a defence to stop conceding the same kind of goals but it doesnt seem to happen, its not just that mind you, neither Distin/Jags win an awful lot in the air and that worries me.
We should be looking into sorting the problem not pretending its doesnt exist. Yes we kept clean sheets against Villa, Spurs,Palace but with all due respect Palace missed a shit load of sitters and Villa could have been out of sight before HT.
I am not one of these people who thinks just because you have been capped by England you must be good as some regard Jagielka but we have seen his limitations recently.

I am content with a point, gutted we didnt we but with 20 minutes left I would have taken it, the players deserved to win.
Oh and has anyone read Brendan Rodgers having a pop at Mirallas about the Suarez tackle?? Cheeky fucking idiot, what goes around you fucking deluded clown. No chance of winning the League you shite and your a one man team Rodgers.

Chris Leyland
9 Posted 23/11/2013 at 17:09:11
I suspect that Roberto will be putting Alcaraz into the side over the next month in the hope that this improves the deafen and gets them playing more in his style. But why, one why can we never holdout in these bloody games? Yes this was worlds apart form a Moyes Derby performance but we need to learn to see games out and stop giving away stupid free kicks.
Brian Waring
10 Posted 23/11/2013 at 17:07:06
You have to laugh at them fucking redshite wools, saying there was something 'shady' about Dowd not sending off Mirallas.
Carl Sanderson
12 Posted 23/11/2013 at 17:11:32
Well done Kevin Mirallas on a top-class derby foul. Took me back a few years, that did.

And Kevin will have been thinking that he won't have many chances to pay back Suarez for his shithouse challenge last season. (Especially if Suarez fucks off to Spain in January.)

Colin Glassar
13 Posted 23/11/2013 at 17:28:16
I'm blaming Tim Howard for both goals. He was very bad organising his defence for both goals.
Carl Sanderson
14 Posted 23/11/2013 at 17:32:58
The first goal, definitely. I thought the second one went through the wall.
Barry Rathbone
15 Posted 23/11/2013 at 17:25:41
Always thought the centre of our defence was good at last ditch stuff chasing lost causes but for my money weak in the air within the penalty box.

Watching England lose that headed goal against the Germans I immediately thought "is that Jags man?" In fairness it wasn't but that's how I've always seen our centre backs - not dominant in the air at all.

But you can't have everything and both good players despite that.

Jim Bennings
16 Posted 23/11/2013 at 17:35:18
The only thing shady about Dowd was that he did not give Mirallas a medal for doing what every player on these shores has wanted to do for a long time..hobble Suarez.
I am not sure whether Howard could have done alot about the 1st and 3rd goals, maybe he could have predicted where Suarez was going to place the ball on the freekick to go 2-1.
It was a performance that was worlds apart no doubt about that, we only need to remember the 2nd half last season under Moyes when it was level and there to be won, no ambition whatsoever to do so.
I feel fo Martinez slightly because it is going to hard for him without serious money to really correct some of the bad old habits that we have carried as a team for ages, for examply its not his fault Jagielka and Distin cant organise a defence with leadership qualities, its something neither man individually possesses.
I ask myself would we have conceded that third goal today if Dave Watson was in the heart of defence with Big Nev behind him? Probably not.
We need a defender who is going to dominate his opponent, I don't know if Alcaraz or Stones can yet, we know Heitinga cant so the only answer is to try signing someone who fits the bill.
We cannot keep allowing good perfomances and near victories to become just a draw because of this.
Dan Brierley
17 Posted 23/11/2013 at 17:37:20
Everton are winning 3-2, then we make a substitution of bringing on 19 year old Defender John Stones, for one of best midfielders, Steven Pienaar.

Why the sudden loss of bottle that we can win this? Why the defensive substitution at the point of the match where I honest thought we can now go on and win? I am mystified with that.

Apart from that baffling defensive decision, it was the first game where I have seen us fight from first whistle to the last. Very happy with all the player performances today, everyone put their shift in. Pienaar was my man of the match, he seemed really alert and always driving forward when he had the ball.

Mike Gaynes
18 Posted 23/11/2013 at 17:47:57
Colin, another classic clunker of a comment. Howard was blameless on all three goals. On the first, Coutinho was left absolutely, totally, ridiculously unmarked... Lukaku just stood there. The second went inside the end man on the wall, Pienaar, when he jumped and turned his back (and Barry's foolish foul presented the kick in the first place). And the third goes down to the most idiotic foul I've ever seen Distin commit.

But beyond those defensive blunders and some poor finishing, we played brilliantly... took the game right to them and kept them on their heels most of the day. We never stopped attacking. And Roberto's sub of Deulefeu for Baines was gutsy and aggressive.

And oh yes, Colin, did you happen to see Howard's two great saves on Rat Boy? Didn't care for those?

Colin Glassar
19 Posted 23/11/2013 at 17:56:06
Dan, it was done so Barry could move back into MF as Distin moved over to the LB position. I think. Anyway, it was brave of Martinez to blood young players in a game like that.
Colin Glassar
20 Posted 23/11/2013 at 17:59:29
Mike, Howard didn't say a word to his defenders, or even gesticulate, for their first goal. I think I blamed Baines for poor defending earlier on. To be honest, the second goal was a brilliant shot by rat boy but Howard was to blame for not making Pienaar join the wall if he, Howard, was to stay so far to the right.

And as for the third, I didn't blame him for that as it was a killer ball from Gerrard onto the head of Sturridge. No one would've saved that. Oh, and yes, I did see him making some magnificent saves.

Tony Cheek
22 Posted 23/11/2013 at 18:09:11
I was absolutely drained after the game. What a cracker, a real classic. Me and 40 plus RS fans watched the game at the local and I made a right twat of myself by running round the place and yelling "come on you Blues" when Lulu scored the third. Pie-in-face time 5 minutes later when Sturridge grabbed the late one! ...Shit, ruined a great weekend!

But I was proud of how we went about things and we looked best for long periods: 12 shots on goal to Liverpool's 5! I believe we have got a gem of a manager, hope he stays for years! Do you think the dour Ginger one would have replaced Baines with Deulofeu?

Now, please do something about our keeper, Roberto!

Jay Harris
23 Posted 23/11/2013 at 18:44:51
I am very proud of the team today.

When you look at the money the RS have spent and we not only matched them but took the game to them and IMO looked the better side.

However, we need a "set-piece" coach to improve our organization at the back.

Every time an opposing team gets a corner we look as shaky as hell.

With the number of centre halves we have had on the coaching staff in the last few years, we should expect better... but the time has come to rectify this problem if we are to have any ambition of competing for the top spots.

Ian Bennett
24 Posted 23/11/2013 at 18:51:49
When the pressure is on, we shit our pants. No surprise that we shipped 3 goals from set pieces. Same issue for years...
Jay Wilson
25 Posted 23/11/2013 at 18:59:15
The problem with set pieces is that we are a small side with only two players 6 foot plus. Hate to say it but at corners, we miss Fellaini, Jelavic (not anywhere else mind) and from a few years back Tiny Tim who headed away pretty much everything that came in.
Sean Kelly
26 Posted 23/11/2013 at 18:55:29
Brilliant today... shame we couldn't hold on for three points. Maybe we could get that bollocks Stubbs to do some defensive coaching for the first team instead of trying to organise moves for our players to Man Utd.

Well done to Roberto and thanks for your positivity. It makes a refreshing change from that dour ginger twat. What would he have done when Baines came off? Shit himself possibly.

Steven Telford
27 Posted 23/11/2013 at 18:16:21
I had been a bit down on KM from the last few games and comments....etc, and starting to view as a bit of clown in a golden Bentley.

THEN when I saw his take down of Rat boy..... here was my feeling:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UnkefjCES-4

Denis Richardson
28 Posted 23/11/2013 at 19:01:27
Wow, what a game! I was really down after they scored so early, thought it was going to be one of those days. However, the boys fought back well and the game just went back and forth after that. They probably deserved the first half and we deserved the second, so draw a fair result imo.

Was sat in a London pub with about 4 toffees out numbered by about 50 reds! Couldn't stop myself from jumping out of my seat though when that first equaliser went in! Much better performance from the midfield and attack compared to Palace but my oh my, what is going on at the back?

I just knew Suarez would score that free kick as you could see Pienaar standing a yard to the side of the wall leaving the gap where the ball went through. Howard should have spotted that and told him to move in.

Still, Allen missed an absolute sitter and Mirallas should have seen red, so that's one where the dodgy decision by the ref went out way.

Was gutted when they levelled it at the end but having had time to reflect and get the heart beat down, a draw was a fair result to a (surprisingly) good derby. Hopefully that goal and performance will give the midfield and attack the confidence and belief to get some goals over the tough games coming up. Barkley needs to stay in the first team every match from now on! Nice to see much better performances from Pienaar and Mirallas as well.

Lukaku didn't do much but took his goals very well, especially the header. The guy is just a natural striker.

Onto the Adams family of the black country....was a draw but happy with the effort and performance (apart from the defending on the set pieces!)

James Lauwervine
29 Posted 23/11/2013 at 19:37:39
Best game I've seen for a long time, my heart was literally racing throughout the second half. Martinez is such a breath of fresh air. I thought a draw was probably a fair result, but I was still distraught and furious when they got the equaliser. I got the feeling Dowd was determined not to send anyone off, because Mirallas should have been. Barkley was excellent but hope I never him dive like that again, embarrassing to say the least. What a game though.
Andrew Hawes
30 Posted 23/11/2013 at 18:52:44
First derby game in years I've felt we've matched the RS not score-wise but in terms of quality and players. Rodgers has had a few seasons trying to turn a team into playing possession football and we more than matched them! Only for poor finishing and vital decision-making, we could have been out of sight in the second half.

When have we ever been in a position to bring on players that are actually game changers and not just players that are all we have? Barkley and McCarthy immense today... that is how we move forward: young hungry talent, either homegrown or bought, and leave the billionaires with their mercenaries!! COYB

Joe Bibb
31 Posted 23/11/2013 at 20:03:36
Great to watch an Everton team that were not frightened or intimidated by the red sods.

Roberto took the game to them, never gave up and we should have won.

I loved that Mirallas did a 'Suarez' on Suarez... you reap what you sow, red boy.

Tim Locke
32 Posted 23/11/2013 at 19:52:52
Jim Bennings - if we had Southamptons defence.....why stop there chap why not Man City's attack. Maybe after today you would want Tots as they have conceded fewer? Not to mention had more clean sheets. At the start of the day we had the third best defence in the league goals conceeded and second best of clean sheets (same number as Southampton) and not conceded in 5 hours.

Great game. Loads of drama always felt we had goals in us. Was a lot better than anything under Moyes, bring on a forward/attacking mid for a defender. Thought draw was fair results, Allen should have bagged that sitter and we had a couple of good one on ones. Think two of the excellent saves resulted in us scoring so can't say we would have got from there. 8 points has to be the target in these 4 games, we need 7 more then Christmas run and pop out in the top 4/3. COYB

Peter Mills
33 Posted 23/11/2013 at 20:32:35
In 50 years, this was one of the best matches I have been to.
Jim Bennings
34 Posted 23/11/2013 at 20:36:42
The point I was making is when you look at the vast majority of the goals we concede they are mainly all from setpieces. We nearly got done at Palace only the fact the Chamakh is shite let us off the hook and well last season nearly every goal we conceded before Christmas was a cross, set piece or corner, if you are happy for that to go on and on then fine but just don't expect fine performances turned into wins when our defenders keep making schoolboy mistakes.
We were fantastic today and deserved the win but when you score three goals against Liverpool (it doesnt happen much) you expect to win, and the fact they scored all their goals from dead ball situations is galling.
I just think we need to look at the problem sooner rather than later.

Nevertheless it was a great game for the neutral, murder to be at, I hate derbies but I am proud of Martinez not being scared shitless like Moyes spent more than 10 years doing and I firmly believe that once we learn to be more confident defending set pieces we will kick on big style.

We will win at Anfield in January..The win there is coming..FACT

Jim Hourigan
35 Posted 23/11/2013 at 21:24:13
Great performance from the midfield 5, they played well as both a unit and individually. The big problem is the middle of the back 4. Distin has been a wonderful servant but not only is he half a yard slower but he is showing all the signs of age catching up with his heading. Long straight balls, clearances and punts from the goalie can all be dealt with as he has the chance to step forward and his jump with his strength will mean he wins the vast majority.

However, as age catches up, its crosses from the wide or at and angle which require a standing jump that is the problem, and this is where someones age kicks in. This is not a new phenomenon nor is it new for Silvan, this was happening last year but his pace and all round good play masked it. He is still doing well and rarely gets caught out for pace, although this year he is not quite as comfortable. Heading crosses is the problem - last year if you look at the evidence most headed goals conceded came in the centre when we did not compete. What we need is a dominant centre half and sadly it means one needs must go.

This is not knee jerk reaction to today but something that has been happening for 12 months that was merely highlighted again today. A commanding central presence is required. Jags is not commanding enough for me and Silvan is showing his age. To move forward we need a new centre half so that we have a more solid central defence - lets be honest palace should have scored 3 last week and 2 were headers and one came down the middle.

James Martin
36 Posted 23/11/2013 at 21:36:41
Exactly right Ian Bennet. Whenever the lsightest bit of pressure is applied to us we can't perform. It was a simple test, hold out at home for ten minutes against Liverpool. Where was the solid defense and counterattacking we'd seen against Chelsea? Instea dit was Mirallas off another defender on and sleeping at a set piece. It may as well have been Moyes in charge. The more often they do this sort of ridiculous chokign the more often they'll worry about oding it and therefore continue to do it. This team is just not winners and never will be until there's some personell change. Gone are the characters like Cahill Gravesen Ferguson Carsley who knew what it took to win. They may not have been the best footballers but they weren't scared of winning. When we went 3-2 up Jagielka and Distin looked as though they'd wondered into the womens lingerie section or something, they were just not comfotable with the possibility of such a great win against Liverpool (despite their best efforts to cock it all up earlier). If this team wants to win anything we need a new CB partnership and have done since Lescott went. They just don't work and how many derbies do they need to choke in and not defend simple high balls and crosses before people realise this. It was bad enough last year at Goodison when they let Suarez almost win a game they had no right to even be in but this year they almost did it again. I mean how hard is it. Every set piece mark Suarez Sturrudge and their two centrebacks, that's it. Somehow, however, two strikers neither of which are over 6 foot seem to get as many headed opportunities from dead balls that they want.

What was so annoying toay was for the first time in a long time our midfield stamped their obvious authority all over theirs both physically and technically. They gave us the best platform you could want to win the game. Yet again though they were let down by shoddy finishing from Lukaku and Deulofeu, calamitous defending (becoming a reoccuring theme), and bad keeping (when will someone tell Howard he is too far over on every free kick, all of us where I was sat called it before Suarez had even hit it)

Paul Ferry
37 Posted 23/11/2013 at 21:59:24
Here we go again Mike Gaynes - 693 - 'Colin, another classic clunker of a comment. Howard was blameless on all three goals'.

Let's put this into the proper context that MG is waving his star spangled banner and – shock of shocks – we have an American claiming wrongly that his national team goalie was 'blameless on all three goals'. Not the first, second, or third time Uncle Sam has come on these boards with a sanitizing stick for the beard.

Big word that blameless, absolutely no blame at all must fall on Timmy's shoulders when in fact it is a rarer than rare game if a goalie is utterly "blameless" when three goals are scored from set pieces.

The point being that "blame" if that is what it is to be called more often than does not fall on one pair of shoulders. It is quite likely that "blame" is something shared when a goal is conceded from a set piece. I feel, for instance, that zonal marking at set pieces puts extra pressure on said goalkeeper. Howard is off the hook in Gaynsey's book for the third goal because of a dumb Distin lunge and so in the same spirit take a look at Howard not coming for the ball when it went out for the corner that led to the first goal. It is a goalie who sets a wall for free kicks or ought to at any rate and so a share of the "blame" for shitbag's goal falls on the beard although shitbag did something special there. I've seen replay after replay of each one of these goals and I would rather hope that with a free king coming in from the right flank that a goalie would not be hugging the near post but again "blame" ought to be shared around and, to be fair to Howard, who is hardly the most reliable goalie when a cross is heading for the box, the two central defenders in front of him have not exactly been rock solid have they?

Anyway, the bald eagle's attempt to whitewash Howard seems somewhat overstated to me at any rate. The beard did make a couple of cracker saves bot goalie is one of the few areas of the pitch where I would very happily swap what we have for what they have.

–

Tim Locke
38 Posted 23/11/2013 at 21:48:05
I see the hangover from the CP game remains, and that general feeling of we could do better keeps coming back. Weeks of not scoring but keeping tight at the back has now turn to people complaining about the back 4 or 2. There was some poor defending at times but there was poor decision making up front and in the midfield.

People saying our defence is getting worse look at some stats from last year, we had one game where we conceded 3. Set plays are always hard to defend but it's not like we conceded from every corner. Jags prevented Suarez having any real chance from open play, I agree Distin was a bit out if sorts but we all can have an off day. I don't think there is much to worry about and would expect a clean sheet in the next match.

James Martin
39 Posted 23/11/2013 at 22:08:31
I'm sure they probably wil have a clean sheet in the next match Tim but that's my point about them, they only perform when the pressure is off. They'r eboth great on the gorund but have an inherent weakness with the high balls or balls hit in on the diagonal. They've cost us so many points. I've never really got over the Newcastle home game last season where the pair of them contrived to throw away three points. The home derby last year was a horrendous display of defending in a game we dominated, Tottenham away last season, they just didn't let us get that win that mgiht have emant we oculd have odne something on the run in. They're good defenders, and good enough for to 6/7, jagielka by himself may even be good enough fo rhigher and when he was with Lescott as a pair they certainly were but him and Distin just do not go well together. When the pressure is on the whole team knows they're going to buckle and the crowd can sense it. I really don't mind if a team is good enough to play or run through us, but Liverpool were so far away form that. All they had were set pieces and our monster back two somehowallowed three of them to end up in the net, just not good enough at this level and its mistakes they keep making in big games especially against Liverpool. Stones and Jagielka next season please.
Steven Telford
40 Posted 23/11/2013 at 22:06:02
Yes, its true everybody has an "off day" however it seems Distin's are becoming every more frequent. Add to that a "draws are good" attitude...... well,
Paul Andrews
41 Posted 23/11/2013 at 22:21:29
James Martin 758

"All they had were set pieces. Our monster back two allowed three of them into the net." — Can you please explain how you see it that our monster back two allowed Coutinho's goal,and allowed Suarez's free kick into the net? Just interested in your opinion on the two goals

David Baxter
42 Posted 23/11/2013 at 22:31:17
One of the better derby games.

● Mirallas should have been sent off for leaving his studs in Suarez's knee.
● Barkley is a diver
● Everton need to practise one-on-ones.
● Great header from Lukaku for 3rd goal.
● Pienaar left the gap for Suarez's free kick; Suarez hit the ball perfectly.
● The atmosphere at Goodison was brilliant.

Andy Meighan
43 Posted 23/11/2013 at 23:04:55
I loved what Bobby said in the post-match interview. "No, I can't understand why Liverpool were looking for a sending off for Kevin. Yes, he went in high but he closed his eyes at the last minute." Superb Bobby. Only been here 5 months but already steeped in Evertonia. God, am I going to love this man. Yes!
Kevin Tully
44 Posted 23/11/2013 at 23:05:26
James Martin - it may as well have been Moyes in charge.

Thank you for confirming you haven't a jar of glue about anything about football.

Goodnight my blue brethren. It's been a long day.

Mark Frere
45 Posted 23/11/2013 at 23:33:01
Match of the Day seem to be very keen to point out the fantastic displays from Barry and Barkley this season (and rightly so), but poor McCarthy never even gets a mention. Any neutral would think McCarthy has just been a passenger making up the numbers – a travesty really – he's been outstanding and deserves some recognition.
Steven Telford
46 Posted 23/11/2013 at 23:26:32
Even though I think we should have sealed the win today, taking a draw to be 'not unjust' over all - I consider that we should have between 7 and 9 more points than what we currently have. Looking at the league table and seeing what that would have entailed is more than a touch frustrating. It's not an exaggeration to say that we could very feasibly have been on top (at least) second spot.

Roll on Roberto, I'm not for a second saying he is not off to a good start, I believe in this manager, and appreciate what he is trying to do, but it's just if we could tiny up our consistency a bit, then there is the real potential to turn a decent season into a great season. every pint is gold duct to us - and they players (including Distin) need to play like they recognise that, today they did - if they had done at Palace, against Cardiff, against Norwich, against West Brom......... imagine.

Harold Matthews
47 Posted 23/11/2013 at 23:34:53
Can't see how the heading ability of Jags and Distin had anything to do with their three goals.
Craig Fletcher
48 Posted 23/11/2013 at 23:24:23
Fantastic match. Probably the biggest disappointment was that KM's tackle didn't end Ratboy's season, or his World Cup.
Patrick Murphy
49 Posted 23/11/2013 at 23:50:20
No Craig - I don't want rat-boy injured by our players and besides which I'd be surprised if he is still playing in a Mersey derby this time next year. Miralas will have to watch his step - I just love MOTD they do like to highlight our foibles but I don't remember the Sewer Rat being castigated for either of his two horrible fouls in last seasons game. RM was lucky to stay on - but Dowd had to decide if it was deliberate and I don't think it was - in fact KM is lucky he didn't get injured himself - going into tackles with eyes closed WTF.
David Donnellan
50 Posted 23/11/2013 at 23:59:55
Thats more like it! shame about the shitty goals we conceded, but a much better display overall, could only see one team winning second half, gutted when they equalised right at the end.

I had to endure this match on BT sport & I don't use the word endure lightly. I have honestly never heard such biased unbalanced co-commentary from an ex-player, as the utter untrue crap Michael Owen was spewing out. If I was him I would be embarrassed after that so called 'commentary'. He hasn't got the hang of this punditry lark, he is supposed to give a balanced view of the game. Ok rant over.

COYB!

Carl Sanderson
51 Posted 24/11/2013 at 00:14:47
Liverpool scored three goals away from home and yet their goalkeeper was man of the match. That tells you how good Everton were - going forward.

Martinez has to sort out the defence; that has always been my reservation about him and nothing has happened to alter my view.

Congratulations, by the way, to Sr and Sra Martinez on the birth of their little girl: far more important than any derby.

James Lauwervine
52 Posted 24/11/2013 at 00:15:25
Totally agree David re Owen. I was streaming it on a BT sport feed but at half time decided I'd had enough and changed to a French one, and I don't speak French. Much better without that thick little gobshite wittering on.
David Donnellan
53 Posted 24/11/2013 at 00:24:04
By the way, the RS physio....WTF!!
David Donnellan
54 Posted 24/11/2013 at 00:25:23
You had the right idea James, I think in hindsight I would rather have rather have listened to one direction than the shite coming out of his mouth.
Craig Fletcher
55 Posted 24/11/2013 at 00:26:18
Fair enough, Patrick (777) - I guess the sight of that filth on a sports field makes my teeth itch. I liked Roberto's analysis of the tackle though - he was honest, especially in saying that if it was an opposing player who made a tackle like that he would be thinking it should be a red. A lesser manager would have pulled out the old "I haven't seen it" line......
Mike Jones
56 Posted 24/11/2013 at 00:57:47
Something happened today; I cant quite put my finger on it... but that is the most composed performance I have ever seen Everton give against Liverpool. Forget the mid-80s and the Dogs of War... there was a subtle shift in power seen today, and I liked it.
Andrew Presly
57 Posted 24/11/2013 at 01:05:09
They ended the game going for the winner.
Rob Smith
58 Posted 24/11/2013 at 01:12:48
We showed we had balls today, took no crap from them, gave better than we got. I haven't seen the side stand up like that for a long time, especially in a derby, Mike Jones is right, something happened today, a subtle shift.
Roman Sidey
59 Posted 23/11/2013 at 22:34:10
James, regarding the partnership of Jagielka and Distin, it is perhaps worth a mention that, whilst not individually our best defenders, our best 5-6 partnership since Lescott went to City has probably been Distin and Heitinga. Though Heitinga obviously had a very poor season last year, when he paired with Distin (and even Duffy) he seemed to play extremely well.

I've been vocal with my criticisms of Jag of late, and I think it's warranted. He doesn't seem like an inspiring captain when he's on the pitch, and it could be argued that Lescott brought out the best in him.

Mick Davies
60 Posted 24/11/2013 at 01:27:32
If Mirallas should've gone, then so should Gerrard for leading with the elbow. I thought Dowd reffed the game well, good job it wasn't our friend Kevin, who sent of Wes Brown for . . .? God knows.

I agree with some on here, this looked liked a shift in the fear factor today, and our midfield is looking better each week. I just wish the skipper's armband was on McCarthy's arm, and Stones or Alcaraz were playing.

Well done Roberto for moving this stagnant club a notch forward and, come January, let's see some new young blood and a late push for the cup and/or Europe.

Also, a mention for an ex-player and fan, RIP Gary Speed, 2 years this week.

Tony Farrell
61 Posted 24/11/2013 at 03:38:43
I am glad to read on this post that someone... Colin, I think, has had the balls to have a pop at Howard. I totally agree with ya, mate.

He was at fault with the three goals – mainly because he dosen't come off his line. Rat-boy's free kick was good, okay... but Bin Laden didn't organise his wall properly. Maybe Pienaar was at fault for jumping over the ball as well. For the third goal, he was rooted and he nearly conceded again when little Moses beat him to a cross at the death.

Shave that friggin beard off, it's weighing him down. I only wish Big Nev could have a word... Anything in and around the box was his. Waggy must have had more injuries from Nev than any other strikers. Tim's a great shot-stopper but he's crap at set-pieces.

Phil Smith
62 Posted 24/11/2013 at 03:51:09
Just off to bed now and still buzzin' about the game. Gutted not to beat the shite but we really played 'em off the park today. 3 poor goals conceded and rode our luck but we could/should have scored more than 2 in the second half. Be nice to have 2 really good halves against somebody. Then we might start changing draws into wins.

2 years already, eh. Seems like a few months ago. Still so sad...

Steve Brown
63 Posted 24/11/2013 at 04:16:51
After watching that great performance, I know understand properly what 'sin miedo' means.
Paul Ferry
66 Posted 24/11/2013 at 04:27:30
Andrew Presly -790 - 'They ended the game going for the win'. Erm... game ended after a driving run from our Number 23 with the ball going out for an Everton corner and then, 'peep, peep' Dowd blows. Please don't try and detract from a lovely second half display and please read Rob Smith's spot-on post before your... well, I don;t know what. — What was the point of your post with regard say to our overall performance?
Norman Merrill
67 Posted 24/11/2013 at 05:17:35
The one thing that Roberto kept mentioning was thiier goals came from set pieces!
So let's hope he spends this week on the training ground, sorting it out!
We deserved better, but you only get that if you get the basics right.
I would like to know, why Phil Dowd allowed that guy in the track suit to stay on the field, when he obviously made remarks that Jags & others found offensive.
As for sewerage, well RS fans have short memories, it was rat boy who put Mirallas out for many weeks, last season after raking his achilles.
What goes round comes around, or words to that effect.
Ajay Gopal
68 Posted 24/11/2013 at 05:34:57
I think Phil Dowd refereed a good game. But the Sky commentators (Banyard & ??) were so biased it made my blood boil. The nasty elbow from Gerrard that Barry was lucky to duck out of was dismissed as not being anything worse than Distin's elbow on Agger during a corner kick. Did they even replay the stamp on Baines foot that led our best player to be substituted just after half-time? (A different matter that after Baines was replaced by Deulofeu, we created more chances and we generally played better). It is sickening that the post-match interviews focused on Mirallas' foul rather than the fantastic game of football we saw.
Darryl Ritchie
69 Posted 24/11/2013 at 05:38:49
Just home from work. Had a chance to watch the match. It was shown live here at 4:30 am...I recorded it.

What fantastic game!!! It was a game I wish I could have watched as a neutral; but a blue blood am I. Could easily been 5 all, with all the chances either end. I thought we had the better quality possession and generated the most chances.

When Bainsey went off, I thought might have been in the deep stuff. They thought so too, because they tried to push forward more. Very impressed with our speed on the counter with the kids in there. Barkley, Delboy, Mirallas, McCarthy were showing their heels to their midfield. McCarthy is worth three times what we paid for him. Tireless and passionate!!! Joe Allen on the other hand.....

Dowd did well. Seemed determined not to have his decisions decide the outcome.

Thought we had three points. Ah well. Spend a week working on defending set pieces, and bring on ManU.

Darryl Ritchie
70 Posted 24/11/2013 at 06:38:39
Getting ahead of myself... Stoke.
Chris James
72 Posted 24/11/2013 at 07:45:01
Watched it again this morning, still feel as I did on the day that we totally deserved to win that. Not quite sure how we didn't really.
With marginally better finishing and pass selection in final third we could have had 6. Lukaku alone could have had 4 or 5 if he'd been sharper.
Jim Lloyd
73 Posted 24/11/2013 at 09:10:20
I thought" we have just seen the introduction of youth into our side...at last!" Well done Roberto...and to the kids for giving us some great football.

On a side note, I just looked at Newsnow Everton to see what reports said about us and how Bainsey was doing. Shouldn't have bothered...It' should be called Newsnow RS instead!

Ian Burns
75 Posted 24/11/2013 at 09:52:27
Had to endure the game on radio yesterday – it was heart stopping at times. Just had the chance to see the game.

I would like to say a huge thank you to Roberto, he has changed the mind-set, you could see it in the performance.

I would like to say a huge thank you to McCarthy who – particularly in the second half – did what he was bought to do.

I would like to say a huge thank you to Deulofeu - now I see why you are here young man – you should be on the teamsheet from the word go next week.

Finally a massive thanks to Kevin, wonderful game changing tackle, almost as good as the one Barry made on his debut!

How I wish I could get to GP these days, the atmosphere came across as utterly electric.

I am praying that game will give us the next step into Roberto's sin miedo way of playing – can't wait!

Ian Bennett
76 Posted 24/11/2013 at 10:16:03
Deulofeu just has to start against Stoke. His pace and trickery will unlock tight defences that play deep. The time has come to let the youth play.

Brin Williams
77 Posted 24/11/2013 at 10:33:05
ST 759 -'Yes, it's true: everybody has an "off-day" however it seems Distin's are becoming every more frequent.'

But for me one of the highlights was Distin's flooring of their No 5. After being held, dragged and generally fucked about by the twat while jostling for our corner, once the ball was on the way Distin placed a neat punch which floored the big Jessie — who then moaned to the ref.

Priceless, and one of the highlights that showed that Everton are not for being pushed around by anyone any more.

COYB

James Fletcher
78 Posted 24/11/2013 at 10:48:54
Can't believe we conceded a headed goal from a set piece when we had 3 centre backs on the pitch.
Vinny Garstrokes
80 Posted 24/11/2013 at 11:22:47
Dave #85 re Physio WTF?!

From where I sat, I could not believe that KM didn't get a red. Phil Dowd would not have seen that he had his eyes shut and looking away as it was all too quick. I honestly believe, and so do those around me at the time, that he was going to produce a red and so we were very relieved to see a yellow.

Then I watched my BT tape when I got home and saw that the physio had said something to the ref. Dowd looked a bit incensed by this and I think that made him think a little longer and possibly made him change his mind.

Also, 2 goals from RL was awesome but I still thought he had a fairly indifferent game apart from that, but Owen had him as MotM!!

James Marshall
81 Posted 24/11/2013 at 11:29:07
I agree - I'm of the opinion that Mirallas was about to be sent off but once the physio came on and TOLD Dowd to send him off (probably having seen a replay), that Dowd had no option but to give him a yellow, or be seen to have taken the advice of the Liverpool physio.

It was a dead-cert 100% red card challenge. No question.

Aside from that, what a game. We need to learn to defend tighter on crosses and set pieces (stating the obvious) because this zonal-marking we seem to be employing is rubbish. It just doesn't work because you end up with players in front of you, too many bodies between the keeper and the ball and generally everyone looking a bit lost.

Mark a man each, like the old days. It's not rocket science.

David Donnellan
82 Posted 24/11/2013 at 11:30:39
Vinny, yeh, if that would have happened the other way around, I would have been incensed, as I was last year when Mirallas was raked by that shithouse. I was expecting the worst, so I too was relieved when the yellow was shown. I can never remember a physio getting in the face of a ref like that, he should worry about his bucket & sponge.

Agreed, before Lukaku got his first goal, I was commenting to my old man that Lukaku needed to impose himself more on the game. Owen was so unbalanced in his commentary, that I was amazed that he gave an Everton player MotM; however, he gave it to the wrong Everton player in my opinion — it should have gone to McCarthy or Barkley.

At one point he commented that Jags & Distin had spent the 2nd half heading balls away... really?? they couldn't live with us 2nd half. I began to wonder if Owen was playing his own derby on the X-box & he was commentating on that, because I was seeing a different game to him.

Brent Stephens
83 Posted 24/11/2013 at 11:58:25
James, if it was zonal marking, then we didn't have the zone at the back covered for Coutinho's goal.
Brent Stephens
84 Posted 24/11/2013 at 12:01:55
Re Delboy, I can see why some have wanted him to start - he has pace and at times can jink his way past players. But the lad has so much to learn. He needs to learn to pick the right pass at the right time. But worse is his tracking back. The worst I have ever seen. There were times yesterday when Coleman had to pull inside, exposing the RB area. Delboy just watched! You seldom see that amount of space conceded to the opposition. They should have punished us for that.

Sorry, but Delboy can get sub time to prove he can deliver on all requirements. But no start until he can prove that.

Brent Stephens
85 Posted 24/11/2013 at 12:08:04
We've had possession and passes in previous games. But what was so impressive yesterday, was what we've been asking for - PLAYED AT PACE, FOR THE WHOLE GAME. Brilliant! There's no reason we can't do that against all sides.
James Marshall
86 Posted 24/11/2013 at 12:09:15
Brent, you're right we didn't. If you watch it again, you'll see Countinho ran from the opposite side of the box to that position at the back-post and nobody picked him up because we don't mark individual players, we mark the zone. By the time the ball got to him, those zones weren't marked properly because everyone had been sucked under the ball. This is my point exactly - if you mark the man, then this happens less frequently because defenders go with the runners.
Brent Stephens
87 Posted 24/11/2013 at 12:16:59
McCarthy was inspirational for us yesterday. Work rate massive, effective in the tackles. Supported the attack. So far, looking a good buy.
Paul Andrews
88 Posted 24/11/2013 at 12:20:39
Deulofeu needs to get his head up at times and pick a colleague out.
He won't learn that sitting on the bench.
An out and out match winner in the making,goes past defenders like they are not there.
In tight games he will make the difference.
As for tracking back,sometimes you have to allow the luxury of playing players like him for what they can give in attack rather than worry about them covering full backs runs.
Brian Harrison
89 Posted 24/11/2013 at 12:18:26
I tend to agree with a few of the posters that there was definitely a seed change yesterday and time will show if it is a change that will last. I have seen us outfight out muscle them and show a dogged determination, but yesterday we out foot balled them over the 90 minutes. I know it was disappointing not to hold onto our lead till the end, but were on many occasions having held the lead we would have played 10 men behind the ball and hung on for grim death we didn't do that and were still attacking at the final whistle.

Kevin Mirallas had his best game of the season and seemed to enjoy being allowed to play in a more central position for most of the game. Yes Deulofeu needs to be aware of what position he should take up when we haven't got the ball, but my what a talent this boy is. I am sure with even more game time he will just get better and better.

Then there was Barkley for me his best game in a blue shirt, he ran the game for large parts against a good side, he is so exciting and talented beyond his years. Finally, I think if, in either of previous seasons, we had lost Baines, we would have been losing our best attacking option; now, this isn't the case and maybe, if he does move, in January, it won't have as much impact as it may have done in the past.

James Marshall
90 Posted 24/11/2013 at 12:30:53
Mirallas doesn't track back either so it's swings & roundabouts. Deulofeu needs to play more to get better, not play from the bench. As Martinez said, he'll get his chance as the season progresses. We have to be careful because Barkley and Lukaku are both very young as well and I think at times people forget that - especially with Lukaku. He's a big unit but still only 20 and learning.
James Martin
91 Posted 24/11/2013 at 12:38:59
It doesn't matter if its Zonal marking or not, even in previous seasons when we did man to man we still conceded goals in big games especially against Liverpool from crosses and set pieces. Aby good defense can't be allowing Suarez and Sturridge as many free headers as they want in the box, they're not even that tall, their also seemed to be a space at the back post when every ball came in that Coutinho profited from and Suarez would have had it not been for Howard.

Kevin my comment about it may as well have been Moyes in charge was to do with our inability to see out a lead after taking off an attacking player bringing on a defender and conceding from a load of set pieces. It didn't include any other part of the game but if you want to just pick and choose the bits you want to overreact and throw a hissy fit to then be my guest.

Mark Tanton
92 Posted 24/11/2013 at 12:47:54
I think that Osman will surely be marginalised after Barkley's display yesterday, and that Deleufeou has surely marked the beginning of his emergence as a first team starter for us. If we can be that bold against Arsenal and Man Utd in the coming weeks we'll be in a great position.

If we're still right in touch by Christmas, the question is, what will the board do? Will we, for once, make two or three important signings to improve and freshen the squad up?

Scott Jones
93 Posted 24/11/2013 at 12:41:10
I don't want to mention negatives about the derby... I'm just thrilled at what RM is trying to do:

1) Play to our strengths, not theirs:
2) Show some bollocks;
3) Dominate possession;
4) don't take shit from no-one;
5) Make the paying public have squeaky bums!

LONG LIVE THE KING.

Paul Andrews
94 Posted 24/11/2013 at 13:17:56
James Martin,

I see the point you are trying to make. I would prefer to highlight the change made by Martinez taking a defender off to play an attacker, Baines for Deulofeu. That enabled us to get he lead you mentioned.

James Marshall
96 Posted 24/11/2013 at 13:20:21
James Martin - you're both missing and making the point in your last post. We can't let anyone have a free header, the reason we let them have so many is because we zonal mark. Our defenders stand in a certain area, generally the six yard box, but don't actually pick up a man. It was evident with England last week as well and look what happened there - 4 times on the bounce German players had free headers and eventually one went in the net.

It does matter and it does make a difference. You say it doesn't matter and all we have to do is stop the free headers. Well to do that you have to mark players properly and not just mark the zone.

I'm not sure which bit of this I'm not explaining correctly!

Paul Andrews
97 Posted 24/11/2013 at 13:27:53
When was the last time anyone saw Space score a goal?

Touch tight on the man you are marking; if you're man scores, it's your fault.

Sam Hoare
98 Posted 24/11/2013 at 13:45:02
Am I right in saying it's the first corner or set piece we have conceeded from this season?
Brent Stephens
99 Posted 24/11/2013 at 13:48:55
"When was the last time anyone saw Space score a goal? Touch tight on the man you are marking."

Exactly, then "space" won't score. But don't get tight and leave a man in space, then "space" (ie man) does score. Happened with the goal and threatened down our right when Delboy didn't pick up.

Raymond Fox
100 Posted 24/11/2013 at 13:44:56
I too can't see the advantages when using zonal marking, presumably there are some or teams wouldn't employ it, anybody know what the theory is?

Surely marking the man is less complicated! I was terrified every time they had a corner.

Brent Stephens
101 Posted 24/11/2013 at 13:52:58
Paul, Roberto didn't take a defender off in order to play an attacker. It was a forced change to take Baines off. His decision was then, who to LB. Barry? And who into Barry's role? Barks. And etc ..
Lee Simpson
102 Posted 24/11/2013 at 13:49:34
We were outstanding yesterday. Them bastards just score when they want. They're fucked when Suarez goes. Lost count of how many times he came back and won the ball for them in midfield.
Paul Andrews
103 Posted 24/11/2013 at 13:57:44
Yes Brent he did.
Left back off,winger on.
Stones?

Not quite with you in your reply at 880?

James Marshall
104 Posted 24/11/2013 at 13:54:57
The theory is that you attack the ball, and ignore the opposition players but this, to my mind gives every player an equal opportunity to attack the ball, and therefore win the ball. It almost makes every ball into the box a 50/50 ball, whereas if you mark the player, you can gain an advantage by being in the right position (ball-side) when the ball comes in.

It's mainly a European thing which has crept in to the English game because of European managers, but Brian Clough also used it and his teams did pretty well didn't they?

It's hugely debatable of course but like Raymond says above, it does make supporters feel uneasy and it almost always makes the keeper look stranded. See the current level of animosity aimed at Tim Howard on here.

Brian Waring
105 Posted 24/11/2013 at 14:26:43
James, you say it might as well have been Moyes in charge, one huge difference, Martinez didn't bend over and take it up the arse even before a ball was kicked.
Kevin Tully
106 Posted 24/11/2013 at 14:40:58
Spurs getting mullered at City - 4-0 after 50 min's.
James Martin
107 Posted 24/11/2013 at 14:39:56
Look I'm not interested in any of these Moyes vs Martinez debates. I made a throwaway comment during my criticism of our defense. I said that all we had to do was hold on for ten minutes. Martinez even took Mirallas off for Stones (similar to what Moyes used to do) to help us achieve that but we couldn't do it. I didn't say anything about either manager concerning the rest of the game. If people want to try and point score for Martinez or Moyes then fine. I was criticising a defense and a mentality that has been evident under both Moyes and Martinez – an inability to hold on for big wins against tough opposition especially Liverpool.
Raymond Fox
108 Posted 24/11/2013 at 14:26:35
Thanks James, I think RM needs to change the marking system then, because it definitely didn't work yesterday. As I say, myself and I guess all Blues had their eyes closed when they took a dead-ball kick.
Brian Waring
109 Posted 24/11/2013 at 14:49:38
What we need to do is stop giving silly free kicks away.
Ross Edwards
110 Posted 24/11/2013 at 14:58:26
Kevin, it shows that we are much better than Spurs at this moment in time. They are 5-0 down nowhere near FT, and we reduced them to 3. Spuds in 9th as it stands, below the Barcodes.
Ray Roche
111 Posted 24/11/2013 at 15:07:13
Just a quick observation, without Suarez and Sturridge, the shite are a very, very average side. And the way Spurs are getting shagged at City, they are also, despite the massive amount that they've spent, also an average side. With fewer draws we should be top four right now and may even finish above our final placing from last season but we look a better, more attractive side than we've had in many years.
Ross Edwards
112 Posted 24/11/2013 at 15:17:13
I agree with James, we need to sort out the defence.

Martinez has got the attacking side sorted, we are probably one of the most dangerous teams in the PL on the break, especially when we went on the break, 4 on 2 when Lukaku cocked up the pass.

What I think sums up Martinez as opposed to DM is that he was disappointed afterwards, whereas our ex manager would more than likely have taken a point.

Colin Glassar
113 Posted 24/11/2013 at 15:25:17
A bit off topic but, as others have mentioned, Spurs and the RS are vastly overrated and if Cardiff can beat the Mancs then that 4th place is wide open.
If the defence sorts itself out, and I emphasise itself as they've been playing together for a long time now, then we have a real chance of top four this season.
James Martin
114 Posted 24/11/2013 at 15:38:31
In terms of the game overall it made such a difference being able to match them physically in the middle of the park. It was as though they went for their usual rough-house tactics from the off and realised that, rather than Osman and Neville, they were met by Barry, McCarthy and Barkley, better faster and stronger than their three. Once they realised this, they actually just backed off us and let us dictate the midfield, choosing instead to just defend and play on the break with long balls and set pieces. The tables really have turned.

As Ross said, I couldn't believe how average they looked on Saturday. Suarez and Mignolet kept them in the match, I've never seen us make so many chances against them. That's two matches in a row at Goodison that they've been lucky to come away with anything.

They can keep living in this delusion that all their players are better than ours but the recent league finishes and most recent derbies show that the sides are very equally matched; if anything, we've got the smallest of edges on them. Staggering when you consider they've spent upwards of a quarter of a billion recently and we're making a profit of our transfer dealings.

Graham Mockford
115 Posted 24/11/2013 at 15:46:29
Our best 90 minutes of football all season by some distance. We dominated midfield, played with more tempo and intent than previous weeks.

Our midfield were dominant especially McCarthy and both Mirallas and Pienaar put decent shifts in.

Whilst it is frustrating not to have taken all three points, it was only due to a great goalkeeping display that we didn't. Let's hope Suarez does go in January because odious as he is there has never been a Liverpool player who causes me more consternation when he is in possession. Without him they have no chance of Top 4.

Paul Andrews
116 Posted 24/11/2013 at 15:52:38
Staggering indeed, James. And as we develop,and them that hold the purse strings over the park tighten up, the slight edge will grow bigger.

I can't believe the difference in our outlook on things since we changed managers. Granted Lukaku will be gone, I think Barry will stay. Potentially the midfield 3 of Barry, McCarthy and Barkley is as good as it gets.

As Roberto develops the squad it is onwards and upwards.

Brent Stephens
117 Posted 24/11/2013 at 16:05:59
Paul #884. Roberto did not take off a defender because he wanted to bring on an attacker. Baines was injured so the change was forced.
Brent Stephens
118 Posted 24/11/2013 at 16:10:37
Paul (#884). What I was trying to say was that allowing large areas of space to the opposition is dangerous as they can just race into it unless our man picks up. The space around RB at times was staggering as Coleman had to cover inside (not his fault) but Delboy just watched the play not the space. We were lucky RS didn't exploit that. He's great going forward but disaster waiting to happen (not) going back.
Paul Andrews
119 Posted 24/11/2013 at 16:29:24
Brent,

Not to labour the point.
It was a positive change to Baines injury.
If he wanted to swap a defender for a defender Stones was on the bench available.

Tony J Williams
120 Posted 24/11/2013 at 16:51:23
Paul, what Brent is probably trying to say is that he moved a midfielder back into the back four, so it wasn't as if we went three at the back.

We did have one more attacking midfielder, which was nice for a change

Brent Stephens
121 Posted 24/11/2013 at 16:49:47
Paul, I assume Roberto saw Stones as too risky (and witness how he froze when he did come on!). So he chose Barry instead. And that meant we'd lost a positive strength in DM. So he opted to drop Ross back there. And that lost us a strength where Ross had been. His final decision to bring Delboy.

So Delboy was the end point in a series of decisions is what I'm saying. Barry to LB was swapping a man who could defend for a defender. He didn't put Barry there to be able to bring Delboy on.

Jim Bennings
122 Posted 24/11/2013 at 17:13:03
Having watched a re-run of yesterdays match and now that the emotions have calmed I can appreciate what a great game it was, still talked about on radio/tv alike and to be honest I feel pride in Everton and Roberto Martinez today.
I watched the game and thought to myself 'when did we ever go at That Lot with so much gusto under Moyes'. Even at 3-3 with seconds left I was astounded at the amount of men we had in their box going for the win, Christ when I saw some of the shite Liverpool sides they brought here under Moyes and won at a canter, I remember one when I think they had Diao in midfield and Traore and Biscan at the back but I recall we were shit as fuck that day.
Martinez will not be scared of anybody and we can rest assurred that we will go out to win EVERY match we play this season. Of course we wont win every one and we will play bad in some but bloody hell it sure is refreshing to know we want to win and not just draw.

Carl Sanderson
124 Posted 24/11/2013 at 17:54:44
Jim,

"I watched the game and thought to myself 'when did we ever go at That Lot with so much gusto under Moyes'?"

Last season, right up to the moment that Ratboy put Mirallas out of the game.

Peter Mills
125 Posted 24/11/2013 at 18:06:10
Having been at the match yesterday, and just watched Cardiff v Man Utd, I have a better understanding of zonal marking. The defender has his own bit of space to look after, he stands still in that space and attackers run in and have a free header.
James Marshall
126 Posted 24/11/2013 at 18:13:26
Exacly Peter. The player is supposed to defend his own bit of space, so is often static with attackers running into his bit of space - it's a rubbish idea for so many reasons, not least of those being that forwards get a run on defenders so they're instantly in a difficult position.

Zonal defending is rubbish and defenders hate it. Goalkeepers hate it just as much.

Colin Glassar
127 Posted 24/11/2013 at 18:15:39
A lot of teams' defending has gone down the toilet this season. I've just watched Spurs getting pulled apart and Man Utd defending really badly against Cardiff. Maybe it's some sort of virus going around...
Paul Andrews
128 Posted 24/11/2013 at 18:26:16
Brent,

In my humble opinion you presume wrongly.
Listen to what Martinez said about Stones a couple of weeks ago.

Brian Waring
130 Posted 24/11/2013 at 19:46:35
Baines went off and Martinez moved a defensive midfielder into a defensive role and brought on an attacking player, how is that not positive? I know he never took off Baines purposely to get Delboy on, but he could have easily just brought on another defender.
Brent Stephens
131 Posted 24/11/2013 at 20:37:29
Paul, I should have said in comparison to Stones, I guess. I remember Roberto expressing such confidence in Stones. And I actually rate the lad from what I've seen in U21.
Dan Brierley
132 Posted 24/11/2013 at 20:23:39
I thought it was very brave to bring on Delboy for Baines, and it paid off. We were much more effective with Mirallas alongside Mcarthy in the centre, and we started getting more balls into Lukaku who had been largely anonymous due to a lack of support. We got back to level, and at that moment I honestly thought we were looking the most likely to win it.

Then Liverpool get a couple of chances, and immediately Stones is on the touchline to try and shut up shop and play for a point. Even after scoring, Martinez still did not have enough belief and decided to bring Stones on instead of a like for like attacking player. Low and behold, Liverpool then get more into the game and force the equaliser.

I want to see more of that approach, of having Mirallas or even consider Ossie alongside Mcarthy, who is the better defensive midfielder between him and Barry. Liverpool were there for the taking yesterday, they were very weak at the back. We have to really capitalise on these games if we want to make progress, we have thrown a shit load of points away this season.

Paul Andrews
133 Posted 24/11/2013 at 22:12:29
Dan,

Mirallas didn't play alongside McCarthy after Barry dropped in; Barkley did.

Max Wilson
134 Posted 25/11/2013 at 16:10:28
Brent and Paul;, hiya! Don't know if you were there, but I was and at the end where we were defending second half. Stones came on and in every Red attack froze with fear; everyone in our part of the stand was remarking about him e.g.""look at Stones, he's shitting himself" etc (So unfair on the ground staff). Such lack of confidence in ones ability to handle the guys in front of you is a fatal flaw in a players make -up. In a big match, in a tight situation, showing you have the bottle to handle it is the test of a good defender.After what we all witnessed, all the supporters in our part of the stand won't trust Stones again for a long time and I bet his colleagues are thinking the same. Alcarez is available soon, thank the Blue Angel.

Overall, Saturday was a turning point for our team. They produced the playing we'd all been asking them for. Barkley's value has just soared.Real Madrid beckons!! Lukaku had some service. Delboy eventually looked useful, the rest of the lads were great. Now we know
Bainesy is injured we probably saw his last ever game in a blue shirt.
We now expect to pulverise the Potters don't we?

Brent Stephens
135 Posted 25/11/2013 at 16:41:02
Max, aye, had the privilege to be there.

Yes Stones did look a wee bairn without his mammy. But I reckon he's got great potential. What a testing match to come on as sub for a young lad. So I'm thinking try him some more against Stoke?

But Alcatraz also looked very confident on the ball pre-season. So maybe him.

Gerry Quinn
136 Posted 25/11/2013 at 16:55:18
I read that these were the first goals that Everton have conceded this season from a corner or a free-kick. If that is true, you couldn't have written the script for how the Redshite would score - and 3 frickin times!
Paul Andrews
137 Posted 25/11/2013 at 16:59:26
Max, Brent.
Did Stones have that attitude for the full 7 minutes he was on the pitch?
Injury time not included.
Brent Stephens
138 Posted 25/11/2013 at 17:11:08
Paul, yes, ok, I think I see where you're coming from! Yes, let's say the full 7 minutes. So, in fairness, if he'd been on longer he might well have settled in. I really hope this is the case, as given what I've seen of the lad I think he'll go places (well, hopefully stay with us).
Raymond Fox
139 Posted 25/11/2013 at 17:17:38
Stones did look petrified when he came on, I noticed that.
Strange in some ways when you think of the 'balls' it took to take the chip penalty against Juventus in the states.
I wouldn't hold it against the lad though, it was a very pressurised moment when he was sent on.
Mick Davies
140 Posted 26/11/2013 at 00:54:46
To be fair to Stones, a friendly in the USA and the maelstrom of a frenetic local derby don't bare comparison. I think he deserves a bit more playing time before he can be judged.
Paul Andrews
141 Posted 26/11/2013 at 06:28:29
Mick 337

Thank you.
7 minutes he was on the pitch for. Seven minutes.

Ste Jackson
142 Posted 29/11/2013 at 09:33:45
Must have been a poor game to watch for the neutral, with only Lukaku's first goal not coming from a set piece. All this talk of more possession and better football doesn't wash with me. It wasn't a good game, just terrible defending from set pieces from both teams.

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads

© ToffeeWeb