U18s crash to 1-4 defeat at Man City

, EvertonFC.com , 30 November, 20comments  |  Jump to most recent
Everton's Under-18s crashed to a 4-1 defeat at Platt Lane against Manchester City on Saturday.

City took the lead after 17 minutes when Ashley Smith-Brown fired home a loose ball. The lead was double just two minutes later when Thierry Ambrose converted at the near post. The Blues did pull a goal back after the half-hour to make it 2-1 off a well-taken corner, when Courtney Duffus was on hand to flick the ball into the back of the net, and that was the way it stayed until the break.

But just after the second half started, Ambrose struck again to extend the home side's lead. Everton rallied at that point and applied pressure to the City goal, going close on a number of occasions.

But instead of finding a way back into the game, the Toffees found themselves 4-1 down when Denzeil Boadu struck with just eight minutes left.

Everton U18s: Griffiths, Birch, Connolly, James, Langton, Shannon, Dyson, Charsley, C Duffus, T Duffus, Green.
Unused subs: Hewelt, Walsh, Newell, Edge, Dowell.

Quotes or other material sourced from EvertonFC.com



Reader Comments (20)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Colin Williams
1 Posted 01/12/2013 at 15:18:42
Don't worry blue boys just a learning curve in your development to the top table. Keep up with Robbie's philosophy about how the future game should be played and you will find your level!!!!
Good luck!!
Kieran Fitzgerald
2 Posted 01/12/2013 at 16:18:46
Colin, you're right about this age group focusing on development. While results may start to matter at U18 level, the focus should remain on development and learning how to play the game right. This U18 squad seem to be talented and hopefully they will pick up a lot of the Martinez philosophy to add to that talent.
Steavey Buckley
3 Posted 01/12/2013 at 16:39:33
If it was possible, the Under-21s and the Under-18s should be abolished and replaced by an Under-19s that allows players to reach their 20th birthday during the football season. That is about age limit of expectation and potential because, once a young player reaches 20, it should be obvious if the player will make it or not.
Charles Brewer
4 Posted 01/12/2013 at 17:22:34
Steavey, I have no idea about whether U-18 and U-21 should be amalgamated, but as to the suggestion that a player's talent is clear by the age of 20, I would, with respect, mention one Seamus Coleman.

And while they were clearly talented footballers (anyone playing professionally must be pretty good), Peter Reid and Tim Cahill weren't exactly in the top drawer, while Jack Rodwell and Danny Cadamatery looked excellent.

(Actually, I'd forgive Danny the Squid a great deal for his goal against the RS, it really was magnificent).

Steavey Buckley
5 Posted 01/12/2013 at 17:33:42
Charles Brewer: At present, most young players who came through the ranks, either stay or leave the club by the age of 20. Coleman came through the ranks of another football club.

I do believe the Under-21s are a waste of time, because by the age of 19, the club has a good idea if the young player is going to make it or not. So why are players who have passed that age hanging around the club for another 1, 1.6 or even 2 years with the Under-21s?

All of Everton's players who came through the juniors who have made it to the first team squad since Rooney, who broke into Everton team at 16 going on 17, did so under the age of 19. That includes Rodwell, Vaughan, Anichebe and most recently Barkley. And hopefully, Lundstram and Duffy.

Denis Richardson
6 Posted 01/12/2013 at 18:58:00
Steavey - sorry but have to disagree for the simple reason that everyone is different. Some players develop early, others late.

Remember a certain Ian Wright? He was playing sunday league football until a Palace scout spotted him at age 22. Rest is history. Ricky Lambert is another example of a late bloomer...

The current youth development is not optimal but you can't chuck out players simply because they haven't made it by age 20. Could just be that they haven't been given a fair crack - would Barkley be a first choice first teamer if Moyes was still here?

Andrew James
7 Posted 01/12/2013 at 20:06:55
Look at Osman...we stayed with him and he blossomed around 23 to then be a stalwart for a decade.

Steavey Buckley
8 Posted 01/12/2013 at 22:30:32
Denis Richardson: The game has moved on big time since Ian Wright was around and to a certain degree with Leon Osman. The main reason is the fast change of pace and the way football can be turned around suddenly because of the need to get results.

In the Premier League, there is no luxury of time to wait for players to develop into their 20s because big money from Sky TV and now BT etc allows clubs like Everton to go out and buy ready-made players from anywhere in the world. That is why clubs like Everton usually allow most of their Under-21s move on when their contracts expire.

And Everton hope those from the Under-18s, such as George Green, can move up a gear in the Under-21s and be ready for the first team squad by the age of 19. It really is a production line of young budding aspirants hoping the reach the first team squad sooner than later or just being released.

Phil Sammon
9 Posted 01/12/2013 at 23:25:05
Steavey

So if it's 'obvious' a player is going to make it aged 20 but he's not quite ready to hit the first team yet, what are you supposed to do with him?

I'm sure you just try to be contrary for the sake of it.

Steavey Buckley
10 Posted 01/12/2013 at 23:48:32
Phil Sammon: The stats for the last 10 years at Goodison Park shows that, unless a homegrown talent is in the Everton squad regularly by 19 years of age, they are not going to make it at Everton.

Just to remind you of players who did make it to the Everton squad regularly before and at the of 19 years of age: Rooney, Vaughan, Anichebe, Rodwell and Barkley. That's not a lot, when considering how many homegrown players did not. 80 young players who did not over 10 years? Basically, 1 player every 2 years who did.

Harold Matthews
11 Posted 02/12/2013 at 04:28:03
Yeah. The stats are pretty miserable but the money recuperated from the sales of Rooney, Rodwell, Vaughan and Anichebe will have put a big smile on BK’s face.

Back in early September, Martinez stated his admiration of John Toshack’s youth system at Real Sociedad, which unearthed Xabi Alonso, Javier de Pedro and others. I don’t know how it operated but our lads will be following a similar route.

Dennis Lawrence was brought in to liaise between the different groups and select for special training those individuals who appear to have the right character and are grasping the new football principles ahead of other members of their group.

The Real Sociedad team of the mid-80s were a smart outfit and won the Copa del Rey with a blend of home-grown youth and foreign imports. Martinez may try to go this way. We’ll just have to wait and see.

Denis Richardson
12 Posted 02/12/2013 at 12:09:51
Steavey,

Agreed, the game may have moved on since the early 90s but the principle is still the same: human beings are human beings – ie, everyone is different. You cannot simply chuck everyone out if they haven't made it to to the first team by the time they're 20. What about goalkeepers and defenders for starters, who tend to mature later as it is?

Our youth results over the last 10 years have not been great but that's nothing to do with players not being ready by 20 – that's simply because we haven't produced that many decent players for whatever reason. Although some would argue neither has any other top league side in that period.

I'll admit that we ideally need to have a conveyor belt producing (hopefully) one player every 2-3 years that can make it into the first team, so as to have a base of homegrown players in the squad as well as obviously help on the financial side. Whether they make it at 17, 19 or 23 is another matter and depends completely on individual circumstances.

In keeping with modern-day football, just look at Ricky Lambert. Also, I seem to remember Ronaldo coming to Man Utd at 18, far from the finished article. It took him a good 3-4 years before he started to show people the world-class player that he is now. Should SAF have chucked him out on his 20th birthday?

Outfield players tend to peak around 24-28 years old, by which time they have a load of experience but haven't yet started to lose their athleticism, so 20 is still very early stages for most players.

Everyone is different, some players simply develop earlier than others, some get their break earlier than others – you can't just chuck them out at 20, it all depends on whether they show enough potential. I would argue that the majority of players are not ready for regular first team action at 20 as they're still learning their trade. Only the exceptional ones are ready by that age. Give the kids a chance mate – it's not like we're paying them millions anyway.

Steavey Buckley
13 Posted 02/12/2013 at 23:20:26
Denis Richardson: Whatever way you look at young players coming through the Everton youth development, 19 years of age is make-or-break time for younger players to make it into the Everton squad on a regular basis. That's how it has been for the past 10 to 11 years.

And, of those players who did make it before they were 19, Rooney is the only player in the past 10 years to have cemented their place in the first team of a premier league team and became indispensable. The others – Rodwell, Vaughan and Anichebe – have not. While Barkley has shown that he is on the way to becoming indispensable.

That is why I commented before in this thread that the Under-21s should be abolished and focus more on the Under-18s towards the 19-year-olds. Because if players by the age of 19 are not being included in the Everton 1st team squad at least for a few games they are not going to be around beyond their 20s except for now, making up the Under-21s. Because every Premier League team is in a hurry to get 3 pts as often as they can. And that means looking somewhere else for players other than from their youth teams.

And if Everton had some really good 19-year-olds (other than Barkley) or even 20-year-olds from their youth teams, why was Martinez forced to bring in a 19-year-old from Barcelona and a 20-year-old from Chelsea?

Steavey Buckley
14 Posted 03/12/2013 at 03:31:44
Harold Matthews: The Under-21s are not a seamless transition to the Everton first team squad that FA would like them be, because they know very little about the reality of the Premier League; they are the end of the road for those who have never appeared in an Everton first team squad.

Today's modern Premier League is about high quality technical ability, and a player should have it already while playing in the Everton Under-18s. Then, by the time a player is 19 years of age, he should be physically and mentally strong enough and prepared to be included in an Everton first team squad.

If an Everton apprentice by 19 years of age (going on 20) has never been included in any Everton's first team squad for any games, my advice is to have an agent who will talk to any other clubs in the Football League who will arrange for a trial with the view for a full-time contract before it's too late. The competition is frightening to get contracts with clubs in lower divisions for young players of the Premier League who never made the grade at the top.

Since Rooney became an England full international at 17 years of age, nearly 10 years ago, there has not been another player like him at Everton who has graduated from Everton youth teams and played a full season for any club in the Premier League – Rodwell, Anichebe and Vaughan were either injured or on the bench and have since left the club.

Martinez will be demanding more technical ability than Moyes ever would. And as a Spaniard who probably knows the Spanish-speaking world very well and will probably has already a database on excellent Spanish-speaking players with EU passports. Olé.

Michael Kenrick
15 Posted 03/12/2013 at 04:21:23
Steavey,

While a lot of what you say about youth player development rings true, I don't think your claim about jumping from Under-18s straight into the first team makes much sense. In fact, the Under-21 League and Cup were instituted to help bridge that huge gap.

Personally, I prefer it to the existing loan system, especially as most of those who go out on loan from Everton to Football League clubs eventually end up leaving Everton to join Football League clubs. The ones who have actually benefited from that process and returned stronger to further their Everton careers in the last 10 years you can count on the fingers of one hand.

The aim of the new U21 system is to make the football more competitive but the real limit to progress will continue to be the vision and skill of the coaches – or lack of it. With so many first-class athletes revealed in the UK's many-pronged drive to the 2012 Olympics, I can't help wondering if it's the methods and preconceptions that are holding back our youth players, while the standard of the Premier League becomes increasingly unattainable.

Steavey Buckley
16 Posted 03/12/2013 at 04:50:23
Michael Kenrick: The fundamental problem with young English players, there are not enough of them with high excellent technical ability. That managers are looking for, for the premier league.
Such abilities should be known already when a young player is playing in school boy football. At 18 years of age it should be obvious. And I do believe most youth coaches at premier league clubs know they are just making most of the teams up, year after year, with players who are not going to make it.

And with so many excellent players with the right technical abilities from abroad, premier league managers have no hesitation snapping them up, much cheaper than home grown who have made it.

Pardew of Newcastle, who are on a good run, at the moment, has signed a lot of players from with French football experience. Because he knows the standard of football that is required to make Newcastle united successful are players who will not be home grown but are from abroad. That goes for Chelsea, Arsenal and Man City.

The days of preparing the old 1st division of players, who came through the youth teams, who were basically athletic but excellent ball control, and could go box to box throughout the 90 minutes, have gone.

Ian Burns
17 Posted 03/12/2013 at 12:37:41
Steavey,

Michael Kenrick has it just about spot on, although I don't entirely agree the loan system doesn't work. Osman at Derby and recently Barkley have gained invaluable playing time which benefits EFC and it remains to be seen if the same can be said of Duffy and Garbut.

Looking at it from a different standpoint, Lukaku and Deulofeu are terrific examples of the loan system working.

However, Michael's core point about the Under-21s bridging an invaluable gap to the first team is absolutely correct. You cannot have Under-19s then the first team, there has to be a sensible stepping stone and the more they make the Under-21 system a competitive and meaningful exercise, the more the players will benefit and when/if that step into the first team comes, the leap isn't such an ordeal.

Everybody knows only a few make it through the system but to disband it would be a retrograde step. Even if most coaches do believe they are coaching players who will not make it, I would bet my bottom dollar they go out there every single day looking for the sort of improvement or the one or two gems they know will make it into the first team squad.

But to rely purely on Under-19s is a mistake and you can't ignore the fact that human beings develop at different rates. We haven't suddenly walked into such a mechanical stage of human development where all that has changed in the last decade!

Steavey Buckley
18 Posted 03/12/2013 at 15:00:25
Ian Burns: The Everton squad at the moment are a 'bit light' in midfield and in the attack with Kone and Gibson out injured for the season, and would be a perfect opportunity for a couple of players to step up from the Everton Under-21s to the first team squad. But this not happening. Instead, Everton are looking to strengthen when the transfer window opens for any player at any age who will come in a do a job in the meantime and short term; while Everton's long-term casualties recover from their injuries.

That's how much confidence the current Everton manager has in the Everton Under-21s. And that was the same situation last season with the previous manager when Everton were struggling after Christmas but could not strengthen when last year's transfer window opened, but Moyes did not look to the Under-21s for a short term answer. Instead, Everton struggled on to the end of the season and missed out on a likely 4th place before Christmas. And got beat at home relatively easy by Wigan in the quaterfinals of the FA Cup.

Everyone mentions Barkley transition from the Under-21s to the first team and being loaned out as part of his development, yet, he was earmarked for great things when he was 16, and made his debut for Everton when he was 17 against QPR, and was Everton's best player on the day. His delay for further first team opportunities was caused by his need to become more aware of team tactics. Yet, the old football adage still holds true: if a player is good enough, he is old enough. So there is no need to wait for years if a player is good enough at 18 or 19 to play for Everton's first team.

Ian Burns
19 Posted 03/12/2013 at 17:08:52
Steavey - I take your point and you have a valid argument based on facts, of that there is no doubt.

However, my own view is that there is a need to improve the quality of the Under 21's by improving the quality of the lower age groups coming through the system. Improve the competitive nature of the Under 21's and thereby creating a meaningful stepping stone.

I still stick to the firm belief that talent should not be thrown away at too young an age and that we develop at different stages of our lives and that goes for your and up and coming footballers.

I take your point Steavey and I am not dismissing your argument it is just that I can't commit to it personally.

Steavey Buckley
20 Posted 03/12/2013 at 17:52:41
Do the Everton under 18's or 21's have a Deulofeu, Lukaku or a Barkley right now? If there is not, then they have little or no chance making it to the first team, because they are the type of young players Everton need and want right now.

Last time Everton produced a home grown centre half on a regular first team basis? I can't think of one

The last time Everton produced a home grown goal keeper was 40 years ago with Andy Rankin.

Because goal keepers and centre halves are specialist positions of vital experience that need to have come from other clubs with experience for a few seasons at first team level of good quality.


Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads