Fixing the loan system mess

, 2 December, 89comments  |  Jump to most recent
In the Daily Mail, Martin Samuel makes some interesting points about the 'corrupt' loan system, using the words of Jose Mourinho to point up the absurdity that has Romelu Lukaku scoring goals for Everton against Chelsea's opponents... but not against Chelsea.
Amid the bickering, the crux of the matter got rather lost. "From my angle, I'm happy that he's scoring goals against our direct rivals, and he doesn't score against us because he can't," said Jose Mourinho of Romelu Lukaku. "It's phenomenal you have a player that, even when he is not playing for you, is scoring against your opponents."

Indeed it is. Phenomenal, outrageous, diabolical, the choice is yours really.

Lukaku could not play against Chelsea when they visited Goodison Park on September 14 and will not travel to Stamford Bridge for the return fixture on February 22, but he will be in action against Manchester United on Wednesday and last week scored two goals in the Merseyside derby to ensure a 3-3 draw, in a game Liverpool would probably have won otherwise.

Everton are breaking no rules, neither are Chelsea, but that is hardly the point. There should be rules, there should be limitations.

» Read the full article at Daily Mail



Reader Comments (89)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Terry Murphy
1 Posted 02/12/2013 at 02:37:40
Said this many times before... salary caps won't work but squad limits would... name your 22 (or 25 - let the clubs agree on the number) players and that's how many contracts the club can hold during that season. Any players who can't make it into your 22 man squad should be released to sign for other clubs. Problem solved.
Harold Matthews
2 Posted 02/12/2013 at 03:32:38
As a football Journo pointed out yesterday. On the bench at Chelsea his value will decrease. If he keeps on scoring goals with Everton it will soar.
Eric Myles
3 Posted 02/12/2013 at 05:02:52
"scored two goals in the Merseyside derby to ensure a 3-3 draw, in a game Liverpool would probably have won otherwise."

Bollocks they would have!

Derek Thomas
4 Posted 02/12/2013 at 07:21:48
Sounds like a whinge from some sort of rs / manc brown-noser. 'koff!
Matt Traynor
5 Posted 02/12/2013 at 08:38:47
It's the Daily Mail!!!

It's Martin Samuel!!!!!

The loan system has been around for years, but it's only an issue over this one loan of a player from a club loaded with players? I don't recall too much outrage when we loaned Jo (twice) from Man City? Oh, that's right, that's cos he was shite.

I've mentioned before how the Premier League has also spawned a £billion subset of industry "serving the interests" of the game. Sadly loud-mouthed journalists are part of that. One of the many downsides of the Internet age is that newspapers put up a lot of content that doesn't make it into print.

Alan Humphreys
6 Posted 02/12/2013 at 09:12:47
1) it's in a rag of a paper that should go the same way as NOTW and 2) he also fails to mention that Lukaku was sat in the stands at Goodison when Chelsea visited and left beaten.

Al Reddish
7 Posted 02/12/2013 at 09:44:03
I agree you shouldn't play against your parent club. What if Chelsea need to beat Everton to win the league and Lukaku gets the only goal....an own goal. Think of the shit the player and the two clubs will get. It's all hypothetical though as we would beat Chelsea and win the league ourselves!!!!
Kevin Tully
8 Posted 02/12/2013 at 10:11:52
So if Lukaku wasn't scoring goals, this wouldn't be an issue then?

Tony I'Anson
9 Posted 02/12/2013 at 10:15:41
Own or Loan. What's that saying the business advisers put out? "Own what appreciates and loan what depreciates".
Paul Kelly
10 Posted 02/12/2013 at 09:46:06
Always thought Samuel spoke sense in a lot of his articles, obviously I was wrong, twat.

Now it's a problem, the loan system is, because now we've made progress utilizing it. When Manure signed Larsson, apparently it was good business, when the RS loaned Mascherano, good business (third-party ownership?) but now it's us reaping the benefits, it's an issue? — Fuck 'em all.

How dare plucky little Everton be punching above their weight using the loan system — Fuck 'em all. Let's just sign Gerard and Romelu, anyone got a spare £60 million?

And did I mention — Fuck 'em all.

Sam Hoare
11 Posted 02/12/2013 at 10:24:55
I think he has a point. The loan system facilitates the rich clubs hoarding all the best young talent who are happy to move in the knowledge that they will earn big wedge and get a loan move to ensure playing time if not near the first team.

Something needs to change. Perhaps a salary cap or transfer cap or cap the number of players allowed at one club or allowed to be sent out on loan.

As much as we are profiting from having Lukaku there does strike me as something inherently wrong with the system at present.

Patrick Murphy
12 Posted 02/12/2013 at 10:23:51
While Everton have benefitted from this system I have always been against it in principal and in practice. But like others I do agree that the sudden upsurge in opinion by the nationals and media in general seems to be because it is Everton and not WBA who are doing well from Lukaku's services. I don't remember anybody complaining when Big Rom was banging the goals in at the Hawthorns.

The Daily Fail must have a larger number of Dark Siders among their readership than the average Norwegian watering holes combined.

Jim Hourigan
13 Posted 02/12/2013 at 10:23:21
The loan system stinks, Wegner was the only one prepared to say so and stick to his principles, until the other winging clubs got involved. If you loan someone out because they are not good enough for your first team then live by that decision. If they come back and score against you tough. Would it stop loans? yes, in the short term until the clubs saw the effect of lots of negative, undermining players in their squads and the money men looked at the costs.

If we draw Yeovil in the cup, why shouldn't Duffy play against us? if he plays out of his skin, great. If he scores the winning goal against us then why wasn't he playing for us anyway? — down to the manager.

The present system shields the managers from making real decisions: Torres, Eto, Ba or Lukaku was his decision; he made it and should be made to stand by it — not hide behind his mistake like a smug know-it-all.

Patrick Murphy
14 Posted 02/12/2013 at 10:32:37
I don't even think the loan system is about managers and their views about individual players, it's more about the bean counters. If the big six take up all the young talent at premium prices which are way out of the budget of other PL clubs, it takes the average players price up as well.

I'm not an expert in economics but it seems to me that it suits the agents, bankers, investors et al to have this system in place and has little to do with fairness or the sport itself.

Raymond Fox
15 Posted 02/12/2013 at 10:33:46
In defence of the loan system, it gives the 'near skint' clubs a chance to be more competitive.
There's no way we could buy our 3 loan players and its a near certainty we would be a far worse team without them.

Of course it has its faults which have already been mentioned, but we all know that the Prem. is more or less done and dusted each season because the money clubs simply can afford to buy a better standard of player.

Anything that can make the smaller clubs more competitive has to have some merit.

Albert Crocker
16 Posted 02/12/2013 at 10:58:02
Could someone perhaps update me on the position of players playing/not playing against former clubs?

I, perhaps wrongly, thought that this had been resolved via the Tim Howard ruling.

What exactly is the position of loan players who face their former teamates? Is a ban contractural, is it legal (seems to me not), and when does it end?

Phil Bellis
17 Posted 02/12/2013 at 11:01:01
Terry's (676) limitation idea sounds sensible; anything to stop the stockpiling, especially buying players to prevent rivals having them.

And Raymond, I know it was a slip of the keyboard but, please, don't class Everton in with the "smaller"; let's say "less-rich".

Still, as a dreamer ("and I'm not the only one"), I still believe a team of bonded, talented players, working with an imaginative, intelligent manager can become far more then the sum of their individual abilities, regardless of money. Oh — it couldn't be the seeds of this happening... could it?

Raymond Fox
18 Posted 02/12/2013 at 11:13:44
Ok Phil, let's say 'less-monied clubs'.
Steven Telford
19 Posted 02/12/2013 at 11:13:30
Fully agree with Terry #676
Squad caps would be a very progressive move, it would prevent hoarding of talent, promote mobility..... etc

Salary caps would back fire, badly on the league, and the EPL would be hit more than most.

Matt Traynor
20 Posted 02/12/2013 at 11:22:34
Albert #736, the ruling at the time was that Howard WAS eligible to play, even though he was on loan at the time.

Moyes claimed afterwards that there was a Gentlemans Agreement with Man Utd that Howard wouldn't play. Of course, Ruddy played, and had a mare when we were 2-0 up and looking comfortable, aided by one of Neville's "unfortunate" own goals, and suddenly we've lost 2-4.

The FA clarified the position on rules after that.

Steve Guy
21 Posted 02/12/2013 at 11:24:20
The loan system benefits the rich clubs just as much as those without a handy billionaire. It allows them to keep large squads which would be impractical without the loan system... too many players wanting game time and never getting it. It also allows the value if loan players to usually increase... Lukaku is a case in point. It allows those clubs to assess players in a risk free way and,if they bomb, they don't drop points and if they do well then, like Mourinho says, they do it against your rivals.

It's a major plus for teams like Everton and astute loan signings can keep you competitive. However I disagree with not being able to play against the club you are loaned from. I get the potential conflict of interest argument but I hope we aren't paying for the two games where Lukaku is forced to sit in the stands!

Tony J Williams
22 Posted 02/12/2013 at 11:56:38
I don't like the idea that the monied clubs stockpile the best players... but what are you going to do?

The writer sounds like a bitter red bellend, it has been around for decades, but now we are actually getting a decent player, it's all of a sudden an issue?

It's not immoral, it's not cheating, it's completely within the rules of football and what the bitter red bellend forgot to add to his piece was that, even without Lukaku, we beat them... kind of shits on his piece from a large height really.

Paul Mackie
23 Posted 02/12/2013 at 12:08:54
The main issue here is that Chelsea (and to a lesser extent Man City) have so much cash that their youth policy is "buy all the players, loan them out and see who's any good".

Now I know that we also loan out our young players, but it's not usually to Premier League opposition where they can do damage to our rivals. We also don't buy them and loan them our straight away.

I really like Terry Murphy's suggestion of a hard cap on the number of players a club is allowed.

Paul English
24 Posted 02/12/2013 at 12:23:15
I don't hear the London press moaning about Moses loan move to the RS...!!!
Mark Stone
25 Posted 02/12/2013 at 13:08:46
"I'm happy that he's scoring goals against our direct rivals, and he doesn't score against us because he can't,"

No, Steven Naismith had to instead, didn't he Jose.

Winston Williamson
26 Posted 02/12/2013 at 13:15:02
I find this piece completely one-sided.

No mention of the fact Victor Moses is on loan from....CHELSEA!

Would they be bleating on about this if he'd scored the winner against us???

Typical Kopite toilet-paper writers.

Ray Robinson
27 Posted 02/12/2013 at 13:28:19
I know that we wouldn't have got Barry and Lukaku but I really think that, in order to avoid all forms of potential skulduggery, there should be no loans between teams in the same league. As others have already suggested though, limiting squad numbers in the first instance would stop teams stockpiling players.

Chelsea have been the worst culprits, I believe, with 9 recognised players (as opposed to youngsters with potential) out on loan one season, including a Russian (I think) who was signed and then immediately loaned out to Portsmouth.

By the way Matt (#742), it was Iain Turner who played against Man Utd when Howard was left out, not John Ruddy - doesn't alter your argument at all though.

Adam Carey
28 Posted 02/12/2013 at 13:38:39
I can see Samuel's point, but as has been stated elsewhere we are not breaking any rules. It sounds like some European employment law restriction of movement thing, just like the Bosman ruling so until they change it the journos may as well just let it go.

I personally don't think you should be able to loan a player from a team playing in the same division for the exact reason stated above, but the whole transfer scene is messed up with mega-rich clubs taking all the young talent so this gives other teams a chance.

Also, Jose Mourinho is just trying to justify why he let an in-form striker out for a year while his aging, mis-firing strikers continue to be outshone by him. I call that bad management and slightly sour grapes...

Jackie Barry
29 Posted 02/12/2013 at 14:23:04
Why wasn't this fuss made when Lukaku was at West Brom? Hmmm, it is beginning to look like the media are starting to take notice of us, they see us as a threat. Notice how no remarks were made about Victor Moses, and you can bet there wouldn't have been anything said if he had been anywhere near as successful as Lukaku.

This stinks, firstly the media went on and on about the Mirallas challenge and now this. I seriously don't know what issues they have with us doing well. I know it won't happen but it would be seriously funny if we won the league, they would be coming out with all kinds of trash to discredit us.

Danny Jones
30 Posted 02/12/2013 at 14:29:58
Firstly, never buy this newspaper, never read this newspaper and never click on a link to this newspaper's website.

That said, the loan system, or how it is sometimes used these days, is symptomatic of the increasing discrepency between rich and poor in football. That and the bias shown towards the rich. Sadly, this is a reflection of our society, perfectly displayed by the recent energy debate where the real issue, that of greed, has been ignored.

Lastly, never buy this newspaper, never read this newspaper and never click on a link to this newspaper's website.

Tony J Williams
31 Posted 02/12/2013 at 14:44:08
Amen Danny
Trevor Lynes
32 Posted 02/12/2013 at 14:42:27
The media is Manchester- and London-based so Samuels is as biased as Henry Rose was years ago. When EFC had John Moores, the media sniped at our wealth and christened us the "Mersey Millionaires". They over-hyped the Busby Babes even though we took them to the cleaners 5 goals to 2 at Old Trafford with a pretty average EFC team.

We had won as many first division titles as Man Utd until Sky came along and totally swung the balance away from equality. Now, the top league belongs to the big money clubs and Samuels champions them, as do the rest of the national media. We just chug along doing fantastically well with stability of manager at the helm and consistently have a big shout at whoever wins the title. If we happen to turn Man Utd and Arsenal over, it will be against the grain, it will annoy the media immensely and they will have to eat sour grapes.

I really want EFC to win the league title and shut the media darlings up and stop them crowing about Ferguson as the greatest ever manager. Our Roberto should be teaching him how to speak English correctly!!

Robin Cannon
33 Posted 02/12/2013 at 15:43:40
Regardless that it's in the Mail or from Samuel, he's absolutely right.

I don't get where he's somehow biased against Everton in raising it. The only thing he suggests is that under his suggestion we wouldn't have to rest Lukaku against Chelsea; which would be to our advantage.

It's stupid that the loan system seems almost designed to allow the richest clubs to stockpile the best players, and to be able to loan them out without possible penalty to themselves.

Dan Brierley
34 Posted 02/12/2013 at 15:51:39
While there are teams like ourselves willing to feed on the scraps of the top teams by developing their players for them, and paying for the privilege of doing so, it won't change.

I would like to see all the teams outside of the rich list, to unite and tell the top teams to go and fuck themselves, and refuse to take their players on loan. Alas, due to the finances in the football world most teams will take any top young player on loan just to try and boost their short term coffers by perhaps qualifying for europe. But indirectly they are essentially making it more difficult to get past the teams above them, as they have these super size squads with PL experienced players.

People keep banging on about we shouldn't have a small club mentality. But what kind of mentality is it when you take a top young striker from Chelsea, just because their manager doesn't see you as a threat, and hopes that player will help to take points of their rivals? Being a feeder club is one thing, helping another team to win the fucking title is another….

Paul Andrews
35 Posted 02/12/2013 at 16:15:11
We played the system to perfection.
Barry,Lukaku & Deulofeu were available to all the other clubs outside The top 4 clubs.
We moved,they didn't.Good for us.
And Dan,do you not think having the above 3 players training with our up and coming players will benefit them?
Nick Entwistle
36 Posted 02/12/2013 at 16:24:26
But Paul, these players could be at our club. Or other clubs. And who did we take them off? Barca, Chelsea and City. Practically the three richest clubs in the world. Scraps it is.

Funny thing is, we would probably have a better quality squad this season than if we were in the CL season next year. Couldn't afford Lukaku, he wouldn't be sold to us.

Colin Wainwright
37 Posted 02/12/2013 at 16:27:42
The kind of mentality, Dan, that leads to taking a top young striker from Chelsea, is to become a threat to them, whether they see us as one or not.
Colin Wainwright
38 Posted 02/12/2013 at 16:27:42
The kind of mentality, Dan, that leads to taking a top young striker from Chelsea, is to become a threat to them, whether they see us as one or not.
Paul Andrews
39 Posted 02/12/2013 at 16:36:08
Nick,

I hope Roberto can find some more "scraps" with the same quality in January

Paul Andrews
40 Posted 02/12/2013 at 16:38:22
Nick 807,

No offence pal.
Could you expand on your last para there please.
Not sure I understand what you are expressing

Nick Entwistle
41 Posted 02/12/2013 at 16:36:49
You could also argue that hoarding players that the richest clubs do restricts the number of players available elsewhere creating an artificially high fee/wage for the quality received.

Phil Neville £50k pw!

Nick Entwistle
42 Posted 02/12/2013 at 16:46:08
Paul, if Lukaku fires us into the top 4... would Chelsea loan him to us next season? If he was available to loan of course.

Even if we were top 4 would we have the money to buy an equivalent to Lukaku? But, if top teams didn't hoard the young talent, he may well not be at Chelsea... maybe more a West Brom or an Everton perhaps.

Roman Sidey
43 Posted 02/12/2013 at 16:31:23
Ray Robinson, I'm sure there will be a rule you speak of in the not-too-distant future. They will eventually only allow players to be loaned from other leagues/divisions.

Alan Humphreys, I think he did mention that we beat Chelsea without Rom anyway, but what wasn't mentioned was that it was our first match since signing him so he wasn't yet an integral part of the squad. That said, had our first opponent been anyone else, I think he would have started.

Al Reddish, that is quite the scenario. I remember in 2005 when Chelsea were in the UCL semis along with AC Milan, one commentator in Australia asked of the Crespo situation, "What if he scores against his own club to win the final?" I don't think it occurred to anyone at the time that he could potentially score an own goal or miss a penalty for his opponents/true owners to win. Well spotted. However, with the war of words escalating between Rom and Jose, I have a feeling that he isn't the type of player that would do that. He strikes me as the sort of bloke that would take great pleasure in showing his parent club just how important he can be, and would happily defeat them for the good of his playing club. Call me naive...

Dan Brierley
44 Posted 02/12/2013 at 16:52:40
We will only become a threat Colin, when we are fielding our own players. I don't see loaning players year after year as a sustainable solution.

Paul, you raise a good point, but it could ultimately be a double edged sword. No doubt our players will benefit from having the likes of Del Boy and Lukaku around for a season. But what impact does it have on the younger players, like Barkley? Day in day out, he is seeing and hearing Delboy and Lukaku talk about how they will use Everton as a 1 year stepping stone to secure first team football at another club, where they believe they will get more success. Its a very different message than those of our senior players, who say that Everton is the greatest team to play for. Will it have an influence? Hard to say.

Similarly, we are in danger of making the statement to our youth players, that we will take on loan youth players that cannot get a game at other clubs, and develop and play them ahead of our own youth players.

However if it works out well, and we get into the CL this season then there is nothing to complain about, it will be a gamble that worked. If we don't get into Europe, we will have blown 6+ million on wages and arrangement fees and will be left with holes in our squad, and youth players that have missed another 12 months of development.

Paul Andrews
45 Posted 02/12/2013 at 16:50:54
Nick,

If Lukaku gets us into the top 4 he will have done his job and if he goes so be it.
The lad is a star.
Am I right in thinking you are saying you hope we don't finish in the top 4 so we have a chance of keeping Lukaku?

Paul Andrews
46 Posted 02/12/2013 at 16:55:02
Dan,

The board will determine when Barkley is sold,not the influence of players around him.

We don't have any players at the moment being kept out of the first team by the 3 loan players,nobody at that stage of their development yet.

Winston Williamson
47 Posted 02/12/2013 at 16:18:35
Robin:
He's biased, as it's only being highlighted now Everton have taken advantage of the situation and precious Liverpool were made to suffer in a Derby...
Dan Brierley
48 Posted 02/12/2013 at 16:59:09
Very naive Paul, it has nothing to do with the board. Only Ross and his agent decides if he signs a new contract or not, or puts in a transfer request.
Raymond Fox
49 Posted 02/12/2013 at 16:58:12
I don't know what some of you are complaining about, under our circumstances ie. lack of cash, the loan system is our best/only chance of competing, or should I say trying to compete with the money clubs.

As far as holding our own young players back, I think them seeing what the likes of Del and Lukaku can achieve should only spur them on to work harder.
If there good enough they will get 1st team football, history shows that.

Kevin Tully
50 Posted 02/12/2013 at 17:15:26
Dan - I wonder what advice Ross will get from his agent, who would stand to make a fortune if he moves?

Never mind players wages, these leeches need purging from the game. Surely it's time we had a legal framework in place if a player wants to move. A flat fee for conducting negotiations would be a start.

The agent should only be rewarded for outside commercial operations. Encouraging a player to move so they get a massive backhander is just plain wrong.

Jon Ferguson
51 Posted 02/12/2013 at 17:09:39
Whilst loving having Deulofeu and Lukaku, and hating the Daily Mail generally, I have to agree with parts of the article.

The system props up the top teams. The price of players is driven up as 10 or so teams are willing to pay £10mil + (£20mil for Lukaku), on potential alone. They hoover up the talent across Europe (and the world). To keep players happy, they loan them to a suitable club who will give them game time. If the player is really good , they bring them back, if not they sell them for as higher price a possible. They make the profit on the players that come through, and are able to absorb.

Only the richest clubs can speculate to accumulate in this way. Chelsea are the perfect example. They have loaned us Lukaku, Seville - Marin and De Bruyne was in Germany last year and is going to Athlectico in January (apparently), they also have Van Ginkel who hasn't had a look in and will probably go out on loan. Plus Moses and the goalkeeper are out on loan.

If they were prevented from loaning players out, they would have to work harder at keeping them happy. They would be forced to buy less players, pushing down the price of players generally. Theoretically, this would make clubs like Everton more appealing to up and coming talent, and if the price was generally lower, we may be able to afford to buy more.
The richer clubs pay these players, ridiculous wages to entice them, driving up the wage demands of players generally.
So, whilst it's great having Lukaku this season, and Deulofeu this season and possibly next, the loan system generally is detrimental to us. If player transfers and wages were generally lower, then we might be able to afford to take more players on permanently.

John Crawley
52 Posted 02/12/2013 at 17:26:10
824 Winston - he's not bias. Samuel has been complaining about the loan system for a number of years. This isn't the first article that he has written about it, so people need to stop using that as an excuse to bash him. I don't think you can deny that he is correct, the loan system is a mess. I don't think his solution is the best one but it would be easy to implement.

The reality is that this is a systemic problem that can only be fixed by clubs having strict limits on squad numbers and limited ability to loan players out and those players shouldn't be allowed to play in the same league as the parent club. In saying all of that Martinez has played the current system very well and given our limited finances you can't blame him.

Paul Andrews
53 Posted 02/12/2013 at 17:32:48
Dan,

You obviously haven't been paying attention to Mr Chairmans manipulation over the years.
" it has nothing to do with the board" hahaha nice one

Roman Sidey
54 Posted 02/12/2013 at 17:35:50
For the record, is Samuel not predominantly a Spurs writer/fan?
Raymond Fox
55 Posted 02/12/2013 at 17:33:26
Jon, if the money clubs were restricted to the number of players they could sign, would that not put the price of the elite players up.
There would be more competition for very best players causing the price to go even higher.
Barry Rathbone
56 Posted 02/12/2013 at 17:48:35
Roman, he's a self confessed hammers fan.
Gerry Quinn
57 Posted 02/12/2013 at 17:50:31
I'm all for the current maximum of 3 loan players coming in - it's the only way that teams like us will stay the pace of the EPL. What makes me vomit though is the fact that I read somewhere that Chelski currently have a total of 25 players out on loan - now that is what I call obscene!
Jon Ferguson
58 Posted 02/12/2013 at 17:47:01
Raymond - I agree the price of elite players could possibly go up, but we are not (anytime soon) going to be in a position to sign an elite player in their prime anyway. Only a handful of clubs are.

However, for the example of Chelsea, we may have been able to sign De Bruyne, Marco Marin or Van Ginkel. All players with the potential to be great.

Instead Chelsea can Hoover them up, loan them out and then reep the benefits when the player becomes the finished article. They are in the financial position to absorb any losses made.

It takes the skill out of management as well. Chelsea's manager doesn't have to have an eye for a player, he just has to sign them all and see who does best.

Stopping loans would prevent this. They'd have to be more selective in who they buy. Less competition in the market would bring down the price of these players.

Roman Sidey
59 Posted 02/12/2013 at 17:55:29
Cheers Barry.
Paul Andrews
60 Posted 02/12/2013 at 18:01:17
Gerry,

Genuine question mate.
Would it make you vomit if we were taken over by a billionaire and we where in the same position?

Kieran Fitzgerald
61 Posted 02/12/2013 at 17:55:08
Didn't City have something like forty plus players on their books the season they got relegated?

I think a salary cap would work better as it means that a players are more likely to look further afield when planning a move. Also, it wouldn't ruin players for clubs that don't have the resources to pay 100 grand plus a week.

Players retire in their mid thirties. If a player is two years into a 100 grand a week contract at Chelsea, he is going to have investment plans, pension plans and God knows what else in place to make the most of his wages. Say he 's not getting a gamer at present. Everton come to him and say, we'll give you the game you're not getting at Chelsea at the moment but we can only pay you 50 grand a week. Do you think he really want's the hassle, if nothing else, of having to rearrange all his pensions and invsetments. Millionaire or not already, he's laugh in our faces. It's greed and self interest I know, but what would you do?

Kieran Fitzgerald
62 Posted 02/12/2013 at 18:06:41
John @851,Arsenal are held up as the opposite of the approach Chelsea employ. Yet when you look closer at Wenger's approach to developing young talent, he just buys young players with potential in by the bucket load in the hope that a couple make it. He gets lauded for what is supposed to be a fabulous youth system when he could have spent the same money just buying the finished article in the first place.

Paul @856, a large section of City fans were discusted at what their club mutated into when they were first bought out. I wonder if you went to City fans now, whatever number of seasons on, and asked them again what they felt about being bought out, I think you may find that the attitude of many may have softened.

I would be sickened in many ways if we got bought out the way City did. The thing is though, as time went on, and we were winning major trophies, I would have to honestly ask myself if I was now happy with things. I have a horrible feeling that the answer would be yes.

Gerry Quinn
63 Posted 02/12/2013 at 18:04:05
Paul, as a fan I would not have any choice in the matter if and when that opportunity ever arose - but I would say - and with all honesty - that I still think it would be obscene - and embarrassing!

I don't believe that any team should be cornering as much of the market in young talent as Chelsea are and then throwing them out on loan as soon as they arrive. WTF are they doing to produce any kind of English talent?

Butland had the right idea in telling them to shove their "join us contract" up their arses - he saw sense and knew he would not get games there the way they go through players.

Spend millions and if they are not good enough spend more and more millions.

Am I jealous of their fortunate situation? Of course I am - but that doesn't mean I would agree with their PUKE-WORTHY principles.

Give me the Everton way any time - and if Everton achieve anything with their principles and dignity it will mean the world to me - and to shitloads of fans throughout the world in general.

Andy Meighan
64 Posted 02/12/2013 at 18:21:24
Paul (760), you don't hear the London press moaning about Moses because he's fucking shite. Big mouth Josie had got a bee in his bonnet because Big Rom is banging them in left right and centre and, as a few have already pointed out, they wouldn't bother their arses commenting if he was struggling.

Every time he notched must be like a dagger through the heart of that arrogant prick and their nouveau riche fans. And as for fat Samuel, "a game Liverpool probably would have won." Honestly what game was he watching 9-4 wouldn't have flattered us.
Paul Andrews
65 Posted 02/12/2013 at 18:23:33
Me too Gerry.
In an ideal world we could do that.
I believe Martinez will attempt that,he will have all the age groups playing the same style of football.
I would take the money though every time.
I agree with the buying lots of players to corner the market scenario sickening you.
Just to have an annual budget of say £25 million and this lad would have us regularly challenging the top 4 within 3 years.
Ray Robinson
66 Posted 02/12/2013 at 18:20:44
Not trying to make any point here, just seeking confirmation that Mick Ferguson (who subsequently played for us) actually scored a goal while out on loan to Coventry against his parent club (Birmingham) which relegated them and saved the Sky Blues. Can anyone else corroborate this? It's easy to see why loanees should not be allowed to play against the club that holds their registration!
Nick Entwistle
67 Posted 02/12/2013 at 18:31:22
Rule 1, can't loan to teams in same league
Rule 2, loan in max three players
Rule 3, loan out max three players

You do this and players would be shared among clubs fairly, not hoarded by the richest. Also, all that coaching talent would be spread out to other clubs too.

Of course, it won't happen.

Mike Gaynes
68 Posted 02/12/2013 at 18:42:17
Great thread, very educational.

One thing I haven't seen addressed much here is the benefit to the players themselves. Seems to me that for a young, talented player like Lukaku or Delo, the loan system is ideal -- they get to sign for a top club and then get seasoning someplace else, and they develop more thoroughly than they would on the bench or in the reserves for the big club. And if it turns out they're never going to be first choice at the big club, the loan opens up new career opportunities for them.

And Gerry Quinn (867), I think Butland is a pretty rare example. Most young teenaged stars think they are going to be worldbeaters, and will leap at a Chelsea-esque contract in the certainty they'll be starters someday. And when they're 22 and the club splashes big bucks on some German or Dutch star, it's a jolt to realize they'll never reach the top rung.

Kieran Fitzgerald
69 Posted 02/12/2013 at 19:10:59
Gerry @867, Chelsea's problem has been a complete lack of decorum, the club, the players, their approach, everything.
Roman Sidey
70 Posted 02/12/2013 at 19:17:33
Entwistle, by no means having a dig, but rule three? Would you include youth-ish players who have not fared much/at al for the first team in that three? I see the merits of your idea, but surely clubs loaning out U/20s (for example) for short term loans (the month or three month loans seem quite useful) to lower leagues is better for player development than playing in the reserves.
Gerry Quinn
71 Posted 02/12/2013 at 19:40:01
Keiran 902 - you are preaching to the converted with that statement... However, you forgot to add their arrogant fans to that list - and I bet their tea lady has a "haughty-taughty" tone about her too! :)
Jay Harris
72 Posted 02/12/2013 at 19:53:21
I think there are two problems that need addressing in the English game.

1. The jump from reserve team football to the prem is far too great a leap.

2.There has to be the opportunity for corruption or at best unfairness if teams with all the money can simply buy up the best and loan them to other clubs in the same division.

I would set a limit on squad size, number of players being loaned out and make it a rule that loanees cannot play in the same division as the club that owns their contract.

I think FIFA should also introduce a charter for agents which restricts their fees to a set amount and sets down a program for licensing that they have to undertake before they can represent a player.

Winston Williamson
73 Posted 02/12/2013 at 19:53:30
John Crawley

What annoys me is the fact this is getting increased discourse centered around EFC. Why not as a result of other clubs taking advantage of the system?

It feels like we're being victimized because we're a top 6 team taking advantage of a legally sound system. Liverpool have done exactly the same, but no mention of Moses? Is this due to the fact that we have loaned the better player? Or that Lukaku got a brace in the Derby?

I agree the system is flawed. But if he's going to discuss this issue, please do it in a balanced manner.

Roman Sidey
74 Posted 02/12/2013 at 20:23:33
Jay, and I know others have mentioned it, I agree about the agent fees. For someone living in North America, it is similar to the customary tipping culture, whereby you are expected to pay a certain percentage on top of the bill. The problem lies in the cost of similar services. For example, a $35 bottle of wine should receive a tip of $7 if you are tipping the 20% that is somewhat expected, whereas a $100 would receive a $20 tip. Both bottles are the same size and took the same effort to pour. Likewise, if Gareth Bale's agent took a 10% fee for his sale in the summer, did he really work twice as hard as Ozil's agent? Perhaps, perhaps not. So yes, a set fee would go a long way to curbing the ridiculous transfer dramas that seem to be very agent-driven.
Ray Robinson
75 Posted 02/12/2013 at 20:31:44
Talking of Butland - he may have turned Chelsea down but then he signed for Stoke (probably thinking Bergovich would be sold) and has now ended up being loaned to Barnsley!

As an aside, if there are any rule changes, I think that the conditions for goalie loans should be different as they can only compete for one position.

Chelsea had 51 professionals on their books one season!

Roman Sidey
76 Posted 02/12/2013 at 20:36:37
Winston, although there is no such thing as bad publicity. Perhaps all this exposure will sell a few extra shirts.
Gerry Quinn
77 Posted 02/12/2013 at 20:18:41
Jay #913 - "The jump from reserve team football to the prem is far too great a leap"....

It never used to be such a great leap.

We've pissed around so much with things that we have created this mess.

Back in the days when the Reserves played a full and proper League season it was only a matter of time before those players made their way into the first team. Week by week they were playing with and around first-team stars - and also week-by-week they were playing against first-team stars.

Nowadays the ""Reserves""??? only play a few meaningless games and need to be farmed out on loan to gain any value to their weekly footballing life.

The whole FA system needs a great big boot up the backside - and needs to go back in time to provide non first-team players (the Reserves) with better opportunities

Philip Bunting
78 Posted 02/12/2013 at 20:41:55
How about this for a radical change of policy. All players must develop somewhere via a club's youth policy. During a player's development let's say the club is limited via fair play rules to pay that player max 10k a week up to the age of let's say 21, it is then is up to the player and club after that age to agree a future deal. That deal can only be agreed up to a value of 30k a week, fair play rules.

If club and player cant agree, fair play rules state that a transfer fee can only be agreed with the club 'no agent' but the player can still only command a fee up to 30k if he decides to move.

Imagine the change, no agents needed, no massive wage bill, cheaper tickets, keeping hold of your youth players, the Rooneys the Barkleys etc as chasing the money becomes irrelevant. The league becomes competitive, the Shieks/Oil barons disappear and football returns to the masses.......Youth players end up getting a chance and international football blossoms. Where can it go wrong...
Robin Cannon
79 Posted 02/12/2013 at 20:48:05
@Andy (869) - "And as for fat Samuel, "a game Liverpool probably would have won." Honestly what game was he watching 9-4 wouldn't have flattered us. "

...and if Lukaku wasn't playing for us, it's not unreasonable to think we probably would have lost. That's exactly why he's getting so much attention, because he's given us a cutting edge.

So, yes, the shite 2-1 up with twenty minutes to go, and us without Lukaku; they probably *would* have won, however well we were playing.

Nick Entwistle
80 Posted 02/12/2013 at 20:47:29
Sidey...

Look at the difference between us and Chelsea/ City/ Barcelona.

They loan us a potential word cup golden boot winner, one of the most intelligent players in the Prem, and a future La Liga legend, and we're helping Yeovil and Brentford sure up their defences.

If those three rules were in place you wouldn't have the richest teams hoard players, as these players would be at other clubs who can provide first team football. And those clubs would have ownership, not providing richer clubs with better players for the future.

Paul Andrews
81 Posted 02/12/2013 at 21:14:25
Nick,

As we speak,the difference between us and Chelsea is 3 points

Roman Sidey
82 Posted 02/12/2013 at 21:22:09
True, Nick, I do agree that all three rules you put forward would be good ideas. My only point to raise was should the younger (U/20s for example?) players being loaned out to lower league teams before they've really been seen in the first team count in those three allowances?
Nick Entwistle
83 Posted 02/12/2013 at 21:48:22
Well ok Roman, we'll compromise. Loan out as many u20 home grown players, and three any other players.

Today the loan system, tomorrow the middle east!

Roman Sidey
84 Posted 02/12/2013 at 22:13:40
Nick, the thing about the Middle East is...
Eric Myles
85 Posted 03/12/2013 at 05:32:14
Ray #922, when FSW was manager one season our neighbours had 67 players on their books, over 40 of them were Spanish I believe
Peter Roberts
86 Posted 03/12/2013 at 13:24:44
Interesting debate. Can only assume the reason no-one has shared talkSPORT's siede of the debate is because no-one listens to it.

They, in particular Adrian Durham (who is usually the biggest prat on the radio) turn this argument round and criticise Chelsea for exploiting the system by snaring the talent and then loaning them out to clubs who they don't view as a threat to them but maybe to their rivals. Because surely if they were using him to score against their rivals, what is the point in not keeping him anyway as he is (technically) their top-scoring striker to my knowledge.

They make no criticism of Everton, apart from last night Durham called us Ever-loan (which I actually found fairly amusing) as we're not breaking any rules. The one who stand to gain most after us is Chelsea because they can't lose if Lukaku becomes a star while on loan to us.

Bill Gall
87 Posted 03/12/2013 at 14:02:43
I do not know when the loan system was introduced into the game but, like any other system it is exploited by all the teams to take advantage of. As far as Chelsea go, all Mourinho is doing is stating the truth. As manager, he believed that Lukaku was not going to get playing time as 3rd choice but wanted him to get playing time to develop.

I understand that if Everton say played Chelsea in the Cup Final, they would not want Lukaku scoring the winning goal. What upsets me is if Everton say, played Man City in the final, we would not be able to play Barry who has become influential in our midfield. People are going to say "What's the difference?" — To me, the difference is where Chelsea have a young up-and-coming talent, the player City are loaning out was not wanted by the club; he would not be in the first team and may not have even made it to the bench.

This is what makes the loan system a joke: on one case, it seems justified and on another it is hypocritical.

Si Cooper
88 Posted 03/12/2013 at 14:26:58
Peter (056) - "loaning them out to clubs who they don't view as a threat" - we must be viewed as some kind of threat otherwise we wouldn't be potentially damaging to their closer rivals and there would be no harm in letting the player compete against his parent club. Weren't many commentators suggesting Liverpool would be serious contenders this year?

If the point is to threaten the other top clubs then, as long as the player cannot play against his parent club, it actually makes sense to pick a club who are really close to competing with the best to maximize the effectiveness of the loanee. The acquisition of the likes of Lukaku, Barry and Deulofeu is actually a big compliment.

If one club were to loan a group of players who would vastly improve the first team of the host club (thus greatly weakened when the parent club were the opposition) then that argument would make much more sense.

One or two player loans are not the issue, but if the loan system helps the rich clubs to hoard good players then that needs addressing.

John Zapa
89 Posted 04/12/2013 at 19:34:50
Fully agree with Nicks 3 rules. That would put some control over the player hoarding that the rich clubs can do.

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads

© ToffeeWeb