Classy James McCarthy the unsung hero as Everton show they have midfield to match Arsenal

, 9 December, 69comments  |  Jump to most recent
Ex-Gunner Alan Smith waxes lyrical about James McCarthy after another imperious midfield display by the young Irish international as Everton matched Arsenal in the 1-1 draw at the Emirates.
Up until last week, Arsenal could claim to boast the best midfield in the Premier League... Now, however, they have a rival. A serious rival. Having totally overwhelmed Manchester United's midfield last Wednesday, Everton came to the Emirates Stadium on Sunday and achieved something similar, at least in the first half.

Gareth Barry, James McCarthy, Steven Pienaar, Kevin Mirallas and the dynamic Ross Barkley might boast different qualities to Arsenal's prized collection but it dovetailed beautifully to leave their opposite numbers floundering at times.

Of the men on show, Barkley inevitably catches the eye with his dynamic play. But another young man consistently excelling this season enjoyed another good day at the base of midfield. McCarthy's maturity, his understanding of the role, shone through as Everton moved through the gears.

» Read the full article at The Telegraph



Reader Comments (69)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Danny Broderick
1 Posted 09/12/2013 at 18:28:52
Hear hear! This lad has been outstanding or us. He just never stops running. His use of the ball is good too. Him and Barry allow our full backs to bomb forward, they fill in every time if the move breaks down. He's having a blinding season. I thought we paid over the odds initially. Now I think we got a steal...
Brent Stephens
2 Posted 09/12/2013 at 18:34:06
How much did we pay for Macca, again? Is there anybody now who believes that was OTT? Or is it too early to tell?
Richard Lyons
3 Posted 09/12/2013 at 18:33:52
Yes indeed - we have a new Holy Trinity in the making. Barkley and McCarthy are Son and Holy SpiritĂ¢â‚¬Â¦ Barry, if he stays after the loan deal expires (and why wouldn't he?) can be God the Father, at least for another year.
Kevin Tully
4 Posted 09/12/2013 at 18:32:58
McCarthy and £14m change for Fellaini. Incredible piece of business.
Jamie Crowley
5 Posted 09/12/2013 at 18:52:00
I just posted this bit re McCarthy possibly being similar to a young Roy Keane on another thread:

Ciaran @948 -
I honestly thought the exact same thing. McCarthy looks to me just like Keane.

I have to be very clear - I was not "following soccer" until 7 years ago and I never saw Keane play. I only was introduced to him when he was Sunderland manager. Having just started to watch the beautiful game I'd heard Roy Keane was an excellent and hard midfielder for United, recently retired. I googled the bejeezuz out of him and have seen more YouTube videos of him plying his trade than I care to count. I absolutely loved what I saw, ManU player or not. The man was incredibly skilled and was tough as nails.

I do understand he is one very controversial figure having shot that poor man's career to shreds when he took his knee out. Unforgivable but...

If some douche stands over you when you are seriously injured and talks shit do you forget that? No... not me.

I digress.

McCarthy from everything I've seen is our Roy Keane. I stand, due to my lack of "real" knowledge, to be corrected. But my limited exposure tells me he is extremely similar, and man alive does that boy come out of 50-50s with the ball more often than not.

$15 million worth every single penny. Absolute gold this kid.

Dan Brierley
6 Posted 09/12/2013 at 18:48:39
He looks like he is going to be a decent Defensive midfielder, he has put in two superb performances in that position. He has pace, stamina and good positional awareness, and also seems to now drop deep to offer support when Jags or Distin are in possession.

My only question mark about him, is whether or not he is going to become the full package and be able to contribute towards attack when we are in possession. A kind of Arteta, Alonso, Toure type player. With all that energy, I would hope to see him making surging runs giving space to those around him. Up to now though, he seems to look for the easy pass when in possession.

I personally didn't feel we needed him at the start of the season, as our defence was already so solid the year before. But the back four clearly needed some support, and I think McCarthy is now offering that.

Mick Davies
7 Posted 09/12/2013 at 18:47:04
Spot on
Kevin, we got one of the best midfielders in the PL with possibly 12 years ahead of him, plus £14m and 'lost' a player who can't get a place in a struggling side. In Roberto we most definitely trust NSNO Sin Miedo Homage to Catalonia etc etc there will never be enough platitudes for our manager
Veselin Petrov
8 Posted 09/12/2013 at 18:52:11
I have to admit I thought he cost us too much at first and now I am sure he is just terrific!

Looks so mature and calm when under pressure. How could nobody among the rich ones manage to get him I cannot tell.

Happy he is now one of us.
Ross Edwards
9 Posted 09/12/2013 at 19:10:13
I remember deadline day on that live forum, when the news that we'd signed McCarthy came through. Some of you were furious, slating Martinez for wasting £13 million, now look at him.

Absolutely brilliant signing, and money well spent.

John Crook
10 Posted 09/12/2013 at 19:06:10
Its fair to say the future looks bright. McCarthy 22 and Barkley 20. With the short term (next 2 or 3 seasons hopefully) experience and know how of Barry and hopefully this time in 6 months the return of a fully fit Gibson (who is still only 25) then we have one of the most solid exciting central midfields that a club without billions can seriously imagine having.

No McCarthy on Saturday, though, so I say drop Barkley a little deeper and let him come out from the back more (in the same way Arsenal play Ramsey who has been one of the most effective players this year).
Mike Gaynes
11 Posted 09/12/2013 at 19:14:51
Ross, it wasn't just deadline day. I saw posts as recently as two weeks ago complaining how badly we "overpaid" for this guy.

It's rare to find a player who is so completely comfortable on the ball and so absolutely ferocious in pursuit of it. I agree it would be great to see him develop more fully as a creative threat, but I doubt he will ever be Keane or Toure because he's clearly not a goalscorer.

And I don't think it matters one whit. He could be a mainstay of this team for a decade.

Jamie Barlow
12 Posted 09/12/2013 at 19:18:24
What do we know, Ross? Most on here thought Gareth Barry was shite and well past it.
Paul Andrews
13 Posted 09/12/2013 at 19:25:45
Without a shadow of a doubt a future captain of Everton
Jamie Barlow
14 Posted 09/12/2013 at 19:29:05
Dear me. *past*
Phil Sammon
15 Posted 09/12/2013 at 19:24:01
Mike Gaynes

Interesting you should mention his goals, or lack of. McCarthy was interviewed the other week and it's something he is looking to improve on. He said he has always been a goalscoring midfielder but hasn't been getting into the positions he has in the past.

Who knows how he will mature. One thing is for sure, we have a young player with real potential on our hands and a manager who trusts him entirely.

Mark Frere
16 Posted 09/12/2013 at 19:20:39
Jamie Crowley

So, you only started watching "Soccer" as you call it 7 years ago and you're from the States. How did you come to support Everton in the first place?

I've seen Roy Keane play many times and he was one of the best CMs the PL has ever seen - right up there with Patrick Viera.

McCarthy looks like he's going to be a top midfielder but I don't see him ever been the top all-round midfield general Keane was.

Mike Gaynes
17 Posted 09/12/2013 at 19:34:30
Phil Sammon, he's only scored seven goals in 150+ games over five years of top-level competition (Wigan/Everton/Ireland), so I'm not sure what he means by "always been a goalscoring midfielder", but I'm all for the optimism!

I'd just be really delighted to see him creating opportunites for others in the box like Barry does. If he can finish himself, all the better.

Mark Frere
18 Posted 09/12/2013 at 19:39:20
Mike Gaynes

Since when was goals a big part Roy Keane's game? He chipped in with the odd few in a season.

Phil Friedman
19 Posted 09/12/2013 at 19:49:05
I too thought the price was too high, but Happy to admit I was dead wrong. He's been superb, now that someone (Roberto?) had a word with him that it's ok to pass the ball forward...in the first few games it was all sideways or backwards. Now if only he got fewer yellows...
Mike Gaynes
20 Posted 09/12/2013 at 19:49:58
Mark, I just recall him scoring big goals in big games. Yes, he only put up four or five a season, but somehow they were always huge. And since I was always rooting against ManU, I hated him for it.

And didn't he score a couple for Ireland in WC qualifying? It's a long time ago, but I remember watching those games because the Cup was in the US that year.

Colin Glassar
21 Posted 09/12/2013 at 19:58:31
We do have the makings of a new Holy Trinity.

The Father = Barry
The Son = Barkley
The Holy Spirit = McCarthy.

Phil Sammon
22 Posted 09/12/2013 at 20:16:02
Mike Gaynes

He was speaking about his days as a kid rather than his time at Wigan, Mike.

Jamie Crowley
23 Posted 09/12/2013 at 20:51:47
Mark Frere -

Long story short - always wanted to watch. grew up playing hockey and had my American sports... decided 7 years ago to take the plunge. did exhaustive (and I mean exhaustive) research on the Clubs... sports allegiance is akin to marriage and something I don't take lightly at all.

Everton it was, errrrr..... I was chosen.

7 years and I've only missed the odd untelevised FA Cup or League Cup game.

TW is like fucking crack to me now.

Wayne Smyth
24 Posted 09/12/2013 at 20:56:45
To be a Keane, you need to have a bit of the nasty bastard about you. You need to be the kind of player that drags the entire team with you when those around you have given up. Players like that don't come around often.

McCarthy is a great signing and good value for the money we spent on him, but he's no Keane. He'll be the proper centre mid we've been craving for years and he's a great all round box to box player who can do a bit of everything.

To go to the next level we do need a real leader in the team. Someone who doesn't settle for a draw, despises getting beaten and will bang some heads together on the pitch when necessary to get the team winning matches.

Lewis Barclay
25 Posted 09/12/2013 at 21:15:09
Roy Keane comes across as an absolute bell end. More a character of humour than anything else these days. Great player or not I hope the comparisons with JMc stop. Maybe comparisons with Peter Reid would be more appropriate.
Christopher Kelly
26 Posted 09/12/2013 at 21:38:09
Hear, hear Wayne Smith!!

If Barry were here longer I'd hope it would be him. I have a feeling that Barry is almost as important off the pitch as he is on. McCarthy and Barkley must look up him like The Father.

McCarthy seems like too shy a lad to ever be a Keane type. McCArthy seems the type of bloke that you'd want to marry your daughter. Keane would just fuck her and never call her again.

Kevin Rowlands
27 Posted 09/12/2013 at 22:25:20
True story, I was at the meet and greet in Miami pre season and asked RM right to his face was McCarthy coming onboard, instantly a huge smile came on his face and he said to me and I quote 'he's an Everton style player and we hope to sign him but he will cost a lot of money' right there I thought ok this guy really rates him I hope he's right. Funnily enough, Fellaini was sat just by him and I asked if he was staying, RM said we hope so, would anyone swap now? I don't think so, McCarthy and a 14 mill profit on the deal is an incredible piece of business.
Trevor Lynes
28 Posted 09/12/2013 at 22:43:35
McCarthy does need to chip in with a few goals otherwise we are virtually a one trick pony. Lots of so called creative players without punch. Other players must chip in with goals, it cannot all be left to Lukaku and Deulofeu. Osman, McCarthy and Barkley need to score a few otherwise good defences will just tie Lukaku up and our goals will dry up.

Incidently I agree that McCarthy has been a good acquisition but the much maligned Fellaini was our top scorer last season.

Kev Prytherch
29 Posted 09/12/2013 at 22:53:11
Jamie Crowley. Not sure I agree about the 'tough as nails part' with Roy Keane.
I notice he was always quiet in the presence of the likes of Duncan Ferguson and David Unsworth. Also, I remember playing Utd 1st game of the season when we had Richard Gough playing for us, Keane tried his hard man impression with someone like Scott Gemmill (could have been someone else), anyway Richard Gough marched 30 yards over to Roy Keane and took the ball out of his hands. Hard man Keane looked at him, shit himself and ran off.

Tough as nails??? Only with people smaller than him.

Prick?? Yes.

Dan Brierley
30 Posted 09/12/2013 at 22:59:15
Seems to be a lot of short memories here, didn't Fellaini manage 12 goals and 7 assists last season? Or put another way, at the same point in the season last year, hadn't Fellaini scored more goals, and laid on more assists, than Barkley, Barry and McCarthy combined?

I am all for discussing the merits and weaknesses of our own players, but its ridiculous to not recognise just how important Fellaini was to our team in seasons gone by.

Kevin Rowlands
31 Posted 09/12/2013 at 23:15:44
Dan, no one is saying Fellaini wasn't important, he's had an awful start to his career at Utd, I hope he comes good but he won't be given the same appreciation and respect he had at Goodison, most of them already think he was a waste of money, McCarthy plus 14 mill was fantastic business however you want to paint it.
Paul Wharton
32 Posted 09/12/2013 at 23:25:29
To our soccer mad US Evertonian , you should look at our 80's team with Paul Bracewell in it , I think this lad is in the same mould. This lad is getting better & better with every game.
Graham McCann
33 Posted 09/12/2013 at 23:52:43
Moyes and Fellaini are history. The big fella did score and create goals, but he did it in Moyes' Everton. McCarthy, Barkley and Barry do things so much better in Roberto's team. Different Manager,(some) different players, different system, totally different mind set..............totally different expectations from all of us Blues.

EFC have moved on, and the football world is starting to take notice at last.

James Martin
34 Posted 09/12/2013 at 23:48:01
McCarthy is twice the player Fellaini is. So what that Fellaini scored a few upfront for us last season? With his height and Baines' deliveries you'd expect him to. The entire team was built aorund him and we were playing really well as well. He even had strikers making crazy runs out wide to drag defenders away from him.

McCarthy has everything Fellaini doesn't: pace, agression, tackling ability, quick passing and tactical awareness. You don't need to build your team aorund him to get his performance level above the average mark. He just slots in and gives you 8-9/10 every game. Fellaini would occasionally give you a 9 (if you played him in exactly the right place and gave him exactly the right service) and then give you three 4s. It was never his fault of course though.

You can say what you want about Fellaini but I got fed up of watching him huffing and puffing around in derby matches getting ran over by dross like Lucas and Charlie Adam. He was too slow in body and in mind and to add to that he was a reactive loser, quite happy for the game to just go on around him. Contrast that to the performances of this week where we've just wiped the floor with United and matched one of the best midfields in Europe at the moment. Barkley and McCarthy give everything all the time and look like they hate getting beat. They don't reckon themselves to be superstars or mouth off about wanting to play for Chelsea or whoever. Best of all they don't consider themselves inferior to anyone, rather they have that quiet confidence that comes with knowing you're a top player, they don't spoil their shorts at the mere sight of a geriatric Gerrard lining up opposite them, McCarthy just choked him out the game much like he did Ramsey. They also don't run around elbowing people and they don't lose their men on set pieces all the time (Fellaini's part in our semi final defeat is always conveniently forgotten). They are part of a new breed of winners along with Deulofeu Lukaku Oviedo Mirallas who don't just accept that 'nearlyness' associated with Everton. They trust their talent against the best in the game and aren't afraid to win. They're not scared to bash in audacious late goals at Old Trafford or the Emirates. As contentious as it may seem, I would have put money on Baines missing that chance that Oviedo had at Old Trafford. For all his talent he's never had the mentality. Oviedo does though, you can see it in that finish and in his tackles. This is a mentality Fellaini never had.

Our midfield is far better without Fellaini in it and the results show that

Graham McCann
35 Posted 10/12/2013 at 00:14:50
James, more or less spot on about Fellaini and the mind set that evolved in the previous managers tenure. Would take you to task about Baines/Oviedo comparison though. The main thing is, is that we have players working in tune with a forward thinking manager. In the last 5 minutes of yesterdays game we had Jags, Coleman and Oviedo in Arsenals' box. The players believe that they are good enough to compete. Talking about Jags, what ever happened to hoofball? I just get the impression that it was not his idea but a certain previous manager.

Was watching Sky tonight and Gary Neville was saying that Everton play 3 at the back when we have the ball. Our full backs are wingers, Barry or McCarthy slot in and become the 3rd centre back, keeping the pressure on the opposing team because we've got so many players upfield. We make the other team worry about us, we don't worry about them.

No more hoofball. The School Of Science is reborn in the 21st Century.

Kevin Rowlands
36 Posted 10/12/2013 at 00:47:02
Agreed James, just realized that our friend Dan is one of them that loves to stir the shit, if you asked any Utd fan who they would prefer in their midfield Fellaini or McCarthy guaranteed most would have Maca, 14 mil profit? gotta be one of the best piece of transfer window deals ever.
Peter Bell
37 Posted 10/12/2013 at 01:45:47
James McCarthy is a mirror image of Paul Bracewel, all engine and running, those comparing him to Reid are misguided
Paul Ferry
38 Posted 10/12/2013 at 02:09:48
Mark Frere don't doubt Jamie Crowley for a single second, he's a top bloke and knows his stuff and is currently raising four more Evertonians for the next generation, one of whom poops everywhere.
Jim Harrison
39 Posted 10/12/2013 at 04:31:28
I suppose when comparing Fella & JM as defensive midfielders there is only one winner at the moment. Happily its the one that came to Everton not left. But I do feel had the big man stayed he would have still played a big role.

His ability playing behind the striker to bring the ball down is scary and pretty unique. He isn't a target to provide knock ons but a target to get the ball back on the ground allowing a quick switch from back to front whilst still being able to maintain a passing approach.

This may not convince many, but I never classified the long ball to him as hoofball (obviously there were plenty of pointless punts played as-well) but long passes. Now, in the current system he would take Barkleys role, which we wouldnt want, but he would have provided a very different option to change games without abandoning the passing approach.

All that said, 27 million for a him is a great deal, and the manager who took him off us is playing him away from his best position!!

On JM, I will happily concede I wasnt sold on the deal at first and gladly hold my hand up and admit how wrong I was. Bundles of energy, fantastic commitment and good on the ball. All at only 22. Great bit of business

Jackie Barry
40 Posted 10/12/2013 at 06:12:05
This lad will be better than Roy Keane, he is only 22 and is only going to get better. In the end though the comparison needs to stop, he is McCarthy and has a right to create his own script. As good as Keane was he is gone now and to some extent he was made to look better than he really was playing in a fantastic side.
Harold Matthews
41 Posted 10/12/2013 at 07:05:39
I'm a McCarthy fan. Always have been. After many months screaming for a midfield tiger we finally got one. OK he doesn't score goals. So what. He helps prevent goals against and provides link-up and cover for the attackers. That's good enough for me.

With the new set-up the goal scorers are the striker, the two wingers, the fullbacks and the forward midfielder. These six guys can attack without fear because they know the five guys behind them have everything covered. Jags and Distin are also a scoring threat at set-pieces.

Our biggest problem everyone knows about. Martinez, his coaches, the players, the fans, the groundsmen, the tea lady. We are not getting things right in the final third. Players not getting their heads up, making poor decisions etc, etc, etc. They'll be working every day on putting it right, but if it's not sorted quickly it will surely cost us.

Jamie Crowley
42 Posted 10/12/2013 at 08:08:27
Paul -

5 sons, and all current Evertonians. Even the little pooper says "I like blue" when we watch the games.

:0)

David Ellis
43 Posted 10/12/2013 at 08:22:38
McCarthy is no Bracewell - at least not yet. Bracewell had a fantastic tackle and great long pass on him - one of the all time best midfielders, although sadly only for two golden years, he was never the same after that injury in '86. Had he been fit that summer England would have won the World Cup and he would have stopped Maradona in his tracks.

But I'm happy with McCarthy at the moment and suspect he will last a bit longer the Bracewell. And there is a simularity in the amount of ground they both cover.

Conn Prosser
44 Posted 10/12/2013 at 10:55:56
I was a slow adopter of the Jimmy Mac appreciation brigade, but having closely watched highlights of the last three games, I'm a fully signed up member. Let McCarthy Era rule!
His reading of the game, awareness of danger and sheer miles put in make him essential to Everton. I used to squirm at his sideways-to-back passes and feared he had a throttling effect on our forward movement. It was all part of the plan. His passing is perfect for engine room organisation.

There are plenty others on the park available to make killer passes, thanks to McCarthy.
Keep it up Jimmy, become a blue legend!

Andrew Ellams
45 Posted 10/12/2013 at 11:18:21
Kev @ 209 I remember Tim Cahill putting Keane on his arse in the first minute of the 1-0 win in the 4th place season. Keane tried a revenger kick shortly after and Tim jumped straight up, went nose to nose and Keane disappeared for the rest of the game. Playground bully
Brian Furey
46 Posted 10/12/2013 at 10:48:52
I'm from Ireland and was delighted when McCarthy finally decided to play for us rather than Scotland. I believe he would have chosen Scotland had they have came knocking on his door first.

I've never watched the lad in the flesh but like so many I've admired him from his Wigan days and was delighted when RM signed him. I was amazed at how many of ye on here thought we'd paid too much for him but for an up and coming 22 year old Scottish lad you're always gonna pay over 10M if he's any good.

Personally I think he's nothing like Roy Keane as he's much more shy and not an aggressive dominant person. Yes he can make some crunching tackles and works his a$$ off every game. Roy as he admits in the article below, was much more aggressive and influential. He would often take a game by the scruff of the neck and lead the charge where his teammates followed. By the way I am NOT a fan of Roy the person but thought he was an awesome player.
http://goo.gl/8MgaQg

Maybe James will progress and add those attributes to his game but
at the moment he does the simple things well and as someone said makes the simple pass to those around him who can use the ball better. In my eyes he's there to win tackles, lay if off and protect the back four/three. I saw that analysis last night on Sky as well where they showed how much our 2 FBs push forward and then McCarthy or Barry drop back as a 3rd defender.

So whilst I'm very pleased that James is getting all this well earned praise I think people need to maybe lower their expectation of what he can bring to the table. If we start looking for him to push forward and maybe lose possession will we then be caught out at the back. Personally I think we've got the 2nd best defensive record of the league because of where and how he plays and having Gareth Barry next to him has really helped him settle into his new team like he's always been here. Well done Roberto and Co for doing so well in the transfer window. Hopefully you will have a super striker lined up for Jan if we are serious about competing for 4th place or the FA cup.

CiarĂƒÂ¡n McGlone
47 Posted 10/12/2013 at 11:50:55
If you don't think McCarthy's an aggressive footballer then you haven't been watching him properly...

Remind me, why's he not playing on Saturday?

Raymond Fox
48 Posted 10/12/2013 at 11:33:50
Blowing my own trumpet somewhat hear!
I said when most were complaining that the price was too much that I'd seen him play a few times (full matches) and he reminded me of Alan Ball a lot, his tremendous work rate was Balls biggest asset also, same build, size etc.
He needs to add a few goals to his MO to be as good as Alan was, but he should be able to improve his finishing, he's only 22.
As far as our manager signing the 3 Wigan players, he should know what they can do he was their manager for 1yr+.

I'll wager that Kone and Alcaraz will also prove to be worth what RM has spent on them in transfers and wages, they have just been unlucky with injuries which couldn't be foreseen.

Sean Kelly
49 Posted 10/12/2013 at 11:21:48
For those of you non-McCarthy believers out there, just take note of what we will be missing against Fulham.
Michael Kenrick
50 Posted 10/12/2013 at 14:49:40
No problem... we'll have Ossie.
Brian Garside
52 Posted 10/12/2013 at 21:41:40
He reminds me more of Peter Reid than Paul Bracewell. Still, to be compared to those two class acts is indeed impressive.
David Ellis
53 Posted 11/12/2013 at 07:27:20
Brian - yes Reid was always there as an option to receive the short pass and was an effective ball winner. But not sure he covered anything like as much ground as McCarthy (and was perhaps a bit more skillful) - McCarthy is a sort of Bracewell/Reid hybrid. Not better than either, but having some of the qualities of each.
Anto Byrne
55 Posted 11/12/2013 at 07:49:04
I still reckon Jelavic can do a job upfront with Lukaku. We are playing with a lot of confidence and RM won't have him running the channels, tracking back and looking lost. If he can regain that one-touch finish, I reckon we would be one hell of a force.
Sam Hoare
56 Posted 11/12/2013 at 07:57:43
I really wanted McCarthy here and although I thought they did overcharge us a bit he is already making it look like good business.

He's not often flashy but he doesn't need to be. He often wins the ball and rarely loses it, moving it along quickly and efficiently. He could do with a tad more confidence and occasionally, when right, attempting the trickier passes that might open up a defence but at 22 he has time on his side.

Let's really hope that him and Barkley will be dominating the centre of the park in blue for a long time to come. I suspect we will need Champions League football to make that so.

Kevin Jones
57 Posted 11/12/2013 at 09:09:30
To be honest I don't think James is an "unsung hero". As far as I can see, we praise the lad week-in & week-out, and if the so-called "experts" don't recognise that, then that's only to be expected from so-called "experts" So far he's been my Player of the Season. I know we've had a lot of good performers this season, and I include Tim Howard in that (something I thought I'd never say).

But James has been a consistent 8 in all the games I've been to our seen on TV, long may it continue. It'll be interesting to see what Roberto does on Saturday, when I saw the team against Stoke I was surprised, but what a result. I think most of us now trust Roberto 100% to get it right.

Nick Taylor
58 Posted 11/12/2013 at 10:42:34
I agree with Peter Bell, McCarthy bears a striking resemblance to Bracewell. I just hope he has more luck with injuries given the intensity of his approach.


Iain Johnston
59 Posted 11/12/2013 at 10:49:43
James Martin... Fuck me! That post is like the speech in Independence Day!.
Quality mate!
Harold Matthews
60 Posted 11/12/2013 at 12:33:15
Great movie.
Brian Furey
61 Posted 11/12/2013 at 14:18:14
CiarĂ n 330. Did you not read what I wrote carefully? I said "he's much more shy and not an aggressive dominant person. Yes, he can make some crunching tackles and works his ass off every game."

Yes, he makes loads of tough aggressive tackles and that's why he gets so many yellow cards but what I was trying to say was that I don't think he's an aggressive personality like Roy was. He's not going around shouting at people to do their job better or bossing the whole midfield area. He gets on with his job quietly and efficiently without much fuss.

Maybe it will come later but he's not a natural leader, I suppose. The first time I saw Roy play was in an international and I was amazed how many 40/60 tackles he was winning.

It will be interested to see how much Barry misses him this weekend. What's the longest a player has gone through a season unbeaten?

Ray Roche
62 Posted 11/12/2013 at 14:59:38
This is Roy Keane, a cowardly shithouse, he would fill his kecks if he came anywhere near a Tony Kay, Johnny Morrisey or Duncan Ferguson, but trying to maim Neil Pointin is his level.


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cuyw7zWgKOQ
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=p_st29mlQwU

Jamie Crowley
63 Posted 11/12/2013 at 17:16:11
Ray -

First tackle was a red. Simple. Pretty dirty challenge.

Second link - the one on that Halland fellow... Yep, no problem with that whatsoever. When I played hockey, you "got his number" - meaning if you were hit in the back at the boards, slashed, ran, whatever... You checked for the guy's number and you didn't forget it.

Keane "got his number" and enacted a level of revenge I've no issue with whatsoever. Dude (Halland) was a shithouse of the highest order standing over him and saying whatever unpleasantries and crap he did. If you hurt someone, shouldn't you check to see if he's ok? Rhetorical question...

I generally detest the small man-parts fella who's a cheap shot. I class the Keane-Halland incident much differently.

Cowardly? No. Simply taking umbrage to bullshit and taking matters into his own hands to let the world know they'd best not ever do that again.

If McCarthy was tackled and went down, and then the perpetrator stood over him and told him he was a fake and a pussy; would you be up in arms if James went in knee high on the unsporting fuck sometime in the future?

Take this with a grain of salt as I'm a proponent of letting the guys drop the gloves to settle things.

Jamie Barlow
64 Posted 11/12/2013 at 18:17:54
Bollocks Jamie. Premeditating seriously injuring another professional footballer is a shithouse trick. Settling your issues by throwing your gloves down and having it toe to toe is fine. Keanes a supposedly big hard man. He could have settled it another way. Total c**t for doing what he did.
Ray Roche
65 Posted 11/12/2013 at 18:24:19
Jamie Crowley, Keane is a cowardly, snidey little shit. It wasn't a case of "getting his number", I have no problem with that, hitting someone hard but (nearly) fair or sticking the nut on someone without the ref seeing it (wouldn't happen nowadays with the cameras everywhere) but Keane injured himself trying to get Halland in the first instance which is why Halland was so pissed off with Keane who was lying on the floor injured, an injury which was self imposed. Halland was not "a shithouse of the highest order standing over him and saying whatever unpleasantries and crap he did. If you hurt someone, shouldn't you check to see if he's ok?" But to try and seriously injure Halland in that manner is just not on. I repeat, Keane didn't have the balls to take real hard man on, preferring to smack players who were not up for it.
Mark Taylor
66 Posted 11/12/2013 at 20:04:08
McCarthy has made a very good start.

I loathe Keane, a truly evil shit....

Jamie Crowley
67 Posted 11/12/2013 at 20:13:04
Jamie and Ray -

If someone celebrates you being injured and gets up in your mug while you're injured, I have no issue with premeditated retribution.

Now here's the thing, and to Ray's point... I have only seen YouTube clips of the incident. As I mentioned, this was done before I followed the game. If Keane actually tried to injure Halland, failed to do so, and hurt himself, I'd retract my initial stance. In the clips I've seen, I only see Keane attempting to "cross behind" Halland, getting tangled up, going down and doing something that clearly left him in pain while Halland leaned over him and gave him an earful.

In short, if he was trying to injure Halland at the first instance, than I agree - he has no right whatsoever to come back and lay him out. If however it was a physical coming together that left him down and out and Halland has the words in his ear - Keane in my opinion can exact some retribution, premeditated at that, for a horrible display of sportsmanship by a fellow professional.

If it's the second situation, Keane's not a c**t, not cowardly, and not out of line. If it were me the guy would be hobbling off the next time I laid eyes on him.

Note - this sounds very "tough guy" and I really can't emphasize enough how much I detest that type of person. I did play hockey but weigh in at 150 lbs and stand 5'11" tall. Not a big man by any means and certainly not the type of person who runs around very sophomorically picking fights in the name of manhood. All hockey ever taught me is not to back down and don't take crap. I was on the bad end of many skirmishes more often than not... Rarely "won" a fight.

But I just see all the justification in the world for Keane (again if he wasn't "in the wrong" initially) to "get his number" and "even the score".

How many cliches can you place in quotation marks in a post?

I do understand and dare I say respect both yours (Jamie and Ray's) comments. No matter what the situation, you clearly have an ability to take a much higher road than I.

But if I got hurt and someone leaned over me and talked smack, I'd get even. Even if it was in a cheap fashion by a skinny dude like myself, you almost have to. You really shouldn't take that.

Ray Roche
68 Posted 11/12/2013 at 21:24:27
To be fair to Halland, Jamie, it wasn't clear at that time if Keane was badly injured or not when he bent down and gave him a mouthful , but it does serve him right, injuring himself as he tried to get Halland. Having watched Everton since 1959 I've seen how the game has changed, what was considered a hard tackle in my youth will now have a player red carded, or put against a wall and shot. I don't necessarily agree with the "wimping up" of our national sport but there is a line to be drawn and Keane crossed it.
Gerry Western
69 Posted 11/12/2013 at 22:21:56
Mc Carthy has proved to be an excellent acquisition and well worth his transfer fee. Attempts to justify his worth by seeking to malign the contribution of Fellaini are simply ludicrous as Fellaini was more often than not required to play a different role to that of Mc Carthy hence why Mc Carthy's goals contribution is much less, hardly rocket science. Equally judgements arrived at in favour of Mc Carthy are equally flawed as Mc Carthy has the likes of Barkley & Barry to play alongside him whereas Fellaini was lumbered with Neville and/or Osman. Hardly surprising that the one game this season where we were comprehensively outplayed in the middle of the park was at Eastlands. On that occasion Mc Carthy was partnered by Osman who was hooked early in the second half and replaced by a half fit Gibson. Consequently, conclusions arrived at are well wide of the mark.

Added to this was the Moyes factor, I'd rather not elaborate but suffice to say that almost every member of the squad has raised their game since he departed. Fellaini was a superb signing and played a huge role for the club. Mc Carthy has come in and done an excellent job since his arrival and will eventually become a truly outstanding player for the club. Both parties are excellent players and have earned the respect of the fans.

Neil Cremin
70 Posted 12/12/2013 at 19:13:13
What makes me laugh with you regulars is that nearly all of you a few months back were slating Martinez for buying McCarthy. He is a class act, always has been, has kept Wigan in the Premier League almost single handedly. We got a bargain.


Now as for Martinez, the jury is still out. At present, he has had a successful season as we are only 13 points away from safety. He is making all the right moves to improve the strength in depth of our squad by rotating Barkley and Mirallas with Osman and Deulofeu. The real test is whether he can bring us to the next level by shoring up our ageing defence. The January transfer window will tell a lot.


Don't forget in Moyes era we would have been disappointed not to be in our current position (still too many dropped points from draws). The next two months will determine Martinez's credentials but somehow I believe he will deliver.

Ian Bennett
72 Posted 12/12/2013 at 19:31:08
He was always the best player for me at Wigan. Very unsung from a lack of goals or assists, so was never a Match of the day player hyped to the extreme (does shit all, but the odd fancy flick and a couple of goals -cough Young, Cleverly etc). But if you watched him he influenced Wigan games even though pretty young. I think others also got confused with Mcarthur who also played midfield/moved down from Scotland.

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads

© ToffeeWeb