Is Everton for real?

, 13 December, 33comments  |  Jump to most recent
Supplemented by some interesting heat maps, Mike Goodman looks at how Everton have changed under Roberto Martinez and argues that the next four League games are crucial to answering the question of whether or not they are the real deal this season.

» Read the full article at Grantland



Reader Comments (33)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Colin Wainwright
1 Posted 13/12/2013 at 21:24:36
To fuckin' right we are.
Dave Lynch
2 Posted 13/12/2013 at 21:45:28
They don't want us to be the real deal.

It would upset the media darlings across the park, so fuck the lot of em.

Gerry Morrison
3 Posted 13/12/2013 at 22:16:07
Is Everton for real? or in English: Are Everton for real?
Gareth Lucy
4 Posted 13/12/2013 at 22:51:52
Gerry, sorry to piss on your chips but the title is correct - Is Everton for real?

Everton is a club, which is one entity. Therefore you would say 'is' not 'are'

You would say 'are Evertonians for real' because that is a collection of entities, but Everton is just one.

English lesson of the day. You're welcome.

Gerry Morrison
5 Posted 13/12/2013 at 23:04:01
Gareth, are you for real?
Try singing "Everton is magic, Liverpool is tragic."
You're welcome.
Roberto Birquet
10 Posted 13/12/2013 at 23:33:04
Group entities can be written singular (Government is) or plural (Government are). But in football, we always use plural. Everton are the champions (we can always dream)!

But Americans use the singular: Everton is the champion!

...
but we are for real!!!

Gerry Morrison
11 Posted 13/12/2013 at 23:40:56
Roberto,
Looks like you have unearthed an American. Nothing wrong with that of course. It is just that there are different rules in Walton and Washington.
Paul Ferry
12 Posted 13/12/2013 at 23:40:44
You gotta think that a fella with a name like Roberto Birquet has got to know his grammar! Sounds very bookish. Fecking Irish Christian Brothers and poisoned Ursuline nuns drilled grammar into me and so I take grammatical slip-ups to be tokens of rebellion and sedition and am all in favour of them. For what it's worth I think that Professor Birquet has hit the grammatical nail on the head. We must now regroup and move on.

And yes Everton are most definitely for real if only because bookisk Birquet said so!

Gareth Lucy
13 Posted 13/12/2013 at 23:42:09
Fur enuff Roberto.

And yes I agree, we are for real! I've never seen us play like this. I had goosebumps against the gooners.

Antony Matthews
15 Posted 14/12/2013 at 07:02:58
When I first saw the headline I thought Bill Kenwright was after changing our name to Real Everton FC.! What would the supporters think if a new owner was found and he decided to start tinkering with the name like Hull City's new owner is trying to do? Maybe we could open this up on a new thread. If Everton needed to compete with the big boys would we welcome a change to REAL EVERTON or would it be all out war against a new owner. Hull City fans must be in despair because without this new guys money they probably wouldnt be in the premiership.
Chris Williamson
16 Posted 14/12/2013 at 07:58:22
Interesting grammatical skirmish, however, nobody has yet commented on the phrase "for real".

It's the same common error as "for free". 'Free' and 'real' , being adjectives, should not follow the word 'for' any more than you would say "this apple is for green".

Hence the phrase should be "are everton real?".

The history books, the crowds, fans and players suggest so. The media seem to pretend we are not, but it is becoming harder for them to do so.

Are any of us real?

Brin Williams
17 Posted 14/12/2013 at 08:05:37
Many are real but not all are realistic.

Brin Williams
18 Posted 14/12/2013 at 08:13:40
Everton IS a place
Liverpool IS a City
Everton IS a Footy Club
Liverpool IS a FC (but not in Everton's class)
Everton ARE a team
Liverpool ARE a (one man) team
Everton ARE Phenomenal
Liverpool ARE Shite
Anthony Flack
19 Posted 14/12/2013 at 08:45:35
R5 pissed me off yesterday by describing top 4 being between Chelsea Arsenal Man City and One of Liverpool or Spurs, with the one missing out 5th. No mention of us at all.
Anthony Flack
20 Posted 14/12/2013 at 08:54:24
Then again Savage has us for 4th on the BBC website. 10 points from next 4 games has us 3rd in my mini mental forecast.

Chris James
21 Posted 14/12/2013 at 08:54:57
I really don't think that's a bad thing Anthony. The more we stay under the media's radar, the better. The truth is we could, probably should actually be 2nd in the league now. Indeed with a bit more luck in any of our first 3 games (Norwich was especially tough), some defensive organisation against Liverpool (should have stopped at least 2 of their goals) and having properly gone for it at Palace we could be 4-6 points better off and waiting for Arsenal to trip up.

We really are playing amazing stuff, CL-qualifying stuff, title-challenging stuff even. If we can keep playing that way (without fear, with possession) then there's no reason we shouldn't be in the mix for everything come May. Of course that is a big IF and the same one that dogs all teams - can we maintain somewhere near our highest form when tiredness, injuries and the real pressure of the run-in come along.

I genuinely don't know the answer to that. Historically (under OFM) we've actually coped better than most in the second half, recovering from an often weak start to the season. If we've maintained similar fitness levels they should be even more telling this year now we're no longer spending most of matches chasing the ball. Likewise it does seem that for once there must be a little cash in the kitty to strengthen in January and a manager who's not afraid to use it.

One thing I do know for sure, is that for once I'm looking forward to every game and feeling we can play great football and win. So bring on Fulham today for our latest test. COYB!!!

Chris James
22 Posted 14/12/2013 at 08:54:57
I really don't think that's a bad thing Anthony. The more we stay under the media's radar, the better. The truth is we could, probably should actually be 2nd in the league now. Indeed with a bit more luck in any of our first 3 games (Norwich was especially tough), some defensive organisation against Liverpool (should have stopped at least 2 of their goals) and having properly gone for it at Palace we could be 4-6 points better off and waiting for Arsenal to trip up.

We really are playing amazing stuff, CL-qualifying stuff, title-challenging stuff even. If we can keep playing that way (without fear, with possession) then there's no reason we shouldn't be in the mix for everything come May. Of course that is a big IF and the same one that dogs all teams - can we maintain somewhere near our highest form when tiredness, injuries and the real pressure of the run-in come along.

I genuinely don't know the answer to that. Historically (under OFM) we've actually coped better than most in the second half, recovering from an often weak start to the season. If we've maintained similar fitness levels they should be even more telling this year now we're no longer spending most of matches chasing the ball. Likewise it does seem that for once there must be a little cash in the kitty to strengthen in January and a manager who's not afraid to use it.

One thing I do know for sure, is that for once I'm looking forward to every game and feeling we can play great football and win. So bring on Fulham today for our latest test. COYB!!!

Gerard Carey
24 Posted 14/12/2013 at 09:21:14
Is we is or is we aint for real??!!, WE will know for real if the board dip in to funds for the January window. Then it will show that its not only the fans that believe. And a few extra bob to send us fans to grammar school!!!.
Ron Sear
25 Posted 14/12/2013 at 09:35:59
Amazing, I wonder how many football clubs have their fans arguing about the finer points of English grammar. like it makes you fink like
Brin Williams
26 Posted 14/12/2013 at 10:14:05
'I wonder how many football clubs have their fans arguing about the finer points of English grammar'

Never mind the finer points of English Grammar - these fans are steeped in Latin la' Nil Satis is in their blood or should that be are in there blud?

Mick Davies
29 Posted 14/12/2013 at 14:14:35
Antony Matthews, our club has been Everton for nearly a century and a half and the moment we start changing things for publicity is the day we sell our soul.

The 'Real' in Spanish football is Royal in English, so playing in Royal blue would be tempting but a) we are not Spanish and b) there are Evertonians who are democratic republicans who wouldn't like the club associated with royalty.

There are dozens of topics to discuss this season but changing the name of our beloved club should never be even suggested

Albert Crocker
31 Posted 14/12/2013 at 15:37:07
As a regular reader of the New York Times this practice of calling teams 'it' really grates with me.

Ask yourself this: if someone asked you how Everton were doing during a match would you really say " Everton is two up at half time".

If someone enquired about the cricket down under would your reply be that "England is chasing the Aussies 1,000,487 for two (declared)?

I think not.

As far as teams go it is the obvious plural that dictates the pronoun.

Paul Johnson
33 Posted 14/12/2013 at 20:23:59
Fuck grammar — we are for real!!!
Paul Day
34 Posted 14/12/2013 at 21:01:23
Is or are, ifs or buts. One thing is for sure: but for some drawn games early this season Everton would be top. Reality COYB.
Julian Wait
35 Posted 15/12/2013 at 03:52:58
Redshitus ite domum!

(I watched Life of Brian last night with the now 12-year-old ... he just doesn't get the Latin teacher joke .... )

Chris Matheson
37 Posted 15/12/2013 at 20:31:29
And this thread is the reason why I love ToffeeWeb so much. Well one of the reasons.

................

Steve Pugh
38 Posted 16/12/2013 at 12:59:31
I'd just like to say that it's a really good article and pretty much mirrors what a lot of us think.
David Ellis
39 Posted 19/12/2013 at 06:32:33
Meanwhile the Guardian is arguing that Everton won't finish top 4 because the 4 teams above us have all won 10 games to our eight. Er...yes, but the other side of the coin is that we have lost fewer games than any of them...that's why the points system was invented to give due value to wins, draws and losses, focussing on any one of these gives a jaundiced view.

It then goes on to say that Everton would need to do well against the other big 7, er... we have already played them all and come out on top so far.

It then goes onto list Man U's next 3 fixtures and suggest that as they are all winnable they will be in the mix in 3 days time, but no reference to our equally winnable next 6 fixtures.

We may not finish top 4, but if we don't it will be because we lose form or run into injury issues, these other arguments are tosh to support a pre-conceived view. Perception still lags reality.

Paul Andrews
40 Posted 19/12/2013 at 06:49:39
David Ellis,

We are the fly in the ointment. They are used to the usual suspects involved season after season. The pecking order has become the norm, with even our own people perpetuating the myth that we can't gatecrash the party.

Just keep winning the games; if we maintain our current points ratio, we will be there or thereabouts.

Tommy Coleman
42 Posted 19/12/2013 at 08:18:41
Ha ha. Best England lesson I've ever had.

We are not contesting 4th, we are chasing the title.

COYB.

Tony Draper
43 Posted 20/12/2013 at 17:33:46
Really enjoyed the original view of Everton, journalistic style quite different from what I is used to here innit ?

This season is the most open and competitive possibly since the Premier League was formed

And Spurs just threw their hand in by sacking AVB, what a shame that Vincent Tan didn't take over our cheeky scamp neighbours !

Dennis Ng
44 Posted 23/12/2013 at 18:17:49
We don't have the wage bill to be the soap opera the media needs. Look at Athletico Madird. I reckon we can do the same if not better. But we need to keep our heads down and keep working with optimism. I always felt we were good enough for top 4, just OFM putting our heads down too low!
Mike Green
45 Posted 23/12/2013 at 18:23:08
Everton always was, are, and always was be.

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads

© ToffeeWeb