Everton seen as 'perfect step up' for Continental talent

, 18 December, 126comments  |  Jump to most recent
European clubs contact Martinez following loan successes

Roberto Martinez says that the success of Everton's summer loan acquisitions is prompting calls from European clubs seeking to farm their emerging talent out to Goodison Park.

The significant role played by Gerard Deulofeu and Romelu Lukaku in the Blues' season thus far and the impact they are having in what is arguably Europe's toughest league has caught the eye of some of the Continent's biggest clubs who see Everton as a place to broaden the experience of their young players with Premier League football under the guidance of the Spanish manager.

"Clubs have been offering us players," Martinez says in The Guardian. "They have seen the other loanees and how well they have been looked after.

"It hasn't happened with the clubs in the UK but it has happened from abroad. We have had phone calls from clubs asking about taking their players for next season. They see it as a perfect step up in their career."

Martinez sees the logic in their thinking. "Put yourself as a director of football," he continues. "You spend £20m on a youngster but there is no place for him in your team yet. Where are you going to send him? You aren't going to send him somewhere that he is not going to develop or be at a club with a different style. That's a danger. You are not bothered about making the team, you are sending him to get stronger.

"When you have got a big investment, you cannot give it away easily. I think that you want to make sure that the next step is the right one for a player's development.

Teams that have got great investments for their squads will want them to come to Everton rather than elsewhere. That is a compliment. And it is something that is very important for us."

Martinez's comments will no doubt prolong the debate over the loan system in the Premier League, particularly as it pertains to loan players — like Lukaku — assisting their parent clubs by taking points off their rivals, and add fuel to churlish assertion from some quarters that Everton are somehow gaming a system that is the same for all clubs.

"Chelsea are delighted with Romelu," Martinez says. "He can't play against them. The other week he helped take two points off Arsenal, three points off United. That is the way you are looking at it [if you are Chelsea]. It is perfect for them.

"You are not going to stop every team but if you can stop your rivals then you are doing well."

 

Reader Comments (126)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Mike Gaynes
1 Posted 18/12/2013 at 06:31:36
Just curious.... has anyone ever tried to build a Champions League team on a year-in-and-year-out loan strategy? Is it possible that given his limited budget for purchases and his apparently unlimited relationships with loan-minded Euro clubs, Roberto is actually going to use this as an ongoing business model?

It would certainly be an imaginative approach.

Terry Murphy
2 Posted 18/12/2013 at 06:47:24
Said it all before... I loathe the loan system. If every team had a squad limit all these young players who couldn't make their own squads would be released. Other teams could then take them on on a Bosman. If the original club wanted to buy them back later then they would have to pay the proper market rates. Thus spreading the talent and the wealth around. Squad limits are the only way to address this issue imho.
Brett Jonathan
3 Posted 18/12/2013 at 05:55:49
Pretty sure Premier League clubs can only have a maximum of 4 loan players a year, so makes it difficult to build a year in/year out team.

Imaginative approach maybe, actually possible, unfortunately not Mike.

Kevin Rowlands
4 Posted 18/12/2013 at 05:57:18
Truth is, every player is on loan these days, all clubs basically loan them from their greedy management/agent set up until they decide pastures are greener and money is better elsewhere. It doesn't matter if they sign a five year contract these days, they have a great year and all of a sudden they become transfer speculation, gone are the days of loyalty, its cash in when you can, that's when I laugh when other fans call us Everloan, anyone think the rat is going to be at the RS next season? no chance.
My advice, don't ever buy a shirt with a players name on it, you never know when they're moving on.
Mike Gaynes
5 Posted 18/12/2013 at 06:16:32
Brett (292), obviously four players can have a hell of an impact, particularly in a chronically shorthanded squad like ours. We started three against Fulham, and we wouldn't be anywhere close to where we are now without Barry and Lukaku. I wouldn't put it past Roberto to try this.

But Kevin (293) is right, everybody's on loan. The only named shirt I saw in SF when our guys were here last summer was a fellow in the bar who was wearing a Magaye #19. Not much cachet, but it least it has lasted three years.

Albert Perkins
6 Posted 18/12/2013 at 06:17:41
Roberto seems to have an imaginative way of working the system and making it work for us. He is the conjurer, ever pulling the rabbit out of the hat, with a beaming smile. He plays magnificently to his strengths and is always surfing ahead of the wave. The silver tongued Spaniard is such a breath of fresh air, and I'm breathing deeply.
Lewis Barclay
7 Posted 18/12/2013 at 07:23:20
Excuse my cynicism but this looks like a god PR move that explains why we'll only be getting one loan signing come January and maybe ship out two perm players (Heitinga and Jelavic?).
Are aloud two or more loans coming in on Jan, I count three already at the club.

I think RM is doing a fantastic job and applaud more loans like the three who came in in the summer.
I don't think it will work consistently season to season.
Maybe it might get us in the CL and then the strategy will change.

Lewis Barclay
8 Posted 18/12/2013 at 07:30:59
Crikey Albert don't go down the tattoo parlour just yet.
Kevin Day
9 Posted 18/12/2013 at 07:33:00
If Barry signs a pre contract in January, would he still be regarded as a loan player? If not this would allow a further 2 for our top 4 push.
Tom Dodds
10 Posted 18/12/2013 at 07:20:11
There are two repercussions with this strategy:

1. And the most important drawback, is you'd give Kenwright a new 'box canyon' to save/sky (sic) away funds on permanent players.

2. Now every other young-minded manager in other clubs will immediately put their "we do loanees too" adverts in their shop window.

I'm sure it will work for a while, though... and, yes, it's working this season... and, yes, Martinez is probably revered more than most other managers, at the moment. But, like I said, and from now on in, let us all keep one eye on the transfer kitty fund.

Kevin Tully
11 Posted 18/12/2013 at 08:17:43
I don't know whether to feel embarrassed that our great club is looking in the bin for scraps, or be happy that our bright young manager has clubs ringing him to nurture their young talent.

When I'm watching Deulofeu, I'm not thinking he is a loanee from Barca, he's a blue when he's on the pitch.

You watch though, if we manage to be successful at the expense of one of the rich clubs, they will soon change the system. Wouldn't it be ironic if Lukaku put us in the C.L. at the expense of Chelsea? How foolish would the special one look then?

Robin Cannon
12 Posted 18/12/2013 at 08:19:16
"You spend £20m on a youngster but there is no place for him in your team yet. Where are you going to send him?"

Kind of highlights a major problem with football today.

Although I know that RM can only work within the existing system, and he's working it as well as he can, whole piece smacked too much of "plucky little Everton are a good feeder/training club for the big boys"; which is not a situation we should ever be satisfied with.

Phil Sammon
13 Posted 18/12/2013 at 08:35:21
Squad limits have to be looked at. But then you'd get clubs like Chelsea who would simply fund a feeder club to 'store' all their young talent. It really needs addressing though.

That said, while the system is like it is we are right to exploit it. I want us to get right back to the top. If it means we get a Deulofeu or a Lukaku every year then I'm fine with that. It's nice to see fresh talent on the pitch with ambitions of being world class players. It may also increase our exposure across Europe. I know I always look out for the teams where our lads are on loan.

Paul Mackie
14 Posted 18/12/2013 at 08:58:16
The good thing about having a manager like Martinez with a "philosophy" is that the actual players themselves are largely interchangeable. This means that if clubs across Europe are throwing their players at us then he's in a good position to pick and choose the most suitable ones and fit them nicely into the team.

Until we reach the promised land of the CL on a regular basis, loan players are going to be a means to an end for a club that has been out of the big money since Sky invented football. I don't like the loan system but it sounds like we have a manager who can take advantage of it even better than Moyes ever did.

Wayne Smyth
15 Posted 18/12/2013 at 09:10:44
The system whereby rich clubs hoover up all the best young talent is rotten; then again how many of us would think twice to taking on two or three of the youngsters from Dundee Utd we've been linked with and loaned them back to them for next season?

I'm glad we have a manager who is able and willing to work the system in our favour and get us players who actually improve us rather than bench warmers to make up the numbers.

What we need for now are one or two players of the quality to fire us into a top 4 place, after the money starts coming in we can think about attracting and paying for some of the top quality players we're going to need to stay there.

Craig Fletcher
16 Posted 18/12/2013 at 09:13:50
The thing is, haven't we also exploited the loan system in farming out our own young players so they can get exposure? Barkley last season is the most recent example I can think of. Going back further, Osman broke into our first team after a successful loan period at Derby. Swings and roundabouts. As Phil (305) said, while the system is like it is, we are right to exploit it.
Colin Glassar
17 Posted 18/12/2013 at 09:14:35
I agree with Terry Murphy, the loan system should be scrapped. If rich teams want to accumulate young talented players to spite their rivals without playing them, then so be it. We shouldn't be an escape valve, even though it benefits us, to develop their players.

If the system was scrapped, the likes of Zaha, Lukaku, Moses etc...wouldn't either join or want to stay at their parent clubs and this would give us the chance to keep and develop our own young players.

Wayne Smyth
18 Posted 18/12/2013 at 09:23:36
Craig, I think there is a slight difference between the Barkley/Osman situation whereby we actually developed them through our academy then loaned them out, as opposed to buying up the most promising players en-masse when they're already mostly developed and having no-where for them to go, then loaning them out as has happened with Lukaku.

Colin Glassar
19 Posted 18/12/2013 at 09:28:38
So basically, he is also admitting that we are a feeder club for the rich and powerful. Not sure I like this.
Sam Hoare
20 Posted 18/12/2013 at 09:27:42
One problem is that we depend upon being able to sell players in order to find money for the transfer kitty. If we are spending alot of money on loans (and they are not cheap) then we are essentially bringing in far less saleable assets to the club. It puts alot of pressure on the youth team to keep producing but maybe that is something Martinez has faith in.

Wayne Smyth
21 Posted 18/12/2013 at 09:33:33
Sam, I'm not sure the loans do work out that expensive.

We've paid £3m for Lukaku who is rated at £20M+. We also pay his wages which are probably about £60k. For that we have use of a top quality striker for 1 year.

If we had signed him permanently on a 5 year contract for £20M on the same wages, we'd have had to take a depreciation hit of £4M / season, with no guarantee that he'd walk out for nothing at the end of it, or that he'd actually justify that investment. There are lots of players in the £20M+ bracket who have turned out to be poor value.

In terms of Barry, I understand there was no fee involved but we pay a large portion of his huge wages(£70k / week?). For what we've got so far I actually think we've had very, very good value from that deal. Barry has been an integral member of the squad and adds important experience and solidity to the centre of our midfield. He's also available for free at the end of the season and is likely to want to stay with us.

What I will say is that it can be disruptive to the team to have new people coming in every year who are gone after 8 months and aren't settling in the area....and obviously each loan we get in and each player we develop is a spot less for one of our own academy players to compete for.

This is why I'm absolutely in favour of Roberto's use of the loan system to add players of quality we could never have bought outright. Players who will walk into our team. What I don't want to see is bench warmers like McFadden and Straq who were adding nothing but numbers. For me, that is what our youth team is for.

Craig Fletcher
22 Posted 18/12/2013 at 09:37:20
Point taken Wayne. Makes you wonder....it must get discouraging for a youngster like Lukaku to go from signing for a club in the Champions League, seemingly fulfilling his ambitions, to immediately be farmed out to other clubs. Surely can't be an ideal situation, especially for a young lad in a foreign country.
Pablo Connelly
23 Posted 18/12/2013 at 09:39:51
Its difficult to criticise Martinez. He doesn't have the funds to bring these players in permanently so he is doing what he can and results/performances have been excellent as a result. His comments still leave an uneasy feeling for me though. This interview is basically a sales pitch to the top 10/15 rich clubs that Everton is a short term development tool to help them achieve their long term goals. There is an acceptance in what he is saying that we have no ambition to take these sort of players with a view to buy and therefore a guarantee that we will never have them at the peak of their powers. Like I said though I am not going to criticise him because I certainly don't have a better idea of how else Everton can bring the sort of players that can dominate consecutive games at OT and the Emirates, I just think this brings home a bit of reality.
Patrick Murphy
24 Posted 18/12/2013 at 09:52:07
I dislike the loan system and I dislike the fact we can't afford to buy our own players - but we as a club that has to get players on the park who are good enough to challenge at the top end and that means exploiting the current system to our advantage.

One possible way of curtailing the number of players in a clubs squad is to to have a rule whereby a player who has cost the buying club £10m or more they cannot be loaned out to another club. Loaning youngsters out is not a problem but if they have been an expensive purchase then it is quite clearly wrong.

Ben Jones
25 Posted 18/12/2013 at 09:58:30
There are two ways of looking at this.

The first is a club of our size shouldn't keep relying on loan deals, and that is a completely reasonable view.

The second is it brings talented players to us and if it gets us successful, why not?

Me being a glass half full person, I'd say the second. Lets say in a few years, it makes us successful I.e qualify for the Champions League. That will also give us more money and we can hopefully loan less and less gradually and buy more and more.

That's the plan anyway! But it is very creative, and it's quite innovative thinking from Roberto. There's nothing saying one or two of these youngsters might want to stay too!

Nigel Gregson
26 Posted 18/12/2013 at 10:08:17
This is great - imagine the next Messi / Ronaldinho / Ibrahamovic coming to Everton first and then moving to other places.We get to pick and choose who we want as we are the best training ground - the school of science. Graduates go take over the world. A finishing school for young guns.

I think if we let go of any excessive ego, this is a brilliant way to move forward as just the publicity this generates will grow our club to the next level. Fans around the world love exciting young raw talent and we create this brand for ourselves. Its really good business.

Mike Gwyer
27 Posted 18/12/2013 at 09:26:23

If you look at this loan system a bit deeper you will see that these rich clubs are far from being in a better position than Everton.

For example Lukaku has 2 years left on his contract with Chelsea, now if he had the same contract terms at Everton we would be shitting it - Lukaku can demand exactly what terms he wants otherwise he can see out the 2 years and fuckoff for free - for me, looking at his current relationship with the chosen one, I'm guessing Lukaku is going to fuckoff for free & poking two figures as he goes. Even Rooney has under two contracted years at United and on 250K per week. You can bet he probably wants at least the same terms or, once again, he will also fuckoff for free (with numerous buyers waiting in the wings). These rich clubs have to keep stumping out the cash (and lots of it) for top players who may not even make their match day first 11 - take a look at that lot across the park who have lost fucking bundles trying to keep their squad big enough to access the EPL top 4.

We have a manager who has been able to get hold of these absolutely top players with Everton only having to cover the costs of wages and loan fees for a single season (granted, Lukaku cost around 3M but come on, 3 million for a fuckoff striker giving you around 25 goals is worth far more - higher gates, higher league position, more TV, FFS you can go on and on).

Yes we have manipulated the loan system to perfection, but to do that you need to have the right people to do it - and we have. Moyes loaned players that were total fucking shite and other than WBA, no other EPL club has perfected this system as well as Everton and maybe Remy to Newcastle.

With the rich European clubs continuing to gather young players, irrelevant of whether they will get a game, is going to get far worse - this is fantastic news for Everton's RM loan machine.

Barry Pearce
28 Posted 18/12/2013 at 10:19:22
All well, and good, but what about our own emerging talent the likes of Conor Grant, Chris Long to name but two... What – aren't they ever going to step up? Seems unlikely with this system.
Tony Waring
29 Posted 18/12/2013 at 10:30:59
I'm with Terry (291) on this aspect of the game. The wealthy clubs use financial muscle to deny talent to the less well-off. It's like the big supermarket chains who buy up all development land and hang on to it for as long as they wish, thus denying other businesses an opportunity to expand. Squads should be limited and, dare I say it, there should be a cap on foreign players. That would restore some normality to the sport.
Iain Johnston
30 Posted 18/12/2013 at 10:05:31
Did Lukaku honestly believe that when he signed for Chelsea at 18 he would be a first team player? Did he believe at 19 he would be also?

Lets not pile all the blame on the club here. If we had offered Anderlecht the same £10m and offered him 1st team football, I wager he still would have opted for Chelsea.

I think he'll be loaned out next season also, over three seasons WBA, EFC and A N Other would have financed the further £7m Chelsea have to pay for him. With 2 years left on his contract his parent club now have an experienced EPL player.. It's bloody good business and four clubs will have benefitted from his services.

I think Barry is slightly different, he knew he was surplus at City and with a year left wasn't going to feature in their squad at all. If he waited his contract out he'd be lucky to be offered £10k pw next season, this way he knows he'll probably be offered £40k for two years. Look how it's turned out for Sinclair, he waited, he's vanished.

With Roberto having close links with Barca this could give us a huge advantage with their young fringe players particularly if we can get a buy option. Imagine having 1st refusal on youngsters like Fabregas and Deulofeo after a two year loan spell?

Wayne Smyth
31 Posted 18/12/2013 at 10:35:02
Thing is Tony, until that day comes and the transfer and loan system is made "fair", do you think its right for us to take advantage of it?

Personally, I think we need to play the game in whatever way is best for the club. If getting into the top 4 in the short term requires us to give an opportunity to another teams player who is out of favour then thats what we should do.

Mark Jones
32 Posted 18/12/2013 at 10:36:40
Is Stracqualursi available in January?
Iain Johnston
33 Posted 18/12/2013 at 10:50:55
Probably Mark, I think he's off to the theatre of screams, so we're out of luck!!
Barry Rathbone
34 Posted 18/12/2013 at 10:42:19
I remember every man and his dog saying it's all about money and the season on season dross boiled down to this unassailable point.

Suggesting it was the manager's job to deal with it and find a way was met with flaming torches and pitchforks by the visionless - well done Roberto for spectacularly proving the point.

Plus footballers are "hot" for only a couple of years they get stale want more money and get into the" grass is greener" mentality, manipulating the loan system keeps it fresh and doesn't hold the club to ransom financially.

Lot to be said for it.

Thomas Lennon
35 Posted 18/12/2013 at 10:54:45
Its pragmatic and strongly depends on the loaned players playing in a team with the right style so that they learn the right things. It means we get good players and we see good football. Until we are all paying £70 a ticket, have a wage bill of £120 million and watching Champions League at Goodison that will do for me.
Mick Davies
36 Posted 18/12/2013 at 11:04:18
Roberto has raised the profile of EFC like no one since the 80's heyday. For 25 years this club has been trying to claw back what was criminally snatched away from us: a seat at the top table of European football. The 5 years of that unfair ban destroyed our club more than any other and the introduction of the greedy Sky PL made things even worse with clubs who were also rans in the 80's now dominating and attracting obscene amounts of wealth while we stagnated.

If we can attract the cream of European talent while building up our own squad, then why not? Man City's bench contains enough talent to challenge for the CL spots itself and if we use other club's players to increase our position and wealth, its the fault of the system. The same system that has kept us down as paupers for the last 2 decades. All I can say is, thank god we have a boss who is fighting the good fight with weapons no one has utilized to this extent, and his influence on the European stage seems to be growing immensely, and shining a spotlight on Everton like we havent seen for a generation.

Another strange benefit from the burgeoning Martinez regime is a lack of input from Boys Pen Billy; maybe hes realised that its best to leave the limelight to this amazing manager and let results talk, instead of bullshit

James Martin
37 Posted 18/12/2013 at 11:16:01
Don't mind this policy in the short term but in the long run we shouldn't be a stepping stone for anyone. Look at Barkley Coleman even Baines, there are other ways to get class talent in the team without borrowing others continuously. We are not a finishing school, we should be the final destination. What does Barkley think when Lukaku and Deulofeu go back to their 'big' clubs later? He's going to want to graduate as well. Martinez has done many good things to shed our plucky underdog image, but he needs to be careful with this one.
Ian Burns
38 Posted 18/12/2013 at 11:18:17
I have read each post on this thread with great interest and it seems by and large we are all on the same page, most unusual for any thread on TW!!

We have a terrific manager thinking his way through the system for the benefit of EFC. He doesn't have funds to play with, so he uses the system which is available to him and highlights EFC to the rest of the world by showing big European clubs are looking to us to bring on their own young players such as we are doing with Lukaku and Deulofeu.

However, therein lies the rub as Kevin - 303 - alluded to in his post.

It is a great sadness to me that EFC are seen as a stepping stone for other clubs' young players and we are resorting to boasting about our ability to bring such players to the standard required then sending them home again.

I apologise to our younger readers but I remember the pride when we were described as the Millionaires Club in the days of John Moores. I wonder what he would make of the present day situation seeing EFC as a stepping stone instead of sitting with the big boys at the top table.

Sorry to go on chaps but there is touch of sadness about this article although I recognise its immense value to today's EFC.

Mick Davies
39 Posted 18/12/2013 at 11:35:12
Ian Burns, cant you see that a player with something to prove to his parent club is going to give 100% to show what they're missing, and knowing it could be his big chance to upstage the competition (Lukaku is a glaring example). If that player does well, we've benefited, if not, we send him back and we've lost nothing. in the meanwhile these players could get us into the Champions League where we'll receive vast amounts of money to be able to invest in our own players; it's a no brainer
Mat Smith
40 Posted 18/12/2013 at 11:34:32
I think it's a great idea - like others have pointed out we get the pick of Europe's brightest young stars - get them in on similar deals to the one with Barca for Gerard and we only pay when he doesn't play. And look how he's turning out - the prospect of also getting to extend the loan for another year really excites me!

If this took off it could really take the pressure of Martinez when it comes to bringing players in as it would allow him to spend what little money we do have each year on the main areas that need improving whilst getting good youngsters in to bulk up the squad - would also be worth trying to get a clause added in
which gives us first refusal if the parent club decides to sell

Kunal Desai
41 Posted 18/12/2013 at 11:36:33
Maybe Martinez can go back to Barcelona or even Real Madrid and ask for more of there 'B' team players.
Kevin Tully
44 Posted 18/12/2013 at 11:51:44
One of the advantages of the richer clubs bringing youngsters in from all over the world, is that local talent is often overlooked.

When you think of the gems that the dark side have unearthed (mostly boyhood blues!) then you realise there are young world class players on our doorstep. Junior scouting has let us down in the past, although we have had a few come through our academy. I'm sure we can find a few more.

Hopefully Martinez is taking an interest in our younger players, but it's the junior scouts that bring them to the club in the first place.

Tony J Williams
45 Posted 18/12/2013 at 12:17:53
Sounds good to me, I don't see it as a jab at Everton, more as we have been noticed again and teams want their future stars to get game time with a good team in a better league.

Bring it on I say

Brian Harrison
46 Posted 18/12/2013 at 12:11:04
I don't think Premiership clubs should be allowed to take in loan players, the idea originally was for young players who couldn't get a game with a Premiership club to be loaned to a club in a lower division. But seeing as we are acting within the current rules then why not take advantage of the system, I think our 3 loan players are exceptional and maybe clubs who haven't been as successful as we have are feeling a bit irked especially the other lot.
Who themselves have used the loan system this season.

Obviously top European clubs have seen how RM has looked after the players on loan, and our style of play is very similar to most top European clubs so it makes sense for them to send their best youngsters to us. I know some posters have moaned about us being used as a stepping stone, but seeing as we would have no chance of purchasing these players on the open market what a clever way of allowing us to compete for a Champions league spot without needing to spend huge amounts of money.

Nicholas Page
47 Posted 18/12/2013 at 12:32:51
We won't get in the CL, even if we finish fourth. Quite simply, we are not allowed
Ross Edwards
48 Posted 18/12/2013 at 12:32:49
Why not? I don't see why James Martin, there is a problem with this. We need to become wider known in Europe and helping clubs to bring through talent will benefit us greatly in that regard.

Imagine it, us signing an academy link with the likes of Barca, Bayern, Real?

Exciting times indeed.

Trevor Lynes
49 Posted 18/12/2013 at 12:23:36
Strangely enough I have often complained about how many young players we have loaned out every season mainly to lower our wage bill and we have brought in very poor loan players eg; Jo from Man City and others I cannot remember. In the past we have loaned OUT far more players than we have loaned IN and consequently our squad has remained very small. We have taken lots of bench warmers like McFadden, Hahnemann and Hitzlsperger who have lowered the ability of our squad and taken the cameos they have played away from the younger players who may well have blossomed.

Now at long last we have a manager who wants to use the loan system to the benefit of our club instead of the detriment just to save money ! I welcome this new manager like a breath of fresh air, he has the 'right' approach to playing and his style will only improve the ball control and passing of the team and really entertain the fans. He has very good ideas and now he is with a club who already have the nucleus of a great side I am sure he will add the ingredients to not only achieve success but will make friends with neutrals and media alike. At the moment I am really happy with his whole demeanour and he seems to have the natural integrity to charm any remaining critics and make us more popular.

Martinez's dealings with other clubs appears spot on and if he can 'charm' other clubs into loaning him players like Deulofeu and Lukaku then I am well satisfied!

James O'Connell
50 Posted 18/12/2013 at 12:40:49
For the first time in many years I am looking forward to the January transfer window after the exceptional loan deals Martinez did last time. Permanent is better but Lukaku and Barry on deadline day was just magic and made such a change to the years of shite that had gone before.
Nick West
52 Posted 18/12/2013 at 12:58:22
The key is to get in the CL. If loan players get us there, so what? If we can get to the group stages of the CL we'll generate more cash and attract better players. Remember when we finished 4th Moyes said he was surprised at the quality of players who were interested in talking to him.

We gotta get top 4 and qualify for the group stages. That's the only thing that will move the club forward.

Steve Pugh
53 Posted 18/12/2013 at 12:35:52
The big thing here is that other clubs are asking us to develop their talent and to me that means one thing, we do not pay a fee at all, maybe even wages. We get to pick the ones that we want whilst using the money saved to strengthen the squad properly. Imagine 4 Lukaku quality players each season for free, that would free up £12m to spend on a permanent addition to the squad.
Mark Taylor
54 Posted 18/12/2013 at 12:48:18
First, just to clarify the loan system. The limit is on domestic loans. International loans are classed as transfers. So in theory, we could have a full team of loanees from abroad. This is precisely what happened with Watford in the Championship and they have just changed the rules to stop this- but in the EPL, it hasn't changed and they are apparently 'monitoring' the League's changes. On top of the international loans, you can add the domestic ones; up to 5 under certain circumstances. Feel free to correct me if I'm wrong.

Is it a good idea for us? Like a few others on here, I have mixed feelings. I think it's a good call if we accept the reality of our situation, namely we are skint (relative to the 'big' clubs) and this is a way of keeping us competitive.

However if we have ambitions to go beyond that, it isn't a long term fix. Moreover, the moment we qualify the CL, if we ever did, I imagine it would also be a strategy that would run out of road very quickly. But perhaps you could say it is a valid means to that end. Certainly our current loanees have at least helped to get us all talking about CL

I suspect this is a case of RM speaking to recognise the reality of his situation. He won't get £20m to spend in Jan (unless we sell Baines or Barkley) It's a preface to another loan or two, hopefully of the quality we have had this season, not bench fodder.

Craig Walker
55 Posted 18/12/2013 at 13:03:37
I watched 10 minutes of Sunday Supplement last Sunday. They were discussing Everton. The conversation started ominously when one of the wise journos said "Martinez has been lucky because of what he inherited". I thought "Alright. That's rubbish. The key players this season have all been either new recruits or players that OFM didn't trust but I'll continue watching".

They then spent 5 minutes debating why the loan system should be abolished. Call me a cynical, whinging Evertonian if you like but it smacked to me of Everton getting into the top 5 and the press/media being unhappy about it. Let's face it, their readership are RS, United and Spurs fans.

We don't have a proverbial pot to piss in. How else are we meant to challenge the money bags without exploiting the loan system and bringing through our own youth? Unless we see some kind of salary cap or limits on squad sizes then I don't see a way of ever getting into the top group of clubs without relying on loan signings.

Don't get me wrong, I wish these players were ours permanently but we are where we are and we have to cut our cloth accordingly. Thank God we've got RM who can spot these players and integrate them into his vision.

Brian Harrison
56 Posted 18/12/2013 at 13:17:47
Craig 351

I wouldn't bother watching that Sunday Supplement on Sky, every week they are only interested in talking about Man Utd, Arsenal, Chelsea, City and Liverpool and England. They only talk about any other clubs to fill out their programme. When you look at some of these journalists I doubt if they have ever played the game even at school, and they are so far up themselves, that Patrick Barclay looks like his bum is sticking out of his shirt. Then there is that Martin Samuels he looks like he would need a forklift to get him to his seat in the stands. So if you tune into this programme and expect them to say anything about us it will only be to suggest which of our players should move to another club as obviously they have decided that a club like us shouldn't be allowed to have talented players.

Kevin Tully
57 Posted 18/12/2013 at 13:28:51
Actually, this follows our business model if you think about it.

We loan Goodison Park from the mortgage lender.

We loan Finch Farm from the Council.

Now we loan the first team — brilliant.

Brian Waring
58 Posted 18/12/2013 at 13:32:10
I watched that Craig.They gave credit to Moyes for what Martinez inherited from him, spent about 2 mins only talking about Martinez, and then they couldn't wait to get onto the loan deals topic.Fucking nobs the lot of them.
Brian Waring
59 Posted 18/12/2013 at 13:35:48
Meant to say, it looked like it had been set - up to talk about us and then have a pop at us by then talking about the loan system.
Gavin Ramejkis
60 Posted 18/12/2013 at 12:06:38
My own view on the situation is that whilst we have the chairman and board we have little else will change in terms of funds available to the manager as nothing they do or plan to do is going to a sudden windfall. Unlike his predecessor, Martinez is just getting on with the job, quietly, confidently and with dignity. He isn't whingeing about fixture lists or lack of money, he also isn't strikingly coming out demanding managers are given long time to make their mark (hmm 11 years to earn wads for no return?)

At the end of the day you can only play the cards you are dealt, Martinez has a bigger and more valuable contact list than his predecessor will ever have, he is using it to the advantage of his job and subsequently the club we all love. Whatever wheeling and dealing he can do to our benefit be it loans or sales and purchases from the monies made from them. If he can give us the cream of Europe for 12 month stints on a conveyor belt I'll take that.

Tony J Williams
61 Posted 18/12/2013 at 13:46:15
Craig, have you noticed that the loan issue has only really reared its head this season because we have utilised it brilliantly?

The Redshite have quite a few loans, yet that is not mentioned.

The more it winds up the hacks in the news/media, the more I love it.

Iain Johnston
62 Posted 18/12/2013 at 13:48:10
Seems to me it's now a big topic because our loan players have been instrumental in our performances.

We've always loaned players in, Arteta, Gravesen, Pienaar (twice then raped by Spurs), Campbell, Jeffers, the list goes on and on and on.

It's not news.

Bill Gall
64 Posted 18/12/2013 at 13:48:50
Sorry, I am not in favour of the loan system. To me, if young players with talent are being offered for a loan, it is (a) not helping our young players gain experience, and (b) giving our scheming chairman and board an excuse to transfer our better players.
Patrick Murphy
65 Posted 18/12/2013 at 13:50:16
Paul Wilson writing in the Guardian today mentions the irony of Everton qualifying for CL at the expense of Chelsea due to Lukaku's loan spell and goes on to say: -

Though strongest of the chasing group so far this season, Everton have won only half their 16 matches. The four clubs above them have all managed 10 wins or more, and whether Chelsea's form is stuttering or not, that makes the present top-four favourites to finish as the final top four.

For Everton to achieve a Champions League finish, three fairly unlikely things have to happen. One, they must continue playing well for the rest of the season, beating rivals such as Liverpool (at Anfield), City (Everton lost at the Etihad) and Chelsea (without Lukaku) when the head-to-heads come along. Two, one of the present top four (Arsenal, Liverpool, Chelsea and City) will have to drop out of contention. Three, Manchester United will have to remain out of the picture in mid-table and not complicate proceedings by climbing back into the reckoning in the second half of the season.

He also sees the dark-side as not merely vying for CL but to win the title, why don't they just have a mini league with just their favoured clubs involved who can play each other six times a season and we can get on with watching our favourites in peace without this constant barrage of Everton not big enough to compete, unlikely to maintain form, the loss of a main player will hurt their chances, over reliant on loanees, etc etc etc.

Jimmy Sørheim
66 Posted 18/12/2013 at 13:40:08
Sam Hoare has grasped the point I have been trying to make.

We need permanent players in order to actually being able to develop and sell them if we need for a profit.

Loans only stop a gap in a very short sighted way, and we need to find some top talents in the permanent transfer market.

Seamus Coleman is the exact example of how I want us to operate long term.

James Stewart
67 Posted 18/12/2013 at 14:05:48
@363 Nothing new there, Patrick. Paul Wilson embarrasses himself with most articles he writes. Claims to be a Blue in a house of Reds but I don't buy it.
Paul Tran
68 Posted 18/12/2013 at 14:18:40
Terrible, isn't it, the Everton manager brings in three successful loan signings and people just don't like it.

Has our recent history has been built on buying players cheap and selling them on? Of course it has, the management on and off the pitch were unambitious beyond survival.

By my reckoning, we are as skint as we were before the current manager walked through the door. So what's the solution? Take a punt on cut-price Carlos Kickaball, hope he's good and then watch him get sold at a profit? Blood some youngsters, get them playing and then watch them sit on the bench for Sky Darlings?

Maybe we try something different, yes different, it doesn't always hurt! Get some loan players in, raise the profile of the club, attract better players and get known for playing good football and developing players. Now, there'll be occasions when we have players for one year and they go, but my thinking is that this is an interesting and cost-effective way of finding the right players to take us forward. You never know, we may end up being regarded as a club worth playing for and may even keep some of these players. Remember, they won't all want to sit on the bench for a year.

Martinez can't win. He's lucky that he inherited a glittering array of talent. He lucky when he gets players on loan who happen to be good, he's lucky when he buys a 'rubbish' midfielder from Wigan who turns out to be good when people judge him on performance. He's also lucky when he makes the dirty, corrupt-ridden loan system work for us.

If you still don't like our current manager, fair enough. I can understand lazy journalists coming out with this nonsense, but some people on here are appearing so desperate to crab a manager who has been here a few months and is doing a so far so good job.

Why?

John Ford
69 Posted 18/12/2013 at 14:28:59
I found this quite depressing.

Sure RM is a very positive influence on players coming in, but being an incubator club (or giving the impression) for the 'top teams' surely defeats the objective we have in getting to the top table ourselves, albeit without other teams resources.

OK I get that we need to bring in talent in whatever form and by whatever means, including loans, but lets not make this a fecking policy decision. It just highlights our pauper status.

Andrew Clare
70 Posted 18/12/2013 at 14:44:46
We have been a badly run club for many years with the result that from being one of the biggest clubs in the country we are now unable to compete financially with 6 or 7 other clubs in the Premier League. Having said that RM is bringing us back to the top table with his man management, tactical nous and knowledge of the European and Loan markets. If he can maintain our assault on Champions League football and be successful, then over time we will establish ourselves at the top again.

It is possible, it can be done. Two good signings in January could really strengthen our position.

On another note, never watch or listen to the Sunday Supplement or Talksport. These people know nothing and they are totally disrespectful to the many English clubs with great histories.They think that money is the only factor when talking about success.

Paul Holmes
71 Posted 18/12/2013 at 15:01:50
Martinez is using his brain and exploiting the system (just like Zola at Watford last season with all the Udinese italian players). If we can get top Spanish players, why not? Moyes can't get top Spanish players to sign for Man Utd, but Everton might get them on loan! Brilliant if you ask me.
Steavey Buckley
72 Posted 18/12/2013 at 15:09:51
Is that because there is a dearth of local home grown talent? And it maybe good in the short term to have loan players playing for Everton, but what happens when they go back to their home clubs? The whole cycle repeats itself. And Everton are not really better off in the long term.
Steve Brown
73 Posted 18/12/2013 at 15:19:29
Everton have had a decent record of bringing loanees - Arteta, Pienaar, Manuel Fernandes, Donovan. Now Barry, Lukaku and Deulofeu.

Sure there have been some duds - Jo, Stracqualursi - but overall it has served us well over the years. It we want to control clubs like Chelsea buying up all the young talent and then loaning them out, simply set a quota of how many players a club can loan out/bring in on loan.

Winston Williamson
74 Posted 18/12/2013 at 15:01:03
To be fair, RM has not said this will be our 'only' transfer policy.

He said it's a good policy.

Is it an improvement on previous transfer policies the club have adopted? Well, it's an improvement to the way we use the loan system.

Time will tell if he improves the permanant transfer policy of the club.

However, for me the two policies are linked. If the loaned players allow us to play a more expressive style of play, raise our profile and our league standing, then a higher level of quality players will want to sign for us on permanant deals.

Or young talent, like Stone, will feel they're likely to be played and developed if going to Goodison Park.

James Flynn
75 Posted 18/12/2013 at 14:57:43
Regarding the media, it’s not about loans. It’s about loan; Lukaku and the manager who sent him out.

If we were only talking about Barry and Deulofeu, there wouldn’t be near, remotely near, the press attention we’re getting now regarding loans.

Eugene Ruane
76 Posted 18/12/2013 at 16:29:48
The PL, Sky, The FA, Barclays etc seem to have no problem at all with the idea of a league where some teams are skint while others have the HUUUUUUGE advantage of being able spend unlimited money on players.

If that changes and each team can only spend the same on transfers (nb: so it's fucking fair and we don't start every season at a massive disadvantage), I'll be more than happy to say 'NO!' to loans.

Until then, I say bring them on, more the merrier. (Especially if we get lads like the present crop who appear to get what we're about and put in shifts that do credit to themselves and the shirt.)

Dan Brierley
77 Posted 18/12/2013 at 16:25:19
News Headline in the year 2015:

'Everton have become the first team to field a first eleven of entirely loan players, and will continue to do so following the signing of youth player development contracts with europes elite clubs.

A spokesman for Everton said 'This is a phenomenal achievement, and gives Everton first pick of which top young player they next want to develop. It is unfortunate that we have now closed our own academy, but the saving in costs means we can now afford to bring in the young players which are on higher salaries. The top clubs are also allowing us to finish in 5th place, for which we are thankful.'

A spokesman for europes elite also commented by saying 'This is great news for the cartel, we now effectively control young talent development in world football. If the players deliver on potential during their loan spells, we will of course keep them. If not, then no doubt clubs like Everton will be willing to take them for what will still be a profit for us, as we haven't had to pay their wages since they signed.'

I would love nothing more than for all teams to who are offered high priced youth talents from the cartel, to give a big 'FUCK OFF' in unison and refuse to support their strategy. Only then will you see youngster thinking twice about joining them. But it will only work, if everyone agrees to refuse.

Richard Reeves
79 Posted 18/12/2013 at 15:49:29
You can't help but think Roberto may have even less to spend when you compare the amount of money that came in from all revenues this season compared to previous seasons, savings on wages from players being released or sold, yet still money is held back.... and now talk of how important the loan system is – but this could all be part of the Martinez master plan.

Maybe the manager will have some money to spend on one or two decent players every season, take a few of the world's most promising young players, improve them, mix it all up with our young players, help bring them through and create more competition at the club.

It just depends on how much money Roberto has to spend so I'm not sure if this is a way of saying that the loan route is the main route due to finances... but I do think that the manager wants to bring through the youth players and I get the impression he's really impressed with the youth set up and the amount of quality we have in there.

Kevin Day
80 Posted 18/12/2013 at 17:01:26
Martinez said a few months ago that we have to be creative regarding transfers, this is what he's doing,it's already been said but if this helps us in the short term of achieving Champions League football, which will in turn provide more revenue, thus being able to actually buy better quality players in the long term then I see no problem with this.
Raymond Fox
81 Posted 18/12/2013 at 16:44:54
With Roberto's Spanish connection. it always going to happen from Spain.
Whether RM is getting enquiries from Germany, Holland etc, we don't know.
Obviously he's only going to take players with the best ability and can fit into positions where we need strengthening.

So if its only a short term fix for a club like us, I am all for it, its working well enough for us this season up to now.

Christine Foster
82 Posted 18/12/2013 at 17:22:35
This is a problem made at the top table in FIFA. There is a way to level out the playing field but alas I think there are too many clubs with power and influence to prevent it from happening.

It isn't about being fair, it's about allowing a select few to succeed, to buy who they want, how many they want, when they want. In fact it is the very notion of unfettered power of a few clubs that in a perverse way ensures the success of the Premier league.
Although capping transfer numbers including loan players that a club could have in any season, would level out the playing field, or even a monetary cap set at a realistic level, the fact is clubs don't want it. The whole business model of football sanctioned by FIFA, is based on wealth creation and not football equality.

Phil Roberts
83 Posted 18/12/2013 at 17:02:38
One line not featured above is what might be called Bosman +

The organisation that provided the legal and financial muscle to bring in the Bosman ruling are now trying to get the European Courts to give rights to footballers that are the same as all other employees. As such, a footballer will simply be able to terminate his contract by buying it out.

So Rooney on £250k per week = £13m per year and 2 years left to run could move to any other club for the payment of the £26m. And there would be nothing his current club could do about it. In the same way Johnny Heitinga on £55k per week could walk tomorrow for £1,54m. To digress slightly there is no mention of merchandise payments making the buyout higher.

But it does raise the possibility that Lukaku who is earning £2m a year and with 2½ years left on his contract would under these new rules be available for £5m.

It may be that players contracts will be staggered to have lots of money at the end for little at the front, making them stay for the whole contract or making it more difficult for them to be taken early if they show huge promise. It may mean that players will be asked to re-sign a contract each year, otherwise their transfer fee will drop each year by the value of their pay. But it will make a huge change to the transfer system and maybe loan system.

Which brings us back to this topic. Would Lukaku now be talking to Chelsea about moving to GP for £5m or a new 5 year deal on £10m a year? Gerard could probably move to us for peanuts. But equally, Baines could go for £4m or thereabouts. The loan system will mean that players can be tried and "stolen" more easily.

Patrick Murphy
84 Posted 18/12/2013 at 17:35:53
I can't remember exactly but wasn't our most successful manager Howard Kendall referred to as the 'Loan Arranger' I believe it was an Echo Headline shortly before our successful period - probably when we got Terry Curran on loan.
Carl Sanderson
85 Posted 18/12/2013 at 17:32:32
So Chelsea are delighted with Lukaku? Well, I'm happy for them, obviously, but it's a sign of how far Kenwright has lowered expectations that we are now praising the Club for this pathetic hand-to-mouth existence.

One of England's greatest clubs is now making a virtue of necessity because its custodians have failed utterly on the financial side.

Drew Shortis
86 Posted 18/12/2013 at 17:50:18
Most players are transitory nowadays so I don't think we should get too precious about this. The only major drawback I can see is that we don't get a transfer fee when they leave after doing well. However this is adequately balanced out by the fact that we don't pay a transfer fee to get them in.

Of course I would like to see the club in a financial position where we can splash the cash to get the best talent on 'permanent' deals, but as this is currently not the case I can see no reason not to take full advantage of the situation and get the cream of Europe's youngsters in the squad. Perhaps if we exploit this situation for a few years we will have the success to attract investment!

Wayne Smyth
87 Posted 18/12/2013 at 17:05:26
Complain all you want about Martinez using the loan system, but for any whine to be taken seriously you really do need to come up with an alternative solution that is workable....and that doesn't include some pie in the sky ideas about how the loan system needs to be made fair, or otherwise reformed.

We don't have anyone available from our youth system close to being as good as Deulofeu or Lukaku, so they're not keeping anyone out of the side. What they are doing in the short term is propelling Everton into the business end of the league where money is made and giving us a real chance of some silverware.

Maybe, just maybe having future world stars at the club might actually improve our own young players by showing the benchmark that needs to be reached to get into the first team.

Roger Helm
88 Posted 18/12/2013 at 17:45:41
It seems our new manager is a lot more savvy in many ways than Moyes. Let's hope he has a bit better luck prising open the board's wallets. But I'm not fussed about whether a player is a loanee or not. Let's face it, they're all here today and gone tomorrow - contracts mean nothing these days in terms of stability. If you buy a player and sell him on, you can make a profit as with Fellaini, or you could just as easily make a big loss. A marquee signing could turn out to be an expensive flop. At least loanees are not as much a financial commitment. Unless we get a dodgy billionaire owner, we'll never compete with the likes of Chelski. Do we even want to?
Niall MacDiarmada
89 Posted 18/12/2013 at 18:02:26
Get more loan players in,

Spend the savings on redeveloping the stadium.

Simple as

Patrick Murphy
90 Posted 18/12/2013 at 18:19:36
The major problem is that it is the younger squad members and the players such as Arteta, Lescott et al who when sold on for a profit then subsidise the wage-bill. So while it may help in the short-term it won't in the long-run.
Carl Sanderson
91 Posted 18/12/2013 at 18:17:47
"Unless we get a dodgy billionaire owner, we'll never compete with the likes of Chelski. Do we even want to?"

Yes, please. That is the only way we will compete consistently with the so-called elite. We can talk all we want about how Martinez will do this or do that, but it's all short-termism. Let's say we finish fourth this season: even if we kept Lukaku and co we would have half the squad knocking on the door asking for a whacking salary increase. Any new arrivals would want top dollar. Kenwright must be dirtying his pants at the thought of Everton getting into the Chanpions League.

As for "dodgy billionaires", well, how many Manchester City fans are complaining about their lot? None, of course. They're having the time of their lives. I want some of that.

Mike Green
92 Posted 18/12/2013 at 18:38:48
The beauty of what Martinez has done is he has given us a very strong option, when in the past few years we thought we had none.

When clubs are playing hardball for transfer fees he can just shrug his shoulders and say he'll get a loan instead, one which is probably twice the player they're looking to sell.

Also - we can talent that's straining at the leash to prove themselves - as has been illustrated by all of our loanees.

What's not to like?

Bravo Roberto.

Robin Cannon
93 Posted 18/12/2013 at 18:42:39
@Carl (407) - I don't. I genuinely don't. I don't want to be a vanity project for some billionaire.

I'm sure Manchester City fans aren't compaining, but so what? Doesn't mean that much to buy everything. When do you think the next local youngster might genuinely make it through their system? And when the *best* billionaire owners are dodgy as fuck oligarchical dictators on a vanity run, then that's not something I want to be involved in.

I want us to be run well, as a business and as a team. I don't want us to be reliant on any one individual. I want our finances to self sustaining, while still giving us reasonable flexibility in the transfer market. I want us to invest in youth.

I would far prefer us to follow an Arsenal type model; of a well run business that can sustain itself, not be reliant on anyone, than have some sugar daddy who couldn't give a shit about our history.

Mike Green
94 Posted 18/12/2013 at 18:52:54
In short - the loan system has given Roberto a lot of power, with little responsibility. It's like he's turbo-charged the squad without haven't to pay for an entire space programme (if you get my drift.....)
Mick Davies
95 Posted 18/12/2013 at 19:01:24
How disgusting it is for Everton to be using loanees who may get them in more favourable position ahead of that wonderful club across the park; you know, the one whose Captain assaulted a defenceless DJ in a club, tried to break that defender Naysmiths legs and his friend, the majestic, darling Cilla Black impersonator who racially abuses his fellow professionals and loves them so much, he regularly bites chunks out of them. This Martinez fellow doesn't know his place; how dare he try to break into the sacred club. He shouldn't be doing it without billionaire foreign criminals

Carl Sanderson
96 Posted 18/12/2013 at 19:01:45
Robin,

Some excellent points there - but look at the academy Manchester City are building. It is going to be unbelievable. It'll be La Masia with knobs on.

It's not (just) a vanity project. (Aren't Everton a vanity project to Kenwright?) Sure, they're shelling out now, but ultimately the products of their youth system will come through to the first team.

They'll have the new Xavi, Messi and Iniesta. What will we have - loans, frees and cast-offs. And to think that Kenwright is rumoured to have knocked back City's present owners...

Brin Williams
97 Posted 18/12/2013 at 19:05:40
Robin Cannon, 410 - so what you're saying is that we are not cannon fodder?

Of course we all want those things BUT there has to be a means to an end. After all this is just (?) a game and if you don't play or understand the game you lose.

I believe Roberto not only understands the game and can play the game, but he may well have just invented the game.

Game on!!

Dennis Ng
98 Posted 18/12/2013 at 18:31:50
Carl (407), true, but you're also likely to get those that did the Malaga, Blackburn or other one and done deals. I would say that dodgy is really not the word I would describe owners of City among elites.

Roger (401), I dare say we're competing with the elites right now. We might be there yet but we've always been hanging around with the lot since Moyes. I like RM's work so far, I just hope we gain back some of that defensive grit and clean sheets while we flood the opponent with goals.

Dan Brierley
99 Posted 18/12/2013 at 19:11:19
Mick 412, I don't know where you have been hiding fella, but we have finished above Liverpool for the past 2 years. And both times has been achieved using our own players, and not developing the players of our rivals.
Andy Crooks
100 Posted 18/12/2013 at 19:16:12
Roberto Martinez is being admirably pragmatic. At present there is absolutely no alternative and at least it is a strategy.With a lot of luck with injuries, and sadly we don't ever seem to have it, then Champions League is a possibility. Therein lies our only chance of progress with the current board.

Roberto has come up with a way of playing a system that has long been against us. He is the coach to lend to. Can anyone envisage Barcelona thinking, er, this lad needs to develop, Moysie's the man. No, we have a chance of breaking the glass ceiling and we should grab it.

Scott Jones
101 Posted 18/12/2013 at 18:27:13
I say lets keep using the loan system to our advantage for a couple of years,bring in the odd "James McCarthy" on permanent deals and slowly develop a first team 11.

I don't see any reason why a good scouting network like we now have cant pick up a quality youngster like Barcelona do year after year. most of the big clubs tend to spend 20+mill on a player who as impressed in a big game or tournament....these players could have been bought for a quarter of the price 12months before...the trick is seeing this potential before they start to impress in the big games.

Timo Werner of vfb Stuttgart is a star of the future for example.

http://www.bundesliga.com/en/liga/clubs/vfb-stuttgart/spieler.php?player=49905

Mick Davies
102 Posted 18/12/2013 at 19:18:16
Dan, I wasn't referring to league position; more the position of contempt the so called "sports media experts" regard us. We can never win with the media and authorities: even when we do things right we're criticised so it's good to see our manager putting his middle finger up to them.

Robin Cannon, is that the Man City that's been bankrolled with billions of oil dollars yet still lost at Newcastle, WBA and even West Ham!!!

Dennis Ng
103 Posted 18/12/2013 at 19:30:28
Mick, I think there are just too many fans of other clubs in the media. I've been reading too much manu and RS BS back when I was in Singapore. No point thinking about what they say. All it matters is that RM does it on the field.

I'd rather have a winning team of loanees or "average players" than a room full of prima donnas. Besides, we are winning more often than we did these days than the past 20 years, right?

Dan Brierley
104 Posted 18/12/2013 at 19:28:10
Do we actually want those pricks liking us though Mick?
Tony Draper
105 Posted 18/12/2013 at 17:45:53
As I see it Roberto is rectifying a problem with a creative and positive application of the rules

The circumstances of Everton no longer being "The Millionaires Club" are not of RM's creation, but rather than whining about teaspooons at bunfights he now has the phone ringing off the hook as he is offered even more prospective emerging talent

Not bad considering he's only been in charge for a matter of weeks

Our way out of the drab "work hard and keep hoping for a lottery win" circumstance/mindset looks remarkably closer right now with his bright and sunny positive thinking, positive approach and attractive football

He has not plunged us deeper in to debt for a false dawn season
(only to fall at the last hurdle)

So Roberto is fully exploiting possibility and revelling in being the brightest Professor of The School of Science for what feels like eons

Well GOOD !

TBH my greatest fear right now is that Roberto is so damn good he'll attract invites from these same clubs who currently would entrust him with emerging talents.....

And yet I really hope that he is that good
Cos fuck knows we bloody well deserve that

Eugene Ruane
106 Posted 18/12/2013 at 19:33:24
I might add, anything Andy Dunn is against, I'm for.
David Chait
108 Posted 18/12/2013 at 19:35:46
Hear hear Ian Burns! #333
The fact that having transient players at our club year in year out with the full knowledge we do this to promote players for other clubs is very sad.... I know the value they bring, but it's a complete summer fling... We get the starter but never can enjoy the main course...
Hopefully this tactic can push us to top 4 because as soon as that happens the game changes ...
David Chait
109 Posted 18/12/2013 at 20:26:45
The truth is I'm torn and even as I wrote that it occurs to me... A club doesn't truly own a player or his loyalties... we own his contract. The difference between buying and loaning is purely the length of the contract. If we can have the best young talent of the best clubs honing their skills with us... Why is that bad? Do they try any less hard... No.. A player today plies his trade and performance comes from the players wanting to be the best and professional pride... I just don't know.

And you can't compare these loans to those we have had before. The nature of those was completely different.

Mike Green
110 Posted 18/12/2013 at 20:32:46
How about Landon Donovan?

He was a great loan for us, gave us a real shot in the arm when we needed it, brought extra professionalism and quality to the squad, raised standards, led by example - and many of us see him now in some way as and Evertonian.

I'm glad we got him in, he did a great job, treated the whole deal and us with respect and moved on - I'd do it all again tomorrow - win / win.

Andrew Hawes
111 Posted 18/12/2013 at 20:14:03
Okay, so we have made three loan signings that have worked brilliantly so far. This could well be just luck that all three have settled so quickly and made such a difference to our side; it's unrealistic to expect all future loan signings to have such an impact. From someone who has watched players such as Jo come in on loan, I am only too aware of the downside to this practice!

The only way our club will grow is some very clever permanent signings such as McCarthy etc. I find it very worrying that Roberto has come out with all this loan talk a week before the window opens when, if we are serious about Champions League places, we need to add at least two quality signings!!

I believe this season is now or never for us; not only the fact that we have the perfect blend of youth alongside Distin, Osman, Pienaar, and others who next season might just begin to decline, but also the fact that the richer sides like Chelsea, Man Utd etc are so inconsistent — which I can't see happening going into next season.

Brin Williams
112 Posted 18/12/2013 at 20:57:14
I think it's a great idea, not only do we now have a production line of future stars to chose from, we can also send them back at little cost, no capex.
Allied to this our young chaps are able to compare themselves against these future stars and hopefully learn.
This to my mind is a no brainer and a win win all the way for Roberto and Everton.
Phew, what a chap.
Mike Green
113 Posted 18/12/2013 at 21:43:31
.....and it keeps all the others guessing!
Lloyd Brodrick
114 Posted 18/12/2013 at 23:49:54
When Lukaku arrived I suggested we were perhaps witnessing the emergence of a new strategy within football. I'm comfortable with it providing it's the embryo of greater things. You of course need a manager who's a visionary and you also need to play the right style of football, we have that and not many will be able to replicate it.
So, as Nigel said in an earlier post, School of Science! Why carnt we become the Cambridge of the footballing world or the Hogwarts given the magic RM possesses. We can benefit greatly but like all great institutions the students can pay us and before long the talent will come to us first. It certainly has potential...
Kunal Desai
115 Posted 19/12/2013 at 00:11:49
Heitinga will be leaving in January, this should hopefully free up some much needed funds for cover in other areas.
Si Cooper
116 Posted 19/12/2013 at 00:32:23
The loan system can work for us in two ways.

On the one hand we can 'try before we buy' with players who are being allowed to run down their contracts as they are no longer central to their current clubs, and on the other we can give game time to prospects who have not yet broken through at clubs who have more than enough players to choose from.

The simple truth is, we have had those options for years and have already made plenty of use of the 'try before you buy' loanees. What will make a difference, as has been seen so far this season, is the quality we can attract at the prospects level as well. Hopefully we can solidify the current success so that the process becomes self sustaining in the future.

It is definitely something we need to exploit. If Lukaku is helping Chelsea while he is helping us, then surely their rivals should be thinking how we can be mutually beneficial for them as well.

Jamie Sweet
117 Posted 19/12/2013 at 01:05:59
How can a club like Everton dream of achieving Champions League football with a net spend of £0?

This is the task that Uncle Bill has essentially set for our Roberto.

Roberto has come up with a strategy which includes the utilisation of the loan transfer market.

I personally think it's very smart.

If we achieve Champions League football, then just maybe we can start thinking about buying players the calibre of Lukaku and Deulofeu.

But until that day comes, I'd much rather watch these two playing for us for a year and fighting in the upper echelons of the league than I would watching a couple of Championship standard players that we own, scrapping it out for five years of nothing but mid-table mediocrity.

Brent Stephens
118 Posted 19/12/2013 at 04:00:15
Sounds good to be able to bring in loanees b ut beware an excuse for Bill not to spend - so problem with many comings and goings of loanees, in trying to knit a settled side.
Tim Jones
119 Posted 19/12/2013 at 06:09:14
Is the rule only four 'Loanees' at any time with any club or only four 'loanees' in the Team at any time?
Bob Parrington
120 Posted 19/12/2013 at 08:19:59
Mick Davies #331 - Last 10 years I've been travelling too much. All over the place people ask me why I hate LFC so much. I'm not normally a "hater". You put it in a nutshell, mate. Well expressed!
Sam Hoare
121 Posted 18/12/2013 at 09:46:56
Wayne, they are obviously cheap compared to purchasing said players wherein lies the attraction. However when you think how little was spent on players in Moyes last 3 years or so then a £3m transfer fee is not insignificant for a player that is not effectively ours. Its a risk I suppose as if that player gets you sufficiently up the league or even into the champions league then they have repaid the fee and hopefully that will be the case with Lukaku. If however we still finish 6th and don't win any cups then arguably that 3m may have been better spent on some young Arteta type who would have made the club £7m profit after a few years good service.

I'm not against loans per se but it does seem that our financial model at the moment means that the majority of our transfer kitty comes from the sale of players and if we are not bringing in permanent players then it puts alot of pressure on our youth system.

Mat Smith
122 Posted 19/12/2013 at 09:22:44
think people are missing a couple of things here:-

A: if clubs are contacting us to take their young players why would we be paying large fees? (we wanted/chased Lukaku… we were made to pay for the loan) - Surely anyone coming in would be similar to Gerard’s deal - more he plays less we pay.

B: where does it state in the article or from what Martinez or anyone else involved with the club that if we do start loaning more youngsters we will never sign a player again? - People always look for a negative in these kind of statements.

Way I see it is that Martinez would get the pick of Europe’s youngsters whilst also bringing in permanent signings.

Colin Glassar
123 Posted 19/12/2013 at 10:20:20
If clubs want us to take their players, surely they should pay us something?
Tony J Williams
124 Posted 19/12/2013 at 11:26:05
I don't have a problem with it.

Dan, you have taken it to the complete extreme in your 383 post, it will never be like that.

We are doing nothing different than what we have always done, however the class of loanee has pleasingly gone up. It just a "big news" story because of the Maureen spat.

Move along, nothing to see here.

Iain Johnston
125 Posted 19/12/2013 at 11:32:25
Have to agree with Tony J. It's getting daft now.

We have THREE loan players, THREE!.. One is a "B" team Spaniard, one wasn't wanted by his club and one was farmed out for experience.
Who was to know Lukaku would be as good in his second season?. How many young strikers are?

Just because they fit in doesn't mean this is the new blueprint for EFC to attract players. Most clubs have loanees. Hull City have Livermore, the barcodes have Remy the RS Moses, all arguably high profile players. Do we think this is the way they'll conduct most of their business now?.

I'm sure we've always been inundated with clubs offering us players to ease their wage budget..

We have money to spend. We offered Porto £15m for a midfielder which wasn't dependant on the Fellaini deal..

The deal for Gibson was £2m, do you not think loaning him first would have been a better idea?.

Loan players are an established, no brainer way, to augment a squad and to look at players who for whatever reason need to prove themselves again. If they are successful all the better.

Tom Bowers
126 Posted 19/12/2013 at 12:15:10
It is a part of the game now and a way for other clubs outside of the ''billionaire set'' to get by especially when injuries happen with threadbare squads.

Gareth Barry has arguably been a Godsend at Everton with Gibson getting injured.

There seems to be a plethora of top class players in the Prem. these days and it doesn't make sense that some of them would languish in reserve teams or on the bench without being used.

In light of Everton's lack of ''billions'' the loan deals have been great so far after the success of Donovan and were not Howard and Arteta loanees at first?

These successes are getting Everton to a status whereby they are becoming a more attractive item for potential investors.

Hopefully finishing in the top four would put the icing on the cake.

Phil Sammon
127 Posted 19/12/2013 at 12:14:05
I think it's the nature of the loans rather than the amount of loans we have. Firstly, I think it has irked and surprised other clubs just how well our loanees have done.

However I think a more important detail is that two of these players are likely to be world class players one day. It's rare that a club should loan out a player of such potential, and even rarer that they should loan them to a rival in Chelsea's case.

Newcastle's loan with Remy is more common and something Everton have done many times in the past. They are taking on a player with a view to a permenent transfer. We are not doing this with Lukaku and Deulofeu. It's very much a case of helping Everton out for one year only.

We can all surely agree that the loan market and player hoarding needs addressing, but while the rules are as they are then we should use it the best we can.

Steavey Buckley
128 Posted 19/12/2013 at 15:53:09
Ever since Everton and the rest of clubs belonging to the football and premier leagues disbanded their reserve teams there has been a real lack of competition for youth players to play alongside first team squad players against similar. This has been to the detriment of future youth talent making into the first team squad. That's why the alternative for load signings is on the agenda.
Bill Gall
129 Posted 19/12/2013 at 23:00:35
We can argue till we are blue in the face on the pros and cons of the loan system but the bottom line is: Everton are not doing anything illegal, just operating in a approved system by the FA.

These journalists should be criticizing the governing body that voted this system in and not clubs that are simply using the same rules that are available to all clubs.

John Zapa
130 Posted 20/12/2013 at 12:39:17
Depending on loan signing for continued success is doomed to fail in the long term. The only. Reason premier League clubs like Man City and Chelsea are loaning players to Everton, is because they don't view the club as serious competition for the title/champ league places. If Everton break thru the glass ceiling this season on the back of strong performances from loan players, you can be sure this source of loans will dry up.

The other option is bringing in loan players from abroad. This is also very risky as many players need time to settle, and when you have a player for a season, you can't afford to wait that long. I think people should accept that the club got lucky in the sense that all 3 loan signing hit the ground running. It's not realistic to expect that to happen every season.

Also the timing of this talk is suspicious. It hints at another loan signing coming in in January with a permanent player (Heitinga?) leaving.

Harold Matthews
131 Posted 20/12/2013 at 14:19:10
With regard to lending out young players with potential.

In January this year French youngster, Florian Thauvin, rumoured to be going to Arsenal, was snapped up by Lille for €3.5M. He was immediately loaned out to lower club Bastia till the end of the season, where he was a sensation. In September he signed a 5 year deal with Olympique de Marseile for €15M including bonuses. Probably cheap at the price and nice business all round.

Dennis Ng
132 Posted 20/12/2013 at 19:47:51
Given RM's familiarity with the Spanish league, or Barca in particular, I think that familiarization timeframe will shorten. Our market has traditionally been about targeting players outside the big leagues and more of poaching from smaller leagues and teams, or players surplus to the EPL rich. It is be step up to be able to tap into bigger markets of talent. I kinda fear if this will change if they change the rule about parent club.

I believe we enjoyed a great deal of luck with the 3 loanees. No doubt it will end, but I look forward to the new faces RM brings in, whether loan or some bargain deal he found overseas. Only red mark against him so far is Kone, and that is a massive bill. I do hope he actually pans out well.

Heitinga has been "going away" for more than a year or two now. For him to get into the WC, he needs to leave and get playing time. He is a great stopgap player due to his versatility, but his performance has not been good in the games I saw. If this gives us more funds for some new faces, however unproven but cheap, I'm all for it. We have been in the bargain section for years and its nice to finally be successful for it, even if it is for a season or two. If we break into UCL, cash problems should subside.


Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads

© ToffeeWeb