Stunning Barkley strike keeps Everton rolling

, 22 December, 77comments  |  Jump to most recent
Swansea City 1 - 2 Everton

Everton extended their unbeaten run to 10 games and moved back to within two points of the top of the table thanks to a magnificent free kick from Ross Barkley.

The Blues had seen Seamus Coleman's 66th-minute strike, a moment of brilliance itself, cancelled out by an unfortunate own goal for Bryan Oviedo with 20 minutes left of a second half that had been a marked improvement on the first, as Swansea threatened to grind a out a draw.

But when Ben Davies chopped James McCarthy down to end the Irish international's surging run with six minutes left, it set up a chance for Barkley with a dead ball from 25 yards. And the emerging midfield star produced the goods with a stunning shot that flew in off the underside of the crossbar.

The goal was a fitting winner based on the 20 year-old's performance to that point and only a combination of the slick turf and Gerhard Tremmel in the Swansea goal had prevented him from opening his account earlier in the half.

Barkley slipped at the crucial moment with just the 'keeper to beat in the 56th minute before Tremmel pushed his stinging left-foot drive onto the crossbar 9 minutes later.

Those two incidents were indicative of how the game had been warming up after a pedestrian and fairly dour first half and Coleman rewarded Everton's improvement by lighting the contest up with a terrific goal. The Irish defender unloaded a wickedly swerving drive from well outside the penalty area that left Tremmel with no hope before celebrating defiantly in front of the travelling faithful.

The goal roused Swansea, though, and they began to ask more questions of the Blues' back line, no more so than when Davies crossed from the left and Dwight Tiendalli stole and made contact with the ball ahead of Steven Pienaar. It was heading wide of Tim Howard's goal but bounced off Oviedo and into the goal to make it 1-1.

Roberto Martinez's side had caused Swansea's defence with plenty of surging runs throughout the game but they lacked composure with the final ball. Barkley produced the goods with a sumptuous dead-ball finish, though, and Howard would make an excellent late safe to deny Roland Lamah and put Everton back into the top four pending the result of tomorrow's clash between Arsenal and Chelsea.

Quotes or other material sourced from ToffeeWeb Match Reports



Reader Comments (77)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Sharabi Singh
2 Posted 22/12/2013 at 20:20:17
Got to mention Seamus. Had a blinder of a game and what a goal. Is there a better right back in the league right now, I don't think so.

Should be above the scum by next week. Can't wait. COYB

Karl Weaver
3 Posted 22/12/2013 at 20:19:08
I don't want to focus on the negatives as I thought today's result was richly deserved... but the only under par performance for me lately has been Kevin Mirallas. Very lazy and greedy when he had a simple chance to put Lukaku through in the six-yard box!

The only reason we wont make the top 4 this season will be our lack of squad depth compared to the competition. Let's hope Martinez's "let's go for it" positivity is infectious enough to make Bill back him in January!

Mark Taylor
4 Posted 22/12/2013 at 20:38:44
6 more points and we should be safe....
Mike T Jones
5 Posted 22/12/2013 at 20:32:43
Peter Jones, contributor # 2 above. add an initial like me. McCarthy is the best player in our team by far. I love him,
Paul Smith
6 Posted 22/12/2013 at 21:04:58
I cannot believe anybody having a go at McCarthy. I think he's been superb for us this season and is the heartbeat of the side.

The worries I do have are about Lukaku whose first touch and effort seems to have dwindled these last few weeks. Also, Mirallas whose form has been very patchy this season. I thought Coleman was great again today.

Gavin Ramejkis
7 Posted 22/12/2013 at 21:25:43
It would be disingenuous to slate McCarthy as his role is pretty similar to the old Carsley water carrier one, one which we missed since he left, he and Barry keep the midfield tidy and clear in front of the back four, no glamour just hard work and a decent job breaking up attacks and sending the ball back in the right direction.

Interesting to see the tweet from Barkley after the game about being good to prove someone who doubted him wrong, I wonder who that could have been aimed at? If they sort out sharing the wealth in front of goal we are close to smashing some poor sods out of the park, lets hope Roberto drives that message home for Christmas and we all get an entertaining destruction of Sunderland on Boxing Day.

Coleman for 60k, still grin when I think of how much he cost to buy.

Mike T Jones
8 Posted 22/12/2013 at 21:27:45
Paul #082. McCarthy is supreme. I have my opinion that he is the best footballer I have ever seen play for Everton. But....he needs 100 more games like the ones he has had to become a legend. He is on his way though. Am I contradicting myself??
Jamie Sweet
9 Posted 22/12/2013 at 21:20:13
The Peter Jones comment posted by Colin shows a complete ignorance to the game of football.

McCarthy is a defensive midfielder and his key responsibility is to shield our defence whilst giving the likes of Barkley free licence to bomb forward knowing that young James will always be there to cover.

He goes about this job almost flawlessly. To suggest that if he was really any good we would be winning five- or six-nil and he would be scoring hat-tricks is a comment not even the most stupid of Sky pundits could come up with.

If he really was any good at his job, we would probably be close to the top of the table, have the best defensive record in the league whilst scoring with relative freedom in front of him... hang on a minute, Peter...

And to the other Peter Jones... the one with a brain... I would just change your name completely so as not to risk being associated with such utter silliness.

Dan Brierley
10 Posted 22/12/2013 at 21:01:40
Another good result, and a deserved three points on the overall balance of play. The interesting thing about this performance, was that we have previously struggled against resilient defences. Today, it was two individual moments of brilliance that won the match.

After seeing the replays, I think Seamus was fortunate regarding the bounce of the ball just as he hit it, but he deserves the benefit of the doubt based on his ’Evertonian through and through’ goal celebration. How inspiring was his attitude? I loved every second of the passion he showed.

Ross’s free kick was an absolute blinder, albeit another game where he was relatively quiet. He still seems to want that extra touch, and loses the ball too much. The lad is a joy to watch, but has some serious work to do regarding his football brain and decision-making. But nevertheless I think it’s easier to be talented and learn the game, than someone who knows the game well but has limited skill.

And we come on to James McCarthy, who is the new Fellaini in terms of the split on the fan base. And the comparison to Fellaini is quite interesting because they seem to be right at opposing ends of the scale. Fellaini was majestic in possession and banged in the goals, but was quite frankly lazy when not on the ball. McCarthy seems to be the complete opposite, in that he has incredible effort and determination when not in possession, but very little skill or vision when on the ball. I hope the lad is going to be able to develop more when in possession, instead of being a player who’s biggest compliment is that ’he covers a lot of ground’. Still more Sidwell than Alonso or Toure.

One of the most pleasing elements about today, was Mirallas put in a good shift and caused a lot of problems. I personally hope he makes that right berth his own, as I prefer watching Everton players as opposed to loan players who see their future elsewhere, regardless of how good they might be.

Another 3 points, and it has already been one the of the best Decembers that I can remember as an Evertonian. Let’s hope we maintain this good form, add a creative central player in January, and push on to cement a 4th place finish. COYB!

Mark Taylor
11 Posted 22/12/2013 at 22:14:37
Dan I think you're on your own with Mirallas, judging from the comments I've seen. I tend to agree with you-he was far from the least effective player on the pitch. Personally, I'd play him up front next match where he can be as selfish as he likes and might give us mor cutting edge than Lukaku currently does.

I think McCarthy is better than you describe. I wasn't convinced when we bought him but I think he is going to be very good for us.

Robert Elliott
12 Posted 22/12/2013 at 22:22:51
McCarthy- very little skill or vision? Must me watching a different fella to some of you.
Danny Broderick
13 Posted 22/12/2013 at 22:21:59
I think you'd struggle to find a better midfield partnership than Barry & McCarthy.
Brent Stephens
14 Posted 22/12/2013 at 22:32:33
Macca does it for me. An absolute workhorse. Closes down the opposition, puts in the tackles. That's his job, not a creator.
Wayne Smyth
15 Posted 22/12/2013 at 22:30:15
Dan I think any serious criticism of McCarthy is misplaced and harsh. He's young, new to the club and trying to learn with a new group of players.

That said, his performances have been understated yet highly effective and certainly don't require any apologies or explanation. He does work hard, but he also passes very well....and not just easy 5 yard passes, but he sprays the ball and has shown he can get forward too. His player of the month award was not because he's shit.

Saying he's not creative is like saying Distin could score more. McCarthy is there as a defensive midfielder to win the ball back, give options to the people around him, or switch the play. He does this very well.

We have 4 players further forward whose job it is to create, score goals and two of the best attacking wing backs in the league too. Not everyone can attack. The reason we're doing so well is because for the first time in many years the 11 players on the pitch are well balanced.

Under OFM we had to make do with square pegs like Neville, Heitinga, Osman, Cahill or Jags trying to play centre mid. All were deficient in one way or another. We've now got two very good defensive centre mids in Barry and McCarthy who complement the more attacking, creative Barkley, Osman, Mirallas, Deulofeu, Pienaar and Lukaku very well.

It'd be great if McCarthy developed additional strings to his bow, and he's young enough that I'm sure he will. If not we've still got a cracking player who does his job very well.

Phil Sammon
16 Posted 22/12/2013 at 22:30:47
Dan 109

I've never seen anyone make so many misinformed assertions in a single post.

Firstly you damn Barkley with feint praise. The lad is 20, he made a few mistakes but so will any player. He was fantastic going forward today and scored a wonderful winner...yet you focus on him 'taking an extra touch'. Give over. And your comment, 'But nevertheless I think it's easier to be talented and learn the game, than someone who knows the game well but has limited skill.' That implies that you think Barkley lacks a football brain. He's just about the most natural player I've ever seen kick a ball. You're talking rubbish.

Then you go on to bash McCarthy and big-up Mirallas. The former has just landed Player Of The Month after a string of top class performances - the latter would probably not have started had Deulofeu been fit. In fact the person you have chosen to heap praise upon, Mirallas, is the one player who I was really disappointed with today. You have the nerve to slag Barkley off for losing possession...well what about the Belgian? His decision making was woeful today.

All in all, Dan, it was a terrible post there mate and I'd expect there will be more than a few comments below this telling you just how wrong you got it.

Michael Winstanley
17 Posted 22/12/2013 at 22:48:39
Yeah Dan. Mirallas was gash.
Callum McNab
18 Posted 22/12/2013 at 22:44:36
Karl Weaver,Spot on mate. So dissapointed in Mirallas today. He left Coleman so exposed at times,and his attempt to try and stop the cross that Swansea scored from was so dissapointing. To me I was watching a player today who knew his place in the team was save for the next 6 weeks or so. Why did he keep telling Lakaku to go right while he went in the centre. Great result today,I thought Barry was outstanding and Coleman was man of the match for me,what an engine that kid has. I don't know what game Laudrup was watching stating we were lucky to get a win,it should of been a cricket score today for us. COYB
Mike T Jones
19 Posted 22/12/2013 at 22:49:38
All those criticising McCarthy (Dan) can just do one. He is quite simply one hell of a footballer. I suggest you watch him closely. He is the best thing since Paul Bracewell (love him too)
James Marshall
20 Posted 22/12/2013 at 22:50:12
McCarthy vs Fellaini? Seriously, Dan. McCarthy is invaluable to this team, and his worth cannot be underestimated as many are already responding. We have zero need for a player like Fellaini, and quite frankly I don't think many teams have a need for a player like him - he's a square peg in a round hole.

McCarthy is quality, he covers so much ground, disrupts play, gets the ball, moves the ball. No frills, box to box, covers everything and keeps us moving. He's an engine-room player, not a playmaker and not a goalscorer. He's not in the team for his vision, he's in the team to allow others to play. You think Barkley gets forward the way he does purely of his own volition? No, he gets forward because McCarthy (and Barry) is there to cover him. Same goes for our fullbacks - there's no way you'd see Coleman & Oviedo so far up the pitch if it wasn't for the things that McCarthy (and Barry!) do.

A good football team is only as good as the sum of it's parts, and I have no doubt in my mind that without a solid defensive base and holding midfield players, that we would not pose the same attacking threat.

It's often the things you don't see, the unsung players, the ones that make things happen by appearing to do very little, are the ones making the difference. McCarthy is a class act, and will be for a long time hopefully. The new Roy Keane.

Mike T Jones
21 Posted 22/12/2013 at 23:03:33
James #150. Just lovely. Well done for saying it for me as I have had a beer. It is xmas after all
James Marshall
22 Posted 22/12/2013 at 23:11:40
Welcome, Mike. I think most of us see it pretty much as I've said it - give or take.

I love watching McCarthy play. The kid is so bright and full of energy. He's something we've missed for years in our midfield. Everyone always raves about the attacking players and rightly so because they excite people, but if you have a love of the defensive aspect (as I do, having been a defender and goalkeeper), players like McCarthy are equally as exciting to watch in their own way.

Oh, and a happy Christmas to you!

Mark Frere
24 Posted 22/12/2013 at 23:15:20
It's really tiresome reading Dan Brierley's posts, he always posts the opposite of what the majority think. Why? The guy is on the wind-up that's why. I seriously doubt he even believes the bollocks he writes.
Mike T Jones
25 Posted 22/12/2013 at 23:17:09
James. Agreed. The guy is awesome. Have a good xmas. I will. COYB
Colin Wainwright
26 Posted 22/12/2013 at 23:24:34
Two fantastic goals by the best two young players in the country. Don't know what fuckin' game Dan was watching, btw. Based on his recent posts, I don't know what team he's watching.
Jamie Sweet
27 Posted 22/12/2013 at 23:46:48
To put things in perspective, after 17 games last season, the eventual top 4 were on the following points totals:

Man Utd - 42
Man City - 36
Chelsea - 32
Arsenal - 27

So we're right on course for something special here. The main concern being the size and strength in depth of our squad.

It would be criminal not to throw a nice transfer kitty at Roberto in January because if he manages to work his magic in the next window, we could have a serious chance at the big time.

Graham Cass
28 Posted 23/12/2013 at 00:41:13
I think McCarthy is the same bracket as Bracewell was in the 80s team, the unsung hero who did all the gritty stuff to allow the more creative players to get on with it. Those types are vital and just as important as the headline makers but tend to get forgotten about.

I was disappointed with Lakaku; I thought he lacked desire to get onto the end of things but he's only young and does have the knack of popping up with a goal even if he's not in the game, you can see why Chelsea can't risk him in the Champions League at the moment which This good news for us. The main thing is we win when not being on top form and that's the sign of a trophy winning side.

Drew Shortis
29 Posted 23/12/2013 at 01:01:14
McCarthy and Barry make the midfield tick and protect the back four magnificently. They are our main route for playing the ball out from the back. They may not make many eye-catching passes, but they do the simple things very well and link the back four to the front four allowing us to move forward whilst retaining the possession.

Fellaini was most effective when playing in Barkley's position. When he was playing in the deeper role I felt he was less effective and the game sometimes passed him by a little. Barry and McCarthy give an importance balance to the team and I would have those two over two Fellaini's. I loved the big Belgian whilst he was here, but he clearly didn't fit Roberto's system as became obvious in the early games of this season. I don't see him fitting into Man Utd's side as a DM either!

Mike Dolan
30 Posted 22/12/2013 at 23:47:35
Great result today. This was always going to be a tough game because both teams use a similar shape. I thought Coleman was MotM. Can't believe that Macca's ability is being questioned. He reminds me a little of Tony Kay, the guy is a gem. I think his passing will open up a little more in time, he used to spray the ball around at Wigan, but for us, now, he's perfect.

Where do you think Gibson would fit into this team if he were fit? Can you play Gibson, McCarthy and Barry on the same team?

Roman Sidey
31 Posted 23/12/2013 at 01:47:09
James Marshall has hit the nail on the proverbial. The players that make a team tick are akin to the locks and, to an extent, the breakaways in rugby - if you don't see them it's because they did their job.

Also, Coleman's goal was so good I think the build up didn't get enough chat. Quick, neat pass and move from... Here it comes... Oviedaar (?). Loving this little Latino left-back. Baines or no Baines, keep him on the field.

Tim Greeley
32 Posted 23/12/2013 at 01:07:58
Good stuff there, Jamie, makes me think that this all might be actually leading to something. I feel like Man City has the chance to pull away but there are 4-6 other squads vying for places 2, 3, 4........and we are gonna be there til the end.
Andy Osborne
33 Posted 23/12/2013 at 03:28:33
Wayne (#143),

Well said. We are a balanced team. I seem to remember the championship winning team in 1985 we had goal scorers all over the pitch, Derek Mountfield scored 10, I think. The next season Lineker scored 40 and we came second. The team at the moment is balanced with goal scoring opportunities all overt he place. I, for one, don't mind a little bit of selfishness in front of goal, but I would like to see Mirallas pass more.

On Lukaku, I think he is playing well and fulfilling a role. He is a handful for defenders and therefore creates space for other players to use. If he wasn't there, neither would the space be and Barkley, Mirallas, Coleman etc would have fewer opportunities. If we carry on playing like this, we should be thinking of top 2 not top 4.

Harold Matthews
34 Posted 23/12/2013 at 03:39:41
Dan. Try Specsavers.
Jon Withey
37 Posted 23/12/2013 at 08:18:14
Didn't expect any criticism of McCarthy, he gives the midfield bite, wins and keeps the ball + drives it forward. I'm sure Man Utd would love a player like him.

Lukaku was pretty ineffective, to the extent I was waiting for Jelavic to come on. Have him and Mirallas fallen out or something ? they don't click at all.

Barry Pearce
38 Posted 23/12/2013 at 09:11:12
I believe that Barry and McCarthy have been the main reason for our progress this season. Both are doing wonderful jobs in their midfield roles.
James Fletcher
39 Posted 23/12/2013 at 09:10:58
Lukaku would have had a much better game had Mirallas looked up occasionally.
Keith Knowles
40 Posted 23/12/2013 at 09:35:42
£15-Mil for McCarthy? It's gonna be a snip! The lad has slotted in so well you would not think it is his first season with us. Gets to the opposition much faster than that lump Gibson who I am dreading coming back.

Phil Bellis
41 Posted 23/12/2013 at 09:43:12
Dan

The most bollocks you've spouted since the last time... That young man is going to run the Everton midfield — an absolute gem in effort and ability; every great team needs this type of "unsung" water-carrier.

Get yourself a keyboard lock.

Jim Potter
42 Posted 23/12/2013 at 09:37:00
All the Bracewell / McCarthy comments are, to me, spot on. Brace was my favourite player of that sublime period. An understated workhorse who gave his all for the side and was a top, top player.

Mirallas and Pienaar to me are too 'up and down' - never any real consistency. A real pity the Barca lad is inhjured as he was coming into his own (and giving Mirallas a kick up the arse if he wanted a starting berth).

We could easily have accepted that own goal as a game that got away from us yesterday - but we got our heads down and went for the winner. Brilliant.

If, if, if we can keep this form going I reckon we will be top in a few matches time. I'm not saying we'll stay there necessarily - but ... if we all write to Santa now and tell him what we want .... you never know.

Merry Xmas to all Blues and a HNY.

Dan Brierley
43 Posted 23/12/2013 at 10:48:01
Sorry chaps, I think I haven’t explained clearly. For me, the ’Roy Keane’ midfield enforcer type is now almost dead in modern football. Instead, what you see more now for the top teams are players like Ramsey, Arteta, Alonso, Toure, Javi, Martinez playing in the holding role. These players can cover the ground and break up play when not in possession, but also are comfortable on the ball when going forward.

I see the out and out holding player as inefficient, as they are only fully effective when you haven’t got the ball. If you have a hybrid player, he can defend and attack so adds value to the team whatever the situation. This is what I want to see more from McCarthy, I want to see him to develop beyond a Sidwell or Lucas type energetic player, and become a world class player that can also pick out a pass and help to turn defense into attack.

If you are happy to see Everton playing with a ’water-carrier’ type player, then so be it. I never watched Everton in the 80s as I was simply too young. I personally would like to see us evolve into a team where we have 10 outfield players that are all able to contribute to fast, attacking football.

John Staines
44 Posted 23/12/2013 at 11:21:47
James Marshall #150

Bang on the money, Mate.

So good to see a like-minded post....saves me having to write one!

How good is it being an Evertonian at the moment! Happy days.

Cheers

Phil Bellis
45 Posted 23/12/2013 at 11:28:48
Dan Brierley 250

The great Everton teams of my past have always had water-carriers, going back, as has been said in other threads, to Dennis Stevens.

This type of player (Bracewell, Morrissey, Reid etc) allowed others like Sheedy, Young, Harvey the protection and freedom to strut their stuff.

Water-carrier etc no way denigrates the player's ability — one of the hardest, yet most skilful Evertonians I've ever seen was Tony Kay — their contribution to a successful team is immense.

Dan Brierley
46 Posted 23/12/2013 at 11:50:01
I think a lot has changed since those teams were successful though Phil. I am not convinced that the best way for our team to go, is to emulate football eras from previous years. If I understand correctly, the teams you mentioned also had orthodox full backs that do not have any mandate to get down the wing and put crosses in. Whilst there is no doubt that the team of the eighties was magnificent, it doesn't mean that the tactics they employed are still the best in today's modern game.
Kevin Tully
47 Posted 23/12/2013 at 11:55:49
I suppose that's something you don't take into consideration when debating the finer points of Everton's history on here.

When the likes of Dan or others thought Moyes and his anti-football was the best this fine club could hope for, they knew no better.

Hopefully our younger posters can now start to see what the School of Science is all about.

Liam Reilly
48 Posted 23/12/2013 at 12:09:06
Dan # 250
I was lucky to see Bracewell in his prime in that midfiled with Reid, Steven and Sheedy and I can tell you; he was no water carrier. That boy could play.Injury curtailed his career.

I can see strong similarities in Mccarthy who is certailny no water carrier either. He is confortable on the ball and is like a man possessed when we don't have it.

They boy has been awsome since we got him and long may we hold onto him and Barkley.

Brent Stephens
49 Posted 23/12/2013 at 12:13:44
Kevin #258. That's a little condescending, mate. It sounds like you can only have a view about the modern game if you've experienced the old stuff. We may or may not agree with what Dan says but he arguably has a point about the way the game is played today and the way players are used today.

Surely we wouldn't expect a manager and players to get stuck in old routines?

And this isn't a debate about then versus now. It's a debate about one approach now to another approach now.

That's the problem with having been there, done that. You can locked into old ways of thinking.

Phil Bellis
50 Posted 23/12/2013 at 12:11:48
Dan
Tactics and formations evolve, I agree, but a team has to be a composite of differing abilities and roles
Are all Barcelona players Messis? Don't think so

It'd be great to see Everton back to the style, quality and class of 67-70, but, believe me, we were not a team of softies

I'd rather have a Reid, Makalele or Busquet alongside me if the going got tough

Dan Brierley
51 Posted 23/12/2013 at 12:21:55
Kev, my first match at Goodison was Brett Angell's home debut. I can assure you, that Moyes was a fucking god compared to the football I had to suffer for my early days of watching Everton.

Brian Harrison
52 Posted 23/12/2013 at 12:26:46
Yet another great result, OK we were not at our brilliant best but no team can be right through the season. The key is to get results when not at your best and we are doing that very nicely.

I think if we are being picky maybe Lukaku was quiet, but with young players you get inconsistent performances and today was probably his worst in a blue shirt.

I posted yesterday that this period would possibly define our season and yesterday was an excellent start to this period but just because our next game is Sunderland we can't take anything for granted but the teams confidence must be through the roof at present.

Dan Brierley
53 Posted 23/12/2013 at 12:33:21
Phil, I am glad you mentioned Busquets, he is the one that ultimately created the hybrid role I talked about. I don't know how much Barca you get a chance to watch (I am in South West France, so its always on here), but he is the reference for the modern day holding player. No doubt, his 'core business' is defending which he does incredibly well. But going forward, he links up with others in triangles, drives with the ball making space for others and is able to pick out killer passes. Javi Martinez at Bayern is also someone worth watching. Yaya Toure also does an exceptional job in this role, as does Xabi Alonso. When I measure McCarthy agains these guys, he still has some work to do in my mind.

But if people only ever watch Everton, I can fully understand their reaction to what I am saying. For those with the luxury of not having a family who can watch a lot of world football, I am sure they can understand the point I am trying to make about why this role needs to be more than just about having a 'good engine'.

Sam Hoare
54 Posted 23/12/2013 at 12:43:28
Kevin 258. I know is Xmas and you're possibly wearing a large reindeer wooly jumper but that was pretty patronizing!

All I really care about today is that we don't relax and get complacent with Sunderland and end up with a scrappy draw. We don't have as much quality in reserve as the likes of arse, Chelsea and city so the next few weeks may be telling. Will be interesting to see how RM juggles things.

Andrew Ellams
55 Posted 23/12/2013 at 12:43:32
If it wasn't for Sturridge's last minute goal we would be top of the league.

How can anybody possibly criticise Barkley or McCarthy? They are the two standout players at Goodison Park for many a year and a perfect blend and they are only 20 and 22. It's going to be a tough battle for all of those clubs chasing top 4 places and make it or not this team will fight right to the death to get there. BBC news even called us title contenders this morning.

Patrick Murphy
56 Posted 23/12/2013 at 12:42:25
I read an article I think it was in the Echo where Howard Kendall was full of praise for the way this Everton side are progressing, the game hasn't really changed – save for the officials seeing every tackle as a foul – the '80s team did have hard-working individuals and a few players with skill to spare, but Howard acknowledged how important it was to have your full-backs playing like wing-backs and attacking at every opportunity, he felt that his team were able to employ that tactic because of the tremendous positional play of his centre-backs Ratcliffe and Mountfield.

The successful sides have always had a mix of hard-working 'water-carriers' and explosive talent, Everton are nowhere near that level yet, but the signs are very encouraging. Football is a very simple game and when players learn how to keep things simple and become proficient at passing and moving at pace, it can be very beautiful to watch.

Keep it going Blues'.

Andrew Ellams
57 Posted 23/12/2013 at 13:01:51
The simple game quote is spot on Patrick. What Everton have right now is an excellent future if they hold on to some of these players.
Mike Dolan
58 Posted 23/12/2013 at 12:44:50
I think Dans comment re McArthy presume that he is a strictly defensive player which from what I have seen he is not. The style of play employed by Martinez (May Allah kiss his naval) demands that you have possession of the ball so that the opposition spends more time chasing you without it. A player like McArthy is fantastic at closing down and harrying the opposition and not misplacing the outlet pass under pressure. While he might not be a highlight reel he is brilliantly effective at what he does. If you look at his you tubes you can see that his passing is actually spectacular at times . I think he will really blossom in the second half of the season when he is completely integrated into the team. He is a great player.
Jim Knightley
59 Posted 23/12/2013 at 12:59:12
Fantastic result yesterday. It's brilliant to win with two instances of pure class from our players. It's great to see we have a team capable of playing like a team, and players capable of individual brilliance.

I didn't believe we could get top four at the start of the season. In fact, I didn't think we would be anywhere near it. I hadn't changed my opinion before the derby either. But now... I'm beginning to believe it's possible.

January isn't a good time to buy, but we have money. We must take a risk... because this squad can't get top four without a little help. A striker/winger to allow Mirallas to move up top, and midfield cover is a must imo.

I think the Mirallas critiques are justified to an extent. However, I think Coleman's attacking movement is affecting him a bit, as he is being forced into positions where he is less comfortable. I'm also of the opinion that he is better on the left than the right.

Strange to think we've been so good lately, and have Baines to come back in. Oviedo has really impressed and surprised with the speed of his transition into first team football.

And Dan, I think there are clearly spaces for pure defensive central mids in modern football. The players you mention are not McCarthy players... he is not a deep lying midfielder like an Alonso, or a box to box player like Yaya. And Ramsey is similarly a completely different player. Flamini has proved just what a pure defender can do for a team. Arsenal look so much more solid what he plays. Similarly, Mascherano showed his brilliance consistently as a real tackler, even if he has moved into the back-line over the past few seasons. Obviously, the hybrid has become an increasing presence in high possession attacking teams. But, the Premier League is not La Liga, nor is it the Bundesliga. It's the most competitive and high tempo European league across the teams, and not as 'Europeanised' as the others yet (although it's getting that way). Pure tacklers with high workrates have their place still. That said, I think McCarthy is more than that.

Brent Stephens
60 Posted 23/12/2013 at 13:17:42
Lee Mason took a heap load of flack before the game. What he wasn't going to do to undermine us. A pretty fair game, I thought.

Sorry, not meant to praise refs, I know!

Alan McGuffog
61 Posted 23/12/2013 at 13:14:08
And that in a nutshell is it. An excellent future IF we keep hold of these players.

We have been for many years now a selling club. We do not have the resources to offer immense contracts to individuals or, realistically, promise silverware.

I would love to think that we would be able to develop a team for the future around Coleman, McCarthy and Barkley but that will not be allowed to happen. Buying clubs will covet their skills and, without getting too "grassy knollist ", will also seek to kill off any further competition from the likes of Everton.

I have heard the rumour that our favourite Uruguayan (I love the fans and they love me) has a £100 million escape clause in his much vaunted contract. Is there any way such a clause could be put into our top players' contracts? For example, if OFM comes a-calling for Ross can we not say " sure thing... where's the £80 million cash? Or doesn't plucky little Everton play hard ball?

Michael Ward
62 Posted 23/12/2013 at 13:40:31
Didn't this wholly defensive minded McCarthy win the free kick that won the game with a driving run through the middle? Wasn't he also the guy who will claim the assist for Coleman's goal?

As for the players you mention what are Alonso, Toure and Javi Garcia doing while Khederia, Fernandinho and Lahm are running around getting the ball back for them?

Derek Williams
63 Posted 23/12/2013 at 14:15:29
Loved seeing:

a) Coleman doing a Ketsbaia after his screamer.
b) Barkleys coming of age 'Rooney against Arsenal' moment.
c) Martinez screaming "What a fucking Goal!" after b).

We need to be targeting Top 2 after Christmas and defo need to spend in the January sales.

Brian Furey
64 Posted 23/12/2013 at 15:07:17
Another Monday where I can't wait to get onto TW to read the banter. I was worried we could slip up this weekend away to the Swans and they sure did make it hard for us. Being from my neck of the woods I am delighted with Coleman. His determination to win and work his socks off is a credit to the lad and should show all budding teenagers what is required to succeed if you don't possess that raw talent of Barkley or Rooney. Anyone know his twitter account or how I could contact our Seamus. I think he's changed from a raw hard working full back to a fast, intelligent player who can now take on his man with both speed and skill. Of course he'll take the wrong option the odd time but I think he's really passed out Baines with his ability to get forward and beat a man and have a shot. Hopefully we see you should a lot more Seamie and not be following Mr Bale

Come on Arsenal. I'm off to the local to watch it tonight with a Gunner, a Manure fan & a RS fan.

Jon Withey
65 Posted 23/12/2013 at 16:07:53
#281 spot on. The game is still played when the team doesn't have the ball, modern or not.

Anyway, McCarthy is always moving us forward, he's not just a wrecker or defensive shield.

Dennis Ng
66 Posted 23/12/2013 at 16:20:40
I thought McCarthy and Barry did a wonderful job. Coleman and Barkley were ridiculous in the game. Only thing I was not too amused about was Mirallas's shots. I saw him squirming the ball too tamely towards the GK quite a few times now in other games... Maybe they should play him less deep, I always remember him doing better when he's moving towards the half circle of the box.

Alan, I don't think they have those clauses right now but I'm sure they will be in there IF they give new contracts. And I hope soon. If these guys do well in the WC, god knows what clubs might come for them...I don't think we are at real risk of selling them right now though. It would be more of a risk if we are mid table right now. We are not really in great need of selling as we were a years ago.

Harold Matthews
67 Posted 23/12/2013 at 15:40:02
Yes Brian, we all love Seamus but Lukaku would welcome a few early crosses. In fact, playing up front for Everton must be a nightmare. Mirallis doesn't like to part with the ball if he's anywhere near the goal, Pienaar passes it too far or too short, Barkley likes to shoot from outside the box and Coleman won't cross till he's had a go at dribbling the fullback. A sorry state of affairs which need to be sorted. We've harped on about it for months but nothing has changed. Apart from Lukaku not scoring goals.
Linda Morrison
68 Posted 23/12/2013 at 16:35:42
Like Brian I was worried about a slip up yesterday. Just not used to Everton winning all the time.

What a good team performance. I can only echo the concerns of the rest, the squad is small.

Looking at Distin it is hard to believe he is 16 years older than Barkley!

I have confidence that Bk will provide Roberto with the funds to add to the squad. We will be mathematically safe on 40 points if we win our last 2 games this year, how's that for starters.

Merry Xmas to all TW

Dennis Ng
69 Posted 23/12/2013 at 17:13:55
Harold, indeed, Everton is the bane of all strikers. I wonder why we still buy them. I think Lukaku is unlike the typical striker, e.g. Jela.

RM's approach is working wonders because of our bad recent history with strikers and opens up the game to our advantage. I rate Lukaku highly and he provides options to play a #9 when the opposition warrants that. I do think we should not worry about the #9 problem though. Lukaku will find ways to score later on in the season. I wasn't expecting Coleman to be such a dribbler but he sure is darn good for a right back!

We might want to sign a few good crossers just to open that up. Our corner taking has been horrible lately...Wasting the good bodies we have in there with Lukaku and our regular defence...

Ross Edwards
70 Posted 23/12/2013 at 21:51:58
Dan, with the greatest of respect, I have to disagree with you regarding McCarthy. I haven't noticed a split within the fanbase, mainly because he has been so good since he has signed.

£13 million was an absolute bargain. We are much more solid with him in the side. When we missed him v Fulham, there was a marked difference in our defending in that game compared with the Stoke City and Man Utd games.

Jackie Barry
72 Posted 24/12/2013 at 07:01:24
Not sure how anyone can come to the conclusion that Dan has on McCarthy. I certainly have not noticed a split in the fan base the vast majority of Evertonian's are extremely happy with him, in my opinion he is head and shoulders above Fellaini, somebody who we are not missing at all. An absolute bargain and he is only going to get better.
Steve Pugh
73 Posted 24/12/2013 at 07:43:10
I have noticed a split over McCarthy. There are those that think he is really good; and then there are those that think he is really fucking good.
Gavin McGarvey
74 Posted 24/12/2013 at 07:18:52
I'm pleased with McCarthy so far, and I think he has been a big part of recent success. We're certainly missing him when he's not there as RM's style of play relies on having the two holding midfielders to provide enough cover for the other players to get forward. Also they are crucial in keeping possession and gaining control over the centre of the park, something we haven't seriously tried to do in years.

A lot of players that Dan is comparing him to are much older and more experienced and some are just to me different types of player, e.g. Yaya Toure doesn't really play a similar game. That said, things have changed since the '80s and, no matter how great that team was, this isn't the Blues Brothers where you can just get the old band back together.

Bearing that in mind, I think it's quite refreshing that Martinez is finding a way to play that is a little more progressive than before. Also RM's comments on McCarthy show me at least that he expects progression from him beyond that of breaking up play (important though that still is). Indeed, while I would obviously like a little more creative work now and again (eg, he was all a bit head down run as fast as you can for that free kick), the main thing I'd like to improve would be a few less dangerous tackles as he has jumped in without thinking at times.

Dennis Ng
75 Posted 24/12/2013 at 11:27:03
Steve, I'm on the lesser good side then, though I am equally curious how Dan got the negative impression on McCarthy. He's outperforming my expectations and while I still consider £13M a lot for him, RM is working every penny off that price tag of his.
Dan Brierley
76 Posted 24/12/2013 at 12:34:47
Ross, I think the Fulham game is a good example. We had a creative player in the centre, who scored one and set up another with a perfectly weighted pass. and ended up scoring 4, even after a sticky part in the 2nd half. I don’t see what’s not to like about that? Would you not love to see McCarthy chipping in with clever balls and goals?

Lukaku looked completely starved against Swansea, absolutely no balls to feet or anybody picking him out when he was making a run. I would like to see McCarthy develop into a player that is also able to contribute to attack when we are in possession. It seems a lot of people believe he is already the complete player, and needs no development which I am surprised about. He is great at what he does, but up to now his greatest plaudit is that he covers a lot of ground.

As I have mentioned before, that was also something that Steve Sidwell was lauded for, and I personally didn’t rate him as highly as the media and pundits as on the ball he looked lost. I don’t know, perhaps you guys think he is an excellent player! Each to their own I guess.

I think the reaction here, is that nobody seems to be willing to recognise the areas for improvement when we are on a good run. I can guarantee you that the manager and players won’t be sitting round saying all is wonderful. If we want to be a top team, then we need a mindset that says even when we win, we still focus on improving.

There will be a difficult run for us at some point; every team has one. So when our front line are misfiring, I would love to see players like McCarthy also taking some creative responsibility. But, like I said before, if all is rosy in your world then so be it. I personally always want more from our team.

Mark Frere
77 Posted 24/12/2013 at 13:29:08
Dan Brierley

There was a real lack of energy in our midfield against Fulham, the 4-1 scoreline definitely flattered us. It's been very evident that when McCarthy plays we play much better. With Barry and McCarthy playing in the middle, it allows our fullbacks to get up the pitch and attack at will because Barry and McCarthy cover for them.

McCarthy is excellent at retaining the ball and rarely gives it away. The duo which you always seem to criticise control the midfield and don't allow the opposition a foothold in midfield. We could have a player like Cazorla playing in McCarthy's position – yes, he has considerably more creative talent but he doesn't have McCarthy's other qualities that complement our team.

It's all about what works best for the team and I've got say we look well balanced; we are creating chances and scoring goals.

It really doesn't matter how Barcelona, Bayern Munich, Man City etc, play – it's all about what works for us. Systems like 3-5-2, 4-4-2 and 4-3-3 go out of fashion, then teams start to use them again. The Shite from across the park have deployed 3 at the back in parts this season, just because most other teams haven't, it hasn't stopped them.

My point is: just because we play with 2 CMs that don't have the creative talent of Cazorla and Alonso, it doesn't mean we are going about things in the wrong way. We don't have to be like sheep – following the way Bayern, Barca and Man City play. If its working for us then there's no need to nit-pick for the sake of it.

Wayne Smyth
78 Posted 24/12/2013 at 14:19:47
Dan, the problem is, you're nitpicking a young player who has barely played a dozen games for us and comparing him against the very best in the world. I agree I'd love to see McCarthy play like Toure or Busquets, and he may well turn out to be that good.

However, we have more serious problems elsewhere than McCarthy's shortcomings. How about a striker who can score 40 goals like linker? Centre backs who are as good as Beckenbauer? Shall we criticise Pienaar because he's not Messi? Or Mirallas because he's not quite as good as Ronaldo? How about Barkley, who is improving, but he's not quite at Zidane's level yet....

Sorry, but your criticism just looks misplaced (and thats the most polite way I can put it). If we could afford any of the great players you're talking about then it would be a different matter. We can't, so no point in the criticism really, is there?

Tony Waring
79 Posted 24/12/2013 at 15:45:34
Never mind the fabulous footy we are witnessing this season. When will somebody, anybody, address the biggest problem facing EFC? Barkley's haircut!
Dan Brierley
80 Posted 24/12/2013 at 16:16:31
think its fair to say that there were plenty of people making comparisons with greats from yesteryear Wayne, hence the reason I compared him to todays great players. But you are right, it will be seen as unnecessary nitpicking as today we are on a good run.
No doubt many of those saying he is the best player they have ever seen will be ripping him to shreds for not doing enough when we are enduring a difficult run.

But I am sure they are aware of his weaknesses on the training ground, and will be trying to develop that side of his game. I hope he goes on to being truly world class.

Colin Wainwright
81 Posted 24/12/2013 at 16:45:40
Just let it grow Tony. Let it grow mate.
Paul Davies
82 Posted 24/12/2013 at 18:08:38
Fantastic atmosphere in the away end on Sunday. Got talking to a few Swansea fans on the way back to the car and they reckon that's the best away support they've seen in many a year.

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads

© ToffeeWeb