Boxing Day disaster ends proud unbeaten record

, 26 December, 76comments  |  Jump to most recent
Everton 0 - 1 Sunderland

Tim Howard's dismissal after 25 minutes for a foul on Ki following Osman's error left the Blues with a mountain to climb
Everton's hopes of going all of 2013 without being beaten at home were wrecked by a disastrous moment after 25 minutes when Tim Howard was sent off for tripping Ki Sung-Yeung and the South Korean scored what would prove to be the winning goal from the spot.

Everton had been in familiar control of proceedings, albeit without really troubling Vito Mannone on the Sunderland goal but the game turned on an awful slip by Leon Osman where he mis-controlled in front of his own penalty area and Ki robbed him to set up a one-on-one with Howard.

Referee Lee Probert had little option but to give the American his marching orders once he'd brought Ki down and Roberto Martinez was forced to hook Osman to put Joel Robles in goal to face the penalty. The Spanish 'keeper guessed the right way but couldn't save the spot kick and the Blues were up against it.

Martinez was forced into another change at half time when Kevin Mirallas was withdrawn through illness but his replacement, Ross Barkley, was a good deal more effective than the Belgian had been but he was unable to produce the heroics needed to pull Everton back into the match.

Like Romelu Lukaku, the 20 year-old had a number of efforts from outside of the area that tested Mannone to varying degrees but the Blues were generally frustrated by Gus Poyet's men who dug in and soaked up the pressure

Barkley came closest to salvaging a point from a Boxing Day disaster but Mannone pushed his 84th-minute free kick wide at full stretch and Borini headed off his own line from a Nikica Jelavic header off the resulting corner as the Blues threw bodies into the visitors' area in a desperate attempt to score.

Unfortunately, it wasn't to be and Everton fell to only their second League defeat of the season and remain in fifth place going into the last match of the year against Southampton on Sunday.

Quotes or other material sourced from ToffeeWeb Match Reports



Reader Comments (76)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Andy Meighan
1 Posted 26/12/2013 at 23:31:43
I've praised Roberto to the hilt but leaving Barkley out for a one-paced ageing midfielder was criminal. Leaving out our best player, trying to be clever, thinking the points were safe, just isn't on. And I am one angry bastard tonight.


Susong Hermawan
2 Posted 26/12/2013 at 23:44:47
Next match win is a must... Up the Blues!!
David Pearl
3 Posted 26/12/2013 at 23:56:47
Surely Andy, Martinez should be able to utilize his squad without fear of school boy errors. I don't know why it was Osman collecting the ball so deep anyway... that usually Barry's job. I think a little protection of Barkley was what he was thinking. As it is we have to cover both suspensions, Barry and Howard on Sunday. With Del Boy, Gibson and Kone out injured our squad now appears very thin. Onwards and upwards though. Poyet called us the best team they have played this season; we were all over them with 10 men. We are going in the right direction
Mick Davies
4 Posted 27/12/2013 at 00:12:16
As long as this puts to bed the love affair with Osman I can take it. Need some fresh employees in January
Shahul Hameed
5 Posted 27/12/2013 at 01:54:29
It wasn't our day. Osman and Howard had given us points and games before. Let us not be too hard about it. We will rise stronger from this.
Harold Matthews
6 Posted 27/12/2013 at 02:41:23
Mick. There is no love affair. Just genuine fair minded people stepping in to defend him from the constant stream of obscene hatred. Wishing misfortune on others is the surest way of bringing it on to yourself.....and on to whoever you support.
Tony Farrell
7 Posted 27/12/2013 at 03:16:34
Spirited display, I agree, but why leave young Barkley out of the side? He's buzzing at the moment and scoring goals. You could see the difference when he came on; he lifts not just the fans but the players around him. He dosen't need a rest, he's a young man for god's sake.

Usual season slip up by Tim Howard... why roll a ball out to a player that has a man up his arse? And why did Ozzie want the pass there in such a dangerous position? Apart from that, the second half display was sound; we deserved at least a point.

Has anyone else read Lukaku's comment on Sky Sports about him returning to Chelsea next season, being one of the world's top strikers? It was only a couple of weeks ago he was saying he would like to stay at Everton if we made the Champions League. A January striker is Bob's main priority... I don't think Jelly's the answer.

Jimmy Sørheim
9 Posted 27/12/2013 at 05:14:30
Osman is an average player who does not deserve to wear the Everton shirt.
To lose this game of all games is so very typical of the old Everton I know that it seems we are heading towards a poor second season syndrome.

Today I am embarrased, Martinez has a long way to go, this game goes to rove that, but the worse is yet to come. Lukaku has lost his form, he looks lost and tired.

I am blaming this loss on Martinez!!!!!!!!!!

Steve Brown
10 Posted 27/12/2013 at 06:46:45
It was just one of those days where everything that could go wrong did. The annoyance on here just shows the weight of expectation given the season we are having. If it hadn't been for one moment of JOINT stupidity by Howard and Osman, then we would have won that game.

Let's see how the team responds to the setback... I expect them to bounce against Southampton.

Mark Andersson
11 Posted 27/12/2013 at 07:31:46
Well well, the real fans are the ones who are staying positive. As for all the negative bull s--- rants, get over your self. It's been a good season so far. Some good football some good goals. Great team spirit shown today. It was just one of those day's .

The manager is doing a great job, the players are working hard so do what the word Support means and get behind your team even Leon. You moaning fw

Andrew Clare
12 Posted 27/12/2013 at 08:10:13
Well said Mark.
It was just one of those games!
Paul Andrews
13 Posted 27/12/2013 at 08:17:13
He tried to manage his squad with two games in 3 days. That is why he saved Barkley for Southampton.

Be honest, which of you thought Sunderland was the easier game to rest players? The honest answer is all of us did.

Christopher Kelly
14 Posted 27/12/2013 at 08:13:18
Surely a stupid pass to Leon but I've been playing soccer for 25 years and I don't recall a player tripping on the ball like that.

The infuriating part is that it's just so typical Everton. Even in the Moyes era we'd drop these silly points.

until we can ditch the old guard (Osman' Pienaar, HIbbert etc.) we're still a 5-7 team and not really a top 4. Sorry lads. It's JUST the way it is. There's a reason why no one;s EVER come in for HIbbert or Osman and Pienaar couldn't get the job done at Tottenham.

Charles Brewer
16 Posted 27/12/2013 at 08:43:14
It was a horrible error that required both players to make a really bad error.

What concerned me more wasthe inability to seriously trouble another mediocre team who came to "park the bus". The free kick apart, there wasn't a really good chance, indeed they had more than we did. In fact a 0-0 would have been little better.

Martinez has the style and ability for playing open matches against teams which want to win, which is why we are doing well against top half teams, but no answer to closed games where they just want to defend. In fact I suspect we do better in games or periods within them, where we have less rather than more possession.

Closed games call for a Duncan-style striker who gets lots of service in the air and manages to get on the end of a few crosses. And we don't have one of those. Lukaku looks the part, but doesn't seem to have the mindset.

Charles Brewer
17 Posted 27/12/2013 at 08:43:14
It was a horrible error that required both players to make a really bad error.

What concerned me more wasthe inability to seriously trouble another mediocre team who came to "park the bus". The free kick apart, there wasn't a really good chance, indeed they had more than we did. In fact a 0-0 would have been little better.

Martinez has the style and ability for playing open matches against teams which want to win, which is why we are doing well against top half teams, but no answer to closed games where they just want to defend. In fact I suspect we do better in games or periods within them, where we have less rather than more possession.

Closed games call for a Duncan-style striker who gets lots of service in the air and manages to get on the end of a few crosses. And we don't have one of those. Lukaku looks the part, but doesn't seem to have the mindset.

Carl Sanderson
18 Posted 27/12/2013 at 08:47:47
Mick 149:

It's not a "love affair" with Osman. That lad, a talented, loyal one-club man, has taken unbelievable abuse on here. Some people find that distasteful and wish to provide some balance.

Anyway, that colossal balls-up was Howard's fault in the first instance. He had the bigger picture and must have seen Ki being touch-tight with Osman. It was a stupid ball to play.

But I can't expect you to appreciate that simple point: wasn't it you who compared Osman with Tiger McLaughlin?

Scott Jones
19 Posted 27/12/2013 at 08:23:14
Why all the negativity, guys? If Martinez had of started with Barkley and he had of "done" his hamstring, people would have roasted Martinez for risking Ross against the bottom team! No-win situation for the gaffer.

Some of the comments on this site are exactly the attitude Martinez is trying to eradicate from the playing staff... a NEGATIVE attitude is what has held this club back for years!

I'm sure Martinez will use the next game as an indicator of which players have the mental strength to roll there socks up, wipe the sweat from their brow, and WIN!

Ray Roche
20 Posted 27/12/2013 at 08:58:03
Christopher Kelly @ 185

"I've been playing soccer for 25 years and I don't recall a player tripping on the ball like that." So, Chris, you didn't see Barkley fall over his own feet at Swansea when clean through?

I've said both on here and at the match that we piss about too much playing short balls all the time to the edge of the area to Distin, Jags, Barry or yesterday, Osman, frequently when there's a man close to them. This has been on the cards for weeks and Howard is as culpable as Osman. What is it about Everton fans who feel the need to heap bile and hatred on a player because he has either come through the ranks or because he didn't cost the earth?'

If Lukaku were to look a bit more interested ALL the time he'd be banging more goals. Or, alternatively, if we had players to play to his strengths he'd be scoring more. There are two ways to look at his performances but he needs to start scoring more or give him a rest.

James Wong
21 Posted 27/12/2013 at 09:13:12
1. Martinez left Barkley out cause he was on 4 yellow cards, Barry was also on 4 yellows as well.

2. Not to play the blame game but it was more Howards fault than Osman, he had the view of the whole pitch. PLUS he should have never fouled Ki in the first place, concede the goal but don't get a red card!

3. Both Howard and Osman have been match winners this year so the amount of stick they have got here and other sites is unbelievable. Osman in the last couple of years has been playing very well.

Brent Stephens
23 Posted 27/12/2013 at 10:12:39
If you take the view that this is the game that Roberto wants us to play, short balls in and around the box, even when the opposition are close by, and if you take the view that all players make boobs, then this was a "disaster" waiting to happen.

If you also take the view that Roberto likes to mix things up and have players moving into all sorts of positions, to keep the opposition thinking and try to free up space, then it's not surprising that Osman was looking for that ball from Howard, instead of the usual others.

If you also take the view that a horrendous slip should banish a player for ever, then we'd have banished the lot of them before now - they've all made and will make horrendous slip ups.

I'm gutted but now look to the Sarfampton game knowing how well we've already done this season.

Max Murphy
24 Posted 27/12/2013 at 10:08:30
Using the argument that Barkley was not played because he was on 4 yellows is ludicrous. If that was the case, he'd never be selected for the rest of the season.
We all know RM has changed our style of play with the short passing game, and playing the ball from the back. But the team must realise if the pass is not on, then don't make it! Hoof it up the pitch! This hasn't quite got through to Howard. If you remember earlier in the season he did another ridiculous short pass, and if not for the heroics of Barry we would certainly have conceded a goal.
As supporters of this club, and contributors to TW, we have every right to criticise the team, giving praise when due, and castigating them when they act like clowns.
These mistakes had nothing to do with our manager. It was bad decision making and technically inept play by certain members of the team.
Roberto Martinez is doing a great job.
Wayne Smyth
25 Posted 27/12/2013 at 10:30:00
Max I think the issue is that with Barry also on 4 Martinez may not have wanted both Barry and Barkley unavailable for the Southampton game. Also need to remember the slate is wiped clean for the New Year. Ultimately none of us know why Barkley was not picked. Osman is not shite and should've been a capable deputy.

Osman was in that position because the entire midfield rotates with the exception of Barry who always seems to hold. He fucked up on this occasion - as did howard - and it cost us, but that is not the managers fault.

As for the whole goals conceded due to passing around the back, I think its not an issue. We've played 18 games like this and conceded 1 goal due to bad individual decision making and got off the hook with the Barry save on his debut.

I think the positives that we are getting used to being more comfortable on the ball and don't give it away so much far outweigh the odd goal here or there. When we've gone long it is so shit. Giving away possession and giving the other team the opportunity to attack. Fellaini is not in the team anymore and Lukaku, despite his size, doesn't seem to hold it up particularly well......and in any case the long balls are too often wayward.

We've one of the best defensive records in the league so Roberto is doing something right with is system of retaining possession and passing it from the back. One individual error should not and will not change his philosophy. What we need is to give the players time to adapt or Roberto the chance to bring in his own players he feels are capable of playing his system.

Robbie Shields
26 Posted 27/12/2013 at 10:27:53
Well, after nearly 24 hours to come to terms with that defeat, I think I am finally ready to talk about it.

Firstly, I'd like to say that whilst I am, and always have been, one of Martinez's biggest fans, for me he has royally fooked up 3 times this season, each time costing us wins. Barkley must start every game when he is fit, no ifs or buts. The 3 games Martinez put Osman in instead of Barkley we have failed to win. Not just that, but they have been our poorest performances to boot, no penetration, no creativity, no pace, no inventiveness.

Secondly, Osman must never ever start a game when we have anyone else available, he is a complete liability from the start of any match. Osman can come on with 20 minutes to go and inject a bit of class when everyone is knackered and/or running out of ideas. In truth, I believe Osman should always have been a last 20 minutes sub, for exactly the reasons Tony Marsh has been banging on about for the last 10 years.

I'd also like to say that Martinez has more often than not got it right, signings, subs, team selection, formations, style of play, philosophy, media etc etc. But he has screwed up in those 3 matches for me, I hope he learns and damn site quicker than OFM did, and I'm pretty confident he will.

The game itself was 'one of those games' and despite us playing some great footy with only 10 men for an hour and Sunderland playing very well as well I might add, we couldn't salvage a point. I think Martinez has been waiting for Howard to drop his annual clangers and give Robles a chance, this could well be the last we see of Howard for a while if Robles has a good game against the Saints.

Finally, can all the blues who were spouting crap about us winning the next x games and only having to turn up please cut it out. It's pathetic, disrespectful, arrogant, bloody annoying and one of the most basic errors that can be made in Football, plus it makes you sound like Kopites. One game at a time and 'Fight, fight, fight with all our might' in every game, because that's exactly what the opposition does and exactly what we need to do to get the maximum out of the season.

COYB

James Marshall
27 Posted 27/12/2013 at 10:42:14
Look, we lost a game but seriously, all the bile aimed at players and even the manager, is childish, reactionary bullshit I'm afraid. Get some perspective.

We're still 5th, still only 3 points off 3rd place, and with plenty more winnable games to come. Plus the teams above us still have to play each other again - it's still very much game-on.

Osman was exactly the right choice yesterday, because we were playing the team bottom of the league at home. It's a squad game and Barkley is essentially a child playing in a mans league. Do not underestimate the power of burn-out and mental fatigue on a kid his age.

It's alright for us, shouting from the stands or behind our laptops, but seriously you have to give the kid a break for his own good, and Osman is a worthy replacement - OK he made a glaring error yesterday, but what about all the times he's played really well for us and scored vital goals/set them up? All too easy to forget when it suits us, right?

Howard should never have played the ball to him in the first place, and then gone on to give away the penalty and get himself (yes, himself) sent off. Osman made a mistake, Howard made two, so if anyone is to blame, it's the pair of them. Scapegoats so not help though, and I guarantee you that at the next training session you won't find them all blaming each other or pointing fingers - that's the difference between positive, winners and professionals, and us, the mere mortals and armchair critics who actually do nothing to help the cause.

Complaining and a culture of blame is a massive negative that Roberto Martinez is stamping out at Everton. We would do well to take a leaf out of his book here on ToffeeWeb.

Liam Reilly
28 Posted 27/12/2013 at 10:47:40
Just one of those days. Even with 10 men, we bossed it. Poor decision by 2 senior players.

Charles 189, "closed games call for Duncan style knockdowns".

Jesus, Ive seen Everton play enough of that style to last me a liferime.

James Marshall
29 Posted 27/12/2013 at 10:51:36
Oh, and Robbie#207

Arrogance is an important part of what Martinez is bringing to the club, and should be encouraged not stamped out. A winning mentality is built around the arrogant nature of the way we play and the attitude we take into winning games, not just playing games.

That arrogance should be fed into the supporters as well - just look at the way the RS, Utd, CIty, Chelsea and Arsenal supporters talk about their teams. I hear constant comments like, "we should be beating these teams easily" every week, and it's that attitude that sticks and it's that attitude that helps teams win games.

I completely disagree about not being arrogant and not expecting to beat the teams below us. 100% the wrong way to look at it. Arrogance breeds a winning mentality. Go listen to some of Roberto Martinez' recent interviews.

Max Murphy
30 Posted 27/12/2013 at 10:54:33
Thanks Wayne for clarifying the cards' situation
Raymond Fox
31 Posted 27/12/2013 at 10:48:03
I have been waiting for something to go wrong, its been all going too well! That's life isn't it.

We've not made many mistakes lately, but the pass to Ossie was ill advised, then he slips which you cant hold against Osman.

We still had some good attempts at scoring and were unlucky not to at least draw in the end!

Its very disappointing, welcome back to the real world!

Terry Downes
32 Posted 27/12/2013 at 11:16:19
Unbelievable some fans on here cant wait to blame Martinez as soon as something goes wrong... get a grip, lads. For one, we have no divine right to win every game and mistakes will happen to us and every other team.

Leave Ma,rtinez alone, calm down and go for a pint!

Paul Tran
33 Posted 27/12/2013 at 11:21:55
It's still going well, Raymond.

Martinez made his first blunder yesterday in leaving out Barkley. He should always start, especially against teams who are going to park the bus. If you're worried about burnout, take him off after an hour when we're in front. That's when you bring on Osman to do his fresh legs, steady as we go stuff.

The first half was like the Fulham game, we were struggling to get past the bus, Barkley opened things up in the second half, from when I thought we played very well, created lots of chances and came up against a keeper in fine form.

If I was Martinez I'd take a DVD of the game into the board and say 'here's where we are now, how good could we be if we bought.........?

Someone mentioned choking. I didn't see any of that yesterday. I thought we stuck to our guns, did the right things and on another day, would have got a bagful.

Same again on Sunday will give us three points.

We're still a good side, playing good stuff.

We still need reinforcements. January will be interesting.........

Brian Harrison
34 Posted 27/12/2013 at 11:33:22
Disappointing to lose to the bottom club, but I think the reaction to the players from the fans said everything. Yes it was a silly mistake that not only led to their goal but probably worse was we were down to 10 men. Despite that it was Everton doing most of the attacking and in the second half I think Sunderland only got in our half a couple of times.

After playing for most of the game with 10 men, I just hope it hasnt taken too much out of the players for the Southampton game, who came back to form on Boxing day. Apart from the result I thought Mirallas and Lukaku were not at their best yesterday and unfortunately Mirallas is having a really disappointing season for me. But as games come thick and fast no use feeling sorry for ourselves so need to be ready to start another great run of results starting with Southampton.

Robbie Shields
35 Posted 27/12/2013 at 11:45:37
James, I think the arrogance Martinez talks about was more about the players playing with confidence and even a little arrogance. To me, that's very different to the arrogance of supporters saying 'we'll win the next 4 games' as if it's a computer game. Rookie mistakes, just makes us look like pricks. Personally I can't stand it when I hear any supporter saying, we'll win the next 5 games, they're easy, just reminds me too much of Kopites, not becoming of Evertonians, just my view, that's all.
Robbie Shields
36 Posted 27/12/2013 at 11:53:53
Actually, the game reminded me of one when we first won the League with Kendal. If my memory is right, we played Chelsea on Boxing Day and battered them, but it seemed that every time they broke away they scored. We ended up losing something like 4 - 3, but Everton left the pitch to a standing ovation. At half time all the fans in the Gwlady Street End (Of which I was one) were singing along to Paul McCartneys Frog Chorus in the rain, amazing days in which we just seemed to know something special was happening to our great club despite the disappointment on the day. I think we may even have gone on and not lost another game until the end of the season.

Yesterday's match reminded me very much of that day, hopefully it's a good omen :)

James Marshall
37 Posted 27/12/2013 at 11:59:52
Robbie - that's fair enough mate, I get the picture and agree.

We do need a certain amount of arrogance about us, as a club I mean. And in that I mean from the players up to us, the supporters we need to be confident in beating teams like Sunderland. I would hate us to have the full-blown-RS type arrogance though, as you say which just makes us look like pricks. As you say!

I do think we 'should' be looking to win the next few games, but saying we WILL win them, is just foolhardy. Arrogance needs to be tempered with realism.

Patrick Murphy
38 Posted 27/12/2013 at 11:57:41
Robbie I'm similar to yourself - I only like to know who we are playing in the next game and all this 'four winnable games coming up' is utter nonsense; Every match is winnable otherwise there would be no point in turning up, conversely every match can be lost or drawn.

I suppose all supporters of every club have the same range of views as TW from wildly optimistic who think 'we only need to turn up to win' to the doom-mongers who can't see how the Blues' can win any game.

It was good to see the fans' reaction in the second-half yesterday, but we only seem to produce that type of support in adversity, if we could just be like that for the whole season against every team it would be tremendous, but that is probably asking a little too much.

I wish someone could have told me that the bottom three at kick-off would all win I could have made a killing at the bookies - I think it was Lineker who said the odds were something like 145-1.

Steve Sweeney
39 Posted 27/12/2013 at 12:01:05
I remember that Chelsea game... I think Kerry Dixon scored a hat-trick.

And yes, we won 12 on the trot after that.

Robbie Shields
40 Posted 27/12/2013 at 12:09:46
Good points James, I actually think Martinez has done a great job of turning the mindset of the players, fans and club in general to be positive and confident in such a short space of time, it's amazing actually. I think I'm just concerned that arrogance tends to lead to complacency, not good if you want to win anything.
Andrew Ellams
41 Posted 27/12/2013 at 12:46:00
We can only hope that this was a bad day at the office. The silver lining to the cloud is that a win on Sunday will bring us to the half way point as serious top 4 contenders with fewer defeats than anybody else in the league.

If Osman is not for you then I would stay in dark room on Sunday because I can't see anybody else playing instead of Barry unless we see Heitinga come in to counter the deep striker that Southampton play.

Mike Powell
42 Posted 27/12/2013 at 12:48:35
Yes, we lost the game to a very poor side and Martinez made a mistake in starting Osman, but I was proud off the team the way they played in the second half. The ref never helped at all, he gave them everything although the penalty and sending off was the only decision he got right. Southampton is a must-win game.
Mike Keating
43 Posted 27/12/2013 at 12:59:12
Treble error
1. Howard to Osman with a man bearing down on him
2. Osman for day dreaming
3. Howard for diving in and getting the mandatory red (even if there was no contact).
Only Everton could boast the best unbeaten run in the Prem interrupted by 2 defeats - one to the favourites to win it and the other to the favourites to go down.
Having said that - as with the derby - their goalie was MOTM and that was the best 10 man performance I have seen by any side in ages.
COYB
Kevin Tully
44 Posted 27/12/2013 at 12:45:14
We lost because of one glaring error by two players and bad luck.

Down to ten men, we forced 11 corners to their 2. We had 21 attempts on goal with 9 on target, and an 88% pass completion rate.

In seasons gone by, we would have struggled to match those figures with 13 on the park. I'm not happy we lost, but it's not as if we took a hiding on the back of a player being sent off. The team with 11 men were hanging on for dear life, as they would have done against any of the other top sides.

Andrew Ellams
45 Posted 27/12/2013 at 13:45:17
There have been some odd results so far this season, one had to come out way at some point
Mark Taylor
46 Posted 27/12/2013 at 13:39:06
Although I think it was a mistake picking Osman, it's at least possible to see the reasoning behind it and one still couldn't anticipate the 'mistake compounding mistake to yield disaster' scenario we had yesterday. Beating even a cr@p side like Sunderland with 10 men from 1-0 down is a big ask.

Of more pressing concern is the form (or complete absence of it) of our two key attacking threats, Mirallas and Lukaku. Both Belgians have been poor recently. As someone on another thread asturely put it, Lukaku looks increasingly like a rich man's Vic, while Mirallas has been well below the level we've seen in the past.

Our big problem is, alternatives are thin on the ground to the point of emaciation. Delboy is still a month away, Jelly appears to be a man never destined to score again and Velios does not look to have the class to make it at this level. What to do?

My own suggestion is a bit radical, but I think we need to try a non Lukaku solution (and hope that makes him buck his ideas up).

I'd switch Pienaar to the right where I think he can link up well with a rampaging Seamus, bring back Baines at LB and push Oviedo into LM, allowing them to interchange. Then the risky bit- Mirallas up front. While he has been pretty poor, I think we are also playing him out of position and the selfishness we have all seen is less of a liability as a striker- in fact it's an asset. I think his pace and movement might also fit in better with the different style we have this season, with more going through the middle.

The team needs a bit of freshening up and since we don't have a deep squad, this might be a route. The other option I guess would be RM's favoured 3 at the back but that means leaving out either Baines or Oviedo.

Steve Cotton
47 Posted 27/12/2013 at 13:59:21
A good opportunity on Sunday to play with just one holding midfielder and play an extra striker. If we start with two attacking midfielders instead of the one we should prove more likely to score.

Time for Pienaar and Mirallas to hit top form and let's go for it. We were expected to beat Sunderland but lost, so now with Southampton hitting form we will expect a tougher game and probably respond the right way. nothing less than 3-0 please.

Dan Brierley
48 Posted 27/12/2013 at 13:44:37
We showed a lot of grit and determination to get back into the game after the mistake, but our composure when we get near the goal still needs a lot of work. We had a lot of shots, but the majority were from 25-30 yards and comfortable for the keeper. The only times we really tested their defence was on set pieces, and Sunderland deserve some credit for resolute defending at the back. But this was a team that had lost 11 of 17 matches going into yesterday, I would still expect that a team challenging for the CL places would be able to get at least a draw.

My biggest concern is again, none of players seem to look for the runs of Lukaku. The man is a bonafide scoring machine, and here for only a season so we have to make use of him to justify his wage costs. There is nothing coming through the middle as Ross only wants to shoot when in some cases the pass is the better option, Barry and McCarthy both play deep and now our full backs both want to cut inside and have shots themselves after scoring a few between them. We might as well put another midfielder on if we are going to play this way, as having a poacher up front is a waste of time.

Lets hope we pick up the pieces against Southampton, and go back to playing as a team like earlier in the season, instead of playing as individuals that think they are going to score wonder goals every time we get the ball. I would love nothing more than to see us score goals of the calibre we got against Fulham week in week out, but its not going to happen. Lukaku has proved that if you give him the chances, he will score, so lets try bringing him into the game.

Andrew Ellams
49 Posted 27/12/2013 at 14:20:36
We could make a back 3 work Mark by bringing in Alcaraz and Barkley for Osman and Barry. Coleman and Oviedo/ Baines as wing backs, Pienaar and Barkley playing in the middle with McCarthy as the holding man and giving Miralles a go behind Lukaku as the second striker.
Steavey Buckley
50 Posted 27/12/2013 at 14:28:59
What concerns me most, there are no new exciting talent breaking through to the first team from the youth teams for a waver thin first team squad. And that has to be a big concern with losing Deulofeu, Kone and Gibson to injury and Barry for suspended for the next game against Southampton. And if anyone thinks it easy bringing new players on loan or to buy, they can take time to settle, even if they can be persuaded to sign from their clubs, often reluctant to do so, and only then with a hefty transfer fee attached.
Kevin Rowlands
51 Posted 27/12/2013 at 15:13:54
Barry is going to be a huge loss for the Southampton game, we really need to add 2/3 players in January to replace the injured ones and freshen things up, might get slagged off here but for me Berbatov would be a great signing and really strengthen our forward line for the run in, watched him a couple of times for Fulham this year and he's still definitely got it.
Dan Brierley
52 Posted 27/12/2013 at 15:18:00
Andrew 244, that sounds a much better option when playing at home against teams with stubborn defences. At the moment it seems we have a 'one size fits all' style of play which seems to be effective against the top teams that come at us and open up space, but a struggle against resolute teams. I think its distorting to look at only the sending off, as there was more than a quarter of the match played out before the sending off where in all honesty we had created very little.
Derek Thomas
53 Posted 27/12/2013 at 15:32:12
It's Karma... we've all got to be Calmer

It was always going to happen and, as per usual, it happened in typical Everton "shoot ourselves in the foot" manner.

4 days from a year-long unbeaten run, versus the bottom of the league, at home, on Boxing Day, one of the biggest fan occasions.

0-1 a penalty, red card for the keeper, the anti-"fannying about at the back" merchants will be "I told you so"-ing fit to bust. Their keeper saving everything, one headed off the line.

The only thing missing was the scorer hadn't;

a) Ever scored in his life, or

b) Broke an 18-month goal drought.

As with Fulham (when your luck's in, it's IN!) so with Sunderland... when it's out, it's as far out as the tide at Southport.

That's the Karma bit sorted... Now for the Calmer.

We have a window to hopefully do some player trading. There are 20 games left... 90 points to play for. We are averaging 2 points per game and show no signs of not being able to keep that up.

The League will go down to a photo-finish or Goal Difference in May. The team is playing to win, not playing not to lose. Yes, it could better, but getting ahead of ourselves by looking at blocks of 4 or 5 games, mentally claiming the points, the following disappointment when the fates (and Howard and Osman) say "Oi! You!! No!!!" is the cause of much of the angst.

We're still in this... just that "one game at a time" as is the proper manner.

Brian Wilkinson
54 Posted 27/12/2013 at 15:38:32
Unbelievable after the season we have had how some can blame Martinez. We had two players on 4 yellow cards; in my opinion, Martinez played the percentage game to ensure both did not pick up a yellow card. Okay, in hindsight we can all say "wrong choice".

Had Osman scored the winning goal we would still have fans slating Osman, mistakes happen. Jagielka earlier got away with it and no slating there; Barkley slipping when clean through at Swansea; Distin's backpass in the semi; Graham Sharp missing an absolute sitter at Forest 3 yards out when that goal would have been enough to win the Championship in 1986; Lineker forgetting his boots at Oxford... these things happen, Osman does not need telling it was a bad mistake but they are a team and all the above stand together through good or bad.

Just one of those days when we could have played til midnight and Lady Luck would have been against us. Get behind the team and players, it was just one of those days nothing more.

But to slate Martinez after one game is unbelievable, I would love Osman to score the winner Sunday and stick two fingers up to the knockers on here, he may have had better days and not be as quick but until we get replacements in at least stick by the player and not wait for any minor mistake and lynching the guy.

Brian Wilkinson
55 Posted 27/12/2013 at 15:59:14
Spot on, Derek (256). At last, a post we should all be thinking of, instead of the rent a lynch mob at the slightest upset.

I doubt we would have scored with 11 players on the pitch, everything we threw at them the goalie saved, cleared off the line or hit one of them when we had shots on goal.

Linda Morrison
56 Posted 27/12/2013 at 15:52:05
Andrew's suggestion (#244) is good. I agree we will miss Barry more than Howard I think.

2 of our players made mistakes, I still don't understand why Howard didn't let the chap score at least we would not have needed to play most of the game with 10 men and he would be there on Sunday.

At least RS didn't win against City so I expect a response and a win against Southampton.I predict that Baines will play and score.

The Cardiff manager has finally been put out of his misery, what a way to run a club.

Dennis Ng
57 Posted 27/12/2013 at 15:54:37
Robbie (219), I totally agree. As much as we can question the decisions, we should be happy that RM is taking the club in the positive direction. Frankly, if we get into a relegation dogfight next season, I'll stand behind him still for the miracle he brought us so far.

Derek (256), yea, though I think Karma is a harsh way to put it, since some teams, and I shall not name the obvious, don't suffer from them due to their good pals. Mannone had the game of his life. We would have beaten them by at least 3 if he played with anything less. Beating Soton will be a great bounce back for us and I think we have the personnel for it regardless. These chaps are playing their hearts out and its pleasing to the eye too. If BK can help bring in a few more good chaps, we'll have a title run for sure.

Matthew Salem
59 Posted 27/12/2013 at 16:31:53
Bad day at the office...it happens. Come on you Blues!!!
Jamie Barlow
60 Posted 27/12/2013 at 16:39:23
It's been mentioned a few times that Howard should have let the lad score. Just let him waltz past him. Is that what Howard should do every time there is a one-on-one with him? Nonsense.
James Byrne
61 Posted 27/12/2013 at 16:41:40
I said this after getting back from the game yesterday and the root cause of our defeat was the manager not picking Barkley from the start. I'm getting the impression Roberto is obsessed with Ross Barkley!

I'm fully behind our manager and up to now he's done a superb job, but yesterday was an example of his naivety on team selection. HE GOT IT WRONG!

If he was concerned about the yellow cards that Ross was already on then why even put him on the bench in the first place; what the fuck does Barkley now think mentally after being asked to come one for 45 minutes to chase a lost cause when it all could have been avoided! If Barkley had of started the game I'm not convinced we'd be going in at half time 1 nil down and with only 10 men on the pitch.

We now go into a very tough Southampton game without two key players and the possibility of getting nothing out of what should have been a potential six points.

Huge lesson learned for Roberto and a schoolboy error in the importance of playing your best players first!

Roger Helm
62 Posted 27/12/2013 at 16:58:41
I don't think Sunderland were shite - I think they played very well. There's more to playing well than just nice passing -you have to defend well, avoid mistakes and score as well! We made three bad mistakes and couldn't manage to score at home against the bottom club; therefore we played badly. They were solid, well organised and defended resolutely - they had their goalie as MOM; therefore they played well. Surely no-one expected them to come out and start spraying passes around like they were Real Madrid? Bad day at the office, put it behind us, and make sure we win the next match.

Keith Young
63 Posted 27/12/2013 at 17:19:59
Let's look on the bright side. Any more results like this one against Sunderland and RM won't be going to Barcelona any time soon.That's one less worry!!
Mark Taylor
64 Posted 27/12/2013 at 16:20:08
Andrew 244

I assume you meant your formation to cater for the absence of Barry in the next game? Because I was looking at 3-4-3 beyond the next game, assuming that Barry and McCarthy would form the midfield two, then you can have Barkley, Delboy/Pienaar and Lukaku/Mirallas at the attacking 3.

I don't think RM favours the 5-3-2, as you are describing, and the idea of playing a back 3 is less the advantages of having a back 3 per se, more the offensive capability that a 3-4-3 can offer in terms of width and fluidity. Not many teams play it. Wigan did, of course and Napoli too, but it works best if your midfielders are defensively minded (like Inler and Gargano for Inter).

The other thing you need is for your wing backs in the midfield 4 to be very comfortable offensively, not just full backs pushed forwards. Not many teams have these for both wings. We do, In Baines (or Oviedo) and Coleman. It wouldn't work, for example, if Coleman was injured because none of the alternatives would work.

I think RM will eventually deploy this system but for the next match, I suspect he will stick with the current 4-5-1 (or strictly speaking, 4-2-3-1). With Gibson out, that means we are probably stuck with Osman next to McCarthy (far from ideal) or depending on how he is going in training, maybe put Heitinga in alongside. Personally I think Barkley is wasted in that role and I would sooner have him as the attacking midfielder.

Dennis Ng
66 Posted 27/12/2013 at 17:21:53
Jamie, spot on. I don't expect any less effort from Howard though that tackle was probably not the best play he could make. I believe Ki was going to the ground regardless after he cut to the left. Also, just heard RM's comments. They should change the rules. A red plus a penalty puts the team at an extreme disadvantage.

Roger, you're indeed right. Anyone who thinks there will be easy games in the EPL is watching the wrong league. Even the mighty SAF has heavy losses through his nose on his bad day. And did I mention the upsets? If we're a club of big aspirations, we should be looking at the table at the end of the season, NOT anywhere in the middle. Unless we're runaway league leaders.

Dennis Ng
67 Posted 27/12/2013 at 17:27:50
Keith, even mighty Barca gets upset'd. Look at their pre-Pep history and you'll know. Beautiful football for losses to teams that park the bus. I don't think RM is foolish enough to go to a team in turmoil though. Barca management suck big time right now. Pretty much like galacticos minus the spanish bankrolling. I think Laporta is better for Barca than what they have right now.
Mark Taylor
68 Posted 27/12/2013 at 17:25:21
Jamie273

It's a fine line. Obviously your goalie needs to try to defend against a one on one. But there is equally no point in preventing a goal by giving away a penalty when you are the last man, for example by leaving a traling leg as Howard did, because you are punished twice.

As someone pointed out earlier, you could argue that it's a moot point whether a red card should be given in these circumstances. It's supposed to be if you prevent a clear scoring opportunity but if a pen is awarded, you have merely delayed that happening, not prevented it.

I think it's clearer cut if it happens outside the penalty area, when the odds on scoring are tiny compared to a penalty.

Dennis Ng
69 Posted 27/12/2013 at 17:50:57
I do want to point out. I think RB took too many shots. He has a great shot but he was quite predictable and 1 dimensional sometimes because of that and I think that really hurts his strength which is his creativity.
Jamie Barlow
70 Posted 27/12/2013 at 17:52:07
Of course it's a fine line. He obviously didn't think he was going to give a penalty away though did he? It's instinctive to try and make a save. It's the same as someone being played through our defence with only Howard to beat as the last man. Should he never try and save them? Just let them walk it in?

I like Howard and think he does a decent job for us but he must have seen the lad coming up behind Osman and whether Ossie called for it or not, he shouldn't have received the ball where he did. Anyway, I don't like all this blame game stuff. Two players in one way or another messed up and hopefully (as Martinez says) they'll learn from it. Both players involved have played well this season. It happens.

Mark Taylor
71 Posted 27/12/2013 at 18:08:51
Jamie, had he dived at his feet and fouled him, then that could be just a misjudged attempt at saving, but I felt he left a trailing leg which could only end up in a trip not a save. That's my interpretation of the fine line.

I agree that Howard shouldn't have passed to Osman in the first place and also that $hit happens. I guess it's another fine line, the one between blame and accountability.

Darren Hind
73 Posted 27/12/2013 at 17:39:18
I felt the criticism directed at Martinez earlier in the season was fair, but I don’t think the criticism of his selection yesterday is.

It’s a simple fact that we have a smaller squad than the clubs we are trying to to compete with; whilst I don’t / can’t accept the "players are tired" argument, I totally believe the sports scientists who tell us that 1 or 2% drop in energy levels can make all the difference in the world at this level. Whether we like it or not, Martinez has no option but to use all of his players; he also has an obligation to look after young Ross.

The boy is still physically developing and, by playing him every minute of every game in the toughest league of all, Martinez would risk doing him more harm than good.

There are no "culprits " here. Whether you rate Howard and Ossie or not, both have played big parts throughout the magnificent run we’ve been on .

I don’t get the "I support Robbie BUT" post. How can you claim to buy into the risky "playing out from the back" game, if you’re going to moan like fuck the first time it backfires?

There’ll be more days like this, but there are no perfect teams out there so we CAN recover.

Kevin Day
74 Posted 27/12/2013 at 18:34:04
Keith Young- that's not the greatest statement I've read on ToffeeWeb, Martinez re-grouped the players at half time, got his tactics spot on for our numerical disadvantage, we battered Sunderland 2nd half, if it wasn't for their keeper we could of won 3-1. As it was it just wasn't our day.
Richard Reeves
75 Posted 27/12/2013 at 18:10:20
Barkley has played nearly all the games this season so Roberto has to decide when to leave him out and give him a rest so he can keep his form throughout the season. Yesterday was a game I would've identified as a good opportunity for just that (especially after his performance against Swansea) so I could understand his decision, as much as it hurts to see Osman's name on the team sheet.

Due to the way we play and from what happened to Wigan last year when they were getting caught out playing from the back, I thought there would've been more of these incidents by now. Of course, this won't be the last time it happens but Roberto's aiming for a type of play that is strong enough and clever enough to compensate for any of these types of mistakes.

What happened to Osman could of happened to anyone but the sooner we find a replacement for him the better. It's nothing personal; he's just not good enough.

Gary Mortimer
76 Posted 27/12/2013 at 18:35:04
I am a bit surprised at how much blame is being apportioned to Howard. Yes it was his fault for giving the penalty away and for getting himself sent off, but I cannot see how he can be blamed for a nicely weighted pass to our most skillful player at the club (according to some) who is in yards of space - albeit with a player coming to close him down.

IF Ki had been touch tight then Ozzie might have got away with the mis-control as his body would have shielded the ball, but Ki was so far off he just ran onto the ball as Ozzie lost his balance and fell out of the way.

Ozzie divides opinion just like Moyes. Unfortunately for the Pro lobby, the mistake yesterday presented us with a mountain to climb and as Sunderland played with all 11 players behind the ball in the second half it was one which we just didn't manage. To blame Howard is like blaming Peanuts when Ross tripped himself up running in on Swansea's goal last week. It was a dreadful mistake which has halted our brilliant run of results.

We did still create over 20 chances and on another day, could still have won the game. How did Lukaku miss that header in the last minute? Any proper contact and it would have been in.

Onwards and upwards - hopefully learn from this bad day at the office - on my birthday too - ruined it completely.

Dennis Ng
77 Posted 27/12/2013 at 19:19:21
Gary,
I was very surprised by how much people are calling for the players to be replaced. They will make mistakes and all, they will be replaced when we get better players but till then, they are our best players. I am very encouraged by the siege we put on Sunderland and I hope we will do exactly the same in every game from now on. No point waiting for us to go a goal down to do it!
Keith Young
78 Posted 27/12/2013 at 20:29:37
Kevin#309 I'm sorry my humour didn't get through to you. The point was as so many on various threads had us possibly winning the BPL and then losing RM to Barcelona( see Rumour thread) I thought a bit of realism was needed. RM is doing just fine but he does need time and further resources from the Board.Times are so much better now but RM knows he has a lot to do
Kevin Day
79 Posted 27/12/2013 at 21:12:31
Keith I apologise and retract my earlier post, I may of been lazy in not reading other posts and threads thoroughly.

Though reading your last post, maybe winning the league could be a possibility with further recourses you mention, I mean, the idiots on TalkSport seem to think the shite have a chance, in my eyes, if they do, then so do we.

Jason Lam
80 Posted 28/12/2013 at 02:53:52
Check out Gus Poyet's post match interview he was very gracious to Everton. Feel really sorry for Sunderland fans and the club as a whole they're in the shitz! Proud to be an Evertonian. One minor critique I would say is that every player is now shooting on distance when Lukaku is clearly wide open. Bad luck Jela he could've broken his duck. Things are looking good COYB!
Jimmy Sørheim
81 Posted 28/12/2013 at 03:47:41
What surprised me was that we have exactly the same points as last season at this stage.
Seems Moyes and Martinez are not that different when it boils down to points gathered.

I see a desperate need for a REAL goal scoring striker in January. Also our midfield is thin as paper.
Mirallas is doing the same as Jelavic, starts okay first season but drops out in the second.

This game has really shown that we are missing key players such as Baines, Gibson, Delboy and Kone.

I think we need more then 2 loan players in Jan. if we are to get into the top 4 this season.

Shane Corcoran
82 Posted 28/12/2013 at 08:09:20
I've only just caught up on the "highlights" on MOTD and I'm surprised I haven't seen anyone mention Robles save shortly after their goal when he fumbled the initial shot.
Also, Jelavic's dive to win the free-kick was terrible to see and embarrassing. If it happened against us we'd be very annoyed.
I predict a 3-0 victory today with Osman getting two before a late Howard penalty.

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads

© ToffeeWeb