Browning is next out on loan

, 10 January, 45comments  |  Jump to most recent
Tyias Browning has joined the long list of Everton Academy and U21 players out on loan, signing for Wigan Athletic for an initial month-long spell.

Roberto Martinez indicated earlier in the week that he felt the defender was now ready for the first team and that it was time he got first-team experience in the Championship.

“I've been at Everton most of my life. This move will be a good experience and I'm sure I will enjoy it," Browning said.  



Reader Comments (45)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Jon Ferguson
1 Posted 10/01/2014 at 16:01:33
I think it'll be great experience for him. He's unlikely to get a game with us anytime soon, and he'll be playing top half of the Championship football.
Karl Graham
2 Posted 10/01/2014 at 16:18:08
Browning, Pennington, Duffy, Garbutt, Junior, Lundstram, Kennedy, Long, Hope. If McAleny hadn't broke his leg he would be at Brentford — that is a full outfield team plying its trade to get better.

The future looks very bright. Along with Barkley, Stones and Vellios in first team squad, who needs millions when you've got local talent and talent spotting like we've got? Also, we have Roberto Martinez who seems to bring best out of players.

Harold Matthews
3 Posted 10/01/2014 at 16:02:36
I first noted Tyias when he was a young kid playing right back in a reserve friendly against our arch rivals. (I think his christian name was on his shirt.)

Anyway, despite one or two youthful mistakes, he really impressed me. His action reminded me of Pele.

Years later I enquired after him on Toffee Web and by this time I had forgotten his name. All I had was a description and a vague recollection of the name on his shirt. Thankfully, our friend Sam Hoare set me right.

Good luck to him at Wigan. I hope he still moves like Pele and I wish him well.

Stuart O'Malley
4 Posted 10/01/2014 at 16:41:30
I would have liked to have seen how Jose Baxter would have come on under RM's tutelage. With all the youngsters that Karl has just named out on loan, it just gives me more faith in Roberto's masterplan. I just feel that the club has found a new sense of direction,and its feels like an upward trajectory all the way. Really excited about seeing some of these young lads developing in the future too, and I shall be following their progress at their loan clubs with interest. RM impresses me very much, if he told me I needed an umbrella in the Sahara, I would believe him.
Patrick Murphy
5 Posted 10/01/2014 at 16:52:52
Harold I hope you mean Pele in his prime and not as he is now.
Stuart O'Malley
6 Posted 10/01/2014 at 16:57:22
Actually an umbrella would be quite handy against the sun. Robert is right again. Sorry.
Ian Burns
7 Posted 10/01/2014 at 16:59:05
RM mentioned Browning as a bright prospect in a recent fans interview.

So many young players gaining the right sort of experience and hopefully the majority will make it onto our first team squad. Can you imagine the 9 or 10 youngsters out at the moment coming to the boil with the likes of Seamus; Ross; Stones; McCarthy; Oviedo; Robles et al - not been this excited for many a year.

Dennis Ng
8 Posted 10/01/2014 at 16:58:45
Patrick, I wouldn't mind if there is a Maradonna comparison in that too! And at his prime please! How great would it be if the goal scoring problems can be solved by these young kids instead!
Karl Graham
9 Posted 10/01/2014 at 17:00:22
Baxter and Wallace would both still been here if Roberto had taken over sooner. Also I suspect Vaughan would have been given a go. Rodwell must be kicking himself he saw the £ signs he would really have flourished in this team if he could have stayed fit.
Harold Matthews
10 Posted 10/01/2014 at 16:59:01
Nice one Patrick. In his prime of course. Haven't seen him lately.

Colin Williams
11 Posted 10/01/2014 at 17:05:22
Top talent... hope things work out for the lad. Tyias could be a real top player. Many of our u21s going out on loan are excellent prospects who will be considered for our squad for next season. These young stars are so lucky to have Robbie guiding them to hopefully play for our special football club!!!!
Paul Thompson
12 Posted 10/01/2014 at 17:07:18
All good stuff, but attributing messiah-like powers to Roberto to transform any past, present or future aspirant first teamer may be overdoing it a bit. Given the available places at senior level and the potential pool of in-house talent, most are not going to make it here. A major plus for sending them out, however, is to help the club make a better judgement about which has a more realistic chance. By the way, have we got enough players left for an under 21 side?!
Steavey Buckley
13 Posted 10/01/2014 at 17:19:12
Paul Thompson: There's the under 18's who can fill any gaps in the under 21's. And possibly a great 16 year old who could even be included in the first team squad. There has to be another Rooney somewhere on Merseyside?
Karl Graham
14 Posted 10/01/2014 at 17:20:02
I wasn't saying he was a Messiah but Moyes was very quick to take players out of team. Look when Duffy started 2 games did nothing wrong then was dropped for Hibbert right back by trade. Barkley gave one penalty away didn't start a Premier League game for 18 months. Vaughan missed a chance against Arsenal never trusted after.
Kane Dennison
15 Posted 10/01/2014 at 17:23:33
With pretty much all our first team U21s out on loan getting more competitive games and therefore gaining that much needed experience boost, it would be interesting to see what U18s can step up to the mark in the U21 games, the like of George green, jonjoe Kenny and the duffus brothers to name a few.

It sort of works both ways... They are all getting a chance, I just love what's evolving from this.

Patrick Murphy
16 Posted 10/01/2014 at 17:36:40
Don't forget that Roberto has only been at the club for six-months or so and by the summer he will have a good idea of the players who will make it into first team contention and those that have to be let go. I also think some first team regulars will be sweating a little at the end of the season as Roberto moulds his squad for the start of next season.
Dennis Ng
17 Posted 10/01/2014 at 17:27:42
Paul, I think the biggest difference between past and present is really risk taking. We're at the stage where, given our shackles, we've still be able to build a formidable team, horde capable youngsters of potential and groom them significantly. The only thing we lack is someone to use those resources to the maximum. This can happen to any club but we're probably a gold mine to be tapped in my opinion. Why we're not bought over by any mogul, not sure. If I had a billion bucks to blow, I buy our team.

OFM did well to build a reserve (think of a gold mine, not the reserve team). Now, we just need some polishing and shine. Give them exposure. It's like marketing after producing great products. I think this will also help us sell players we don't need easier. I really hate to see us cut young talents to see them do better elsewhere.

I'm not saying this will all change overnight but I see our effort to send these youngsters on loan as a great first step!

Colin Williams
18 Posted 10/01/2014 at 17:16:06
Paul.. "messiah-like powers", I agree, but what a top -coach and a wonderful philosophy on how the game should be played.All young, developing players would love this type of guidence during their development.
Harold Matthews
19 Posted 10/01/2014 at 17:20:50
These U21 loans are an Alan Stubbs thing. They are his lads and he is trying to get them physically and mentally ready for a possible move to the first team squad.

With an U21 side to run it is not easy but, as he states on the official site, "What we lose in the short term, we gain in the long term."

Dennis Ng
20 Posted 10/01/2014 at 17:48:56
Harold, absolutely agree! I wonder how Stubbs feel of the kids' chances of breaking into the first team now compared to before!
Paul Thompson
21 Posted 10/01/2014 at 18:05:24
My comments not a dig at Roberto all. His interest in and willingness to take risks with younger players is exemplary. Just want us to have (more) realistic expectations of him and those players.
Chris Williamson
22 Posted 10/01/2014 at 18:11:39
I'd really like Alan Stubbs' job right now ..... just put the kettle on, sit back and put my feet up!

Si Cooper
23 Posted 10/01/2014 at 18:17:45
From what he said the other day, I would imagine RM has people like Alan Stubbs doing overtime to ensure that each loanee is getting an appropriate placement and then keeping tabs on them whilst they are away from Everton.

Tyias Browning was mentioned as one who was already capable of playing first team football so his loan is definitely of the finishing school variety, but I don't think all our loanees can be assured of making it as Premiership players even if they apply themselves on loan. RM did say the aim was to make sure they could all have successful careers as professional footballers, but his expectancy was of the order of two players every couple of years making the transition from the academy to the first team.

George Green is still supposed to be at stage one of his development and, although I don't know how many stages RM has, I think that means it will be a while before any really young players are strutting their stuff in front of the Goodison faithful.

Brian Waring
24 Posted 10/01/2014 at 18:33:38
Thing is though Harold, you say this is a Stubbs thing, but I can't remember this many young players going out on loan under Moyes, but I may be wrong.
John Crawley
25 Posted 10/01/2014 at 18:28:38
Harold 828 the loans may be something that Alan Stubbs favours, but it is as clear as day where the drive for them has come from and it's Martinez. He said in his latest interview with the fans that his plan was to work on the youngsters on a technical and tactical level for 6 months and then loan them out to get game experience to develop them.

I posted about 12 months ago that the best thing for young players like Barkley and Duffy was to hope that Moyes left. I am so pleased to finally see someone who trusts young players and actually has a plan to see them develop to the best of their ability.

Simon Hermansen
26 Posted 10/01/2014 at 18:30:27
At least we're now hearing the names of our exciting young players and will maybe get an better insight into how they can play in proper competitive matches even if it is out on loan

For too long, with the odd exception, its been a case of ... where are all the kids coming through??

Breath of fresh air in so many ways

Dennis Ng
27 Posted 10/01/2014 at 18:41:27
Paul, I think you should have no worries on that. It seems to me that Bobby knows the reasonable concerns from the outright ridiculous expectations some fans might have. We'll always have large variations. Many of us would be very happy to see just these news coming out so much more, as Simon mentioned. I think we all expect the youngsters to get a fair number of loans before a decision is made to whether they are or not cut for the first team. Having young players come through not only helps the first team directly, but also think of the bench! We lack options right now and any added option that Bobby trusts would be of so much more significant help to our financial situation. We no longer have to buy players just to sit them on the bench!
Mikey Waterman
28 Posted 10/01/2014 at 18:53:48
Regarding what Paul #813 asked about who will be playing for the 21s - that is the beauty of Roberto's system concerning youngsters, the best lads from the u18s and possibly even the u16s will now get a few games for the u21s which will be beneficial for themselves because they're playing at a higher level against better players in a more competitive environment. Great to see what Roberto is doing regarding the entire process of developing players from kids into one day premier league professionals. In a few years time is when we will see the true genius of his ideas, it will take a couple of years at least reap the rewards fully but when we do... christ that will be unbelievably exciting (not that it isn't already ha).

Very happy for the lad Browning, clearly he is highly thought of and would appear to be at the most advanced stages of his development compared to the others who have gone out on loan given Wigans position in their respective league.

Robin Cannon
29 Posted 10/01/2014 at 19:00:18
Really loving this push for the young players to get some highly competitive experience at different levels throughout the league.

Also has the added advantage of pushing our even younger players into U-21s earlier, a more challenging environment for them.

I think that's really how the system should work. U-21 is to push players until they're ready for a competitive environment (whether in our first team, or on loan as a further step in development towards our first team).

Phil Walling
30 Posted 10/01/2014 at 19:27:57
Whilst its no longer the done thing to appear even mildly critical of the present regime, I can't help thinking that the current rush to get seemingly all of our under-21 side off the payroll -albeit temporarily- is more to do with balancing the books than 'developing their skills elsewhere.'

With money having to be freed up for the signing of McGeady and one or two other newcomers, the hailing of this divesting of 'our most talented' as a move of genius is, I feel, misplaced.

Most who get shipped out never return to make any useful contribution and the tactic is more a feature of the BK school of accountancy than the indication of a master plan in progress.

Harold Matthews
31 Posted 10/01/2014 at 19:42:21
Clearly Martinez has accelerated the process but Stubbs is the one making the judgements as indicated in his interview on the official site. In another interview 12 months ago he said that getting a lad out on loan gave him a great sense of achievement.

Another factor here is the imput of Dennis Lawrence, the man Martinez specifically brought in to liaise between all the different groups in order to promote those youngsters who are quickest to adapt to the new philosophy. A Barcelona / Real Sociedid tactic favoured by Martinez. Using this method, Real S unearthed Xabi Alonso and other top players. who were gradually integrated into the main squad where they mixed with seasoned internationals from various countries.

Players like Rooney and Barkley are rare gifts from the Gods but this new regime seem determined to find youngsters who might one day wear the first team shirt. Let's hope they succeed.

Robin Cannon
32 Posted 10/01/2014 at 20:55:29
@Phil (874) - Given that most of the youngsters will be on very minimal wages, don't really imagine that's much of a factor (or would have much of an impact).
Mick Davies
34 Posted 10/01/2014 at 21:12:53
Phil, haven't you heard of the great new 5 year plan? Apparently BK is going to send Coleman, McCarthy, Barkley and Stones out on loan for a few years, bring back the kids and throw them in the side, thus saving all the wages he would have paid. Also Finch Farm will be loaned out to Billy Smarts for their circus acts and we're moving to Southport to ground share with the funhouse. Have you thought about writing a Cold War type thriller? You'd create more twists than Chubby Checker
Martin Handley
35 Posted 10/01/2014 at 21:32:38
If only 50% make the grade here at Everton that would be fantastic , I also believe that the Martinez regime is geared to getting the most out of our academy system . Moyes just seemed to mistrust the system ,which insidently he was instrumental in setting up.

I also think its great to see Tranmere benefitting from us as it's long overdue. Hopefully this could be a mutual thing and we could get first refusal on any hot prospects they produce . Just a thought guys.

Brian Waring
36 Posted 10/01/2014 at 22:09:24
" I can't help thinking that the current rush to get seemingly all of our under-21 side off the payroll -albeit temporarily- is more to do with balancing the books than 'developing their skills elsewhere."

" the hailing of this divesting of 'our most talented' as a move of genius is, I feel, misplaced."

Only you hey Phil.

Mick Davies
37 Posted 10/01/2014 at 22:59:19
Martin Handley, I'd love a repeat of history and Tranmere provide us with another Dixie. I expect we'd have to cough up more than the £3,000 they got for the greatest striker of the century though. Then again, the way Martinez is working the market with criminal deals like £27m for the wig, £6m for Vic and now it's looking like a Dick Turpinesque £7.5m for Jeli, I expect the new Dixie would be recruited for a couple of Blood Brothers tickets and a bottle of Sangria
Mark Stone
38 Posted 11/01/2014 at 00:52:45
Brian, you seriously don't remember any young players going out on loan under Moyes??? Even in just the last couple of years Baxter and Wallace were both loaned to Tranmere. McAleney went to Brentford (as did Forshaw and Bidwell) and Scunthorpe, Duffy has been to Burnley and Scunthorpe, Coleman to Blackpool, Barkley to Leeds and Sheffield Wed, Garbutt spent the season at Cheltenham, Lundstram went to Doncaster. Look back beyond a couple of years and there are many, many more. I'm loving the RM times so far, but let's not rewrite history, hey?
Brent Stephens
39 Posted 11/01/2014 at 01:49:17
Haven't read the thread. Apologies if it's been said but with so many going out on loan, who's playing for which of our sides now? Is this all promoting any Academy lads to the U 21s?
Harold Matthews
40 Posted 11/01/2014 at 08:40:16
Brent. I've tried to explain the youth promotion business in post 875.
Derek Thomas
41 Posted 11/01/2014 at 08:38:16
Brent # 054; (most of ) The under 21's are out in the real world, a step up or 2 in some cases. The under 18's are thus extended in the U21's, no comfort zone, going through the motions without any pressure, being big fish in small ponds.

Browning I think, in being sent to a highish team in the Champoinship, to be tested for the 1st team, if he can hack it, and hack it well, we have a winner.

Sad to say though, the others are being given a chance to make a living in the Yeovils of this world, with maybe the added bonus that the odd one will find it within himself to grow and learn by doing and maybe, just maybe, be seen as worthy to move either up the Leagues, or, don't hold your breath, be welcomed back into the fold ( Lundstrum??)

Brent Stephens
42 Posted 11/01/2014 at 10:06:27
Harold, Derek, as I thought - very progressive on the part of the manager.
Brian Waring
43 Posted 11/01/2014 at 10:31:05
Mark, that's why I say " I may be wrong" It could be that in such a short space of time there has been so many going out on loan in one go.
Phil Walling
44 Posted 11/01/2014 at 11:07:50
Most, if not all, these kids are destined to earn their living in the lower /non leagues. That's how its always been in the multi-national Prem era. Everton, like all other top status clubs, are in reality providing a steady flow of players to the Football League/Conference rather than developing a steady stream of players for their use. All clubs get most of the Prem players from overseas !
John Crawley
45 Posted 11/01/2014 at 11:21:34
Brian - you're correct in your assessment. Yes we have sent players out on loan in the past but what we are witnessing now are large numbers going out on loan as part of a clearly thought out strategy. That is something that we haven't seen before and signals a change in approach.
Kristian Boyce
46 Posted 11/01/2014 at 13:46:42
Moyes always sent one or two of the U21s out on loan but nothing like the numbers going out now. The players that went out were only the ones which were on the fringes of the first team (Duffy, Baxter etc). This was only in the latter years of his tenure.

I always said that Anichebe & Vaughan needed a loan stint to improve their position in the team and development (Vaughan did have one loan but got injured straight away).

The one thing that baffled me in the past is that we kept so many players in the U21/Reserve team without any of them ever being promoted. The one thing that I never got was when a player won the Reserve Player of the Year award, they were pretty much released or sold for pennies to a League One or Two club at the end of the season.


Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads

© ToffeeWeb