McGeady unveiled as new signing

, 11 January, 120comments  |  Jump to most recent
Everton unveiled Aiden McGeady as their first signing of the January transfer window prior to the kick off of this afternoon's game against Norwich City after the 27 year-old put pen to paper on a 4½-year contract.

The club were able to hammer out a deal with the Irish international's former club, Spartak Moscow, that brings him to Goodison Park this month rather than waiting until the summer when his contract expires.

The fee is officially undisclosed but is believed to be a compromise on Spartak's initial €2m asking price.

A right-side winger by trade, McGeady offers pace, trickery and Champions League experience but admitted in an interview before he took to the field to be paraded before the faithful that he is short on match fitness having not played much in the past month.  



Reader Comments (120)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Mark Tanton
1 Posted 11/01/2014 at 15:22:48
Welcome Aiden. Now lose some fucking weight!
Chris James
2 Posted 11/01/2014 at 15:48:10
Steady on Mark, the lad's just hungry for first team football ;-)
Terry Maher
3 Posted 11/01/2014 at 16:01:50
Good luck, Aiden.

Welcome to Everton!!

Albert Crocker
4 Posted 11/01/2014 at 16:33:39
If what I've seen on You Tube is anything to go by I confidentally predict that he'll be known as McGreedy.

Some serious coaching ahead here methinks.

Drew Shortis
5 Posted 11/01/2014 at 16:55:48
Good signing. I know some commentators on here have some reservations and I must admit that I have seen little of him apart from on You Tube. However, Martinez has been tracking him for a long time now and he obviously rates his ability and that's good enough for me.

A new striker next and possibly a midfielder, even if its just a loan and we look set up for a strong finish to the season!

Mark Taylor
6 Posted 11/01/2014 at 16:56:08
First 27 year professional athlete I’ve seen who could pass as a 40 year old. Were Spartak paying him in fried Mars bars?

You’d have to assume RM has seen something in him not apparent to the casual observer….

Dennis Ng
7 Posted 11/01/2014 at 17:05:05
Mark, I have my concerns too but regardless, he's our player now and I hope he turns in the many good performances we've come to expect from each and every player.

Will be eager to watch him against West Brom.

Mark Taylor
8 Posted 11/01/2014 at 17:10:10
Dennis, I'm not sure he's in any shape to start an EPL match right now. Maybe a bit of sub time as he builds up his fitness.
Dennis Ng
9 Posted 11/01/2014 at 17:12:10
Yep, I agree. He's not been playing at Spartak, right? Too much time for beer over there? If he can chip in some good performances with 20-30 mins each, that would be great. Our bench is very thin at the moment.
Amit Vithlani
10 Posted 11/01/2014 at 17:08:48
I guess the vodka and Russian food really agreed with him. Welcome to the club son and hoping you have a long and successful career. Any news on the fee?
Eric Myles
11 Posted 11/01/2014 at 17:21:54
Undisclosed Amit
Ray Williams
12 Posted 11/01/2014 at 17:14:58
As always, lots of pertinent and intelligent comments on TW. Too fat, lazy, greedy blah blah blah, all from the fingers of the many professional athletes who comment on here.

For what it is worth I think we can be happy we have signed a seasoned international player with CL experience and who the manager has tracked for years.

Nominal fee spent, cover on both wings and in the middle, which we will be grateful of as the season goes on. Especially as Ossie an Pienaar have looked tired at times this season.

On you go with the slating! I'll stick me tin hat on now

Amit Vithlani
13 Posted 11/01/2014 at 17:27:26
Ah ok Eric.

Ray - hopefully he has a hunger for success, and an appetite for goals. Perhaps his physique belies a fluid style of play, and we see him produce a feast of attacking football.

Ok, I'll get me coat.

Dennis Ng
14 Posted 11/01/2014 at 17:32:33
Ray, I do hope the fee is nominal. For many days, I thought this one is a June acquisition. I wonder if Spartak took the opportunity to dig out pockets.
Phil Friedman
15 Posted 11/01/2014 at 17:40:17
Ross is out for a while with a broken toe, we need bodies, which is probably why this was moved up from the summer to now.
Jackie Barry
16 Posted 11/01/2014 at 17:41:08
I think people are being harsh on him, his stats are good. He was regarded pretty highly by the Spartak fans and another plus is that he champions league experience, something that is a big plus if we are indeed aiming for that.
Ray Griffin
17 Posted 11/01/2014 at 17:40:36
Saw a lot of him playing for Celtic & Ireland. Has a trick in him and can beat a player but takes too much out of the ball on a regular basis. Doesn't score goals and might lack the phyisicality for playing in the Premier League. However, Bobbby M seem to have a plan for him and could be a useful squad player IMHO
Jackie Barry
18 Posted 11/01/2014 at 17:44:12
Aren't Spartak loaded?
Jackie Barry
19 Posted 11/01/2014 at 17:48:41
I would rather bring on McGeady than Naismith or Heitinga. Wouldn't you?
Scott Ellis
20 Posted 11/01/2014 at 17:37:35
You just about said ray.

Picked up a talented player, who with our other talented players will entertain us.
Picked this fella up for a fraction of his true value.

I really cannot see any negative issues with this signing.

But then I am glass half full blue

James Stewart
21 Posted 11/01/2014 at 17:54:15
Good point Jackie and I think thats how he will be used most. Impact sub in the last 20 mins.
Barry Rathbone
22 Posted 11/01/2014 at 17:53:56
Ray Williams

Well said.

Jackie Barry
23 Posted 11/01/2014 at 17:56:52
I think he will be better than that, think a lot of us will be pleasantly surprised.
Patrick Murphy
24 Posted 11/01/2014 at 17:57:06
It's funny isn't it, a player is about to leave (Jelavic) and a lot of people are bemoaning the loss of a striker and if we didn't know better it would appear we are selling a 20 goals a season bloke. McGready I have no idea how good or bad he is but to many it's as if we have bought a lazy, fat useless waste of space - strange!
Mark Taylor
25 Posted 11/01/2014 at 17:57:30
Ray 222

You don't have to be a professional athlete to spot an out of condition athlete. In fact, I'd suggest you don't even need to be an amateur one...

Colin Glassar
26 Posted 11/01/2014 at 18:21:37
The Russkis are in the middle of their winter break so it's obvious he's a bit chubby after all that whale blubber and pavlova that they eat while hibernating.
Jim Bennings
27 Posted 11/01/2014 at 18:21:46
Stop being so fucking negative everyone.
The lad has played Champions League football at two different clubs, is quick and can beat a man, like someone said who would you rather bring on Naismith, Heitinga or McGeady? And if anybody thinks Martinez is going to play fool to any player with an attitude problem then they really don't give this knowledgable football man any credit at all.
Colin Glassar
28 Posted 11/01/2014 at 18:26:21
Robbie's a bit of a fibber isn't he? He only said yesterday that there was no news on McGeady. I think the lad will be a valuable addition to the squad. I also think we need two more players though as injuries are starting to mount.
Iain Thomson
29 Posted 11/01/2014 at 18:24:51
Seen his early days with Celtic and a few Champions League games for Spartak, undoubted talent... He is a bit of a cock by all accounts but I am comfortable with fact he may thrive in a Martinez team.

There are plenty of players with less ability than him who are big-fee players. If Martinez gets the best out of him, it's a very good signing. He is direct, will earn free kicks in dangerous positions and will drag defenders around; assists and goals hopefully too.

He is a minimal-fee transfer who can play anywhere across the front line and, if he doesn't work out all that well, he still has sell-on value...

Ray Said
30 Posted 11/01/2014 at 18:28:03
A quote about our new signing:
"Aiden McGeady is a fast and skilful winger and someone I rate highly," he told the Record Sport.

"We will have to be careful with him because his movement can be special and he has a great ability to appear in goalscoring positions out of the blue.

"I really like the way he plays football. He is a natural talent, who can create a brilliant piece of play in the blink of an eye and I can assure you our defenders will be paying very close attention to him." — Lionel Messi

-that will do for me and give the lad a chance to actually get the shirt on and kick a ball eh?
Iain Thomson
31 Posted 11/01/2014 at 18:32:25
Ray

I remember reading the Messi quotes at the time.

I think there is potential for McGeady to be fantastic in our system.

Ben Howard
32 Posted 11/01/2014 at 18:36:43
What Ray Said said
Trevor Lynes
33 Posted 11/01/2014 at 18:31:06
I'm glad we have signed a player who will be able to come on and change things. Both today's subs cannot do that, they are both doing what footballers call 'jobs'.

If we lose Deulofeu at the end of this season, then McGeady is his equivalent at this stage of their respective careers. Deulofeu will possibly get up to world class standards but not with us!

If we are going to make a serious challenge, then McGeady playing in front of either Baines or Coleman will be a big plus. Mirallas can then play more centrally and possibly score more goals. I just hope we do not end our activity with just McGeady and that we acquire a couple more really useful players to strengthen our bench and allow the fringe players to leave.

Hibbo deserves to stay until the end of his contract but the likes of Vellios, Gueye, Junior and Heitinga need to be got off the pay roll as soon as possible.

Jim Bennings
34 Posted 11/01/2014 at 18:37:52
Lads he can be the biggest cock in the world but I tell you this: if he came off the bench at Anfield in a fortnight's time and twats one in at the Kop then runs in front of it to celebrate, I won't give a shite.
Dean Adams
35 Posted 11/01/2014 at 18:36:13
I have no idea where the supposed bad attitude comes from, but I would be amazed if he was that bad that our other Irish internationals would have failed to notice. It seems strange that none of them have said anything to back up the allegations, unless of course they (the allegations that is) are total utter bullshit!!

Who knows..... well probably the players have a great insight. Welcome to the fold Mr McGeady. I hope your stay works well for you and us.

Colin Glassar
36 Posted 11/01/2014 at 18:45:00
Attitude and reputations mean sweet FA. Remember big Dunc when he joined us? That he was a nutter, a sulky sod, dangerous etc... Well they weren't far off but he's now an Evertonian legend so let's give the lad a chance.
Mike Hughes
37 Posted 11/01/2014 at 18:33:47
As Ray Said said ...... give the lad a chance ......

I can't see much in the way of downside here. We need cover and he gives us that in addition to (1) options and (2) pressure on those in the attacking roles to keep performing.

Our dressing room is apparently strong with a good team spirit and I'd imagine this would have a positive effect on any potential attitude issues to which others have referred. In other words, if he was a bit of a knob, he'd be isolated rather than fragmenting the squad.

Regarding his physical condition, this move is a big opportunity for McGeady at this point in his career. If he has any sense he'll take it with both hands. This is the highest profile league in the world, we are sitting in 4th place in it and heading up, so I think he'll be keen to get rid of any spare tyres with all the high profile media analysis.

Mike Allison
38 Posted 11/01/2014 at 18:56:56
Just over a year ago, I went with my younger brother to a Nottingham Forest match. It was his stag do so we'd gone for the hospitality in the lounge and meeting some players afterwards.

Andy Reid is basically their best player and came in to meet some fans. Now I don't know how many people keep up with The Championship but when you see him on TV, and even from the stands, Andy Reid looks like a dumpy little fella who clearly doesn't keep up with a professional training regime. When you meet him in person he looks absolutely as fit as a fiddle. I don't really know how that works, but I guess its just his natural body shape not doing him any favours.

My point is, it could just be that the same thing is true of McGeady. The way he looks to the untrained eye is not necessarily the same as the reality. To strengthen my point, I've always looked at Jon Walters at Stoke and thought he never quite looked in shape. Asmir Begovic described him as the best trainer and hardest worker at the club on Sky this morning. It can happen, and appearances can be deceptive.

I also agree with the importance of the fact that we have three Irish internationals at the club. They will know what he is like and Martinez will have at least discussed it with them to check that he isn't a liability.

My main concern is that with Jelavic going, this signing merely keeps our squad at the same level, and we still need two signings to give us the kind of boost we're looking for to genuinely push for the top four against richer clubs.

Tommy Coleman
39 Posted 11/01/2014 at 19:08:28
Decisive in the transfer window. Good bit of business. He'll give us even more options.
Dave Roberts
40 Posted 11/01/2014 at 19:10:06
The lad has what is known as an ectomorphic physique. This means his waistline is lower than the mid point of his total height leading to a stocky appearance. Anybody out there old enough to remember Johnny Morrissey will recall he was exactly the same and if Aiden is half as good as he was he will do for me.
Patrick Murphy
41 Posted 11/01/2014 at 19:20:19
As somebody mentioned Forest earlier, John Robertson did not in any way look like a footballer and he lacked speed, but boy could he play; if McGready can do similar for Everton, we should be well pleased.
Sean Kelly
42 Posted 11/01/2014 at 19:19:10
Dave R he may have that funny physique and he might run like Jordan but it looks like we will have to send him on hols with Rooney to fat camp.

Sorry that should be Henderson but hey they run the same anyway.

Colin Glassar
43 Posted 11/01/2014 at 19:21:16
Agree with the last couple of posts. Rooney and Lampard have always been called fat but they are anything but.
Steve Ferns
44 Posted 11/01/2014 at 19:26:52
A few points:

1. We nearly signed him when he went to Spartak and have been linked with him ever since.

2. Moyes and Martinez have both wanted him, as whilst point 1 was mainly Moyes, Martinez has tracked him before he came here.

3. Whilst we may be hesitant over Moyes's signings, surely Martinez has earned a free pass or two? If he wanted to sign some 25 stone monster he saw playing Sunday league, then I'd still think, ok, if he's good enough for you Roberto. Surely the guy's earned unconditional support for the time being?

4. McGeady was a decent player for Celtic and looked alright for Ireland. And to repeat myself, I'm sure Roberto knows what he's doing.

Steve Ferns
45 Posted 11/01/2014 at 19:34:10
Colin, going back to your comments on Duncan, I'm afraid I couldn't disagree more with you about him being an Everton Legend. But we've done that to death on here many times before and no point going off thread.
David Finney
46 Posted 11/01/2014 at 19:47:05
No concern about this deal other than the comments of Roberto: "It seemed as though we were going to get him in the summer but with Jelavic set to move to Hull it was important he could join us quicker."

We still need a striker and I just hope this isn't all we are getting in place if Jelavic leaving. Another case of money coming in and none going out.

Patrick Murphy
47 Posted 11/01/2014 at 19:53:58
David, it wouldn't be the first time that BK has shafted his manager; add to the fact that we don't have a home game until the window has been slammed shut and it sort of justifies your concerns. BK wouldn't do it again would he?
Mick Davies
48 Posted 11/01/2014 at 19:50:06
Looks like Pienaar got injured today, so he may be out there sooner than he expects. As for his weight, has anybody seen Aidy Akinfenwa? He scores goals regularly in Div One but he looks like the Nutty Professor.
Kevin Rowlands
49 Posted 11/01/2014 at 20:12:57
Good signing, I think this is going to mean we are going to see a lot more of Mirallas playing down the middle which is good news he's looked a real threat when playing that position this season.

I've watched a few clips of McGeady on YouTube (I know) there's no doubt this lad's a very skillful footballer and when he gets fully match fit he's going to be a real threat, him and Coleman on the right, Baines / Oviedo / Pienaar on the left, I like it.

Dave Roberts
50 Posted 11/01/2014 at 20:34:24
Sorry, in my last post I suggested McGeady was ectomorphic....I meant endomorphic. Crouch is an ectomorph!
Geoff Freeman
51 Posted 11/01/2014 at 20:36:52
I agree with Dave 308 if he's half as good as Morrissey our younger fans are in for a treat.
Brian Wilkinson
52 Posted 11/01/2014 at 20:36:57
Yeah, too fat — just look how it affected Rooney, Gascoigne, Molby and Reid. Shame on you, Martinez.

Yet to see a fully fit Kone but I am more than happy with every player Martinez has brought in so far.

He has had his eye on the player for a while so that's good enough for me.

Colin Glassar
53 Posted 11/01/2014 at 20:44:20
Geoff, Morrisey was built like a brick shithouse but god was he quick and nimble. And as tough as old nails.
Brian Denton
54 Posted 11/01/2014 at 20:49:17
Tougher.
Geoff Freeman
55 Posted 11/01/2014 at 20:51:25
Oh happy memories
Steven Telford
56 Posted 11/01/2014 at 20:57:37
What would people guess the "undisclosed fee" actually is.
500,000 - more or less?
Patrick Murphy
57 Posted 11/01/2014 at 21:09:20
If we buy any more Irish lads perhaps BK should seek sponsorship from Paddy Power?
Brian Waring
58 Posted 11/01/2014 at 21:06:04
Wouldn't surprise me if it's something like £500,000- £750.000 Steven. Spartak probably asked us for something stupid to let him sign for us now, we fucked them off and said we'll wait till the summer,they have realised that keeping him for the remainder of his contract is going to cost them around £1.7m in wages, probably a no brainer for them to let him go now and at least get some cash.
Pablo Connelly
59 Posted 11/01/2014 at 21:02:30
Ste Ferns, like most I have lost all respect for Moyes but to suggest we should be 'hesitant' over signing a Moyes target shows a bit of selective memory. If Moyes had targeted McGeady that for me is more indication that it is definitely a shrewd signing as the majority of today's starting line up illustrates. Let's be clear though: Moyes had massive limitations but he his transfer targets (and his scouting network) wasn't one of them.
Dick Brady
60 Posted 11/01/2014 at 21:18:23
Wow it looks like Aiden McGeady had himself a very good Christmas! I mean we all put a little weight on over the festive period but wow!!!!!

He might be a useful addition to the squad but lets get his weight down first. At the moment he looks like he would struggle to tie his boot laces much less play 90 minutes of Premiership football.

Dick Brady
62 Posted 11/01/2014 at 21:23:51
I agree with Pablo. Moyes was a genius at finding a transfer gem and any player that Moyes may have targeted is probably worth a punt. I'm sure that Harry at Spurs would wait to see who Moyes targeted and then put in a bigger bid to steal that player from Moyes.

I think Aiden McGeady was a player Moyes was interested in but that may have been 2 years and 30lbs ago.

Dave Williams
63 Posted 11/01/2014 at 21:24:05
I hope McGeady doesn't read this site cos he'll not be too impressed with the supporters of his new club!

For heavens sake chaps he is one of us and we should encourage him and make him feel welcome not slag him off before he has kicked a ball.

Dave Lynch
64 Posted 11/01/2014 at 21:35:17
God knows what they put in that borscht or whatever the right spelling is but he looks like he's eaten tons of the stuff.

Deffo looks a month away from being fit.

Mat Smith
65 Posted 11/01/2014 at 21:31:22
I'm happy about this signing and looking forward to seeing him action - from what I've seen of him in the past he's a quick skillfull winger who can unlock defences! Also can't help but think just one game I'd love to see an attack of:-

------------------------- Mirallas -------------------------

--- Mcgeady --------Barkley -------- Deulofeu ----

Then Barry, Mccarthy ect behind them

just the pace and skill of those four going forward excites the hell outta me!!!

Mike Hughes
66 Posted 11/01/2014 at 21:39:42
According to the Daily Telegraph online, we shelled out about £1million for McGeady.
Mike Hughes
67 Posted 11/01/2014 at 21:42:25
...and according to the Daily Telegraph online, Barkley and McGeady are off to a training camp in Tenerife this week.

Ross is there to increase vitamin D intake (via sunlight) with the hope of healing more quickly.

The same article states that RM hopes to add another striker to the squad......

Colin Glassar
68 Posted 11/01/2014 at 21:44:45
That sounds about right Mike. Now if we can get Johnny H off our books that would pay for the Mcgeady deal.
Matt Muzi
69 Posted 11/01/2014 at 21:43:20
Welcome Aiden, hopefully you are the first player in this January window,, because today showed we need some more players with the injuries we've currently got and are likely to get before the end of the season, we need another CM and a striker, minimum.

Personally think McGeady must have something about him for RM to have be after him for 3 years. Our manager strikes me as being an extremely switched on individual who knows what he's doing, so I'm happy it's a face in just need a couple more now and I'll be absolutely made up.

Dick Brady
70 Posted 11/01/2014 at 21:49:00
Respect and loyalty have to be earned. You don't get them just because you sign a piece of paper or because you always go large at McDonalds.

Aiden McGeady will have my respect and loyalty if he earns them on the field.

Vic Flange
71 Posted 11/01/2014 at 21:48:27
If the reported £1M fee for his services is correct, then the deal is a winner in my book. The Kopites can laugh all they like.
Martin Handley
72 Posted 11/01/2014 at 21:38:47
I don't actually think we paid anything for him he waived the last bit of his contract including bonuses which will save Spartak a fair few bob.
Brin Williams
73 Posted 11/01/2014 at 21:52:05
'I would rather bring on McGeady than Naismith or Heitinga. Wouldn't you?'

Not sure mate – will reserve judgement – but he looks like a bonnie wee laddie and no doubt a few weeks on the treadmill will bring him into the reckoning.

Patrick Murphy
74 Posted 11/01/2014 at 21:55:01
I bet McGready is made up to hear that you will give him a chance eh Dick, you are a very difficult man to please by the sounds of it.

At least Garbutt has your approval if your Colchester report is anything to go by.

There was a time when as long as the guy in the Royal Blue jersey gave his all and tried his best the fans would support him, sounds like you need to be like Pele or Messi to get instant approval - I must have missed something in recent months.

Mike Hughes
75 Posted 11/01/2014 at 22:01:42
...... and according to The Independent, we paid £2 million.
Take your pick - undisclosed fee really is irritating.
Mike Hughes
76 Posted 11/01/2014 at 22:07:58
Moral of the story — don't waste money on newspapers. Check them online for free. And don't even bother online with The red Echo.

Jimmy Hill
77 Posted 11/01/2014 at 22:20:31
McCarthy #2 perhaps? He shit and we paid to much too. Give the lad a chance to at least prove many on here wrong.
John Crawley
78 Posted 11/01/2014 at 22:33:01
I'm looking forward to seeing him play. I've got a feeling he could do a John Robertson for us! Welcome to Everton Aiden and good luck for the future.
Ed Smith
79 Posted 11/01/2014 at 22:37:10
He has scored 3 goals in 63 appearances for Ireland. His crossing is dreadful and he often struggles to get it past the first defender. Hopefully Roberto can improve him. However I have to add I have total belief in Roberto so he must have seen something there.
Sean Kelly
81 Posted 11/01/2014 at 22:48:38
McGeady has always flattered to deceive. He's done it at Celtic, does it regular for Ireland but seems to gone supersize in Moscow. He looked out of breath after running up the stairs to the pitch. I trust Roberto to revive his career as it was going south big time... along with his waist.
Dave Williams
82 Posted 11/01/2014 at 23:24:45
Guys posting on here reckoned Martinez would have a leaky defence, we 'd be lucky to finish 10th, McCarthy was a waste of money and Barry was a Man City reject who was past it!!

I'm with Patrick — if they play for us they should get our full backing; that has always been the way with our club. Give the lad a chance to show what he can do and give him proper support. Ridiculous for him to start with an uphill battle.

Kevin Rowlands
83 Posted 11/01/2014 at 23:41:31
Don't forget Oviedo should be nowhere near the pitch, Dave. Also you'd have thought we'd signed a fucking sumo wrestler with all the fat comment, can't' we just see him kicking a ball for us before we crucify him?
Dennis Ng
84 Posted 11/01/2014 at 23:49:41
Kevin, it is kinda what happens when the word fat is thrown around. Yet, one of the best amateur players (pro football in Singapore is a joke) I've ever saw was this guy in his 50s with a waistline equally in the 50-60 range, dancing circles round defenders with the ball.

We'll know more when we see McGeady on the pitch and hopefully he can provide a steady supply of crosses and goals!

Mike Green
85 Posted 12/01/2014 at 00:02:14
I think McGeady will do well once he's match fit.

Loads of talent, something to prove, knows some of the lads in the squad who must've given Martinez the thumbs up on him and great to start, for cover, as an impact substitute. I think it's a great bit of business when I imagine he's cost us next to nothing.

Top marks also to Martinez for signing an attacking, skillful, footballer who'll take players on and get bums of seats and create some excitement and hopefully some goals.

The other thing that gives me a bit of hope is in his interviews McGeady was a bit coy but also had a bit of a twinkle in his eye and a wry smile as if to say 'just wait and see....'

Great addition to the squad, best of luck to him.

Colin Glassar
86 Posted 12/01/2014 at 00:17:02
According to the mirror, we are going to trigger the £7m release clause for that kid, Batsuhayi, from Standard Liege. He's one of europe's hottest prospects and a few top clubs are after him so it would a great deal for us.
Ian Tunstead
87 Posted 12/01/2014 at 00:18:40
McGeady seems to be heavily reliant on speed. One of the first things a player seems to lose is pace. Now in his late 20's we will be lucky to get a couple of good seasons out of him. I doubt we will get much out of him this season either. He looks like he needs to lose a couple of stone.

Nicholas Ryan
88 Posted 12/01/2014 at 01:29:51
I arrived a few minutes late today; saw a bloke on the pitch. I couldn't understand why we appeared to have signed Mike Gatting!!
Noel Early
89 Posted 12/01/2014 at 01:39:41
This lad will make you all pull your hair out. I have seen him play for Celtic and the Republic on numerous occasions.

I will start with the positives: he has good pace and beats men for fun. When he is in the mood, he can be excellent. He is two-footed....

Problem is: he probably the worst crosser of a ball I can think of. And his goal record is also very poor. I think it took him 50 games to get his first international goal.

Chris James
90 Posted 12/01/2014 at 01:43:33
Assuming he's fit to play PL football (looked a little on the chunky side), I can see him slotting in upfield from Coleman on the right, Mirallas on the left and Pienaar in the Barkley role behind Lukaku (with Osman, Oviedo and shortly Delboy as options from the bench).

Hopefully we can steer clear of further injuries before the derby - the media have largely glossed over our absentees (Distin, Alcaraz, Gibson, Barkley, Del and Kone all out currently plus young prospect McAlney with the broken leg).

Colin Williams
91 Posted 12/01/2014 at 02:24:15
McGeady is a massive talent, great technical ability and will excite Goodison! This boy can play the game and is perfect for Everton, give him time to find his legs/fitness and he won't let us down.
Si Cooper
92 Posted 12/01/2014 at 02:23:58
Maybe my TV image is severely distorted (isn't it supposed to add weight) or Sky photoshopped their images, but Aiden McGeady didn't look particularly out of condition to me.

Looking at his jawline, neck and arms it looks like he might actually have been spending quite a lot of time in the gym working on his upper body strength. A couple of weeks hard work should see him ready to try to make an impression coming off the bench.

At 27/28 he should still have the vast majority of his pace and be able to keep it into his early thirties if he is committed to his training (Sylvain Distin being a prime example). The biggest killer of pace is injury, not age, so unless he has a history of chronic leg problems I wouldn't write him off on that score just yet. He doesn't have to be greased lightning over 60-100 metres, just 6-10, to beat a man and play someone in.

Phil Friedman
93 Posted 12/01/2014 at 02:57:46
Ed Smith 448: study his record (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aiden_McGeady). He doesn't score goals, but lots of assists. But it's what we need...someone who can pick a pass.
Dennis Ng
94 Posted 12/01/2014 at 03:18:33
Si, I relooked at the video of his unveiling and have to correct my previous statement. He looks fitter than I first remembered. Might be my streaming. It's not the game on TV (they had spurns vs CP...like really? the combined positions is worse than our match!) and I absolutely blame NBC for that!
Brian Wilkinson
95 Posted 12/01/2014 at 04:38:13
If we signed Messi, I'm pretty sure some on here would say the lad's too small.

Let's just wait and see and pass judgement when the guy takes to the field.

I trust Martinez, he has not let us down yet with the players he has signed, so welcome to your new club, McGeady.

Bob Parrington
96 Posted 12/01/2014 at 07:33:40
Mark 1 and mark 2, does negative attitude go with the name? If he's not fit he won't be played until he is fit enough. Fitness can be trained but attitude and intuitive skill cannot. Give the player a proper welcome to the club.
Matt Traynor
97 Posted 12/01/2014 at 08:05:49
People saying things like "he's heavily reliant on..." or "he's a massive talent" are really feeding the trolls!

I'm trying to remember signings that left us under-whelmed at the time, but proved to be better than expected.

Reid and Power in the 80s spring to mind. More recently there's been Kilbane (?), and of course the late Gary Ablett. But then I remember players like Alexanderssen, van der Meyde and Bilyaletdinov who were the textbook definition of "let down".

Gotta give him a chance at least. Maybe he'll strike up that telepathic understanding with Nais that we never saw between him and Jelavic ;)

John Ford
98 Posted 12/01/2014 at 08:13:15
Joins us and gets his first week over in Spain sunning himself. Beats working I guess.

Good luck to the new boy.

Sam Hoare
99 Posted 12/01/2014 at 10:02:48
Martinez said "He is a clever,clever footballer who has a real understanding of how to hurt teams". Sounds good to me.

When Martinez took Maloney to Wigan most thought of him as a washed up journeyman but Señor Bob turned him into a vital cog in that over-achieving side. McGeady is similar to Maloney but better.

We won't see the best of him till next season but for £1-2M I feel confident we have a good bargain on our hands.

Denis Richardson
100 Posted 12/01/2014 at 10:34:27
Welcome aboard son.

Very timely given Ross's injury. Excellent bit of business as he's cost us pretty much fuck all and I presume he's not on massive wages as he was desperate to get out of Moscow.

Get on the treadmill and show is what you can do.

For those who are criticizing already, keep two things in mind:

i) You probably said the same things about Alcaraz and he's doing fine so far;

ii) the guy cost us fuck all and is an international with CL experience;

iii) Roberto's been after him for ages and his player choices so far has been simply fantastic;

iv) He can't be any worse than Naismith!

Give the guy a chance at least.

Paul Thompson
101 Posted 12/01/2014 at 11:05:53
I watched the YouTube compilation. You have to get past the first couple of minutes which do tend to feed the perception of over-elaborate dribbling. After that there is ample evidence of 'assists' – a lot of very clever through balls rather than conventional crosses from wide. He's two-footed and has pace. He'll certainly cause defences problems. Beyond that, we'll just have to wait and see.
Noel Early
102 Posted 12/01/2014 at 11:13:31
Fee is being reported at just under £2m, Roberto must really want him considering he would have been free in the summer.
Mark Taylor
103 Posted 12/01/2014 at 11:42:10
I find the reaction to some of the more negative views of McGeady somewhat bizarre.

I've said earlier on here that he looks out of shape to me and he comes with a reputation for being 'difficult' which may or may not be deserved. So I'm on the negative side.

But I think it would be sensible to remind ourselves that this is a discussion forum and that while all of us want precisely the same thing, a successful team, the idea is we discuss events that will shape whether this comes to pass. So just because I, for example, think he looks unfit, and have not been overly impressed with what I've seen does not mean I'm writing him off, or not 'welcoming' him, or in particular, hoping that he fails- quite the opposite in fact. I hope RM has found a rough diamond he can polish for a bargain price. But I do have my doubts.

I don't know about anyone else but I'd find this forum a lot less interesting if it was just a repository for nodding dogs and there was no dissent to a given line.

Brian Waring
104 Posted 12/01/2014 at 12:01:02
The difference is though Mark, your offering a legitimate opinion, some lads on here are so negative about him it's ridiculous.
Wayne Smyth
107 Posted 12/01/2014 at 12:18:45
Mark, the issue I have is not any particular comment, or view of any particular player. Its a general vibe I get from some people, that no matter how good a job Martinez does, or how well our team plays, there is always a negative to be found....and if there is no negative to be found, they don't post at all.

I recall a reading something not long ago from one of the usual suspects explaining that Martinez had actually spent £30M+ this season, because they were counting the actual value of Lukaku, and not the £3M it took to get him from Chelsea this season.

How can you discuss anything with people who seem like they're here to wind the rest of us up with such warped logic?

Mark Taylor
108 Posted 12/01/2014 at 13:13:35
Wayne, I take your point but then isn't that to some extent an example of human differences? For example, I tend to be on the 'bucket half empty' side and tend to more see the negatives than extol the positives. Maybe there is an element of me taking the positives for granted (dangerous) but that is just the way I am, and presumably others also. Another way of putting it is, do you prioritise maximising your strengths or eliminating your weaknesses. It's almost a philosophical position.

There's another aspect too. I can't personally climb full onto the "Martinez is the Messiah and we are heading for CL" bandwagon. Not because I don't want it to pass – believe me, I do – more as a means of not setting myself up for disappointment. Or to come back to the specific example in hand, if McGeady turns out to be rubbish, I will probably wail less than most!

So long as each and every one of us genuinely wants the same outcome, for us to succeed, I'm not much bothered how we all go about it, whether from a position of incontestable faith or as the ultimate Doubting Thomas, or any point between.

Harold Matthews
109 Posted 12/01/2014 at 13:23:05
Delighted with McGeady. Certainly didn't look overweight. I''m with Glen Hoddle who rates him highly and was impressed with his new stronger physique. Good luck, Aiden.
Matt Butlin
110 Posted 12/01/2014 at 13:29:30
Told the kids who we'd signed. They asked who was going to drive the bus in Balamory now?
Gavin Ramejkis
111 Posted 12/01/2014 at 15:07:05
Brian #545 the funniest part of Messi's height is that if it wasn't for Barcelona paying for the hormone treatment he needed when he was much younger he would be even smaller!

Having seen my backside and admitted on here about Gareth Barry, I'm mre than happy to see him in a blue shirt for a few games before I criticise what he can and cant bring to a game. If he's good enough for Martinez then he must have a plan on where and how to play him, thats good enough for me for now.

Simon Jones
115 Posted 12/01/2014 at 20:02:54
Just been looking up some stats on him, one thing is obvious, he's a lot thinner when he's fit. Don't think we'll be seeing him in the first team for a few weeks yet! Can't make me mind up if he's a good signing for us, though the lad has obviously got good experience.
Wayne Smyth
116 Posted 12/01/2014 at 21:12:38
Mark, I don't think it is about differences in opinion. We all happily argue our different positions here.

It's a certain stubbornness and something a bit more deep seated with a few people. I can imagine them actually not enjoying watching us beat Utd at OT, or demolish Newcastle in the first half at Goodison, mumbling through gritted teeth how OFM could've done it better.

Personally I couldn't care less who our manager is or which players are doing the damage. If we're wiping the floor with someone, I'll be bouncing off the walls with joy.

Kevy Quinn
118 Posted 13/01/2014 at 09:01:53
I think a lot of the negative comments re this signing need to be taken with a pinch of salt. Don't forget he played for Celtic, so any Blues with connections to Rangers etc. may feel the need to have a go.

Decent signing I think and if Roberto wants him. That's good enough for me.

Trevor Lynes
119 Posted 13/01/2014 at 13:11:38
I just remember that we were promised that replacements were to be made for Gibson and Kone in this window and that we would end the window with a stronger squad. So far we are actually worse off as we have lost Lukaku's natural substitute (Jelavic if he goes) and just gained one extra wide midfield attacker. McGeady is not a replacement for Gibson or Kone IMO.

I just hope that we have sufficient irons in the fire to be able to live up to Roberto's promise!!

John Keating
120 Posted 13/01/2014 at 13:35:01
I heard McGreedy left Celtic cos he thought the rest of the team weren't good enough to showcase his talents. I also heard he disagreed with the Russian mob training regime, style of play, position he played.

We could be in for an interesting time. I hope he doesn't upset what appears to be a very happy team spirit!

Jackie Barry
121 Posted 13/01/2014 at 13:46:02
Blimey there are some negative comments on here and he hasn't even kicked a ball for us yet, In the end for whatever reason he left Celtic to better himself like many other players leave their clubs to do just the same thing. Give the guy a break and lets see what happens. AS for team spirit well that is down to RM, I am pretty sure while he may come across as Mr Nice guy he also has a hard side to his persona too and will be able to deal with any tantrums.
Bill Griffiths
122 Posted 13/01/2014 at 14:25:55
Personally I haven't seen anything at all of McGeady to say whether he's any good or not. If I were to just go by many of the comments made in posts on this site, I'd be asking "What are we signing this lump of shite for?"

However, I think I will go by Roberto's judgement in this matter as he obviously has seen something in him and trust that he will get the best out of him. If, however, he doesn't work, it's not as if we have laid out a great outlay in getting him.

Just one other point: one of the main criticisms against him is lack of end-product and poor decision-making. These are comments that can well be applied to DelBoy also. Would all those opposed to signing him for this reason advocate kicking out DelBoy for the same reason?

Ian Burns
123 Posted 13/01/2014 at 14:16:26
I have said on different threads that I didn't want McGeady and that he could dribble the ball up his own arse and lose it. He just doesn't do it for me, personally.

However, he is now a blue; he is rated by RM and from this point on he gets my 100% support and if he turns out to be as good a signing as Barry/McCarthy then who the hell am I to complain!

Welcome to EFC Aiden and enjoy your time at the best club in the world.

Nicholas Ryan
124 Posted 13/01/2014 at 18:41:37
Has it occurred to anyone, that McGeady is about the same size and build as Diego Maradona ?! ....And let's face it, you couldn't call Messi, thin!
Matthew Mackey
125 Posted 14/01/2014 at 13:09:02
Aiden, we hope you enjoy your time at Everton and do well for us. Just one request though..............stay away from the pie truck and loose some weight.
Matthew Mackey
126 Posted 14/01/2014 at 13:12:10
Nicholas #127 ;- Her may be the same size and build as Maradona, but he ain't Maradona! Know what I'm Sayin here?
Jackie Barry
127 Posted 14/01/2014 at 13:17:39
Well even with this supposed extra weight he is faster than most of the other players in our squad. Crikey, he could become even faster. Honestly don't know what some are bothered about with this, we have paid virtually nothing for a player that wants to play for us. In my opinion I'm not sure he would have wanted too with the old regime in charge.
Raymond Fox
128 Posted 14/01/2014 at 13:29:55
RM stated that he likes players that can go pass defenders, one on one.

McGeady fits that MO.


Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads

© ToffeeWeb