'Some of our play was magnificent'

, EvertonFC.com , 11 January, 89comments  |  Jump to most recent
Roberto Martinez saluted the efforts of his players as they overcame Norwich City at Goodison Park in what the Blues boss called a ‘tricky game'.

Speaking to evertontv, Martinez said: “I'm very pleased. I think it was a very tricky game for us because obviously for any home game you feel like you have to concentrate on what you do on the ball and in your attacking play.

“I thought we were very good with that and some of the aspects of our play were magnificent.

“Of course with those types of games, you can leave yourself exposed and you can drop your level of concentration defensively but today we were at our best in that department. Together we got a clean sheet out of that and that was very satisfying.

“We made six changes from the FA Cup game for one reason or another and to see a team so close to together, showing a great understanding of what's needed, was very, very pleasing.”

“Obviously we had the bad news of Ross Barkley having to miss the game, and Antolin Alcaraz not being able to play so many games having just come back, so to get Phil Jagielka back with Leighton Baines as well, that gives you an incredible strength.

“Then we had Tim Howard back in goal, and he showed an incredible sharpness in his performance.

“We look at every game as a challenge for this football club and each member of the squad is ready to come in and play the way the team expects. That is very satisfying.”

Quotes or other material sourced from EvertonFC.com



Reader Comments (89)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Ian Tunstead
1 Posted 12/01/2014 at 00:50:43
I notice Martinez discussing what brilliant football was on show for the first goal, looked like a hoof up field to me, but excellent finish by Barry.
Dennis Ng
2 Posted 12/01/2014 at 00:53:52
Ian, it was more like a clearance that dropped just right for Lukaku. But you might also want to look at how the rest of the players ran up field and stretched the defence thin, like literally a flat line right at the edge of the box. That gave Barry that awesome opportunity to shoot.

Gavin Ramejkis
3 Posted 12/01/2014 at 02:44:53
Ian, I'm not sure if you were at the game or only reliant on MotD's blinkered as fuck version of events, there was an attempt on goal in the first half which, if it would have ended in the back of the net, would have been goal of the season with numerous backheels and flicks between the Norwich defence.

Have you ever seen Disney's Jungle Book? There's a scene in it where Kaa, a large Boa Constrictor, hypnotises Mowgli and his eyes turn into spirals.... well, that's what the move looked like we had done to the Norwich players who were stood unable to get anywhere near the ball flicking between them.

Ian Tunstead
4 Posted 12/01/2014 at 03:04:42
Yes Gavin, but I was specifically talking about the goal and the Martinez interview. I'm not trying to criticise, I am merely pointing out that for all the fancy football we struggled to break them down in open play and didn't have that many clear cut chances. It took a free kick and a hoof up to Lukaku to get a goal.

Without Barkley, we seem to lack that cutting edge to turn the game when playing the same way which might cost us in the long run when other teams suss us out. Perhaps McGeady can step in and become the game changer...

Lukaku has been a bit quiet over the past few weeks and maybe he is not being utilized as effectively as he could be. I saw two long balls or "clearances" from Barry during the game up to Lukaku and one resulted in a goal for Barry and the other very nearly resulted in a goal for Lukaku, maybe something to consider. Just my observations.

By the way, can someone explain to me the difference between a hoof, a long ball and a clearance?

Michael Kenrick
6 Posted 12/01/2014 at 06:24:16
I'll have a go, Ian.

A hoof is an aimless hopeful ball pumped upfield by the team in possession, usually to no-one in particular; a percentage ball that might hit the head of one of our players, or the opposition, or go just about anywhere.

A long ball is a well placed pass from deep or cross-field that is executed with skill, timing and pace to fall for the intended target man, with that man either controlling the ball or laying it off.

A clearance usually implies it is made as an instinctive defensive move as a first-time play under some opposition pressure, with little or no consideration for where the ball goes — upfield or out of play — so long as the lines are cleared.

A and C are kind of samey; B is a bit rarer. I can understand your question because, until recently, Everton teams have not used this higher quality ball very much, preferring A or C as the primary means for advancing the ball down the field.

Hope this helps!

Eric Myles
7 Posted 12/01/2014 at 06:59:45
Some of our play was magnificient, and some of it was terrible.

Obviously still more work needs to be done on passing to our own players.

Robbie Shields
8 Posted 12/01/2014 at 07:08:12
Now that's sarcasm!!!! Love it.

Comprende Ian????

I know you've struggled for a long time to understand certain aspects of the beautiful game, so your question comes as no real surprise.

Dennis Ng
9 Posted 12/01/2014 at 07:26:33
Michael, might I add:

A = Most of our plays last season hitting the ball towards the general direction of afrohead, even when we have the situation under control

B = Some of the plays today that Barry tried to catch the defenders and GK sleeping

C = Anything too complicated for our defenders to clear on the ground goes into this bucket, but typically a calculated decision on defensive terms

Ian, sorry I'm a bit picky on the choice of words. If anyone says hoff to me, I would think as "Shit, I don't know what to do with the ball going upfield...don't really know where to move the ball towards...crap, let's just try kicking it high towards their goal and see what others can do"

Ya, I'm very particular in description...

Kevin Rowlands
10 Posted 12/01/2014 at 07:32:27
Ian, we totally dominated the game for the best part of 75 mins, we won 2-0, were 4th in the league, were playing some of the best football many of us have seen since the mid 80's, we had a new exciting signing today, but you chose to come on here and nitpick about hoofball for the goals? you, nick, and phil are a treble for the ages!
Mike Green
11 Posted 12/01/2014 at 07:15:53
Ian

We've won plenty of points playing the passing game this season, and some would say we've dropped some more when we couldn't convert a draw into a win - and no doubt on those occasions there will have been much criticism for us not being "direct" enough.

There's nothing wrong with hitting it long, so long as it does the job and it's not the only thing you're capable of. Besides, Barry's goal was hardly something out of the John Beck training manual was it....?

Personally, for me one of the great sights in football is seeing a ball sprayed from side to the other and completely changing the status of play. Where it gets tedious is when you constantly get a team humping the ball up to a big man who more often than not loses it, and win, lose or draw makes watching the game torturous - something you couldn't level at the Everton team.

If Barcelona, Man Utd or Brazil do it they're applauded for their versatility, when we do it dark clouds gather and the "long ball merchants" tag starts to loom...and when we can't win by playing 32 short passes but try a different mode of attack that works it's seen as a deficiency rather than a quality even by our own support.

Regarding breaking teams down, Arsenal have been hailed for years as the best footballing side in England but often criticised for trying to walk the ball in. We are still a work in progress, it's very early days, we've made amazing progress so let's take yesterday for what it was - a dominant performance, clean sheet and 3 points over a side who've recently been a bit of problem for us - and all done, generally, playing great football.

Matt Traynor
12 Posted 12/01/2014 at 08:15:31
Reminds me of a story from yesteryear, back when they had the Lilleshall "School of Excellence". Schoolboy players in a lecture theatre, and that master tactician, Don Howe, shows a video of a Brazil match, 30-odd passes, play eventually breaks down. He then showed a clip of an English side (probably one managed by Howard Wilkinson) hoofing the ball upfield, loose ball played into the area, striker scores.

Kid gets up from the classroom, checks himself out from the school, goes home.

Now, I can't remember a) Who told the story b) Whether it's an urban myth or c) if true, what became of the schoolboy - did he quit the game?

The point is that to some it's all about what's in the "for" column versus what's in the "against" column. For others it's how you beat the other team.

I had to watch it on the net yesterday, as despite being in the Middle East with 19 fucking sports channels (including Ipswich v QPR FFS yesterday) our game wasn't on. At half time I watched on the TV in my hotel room as Richard Keys and Andy Gray went through the half times during the Tottenham v Palace game, and Keys chuckles something like "how's this for the excellent football they've become known for" as they show the goal. To be fair to Gray he pointed out that Lukaku held the ball up well as Barry ran into the space etc.

This season we've spread the goals around. We've got full-backs who between them have scored more from open play than some teams' expensively-assembled front line have managed all season. We've scored goals at the end of some sublime interplay and passing, and yesterday we got one off a hoof/clearance that Lukaku managed to control, for once.

I don't care what Richard Keys (or Ian Tunstead) says. I'm liking this Everton that looks like it has goals from all over, because it must scare the fuck out of defenders.

Dennis Ng
13 Posted 12/01/2014 at 08:54:47
Guys, I think its merely that he started the conversation in the wrong direction. I for one added fuel to fire by further classifying it. Sorry, force of habit. Reminds me of the YT channel CinemaSins.

Matt, I concur and think the goal actually makes other teams fear us much more. While we cannot convert all our chances, we're still good with the good'ol smash and grab. Give our players a chance and they will take the shot. If not, we'll press till we see a cress. As mentioned a few times, I can't wait for Jan to end so we'll know all the players that RM wants to bring in and what the team will finally be.

Tim Rydings
14 Posted 12/01/2014 at 09:01:29
Matt,

I watched Keys and Gray on the same channel as you, here in Jordan. After focusing on all their usual favourites, when showing the tables they noticed that .... ' Everton have drifted into the top four....'. They spend hours discussing how and why their love children like the Spuds, the Shite and the Mancs need 'the top four' and how they can manage it then leave us like the ugly duckling or an uninvited party guest.

Can't wait for RM to make these pundits realise we're well worth a seat at the top table!

Eric Myles
15 Posted 12/01/2014 at 09:26:52
Mike #573 "and some would say we've dropped some more when we couldn't convert a draw into a win - and no doubt on those occasions there will have been much criticism for us not being "direct" enough."

That's exactly the criticism that the commentators came out with in our first 3 games.

Brin Williams
16 Posted 12/01/2014 at 10:17:55
This Ng fellow seems incredibly knowledgeable - in fact there seems very little he doesn't know - or so he says.

Perhaps MK should get him on the editorial team.

Wayne Smyth
17 Posted 12/01/2014 at 10:24:02
Ian Tunstead, did Martinez sleep with your wife, or are you OFM in disguise?

Since Moyes left, virtually the only things that seems to have come out of you - and Entwistle - is bile.

Our manager is doing a superb job keeping us in touch with the league leaders with 21 games gone, half his fucking squad injured, playing brilliant football, blooding our youngsters and having turned a massive profit in the transfer window and and the best you can do is come here and snipe about long balls and how our new signing will be shit before he's even kicked a ball.

Mike Keating
18 Posted 12/01/2014 at 10:32:46
Agree with Gavin @ 535
MOTD coverage was pathetic and did not reflect our dominance or style of play. Let the cry babies howl - it's great to be Blue.
One thing which doesn't seem to get a comment is why RM decided to go with 3 CBs for the last 15 mins. It gave Norwich a new lease of life when they had clearly given up the ghost.
Let's hope we learn something from this little experiment - it didn't work!
Having said that I thought Heitinger did well and just hope it caught the attention of someone with a few bob to spend.
Phil Sammon
19 Posted 12/01/2014 at 10:52:22
You know what has really put a smile on my face today? The fact that I can't remember the last time I saw one of our full-backs clip a ball down the line with the feint hope of a flick-on. We used to do this literally 15-20 times a game and it always did my head in.
Dennis Ng
20 Posted 12/01/2014 at 11:07:24
Brin, surely you jest. I just sit around TW too much to listen to what everyone wants to say. Most of the time, I'm just copying things I read elsewhere :)
Kevin Tully
21 Posted 12/01/2014 at 11:06:36
Really annoying that some think we will slide like West Brom when Lukaku's loan period expires. Lots of commentators (and posters) convinced we will be poor next season because we will be missing our loanees. Does anyone still think that? Barry will be here, and we are not missing Deulofeu, especially now we have McGeady. No doubt we will bring in another striker.

Our play is not reliant on any one player or position. We will obviously suffer when we are missing half of our first team, but we don't compromise on style if players are out with injury.

We have a good chance to recuperate now, as our next game is on Monday against West Brom, we are also off on a little jolly for some warm weather training.

Our centre back pairing is changing game by game, yet we are not witnessing the any tinkering with the rest of the side to compensate what may have been a problem area - only two or three at the back for the majority of the game yesterday.

The future's bright because of how the team is set up to play - not because of individual talent.

Jason Ingham
22 Posted 12/01/2014 at 11:20:10
I didn't think we played too well in this game. 2 v.good goals, not the type of goals you can regularly count on and we didn't create too much from general play. Frustrating, not just in this game but others, to see Lukaku on the defenders shoulder but the required thread pass is rarely attempted. I would also like to see defenders try and play Lukaku in over-the-top occasionally, mix it up a little. Though we were a little lucky that Norwich didn't turn up, we need to up our game against these struggling terms and start matching the appetite we show against bigger teams.
Brian Waring
23 Posted 12/01/2014 at 11:44:23
Wayne, I was thinking the same thing, the lads who always feel the need to get in a pop at Martinez are the one's who backed Moyes to the hilt, Walling, Entwistle and as you mention Tunstead.

They just don't seem able to let go of the umbilical cord.

Alan McGuffog
24 Posted 12/01/2014 at 12:01:17
Only been to a couple of games this season. I noticed something yesterday that has me most concerned, regarding our tactics that is sure to bring us grief.

Twice in the first half (didn't notice in the second) when Norwich had a corner, Mirallas was left up field. Now most of you guys are more tactically aware than I am but wtf is that all about?!? It means two of their galoots had to stick by him and not get into our penalty area... AND it gave us options when clearing the danger.

Please Roberto, may we have everyone, however small and useless with his head BACK in our box at times like this. Sort it!

Ian Tunstead
25 Posted 12/01/2014 at 12:12:16
Thank you for the explanation Michael, I agree with your explanations and have the same opinion but just wanted to clarify.
Phil Bellis
26 Posted 12/01/2014 at 12:06:13
Mr "I'm not trying to criticise" Tunstead appears to have the football tactical appreciation and acumen of Tommy Smith's arse. A few words about movement and creating space, young Ian
Watch the build-up to Barry's goal again.
Things to look out for...

Baines runs wide left, Osman runs left into into the area, Lukaku runs right into the area, two more everton players race into the far right of the area. This movement causes utter confusion to the Norwich defence, some remain static, some back-pedal.
This movement coincidentally(!) opens up a rather inviting, unprotected gap into which Barry strides unopposed and thumps the ball into the net

I realise this running about a bit with purpose, intent and astuteness is not what you have been used to seeing from Everton sides in the recent past, but, stick with us, give it time – it will grow on you (hopefully)

Mark Andersson
27 Posted 12/01/2014 at 13:01:18
I've been reading with interest peoples post over the past couple of months. While I find some of them insightful and eye opening I still wonder why some fans always seem to pick up on the negative, even when there is way more positive stats and good even some great football being played.

Born a blue in 1960 I've witnessed some great teams and some brilliant players. I predicted a win against Norwich while others went into doom and gloom mode before the game thinking they would turn us over.

As for the first post on this particular thread, please Ian, get a life, or are you one of these people who just like to wind people up for a reaction? The two goals scored – and I quote from the TV commentator – were "World Class". End of.

James Stewart
28 Posted 12/01/2014 at 13:18:08
"Some" of our play being the key word. After we switched to a back 3 I thought it was one of our worst performances of the season and, had Norwich had a half-decent team, we would have been punished.
Ian Tunstead
29 Posted 12/01/2014 at 12:58:53
To be fair this is not the interview I was talking about, I was talking about the interview on MotD were they were specifically talking about the goal.

My issue is that in interviews with Martinez he wants to only play one way, and if that doesn't work he will continue to be patient and continue to play that way. Fair enough, those are his methods, if he thinks that will get more good than bad results over the course of a season then he should stick to his principles, but there have been times when I have felt some mixing it up might have got more rewards.

Dave White
30 Posted 12/01/2014 at 13:09:19
Right I'm going to add my two penneth's worth on the perceived lack of form of Lukaku.

For me the boy's movement is a massive part of our success, irrespective of whether he ends up getting the ball. In the next game I recommend taking your eyes off the ball and just watching the Luk's runs in the final 3rd. The way he pulls defenders out of their positional comfort zone creates space and open the channels channels for our marauding midfielders and full backs. What he does off the ball is just as important as what he does with it. Personally I think the boy is doing just what he needs to do, I just hope he doesn't get frustrated that a lot of his play will never actually see him get the ball.

As this side develops and Martinez continues to change the way we play I can even see us playing without a recognised striker.

Kevin Tully
31 Posted 12/01/2014 at 13:36:02
Yay - Hamann & Carragher to assault my hearing all day Sunday.

Sky have pointed out Hamann played 31 times for Newcastle though!

Why don't these red buffoons just go and play golf instead? It seems every single one of them wants to get their ugly mugs on telly.

They are all as thick as pig shit, why do they think the nation wants hear their banal mutterings?

No doubt they will be all over the radio as well. Twats.

Brin Williams
32 Posted 12/01/2014 at 13:44:19
'Brin, surely you jest. I just sit around TW too much to listen to what everyone wants to say. Most of the time, I'm just copying things I read elsewhere :)'

Ng – now that's just what I thought – no original thoughts. Try and get yourself to a match at Goodison – there are one or two clever sods that pop in there from time to time to tell us all how the game should be played, who is good but more particularly who is crap.

Don't see them often and but there is always someone else to take their place. Pisses off most of the regulars.

Brian Denton
33 Posted 12/01/2014 at 14:10:08
Gavin (535) yes I was looking forward to seeing that brilliant move on MotD. Ditto Lukaku's 'offside' goal. Neither was shown. I know conspiracy theories are nonsense, but .....

I wonder if we do gatecrash the party whether they'll change the rules to ensure that teams called 'Everton' are not allowed in.

Al Reddish
34 Posted 12/01/2014 at 15:03:06
They tried and nearly succeeded in 2005 Brian, and just to make sure the job was complete we had the hardest qualifying task any team has had to face and they threw a dodgy ref in too.....just in case!
Phil Walling
35 Posted 12/01/2014 at 15:12:19
Still think the "educated hoof'" has a part to play as per yesterday's example. After a period of tica taci, it comes as a great surprise to the opposition defence and is a tactic often employed by Arsenal's 'pass you to death' teams.
David Chait
36 Posted 12/01/2014 at 15:23:26
Completely agree Phil. Sometimes it's clear the pressure needs to be relieved and there is nothing on.., clear the lines.
There was one moment when we passed out of defense so well, bisecting their pressure, you could hear the stadium gives its appreciation for the skill. Was very satisfying to watch.
Patrick Murphy
37 Posted 12/01/2014 at 15:29:35
Everton have played every Premier League team at least once and the refrain keeps coming if this team or that team had have been half decent or had a better attack or whatever other quality they were lacking then the Blues would have fallen flat on their face. The fact that we have only lost two matches and have one of the best defences seems to have escaped those who repeat this mantra game after game. Everton are from being the finished article but we are playing good attractive football with the odd victory thrown in, I do wonder if any team on the planet could match the high standards that some fans seem to have set.
Mick Davies
38 Posted 12/01/2014 at 15:11:48
For the first time on TW, I feel I have to agree with Ian Tunstead; for all the sexy football we played – and at times it was breathtaking – the opening goal came from a defensive lash from Jags which Lukaku did well to bring down and control then lay off to Barry.

Jags by the way was playing like Bobby Moore, and he's now adapted well into Roberto's system. Some of his clever little flicks under pressure and the coolness when bringing the ball out of defence were a joy, whereas young Stonesy made a couple of ricks, but never stopped him from playing the right way up to the end.

We really do have a good squad of players, doing things the right way, under a manager who has a vision of the future and is intent on taking us all there. The only problem is, at some time in the mid-1980s, someone at Everton must have smashed a few mirrors, or a Gypsy kopite must have been angered by the club, because every time our EFC have something going, if it's not Heysel, or refereeing decisions etc, it's injuries. We must have been cursed.

Kevin Tully
39 Posted 12/01/2014 at 15:36:40
Wrong I'm afraid lads. I've just watched the replay on MotD and Jagielka cleared the 50/50 loose ball, with a Norwich player closing him down.

It was a clearance upfield, he never even had time to look up, plus it took a big deflection on its way to Lukaku.

Ian Tunstead
40 Posted 12/01/2014 at 16:07:04
So are you saying the goal was luck then Kevin, because we weren't playing the way Martinez wanted? As Michael said, a clearance is basically the same as a hoof. A hit in hope in the right direction. That's why I asked for a definition and nobody disagreed with the definition Michael provided.
Kevin Tully
41 Posted 12/01/2014 at 16:43:52
Yeah Ian - it was the luckiest 20 yard screamer I've ever seen.

Michael Kenrick
42 Posted 12/01/2014 at 16:36:51
This is basic, but most of us know and understand that goals in top-class football are a rarity. They happen in a very short space of time when things go right... or when luck kicks in, or a myriad of infinitely variable scenarios in-between.

But how much of a typical game involves playing football and NOT scoring goals? How many minutes are spent executing moves or attacks that are unsuccessful? It must be between 90% and 98% of the total minutes in Premier League games that do not involve goals. Then, it's down to how you play football.

Ian is being incredibly annoying with his disingenuous characterizations of the football Everton are playing and the goals Everton are scoring. He is supposed to be entitled to his opinions, but there is a line somewhere where a seemingly deliberate failure to recognize what is happening in front of your eyes needs to be rejected as unacceptable in a debate among Evertonians.

Jackie Barry
43 Posted 12/01/2014 at 16:38:40
Blimey some weird comments on here. At times yesterday our play was very good, it was only towards the end when the changes were made that we started to stutter a little. As thankful as I am to the ginger one for the stability he brought to the club nobody with eyes can deny that we are playing better football under RM, it's not a claim it is pure fact. The hit up field was controlled very well by Lukaku, the running of the players was very effective in drawing their player and the goal was superb! What isn't great about that?

There is nothing I can do about this but I sure get the impression that some of you are just not getting over Moyes leaving us. I don't know whether it's because you are young and started supporting Everton during his tenure but you need to see past the description of Everton you have been fooled with all these years.

This club is huge and RM has started to get us believing in a way that I last remember being back in the 80s. Time to move on guys, join the excitement, something special is happening, something that is going to put this club back where it belongs, in the echelons of English football. Start believing!

Ian Tunstead
44 Posted 12/01/2014 at 16:51:16
Michael the football was very good at times but it doesn't help when my comments are taken out of context. I was talking about the interview on MotD when they are specifically talking about the goal and Martinez said something along the lines of "Yes, it was fantastic football for the first goal."

Admittedly brilliant control from Lukaku and great strike from Barry but it had nothing to do with brilliant build up play or anything like that. It was just a hoof or clearance up the field which caught the opposition out because they thought they could just contain us and allow us to pass in circles in front of them until we lost possession.

Ian Tunstead
45 Posted 12/01/2014 at 17:00:44
Kevin I asked you the question if it was luck. I'm not sure that I believe in luck. I have always said you create your own luck. What was that quote? Something like the harder I work and the more I practice the luckier I become. It wasn't luck that Lukaku controlled the "clearance" and Barry's shot and goal was not luck either. The point I am making is in interviews Martinez says he doesn't like to rely on luck or percentage football but that first goal happened playing the percentages. I see nothing wrong with trying it a bit more often.
Ian Tunstead
47 Posted 12/01/2014 at 17:20:03
Jackie it is not fact that we are playing better football, it is your opinion. The best football is the football that gets the best results, so far we have had similar results to last season and so we can't say for sure until the end of the season who plays the best football. But we also need to consider that it is easier to play better football with better footballers.
Tom Bowers
48 Posted 12/01/2014 at 17:24:05
Yesterday showed once again how the club has progressed under RM. Another change at centre back but the defence solid as ever with Stones showing class for his age. Mirallas bouncing back to his best and Barry proving as good a loanee as anyone has had.

Just an odd footnote, Everton are playing the same three teams in the same order as they did at the start of the season.

Michael Kenrick
49 Posted 12/01/2014 at 17:29:53
"It is not fact that we are playing better football" — Un-fucking-believable.

And don't conflate quality of football with results — even though they are also pretty good.

But if you personally wish to wait until the end of the season before figuring it out, we can certainly accommodate that.

Ross Edwards
50 Posted 12/01/2014 at 17:34:37
Ian, you are fast becoming a minority WUM. Someone who deliberately voices an opinion which most contributors disagree with.

We know you hate Martinez and your unwillingness to attribute any success to him, so there's no point clarifying your view as you are just digging an even bigger hole for yourself.

Jackie Barry
51 Posted 12/01/2014 at 17:40:12
Ian, you are quite frankly unbelievable. Not sure whether you watch the games, go to the games or just read the paper the day after but even that should tell you that most people are saying we are playing better football, that would make it 'NOT' just my opinion. Obviously the end of the season will reveal all to us but so far for me and most of our fans we are pretty darn happy with RM and wouldn't take back Moyes.
Paul Ferry
52 Posted 12/01/2014 at 17:45:57
Totally agree Jackie - 767. On this and other threads Turnstead is pure caricature in this post-ginger world where he clearly struggles to find his step. it's now becoming a trifle embarrassing, not least when he gets pulled apart on this thread but pops back on a handful of times not to deal head on with the other side of the argument but to reiterate that he agrees with MK's hoof definition! Does he feel that somehow snuggling up to MK is some sort of credible validation for his history?

Thankfully the number of grudging curmudgeons continues to fall with each new Bobby day but in the meantime what was once a laugh is now nothing more than Turnstead/Entwhistle dogsbollocks drudgery.

Dennis Ng
53 Posted 12/01/2014 at 17:30:14
Brin, if I get time and money to go to GP, I definitely will.

Been lucky to be able to catch quite a few games online or on TV. I try to be as original in thought and intent as possible. Sometimes, I do think people who speak their mind way too freely gets taken out of context as trying to act in-the-know. I know some say I sound like that too though I just say things straight from the heart. No offense intended.

Ian, the way Kevin said it was the same as what I interpreted when I saw the exact action leading to the goal. If one wants to say its an intelligent hoof, I don't care. That is one minute out of 90 that we have a play like that and for the most part, our team played beautiful. My comment on the build up play was just trying to justify what RM said, though at this point it doesn't matter. We want to win, we got the win, we want to play 90 mins of beautiful football, we did that too.

Also, if we justify the quality of football by the results, then watching the match would be very boring. That's 90 mins of football but you only cared about the 1 second after the final whistle.

John Daley
54 Posted 12/01/2014 at 17:45:31
"... The best football is the football that gets the best results, so far we have had similar results to last season"

Err...except better.

"Ian is being incredibly annoying"

What? Outrageous. I refuse to believe it!

Talk about stating the obvious Michael.

It's like someone saying 'Lenny Henry is being a twat again'

Ian Tunstead
55 Posted 12/01/2014 at 17:45:16
Michael, Jackie, never count your chickens before they hatch. We played great football at the start of last season but crumbled in the second half of the season. There have been times when the likes of Blackpool, Hull and Newcastle have been flying a good way into the season, it doesn't matter until the end of the season. I am not disputing that the results have been very good this season but it will count for nothing if we have any more injuries and fall away in the 2nd part of the season.

You only have to look at Arsenal and Chelsea over the past few years especially during Morinho's first stint. Chelsea didn't exactly play the most flowing and expansive football using Drogba as a target man a lot of the time where as Arsenal would pass a team to death but Chelsea would finish as league champions and Arsenal would just about finish in the top 4, so who is the better team and the team that played the best football? I would say its the team that got the best results ie Chelsea.

Now we see Arsenal with more of a target man doing very well and Chelsea lacking a real target man not doing quite as well as they once did. We have a very good target man who is a very good all round footballer but I feel he could be utilized a bit more effectively, that is all I am saying.

Dennis Stevens
56 Posted 12/01/2014 at 18:00:29
"The best football is the football that gets the best results..." - Only if your definition of "best" is "most effective" rather than "most entertaining", Ian. However, I suspect Martinez is aiming to deliver both in the longer run & he's made a great start considering he's working, largely, with his predecessors squad.
Patrick Murphy
57 Posted 12/01/2014 at 18:08:02
I'm not old enough to remember but many Evertonians who had the privilege of watching the Blues' in the late sixties thought that the football played by Everton a couple of seasons prior to winning the Championship in 1970 was superior to that played during the 69-70 campaign. Perhaps someone who did witness those teams can enlighten us.
Ian Burns
58 Posted 12/01/2014 at 17:56:46
Michael, as editor of this site, I think you recently tried to get those of us on TW to move on from discussing in detail what WAS in the past seasons EFC and to enjoy what is NOW EFC under RM. If people wish to wait until the end of the season then compare it to past seasons, then so be it.

However, for the life of me, I cannot understand those who cannot see the sheer enjoyment the majority of those who post and certainly those who attend GP are getting from this new, exciting new manager.

The majority of us (me included) expected this to be a season of transition but the problem we are now seeing is the rapid improvement under RM is causing some to keep harping back in comparison and doing their level best to prove this improvement is either fleeting or no improvement at all.

We are ALL blues; everybody is entitled to an opinion but for goodness sake the minority of posters (we know who they are), should take their misery and shove it where the sun doesn't shine and allow the rest of us to enjoy what we are seeing; enjoy the improvement and enjoy the throw back to the School of Science.

So we score a great goal from a "hoof up the pitch" – who cares? It is the overall improvement in style; class and I for one is loving every single minute.

Ross Edwards
59 Posted 12/01/2014 at 18:18:20
Ian Burns, pat yourself on the back. Stunning post. 1,000,000% correct.
Ross Edwards
64 Posted 12/01/2014 at 18:49:50
Ian, we can't win with you can we?

If Jags had dithered like Osman had done and given the ball away, resulting in a goal, you would have slaughtered our "tippy tappy" style.

But when under pressure, he does the right thing and clears it upfield, resulting in a stunning Barry goal, you describe it as hoofball.

We played sensational stuff yesterday. It's just that the minority doesn't want to give Martinez credit for our improvement from the previous regime.

Dennis Stevens
65 Posted 12/01/2014 at 18:53:12
Ian #779 "You only have to look at Arsenal and Chelsea over the past few years especially during Morinho's first stint. Chelsea didn't exactly play the most flowing and expansive football using Drogba as a target man a lot of the time where as Arsenal would pass a team to death but Chelsea would finish as league champions and Arsenal would just about finish in the top 4, so who is the better team and the team that played the best football? I would say its the team that got the best results ie Chelsea."

So the team at the top of the table is always the team that plays the best football, because the stats prove they got the best results? It almost sounds as though you don't actually watch any matches for real, but prefer to study the tables instead.

Paul Ferry
67 Posted 12/01/2014 at 18:57:59
Ian (Tunstead) pick your battles this is not one of them. Just take a break because your preaching is honestly getting you nowhere - except a somewhat silly caricature image that you don't want - and the tide has drowned your pulpit. Have a week off or a winter break, think things through a little more deeply, watch something funny that the rest of the world finds funny.

One thing that really bugs me though, that all said, is that if by chance the second half of our season is not as good as our first half, as night follows day, Ian (Tunstead) will bounce on here with loud ringing ungracious undignified 'I told ya ... eh eh ... I told ya, didn't I ... eh eh eh ... ya wouldn't listen eh ... eh eh ... who was right and who was wrong ... eh, eh, eh ......

Why bother? Why harp on like this? Why? An objective outsider reading ToffeeWeb for the first ever time might even feel that you might even take a little smug satisfaction on being proven right even if that means that the club you support is suffering.

Makes no sense to me at all.

Come in from the rain, enjoy the sunshine.

Kevin Tully
71 Posted 12/01/2014 at 19:40:39
Kinda reminders you of one of those Japanese soldiers from WW2 who is found on an island and still thinks it's all kicking off 40 years later.

Except I imagine Ian in a boozer in Bootle preaching to an oblivious youngster in 3D google glasses about the good old days of KITANO.

"We nearly got a win at Old Trafford that season as well son."

Paul Ferry
73 Posted 12/01/2014 at 19:59:36
Ian Burns - 800 -and John Daley - 856 - super posts!
Phil Bellis
74 Posted 12/01/2014 at 19:46:41
Patrick (#799),

I'm sure I've waffled on in the past on here about seasons 66-67 to 68-69. It's all subjective, I suppose, but for me and my still match-going mates, they were "the best of times". It was a joy going home and away with that Everton side; not a weakness and you knew – win, lose or draw – you would see a performance.
It was a hard division and there were also great players scattered around other good sides: Best, Moore, Bell etc. It all led to a great Championship-winning season; as now, we were not the finished article but working towards it, bit by bit each season, with a mixture of arrogant youth and practised maturity.

Patrick Murphy
75 Posted 12/01/2014 at 20:13:48
Thanks Phil, that is the same response as my Uncles and their mates had to that late 60s team.
Peter Mills
76 Posted 12/01/2014 at 20:05:07
A matter of fact rather than opinion - We are now into the second half of the season. During that time we have won one, drawn one in the League, and progressed into the 4th round of the FA Cup. Quite acceptable.

Opinion - Patrick #799, as someone who did witness the team of the late 60s, I believe our best football came during the 1968-69 season.

Alan McGuffog
80 Posted 12/01/2014 at 20:27:29
Patrick....

The football we played in 1968-69 was sublime. They were the golden days of the Holy Trinity.

1969-70 was wonderful obviously but I recall we dug in and ground out any number of "ugly" results... and of course the trio only actually played together for about 10 games due to injury, suspension etc. Step forward, Tommy Jackson... a precursor to Kevin Richardson and Alan Harper.

Calling all other aul arses out there: remember Colin Harvey's goal against Albion in 68-69? I can.... but why do the nurses keep calling me Alan... and they've taken me teeth y'know.

Ian Tunstead
81 Posted 12/01/2014 at 20:30:52
If it's within the rules of the game and its getting results and winning then it must be good football. If we finish above a team in the league then we must be a better team than the teams below us because that is the whole point isn't it? I don't care how the team plays as long as it get the results. It's the goals that get me off my seat not a great pass from Jags to Coleman.
Michael Kenrick
84 Posted 12/01/2014 at 20:57:25
I can't believe, Ian, that you are unable to distinguish good play from good results. The two can be quite separate, and I firmly believe most people who watch football can differentiate.

Can you really not grasp that good play does not always lead to scoring goals? Any goals, either good or bad?? That you can play really well, play really good football, but still lose???

And conversely, play badly but win. Does that whole concept not exist in your world?

You say "I don't care how the team plays" — There we have it; at least that would explain why you are having so much trouble grasping the concepts on this thread... but why would you even bother watching if it's all about the results? And most pertinent to this forum — why would you comment on it if you don't care?

James Tunstead
85 Posted 12/01/2014 at 20:59:22
Getting results whilst playing attacking and attractive football is the ideal scenario and this is what we are getting at the moment. I think our play in the final third can be improved up though.
David Finney
86 Posted 12/01/2014 at 20:40:11
Ian, you said, "But we also need to consider it is easier to play better football with better footballers." — Are you somehow saying Martinez has it easier because he has better players?

If so I don't understand your point as Martinez is the one who brought them in and made a profit whilst doing it.

Also, if you are right, and I see no reason to disagree with your statement, how do you explain the performances OFM has been producing with a squad that won the Premier League by 10 points? As for everyone else - WUM?

Tommy Meehan
87 Posted 12/01/2014 at 21:10:39
David, a number of months ago, Mr Tunstead (and I'm paraphrasing here) made a comment to another poster to the effect that since they were criticizing Moyes, he was going to criticize Martinez and see how they liked it. If you look at most of his criticisms of Martinez in that context, his skewed and obtuse 'logic' becomes comprehensible.
Paul Ferry
88 Posted 12/01/2014 at 21:10:29
Ian Tunstead/James Tunstead, this gets more farcical with each one of his/their/its/her posts!
James Tunstead
89 Posted 12/01/2014 at 21:18:05
What's farcical with what I posted, Paul Ferry? Do you think we are incredible in the final third, à la Barca or Bayern? Can our final ball/crossing not be improved upon?
Ian Tunstead
90 Posted 12/01/2014 at 21:22:42
Michael it like the whole argument who is better Pele or Maradona, Messi or Ronaldo, some people prefer players with great passing and vision some people prefer player with great skill and dribbling ability some people prefer players who are solid in the tackle who give their heart and soul. With regards watching a football team some like watching nice tippy tappy passing football, that's clearly you and many others on here, I respect that, but I also appreciate the role of a centre forward who wins the physical battles bullying defenders that's why I don't mind using the long ball approach every now and then (if it is effective) and from what I have seen of Lukaku he can do it very well. He is an excellent player who can be played in different ways but we are only seeing one side to his game.
Tommy Coleman
91 Posted 12/01/2014 at 21:17:17
Ian Tunstead, Phil Walling, Nick Entwistle ..... yawn!

Fellas who would rather talk shite than admit they were wrong.

No one has any respect for their opinions, obviously, and even if we were to win every trophy we ever entered they'd still defiantly see no sense.

It still makes for some amusing reading though as I've no sympathy for stubborn pig headed people who don't want to learn. Fundamentalists is the word.

The more they squirm, the the worse Man Utd are, the better Everton get. Keep it going.

Mike Corcoran
93 Posted 12/01/2014 at 22:07:06
"I don't care how the team plays as long as it get the results."

If I felt like that I'd have given up sex years ago.

Harold Matthews
94 Posted 12/01/2014 at 21:27:07
James T. Yes, we're not yet up to scratch in the final third but we're definitely much better than earlier in the season when play slowed to a walk on the flanks. We can't play the Barca or Bayern way because we don't have their players but our lads will be playing it the Martinez way. Take a man on one-to-one and go for goal. It's the way Wigan blew us away in the Cup. He loves quick dribblers because they open games up....a la Macmanaman against City in the final. He ripped them apart. What is Aiden McGeady? A quick dribbler.

These are Martinez's ideas, not mine. I'm just repeating his quotes. What he thinks about the lack of crosses I don't really know. He never mentions them, but the Mirallas one to Lukaku's head would have pleased him even though the big fella cocked it up.

Dennis Stevens
95 Posted 12/01/2014 at 22:31:37
If you're only interested in the result & not the performance, why bother? I've seen fantastic nil-nil draws & yet also witnessed dreadful high-scoring matches - the result isn't everything, to me anyway.

I suppose you only listen to music that hits the top of the charts, because that must obviously be the best. Why would anybody listen to stuff they just like even though it doesn't sell so well?

What nonsense!

Si Cooper
96 Posted 12/01/2014 at 22:41:39
Ian Tunstead - "I'm not sure I believe in luck."

Definition of luck - success or failure apparently brought by chance rather than through one's own actions.

Seems like a straightforward concept to me. A ball rebounding straight to a supporting player or a hoof up-field falling perfectly for a team-mate are perfectly reasonable examples to be found in football.

People not understanding that chance factors can be mitigated by tailored training or ability (always chasing in after shots, or being able to control a spinning ball descending from the heavens) is what is perplexing.

Ian Tunstead
97 Posted 12/01/2014 at 23:17:53
That's your opinion Dennis, we are all different, For myself I get a buzz when I see a good tackle put they are becoming less frequent with more strict officiating, and I get a bigger buzz when we score, but the biggest buzz I get is when the whistle goes and we have won. All this passing doesn't really do much for me, especially the fannying about at the back on occasions.

Si, there are lots of things in the dictionary that may or may not exist but I see what you are saying that's why I said I'm not really sure if I believe in luck, its debatable. I can understand if a referee makes a bad decision it might be considered unlucky or lucky for the opposing team because his decision is just his opinion and might differ to another referees opinion but its not necessarily fact. But for your examples im not sure I go along with.

"A ball rebounding straight to a supporting player" I could argue that it is not luck because the player has made a positive decision to get into the space. There are plenty of players that always seem to find themselves in the right place at the right time. I would argue it had nothing to do with luck and more to do with initiative.

David Ellis
99 Posted 13/01/2014 at 01:31:41
When I moved to London in the early 80s I lived in Upton Park and occasionally watched West Ham. I was stunned how the Hammer's fans celebrated goals scored by percentage play - stick it in the box, let it richochet about a bit and maybe it will fall nicely to one of our boys. And when it does, and he scores, he's a hero, a genius, and England player.

They don't know what football is. Nor it appears does Ian T.

Phil Walling
101 Posted 13/01/2014 at 11:08:55
Tommy Coleman @ 914. The arrogance of this post is breath taking! You seem to imply that anyone who didn't immediately see Martinez as the 'second coming', as you did, is in some way sub-normal.

True, I did not jump on the band wagon with the majority, preferring to see the new man 'earn his spurs' before pledging lifelong affection. But as I have said ever since the derby match, I have become delighted with the quality of our play and am certainly less nit-pickity than some of the posters above.

The irony of your remarks is that the very people who would, in consigning the Moyes era to the dustbin, hail Roberto as 'the greatest-ever', are the same ones who will turn on him at the first run of bad results he experiences.

How well we all remember the anointing of OFM immediately he coined 'The People's Club' appendage and how soon he has become the devil incarnate. Such is the fickleness of some Evertonians. Beware, Roberto!

Brian Waring
103 Posted 13/01/2014 at 18:17:50
Phil, I could appreciate the job OFM has done, the reason he has become, as you put it 'the devil incarnate' though, is because as soon as he left he started coming out with some nob end remarks.
Patrick Murphy
104 Posted 13/01/2014 at 18:35:36
Phil does have a point though - not so much with regards to our former boss,- but to the reaction of some supporters if things go awry for Roberto in some shape or form. I too was a little unsure as to how Roberto would get on at Goodison. Firstly, because Everton is a far different club to those he had managed previously and secondly due to his preferred style of play.

On both counts so far I think he has exceeded expectations and is a little unlucky in that the rivals for the CL spots are proving more durable than has been the case in most of the PL era.

But Roberto's handicap is the same handicap that our previous manager had and that is the lack of funds available to make significant additions to the squad and the realisation, whether we like it or not that we are indeed a selling club.

I hope that most Blues' appreciate that the only major thing that has altered - aside from the pleasing style and generally good football - is that the name of the manager is different, the state of the club is exactly the same as it has been for the last five years and no manager can alter that reality.

Dean Adams
105 Posted 13/01/2014 at 18:51:34
Can anyone point me in the directiom of the offensive remarks that OFM made. I have an annoying Manure fan as a son and he reckons TW made it all up( Iknow thats bull) and I want to slap it in his face about the record creating presbeterian dreary one.
Dominic Tonge
107 Posted 13/01/2014 at 19:36:14
I can try and explain the difference between a hoof, a long ball and a clearance in laymans' terms:

Hoof: When a player just lumps the ball forward in the vague direction of an attacker .... à la Jagielka in the Moyes era.

A long ball is a deliberate lobbed pass used to hit the front men quickly, normally bypassing the midfield..... anything we do over 5 yards, according to MotD, well captain scarlet anyway.

A clearance is when a defending player moves the ball with his first thought being to snuff out danger — if in doubt, put it out.

There is another more mythical option. The much fabled 'cultured 40-yard pass' basically though this is a) , b) or c) under certain circumstances. The circumstances are you have to be called Frank or Stevie or play for Man Utd, and happen to be being watched by a Sky Sports or MotD commentator.

Phil Bellis
108 Posted 14/01/2014 at 00:05:33
"...- aside from the pleasing style and generally good football.."
that'll do me for starters, Patrick

David Ellis
109 Posted 14/01/2014 at 07:57:00
Patrick 128 - Shankley changed that reality - different era though. The way the money works now though the fact that we can't get so much match day revenue becomes less and less of a factor. If we happened to get a long run in the CL and won a few pots then I think our reality would change quite rapidly. Not very likely but is it so far from what Cloughie did with Forest and Derby? The TV money is levelling the playing field for a club that crawls its way into the CL.
Phil Walling
110 Posted 14/01/2014 at 09:54:28
It seems to have been somewhat overlooked recently but we always have to judge any Everton manager in the light of the resources available to him.

Those who would see a failure to qualify for Europe as catastrophic MUST always take cognisance of the severe restraints on our budget as seen against the turnover of the Sky Six.

That's why we can only hope for a Martinez Miracle rather than expect one.


Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads