Pienaar scan reveals no injury but Alcaraz sidelined again

, 12 January, 53comments  |  Jump to most recent
Steven Pienaar received the all-clear from a scan at Finch Farm today, calming fears that he had picked up an injury during yesterday's win over Norwich.

The midfielder was withdrawn as a precaution after 70 minutes of the 2-0 victory with a suspected niggle but an assessment by club medical staff revealed no problems.

There was not such good news regarding Antolin Alcaraz who was apparently rested yesterday following the return from injury of Phil Jagielka.

The club captain missed two weeks with a hamstring strain but recovered more quickly than expected and partnered John Stones in front of Tim Howard, helping the Blues to another clean sheet.

Alcaraz deputised superbly in the games against Southampton, Stoke and QPR but was given a break as he eases back to regular action following an extended layoff after hernia surgery. Now he will apparently be missing for up to two weeks with 'muscle fatigue'.

Quotes or other material sourced from EvertonFC.com



Reader Comments (53)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Kevin Day
1 Posted 12/01/2014 at 19:59:19
Just hope we receive the same news about Barkley, and with Aiden now on board and the rumoured soon to return Deulofeu, we may just reach that 71-point mark that Martinez said should get us a Champions League spot, which is winning ten more games, which I feel with players coming back and hopefully new ones to arrive this surely is a very real scenario, right fellas?
Patrick Murphy
2 Posted 12/01/2014 at 20:04:37
That's good news on both fronts, we need as many fit lads as possible for the remaining part of the season and Pienaar in particular has a big role to play if Barks is unavailable for the next few weeks.
Matthew Williams
3 Posted 12/01/2014 at 20:04:45
It has to be a reasonable chance. I feel it's between us Liverpool and Man Utd. Obviously the derby is gonna be real tense; if they win it's gonna make it more difficult for us, we need to get a point from that at least, if we win then we will be favourites. I do hope we get another striker, though... if Lukaku gets injured, we are fooked
Colin Glassar
4 Posted 12/01/2014 at 20:07:03
Thank Christ for that. I don't think I could've coped with another injury. The Alcaraz rest seems a bit unnecessary but I suppose Bobby knows best.
Dennis Ng
5 Posted 12/01/2014 at 20:07:58
Awesome news re Pienaar!
Si Cooper
6 Posted 12/01/2014 at 20:13:23
Colin, I wondered about why Alcaraz didn't play yesterday and it did make sense to me that he might be rested having been out for so long with injury given that it gave the manager an opportunity to try out another central defensive pairing that he may have to rely on at some stage in the future.

I am sure the manager is of the type who will look at how they handled the opposition between them and not be shy about giving them a few pointers to improve that partnership.

Phil Sammon
7 Posted 12/01/2014 at 20:22:15
Great news. I think he's been brilliant recently. One of the most technically gifted players we have at the club and widely underrated.
Sam Hoare
8 Posted 12/01/2014 at 20:31:17
Good news. Our bench showed yesterday that we are down to pretty bare bones with some tougher games coming up.

I suspect we might see Jags and Alcaraz as our CB combo for the next few games.

Very much hope Barkley and Deulofeu might make the derby.

Al Reddish
9 Posted 12/01/2014 at 20:37:42
If McGeady can get his fitness up I would like to try him in Pienaar's place and put Pienaar behind Lukaku in Barkley's absence.
Karl Graham
10 Posted 12/01/2014 at 20:57:10
With Barkley injured we will need Pienaar to come more central so its great news. Hopefully with the West Brom match being Monday we might have Alcaraz, Distin and maybe even Deulofeu available to play some part.
Paul Smith
11 Posted 12/01/2014 at 21:01:12
Not trying to be a party popper, but the Twitterspere is alive with rumours that Antolin is out for 3 weeks with... wait for it - muscle fatigue.
Jim Bennings
12 Posted 12/01/2014 at 20:53:16
Great news about Pienaar and about time we had some on the injury front.
Thought there was a lot more purpose and vigour to Pienaar yesterday, it was almost like the Pienaar of old, and the one who played to impress during his loan spell in early 2012.

I like the idea too about moving Pienaar behind Lukaku and McGeady on the left, we could swap wings with McGeady and Mirallas from time to time as in my opinion, I always think you see the best of Mirallas when he is on the left flank as apposed to the right.

The reality is we possibly wont see McGeady start until February, sounds like Roberto wants to work him slowly into things and work on his match fitness, he has'nt plated since November has he?
Think he will beigin the first four of five games from the bench, nevertheless its just good to have him in now, gives us more selection choices.

On to Pienaar, I believe in Barkley's absence he could really prosper as a creative player behind Lukaku, I just wish sometimes we could get a few more goals from him, I think he has it in his locker to score near the 10 goal mark but it never seems to happen enough, so maybe just maybe a switch temporarily inside might see a better goal return.

Yesterday we lost the momentum when Pienaar and Osman went off for Naismith and Heitinga, thats the only thing I didnt quite agree with that Martinez did because for me I would have made Oviedo for Pienaar the straight swap but no worries, it was straightforward in the end anyway.

Simon Harris
13 Posted 12/01/2014 at 21:00:39
What Phil Sammon said. - Great news indeed.

We're a much better 'team' when the little wizard plays.

Paul Smith
14 Posted 12/01/2014 at 21:04:33
Belay my last - it's out for two weeks after 3 quick games in succession.
Mark Taylor
15 Posted 12/01/2014 at 21:10:29
To the poster who thinks Delboy is almost back, sadly I think it could be another month. Not sure where you heard otherwise.

Good news on Pienaar. We're getting down to bare bones (i.e Gueye and Vellios) right now. I'd be happier still if Barkley was as minor but that sounds like the best part of a month.

I find it almost incomprehensible that Alcaraz had no injury and was rested. Surely he needed to be on the bench, he's hardly overplayed recently. I think a more precise explanation is that he wasn't fit because he's been feeling it physically, after playing several games following a very long lay off.

Harold Matthews
16 Posted 12/01/2014 at 20:45:31
Huge sigh of relief but Barkley is the big one. We can shuffle all we like but we won't get near replacing him. He's the one who rips teams apart and puts them in a spin. The big teams especially.

Nevertheless, without him and no further injuries, we're still a pretty good outfit and will probably be even stronger by the end of the window. As Sam pointed out, apart from Oviedo, our bench was down to the bare bones and useful reinforcements will be most welcome.

Trevor Lynes
17 Posted 12/01/2014 at 21:18:33
Muscle fatigue often follows an injury like Alcaraz had so he will need patient handling to ensure he fully recovers. He obviously has class and a great acquisition. I just hope Deulofeu will be meeting up with the squad in Teneriffe as he is essential over the remaining matches this season. McGeadie should be fit by the time he comes back from teneriffe and may well make the bench for the West Brom match with a bit of luck. I just hope that a couple more players join us as is rumoured during this window.

Pienaar is a great lttle player and always gives 100%. He must be one of the most fouled players in the league as he always takes players on. The much maligned Osman is also a fine player and can bring the likes of Barkley on a lot in the same way that Barry can help McCarthy.

Rob Dixon
18 Posted 12/01/2014 at 21:42:44
I believe that in respect of Alcaraz, if a player has had a long lay off, then plays a few games, then it is common that they can pick up 'niggles', muscle fatigue etc. They tend to get through the games on adrenalin and Alcaraz I recall was straight into 3 full games!! Maybe it was precautionary only.

In respect of McGeady, he's missed the best part of 7 weeks and I think it shows a bit!! RM will ease him in slowly, I believe, but we may just need him from the bench. He's got to be a better option than Gueye??

Kevin Day
21 Posted 12/01/2014 at 22:00:51
Mark Taylor- it's just rumours that I've seen on threads on Facebook that Deulofeu is near to returning, and the YouTube video that was posted of him training in Spain, and I've seen a few posts on TW saying the same. But I guess no one really knows until we hear from the clubs themselves.
Colin Glassar
22 Posted 12/01/2014 at 22:40:32
I knew there had to be more to the absence of Alcaraz. When is Distin back? Hopefully in time for the WBA game.
Noel Early
23 Posted 13/01/2014 at 00:09:35
Barkley out for 3 to 6 weeks, massive loss and couldn't really have happened at a worse time. He ran the show in the last derby and would have fancied him to do so again. Barcelona will not take any chances with Deulofeu so it looks like Ossie will be playing in the hole for the near future.
James Stewart
24 Posted 13/01/2014 at 00:27:56
Desperately need some players back for the Derby. Will be a tough ask to win without Barkley or Gerard.
Rahman Talib
25 Posted 13/01/2014 at 01:41:28
Here's my take; Pienaar will take Barkley's place while he's injured.

Oviedo will take Pienaar's place in left midfield.

We play Osman as a super sub.

David Ellis
26 Posted 13/01/2014 at 02:03:09
Great news. With Barkley and Deulofeu both still out we can't afford to lose another of our attacking midfielders - we only have 3 servicable one left in Pienaar, Mirallas and Osman. Hopefully McGeady will add to this arsenal - can't see him starting for a month but we need him on the bench for WBA.

Apropo nothing in particular I thought Baines had a blinder on Saturday.

Rob Baker
28 Posted 13/01/2014 at 08:46:17
I agree with Rob Dixon #917, as I am wondering why Gueye is still in the sqaud tbh. I'd be happy for McGeady to warm that bench for the next couple of weeks, get some fitness under his belt and have 30 mins each game to terrorise that full back with his pace. Gutted @ Barkley broken toe. Two broken toes from key players. Hope Alcaraz gets fit again soon as he seems class!
Jimmy Sørheim
29 Posted 13/01/2014 at 08:31:09
I think it would be smart to put McGeady on the bench, but he desperately needs the game time given he has not played in over a month. He has been training himself though and I think it is imperative to get him ready for the Liverpool game given Delboy and Barkley will be out. I think he should play 30-40 minutes in the next game and then start the game after that.

RM will have to give him extra attention in the Tenerife training trip and assess if he could start our next game. Currently I think Mirallas is the one who should drop to the bench, but it depends on what kind of form McGeady is in too. So far this season, Mirallas has been far from what we know he can be. Lukaku is starting to suffer not scoring in 7 consecutive league games.

Given Jelavic will be sold, and that he probably would have played against Norwich, it is vital we get a striker before the next game, I am beginning to understand more of Mourinho and his reason for loaning Lukaku out; I think he needs to be a regular scorer which it seems he is not.

Last season he seemed to do much better coming off the bench and I wonder if his fitness can take playing 90 minutes each and every league game. He seems passive in front of goal in his movement, always hesitating and moving too late to reach the ball.

I think either his fitness is not good enough or he is in a tough spot mentally, which is hard to tell from the outside, but there should be no doubt that we are in trouble once our top scorer is not scoring anymore. I think a new striker is a must before the next game if we are to reach CL next season.

Brin Williams
31 Posted 13/01/2014 at 09:50:28
No wonder they have broken toes with these flimsy boots!!
Jim Bennings
32 Posted 13/01/2014 at 10:03:21
We need to forget about Barkley and Deulofeu for the near future, its obvious with regards to Barkley, Martinez is trying to soften the blow by saying "We expect Ross to be out for some time, but until we get a scan we won't know exactly". That to me tells me it's more likely going to be a 6 weeker.

As for Deulofeu, well he is making his way back to fitness, but as with any hamstring injury, the muscle cannot be rushed too soon and I remember Mirallas last season, we rushed him back from hamstring problems and it didn't help him at all.

I agree that, when Pienaar plays well, it seems to drag the rest of the team out of their slumber; I always resemble Pienaar to a busy bee in a bottle, and when he starts to get busy we play well better. Over the last 12 months, he seemed to lose purpose and started playing the game in a comfort zone slightly but thankfully Saturday was more like what we know; if he carries on that form the rest of the season, we will be smiling.

Does anybody else think that performance on Saturday could also have something to do with a certain McGeady coming in? Knowing he plays on the left? Hmm... I just wonder what the powers of having a bit of competition can do for a player.

Ray Roche
33 Posted 13/01/2014 at 10:17:19
Brin, I was in one of the Sports Direct or JJB type shops a couple of weeks ago and, just out of curiosity, I picked up a couple of pairs of these ghastly luminous boots. I couldn't believe how lightweight and, as you say, flimsy they are. It is no wonder that there are an increasing number of foot injuries in todays game. We counted something like 12 pairs of hideous, bright orange boots on display on Saturday, the same as Barkley was wearing against QPR when he was injured. No doubt the players are being paid to wear them but, come on! They're awful and clearly provide insufficient protection.
Steve Brown
35 Posted 13/01/2014 at 11:35:30
As a previous poster said, Alcaraz is made of glass - "muscle fatigue"! I know Pat van den Hauwe suffered from many things but I bet that wasn't one of them. Why do we persist in signing injury-plagued players and expecting them to be fit. If Kone and Alcaraz ever play 5 consecutive games for us, I'll eat my hat.
Tony McNulty
36 Posted 13/01/2014 at 11:44:45
Don't think my old PE teacher would have been impressed by muscle fatigue. Presumably it is what you get after using your muscles?

I could however imagine that some ex-RS players might be suffering from brain fatigue. Anyone heard Carragher recently?

Tony J Williams
37 Posted 13/01/2014 at 12:10:32
I can see McGeady getting his first start against Stevenage, I imagine there will be a few changes in the side for that Cup match, a few days before the derby.
Rahman Talib
38 Posted 13/01/2014 at 13:09:53
It's these long injury lists that made me thankful that we once had the likes of Amokachi on our bench all the time.
Tom Bowers
39 Posted 13/01/2014 at 13:39:58
With the injuries now flaring up it would seem that any aspirations of finishing higher than fourth are disappearing.

The great attacking flair displayed by Delboy and Barkley has been missing although Mirallas has bounced back.

Still, it will be nip and tuck between the Blues, Redshite, Manure and Spurs over the next few weeks to see who can forge ahead in fourth although it may go right down to the wire.

We have to win the six pointer against Redshite for sure and it's likely several key players will be rested for the Stevenage game as Redshite will surely do for their cup-tie.

The top 3 seem assured of staying there simply because they have the strength in depth to get them through injury phases.

Here's hoping McGeady is a very timely signing.

Kevin Tully
40 Posted 13/01/2014 at 13:38:01
We are averaging 1.95 points per game after 21 played. If we can keep that up, we are on course to finish on 74 points – and hopefully CL qualification.

The matches against our rivals will seal our fate; this years derby will be crucial. It may well decide that 4th spot at the end of the season.

I cannot see Man City or Chelsea slipping up now, but we are only 6 points off the top of the League. Everyone who is asked for their opinion thinks we will slowly fade away, but I don't see us becoming a weaker side. If we can get McGeady fit & firing, as well as adding a striker who can bag 8-10 goals there are no excuses.

It's all to play for as 9 wins, 6 draws and two more losses would see us over the line with 74 points.

Simon Hermansen
41 Posted 13/01/2014 at 13:41:06
Where's an international break when you need one!

The feel good factor and confidence around the club will make players believe any 11 can get a result but, in reality, we will need our game changers to be fit for the big matches coming up from the Derby onwards and that means Barkley and Deulofeu

Just hope our season and dream of Euro football isn't scuppered by injuries and lack of strength in depth. Even if we can sign players in this window, other than McCready, we're unlikely to have the budget and pulling power to get those players that will give us the edge we need in those big games

Concerned but (with RM at the healm) positive ...

Simon Hermansen
42 Posted 13/01/2014 at 14:26:59
Tony 019, yes ... Carra is (barely) living proof that being ex RS is all you need on your CV if you fancy a bit of pundit work after you've hung your boots up at that shit hole across the park
Drew O'Neall
43 Posted 13/01/2014 at 14:24:01
Depending which toe it is I expect to see Barkley available for the derby.

I broke my little toe and aside from the pain it doesn't really have any function so could be mitigated with a HC injection.

Brin Williams
44 Posted 13/01/2014 at 15:04:45
Just seen a comment somewhere that Martinez has warned off Manure on Coleman and put a £25M price tag on him.

What the fuck is that all about - he must be worth £35M as a minimum - bloody hell at £25M they'll all be queuing up for the poor bugger.

Brin Williams
45 Posted 13/01/2014 at 15:09:03
On this topic of toes - I had one amputated and I was back in action in six weeks - kicking the cat again - should never have done it the first time tho!
Tom Bowers
46 Posted 13/01/2014 at 18:28:38
I suspect the cat doesn't get kicked very often these days?
Ray Roche
47 Posted 13/01/2014 at 18:34:03
Brin, the £25m crap was in the Daily Star, or Billy's Weekly Liar, as it's known.
John Zapa
49 Posted 13/01/2014 at 17:53:41
Alcaraz is turning out to be the most expensive 'free' signing the club has ever made. His rumoured 30k/week wages comes to approximately 1.5m per year. If he plays his usually 10-15 games a season then he will end up costing 100-150k PER GAME. Not sure signing him was such a good idea...
Jonny Flynn
50 Posted 13/01/2014 at 18:50:42
Are you for real, John? Okay, Alcaraz hasn’t played many games so far but the chap is a class act on the comeback trail. He’ll be vital to us this year.

At least wait till the season is over before you start the negativity. I’m sure those words will come back to bite you. He’ll be another shrewd Roberto signing!!

Harold Matthews
51 Posted 13/01/2014 at 23:07:57
Yes John. It's all a gamble. During the last 12 months, Jelavic, Heitinga, Gibson, Vellios, Hibbo, Gueye and others have been paid a tidy wedge for not doing much. It's the way it goes.
Harold Matthews
52 Posted 14/01/2014 at 06:46:06
Jonny. With you on Alcaraz. Great positioning and so comfortable on the ball.
David Ellis
53 Posted 14/01/2014 at 08:15:20
John Zapa - no signings are free - the wages are big. Neither Alcaraz or Kone is injury prone. They just happened to be injured now (and Alcaraz also missed last season). But neither has a history of constant injuries unlike, for example Rodwell, or (going back a bit) Tony Grant or Jonathan Woodgate (or possibly Gibson).

In any event if you want a decent strong squad you must have high earners not playing many games. Its just the way it is.

John Zapa
54 Posted 14/01/2014 at 09:23:49
Harold,Jonny,
The point isn't about whether he is a decent footballer or not, it's about if he is worth the very high cost that the club will end up paying for what will amount to a handful of games over his 2 year contract.

David,
He has missed a lot of games for Wigan in his 2 seasons prior to joining. He played in less than 50% of the games during that time. This is his 3rd injury prone season in a row. Not sure how much more he has to do to be considered as injury prone.

David Ellis
55 Posted 14/01/2014 at 10:04:06
John - he's had 4 significant injuries in his career. One this season, one last season, one for 6 weeks in the 2011/12 season and one for 3 months in 07/08.
In that time he has played 38 matches in 08/09; 40 matches in 09/10; 38 matches in 10/11; 25 matches in 11/12; 14 matches last season.
So yes he has had 3 injury disrupted seasons in a row. But in one of these he played 25 matches and the other 14 matches. This season he was injured until November but since then was kept out of the side by Jags and Distin.

As to whether this is considered injury prone or not depends on what the test is for applying that label. I can understand why you would call it injury prone, but to me it would need more constant niggles and a lower participation rate overall. He had 3 consecutive seasons at 38 appearances or more.

Steven Telford
56 Posted 14/01/2014 at 10:32:11
Pretty clear that we need to be in the market for another centre back.
Harold Matthews
57 Posted 14/01/2014 at 13:30:22
Yes John. Your point is very interesting but I've watched this lad in training with Paraguay and he'll bring a lot more to the club than appearances on the pitch. His fantastic technical ability, witnessed in a pre-christmas Everton video, is bound to rub off onto Jags and the rest of the squad. Martinez wanted his experience, ability and influence, especially with the new football philosophy, and we haven't made a bad start.
Chris Stubbs
58 Posted 15/01/2014 at 10:11:15
Whenever I read about footballers recovering from hernia operations, I cringe. Having had a double hernia 20 years ago and another one on Christmas Eve, I know how difficult the recovery can be. It seems that many people think that a hernia repair is just another routine operation. The one I had on Christmas Eve was a strangulated hernia which required an emergency operation. I am a lot older than Alcaraz, but I have kept myself very fit. My rate of recovery may be slower than his, but I know what damage can occur if recovery is rushed. I tried to rush back to normal routines 20 years ago and suffered a set back then.

Can I suggest that we cut Alcaraz some slack? One thing about hernia repairs is that a repair actually strengthens abdominal muscles. I had a 20 year gap between hernia repairs. If Alcaraz has another one 20 years from now I don't think we would be posting comments on this website about him being injury prone.

Anthony Jones
59 Posted 16/01/2014 at 10:36:38
Regarding Alcaraz: Hernia operations almost inevitably cause some nerve damage and throw core muslces out of sync. Relapse is not uncommon. The player should be applauded for playing 3 full games in succession. This made of glass bullshit is out of order.

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads

© ToffeeWeb