Sin-bins could be introduced in football

, 13 January, 44comments  |  Jump to most recent
From a report in the Daily Mail:
Sin-bins will be considered by two new panels which are being set up to advise on law changes in football.

The sin-bin system is being trialled in the Dutch amateur leagues this season and both FIFA president Sepp Blatter and UEFA president Michel Platini have suggested time penalties for players should be looked at.

It is expected sin-bins will be considered when the new advisory panels to the International Football Association Board (IFAB) are set up in March.

» Read the full article at Daily Mail



Reader Comments (44)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Harold Matthews
1 Posted 13/01/2014 at 19:59:00
I'd like a sick bin. Anyone who appears seriously hurt spends 10 minutes in the bin or is substituted.
Harold Matthews
2 Posted 13/01/2014 at 19:59:00
I'd like a sick bin. Anyone who appears seriously hurt spends 10 minutes in the bin or is substituted.
Pat Finegan
3 Posted 13/01/2014 at 20:56:40
Harold Matthews loves the idea of sick sick bin so much that the mere thought of it causes him to uncontrolably click the submit comment button. I agree, Harold, perhaps to a lesser extent. If you're hurt enough that you roll on the ground and scream you should either be subbed or be punished for being a wuss.
Colin Glassar
5 Posted 13/01/2014 at 21:08:00
Sin bins? What next? Chains to measure distance of walls from free kick takers? Time outs? Designated penalty takers? Sounds too much like soccer to me.
Darryl Ritchie
6 Posted 13/01/2014 at 21:24:04
Sin bins. Penalty boxes. Why? What's to be gained. The system in play now works well. Don't give the refs more power to influence the outcome of matches than they already have.
Mick Davies
7 Posted 14/01/2014 at 00:21:45
After 100 years of British football, the PL plc came along and turned it into a panto. What next, ref's on electric scooters, head cams for goalies, triangular footballs, orange grass? It's all getting too effin daft. If it's not broke. . .
Ian Tunstead
8 Posted 14/01/2014 at 01:04:17
We invented the game, they should ask us for permission if they want to suggest any changes. I doubt anything like this would be allowed to happen anyway but, if it did, what's to say they couldn't bring in other ridiculous changes?
Chris James
9 Posted 14/01/2014 at 07:53:34
Sin bins would be a brilliant idea and could cut back on some of the currently less punished sins such as referee pressuring and play acting straight away.
I'm personally fed up of petulent players surrounding the ref at every opportunity and if we could get a bit more of the professionalism shown in Rugby (where it's just the captain who can talk to officials) then all the better.
David Ellis
10 Posted 14/01/2014 at 08:23:48
Chris James - I'm with you on this. Those who say "if it ain't broke" well, it kind of is broke. I don't have people surrounding me and swearing at me in my day job. Swearing at refs is not OK. In the rule book its a yellow card, I think they should enforce it, it wouldn't take long before behaviour changed.

But the sin bin works better because it punishes the team there and then, whereas a yellow card has a less immediate effect.

Mark Stone
11 Posted 14/01/2014 at 08:28:45
David #314 re: players surrounding, and swearing at, the ref

Whats your thoughts on a challenge system, like in tennis, cricket etc. If players disagree with a decision, play to the whistle and then challenge at the next break in play. If the players are wrong, they lose their challenge. If they are right, they keep it and play goes back to point of the challenge. Would definitely put an end to the crowding round the ref and appealing for everything. Also if they have wasted their challenge and then concede an offside goal or similar, its as much their own fault as it is the refs!

Tommy Gourlay
12 Posted 14/01/2014 at 10:31:43
"if it ain't broke" - new 'rules' (directives) are brought in often which could potentially break the game regularly. When they get more stringent on certain things (e.g. tackle from behind) the result of this new stringency is more yellow cards. This is because players don't change the way they play accordingly, but who gets the blame for the extra yellows? (until they are forced to just ignore the new rules) Referees.

With the increasing pressure on refs, we need to give them more TOOLS (not power) to punish teams, while at the same time diminishing the likelyhood of them getting death threats for the 'game changing' decisions. By giving them more tools it allows them to punish teams while effecting the outcome less, and less pressured refs are more likely to make 'less influenced' decisions.

Also, defensive players kick creative ones and are happy to take a yellow if it means it discourages and puts the creative player off their game, this creates the despicable football we hate to watch. If they knew they'd face 5 minutes off the park every time they tried to be so cynical, they'd think twice about it.

Karl Graham
13 Posted 14/01/2014 at 11:01:59
I'm not keen on idea but if it was for diving and dissent I could kind of see the benefit as they are 2 of my pet hates. However with the minimum of 7 players per team having to be on field what would happen if 5 players surrounded the ref you would have the farce of a forfeit game!
Albert Crocker
14 Posted 14/01/2014 at 11:06:49
As someone who was at Wembley when we lost an FA Cup final against ten men would it be OK if I had some reservations about this idea?
Brian Harrison
15 Posted 14/01/2014 at 11:11:50
Well if Blatter and Platini are for it then I am definitely against it. These pair of clowns decided it was a good idea to have extra refs behind the goal in European games, yet didnt want cameras to decide if the ball had crossed the line. So I take it that the sin bin would replace the yellow card, so obviously cant be sent off for 2 yellow card offences.

So I presume it is either a straight red or a sin bin, now I wonder how many refs will use the sin bin instead of the red card. Yet another decision that refs have to make, I can only see it causing more controversy.

Roger Helm
16 Posted 14/01/2014 at 12:21:19
Using foul and abusive language is against the law. If refs had microphones, someone (not necessarily the ref) could make a complaint to the police under Section 25 of the Public Order Act. A few convictions would stop the problem.
Dennis Ng
17 Posted 14/01/2014 at 17:49:38
I like Harold's sick bin better. I'm torn between 5 to 15 minutes. This should cut down on diving imo.

Sin bins are pointless imo. I watched replays of the tackle on Nasri, most cynical and worthy of a red regardless of my dislike for him. Do we want such a player back in the game to break another leg?

Besides, if we dump a GK into the bin, do we sub him? Aren't we forced to have to be without a GK for the duration of the sin bin? Or waste 2 subs? Platini is starting to disappoint me...A LOT!

Mick Davies
18 Posted 14/01/2014 at 22:42:17
What happened to free kicks being moved 10 yards for dissent? The idiots running our game haven't got a clue, and won't be satisfied until they've destroyed our national sport.
Brian Wilkinson
19 Posted 14/01/2014 at 22:44:24
Interesting point for a sick bin which leads me to an annoying feature.

If a goalkeeper is injured he is not ordered off the field. Why is it then that a player fouled and injured, who is treated on the field is then penalised and leaves the field?

If the player is the regular free kick or penalty taker, he cannot then get up after treatment and has to leave the field of play.

I understand with the goalkeeper but there's nothing more annoying than making a player go off then back on a few seconds later.

Steve Carse
20 Posted 15/01/2014 at 01:17:49
One of the worst suggestions ever. We should be reducing the potential for lousy reffing decisions to determine outcomes, not increasing it. Who wants to see even more instances, albeit for limited periods, of fewer than 22 players on the park? Football should be 11 on 11 for all bar the worst offences. Apart from creating a new angle for spot betting the only thing to be said in favour of the idea is that it is preferable to booking in that it immediately benefits the side transgressed.

If you want to regularly end up watching 9 against 10, see more and more matches determined by woeful refereeing, see more and more play acting and cheating on the pitch and -- perhaps the main negative -- witness periods of eventless, time-wasting as teams try to run down the clock before the sin-binned player returns to the field, then the sin bin is the thing for you.

Si Cooper
21 Posted 15/01/2014 at 02:00:51
You couldn't use a sin-bin for offences which could be punished with a yellow but are often allowed to slide, such as hounding the referee, as that would be overkill. The ideal punishment for players harassing / abusing the referee would be the award / reversal of a free-kick or an extra ten yards nearer the oppositions goal but that idea was trialled and never got anywhere.

How would the sin-bin be used? As an alternative / instead of a yellow (or a red), as an extra step between the two, or for specific offenses only?

I was for the extra ten yard punishment as it quickly snuffs out dissent (the captain is allowed to speak to the referee) but if something as simple as that didn't work, I can't see the benefit of something that will only add to the potential for game changing inconsistencies.

Derek Thomas
22 Posted 15/01/2014 at 07:24:50
Sin bins, OK in theory, but the 'cure' will turn out to be worse than the sickness.

All that is needed is for FIFA to 'advise' the reffs to yellow card for ungentlemanly conduct ( or have they got rid of that as well ) everybody who dives, gives dissent, takes part in the WWF antics at corners.

Like a lot of things in the none football world, effective enforcement of the laws that are there coupled with punishment that is more than a slap on the wrist.

Oo-er missus a bit of politics, my names Derek Thomas, Goodnight.

Steve Murphy
23 Posted 15/01/2014 at 07:21:15
Not too sure about a sin-bin. What I would like to see is, any player who is shown a straight red card for a particularly nasty/malicious tackle (a la the one on Nasri at the weekend), suspended until the player he fouled is fit enough to return. If you put a player out for the rest of the season then YOU don't play again that season! Simples.
Obviously a players whole career (Keane on Haaland) cannot be decided by one referee's decision, there would be an appeals panel who would consider the challenge from every angle.
Why should the fouled player not be able to play football for, say, six months, when the coward who tore his ligaments is back 3 games later?
Chad Schofield
24 Posted 15/01/2014 at 07:18:52
Isn't this the whole point of trailing the idea. I thought the rules were red card for foul & abusive language at ref... which is why it's not used. Yc for ungentalmanly conduct is used in place - at least That's what was mentioned after twattenberg's Southampton "you've changed" row.

The problem is implementing as a separate punishment because youre tgen opening up interpretation as to whether an offence should have been yellow, sin or red. If a yellow card has a bigger impact (as it does at amatuer level where the player is fined), by having a "sin bin" then we might see less cynical play... something a lot of people complain about.

As others say, rules adapt all the time. Would people perfer the old pass back rule? What about substitutes... should football just be two villages marauding through an unmarked pitch kicking lumps out of eachother? The "we invented football" argument is like crediting Alexander Graham Bell with inventing the internet. I also think that while the game is a matter of opinions on one hand, the rules should be clear, but referees should be allowed room to interpret and then be held to account afterwards. The big problem is this is currently done behind closed doors without explanation.

Swearing at and surrounding referees has to be clamped down on as it sets a precedent which is copied.

David Ellis
25 Posted 15/01/2014 at 09:08:14
Steve Murphy 704 - I think that "eye for an eye" approach would lead to wild injustices which is why it is not used in progressive society at any level.

Sometimes legal tackles lead to leg breaks. You can't link the punishment entirely to the effect - its more about the intent and recklessness of the tackle rather than the actual outcome. The actual outcome depends on all sorts of other factsor not relevant to the culpability of the offender. What if the other player has an egg shell skull or weak knees (or whatever).

In rugby the sin bin has worked well and made the game safer and easier to manage. In rugby though losing a man is a greater punishment than in football, probably why sending offs are so rare - its basically game over if it happens early on.

In rugby a bit of punching of opponents is tolerated - but swearing at the ref definitely not. Seems the right way round to me!

Brian Waring
26 Posted 15/01/2014 at 12:14:43
Hmmmmm, one of the so called top clubs is getting beat at home by one of the lesser clubs, the establishment aren't happy about it and want something done to help that so called top club, cue ref and sin bin for lesser team players.
Tony J Williams
27 Posted 15/01/2014 at 17:22:55
Fucking stupid idea.....there! it's so bad it's making me swear again on here.
Darryl Ritchie
28 Posted 15/01/2014 at 18:22:37
What if there was a third card? A yellow with a red stripe. This card would be exclusively used for dissent, and would be shown to the manager not the whiner. Second offence, red, and the captain goes off. The captain because he didn't do his job, and keep his squad in line.

A third card because everybody that sees it will know what it's for.

Garry Corgan
29 Posted 15/01/2014 at 23:42:26
I'm neither for nor against this particular idea but I do recognise that the laws of the game are always evolving and it's always worth investigating sensible suggestions.

In the not-too-distant past we've had:
- Goal line technology introduced
- Passback rule
- Goalkeepers '6 second rule'
- Keepers allowed to move along their line during penalties.
- Receiving a direct, rather than indirect, free kick for obstruction.

Did you even realise these rules had changed?

That's in addition to the minor amendments to punishments, such as red cards for tackling from behind, offside rule changes, etc.

Rule changes are often trialled in a league or tournament before being introduced. Anybody remember the 'time outs' during the 1995 Women's World Cup? And the days of Golden and Silver Goal Extra Time?

The sin bin will probably never see the light of day but, as I've said, the laws of our game have never been static and I accept they'll evolve just as formations, skills, techniques, pitches, balls, and just about everything else have.

Steve Barr
30 Posted 16/01/2014 at 00:19:06
Just keep moving the free kick 10 yards forward until they get the message. The rule should apply to divers, moaners, fakers etc...

Brent Stephens
31 Posted 16/01/2014 at 11:09:49
Steve, I'm absolutely at one with you on that. Look how it works in rugby. Why oh why did we not extend the trial run?
Drew Hepburn
32 Posted 16/01/2014 at 11:27:46
To say rules should not change is narrow minded. Who remembers the days before the pass back rule? Before the offside rule? Before we had substitutes? One point for a win?

If they are looking at introducing the sin bin idea to deter behavior then they are wasting their time. People rarely consider punishment before committing an offense. Its why capital punishment does not work as a deterrent. Fast paced sports are emotional and reactive, its not a game like chess or poker where each move is carefully considered.

If they feel its a more appropriate punishment for minor offenses then I think they have lost the plot. Do they even know what is actually a worse punishment, a yellow card or being sin binned for 10 minutes?

Tony J Williams
33 Posted 16/01/2014 at 12:06:25
Probably because it's shite Brent and sometimes it can be more of a hindrance to teams. Free kick about 20/25 yards out, perfect for a free kick specialist....moan...moan....moan, moved forward ten yards into the box and everyone is on the line or it is too close to get the ball up and over the wall and on target.

It was a shite punishment and rightly gotten rid of.

Si Cooper
34 Posted 16/01/2014 at 12:21:14
TJW in the situation you have described where it is a problem for the attacking team it just needs some refinement.

How about, when the original offence is within 25 yards of the opposition goal line the attackers can place the ball anywhere within ten yards of the original offence (including not moving it at all) but the wall has to retreat 5 yards further. That should make it a better opportunity for the attacking team and so provide the incentive for the penalised team to keep their mouths shut.

Sometimes things can be adapted rather than just dismissed and the general punishment could have been enough to prevent players surrounding and verbally assaulting the officials.

Tony Cheek
35 Posted 16/01/2014 at 14:47:38
I would welcome it! Anything rather than see a game where 11 play against 10! Amazing that we can fill stadiums with 40-60 thousand people paying for expensive seats, and ruin the spectacle by reducing a team to 10 men.

Sin bins are a step in the right direction, but I still think that an ORANGE card should be introduced. A player that receives two yellow cards gets an automatic orange card is sent off but can be replaced by a substitute. Sending offs piss me off and always will, even when OUR opponents get a man dismissed.

Ross Edwards
36 Posted 16/01/2014 at 19:13:46
I've thought of something to stop diving.

For instance, let's imagine that a player dives to win a penalty, rather than giving him a yellow card, give the OPPOSITION side the penalty instead as punishment.

In that way, players would learn to stop diving to try to win free kicks and pens because they would be conceding them rather than being given then.

Robert Workman
37 Posted 17/01/2014 at 10:21:35
I support the concept of the Sin Bin for one simple reason - it would mean that a yellow card offence could be punished during the actual game in which the offence is committed. As an example the deliberate, so called professional foul, committed by Luiz of Chelsea against an Everton player near the halfway line - not deemed worthy of a straight red because of the distance to goal.

I do agree, however, that it would give the referee yet more discretion as to when to use the Sin Bin and when to just give a yellow. My criteria would be the effect on the game itself. So kicking the ball away, showing dissent etc would still be just a yellow - but fouls like the above example would mean a ban during the game.

I must admit that a very good point was made earlier in the case of goalkeepers. There would have to be a special amendment in their case.

PS. I was delighted by the introduction of the Golden Goal (remember a euro Final being decided that way - what a dramatic conclusion!). Anyone know why was it dropped?

Shane Corcoran
39 Posted 17/01/2014 at 11:08:22
Tony Cheek, a similar rule to your Orange Card has been brought in in GAA this very month. There are a number of categories of foul that warrant a Black Card, but generally speaking it's for any foul in which the ref deems that the player made no attempt to play the ball.

To transfer that to soccer, a late challenge where the ball was missed by a split second is sill a yellow card but stopping a counter-attack by dragging a player back would meant that you leave the field and are replaced by a substitute. If a team get's a fourth black card then the player is not replaced.

The idea is to allow players to still make tough tackles but to take away the cynical play.

It's early days but I look on keenly.

I wouldn't trust FIFA to pick the correct approach but I don't see why people on here are against a rule such as the sin bin. Players are selfish and will behave themselves if they think they'll have to sit out some of the game.

It sounds to me that some people don't like a game changing towards another sport for whatever reason.

Tony Cheek
40 Posted 17/01/2014 at 19:11:42
That sounds like it would be a great improvement Shane (whats GAA?). Would also love to see an end to the "double punishment rule" ,conceding a penalty and having a man sent off, which is just bollocks IMO!
Chad Schofield
41 Posted 18/01/2014 at 00:14:57
Playing Devil's advocate, if the Sin bincard were a case of sub comes on, would playersnot deliberately get these if they were about to come off? Fifth uellow cards are routinely picked up if the one match ban is against weaker opposition, so never understate using rules in favour.
Patrick Murphy
42 Posted 18/01/2014 at 00:41:40
I'm not sure if a sin-bin would work in practice, silly bookings are already handed out and obvious red-card offences are often given just a yellow, whilst some obvious yellow-cards are not issued. it could lead to an almighty bust-up when a key player is benched albeit temporarily. I would think that maybe 3 yellow cards are worthy of a dismissal or perhaps a 3 card system so that the referee has room for maneuver, but as always no system is perfect. I would however like the FA or FIFA to allow an appeal for yellow cards as well as reds' which may help to ensure that the referees are more circumspect in their decision making.
Si Cooper
43 Posted 18/01/2014 at 12:48:41
Tony Cheek (518), the double punishment is merited in some situations, such as a deliberate handball on the line or an obviously cynical foul to deny a goal-scoring opportunity, which may be especially significant in the later stages of a game.
Shane Corcoran
44 Posted 18/01/2014 at 14:51:08
Tony Cheek, google GAA if you have. I assume you're from the UK and if so I'm amazed you don't know what it stands for.
Tony Cheek
45 Posted 18/01/2014 at 17:18:06
Googled and got!.....from UK, but moved here 33 years ago, so out of touch, you could say!
Tony Cheek
46 Posted 19/01/2014 at 16:08:22
Here being Norway!

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads

© ToffeeWeb