Kenwright salutes community efforts

, 15 January, 99comments  |  Jump to most recent

In a statement this week, Bill Kenwright has gone public with his praise for a number of Everton's recent community and fan outreach initiatives, off-field aspects that he says make the club special.

The Chairman has been relatively quiet since introducing Roberto Martinez as Everton's new manager last summer, preferring to let events on the field this season do much of the Board's talking this season.

He was moved to pen a statement for evertonfc.com, though, by the club's Junior Day festivities at the Norwich City home game last weekend, the latest in a string of fan-focused efforts by the club's communications and marketing departments in conjunction with it's official charity, Everton in the Community.

"Like all of you, I find it difficult at times to adequately sum up my devotion to our Football Club," his statement reads. "But a few recent events have reiterated to me just where this love affair comes from… And that's quite aside from the wonderful football we have been blessed with this season!"

Complete with an obligatory reference to Dave Hickson and the Boys Pen, the Chairman's message also describes his joy at last Saturday's focus on the club's young supporters — "Our history, my history; soon to be handed over to the young Evertonians who will take our Club forward" — the Missing People Campaign and "Blue Chrimbo" efforts.

"We are a great Football Club. The best. But we are more than that — we are a family that looks out for, cares for, and ultimately celebrates the unique privilege of being what we are: Evertonians.

"Now I obviously know that all of this wonderful activity we see at Goodison is based on a clear plan, and is motivated by a relentless pursuit of excellence that can only be brought to life by long hours, hard work, and great commitment — but it still makes me proud to be Blue!"

The full message can be viewed on the Official Everton Website.

Quotes or other material sourced from EvertonFC.com



Reader Comments (99)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Tony McNulty
2 Posted 15/01/2014 at 17:14:37
As I read Bill's message through, I began to get the feeling it was the preamble to some big announcement in the final paragraph. You know the sort of thing:

"And it is for these sorts of reasons that I have finally decided to sell my beloved club. The new Chinese owners of "Everchang" will be unveiled at the time of their New Year, the year of the sheep in wolf's clothing — The new kit will be purple with yellow hoops etc. etc."

Having got to the end of the announcement — frankly harmless in its way, albeit as Brian says a reprise of fairly familiar sentiments and themes ("Boys' pen is to Bill is as broken leg is to Whelan") — I felt a kind of relief.

Which US President was it who said something about your own words giving you warm feelings but it's like pissing in your pants: feels good to you but probably doesn't do much for anyone else?

Ant Sorvoja
3 Posted 16/01/2014 at 23:10:40
Excellent statement. Bill has many flaws but there is no doubt about it that he is a true blue, and a proud Evertonian.
Phil Sammon
4 Posted 16/01/2014 at 23:13:29
Just the way he writes and the language he uses is enough to send my blood pressure soaring.
Kevin Rowlands
5 Posted 16/01/2014 at 23:20:36
No wonder he's smiling from ear to ear these days, he won the lotto with Moyes, then unbelievably hit the Mega Powerball with Martinez, read this and weep, http://t.co/AeUCf3wW2m
David Hallwood
6 Posted 16/01/2014 at 23:18:16
Agreed Ant(#257) We've done to the death BKs flaws; but when you see the shenanigans of Hull City, Cardiff and Southampton you realise that it could be worse. Can you imagine Bill agreeing to Everton being changed to North Liverpool Pirates no matter how much money was at stake.
John Audsley
7 Posted 16/01/2014 at 23:21:50
At least he seems to have gotten over his Moyes fetish. I think he mentions the boys pen everytime he talks. Sadly no mention of a possible buyer but the 24/7 search must come off sometime soon.....
Mick Davies
8 Posted 16/01/2014 at 23:25:37
He's a blue like me, so until he does something to endanger this club's survival, he'll do
Kevin Rowlands
9 Posted 16/01/2014 at 23:29:44
Kings Dock, Kirkby, Fortress Funds, Bellfield, how's about that for starters Mick, oh and btw have a look at the transfer table in my previous post, yep he's a blue and he's the man, right?
Ray Roche
10 Posted 16/01/2014 at 23:39:48
Tony McNulty
@ 822

"it's like pissing in your pants: feels good to you but probably doesn't do much for anyone else? "

Feels good to you??? Tony, you worry me.....

Patrick Murphy
11 Posted 16/01/2014 at 23:36:16
Kevin that was indeed eye-opening to say the least - So it's a good job we do manage to sell on the likes of Rodwell, Felli, Anichebe et al at a profit otherwise we would have to rely on youth players. A minus net spend on average for the last ten years and the Dark Side have spent more than United on transfers in that period. But it will be interesting to see what the figures for wages are this season for the PL as a whole and see where we are in that table.
Graham Mockford
12 Posted 17/01/2014 at 00:05:20
Bill must be laughing his cock off, Roberto has certainly managed to take the Blue Union off the agenda.
Dave Kelly
13 Posted 16/01/2014 at 23:30:39
I always find Blue Bill's self-gratifying testimonials good value and entertaining. I'm never overly keen to take part in a Kenwright "Love in" or "Kick off".

So let's look at the facts: Bill and his fellow custodians on the Board will always wax lyrical about the excellent and, in my opinion, the peerless Everton in the Community. An absolute shining light of embracing the local community, Everton's Beacon.

They are the perennial Champions League qualifiers and oft, Champions League winners, with doubles and trebles delivered with great frequency. The ultimate trophy delivery Community Group.

When you also consider the amount of time and effort required to host initiatives like the Fans Zone, the entertainment, printing (what an excellent addition the Junior programme was), hiring of PA equipment, insurance etc.

However, this excellence comes at a cost: our erstwhile CEO revealed this week that he currently spends a day and a half a week on resolving the long standing and as yet unresolved Stadium issue. How much of his time is spent on EiTC business and when you also consider he also has responsibilities for the finances of the Free School. It doesn't give Robert much time to spend on his "other responsibilities.

When you also factor time and cost of releasing Denise Barrett Baxendale our Deputy CEO — who has responsibilities for EiTC and the Free School and all the other Staff and volunteer costs — the overall cost to Everton FC must be considerable.

When you then consider that company accounts that were registered in Company House in May of last year have yet to be presented to the Shareholders, and there's no immediate plans to hold an AGM in the near future, you can only assume that the accounts will not make pleasant reading, given that the new broadcasting revenues will not appear till next years accounts.

Personally, I feel that the senior management team should be spending more time on our core business interests:– "Football." Given that the Stadium is potentially the second biggest revenue generator for any football club and the main one we can exert any influence over (given that the Broadcasting deals done externally at the Premier League), why are we spending so little time on addressing it?

Yes, the peripheral activity shows us in extremely good light but if we wish to smash through the "glass ceiling" and become genuine Champions League contenders rather than pretenders we need to become far more Business like less Charitable.

Bill Kenwright needs to realise, he currently has the unenviable record to been the Everton Chairman during the longest running trophy-less drought.

It's time to hand over the keys to the train-set, Bill, and gratefully accept your new position as the Honourable Life President of Everton in the Community. You will then be able to tell future generations about your Evertonian credentials, attending photo shoots, and kiss babies to your heart's content.

I for one an extremely careful what I wish for.......

Frank McGregor
14 Posted 17/01/2014 at 01:39:44
When one looks around the Premier League at the various clubs, I am quite happy to have Bill Kenwright in place, even with all his faults that I recognise he has. Sure it would be great to have new people in charge but – as has been mentioned – "Be careful what you wish for..."

Bill Kenwright does deserve a bit of credit even though it may be hard for some to admit it. I would suggest that he has done more to promote Everton than KEIOC and the Blue Union in the recent past.

Tony Sullivan
15 Posted 17/01/2014 at 04:43:07
Like our Chairman I too salute our efforts of our Communications and Marketing Dept's. Certainly, they have shown a massive and welcome improvement in reaching out to the fans and the community.

Like most Evertonians I too feel part of the family, however, there appears to be a section of the 'family' which have a blind spot/hatred of BK and will give him no credit for anything.

It never ceases to amaze me the amount of vilification shown towards him.

After all, he only stabilised the club through the appointment and support of David Moyes. Now he has installed an inspirational manager in Roberto Martinez.

Great that we have unified teams at all levels in the club. RM needs all the support we can give in bringing the School of Science tradition back to our great club.

I for one am loving it, long may it continue to prosper.

Dennis Ng
16 Posted 17/01/2014 at 05:09:27
Patrick, Kevin, are there any other financial stats (like our debt) since the 90s? It is indeed an eye opener, though not surprised.

http://debt.co.uk/football/everton/

Not much to infer, given that we made losses last season (How the heck did we do that?) I am very eager to look at the next year's financial results. Without a backer that just throws money into the bottomless pit that if football, I think our overall position is wonderful. It is a worry how long this will go on.

Another site that shows our worrying spending trend...

http://www.transfermarkt.com/en/fc-everton/transfers/verein_29_2011_default_default_alle_a_default.html

I believe it doesn't account for loan fees though...I can see that skewing the infographic a bit but should not be that much of a difference. Makes me wonder, what ARE the parts within the club that is weight us down?

Eric Myles
17 Posted 17/01/2014 at 05:37:25
Dennis, besides the obvious wages of the players which account for the majority of our expenditure the other major outgoing I Other Operating Costs which account for 30% of our income.
Matt Traynor
18 Posted 17/01/2014 at 05:36:28
Dennis #300 someone a while back calculated using the available data that we are paying out around £9m a year in debt servicing in interest and finance charges (i.e. before paying down the debt). Given the club are not maximising commercial revenues because they chased longer-term deals with guaranteed income over time (to borrow against) you can see how the increased TV revenues this season are a blessing. This will eventually allow us to stabalise financially (provide wages don't increase significantly) however it also represents extra revenue for other clubs to invest in squads.

One of the first things Bill and friends did when they took over was start borrowing. The securitisation of season tickets, the mortgaging of Goodison Park, the sale and lease-back of Finch Farm (after the sale of Bellefield), and when they ran out of easy borrowing, the high cost loans against TV revenue from the likes of Vibrac. In other words, not having the funds in place to either fund or build the business, they've borrowed what they can to keep it running.

I've no doubt they want to sell, but they want to sell at the right price, and trust me if someone has the money, it won't matter whether they're from Thailand or Tuebrook, Azerbijan or Aintree. I don't hate Bill, I know he's a huge fan. But lets call it how it is, he's trying to make a personal fortune - and there's not many on these boards who wouldn't try to do the same, given half a chance.

Eric Myles
19 Posted 17/01/2014 at 05:41:48
Frank #288 "Be careful what you wish for..." was the phrase oft used with regards to Moyes leaving, and look how that worked out!
Dennis Ng
20 Posted 17/01/2014 at 05:40:41
Yes Eric. Interesting fact is that though some fans mentioned that we're a selling club, note that ~2007-2008, we bought much more than we sold. A lot of it is really bad biz deals. e.g. Yakubu sold for ~10% of the fee we paid. I always felt we sold way too cheaply. afrohead is the first counter example. I hope RM can stem the trend of us selling cheaply. If I ever thought BK is one thing, is that he's a bad salesman at least before the afrohead sale. Surely many players we sold can be sold higher.

Matt, no doubt about that. I always hear that our finance was horrible back in the 90s, so probably that was the easy borrowing drying up. When you mix fanhood with biz, you can get irrationally greedy. I think that's what BK is now. He is doing a good job otherwise, those this is the first season we've actually sold players above market value. I do wonder if it has something to do with the manager as well, i.e. the manager is ok to sell, so BK doesn't really negotiate well.

Brent Stephens
23 Posted 17/01/2014 at 05:54:50
Eric #304 personally I love our Roberto and think he will deliver some nice pot to go on the mantle-piece. But in all fairness we cant yet say "look how that worked out", can we? Many have said from the start that he needs time before we can judge him. So to be consistent...

Unless we'd be happy with the great football, which we already have, but no pot.

(You know what I mean by "pot").

David Ellis
24 Posted 17/01/2014 at 06:27:06
Dennis
I don't think we have sold "cheaply" over the years. Transfer fees are generally a massive waste of money as players decline in value like second hand (used) cars as they get older, and as their contracts run down. So of course we often sell players for a lot less than we paid for them...but that would be the usual cycle if you buy a player who is older than say 25, and if their contract is running down (for a player of any age). So just because we sold say Yakubu for 10% of what we paid for him does not mean we sold him for below market value - he was 29, not in the first team, wanted to leave, off form and had 6 months left on his contract. A bit like Kenwye Jones really - which is why his market value is GBP1m and no longer GBP9m.

Loan fees are a bit of a hybrid - part a portion of the transfer fee and partly wages, depending on the age of the player and the reason for the loa - sometimes they are all wages (and less than the wages the parent club pays).

Also Dennis players earn so much that if they are not working out it is good to sell them at a discount so that you are not stuck with their wages until the next transfer window. Typically the all earn GBP 1.5 to 2m per year so if you miss a transfer window the amounts can be significant.

Thomas Lennon
26 Posted 17/01/2014 at 07:16:12
Going back to the 1990's we had a recurring habit of losing money on most transfers (pre Bosman). Buy em big, sell em cheap. I remember it highlighted by the Echo. Another change for the better since around 2002?
Andy Meighan
27 Posted 17/01/2014 at 08:05:23
My toes curl up and I go crimson every time he opens his mouth. Can't he ever make a statement without all the theatrics? I'm surprised dear old uncle Cyril (god rest his soul) never got a mention...

Still, as David Hallwood said, when you look at the capers at other clubs over the years – and I'm including our loveable neighbours in this – I suppose it could be worse.

It still rather begs the question though: How come, in all of his tenure, have we never been approached as regards a buy-out? Or have we, Bill?

Colin Glassar
28 Posted 17/01/2014 at 08:58:37
I wonder if any Boys Pen regulars from those days actually remember BK being there? He'd be the fat kid with specs, always crying and asking for his teddy.
Barry Rathbone
29 Posted 17/01/2014 at 09:08:57
Colin you wouldn't be able to see young Billy — you could hardly see your hand in front of your face!

The Boys Pen was like the Black Hole of Calcutta — a mesh fenced cage hidden in the corner under the Gwladys St stand with loads of rag-arsed urchins running round like refugees from Oliver Twist.

Colin Glassar
30 Posted 17/01/2014 at 09:17:08
I remember the boys pen Barry, as you say it was more like a zoo than an enclosure for young scallys. I just can't see sensitive Bill being part of all that pushing and shoving and foul language.
Geoff Freeman
32 Posted 17/01/2014 at 09:20:51
Barry, yep we were a bunch of rag arsed urchins, but it was one place where I could afford to get in (6 old pence if I remember correctly) and where my love of Everton began in the 50s.
Tony McNulty
33 Posted 17/01/2014 at 09:51:30
Ray (273) Following your intervention, the phrase, "warm words of comfort" will never seem the same again.
Jason Lam
34 Posted 17/01/2014 at 09:59:24
It's at times like this I worry about his delusional state and self-admiration. Or not.

Still it's good entertainment and nice way to start the weekend. Complete bonkers.

John Gall
35 Posted 17/01/2014 at 10:48:14
Frank –- 288. Completely agree. The game has changed beyond recognition in the 27 years since we last won the league. That we are still in with a shout of finishing top 4 and we still have our integrity, soul and identity in place is little short of miraculous and is a testament to Kenwright's canniness and charm in appointing Moyes and then Martinez.

Look at the chaos elsewhere in the Premier League — foreign owners passing through, having their fun and shafting the fans and the identities of the clubs they are playing with. Everton still has the shape, feel and identity of the club it was 27 years ago and that, in the current vile, money-corrupted modern game, is something we should be thankful for. Kenwright deserves a medal, not abuse. Nil Satis, yes — but not at any cost.

Eric Myles
36 Posted 17/01/2014 at 11:34:09
Brent #308, several seasons ago there were numerous posters proclaiming we'd be relegated if Moyes left 'cos he was the only thing keeping us in the EPL.

That's what I meant by "look how that turned out" — It's not happened and doesn't look remotely possible.

Brent Stephens
37 Posted 17/01/2014 at 11:44:23
Eric, ok, we're avoiding relegation. As you say, not remotely possible. Turning out well.
Gavin Ramejkis
38 Posted 17/01/2014 at 12:47:57
Here's one for ya, Bill, how about the Pocket Reach program? You and your silent buddies put up or shut up and get the fuck out of Dodge.
Ste Traverse
39 Posted 17/01/2014 at 13:20:31
I wondered when this clown would finally crawl out of the woodwork.

He's been silent all season. Couldn't he bloody stay that way?

Joe Bibb
40 Posted 17/01/2014 at 13:35:31
He should go to St Luke's Church in Gwladys Street before any home game. Upstairs is a display of Everton Football Club's History put on by the EFC Heritage Society. They have old programmes rare memorabilia, signed Everton books and an information point if you want to know more about any aspect of Everton Football Club's History. Its all free open to away fans and all Evertonians.

Everton Chile are represented by the Ruleteros Society who have some nice merchandise on sale. If anything is happening for the benefit of Everton fans you will hear about it here first.

Get there between 1pm and 2:30pm and enjoy a great matchday atmosphere. Also open before night games and Sunday matches. A brilliant place for fans with their family and downstairs a good priced cafe run by St Luke's.

Brian Waring
41 Posted 17/01/2014 at 13:45:49
Things are going well Ste, so he was due an appearance.

Also, I would rather him be coming out and talking about the direction we're taking, and how much has Roberto got to spend etc.

Brian Waring
42 Posted 17/01/2014 at 14:05:35
What could have been hey Bill
http://news.bbc.co.uk/sport1/hi/foot...on/1454035.stm
Conn Prosser
43 Posted 17/01/2014 at 14:00:43
Pocket Reach program. I like that. Kenwright doesn't have Premier League pockets and I wouldn't expect a shareholder to invest half his personal wealth on a football player for the club. However, Mr Earl and Mr Woods have ten times the wealth of BK each, thus I would expect them to put some money into the club.

Surely by clearing the debt, repurchasing important assets and investing in key revenue areas, they could easily make the club more attractive to heavyweight buyers. they could even make the club profitable and take dividends themselves.

It would be nice to think that, with an inspirational manager at the helm and everything football looking so rosey, this could happen.

Brian Waring
44 Posted 17/01/2014 at 14:17:27
From July 2001: Everton's grounds for hope.
Patrick Murphy
45 Posted 17/01/2014 at 14:22:58
Brian - how time flies when you're having fun - I hadn't realised it had been that long ago? Was it all a sham? I suppose we'll never know.
Dennis Ng
46 Posted 17/01/2014 at 14:08:38
David, true, I forgot about that point and would consider it much more positively for our past sales. However, that does not help as situation as we seem to spend more when we shouldn't and then forced a la nearly bankrupt fashion "ban" from buying players in 2009. Just found that it was EPL legal that forced us to make more sales than buys in 2010.

I just read the articles where BK was revealed to be begging the banks not to close on us. We'll have to see if RM can continue the magic he did at Wigan and us. We need to be careful in that we do not cut the squad too thin that we are one injury away from imploding. Wigan performed magically all the way to the Cup but unfortunately too mistake ridden to survive EPL, perhaps due to injuries.

Of course, we're near CL and I think he'll manage wonderfully if he gets what he wants. Just saying we should not expect him to take a lower midtable squad into CL. We have a paper thin title contender squad and should manage to be near or even get CL.

The part I like about what's happening now is that RM seems to be keeping the squad small enough to avoid "fire sale". That should keep the "buy high sell low" problem at bay. I still think Yakubu and Arteta were sold cheap, though I can see why their valuations are depressed by their individual situations. We need to not give our players and other clubs the chance to take money out of our pocket for granted.

Kevin Tully
47 Posted 17/01/2014 at 14:26:37
Brian - Looking at that is like divorcing your missus months before she wins the Euromillions lottery, then watching her drive by in her new Aston as you are on your way to another 12 hour night-shift in McDonalds.

Brian Waring
48 Posted 17/01/2014 at 14:34:24
Like it Kevin. By the time I had got to the end of the piece I was that depressed I had to get my other half to give me a hug, she now thinks I'm carrying on because I never ask for a hug.
Ian Burns
49 Posted 17/01/2014 at 14:07:23
TW gives us all a terrific opportunity to air views; vilify or praise players; managers; directors and anybody else who takes our fancy.

Sometimes those views are expressed with deep, personal feeling recently against Moyes and whenever the opportunity arises against the Chairman.

Quite often, during a match when we are not playing as well as we might, feelings spill out all over the place on the TW Live Forum during the game and occasionally extreme views are expressed about this player or that player, I am thinking as I write of Ossie and Nessy who get it in the neck every game. I might just add here that many an amusing comment mixed with some praise is also evident, which makes it an unmissable experience if you are like me and unable to get to GP these days.

However, the point I am trying to make in a drawn out way is one thing we ALL have in common is that we are ALL true blues, no matter what our opinion is of fellow contributors to this site and that goes for BK. No matter what we might think of him, first and foremost he is a true blue since he fought his way in and out of the Boys Pen! – and that is something you cannot say of most Chairman. We all have our issues but as it has been said many times on this thread alone, be careful what you wish for – we could end up as Everton Elephants in the wrong hands with Kenwyne Jones playing up front.

Brian Waring
50 Posted 17/01/2014 at 14:41:33
Can't believe how long ago it was myself Patrick. Tell you what would be a good read, a no holds barred autobiography by BK when he eventually steps down.
Patrick Murphy
51 Posted 17/01/2014 at 14:43:01
Ian, I fully agree with your feelings about TW and Evertonians in general, however, more often than not Dictatorships start out by someone who is just one of us and very often the majority feel that they should have stopped him sooner or question why they failed to see the signs that had flashed in front of them in 12 foot neon letters and then as they view the wreckage ask themselves why did he lie to us – and then come to the conclusion that he wasn't really one of us, no wonder he behaved like he did.
Michael Kenrick
52 Posted 17/01/2014 at 14:56:34
Dennis (#400) — Just found that it was EPL legal that forced us to make more sales than buys in 2010.

I'm not sure I recall that... can you provide a link to where you read it, please?

Ian (#404) — "Nessy" ... Really? I know he's Scottish, but surely not...

Ian Burns
54 Posted 17/01/2014 at 15:06:31
Michael, it must be his long neck or his ability to go missing when we want to see him perform!

Joking apart, apologies Mr. Naismith

Eric Myles
55 Posted 17/01/2014 at 15:07:23
Brent #364, a little bit better than avoiding relegation don't you think?
Dennis Ng
56 Posted 17/01/2014 at 15:08:21
Found it pretty quickly. Might not be the best article on it so I'll search more later.

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/sport/football/article-2027633/Dont-kill-season-debt-ridden-Everton-tell-bankers.html

It was a "ban" on overdraft but that meant not being allowed to get players by putting more debt, even if slightly.

Michael Kenrick
58 Posted 17/01/2014 at 15:10:47
Thanks Dennis, I see what has happened here...

Where the article says "Barclays have blocked the club making any additions to their playing staff and forced the club to reduce its overdraft." — that is because Barclays were Everton's bankers at the time.

Nothing to do with Barclays sponsoring the Premiere League — that's only been in place for the last two or three seasons, and occurred after the events related in this article, which I remember only too well.

Cheers.

Dennis Ng
59 Posted 17/01/2014 at 15:14:08
I see. They change sponsors so often I mistook it as the league. Good point. But most clubs get their loans from Barclay's right? So I suppose that's a dead end during 2010.
Ian Burns
60 Posted 17/01/2014 at 15:09:46
Patrick - 407 - I understand your point, if I don't entirely agree - but that is the beauty of TW - we can differ in many ways but we are all true blues, which was my point about BK.

I am not defending his record; I am not defending the manner in which he has handled any number of issues but my point is that it could be worse. He appointed Moyes at the right time and when the time came he brought in RM, who has yet to prove he can do it over the long term but I will take every day what he has delivered to date - and like me he came up from the Boys Pen - that gets a tick in my book!!

Eric Myles
61 Posted 17/01/2014 at 15:15:11
Dennis (#413) from your link, "'On average we give him £5.6m every year. Nine years, that's £45m that we haven't got."

As a man of numbers I'm sure you can spot something wrong with that.

Michael Kenrick
63 Posted 17/01/2014 at 15:22:32
But most clubs get their loans from Barclay's right? — I have no data on this but would strongly suspect the answer is a resounding "No".

I am pretty sure the banking arrangements of the Premier League clubs are entirely independent and separate, with no connection to Barclays — other than cases like this where Barclays was (and perhaps still is/are) the club's bankers.

From Barclay's perspective, I believe Barclays' EPL sponsorship is a marketing tool, not an investment strategy. They would be mad to take on more than a small fraction of the total PL debt themselves, and prefer to have it spread widely among many different banking institutions and finance houses.

Eric Myles
64 Posted 17/01/2014 at 15:24:50
Ian #420 "my point is that it could be worse" — and it could, and should have been, a whole lot better. King's Dock ring a bell?

Dennis, another thing from that article "Kenwright also said proceeds from recent player sales, such as Steven Pienaar's £3M switch to Tottenham, and Bellefield, the former training ground sold for £9M, had been taken by Barclays."

So what I take from that is maybe the real reason we couldn't give Pienaar the pay rise he deserved at the time was because we couldn't afford it and even had to sell him to pay the banks some money.

Eric Myles
66 Posted 17/01/2014 at 15:39:40
Brin #423, I doubt that there's anyone posting on here that has "first hand knowledge", we all get our info from various sources and interpret it as we see fit.

It's just that maybe Dennis is not taking the time to absorb all the information he is gleaning before jumping back into his work, and out again.

Youthful enthusiasm I hope, rather than a WUM.

Brian Hennessy
68 Posted 17/01/2014 at 15:44:02
Yes, like all Everton fans I would love for us to be able to compete financially with the "moneybags" clubs.

Yes it would be great to have a shiny new 60,000 seater stadium.

But I still cannot help with being proud of the way BK has overseen the running of this great club these past years.

You cannot question his love of Everton and when you see how certain clubs, who were taken over by the first billionaire who wanted to own their club, have now ended up in a mess, maybe Bill has been correct in not just selling on to the highest bidder.

Eric Myles
70 Posted 17/01/2014 at 16:07:16
Brian #441, you consider Chelsea a mess? Why?

And City too? How come?

Linda Morrison
71 Posted 17/01/2014 at 16:11:16
Is it possible we can all agree to call time on this theme?

If you look at the financial results posted in the various newspapers about income/outgoings, most of the income of all the clubs in the Premier League goes on salaries for players, quickly followed by agents fees.

Everton have tied up 3 of their best players on really good financial deals. How many people do you know who earn £75,000 a year never mind a week? I think the likelihood of us getting a new stadium is highly unlikely unless Liverpool agree to a ground share.

What we do know about BK is he won't get fed up with the club and walk away leaving us to go to the wall. The same can not be said of others in the league.

Paul Scholes was that rare thing, a player without an agent. It's frightening that clubs are paying millions of pounds to them.

Eric Myles
73 Posted 17/01/2014 at 16:35:03
Linda #449 "How many people do you know who earn £75,000 a year never mind a week?"

Lots.

Andrew Ellams
76 Posted 17/01/2014 at 16:38:38
Eric, I bet they all do a lot more for their £75k a year than footballers do for their weekly.
Patrick Murphy
78 Posted 17/01/2014 at 17:16:18
Linda - I promise this will be my last post on this thread regarding BK.

BK will not walk away from the club because he needs to settle his debts before he can do so - but he will probably want to make a profit as well. Why shouldn't we discuss the issues that prevent Everton from fulfilling its true potential? If we just ignore the issues then they are unlikely to be resolved?

Reading the link that Dennis gave earlier suggests that we are run at an average loss of £5m per year and that loss is used to buy players over and above what we receive in fees for the players we sell. Ten years at £5m loss is equal to about £50m debt which I imagine is where we are at this moment in time, give or take a few million.

The extra TV money is probably divided between players/staff wages and interest payments on loans.

It's a miracle that we have been anywhere near the top half of the table in the last five years and we can thank the manager(s) and players for that, but a new ground will have to be a freebie or built with more borrowed money but the new structure will have so many strings attached that Everton FC and the team won't fully benefit from it.

I know it's boring and brings many fans out in a rash, but the truth is the truth regardless of how sugar-coated it may be sold to us and we ignore it at our peril.

Most of our peers in the Premier league actively seek other revenue streams and are not tied into long-term deals that prevent then from improving their financial situation.

On the pitch we overachieve, off the pitch we are punching well below our weight. The question is how long before the team on the park start matching the situation off the pitch. I suppose if that circumstance ever arrives it will be OK to discuss the pros and cons of BK's tenure.

Dan Brierley
80 Posted 17/01/2014 at 17:33:23
I am still yet to hear anyone give a good reason why all the protesting stopped? It seems there are still lots of people unhappy with the chairman, but now seem to be unwilling to do anything about it?

Matt Traynor
81 Posted 17/01/2014 at 17:26:34
Patrick #471, you raise good points. I admired what the BU were trying to do as they were calling for the board to seek new owners at a time when much was going okay on the pitch.

The mythical billionaire that so many fear is not going to appear, because there's too much to be done to fix the club. That's one of the reasons the club engaged several Venture Capital firms to try to find a buyer. EFC need a particular buyer – someone who will see what the opportunity is in increasing the asset base over the longer term to get their return (stadium development with increased commercial revenue in medium term). Whether that buyer emerges is down to the terms of the sale. If they were willing to sell to reflect what they'd put in, and without onerous terms, then I'm sure there'd be interested parties making enquiries tomorrow.

Supposed "sports brokers" claiming personal friendships using family members as interim advisers on 6-figure "consulting" commissions from their East Sussex base is not going to attract the kind of buyer needed. Fan or not, they'll tell them to sling their hook.

Michael Kenrick
84 Posted 17/01/2014 at 17:43:40
Isn't it simple, Dan?

The team's doing well, the new manager is brilliant.

No-one has any appetite for protest under those circumstances.

Dan Brierley
85 Posted 17/01/2014 at 17:39:50
Matt, I think you have overlooked the point about first of all needing to heavily invest in the squad. As it stands now, we don't need a bigger stadium, we cannot even regularly fill our current capacity.

Perhaps when you have a squad that has proved it can consistently finish in the CL places, then an investor would consider putting money into a new stadium that would optimise the increased exposure. At this moment in time, I don't see any investor in their right mind that would pump money into infrastructure that would potentially sit empty.

Dan Brierley
86 Posted 17/01/2014 at 17:45:21
It depends on people's views I guess, Michael. As we saw with FC United & the Glazier protests, some fans de-link the on pitch performance with their fundamental moral values.

But, it could be argued (for those who believe it) that Kenwright is holding the club back even further now we have a new, hungry manager who appears to be capable of breaking the glass ceiling?

Michael Kenrick
87 Posted 17/01/2014 at 17:50:59
I guess my personal view, Dan, is that we know we have no money (for many reasons) and that we know the club is fundamentally unsaleable (for a few fairly specific reasons) — despite the KEIOC and BU protestations.

So here we are... stuck with Bill, despite what we may think about him. The only things going for us are the player assets, and the brilliant manager.

It suggests that all the fevered anticipation over big signings this window, that some have posted about continuously these past months, may well be misplaced... but Roberto surprised us at the end of August.... and may well be lining up a few surprises this time around. We'll just have to wait and see...

Matt Traynor
89 Posted 17/01/2014 at 17:55:45
Dan I was talking about selling the club. One would hope any buyers would be aware of the need to invest in the playing side. Lots of clubs that aren't in the Champions League get sold. I see my old mahjong foe Peter Lim is expecting to be made preferred bidder for Valencia. That involves stadium redevelopment, and Kenwright-esque, he's come out and said €40M for January transfers isn't enough, he reckons €50M.

This was the guy who claimed he wanted to by LFC when Stadtler and Waldorf were being forced out. He never tabled a bid.

Oh, and he also runs the Man Utd themed bars in Asia.

Brian Hennessy
91 Posted 17/01/2014 at 18:00:26
Eric #444 Yes I think Chelsea are a perfect example of a club where money has bought trophies but as far as any decent moral standands are concered they couldn't care less.

Just look at the behaviour some oftheir players on and off the field the past few years, I just couldnt see that happening at Everton. Add to that an owner who appointed Benitez knowing what the fans would think.

As for City, who wouldn't love to have the incredible players they have, but for every owner like Man City's, there are dozens more who have taken over clubs and distroyed them.

I'm not saying we don't need new owners/investers it just has to be the right kind!

Dan Brierley
92 Posted 17/01/2014 at 17:59:44
I wouldn't agree with that, Michael, I think there are plenty of people out there that would buy into EFC. But I am equally certain that none of them 'fit the bill' in terms of what Kenwright and the board expects for the future of the club he has been heavily involved in for the last 20 years or so.

But one thing that is clear, only protesting when the manager is unable to continually pull the rabbit out of the hat and on pitch performance slumps is shallow at best. It's a bit like saying "To be fair, the Assad regime haven't used chemical weapons on their people for a while." My point being, you gain much more respect and support if you remain true to your values at all times.

Jack Thomas
93 Posted 17/01/2014 at 18:09:36
I'm nine years of age and really enjoyed it last Saturday before the game. Thank you, Bill and Alan Myers.
Dan Brierley
94 Posted 17/01/2014 at 18:15:22
Matt, you are indeed right. There have been literally hundreds of take overs over the years. But, only the City and Chelsea take overs have been successful in delivering consistent CL football. So to be successful, you either need to spend a billion like City or Chelsea, or do something that has never been done before in English Football.
Matt Traynor
95 Posted 17/01/2014 at 18:29:50
No Dan you are saying a new owner has to deliver a sustained period of CL football to be considered a success.

I'm saying from a financial point of view, if I were advising new owner, I would view an increase in the asset value of the club as being a successful ownership period. (In other words the purchase price and operating investment are more than returned in the business valuation). Obviously on-field success will bolster this, that goes without saying. But we can't replicate what Chelsea and Man City are doing because that ship has sailed thanks largely to FFP - which as I've said for a long time is there to protect the interests of the old G-14 clique - that is, it's now nigh on impossible to crack through the glass ceiling.

Ironically a new stadium (or a redeveloped stadium to a lesser degree) would allow the club to massage its figures reported as part of FFP under the "allowable expenses" component. We could always ask Man City for advice.

Dan Brierley
96 Posted 17/01/2014 at 18:42:34
It's an interesting thought, Matt: would a £200 million investment in a stadium raise the 'selling' price of our club more than £200 million?

Kind of like doing up an old house I guess.

John Audsley
97 Posted 17/01/2014 at 19:21:45
Sadly MK nails it at 487

That's my view as well and I hope we do sign another couple of people in the next 2 weeks. BK loves being "Mr Everton" and it would take an amazing offer for him to go.

He would want to be "Life President" or something to go with the bundles of cash as well.

He is here forever, I'm afraid.................

Christine Foster
99 Posted 17/01/2014 at 21:20:40
Okay, so ask the simple question of BK: Is the club for sale? Ask for how much. Ask what he would consider a fair price for his shares.

MK is right to a point: team doing well, manager with his head screwed on and the departing old David Moyes (a big feel good factor to many), the style of football we now play... All are good reason to feel better about the club. But the club is not Bill Kenwright, even if he thinks it's his — he does not have a majority shareholding.

Unless over 51% sell their shares to a given party, then controlling interest, a very different thing to ownership, is shared — as it is now.

For the club to have been sold, means not just a controlling interest but the ability to change the constitution, which if memory serves me correctly, requires ownership by a single entity of 75% of the shares.

That's probably where the fudging of lines between selling the club, or investment. Not enough wanted to sell the shares to secure "ownership"? Instead, BK and others wanted to sell their investment (shares) to somebody else, which of course becomes their investment!

The most likely reasons for any sale of any business not going through is exactly that: price to purchase enough shares to gain full control is set too high by the board. Given the amount of money to be outlayed just to get to the table, it's not worth a minority investment.

Remember, not one penny of any sale is actually invested in the club.

Mick Davies
100 Posted 17/01/2014 at 23:10:07
If the Russian gangster walked out of Chelsea, they would be in a worse state than Portsmouth. His filthy lucre has been bankrolling the club for years, just so he can attain British citizenship. The wages and debt are astronomical and they'd have to sell the lot, with the buyers knowing the state the club would be in, therefore picking them up for a song. Then we'd see what kind of manager Moaninio is.

Kenwright, apart from his KD and other feck ups, of which we don't know the full details, is a blue. If he stood in the pen, like I did years later, he must be dedicated, believe me. Therefore he wouldn't do anything to destroy our club, like Shinawatra, Hicks/Gillete, Gaydamak, Tan, Allam etc. if he can't sell the club, has anyone got any proof that its his fault? And if it was,who knows whether he's deliberately keeping EFC out of the claws of people like those aforementioned?

I believe if its not broke, then leave it alone, and if the protests flare up again and destabilise the job the manager is doing, it will show just who really loves the club, and who just wants money and trophies without thinking of the consequences of prostituting this great institution to all the selfish business people on the planet. Remember, these shysters have shafted their own people to get what they want; would they give a shit about a foreign soccer club of which tney know nothing? Just look at Hull, and a man who has threatened to walk away, leaving the manger and the club in schtuck if he doesn't get his way. Or Cardiff, where the owner fires the manager in public during a relegation battle, and brings in a young boss with no PL managerial experience. In Celine Dion's words; think twice

Tony Sullivan
101 Posted 18/01/2014 at 05:48:15
Barry Rathbone (331)

I thought the Boys Pen under the Gwladys St stand was a good 'spec', especially as it was only a 'tanner' (2.5p) to get in!!

I don't remember seeing BK, but I used to see Aiden Maher regularly who ended up playing for us a few times, sometime in the 60s I think?

Michael Kenrick
102 Posted 18/01/2014 at 06:07:15
Dan (#498) — I think there are plenty of people out there that would buy into EFC. But I am equally certain that none of them 'fit the bill' in terms of what Kenwright and the board expects for the future of the club he has been heavily involved in for the last 20 years or so. – That's the sort of thing I meant when I said the club could not be sold.

The main contention of the protesters, as I recall, was that Bill should sell the club. Despite interpretations of his words to the contrary (eg, "looking for investors 24/7"), actions speak louder: there really has been no sign that he has any intention of selling the club. Hence the impasse...

Without movement on this key issue, what do the protesters have? What can they do? The incredible thing is how they allowed themselves to be 'played' by — of all things — rumour of a takeover that was at a delicate stage and could be sent off track if they continued their protests... Are you kidding me?!?!

I think it was at that point they lost any remaining shreds of credibility.

Eric Myles
103 Posted 18/01/2014 at 10:16:13
Dan #503, haven't United and Arsenal had consistent CL qualification in the years it has been going? Or do they not fit your argument?
Eric Myles
104 Posted 18/01/2014 at 10:59:34
Dan #485, a bigger stadium isn't just about getting a few more fans bums on seats, it's about all the other commercial revenue that the Club can bring in, consistently, aside from the footballing revenue.

Attendances may go up and down depending on success, or lack thereof, but having a consistent off-field income means the bad times aren't so bad as they have recently been.

Eric Myles
105 Posted 18/01/2014 at 11:05:20
Mick #616 "I believe if its not broke, then leave it alone,"

But Mick, it has proven to be broke, it needs fixing.

Brian Harrison
106 Posted 18/01/2014 at 11:18:30
I think for us fans it is just disappointing that we don't have the financial resources to challenge year in and year out for a top 4 spot or better. Also the lack of funds mean that when we unearth a special talent like Rooney or Barkley we know that it is only a matter of time before these players are snapped up by one of the monied clubs.

There must be a reason as to why there has been no concrete offers for our club, some say BK wants to big a price but I think Elstone said in an interview last year that £125 million was about the going rate. Maybe along with the £125 million there would then be the additional cost of building a new stadium say another £300 million, so a new buyer would be looking to spend £425 million and he hasnt bought a player and add to this that we still don't own our own training ground. So compare this to Man City were the new owners already had a new stadium so there money went straight on improving the playing squad, which ultimately is the most important thing.

Dan Brierley
107 Posted 18/01/2014 at 11:20:05
The great prophet...Celine Dion???
Eric Myles
108 Posted 18/01/2014 at 12:39:43
Brian #685, why would a new owner have to build a new stadium? Why not spend £50 million improving what we have and the same on the squad?

So for half your estimated layout we are already in a far better position than now. Or if you prefer only spend the first £50 million improving the squad and improve the ground when the CL money comes rolling in.

And although City's owners inherited a ground, haven't they tried to buy it outright? and spent just as much on training facilities?

Brian Denton
109 Posted 18/01/2014 at 13:08:14
Dan (503)

"So to be successful, you either need to spend a billion like City or Chelsea, or do something that has never been done before in English Football."

Don't understand what you mean by 'never been done before in English football'. By 'never' do you mean 'post 1992 Sky'?

It's like 1992 was Year Zero or something.

Colin Wainwright
110 Posted 18/01/2014 at 13:34:02
Mick @ 616.

Dan Brierley
111 Posted 18/01/2014 at 13:49:26
Sorry Brian, I should have clearly put 'since the PL began'.

Colin 714, I am not sure that I agree with your belief that 'all' the details are available online. All I have ever seen online, are peoples thoughts, opinions, educated guesses and assumptions. I am yet to see any factual report on things like the KD or Fortress Fund or any other apparent 'BK fuck up'. All I know is what I generally read on here, of which I think most is made up bollocks to suit someones personal agenda.

That said, I even admit to almost believing in the well presented myths of the 'Other Operating Costs' and 'Shirt Deals' that were the mainstay of the anti-BK on this very website. It is something I do regret doubting, after the club blew those myths out of the water at the last General Meeting.

Colin Wainwright
112 Posted 18/01/2014 at 14:54:04
Check out the Kirby court transcripts, reports and comments, Dan. You can lead a horse to water....
Alan McGuffog
113 Posted 18/01/2014 at 16:12:48
Then again Dylan said "Don't think twice". Who's a boy to believe?
Andy Crooks
114 Posted 18/01/2014 at 16:14:36
Dan #498, the Assad analogy is just silly. For purely pragmatic reasons a protest from the Blue Union now would be mad. In my view Kenwright remains the problem he always was.

He offers nothing to the club that is unique and different from any Evertonian. He has appointed two coaches who have protected him and pacified the support but the appointments weren't innovative strokes of genius. Martinez was bookies favourite from the off, not some unknown picked out of the blue by the magnificent Kenwright.

Protests now would be pointless but surely you must see that having the Blue Union in the background can only be a reminder to Kenwright that he is being watched and that his bullshit has not suddenly become okay.

Eric Myles
116 Posted 18/01/2014 at 16:28:36
Dan #718, I take it you also believe in the other propagated myth that Kenright saved the Club by taking out a second mortgage on his house?
Eric Myles
118 Posted 18/01/2014 at 16:38:26
Andrew #458, speaking for myself, no!
Colin Wainwright
119 Posted 19/01/2014 at 10:08:59
Did he not take out a second mortgage, Eric? Is there no end to the mans lies?

Andy, you're being very kind, calling Dan's Assad analogy, silly.

I understand that we all got it wrong at first. It took me years to work out what this board and it's "friends", were up to. Kirby was the final nail for me. But the point is, I realised, I changed my mind. An argument based on willful ignorance, is no argument at all.

Eric Myles
120 Posted 19/01/2014 at 10:33:09
Colin, he may well have taken out a second mortgage on his house. But what is the value of that house and was it enough to "save Everton"?

Well considering that Kenwright had to borrow money £7+mn from Paul Greggs wife to buy his 25% of shares, I'd say no.

So considering that the Gregg family paid for 50% of the Club's shares at the time it was sold to True Blue Holdings wouldn't it be more accurate to say that if anyone 'saved' the Club by the purchase from Johnson, that it was the Gregg's?

Colin Wainwright
121 Posted 19/01/2014 at 11:32:30
I agree with every word Eric.
Dave Kelly
122 Posted 20/01/2014 at 00:14:58
Dan Brierley, various; your compulsive and obsessive fixation with The Blue Union is the source of great amusement to many.

Never one not to insert a figment of your imagination to any of your rambling's, innuendo or musing's you continue to mis-quote, misinform and misrepresent an organisation that you have absolutely nothing to do with, The Blue Union.

For the avoidance of any doubt, The Blue Union is fit, well and fully functioning. I'm only sorry that this must come as a massive shock to you and others in your small but insignificant group of "Happy Clappers."

We continue to meet with journalists, broadcasters, local and national politicians as well playing a full and active part in the Football Supporters Federation and Supporters Direct.

We have also held a number of productive meetings with Everton over the course of the last month or so. Much of our work is conducted well away from the glare of the general public, and will continue to do so.

It's always been the our remit to campaign, lobby and dare I say even protest as individual groups and as a collective on all matters appertaining to Everton Football Club.

We wont take part in Bill Kenwright "Love In's" or Bill Kenwright "Kick In's" for that matter. However, we still feel that Bill isn't the best served person to move the business on, "smash the glass ceiling", address the "stadium issue" or bring to a conclusion his "24/7 search for investment."

It's business as usual for us, we are once again in good shape on the pitch............... off it is a cause for great concern.

We continue to be "very careful what we wish for " and to have concerns on the soon to be released accounts and stadium update.

If your going to the Hawthorns, why not come over and have a chat. You may learn something.


Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads

© ToffeeWeb