Season › 2013-14 › News
Blues close in on Traoré

Traore is snapped in Tesco's in Huyton in a photo currently circulating on Twitter
In a mobile phone photo circulating on Twitter, Traoré was snapped in Tesco's in Huyton earlier today trying his best to remain inconspicuous despite his giant frame.
The Ivorian international looked set to join West Ham this past week after the East London outfit agreed the loan move with the French club and were granted a work permit on appeal.
The West Ham board hesitated to push through the paperwork, however, when Traoré sustained a minor hamstring strain in training and Roberto Martinez stepped in with a loan proposal of his own.
Hammers boss Sam Allardyce admitted today that the player was now going elsewhere, saying: "I had a terrible day yesterday when I found out a player was going elsewhere. If we got a permit for him, so will they."
The "they" in question is believed to be Everton and with Traoré having apparently agreed on the loan switch, all that remains is the issuance of a new work permit to enable the 23 year-old to play for the Blues.
Traoré moved to France from Anzhi Makhachkala last summer for a whopping £15m but has yet to play a game in Ligue 1 — it was always Monaco's intention to loan him out to gain first-team experience elsewhere. He played 29 times for Anzhi, scoring 13 goals.
Reader Comments (256)
Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer
2 Posted 18/01/2014 at 21:39:52
3 Posted 18/01/2014 at 21:41:14
I'll raise that with skid-marked stained bell-ends on the kop.
4 Posted 18/01/2014 at 21:46:02
11 Posted 18/01/2014 at 21:48:22
I see our brothers from across the park won the 'most exciting home draw' of the weekend this afternoon and are doing an open topped bus tour of the city as I write!
12 Posted 18/01/2014 at 21:50:04
14 Posted 18/01/2014 at 21:59:22
15 Posted 18/01/2014 at 21:58:35
Brilliant.
16 Posted 18/01/2014 at 22:07:11
https://www.westhamtillidie.com/posts/2014/01/18/just-what-happened-with-the-lacina-traore-loan
17 Posted 18/01/2014 at 22:04:20
18 Posted 18/01/2014 at 22:04:41
19 Posted 18/01/2014 at 22:18:14
20 Posted 18/01/2014 at 22:20:29
21 Posted 18/01/2014 at 22:24:02
22 Posted 18/01/2014 at 22:34:42
The striker looks good but he's injured isn't he? How will this deal make sense if we want immediate support?
23 Posted 18/01/2014 at 22:29:09
24 Posted 18/01/2014 at 22:36:43
25 Posted 18/01/2014 at 22:41:17
If this comes off, we will have two absolute beasts( I mean that in a nice way) playing up front the next 4 months, with service from, Baines, Coleman, Del boy, McGeady, Pienaar, Mirallas and Barkley, that is scary!
26 Posted 18/01/2014 at 22:49:45
I hear he's estimated to be out for a month and WH wanted to delay proceedings, which is why he hijacked it. All rumors though so better to wait for official news.
Def wish we can free up the JH funds soon Kunal. Got any friends in Rome to hurry them up? I think a def mid is a priority if this deal goes through. We can handle things for now (fingers crossed, no other injuries) with Mirallas up top.
27 Posted 18/01/2014 at 22:58:02
And that's just the WAGS.
28 Posted 18/01/2014 at 22:58:33
On 17 January 2014, Traoré rejected a move to West Ham United after the East London club applied at a hearing for a work permit. After learning of interest from Everton FC, the chance to challenge for The UEFA Champions League was too good to turn down, and after speaking with Arouna Koné decided to fly up to Merseyside with his family. The deal, with a further season loan option, will be confirmed on 20 January 2014 prior to kick-off against West Bromwich Albion.Doesn't mean it's fact of course, Wikipedia and all that.
29 Posted 18/01/2014 at 23:17:33
West Ham or the Toffs? It's a no-brainer, fat head. One team on the cusp of the Champions League spots and the other in a basement battle — and the latter sure ain't us! The lad must've been delighted when he heard the brown shoes were in town...
Me, I'm just made up it's not Kenwyne Fuckin Jones. And yes — that really is his middle name. I knew Bobby would have something up his sleeve... and I don't think it ll be the last.
30 Posted 18/01/2014 at 23:24:31
What a smug get.
Always looks like he's enjoying smelling his own farts while being interviewed.
Probably related to Gerrard.
31 Posted 18/01/2014 at 23:30:32
32 Posted 18/01/2014 at 23:21:41
Know what you mean about the likes of Zigic (lumbering) and Crouch (under-powered beanpole), but hopefully this lad (should he turn up) will be a lot more dynamic.
33 Posted 18/01/2014 at 23:34:52
But just click on the link and tell me I'm wrong.
http://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/0/
34 Posted 18/01/2014 at 23:32:59
35 Posted 18/01/2014 at 23:39:06
36 Posted 18/01/2014 at 23:52:33
37 Posted 18/01/2014 at 22:55:23
38 Posted 19/01/2014 at 00:42:06
39 Posted 19/01/2014 at 00:57:06
43 Posted 19/01/2014 at 01:55:27
With Roberto bringing in McGeady and whoever else he's got up his sleeve, the face Everton shows the opposition is scaring the hell out've them!
48 Posted 19/01/2014 at 02:44:59
49 Posted 19/01/2014 at 08:29:00
Incidentally if we don't get Lukaku I think Remy would be an excellent target. Runout is he has a 10m release clause if QPR don't promoted and has adapted very well to premier league. He has the pace and mobility to suit our system as well as knowing where the goal is. He's a good age and I reckon would score us at least 15+ a season if fit.
50 Posted 19/01/2014 at 09:12:02
What say you?
51 Posted 19/01/2014 at 09:29:26
52 Posted 19/01/2014 at 09:27:23
53 Posted 19/01/2014 at 09:23:16
There was hope when Harry Renknap offered to let them use his dog's account in Monico to facilitate the transaction, but the deal could not be saved.
55 Posted 19/01/2014 at 09:34:31
But will so many loan players really bust a gut on a cold wet day?
56 Posted 19/01/2014 at 09:53:38
RM's preferred tactic is 352 apparently......push barkley back a little. but where that leaves all our wingers is another story
57 Posted 19/01/2014 at 09:55:27
I had an idea there would be way too much red tape in the way of making this deal a smooth one to complete.
The question is why did we wait until West Ham had already applied for a work permit before making a move for him?
It all smacks of a bit of desperation if you ask me.
Cannot see this happening now.
The latest crazed media story is that we are happy to wait until summer for Steven Fletcher.. No thanks
If we were so eager to bring a loan player in why did we not at least approach Spurs regarding Defoe before he went off to Vancouver or whatever far flung place he went.
It seems like we let Jelavic go for good money but as has been mentioned what are we going to do with it?
I hope we don't fuck up our chances during this window of having a go at getting 4th because it would be typical that as soon as the window closes if we don't sign a striker that Lukaku gets injured..
58 Posted 19/01/2014 at 10:21:50
59 Posted 19/01/2014 at 10:42:48
60 Posted 19/01/2014 at 10:37:50
The likes of Ba at Chelsea can't get a game for love nor money I still believe Mirallas would get goals for us playing just behind lukaku who lets face it needs help he's got skill in abundance great balance and an eye for goal and is wasted out wide. Then again maybe I've just got a downer on extremely tall people with me being 5 ft nothing.
Wonder if Pellegrini would fancy a swap with Aguero for me. Nah thought not...
62 Posted 19/01/2014 at 11:15:20
There is a lot of red tape surrounding the whole transfer apparentlt and it looks like if a deal can go through it will be a long drawn out process, so it states that the move is unlikely now.
63 Posted 19/01/2014 at 11:26:14
64 Posted 19/01/2014 at 11:39:17
65 Posted 19/01/2014 at 11:56:11
66 Posted 19/01/2014 at 11:52:20
How does this smack of desperation? There is a quality striker available for loan and this may well fit in with Martinez's plans to wait for the summer to see what the Lukaku situation is / bring in another striker when the market is more active.
His injury issue doesn't sound too much of a problem. A pull rather than a tear like Deulofeu has. Should be fit again within a few weeks. West Ham must have been confident that a work permit would have been granted, evidenced by how pissed of Allardyce was in the interview. Why shouldn't we hijack the deal if Monaco and the player would prefer us?
As with the deal for Lukaku under the noses of West Brom, its nice to see us being a little more shrewd and ruthless in our pursuit of quality players!
@Kunal Desai
I agree you have to be careful about what you read on Wikipedia. I think it is an amazing site, but I wish new submissions would be checked before they go live, rather than be removed retrospectively. This puts doubt into peoples minds and somewhat undermines the great effort people put into the site.
67 Posted 19/01/2014 at 12:06:45
68 Posted 19/01/2014 at 11:59:57
"People should not take notice of Wikipedia. Anyone can edit details on there."
I've just edited Wikipedia.
Liverpool are now a 3rd division Norwegian outfit, estd 2007 and struggling to stay afloat.
Their badge is a picture of Tarby with a thumbs-up gesture.
They don't have a stadium - only a park field covered in dog shite.
On match days they run out to the tune of, "Don't Leave Me This Way" By The Communards.
Their fans' website is called, "Gobshitia".
After the final whistle there is always a strident whining sound emanating from their end.
Their club motto is, "Ahrey, it's not our fault".
69 Posted 19/01/2014 at 12:13:53
70 Posted 19/01/2014 at 12:08:38
71 Posted 19/01/2014 at 12:31:15
I can get a ticket in with the Baggie fans but I'd rather be with the blue boys.
72 Posted 19/01/2014 at 11:16:56
Patrick and Mike, I checked out that picture of Merde Pardew.
What an anal plank he really is! Written all over his Kipper is "I know the answer whats the question?"
May well be in a different league.
73 Posted 19/01/2014 at 12:37:45
74 Posted 19/01/2014 at 12:29:37
Still a big club ? Don't make me laugh. This lot are making a mockery of one of football's greatest institutions . You don't get EL qualification on the cheap!
75 Posted 19/01/2014 at 12:33:45
76 Posted 19/01/2014 at 12:26:11
now have your way with Ratfuck Suarezs page........
There are four clubs in the Premier League that don't bring in Loans and for obvious$$$ rea$ons. So they, and everyone else, can shut it.
77 Posted 19/01/2014 at 13:08:29
i.e. close the gap on Chelski if we were to win on monday, Or should that be WHEN we win!!
78 Posted 19/01/2014 at 13:16:26
79 Posted 19/01/2014 at 13:18:48
I wouldn't argue with you about the board's lack of ambition, but Martinez can only work with what he is given and so far he has been doing an excellent job. I think the Watford comment is very unfair to him. So far he has loaned three excellent players. If this is what is required while he builds his squad then I'm all for it. After all, would you prefer Lukaku on loan for the season or Jelavic leading the line because he had a permanent contract?
I have yet to encounter anyone who has mocked Everton for their loan signings. In fact most fans I chat with have only good things to say about Martinez and the team, even Liverpool fans! I agree, it's sad that we are not amongst the financial elite, but our league position shows that we are still a big team in England and, on the pitch, we are heading in the right direction.
80 Posted 19/01/2014 at 13:38:25
I don't see the point in spending good money for a 10 goal a season striker. We need to put a marker down in the summer, the best chance of value is then, so I think it is all the better for keeping the powder dry until June
81 Posted 19/01/2014 at 13:26:09
Why do you moan so much about Everton making loan signings? It's obvious we do not have cash or more importantly, the status, to buy the likes of Lukaku. But this is my guessing, if Lukaku gets us into the CL then the generated cash and increased status will help us purchase the likes of Lukaku.
From an Everton point of view I cant see what the problem – however, if you're a Redshite twat, then your going to moan like fuck about anything that Everton do successfully. With the media crammed full with RS fuckers, who somehow call themselves football correspondents and pubs full of armchair RS fans, plus the likes of Twitter and Facebook also available to those across the park, then guess what, we are going to hear lots and lots and fucking lots of mooooaaaanning.
82 Posted 19/01/2014 at 13:49:36
1) January offers an insufficient market
2) We play a one striker formation, with a £25-30M striker playing there at the moment.
3) That striker may be available in the summer.
There will be £15-20M available to spend in the summer We are in a better position with wages, and money generated from outgoings, than we have been in a very long time. Traoré is a £10-15M striker, and will be a perfect backup for Lukaku until the summer.
I will be overjoyed if this comes off. I think we could do with an extra central midfielder player too, and even another back up centre-back if Heitinga goes, as Stones does not fill me with confidence.
83 Posted 19/01/2014 at 13:57:03
Your question shold be addressed to B. Kenwright. Goodison Park, Goodison Road, Walton, Liverpool. L4
84 Posted 19/01/2014 at 13:49:02
Virtually every manager out there tells us that January is a shit time to get players in, teams don't want to sell and decent players are just not available. Look at your favourite (OFM), he's got cash coming out of his arse and still is unable to get the players he wants.
What I'm watching leads me to believe that Martinez does have money, but he is being careful with it. He is giving us cover for key positions till the end of the season at a minimum cost, by bringing players worth £15M (Traoré) and £20M (Lukaku) to the club temporarily for small fees to enable us to keep pushing for the top 4.
At the end of the season, we will know if Gibson and Koné have recovered, whether Deulofeu is going to stay another year, if the Lukaku signing is a possibility and something we'd want to push. At that stage, we'll also know if we've got European football to attract a better quality of player than we're currently able to get. Oh and we'll probably get Barry for for free... such a shit loan he turned out to be.
Anyway, keep posting your negative views on our club and our manager, it's amusing to watch when the opposite of whatever you predict comes to pass.
85 Posted 19/01/2014 at 13:42:26
That's a cheap-jack policy very much in line with the Kitbag, catering and other quick fixes applied to everything the club touches. We have come to expect expediency being applied across the piece and Evertonians now buy into it as the norm.
Like you, I have loved most of the football we have played this season but suspect that, were it allowed, Roberto would be urged to field a whole team of loanees 'because that's the only way we can compete!'
But I guess as long as we win on Monday, nothing else matters much, does it? Blue Bill won't be the only grinning jackass, will he?
86 Posted 19/01/2014 at 14:07:33
"Our manager is dancing to the Board's tune just as his predecessor did"
"This lot are making a mockery of one of football's greatest institutions"
People, remove your hands from your ears, banish the blinkers from your eyes. Heed another wailing Walling warning.
He warned you Everton would become Wigan. He told you Martinez was a total tit in the transfer market. He deduced that Everton's defence would crumble like Joan Collins crumpet exposed to sunlight.
Only he dared speak the truth in a valiant attempt to illuminate the dark days ahead. Now, he returns to reveal the evils of the loan system and the deceptive machinations of our manager. Let a skeptical populace ignore him at their peril!
Seriously Phil, what happened? During Roberto's first press conference did you spot he had a mutated little finger stuck out an an unnatural angle or something?
It certainly seems like you're starring in your very own, long-running version of 'The Invaders':
(Cue intro)
"Du-du-der. Du-du-der. Du-du-derâ"
'The Martinez, alien being from a dying planet. His destination: Goodison. His purpose: to make it his world. Phil Walling has seen him.
For him, it began one lost night on a lonely country road, looking for a shortcut that he never found. It began with a closed deserted diner, and a man too long without sleep to continue his journey. It began with the landing of a craft from another galaxy.
Now Phil Walling knows that Martinez is here, that he has taken human form. Somehow he must convince a disbelieving world that the nightmare has already begun.'
It might be best to defer your declarations of doom until at least the end of the season. Especially when, thus far, they've proven about as deadly accurate as the A-Team in a shoot out.
Either that or continue your descent into becoming the fucking David Icke of ToffeeWeb.
87 Posted 19/01/2014 at 14:06:34
To get us on a par with the rich 6 or 7 teams from a style as well as a from a results perspective Martinez is doing EXACTLY what someone in his position needs to do for us which is to use EVERY weapon available to him to get us performing as good as we can.
He's not bitching that the club needs to borrow more cash to compete, like OFM did; he's being clever in his use of the loan market to bring in £40M or £50M of talent while he gets quality players like McGeady and Alcaraz in for peanuts.
Personally I'm overjoyed if Martinez can bridge the financial and quality gap using the loan market; I'd rather that than he go to Old Trafford mumbling about knives and gunfights.
88 Posted 19/01/2014 at 14:20:31
89 Posted 19/01/2014 at 13:47:56
It just shows that we have a switched on manager who resolves our shortcomings within the rules of the Premier League. How we get there is of no concern to me; how we stay there once we do (and we will), I still don't give a fuck – as long as we are shafting the so-called Premier League elite, and the obvious biased media of the darling clubs.
92 Posted 19/01/2014 at 14:18:33
"Drew: On one level, I agree with you and, of course, we should enjoy the moment. But I fear it is a false dawn as you cannot expect to build for the future whilst relying on other clubs' players."
I completely disagree with you. I believe that the loans Roberto has brought in are exactly what a club in Everton's financial position need. I think every club in the league outside the top six would jump at the chance to have Lukaku, Barry, Deulofeu and (possibly) Traoré in their teams. They just don't have the manager to make that happen.
In his first press conference, Martinez said his goal was to get Everton into the Champions League. I think most people (including myself) raised an eyebrow when they heard that, but it is now a distinct possibility. If he can pull it off then we will be in a position where we have the resources and status to bring in permanent signings of the same quality as these loans. The end justifies the means!
93 Posted 19/01/2014 at 14:31:31
95 Posted 19/01/2014 at 14:51:25
As you said but not so poetically.
96 Posted 19/01/2014 at 14:50:31
"He deduced that Everton's defence would crumble like Joan Collins crumpet exposed to sunlight."
Fuckin' brilliant.
97 Posted 19/01/2014 at 15:00:49
You just do not built for Europe on loan signings, believe me!
98 Posted 19/01/2014 at 15:04:12
http://www.bbc.com/sport/0/football/25800692
I think most of us want Baines to stay if possible. This would be most excellent and I like the way he works the media.
102 Posted 19/01/2014 at 15:20:56
105 Posted 19/01/2014 at 15:41:27
Just think, Phil, if we had done the usual trick and had not brought in Barry, Lakaku et al on loan, we could be mixing it with the lower-half teams. As someone else said, enjoy this season while it lasts.
106 Posted 19/01/2014 at 15:32:24
In the real world, we all have taken temp jobs or fixed term contracts, what's the difference? If it improves the team, then it can only help us.
Finishing 4th is not good enough, we need higher, I believe as others have said they will fuck us up If we played a CL qualifier. Collina went from one of the best referees to somebody I now think of as bent / dodgy.
COYB
108 Posted 19/01/2014 at 16:03:44
109 Posted 19/01/2014 at 16:03:18
110 Posted 19/01/2014 at 16:37:09
Barry will sign a contract and possibly we buy Lukaku. I think all the unknowns at the end of the season are having an impact on the transfer window.
Spurs won so we need a win tomorrow but I'm sure the team will go out and play as they do, their best.
I have to admit to an uneasy feeling about the game though as usually when they have not played in competition for a while, Everton start all over the place and we usually get a draw.
111 Posted 19/01/2014 at 16:51:07
Link to the piece this was from
http://www.getfootballnewsfrance.com/2014/lacina-traores-future-up-in-the-air-due-to-hamstring-injury/
112 Posted 19/01/2014 at 16:56:48
113 Posted 19/01/2014 at 17:00:47
114 Posted 19/01/2014 at 17:00:44
Why would he be going anywhere else apart from FF?
This does not ring true.
115 Posted 19/01/2014 at 17:05:31
116 Posted 19/01/2014 at 17:06:32
It's on Sky News 16:44 that indeed the player is at Everton having a medical.
Let's be honest, at that height he will take the attention of defenders and Lukaka can get lots of goals.
I hope we sign him.
117 Posted 19/01/2014 at 17:08:20
118 Posted 19/01/2014 at 17:04:55
119 Posted 19/01/2014 at 16:53:06
http://postimg.org/image/mk69ecfj9/
120 Posted 19/01/2014 at 17:12:25
121 Posted 19/01/2014 at 17:13:35
122 Posted 19/01/2014 at 17:05:19
Us? one striker, out of form, has been sold for good money. One exciting winger has jointed permanently, and a loanee, with a market value of 15mil? looks to be joining. Poor us eh? We are bringing in players, when others are not, and we are worse off? We are potentially testing players to purchase later, and we are worse off? we have improved the team, whilst cutting the wages, and leaving a good surplus for buying the striker we need in the summer, and if we win tomorrow, will move into fourth.
One more thing...this is not the 80s anymore. If you hadn't noticed, football has changed. In the 10 years prior to the Moyes era, we were a club more likely to get relegated than get into Europa. Stop longing for a status what is unrepresentative now. Personally, I'm proud of what we have achieved since, and proud of what we are doing this season. And I will have a massive grin on my face if Traore signs, if we sign the extra midfielder we need (a loan wont bother me), and if we win tomorrow.
123 Posted 19/01/2014 at 17:17:53
124 Posted 19/01/2014 at 17:24:14
125 Posted 19/01/2014 at 16:36:15
The world has changed Phil but you are not for moving. The fact of the matter is that there are a group of players available who may not be quite the pick of the crop because they are either not yet the finished article or they are on the down-slide of their abilities, and it may well be possible, through judicious selection and good coaching, to build a team that can challenge for European qualification.
The loan market appears to have changed radically (or perhaps we have only recently become aware of it) in that the really wealthy clubs are using it to develop their investments. Buying a promising player (or even one from your academy) and then loaning him out seems to have become the norm. It allows the parent club to recoup some of their outlay, lowers their overheads and the player gets decent game time and development they can't give him in-house. If this is a permanent trend, then clubs that can develop these fringe players become quite valuable to the mega rich ones, and we could use players from the foreign elite to make ourselves more competitive domestically until we are able to stand on our own two feet .
At the end of the day the player will go back to his parent club and, if he is good enough, stay there as a first choice player. If, however, the player is no longer wanted by his parent club then there is a chance that the relationship he has developed at his loan club will see him happy to move there permanently.
What Martinez has gotten from his use of the loan market so far is threefold. It has gotten us players who were not available to buy (and which we probably couldn't afford anyway) for immediate use which has made us more competitive than we would have been, and (due to the coaching and style of play) is giving us links / relationships with good players and elite teams that could easily benefit us in the future.
We came fourth in 2005 with a relatively inexpensive team (which proves your statement wrong in any case), but that was an unsustainable way of creating ongoing success.
126 Posted 19/01/2014 at 17:37:06
They have mega bucks to throw around and look less likely than we do to get CL football.
The second paragraph in Si's @215 post explains perfectly what is happening with us.
127 Posted 19/01/2014 at 17:40:35
128 Posted 19/01/2014 at 17:42:02
129 Posted 19/01/2014 at 17:34:59
130 Posted 19/01/2014 at 17:36:45
I'm not really au fait with a beanpole target man but let's give the lad a chance he'll obviously be on the bench his first few games and possibly be a different option if we are struggling in games so he'll give us something different.
Looks like Bobby has got a touch of the cat about him. The way he goes about his transfer business.
131 Posted 19/01/2014 at 17:50:17
132 Posted 19/01/2014 at 17:48:26
133 Posted 19/01/2014 at 17:58:53
134 Posted 19/01/2014 at 17:58:03
Like a 6-12 month test drive, where you get full use of the car, bu can just hand it back in the end.
135 Posted 19/01/2014 at 18:05:53
136 Posted 19/01/2014 at 18:05:03
137 Posted 19/01/2014 at 18:09:11
"While you gather your thoughts on the events at the Bridge, here's some news from another side interested at the top of the table, Everton. Lacina Traore is due to have medical at Everton. It was believed the 6ft 8in striker was on his way to West Ham. But Sam Allardyce confirmed yesterday that despite reaching an agreement with Monaco, to bring the 23-year-old on loan to Upton Park, it was unlikely the Ivory Coast international would complete the move."
138 Posted 19/01/2014 at 18:02:20
Martinez is doing this with better players. If we end up unable to buy them, their and our improvement is more likely to get us known as a place worth playing. If we end up buying them after finishing fourth......
Phil, I take your point about not building lasting success on loan players alone. You're right, it's a good, obvious thing to say. Bear in mind that Martinez has only been here a few months. On one level, its a punt to get us top four in his first season. on another level, its a way of getting us playing better football more quickly and making us more attractive to better players more quickly.
Like I've said previously, the better players want to play for a club playing attractive, successful, methodical football rather than one 'punching above its weight' and 'doing the numbers'.
139 Posted 19/01/2014 at 17:58:03
Or, just get a bus pass and ride a different vehicle each day ;-)
140 Posted 19/01/2014 at 18:20:34
141 Posted 19/01/2014 at 18:10:59
142 Posted 19/01/2014 at 18:18:59
143 Posted 19/01/2014 at 18:22:06
144 Posted 19/01/2014 at 18:13:34
Everton – and so many Evertonians – seems to have lost all their pride at the expense of expediency!
145 Posted 19/01/2014 at 18:29:06
147 Posted 19/01/2014 at 18:30:51
Unlike yourself Phil, Evertonians are actually enjoying watching the team, and getting behind Roberto and his signings.
Maybe you should start doing the same.
148 Posted 19/01/2014 at 18:30:25
Would the average person in said supermarket in Liverpool recognise a person that 99.9% of Everton fans hadn't even heard of (let alone seen a picture of)??
Would said millionaire allow a mobile photo to be taken?
Make your own minds up.
149 Posted 19/01/2014 at 18:32:47
150 Posted 19/01/2014 at 18:32:50
151 Posted 19/01/2014 at 18:40:54
152 Posted 19/01/2014 at 18:29:26
Don't get me wrong, Martinez has developed a team in the short time he has been with us that genuinely entertain and now have a decent outside chance of finishing 4th. This is the best squad we have had since the Premier League was started and optimism is now on the lips of every fan. If we do fall short due to the lack of monetary support, then it will be a shame for more than just the fans' sake. Finishing 4th brings money into the club coffers and make us much more attractive as an investment and also to attracting top players to join us.
I see the pundits talking about the top four and they still mention Man Utd and Spurs as contenders but we are never talked about seriously. I don't really mind as its nice to be sneaking along on the outside keeping in touch with the front runners. I wish Roberto could acquire a few really good players and really shake up the supposedly top clubs. But he needs support and that is another story methinks!
153 Posted 19/01/2014 at 18:41:07
154 Posted 19/01/2014 at 18:22:09
Clearly a better manager like Martinez can make do with less finance than a poor one, but he needs some, especially during the transition.
People seem to think that having a 'quiet' January window is no big deal because it will leave us up to £20m net to spend in the summer. If we actually spent that amount, net of proceeds, in the summer, we would just about have spent what we have raised net in the past year or so – in other words, we would still not have made a net transfer investment. But I think the chances of us even spending £20m net are very low. That isn't our business model.
If that is so, then quite how far RM can take us on smoke and mirrors is anybody's guess. It's not impossible to get CL the way he is having to go about it, just very challenging. If nothing else, it should be a fun ride, more so than in the Moyes days, but equally I really don't see why a sense of realism about our circumstances is so misplaced.
155 Posted 19/01/2014 at 18:47:46
156 Posted 19/01/2014 at 18:52:24
157 Posted 19/01/2014 at 18:50:29
159 Posted 19/01/2014 at 18:53:51
........ to a tax haven for 2 weeks, there is something very fishy about all this.
pay 15m and then in 2 weeks off he goes on loan. Money laundering for sure.
160 Posted 19/01/2014 at 18:56:32
161 Posted 19/01/2014 at 18:39:34
What I see are the first steps being taken to regain our pride and our place as one of the big clubs. Loan players can get us into Europe and we can use the money to buy our own top class players until we reach the point that we don't need loans anymore.
Simple really.
162 Posted 19/01/2014 at 18:58:19
And as for him who accused me of being RS, I'll pitch my 40odd season ticket stubs etc against anything he can produce.
I just don't row along with all this euphoria about a fouth loan signing is all!
163 Posted 19/01/2014 at 19:09:22
Geoff, don't know, can't see the evidence on here for that, but it would be for him to answer.
Certainly I don't see a sense of realism and a desperate desire to restore the club to its former lofty perch as mutually exclusive positions.
164 Posted 19/01/2014 at 19:08:53
There are opportunities for us to sign these loanees if things go really well. Like Lukaku when it was unlikely just a month ago. What's he going to do with Matic, Eto'o, Torres there and possibly Rooney and Costa on the way? I am suspecting the same for Deulofeu as well, though that has more ways to go before a real story for him to sign with us can emerge. Look on the bright side, loan signings are like signings on 1 year deals. We've players signed and wanted out for less than 1 year. We'll be fine.
Def agree with many on the need for investment though.
165 Posted 19/01/2014 at 19:23:28
166 Posted 19/01/2014 at 19:34:15
If you look at Roberto's signings so far they have all been either loans or older players. There's no long term future in Lukaku, Defoulou, Alcaraz or Kone.
So far only McCarthy looks like he could be in the future of Everton. I suppose McGeedy is a player who could be around a few years but he'll be 28 soon.
I really think Roberto needs to give up on this short term philosophy and start thinking about a 5 year plan. That's what David Moyes used to do and he was always unearthing gems like Stones, Coleman and George Green.
167 Posted 19/01/2014 at 19:35:39
Moyesy would of never done it, he'd of rather spent what little funds on not the best players and build year by year and not get us anywhere. Don't get me wrong, when he sold players he replaced him with good ones more often than not, but he'd of never tried for the likes of Barry, Lukaku & Deulofeu!
Martinez sees the bigger picture, he sees that these good players for other clubs that aren't in there plans, would be good enough for us and help us along our way to where we want to be and I applaud him for that!
Spend a bit here and there and fill the squad out, then get some good loan signings in to make the team better. And IF it gets us to the CL then thanks very much for there help, we'll be quids in and then possibly try and sign one or 2 of them on a permanent deal along with some other class players now that weve got a fair bit of money due to the new tv deal AND champions league money?!
For me, you do what you can to make your team competitive and good enough to challenge for things and Martinez as done that with one or 2 loans here and there and IF we do end up qualifying for the CL, it could be a real turning point for us and the direction we go in with the funds that will be generated from such a scenario?!.
168 Posted 19/01/2014 at 19:42:55
169 Posted 19/01/2014 at 19:44:44
170 Posted 19/01/2014 at 19:41:40
171 Posted 19/01/2014 at 19:47:42
172 Posted 19/01/2014 at 19:42:24
173 Posted 19/01/2014 at 19:45:12
174 Posted 19/01/2014 at 19:26:48
"Do multi-millionaires with entourages stop off at supermarkets in Hutyon?"
Yes, if they are peckish after their medical
"Do multi-millionaires with entourages even do their own shopping?"
Yes, all the time!
"Would the average person in said supermarket in Liverpool recognise a person that 99.9% of Everton fans hadn't even heard of (let alone seen a picture of)??"
Yes. I think 99.9% of Evertonian's would now recognize a 6'8" Ivorian with a distinct orange stipe on his head, especially after seeing dozens of images of him on the news sites and watching videos of him on You Tube.
"Would said millionaire allow a mobile photo to be taken?"
Well he did try and disguise himself (tough task) with his hood up, but what can he do? Grab the phone and smash it? Not the best way to endear himself to his new teams supporters!
"Make your own minds up."
I rest my case.
@Phil Walling
I respect your right to an opinion, it just seems like your trying to wind people up with your negative attitude. Of course we would all like to see us spending money on players but what money we do have we have to spend wisely and January might not be the best time and might not fit in with Martinez's long term plans for developing the squad. Surely its better to bring in quality loan players in the short term and bring in the permanent ones when they become available at a sensible price.
I think a majority of supporters (certainly on ToffeeWeb) feel noting but pride and anticipation in the direction our club is now heading in and that's why your comments are drawing such a backlash. As a long standing season ticket holder you have every right to your opinion, I just can't get my head around why you see this as a negative thing. Sure, if other fans were mocking us for our loans it would wrangle, but in my experience nobody has a bad thing to say about Everton at the moment.
175 Posted 19/01/2014 at 19:56:09
176 Posted 19/01/2014 at 19:59:29
178 Posted 19/01/2014 at 19:55:11
Slow, cumbersome, can't head, 'shit feet for a big man', languid...I trust RM and I'd back him whoever he signed...but this lad looks hopeless to me.
179 Posted 19/01/2014 at 19:53:52
Why TOO much faith?
And how has what we've had from our loan players ONLY benefited the parent clubs?
Seems (from the small number of hits) not many listened to RM on the Followtonians podcast on youtube.
They should have imo as RM explains why loans are nothing to fear and (for us) make perfect sense.
For anyone who wants to be better informed regarding our manager's thinking on loans (and many other Everton-related subjects) I suggest a listen.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fTpIh_0h-WQ
180 Posted 19/01/2014 at 19:59:09
181 Posted 19/01/2014 at 20:08:54
182 Posted 19/01/2014 at 20:12:09
183 Posted 19/01/2014 at 20:10:38
I think we will need to wait until the summer before we start judging our board and Martinez on the future direction of our squad.
184 Posted 19/01/2014 at 20:15:32
Dick, you say "I really think Roberto needs to give up on this short-term philosophy and start thinking about a 5-year plan".
I actually think Roberto has a short-term and a long-term plan. Both of which aim to make us actually win a trophy rather than just maintain our status as "best of the rest".
Surely a long-term plan from a manager who won nothing, was not a successful plan. Why not embrace a change of strategy, which, let's face it, is already reaping huge rewards both in terms of results, style and level of performance.
185 Posted 19/01/2014 at 20:28:53
186 Posted 19/01/2014 at 20:36:32
187 Posted 19/01/2014 at 20:48:04
I can only lead a horse to water.
188 Posted 19/01/2014 at 20:45:12
189 Posted 19/01/2014 at 19:53:33
When you got your first flat or house did anyone give you any stuff to furnish to make do until you were in a position to get better quality ? I'll bet quite a few on this site did . It's the reality of life.
The same with loan players.
Pragmatism is the combination of reality and idealism . Roberto is pragmatic.
None of us know how much money he has available.Whatever it is I trust him to spend it as if bit his own. Wiseley.
If he sees players that he doesn't think are in" the Everton mould " he won't bring them in .
I've watched Everton now for nearly sixty years.
I was a mere codling when I started and now I'm a grumpy old sole. I am no wiser or erudite than any other poster but I might have seen a bit more ,it's all about opinions ,everone is different no one is right or wrong
Andy# 222 Just given your age away!! T.Hewitt Edward--TheCat .
Harry Catterick never disclosed anything about his dealings until the player was signed ,sealed and delivered in an Everton shirt.
Players and supporters in Europe and round the World follow the EPL avidly. What can they see at the top of the league ? All the monied teams, all the usual suspects but wait !! Everton !!! ??? Everton-who?? Who are they ? For a long time now we've been a forgotten team (but not by us Bluenoses )
We are now playing attractive,purposefull, exciting football thanks to Bobby Brown Shoes.
It will make players and viewers want to play for us and support us.
The season so far has been exciting,however,whatever happens from now till the end of May I know I won't be disappointed. He's put a spring in my zimmer!! (no. it's not a Russian car)
With our previous manager you knew what to expect,but Roberto has given us something we haven't had for along,long time---expectations.
190 Posted 19/01/2014 at 21:03:55
191 Posted 19/01/2014 at 21:01:08
So we ship out all but our top squad players and sign up other clubs''surplus to requirements'. Can that really be seen as 'building a squad' to bring us anything but very short-term success.
A year ago, this situation would have been met with derision but a few wins and a lot of smooth talking and we be glory bound !
And ain't all those BK protest groups quiet these days? Guess they've bought into 'the philosophy' too, eh?
193 Posted 19/01/2014 at 21:20:06
194 Posted 19/01/2014 at 21:21:35
"Traoré moved to France from Anzhi Makhachkala last summer for a whopping £15m but has yet to play a game in Ligue 1"
He only joined Monaco on the 4th of Jan this year.
195 Posted 19/01/2014 at 21:29:22
However what he misses is that sometimes a short term solution can be part of a long term plan. I for one believe RM has a pretty good idea of what he's doing and if these short term solutions get us into or near the CL places then we will be better placed to spend what money we have this Summer and RM will have a much clearer idea of what we need. I'm not sure I want to see us loaning 4 or 5 players every year but while we are in transition and RM is identifying who at the club fits and what he needs to bring then I'm fine with it.
In short, this is good news.
198 Posted 19/01/2014 at 21:39:58
If Moyes had us playing this football, on this points tally at this stage of the season then he would have been roundly cheered.
That is a fact.
199 Posted 19/01/2014 at 21:40:19
201 Posted 19/01/2014 at 21:45:32
Lukaku has already stated he'd be interested in a permanent move if we got CL football, Deulofeu has an additional year in the offing and who is to say that if Barca don't think he's going to compete with Messi and Neymar in 18 months time, we end up with a permanent deal for him too?
In the meantime, youngsters such as Stones and Barkley are getting game time and experience, Roberto is able to pick up permanent gems such as McGeady for relatively little, cover for long-term injuries to Kone and Gibson, and he's also able to ship out deadwood he doesn't rate such as Anichebe Jelavic and Heitinga.
Of course in Phil Wallings world none of this is necessary or makes sense. Why don't we just go and buy other teams "not surplus to requirements"? Lets go bid £30M for Rooney. Oh wait, we don't have £30M and Rooney probably wouldn't move to a club not in Europe. Lets not get facts in the way of a good argument tho.
Moyes also used the loan system to get us players like Arteta and Pienaar....and I disagree with Sam that people would have complained. I don't recall many complaints then. What does piss me and others off is when we get utter shite like McFadden, Hitz and Straq coming in who add nothing to the squad other than bodies on the bench. Roberto's loans are players of better quality than is available to us in the transfer market as permanent signings and I've no problem with this at all.
If Roberto wants to use up our 4 loan slots next season and sign us Messi, Ronaldo, Hazard and Mata I'm not going to complain on principle like some people are doing just because somehow "loans are shit"....although I happen to agree with Sam that the loans we're seeing at the moment are part of a long term plan that Roberto has in mind and are therefore even more acceptable.
202 Posted 19/01/2014 at 22:02:27
Going to a different sport, Rugby Super League, since the salary cap came in, it has stopped clubs dominating and given other clubs a much fairer chance and anyone who follows the sport will see not one club is now dominating in Super League.
We all know Sky dominates football and would never bring in a salary cap as this would dampen their little Sky darlings' chances of dominating, season-in & season-out, but the likes of the big clubs with mega-rich owners can sign players just to stop teams close from strengthening.
Anyone who looks to Bayern Munich is a perfect example, they have openly admitted if a team gets close to challenging in the league, they will sign a player from that team just to weaken it.
Now is the time to give a fairer ruling to help the clubs outside the big four.
Cut down the amount of players you can sign and loan out.
203 Posted 19/01/2014 at 22:20:33
204 Posted 19/01/2014 at 22:27:25
205 Posted 19/01/2014 at 22:18:28
206 Posted 19/01/2014 at 21:47:15
Where are we getting that kind of money?. What has miraculously changed in the past 12 months to allow us this kind of spending?.. Nothing.
Are long term future is our youth set up.
It's not spending what little we have on some fly by night player who will be invisible in 12 months.
A player we buy because we just have to, because it's the transfer window, because we have some money so we must spend it, because our team is crap even though we'll probably be fourth tomorrow, because if we don't the wheels fall off and we'll finish 8th..
Yeah, I had to spend all my pocket money when I was ten too.
Well, we had this argument when we signed Beattie, when we signed Jelavic.
Do you think maybe Roberto might be trying something a little different?
Maybe signing the mercenaries on loan rather than have them hanging around sucking us dry for what little money we have because we are unable to off load them, i:e Heitinga, might be a good idea.
The argument about a players loyalty is crap. A good footballer will play well whether you have him for 6 months or 6 years.
207 Posted 19/01/2014 at 22:44:57
208 Posted 19/01/2014 at 22:48:08
209 Posted 19/01/2014 at 22:56:17
210 Posted 19/01/2014 at 23:00:59
We need cover. There aren't many players around. We don't have much to spend. Seems like a good idea.
He's everso tall.
211 Posted 19/01/2014 at 22:11:13
213 Posted 19/01/2014 at 23:43:19
I'm not a fan of salary caps, but hoarding players and loaning out 25+ every season shows there's an issue.
If there were limits to the number of loans out from a club each season, we could actually own Lukaku and not help make Chelsea or Barca or Monaco in this case stronger for next season.
214 Posted 19/01/2014 at 23:56:01
215 Posted 20/01/2014 at 00:16:24
216 Posted 20/01/2014 at 00:30:01
It isn't ideal because it isn't as good as being able to bring in the players with a view of how they might form a unit for the next 3 - 5 years, but things being as they are I am all for us making use of every resource we can.
As for Lacina Traore; I am a little surprised at the move (should it be confirmed) as it doesn't look like we would have been in the race if West Ham hadn't hesitiated. I am assuming that RM had him on the radar as an option and struck when it was opportune. Isn't there the possibility of an additional 12 months after the initial 6 months? Maybe that possibility of longevity made it a much more attractive proposition?
217 Posted 20/01/2014 at 00:29:33
218 Posted 20/01/2014 at 01:39:36
Remember Anichebe's turn and shoot goal. What's he so famous for?
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oIiBdZPt7Qo
219 Posted 20/01/2014 at 02:17:14
220 Posted 20/01/2014 at 00:23:21
1. The loan system's benefit to Everton
This is patently benefitting Everton this season in that it's allowed us to get in 3 cracking players we couldn't have otherwise afforded, who have all improved our first team squad and are helping our push for a CL spot.
If Lukaku does go back to Chelsea and Delboy returns this season to Barcelona, then, well so what? Will we have to forfeit the points they helped us earn or the european place? Err, no.
Will we have to find replacement players, err yes probably, but then we could always loan more in or buy others, that's player trading. It's also assuming that we won't buy at the end, which I think we will in one case at least (Barry - the player I'd say that actually makes the must consistent difference to our side out of the 3)
1.2 Benefits to other clubs
Will Chelsea and Barcelona be better off for having more players in their squad who's experience and transfer value has been increased? Possibly, yes. But why do we care about that? If we've got benefit and they've got benefit, isn't that the essence of a win-win situation? And doesn't it make it more likely other clubs will want to loan to us?
1.3 The whole concept of player 'ownership'
I think there's a basic misconception about player ownership outlined in some of the comments above. Clubs don't own footballers ever, they only ever rent them for the length of their contract (or rather the length minus the final 12/18 months and as long as the player is actually happy). Buying players outright is far more costly than loaning in the main, necessitating lots of upfront costs + ongoing payments regardless of the quality of the player or performance.
Of course we want to hang onto star players who can impact the team positively and on the business front having an 'appreciating' asset is always good. But for every Barkley, Baines or Coleman you have to remember there's a Billy, Yakubu or Van der Meyde to balance it out where the player simply hasn't performed and his value has markedly decreased.
What's more, even when the player is under a regular contract and their transfer value is raising, the clock is ticking on that value. Every month that passes can chip a little more off the value, more markedly so when the contract gets toward the 12 month point and the spectre of a Bosman deal drives all that value downward again and offers most of the power to the player. Hence the asset you've protected and grown (partly through loaning them out perhaps?) starts to rapidly shrink again (and this isn't to even consider players going on strike, being disruptive or just playing badly to force a move).
Supposed assets like our own Heitinga or any of the players mentioned in this piece (http://www.mirror.co.uk/sport/football/news/best-free-agents-25-players-2980488#.UtySDmTFInU) become virtually worthless as they play out their contracts, all the while their wages tick along.
Don't even get me started on the need to pay up a chunk of the players contract or offer a loyalty bonus when they are transferred out...
My point with all this is that the whole own/loan situation is just not so black and white as it's being painted. One way or another football clubs are always just renting players and the economics are complex as to what represents the best value both on the field and in the books (we won't be able to sell Lukaku like we did Jelavic of course and we can't rely on him being here next season, but then again we didn't have to pay for Lukaku based on his market value in the first place and we're not tied to him if he loses his form).
2. Martinez has somehow weakened the squad with his transfer dealings...
I just don't see evidence of this at all.
Putting aside Jelavic who will be replaced, this summer we've had...
Out: Fellaini, Victor Anichebe, Jan Mucha and Phil Neville
In: McCarthy, Kone, Robles and Alcaraz
That's 4 players out, including a keeper who never played, a defender who was retiring anyway and a striker who had his moments but wasn't exactly our first choice dream. Granted Fellaini was an important first team player but he was agitating for a move and was plainly less suited to the new managers plans plus we got an absolute fortune for him.
And how many have we got in? Oh yes 4 players. And what positions are they? Ah right, so pretty much exactly the same then...with the exception that they are actually better suited to our new game and generally, well, better.
In addition to this we've had 3 absolutely top draw loan players come in to balance out the one expiring loan of the decidedly average and at the end of his career Hitzlsperger.
So far in January, we've sold our back-up striker who'd hardly scored in 18 months on and brought in another winger with at least 1 striker apparently soon to follow (admittedly on loan initially).
Quite how that equates with weakening the squad is beyond me.
221 Posted 20/01/2014 at 03:51:57
As for Lukaku, Delboy and Traore it seems possible that all three will be allowed to stay with us for another season, if not, why not just enjoy them whilst there here?
If the gloom and doom merchants are worried now, what the hell were they like during the Walter Smith and some of the Moyes years? Jeez they must of been bordering on suicidal.
222 Posted 20/01/2014 at 04:36:21
But the difference is when a club owns a player's registration it can recoup money from selling that registration, but when a player is on loan the club does not recoup anything.
Same like the argument about buying vs. renting a house.
223 Posted 20/01/2014 at 04:57:57
Chris, while it doesn't directly weaken the team, it adds uncertainty of whether you'll have the player after the current loan expires. I'm sure we agree most people hate uncertainty so I can see fans being negative to that. I like the loan system, especially when the market is so distorted by oil money. No way we can outbid any UCL teams if we're targeting the same player. Loans make for a good test drive with possibility to sign them later in some cases.
224 Posted 20/01/2014 at 05:04:14
And when a player, or manager, does honour their contract they get abuse for it too
225 Posted 20/01/2014 at 04:59:23
Chelsea paid what, £17m for Lukaku? I've seen reports of us paying anything up to £6m for the season loan, plus his wages.
Last season he was on loan at West Brom. No idea what they paid for him, but lets say £3m plus wages?
It's feasible that Chelsea could loan him again next season, as the "final" part of his development before he's ready. And lets say they again get £6m plus wages for him after he fires the Toffees to a top 4 finish....
So they signed a young teenager and planned to loan him out for most of the first long term contract he signed with them. In doing so they recouped most of the transfer fee and had little wage liability during that time.
So, extrapolating your buying v renting, it's buy to let? At least till you're ready to live in it (but after getting the mortgage almost paid off in 3 years!)
All of this probably helps Chelsea out in their FFP statements. Only the top clubs that amass these young players can do this. All those bitching about the loan system are crying because its not working for them. RS borrowed Moses off Chelsea remember! I'll bet Chelsea were banking on Suarez not being their and their title/top 4 challenge being over by Xmas.
226 Posted 20/01/2014 at 05:17:26
And the same Matt, yes buy to let helps out the loaning club, but not the borrower financially.
227 Posted 20/01/2014 at 05:45:54
When you look at Total Cost of Ownership of a player, a £10m player on a 5-year contract of £60k/week has a rough TCO of £25m, or £5m / year. You can recover some of that if the player is sold, or you can extend the contract to sell at some future point.
The difference between the monied clubs and the rest is they have large squads - Chelsea have around 23 players out on loan at the moment? That's a whole EPL squad. Granted, some are youth players, and not all are on loan at top flight clubs in whatever country they're in.
Most clubs loan players to aid their development. The loan system is failing as the monied clubs are loaning players to improve financial trading figures - but to get that £6m fee and £2-3m wages covered the player has to be worth it and the borrowing club has to be desperate, to a degree. Also, how many prem clubs have players on loan to other Prem teams? Chelsea, RS and VIlla are the only ones I can think of.
In Lukaku's case we were probably sufficiently desperate knowing that at that time a) Jelavic couldn't score in a brothel and b) Kone isn't a 20 goal a season striker. That's why we out-bid WBA for Lukaku. But spending £8-9m a year on loaning players has got to be very short-term for Everton. Luckily, we have a track record in short-term finanical planning.
228 Posted 20/01/2014 at 05:50:03
I misread your statement earlier. The first time I read it I thought you're thinking that loans are bad for parent clubs because you mentioned about owning the registration. Fortunately my previous statement was a bit generic so not a hard save.
Yes, the fees are a downside but minor compared to an outright buy. Plus wages is shared among the 2 clubs, so the burden of buying a player is minimized. I would think of it as signing a free agent on a one year contract, except the player is registered with a club. I like the example by Iain #437 and I think that would be an example of buying Lukaku vs. loaning. Much like, do you want to spend 5m for 1 year or stuck with 20m for 5 years? And if we're lucky, like in Barry's case, we could get him for free and lower wages (I hope).
229 Posted 20/01/2014 at 07:41:30
If you consider it as buying a leasehold property that only has 4-5 years left on the contract, that analogy might work a bit better, although even then your house doesn't just walk off at the end of the leasehold (you have a legally supported right to agree an extension to the loan) and is unlikely to go on strike or agitate to be sold to another homeowner.
230 Posted 20/01/2014 at 08:49:02
Cheeky one!
231 Posted 20/01/2014 at 09:06:43
232 Posted 20/01/2014 at 08:02:56
1. The housing analagy is flawed. Players are ultimately a wasting asset (but have periods of growth (sometimes) depending on form/age). They have very high running costs (wages) which houses do not ( imagine a rates bill equal to 25% of the value of a house every year!). They are a terrible asset class to invest in.
2. Chelsea etc are not trying to make money from the loan system as some kind of independent revenue stream. This is far too risky (given point 1 above).
3. Yes, Phil Walling, we know we do not have as much money as other leading clubs... to repeat this is nether interesting nor illuminating. You could say everything is pointless until we have a billionaire owner or some other source of massive wealth. Or you could choose to enjoy what we have.
233 Posted 20/01/2014 at 09:31:53
Tyias Browning
Matthew Kennedy
Chris Long
Matthew Pennington
Hallam Hope
John Lundstram
Shane Duffy
Luke Garbutt
Francisco Junior
234 Posted 20/01/2014 at 09:35:23
Our development of youth is paramount for me.
235 Posted 20/01/2014 at 09:39:25
3 Loan signings with 1 potentially looking at turning permanent with every Evertonian hoping Lukaku also turns permanent. Already talk of Deulofeu having another season with us and as such we'll be in the same position next season if we do qualify for Europe with money in the bank.
236 Posted 20/01/2014 at 09:51:22
237 Posted 20/01/2014 at 08:56:21
"Funny how after less than a dozen wins everybody is buying into this cheapskate policy which smacks so much of BK economics!"
I think everyone is buying into Martinez's philosophy of attractive attacking possession football that gets results and is a joy to watch. That doesn't mean people have forgotten about the bigger issues, but we support Everton for the enjoyment it brings us, not the frustration of the boards mismanagement. Would gambling a heap of cash guarantee us Champions League football? Not necessarily. I'm happy to see us get Traore in on loan and hopefully one other signing in midfield and see where we are in the summer. Then we can continue to build.
If we are successful on the pitch then we will be in a much better position for a takeover. Spending money we don't have would only see us heading in the same direction as Leeds, Bolton and a dozen other teams who have disappeared over recent years. Kenwright is always going to be frugal, but my main concern is stability and building towards our goals. At the moment that is what he is delivering.
"So we ship out all but our top squad players and sign up other clubs''surplus to requirements'. Can that really be seen as 'building a squad' to bring us anything but very short-term success."
Which of our top squad players have we lost? Fellaini is the only one of real quality and we got a great deal for him. All of those leaving have been replaced by better players (not including the loans). Granted the loans are surplus to requirements at their parent clubs, but that does not mean they are not top quality players. It is more of an indication that the likes of Chelsea and Man City have too much money.
Short-term success could be the springboard we need to to build for the future. Martinez has already brought in/through players like McCarthy, Stones and Barkley who will be part of our long-term future and I would expect to see him investing in more exciting youngsters and bringing through more from the academy in the near future.
"A year ago, this situation would have been met with derision but a few wins and a lot of smooth talking and we be glory bound !"
I disagree. I would have been delighted if Moyes had got these players in and if we had finished two places higher up the table!
"And ain't all those BK protest groups quiet these days? Guess they've bought into 'the philosophy' too, eh?"
If it works (ie, Wins us the FA Cup and gets us into the CL) then I will buy into it! I think there is a difference between supporting our great new manager and having doubts about the owner. To be fair, though, I don't see these loans as an indication that BK isn't willing to spend. I think there is money there, but I believe Martinez is biding his time until the summer when he can spend it wisely. These loans are a pragmatic solution. I like pragmatism if it gets results! Obviously the stadium is still a big issue, but if we are heading in the right direction then I'm willing to give the club time.
238 Posted 20/01/2014 at 09:58:38
239 Posted 20/01/2014 at 10:19:33
240 Posted 20/01/2014 at 11:14:15
@Phil Walling
I suspect you may do a bit of moaning ;)
I just can't understand how getting a £15m rated striker in until the summer and then spending on the player we really want for the future is a bad strategy! Time will tell I guess.
241 Posted 20/01/2014 at 11:20:38
242 Posted 20/01/2014 at 11:20:07
These loans – just like all the others this Board are committed to – don't come cheap and merely paper over the cracks in the short term. Even if Roberto does pull off the miracle of EL qualification via this tactic, do you really believe he will be able to loan a way through the preliminary stages.
It just sickens me how the PTB seem to see borrow, borrow, borrow as the ONLY way to run such a great institution.
243 Posted 20/01/2014 at 11:23:07
I don't know if I'm wrong with this notion... but, could we be looking at the best transfer window in the league? Hull have arguably improved more, but have any of the teams in the top half done as much as we have when/if Traore comes in? And I wouldn't be surprised if we get another through the door either (the centre-mid we need for cover).
Our potential first 11 and bench:
Howard, Coleman, Jagielka, Distin, Baines, Barry, McCarthy, Mirallas, Barkley, Deulofeu, Lukaku (just to show off the attacking talent... for balance I'd have Pienaar).
Bench: Robles, Oviedo, Pienaar, Alcaraz, McGeady, Osman, Traoré.
That looks damn impressive, and not in bad shape ahead of a match which could take us 4th, and a possible cup run. The irritating part is going to our biggest rivals for 4th imo, without Barkley, Deulofeu, a fit Traore, or a match-fit McGeady.
I think we have good reason to be happy at the moment.
244 Posted 20/01/2014 at 11:36:18
1) He has injury worries – we've already bought three "sicknotes" in Gibson, Kone and Alcaraz
2) At 6ft 8in he will simply be the battering ram you chuck on with 15 mins left when we are losing and RM needs to go direct
3) the biggest factor that worries me... Allardyce wants him!!
245 Posted 20/01/2014 at 11:44:20
And some people are still finding things to moan about. Sheesh.
246 Posted 20/01/2014 at 11:38:15
247 Posted 20/01/2014 at 11:46:14
248 Posted 20/01/2014 at 11:43:10
I can't claim to be an expert on Traore but, from what I have seen on YouTube, it doesn't look like Anzhi employed him as a target man to pump balls over the top to. In fact, I have only seen one headed goal from him. A lot of the goals on YouTube were created by Traore himself taking on players and using his pace, strength and balance to get past the opposition, much like Lukaku does.
Sure the Premier League is a step up and I'm not saying he's a guaranteed star, but Martinez obviously sees a player who can add to our attacking options and Anzhi and Monaco wouldn't have have spent €18M and €15M if he didn't have talent.
All players get minor injuries so that shouldn't be a big concern. To balance my argument, I was a big advocate for signing Koné, so I'm not claiming to be right every time! That said, I still think Koné will come good for us next season.
249 Posted 20/01/2014 at 11:42:14
Have to say, I disagree with you as follows:
1) You say players are an appalling asset class to invest in. That is patently untrue. The business models of most professional clubs and pretty much all clubs outside the top leagues, depend on investing in player assets and player trading.
2) I'm not entirely sure of this, but I think Chelsea are indeed trying to create a revenue stream from loans. They are less publicised than transfer fees, but I suspect the size of loan fees are on the increase. FFP might be having an effect on this.
3) I think it is possible to both enjoy what we have but also be critical of the board's lethargy and risk aversion, as well as their periodic dissembling. Who else holds them to account but us, the fans?
250 Posted 20/01/2014 at 11:57:02
If you take a look at the link I added on post 549, it is clear that Martinez does have money to spend, now or in the summer. He just feels it is more prudent to bide his time and wait for the right players, using the loan of Traoré to tide us over.
Barry has been loaned in with a view to signing him up on a permanent deal in the summer. Lukaku was an inspired loan signing. Where would we be without his goals. If we qualify for the Champions League we may be in a position to bid for him. He is clearly enjoying his time here. Without the relationship he has built with Martinez, the team and the fans such a move would be highly unlikely. If we can't get him in the summer then Martinez will spend the money on another talented striker to replace him.
Deulofeu is like the wildcard in a World Cup squad. Okay, there is very little chance of us signing him permanently, but it is great to see Everton building relationships with top teams like Barcelona.
Until we find someone to invest in Everton I'm afraid we have to be pragmatic and creative with our resources. Cash is such a massive factor in today's game and by rights we shouldn't be anywhere near the Champions League spots with our resources. Surely the fact that we are proves that Martinez's strategy is working. That's not to say I'm enamoured with the way Kenwright is running our club and I do share your concerns about the board. We do need a change if we ever want to win the league again, but that doesn't mean we can't enjoy what is happening in the here and now!
251 Posted 20/01/2014 at 12:10:08
252 Posted 20/01/2014 at 11:27:11
OK, many fans are expecting too much too soon and many will moan if we don't get top 4, win a trophy.or finish above the RS and United. What they won't moan about is feeling happy and positive throughout the season, for the first time in decades — and, when the window closes, it might get even better. Roll on.
253 Posted 20/01/2014 at 12:53:05
Brilliant
254 Posted 20/01/2014 at 12:41:38
We can't buy these top quality players outright, we haven't got the youth ready (yet), and RM has bigger plans than simply buying to stay stable as OFM did.
For me, RM is impressing on all fronts – playing style, youth policy, transfers, media, club PR.
255 Posted 20/01/2014 at 13:14:42
I will not be happy however if we still have 3 or 4 loan players as essential parts of our starting line ups at the start of next season.
256 Posted 20/01/2014 at 13:47:47
257 Posted 20/01/2014 at 13:46:21
I read your link. I hope you will forgive the likes of me and Phil Walling if we plan to wait until we actually see £40m net spending in the next transfer window- or even half that. Personally I don't think that will happen.
I agree Martinez is doing an excellent job but I think it is possible to both enjoy the football we're playing right now, but also to have 100% cynicism about any spending and investment by our board/shareholders. Like Phil, I'm bored of hearing Bill say the money we generated in this window, will be there to spend in the next window. It never is.
258 Posted 20/01/2014 at 13:49:07
And he knew a thing or two about turkeys.
259 Posted 20/01/2014 at 13:54:03
What won't work is player trading for profit of the type we've seen in the past 5 years or so, together with increasing loan players- that's just asset stripping.
It is likely to stop working entirely when the other clubs start seeing you as a direct threat. If you qualify for CL, that will include Europe's top teams too. If you want some evidence of this, count how many at the EPL's top teams are loan players. Perhaps this might explain some people's frustration on here. We aspire to be CL, yet seem to have to rely increasingly on loans, which are really the province of the next level down.
260 Posted 20/01/2014 at 14:00:25
261 Posted 20/01/2014 at 14:03:12
I agree with your point. Clearly money is coming in from transfers and not all of it is being re-invested. I think you are right to be cynical as there's years of evidence to back it up.
My argument on this thread is against the negativity to Martinez's use of the loan system to benefit the team, not a defence of the board. I realise the two are linked, but Martinez does not control the clubs finances so there has to be a divide between criticism of the way the club is run on the financial level and how it is run on the playing level.
262 Posted 20/01/2014 at 14:12:46
Best laugh I've had all day. Oh, wait...you were being serious?
263 Posted 20/01/2014 at 14:00:47
The value of housing fluctuates also and can go down, so can be a wasting asset also.
And rates are not the only running costs of houses, what about that damp problem caused by the gutters? Or the subsidence? Or the burst pipes? (What does a plumber cost these days??) Or the high running costs because the roof's not insulated and there's no double glazing? And the cost of lawnmowers is ridiculous — according to our accounts.
264 Posted 20/01/2014 at 13:51:57
(a) Lukaku — a young player who Chelsea want to be given experience in the Premier League and is out of our price range;
(b) Deulofeu — a youth player from Barcelona who want him to gain experience and is not expected to get in the first team and too good for the youth team; and...
(c) Barry — a player that Man City do not even want and would have been lucky to get on the bench.
I do not like the loan system but, as Everton are not breaking any rules, you have to accept it. The people who are making snide remarks are not taking in to account the great job the manager is doing with the whole team by integrating these players in the squad.
If the loan system is unfair, why didn't people complain last year when Lukaku kept West Brom competitive? The problem seems to be that Everton's loan players are in the first team while other clubs just take on loan players as coverage for their first teamers. To me, the media is just trying to bring negative comments to Everton as they are daring to challenge their Sky favourites..
265 Posted 20/01/2014 at 14:17:57
266 Posted 20/01/2014 at 14:39:46
267 Posted 20/01/2014 at 14:43:42
I certainly don't have negativity towards Martinez. I guess when we debate, we can talk about the ideal (shareholders who had the backbone to speculate to accumulate) and the reality (good loan players are better than nothing and, as I said in my subsequent post, can even be a viable longer term plan, at least until you get successful).
268 Posted 20/01/2014 at 15:11:09
I really hated the way we filled our bench with players who were not worth an Everton jersey — McFadden, Hitzlsperger, Hahnemann etc etc.. Now we seem to be using the loan system in a positive way by taking players who we are USING! They are worth a place in the team where the others were not!
I saw the poor way we were using the system as a drain on whatever resources we had towards a transfer budget. We were giving jobs away to unproductive has-beens.
Looking at Traoré, he is with us for less than a season and could perhaps be the catalyst to enable us to get a spot in Europe, whether it be Champions League or Europa League. He has played in the same side as Samuel Eto'o and Zhirkov when in Russia and I am sure that McGeady would be worth asking about the lad's merits.
He looks a strong handful with a lot of pace, he runs at opponents and knows where the goal is. We are getting him to bolster up our striking options and I am sure he must be worth a punt if Roberto wants him. I see him coming in as a no-brainer !
269 Posted 20/01/2014 at 15:38:07
No, really.
271 Posted 20/01/2014 at 16:01:07
272 Posted 20/01/2014 at 16:13:10
They are now making up things about Coleman leaving. McGeady stated that Coleman loves the club and even more so under the present manager as his game has come on leaps and bounds with the style Roberto wants him to play.
Traore is not a target man, he scores many goals in and around the 6 yard box. It will be like having an octopus in the box never mind a fox in the box, stabbing in from close range with those long legs reaching balls an ordinary mortal would not reach.
Lets hope we also bring in another striker in this window and a DM to cover Barry and McCarthy too then we have once the injuries have cleared up quite a fearsome squad.
273 Posted 20/01/2014 at 16:21:40
274 Posted 20/01/2014 at 16:15:10
Let's not forget, he brought arguably our greatest ever player (after Dean) to the club in Alan Ball and it still rankles with me to this day that Harry never ever gets the recognition he deserves only because of that show pony across the park.
When you hear the likes of Nicholson, Clough, Revie etc – all great managers in their own right – get lauded, it gets on my nerves the way The Cat never gets a sniff... but, as my Uncle Tommy used to say, "It's because he never entertained the press." Unlike some, hey Shanks? — and that's what probably went against him. But still, we're Everton... and we'll be Everton forever.
275 Posted 20/01/2014 at 16:37:23
The Premier League is a part of a global market and to maintain it's market share has to compete with leagues such as La Liga that produces better younger players than the premier league. The best young English players such as Barkley would still force their into the Everton even if the conditions for work permits were relaxed.
276 Posted 20/01/2014 at 15:56:45
But when I hear that Chelski have 22 players out on loan, I do care because that isn't helping the game at all
It is, however, within the present rules
Rules which clearly favour the monopolising cartel and the staggeringly unimaginative tv companies where dickheads (on very short contracts) who know fuck all about football simply troll out the easiest crap with "mass appeal" to ensure "good ratings"
Blithely ignoring the fact that if left to their logic they would kill the game entirely in favour of some man utd wankfest
Moan all you like about Everton relying on borrowed talent, but don't be a bloody hypocrite and casually ignore our youngbloods gaining experience whilst out on loan in lower divisions
We don't have a sugar daddy, and sometimes Kenwright reall makes me puke
BUT
If that cretin Tan waltzed out onto Gods Acre with a RED Everton jersey over his shirt & tie and tucked right down into his "mighty tighty whities", then I promise that I would hoof him in the crocks so hard that he'd land in the home of "Everton F.C. and Athletic Grounds Ltd" (Everton Athletic for short)
Having a shagload of money can provide answers to the majority of the worlds problems, but as Roberto is proving admirably, not having a bottomless wallet is no fuckin excuse for not playing decent football
That myth has been well and truly BUSTED
277 Posted 20/01/2014 at 17:05:13
278 Posted 20/01/2014 at 17:08:09
279 Posted 20/01/2014 at 17:15:56
280 Posted 20/01/2014 at 17:17:04
In order to have brought anyone in with the talent of Lukaku, Deulefeu or Gareth Barry, would have cost this club at least £40 million, if not more.
I think what RM has achieved in such a few short months, verges on the miraculous. He has changed the way we play on it's head and its a pleasure going to the match now.
I don't see the loan system as being damaging to us. I see it as way that we can get extrememly talented players in the team, for 6months, a season, maybe two.
I l;istened to that brilliant interview that Roberto gave, with the lads from the blues web sites and he made such sense, it's a wonder why anyone finds it so bad that they criticise vehemently, his use of the transfer/loan system.
He said in that interview that its not whether we have a player for only a year compared to having him for ten. He made the point that we have world class players, in Everton's team, for maybe a year, maybe more, rather than never having that player.
He also said that he looks to a player's outlook and if he is the right type of player for EFC
We haven't done too badly so far.
I'm sure that when the Summer window comes, we will have wonderful players being signed up on permanent basis. And also wonderful players on loan.
That sounds bloody right to me! If we had bucket loads of cash and could buy any player we wanted, as Man City do, then I still think Roberto would use the loan system, to see if a player he's not 100% sure of, to make sure he gets the players that are best for this club.
I can't ever, get round to liking Kenwright and his bloody cronies but we seem to be stuck with him. While we are, I cannot imagine any manager I'd rather have at the helm of this great club, than Roberto Martinez,
281 Posted 20/01/2014 at 18:14:16
282 Posted 20/01/2014 at 18:35:25
283 Posted 20/01/2014 at 18:20:23
The whole premise that we should have permanent signings at all costs is flawed. It assumes players of the quality we need will come to a side with no European football on a permanent basis and it assumes players are being made available by their clubs.
Moyes showed us the kind of knee-jerk reaction that I definitely DON'T want to see, with his signing of Fellaini. That's twice he overspent on him. He'd have been better off getting Barry on loan while his long-term targets became available.
Man Utd can recover from completely wasting the best part of £30M on a player who doesn't fit; we can't. I'm glad we have Roberto in charge and not Phil Walling. A club in our position needs a manager who only spends big when he's sure he has the right player. I'm happy for him to try out top quality loans every season, which can only raise our profile and improve our chances of Champions League football.
284 Posted 20/01/2014 at 18:37:20
When players who would obviously be useful for us are being picked up for reasonable sums by other teams then you will hear people complaining that the money that should be available has obviously disappeared.
285 Posted 20/01/2014 at 18:55:52
286 Posted 20/01/2014 at 19:02:49
Hope for a good result tonight.
287 Posted 20/01/2014 at 19:36:13
We simply can't compete in the money transfer market with the likes of City, Chelsea, Utd, Spurs and Arsenal.
A pity, buts that's the reality, no use wishing we could.
We have a manager that I wouldn't swop for anyone, he's intelligent enough to choose the best way in which we have a chance of the top 4 in the circumstances that the club is at this time.
288 Posted 20/01/2014 at 21:00:26
289 Posted 20/01/2014 at 22:01:46
290 Posted 21/01/2014 at 20:53:49
Add Your Comments
In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.
Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.
1 Posted 18/01/2014 at 21:37:23