Everton let advantage slip in draw at The Hawthorns

, 20 January, 77comments  |  Jump to most recent
West Brom 1 - 1 Everton
Everton passed up the chance to move back into the top four as they allowed West Brom to grab a draw after Kevin Mirallas had given them the platform to take all three points.

The Belgian's calm finish off Romelu Lukaku's knockdown put the Blues ahead late in the first half but a flat second-half display by Roberto Martinez's men allowed the Baggies back into the contest and Diego Lugano scored a 75th-minute equaliser to earn a point.

With Steven Pienaar a late absentee from the starting line-up, Bryan Oviedo was deployed on the right side of midfield as one of two changes made by Martinez to the team that started against Norwich. Sylvain Distin's return alongside Phil Jagielka in central defence was the other, John Stones dropping back to the bench, although the 19 year-old would see action late in the game with Seamus Coleman was forced off with an injury.

Though the Blues seemed unable to assert their now-customary passing game on Pepe Mel's West Brom, they did fashion the best chances of the first half. Two of the best fell to Oviedo but his volley flashed the wrong side of the post for the first and he screwed the second into a similar spot wide of goal a few minutes later.

Mirallas and James McCarthy had also failed to really trouble Ben Foster in the Baggies' goal when the fired straight at him but the 'keeper was left stranded when the former easily beat Lugano to Lukaku's header off a long ball forward by Distin and he slotted home with aplomb.

West Brom came into the contest more and more after half time as Everton's influence waned and when James Morrisson squeezed a cross from the byline past two yellow jerseys, Lugano stole in ahead of Distin and powered home a header past Howard with 15 minutes left.

Everton rallied in the closing stages but without much penetration until Sylvain Distin turned Gareth Barry's shot home off an injury-time corner but his goal was chalked off for offside.

Quotes or other material sourced from ToffeeWeb Match Reports



Reader Comments (77)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Mick Davies
1 Posted 21/01/2014 at 00:00:36
Disappointing, any news on Coleman?
Si Cooper
3 Posted 20/01/2014 at 23:58:11
Just watching the game again (first half for the first time).

Up to 27 minutes the play has been a bit patchy but the vast majority has taken place in their half and they are only able to attack on the break. Oviedo on the right has actually worked pretty well with him being able to threaten when balls have come in from the left. No sign of the neat little triangles that are normally so evident on our left flank so Baines is unable to get into the game as much as he would like.

Quite a lot of lofted balls for Lukaku to compete for and he really is trying. Some of his control is poor but he is always looking to link up with others and has been clattered quite a lot by Lugano who is all over him like a rash.

Biggest miss is Ross Barkley who can shred opposing midfields with his ability to keep the ball at his feet while moving forward.

Even though we are not wiping the floor with them there is a huge difference between this and the last 35 minutes that I saw live.

Jim Knightley
6 Posted 21/01/2014 at 02:20:50
Obviously this was a very disappointing result..it seems strange to say, but Barkley's importance is almost more obvious in his absence. I'm usually of the opinion that Osman is given an overly harsh time on here...but he was so disappointing today. Our passing was generally poor, and we never really had control imo. But then, in our defence, injuries did bite. There is no Gibson and Kone, and more importantly, no Pienaar, no Barkley, and no Deulofeu. With McGeady unfit, and Traore joining soon, we can look forward to several different options over the next few weeks. I think this result today was representative of a depleted team. Unfortunately, we have the biggest game of our season in 8/9 days, and the idea of playing that with today's team (possibly minus Coleman) is frightening. Let's hope for some good news on that front.

I also think Lukaku is really in need of a rest. Traore will give him that opportunity long term, and I'd like to see Velios come in for the Stevenage match.

Darryl Ritchie
7 Posted 21/01/2014 at 03:07:00
Another draw, although a draw when we suck is more acceptable than a draw when we dominate.....sort of. Had the players on that should controlled the middle, but never seemed to get going. Bad passes were almost the norm rather than the exception. Roberto mentioned the condition of the pitch in his post game interview. From what I saw, it was terrible! Does West Brom share their ground with a rugby side?
Steavey Buckley
8 Posted 21/01/2014 at 03:20:28
Everton could not control the game in midfield against WBA last night because of Barkley's absence, which showed up weaknesses in other players games, who rely upon Barkley to run the game. In hindsight, it was not a good idea to play Barkley in the FA cup, because at least 4th spot in the premier league is more important than a day out at Wembley and a cup to bring home. The champions league is the holy grail of football, whereas the Europa league is the no hopa league.
John Daley
9 Posted 21/01/2014 at 03:33:31
A horrible game and a dismal performance. However, I do feel there are at least some mitigating circumstances right now. The squad is down to it's bare bones and the players currently missing are the one's who can provide that extra bit of creativity and spark to turn a tight game into a win.

Barkley, Pienaar and deulofeu are massive misses. That leaves only Mirallas and Coleman with any real invention in them and the first is reliably hit and miss, whilst the second can't be expected to come up with the sublime every week. I discount Baines from that list because he has been a shadow of his former self all season and, apart from those two free kicks against West Ham, seems to be struggling to rouse himself from some kryptonite induced coma.

So, those who say Martinez sat on his hands throughout the second half, please, identify what other options he had to swing that game back our way? The only player on the bench who might have had the capability to create anything was the half-fit hamburgler he actually brought on first. Mcgeady surely couldn't be thrown on any sooner due to the double whammy of lack of match practice and excess poundage.

I actually heard some people even criticising the substitution of Coleman for Stones earlier on. Surely you didn't think Seamus was delicately fondling his own thigh for fun like some droop-eyed farmyard deviant do you? He was replaced out of necessity.

Obviously Martinez set out to win the game but the tools that would normally give us the means to pull something off just weren't at hand today. It was like strutting in to donate sperm and finding that the only grot mag they've got in the cubicle is a 1977 summer special containing snap after snap of a slightly chunky, sweatband sporting midget, with a minge more like a stab wound in Mighty Joe Young's back.

There's no real substitute for top shelf talent and when you're shorn of it you're always going to struggle to produce the goods...no matter how much you bang away at it...especially with only an outdated shortarsed stand in (Osman) to try and bridge the gap.

Steavey Buckley
10 Posted 21/01/2014 at 04:30:10
John: With players missing and Stones playing so well in previous matches, should have played right back in his normal position and pushed Coleman up on the right side (a position he knows very well) to provide energy, zest and a goal threat.

Instead, Coleman maybe missing for awhile through injury after having to struggle and cope with defensive duties and making efforts to get forward against WBA as well.

As for Oviedo, why did Martinez switch him from the left side, where he has performed so well in previous matches providing for others as well as as scoring a couple of goals, to the right side, where he was less effective? As for Osman, less said the better.

Jimmy Hill
11 Posted 21/01/2014 at 05:23:35
We freeze and don't believe we should be there. I thought this time we do it, if Liverpool have a bad result we oblige and do the same sick of it. Same as Moyes just prettier.
Jimmy Hill
12 Posted 21/01/2014 at 05:54:23
Sorry all. Just really disappointed with this one. Sure we will win next weeks derby, just annoying we are not going in the match above them. Think it would have increased the pressure on the RS.
Jimmy Hill
13 Posted 21/01/2014 at 06:18:53
That's the pressure. Maybe we will have the big boy at 6'8" he will be hard for that rubbish defence to handle.
Darryl Ritchie
14 Posted 21/01/2014 at 06:23:43
Jimmy. I read he's got a hamstring problem and out for a month. Maybe true, maybe not. We'll see.
Harold Matthews
15 Posted 21/01/2014 at 05:30:09
They all looked like they needed a holiday to get over the holiday.

Without Barkley our attacking midfield was non-existent. Osman was trampled underfoot by a physical side and should have been replaced at half-time.

Their goal. Initiated by Howard's stupid throw and assisted by McCarthy's weary attempt to stop the cross....as Baines looked on.

We did what they wanted us to do. By pressing high up the pitch, they forced us to hit long high balls to Lukaku who was marked by big defenders. For such a large man he showed very little fight.

Coleman got on my nerves all night. So many opportunities for an early cross but he needs to dribble the fullback and they knew it and doubled up on him. Baines was almost invisable.

Possibly our worst performance. So much for warm weather training in January.

Steavey Buckley
16 Posted 21/01/2014 at 06:31:48
The present business model that Everton have at the moment makes it difficult to achieve at least 4th place in the premier league. Mainly, because Everton don't have the cash to splash when there is a need to spend on the finished article of a player good enough to compete with the top 6 in the premier league

Everton will need to focus and concentrate more on young footballers who can play for Everton's 1st team asap, who before joining Everton are the next big thing at their present clubs (wherever the clubs happen to be - work permits, permitting) because Everton don't have time to wait for players in the Everton junior ranks to show when they are ready sometime in the future.

In last night's Everton game, with a threadbare and depleted squad, there was not one player from academy who could make it to the Everton bench for whatever reason. That speaks volumes about a lack of excellent young Everton players.

And it it not because I don't want players from academy to achieve their goal of playing for the 1st team, it is just the reality of how competitive football is these days. The teams imminent need for 3 points cannot wait for young players to show what they can really do, if the club just waits a little while. When it is not in a position to.

Christine Foster
17 Posted 21/01/2014 at 07:10:21
Pretty average fare, Lukaku's first touch is generally very poor, constantly loosing out without an ability to shield the ball when he has it.
Osman crumbled under pressure and McCarthy were nowhere to be seen. Tactically Baines and Coleman hardly got forward.

All you can of this was we got a point. But Coleman joining a longer by the day injury list is a real blow. McGready has a lot of work to get match fit.
Desperately trying to look for positives, we should have cleaned this up in the first half but we didn't and lose 2 points again.. very depleted performance.

Max Murphy
18 Posted 21/01/2014 at 07:24:09
I know many sing the praises of James McCarthy on this site, but after watching him closely last night he was largely anonymous in the first half, and apart from a few speculative long-range passes down the right wing in the second half he was totally ineffective. Compare his play to Gareth Barry - fraction of the work-rate, no threat up front, no tackling and no passion.
I believe the team start believing all the press and media speculation about us being a top-four candidate - this results in their half-arsed attituded against teams like Stoke and West Brom.
Sam Hoare
19 Posted 21/01/2014 at 07:51:06
Must do better.
Rob O'Brien
20 Posted 21/01/2014 at 07:53:55
Interesting to see if/how RM can put his usual positive spin on a performance like that!! Absolute shite from start to finish! Aimless long balls, chips into empty space, couldn't pass 3 yards to a team mate and lost the ball almost constantly! Positives are only that at least we got a point and we can't possibly play any worse than that. Hopefully that is our shit performance out of the way before next week! I would be delighted with a point next week!!!
Simon Hermansen
21 Posted 21/01/2014 at 07:45:48
Lyndon you're right, flat sums this one up. Passing poor and control - especially the front players - was even worse. Lukaku needs to ditch those ten bob boots he wears and someone point out to Mirallas there's another 10 fellas on the pitch.

Positive ... Mcgeady looked promising if a touch rotund!

Steve Alderson
22 Posted 21/01/2014 at 08:16:24
Our worst player on a bad night for quite a few of the team was Distin.

There were schoolboy errors across the park but he stood out as the biggest culprit and it's no surprise that he was involved in not clearing the cross for their goal.

I'm gutted that Seamus might be out for a few games and my pre derby match phobia is heightening.

Steavey Buckley
23 Posted 21/01/2014 at 08:22:35
Rob a point next week may not be enough, there are 3 clubs involved with a 4th place at the moment, Spurs, in ascendency, are at home and if they win, would go 4 points ahead of Everton, who are in the descendancy, with so many quality players out injured and just one fit goal scorer who does not score, especially, away from home any more.
Darren Warkcup
24 Posted 21/01/2014 at 08:15:56
Not really able to offer anything more than really has been covered here. It was a poor pitch which didn't help us to play our on the floor passing game but there were too many individual battles not won last night from a side that looks like it is suffering from lack of depth and just generally running out of steam.

It was almost like watching a David Moyes Everton team than a Roberto one particularly the second half and he is going to need to get them all together and back up for the trip to Mordor. Hopefully this is the low point of the season in terms of performance and actually will probably decrease the growing levels of expectation from the media and allow the players to continue just getting on with it.

John (951) as for the 1977 porn I remember it well those kind of images tend to stay with you. Thankfully now we have ipad's so that we never need to go down that road again.

Patricia Beesley
25 Posted 21/01/2014 at 08:30:15
The excuse given in the after-game comments was that the pitch was bad and stopped the usual flowing passing style of football we are now becoming used to. What do they think the pitch at Stevenage is going o be like – Wembley?

I'm really pissed off with last night's failure to go above Liverpool and now down to 6th. What chance do we have against the Shite... not a lot, with the injuries we are now carrying to our best players and only one striker. Perhaps Liverpool will let us borrow one of theirs !!

On the other hand, if they play four strikers against us as they did against Villa, it may be their downfall. I'm dreading it... don't know whether to torture myself watching the Derby or just tune in to the final result. The trouble with the game being on BT Sport is that the rest of the footie supporters in the UK won't see how unfairly we are likely to be treated by their twelfth man only the result.

Matt Smith
26 Posted 21/01/2014 at 08:22:08
First half looked okay if not spectacular, and one-nil up was doing the business. Hate to say it though: the team sat back and looked a tad arrogant, not really looking to kill the game, and their goal was on the cards for 10 mins.

West Brom crumpled the midfield space and, without having space and time, we looked devoid of ideas from midfield. Osman was physically steamrollered by them.

I sense the next few weeks will be crucial to where the season pans out as been grinding results of late and with Spurs/Newcastle looking good we could
drop right down.

Keith Knowles
27 Posted 21/01/2014 at 08:42:31
Hate to say it but this was the nearest to a Moyes performance since RM took over.
Craig Walker
28 Posted 21/01/2014 at 08:51:31
Disappointing performance and agree that it was very Moyes like. You could sense them scoring and only when that happened did we then have a bit more urgency. Distin looked shaky and Lukaku didn't really offer much apart from the knock-down for the goal.

A thought Jagielka played quite well.

Have to say it but a draw was a fair result. It's still better than we got at the Hawthorns last season but I can't help thinking that the draws away from home are going to cost us.

Fair play to Anichebe. He looked up-for-it and made a difference when he came on.

Simon Hermansen
29 Posted 21/01/2014 at 08:57:14
Vic gave Lukaku a lesson in hold up play last night - always a big strength of his and it made a difference in the 2nd half

In the meantime every ball into Lukaku seemed to come of his shin or the defender got a boot in. Unless he really goes back to school on this part of his game I'm not sure he'll ever be the strike HE believes he can be

Dick Fearon
30 Posted 21/01/2014 at 08:34:01
Steve A @ 992I can understand you thinking Distin was our worst player but you are wrong. It took a keen eye plus multiple use of the replay button to spot the true worst player.
Had you been quick you might glimpsed himgetting to his feet after being dumped on his arse after many innocuous gentle bumps.
Or you may recall a lonely little fellow wandering aimlessly and generally far distant from any action.
Once I saw him breaking into a very slow imitation of a jog.
It was far too late when it dawned on our much vaunted manager that the player in question was more of a hindrance than a help to the team.
How many more times will he be allowed to drag us down. How many more displays like that of last night before Martinez just like OFM sees what thousands of us have seen for years.
Until that day dawns I reserve judgement on Roberto's qualities as a truly top manager.
Dan McKie
31 Posted 21/01/2014 at 08:45:38
WBA is one of those places you go to where their mentality is to stop the other team playing, then hope something positive happens at the other end. Not quite Stoke, but certainly not far off. We struggle with games like that, coupled with how many players we have missing.

We never seem to get much luck with injuries. Whenever we bring someone in, and it starts to look like we will have a few options, somebody else gets injured out of the blue. Its never a Naismith or an Osman though, it's always a Pienaar, a Barkley, a Deulofeu. It's always somebody decent.

I hope this Traore is good, and can play pretty soon because Lukaku is getting worse. His first touch is as bad as I have seen in a player. You can roll him the slowest of passes to control and it will pop up and hit his knee soon after it touches his foot.

Steven Telford
32 Posted 21/01/2014 at 09:00:44
its hard to know what type of deliverance actually suites Lukaku, very little comes for him to "run on to" rather the majority is when he has his back to the goal, and like has ben mentioned here already, too many shin bounces or heavy touches.

he can sometimes run with the ball in the box, but when he runs with the ball in other parts of the field, he seems to play it way too far ahead of himself.

Sam Morrison
33 Posted 21/01/2014 at 09:08:31
Agree with most of the above really - I have defended Osman in the past as I think he gets a bum deal on here, but last night he should have been taken off. But nobody played brilliantly - it's saying something Mirallas looks like he's trying the most.

What has happened to Baines? I hope we're not paying £75k for that every week.

Simon Hermansen
34 Posted 21/01/2014 at 09:12:06
Steven, if you rewind back 20 or so seconds before their goal I beleive you will see Lukaku do just what you describe in your last line!

I don't want to damn him too much - defo loads of potential - but not sure we're going to have time to get to grips with him, and improve him, in what remains of the season for him to contribute much more to our push for 4th.

Can see Traore getting a lot of game time if RM sees it the same way, but not sure he does

Darren Bailey
35 Posted 21/01/2014 at 09:09:48
Positives to take from last night... Not much tbh. WBA stopped us playing but we didn't help ourselves either by not using the ball properly.

Final third was awful as was Lukaku. He really needs to find some form. Osman worst player on the pitch, Barry same age & was head & shoulders above him. Substitutions too late & why not throw McGeady on for Osman with half hour to go? First time I felt Bobby's tactics were wrong, sorry Bobby.

We have no strength in depth at all. Traore in (I have my doubts – I would prefer the Belgium fella) but at least another body for no money. I've called for Holtby before & I still think he'd be very good for us as would Defore who's been linked with Fulham today. One attacking midfielder & one playmaking holding midfielder as well as McGeady & Traore. A very good window if you ask me. Surely that's doable???

Dave Lawley
36 Posted 21/01/2014 at 09:18:55
What killed us last night is the number of times the front two gave possession away. We did play more long balls than usual but it was necessary as they were pressing us high up the pitch, this left space for us in their half, a lofted long ball to our strikers was absolutely the right counter to this tactic. To be fair most of these long balls found their mark.

The front two then hold the ball or knock down to bring midfielders into play, the problem was Lukaku (who should be watching videos of Anichebe on how to hold the ball up) did not bring players into play, his first touch is awful (as is Mirallas's) when he did flick on for the goal (more luck as the defender got some of the ball) it was down to Mirallas pace that made something of it. 90% of the time the front two gave possession straight back to the baggies from good accurate balls from the back.

I'd love to see the pass completion stats from Lu and Kev compare that to big Vic who (crosses apart) I did not see give the ball away once.

Jim Bennings
37 Posted 21/01/2014 at 09:36:48
Up until about three weeks ago I was really eagerly anticipating the Anfield derby, far more than I have done for years, but now with the injuries to Barkley and Coleman (as soon as I hear the words scan and results, I expect the worst) I just have the usual empty feeling about our trip there next mid-week.

We have a real headache with what team to select for the Cup match on Saturday, we can say its only Stevenage but they ran us mighty close in August at Goodison, plus their pitch wont be top notch obviously.

Who do we look to rest? Will the likes of Niasmith be able to outclass even a fighting Stevenage team?
I think its fair to say we wont see Coleman and probably Baines.

I am keeping my fingers crossed on Traore coming in and getting up to speed ASAP because I am starting to get a similar feeling watching Lukaku to the one one I did watching Jelavic about this time 12 months ago. Its almost hoping he can score or play well rather than expecting, like when he first came here.

The next month is going to be very important in the context of the season.

We have a trip to Anfield, followed by a tough looking home game against a Villa team that always looks better and more vibrant on the road.

A trip to Spurs is quickly followed by a Wednesday night home match against Crystal Palace, again a tougher nut to crack under Pulis and again, its the type of team that we consistently seem to have difficulty dispatching.

February then ends with a hard away games at Stamford Bridge before the FA Cup 5th round..If we are there.

Callum McNab
38 Posted 21/01/2014 at 09:43:04
If that doesn't show billy liar needs to support this manager with more quality ,then I don't know what will. We just went back to our old style under Moyes. Long balls,shutting up shop when we score trying to hold out for the win.i could not understand Bobby's line up, I hope Mirallas isn't calling the shots telling him he wants to play centre.
Baines did have a poor game ,but he had no one in front of him he could link up play with,and when he did it was ossie who was goosed . Bobby dithered on the subs as we'll ( which he is normally spot on) I like so many other blues could see there goal coming ,but he did nothing till it was to late.
We defo need cover if these players are going to be long term injuries,who I don't know who could be available,so that's worrying . One last point,I was pissed with gibsons comments on twitter,telling Everton fans to get over it and move on,and they had worked there socks off. Try telling them poor buggers who travelled it was just one of them nights so move on and stop moaning,or better still get of your day arse and either get fit or frig off.
Brin Williams
39 Posted 21/01/2014 at 09:51:20
Listened to the match on the radio with the live forum running alongside.

The match was dire but the forum was a scream as usual and the comments just reflected how passionate we are about Everton.

Max Murphy
40 Posted 21/01/2014 at 10:27:29
Rob (#987) - I'm sorry, but the home draw against Spurs earlier this season was the worst performance by Everton I've seen in over 30 years. As one TW contributor said after the game, "A draw unbelievable, I would've been happy with a 3-0 defeat."
Patricia Beesley
41 Posted 21/01/2014 at 10:36:45
Roberto blamed the pitch!! Does he think the Stevenage pitch is going to be like Wembley's? I blame Distin for the disallowed goal in the dying seconds which must have had the shite shitting themselves and then laughing their socks off.
Mike Gwyer
42 Posted 21/01/2014 at 10:26:22

Harold #977.

Agree about Osman - he got battered physically and dispossessed at will, he drifted out to the left and Mirallas drifted inside. Well that really was dooms day.

With Osman out on the left Baines now had fuckall cover hence he would not attack, absolutely no fucking way; he knew what was ahead him for the rest of the game, yep, Osman in front of me means I've got the whole of the left side on my own. Say what you want about Osman; nice foot work, vision, local lad, true fucking blue, whatever you like, but he cannot fucking defend, tackle or win the ball. Once he loses the ball he stands still and reflects on the moment - he literally stands still, looks at the sky and probably wonders how the fuck he's still on the pitch.

West Brom were hitting us physically and ref didn't give a fuck till every player wearing blue had been kicked - then he booked them. McCarthy & Barry attempted to level it out with some late tackles and Barry was sticking very close to Morrison but he got booked for it - it was not enough though. WBA now had the left side to attack and really if RM cannot see how poor we play against physical teams and how light weight some of our players are, then I guess he did last night.

Liverpool WILL definitely put it about, guaranteed. Stevie G is losing it, he is slowing down, but he knows its the derby, he will know that almost anything goes in this game. So if Osman plays, Henderson and Stevie G will have a field day, they will just laugh at Osman when they do the pre match hand shake.

Why can't RM leave Osman for league cup games, friendly matches or for City and Arsenal - you know, teams that just like to pass the ball and pick each up when they fall over.

Colin Glassar
43 Posted 21/01/2014 at 11:29:44
Great post, Mike. I think every manager has a blind spot for a favourite player who is now passed his best. With ginger it was Neville, now robbie seems to have Ossie as his favourite. Don't get me wrong, Ossie has been a fantastic servant for the club and still has a role to play.....from the bench but he can't start every game. Will Roberto learn from this?
Ian Burns
44 Posted 21/01/2014 at 12:26:00
Taken me all morning to get over the depression after that game last night. Lousy pitch; lousy game; lousy performance which was as bad as the Spurs game. Injury list longer growing longer by the day - even the new potential signing has a hamstring problem - performances beginning to show wear and tear.

What I also found disappointing was the report I heard on BBC early this morning when RM claimed we deserved the 3 points! I thought it was the previous night's gin taking effect when I heard that interview! I am a great believer in RM but if he thought we deserved three points last night and he's signing a loan player with hamstring problems - then I am beginning to worry about his need for a visit to specsavers!

The night was saved by the terrific banter and moaning on TW Live - brilliant.

Rant over - I remain 100% behind RM - considering this just a blip along the road to an exciting future under his stewardship.

Eugene Ruane
45 Posted 21/01/2014 at 13:08:45
'Dumb' was a word I must have said 150 times to myself last night (and watching in the Coffee House in Wavertree, 'DUMB TWAT!' out loud about 10 times - apologies to anyone in earshot).

Jesus it was frustrating.

Player with a simple pass available to an unmarked colleague chooses to try and hold onto the ball even though there's a determined attacker right up his hole - dumb.

1-0 up and we should keep hold of it, but it's aimlessly twatted up the park, possession is lost and they're coming at us...again - dumb.

For the 100th time, a fast, hard ball is played into Lukaku, who has a defender glued to him, meaning the chance of anything happening (other than him losing it or managing to just knock it back) are billions to one - dumb dumb dumb....

I really feel these players need to be sat down for half an hour before games and for someone to try and get inside their heads about concentration and about right/wrong choices.

So much of what happened last night was just fucking sloppy.

Drew Shortis
46 Posted 21/01/2014 at 13:59:41
Last nights match was the first I have not watched this season. Had to miss it due to work. I listened to the second half on Five Live and it was torture. Steve Claridge (I think he was the commentator) sounded so frustrated with both teams. I can take it when we are outplayed by a better team, but to hear that we couldn't string a few simple passes together was very frustrating as I know the players we have are better than that.

We can't afford to keep dropping points against the teams we should be beating. I have just been looking through the fixture list and have picked out ten games that we should expect to win: Aston Villa (H), Palace (H), West Ham (H), Cardiff (H), Swansea (H), Fulham (A), Sunderland (A), Southampton (A), Hull (A). That would give us 30 points or 72 overall. If we can pick up some points from the seven other tougher games we would be well within the Champions League spots basted on the final table from the past few years. It is still well within our grasp, but we need to cut out these slip ups against the bottom half teams.

Not a disaster, but very disappointing!

On a positive note, it looks like Traore is about to sign and there is a story in the Metro that Michy Batshuayi is also on his way. Apparently his parents have seen an e-mail to the Standard board confirming Everton want to sign him in January and the Charman is keen to cash in. Just a rumour I know, but the addition of two exciting young strikers could be the boost we need in the final third.

Harold Matthews
47 Posted 21/01/2014 at 13:15:49
Mike. Top post as usual. We just can't hack it against physical teams with a high work rate. Their new head coach sussed out our weaknesses, nullified the pass pass pass and made better decisions than Martinez, who looked a bit shell shocked. Indeed, despite supporting him, I thought our boss had a nightmare and the shuffling of our weakened pack was not up to his usual standard. Barkley and Pienaar were sorely missed but with half the team in a stupor and the other half flying solo, he pulled off Oviedo because he always pulls off Oviedo and he left Osman on. For me, that sealed our fate.
James Marshall
48 Posted 21/01/2014 at 15:11:24
Drew - or, direct quotes (allegedly) from Batshuayi himself in the (ssshhhhpit!) Daily Mail:

"I will finish the season at Standard Liege," he said.
"Beyond that, I don't know, but I won't be going anywhere before the summer."

James Marshall
49 Posted 21/01/2014 at 15:15:23
Well that went a bit wonky, but you can decipher it!
Colin Glassar
50 Posted 21/01/2014 at 15:17:14
Drew, they don't want to sell him until the summer and, it sounds like he's happy to stay until then. I imagine his parents want part of his signing on fee for a holiday in Benidorm so more of wishful thinking on their part.

ps: I'm happy to see that tosser Ince has been sacked AGAIN.

Mike Gwyer
51 Posted 21/01/2014 at 14:39:52

Harold

Still weary from last night but with the derby coming up we need to take whatever positives we can from the West Brom game and move on.

Liverpool will be so up for this game it will be unreal, they need CL football and they fucking want it. Their whole mentality will be to win this game, something I hate to admit, but they are very good at it. You just know that Suarez will just keep diving, acting and fucking everyone off just to win the game - irrelevant of a booking. Stevie G will put himself about big time, getting sent off - not a problem to him. Henderson will tackle late, high and hard to win the ball and their extremely ugly CB's will continuously foul Lukaku, and guess what, they will keep fouling him till one of them is booked or gets a red. They just want to win the game - fuck all the consequences.

If RM could just feel how important it is to win this game he would leave Osman out - this game is just not for him, its not a football match its a fucking battle. My pray mat is out regarding Pienaar, the guy loves this game, otherwise we will be looking at McCarthy and Barry - these two must ensure that Henderson & Gerrard know we have come their patch, to their so called fortress for 3 points.

Eric Myles
52 Posted 21/01/2014 at 15:32:32
"So much of what happened last night was just fucking sloppy." Eugene #085 sums it up perfectly, everyone performed badly yesterday, maybe their heads were still around the pool in Tenerife.
Eric Myles
53 Posted 21/01/2014 at 15:32:32
"So much of what happened last night was just fucking sloppy." Eugene #085 sums it up perfectly, everyone performed badly yesterday, maybe their heads were still around the pool in Tenerife.
James Marshall
54 Posted 21/01/2014 at 15:40:29
Sloppy is the right word.

We just lack any verve or purpose. Aimless balls blasted at Lukaku, high or low making him look shit with Luganu up his arse for 90 minutes.

I can cope with not winning, its the manner in which we blew it that bothered me.

RM should have made a change before they scored too - you could see it coming a mile off.

Harold Matthews
55 Posted 21/01/2014 at 15:32:44
Yes Mike. People try to make out it's not Liverpool's most important game, but we know it is. "A matter of life and death", says Carragher. Gerrard will be in the ref's face from the kick-off, Skrtle will have the shirt off Lukaku's back and Henderson will be looking to stamp on Baines's foot again. We've seen it all many times before but we'll go there looking for 3 points and the disappointment of last nights result may galvanise us into raising our performance. Let's hope Barkley and Pienaar are back.
Colin Glassar
56 Posted 21/01/2014 at 16:10:31
I said on the live forum, before the game, that the players were too chatty and didn't seem focused. Maybe they've started believing the hype and thought it would be a stroll in the park. As previously stated, a very sloppy performance against a very poor team.
Patrick Murphy
57 Posted 21/01/2014 at 16:36:25
Harold I thought that type of phrase that you say Jamie Carragher used was no longer appropriate to either Merseyside club - 25 years and all that.
Harold Matthews
58 Posted 21/01/2014 at 16:12:18
Colin. Two years ago, my son's old banger ran out of juice in a Wirral country lane. The nearest garage was miles away and as my lad, wearing his Cahill shirt, fished in the boot for a petrol can, a big shiny limo pulled alongside and the guy told him to jump in. It was Paul Ince.

Not only did he run him to the garage, but he waited while my lad filled his can and paid the money. He then ran him back to his car.

I ask you Colin. Would you have done that? In fact, how many people would have done that? Let me tell you. Very few.

So you see.You should never cast aspersions about people you don't know. Paul Ince is not a tosser. To me and my family he will always be a top man and we wish him luck in whatever he chooses to do.

Peter Z Jones
59 Posted 21/01/2014 at 16:43:59
Sloppy is indeed the word to describe our performance. How many useless headers and long balls were played when all we had to do was bring the damn thing down and keep it on the ground? Kevin Mirallas scored a good goal, but this guy is starting to piss me off with the number of times Lukaku makes a great run and he is busy doing stepovers somewhere. Look up. Pass to Lukaku. He scores. It's no wonder he has 1 goal in 10 games. I think our selfish streak that pops up often limits our goalscoring potential. Osman can't start and play 90 minutes. Speaking of chance creation, what did he create for Lukaku in the entire game? He had one reverse through ball to Mirallas and that was it. The rest of the time he was doing his trademark "let's lose the ball facing my own goal at the halfway line" routine. Oviedo was bright and unselfish, but was subbed off. We spent very little time getting Coleman the ball also. Oh well. We typically play amazing against the good teams so here's to hoping we play our game next weekend.
Sur Jo
60 Posted 21/01/2014 at 17:29:26
Tim Howard should have exercised better judgement last night on his throw to Lukaku before we get hit by a goal. Right before that goal we were under intense pressure. Following the corner, Tim got a clean and good grip of the ball. Instead of holding play and allow his players to recover from 10+ minutes if tense pressure; he throws the ball to Lukaku within a blink of an eye!!! Where is his judgement? Guess what happened; just like the past 10+ minutes, the ball came back as fast and this time poke the net!
Jamie Barlow
61 Posted 21/01/2014 at 18:06:25
Tim Howard has been doing that all season.

If Lukaku would have put even an ounce of effort into the tackle before he lost it, West Brom wouldn't have scored. Distin, Baines and McCarthy were even more guilty with awful defending.

There's no point blaming Tim Howard for trying to set up a counter attack. It's what we've all been crowing about this season. Still attacking when were winning. You know, the Martinez way?

Raymond Fox
62 Posted 21/01/2014 at 18:13:30
On last nights match, I think you have to give Mel some credit for his tactics.

It looked like he had the pitch heavily watered, and had his forward players energetically press us high up the field.
Not a bad plan against a passing side when you think about it!

That, along with some of our best players missing I think was the main reason for our poorish game.
Still no excuse for some players appearing not to be giving 100%, but theres not going to any easy games away from home and maybe last night was a taster of things to come.

I wonder what sort of team RS will pick V Stevenage?

Patrick Murphy
63 Posted 21/01/2014 at 18:49:33
I hope RS don't have to pick a team for Stevenage Raymond but I'm sure you meant RM
Raymond Fox
64 Posted 21/01/2014 at 18:59:36
Yes I did Patrick, thanks.

I may be giving Mel too much credit also in saying he had the pitch watered, because just looking at the Midland Horse racing tracks going, their all showing heavy going!

Whatever, the pitch didn't suit us that's for sure.

Dan Brierley
66 Posted 21/01/2014 at 18:45:55
I think you are right Ray, Mel tactically nullified us last night. They knew Barry or McCarthy aren’t going to cause any problems through the centre, so basically they needed to contain Mirallas, and close down the threats from the flanks. First half they struggled to keep Mirallas under wraps, second half they seemed to set out to deliberately frustrate Mirallas to which he duly complied with. He spent the second half moaning instead of trying to work out a different approach.

But that said, I wouldn’t call Mel a tactical genius. There are plenty of tapes of matches this season where teams have done exactly the same thing. If a team disrupts our Roberto’s Game Plan by playing a high line with a pressure game, it seems there is no counter tactics. For example, I can never imagine Martinez countering a high line by playing direct balls over the top which will soon push that high line back.

My biggest concern is that RM seemed unaware, or dare I say ignorant, of the other teams set up and tactics. The biggest example being when you see Steven Reid lining up as right back, you know you need someone solid in there with pace, you would think it is nailed on for Oviedo. But instead he decides on one of our slowest and THE most lightweight player in the squad. What on earth was his logic there? The only thing I can think of, is that Martinez thought by switching Osman, Mirallas and Oviedo around it will somehow confuse the opposition.

Brian Harrison
67 Posted 21/01/2014 at 19:03:26
I thought are passing started badly and didnt improve as the game went on. I thought their goal was down to McCarthy and Baines, their player receives the ball with his back to goal and close to the goalline yet they allowed him to turn and cross. Dont know why Neville and Carragher were saying the goal was Distins or Jagielkas fault, the ball should never have got that far.

I thought tactically we weren't clever, WBA played an extremely high line with 2 very slow central defenders as our first goal proved. Yet we never once played the ball over the top for Mirallas or Lukaku to run onto too. I also don't think playing Oviedo wide right helped surely he would have been better on the left, and play Mirallas on the right to run past Ridgwell who is very slow. But we didnt do any of these things, we played the ball into Lukakus feet and holding the ball in tight situations is not his forte.

But having said that we played well below par but still managed to come away with a draw, I think the fact that we scored first and could have got 4th has upset us as much as the below par performance.

Sur Jo
68 Posted 21/01/2014 at 19:13:44
Jamie Barlow @149 - I don't mind the goalkeeper trying to set up a rapid counterattack; but he should have known that for 60+ minutes his attacking players could not even muster a pass, let alone go on a solo dribble from one box to the other. So he has to adjust accordingly. Lukaka didn't do a clean run all day long; so it's up to someone to realize that the players weren't performing as they should have.
Raymond Fox
69 Posted 21/01/2014 at 19:18:11
I agree Dan, it wasn't Roberto's finest moments, although our strength in depth or should I say lack of, didn't give him many options to play with.

We could do with 2 or 3 extra quality players, but I don't know where their going to come from in this window!

Andy Crooks
70 Posted 21/01/2014 at 19:39:34
Our best eleven is good enough for top four. Last night's side was not. Shorn of quality we ground out the lucky draw we just about deserved.
Mike Keating
71 Posted 21/01/2014 at 19:45:55
Might be a good result for Martinez - to show BK we need to get another striker before the end of the month.
Dan Brierley
72 Posted 21/01/2014 at 19:38:51
4-4-2 was a clear option, as it has been for many matches similar to this where we have dropped points. Vellios is 6ft 4, so ideal to play as a target man with Lukaku playing off him. But there is a clear reluctance to do anything different from the shape we have played every match this season.

Ian Riley
73 Posted 21/01/2014 at 20:43:35
Still on holiday, yes they were and when did the plane land, Monday at 18.45 at Birmingham! That performance in the 2nd half was shocking and lets be honest WBA could and should have won with there 2nd half performance. I am a big fan of Osman but he not up to starting away from goodison. He will never get the time on the ball he wants away from home. The final 30 minutes of a game is perfect for him. I cannot defend the team last night and the manager stood and watched it and changed it to late. The pitch was fine, its January, poor excuse from the manager! We did not play well but we have a point would have done!

Mcgeady looks a tidy player on the ball and when he came on we had forward momentum. It was a game that barkley was missed, we had no one driving forward. I knew we were in trouble when we started going long to lakaku. If this our worst performance all season I will take it!

I do feel we are drawing to many games and this may hinder a top 4 finish. The team needs to pick it up again for the remainder of the season. Remember being in contention for a top 4 finish is a new experience for the manager. He has spent years fighting the drop!

So happy to have him at our club!

Best wishes all!

Mick Davies
74 Posted 21/01/2014 at 23:43:22
We've had terrible luck with injuries to key players, and the replacements aren't up to the job. Roberto is doing a fantastic job, papering over the cracks, but the truth is, the club doesn't have the resources to sustain a CL chasing campaign just now. It's only 7 months into his reign and were still playing/benching pre-Moyes players, so we can't expect too much. Barkley has made the difference in many matches this season but if Osman is the best replacement we have, then there will be more West Brom's this season.

I believe we'll have a good cup run - starting with Stevenage - and then look forward to next season, with Martinez having a full summer to build his squad, and welcome back important players like Gibson and Kone. We've had an exciting time with some scintillating football and amazing results and goals so far, and I can't wait for the DVD. That will be something to savour, and hopefully next season will bring success. IRWT

Drew O'Neall
75 Posted 22/01/2014 at 00:30:47
Mick spoken like a true apathetic, 7th place will do, plucky Everton, punching above their weight, polar opposite of Nil Satis Optinum, BK clapper..

Fuck the DVD, we're in the hunt for Champions League football and, while it's mathematically possible, the league too.

I'm sure you didn't mean that to sound as defeatist as it did but for god's sake, wake up and get behind the side.

Drew O'Neall
76 Posted 22/01/2014 at 00:45:48
Tactics wise,WBA played a high line and pushed up every time we turned home to build from the back. This can be countered by dribblers from midfield, rapid pace upfront or early, direct ball and good CF hold up play.. We had none of those things.
Richard Harris
77 Posted 22/01/2014 at 00:49:11
I was really looking forward to going to see us win and move into 4th place ahead of a diversion for a cup game and then 'that game' next week. But what happened?

Players looked like they were still on holiday or just being integrated into a new team. So many wayward passes, sluggish movement, two players near a loose ball and neither seemed to know who should go for it, West Brom knowing the system that we would play and generally nullifying our play.

This is a below average team that we were playing and yet for an objective onlooker who could tell which was the team playing for European qualification and which was near the relegation zone? It was almost as bad as the Crystal Palace game.

At times it felt like watching one of those dire games with David Moyes when a stubbornness to change the system, when we had been sussed out, and to counteract the opposition's tactics lead to conceding a goal and then not looking likely to get back in the game and win it.

Yes we have injuries and a weak bench, so the same story as before under Moyes where there are limited opportunities to bring on players who can change the game but this is just not good enough.

We should have enough talent and motivation on the pitch and tactical flexibility from the manager to beat West Brom if we are to be taken seriously as a contender for 4th place. We cannot compete with any of the three clubs who could win the league, Arsenal, Chelsea and Manchester City, because of the failure of the money (or lack of it) men who own the club but 4th was there for us and we blew it.

So now we're playing catch up to Liverpool and Tottenham rather than them having to catch us. Which now makes those two away games must wins rather than a draw which would have been a worse result for them than us. Or maybe it will all turn around and we'll be the first team to beat Mourinho in the league at Stamford Bridge......

Mick Davies
78 Posted 22/01/2014 at 01:37:47
Drew, It's not apathy but reality; everyone is moaning about a draw at West Brom as though its the end of Roberto's reign, so I'm just informing those suffering from pre-derby depression, that our shit luck with injuries is not the managers fault, and neither is our lack of decent back up. We are competing against multi-million pound squads but to still be in contention is testament to the hard work everyone has put in this season. To have more points at this stage of the season than anytime in the last 35 years is incredible, and if you look at some of my posts over the years, I've criticised the manager for not stating that Everton are out to win the league. I'll always expect the club to be fighting for honours but if we are struck down with injuries, notwithstanding the financial disadvantage, I'd have to defend a man who's been in the job for 7 months by those who defend a man who, for 11 years, only wanted to reach 40 points
Brian Hennessy
79 Posted 22/01/2014 at 10:21:31
Lukaku looks like Heskey after the haircut, come to think of it he has played a bit like Heskey the last few games...
Drew O'Neall
80 Posted 22/01/2014 at 10:40:31
Fair comment Mick. Overreaction by me.

Nice to have realistically high expectations for a change though, and there's enough in the media saying we can't do it (Gary Neville on Monday night) I just like to hear we can every so often.

Mick Davies
81 Posted 22/01/2014 at 18:57:23
Ditto Drew, the psychology of our club and fans has changed exponentially this season and one or two knock backs shouldn't get us too downhearted.

Off topic, but once again our red cousins have dragged their club back into the abyss with their evil threats and racist abuse at Stan Collymore. Jeez, all he said was what everyone in Britain would say; that the dirty Uruguyan scumbag is a diver!!! How wonderful it is to be a fan of this decent club of ours, as opposed to that disgraceful edifice down Breck Rd. - that Sodom and Gomorrah of the football world, where envy and hatred have replaced pride and class since Shankly's era


Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads

© ToffeeWeb