Everton granted work permit for Traoré

, 22 January, 241comments  |  Jump to most recent
Injury to Falcao throws loan move into doubt
updated Everton's application for a work permit for Lacina Traore has been successful, the club have confirmed. Talks with Monaco are now scheduled to complete the acquisition of the giant striker on loan until the end of the season.

The former Anzhi Makhachkala player, who was only bought by Monaco for £15m earlier this month, underwent a medical at Finch Farm over the weekend and while the granting of clearance to play in the Premier League was assumed to be the last impediment to Traoré completing his move, Everton say that, "talks are ongoing with Monaco."

The deal had been expected to go through, however — the French club's preference for Goodison Park over Upton Park was reported to be one of the reasons why an arrangement with West Ham fell through last week — until Monaco's Colombian striker, Radamel Falcao, had to be stretchered off with a suspected injury to his anterior crucial knee ligament which could have prematurely ended his season.

Equipe in France are reporting that Monaco will assess the player's knee before making any decision over Traore.  



Reader Comments (241)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Dennis Ng
1 Posted 21/01/2014 at 19:49:41
Awesome! Hope to see him at least get some minutes at Stevenage and then rs!
Mark Frere
2 Posted 21/01/2014 at 19:51:32
Isn't he injured at the moment, Dennis? Just been reading we are strong favourites to sign Michy Batshuayi.
Dennis Ng
3 Posted 21/01/2014 at 19:55:38
The ESPN report says that RM feels its not too bad. Not sure if "a few days" might mean he'll miss the derby but definitely sounds better than the original timeframe which was a month out.

Link:
http://espnfc.com/news/story/_/id/1687661/everton-add-lacina-traore-loan-monaco?cc=5901

Mike Manchester
4 Posted 21/01/2014 at 19:55:22
Just needs his signature now it seems. Is that true Mark? last I read Dortmund were front of the queue for Michy
Matthew Salem
5 Posted 21/01/2014 at 19:58:22
I thought we were done with Monaco and had come to an arrangement before the pending work permit? Even the Home Office is more efficient that Everton FC it seems.
Mark Frere
6 Posted 21/01/2014 at 20:02:23
Mike, there's plenty of rumours circulating that Michy will sign for us, this is just one of them:

http://metro.co.uk/2014/01/21/everton-open-talks-michy-batshuayi-over-january-transfer-from-standard-liege-4271384/?

Dennis Ng
7 Posted 21/01/2014 at 20:05:14
Now I worry we have too many strikers but not enough supply up front...But not a bad sign that players are linked to us. Any players we might be looking at to cover for Barry and McCarthy?
Mark Frere
8 Posted 21/01/2014 at 20:05:27
Sounds like good news then, Dennis, we definitely need competition for Lukaku, he's really gone off the boil lately.
Dan Brierley
9 Posted 21/01/2014 at 20:00:28
With this guy onboard, we are looking at having spent the best part of 10 million on loan players this season when considering fee's, wages and associated bonuses. And not a single one with a view to a permanent signing with exception to Barry who will be 33 in the summer.

It seems like a huge gamble to me, and certainly not something we can afford to do each season. Lets hope it pays off, and we can get into the CL group stages.

James Elworthy
10 Posted 21/01/2014 at 20:10:28
Sky are linking us with Ricardo van Rhijn of Ajax the Dutch internstional Right Back
Brian Waring
11 Posted 21/01/2014 at 20:11:07
How much is the deal in place for this lad Dan, wages loan fee etc? also, what are we paying in wages to Delboy and Lukaku, and what are we paying their respective clubs in loan fee's?
Dennis Ng
13 Posted 21/01/2014 at 20:11:56
Mark, definitely. I look forward to see how we'll adjust to account for these changes.

Dan, agree. It comes back to the "do we want the player" dilemma. We want the player but can't afford him. Let's hope something plays out and that the player will be more likely to stay with us, granted he plays well. Lukaku seems impossible to sign at the start of the season, surely that looked much more possible now.

Patrick Murphy
14 Posted 21/01/2014 at 20:27:50
Dan you must have access to some good information if you can be so definitive about how much each of our loanees are costing, just to think last years (2013)accounts haven't been published yet, how do you know what our financial situation is?
Dan Brierley
15 Posted 21/01/2014 at 20:19:25
Lukaku and Barry are on around 60K each, and Del Boy around 20K. This lad will be on much more than Del Boy as a senior and a full international, let's say around 40K.

So you are looking at between 5-7 million in wages alone. The loan fees are much harder to estimate. If the player is considered as first eleven of the team he will leave, of course there is compensation required. If he is a squad player, which seems to be the case for our players, the loaning club may agree to a fee that covers the costs of the administration and insurances of the player.

Dennis Ng
16 Posted 21/01/2014 at 20:35:32
Dan, does your source include just wages or all financial info? Like Patrick, very interested to know more.
Eugene Ruane
17 Posted 21/01/2014 at 20:22:24
Great - throw him in against Liverpool, he could be our secret weapon.

(ie: while they're standing looking at him, stunned and mouths agape, thinking 'how fucking tall is HE!?" we could nip in and score).

Patrick Murphy
18 Posted 21/01/2014 at 20:33:18
Naismith, Heitinga. Gueye, Hibbert et al won't be on peanuts either and they are draining resources with little or no sell-on value either. So what are we to do?
Dan Brierley
19 Posted 21/01/2014 at 20:32:06
Patrick, since when has 'the best part of' been considered as a statement that is definitive? I thought it was clear that my view was an assumption. The only data I have access to, is the same newspaper and other online reports that you read. No magic mate.
Mark Frere
20 Posted 21/01/2014 at 20:34:37
Dan, we would still have to pay players wages whether they're permanent or loan players. What's your point?
James Marshall
21 Posted 21/01/2014 at 20:36:24
Ricardo van Rihjn - let's hope he's as good a defender as Rembrandt was a painter!
Raymond Fox
22 Posted 21/01/2014 at 20:37:59
It might work Eugene, you never know, but only once!
Paul Thompson
24 Posted 21/01/2014 at 20:37:36
He's on his way so more debates on the whys and wherefores of loans are secondary. He'll certainly be very different from anyone we've ever had on the books - a 6.8" guy who can't really head a ball, but is fast and can dribble! For a while at least, I think Premier League defences will not now how to handle him. By the way Eugene, he has already scored against Liverpool.
Dan Brierley
25 Posted 21/01/2014 at 20:38:04
I am surprised I have to explain it Mark. Firstly, its better for a team when you have permanent players that are playing with each other for many years. If you replace 3 or 4 players each season through loans, you do not have that consistency as there is often learning curves.

Secondly, buying players instead of loaning gives you the option of the players developing a resale value if they choose to join other clubs in future. If a loan player does well for you, his value goes up and you have less chance of buying him. Simple stuff really.

Peter Mills
26 Posted 21/01/2014 at 20:43:45
Eugene, Raymond, I still wake up in a sweat thinking about when we did it before, bringing on Big Bad Bernie when we had just gone 4-0 down.......
Mark Frere
27 Posted 21/01/2014 at 20:58:57
Fair point, Dan. I just think you were making out that its costing far more in wages than it would be if we signed permanent players instead.

I will be concerned if we don't start signing permanent players in the summer. Martinez's budget will be dependent on weather we're in the CL , of course.

Mark Tanton
28 Posted 21/01/2014 at 21:00:44
Going off course - did anyone see Lukaku's very ill advised defence of Anelka in the post match interviews? It's been taken down from the OS. Who would discipline him for such a thing, if required? Chelsea or us?
James Elworthy
29 Posted 21/01/2014 at 20:56:26
Not sure if saving our dosh to buy Lukaku a good thing at the moment, I would prefer Delefeu as he has got it all.
We are also linked with Tom Ince. I would prefer an additional centre mid to cover for Barry and McCarthy, the lad from Man City Ibrahim is available for nothing.

Raymond Fox
30 Posted 21/01/2014 at 20:47:54
Taking loan players, is our only way of getting certain players in our side.
Its taking a gamble that it will pay off and maybe get us in the top 4.
What with the crazy finances that exist in football now, its realistically our only short term chance!

Its the era of 'loads of money, if you hav'nt got loads, your, shall we say disadvantaged!

Patrick Murphy
31 Posted 21/01/2014 at 21:02:02
I heard about it Mark but I don't know what he said, however, I also believe that our cousins from over the park have been making a big deal of it on Twitter. All part and parcel in the run up to the derby. I also hear that SSN have been examining Leighton Baines 'dive' from last night and Collymore has called it out of order - LB was wrong but why do they only scrutinise Everton's errors of judgement and not others?

As an aside has anyone else seen that BBC3 'comedy' programme 'Uncle'? One of the characters had a nickname he wasn't fond of and said and I'm paraphrasing Nicknames are stupid - Like Everton are known as the Toffees who's scared of Toffees?

Mark Tanton
32 Posted 21/01/2014 at 21:06:50
I'd love to buy Deulofeu but I don't think Barcelona will sell him. Mind you, he might come back next season anyway, which would be brilliant. Cannot wait to see him fit.
Mark Tanton
33 Posted 21/01/2014 at 21:08:01
Patrick he basically echoed Anelka's self defence from last week - harmless freedom of expression.

I am now fearful of the derby. We don't have a side to put out. Mind you, every time Martinez has asked for a reaction from his players so far, he's got one.

Dennis Ng
34 Posted 21/01/2014 at 21:12:07
Mark, if Batsy rumor turns out to be true and he comes in time for the derby, maybe RM can play 3-4-3. Just saying.
Patrick Murphy
36 Posted 21/01/2014 at 21:18:54
Mark - I've just been on the BBC website and Jose' has had a veiled pop at our neighbours saying how they defend their own players for diving but want others booked for doing the same thing. He was asked which club he was on about but he wouldn't say, but to me it was pretty obvious.
Jon Withey
37 Posted 21/01/2014 at 21:13:27
Would be interested to know how much 'loans' cost, I hope it's nothing like Wonga.

If it is just wages, even at 60k a week, that is still a bargain for a top player.

For a top player you'd have to pay 125k a week on top of the transfer fee. Rooney is on 200k a week or something around that.

Steve Guy
38 Posted 21/01/2014 at 21:19:32
Any RS having a pop at our players need a long hard look in the mirror (if they have any in Mordor) Media doing its best before the Derby to pysche Atkinson out of giving us anything.
Si Cooper
39 Posted 21/01/2014 at 21:24:00
James (222), what's Ibrahim like, as I don't think I've ever seen him play?

Another reminder of how many players the likes of City have hoovered up and placed in limbo. There was a story in one of the comics on Sunday about Alex Nimely, who Sven Goran Eriksson raved about when he signed for them 5/6 years ago. The lad chose to represent England rather than Liberia at one stage but his career seems to have really stalled.

Kevin Tully
40 Posted 21/01/2014 at 21:40:40
At least the RS are suffering - Lucas is out for 2 months, an important player in their midfield. Let's hope Bournemouth can leave a few casualties on Saturday!
Eugene Ruane
41 Posted 21/01/2014 at 21:44:48
Kevin - and Gerrard's diminishing pace is pushing him so deep he might end up in goal.

Whoever we have fit, we need to go at them.

As dangerous as Suarez is, their defence is fucking shite.

Mark Frere
42 Posted 21/01/2014 at 21:46:53
We definitely need cover for Barry and McCarthy. We were once linked with Tomas Rincon, he only has 6 months left on his contract at Hamburg and shouldn't cost a fortune. He fits bill - a tough tackling holding midfielder with a good engine.
James Elworthy
43 Posted 21/01/2014 at 21:51:29
Jack Rodwell didn't even play tonight despite City leading 6-0.
A lesson to any young English player to join such a club. Scott Sinclair was another one.
Sam Fitzsimmons
44 Posted 21/01/2014 at 21:23:59
Perhaps the strategy of bringing in loan players should concern me but frankly during this period of transition I'll hold judgement until the end of the season. Until things start to go belly up on this front I'll stick with RM's judgement on loan signings. It seems to working at the moment. I'm thinking of Torres and Carrol, they were good permanent signings for their respective clubs.
James Marshall
45 Posted 21/01/2014 at 21:51:28
The problem with the RS that none of us can deny, is that regardless of who's missing, they still have Sturridge and Ratboy up front who can cause any defence problems.

You can remove anyone from their backline, or midfield but love them or hate them, those two are quality players who can and will score goals. We just have to make sure we score a couple, because Skrtel and Toure are fucking dreadful :-)

The Batshuayi link looks like a dead duck - he's stated (and so have the owner of Liege) that he's staying there until the summer at least. Dortmund are also in the queue so don't hold your breath!

Colin Glassar
46 Posted 21/01/2014 at 21:45:07
Traore, Batshuayi, van Rjhin all sound promising. I'd go for Defour as well and really strengthen the squad.
Nick Armitage
47 Posted 21/01/2014 at 21:58:03
Mark Tanton - why on God's earth should Lukaku be disciplined?
Patrick Murphy
48 Posted 21/01/2014 at 22:01:22
James #259 Rodwell came on as a substitute according to BBC text commentary.
James Marshall
49 Posted 21/01/2014 at 22:05:00
The thing with this Batshuayi link is that there are about 5 different scenarios being played out, depending on what rag you read. One of them even says we're talking about buying him then loaning him to Anderlecht for the rest of the season - Liege's big rivals!

Seems massively unlikely to me. Why on earth would Liege sanction a deal if they knew were were going to do that? They could just flog him to Dortmund.

James Elworthy
50 Posted 21/01/2014 at 22:06:28
Sorry I meant he didn't start.
Eugene Ruane
51 Posted 21/01/2014 at 22:34:41
How Rodwell's appearance was reported on the Telegraph's live feed.

"63 min Rodwell - remember him - is on the pitch in place of Garcia"

He must have been told "Oh and Jack, if we get to 9-0 up on agg, we'll give you a run out - promise!"

Mick Davies
52 Posted 21/01/2014 at 23:01:39
If Lukaku should be disciplined, then so should Brendan Rodgers
Peter Laing
53 Posted 21/01/2014 at 23:25:47
Anyone reckon Rodwell's really all that arsed bench warming at City and picking up his reputed £100,000 per week ? The lad is financially secure for the rest of his life and has probably sacrificed his career at least in the short term to gain such stability. It amazes me how any English player with an 'ounce' of prospect can double or treble their true valuation and worth based upon a handful of decent appearances and future 'potential'. I suppose its synonomous with the gravy train that the Premier league has become and an indication as to why the English game and grass-roots football in general in this country are fucked.
Harold Matthews
54 Posted 21/01/2014 at 23:30:13
Linked with Van Rhijnm Not surprised. With Coleman injured we'll be linked with every available right back in Europe.

Personally I prefer Hibbo to Stones. The youngster is comfortable on the ball and has a promising future. Unfortunately, his positioning is not up to scratch and he is still playing at U21 pace.

Peter Bell
56 Posted 22/01/2014 at 00:05:52
"I prefer Hibbo to Stones."

FFS! I’ve heard it all now...

Mick Davies
57 Posted 22/01/2014 at 01:34:33
Harold Matthews, Stones is a footballer. Andrew James, have you no pride?
Tim Jones
58 Posted 22/01/2014 at 02:26:47
It is my opinion that a lot of the 'hoovering up' of footballing talent by the "Big Four' is more about stopping them playing for their current teams than it is about strengthening their new teams. Its using their financial 'clout' to damage opponents by removing their good players and by so doing to therefore make the 'Big Fours" Prem games easier.
Matt Traynor
59 Posted 22/01/2014 at 03:14:23
Dan's point on loan fees is pretty spot on - I'd wager we're paying more than £10m in fees and wages. The point is that we don't own the players, and are unlikely to (except in Barry's case). Barca won't sell Delofeu, at least not until they're satisfied he won't make it - and that decision will come later. We're not going to get 4th place, so no chance of signing Lukaku - and as others point out, would you want to splash £25m+ on someone who is still very raw?

I wouldn't want another loan of Lukaku either - unless the £6m loan fee was coming off an eventual agreed purchase price - otherwise over 2 years we'd have paid out £12m in loan fee before any transfer fee.

I understand Martinez philosophy with loan players. Get in players you wouldn't otherwise be able to sign - for financial reasons (Barry) or our current stature (Delofeu, Lukaku). It's a lot better than makeweights like Jo or Stracquilarsi, but it's horribly expensive at that level.

Christopher Kelly
60 Posted 22/01/2014 at 03:24:10
Loans are rentals, and we're mortgaging our future to win now in a way. Not a bad plan as far as I'm concerned (at least not with this pitiful Board).

Has anyone thought of Jovetic? Not a bad shout although I didn't see a TON of him in Italy. Thoughts?

Simon Hermansen
61 Posted 22/01/2014 at 05:54:41
True, most of these loanees wont stay, in honesty they have too much potential for Everton in our current state. If we were loaning to buy then they would be lesser players who'd probably keep us stable but Bobby is looking to plug the gaps he sees with real quality in the short term by loaning it in.

Hopefully the longer term plan is to bring through the youth or (through short term success) be able to afford to buy real quality rather than loan.

Yes a gamble but no other option if we want to get things moving early on, better than sitting on his hands moaning about lack of funds

Peter Leslie
62 Posted 22/01/2014 at 06:07:30
Loans make total sense to us right now: basically means we can take players of a level we couldn't otherwise afford, and hence improve/ freshen the squad.

The 'mortgage' metaphor is a good one: it costs the same per month to rent as to buy, but while we miss out on any possible appreciation in value, the flip side is reduced exposure to having dead losses on our books for years if they turn out to be useless.

I agree this is not sustainable, but in the mad world of football finance, what the fack is?? its surely more so than other 'models', like the RS vanity express blurting 500m over the last few years to still have other even bigger and more vain club owners go past them.

The kind of players we are loaning (Barry apart) are unproven raw talents - if they do well, and enjoy being at EFC, we are in pole position when it comes to negotiating for permanent transfers. We get to 'try before we buy'

At the pace at which these source 'mega-clubs' turn over their squads it also means there's a good chance they will have a 'new shiny player' in position by the time the loan is up, and may be more inclined to trade.

Fact is - and let's all admit it - Roberto knows better than all of us when it comes to every single aspect of football - both on the playing and business sides, so I say relax, and trust his judgement (except maybe on match day, when Osman plays, and all common sense and self- control naturally goes out the window)

COYB

Harold Matthews
63 Posted 22/01/2014 at 06:23:02
Peter / Mick. I happen to like Stones. Just don't think he's ready for the Premier League yet. Carl Jenkinson is older, bigger, stronger. faster and ahead of him in the U21s but Wenger prefers the experience and physical strength of Sagna. It's a rough, tough jungle out there, as we found out at The Hawthorns on Monday night.
David Ellis
65 Posted 22/01/2014 at 07:01:16
Its not clear to me of the so called loan fees are paid on top of salary. So we could pay a loan fee to Chelsea of GBP 3m, but does this mean that Chelsea will pay the players salary - so the loan fee compensates Chelsea for the salary and with perhaps a bit more on top to cover the capital investment in the player that they originally made? This makes a massive difference as to whether these deals make financial sense. Paying GBP3 million a year for Lukaku may make sense, but not if we have to pay his salary on top of that (which would be a similar amount)

Paul Smith
66 Posted 22/01/2014 at 07:19:00
I think it's good that we're attracting loan players of this calibre and having them prefer Everton over (all be it) the Hammers is a step forward.

For me though, these are only stop gap measures which paper over the fact that we are SKINT compared to the clubs which are fighting for the real honours.

I'm not down, I'm really excited about what's happening at Goodison, merely adding my twopenneth worth.

Sam Hoare
67 Posted 22/01/2014 at 07:51:55
Will all these loans have been worthwhile if we don't come 4th? It's been great in terms of excitement and pretty football but in some ways there is little difference between 5th/6th and 7th/8th where we might have expected to come. It does rankle spending so much of our limited means on players who even if they play well will not really make us any money unless we hit the top 4.

I hope next season we will be bringing in more permanent players to turn into a stable developing team that can blossom under RM over a few years period.

Steve Pugh
68 Posted 22/01/2014 at 08:08:09
Let me get this right, £10m for two strikers, a top winger and a brilliant defensive midfielder.

Are people really saying that they would rather have bought 4 £2.5m players instead of loaning the people we have. That sort of money would get you young players not yet ready for the prem (we got plenty of them already. Players coming to the end of their careers (negates the no sell on argument), or players that are not yet good enough.

I would rather spend £10m a year on top quality loans whilst Roberto sorts out the team. To be honest I am still looking at next season for a CL spot, probably with Barry as a permanent signing and a new group of loanees.

Sam Hoare
69 Posted 22/01/2014 at 08:18:35
Steve, I've no problem with it this year but if we do the same again next year then we will have spent £20m on four players that we don't own.

You could potentially for that have bought benteke,arteta, michu and vertonghen.

While Roberto works out what he needs and identifies targets I'm fine with short term loans but ultimately I'd prefer to see us unearth and develop our own talent as opposed to other teams' .

Oliver Molloy
70 Posted 22/01/2014 at 08:32:19
We have had all our loans. It is 4 maximum is it not?
Danny Broderick
71 Posted 22/01/2014 at 08:40:08
You can't include the players wages when working out what the loan players are costing us. Remember, we shipped out Mucha, Fellaini and Anichebe, which equates to around £130,000 a week, before we brought them in.

I believe Lukaku cost us around £3 million, Del Boy £1 million, and Barry £1 million. Their wages were offset by the wages saved on the players departing. It's all relative. So the cost of loaning these players is not £10 million+.

Sam Hoare
72 Posted 22/01/2014 at 08:54:20
Danny, alot of that is guesswork though right? Wasn't Barry alone rumoured to be on 100k a week. Not sure anyone on this site is 100% clear on the figures we have paid/are paying...just hope someone at the club is!
Ray Roche
73 Posted 22/01/2014 at 09:26:20
Sam, I was under the opinion that we were only paying a percentage of Barry's wages and that City were still making a substantial contribution.
Drew Shortis
74 Posted 22/01/2014 at 09:26:16
Dan Brierley 197
I don't see how players wages are an issue. Whether they are loans or permanent deals they need to be paid. As long as they are getting first team football then that's fine. In fact its better to be paying a loan players wages to play than a paying a contracted player to warm the bench (Heitinga).

You do have a point about the loan fees. Long term it is not a sustainable business model. Unfortunately we do have to consider resale value. However, I think these loan deals are part of Martinez's plan during the transitional stage. We can't afford to buy these players at the moment so loaning them to speed up the transition and, please to god, get us into the Champions League makes sense. If we do qualify the loan fees will seem like money well spent!

Phil Walling
75 Posted 22/01/2014 at 10:12:16
Loan players cannot be seen as building for the future unless they are 'with a view to buy' clause attached. Can't blame RM, though, because like his predecessor, January is always 'finger in the dyke' time under BK's regime.

Be that as it may, The Big Fella looks like joining the ranks, so will he be as talented as an in-form Peter Crouch or, as mentioned above, bring back memories of the freak that was Big Bernie Wright? If the latter is the case then Finch Farm should be a fun pace to be!

Brian Harrison
76 Posted 22/01/2014 at 10:18:08
I don't think clubs in the Premiership should be allowed to have loan players, but seeing that the Premiership allow it then exploit it for all you can. This is not knew us loaning in players we have done this for many many seasons. There are advantages and disadvantages to having loan players, the down side is if one of your loanees is playing well it might make the parent club think twice about letting you purchase the player, or it might alert one of your rivals to make a counter bid when the loan period ends. The plus side is you get to look at the player every day for a decent time and allows you to asses whether to buy or not when the loan is finished.
Phil Walling
77 Posted 22/01/2014 at 10:29:25
Drew: Do you know what financial rewards attach to 4th place qualification for EL ? Would qualification alone provide the funds for the necessary player recruitment to see us make a decent show? Can loan players play in EL or do their 'rightful owners' insist on barring-out clauses?

Not clever-arse questions, merely a request to understand the economics.

Kevin Tully
78 Posted 22/01/2014 at 11:07:06
If you have cowboys as owners, it's only a matter of time before you will end up with 'The Loan Ar-aranger' as your manager.

You can have that one!

Linda Morrison
79 Posted 22/01/2014 at 11:07:10
Phil clubs get around £40 million for making it to CL even if they don't get beyond the group stage.

That could possibly but 1 decent player.

Realistically unless we get Pinnear, Coleman and Barkley back I cant see us getting to the top 4 the squad is too thin

Patrick Murphy
81 Posted 22/01/2014 at 11:44:21
Oops - costly error by the Blues' but the wheels of justice at the FA turn rather slowly don't they?
From BBC website today:-

Everton have been fined £45,000 by the Football Association for an unauthorised approach for Nottingham Forest's Jamaal Lascelles in 2010.
The Toffees have also been warned about their future conduct after breaching the FA's football agent regulations.Lascelles, 20, is still at Forest and has made 15 appearances this season for the Championship side.The defender has been given a warning and his agent at the time, Andy Niedzwiecki, has been fined £10,000.

Brian Furey
82 Posted 22/01/2014 at 11:53:05
What's the story with Traore groin then? Will he be fit to even come on as a sub on Tuesday night or will it be a month before he's ready?

I too am very disappointed with the injuries we have now for next Tuesday night. Without Ross, Pienaar & probably Coleman I think we'll really struggle. We were very poor v West Brom all over the park.

I'm wondering is Lukaku playing poor and being controversial to persuade Chelsea to sell him on. Hardly I know but he did nothing on Monday night though there wasn't much supply to him either.
I hope we don't be guilty of one eye on the derby and mess up on Sat. Will Roberto play a 2nd choice team?

Brian Furey
83 Posted 22/01/2014 at 12:04:27
How long is Deulofeu out for now and how long will it be in total?
Remember when it happened we were initially, how long did they tell us 4 weeks?
Simon Hermansen
84 Posted 22/01/2014 at 11:53:16
'Loan players cannot be seen as building for the future unless they are 'with a view to buy' clause attached'

Bit of a black and white statement, surely this strategy could be part of an over all plan to give us short term gains while we also build for the longer term within the club? In effect this statement in saying that RM is after some 'quick wins' and sod the future. Seen no evidence that he's of that mind.

If anyones got a better strategy (within our means/limitations) to move us forward rather than maintain stability, then I'm all ears.

Risky ... yes. Better than a steady 6th or 7th every year with same old playing style and players ... oh yes.

Dan Brierley
85 Posted 22/01/2014 at 11:10:45
Danny Broedrick indirectly makes the point I was trying to highlight:

Felli, Anichebe & Mucha leave: 130K weekly wage saved

Lukaku, Barry & Deulofeu arrive: 130K weekly wages spent

So on this balance, it seems loan players has absolutely no effect on the bottom line at all. But wages are not the sole consideration.

Felli, Anichebe & Mucha leave: Up to 35 million recieved into the club coffers

Lukaku, Barry & Deulofeu leave: We receive nothing, but a thank you letter from their respective clubs for either getting the wages of fringe players of their books, or technically developing their youth players for for free.

I think the bigger picture is clear for most of those who are looking at this situation as an Everton fan. But I think there are also some blues that are also diehard Martinez fans, and have stopped looking at the merits of situations, and concluded that if RM has done it, it has to be a good thing.

Until we have access to unlimited cash, I like to think of the wage we pay our own players as an investment in their development. Its our way of ensuring that if they do move on to other clubs, we at least get compensated and are able to rebuild. Thats without even mentioning the benefits associated with building a stable core of players that grow together season upon season. So my hope is, that Martinez makes a U turn on his previous statement that Everton will become the feeder club of any team wishing to loan out talented players, and spend more time and focus looking for the next Seamus Coleman. But as people have quite rightly pointed out, we wont get a view of this until a couple of seasons have passed and Martinez is able to mould his own team.

Patrick Murphy
86 Posted 22/01/2014 at 12:40:47
Martinez has and only is doing what we have always done at Everton FC, trying to get the cheapest option into the club on a limited budget.

If he had splurged all of his money on deadbeats then we could complain. Now the jury is still out on Kone and Robles but in the early 1980s Howard Kendall used the loan system to mixed effect why? Because we had no money then either.

BTW the squad has been getting older every season and some of those in the current squad should have been shipped out ages ago but a combination of BK's tight-fistedness and DM's reliance on the usual suspects meant that many players have become used to contributing very little and taking money out of the budget.

In three years time if RM can put up with the financial restraints, I'm pretty confident that the squad will be a lot younger and hopefully it will be capable of contributing a lot more than some have done in the past few seasons.

Drew Shortis
87 Posted 22/01/2014 at 12:22:31
Phil Walling 385
What I meant was that the financial benefits of qualifying for the Champions League would far outweigh the fees we have paid for these loans and we would also have enough left over to spend on permanent players. I'm not saying we WILL qualify, but these loans give us a much better chance. If we fall short at least we gave it a go.

I agree with Simon Hermansen 408's comments. It is clear that Martinez is planning long term, bringing in players like McCarthy and putting his faith in the likes of Barkley and Stones. If he had used this transitional season to replace the old guard with younger players who need time to gain experience and settled for a safe mid table finish I don't think he would have drawn too much criticism as most fans would have understood it was part of a long term plan. Instead he has opted for a blend of youth and experience which, overall, has been paying off well so far and could see us achieve some immediate results. I'm glad he has kept the core of Moyes team together and had them adapt to his system. It would have been a mistake to make too many changes too quickly. The loans have given us a boost in key areas without the causing major disruption (IE selling players like Baines to fund an overhaul of the squad).

If in two or three years time we are in the same position (EG loaning in our best players) then I will gladly apologise to you Phil. However, I fully expect that over the next few seasons we will see many more young players coming into the team, both through transfers and through the youth set-up and the long term team building you crave will be realised.

Put it this way. If we had spend the £3m Lukaku fee (if that's what it was) on a signing a striker what would we have got? That would get you half an Anichebe or Jelavic, or a past sell by date Kenwyne Jones. Perhaps a decent young prospect who would be ready in two or three years time. Give me a proven goalscorer for a season over a squad filler on a permanent contract any day! Perhaps in the long term youngsters like Hope or Long will make the grade and Martinez will get in someone like Batshuayi, but we need goals now and I think the money has been well spent.

If Traore comes in and scores the goals that get us in the CL or helps fire up Lukaku again any fee we pay for him will also be well spent. I know we only got a point at the Emirates, but Deulofeu's goal was priceless in showing that this Everton team can stand up to the Sky 4. It's a real shame he got injured because he has that X Factor about him.
And don't even get me started on Barry.

I'm just struggling to comprehend your preoccupation with the loans. Moyes did it with the likes of Fernandez, Jo, Straqualursi, Senderos and Donovan. The difference now is that these loans are of a higher quality and are helping us towards our goal of Champions League football, which if achieved will mean that we DON'T have to rely on loans. If it works then nobody will be saying "Oh, but they only got there because of their loan players". How is it any less noble than Man City or Chelsea just buying multi-million pound players with their owners riches?

Rant over ;)

Chris Leyland
88 Posted 22/01/2014 at 12:46:17
I'm all for "building for the future" but, as football fans we pretty much live in the now don't we?

Martinez has come in, assessed the squad, looked at our inability to compete in the transfer market against the monied clubs and come up with a strategy to try and shorten the gap. The plan appears to be to try and get into the promised land of the top 4 now by bringing in better-quality players on loan than we could afford to otherwise buy outright.

Does it make economic sense? To a degree yes it does. Take Lukaku. We can't realistically afford a £20m striker. Maybe we could get an £8m one at a stretch. But which is better? An £8m man paid for over the course of his contract of 3 or 4 years at £2m a year, who, depending on his age may have a re-sale value at the end or may non and, because of his quality may get you 10 goals a season. Or a £20m man on a one-year £3m loan who may get closer to 20 goals but who will probably leave after than one season? Finish 4th because of those 20 goals, get through the qualifiers and into the Champions League proper and the latter deal starts to look better.

It is a calculated gamble by Martinez. It is also one that only a club like Everton can actually do within the Premier League. The Man U, Man C, Arsenal and Chelsea couldn't try this as the so-called "big" clubs wouldn't lend each other their players. Liverpool can't do it either (Moses aside) as they perceive themselves as a big club despite the fact that they don't have the recent track-record and that the above-mentioned clubs won't lend their better fringe players to them. Spurs can't/won't do it either as they operate on a speculate to accumulate strategy with lots of player turnover.

James Elworthy
89 Posted 22/01/2014 at 13:07:48
The first loan signing I can remember we got was a guy called Terry Curran. If I remember rightly he was outstanding on loan and we bought him I think eventually and he was awful. I may be wrong but I am sure he came back.

You are allowed 4 loan signings so you should get the best quality players available and possibly in the case of Barry sign them and the end of the period. In the past we have loaned the likes of poor players like Senderos.

Good on Everton for doing what we are doing and hopefully next season we can have four more good ones, Delboy on a second year, and Lukaku and Barry signing for us permanently.

Drew Shortis
90 Posted 22/01/2014 at 13:09:14
Spot on Chris!

An interesting article on Traore here

If he can have the effect for us that this guy believes he could have had for Arsenal it could prove to be a shrewd bit of business.

Also an interesting article with. Martinez defending his loan policy

Jim Knightley
91 Posted 22/01/2014 at 13:13:17
Phil, are you ever going to acknowledge that most teams do not do real business in January? Or just keep spouting the same BK narrative, whilst betraying an utter ignorance of the footballing environment in the process? It's getting embarrassing.

Moan if we don't sign players in the summer, not now.

And one more thing Phil. United have brought...no one in January. Arsenal? no one. Liverpool? no one. Chelski? one player in, and one out. City? no one. Spurs? sold Defoe, and maybe Holtby will be leaving too. Everton? signed one, are bringing a 15mil player in on loan, and let a struggling striker leave above market value.

Of the top 10 teams in the division, I'd say we are doing the most to improve our team this winter window.

Steavey Buckley
92 Posted 22/01/2014 at 13:00:33
Everton are now in a difficult situation, with so many injuries, players out of form, and new players coming in without being really match fit, as the countdown towards the end of the season now begins.

It now appears less likely that Everton will achieve at least 4th place in the premier league, as the top 3 of Arsenal, Man City and Chelsea start to pull ahead of Liverpool, Spurs, 4th and 5th and Everton in 6th places.

The greater financial opportunities that champions league offers would help Everton to balance the books and buy better players that are at the club at present.

Most of the teams who are in the premier league, except for the top 8 at the moment, are happy just maintain their status in the premier league. And many of them have a similar financial situation compared to Everton without the lofty ambitions that Everton have.

The next question is, can Everton realistically compete in a premier league when they lack the larger finances of the other top 7 when those clubs have good managers as well?

Ray Roche
93 Posted 22/01/2014 at 13:16:56
James, yes, Terry Curran was electric when he first came on loan but when he eventually signed he was gash. He played in the Southampton semi-final I think. I seem to remember that he was after more money when we tried to sign him after/during the initial loan deal but we wouldn't pay what he wanted although we did eventually buy him.
Kevin Tully
94 Posted 22/01/2014 at 13:25:49
Why are we going through the time & expense of medicals, work permit hearings etc. and only just entering into financial negotiations with Monaco?

Seem to be an arse about face way of conducting business?

James Elworthy
95 Posted 22/01/2014 at 13:23:08
I think we loaned Curran from Sheff Utd. I also recollect that they wanted a lot more than he has worth due to his successful loan period. Now I think you loan them with a fee agreed to buy them if the idea is to buy them at the end of the period.
Brian Waring
96 Posted 22/01/2014 at 13:29:45
Kevin, think the financial side of the deal isn't the problem, supposedly we're trying to get the option of keeping him on loan for another season as part of the deal.
Chris Leyland
97 Posted 22/01/2014 at 13:30:55
Kevin, the negotiations may be because the guy currently has an injury the extent of which wasn't known until after the medical. It may be that medical has revealed that it is a minor injury and he is ok to sign but he is out for a month. If so, then the fee may need to be less than anticipated as we have use of him for less time.
Phil Walling
98 Posted 22/01/2014 at 13:26:14
James @ 431. The clubs you name have not strengthened because they feel they are already strong enough to see off the likes of Everton and Newcastle.

Another thing that is being overlooked in the ToffeeWebbers economics calculations is the 'loan fees' that are now attached to the wage obligation of the lend out clubs.

Warnock said on Talk Sport recently that he had heard of a loan fee of £10K being asked by one of 'the big boys' recently !

Brian Waring
99 Posted 22/01/2014 at 13:41:38
Chris, Martinez said it was soft tissue damage and he would be fully fit within a few days.
Eric Myles
100 Posted 22/01/2014 at 13:44:33
Surely the guy needs a contract of employment to be able to get a work permit?

Phil #440, I don't think £10,000 is very much of a loan fee, or £100k for that matter, I think we're looking at millions.

Kevin Tully
101 Posted 22/01/2014 at 13:40:39
Thanks lads. On the subject of Donovan, I didn't hear many whinging when we were loaning players for just 6 weeks!

If we can get Traore for 18 months and Deulofeu for 2 years, that's got to be viewed as great business.

A little off topic - The Liverpool fans are phoning in trying to justify the abuse Collymore took on Twitter because "It was a stonewall penalty."

Dim isn't in it.

Simon Hermansen
102 Posted 22/01/2014 at 14:00:51
Re Terry Curran - anyone remember the chant 'lets all have a whip round, lets all have a whip round etc ... ' when he was here on loan pulling up trees. Then all looking very silly 6 months later when he couldn't get a game for us cos he was that crap.
James Elworthy
103 Posted 22/01/2014 at 14:11:27
Liverpool fans hate any criticism whatsoever – I think this is how the name 'whingeing Scouser' came about based on them.

There is a bloke who runs a website called Liverpool Kop, think he is an Indian guy based in London. His football knowledge is limited and like most RS supporters has never been near the place. He is very critical of Suarez as well as many other things about the RS. He has been getting death threats due to his opinions and the police are involved as well.

Brian Waring
104 Posted 22/01/2014 at 14:12:51
That's how fucking stupid the redshite fans are Kevin, they go into meltdown for some innocent remarks by Lukaku, asking for bans and the fa to look into them, and then in the same breath try and justify death threats and racist remarks to Collymore because they think it was a penalty.
James Marshall
105 Posted 22/01/2014 at 14:13:53
If people don't like the loan system, that's one thing, but what other option do we have, especially in January? There isn't one.
Max Murphy
106 Posted 22/01/2014 at 13:49:42
We have now drawn 9 games out of 22, with only W Brom drawing more. Of the top 7 teams, apart from us,, the maximum number of draws any them have is 4. This is quite a remarkable difference.
Brian Waring
107 Posted 22/01/2014 at 14:20:06
"Our loanees so far, are a large part of the reason we're in the position we're in. Take out Lukaku, Barry and Deulofeu and we'd be threadbare and probably about 10th." Spot on James.
James Marshall
108 Posted 22/01/2014 at 14:17:59
In other news, I've just read that City have released Abdisalam Ibrahim who a lot of people on here have raved about.
Simon Hermansen
109 Posted 22/01/2014 at 14:21:54
Thanks for the links, Drew. The Martinez comments on his loan strategy are interesting and back up a lot of what the more positive posters have been saying on TW.
Patrick Murphy
110 Posted 22/01/2014 at 14:19:18
As you say James there should be a limit to the number of Loans that a club can send out to other clubs. As someone else said previously the only reason that the richer clubs hoard so many players is to prevent true competition from their direct rivals.

That isn't sport by any stretch of the imagination and in time it will kill the game, but everyone seems to be pretty happy with the system at the moment and seem unwilling to do anything which prevents the big clubs from almost doing what they like. The Bayern Munich's, Madrid's, Manchester United and City et al all know full well they hold the whip hand and if they wanted to they could leave Uefa and form their own competition with the aid of the broadcasters and leave the rest of the clubs to drown in a sea of debt.

Drew Shortis
111 Posted 22/01/2014 at 14:26:28
James Marshall 460
We need more midfielders and he is meant to be a real talent. Fingers crossed!
Brian Waring
112 Posted 22/01/2014 at 14:25:30
Think he's gone to Olympiakos James.
James Elworthy
113 Posted 22/01/2014 at 14:27:48
I hope if he signed him Ibrahim is better than that other freebie defensive mid we got from City, Francisco Junior.
I think he is on loan in Holland and cannot get a game.
He looked real promising in preseason and playing for the Reserves and it all went pear shaped v Leeds in the League Cup when he finally got a game.
Ian Glassey
114 Posted 22/01/2014 at 14:31:03
I don't think Junior or this other lad are much good, if they were City would never have given us £12mill for Rodwell..
James Marshall
115 Posted 22/01/2014 at 14:37:33
But they did give us £12m for Rodwell, who clearly isn't very good either!
Jim Knightley
116 Posted 22/01/2014 at 14:36:57
The funny thing is that, with all this complaining about short termism, there is a good chance that we will get one of loans back for a longer period. In fact, if one of them stayed for two seasons, we will have probably got more football out of them than Jelly, or Naismith, or a multitude of other players which have come and gone over the years.

I don't understand why the potential of us actually signing one of them full time is not brought up either. Pienaar and Arteta both started as loans...and look what happened here.

And of course there are loan fees in most cases. And similarly, it is quite common for a parent club to meet some of the loaned players wage requirement, therefore enabling a player to be at the club but costing us less per week than he would if we owed him.

This moaning just seems for moaning sake. And great to see you ignored my post again Phil.

Brian Wilkinson
117 Posted 22/01/2014 at 14:22:13
By taking these players on loan, it makes a big difference; they have a lot to prove and are all class players. I believe the players on loan will give us a much higher finish in the Premier League. If each finishing place is around a million then we have clawed some of the money back right away.

If we get into a Champions League place, we then have a much stronger case for future players to sign for us. It's hard to attract players for a team that has not qualified for the European competitions. A lot of ifs and buts I know, but I honestly believe we would be further down the league without the players we have on loan.

As Dan is aware how much we are paying for loanees, I would like to know, how much we would pay in transfer fees for the players on top of the wages, we would still have to pay, and how much each finishing position is worth in the Premier League. I do agree, Dan, it would be nice if we signed permanent players but to get the best we really need to be pushing for Europe, and with the loanees we have, I think we have a decent chance of achieving this.

In regards to not getting anything but a thank you, you are missing the point: we have already got money from the deadwood we offloaded, we are not paying that much more out after the wages we saved on the sold players. What we will get is a better profile of Everton and a better chance of signing future players with the way these loanees have pushed us on to the brink of European football.

Brian Wilkinson
118 Posted 22/01/2014 at 14:50:00
Spot-on, Jim 472, my thoughts as well.
James Elworthy
119 Posted 22/01/2014 at 14:52:53
I would take Rodwell back on loan but we cant as we have our 2 maximum PL players on loan already.
I liked Rodwell he is one of our own and never caused a bit of bother at the club and I don't think he wanted to leave in the first place.
He is the type that needs to play every week and hopefully City will loan him to someone where he can get a game and we can buy him back for 2 million
Robin Cannon
120 Posted 22/01/2014 at 14:46:32
I think the loans can provide us with short term success and the foundation for a long term future; not necessarily in the players themselves (who may or may not stay), but in terms of pushing our standard of football and improving our profile. Obviously that's particularly the case if we snatch Champions' League qualification.

Probably also worth never underestimating the impatience of young footballers. Sure, seems very unlikely that Lukaku or Delefeou would become permanent signings. But...you're 18-20 years old, playing regularly in a successful team in the EPL, and there's the prospect of going back to a parent club and sitting on the bench or in the reserves. Not inconceivable that you might want to put pressure on for a permanent move at that point, even if the parent club leans towards not selling.

Even from a value perspective; while a loan player doesn't necessarily have a sell on benefit; permanent players can become a long term drain on resources in a way that a loanee never can.

Brian Waring
121 Posted 22/01/2014 at 14:58:00
"Everton are preparing an ambitious loan move for striker Torres."

No, not that one! Oliver Torres from Atletico Madrid.

James Marshall
122 Posted 22/01/2014 at 15:02:28
He looks about 14.
Eric Myles
123 Posted 22/01/2014 at 14:54:33
Max #456 "Why don't we win more of these drawn games? Why don't we take more risks and go hell for leather for the win?
The abnormal number of draws is a legacy from Moyes, and we must alter our midset and change our attitude"

Absolute nonsense, our mindset and attitude is completely different than under Moyes. The drawn games have either been a result of us playing badly (Spurs & WBA) or going hell for leather but being unlucky (RS & Arsenal).

Consistency is the problem and the lack of finishing.

James Elworthy
124 Posted 22/01/2014 at 15:35:46
You can only have 4 on loan.
Max Murphy
125 Posted 22/01/2014 at 15:35:20
Eric, you're entitled to your opinion but we are drawing an abnormal number of games, and it is slowly approaching the total draws we had under Moyes.

Do you remember the drawn game against Spurs earlier this season? One of the worse performances I've witnessed by an Everton team in over 30 years. Which clearly makes your assertion complete garbage.

Andrew Ellams
127 Posted 22/01/2014 at 16:00:10
Max, as we have only lost two games perhaps you could put a positive spin on it and say we are winning more of the drawn games and drawing more of the lost games. Hence the fact we have more points than at any time in Moyes or any of his predecessors since Gordon Lee had at this point of the season.
Ian Glassey
128 Posted 22/01/2014 at 16:14:07
Can you not have as many loans as you like from abroad, but only 4 in the team?

I don't know does anyone know how it works?..

David Israel
130 Posted 22/01/2014 at 16:55:14
Ian, # 520, trying to answer your question, although this text is not very straightforward:

"The Premier League rules
The Premier League rules relating to temporary loan transfers are contained in Section 5, Rule V5 to V10 of the Premier League Handbook. They restrict the number of loan players a Premier League team can have in one season to four and no more than one player can be loaned from a particular club. No more than two players can be registered at one time by a club (unless that player becomes permanent or is an emergency goalkeeper).

Loophole
Neither the Premier League nor the Football League rules contain such restrictions in relation to international loans. When a player joins a club from an international association, the leagues recognise that player as a new signing. They do not register that player as a loan signing but as a permanent transfer while FIFA recognise the player as being on loan. So, in essence, a team could have 11 international loan players in the team on a match day without breaking any Premier League or Football League regulations."

http://www.lawinsport.com/blog/joshua-kaye/item/the-international-loan-loophole-should-and-could-it-be-closed

David Israel
131 Posted 22/01/2014 at 16:56:40
The loan loophole probably means an English club can get 11 players - or even a full squad - on loan from Scottish clubs!
Ian Glassey
132 Posted 22/01/2014 at 17:02:14
Thanks David, thats it then I think we can expect a few more loans then..
Dennis Ng
133 Posted 22/01/2014 at 17:17:59
David (527), nice info. Wouldn't it be easier to just loan the entire Barca bench and academy? They play the football RM envisions already.
Phil Walling
134 Posted 22/01/2014 at 18:20:49
Being really provocative now but the loan system is what separates us from the five clubs above us and the two below. Believe me, if we do break into the top four they will change the bloody rules.

As a Manc customer said to me the other day,' Everton are always on the beg these days !'My repost that their manager would like our defence fell on deaf ears!

Harold Matthews
135 Posted 22/01/2014 at 15:29:30
We finished 6th last season but we were 9 points behind the team in 5th. This season, with an ageing squad, Fellaini gone and a bench down to the bare bones, I dread to think where we would be without the addition of Barry, Lukaku and Deulofeu.
Phil Walling
136 Posted 22/01/2014 at 18:35:10
Totally agree with you, Harold.' Roberto the Loan Wizard' is saving Kenwright's arse!
Dennis Ng
137 Posted 22/01/2014 at 18:42:43
Phil, I was thinking of the same rule change bs that they will have when we get into UCL, but I have faith that the law of unintended consequence to bring us back into contention.
Mark Tanton
138 Posted 22/01/2014 at 18:44:12
I think there's a good chance Thomas Ince will come and sign for us - especially now his dad's left the club.
Dennis Ng
139 Posted 22/01/2014 at 18:47:51
Mark, I like that but where's our CM cover? Looks like all our worries for forward options are solved but now our back (midfield) is sore again. Any word on CMs linked to us? Been a slow day.
Adam Smith
140 Posted 22/01/2014 at 18:45:55
Call me a pessimist (I'm not normally) but I think this deal will now fall through. Falcao has seemingly just done his knee ligaments and may miss the World Cup. Monaco's other strikers aren't great. Surely they won't let Traore go now?!

Although I don't particularly rate Traore (all gangly legs with no touch and no right foot), we are desperately short on numbers and I reckon that the best case scenario now would be a delay so Monaco can reconsider their options. Yet we need people in ASAP with the derby coming up. I think however it would be more likely that they terminate the deal!

Let's hope not!

Colin Glassar
142 Posted 22/01/2014 at 19:00:56
You might be right Adam, it's all gone very quietly recently. I'd go for Tom Ince myself.
Raymond Fox
143 Posted 22/01/2014 at 18:52:20
Phil, you being provocative, now there's a surprise!

Loans are the only way we'll get a sniff of the top 4 in the short term at least.
That is unless you have a spare 100m hanging around doing nothing!

Just been watching highlights of Lukaku from earlier in the season, he looked some player then, he's not been getting the service or the room of late though.

Ross Edwards
144 Posted 22/01/2014 at 19:03:35
The Traore deal could hit another hitch. Falcao has done his knee ligaments in, and their other striker Rivere is attracting attention from a number of clubs.

Maybe we should push for the Standard Liege striker and Ince. Although, as Zaha can't even get in the Man U reserve team, maybe we could go for him.

Just off this topic, why have we been fined £45,000 for a transfer approach we made 3 years ago?

Eugene Ruane
146 Posted 22/01/2014 at 19:05:45
Colin, as his oul feller just got the tin-tack, Ince might be looking for an out - "Sack my oul feller!? Fuck youze, I'm gone!" type stuff.
Colin Glassar
147 Posted 22/01/2014 at 19:12:01
I've seen Ince for the England under 21's Eugene and I think the kids got bags of potential. His dad is a gobshyte but that's not his fault is it? We let Redmond escape to Norwich, we shouldn't commit the same mistake with this kid.
Ian McDowell
148 Posted 22/01/2014 at 19:15:34
seems to be dragging on a bit. Could the deal be on the brink of collapse?
Phil Walling
149 Posted 22/01/2014 at 19:20:30
Think we'd have to take Ince's Dad on as well ! Tangerine fans saying the b....d sold him to the lowest bidder!
Dennis Ng
150 Posted 22/01/2014 at 19:30:53
Falcao's injury just happened so I doubt we'll know anything soon but they have other strikers ahead of Traore. I'll be surprised if they cancel the loan but you never with Tinkerman.
Colin Glassar
151 Posted 22/01/2014 at 19:36:07
Ince is a scumbag Phil, he was down in the smoke on Friday trying to flog his lad to the highest bidder, and refused to take the team training. He's the lads agent, by all accounts, and only wants his slice to bet on the gee gees.
Dennis Ng
152 Posted 22/01/2014 at 19:41:16
Colin, how did he get around the rules like that? Clear conflict of interest.
Colin Glassar
153 Posted 22/01/2014 at 19:43:40
It's common knowledge that he represents his son, Dennis. He might not be his legal rep but he's the one who calls the shots.
Ian Glassey
154 Posted 22/01/2014 at 19:35:22
I think thats the end of that one, back to the drawing board, Roberto will find
somebody he has got to because we are down to the barebones..
Dennis Ng
155 Posted 22/01/2014 at 19:45:55
I see. Ya, you're right there Colin. Wasn't thinking too much into it when I asked. Do we want to deal with Sr though by getting Jr? Seems the whole deal is very shady with Ince Sr in mind.
Colin Glassar
156 Posted 22/01/2014 at 19:58:56
Well, someone said that Traore is like 4th choice at Monaco so it could still happen. Not that I'm too overexcited mind.
Kunal Desai
157 Posted 22/01/2014 at 21:27:57
Rumours now doing the rounds that the Traore deal could be dead as Falcao has suffered a serious injury. Just our luck!
Kunal Desai
158 Posted 22/01/2014 at 21:27:57
Rumours now doing the rounds that the Traore deal could be dead as Falcao has suffered a serious injury. Just our luck!
Patrick Murphy
159 Posted 22/01/2014 at 21:37:37
So McGready it is then: No big surprise really we promise all sorts in January and deliver very little - The Big Guy will probably be all guns blazing in Monaco's next fixture as the Hamstring makes a miraculous recovery. Oh for the days when clubs would just do a deal and parade the player in his new shirt - but all the speculation and people getting excited over nothing is a right pain in the neck.
James Smith
160 Posted 22/01/2014 at 21:24:09
Worried looking at our bench... Even if we do extend a few loans Martinez will have some serious work cut out for the the summer. It will be very interesting to see what happens as i'm sure he will spend everything he can to buy players rather than take the loan route again.

There has to be a reason hes stripping our bench down to just a few decent players and I believe hes collecting all the coins he can for a big rebuild next window.
Ian Glassey
161 Posted 22/01/2014 at 21:37:36
I hope Roberto has someone else in mind, I thought someone would have been in as soon as Jelavic was moved on.

Seems funny that there was no mention of Traore untill he was on his way to
WHU, starting to worry a bit now. Come on Roberto only 9 days to go and I think we could do with 3 players, striker,centre mid/defensive mid and a playmaker...

Kunal Desai
162 Posted 22/01/2014 at 21:53:49
I'm happy to wait until deadline day, especially if RM pulls a couple of signings like the last one. That'll do me.
Chris Wilson
163 Posted 22/01/2014 at 21:55:06
I'm sorry, did I miss something? Is the loan scuppered? I haven't seen anything yet. All I see are a bunch of media outlets who have picked up on one speculative story. And this all may be happening too, but can't we stop the moaning until the deal IS dead, folks? Jesus, the more things change, the more they stay the same.
Mark Frere
164 Posted 22/01/2014 at 22:00:04
Lets not panic! Its still relatively early in the transfer window, a lot can happen and I for one am not convinced by this lanky streak of piss!
James Elworthy
165 Posted 22/01/2014 at 22:03:32
Monday passes medical.
Tuesday gets work permit.
Wednesday deal to go through but silence all day.
We hear Falcao injured.
Is that the reason no deal today.
As usual Evertonians so used to deals falling through, think the inevitable.
Chris Jones
166 Posted 22/01/2014 at 22:20:45
I bet Big Sam's chuckling
Ian Glassey
167 Posted 22/01/2014 at 22:28:10
Daily Mail saying Canales of Valencia on the way on loan was great a few years ago. We were after him but he went to Real Madrid.
Colin Glassar
168 Posted 22/01/2014 at 22:35:39
Sounds like its off. Not too bothered tbh.
James Elworthy
169 Posted 22/01/2014 at 22:45:29
Canales is a midfielder so maybe we will buy Batshuyi now.
Mail also says we have reservations ourselves about Traores hamstring and we may pull the plug.
Colin Glassar
170 Posted 22/01/2014 at 22:49:56
Where are you reading this James? I cant see it. As for Canales, he's never been the same player since he did his knee in a few years ago. I will have to trust Roberto on this one as he hasn't disappointed me so far.
James Elworthy
171 Posted 22/01/2014 at 22:53:14
Go on the Daily Mail and click on sport then football, the story is there.
Jim Bennings
172 Posted 22/01/2014 at 22:47:30
Since the turn of the year, it really has gone tits up a bit.

Injuries to Barkley and Coleman... okay, we hear it's only minor but then again how many times have we heard that, only to not see the player for a month?

And now, on top of this, we hear news that yet another fucking injury, to a guy who doesn't even play for us, Falcao, could scupper the move on loan for Traore. Does this club have any damn luck at all with injuries??

I cannot see this deal going ahead now; if it was going to happen, like someone said above, it would have happened by today, maybe even yesterday. I mean other than Monaco wanted to hold on to him now, what the hell is the hold up?

He's had his medical, been granted the work permit and surely terms and conditions have already been thrashed out, so it looks like its another fucked up Sean Davis, Leroy Fer transfer.

Oh well looks like we will have to just watch Lukaku stumble through the rest of the season before sodding off back to Chelsea come May. If we don't sign a striker what has he got to worry about? Typical Everton, flog Jelavic for pretty good money then spend fuck all.

Why don't we at least test the water for Ince? Blackpool are practically inviting any half decent offers for him and its clear they don't want him going to France in the summer for a shit fee so lets go come on.

Colin Glassar
174 Posted 22/01/2014 at 22:59:34
Found it James, halfway down their gossip column. It says that Everton are unsure about Traore's hammy and mentions Canales's bad knee injuries. The lad is only 22 and is a playmaker in the Modric mould. I can't see either of these coming off if I'm honest.
James Marshall
175 Posted 22/01/2014 at 23:08:05
http://www.dailystar.co.uk/sport/football/361908/Monaco-set-to-scrap-Everton-deal-for-Lacina-Traore-following-injury-to-Radamel-Falcao
James Elworthy
176 Posted 22/01/2014 at 23:03:36
Having previous bad injuries fits the mould of the player we go for.

At least Man Utd are out of the League Cup which means City winning it will open 6th place for the Europa League as the runner up doesn't qualify. Knowing our luck, we will finish 6th and Sunderland will win it.

Jim Bennings
177 Posted 22/01/2014 at 23:10:32
Unless we improve our squad I am not sure we will be finishing 6th.

Top 4

City
Arsenal
Chelsea
RedShite (hate to say it)

5th...United
6th..Spurs
7th..Everton (same as last year again lads I reckon)

Colin Glassar
178 Posted 22/01/2014 at 23:12:19
Matt Law, from The Telegraph, is saying Chelsea let Mata go cos they are going for Barkley in the summer. Apparently, BK had a meeting in London with the Chelsea hierarchy last week. Who knows?
James Marshall
179 Posted 22/01/2014 at 23:15:01
Nobody, Colin. Nobody knows.

Perhaps he was talking to Abramovich about theatre tickets.

James Elworthy
180 Posted 22/01/2014 at 23:14:49
Did BK meet to discuss Lukaku?

A different journalist could put a different spin on it. He would be a fool to go there and get as much game time as Rodwell does.

Patrick Murphy
181 Posted 22/01/2014 at 23:15:09
Jim, I fully understand your concerns but come on mate have a little bit of faith – we still have 16 games to play and all the players won't be out for all of them games. We can still make fourth but the fans have to believe it or else the fear of losing will translate itself to the players and we might as well pack it in now if we only believe we can get 7th. Glass half-full is a legitimate way of looking at life but I'm not even sure you have a glass.
Patrick Murphy
182 Posted 22/01/2014 at 23:19:33
I hope we don't make the mistake of doing a swap with Lukaku for Barkley – I'd rather send Lukaku back in the summer than see Barkley leave.
Peter Laing
183 Posted 22/01/2014 at 23:18:32
Bill Kenwright could get £100 million from Abramovich for Barkley and would still be asking his Missus Jenny Seagrove to rummage down the back of the sofa to try to find a few bob to give to Roberto.
James Marshall
184 Posted 22/01/2014 at 23:29:31
Personally I'm not that bothered if we don't sign this bloke anyway.
James Marshall
185 Posted 22/01/2014 at 23:34:14
On the Barkley front - it would be nice to think that he took Steven Gerrard's advice to heart. The one and only thing I have, and probably ever will commend Captain Fantastic for is telling Barkley to be a one-club-man and stay at Everton while they were on England duty together,

Naturally there are agents and plenty of other forces at work, so it might have fallen from his consciousness by the time the summer comes but it's a small crumb and given that it came from Ross himself, it's worth keeping in mind.

Colin Glassar
186 Posted 22/01/2014 at 23:45:24
I don't think Ross will leave in the summer. For what ever it's worth. I mean, what do I know?
Patrick Murphy
187 Posted 22/01/2014 at 23:49:53
Apparently Chelsea have agreed a fee with United for Mata of £37m. I am now worried that Ross may be sold now rather than in the Summer.
Colin Glassar
188 Posted 22/01/2014 at 23:51:32
No chance Patrick. That just won't happen, believe me.
Jim Bennings
189 Posted 22/01/2014 at 23:48:02
Patrick

I can see where you're coming from, but it's just my opinion mate. We won't get in the top five or six because we don't win enough games, we are still a very very hard side to beat and to a good extent we have added flair to our play more often than not under Roberto but the fact remains, we don't have the punch in the final third that our rivals have, that's because we don't have/spend money like those sides.

We also have wretched luck with injuries. There is no sign of Deulofeu coming back, we keep hearing he is progressing yet he is still in Spain recovering so I assume we wont be seeing him anywhere near match fit before the end of February.

As for Barkley, well he could miss important games at Liverpool and Spurs, games we need to take positive results, or at least one positive result from.

We are going to get further suspensions and injuries, I think that's doubtless to say, plus the striker situation is bleak at the minute; you can't dress it up any other way, Lukaku has scored just one goal in two months and is our only striker.

I didn't know much about Traore but just maybe by signing him we may actually score some headers from crosses now and again. We never ever look a threat from crosses and set pieces these days, due to us being quite a small team outside of Lukaku.

It's great to play beautiful football all the time but it has not always worked, especially against sides who just want to stop us playing and park the bus, it would have been nice to have an alternative way of playing..

But hey glass half full, who knows maybe the loan signing of Traore might still come off.

Jim Bennings
190 Posted 22/01/2014 at 23:59:40
Patrick

You just had a pop at me about having a glass half full then you are worried Barkley may go to Chelsea??

Pot and kettle mate.

Patrick Murphy
191 Posted 23/01/2014 at 00:05:27
I'm always optimistic on the football side of things but when it comes to Everton and money ....well let's just say I'm a skeptic. I wasn't having a pop as you put it. I was just trying to encourage you not to constantly write off our chances of getting CL football. Bill Kenwright is not a man I would personally trust despite the fact that he is a True Blue.
.
Richard Harris
192 Posted 23/01/2014 at 00:03:28
So why would Mourinho not play Mata (who was probably the best player at Chelsea for two seasons and also has European final and international experience) because he is building a midfield around Hazard, Oscar and Willian and then sign Barkley who has less experience and at the moment is not as good as Mata? If Mata was on the bench then why would Barkley be a first choice at Chelsea if they signed him?
James Marshall
193 Posted 23/01/2014 at 00:08:37
Patrick - we won't sell him now.

I'll have a tenner with you on that.

Patrick Murphy
194 Posted 23/01/2014 at 00:11:07
I obviously hope that you are right and I am wrong but the Board at Everton has played this trick so often that nothing would surprise me. Also his English suitors will want to buy him well before the World Cup gets going and the sooner they can do a deal the better it will be for the clubs who want to buy him. As I said earlier I wouldn't want to buy Lukaku if it meant losing Barkley.
Si Cooper
195 Posted 23/01/2014 at 00:20:35
Do Monaco normally play with two strikers? If so then now that Traore has been elevated to their third choice I can see them having a rethink. May depend on whether they can themselves get cover in as the idea is obviously for him to get game time with us rather than be unused with them.

Like (I suspect) many others I am not completely sold on this lad (not even knowing he existed a matter of days ago) but we need to get an effective striker in from somewhere before the window closes 9and the sooner the better).

James Stewart
196 Posted 23/01/2014 at 00:45:27
Very strange of Chelsea to sell Mata to United I think they will regret that decision. Top class player and one of the best in the world.

I can see our deal getting pulled now they have had the injury. We are taking our time with this one!

Eric Myles
197 Posted 23/01/2014 at 00:45:49
James #709 "Mail also says we have reservations ourselves about Traores hamstring and we may pull the plug"

I hope his hamstrings are not as fcuked as Fer's knees.

Si Cooper
198 Posted 23/01/2014 at 01:06:21
Surely your reservations about medical matters are discussed and put to bed when the medical is carried out? Or is it standard practice to continue progressing the paperwork/ negotiations while you are waiting for further tests / a second opinion?

Hope we are not just finding excuses because we have changed our minds; that would be a twat of a thing to do having hijacked his move to West Ham, and I don't want us to be that kind of club. Perhaps it makes no difference but I would prefer us to keep good relations with as many other clubs as possible.

Eric Myles
199 Posted 23/01/2014 at 04:48:29
Jim #472 "I don't understand why the potential of us actually signing one of them full time is not brought up either. Pienaar and Arteta both started as loans...and look what happened here."

They were loans with an option to buy at an agreed price in the deal. Are current loanees are not for sale.

Eric Myles
200 Posted 23/01/2014 at 05:00:14
Max #503, you obviously didn't read my post properly as I referred to that Spurs game as one in which we played badly which is why we drew it, not because of the mindset and attitude of the players as you had stated.
Anto Byrne
201 Posted 23/01/2014 at 07:01:55
I would like to see an Osman replacement in this Window. A proper play maker alongside Barkley. I'm not sure Mirallas is good enough all round – he can't seem to cross or pass that well.
Jermaine Jennings
202 Posted 23/01/2014 at 08:37:04
The Falcao injury could be a blessing in disguise, it might mean that they will be forced to buy Michy Batshuayi from Standard Liege, which is what we need – not anymore loans. It's becoming embarrassing.

Also we badly need another centre midfielder as we can't expect McCarthy or Barry to play every single game it just ain't possible. Steven Defour would be perfect for us. Come on BK!!!

Jim Lloyd
203 Posted 23/01/2014 at 09:14:46
I strongly disagree with those who are complaining about our use of bringing in players on loan. The amount of money involved (someone guessed about best part of £10million) is not a waste, in my view.

It seems to me that Martinez has been told what the transfer fund is and has to work around that. I cannot see any chance in hell of us bringing in 4 players of average (if we're lucky) quality for around £10 million; paying their wages on top of the fees, so that is at least double the amount we have spent in loans. The transfers would be for at least three years and if they didn't come up to the mark, we'd be goosed. True, they might make it but I would think it unlikely.

As it is, we have 3 Premier League class players (possibly 4 depending if Traore isn't dragged back), which we would not have had the money to buy. They have given us a chance of making it into Europe and possibly the Champions League.

Come the Summer, we will see whether the manager gets funding to buy two or three top class players. My guess is that he wont.

So, to me, I can't see any logic in saying loans are costly and have no end product. The players on loan have all made a good impact in the team and the squad and for a club with our lack of cash, they give the manager time to a) develop more of our young players and b) plan for which players he can bring in permanently into the team.

I think that some clubs in the PL will try to have the system banned but while we've got it, I'll be quite happy to see more of the same quality players coming to EFC.

As our manager has said "It's not a question of whether we have a player for 10 years or 1. It's a question of whether we have that player for 1 year (maybe two) or not have that player at all."

Steavey Buckley
204 Posted 23/01/2014 at 09:31:13
At the Everton news conference today, scheduled for 9am, 15 minutes later, Martinez said that loan transfer for Traore should not be affected by injury to Falcao. He said Traore's situation is different because it is about his further development at Everton. But Martinez would know exactly in a couple of hours after speaking presumably the Monaco's manager, Ranieri.
Brian Waring
205 Posted 23/01/2014 at 09:46:59
Fucking hell lads, talk about downbeat! Keep the faith.
James Marshall
206 Posted 23/01/2014 at 09:49:41
Interesting Steavey - where did you get the 9am conference details may I ask?

Regarding Mata above - the reason Chelsea are happy to sell Mata is because he doesn't and never will fit into a Jose Mourinho team. He likes attacking players who also tackle & defend. Mata does neither, whereas Oscar and Willian track back and tackle like dogs which is what JM always wants from his midfield players.

Yes Mata is class, and brilliant going forward, but he couldn't tackle a wet paper bag = Mourinho happy to flog him for £40m to Utd.

James Marshall
207 Posted 23/01/2014 at 09:53:37
Ignore that, Steavey - I just saw it on the SSN feed.
Kevin Tully
208 Posted 23/01/2014 at 10:00:08
If we let bring in McGeady & Traore for Jelavic, then that's got to be viewed as a good bit of business. Let's face it, Jelavic was finished at Everton, even though we all liked him for his attitude. Even McGeady is an upgrade on Jelavic, he will be seen as good cover on the wings.

As Martinez said – we will finish this transfer window with a stronger squad, we can ask no more with this board calling the shots.

Steavey Buckley
209 Posted 23/01/2014 at 10:07:50
James on the EFC home page.
James Marshall
210 Posted 23/01/2014 at 10:11:13
It's a sad indictment of the EFC Official site when it's the last place I look for news on Everton!
Jim Bennings
211 Posted 23/01/2014 at 10:09:42
I don't think there is anything wrong with using the loan system either, its just that we always need to remember that we are going to be at the mercy of the players parent club.

It's now down to Monaco to decide if they want to let Traore leave or not rightly so as he's their player, its just the club who wants they guy on loan is the fall guy.

I am not sure even if Barca had a major injury crisis whether there is something in the agreement to say they can call Duelofeu back or even Lukaku with Chelsea.

It's just the price you have to pay by loaning players, although there is alot to be said of trying before buying in many cases, obviously again that depends on circumstance of the parenting club potentially inviting a permanent deal at the end of the loan.

It has worked a treat with people like Kevin Campbell, Mikel Arteta etc.

Matt Geraghty
212 Posted 23/01/2014 at 10:23:05
Slightly off topic, but I found this link:

http://www.squawka.com/news/2014/01/22/chelsea-wonderkid-im-becoming-a-target-man-thats-not-my-best-role/2014012258058?

Lukaku's having a moan about the tactics we use and the fact that Everton are using him as a target man.

Phil Walling
213 Posted 23/01/2014 at 10:21:25
I'm happy to loan players on the basis that they are on trial for a permanent move but for Everton to be used as training academy for bigger clubs just shows how far off the big time we now are.

I know it's probably the only way we can cling to 6th or 7th spot but as one who lived in better times it genuinely hurts.

Jim Bennings
214 Posted 23/01/2014 at 10:19:53
I am none too pleased though hearing Martinez say that there will be no more signings after Traore. Yet again, it's us sitting on the money we are raking in. What about the remaining Fellaini money or the Jelavic money? Ridiculous what we do with the cash though it is.

How many clubs sell players for the fees we do, yet never hardly splash out? We sold Fellaini and brought in McCarthy for half of that. We sold Anichebe for £6 mill and signed Kone for the same, fair enough. We sell Jelavic for at least £6.5 mill and bring McGeady in for peanuts due to his circumstances.

I thought Martinez was bigging up Tom Ince and stating interest in him a few weeks back? Offer Blackpool a take it or leave it £4 or 5 million, the worst thing to happen is them to say No because he is heading to France in June for a free if we don't or someone doesn't bid, who knows maybe that's already a done deal with Monaco, that's why we aren't making a move.

Still would love to understand the money situation at this club though, I really would.

James Marshall
215 Posted 23/01/2014 at 10:31:10
Jim - he also talked (correctly) about availability and value for money. January is not the right time to be 'splashing out' on players, in part because the right players are simply not available. Don't forget, this is also a World Cup year so players and clubs are twitchy and the market is fluctuating and unstable with regard to prices & (again) availability.

It's not as straightforward as just going out and buying a player because you think he's a good footballer. There are a LOT of things to take into consideration. These are human beings with families, fragile careers (which are short), clubs pressuring them, fans pressuring them, agents pressuring them, you name it.

Just because we have some money doesn't mean we just go out and use it all up here & now.

We've bought a midfielder (permanent) and trying very hard (clearly) to bring in a striker – I don't see what more the club and manager can do to appease supporters to be honest?

Jim Bennings
216 Posted 23/01/2014 at 10:30:40
Lukaku wont be here after the end of the season anyway so I wouldn't worry too much about what he says.

I don't know what it is but I have noticed a change in attitude and body language in Lukaku over the last two months, I can't put my finger on what it is but he just doesn't seem the same player that we saw at the end of September or right through October and November.

When I was at the Newcastle match in September, Lukaku's home debut, I was so excited, I thought we had a beast of a player who was quick strong and could score goals for fun. Over the last 8 or 9 games, he just doesn't seem to be moving well, he has looked sluggish, lethargic and at times disinterested.

Now I know he is only 20 and still learning but he has stopped doing the simple basic things which to a big strong lad like him should be a given. And that is use your power and pace to bully and chase down defenders, Iike the goal he got against Newcastle where their centre half and goalie shit themselves when they saw him coming.

I want him so badly to come good again and have a great end to the season, because I know he has it in him to get at least 16-17 goals, and we damn need him to do it, he is the only hope we have at present.

Mark Tanton
217 Posted 23/01/2014 at 10:41:14
James I agree with you. But we ARE desperate for a central midfielder, with the forgotten Gibson and non-entity non-footballer Leon Osman. Can McCarthy and Barry play every single minute of the rest of the season together?
James Marshall
218 Posted 23/01/2014 at 11:01:53
We have need for midfield cover, yes Mark. I would suggest it won't happen though because the club see us as having plenty of players there – even if Gibbo is injured and Ossie is shit.
David Starsky
219 Posted 23/01/2014 at 10:54:18
Jim, Matt

I just watched the news conference, and also checked Deloitte's new Football Money League report.

Firstly, the club must be getting some money – now I am not an accountant and I do not know where our outgoings are – but according to Deloitte:

"Although Liverpool (12th) grew revenue strongly by 9%, the club was knocked out of the top 10 for the first time since 1999/2000. As the Money League's highest placed non-Champions League club, the Reds may well re-enter the top 10 next year thanks to the new Premier League broadcast deals. The uplifts delivered by these deals will allow other English clubs such as Everton, Newcastle United, and West Ham United to challenge for top 20 positions next year. Tottenham Hotspur maintained their 14th position despite an ultimately frustrating season on the pitch."
And from RM's body language, I am not convinced that Baines is committed to staying. And now as OFM is in the deep doo doo he might wangle a better offer for Bainesy.

Just my wild speculation, apart from the money, and I hope the Traore deal goes through as Lukaku has NOT been the same player for us these past games. He needs the ball fed through to him, and we are not playing to his strengths at the moment.

Things change fast in football, and I hope, when the lads are back from injury over the next weeks, RM will address the issue of getting men in the box and strikes on target.

Andrew Bennett
220 Posted 23/01/2014 at 11:02:34
Concerning Lukaku going off the boil – he hasn't had any decent service for about 10 games IMO... As everyone had been growing in confidence midfielders and defenders are tending to have a shot themselves leaving Lukaku with nothing. This is were McGeady comes in for me – he was the only positive from WBA game.
Phil Walling
221 Posted 23/01/2014 at 11:02:58
Roberto is playing BK's game just as Moyes did before him. The difference is that Roberto can do no wrong so the wise old chairman gets away with it.......again!
David Starsky
222 Posted 23/01/2014 at 11:10:27
BTW, Theresis only ONE club in the top 20 money list that makes it's most revenue from Matchdays – that club being Arsenal.

And there is a warning that NO club in the top 20 will do this in future!!

So the future is Broadcasting money and Commercial revenue steams.

Trevor Lynes
223 Posted 23/01/2014 at 11:03:14
If the Traore deal does not come off, we will be in a weaker position at the end of this transfer window unless we buy or loan in an equivalent player. We have sold Jelavic and only brought in McGeady who did not cost much money. What is going on with our transfer budget? We have taken in far more than we have spent and none of that money is being utilised to actually strengthen the squad when we have a decent chance of a top four finish.

Heitinga and Vellios should not be on the bench. Neither are up to scratch and hopefully both will be on their way sooner rather than later. With the present spate of injuries to virtually all our best players, it is ridiculous to be just sitting back and hoping for the best! We desperately need reinforcements of Premier League standard players to plug the gaps and give us a way to rotate players who are struggling.

Osman is a very good impact sub for Barkley or Pienaar but now Barkley is injured, he has to play a full game and he is struggling. Likewise Deulofeu is another player who can rotate with Mirallas but again he is unavailable for the foreseeable future. Barcelona may not want him to return to us as quickly as we want him to as he is their player.

Lukaku now has no deputy and he is being used as a target man and that is not his game. Our bench is woefully weak and is probably the weakest in the league now that we have loaned out all our better youngsters. To have Hibbert, Heitinga and Vellios on the bench is a very poor situation for any side who are seriously challenging for a top four spot.

Brian Furey
224 Posted 23/01/2014 at 11:21:04
I too was really nervous about this deal falling flat at the last moment as I initially thought the deal was done and we were just waiting on the work permit. When I heard that was awarded I thought we had him but with the injury to Falcao last night I was very worried it wouldn't happen now.

I had a quick look at the Monaco FC Website and there's no mention of the player anywhere. He was only brought in on 4th January so maybe they've not updated their website yet. He seems to have quite a good goal-to-game ratio and even at international level he's scored 4 in 7 games. Not bad at all.

When he scores, we can turn that Irish Tricolour behind the goals upside and make it an Ivory Coast flag.

GOAL website - Martinez hopeful over Lacina Traore loan despite Falcao injury

Could we get him on loan where they can call him back if they need him? So, if they get any more injuries, then he can go back to them?

Linda Morrison
225 Posted 23/01/2014 at 11:31:50
Agree with all the posts. it is very frustrating for supporters and I think it would be better all round if we were not given any information until a deal was signed sealed and delivered.

Of course we can't stop the gossip in the press, but at present it is a week since Baines was signing this new deal. Where is it?

I still think he wants to go to MU and would be very grateful if he did. We could then give Oviedo the position he did so well in when Baines was injured.

We are being linked with all and sundry and now we have Lukaka apparently moaning that he does not like the service he is getting at Everton. If he is a world class strkiker he should be able to adapt, although I have to admit that he is feeding off scraps at present.

I for one will be very happy when February 1st comes.

Colin Malone
226 Posted 23/01/2014 at 12:12:40
Anyone remember Apostolos Vellios?. would have been much more efficent than Lakaku against WestBrom. Vellios could play along side Lakaku if Bobby wants to go to a plan B.
Jim Lloyd
227 Posted 23/01/2014 at 12:15:10
What dou you expect Phil? If by "playing BK's game." you think he is kow towing to the Board...well maybe he is. I don't believe that is the case though. He has accepted a job, knowing what budget he is likely to be working to.

So far he seems to be making a good fist of providing attacking, exciting football within those limits.Try and separate the two things. The football he is providing is not above criticism as you see in some of the posts.
but the problem he has, as would any manager coming to our club, is working to the financial constraints.

I don't expect RM to accept a job and then lead a revolution to get rid of this Board. I certainly wouldn't want to see any other manager in the job and I pleased as punch I got my season ticket again.

We may not get into Europe, we just might do but the pleasing thing to me is the way we are beginning to play our football.

I don't see this as somehow seeing that the "Wise old Chairman gets away with it again."

Kenwright had to pick another manager, it's not as if he said to himself one morning last December "D'you what? I think I'll sack my Pal Moyes 'cos the football he produces is just not good enough. Moyes told him as goog as that he would see how thiungs go in the league and the cup before making a decision about signing another contract.

In my view, Kenwright should have fucked him right off there and then, if he wasn't going to sign.

I don't see Roberto Martinez, stopping me from thinking our Board, and especially the Chairman, should sell up (seeing as he is always talking to 3 interested parties)

While we're stuck with them, this manager is at least a massive step forward from the last.

Mark Tanton
228 Posted 23/01/2014 at 12:36:49
He hasn't acted anything like Moyes so far - he acted quickly in the summer window, with Kone and Robles coming in before Moyes had even logged on his Man Utd computer.

He has also acted differently by creating extra wage capacity and transfer funds through selling players - Moyes was always reluctant to allow anyone to leave and then moaned about having no transfer funds.

We'll see some money spent in the summer, so let's not fret! We need a central midfielder though, and I wish we could find a cheap one this week. Leon Osman should be shipped out - to give him a new contract was absolutely criminal.

Patrick Murphy
229 Posted 23/01/2014 at 12:37:34
I think the three interested parties that BK has talked to in the previous 10 years are the three wise monkeys - "See no buyer", "Hear no offer" and "Speak no chance" of course there is sometimes a fourth monkey who BK represents, and that one is named "Do No Deal"
.
Kunal Desai
230 Posted 23/01/2014 at 12:51:19
If Traore is a no goer then we need to act fast in bringing in another replacement for Jelavic, surely RM must have had some players in mind before he sold Jelavic. I certainly think we needs cover in defensive midfield as well. If we fail in getting atleast two more in, then i'm not entirely convinced we'll make top four. Make it happen Billy Boy!
Jim Lloyd
231 Posted 23/01/2014 at 12:57:53
Well said Patrick!
Col Wills
232 Posted 23/01/2014 at 13:39:02
I’ve said this before... Steve Sidwell would be absolutely ideal for Everton this Transfer Window, He would provide cover, can score goals (usually against us), has the Premier League experience, suffers from few injuries, and won’t cost more than £4- £5m.
Brian Cleveland
233 Posted 23/01/2014 at 13:47:18
By the way, I don't know if anyone mentioned it and I haven't read through all the threads, but Falcao is not Brazilian, he is Colombian!

Come on Ed. get it right! ;-)

(Ex. pat in Colombia with a girlfriend who is now very indignant having seen this error... please fix it so she can calm down!!)

Ian Glassey
234 Posted 23/01/2014 at 13:58:00
So Roberto says that if this deal goes through then thats it, I don't think that
McGeady and this lad will make the squad better than when the window opened.

We could and hopefully do lose Johnny H so I don't think its stronger, these two lads are not match fit and will take a few weeks to get up to speed.

I hope there is more to come but it does not sound promising, at least I will be able to switch my pc off and give my fingers a rest..

Brian Wilkinson
235 Posted 23/01/2014 at 14:52:40
This could only happen to Everton, deal on hold due to main striker injured. Bill frantically having his hand down the back of his settee to try and find funds for Roberto and consoling Bobby by reminding him we still have Kenwyne Jones on speed dial.

Just for once it would be nice to land a player without any complications or last minute pre Big Ben clock striking.

David Israel
236 Posted 23/01/2014 at 15:37:14
Dennis #536, I don't know if it would be easier, but it certainly would be much nicer! :-)
Drew Shortis
237 Posted 23/01/2014 at 15:45:03
Ian Glassey 865
I think we will be stronger at the end of the window with McGeady and Traore in for Heitinga who never plays and Jelavic who never scores. Granted we won't be stronger in numbers, but in quality we will be stronger. I did hope we would get a central midfielder in as well. I find it hard to believe there won't be a little deadline day drama despite what he said in his interview. After all, who here was expecting Lukaku's arrival at the end of the last window!
Roberto Birquet
238 Posted 23/01/2014 at 16:08:45
Jim 821

what money we're reaking in?

do people know anything about football finances?

and Martinez'c omment on traore was: We HOPE [falcao injury] won't affect his opportunity to come to us on loan.

This will be for Monaco and Monaco alone to choose. Not for the lad's developemnt, but the good of Monaco. That's what we'd expect of ~Everton if the tables were turned. And that's how it'll be. I hope we have another iron (no pun on stealing from west Hm intended) in the fire. We neeed a striker or we won;t have much chance of making 4th.

John Crook
239 Posted 23/01/2014 at 16:06:21
Everyone is agreeing that midfield cover is required. Apparently James McArthur has been seen at Finch Farm today. I hope he has only dropped into visit though.
Brian Waring
240 Posted 23/01/2014 at 16:12:08
One of the ITK's on GOT has said we are in advanced talks with James McArthur from.......................................................WIGAN!!!!!!!
Dennis Ng
241 Posted 23/01/2014 at 16:02:39
Patrick, Agree with you on not wanting Lukaku over Barkley. Insane link if you ask me, unless they will table an insane offer, like Lukaku plus 150m? ;) I do hope RM brought BK his new 3 wise monkeys, "Think Positive", "Play Positive" and "Go Make Some Deals". At this rate, Whelan sounds like a better owner than BK by miles.

Jim, Hope he said "no more" on a at the moment mindset. He did say things change in terms of transfer opportunities in earlier interviews and hopefully he does have plans to boost our CM ranks. Even if not now, I hope in summer. Don't see many clubs willing to sell players on the cheap in Jan, other than Chelsea and ManC.

David (882), I know right? Even their reserve frontline/midfield would be good enough! We have the defence covered anyway.

Eric Myles
242 Posted 23/01/2014 at 16:22:26
Colin #849, I remember him, he was rubbish.
Patrick Murphy
243 Posted 23/01/2014 at 16:25:32
Brian - if it's on loan as well Phil Walling will be marching to Goodison as we speak. This is the lad I thought we were signing when we were first linked with McCarthy..Wigan have just got McEachran on loan from Chelsea...so this story might have some legs.
Matt Traynor
244 Posted 23/01/2014 at 16:27:05
Col #862. Steve Sidwell? £4-5m? He’s 31! And shit. Are you his agent?
James Marshall
245 Posted 23/01/2014 at 16:37:33
Chelsea have also just robbed Mohamed Salah from under the noses of the evil ones across the way.

Ha!

Steve King
246 Posted 23/01/2014 at 16:42:17
Sidwell is out of contract in the summer so definitely not £4-5 million.....also he’s crap
Brian Waring
247 Posted 23/01/2014 at 16:32:08
I forgot about Phil, Patrick, I'm beginning to worry for his sanity, maybe I should have kept it to myself.

Col Wills
248 Posted 23/01/2014 at 16:45:13
Matt — Agent? Naargh, just watched Sidwell many times and he’s always stood out as a good player who can pass the ball and score, and we need cover in that area.

Simple really

Mike Powell
249 Posted 23/01/2014 at 16:37:42
I know we need midfielders but Steve Sidwell...?!

You’re right, Matt, he is shit. I wouldn’t take him on a free.

Wayne Smyth
250 Posted 23/01/2014 at 16:51:31
Phil (831) How much has Bill pocketed? How much should we have to spend?

I'm sick of hearing these idiotic negative comments about how money disappears and is withheld with fuck all to back them up. Our chairman is guilty of a lot of stuff, but trousering cash I don't think is one of them.

Of course the whole idea is premised on the fact that there are players out there who Roberto wants and are available but whom we can't sign because of the missing cash.

When we fail to spend a few million as soon as we receive it then it must be that our chairman is siphoning the money somewhere. It couldn't be that actually our manager is waiting for the summer, or putting relatively small change towards a major signing.

Iain Johnston
251 Posted 23/01/2014 at 16:29:42
I think the WBA game proved we have no creativity at the moment, playing Oviedo on the right tells us he's out of options too. I'd like to see Naismith given a go behind the striker, he can't do any worse than Osman. He may also play Lukaku in more often than not. The service to him has dried up completely.

Losing Deulofeo, Barkley and now Pienaar has robbed us of our attacking impetus.These players wont return until the window closes.

Yes, we've signed McGeady and now possibly Traore, another two players who won't be match fit until February. That's FIVE attacking players unavailable until after the transfer window.

If we don't do some business to add to our creativity, we'll be out of it by the time we play Palace.

Anything similar to our Monday night performance against the RS, well...

AV are decent away from home and we've all seen what Sherwood is doing at Spurs.

We need to spent some of the money were supposed to have now, it's got to the point where we can't wait until the summer.

Mark Taylor
252 Posted 23/01/2014 at 18:03:57
"When we fail to spend a few million as soon as we receive it then it must be that our chairman is siphoning the money somewhere."

Er, Wayne, that is precisely what he does. Not directly in his back pocket but to the bank, to plug our revenue shortfall. One reason we have a revenue shortfall is that the board and shareholders have zero ambition and a total aversion to risk, hence we have zero chance of the reward that comes with risk. Thus, we muddle along in a kind of stasis.

This is Kenwrights fault.It is a lousy (and potentially catastrophic) business model. But what makes it worse are his constant claims that the money raised from transfers will be spent, yet it never is. Surely you have noticed this in recent windows? And it ain't going to change while BK runs things.

I can just about live with being the EPL's lowest net transfer spenders (actually, it's a negative spend). I can't abide it though when our Chairman claims otherwise.


Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads

© ToffeeWeb