Lukaku support for Anelka draws criticism

, 22 January, 60comments  |  Jump to most recent
Much is being made in the media of a Sky Sports interview given by Romelu Lukaku on Monday evening in which he offered support for his childhood "idol" Nicolas Anelka, not so much for the West Brom striker's controversial "quenelle" goal celebration but more for calls not to punish him harshly for what he defends as a gesture of homage to a French comedian.

"He was my idol as a kid and he still is," Lukaku said. "I don't think he should be banned for that, he was just supporting a comedian in France. We don't have to make such a big deal about it.

"I hope he doesn't get suspended because he is a player people want to play on the pitch."

Everton withdrew the video from the official website and have distanced themselves from Lukaku's comments. Far from being "in hot water", as The Express are trying to suggest, the Belgian striker, who is an ambassador for football's anti-discrimination group Kick It Out, is likely to be spoken to but not disciplined by the club. Anelka, however, is facing a lengthy ban if the FA decide to punish him for an anti-Semitic gesture.

» Read the full article at The Independent



Reader Comments (60)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Derek Thomas
1 Posted 22/01/2014 at 07:31:44
I hope to be proved wrong ( go on Rom, prove me wrong ). He came in on the ' late late flight ' right at the end of the window, could it be that his 'baggage' has finally caught him up. Though at 20 or 21 stupid ideas are par for the course ( cringes at memory of own youthful, no grey just black or white opinions )

His on field form has dipped since his debut, have defences sussed him out or does he an over developed sense of his own ability.

Yes we seemed to be going through the motions Vs WBA, but if you can't do better than Vic, then all the potential in the world is not worth a carrot.

Built like Tarzan, plays like Jane, Mk II?

A rich mans Anichebe or the real deal.

Will the New Drogba, please stand up, please stand up.

Steve Hopkins
2 Posted 22/01/2014 at 08:23:31
Was having a conversation with a mate of mine yesterday as to why we felt that these idiot footballers just can't keep their mouths shut.....is it lack of intelligence or do they just not care what people think and court controversy just for the crack of it.
My mate thinks they just don't care but I put it down to intelligence and the social circles that these young men get dragged out of. You rarely see tennis stars or rugby players come out with this idiotic crap.
Really disappointed in Lukaku, as a club we rarely get caught up in these controversies and it's a shame to start now.
Rom - stick to trying to sort out your on field problems before defending the un-defendable. Anelka will get his ban and rightfully so
Eugene Ruane
3 Posted 22/01/2014 at 08:42:37
Agree that he (they) should keep it shut on all non-football matters.

They know fuck-all so they should say fuck-all.

However I will defend him on the park as the service he's been getting recently has been shite.

The ball that is constantly banged into his feet when he has someone right up his arse - can anyone explain exactly what he is supposed to do with this?

His success has come with balls he can run onto and I've seen very few of those lately.

Paul Thompson
4 Posted 22/01/2014 at 08:46:11
Steve Hopkins - 'I put it down to intelligence'. Lukaku is a very bright lad who happens to speak five languages - French, Dutch, Spanish, Portuguese and English. There are plenty of 'idiot footballers' around, but he ain't one of them. I have no time for Anelka's gesture and what underpins it, but Rom's comments (which he made because he was asked by a Sky reporter), are being blown out of proportion.
Brian Waring
5 Posted 22/01/2014 at 08:49:14
He should have probably said nothing, but I can't see what he has actually done wrong. He gave an opinion, he never made any racist remarks, made any gestures.

Funny thing was it was redshite fans who were all over this on twitter, and before they started kicking off they should think, because there is a pic of Sakho actually doing the quenelle salute.

Eugene Ruane
6 Posted 22/01/2014 at 09:19:42
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/sport/football/teams/manchester-city/10542383/Samir-Nasri-and-Mamadou-Sakho-pictured-performing-same-controversial-quenelle-gesture-as-Nicolas-Anelka.htmlLink
Peter Laing
7 Posted 22/01/2014 at 09:26:42
Agree Eugene regarding the lack of service to Lukaku, the only player capable of finding a through ball from a central position is Barkley. The Lukaku / Barkley partnership has shown glimpses of clicking at times, however I would hazzard a guess that it is both players lack of maturity at the moment that we have not seen this on such a regular basis. Prime example being the tendency for Barkley to hold onto the ball at times for too long before releasing and offensive pass.
Steve Hopkins
8 Posted 22/01/2014 at 09:34:36
Paul I have nothing but respect for a guy who speaks considerably more languages than I do. It's probably more a lack of maturity and 'social intelligence' rather than about being bright or not. Someone of his brightness should have said "it's nothing to do with me, I have my opinions which are private and I'm going to keep them that way, as for the game.....we stunk and bottled the chance to go fourth in the league, good night and I thank you."
How many of our players can you imagine commenting on this on TV? I can't think of any, you rarely hear of Everton players saying controversial things on TV or tweeting stupid stuff
Damien Dempsey
9 Posted 22/01/2014 at 09:14:42
I am sorry but somebody can be anti-zionist without being anti-semitic. Strong criticism opposing the policies of Isreal (i.e. the occupation of Palestine) will always be labelled anti-semitic, especially when the comedian himself, Dieudonné, is little like Ricky Gervais in that certain limits are passed.
In France there are and there have been many famous people who have supported him, so he is not entirely seen as being racist by everyone here (I live in France) but activist against the establishment.
The quenelle has also been adopted by the extreme right. This is where the problem lies.
Eugene Ruane
10 Posted 22/01/2014 at 10:20:29
Damien - "I am sorry but somebody can be anti-zionist without being anti-semitic"

Agree completely.

Brian Waring
11 Posted 22/01/2014 at 10:25:08
Anelka reckons he made it as an anti-establishment gesture, I had never heard of or seen anything about the quenelle salute until the other day, so is this just a case of the pc brigade getting on their high horses, or is it really that offensive?
Patrick Murphy
12 Posted 22/01/2014 at 10:32:20
Rom has probably made an error of judgement in his defence of Anelka but as has been stated it is not quite as clear-cut as to what Anelka actually meant by the gesture and to who it had been aimed at and for what reason.

Perhaps our friends in the media should have a look at why Stan Collymore has allegedly been the subject of death threats following his view that LS dived to win a penalty on Saturday.

There are some things in society that should not be tolerated and are rightly challenged by many, but giving your views about what happens on a football pitch should not be one of them. Intolerance of opposing views is becoming rife throughout society and it is a worrying trend as it gives those with extreme views an opportunity to push their hateful messages into the mainstream.

Steve Hopkins
13 Posted 22/01/2014 at 10:44:40
Firstly why make anti-establishment gesture on a football pitch anyway, is that really a good forum to air your views?
Secondly if Anelka took the time to formulate a plan to make his anti-establishment gesture, when he finally managed to score (haha), then surely he should have owed it to himself and the thousands watching to research exactly what this gesture meant and stood for.
I'm 100% not PC but if I saw a load of people in brown shirts goose stepping down the high street, arms outstretched, shouting sieg heil I would have the common sense to not copy unless I knew exactly what it was all about
Damien Dempsey
14 Posted 22/01/2014 at 10:42:08
British comedy is unique (shit I feel like Roberto) in that our sense of humour is pretty diverse. In France, comedy is pretty slap stick, it is like it has never evolved since the 1980's and then continues back again in a loop to the 1960's. The only british comedies that work over here are Mr. Bean and Benny Hill, which are still re-run constantly.
In each country political correctness and attitudes are different, so in the context it is difficult to judge. I think if Chris Morris was french he would have offended every single group of person living here and would have been already deported back to Britain.
The other issue is semitism, it is a tricky subject to tackle if you are not jewish and you have something negative to say. For an anti-zionist comedian who has the same verbal sensibility as someone like Rick Gervais it has not been too difficult to upset the Jewish community.
The comedian Dieudonne is very politically and socially motivated so he is appreciated by the political left. This is why he the gesture is seen as anti establishment but because he has antagonised the jewish community he is now being appreciated by the extreme right as well.
Eugene Ruane
15 Posted 22/01/2014 at 11:24:46
Brian Waring, as Damien Dempsey states - "The quenelle has also been adopted by the extreme right. This is where the problem lies"

When there are grinning idiots standing ouside Auschwitz making the gesture, I'm happy to side with 'the PC brigade' (ie: people who aren't happy when others are offended by insults based on sexuality, religion, ethnicity etc).

Neil Pickering
16 Posted 22/01/2014 at 11:32:47
Hate to say this, but I am beginning to think 'the special one' was bang on the money with Lukaku; he said he talks too much, and he plainly doesnt think he is good enough.

On form alone he currently shouldnt be in our team as I think the past 9/10 games he has been really poor. He clearly has alot to learn on and off the pitch, and if Traore is fit then I would be having a look at him with Lukaku from the bench.

Phil Bellis
17 Posted 22/01/2014 at 11:48:17
So it's not to do with Phil Neville then, as in For Quenelle Neville?
Hmm...coat
Eugene Ruane
18 Posted 22/01/2014 at 12:38:44
Neil - "On form alone he currently shouldnt be in our team as I think the past 9/10 games he has been really poor"

Nonsense imo, in the last 9/10 games the service he's had has been shite.

He doesn't slack, he works hard and (because he loves scoring) looks interested for the 90 mins.

I watched him closely against Norwich and he spent the game pointing to where he wanted the ball delivered (ie: to run on to).

That ball was rarely (if at all) played.

And by the way, if you drop him, who do you put in his place?

Tony J Williams
19 Posted 22/01/2014 at 13:07:31
I see nothing wrong in what he has said.

He has suggested/explained that it's not racist/anti semitic so what's the problem with defending someone, who himself as confirmed it wasn't meant to be racist/anti semitic?

Brian Waring
20 Posted 22/01/2014 at 13:38:44
Lukaku " It looks like I'm becoming more and more of a target-man."

Link to what Lukaku said http://www1.skysports.com/football/news/11671/9128005/premier-league-romelu-lukaku-keen-to-score-more-everton-goals

Damien Dempsey
21 Posted 22/01/2014 at 13:10:57
Because unfortunately it is now interpreted as being a racist gesture. The comedian Dieudonne who invented the quenelle years ago is currently on trial in France for finding a loop hole in the system for not paying fines and penalties that he has accumulated over the years. Anelka made the gesture as a sign of support because they are friends.

Problems start because the Jewish community regard Dieudonne as being anti-semitic, Dieudonne believes himself to be anti-Zionist. This is where comedy, satire and political correctness become open to debate. Now that Dieudonne has been labelled anti-semitic, neo-nazis have copied this gesture which has caused all kinds of problems.

Dieudonne continues to to make the gesture because for him it is a sign against the establishment and not anti-semitic. I guess he enjoys the controversy that surrounds him being the provoker and political antagonist he is.

What Lukaku has said needs to be put into context.

Peter Warren
22 Posted 22/01/2014 at 13:54:37
What a load of rubbish. Whether or not Anelka is guilty and/or should be banned is a separate debate. Rom thinks he shouldn't. That's all he said. I don't think he's stupid or daft at all and don't think he should have kept his mouth shut. I don't see he's done anything wrong.
Nick Entwistle
23 Posted 22/01/2014 at 14:04:34
The French can't get enough of Mr Bean, so what the hell do they know about comedy? Then again, the UK it seems can't get enough of Miranda.

As usual a run-for-the-hills attitude when the RACE!!!!! subject appears is usually lead by people looking to do the right thing for the interminable amount of people who will be shocked at all this. No one really knows anyone shocked at all this... but more to the point sponsors maybe and that's where the fear comes from.

Well done Zoopla for seeing this as an opportunity... jeesh... someone's earning their money.

And as above you don't have to be anti-zionist to be anti-semitic. And if you've ever seen Doug Stanhope's Fuck the Jews routine, you'll know being anti-semitic doesn't mean you're anti-semitic.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PDWOP_McMHA

Eugene Ruane
24 Posted 22/01/2014 at 14:44:10
Tony (425) - "He has suggested/explained that it's not racist/anti semitic so what's the problem with defending someone, who himself as confirmed it wasn't meant to be racist/anti semitic?"

I'm not really arsed what he's 'explained', I mean firstly, he (anyone) is hardly likely to say "I hate Jews"

Sorry but (and I know this is sweeping) I'm more prepared to judge on what people DO rather than what they say.

I mean anyone can say anything to (attempt to) justify themselves, courtrooms are full of them - "I'd only had a large whiskey your worship, with lemon and sugar as I'd a stinking cold..."

Did he have a cold?

Maybe, maybe not but what IS true is he got into a car and put lives at risk, so fuck him and his 'explanation'.

A ludicrously extreme example - if I goose step around wearing an SS uniform, sieg heiling all over the show, but say "Nothing fascist about it lad, I just think the dark colours and cut suit me, the walk actually helps my bad back and the salute is just a cardiovascular exercise" - would my explanation let me off the hook?

Peter Warren, you don't see he has done anything wrong.

Maybe, maybe not..but he HAS done something dumb.

How can I be so sure?

Because It's fucking obvious what the smart thing is - if you're a high profile PL footballer (and you KNOW the press are all over a story) - say fuck-all and do fuck-all other than play football.

Oh and when/if you score, ffs punch the air rather than miming wearing handcuffs or making little heart shapes or gesturing your solidarity with some anti-establishment comedian in France.

By the way, have seen Doug Stanhope twice and he is a fucking genius - him and Louis CK, imo, best stand-ups in the world right now (nb: but if he played for Everton, I'd give him the same advice - 'loose lips, sink ships')

Damien Dempsey
25 Posted 22/01/2014 at 15:09:20
Wow 784 comments Nick, though I noticed not everybody found it amusing!

Sacha Baron Cohen is another comic who has been reeling off no end of anti-semitic nonsense over the years. How on earth has he never been punished for all the race hatred he has provoked??

Oh wait... he's Jewish...

Eric Myles
26 Posted 22/01/2014 at 15:25:54
Eugene #416 "Nonsense imo, in the last 9/10 games the service he's had has been shite."

I remember the same being said for Beattie, AJ, Jelavic, etc.

Ray Roche
27 Posted 22/01/2014 at 15:20:36
Eugene, "if I goose step around wearing an SS uniform, sieg heiling all over the show"....I'd assume you were 4th in line to the Throne..
Eric Myles
29 Posted 22/01/2014 at 15:33:32
Damien #493, Lenny Bruce was doing similar in the '60s but that was before they invented PCism.
Damien Dempsey
30 Posted 22/01/2014 at 15:30:24
Eugene didn't Prince Harry do pretty much the same thing at a fancy dress party? I could even imagine in the other example given his grandfather doing exactly the same thing if he'd had a cold! Maybe you could write a script Portrait of the Royal Family: the younger Days...
Brian Waring
31 Posted 22/01/2014 at 15:40:31
Roman Abramovich's missus was pictured the other day sitting on a chair sculptured in the form of a black woman and is similar to the British pop artist Allen Jones's 1969 sculpture entitled 'Chair', which showed a white woman in the same pose. She was slated to death, called a racist etc. One magazine editor said the picture was an example of "white dominance and superiority, articulated in a seemingly serene yet overtly degrading way."

She has since come out and apologised for any offence. I didn't look at the pic thinking, whoa that's out of order, she's racist etc, I just saw a piece of artwork by a Norwegian sculpturor that she was promoting.

The point I'm making, is why do some people see something and, instead of seeing it for what it is, they go off on one?

Eugene Ruane
33 Posted 22/01/2014 at 15:56:31
Damien, indeed Prince Harry did, but to be fair, he's the result of hundreds of years of the royals 'rolling their own' so to speak.

Unfortunately, 'playing the game the whole family can play' results in feeble minds (as well as hairy spines and equine-looking grids).

Eric - "I remember the same being said for Beattie, AJ, Jelavic".

Don't think you do, they were regularly missing sitters, Lukaku simply isn't getting service, there's a BIG difference and I can only think of one sitter he's missed (Jelavic in particular missed sitter after sitter after..).

Plus as I've said before, as he's being so tightly marked, it has opened up spaces for others.

By the way, if you've listened to Lenny Bruce, you'll know the spirit of his material WAS PC (ie: 'liberal' and/or anti-discrimination), the fact is the (lazy, last refuge etc) term just hadn't been coined then.

Eugene Ruane
34 Posted 22/01/2014 at 16:13:55
Brian Waring - "The point I'm making, is why do some people see something and, instead of seeing it for what it is, they go off on one?"

Those 'some people' could equally ask why you DON'T see what they see.

They could also ask 'you see it for what it is - what EXACTLY is it?'

To some a golly on a jam jar was harmless and for years, most white Brits saw nothing wrong in it - we 'saw it for what it was' except...it wasn't.

When it was pointed out most black people were offended, some white people ('tut, the bloody PC brigade!') decided maybe it might be the right thing to try and see things from their point of view and those that did, accepted and understood it was insulting and demeaning.

Of course some continued to to say "What's the problem, it's only..."

I remember it was the same with the black and white minstrels ("they're only singing ffs, they're not having a go at anyone like" etc waffle blah).

Sorry but whenever I hear complaints about 'the PC brigade' etc, I always picture some angry fucker complaining 'Fucking hell, now you have to consider the feelings of others, it's insane!"

Damien Dempsey
35 Posted 22/01/2014 at 16:36:18
Brian I've just had a look at the chair. You wouldn't really want to be losing the remote control under that cushion that's for sure...
Ron Sear
36 Posted 22/01/2014 at 16:53:00
For heaven's sake the lad is only twenty years old and it's much to early to have his wisdom+ and anti journalist injections. Like the rest of us back in the stage of youthful certainty he put his foot in his mouth and said what came into his head. Doubt if he had a clue as to the ethical implications or finer philosophical distinctions of the case, just starry eyed about his hero. I bet the Sky interviewer was licking his lips at such easy prey when he asked the question.
Steven Telford
37 Posted 22/01/2014 at 16:53:51
Damian #370
"somebody can be anti-zionist without being anti-semitic"

Well said.

Nonetheless, it is worrying that Lukaku should find somebody of Anelka's persona an idol.
The guy is the epidemy of a sulking spoilt ungrateful football mercenary.
Him and the likes of Adebayor are cut from EXACTLY the same cloth.
If there is a fair chance that "character-wise" Lukaku is similar, then maybe it's best his future lies elsewhere to EFC. touching of this were showing when he said, "if" we qualify for the CL. he "may" consider o stay............ I mean, come on, that says lot in itself. who does he think he is. He has a price tag, but the reputation is not yet built, and I'm not sure if he realises that.

Ray Roche
38 Posted 22/01/2014 at 17:01:27
Eugene, I know from your posts that I am a bit older than you and I remember the Black And White Minstrels and the Roberton's Jam most clearly. Take it from me, I didn't know/knew ANYONE who saw any form of racism or anything non PC in either of those things at that time. It was of it's era and seen for what it was, entertainment or little lapel badges that children collected stickers for, and when they had enough, sent them away for that lapel badge. There was never any form of racism in my house or in my upbringing and I really don't know when it came about that this was offensive. It certainly wasn't offensive to the black lad, my mate, who sat next to me in school and swapped badges with me. Obviously, I am now aware that it is regarded as offensive to the current generation and don't want this to turn into a thread about racial intolerance, but it was considered harmless by just about everyone 55-60 years ago.
Eric Myles
39 Posted 22/01/2014 at 17:07:16
Eugene #518, yes I do definitely remember many posts saying that our former strikers like AJ and Beattie were not getting the service they needed.

As for Lenny Bruce's anti-discrimination, I doubt if anyone would be willing to broadcast his works now with 'anti-semitic' or 'racist' words words (the K and N) words liberally used in his monologues, even though they were not intended to be abusive.

But now it seems that it's the word (or gesture) that a minority can jump on, not the meaning expressed.

But at leat it means we don't have to suffer any more repeats of "Love They Neighbour" or "Mind Your Language" unless you live in Saudi Arabia.

Damien Dempsey
40 Posted 22/01/2014 at 17:52:02
Nicolas Anelka has responded to his FA charge insisting he is "not anti-Semitic or racist."

The West Brom striker has been charged by the Football Association but has responded urging them to reconsider
Hitting back: Anelka has urged the FA to reconsider their decision to charge him Hitting back: Anelka has urged the FA to reconsider their decision to charge him.

Anelka believes the FA's decision to employ an academic expert to rule on the significance of the gesture was wrong.

"The English FA have employed an expert to rule on the significance of my quenelle," he added. "He has concluded that my gesture had an anti-Semitic connotation, which had led to me being charged by the FA."

The Frenchman posted a video on his Twitter account of Roger Cukierman, head of Jewish organisation CRIF, suggesting the FA should have consulted his advice before making the ruling.

"It would have been legitimate if this expert had been French, living in France and with an exact understanding of my gesture," he added.

"What better expert than Mr Cukierman, head of Jewish organisation CRIF (Representative Council of French Jewish Institutions), who explains very clearly that my quenelle could not be considered anti-Semitic.

"He also explains precisely when this gesture could have such a connotation."

Cukierman said: "It seems a bit severe to me because it seems to me that this gesture only has an anti-Semitic connotation if the gesture is made in front of a synagogue or a memorial to the Holocaust.

"When it's made in a place which is not specifically Jewish it seems to me that it's a slightly anarchic gesture of revolt against the establishment, which doesn't deserve severe sanctions."

Eugene Ruane
41 Posted 22/01/2014 at 18:35:48
Eric (538) - "As for Lenny Bruce's anti-discrimination, I doubt if anyone would be willing to broadcast his works now with 'anti-semitic' or 'racist' words words (the K and N) words liberally used in his monologues, even though they were not intended to be abusive"

Not only were they not intended to be abusive (would have been strange as he himself would have come under K) he actually advocated OVER-use of the N word to take away the hurtful sting of it. His (flawed in my view) theory being that saying the word over and over and over would make it meaningless.

(to be fair, as the N word and queer are now used by many the words were intended to hurt, he might have been on to something)

Ray (534) - "There was never any form of racism in my house or in my upbringing and I really don't know when it came about that this was offensive. It certainly wasn't offensive to the black lad, my mate, who sat next to me in school and swapped badges with me. Obviously, I am now aware that it is regarded as offensive to the current generation and don't want this to turn into a thread about racial intolerance, but it was considered harmless by just about everyone 55-60 years ago"

Just as well the black lad had that attitude or he may have been accused of having 'a chip on his shoulder' or being 'surly' (sometimes known as The Tommy Smith argument)

Look, I'm sure in most homes in Britain in the 60s/70s (like my own) there was little CONSCIOUS racism, but at the time, there would have been what I believe is sometimes called 'casual racism'.

Not surprising or shocking given the circumstances, I mean you only had to put on the telly to see the Irish were thick and you didn't want 'pakis' living next door to you.

However things change and and when we DID become conscious of that change, we had a choice - ignore the changes we were starting to see in society regarding race/ethnicity (and/or rail against them) or accept times had changed and that those of different ethnicity, might be offended by things that might not offend us.

Incredibly (to me), there are still those who cry 'PC!' when it's pointed out they might not be the best people to judge whether someone of a different ethnicity should/shouldn't be offended by an insult.

(ok not quite the same thing, but I'LL decide when a scouse joke is offensive and if some feller from London tells me "relax miiiite, It's jast a joke innit" this will only add to my annoyance and the chances of him being told to fuck off)

By the way, ultimately, (as we're discussing an Everton player supporting a player accused of anti-semitism) this IS a thread about racial intolerance.

Sam Morrison
42 Posted 22/01/2014 at 19:12:21
Eugene, good post.
Steve Short
43 Posted 22/01/2014 at 19:06:25
From a public relations point of view, it was absolutely ridiculous of the club to withdraw the video. The club should have stood by the player and Everton would be in the headlines virtually all over the world. All publicity is good publicity. As for the French comedian, I really do not see what the fuss is all about. People who know very little about the French world, let alone the French language, have no idea as to what the issue is all about:

http://www.voltairenet.org/article181663.html

Lukaku has my full support in regard to this matter. That players are showing themselves to be socially conscious is a good thing, as far as I am concerned.

Colin Glassar
44 Posted 22/01/2014 at 19:15:38
Come on Sunderland.
Oh, and Lukaku should've kept his trap shut. Footballers and politics is like honesty and politicians, it just doesn't go together.
Ray Roche
45 Posted 22/01/2014 at 19:07:27
Eugene,
The "casual racism" remark which you believe was prevalent in the 50's-60's must have affected a third of the population, for that is what the viewing figures were when the Minstrels show was at his most popular! Over 18m. This is of some concern when you look back at how crap it was. Maybe the majority were all waiting for someone far more intelligent and urbane to come and point out what they should be thinking. Incidentally, my mate could never have been considered to have a chip on his shoulder. Well, not then. He might have now he's been enlightened. He became a football referee....
He must be used to getting loads by now.

I must be getting a bit thin skinned myself. I frequently have a Meldrew Moment when the Beeb start the "all scousers are thieving benefit scroungers" thing that they are so fond of. In fact, some of my fathers generation regarded being called a scouser as something of an insult and I don't think my arl fella was particularly fond of it. Bit old school, I suppose, rest his soul.. Anyone else recall that? Maybe we could start our own PC movement to get it outlawed.
In the meantime, Eugene, have a look at some of this crap and cringe at just how bad TV could be...enjoy?

http://www.mirror.co.uk/tv/tv-news/black-white-minstrel-show-most-2077085#.UuAbGcpFCM8

Chris Leyland
46 Posted 22/01/2014 at 19:40:03
Stuart Lee the comedian has this to say about political correctness:

" the kind of people that say "political correctness gone mad" are usually using that phrase as a kind of cover action to attack minorities or people that they disagree with. I'm of an age that I can see what a difference political correctness has made. When I was four years old, my grandfather drove me around Birmingham, where the Tories had just fought an election campaign saying, "if you want a n***** for a neighbour, vote Labour," and he drove me around saying, "this is where all the n*****s and the c**ns and the jungle b*****s live." And I remember being at school in the early 80s and my teacher, when he read the register, instead of saying the name of the one asian boy in the class, he would say, "is the black spot in," right? And all these things have gradually been eroded by political correctness, which seems to me to be about an institutionalised politeness at its worst. And if there is some fallout from this, which means that someone in an office might get in trouble one day for saying something that someone was a bit unsure about because they couldn't decide whether it was sexist or homophobic or racist, it's a small price to pay for the massive benefits and improvements in the quality of life for millions of people that political correctness has made"

Mick Doherty
47 Posted 22/01/2014 at 16:44:27
...I remember reading that some journalist for Ebony magazine was slating Carl Sagan’s design for the Pioneer plaque which depicts a male and female human, the journo declared it racist as the humans depicted were very caucasian in appearance... also NASA decided not to represent the female genitals due to religious fundamentalists and moral conservatives potentially getting their knickers in a twist, the plaque was to leave the solar system and give possible extraterrestrial life an idea what and where we are, should have had a warning to them to stay well fucking clear of this planet....

Agree with the above posts regarding how the legitimate criticism of the policies of Israel are condemned as anti-semitic, when the same legitimate criticism is voiced by a jewish person, they are branded a self-hating jew... it’s nuts, as to football and sport in general being ’not a forum for political debate’ I’d rather think that in the early 80’s there was plenty of sporting boycotts of South Africa due to apartheid, and this was very embarrassing to the NP and certainly had an impact on the end of apartheid, athletes have civil rights just like everyone else which allow for the freedom of political expression.

What about footballers making christian gestures, Hernandez actually kneeling and praying on the pitch, doing the sign of the cross coming out onto the pitch, surely these gestures could be offensive to some....

Damien Dempsey
48 Posted 22/01/2014 at 20:00:44
Mick you're right mentioning the rights athletes have in freedom of political expression in the sporting arena. Jesse Owens in Berlin 1936 with his Black Power salute and more recently those two Russian runners who won gold at the World Championships last year, who kissed on the medal stand as a protest against Anti-Gay laws.

Because they stand for something that's universally approved (against an 'evil of the world')it is acceptable. A gesture that the masses do not quite understand, people criticise the right of the individual to perform the gesture.
Steve Hopkins
49 Posted 22/01/2014 at 20:17:33
If we're being objective then this thread was debating Lukaku's error of judgment, as a current ambassador of Everton FC, in commenting on and supporting this 'anti-establishment' gesture not whether Anelka is a racist moron.

I'm going to play devil's advocate and ask whether those of you who think Lukaku's done nothing wrong would be just as apologetic if he supported Paulo Di Canio's Nazi salute to the Lazio fans? The Nazi salute, is after all and I'm sure Anelka could find another mate to back this up, not an anti-semitic or racist gesture in itself but merely shows membership of a group (albeit a group of racist scumbags). I would suggest that Lukaku and any other player for that matter would be hounded out of here, never to be seen playing for our great club ever again.

All that being said I'm not suggesting any harsh punishment for Rom merely a rap on the Knuckles and a friendly word in the ear telling him to be a bit more sensible about what he says in public in future. Could be a good indication of the lad's maturity and commitment to the EFC cause in the long run!

Damien Dempsey
50 Posted 22/01/2014 at 20:42:56
But this is the issue, Anelka was n't even making the gesture for it's political connotation, he was making the gesture as a sign of support for his friend Dieudonne who is on trial for not paying fines. Dieudonne invented this salute as part of his act.
John Keating
51 Posted 22/01/2014 at 20:44:12
I remember a few years ago Pienaar got done for drink driving or something.
I said he was supposed to be a role model for kids and should be hauled over the coals by the Club
Bloody hell did I get slagged !!
Seemed to range from more or less "he's one of us so it's ok" to "the case hasn't come up so shut up" to "can't punish him twice it's up to the Courts"
Seems reading this thread we've become more politically correct even after a few years !
Tony Draper
52 Posted 22/01/2014 at 20:27:34
Lukaku was in my opinion deliberately targetted fot this question because he is black

What question does that pose ?

But then, I believe that ALL journalists are slippery slimy bastards with absolutely no morals whose sole intent is to create offence and controversy and drag "reasonable" human beings into their interrogative spotlight

Damien Dempsey
53 Posted 22/01/2014 at 20:50:23
The interpretation of the gesture is open to debate. As my post 555 states, if Anelka had made the same gesture in France people would have understood the symbolism of his actions and he probably would have not even been charged..
Steve Hopkins
54 Posted 22/01/2014 at 20:52:49
The Nazi salute wasn't created by the Nazis and wasn't originally a political gesture, it was a greeting used similarly to that used in the armed forces. It's how these salutes evolve and who they're adopted by that shape their meaning.
You see someone doing a Nazi style salute and you instantly think scumbag and I can't think of any situation where it would be forgivable. You see someone doing an armed forces style salute and your first thought is that they must be in the army, navy or air force.
If this quenelle has been adopted for political or anti-semitic purposes then chances are it's going to get an overwhelmingly political reaction.

You'd have to be stupid to walk in to a boxing gym and give the wanker sign to the boxers, you'd have to be stupid to do a Nazi salute in Israel or in Germany and you'd have to be stupid not to do your research before doing a premeditated gesture in front of thousands of people and on TV all around the world and not expect people to take offense and expect to get your arse kicked literally or otherwise

Andrew Grey
55 Posted 22/01/2014 at 21:01:01
Damien - "I am sorry but somebody can be anti-zionist without being anti-semitic

Absolutely!

It's a shame that this episode hasn't enabled the BDS (Boycott divestment & sanctions) and other anti Israeli Apartheid groups to highlight just what is wrong with zionism.

Many Jews are anti zionist which is one of the reasons that Israel is becoming increasingly worried about the loss of business and support that has been prevalent in the last couple of years through boycotts and divestment. Also this is why pro zionist groups jump on the anti semitic bandwagon every time someone mentions and speaks out against Apartheid, illegal settlements, imprisoning children, shooting peace activists, carpet bombing Gaza... the list goes on.

Sodastream have a factory in an illegal settlement, it stands where houses that once belonged to Palestinians stood before they were bulldozed mostly while their possessions were still inside.

I wonder which side of the west bank barrier I stand on!

Damien Dempsey
56 Posted 22/01/2014 at 21:12:12
It is us and the media that have not researched the symbolism of the quenelle. The quenelle is not something that has ever even existed in this country before Anelka did it. The majority of people in France would tell you it is not anti-semitic but our own media band wagon tells us otherwise.
Steve Hopkins
57 Posted 22/01/2014 at 21:44:02
It's crazy to think that this is a football site and we're talking about a footballer. Whatever next....a team who changes the numbers on their shirts to resemble the shape of Palestine before the creation of Israel!!??

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-latin-america-25821058

Kick politics out of football

Steve Hopkins
58 Posted 22/01/2014 at 21:44:02
It's crazy to think that this is a football site and we're talking about a footballer. Whatever next....a team who changes the numbers on their shirts to resemble the shape of Palestine before the creation of Israel!!??

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-latin-america-25821058

Kick politics out of football

Si Cooper
59 Posted 23/01/2014 at 00:38:50
As is often the case, context is everything. Where political correctness does go mad is when tenuous links are blown out of all proportion to create a problem that probably didn't actually exist, such as the term 'black spot' being condemned because of the negative connotations. Only someone who was already racist would take the negativity applied to a colour and mentally transfer it to a particular group of people. Normal right-minded individuals would understand the difference or not even consider it in the first place.

I am not au fait with the situation in France, but if Quenelle has declared himself to not be anti-semitic and his salute is widely considered to be simply anti-establishment then, unless all personal gestures are to be banned, Anelka (a close personal friend) shouldn't be castigated for making the gesture and Romelu Lukaku should be able to give his opinion.

Quenelle has obviously made some powerful enemies and it seems that he may be being smeared because of it. If that is the case (or even if it is disputed), then I don't have a problem with his friends showing their support under any circumstances. I would rather have political statements at football matches than suppress individual freedom of expression.

Si Cooper
60 Posted 23/01/2014 at 01:03:32
Sorry, obviously mixing up my 'Dieudonne's and 'quenelles's. The principle remains the same.
Mike Allison
61 Posted 24/01/2014 at 18:06:17
Steve: "then surely he should have owed it to himself and the thousands watching to research exactly what this gesture meant and stood for." You seem to be under the misapprehension that the quenelle is an unambiguously anti-semitic gesture. It is not. It was invented by Dieudonne, the friend Anelka was supporting. Anelka wouldn’t need to research anything, he knows the source.

The problem is in the appropriation of the gesture by other people, namely far-right, neo-nazi types. The gesture is now clearly of ambiguous meaning. This means Anelka shouldn’t be punished for having made it, as his defence that he had a specific intention which breaches no rules (namely showing support for a friend who’s livelihood is being put in danger by his freedom of speech being restricted) should be accepted. However, it should now be made clear that this gesture can be offensive and that any future re-occurrence won’t be tolerated, and that now that this has been made clear, anyone using it will be considered to be deliberately defying a clearly stated interpretation.

"why do some people see something and, instead of seeing it for what it is, they go off on one?" Anais Nin said: "We don’t see things as they are, we see them as we are".

Steve Short (589) links to a good article. My favourite bit of it is this, because the same thought had occurred to me: "As someone has remarked, a “Nazi salute in reverse” might as well be considered anti-Nazi. If indeed it had anything to do with Heil Hitler. Which it clearly does not."

This isn’t about political correctness, its about understanding French society and what the quenelle means to the person who invented it. Whenever the issue of race or discrimination comes up, there are some who seem to think that the crime is so great that the accused must be punished whether guilty or not. This case is very complex, and all Lukaku has done is support his friend by saying its not such a big deal. It would be if it were a case of anti-semitism, but it isn’t, so it isn’t.

Mike Allison
62 Posted 24/01/2014 at 18:46:31
Steve I've just read your reference to Paolo Di Canio's 'Nazi' salute. You need to do your research I'm afraid. Italian fascism and Nazism were and are not the same thing. I don't particularly know or care about the differences, but conflation of the type you're guilty of is a big part of the problem in dealing with things like this.

It seems subtlety, nuance and ambiguity don't play a big enough part in these discussions. In fact, they seem to be viewed with suspicion by people who just want things to be simple where they can be 'right' and 'good' and someone else can be 'wrong' and 'bad'. If only things were always that simple.


Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads

© ToffeeWeb