Everton: Still A Decent Club In An Indecent League

, 22 January, 21comments  |  Jump to most recent
A Spurs fan revisits a belief he posited a year ago – that Everton are a fundamentally decent club in an indecent League – and concludes that, if anything, his theory holds more water now under Roberto Martinez and the Blues' recent community efforts than it did before.
I’ve always had the impression, and this is obviously tinged with a purely subjective viewpoint, that Evertonians understand that football isn’t just about results or trophies or the narrowness of what happens on the pitch. There’s a very real sense that they understand that there are other, more human factors that unite us all as fans. Perhaps witnessing their neighbours suffer such unspeakable tragedy has forced them to re-evaluate the very essence of the nature of rivalry.

Maybe that’s what it is that makes Everton such a decent club. Perspective. Winning and losing make no difference in that regard. As long as the club exists and attempts to live up to its “nothing but the best” motto is all you can really ever ask of the football club. Silverware, however welcome it might be, is not the ubiquitous bottom line.

» Read the full article at Dispatches from a football sofa



Reader Comments (21)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


David Ellis
1 Posted 22/01/2014 at 07:07:49
Probably a slightly rose tinted view of us - surely to be the best means we need to win stuff too. But I think there is something in his sentiment. Everton players don't appear to dive for example (now that Phill Neville has gone!). Unlike Mordors XI who seem to get a penalty for diving every week
Brian Waring
2 Posted 22/01/2014 at 09:05:41
David, think we need to hold back on the " Everton players don't appear to dive" after watching Baines and Mirallas against West Brom.
David Ellis
3 Posted 22/01/2014 at 09:26:41
Brian - it must be those damn rose tinted spectacles I wear then! Actually did not see the game so have not seen those incidents. Obvoiusly they were unsuccessful dives as no penalty was awarded so perhaps we are just not as good at it as Mordor.
Phil Walling
4 Posted 22/01/2014 at 11:05:05
This is a view I often hear expressed on my travels across the country. Indeed, I hear very few derogatory remarks about Everton as we are seen as a somewhat old fashion institution led be 'an old school chairman'!

Of course, most of us on here 'think different' but I don't spoil the outside world's view of our club so BK gets away with it, tears and all!

Perhaps, if we ever begin to look like serious challengers for honours, vitriol will be poured upon us just as it is on our neighbours by the Mancs and Cockneys !

Ray Roche
5 Posted 22/01/2014 at 11:42:17
Brian, although I agree that Everton players diving is a non-starter as far as I'm concerned, don't you think it's a little bit of the "evens itself out over a season " with Baines, after all, the clearest penalty I've seen all season was the Cardiff defender tackling Baines in the away match, an incident which saw Baines booked! I never want to see our lads diving or going down too easy and the incident at WBA was embarrassing. However, if either of the two incidents I've mentioned here had happened to that shower across the park they would have been given a spot kick. Even the WBA one which was a mile outside the box. If Suarez got one last week for the minimum amount of "contact" (how I've come to hate that word) every club would get 2-3 penalties a game.
Incidentally, while I'm at it, those useless fuckwits on MOTD who constantly use the word "contact" as a means to justify cheating should be taken out, put against a wall and shot. SUFFICIENT contact, you crooked bastards., not just contact!
Robbie Muldoon
6 Posted 22/01/2014 at 12:09:17
I have been saying all season long, I don't really mind where we finish in the league as long as we continue to improve and play the kind of football we have been. It's been a pleasure to watch, dominating nearly every team put in front of us, knowing goals are going to come but unable to pin point from where due to the various goal threats.

Carry on playing like that and you are likely to get some just rewards, the difference between winning and losing sometimes rests on the bounce of a ball or the call of a referee. As long as the performances are there, I can't ask for anymore.

Ajay Gopal
7 Posted 22/01/2014 at 12:26:27
Ray (404), I almost vomited reading this vile headline on Sky Sports: "Gary Neville: Luis Suarez right to go to ground to win penalty". It was so disgusting that I didn't bother reading the rest of the article. It beggars belief that a respected former (ManU) player would justify the antics of Suarez. Would he (or any of the dim-witted pundits) have made that comment if it was an Everton player? It just makes me so MAD.
Mark Taylor
8 Posted 22/01/2014 at 12:41:16
I think this is somewhat rose tinted on a number of fronts, judged by the contributions I read on ToffeeWeb:

- there is a lot of unease about our Chairman and his fellow shareholders

-there is a lot of animosity to OFM

-there is even more animosity bordering on hatred towards our local rivals

To the extent we might be some fans favourite 'second club', I think that is because we are basically unsuccessful and not a threat. Personally, I'd rather be disliked and successful...

Steavey Buckley
9 Posted 22/01/2014 at 14:30:18
Everton are actually in between 2 positions.

Everton are a club that has limited financial resources competing with 7 other premier league clubs who have much better financial situations and all want to be at least in the top 4 and qualify for the champions league.

Yet, at the same time, Everton are happy to maintain their premier league position and status as members of the top flight. But supporters will be again unhappy this season as last, if Everton don't achieve 4th place and qualify for the champions league.

Shane Corcoran
10 Posted 22/01/2014 at 14:54:49
Nicely put Ray.
David Finney
11 Posted 22/01/2014 at 18:22:54
Ray (404) if there is one phrase that books my piss it is "entitled to go down". It's a contact sport yet pundits come on and say even slight contact entitled the player to try to cheat the opposition. Every team does it even the blues and at the moment can you blame them? If you succeed you get a pen and possibly a red card for the opposition. Fail and worse case scenario you get a yellow. Until lengthy retrospective bans are introduced to make the risk greater than the reward it will carry on.
Mick Davies
12 Posted 22/01/2014 at 19:09:19
I too couldn't believe what I was hearing from Gary Neville: he condoned cheating and even - in his playing days - expected his own team mates to do it! It made me wonder what all the youngsters watching this ex-captain of the most successful side in PL history; ex-England player, made of his comments. I now expect schools and JFC games to be littered with kids falling over and moaning. Another thick, classless twat, destroying our national sport for money and attention
Mark Tanton
13 Posted 22/01/2014 at 19:21:26
Neville is a little pre-pubescent, self appointed shop steward and serial moaner. The only good thing about him used to be he hated the reds as much as did, but not him and Caragher are more interested in sucking each other off.
Colin Glassar
14 Posted 22/01/2014 at 19:24:25
I couldn't have expressed it any better Mark.
Harold Matthews
15 Posted 22/01/2014 at 19:05:35
Steavey. I will definitely not be unhappy if we fail to finish in the top 4. In two or three years time I might be.
Trevor Lynes
16 Posted 22/01/2014 at 19:46:37
I really think that many of the fans who write about footballers not trying to gain an advantage are very naiive. Every level of semi pro and pro football will always take whatever they are given whether its a penalty or a hand ball goal ! That is a fact and although it may not be palatable to all the fans it is true.

Over the years I have played and watched decent level football I have seen many blatant dives and hand ball goals and EVERY player and club MANAGER takes them with glee !! This is not a product of foreign players, its happened ever since I can remember.

That is why I had to laugh when Bobby Robson moaned about Maradona. When he managed Ipswich his centre forward Ray Crawford scored a far more obvious goal with his hand at Goodison but he accepted the referee's gift without a murmur. Francis Lee was a master at getting penalty's and got thirteen in one season !!

We are as bad (or as good) as the rest if the occasion arises and I am certain that the fans who write on here will be only too happy if we get one in the derby.

Si Cooper
17 Posted 22/01/2014 at 20:44:38
Are people seriously trying to suggest that Gary Neville is biasesd towards LFC?

Get a grip for heavens sake. As soon as I saw the incident I knew exactly what the 'professional' viewpoint would be as it has been that way for years. All Gary Neville was doing was being honest.

It is the fact that 99% of attackers given the opportunity to tumble when going away from goal would do exactly the same that makes the double punishment of penalty and goalie sent off (not exacted in this case) so unfair unless it is clear that the goalkeeper is solely intent on bringing the attacker down. 99% of the attackers team mates would appeal for the pen and complain if it wasn't given.

The sport changed in this regard years ago, so picking out individuals for censure is unreasonable. Ones who go against the grain and speak out for the common man, like Stan Collymore has done on this occasion, should probably get more support.

Baines dive (for a free kick he got) was far more of a cheat as there was never any chance of the defender actually making the slightest contact, though contact is not always strictly necessary if the evasive action the player has to take is sufficiently disruptive.

Lament the loss of true sportsmanship by all means, but implying that Gary Neville has a RS bias is just daft. I actually prefer the pundits who are brutally honest because they are more likely to give you a balanced view.

Patrick Murphy
18 Posted 22/01/2014 at 21:12:07
They were all brutally honest when they all but ruined Andy Johnson's career - but funnily enough cheating wasn't to be accepted when a club from outside the elite clique did it. Same with Felliani every incident was highlighted to death with zoom lenses to apportion the blame. No pundit is totally honest they are puppets who have an agreed line and they stick to it otherwise they will disappear off the screens quicker than Ratboy can pick himself up from a career threatening injury which he apparently sustains at least once every ten minutes.
Mike Corcoran
19 Posted 22/01/2014 at 21:23:42
Ther are dives and there are theatricals, sometimes a player may dive when he perceives, in a millisecond, that someone is going to injure him. I think that the attack or intent of the tackle should be assessed only.

Just saying like

Ernie Baywood
22 Posted 27/01/2014 at 08:44:15
Just personally, I thought Suarez was impeded and it was a penalty. Had he not fallen over he probably wouldn't have got the penalty he deserved.

Falling over isn't the problem. Staying on your feet isn't the solution.

Diving when you're not impeded is a problem. And claiming every player who falls down is a diver lets these cheating pricks off the hook by devaluing the argument.

Challenge Suarez' behaviour on the other 9 out of 10, not that one.

Steve Carse
23 Posted 27/01/2014 at 20:05:44
Ernie (282), and here's me thinking defending was all about impeding the opposition ie trying to prevent them doing what they are trying to do with the ball. What you seem to be saying, like some of the 'experts' on TV, is that the keeper had no right to challenge Suarez. Suarez dived. 100%. The more you look at it, the more obvious the dive was. The only, and funniest, piece of evidence spouted by RS Redknapp on the day to justify the award was that mud came up off the pitch! Talk about clutching at straws.

PS - There was more contact on Baines at West Brom than there was with Suarez. If you've got the incident still on tape, focus on the upper body, not the feet. Baines though, like Suarez, was still guilty of milking it.


Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads

© ToffeeWeb