Everton announce Traoré loan signing

, 24 January, 195comments  |  Jump to most recent
Deal for Ivorian striker now complete
Everton have completed the acquisition of Lacina Traoré on loan from Monaco until the end of the season.

The striker was granted a work permit earlier this week but final negotiations over the terms of the deal weren't hammered out until this afternoon.

Traoré looked to be destined to make a loan switch to West Ham earlier this month but the move fell through when Everton entered the running and offered a move more agreeable to Monaco.

Even then, the 6' 8" Ivorian's prospects of playing in the Premier League this season appeared to be threatened by a serious injury on Wednesday to Monaco's marquee striker, Radamel Falcao, but the Ligue 1 club have sanctioned the release of Traoré even though the Colombian striker is almost certainly out for the remainder of the season.

Traoré was signed by Monaco from Anzhi Makhachkala earlier this month in a deal variously reported to have been worth between £8m and £15m after spending three years in the Russian league.

He played 38 times for Kuban Krasnodar, scoring 18 times before moving on to Anzhi where he bagged 13 goals in 29 games. He also has four goals in seven international appearances for Ivory Coast.

Blues manager Roberto Martinez said that the 23 year-old will bring speed and technical ability to the squad, as well as versatility — he can play as a traditional number 9 or behind the striker.

He said that the club will make sure that the hamstring injury he recently sustained is completely healed before throwing him into Premier League action, estimating that it would be "a matter of weeks" and that he is looking to use him over the last 9 or 10 games of the campaign.

Martinez also reiterated that the arrival of Traoré will be his last piece of incoming business for the current transfer window, confirming that the Ivorian and Aiden McGeady were his two targets for January.

 

Reader Comments (195)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


John MacDonald
1 Posted 24/01/2014 at 17:43:55
Look forward to seeing the guy in action, all the best to him. Welcome to the School of Science.
Brin Williams
2 Posted 24/01/2014 at 17:47:35
Good - let's move on to the next signing now what's happening to that bast ...fellow?
James Elworthy
3 Posted 24/01/2014 at 17:46:21
Great lets hope he gets his visa in time for the RS on Tuesday
Eugene Ruane
4 Posted 24/01/2014 at 17:52:26
Let's hope they've got a shirt to fit him, could be very embarrassing seeing him running around in a blue boob-tube type thing.
Tazul Islam
5 Posted 24/01/2014 at 17:53:01
Excellent news...hopefully he's fit and can play some part in the derby..
Chris Gould
6 Posted 24/01/2014 at 17:48:55
I trust Martinez to have done his homework on this lad, but question why we only made a move once he had already nearly signed for West Ham. I hope he isn't a desperation signing and is ready to hit the ground running. He won't have experienced anything like the premier league and if he is good enough to be in a team challenging for a champions league place then why were the mighty Hammers our only challengers for his signature.
Christopher Kelly
7 Posted 24/01/2014 at 17:57:26
EXACTLY! Everyone gets their panties in such a twist round these parts. If the manager says he's "confident in the deal" - then be confident with him. May be a tall task but would love to see this freak of nature suit up on Tuesday.

I wish Lulu kept that hair. It'd be the black version of Flock of Seagulls out there if they played together!!

COYB

James Elworthy
8 Posted 24/01/2014 at 17:57:13
Fellaini's old shirt might he is 6 5"
Don't like this reference to him as a gentle giant would prefer a Dunc type to another Crouch
Hopefully when Skertel pulls his shirt in the box the ref will spot it as quite a large shirt to pull.
Amit Vithlani
9 Posted 24/01/2014 at 17:58:20
lol Eugene, maybe they still have Jo's jersey - even then it would be a crop top thingy...
Tony Page
10 Posted 24/01/2014 at 17:58:06
Can you imagine the RS defenders trying to stop him at an Everton corner. The poor lad will have his shorts pulled off he's so tall.
Steavey Buckley
11 Posted 24/01/2014 at 18:09:47
According to Martinez in an interview with Everton TV on Everton home page, Traoré will not be fit enough to play for awhile while he recovers from injury in the next couple of weeks, but should be available to play for Everton in the last 10 games of the season.
Dennis Ng
12 Posted 24/01/2014 at 18:14:01
Steavey, that's quite different from what he initially said. Very disappointing.
Ray Roche
13 Posted 24/01/2014 at 18:12:48
James, he won't be fit for a "matter of weeks" so the Derby will be too soon for him.
Brian Williams
14 Posted 24/01/2014 at 18:13:05
Did nobody notice the "matter of weeks" quote? That makes an appearance against the RS a total nono......
Steavey Buckley
15 Posted 24/01/2014 at 18:16:07
Disappointing as Everton have few attacking and midfield options.
Eugene Ruane
16 Posted 24/01/2014 at 18:09:45
Could be fantastic, could be a disaster, who knows (clue: none of us so 'doing a Mavis Riley' pointless),

Either way, right now I'm excited by the prospect of seeing him in an Everton shirt (at worst we'll see a bit of history made - tallest ever Everton player).

Agree with Christopher, you have to go with RMs decision.

Hope he's made to feel welcome, relaxed, part of the gang etc and can hit the ground running.

James Elworthy
17 Posted 24/01/2014 at 18:18:16
That's great you are talking mid Feb here, we need a further striker that both we own and can play now.

Kenwyne Jones for a million anyone or big money for Batshuyi?
Paul Thompson
18 Posted 24/01/2014 at 18:20:51
As I've said elsewhere, I think his size, speed and ability on the ball could prove a real handful for PL defences. But for how long? Like everybody else I don't know what the loan fee was, but any sizeable amount would seem to offer poor value if it's just for 'the last 9-10 games'.
Raymond Fox
19 Posted 24/01/2014 at 18:21:03
Hope I'm wrong, but I cant get excited about this lad.

I would have thought a small nippy player would be more Roberto's style, the balls not in the air often enough for a 6'8'' beanpole, its not giving him much time to ajust either to the PL or our style of play, hope he's not costing much.

Ian Glassey
20 Posted 24/01/2014 at 18:19:39
I just don't see the point in the deal if he wont be fit, the last 10 games of the season is no good to us. We need someone to hit the ground now, we just seem to be spending money for the sake of it. With the injury list we have got we need bodies in now, centre mid is a priority but Roberto says thats it.

Can not say I am happy, lets just hope we get no more injurys ..

Dan Brierley
21 Posted 24/01/2014 at 18:19:45
'He's gonna be a phenomenal for us'

Every player seems to be phenomenal eh? And an admission that he is the last arrival of the window.

I personally am very disappointed with this, our next three league games are crucial to our season prospects. And we have signed one unfit player in McGeady, and an injured player that is not going to feature in any of theses critical matches. United are on the verge of signing one of the best midfielders in the PL, and have three very winnable matches coming up.

James Elworthy
22 Posted 24/01/2014 at 18:33:16
Oh well if he is our last signing of the window I won't bother listening to Jim White next Friday night.

The delay was probably caused by Blue Bill refusing to pay his wages till he is fit.
Tom Bowers
23 Posted 24/01/2014 at 18:32:16
Any addition to the squad must be good. We are starting to get some injuries and having strength in depth will help as the race for the top spots heats up.

With no sign of Kone getting back yet and a lack of confidence in Velios they need this experienced back-up when he gets fit himself.

We have been through a rough patch somewhat and need to get back on track starting with the Redshite game and so this signing may perk up Romelu.
David Flanagan
24 Posted 24/01/2014 at 18:27:26
Dont agree with selling Jelavic and replacing him with another loanee. We now only own one striker who is injured and getting on. Once again money has been banked but nothing spent.

New manager, same board. Can't build a team on this basis. Big problems will need to be adressed in the summer.

Jim Bennings
25 Posted 24/01/2014 at 18:34:41
I was a bit shocked also when I read that Martinez said it will be a case of the last 9 or 10 games, its a bit strange to say that after the other day, think it was the day of Traore's medical that Martinez said 'just a matter of days'.

Having looked at the fixture list, he could potentially be fir to face Chelsea at Stamford Bridge on Feb 22, we wont be allowed to play Lukaku in that one so we will be up shits creek if Traore is still not fit by then.
.Any later than the end of February and it makes you wonder what the point was in pursuing it because if he hasnt kicked a ball before March its goiing to take him nearly 9 games to get match fit and acclimatise to the Premier League.

I suppose putting a positive spin on the whole matter is now Lukaku knows he is going to have to raise his game over the next 4 or 5 games and start scoring some flippin goals.
I know the service has been a bit average to him lately but he has got to start burying the type of chance he had with the header against Norwich or even the decent chance at Stoke in the first half.. we cant keep saying a lack of service as an excuse every time.

Kevin Tully
26 Posted 24/01/2014 at 18:26:00
If we can get the rest of our players back from injury, we will have a very strong squad for that all important final third of the season. It doesn't matter what has gone on for the first 22 games - we are 1 point away from 4th with 16 to play.

If we can manage a win at the RS, our chances of a top 4 finish rise by a further 14% apparently. Here are the the current projections;

Link

Wayne Smyth
27 Posted 24/01/2014 at 18:43:55
Go back a few months and Alcaraz was "shit", Barry was "shit", Deulofeu was "shit", and McCarthy was "expensive shit".

Traore might be shit and may not contribute much in the next 5 months, but based on past results, I'll go on Roberto's opinion that we've got a quality player in who will make a significant contribution and provide value for money.

Dennis Ng
28 Posted 24/01/2014 at 18:51:40
Wayne, agree there. Just gutted that he's not going to be able to play immediately. Hope we have another on the way however unlikely it is.
Chris Wilson
29 Posted 24/01/2014 at 18:35:24
I'm with Ian Glassey on this. I mean in two weeks we'll have a great team with Ross probably fully fit, maybe Deulofeu back, and then this guy. In that time frame we play Liverpool, Villa, and Tottenham - two of those games away. Chances are he'll be fit for Chelsea, which is the main concern, I.E. to replace Lukaku for the match.

But I almost feel like this was a pride move; we jumped ahead of West Ham, we're waiting on Monaco to greenlight this after Falcao's injury...it just seemed like we committed to see this through out of pride (not saying that's what happened). Maybe our pursuit of Traore is indicative of what the transfer market is right now - there's not a lot available to bolster the team? Regardless, I hope this isn't the end of the wheeling and dealing and RM gets us a central/attacking midfielder and not one of the 50 wingers we're linked with.

Patrick Murphy
30 Posted 24/01/2014 at 18:44:43
Absolutely pointless bringing somebody in who may be or may not be fit for the last 9 or 10 games of the season - this has the smell of BK written all over it - sick to death of it I am - At least we knew Peter Johnson was a red under the bed but ffs Bill what do you take us all for!
Kevin Tully
31 Posted 24/01/2014 at 18:57:03
Maybe there's an option for next season Patrick?
Eugene Ruane
33 Posted 24/01/2014 at 18:58:28
Wayne Smith (272) - Spot on.
Phil Walling
34 Posted 24/01/2014 at 18:30:24
Martinez magic fading fast. As big a bullshitter as the last bloke, it seems!
Jeff Beaumont
35 Posted 24/01/2014 at 19:01:23
Another 3 or 4 of his size & we'll have hell of a wall to defend free kicks.
Chris Gould
36 Posted 24/01/2014 at 18:56:39
Only available for the last 10 games!!! I despair!
Lukaku is looking knackered right now.
In saying that, if we know that then obviously Roberto will. If players are available that will improve us then we have to assume he is doing everything to get them. There I still time.
Patrick Murphy
37 Posted 24/01/2014 at 18:58:43
Perhaps there is Kevin, but we needed players right now to enhance a tired and injured squad - we sold Jelavic which is fine but why should Lukaku suddenly bust a gut if he knows this guy won't be ready until what the beginning of March?

Kenwright screwed up any chance we had last season and imho he has done it again - in fact I would have been happier to have got Landon Donovan in for 6 weeks to give us a much needed boost.

By my reckoning the lad will be unavailable for the matches at the Dark Side, Chelsea and Spurs and possibly at Newcastle if he's fit for the last 9 fixtures as opposed to the last 10. These games are the ones we have to be successful in if we are to even dream of Europe.

Gerry Quinn
38 Posted 24/01/2014 at 19:04:24
Do you think that with this guys height, it will force RM to ask Jags to take our corner kicks?
Eugene Ruane
39 Posted 24/01/2014 at 19:06:20
Gerry - brilliant!
Kevin Rowlands
40 Posted 24/01/2014 at 19:01:31
Haha, just seen this on twitter "and it's Everton, Everton FC, we're by far the greatest team....T e m p o r a r I l y"
Paul Niklas
41 Posted 24/01/2014 at 18:55:29
Nothing matters other than the best possible team out to win the derby, we need everyone I am afraid and that includes Ross.

After that well we might get all back but we could be looking at six points behind fourth with Spurs away in the mix.

I for one need walking wounded for Tuesday night, injected if needs be, we have to win its as simple as that.

I would try three at the back and reduce the space Suerez normally runs through.

Stones Jags Distin

Mcarthy Barry

Coleman Miralles Pienaar Baines

Lukaku

If Ross was fit I would drop Mirallas.

Liverpool will not try 442 again, but with Lucas out Gerard will be exposed and it will be tight in that midfield.

James Elworthy
42 Posted 24/01/2014 at 19:04:27
He has made no bad signings so far, the jury is still out on Kone as injured.
Unlike Moyes, Kroldrup, Simon Davies , Beattie, and Gueye to name a view.
Charles Simpkins
43 Posted 24/01/2014 at 18:51:27
Yeah, I'm with it. Even if the move is just to provide us with a non-Mirallas/Vellios option against Chelsea later in the season (a game which should definitely have top-4 implications) then it's worth it. If it also lights a fire under Lukaku's ass and helps us turn some of these draws against lower opposition into wins then even better.
Dan Brierley
44 Posted 24/01/2014 at 19:07:24
I sincerely hope that there is nothing in the market available and Roberto is conserving funds for next season. But if it transpires that we have spunked all our cash on loan fees and having nothing left to make permanent signings so an injured player on loan is the best we could do, I will be fucking livid.

Terry Davies
45 Posted 24/01/2014 at 19:01:46
Patrick (275).

Us? How the hell are you blaming Bill for this? And what is this?

I've read this deal includes an option for renewal next season: that's half a season that Lineker gave us and he played in the season we finished second between two championship winning years. I cannot believe Roberto has any side to him and if you think Johnson is a better option then God help us all

Kunal Desai
46 Posted 24/01/2014 at 19:05:39
So Martinez says he will be available for the last 10 games of the season, by my reckoning that would probably make him available for Chelsea away end of Feb which means he would miss RS and Spurs away, Palace and Villa at home. Lets hope we are still within 3-4 points of 4th at the very least by the time we play Chelsea. My fear is if the Shite or Spurs start build up a 6 point lead over us then i'm not confident we have enough to catch up on both of those.
Raymond Fox
48 Posted 24/01/2014 at 19:10:33
Give over Phil, your reverting again!
Terry Davies
49 Posted 24/01/2014 at 19:13:48
James (278)

Southampton have stated categorically they will not sell him. Agree would be good but better to pursue someone we may possibly be able to buy. I can't for the life of me bring myself to doubt Robbie

Dan Brierley
50 Posted 24/01/2014 at 19:11:31
Rubbish James:

Robles: Looks less than average, not a good signing up to now
McCarthy: Looks like a 13 million pound player, a solid signing
Alcaraz: Injury record at previous two clubs speaks for itself, bad signing as he has been injury prone since 2007. Managed three games for us
Kone: Looked less than average in the games he played, and hasn't made any further appearance due to injury

So thats one solid signing out of four.

Peter Z Jones
51 Posted 24/01/2014 at 19:06:25
Is Roberto literally saying that he won't play until the last 10 games or is he inferring that his biggest impact in the team won't come until then? I seem to remember Martinez saying that we wouldn't see the best of Deulofeu until the 2nd half of the season. This looks similar, but in a smaller time frame. Really doubt he'd bring the guy in if his hamstring and fitness were that big of an issue. Traore looks like more than adequate cover for Lukaku so personally I don't see what the fuss is about, regarding his supposed inability to make an impact immediately. I'm far more concerned about us not having a backup holding midfielder in the event anything happens to Barry or McCarthy. If we get cover there, I think we'll be ready to kick ass down the home stretch.
Terry Davies
52 Posted 24/01/2014 at 19:17:08
Meant to say half a season MORE than Lineker gave us - sorry
Linda Morrison
53 Posted 24/01/2014 at 19:13:29
i agree with Terry. At some point we need to trust the board (Bill) and the manager. Where are the rest of the board?

You watch we will be in Europe next season but I would be happy to go a way in the FA cup!

Phil Walling
54 Posted 24/01/2014 at 19:07:22
It just riles me that Evertonians buy into this shit. Loan players who are injured....for feck's sake !

Added to Alcarez and Kone spending half a season in Ward 10 and Robles looking like an apology for Richard Wright, I'm almost glad BK's a tight-arse.

Who next will he sign, Saha?

Gerry Quinn
55 Posted 24/01/2014 at 19:14:31
For heaven’s sake, give Traore a chance to at least play a game. The majority have been wrong on RM’s previous ventures into the market, loan or permanent. I often think that if I played in the same team as some of you miserable and utterly negative sods, I’d demand a bloody transfer!
Trevor Lynes
56 Posted 24/01/2014 at 19:06:59
I echo a few of the concerns that have been voiced. If anything happens to Lukaku or Mirallas we will be in a mess. Letting Jelavic go without an adequate replacement may well bite us during the coming month or so. We arer back to playing brinkmanship and hoping for no more injuries.

The promise of being stronger at the close of the transfer window seems a bit hollow. We are certainly not stronger and if anything we may well be weaker. We have actually once more MADE money as we have not spent any of the profits made from the Fellaini and Anichebe transfers and now we are hanging on to the money brought in by the Jelavic transfer. If Heitinger leaves then the clubs coffers will be further enhanced as the wage bill lessens,

I will not be happy if we falter due to lack of monetary support (again) as I am reading of transfer activity being carried out by other clubs in the league.

James Elworthy
57 Posted 24/01/2014 at 19:22:19
Lukaku has only just turned 20, all his knockers should remember that.
Patrick Murphy
58 Posted 24/01/2014 at 19:14:12
This? is exactly what it means a question mark? As regards BK his history tells us that he doesn't like spending money once it has been banked. When we sell Barkley or and Baines in the summer and Bill gives some of the proceeds to the manager to buy replacements many people will have forgotten about this window and last January's window.

If we had a full squad available it wouldn't have been such a major problem. Roberto said before he sold Jelavic that he wanted a midfielder and striker to replace Kone and Gibson because they were injured - but when he sold Jelavic that meant that 3 players were needed to bring the squad size up to strength.

Prior to selling Jelavic our net spend in the last 5 January windows saw a profit of 750K that is hardly what I call helping the manager and with Del Boy still out until god knows when we are still short of options in the final third - god forbid that anything happens to Lukaku in the coming weeks.

As for Johnson at least we knew what he was with the chameleon like Bill Kenwright you can never be sure what his motives are.

Mike Green
59 Posted 24/01/2014 at 19:16:30
Jesus Christ, in six months Martinez has performed a minor miracle with our squad and performances, we hit a blip due to some bad / untimely injuries and people are throwing the baby out with the bath water because we've got a £15m striker on loan for the last quarter of the season.....?!?

He's probably at home now getting bollocked by his missus for not being able to turn water into wine on a Friday night, which he's having to do because as he's clean out of 'Dose of Reality'.

Terry Davies
60 Posted 24/01/2014 at 19:23:02
Gerry (301)

Couldn't agree more. For Christ's sake lets not criticise Robbie until he does something wrong. Some of you lot are seem to be waiting for something to go wrong. I'm just delighted that, with a new manager, totally new system of play (ie playing to win and not to avoid defeat) that we're in the top half let alone being considered as CL contenders. Wake up and smell the coffee

Raymond Fox
61 Posted 24/01/2014 at 19:16:45
The bookies have still got us down to finish 7th then Kev!
With our injury list they might well turn out to be correct.

The way our season has gone up and down it'll be a bugger if we get a win on Tuesday, asking a lot I know, but its a funny old game as Jimmy Greaves used to say, you never know!

Chris Gould
62 Posted 24/01/2014 at 19:25:13
James, everyone realises that Lukaku is going to be a great player and is far from the finished article, but we need and deserve a finished article. Someone who will fire us into fourth not use us as a stop gap to become great for another team! We need a striker who is totally committed to the cause of helping Everton become great not just using us as a platform...and he has to be ready to roll now. I guess that player isn't available to us and it's so frustrating.
Si Cooper
64 Posted 24/01/2014 at 19:05:30
Happy the paperwork has been sorted, but some of the revelations leave a sour taste in the mouth. Where McGeady and Traore really top of the wishlist for this transfer window.

It was revealed a long time before the window that a striker and midfielder were the priority and strictly speaking that is what we have got. However, we have since lost another striker and do not have any more cover for Barry and McCarthy than we had before which is where it seemed the midfield would be strengthened.

I think McGeady is a lot closer to full fitness than most people have expressed, but that doesn't mean I expect him to be starting games or completing a full 90 minutes for a few more weeks yet. He gives us another option at least but unless Alcaraz or Heitinga can step forward I am still worried about what happens if Barry or McCarthy miss games.

I think the Traore loan may have an option for another 12 months which has made it a potentially sweeter deal. I am puzzled by the 9-10 games availability as we have 16 league games left at the moment and that would mean he misses more than a few weeks wouldn't it? Too long to really be able to say we have come out of the transfer window stronger.

I am hoping there is some bluffing going on, with other options still being explored. It is generally accepted that the club are hoping to move JH on; if that still happens then we would need at least one more player 'in' to prevent the manager looking a bit foolish.

Bob Hannigan
65 Posted 24/01/2014 at 19:19:17
I'm an optimist, maybe the timeframe RM stated is to take a bit of pressure off the weekly questions of his fitness. Hopefully he'll be fit much sooner.
Chris Gould
66 Posted 24/01/2014 at 19:35:19
Si, I don't believe Traore was even a consideration until West Ham nearly signed him. I still feel positive that Martinez has other targets and is keeping them quiet, the same way Big Sam probably hopes West Ham had.
Dennis Ng
67 Posted 24/01/2014 at 19:38:04
Bob, hopefully. Underpromise, overachieve. Same hope for others on the injury list.

The only thing I am actually truly worried about in terms of RM's transfers is, why is there so many injuries? I mean, I used to have this view that flair players often are more injury stricken but this is getting too much.

Phil Walling
68 Posted 24/01/2014 at 19:37:52
When we go into Poundland we don't accept damaged goods. But at Everton that's all we seem to invest in !
James Elworthy
69 Posted 24/01/2014 at 19:34:59
Lukaku is a player I think Martinez intends to purchase or at least try too.
Mourinho has no intention of keeping him. Whether he is worth every penny left in Bill's piggy bank is a matter of debate.
When we are left with the likes of Velios on the bench maybe even Kenwynne Jones at 1m would be worth adding to the numbers.
Colin Glassar
70 Posted 24/01/2014 at 19:34:55
Did Roberto say he would only play 10 games? Did he? He actually said he "would be most influential in the last 10 games". What does that mean? It means exactly the same thing he said about Delofeu when we signed him, and what was that? "that we will see the best of him in the new fucking year"!! Now follow me boys. What Roberto means (Traore), meant (Delofeu) is that these lads need time to BED IN. Del boy would've been a massive player for us if he hadn't got injured. Traore could be a massive player once he's got a few games under his belt hence Roberto's "last 10 games" comment.
Jeez Louise don't you read between the lines? I know Phil walling likes to wallow in his own misery but I expected more from the rest of you.
Patrick Murphy
71 Posted 24/01/2014 at 19:42:22
Chris as was stated in the article "Martinez also reiterated that the arrival of Traoré will be his last piece of incoming business for the current transfer window,"it appears that our window is firmly closed, but you never know I suppose.
Si Cooper
72 Posted 24/01/2014 at 19:44:49
Sorry Colin, was taking the OP at face value. If he has said what you quote then it seems rosier on the Traore front.
Patrick Murphy
73 Posted 24/01/2014 at 19:45:55
that he is looking to use him over the last 9 or 10 games of the campaignColin that is how it has been reported here on TW and possibly does not reflect what RM actually said - but you can't blame people reacting to what they have read - albeit if the information has been misrepresented.
Chris Leyland
74 Posted 24/01/2014 at 19:32:33
As I've posted before I'm a big convert to Martinez but I do think we can get a bit carried away at times. For example,

Mike Green: "Jesus Christ, in six months Martinez has performed a minor miracle with our squad and performances"

This makes it sound like he has changed us from a relegation threatened team when, what he has in fact done has changed us from a team that consistently finished in the top 7 to a team that is likely to erm finish in the top 7.

Yes, he has changed our style to try and make us more progressive and entertaining ( forgetting games like Palace away, West Brom home and away, Spurs home, Stoke away) but it is also a bit early to say he has transformed the squad given that the only permanent signing he has made that has made any discernible difference is McCarthy.

The main thing he seems to have transformed for me is the whole attitude that pervades the club. He is a likeable and extremely positive person and this stark contrast to the persona of our previous manager has rubbed off on a lot of people. The feel good factor is back.

Keith Young
75 Posted 24/01/2014 at 19:48:47
Don't worry about Phil Walling he is trying to wind us up. He really loves the new set up.
Danny Broderick
76 Posted 24/01/2014 at 19:46:44
Let's give this lad a chance...but is anyone else thinking he's gonna be shite? I can't think of one decent player in the history of the game who was 6'8. Crouch at a push - but even he isn't quite 6'8. Assuming his main strength is being a target man, I would have thought a smaller, more mobile player would be better suited to our footballing style. I could see him fitting in under Sam Allardyce, but not in a Martinez team.

Also, his goalscoring record in Russia doesn't seem to be anything to write home about. I hope I'm wrong - but combined with the fact that this lad is also carrying an injury, I just can't see him having a major impact between now and May. What we needed is an impact player to fire us up the league. This fella really doesn't sound like that guy to me...

Jamie Barlow
77 Posted 24/01/2014 at 19:50:14
Martinez said he was going to replace both long term injuries which is Kone and Gibson. He’s replaced Kone but not Gibson so I’m hoping he pulls a last minute signing out of the bag.
Mike Oates
78 Posted 24/01/2014 at 19:47:55
Martinez actually said that Traore would be influential in the last 9 - 10 games. He will take a week or two to get over his injury and then I'm sure we will see him given 20,30 minutes a game to get he used to the PL. I think mArtinez will want him acclamitised by then Chelsea game , which means he'll get game time vs Spurs, FA Cup ?, and Palace . Imagine a bench of Deulofeu, McGeady, Traore, ready to be unleashed if we not scoring.
Phil Walling
79 Posted 24/01/2014 at 19:49:31
Chris, your summary is a good one. Certainly, the playing style is much more attractive but some of the bullshit insults our intelligence. Our man is a purveyor of dreams whilst the last guy was good at waking us up to reality.

The end result will still be the same. Seventh !

Mark Tanton
80 Posted 24/01/2014 at 19:55:34
Even for Evertonians, this has been a rather underwhelming transfer window; but then we were warned thus.

Let's just Roberto knows what he's doing, and that he has calculated we can still compete without a load of new additions. Barkley and Deulofeu are almost back fit and clearly the club believes tweaking is the answer in January. Roberto has no faith in the winter January transfer window so is simply biding his time.

However... If the summer comes around and there is no money to spend, then there will be a fucking mutiny. I predict some big signings in an important summer transfer window, but if I'm wrong may the Lord take mercy on Blue Bill!

Phil Sammon
81 Posted 24/01/2014 at 19:55:23
I don't know how much he would cost...but I would honestly have preferred us to go for Ross McCormack. Technically gifted, great attitude and I think he could make the step up.
James Elworthy
82 Posted 24/01/2014 at 19:58:11
Deulofeu in my opinion will be the wild card that gets us to fourth place, get him fit and starting and he will provide the ammo for Traore.
I can see Gerry beating about 4 men and putting it on a plate for Lanky Lascina to stretch out those long kegs to slide it home
Dennis Ng
83 Posted 24/01/2014 at 19:59:46
Phil (333), that would set us on a trend to keep stealing from WH. Not that I care, and I agree with your sentiment. I would also give RM and Traore some time to prove themselves. Just very disappointed he's injured longer than first perceived.
Colin Glassar
84 Posted 24/01/2014 at 19:51:01
Si, Patrick, question of interpretation. A matter of weeks could be; two weeks or ten. The lad passed a fitness test at FF didn't he. I honestly don't think we would've signed him if he'd be out till March. Seamus has the same problem and he might be back for the derby. These are fit young men who, with a bit of rest, heal quickly.
I still maintain that what Roberto meant was that he'd be firing on all cylinders by the last 10 games. Anyway, we'll see. I expect to see Barkley, Delofeu, Seamus, Traore all back to full fitness by mid February and I've been told there's an outside chance that Gibson and Kone might be ready to return by April.
Jim Bennings
85 Posted 24/01/2014 at 19:55:15
I don't know how you can class Robles as average.
The lad has had hardly any football this season, he has made one error, have you any idea how difficult it is for any player to accept that your only going to play a small handful of games all season and how difficult it is to come out the cold and expect to be sharp?

Joel Robles kept clean sheets in the quarter final, semi final and FA Cup final last season so the lad has something about him and is not easliy overawed. Has Tim Howard not made his fair share of goalkeeping gaffs over the last two years?

As for Kone.

Again hardly seen action whilst trying to settle in to a new club.
Kone has pace and last season scored 13 goals for a relegated team.
I was at all three matches against Wigan last season and Kone mightily impressed me in all of them, tearing our defence apart with his movement in the match at Wigan and the quarter final at Goodison.
Its way way too early to judge the lad as a bad signing, do you think he wanted a season ending injury?

Mark Tanton
86 Posted 24/01/2014 at 20:01:25
I think we're all jittery because we're staggering off to Anfield next week in the usual circumstances - in a spot of bad form, massive injury list and confidence draining.

Why does this happen at Anfield every season? The answer is actually quite obvious - we have a small squad and we play them in the second half of the season every year, and this means we're always on our arse by then.

If it always Goodison second up, we'd have the same problem when the second derby came around. Liverpool had donkey gob out, and Sturridge managed on his own. Sturridge was out and donkey gob was back. We just don't have those resources.

Will the derby go tits up? There's a chance. But maybe we'll win. They seem to think they have an injury crisis too...

Raymond Fox
87 Posted 24/01/2014 at 19:49:26
They have a lot of choice in poundland Phil.

Plenty on here getting their nickers in a twist, Roberto didn't actually say that this was the last signing, there's a week left before the windows closes, so lets wait and see.
But he's not going to buy just anyone for the sake of it, maybe he just cant get the players that he's targeted for various reasons.
There also lots of other teams with players out with injuries, it goes with the territory, you just take notice more when their our players.

James Elworthy
88 Posted 24/01/2014 at 20:03:48
I agree with you Jim Bennings
Robles is a decent backup unlike Mucha who only had one good game (his last one)
Kone wait for next season before delivering your verdict.
Barkley is like a new signing as Moyes didn't give him a chance.
Alcarez looked good though a crock.
Barry and McCarthy great
Lukaku started great and will come good again with competition.
Chris Gould
90 Posted 24/01/2014 at 20:04:41
If Martinez said that it will be the last bit of business then it will be. Doesn't seem one for too much bull shit. Did he definitely say that? Can't find that quote on other sites.
Mark Frere
91 Posted 24/01/2014 at 19:53:23
Not remotely inspired this Transfer window, we are desperate for midfield cover for Barry and McCarthy, now Martinez says there's no more signings! Furthermore, Mcgeady and this beanpole striker aren't fit enough to start games - fuming!

James Elworthy
92 Posted 24/01/2014 at 20:13:54
I think Robbie is keeping his cards close to his chest, if you say you need more signings the prices will go up.
Look at fat Sam
Dennis Ng
93 Posted 24/01/2014 at 20:15:53
Mark (343) share your sentiment though I like Jim, James and Colin's optimism on these dealings. I'm holding that dim hope that RM would pull a last minute stunt like "Let's just go get that guy" and bring in CM cover.
Patrick Murphy
94 Posted 24/01/2014 at 20:11:48
You can call be a cynical old so and so but on the OS RM is talking about the new lad and he kinda stumbles when he almost says "not allowed" rather than when he's fit [02:32] of the video it does look as if the deal is to only pay for his services for a particular period of time. If I'm incorrect I will apolgise in advance but I think that is what has happened here.
Mark Frere
95 Posted 24/01/2014 at 20:19:03
I certainly hope so Dennis, if anything happens to the Barry McCarthy axis we really will be in trouble. Osman's days of playing the deeper role are over, plus he's usually cream-crackered after 60 minutes. Surely Martinez must see this as key area that needs addressing???
Si Cooper
96 Posted 24/01/2014 at 20:11:24
Raymond (339) - lifted from the OP, 'Martinez also reiterated that the arrival of Traoré will be his last piece of incoming business for the current transfer window, confirming that the Ivorian and Aiden McGeady were his two targets for January.'

Can you confirm that this reported detail is incorrect?

The incoming bit is a bit alarming because it suggests the outgoings haven't finished yet. Maybe Jelavic and A N Other out / McGeady and Traore will actually make us stronger but it is not what most people will have understood from the stated aim being that we would be stronger at the end of the transfer window.

Perhaps explains why others are getting their knickers in a twist!

James Elworthy
97 Posted 24/01/2014 at 20:25:25
Osman has proven to be a good impact player and more midfielders in the squad would allow him to do that more often.
However when he starts he is usually as said before finished after an hour.
Brian Waring
98 Posted 24/01/2014 at 20:24:32
Colin, Martinez says it will be a matter of weeks before the lads hamstring injury is fully healed, and that means, well, the lads hamstring injury will be fully healed in a matter of weeks.

Also, Martinez says he will be looking to use him in the last 9 or 10 games, and that means, well, he will be looking to use him in the last 9 or 10 games.

I don't know how you can interpret that in any other way.

Mark Tanton
99 Posted 24/01/2014 at 20:28:33
I cannot think right now about the prospect of Leon Osman starting on Tuesday night. If I mention to our lass she'll run around removing my shoelaces and razor blades again. What team with realistic CL prospects has him anywhere near a football?
Dennis Ng
100 Posted 24/01/2014 at 20:26:37
Mark, I definitely agree on the need to cover the Barry McCarthy axis. Actually, I posted before that I value a CM much more than a striker/winger, but RM sees a different strategy. I hope he does see the deficiency or that he actually has maneuver tactics should the axis be in danger of breaking.
John Daley
101 Posted 24/01/2014 at 20:32:19
"Martinez magic fading fast. As big a bullshitter as the last bloke, it seems!"

Don't worry about the encroaching pack Phil. You're still way out in front on that score.

A draw, away, against West Brom, with a badly depleted squad, and an incoming loan signing to share some of the burden up front...and suddenly Martinez is struggling to keep his head above water like a post wank Dale Winton feeling depressed in the bath?

What a load of over-reactive, sensationalist shite from the same day one sceptic, desperate to be proved right and constantly waiting for the slightest chance to put a sneaky boot in.

You're basically becoming a caricature of yourself now: the toffeeweb version of that cantankerous, moustachioed, comic book meff who's always banging on about Spiderman being 'a right nasty bastard' in the Daily Bugle: "He might have saved a bus full of innocent school kids from being eaten alive by Fat Takeaway Boy but that web spinning shithouse still spilt Egg Foo Yung all over my original copy of Enya's 'Orinoco Flow'. He's a menace I tell you. An absolute menace....and probably a nonce."

Didn't take long for you to revert back to your 'Martinez has the reverse Midas touch' mantra (everything he touches turns to Wigan) did it?

Mark Frere
102 Posted 24/01/2014 at 20:30:40
Mark, Osman is a very good player on his day, played in his correct position behind the:: striker. Trouble is: Osman is so inconsistent and he can't last 90 minutes.
Colin Glassar
103 Posted 24/01/2014 at 20:31:21
Brian, I bet you he will be in contention for the Villa game. There, I've said it.
Dennis Ng
104 Posted 24/01/2014 at 20:34:56
Mark (354) I guess those lung bursting training didn't do him any good huh...
Mark Tanton
105 Posted 24/01/2014 at 20:36:43
Some 32 year olds play like they're 25. Osman plays like he's 38.
Brian Waring
106 Posted 24/01/2014 at 20:35:28
On Monday Martinez said the lad was only a few days away from being fully fit, maybe he is playing mind games with the shite.
Brian Waring
107 Posted 24/01/2014 at 20:38:00
Colin I hope your right mate because I'm really looking forward to seeing this lad play.
Mark Frere
108 Posted 24/01/2014 at 20:35:01
If there's no more incoming players then surely we must keep Heitinga for emergency CM cover? He's not ideal but we are desperately short of numbers in that position.
Joe McMahon
109 Posted 24/01/2014 at 20:37:58
Phil Walling (280) – what is Roberto supposed to do?

I have a feeling he will be gone in 2 years for pastures new. We can't compete and he will know that now. We sell players yet the full money is never re-invested. Kenwright isn't going anywhere; we are not for sale; even if we were, who on earth would want to take on building us a new stadium? That should have been sorted over 10 years ago...

Colin Glassar
110 Posted 24/01/2014 at 20:40:57
Brian, while reading/writing on here I've been chatting with a friend who's a urologist (not a leg specialist I know) and she said, basically, a "minor soft tissue" is nothing more than a strain which usually clears up after a few days/weeks rest. If it's a young, healthy person these things clear up quickly.
Colin Williams
111 Posted 24/01/2014 at 20:37:29
Mark, could not agree more!!! he is past it, big time! absolute piss-poor. CM players have to consistantly have a major positive role to play in controlling the game- fuck me, when did Ossie control the ball last never mind control the game.
Raymond Fox
112 Posted 24/01/2014 at 20:35:00
Si 348, no I cant, I thought it was established that he definitely hadn't said that Traore was his last signing. I've gone back in the posts and found where I misunderstood the statement, apologies for that, it goes to show that you can believe nothing what you hear and only half of what you see!

I think most of the managers think that this window is a pain in the backside though and maybe Roberto could not the right players at the right prices, who knows only him and the board are privy to that info!

Kevin Tully
113 Posted 24/01/2014 at 20:49:47
Just thought on, one more loan signing and we could have half of our outfield players owned by other clubs.

Well, Everton always had a great record at setting firsts. It is starting to become a little embarrassing, not that Bill will feel any shame.

Colin Glassar
114 Posted 24/01/2014 at 20:55:56
Just read that Sunderland are going to make a bid for Ever Banega a player we were once after. Now this guy can play.
Ian Bennett
115 Posted 24/01/2014 at 20:57:31
Okay, so the squad's improved. We've the thick end of £20m profit to sign players with. We've lowered the playing age, and Roberto is clearing the deadwood. And people are still moaning. FFS, get a grip.
David Finney
116 Posted 24/01/2014 at 21:05:08
John Daley (353) lmao.
Harold Matthews
117 Posted 24/01/2014 at 19:53:54
People are talking as if this guy is Championship standard. He cost the Russians over 32m euros and Monaco snapped him up for just over half price when the Oligarch decided to cut costs and offload a whole host of top players.

Personally, I'm delighted we've got him but maybe that's because, unlike many, I am not totally fixated on finishing in the top 4. Martinez has a long term plan and I'm happy to watch how he gradually puts it all together. With regard to the present season, he says it's quite pointless studying the tables before the last 8 or 9 games. Too many things can happen. Suspensions, injuries, bad decisions, bad luck. They will all play a part. They always do.

The dreaded Derby has caused TWs to hammer their keyboards with fists and feet. Nothing new of course, Their place is never a level playing field and emotions are running high. Fingers crossed we do ok.

Patrick Murphy
118 Posted 24/01/2014 at 21:11:26
Kevin next season when the old badge is put back on the shirt the powers that be have decided to replace Z Cars with a Gilbert O'Sullivan Classic "A Loan Again - Naturally"

Only kidding, folks... trying to lighten the mood.

Dennis Ng
119 Posted 24/01/2014 at 21:09:46
Harold, another great post! I do hope the correlation to "RM and his injured players/signings" is a mere coincidence. I like Traore, based on the youtube videos. Sad he's injured at the moment. Would be a great help whether we play RM style or revert back to hoofing high balls.

Just for laughs, as I mentioned RM style, I thought we need someone to make RM a "Gangnum Style" video...

Kevin Tully
122 Posted 24/01/2014 at 21:16:44
Now you've started something Patrick, cue every half-wit trying to be funny with a song or saying with Loan in the sentence.

I'll go next - Sgt. Bill's Loan-ly hearts club.....

Patrick Murphy
123 Posted 24/01/2014 at 21:14:36
Harold I've just had a quick recap of the posts and I don't see any saying he might not be good enough - there are one or two who questioned his impact when it looked as if he wouldn't be ready until 9 or 10 games from the end of the season and a few who are not sure about Everton loaning another player but I have only seen a couple who are doubtful as to whether he would suit us or not.

Now you're a fair-minded person perhaps you could view RM's video on the OS and tell me what you think regarding RM's slip of the tongue at [02:32]

Patrick Murphy
124 Posted 24/01/2014 at 21:21:52
Oh I'm a bloody half-wit now am I Kevin? [:- [Bloody smiley face thing]
Dennis Ng
125 Posted 24/01/2014 at 21:20:52
Kevin, wonder if this is good...Change YNWA to "You'll Never Beat Our-Loans"
David Graves
126 Posted 24/01/2014 at 21:21:37
Thank you John Daley.
Raymond Fox
128 Posted 24/01/2014 at 21:17:32
Nice one Patrick, one thing about this site,
your always guaranteed a smile or a laugh or two along with the teeth grinding!
James Elworthy
129 Posted 24/01/2014 at 21:19:02
Maybe Bill will replace Chang with Wonga next seasons as loans are the order of the day.

Too many of our cups are half empty due to dithering Dave, with a leak in the glass.

With Roberto they are half-full and under a dripping tap filling up more...

Kevin Tully
130 Posted 24/01/2014 at 21:24:02
Or Roy Orbison's "Only the Loanees"
Patrick Murphy
132 Posted 24/01/2014 at 21:33:21
Next big West-End production for our famous chairman is da da da da

The Borrowers is a children's fantasy novel by the English author Mary Norton, published by Dent in 1952. It features a family of tiny people who live secretly in the walls and floors of an English house and "borrow" from the big people in order to survive

Based on true-life events apparently and published around the time the producer was strutting his stuff in the Boys Pen allegedly.

Jim Bennings
133 Posted 24/01/2014 at 21:27:15
Yes I just feel that too many people are willing to write off players before they have even seen them or much of them.

I go by what I have witnessed myself before making judgement on players and from what I have seen of Robles, he is an able back up at the minute and would feel comfortable with him standing in for Howard. He made an error for the Saints goal here round Xmas time but as I say its so hard to get match sharp when you sit on the bench week in week out.

I always wait to reserve my judgement and I was one of the fans who actually wanted us to buy Kone before we even did in the summer so I am willing to have patience with they guy once fit.

Same goes for Traore... It may seem pointless a bit if he is out for a long time but he may be back before February is out, its already February next week so who knows.

As a player I like the look of him, and again who knows, we may just start looking like we are capable of actually winning a header from a corner kick (real pet hate of mine how we never seem to produce anything from corners)

Eugene Ruane
135 Posted 24/01/2014 at 21:46:10
Brin (385) - "Eugene - all I can say is we all have our cross to bear - and I am beginning to find mine so far up my nose that it is becoming unbearable"

A cross up your nose?

Well..um...yes that WOULD be unbearable.

(!?)

Terry Davies
136 Posted 24/01/2014 at 21:39:20
Love it, Patrick
Paul Ritchie
137 Posted 24/01/2014 at 21:26:36
Without Barkley we are surely desperate for someone to run with the ball and make a killer pass. Pienaar can do it but looks like he's tired. We need some creativity just like Manure did - and they've got Mata now. We are going to struggle if that's it for this window.
Mark Taylor
140 Posted 24/01/2014 at 22:04:12
RM has enough credit in the bank for me not to jump on his back. In any case, behind the scenes, it might just be a case of him having to face up to the reality of 'Bill's budgets' and the consequent need to make the best of the pool of players who can be obtained cheaply.

It does however seem to be odd to be signing a very short term loan signing, normally done to provide immediate cover, who isn't fit. As to when he will be fit, this is as clear as mud, which seems to be the case with a lot of our players this season. Either our medical expertise is less than razor sharp, or RM is playing the wishful thinking line.

Like others, I am absolutely perplexed by the lack of central midfield cover. Looked at logically, one of either McGeady or Traore isn't vital. If we have the former, Mirallas can be back up striker (to good effect, I suspect), if we have the latter, we don't need McGeady as cover. But we do need an alternative to the Barry/McCarthy axis- unless Roberto has a system that only need one CM.

Harold Matthews
141 Posted 24/01/2014 at 21:34:21
Patrick. Yes, the slip of the tongue does seem to suggest that the lad is not allowed to play for a while. Not allowed by the physio, not allowed by the terms of the loan or maybe something to do with the work permit. Strange business indeed.
Patrick Murphy
142 Posted 24/01/2014 at 22:27:37
Thanks Harold - as you say it might be a medical assessment from the Monaco end.
Harvey Miller
143 Posted 24/01/2014 at 22:08:22
This is very good news. Now we have the aerial threat and the lad seems to know how to dribble and shoot also.
Gerry Quinn
144 Posted 24/01/2014 at 22:32:57
BK to RM...
How do I get you a loan,
How do I get you a loan
A loan,
A loan,
Drew Shortis
145 Posted 24/01/2014 at 21:21:50
I forget which commenter posted that Traore didn't exactly have a good goalscoring record, but I feel the need to defend the lad. Here is his league record:

2008–09 Cluj 6/1
2009–10 Cluj 25/6 one every four games
2010–11 Cluj 13/7 one every 1.8 games
2011–12 Kuban 38/18 one every two games
2012–13 Anzhi 24/12 (plus 12/6 in Europe) one every two games
2013-14 Anzhi 5/1

International 7/4 one every 1.75 games

Now I'm not suggesting that scoring goals in the Russian Premier League means he will be able to do the same in England, just take a look at Mirallas' record in Greece, but to say he doesn't have a good goalscoring record in incorrect. Since his career got going in the 2010-11 season he has averaged a goal every other game!

Until I see the guy play in a blue shirt and see what he can do I'm not going to judge him either way, but I do hope he can have an impact on the last quarter of our season. It seems like a fair few people want to see him fail so that they can say "I told you so" about Martinez. In the same way that I (the eternal optimist) am not ready to commit to saying he will be a star I hope the doom and gloom mongers will hold back on their judgement until he has played a few games and shown, one way or the other, what he can do!

Tony Cawson
146 Posted 24/01/2014 at 22:36:49
In the style of Bob Dylan,
They'll loan him when he's walking down the street,
They'll loan him when he's got two left feet,
They'll loan him cos our squad's down to the dregs,
They'll loan him if he's got two broken legs,
What's that Billy Kenwright shoutin' down the phone...
EVERYBODY must get loaned....
cue trumpets etc.......
Gerry Quinn
147 Posted 24/01/2014 at 22:52:16
Well answered Drew – he appears to have a very consistent record despite the doom and gloom. I look forwards to seeing him loping around the pitch for us causing havoc – have to get one of those mega-big TV screens though, so that I can see the top of his head!
Eugene Ruane
148 Posted 24/01/2014 at 23:05:59
An obvious loan pun?

Try this feller.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4XAGtP1r5tU

And like Roberto, a vision in blue and white and a force for good,

Plus a tune I've always thought this tune should be played whenever we make a substitution.

Goodnight.

Noel Early
149 Posted 24/01/2014 at 22:59:51
Hopefully he will have a super Kevin Campbell affect in the last ten games.Not looking forward to the derby with the injury list and coming of that disaster of a result against West Brom. If we stay within 5 or 6 pts of the top 4 by the time Barkley and Deulefeo come back from injury then I think we are in with a fighting chance.
Brian Wilkinson
150 Posted 24/01/2014 at 22:50:27
So we are going for our targets in the summer it seems, we are playing Russian roulette in the hope we qualify for the champs league.

Not for a long time have we been in a stronger position to convince players to sign as we are now, if we qualify all good and well, but if we don't it will be harder in the summer to convince players to sign.

My way of thinking is they are banking on us finishing in a European spot to see if we can try to sign Lukaku in the summer.

I would rather bring the players in now if they are available, not just to be sure we sign them but also give the extra push for the final third of the season.

We all know what happened when we finished 4th, we didn't strengthen the squad the following season, that was our first chance of moving up a level.

I really hope history does not repeat itself and we bring act and bring in some permenent signings.

Kone and Gibson back next season, how do we know they won't get injured again after a couple of games, big big chance to nail some signings in this window, but I have a feeling it will come back to haunt us later this season.

Here's hoping Vellios gets a shot on Saturday, May not want to go out on loan, but the few times he's played I have been impressed with the guy.

James Martin
151 Posted 24/01/2014 at 23:03:23
Roberto’s got to be careful with these loans. If they come off and we get 4rth its money well spent. If we’re outside the top 4 then the loan fees have literally been money thrown away. If Lukaku was £3 million to loan in (some have reported £5M) then that is an Arteta, a Pienaar, a Cahill... five Seamus Colemans. The latter is an asset that you can keep or sell of at a higher price. The former is a player that at the moment looks completely uninterested and will be back at his parent club in the summer.

Loan signings do have some benefit but if they don’t become permanent what effect does it have on our identity and close knit nature of the squad. I’ve banged on and on about it already and some people don’t like it but the parallels between Martinez and Moyes keep springing up (Martinez even said today that Stevenage were favourites, imagine if Moyes had said that!).

We have stuck rigidly to the same 4-5-1/ 4-2-3-1 system home and away all season. We only ever play one up front. Players continue to be played out of position (Naismith, Osman, Mirallas), old favourites are chosen over players in better form (Baines getting selected over the far superior Oviedo this season).

Martinez appears to keep buying the same type of centre forward. Where is the variety between Lukaku, Kone and Traore? We still don’t effectively rotate which means, for all the fancy training and conditioning work we do, we still have the worst injury list in the league yet again because our small squad is over used.

We still probably won’t make that creative midfield signing we’ve been crying out for since Arteta left, and with Pienaar and Barkley injured we’ll have the same dip we had at this stage last year. We still can’t take a throw-in. We still can’t defend crosses. We still kick it long and don’t challenge for the ball. Our build up play is still too slow.

As many have said if Roberto doesn’t get fourth this season they’ll be excited for how we will improve next season. But were is the improvement with loan signings? Barry may stay which is good although he won’t last for long. The only player we have invested money in that may make us some back in the future is McCarthy. The rest are short term fillers and loan signings. Its fine for the now if we make champions league.Its not a long term strategy though. Roberto is reaping the benefits of a shrewd transfer policy of the previous manager. He my not have played Stones but Martinez has got an incredible core of talented players diligently built up over a period of time. He has to add to them and build it season on season rather than merely topping them up with good loans.

It really would be the biggest con going if the board were allowed to get away with selling off assets like Fellaini, Anichebe and Jelavic for the best part of £40 million and supplementing them with loans and free transfers. That’s 13 million pounds worth of striking talent replaced by two loan signings. Something is wrong in that we’ll have spent the best part of 11 million on strikers this season be that permanent or loan, yet will still start next season with Kone the only senior striker on the books. This needs to be rectified.

Gerry Quinn
152 Posted 24/01/2014 at 23:22:31
Eugene, you old fart - just looked that up and it were on t' telly in the US in 1949!!!!!!!


http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_The_Lone_Ranger_television_episodes

Now tell me which one was your favourite episode :)

Steavey Buckley
153 Posted 24/01/2014 at 23:43:28
Mohammed Sissoko, an one time Everton target, has been freed by PSG and would be an excellent short term solution to Everton's midfield shortage.
Drew Shortis
154 Posted 24/01/2014 at 23:37:44
James Martin 418
Some very good points there. It's good to read an analytical breakdown of some of the arguments against the loan signings instead of just negativity and insults that only serve to drive the pro-Martinez fans further towards his side.

I do believe Martinez will spend in the summer when the market is more active. We saw that he was not afraid to invest big money in McCarthy. He didn't have enough time to spend the Fellaini money in the last window and in this one there is not a lot of players available unless we pay over the odds.

If his Champions League gamble pays off then everyone will be hailing him as a genius. If it fails we will will still be in a very good position, though I agree that the money we paid out for the loans may be seem a a waste. I don't think we paid a stupid amount for Deulofeu as Barcelona were keen to get him playing time and the deal includes clauses that say we pay less the more he plays. I'm not sure how much we paid in fees for Barr, but I would say it was money well spent, especially if he signs permanently in the summer. Lukaku's fee was obviously substantial, but on balance I would say it was worthwhile as we would have had to relied on Jelavic for goals! Its way too early to say if Traore will provide value for money. We don't even know what the fee is.

I think the loans were necessary this season, and I would not be against them in future, but I agree that we have to be careful with our resources and try to invest our money in permanent deals whenever possible. However, Martinez should only buy if he believes the player will add real quality to the team. If that player is not available to buy then I will accept a loan until someone does become available to sign later down the road. Better to have quality players on loan than to be stuck with the likes of Krøldrup or Van der Meyde!

Ross Kerry
155 Posted 25/01/2014 at 00:03:12
Another loan signing. I hope he does well, the model depends on it.
Mike Green
156 Posted 24/01/2014 at 23:44:50
So - Martinez has brought in Lukaku, McCarthy, Barry, Alcaraz, Kone, McGeady, Traore, Deulafeu in different shapes and forms of contract (let's call it trying to make a silk purse out of a sows ear).

Kone had been an obvious disappointment, as has Alcaraz due to injury. The rest in my mind have been successes of varying degrees, or have not even had a proper run out.

He's also offloaded Fellaini for a more than a respectable fee (I note there are posters criticising Martinez who also never rated Fellaini that have decided to omit this from their critique) and to be honest I still owe him a few beers for getting shot of Anichebe regardless of whether the replacement was on loan or not.

Then there's Barkley.

There's also a week left of the window isn't there? Who says he's not going to bring someone else in, and if get doesn't who says he's not got a plan to set things straight in the summer?

He's half way through his first season, we've gravitated around the CL spots almost throughout, played some great stuff and had some duds too but 1.5 transfer windows down the same people that hailed Moyes for working on a shoestring are criticising Martinez for not improving the team - when he clearly has, and far more decisively than his predecessor ever did.

I honestly don't know what more people expect him to have achieved by this stage of his career with us as Everton manager.

Patrick Murphy
158 Posted 25/01/2014 at 00:01:40
I'm hoping that Roberto does have that surplus money available in the summer and that he knows his squad a lot better after working with them for a year - so far he has done OK and we have altered our style of play which is a lot better to watch.

However, the old problems do remain and not all of those problems are under Roberto's control. The injuries always seem to arrive at the same time and perhaps the players are not being asked to play through the pain barrier and that is why they appear to be out for longer than we were used to in the past.

We have some good youngsters and some have proved they can perform at this level but as always experience will always be preferred when clubs are chasing points. Any other season would have seen us at least in fourth place at this stage and probably a few points clear of fifth place.

But I'm not sure how many truly expected a CL berth at the start of the season and I cannot suddenly see why it would seem a failure if we didn't achieve what most thought was beyond us before we kicked a ball.

The team obviously has to continue to pick up wins to ensure we are involved at the business end of the season, which will make a pleasant change as the last half-dozen games have usually had very little importance save for whether we finished in sixth or eighth place.

Even if we only managed to win half our games from now until the end of the season we would end up on 66 points which would be a decent return from Roberto's first season in charge and I think would be the most points we have collected from a PL season - I may be wrong on that I haven't checked If we want CL football then we will have to win at least another 10 games from the remaining 16 and 72 points might not be enough to guarantee a CL berth.

Mike Green
159 Posted 25/01/2014 at 00:17:01
Oh - I forgot Robles - granted, he looks like he's had his hands sown on back to front, you can have that one.
Jimmy Sørheim
160 Posted 25/01/2014 at 00:07:54
If this loan transfer is the last then bye bye Champions League for us!!!

Why bring in a striker that can not play because of injury?

RM says this is his last signing, if true he has just lost us CL.

Harold Matthews
161 Posted 25/01/2014 at 00:16:06
Only the loanee. Onleeee the loaneeee.
Brent Stephens
163 Posted 25/01/2014 at 01:03:51
This was built up by Roberto to be a potentially good window.

So far we have one fat bastard and one crocked bastard and he now says there'll be no more signings!

Halo? Not quite in position?

Brent Stephens
164 Posted 25/01/2014 at 01:12:52
James #418 - just read that post. The second paragraph is well worth a read by everybody.

I don't want to be a Jeremiah nor an anti-Roberto voice (I've actually loved what he's achieved so far). But that is a very sobering paragraph.

James Stewart
165 Posted 25/01/2014 at 01:20:17
Look forward to seeing him play. We could do with a signing as well especially in midfield.
Tim Jones
166 Posted 25/01/2014 at 01:30:54
Very disappointed to hear that Traore is injured and will not be fit for a 'few weeks' as this does not do anything to solve our need for a forward now that Lukaku has gone off the boil especially in the next few important games.
Si Cooper
168 Posted 25/01/2014 at 01:49:51
Brent (#457) – very sobering if you actually agree with it. It is overblown and very subjective if you ask me.

"Where is the variety between Lukaku, Kone and Traore?" – do you think that is a reasonable question given that we haven't even seen one of them play and the other two aren't generally lumped together when drawing comparisons?

Why would we be spending a load of money trying to replace Arteta when the midfield trio of Barkley, Barry and McCarthy have been getting rave reviews? Haven't we just signed McGeady who is a skilful player who can create chances?

Finally, do you really accept that RM is little more than a Moyes clone and believe that his take on the dangers unique to a cup game is on a par with OFM's brand of defeatism?

Mark Andersson
169 Posted 25/01/2014 at 02:16:37
Keep it positive, I really don't understand some of the negative mind set of some supporters. Football is like life itself, some good days; some not so good. You can plan all you want but shit happens.

I buy into Roberto's dream, the world was built by dreamers. If the Everton board back their manager then the future will be good for us the supporters.

Steve Brown
170 Posted 25/01/2014 at 02:15:16
With permanent transfer, you can bring in a player with a minor injury, but you want a loan player to make an immediate difference to a tiring squad. To bring someone in on a loan who cannot even be on the pitch for weeks is illogical.

If he is the last player we bring in during this window, I will be really disappointed. We must be the only team to buy an injured striker in this window I'll bet,

David Ellis
171 Posted 25/01/2014 at 02:50:58
Is it me or has the quality of comments on this board just nose-dived. Cheer up lads (and lasses). We have a cluster of short term injuries - it will pass. The derby could be tricky but the season goes on regardless - have some perspective.
Dennis Ng
172 Posted 25/01/2014 at 02:53:53
It's just how weird this is really,, David. Loaning someone to be on the treatment table. No fear on RM's views but defo sounds like fishy biz. Could they have done better? Probably, but we will never know. There's also debate on whether we'll have new faces. They have and probably will not sign a CM cover this window.
Tim Jones
173 Posted 25/01/2014 at 04:08:55
David, it's just that all the high hopes for this transfer window seem to have become damp squibs. Now that's not the fault of the people making comments.
Jackie Barry
174 Posted 25/01/2014 at 04:38:17
Fair enough, but let's be honest, we can't buy players that are not available and, in the two we have signed, while one is a loan, it is far more interesting than in previous years. After RM's few months in charge, I am not going to see a so-called lack of transfer activity as a means to start promoting the doom and gloom. Also if there is anybody using this as a chance to have a go at Roberto, go for it your looking like a fool!
Brent Stephens
176 Posted 25/01/2014 at 06:36:48
Si, yes, of course most content in posts is subjective. And maybe it is in parts overblown. But there is other stuff in that para which ring alarm bells.

As I say, I'm a Roberto moll. Let's remember, we did say we'd need to give Roberto time before we judged him. That time aint come yet. I so desperately want to be able to laud him, in the fullness of time.

But this could all go either way. Too early to tell. I think all James is saying is let's be careful of a few boobies.

Sam Hoare
177 Posted 25/01/2014 at 08:09:05
Glad to see another body in but a bit deflated that he is injured and will need time to settle in. Also concerned that if that is the end of ou business that we are placing a huge burden on McCarthy and Barry who don't really have any like for like replacements except undesirably osman or heitinga.

Also agree with James Martins point:

'Something is wrong in that we'll have spent the best part of 11 million on strikers this season be that permanent or loan, yet will still start next season with Kone the only senior striker on the books. This needs to be rectified.'

Geoff Freeman
178 Posted 25/01/2014 at 08:51:23
On the subject of loans I wonder how many people are like me and thinking I'm glad Lukaku is on loan and we haven't paid £20mill for him.
Erik Dols
179 Posted 25/01/2014 at 09:12:19
Geoff #491 people who come to this site do have knowledge of the prem. Perhaps you didn't notice but it is a very specific site ;-)
Brin Williams
180 Posted 25/01/2014 at 09:31:42
Harold 435 - was that RO or RM crooning?
Max Wilson
181 Posted 25/01/2014 at 09:49:12
Will he be Abbey Clancy's next?
Mike Manchester
183 Posted 25/01/2014 at 09:51:00
Think I read it was a shoulder injury, anyone confirm/deny?


Chris James
184 Posted 24/01/2014 at 20:23:08
Blimey, there really is no pleasing some people.
As far as I can see we've brought in two attacking players, the main area we needed to strengthen due to injuries and need of an extra edge - one as a full signing and one half season loan (with potential to extend another year),

Both offer something different to what we've got - extra pace down the flanks from McGeady and an even bigger man up front hopefully causing problems Big Dunc style.

With Del and Barkley to come back from injury too and hopefully nothing too serious to Pienaar and Coleman, I think we should have a strong line-up for the run-in.

Would I like 1 or 2 others, sure, but only if it's the right sort of player. Essien actually might have been quite handy as defensive midfield cover, this Belgian lad Baty looks interesting and obviously Mata would have been nice...but aside from these two I don't see a lot of available players that we're missing out on.

David Finney
185 Posted 25/01/2014 at 08:40:38
Steavey (423) surely that is worth a punt. Even if he is not in the form he showed when he was with the RS he must be worth a go as cover and to give Barry/McArthy a rest.
Steve Brown
186 Posted 25/01/2014 at 10:15:00
Chris 502, I think the point some of us are making is that the CL spot is definitely achievable this season with sound additions to a squad that has looked a bit leggy in recent weeks.

Of course we will have a fresher squad in the run-in with Barkely, Deulofeu, Gibson and the new lad all back and raring to go. But we need reinforcements now with the small matter of Liverpool, Spurs and Chelsea away all coming up in the next four weeks.

Steve Brown
187 Posted 25/01/2014 at 10:21:58
After all the top 3 are moving out of sight but 4th is definitely on.
John Daley
188 Posted 25/01/2014 at 10:32:09
"Martinez appears to keep buying the same type of centre forward. Where is the variety between Lukaku, Kone and Traore"

Except he's only 'bought' one of them...and the three players aren't really anything alike. One is a powerful brick shithouse who relies on his body strength to shrug off defenders, the second is a smaller, speedier forward who likes to come deep and carry the ball forward, and the third is an unorthodox unknown quantity: 6 ft 8, all spindly legs and arms, yet surprisingly pacy for his size....bit like one of those 'Prawns' from District 9.

"Lukaku was 3 million to loan in (some have reported 5)"

£5 m loan fee? Bollocks. Love the way the alleged and unsubstantiated loan fee for Lukaku keeps on rising in inverse proportion to his poor run of form. It'll be £8m being bandied about as 'wasted on him' in a few weeks. By the end of the season: 'He's shit that Lukaku. Every Evertonian named Terry, Sean or Shaft, with a season ticket in the Top Balcony, was forced to sport a Shakin Stevens mask and sacrifice their first boy child in the name of Be'elzebub...behind a green door...in order to bring that lazy bastard in. All that innocent blood and shop soiled 'Shakie' memorabilia... and he's not even gonna be here next season. Such a waste of life and life-like face coverings'.


Oh, hold up, we don't actually need to wait until then. Here it comes now:

"Something is wrong in that we'll have spent the best part of 11 million on strikers this season be that permanent or loan, yet will still start next season with Kone the only senior striker on the books. This needs to be rectified."

Where are these figures actually coming from? I count £6m for Kone. What about the rest. Where was it actually confirmed that Everton have had to stump up £3m-£5m for Lukaku? Where and when was the loan fee for Traore announced because I must have missed it when Martinez was revealing almost every other detail of the deal? It's all just conjecture without confirmation.

Anyway, why are people suddenly making such a big deal about 'loan fees' all of a sudden? Have they not always existed? It's nothing new but listening to some on here you would think it is some snide con trick only Roberto is rube enough to fall for. In previous seasons there's not been so much as a peep about pennies being spunked on season long loans, short-term loans or shockingly shit loans (step forward Segundo). Did Jo, Pienaar, Arteta, Howard, Donovan, Fernandes et al all come for fucking free in the past? The whole 'we're gonna be brassic because of these bloody loan fees, lad' lark has only become an issue in the last few months as form has faltered and the press played up the Everton loan abusers angle.

Raymond Fox
190 Posted 25/01/2014 at 10:51:41
For all the members complaining about RMs signings. They have to be available to be signed in the first place, not a great time to be after players, then there's the small problem of the terms of the deal!

No doubt if Roberto had the finance that our opponents at the top of the PL have, he could have aimed higher.
Don't forget he could have been the shite's manager with a lot more money to spend than here.

In my opinion, were lucky to have Roberto as our manager, who thought we would have a chance of a top 4 finish when he was appointed? Not many I'll wager.

Ben Jones
191 Posted 25/01/2014 at 11:30:24
In terms of the explanation for no midfield signings, I think Roberto is using Heitinga as cover there.

I think if Heitinga leaves, we will buy someone in that position.

Dan Brierley
192 Posted 25/01/2014 at 11:13:43
"...bit like one of those 'Prawns' from District 9"

Genius that John. But on your view that loan deals are not a problem, if it does transpire that we have spent upwards of £5 million this season on loan deals where none of them have a clause for purchase, then it looks like a gamble on a quick win. As people have rightly pointed out, £5 million could have bought the next Pienaar, Arteta and countless Seamus Colemans.

The difference with previous years, we loaned in players with the view of looking at them to decide if we want to buy or not. Players like Stracq, Castillo, Pienaar, Arteta, Howard etc. And yes, we wasted money on a few, but others became important members of our squad. Today's loan policy appears to be to rent players with no view of permanent signing, hoping that they get us in the CL.

Eugene Ruane
193 Posted 25/01/2014 at 11:42:20
How this thread works.

Substitute 'fiend' or 'monster' with the word 'loans'.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qLvGnro4Cgw

Jackie Barry
194 Posted 25/01/2014 at 11:35:27
So Dan, how do you know we won't be buying any of the players we have loaned in? Please show me the loan deal paperwork that shows this, because this is what you are saying. Also, what if we sign another midfielder on a permanent basis, is this going to make everybody happy?

In the end, RM could end up failing, but you know what: I have been watching some of the most exciting football being played by Everton in a long, long time and long may it continue. Who knows – maybe the way we are playing will make somebody sit up and take notice and we will finally be released from the clutches of BK and his crew of useless buddies.

Kevin Tully
195 Posted 25/01/2014 at 11:44:35
On the subject of loan fees, don't we pay less to Barca the more Deulofeu plays? I don't imagine it was a large fee for a youngster anyway.

Barry will be wages rather than a fee I would imagine, as he only has 6 months left on his contract, so that has to be viewed as good business.

Lukaku will have been a sizeable amount of money, and nobody has a clue how much we have have paid for Traore, but how much can you demand for an injured player?

Mike Corcoran
196 Posted 25/01/2014 at 12:01:27
John Daley is deffo my favourite Twebber, great sense of humour.
Jackie Barry
197 Posted 25/01/2014 at 12:03:21
Exactly Kevin, this is all ifs and buts based on rumour. I heard a rumour too, we haven't paid crazy money for the loans and we have first option to buy some of these players.
Phil Walling
198 Posted 25/01/2014 at 12:08:57
It matters not a stuff what we say but if this kid comes in and scores a few like Jelly and Rom did, he'll be hailed as our best striker since Sharpey, Lineker and Latchford.

It's only when they hang around for more than 10 weeks that they become shite. RM has cracked it and is saving Traore to make an impact when it counts.

Sheer bloody genius!

Harold Matthews
199 Posted 25/01/2014 at 12:23:05
Brin. Probably Phil Walling.
Paul Tran
200 Posted 25/01/2014 at 12:31:25
I'll save the pontificating for when the window ends. That's the time to judge, then you judge the players on what they do, not whether you 'like' Martinez or not.

Only thing I will say to some folk is that it would be good to come up with the loan 'fees' for Moyes's signings and then compare them with the loan 'fees' for Martinez. At the moment, some are comparing apples with pears, in what I think is a desperate ploy to crab Martinez.

Brian Waring
201 Posted 25/01/2014 at 12:35:15
It's disgraceful the way Martinez is going about it all, I mean FFS he's been here for years, oh hang on...................
Dan Brierley
202 Posted 25/01/2014 at 12:33:37
Jackie, Martinez himself has said there is no buy out clauses. The only player we have a shout of buying will be Gareth Barry, who will be 33 next year.

As I have said before, I am an Everton supporter, not a Martinez supporter. If you want to try and re-write history and pretend that we were somehow shit before Martinez arrived then again, fair play to you. But I remember finishing 6th last season, and playing some great football in the process.

This season has also shown some excellent football, but I am also able to freely admit there has also been some shockingly bad football. If you are happy with this situation and think that it's a good thing that we sign injured players on loan, then fair play, good luck to you. But I don't think it is good enough for Everton.

David Starsky
203 Posted 25/01/2014 at 12:56:49
Dangle some raw steak from the Street End – and see if he is hungry!!!
Jackie Barry
204 Posted 25/01/2014 at 13:01:09
Show me Dan because the only thing I have heard him say was in regards to Lukaku and that there was no way Chelsea would consider selling in the January transfer window. I have yet to see any official loan on the players we have in. Sorry but until you show me that RM spoke words to that affect that I can confirm then no this has not been said in my opinion. This is no disrespect to you by the way.
Dan Brierley
206 Posted 25/01/2014 at 13:07:09
Thats fair enough Jackie. But to be honest mate, I am not willing to trawl through the internet to try and prove my understanding. The info I read was from a media outlet, so is never going to be 100% factual anyway.

If I am wrong, and we sign all these players then I will be more than happy to admit I was completely wrong, and this is a long term strategy. But at the moment, I see this as throwing money at short term solutions which is not the way I expect our limited cash to be spent.

Jackie Barry
207 Posted 25/01/2014 at 13:05:53
Loan information that should say, Dan. As for the right now, I think people are being very disrespectful to our new manager, he has come into what everybody for years has been saying is a tough job. We gave Moyes all the excuses such as he has an unfair playing field in terms of transfer funds, punching above our weight, and every other blah blah you can think of.

Last season was good, in fact there have been many season I have enjoyed under Moyes, but for me I am seeing better football at the club right now than I have seen in years. There is a belief in the players that they are capable and our manager is not constantly moaning about how hard the job he has is or how unjust the refs have been.

I support my club too, Dan, but I also support our manager because, despite my initial objections, he is doing a darn good job and has done nothing to deserve anything but.

Jackie Barry
208 Posted 25/01/2014 at 13:14:28
Firstly Dan, I never said sign "all" these players. Secondly as was mentioned in regards to other player who came in on loan and then we purchased them, how do we know this is not going to be the case with these players?

My problem, Dan, is that some on here talk as if Martinez is some kind of dimwit about to be caught out, when the truth is he has done absolutely nothing to show this is the case. I am sure he has a plan, but obviously he is not going to sit down and tell us all about it.

Maybe we should just sit back and enjoy the ride, have a little optimism about what lies ahead.

John Francis
210 Posted 25/01/2014 at 15:13:46
Crime of the century if Sunderland get Banega. This guy has EFC written all over him, go get him Bobby
Harold Matthews
211 Posted 25/01/2014 at 14:50:45
Jackie. I think I'm with you on this one. Judging by McCarthy, McGeady, Robles, Kone and Alcaraz, Martinez is not likely to give a long term contract to a complete stranger and a loan spell enables him to weigh up the players ability, character and personality.
Steve Brown
213 Posted 25/01/2014 at 15:53:09
Harold, I am sure RM will use the time Traore is with the club to properly assess his value as a player. Agree that loans are good business sense and something we have done well over the years with Arteta, Pienaar, Donavan etc.

But we also have the pressing need of away games in the next 4 weeks against 3 of our top rivals, with Lukaku misfiring, Kone injured and Jelavic sold. If we are serious about a CL challenge then I just don't get signing a player who wont be fit for any of those games. As it stands we are 6th (sounds familiar doesnt it) and I for one think that with some proper reinforcements this squad and this manager have what it takes to make 4th.

Steve Brown
214 Posted 25/01/2014 at 16:03:34
I am also suspicious that this is once again the board failing to back the manager exactly like it did 12 months ago. Expect a bullshit final day bid for a Negredo quality player that has no chance of succeeding.
Colin Glassar
215 Posted 25/01/2014 at 16:49:00
Moutinho Steve?

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads

© ToffeeWeb