Everton vs Aston Villa

, 31 January, 112comments  |  Jump to most recent
Match Preview

Everton are back on home turf after three successive away games that yielded a handsome win in the FA Cup Fourth Round but just one Premier League point and a cold reality check at Anfield that has left them four points adrift of the Champions League places.

The Merseyside derby defeat was the Blues' third away League match without a win and, combined with the Boxing Day disaster against Sunderland at Goodison Park, that sequence has seen a good deal of the heady optimism washing through the fanbase to evaporate.

Though there were glaring tactical issues at play against Liverpool on Tuesday night that compounded the gulf in resources available to the two clubs, the blame for Everton's recent patchy form arguably rests on a mounting injury crisis combined with physical and mental fatigue.

Though transfer deadline day always offers hope of much-needed reinforcements, Roberto Martinez's rhetoric hasn't offered much hope that any major moves are afoot to add to a squad whose lack of depth again looks likely to scupper a bid to finish in the top four. Any late arrival would be ineligible to face Villa this weekend, anyway, but there is no question that it would give the whole place a lift.

Thanks to that list of significant injury absentees, the manager has few options at the back and up front for this one, though particularly where defence is concerned, Tuesday will have given him food for thought.

The unfit pairing of Phil Jagielka and Antolin Alcaraz was ruthlessly exploited by Brendan Rodgers and it's fair to say that against Villa, a team that also likes to play on the counter-attack, Martinez will be asking for more trouble if he deploys the same partnership of, at the least, the same high defensive line.

In hindsight, the experience offered by Tony Hibbert might have been a better option at Anfield than John Stones and he may opt for the veteran this time in the continued absence of Seamus Coleman who remains sidelined with a hamstring injury.

With Sylvain Distin also out, he could also use Stones alongside Jagielka in the centre, as he has done in recent matches, which would mean Hibbert starting by default.

In midfield, Martinez does have some choices, though, including playing Leon Osman and Steven Pienaar either side of the Barry-McCarthy axis and pushing Ross Barkley up behind Kevin Mirallas, or handing Steven Naismith the honour of partnering the Belgian and choosing between Osman and Pienaar on the left.

New loan signing, Lacina Traore, who was unveiled to the press yesterday, could fit enough to play some role, but the feeling is that he could still be about 10 days away.

Villa will travel in good spirits after their stirring Birmingham derby victory over West Brom on Wednesday evening but they will probably be without their chief speed merchant, Gaby Agbonlahor. Christian Benteke has rediscovered some goalscoring form, though, and he will likely by Paul Lambert's biggest threat.

With the Champions League charge suffering a jarring setback on Tuesday, Everton simply have to get back to winning ways with a win over Villa and set the stage for a potentially vital clash at White Hart Lane on Sunday week when Gerard Deulofeu is line to return.

Betting: Here are the odds on Everton vs Aston Villa
KIck off: 3pm
Referee: Robert Madley

Quotes or other material sourced from ToffeeWeb Match Reports



Reader Comments (112)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Kunal Desai
1 Posted 31/01/2014 at 06:50:23
This isn't the game Everton need after the derby debacle, we've got a poor record at home against Villa in recent seasons, drawing many of these games. I sincerely hope one or two players are nearing match fitness as it certainly showed on tuesday night. Villa will probably play similar to the RS where they will counter attack and if our patched up defence is still severely wounded then Villa's front three of Benteke, Agbonlahor (if he plays) and Wiemann will have a field day. Much will depend on how much of a battering our confidence took, I very much hope i'm proved wrong but I see another defeat here.
Ray Roche
2 Posted 31/01/2014 at 07:43:27
Strange one, this, we have only lost once against Villa in the last 11 games, 1-0 (a) in 2010, yet we haven't won at home since Feb 2009 in the FA Cup, 3-1. The last Prem home win is right back in Mar 2006. Our away record in recent times is better than our home one.
Darryl Ritchie
3 Posted 31/01/2014 at 07:46:17
A must win if ever there was one. Hopefully Kevin can show us all that he has the chops to be an effective striker. Put Naismith in behind him, reprising his Stevenage role, and have RB attacking from midfield. McCarthy also in the middle( give Barry a break, have him as a sub). Hibbo and Osman on the right. Baines and Peinaar on the left. Stones and Jags as CB's.

Not the our top 11, but the best we have at the moment. If the walking wounded are a little more game fit, and Roberto is on song, tactics wise, we should be alright.

Steavey Buckley
4 Posted 31/01/2014 at 08:24:28
The game against Aston Villa tomorrow is a game Everton must win after missing out on 2 points against another team (West Brom.) perilously close to the bottom 3.

Strangely, Aston Villa would have to start favourites against Everton tomorrow, because on paper, they have more players to choose from.

For the life of me, I can't consider what team Everton will have out tomorrow with so many players injured, not match fit, while some, are just basically out of form. With Mirallas touted to play up front, there will be no width with any pace. How Everton will go about breaking Aston Villa defence will be more about inspiration than a team plan.

I have just watched recording of Everton (2nd at the time) beating Coventry (3rd) back in the 1970's, 6:0 at home, with Bob Latchford getting a hat trick. Quite easily really for Bob, just waited for Dave Thomas to scamper down the left wing beating his opponents and crossed sublime into the Coventry penalty area for Bob to just put them away.

Dave Lynch
5 Posted 31/01/2014 at 08:55:03
Thios is a bigger game than the derby in some ways.

Draw against the Albion and that other result has got me jittery, lose or even draw this one and confidence will be shot to pieces.

Kevin Tully
6 Posted 31/01/2014 at 09:11:12
Agree Dave. This game will tell us all we need to know about this team. Injuries or not, we should approach this game like a Cup final with a massive point to prove.

I expect a win here, but if we don't manage it, it really could be season defining as we are are away to Spurs & Chelsea in two of our next three.

I know if I was playing I would feel like setting the record straight.

Ben Mackenzie
7 Posted 31/01/2014 at 11:09:01
Daryl, McGeady for Osman, other wise I'd agree with that. Osman to replace McGeady when he inevitably tires.
Max Wilson
8 Posted 31/01/2014 at 12:25:09
My Toffee mates and I are pessimistic about tomorrow. We saw the failings of the team fielded against the Reds and none of our missing first seem to have got fit this week. We don't want to see Naismith and Stones on the team sheet.Sorry! Stevenage were a lowly little club, let's get real! Personaly I'd rather see one of our youngsters given the chance for glory. Say Garbutt in defence and Vellios in attack.At least these young guys have speed and some technical ability. In my opinion we are still suffering from Moyse's mistakes amongst our playing staff and need a good clear out.
Andy Meighan
9 Posted 31/01/2014 at 13:06:30
Just got a fixed odds coupon from Hills and Villa are 7/1 to win what a price that is after that shambles on Tuesday night That coupled with our poor home record against them. Makes it a neutral punter's dream, in my view.

I personally think it'll be a struggle tomorrow, possibly a draw. They've picked up in the last couple of games and should've hammered the Shite over there... something we haven't even come close to for centuries. Tough game tomorrow — it always is against them.

Darryl Ritchie
10 Posted 31/01/2014 at 13:14:55
Ben, oops! Forgot about McGeady. Have to agree with you there.

Max, Vellios? Really? He was on the bench for lowly little Stevenage, and didn't get a sniff. Gueye is rated above him. Gueye! There is something going on with him that we're not being made aware of.

Max Wilson
11 Posted 31/01/2014 at 13:40:25
Darryl, the guys like Vellios because hew's got fire in his belly, would'nt be sent away, believes in himself. Hallam Hope has just come in from

Northampton where he was scoring. He's a silent assasin, runs in onto the ball at the last mo. Big muscular lad. One for the future?

We are gonna get another beating unless we are very careful. You can see it coming. Hope I'm wrong, but.........

Paul Taylor
12 Posted 31/01/2014 at 13:52:32
We need to get back on track. The RS result was a disaster and RM must somehow get us back to winning ways, even with the injuries.
Darryl Ritchie
13 Posted 31/01/2014 at 14:04:02
Max, Fire in his belly and splinters in his ass! Sorry, couldn't resist.
James Lauwervine
14 Posted 31/01/2014 at 14:12:09
My team would be:

Howard
Hibbert, Stones, Jagielka, Baines
Barry, McCarthy
McGeady, Barkley, Pienaar
Mirallas

With Gueye, Naismith and Osman, there would still be some options from the bench.

I don't think it'll be much different to this anyway.

Ben Mackenzie
15 Posted 31/01/2014 at 14:23:31
If we can just get through this one, hopefully Distin, Coleman, Deulofeu, and possibly Traore to become available next week.

Whoever RM puts out there tomorrow really needs to be at full tilt, we can do it!!

Brian Waring
16 Posted 31/01/2014 at 14:38:52
I agree there Ben when you mention about us just getting through this game, I think it's going to be a tight one.
Peter Fearon
17 Posted 31/01/2014 at 14:50:05
I would feel more comfortable putting Mirallas up front or giving Vellios his opportunity rather than persisting with Naismith in a striking role. It's not his game. It's one thing to muscle past the naive defenders of Stevenage. It's another to put him in an unaccustomed role against Premiership defences. It's alarming that we are trying to stay in Champions League contention with no striker. As for the defence, we would be better off bringing Barry into the back four.
Brian Harrison
18 Posted 31/01/2014 at 14:59:26
I cant believe the negativity, are we so fickle that we think that our team that has lost only 3 league games will just fade away. Yes Tuesday was a bad night but don't you think the players know that and will be doubly determined to put matters right tomorrow.

Villa do have a good record at Goodison of late but rather than that being a negative I believe that fact will motivate the players even more. They will want to show that us fans were right in thinking we could get a win at Anfield, and that was just a freak result. Remember last season City putting 6 past Utd it didn't stop them winning the league.

I know it wont be a walk in the park mainly because of our injury list, but I believe these players have shown enough this season for us not to throw the towel in after a bad result.

Harold Matthews
19 Posted 31/01/2014 at 15:23:12
Mirallis and Barkley should get us through this one but Jags must not push his line too high again. He's done it many times before but the pace of Distin has always saved the day.
Raymond Fox
20 Posted 31/01/2014 at 15:11:05
If Agbonlahor is missing that's good news for us, otherwise it might have been a similar game as Tuesday.

I would argue though, about why is Alcaraz being made a scapegoat for Tuesday, I've argued the point before I know, but in my book Stones and Jags made more mistakes than Alcaraz, Baines was in no mans land a few times also.
I said before the game that Hibbert should be at RB because Stones wasn't ready yet for a game of that importance, and he wasn't.
I wouldn't play him in this game either because if we get beat in this game were really out with the washing.

Stones will be very good player for us in the future, I like the lad, but he's not there yet.

Graham Mockford
21 Posted 31/01/2014 at 15:30:15
Brian,

I think the air of pessimism comes not only a reality check on Tuesday bit the amount of injuries we have sustained in the last couple of months that has exposed the lack of depth in our squad.

Saturday is a big game for us, bounce back and we could still get some momentum but a draw or defeat probably sees us dropping into 7th place and a difficult few weeks ahead.

I'm struggling a bit given the squad why we let go or are planning to let go Jelavic and Heitinga if we haven't got better replacements. We've taken another loan striker who is fit or proven and now Lukaku is injured we are forced to play a makeshift striker in Naismith or Mirallas.

It just feels that after a great first half of the season it could all unravel very quickly.

But I admire your optimism.

Darryl Ritchie
22 Posted 31/01/2014 at 16:13:03
Not pessimistic, just very conservatively optimistic.
John Zapa
23 Posted 31/01/2014 at 16:39:15
The squad had an extra days rest relative to Villa, big advantage at this stage. Anything less than a win will destroy the confidence of the team. The season will unravel and the blame game will begin.
Harold Matthews
24 Posted 31/01/2014 at 16:35:22
Raymond. Yes, Alcaraz was far from fit but the big hole all night was the Jags-Stones area. Could have driven a herd of elephants through it.
Jon Cox
25 Posted 31/01/2014 at 17:19:18
Now, I may get hung drawn and 1/4d for this but cast your minds back say, a decade or so. For those old enough to remember lets have a look at Manure.

Remember when they used to get a massive defeat? What usually happened in the following 10 games or so? I’ll tell you what. Every team that had to play utd were faced with not just a team of all stars, but a team that had one big time ingredient.

Anyone suss out what it was? I’ll tell you.

It was an ATTITUDE. And whether you like him or hate him SAF knew how to instill that attitude. Now, to me, it’s perfectly alright to have silky skills and ball control etc but if you, as a collective have the wrong attitude, you’ll accomplish Jack sh*t.

This by the way was the difference between Moyes and SAF.

It’s why Moyes will eventually fail at Man U. It’s ok playing good football but if you don’t have an aggressive attitude coupled up with copious amounts of guile to compliment your Barce style of football then, in terms of the EPL you can forget it.

I’m not very good at English but I do like words and their meanings. So, Tuesdays word has to be this;

ab·er·ra·tion (a-bə-ˈrā-shən)
n.
1. A deviation from the proper or expected course. See Synonyms at deviation.
2. A departure from the normal or typical: events that were aberrations from the norm.
3. Psychology, A disorder or abnormal alteration in one’s mental state.
4.
a. A defect of focus, such as blurring in an image.
b. An imperfect image caused by a physical defect in an optical element, as in a lens.
5. The apparent displacement of the position of a celestial body in the direction of motion of an observer on Earth, caused by the motion of Earth and the finite velocity of light.

Lets do a 5 4 3 thing.
5. Who can tell us the one player that is our "celestial body" who didn’t play against the rs and is on loan? Oh, and he would have cut through their back line like a volcanic-ally heated knife through butter.

4/ Since we are talking about the lens, could that be the lens of a camera and therefore the media? Lets face it those bastards will not have been able to contain their selves after our defeat. Having said that You’ll have to tell me because after Tuesday night the Cox household has had a complete media blackout! Don’t they just love them bastards across the park. Sorry it’s ok i’m calming down and i’m ripping pieces of paper very slowly...

3/ This has got to be about our illustrious manager.

A match of this magnitude and Stones gets the nod before Hibbo. RM your havin’ a bubble. And by the way Lyndon, It might of been hindsight for you, but there’s loads of us on this site that would never EVER have played Stones instead of Hibbert. Sorry but that has to be the worst decision by our manager yet. No problem though for me, he’s still a thousand times better than Moyes ever was.

2 and 1. Pretty much the same really but I like 1.

" A deviation from the proper or expected course."

A full and functioning squad? How we played away at the Arse?

I think you know what I’m getting at.

So my message for our team is, lets get out there guys and lets banish the ghosts of Tuesday past and lets annihilate Villa tomorrow and for the rest of the season, as someone very famous once said,

"Up Up and away, infinity and beyond!"

COYB

Phil Walling
26 Posted 31/01/2014 at 19:20:59
Best price I could get about an Everton win was 4/7. Evens the draw, Villa 6/1.
Mike Hughes
27 Posted 31/01/2014 at 19:51:18
It's a "must win" game - mind you, Villa always give us problems.
Following on from Darryl #573, I'm tentatively, cautiously hopeful.

Simon Hermansen
28 Posted 31/01/2014 at 20:31:25
I'm expecting a reaction. Under DM I'd have expected a 4 or 5 game nose dive. Maybe I'm still in RM positive land despite Tue night and I'm not necessarily saying it will be a hiding, just a reaction.

The key for me is Mirallas playing up front now he's found form and Barkley in behind supporting. Could run Villa ragged. Please not Nessie ... No!!

Chris Leyland
29 Posted 31/01/2014 at 20:55:10
Simon H - I'm all for moving on under Roberto but I can honestly say I think it's a bit unfair on the previous manager to say you expected a 4 or 5 game nose dive after a defeat like Tues. yes, the football did often lack any excitement under Moyes but I can't recall many 5 game nose dives when he was here. Can you?
Raymond Fox
30 Posted 31/01/2014 at 20:59:58
Were all down and losing faith, but looking at the table now, were 1pt behind Spurs, 2 in front of Utd, 5 in front of Newcastle and 10pts in front of the next Southampton.

Hands up who thought at the start of the season that's where we'd be!
Injuries and lack of depth are our only problem.

Robin Cannon
31 Posted 31/01/2014 at 21:01:49
To be entirely fair to Moyes, we often reacted reasonably well to disappointing one off defeats.

I think everyone is panicking far too prematurely.

We hit Liverpool at just the wrong time, with our players still out injured or rushed back prematurely - a definite mistake.

We are still, and rightfully so, favorites for this game. Midfield can still field McCarthy/Barry/Barkley/Mirallas/and one of Pienaar/McGeady - and I'll take that selection over Villa every time. Having Barkley back makes a big difference.

Jagielka should be another game closer to fitness. I'd move Stones into the center and put Hibbert on the right, rather than playing Alcaraz again (I don't even understand this "muscle fatigue" thing). I definitely feel like we're short in central defence generally, but we should be back to mostly first choice in the next week or so.

Striker...not sure. I don't think Naismith has done too terribly on the rare occasions he's got to actually play as striker rather than stuck out wide. I'd probably prefer to see Mirallas moved up, though. And there is talk that Traore, while not match fit, may be a possibility for the bench (RM has said he's 10-14 days away from *starting*). Given Lukaku has been off form the last few games anyway, I'm not sure there's a massive difference in quality there.

Raymond Fox
32 Posted 31/01/2014 at 21:12:11
I also meant to say we should be very proud of this club, because were the only ones to put up a serious challenge each year without spending a bleeding mountain of cash!
Dick Fearon
33 Posted 31/01/2014 at 21:18:58
All Villa needs do is follow the blueprint set down by all those minnows who took points off us and also used by Brendan Rodgers.
It goes something like this, pack the back line, have a token midfield, Everton via a thousand and one unchallenged ticka tecka passes to push forward en mass then hit our two man defence on the break.
Sorry to sound pessimistic but that Anfield debacle exposed far too many faults.
Tony Twist
34 Posted 31/01/2014 at 23:19:20
I think it will be an easy win...for the villa. Mirallas up front at home might be ok but I have my doubts. We have had our chance to bring reinforcements in and failed miserably. I wait in hope to be proved wrong. Perhaps one of the youngsters might get a chance up front sometime during the match and make a name for himself.
Max Murphy
35 Posted 01/02/2014 at 00:16:48
A draw
Sam Hoare
37 Posted 01/02/2014 at 07:46:07
Tough one this especially with us so vulnerable to villas pace on the break.

Hoping Mcgeady and Mirallas pull us through.

Mat Smith
42 Posted 01/02/2014 at 09:47:36
Max - did you actually read what you wrote:-

"We don't want to see Naismith and Stones on the team sheet.Sorry! Stevenage were a lowly little club, let's get real! Personaly I'd rather see one of our youngsters given the chance for glory. Say Garbutt in defence and Vellios in attack."

So at 19 Stones is no longer a youngster? And you'd prefer a youngster with some experience be dropped for a youngster with no first team experience - and then be either be played out of position (as garbutt is a left back) or in place of Baines?

Really????

Personally I'd rather see hibbert, jags, stones , baines at the back with Ross and Kev leading the attack

Adam Smith
43 Posted 01/02/2014 at 09:50:25
Have to say, I really see us getting turned over badly again in this one. Not just a reactionary comment based on the abject nature of Tuesday night either. I often get told I'm too positive about the Blues since Roberto came in, but this is another disaster waiting to happen.

I was looking at our players on the Fantasy Football website whilst I was picking my team; and it makes scary reading (so many red icons!)

I noticed that Traore will also be unavailable for the Spurs game as well. Now we may well get away with it if players like Mirallas, Barkley, McGeady and Deulofeu step up to the plate but that is ONLY if the defence holds it's ground - no chance today.

No Alcaraz either today so Hibbert will be at rb with Stones and a presumably still unfit Jags in the middle. If we play a high line with Hibbert in it we will be as exposed as Tuesday - and I can't see Roberto doing otherwise. Plus Villa are good at counter-attacking, if little else!

I'm also extremely worried at the thought of an injury to Barry or McCarthy, as that means that Osman will be holding mid and our season will fly past us as easily as even the slowest opposition midfielder goes by Leon!

Anyone also think that as well as fourth spot we could have kissed our cup chances goodbye? We already have to beat City at GP really, if we want to stay in the hunt - yet we will have to play Osman against the best midfield in the league. What happens if say we draw City in the cup semi or final (assuming we get there)? Same problem.

Despite what people say our squad has been improved this window - but not enough. We are one injury away from a VERY serious problem!

Adam Smith
44 Posted 01/02/2014 at 10:03:51
Sorry to the pedants out there for the rogue apostrophe!
Ian Bennett
45 Posted 01/02/2014 at 10:16:36
Jesus, a couple more injuries and we'll have to join a 5 a side league. Down to the bones.

Howard

Hibbert
Stones
Jags
Baines

Pienaar
Barry
McCarthy
Barkley

Osman
Mirallas

Karl Graham
46 Posted 01/02/2014 at 10:22:08
Adam 867 we play City in May so hopefully by then Gibson should be back fit and had a couple of games. Even if he isn't Osman can do a job he played in midfield all last season and it was only in games when he played alongside Neville he struggled.

My team for today would be: Howard, Hibbert, Stones, Jagielka, Baines, McCarthy, Barry, McGeady, Barkley, Pienaar, Mirallas. Subs: Robles, Alcaraz, Garbutt, Osman, Gueye, Naismith, Vellios.

I'd bring Hibbert in for Alcaraz as he obviously can't play 2 games in a week also if you drop Stones you could destroy his confidence. Mirallas up top is more likely to trouble Villas defence than Naismith who is a bit one paced. McGeady should start and bring on either Osman or Naismith when he starts to tire.

Raymond Fox
47 Posted 01/02/2014 at 10:15:39
Everyone who has suggested the team for today have left Stones in and took Alcaraz out! Why.
STONES isn't up to speed with the PL. yet, he may be the future, ok.
I know I keep banging on about this, but in the derby game Stones and Jags were worse than Alcaraz so why drop Alcaraz?

Hibbert should come in at RB and Stones should be on the bench, that's what should have happened on Tuesday!

We don't want Agbonlahor to play in this game, if he does theres a chance we could lose in a similar way as Tueday.

If Roberto drops Alcaraz I'll hold my hands up, we'll see.

Mark Frere
48 Posted 01/02/2014 at 10:40:50
My Team:

Howard
Hibbert Stones Jagielka Baines
McGeady McCarthy Barry Pienaar
Barkley
Mirallas

Adam Smith
49 Posted 01/02/2014 at 10:34:33
Karl 874, hope you're right about Gibson but I think he'll struggle for match fitness even if he is back before the end of the season.

Have to disagree over Osman; the only job he can do is a half-arsed one. He is the last of the Moyes era players we have who shouldn't be anywhere near a side chasing Europe (Hibbert at least is third choice right back). Since Roberto came in, he has cleared out Vic, Jelavic and Heitinga. Add to that the fact that Fellaini, although often our match winner the way Moyes used him, actually hinders a good footballing side and the fact that Neville and Hitzlsperger retired and we have cleared away a lot of the detritus!

Osman is just awful. He makes me physically angry whenever I see him play. He has never had the stamina to play more than 60 minutes - and what little stamina he had is waning. He can't tackle or intercept, he isn't strong enough to hold off the opposition, takes an age to make a decision and has appalling positional sense - not to mention the fact that he has the pace of an asthmatic pensioner.

Even going forward he is a liability. I have gone on record countless times on here, complaining about his inability to weight a forward pass. He always plays his passes behind the man and kills our forward momentum which is criminal. He has decent control and occasionally chips in with a goal but that is IT!

If he has to play he can just about do further forward, but lets end this total fallacy that he can play further back - even with Jimmie Mac as a partner and not Phil Neville. The sooner Osman moves on the better we will be!!

Brian Harrison
50 Posted 01/02/2014 at 10:52:50
I hope RM plays Stones alongside Jags today. I think he would be far better than Alcaraz who is slow and his decision making against Liverpool was terrible. Stones is the natural successor to Distin so we have to play him there whenever Distin is injured, Alcaraz is a squad player and only played the other night because both Coleman and Distin were injured.
Karl Graham
51 Posted 01/02/2014 at 10:53:33
If everyone was fit Osman wouldn't make the bench but compare him to other 4th choice midfielders and he'll compare ok. If a player is of better quality than Osman they would be wanting to be regular starter somewhere else. The problem we've had this year is Gibson has missed most games so McCarthy and Barry have not had so much as a breather as we've been using Osman as sub for Barkley. I agree about his stamina not being the best but disagree with the half arsed comments.
Ian Bennett
52 Posted 01/02/2014 at 11:03:46
Ray, Alcaraz is injured.
Linda Morrison
53 Posted 01/02/2014 at 11:07:11
Why should Jags play he was obviously still injured on Tuesday as he could not keep up with the game. I know most of them couldn't.

Realistically I think we lost the chance to secure a top 4 spot when we could only draw in the previous game.

I think we will be lucky to get a draw today.

A win is really essential but to not lose is vital.

Steavey Buckley
54 Posted 01/02/2014 at 11:20:33
Moyes once aptly said (in a Glaswegian accent,) when playing Bolton in a similar situation as today with so many injuries: bring yer boots, you might get a game.
Mark Taylor
55 Posted 01/02/2014 at 11:17:10
Linda,

Jags will have to play because we let our only other fit central defender go to Fulham on a free. For the same reason, Stones will also have to play.

Graham Mockford
56 Posted 01/02/2014 at 11:32:44
Ah Adam Smith,

It wouldn't be match day without an Ossie bashing, sort of reassuring.

Adam Smith
57 Posted 01/02/2014 at 11:39:46
Tell me he doesn't need replacing if we wish to improve Graham!
Robbie Muldoon
58 Posted 01/02/2014 at 11:39:16
Agreed on Osman, a lot of better players out there we could have.
Paul Smith
59 Posted 01/02/2014 at 11:46:33
Nais up top ?
Brent Stephens
60 Posted 01/02/2014 at 11:40:15
And it was only Tuesday when Osman was one of the 2 best players in the second half. Get off, Osman, you're shit!
Pete Edwards
61 Posted 01/02/2014 at 12:09:28
Although far too many draws, I'd take 3 defeats up to now. No need to panic, we're still in the race with key players getting back to fitness very soon. Keep the faith.
Graham Mockford
62 Posted 01/02/2014 at 12:13:33
Adam Smith,

Not yet.

Colin Williams
63 Posted 01/02/2014 at 11:52:54
Calm down everyone, you don't become a poor team over nite! My hopes for today are: Howard to calm down when the ball is knocked behind our back 4 instead of charging out 4 a ball he can't get.(eg 3rd goal and penalty against the shitte) I thought experience gives you composure! obviously NOT!!
Jags to sharpen up a bit and play a Captain's role.
Barry to find his top game.
Last but not least, DON'T PLAY NAISMITH!!!!
Adam Smith
64 Posted 01/02/2014 at 12:26:22
Graham - Hmmm. The Osman love-in from some quarters is worrying!!
Colin Glassar
65 Posted 01/02/2014 at 12:28:58
This is a must win game — not only for the points but to shut up all the pundits and journos who've been wiping the floor with us since Tuesday. COYB.
Graham Mockford
66 Posted 01/02/2014 at 12:31:10
Adam,

It just helps to counteract the uninformed hatred.

Brent Stephens
67 Posted 01/02/2014 at 12:30:22
No love-in from me, Adam. Simply reflecting what happened Tuesday. I'll wait to see what happens today before judging his performance today - if he plays at all.
Adam Smith
68 Posted 01/02/2014 at 12:32:49
Not hatred Graham. Strikes me as a nice bloke. Useless footballer. Also, I think it's a bit rich to call my opinion uniformed - my list of Osman's weaknesses is accurate. The issue is whether or not he still has a role to play. I pay to see games just like you. I watch the games in detail just like you.

I said I don't understand the love in. I never said you were 'uniformed'.

If he scores today he still isn't good enough - it changes nothing! If Brett Angell was just as useless but scored the odd goal here or there, would he still be useless or would people be petitioning to put him in the team?? Facetious example I know, but you could substitute any poor player into that example!

Just seems to me that people pick and choose who they think are good and bad players in a very strange way

Chris Gould
69 Posted 01/02/2014 at 12:32:10
Osman is not consistently great and sometimes not even good, but he continues to pop up and put in match-winning performances when you don't expect it. Other players are inconsistent, such as Mirallas, and don't get the flack Osman gets.
I wonder if it's because he's considered part of the old guard and people just want to move on. I for one wouldn't be surprised if he scored or set up the winner today and still got abuse. He is essential to this squad right now and whilst still with us deserves more support. Especially as he is a blue through and through.
Ciarán McGlone
70 Posted 01/02/2014 at 12:38:23
Uninformed?

Osman's career at Everton has been a classic story of inconsistency - he has been mediocre throughout. Typified by his derby performance.


Just because you apparently disagree with this, does not make it 'uninformed'...neither does it make 'it 'hatred'.

Graham Mockford
71 Posted 01/02/2014 at 12:40:34
Adam

Your final paragraph is something we can agree on at least. Which camp do you think Roberto is in?

Steve Pugh
72 Posted 01/02/2014 at 12:40:13
Adam,several times this season Ossie has come on and changed things around for Everton turning draws and defeats into wins. Did that make you angry?
Brent Stephens
73 Posted 01/02/2014 at 12:44:51
Did Osman have a shit performance in the derby? Must have misjudged that!
Raymond Fox
74 Posted 01/02/2014 at 12:42:17
Ian 890, what do you mean when you say he's unfit.
That he's still not regained fitness from his old injury or he's sustained a new injury.

If so, where have you heard that?

Ian Bennett
75 Posted 01/02/2014 at 12:53:51
I read he was a big doubt for today.
Graham Mockford
76 Posted 01/02/2014 at 12:42:52
Ciaran

I thought I was disagreeing with Adam but now you've contributed I would say most of the criticism of Leon on this site is uniformed.

For instance to say he has been mediocre throughout his career is uninformed ie does not take into account the evidence available.

That doesn't mean he is beyond criticism, he has weaknesses to go along side his qualities. He doesn't get in our strongest midfield but trying to get our strongest midfield out has become a bit of a challenge recently.

His contract runs to the end of next season so I suspect you're going to have to put up with it a little while longer however to cheer you up his appearances will get fewer especially next season.

Adam Smith
77 Posted 01/02/2014 at 12:44:23
Graham I think that Roberto probably knows that Osman isn't really good enough but wants to keep him around because of his connection with the club and his attitude in training. He is probably worried about throwing the baby out with the bath water - although I maintain he just isn't good enough for us anymore.

It is his connection with the club that makes so many of our fans love him, instead of judging his footballing abilities. Lets be honest the flack McCarthy gets from some quarters (I know that MOST of us think he's been a quality addition), makes me wonder how people would think of Leon if he was playing just as often, but if he had been signed by Moyes or Martinez. I'll tell you - they'd say he was shit and moan about all the things I mentioned above!!

If he is still playing regularly next season I will consider that we just haven't moved on at an appropriate pace.

Colin Glassar
78 Posted 01/02/2014 at 12:49:29
I thought Ossie was great when he came on in the derby. I know he's past it but he's been a fantastic servant and can still do a job as an impact sub. He deserves more respect.
Mike Powell
79 Posted 01/02/2014 at 12:48:55
Naismith and Osman — what chance have we got with these two in the team. If we want to get in the top four, which we won't this season after not getting any players in, then we need to get rid of players like these. They are not good enough for the Prem, never mind a top four side.
James Stewart
80 Posted 01/02/2014 at 13:00:13
Osman from the bench with 15 mins to go I have no problem with can be a neat and tidy player. Starting games its a whole different story
Adam Smith
81 Posted 01/02/2014 at 12:55:56
Steve, save your steadfast defence of a player for one who deserves it. Yes it made me angry when Osman has come on this season. He has played well in one game this season (although I can't remember which one atm), when he has come on and scored or set one up it doesn't change how badly he has played.

People like to paint Osman as a game-changer on here, but he Deulofeu he ain't!!

And should he score today there's no point gloating - he isn't good enough for Everton. A poor player can still contribute something, this is more an issue of how good we want Everton to be. If we genuinely want to challenge for CL, even if Osman is fourth choice, we can do better. That's without a huge transfer budget too!

Chris Gould
82 Posted 01/02/2014 at 13:01:00
Please stop saying uniformed because it truly makes you seem uninformed in more than one way.
Osman is needed right now and deserves our support. This argument should be saved for the summer.
Jim Knightley
83 Posted 01/02/2014 at 12:55:57
Osman is just average...that is the reality I think. Football fans, possibly influenced by press sensationalism, seem to have to judge a player either as awful or brilliant...there seems little room for middle ground. Osman has had some great performances for us, and some poor ones, but I think he would have been a consistently better performer if he had always been played in a preferred central midfield position.

Personally I'd rather not see him in the starting 11 this season, or beyond. I think he played very well last season, perhaps his best in an Everton shirt from recent memory, but has generally been poor when appearing this year. I think he will be useful as a squad player over the coming 18months, but I generally think he is too limited for the team. Barkley, for all his naivety and greedy play, offers more to the team, and is a more frightening proposition.

I also echo the concern of some on here about today...Villa's counter attacking ability frightens me. But, that said, I think they've generally been effective on the counter when teams have failed to retain a defensive midfield presence, and given them space between the defence and attack (The Arsenal and Liverpool matches in particular spring to mind). With Barry and McCarthy, who have been generally been superb this season, we won't make that mistake. Obviously Beneteke against Stones or Alcaraz is worrying, but we are sixth for a reason. The injuries will weaken us, but I still think we will win, and hopefully keep a clean sheet, today because I expect us to win the midfield battle.

Graham Mockford
84 Posted 01/02/2014 at 13:00:56
Adam,

Nonsense mostly I'm afraid. You claim Roberto thinks he's not good but has played him in every game this season. An odd thing to do as a football manager.
Not sure what who signed him has to do with anything, just take a player on his merits. I agree McCarthy has been a good addition but the amount of criticism he gets on this site pales into insignificance to what Leon gets.
I'm sort of with you on your last point, I think next season will be his last and he will play a decreasing role.

Dick Brady
85 Posted 01/02/2014 at 13:15:17
Really need 3 points today. It's really important because the season is just starting to slip away and that would be a disappointment for Roberto after such a promising start.
Brent Stephens
86 Posted 01/02/2014 at 13:19:33
The Scottish Manager picked Osman a lot but he was a poor judge of things, as we know. You wouldn't see our new manager picking Osman, would you?
Colin Williams
88 Posted 01/02/2014 at 13:27:59
Adam- 956, agree 100% with your comments, simply not good enough!!! don't rate him as a premiership player. The lad's had a good run in prem, needs to drop down a level, maybe then he can influence games on a regular basis.( to good to retire)
No Ossie bashing, just no presence when he plays.
Robbie Muldoon
89 Posted 01/02/2014 at 13:41:11
It's football Darwinism, survival of the fittest, Osman the weak link when he starts these days just as Pistone, Pembridge, Kilbane, Neville, McFadden and other players with limitations were before him. Time to relace. Nothing malicious, just obvious.
Graham Mockford
90 Posted 01/02/2014 at 13:48:39
Robbie

Just not obvious to Roberto though, strange that.

Steve Pugh
91 Posted 01/02/2014 at 13:39:18
Adam, I'm pretty sure I wasn't defending Osman, I just asked if it made you angry when he came on and changed games in Evertons favour.

To be brutally honest your answer was predictable, you denied it. I you honestly think he has only played well once all season then you either don't watch Everton very often or you have a blind bias that stops you from seeing anything that spoils your argument.

Most of the people you disagree with on here agree that Osman is best used as a backup player, useful off the bench, not a starter if we are at full strength but still useful. They can see the weaknesses that you so gleefully pointed out, but unlike you they can see his strengths and appreciate what he can bring to the team.

Simon Hermansen
92 Posted 01/02/2014 at 13:49:11
Popped onto a pre match thread to find an Osman love hate debate in full swing ... who'd have thought it!
Robbie Muldoon
93 Posted 01/02/2014 at 13:52:36
Well to be fair Graham he is being edged out this season, so I think Roberto does recognise it and it won't be long now.
Graham Mockford
94 Posted 01/02/2014 at 13:54:19
So in your world 16 starts and 7 playing sub appearances is being edged out?

I have consistently said he doesn't make our starting eleven but he has an important role to play. Sometimes that will be off the bench, other games he will start. Comparing him to Kilbane or Pembridge or even Brett Angel, as Adam Smith laughably did,is just ridiculous.

That's the one thing the anti Osman brigade just can't square, what does Roberto see in him.

Anto Byrne
96 Posted 01/02/2014 at 13:32:16
Oh! If only we had Pip Neville orchestrating the midfield and Barkley out on loan at Dipshit United! I thought we could have got Cahill back on loan and while at it some other no mark signing of the Kevin Kilbane or Darrin Bent vintage. Oh wait — we have Roberto and now playing beautiful football and daring us to believe we are on the threshold of something good.

Keep the Faith; just coz the Shite had one of those days when everything goes their way does not make us a pile of shit. From adversity comes strength to eventual greatness.

Robbie Muldoon
98 Posted 01/02/2014 at 14:09:59
Graham, he didn't make the starting 11 ahead of an unfit Pienaar nor did he get a start against Stevenage. At West Brom, he started because of injuries to other players and was replaced after another no show... can you see a pattern emerging?
Steve Brown
99 Posted 01/02/2014 at 14:13:46
Line-up announced for the game. We're not so much playing with a false Number Nine, rather an imaginary Number Nine...

Thankfully Hull have Jelavic up front. Phew, glad they're alright.

Iain Thomson
100 Posted 01/02/2014 at 14:15:30
3-1 to us

McGeady to cause mayhem.

I'm Scottish and never been to a live game... Liverpool supporting colleague here got 2 tickets for the derby and asked if I wanted to go... thank fuck I couldn't get the time off.

Derby was utter wank but I hope that is used to motivate the squad rather than damage their confidence.

Al Reddish
101 Posted 01/02/2014 at 14:18:10
Distin plays. Osman instead of Pienaar. Stones right back. Mirallas up front.
Adam Smith
102 Posted 01/02/2014 at 13:58:50
Steve, I watch Everton a lot. Sorry if you find my attitude predictable but I speak as I find. Like I said people give undue charity and cheer to the 'local lads'. Would be a bit like Liverpool persevering with Jay Spearing because he is a local lad, even though he just isn't and wasn't good enough for their team/squad. That attitude will hold us back eventually. It is great if a local lad has the talent of Ross or Bainsey, but if they don't should be judged on footballing merits and if they're not good enough – move them on.

Also, there is no blind bias – I will always give a player the benefit of the doubt and will change my opinion accordingly. When Coleman came through I thought he looked amazing going forward but so bad at defending that I wondered if he'd even have what it takes to defend at League 1 level. Yet he has worked on it and improved. Still a way to go defensively but has such a strong all round game now it's untrue – I was wrong! First time I remember properly seeing Osman play was when he scored against Wolves in the 03-04 season. I wanted him included over the next couple of seasons as he was better than what we had (Kilbane etc). However, by the time the 08-09 season rolled around and having seen him for years as a season ticket holder, I had the exact same concerns over his game as I had at the start plus his limited stamina was getting worse – ie, he never improved. Now we have and he needs moving on. Like I also said what little he does offer is not as a defensive midfielder. Is it blind bias if I notice every time Osman slows down our play with the wrong pass (doesn't matter if he passes to our man if it's almost always the wrong ball) or loses possession cheaply in midfield, instead of focussing on the odd goal or even rarer incisive through ball? I would say not.

As I said, absolutely nothing against Osman – met him actually and he was a top bloke – just not good enough for a premier league squad at the top end of the table.

It is not character assassination, I know his weaknesses clear as day, as do many others. I also know that people will defend him to the hilt as we have seen. I would never boo the lad - he plays for us - in fact, I applaud him when his name's read out etc. I get angry because he isn't good enough and I want us to be the best we can be. Sadly, that means Osman nowhere near the team!

Also I didn't start 'Osman bashing' per se. If you look at my first post I just said I was worried about his deployment at holding mid. Graham responded by saying we'd be okay with Osman and I responded with why I felt we wouldn't. Very different to targeting a player for abuse.

Barry Hughes
103 Posted 01/02/2014 at 14:11:02
Radio Five shouting up that Distin's playing! So now it's a straight choice: Hibbert or Stones. After the Derby, that'll be a big decision for Martinez.
Al Reddish
104 Posted 01/02/2014 at 14:22:29
McGeady starts. Coleman on bench
Sam Hoare
105 Posted 01/02/2014 at 14:22:48
Decent team. Hope everyone is fit enough though.
Graham Mockford
106 Posted 01/02/2014 at 14:26:12
Robbie

It's all about timing!

Sam Hoare
107 Posted 01/02/2014 at 14:24:21
Maybe that loss at home to Sunderland is beginning to look marginally better... good turnaround so far under Poyet!
Jim Knightley
108 Posted 01/02/2014 at 14:20:09
Better team than I expected. I was under the misconception that Distin had been ruled out. Good to see Coleman back on the bench too. (I also thought he had been ruled out?)
Barry Hughes
109 Posted 01/02/2014 at 14:23:24
Christ, just listening to the Newcastle game. What a fickle rabble those supporters are - lose 3-0 and the fans are running around the pitch ripping up season tickets, berating players. Makes me proud to be an Evertonian when I see how we took our medicine on Tuesday; with class, dignity and continued support for our great Club.
Robbie Muldoon
110 Posted 01/02/2014 at 14:27:50
Shocking bench though, isn't it, three full backs, one injured and one with no experience.
Stan Sheppard
111 Posted 01/02/2014 at 14:30:40
24 Howard
26 Stones
03 Baines
18 Barry
06 Jagielka
15 Distin
07 McGeady
16 McCarthy
11 Mirallas
21 Osman
20 Barkley

Substitutes
01 Robles
02 Hibbert
14 Naismith
22 Pienaar
23 Coleman
27 Vellios
29 Garbutt

Ciaràn McGlone
112 Posted 01/02/2014 at 14:28:14
For instance to say he has been mediocre throughout his career is uninformed ie does not take into account the evidence available.

----------------------------

It certainly does take account of the evidence. Just because I don't evaluate it in the same way you do, doesn't mean its uninformed.

Sam Hoare
113 Posted 01/02/2014 at 14:33:09
I will be curious to see how Mirallas does up front now he is our best fit striker at the club.
Tim Keyes
114 Posted 01/02/2014 at 14:25:53
Adam, I also saw Osman in the Wolves away game (think it was his debut) and had been banging on for months that he should be included and rightly so. I have since watched his entire Everton career as a season ticket holder and frequent away game watcher and have the total opposite opinion that you have so there we go, football — it's all about opinions.

OFM, as I am sure you are aware, had a very annoying habit of playing players out of position most of the time and Ossie suffered more than most. His position is just behind the front man; when he plays there, he is still our best option — apart from Barkley of course. He has probably played half his Everton career wide right which he cannot play to a top level therefore I think he deserves some slack. And yes, as others have pointed out, although he is coming to the end of his career, he was still our best player on Tuesday apart from Mirallas.

James Martin
115 Posted 01/02/2014 at 14:36:42
Osman was one of our better players against Liverpool. At least when he came on, he looked like he was remotely bothered. Barry McCarthy Baines were all awful and lethargic yet it’s Osman getting the rap for daring to be chosen by his manager to start. Weird that. Maybe if Osman was as bad as some people believe he is he might not have played so many games for two of the better managers in English football.
Brian Hennessy
117 Posted 01/02/2014 at 14:43:38
Hope I am wrong but think it's a mistake not playing Hibbert. With doubts over the fitness of Distin and Jags, I would have gone for the defensive ability of Hibbert over Stones.
Steve Pugh
118 Posted 01/02/2014 at 14:38:39
Adam: "... as that means that Osman will be holding mid and our season will fly past us as easily as even the slowest opposition midfielder goes by Leon!"

That is from your first post, and that is Ossie bashing. You then in your second post said that the only performance is a half-arsed one, that isn't a comment about his skill, or stamina or ability it is saying he never tries and that is simply inaccurate and unnecessary.

Tim Keyes
119 Posted 01/02/2014 at 14:47:31
Brian, I agree, Stones was all over the place on Tuesday and looked out of his depth at fullback.
Ciaràn McGlone
120 Posted 01/02/2014 at 14:56:53
Being 'remotely bothered' hardly makes up for misplaced passes and conceding possession.
Adam Smith
121 Posted 01/02/2014 at 14:55:59
Steve - first comment a joke. Second 'half-arsed' one referring more to his meandering pace. When he tries to run it always looks like jogging pace even though I'm sure he's sprinting.

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads

© ToffeeWeb