Mirallas magic completes superb turnaround

, 1 February, 105comments  |  Jump to most recent
Everton 2 - 1 Aston Villa

Steven Naismith scored the equaliser and set the stage for Mirallas' winner
Kevin Mirallas pulled off another moment of dead-ball brilliance five minutes from time, curling home an inch-perfect free-kick that helped Everton to the League double over Aston Villa for the first time in the Premier League era.

The Belgian's goal completed a fine fightback, sparked by substitute Steven Naismith's well-taken goal and earned three priceless points that for long periods of this match looked as though they were going to elude them.

With the game heading into the final 20 minutes, Paul Lambert's gameplan had been working to perfection and frustration was building among a Goodison crowd desperate to see a return to winning ways after Tuesday's disaster at Anfield.

Leandro Bacuna had put the Villains ahead after 34 minutes with what might have been their only meaningful attack of the entire match, at least until a late flurry once they had fallen 2-1 behind.

Fabian Deplh muscled Ross Barkley off the ball in a central area with a borderline-legal challenge before feeding Christian Benteke and he held the ball up until Lacuna arrived on the overlap whereupon the Dutchman fired through Tim Howard's legs.

Everton, who could have been a goal up inside three minutes had Aiden McGeady's curling left-footer crept inside the post rather than cannoning off it, briefly rallied but were continually frustrated by Villa's well-marshalled defence who denied the home side any space within to operate in the final third.

The Blues were largely restricted to a succession of corners from which they failed to unduly threaten Brad Guzan and there were precious few signs in the first half of where an Everton goal might come from.

The pressure would build gradually in the second half but it wasn't until the introduction to the front line of Naismith with 20 minutes left that the breakthrough came.

Steven Pienaar, a second-half substitute himself after Ross Barkley had been forced off with an apparent knock, touched the ball on brilliantly into the Villa area where Naismith, alive to the opportunity, met the pass and knocked it confidently past the advancing Guzan.

Seizing the initiative now, Everton kept up the pressure and when Mirallas was bundled over, he stepped up to take the resulting free kick and produce a sublime match winner.

The win moves the Blues back into fifth place with Tottenham's draw at Hull City and keeps them in the Champions League picture, a point behind Liverpool who play tomorrow.

Quotes or other material sourced from ToffeeWeb Match Reports



Reader Comments (105)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


William Mctaggart
1 Posted 01/02/2014 at 18:50:02
http://www1.skysports.com/football/live/match/287518/video

Restored faith in Bobby and the Team. Great win. COYB

Amit Vithlani
2 Posted 01/02/2014 at 18:44:53
Game of two halves, to quote the oldest footie cliche of them all...
Tony Page
3 Posted 01/02/2014 at 18:52:22
Hopefully West Brom can get at least a point of the shits tomorrow and with a week until Spurs, Everton will have some of the walking wounded back.

Nice match summary, Lyndon.

Ralph Basnett
4 Posted 01/02/2014 at 19:11:30
Going to be a longer second half to the season, lots of injuries and no new faces in the January transfer window.

Obviously keeping our war chest for the summer - not!!!!!

Linda Morrison
5 Posted 01/02/2014 at 19:14:34
Ralph, we have 3 new players in the window. We let go players that did not have games under the current or former manager. We have a manager that seems to know ho he wants in terms of players.

We won today without some of our best players. I'm hopeful; only time will tell if it is displaced.

Colin Glassar
6 Posted 01/02/2014 at 19:20:11
Spot on Linda, but really we only got two players in the window as the young goalie we won't see for years, if ever.
Mark Frere
7 Posted 01/02/2014 at 19:29:46
A vital win today, it will give the players and fans a much needed lift after Tuesday.

Naismith deserves a big pat on the back for his cool finish. He doesn't have much footballing ability but he always seems to know how to get into the correct positions to score. It's so clear now, Naismith should be used as a striker from now on, mainly coming on as a impact sub.

I'm still very concerned that we are desperately short of central midfield cover. If anything happens to Barry or McCarthy we don't have any alternatives.

Chris Corn
8 Posted 01/02/2014 at 19:25:38
Ralph, who would you have bought? There was nothing out there and I would only buy someone to go straight into the first team and make a real difference, not a load of no marks who no one wants just to pad out the squad. Top players cost top money.

We have players back with Gerard fit next week. Traore will be there or thereabouts. Some people need to have a dose of realism.

Mike Hughes
9 Posted 01/02/2014 at 19:32:37
Everton 2 - Villa 1
Possession 71 -29
Shots 13 -4
Corners 13 -1

Lambert "I'm not so sure we deserved to lose the game."

SpecSavers.

Patrick Murphy
10 Posted 01/02/2014 at 19:32:15
Ralph, the second half to the season is going to be a lot shorter than you think as we are nearing the two-thirds stage of the season: next week will be our 25th PL match out of 38.
David Waugh
11 Posted 01/02/2014 at 19:35:30
Result was of major significance today. Given the result on Tuesday and over the festive period, I think a psychological factor may have also emerged and seen us on a poor run of form had we lost. Although we had the lion's share of possession, we just don't look convincing in front of goal. Really disappointed that we did not sign (not loan) a striker in the transfer window.
Jimmy Hill
12 Posted 01/02/2014 at 20:01:52
Naismith doesn't have any football ability? Sorry Mark but being in the right place to score is football ability. Naismith for me is a lot better than people him credit for. If you look at his scoring record I think you will find most his goals come a crucial times. I'd have him in the squad any day.
Denis Richardson
13 Posted 01/02/2014 at 20:02:13
Thank fook for that! Missed the game and when I checked the score after 70 odd mins I thought we'd buggered up again like the Sunderland game and didnt want to look at it again. Only found out we'd won when a mate texted me about an hour after it had finished!

Well all I can say is today we needed the points, the performance was not really relevant. With Spurs drawing and Moyes continuing his record breaking season, that's put us back on track. Hopefully the Baggies can do us a favour tomorrow.

Can enjoy the weekend now before having to think about Spurs away next. At least also another week for the injured to recover, Delboy and Coleman should be back for the spurs game.

Onwards and upwards...

Steve Durham
14 Posted 01/02/2014 at 20:17:06
The Krankies pulling moonies outside The Adelphi
Sharabi Singh
15 Posted 01/02/2014 at 20:35:20
We needed that! 14 games left and with us doing better against the teams around us than the red Scum, other red Scum and Spurs. I think another 8-9 wins could put us in the 4th spot. Also other teams around us are playing with more or less a full squad where we have players to come back.

Everyone was saying how the Liverpool game was the defining game of the season for us but, with the league the way it is, I think it will literally come down to the last 2-3 matches of the season.

Roll on Spurs, all the players would have forgotten Tuesday now and so have I!!!

Brian Wilkinson
17 Posted 01/02/2014 at 20:41:18
That was a very poor display by Villa, we dominated but make no mistake Lambert got his tactics wrong.

What. I will say is for all the Osman knockers, the guy had a decent game.

Stones for me will make a better centre half, he looks like a taller version of Hibbert, same style and iffy when going forward, boy have we missed Coleman.

Once we get our players back we will be fine but today for all our play and fair play we held the ball well, I just think we were fortunate to play a very negative Villa.

Tahir Abdullah
18 Posted 01/02/2014 at 21:09:50
Mike 121, sharp! Specsavers indeed.
Alan Khan
19 Posted 01/02/2014 at 21:02:54
I'm really chuffed with the win today... I thought the lads persisted against a stubborn Villa back line. Decent strike by Naismith after a wonderful touch by Pienaar. And Mirallas was scintillating with the free kick. Like many, I'm so looking forward to Coleman's return and with Gerard also getting back to fitness, the squad will be stronger. Hope Ross will be okay for Spurs?
Milos Milenkovic
20 Posted 01/02/2014 at 21:08:01
Martinez should've brought striker earlier, as it was obvious that we are not creating enough chances. Mirallas is in top form and I think it is mainly because he started to play in his best position as a second striker. He is not a winger and today we saw that he is not a lone striker. Play him from now in his best position and we will be great.
Brian Abbott
21 Posted 01/02/2014 at 21:08:08
Caught the game on an up and down stream and have to say I was a bit surprised at AV approach. They've come to Merseyside and got exactly what they earned. A point at RS ( should have had 3 without the Rats theatrics) and F All at Goodison.

Thought the lads bounced back great after Tuesdays debacle. think at times Miralles looks like a very special player. Baines looks twice as good with a peanut to play with. Loads of great players to come back after injury. Really looking forward to the run in and the cup. Loads to look forward to. ( and Moysey lost at Stoke - it just gets funnier over there) COYB

Sean Kelly
22 Posted 01/02/2014 at 21:25:31
Good result today and great turnaround. Roberto believes so maybe we need to trust his judgement. The two things that need to be addressed are:

(1) need to get ball in the box quicker. We seem to be taking too many touches.

(2) Baines needs to get his accuracy back. His passing seems to be off.

I hope Seamus is back next week as Stones, while doing okay, isn't up to this level yet. Sorry if that's harsh on Stones as he was dropped in the steamy pile against the Redshite.

Alan Corken
23 Posted 01/02/2014 at 21:25:13
I watched the match today and we really were pretty good. We dominated possession and moved the ball around well against a determined and well organised team who were not interested in competing toe to toe.

I think the defeat by RS in mid week has unnerved a few fellowtonions making them both panic and doubt the direction RM is taking us. This however is a only a hangover from the inferiority complex we developed in the last decade.

There will be setbacks along the way, but if we continue to dominate possession we will win more than we lose. The midweek result was a blip I am convinced we will actually gain more from it than RS and will now push on to the top 4.

Conn Prosser
26 Posted 01/02/2014 at 22:20:24
Alan Corken - a hangover? It felt more like a litre of mad dog 20/20 in the park and being brought home by the police with vomit all over your naff co 54 jacket.

Great win today though. I was one of the many muttering we're shit, we're fucked, it's all over. I won't be chastised as faithless though because at one all everything felt very familiar. Thrilled for Naismith and Mirallas, they were played in their natural positions and RM must stick with that.

Alan Corken
28 Posted 01/02/2014 at 23:03:02
Conn - Sounds like a really good Saturday night to me!
Jon Withey
29 Posted 01/02/2014 at 23:50:56
Very good finish from Naismith, superb free kick from Mirallas. McGeady could have had a great goal. McCarthy back to his dynamic self in the second half.

Maybe being underestimated for a bit isn't such a bad thing.

With our injured players back to proper fitness we will be okay. It doesn't take a rocket scientist to point out that we need a striker, hopefully Traore is the business.

Trevor Lynes
30 Posted 02/02/2014 at 00:25:37
Fine result but one note of caution: None of the other top teams are playing with loan players. Their squads are intact and ours is bolstered by loan players who will not be with us in all probability next season. We are right on the fringe of the top four and I am really disappointed that more signings were not made during the window. This is our best chance of making Europe and I would be really disappointed if the chance was missed due to lack of monetary support.

Great to see the side's character displayed and three points won in a tricky fixture.

Paul Kernot
31 Posted 02/02/2014 at 00:39:47
Jesus, can we just support the boys in a tough time and applaud them for this today?

* Distin coming back and playing 90 mins made a big difference

* We were extremely under strength (as we were on Tuesday), yes, against a pretty average side, but their defence looked solid for most of the game

* Man Utd, Tottenham and Newcastle Utd all dropped points today.

Steavey Buckley
32 Posted 02/02/2014 at 00:53:57
Martinez first bringing on Pienaar and then Naismith was a master class of tactical switches because both players made such immediate impacts. The inter play between Naismith and Pienaar that led to the goal expertly finished by Naismith was of the highest order. And the free kick from Mirallas was just out of this world. This team that finished with possible exception of Coleman in place of Stones should play in next week's important game at White Hart lane.
Paul Woolf
33 Posted 02/02/2014 at 01:13:57
Fair play to Naismith, he can look odd at times but he tries 100%. When the ball is played high, he doesn't get beaten to the header many times... and now his goals are coming — two at Stevenage, another today. Good for him.
Paul Kernot
34 Posted 02/02/2014 at 01:44:26
I watched the Tottenham game today. They were shite. Got a good feeling about next week. Win at WHL, Liverpool slipping up tomorrow or sometime soon and we're right back in it.
Peter Bell
36 Posted 02/02/2014 at 02:06:51
Stephen, I am convinced they are due some setback soon, they have had nothing all season. If they had encountered a small percentage of our injuries to key players the would be in th bottom half of the table, all there major injuries have been to fringe players
Paul Ferry
37 Posted 02/02/2014 at 02:22:31

Trevor Lynes - 257 - Fine result but one note of caution: None of the other top teams are playing with loan players. Their squads are intact and ours is bolstered by loan players who will not be with us in all probability next season'

Not true in the first place arse and shite have loan players but yes we have more. But Jaysus our pockets are not as deep so what do you expect? Bobby has already said that loans will be part of long-term strategies because of our sponds situation I imagine above all else rather than a preference.

An absolutely unnecessary 'note of caution' as it's trotted out hundreds of times each week on these boards, hundreds! Given our limitations Bobby has done a super job in the loan market and if he goes there again next year - as seems likely unless ... unless what not sure really .... - he will do another top-drawer job over the summer - coz guess what unlike the last one this gaffer and his style have universal admirers - and we will be in a strong position next season with or without three or four loans.

It's not perfect, don't get me wrong, and I would prefer otherwise and more stability, but given the current minge-bags and '70s relics on the board as I type we should be damn well grateful for this season so far and this gaffer so far and trust him on his record so far to get it spot on next season.

ITFWMWT

So your 'note of caution' is again unnecessary

Andy Kay
38 Posted 02/02/2014 at 02:52:25
Well done Nais, great run and class finish, set up the win. Shame it'll be forgotten soon with all the "Naismith is shite, not a Prem footballer etc" comments if we don't win every game until the end of the season. The lad deserves better on here. He and Roberto were the game changers today.
Phil Sammon
39 Posted 02/02/2014 at 03:34:18
I'm sorry Andy but Naismith deserves a lot of the shit he gets due to a succession of dire performances out wide.

On the flip side, he deserves a huge pat on the back for his impact today. Beautiful finish, linked up well and worked his socks off. If he played like that every week then you'd see a lot more support for him.

Well done Naisy, more of the same please.

Darryl Ritchie
41 Posted 02/02/2014 at 05:43:15
It's funny! Villa today played the way we did....last year. Get an early goal and then circle the wagons. RM got it sorted out at the half with the correct substitutions, and although we didn't realize it at the time, it was game over.

Roberto Martinez ..... Man of the match!

Jimmy Hill
42 Posted 02/02/2014 at 06:06:39
Phil Salmon, sorry but you must be watching someone else. Naismith rarely lets us down. Let's be fair to the guy, he is playing wherever he is asked too. Scores important goals too.
Peter Roberts
43 Posted 02/02/2014 at 09:22:01
Phil Sammon

Not sure I follow. Naismith is not, and never will be, a wide player. He should be played up front like he has done the last 3 games. There he's shown his worth admirably, rather than being a square peg in a round hole. Him playing wide right as akin to asking Robin van Persie to play centre half. So to give him grief for being played out of position by both OFM and OCM is a bit unfair. Same goes for Osman when he was asked for years to play wide right.

Matt Traynor
44 Posted 02/02/2014 at 09:36:01
I don't understand the Naismith hate. As others have pointed out, he's not a wide player. When OFM signed him I thought he'd bring the best out of Jelavic, albeit it might take a bit of time as the lad had come back from 2 serious injuries. Events dictated they never got the chance to show it off, but I think Naismith can play off a front-man, or up front, but not as a lone striker. Although it was a different era he reminds me in some respects of Adrian Heath. It's a question of if, and how, he fits into this team. Heath had the same problem in many respects.
Brent Stephens
45 Posted 02/02/2014 at 09:42:32
The Naismith hate is not surprising as some can't bring themselves to actually acknowledge when somebody they usually slate has a good performance, and are so quick to jump on their mistakes though not the mistakes of their favourites.

While we're on it – that goal we conceded yesterday, that shit Osman again losing possession that leads to us conceding. Ah yes, sorry, it was Ross who lost possession that led to the goal – in that case, let's not slate the guy, everybody makes mistakes, don't they!

Max Wilson
48 Posted 02/02/2014 at 10:55:06
Naismith critics stand up and be counted! I am one for a start. Over the time he's been with us my Toffee mates and I haven't rated much he's done. The criticism has been about not reading situations, poor technical, slowness, sloppy play, and generally we've rated him as Championship standard. His goals at Stevenage looked good, but they were a 3rd rate side.

Yesterday's goal was a great through ball and you would hope any of our players would be on it. It will take a lot more from Naismith before many of us gain faith in him. Sorry. That's what a lot of us think. Me included. It's nothing personal. He looks a nice guy. I'm sure he is.

Shane Corcoran
49 Posted 02/02/2014 at 11:05:55
The threads relating to yesterday's game all seem to have turned into a defence of Naismith against those that don't rate him. So here's my two cents.

What other Premier League game has he performed well in? Fair enough he might not get much of a run in his preferred (?) position but surely basic control and passing should be part of any attack-minded player.

I think if he played at his absolute best in a position he likes then he still would only be a squad player for a team trying to get fourth in the Premier League.

My bet is that towards the end of his contract he'll leave for a relegation battling team. And none of this is disrespectful to the lad. Just how I see it. I sincerely hope he proves me wrong.

Chris James
50 Posted 02/02/2014 at 11:05:44
I've never been in favour of Naismith and I'm no closer to thinking he should be a default starter in normal circumstances, but I do have a certain amount of respect and even a soft spot for him.

Clearly he's not as technically gifted as most of our squad, but he gives his all every match and gets about the pitch, tackling back and offering himself for the ball even when he's playing poorly (something you could never had said about Jelavic for instance and Osman's mobility these days is suspect at best).

Likewise, he most definitely does have an eye for goal given a chance – the finishes at Stevenage and yesterday may have seemed simple, but we don't see too many of our players getting in for the simple finish, we're relying on amazing runs or screaming shots from midfield. Having someone who can just get on the end of a cross or run through to put a ball away from the penalty box is one of the things we've been missing as a team, despite all our great build up play. Maybe Naismith can't be involved in the fancy passing, but if he could be the focal point and get himself in the right place to hit the onion bag, maybe that doesn't matter.

Although he's described as a winger on Wikipedia, he started as a striker and that's the best position I've seen him play for us and he does seem able to snag the odd goal (he's got best goal to game ratio this season with 5 in league and cup from 9 starts (and 11 sub appearances, usually late in random filling positions).

Like I say, he's not going to be first choice to lead the line when everyone's fit, but with Lukaku out for 2-3 more weeks, Traore not yet quite ready, Vellios clearly not up to snuff for either of our recent managers and Mirallas disappointing many on here who've bayed for him to play up front by announcing it's not his best position (and we looked v.poor with him central) then giving Naismith the number 9 role seems like the only sensible option to me.

Phil Sammon
51 Posted 02/02/2014 at 11:10:10
Peter Roberts / Jimmy Hill

He gives 100% and I have always said that aerially he is unbelievable. He probably isn't a wide man, but does playing out there excuse his inability to control a football?

'Him playing wide right as akin to asking Robin van Persie to play centre half.' - errr, no it isn't, it's the same as playing RVP wide right. You don't lose all footballing ability just because you're played slightly out of position.

Naismith has 3 exceptional attributes - work rate, aerial ability and a natural goalscorer. If he could sort out his first touch then hopefully he can excel.

Some of the slack he receives is below the belt, but he is absolutely not above criticism for many poor performances. Likewise, he deserves credit when he plays well.

Chris Leyland
52 Posted 02/02/2014 at 11:22:41
I wouldn't describe yesterday's finish as simple. That is the sort of chance Jelavic would have missed over the past 18 months. Whilst Pienaar deserves credit for the nice pass, Naismith deserves credit for the run and finish.
Dan Brierley
53 Posted 02/02/2014 at 11:30:51
Come on Brent, you know the script. You are not allowed to highlight that Ross dallied in possession, lost the ball which we conceded from. We also cannot mention that he doesn't have a single assist to his name all season. Young Ross has a lot of work to do before he is considered as a consistent player. All the potential is there, but it is far from being delivered yet.

Back to the match, and Jags and Distin managed everything that came at them at the back, but their distribution was slack sometimes. Stones is also another player that has potential, but a long way to go. I think he needs to go out on loan to bridge the gap between his ability and the PL standard. It seems to far ahead of him at the moment. Howard pulled off a crucial save at the end, which saved the three points so hats off to him for staying alert. Baines had his best game for a while, at least effort wise. He seemed really fired up for this match which was a delight to see. Not everything came off for him, but seeing that desire again was important.

Midfield was severely lacking in the first half, Villa sat quite deep and gave us possession, which yet again exposed the limitations of Barry and McCarthy who are unable to do anything productive with the ball. McGeady showed some glimmers of a decent player, but still does not seem physically ready for the PL but at least I have the feeling there might be a player in there. Osman predictably cannot play on the wing, so was ineffective. Why the manager could not see this until the 60 minute mark was beyond me.

Then cue the changes, Pienaar on, Osman back to his normal position and Naismith put up top. Ten minutes later and we are back in the game. I can't say in this case that RM deserves praise, as we should have been set up like this from the start. Hopefully Roberto will now learn that playing Osman on the wing does not work. I would prefer to see Garbutt at LB with Baines out wide than having Osman there who does not have the pace to fulfil that role.

Pienaars pass to put Nais in was magic, and it was also a classy finish also on the outside of the boot. To be fair, Nais played like he plays in every game. Lots of energy, but never going to be a consistent 15 goal a season front man. A good honest player, but only ever going to be a squad player in my eyes.

And Mirallas free kick was an absolute gem, thankfully so as a draw would not have been any good to us. Happy to see the Mancs losing and Spurs dropping two points. Lets hope West Brom do Liverpool, and we can go into the Spurs game with confidence.

Mike Corcoran
54 Posted 02/02/2014 at 11:31:42
I'm taking a guess but Nessi must be averaging a goal every 40mins when played centre forward.....not too shabby. His work rate and team spirit can't be faulted. Still at this time though an impact player.

Sin Miedo is going to mean facing a lot of Bus Parkio in the future, sometimes we are going to have concede possession to create space on the break. Just lacking a little bit of speed and incisiveness to really open up the opposition. We are only half a season into the revolution though and it's pleasing to see us overcome that miners picket line yesterday despite having only one loaner (soon to sign) on display.

Can see Dela staying for another season as he's missed a lot of development with his injury. Really looking forward to what RM can do for the rest of this season and what transpires when/if we get everyone fit for the start of next and hoping he can unearth the next goal machine from somewhere.

Bar the odd glimmer of hope the last 25 years of Bluedom have been pretty shabby. We are now often privileged to be witnessing the sort of play that, as a teenager in the eighties, I expected week in week out for ever.

Colin Glassar
55 Posted 02/02/2014 at 12:05:06
Good post, Mike Corcoran. One of Robbie's biggest tests will be breaking down relegated threatened teams who will be more than happy to get a point against us. The likes of Man City, Man Utd, Arsenal, Chelsea etc will have a go at us and these should be open games but against the bottom teams we are going to have to be patient and the likes of Barkley and Del boy will be crucial in these games.
Brent Stephens
56 Posted 02/02/2014 at 12:24:49
Dan, I'm trying to learn. "NAISayers" beware.
Brian Harrison
57 Posted 02/02/2014 at 12:06:50
I think both players and fans were still carrying a hangover from Tuesday night's game. Obviously they didn't want to be as open as Tuesday and McCarthy played about 3 yards in front of the back four for all the first half. Then, to further compound this, Barkley dropped so deep he was alongside Barry for all the first half, so much so that at one point Mirallas had drifted to the wing leaving the Villa centre backs with no Everton player within 25 yards of them.

But, as he has done on many occasions this season, RM again made the right substitutions: the introduction of Pienaar for Barkley gave us more control and obviously told McCarthy to make more forward runs. Villa were content to defend their lead but as the half went on got deeper and deeper, and it was very much the case of could we break down this 10 man defence.

Although I though it might suit Mirallas to play up front as he had played there for Olympiakos, it just didn't work for him or the team. But the introduction of Naismith really changed things as we had a player who is used to leading the line. I know the lad has come in for criticism but he has never had a chance to play in his proper position, and I thought his finish for the goal was top drawer, even more commendable when you think how little time he had been on the pitch.

I don't think some fans appreciate how hard it is to play wide when you have played most of your career as a striker. I would just remind people that Lineker was a goal machine yet, when he went to Barcelona, Cruyff played him wide right and he struggled from day one till he left Barcelona.

Finally I would just say to our fans have a little bit more faith in the manager and players. Yes, Tuesday was a bad night but you don't go this far into a season only having lost 3 games unless you are a good side. So let's get behind the team and let them and the manager know that one defeat by our neighbours doesn't make us throw in the towel in fighting for a Champions League spot.

Clive Lewis
58 Posted 02/02/2014 at 12:23:59
I think Naismith has found his ideal position, he was dire playing behind the strikers on the right. What a difference Distin makes, we need to replace this guy with equal quality. Good to see better form from Pienaar. Mirallas's free-kick was truly world class, the best this season! McCarthy and Barry good again.

I think that Tuesday was a blip and it was a case of wrong tactics, although it pains me to say so, Osman was missed Tuesday and should have played. When Osman plays well, we are really good; however, the consistency seems to be getting worse.

David Graves
59 Posted 02/02/2014 at 12:29:48
Dan Brierley "Barry....unable to do anything productive with the ball". You right an awful lot about the failings of the team and manager but this has to be one of the most fatuous comments on here. You're a mood hoover and in future I'll just skip over your comments.
Fran Grimes
60 Posted 02/02/2014 at 12:10:24
I'm really amazed at some people's comments saying Martinez should have got a forward in the transfer window, as if you just drop into city centre sports shop, and tailor make your ideal centre forward — cheap, fast, strong, good in the air, and prepared to kiss the badge after his opening day hat trick. Who the fuck fits that description in January? And oh yeah, what colour would you like?

I was there yesterday, the build-up play was pedestrian, but we were playing a dogged team who have made life difficult for us for years at Goodison. We have players such as Coleman, Deulofeu, Lukaku on the way back, we have McGeady & Traore getting fitter, and long term injuries to Gibson, Kone, and Oviedo. We have had our lowest point in midweek, let it be the turning point. A result against Spurs, deal with Swansea, and the season is looking good again. COYB

Brian Waring
61 Posted 02/02/2014 at 12:42:56
Instead of picking holes in everything, why don't we all just enjoy the ride we are on under Martinez and see where it takes us, because for the first time in a long time Martinez has brought the excitement (IMO) back into being an Everton supporter.

Matt Traynor
62 Posted 02/02/2014 at 12:46:41
Brian #364, I also thought Mirallas had played mainly up front at Olympiakos, yet I was surprised in his post-match interview where he said it wasn't his preferred position, and other than the goal, didn't think he'd played particularly well...
Colin Glassar
63 Posted 02/02/2014 at 12:51:54
Absolutely Brian, too many negative nit pickers on here just looking for holes to criticise Martinez.
Kevin Tully
64 Posted 02/02/2014 at 12:57:47
How many great goals have we witnessed this season? If we can get Coleman & Deulofeu back on the pitch next week against Spurs, we are in with a great chance. We are twice the team when confidence levels are high, there was a hangover after that defeat to Liverpool.
Mike Keating
65 Posted 02/02/2014 at 12:20:27
After muttering a sarcastic "here comes our game changer" in response to RM's substitution yesterday, I am pleased to eat humble pie in public today.

If you said a season ago that we would sell Jellybaby within the year and hang on to Naismith, you would have been sectioned. But "cometh the hour, cometh the man"... He has a great attitude, gives 100% and can finish.

I hate to think what his ex-team mate would have done in the same position. Pity the header was straight at their keeper at the end.

Peter Foy
66 Posted 02/02/2014 at 13:07:11
So Dan, basically

Barkley - Has potential but right now he's Shit.
Jags/Distin - Defended great but were still Shit.
Stones - Has potential but right now he's Shit.
Howard - Great game.
Baines - Good, but only effort wise.
Barry/McCarthy - Shit
McGeady - Might be good, but so far is Shit.
Osman - Shit
Martinez - Good substitutions but still Shit.
Naismith - Great goal but still Shit.

And of course, you cannot criticise Ross on ToffeeWeb, which you just did. What a pile of shite.
By the way, Howard was also at fault for the first goal, so he's shit too. That makes the whole team and the manager.
WUM.

Colin Glassar
67 Posted 02/02/2014 at 13:23:23
Brilliant analysis, Peter Foy.
Dan Brierley
68 Posted 02/02/2014 at 16:01:18
David Graves, I can assure I will lose no sleep. It's not the first time I have seen you picking fault with other people's point of view, whilst adding nothing whatsoever yourself to the debate. We have enough sideline snipers on this site as it is.

But it is interesting how different people can view different situations. Peter, you have to learn, like many others, that just because I highlight someones weaknesses, it does not mean that I think they are shit. There is some middle ground somewhere, it does not have to be everything is great, or everything is shit. Distin had a great game defensively, but was poor in his distribution sometimes. Can we not have a detailed view on players performance, does it really have to be 'Great' or 'Shit'?

Linda Morrison
69 Posted 02/02/2014 at 16:41:22
Sometimes I can't believe the comments on this site about or team and the manager, board.

We are 2 points behind Liverpool and 5 in front of Man Utd with the prospect of most of our short-term injuries back for the Spurs game. This has been achieved despite losing most of our first choice players at some point in the season.

The loan players will go back but we have within our own ranks enough players to break that glass ceiling with some new additions in the summer. Barry will get a contract to keep him at the club probably for 2 years due to his age.

Let's be positive as this season we have seen the development of some of our younger players. They are the future for our club. Man Utd lost yesterday despite having 3 players who between them would cost over £100 million just to buy let alone their wages.

The club are right to do what they can to reduce the debt and not try the dodgy dealings that may cost Man City their place in next years Champions League.

I think that some of the comments stem from the wages the players receive and people expect them to be wonder lads all the time. Our players are paid the lower than average wages in the EPL. It is not their fault that that is the going rate for the job.

There is much to be positive about; I think we are lucky to have Martinez and I expect us to reach 70 points or thereabouts.

Our players do a lot for various charities, every year Naismith spends time at a homeless day centre in Liverpool where I worked. They are human after all.

Andrew Hawes
70 Posted 02/02/2014 at 17:03:48
I hope Everton are sending Victor Anichebe a crate of Chang beer tonite?!?
Raymond Fox
71 Posted 02/02/2014 at 17:25:35
Naismith changed the game thanks to the great pass from Pienaar; it takes two to tango to make goals like that.

He seems to be one of the very few, if not the only one, at the club that can time his runs to perfection, he did exactly the same at Stevenage.

The games easy when two players like them combine in that move, RS killed us with similar goals, admittedly with longer passes.

Their impossible to defend against if the two players get the pass and the run correct!

Ron Sear
72 Posted 02/02/2014 at 18:18:59
Fond as some people are of criticising St Roberto and every other Everton player, I can't help thinking the Goodison crowd were up to much either in the first half of that game. Louder everybody, we ain't in Central Library.
Sean Kelly
73 Posted 02/02/2014 at 18:25:13
I've slagged Naismith regularly here but have to give him great credit for his goal yesterday. He can frustrate the knickers off a nun sometimes. He's an honest footballer. He knows he not the most talented player around but he gives his all although admittedly that's not enough most times. But fair play he stepped up yesterday and got us out of a hole

Also thanks to big Vic today. The face on toure was classic. Watched the game Gerard was shite. The only games he performs on is against us and Man U. Falling star me thinks

Harold Matthews
74 Posted 02/02/2014 at 17:55:28
All things considered....and I mean all things considered, we were pretty good yesterday. The first 45 minutes were obviously not up to standard but the way we pulled things together after the break was quite impressive. OK, we can moan about starting with Ossie on the wing and young Stones at RB but Martinez made the right changes at the right time and we collected 3 well deserved points.

Sorry to hear McGeady suffered heavy abuse from frustrated, ignorant fans on his Goodison debut. Judging by Bellamy's remarks arter the Cardiff game, these things are not always easily brushed aside.

Paul Smith
75 Posted 02/02/2014 at 18:27:16
Thought it was a really good and important 3 points yesterday. In the first half I thought we moved the ball to slowly and were too deep. The 2nd half was better and Pienaar definitely made a big difference, the issue I have got is we don't get enough players in the box.

I feel that Ross Barkley needs to add this to his game when he is back fully fit to truly become the world class player we hope he is going to be. In my opinion Ross should be looking to score between 10 and 15 goals a season but doesn't look like doing that at the moment. Also James McCarthy as good as he's been this season needs to push further up the pitch and try and get past the forward otherwise we have to score with a piece of individual brilliance.

These are all minor little details but to push on for the top 4 I feel they would be instrumental in us trying to reach that goal. The top 3 is a step too far for us but 4th is up for grabs with their result today. From now till the end of the season draws are really of not too much use so let's attack and get more players in the box. For me young Gerard should have a bigger part to play when he comes back.

David Graves
76 Posted 02/02/2014 at 19:44:13
Dan Brierley let me remind you of what you said above "Barry – unable to do anything productive with a football". I'm not 'sniping' by picking you up on that, Just pointing out what a completely ridiculous opinion you have of Barry.

I'm sure you won't loose any sleep – I bet bedtime is early the night before school.

James Hughes
77 Posted 02/02/2014 at 19:37:48
Busy weekend due to work... I only just watched highlights. We looked good again; too much huffin' 'n' puffin' again.

My point: Nessie scored AGAIN! I posted my support on here not long after he signed, and got rebuked by many, one of our esteemed editors as well!!

I said "Give him time time and play him in his position and see what happens."

Not world class but a very good player and worthy of our support.

Dan Brierley
78 Posted 02/02/2014 at 19:54:57
David, I said Barry and McCarthy. So please feel free to remind me what I said. I will still stand by it, I did not see them contribute anything productive in the first half when Villa sat back. They seemed to be completely lost when on the ball, and doing their best to try and pass it to someone else as quickly as possible. This is not the first time I have witnessed this, nor is it the first time I have highlighted that we struggle to do any damage through the middle of the park. If you find that a 'ridiculous' assessment, then so be it.

Along with your 'I bet bedtime is early the night before school' comment, you just smack of the stereotypical arrogant old man that thinks he knows everything, and by default the opinion of anybody younger is 'ridiculous'.

David Graves
79 Posted 02/02/2014 at 20:22:48
Hey, Dan, just before you head of for bed, I've done some homework for you. Barry's pass stats (ie, total number, completion, key passes) rank him as good if not better than... wait for it.... Ramsey, Yaya Toure, Ozil, Hazard & Fernandinho.

I could go on but hopefully you get the picture. The info is all out there. You might want to consider it because your subjective opinions are lazy and poorly informed.

Does that "add to the debate" enough for you?

Ian Burns
80 Posted 02/02/2014 at 20:12:53
I would like to make two points:

First, it can't be easy taking on the task of taking a club into the CL, with little to no money being made available but RM is giving it a damned good shot. If he chooses a player to pull on that special blue shirt, then that player gets my full support. I am human so I get frustrated when I know we can do better at times but in the cold light of day I would take a home tie in the FA Cup 5th Round; 5th spot, 2 points behind CL place any time of the day, week, month or year.

Second, great post Linda Morrison - 460 - as always the voice of reason.

David Graves
81 Posted 02/02/2014 at 20:33:34
Dan,
I've made reference to bed time because you said you would not loose sleep. I have no idea how old you are and vice versa.
Dan Brierley
82 Posted 02/02/2014 at 20:39:20
I think we will leave it at that David, and agree to disagree on this one. You label my view as 'ridiculous' and then suggest that Barry is in the same league as Ramsey, Yaya Toure, Ozil, Hazard, Fernandinho.
Jackie Barry
83 Posted 02/02/2014 at 20:47:44
Is there some kind of misunderstanding here? I mean from what I see David didn't actually say Barry was as good as those players he said the stats rank him as good as them if not better. David did not create the stats did he?
David Graves
84 Posted 02/02/2014 at 20:44:02
Ah now, Dan, don't be twisting what I've said. You said Barry does nothing constructive with a football – and it is something that I completely disagree with. I offer the stats as evidence that he does indeed 'construct' – even when compared to the best players in the league.
Phil Sammon
85 Posted 02/02/2014 at 20:52:08
Harold

Where did you hear McGeady received some stick?

I didn't hear anything like that near me. A shame if it happened.

David Graves
86 Posted 02/02/2014 at 20:53:57
I didn't make them up Jackie and thanks for adding clarity. I think Dan and I are in danger of having one of those internet arguments!
Dan Brierley
87 Posted 02/02/2014 at 20:56:42
It depends how you interpret 'constructive'. If you think side to side passing is constructive, then that's where we are not in agreement.

These are the stats from the players you mentioned:

Yaya Toure: 12 goals 4 assists
Mezut Otzil: 4 goals 8 assists
Aaron Ramsey: 8 goals 6 assists
Eden Hazard: 9 goals 5 assists
Fernandinho: 4 goals 5 assists

Gareth Barry: 3 goals 3 assists

I hope thats clear enough.

Passing stats (in my opinion) are not a true reflection of a players ability, you could be top of the passing league just from making two yard passes.

Jackie Barry
88 Posted 02/02/2014 at 21:10:36
Dan, I have seen both Barry and McCarty doing far more than side-to-side passing this season so assumptions that the stats point to this are way off target. A combination of these two has been far more productive than last season in my humble opinion.
David Graves
89 Posted 02/02/2014 at 21:37:48
Dan - read the stats on the more detailed web sites that include key passes, forward passes and passes in the final third. Believe me Barry's stack up. I presume that you have also watched Barry really closely. If you have and don't think that he is a class player then we are never, ever going to agree.
Dan Brierley
90 Posted 02/02/2014 at 21:27:58
So you don't want to discuss the stats anymore Jackie?

Again, I have to disagree I am afraid. I certainly see us as more defensively solid than last season, but I honestly don't see us as more productive yet. Last season between Osman, Fellaini and Gibson (who only managed 22 games), we delivered 21 goals and 12 assists in all comps. Up to now, Barkley, Barry and McCarthy have managed 7 goals and 8 assists. I don't really see what you mean by more constructive Jackie.

Dan Brierley
91 Posted 02/02/2014 at 21:44:52
David, I have been watching Gareth Barry for many years. I have never had him down as a class player, even in his best years at Villa. I personally think that Darron Gibson is a much better passer of the ball, with much better vision. But of course, I consider Barry as the better overall footballer because you have to be on the pitch in order to make a difference.

I am (one of a minority) hoping that Barry does not get a new contract for next season, and we bring in somebody alongside McCarthy who is able to quickly turn defence into attack, a Cabaye/Arteta type player. I see the lack of creativity in the centre a weakness that needs addressing, and I think Osman is well past it in terms of pace and stamina.

Jackie Barry
92 Posted 02/02/2014 at 21:50:42
So the stats show McCarthy and Barry only performing side-to-side passes? I said 'productive', Dan, not 'constructive'. Now you are saying that assists and goals only matter. Once again, I will say that our current midfield is far more convincing to me than last season's, Fellaini scored goals but was frustrating in other areas, in my opinion; Osman started well but before the end tailed off and has not found that form since. Overall, the detailed stats do show Barry in a favourable light... sorry, but they do. I'm done now, work beckons.
Colin Wainwright
93 Posted 02/02/2014 at 21:56:48
Could not disagree more, Dan. You may have been watching Gareth Barry for years but so have some of the best managers in the game.... who have gone on to sign him (or try to). Everything positive that we do on the pitch will invariably be influenced by Gareth Barry. He makes the side tick, sets the tempo. TBH, I had my doubts when he arrived as I thought his best years were way behind him, but he's been a revelation and I certainly hope he's signed up at the end of the season.
James Martin
95 Posted 02/02/2014 at 22:04:27
I agree with Dan sort of. There’s an obvious imbalance in our midfield that is limiting our ability to score. Our attacking options are far greater than last season but we still have the same problem of not being able to batter teams comprehensively. We’re still seeing top quality forwards like Mirallas and Lukaku going games without one meaningful ball being played to them. Add to this we struggle to break down teams who come set to defend: Palace, Liverpool, Villa (needed a worldy), Stoke.

In my case its not get rid of one in favour of the other. I just think they play the same position. For next season I think it should be Barry as first choice DM then a suitable partner with him whether that be Gibson Barkley or ideally some new young Pirlo type to dictate the pace of the game. McCarthy should then progress to take over from Barry and be our defensive mid for the next decade. he’s certainly got the engine, tackling, ball retention and positioning to do it. These things are not that useful though when Barry has already done them for you and you’re being tasked with hitting the right weight of ball at the right angle to start an attack off.

A squad is about having options and combinations. Barkley and Barry would be a first choice one, then McCarthy and Gibson to provide genuine top class cover, balance and of course options from the bench. both pairings match one progressive with one defensive and one fast with one slow. both pairings are physical and can keep the ball.

Obviously the McCarthy-Barry axis has value as we wouldn’t be where we were in the table if it didn’t but surely people can see the penetration we require to consistently beat all types of opposition home and away is just not there in this combination.

Harold Matthews
96 Posted 02/02/2014 at 22:19:32
Phil S. Check John Daley on the "Satisfying win" thread. #409. Quite an upsetting read.
Mark Frere
97 Posted 02/02/2014 at 22:33:26
Dan (547)

I personally would be very disappointed if Barry isn't here next season. You may be correct in thinking the Barry-McCarthy axis isn't a ideal combination for every game. Yes, we could've done with a more creative player in midfield to have broken down a very stubborn Villa defence yesterday.

But I also think they are a perfect combination in a lot of other games. Barry and McCarthy cover for our full backs and allow them to attack without having to worry about their defensive responsibilities. McCarthy's ball retention is excellent and Barry sits in front of the back back 4 giving them protection.

Different games, require different kinds of players. I for one, would just like to have more options in midfield. I think we need a Arteta/Carzorla type player who we can use in games when teams come to Goodison and park the bus.

Gavin McGarvey
99 Posted 02/02/2014 at 22:23:55
Rightly or wrongly the combination of two passing defensive midfielders is a feature of rm's style of play so far. He has decided to try and dominate a part of the park that we generally ceded to the opposition in the past. Like any tactic it has it's strengths and drawbacks, but I can't see it changing anytime soon as it's integral to how we are setting up. Personally I'm in favour of it as it seems to give us more control over games.
Kevin Tully
100 Posted 02/02/2014 at 23:03:38
Posters are assessing this side like they've been together for 5 or 6 seasons, instead of months.

We have brought in half a new starting 11, completely changed our style of play, and I'll take a bet with anyone that we beat our previous best Premier League total of 65 points.

We will see a much more fluent side next season, especially when Martinez brings a few more in suited to his style. What are some posters expecting in his first season?

Patrick Murphy
101 Posted 02/02/2014 at 23:20:15
Forty-five points in the bag, still in with an outside chance of Top4, still in the FA Cup, but oh,,, but we're not really scoring many goals, or we're not really winning enough games, or the strikers aren't scoring, or we look very weak at the back or we are slow and ponderous, we have to wait for ages for a goal or it has to be a worldy by Mirallas or we have too many loan players or the tea at Goodison is too hot, the pies are too small, the seats are too low, the wind is always blowing, the stairs have too many steps and on and on and on and guess who's fault that little lot is? That's right a Spanish bloke who won the FA Cup, but he got Wigan relegated and the Dark Side didn't really want him and he's nowhere near the tactical genius that Buck Rogers is and he smiles too much and he promises things that he can't deliver and well I don't know any other problems that beset the club should be the Spaniards responsibility according to the Goodison Gloom Guys.

We all have opinions on formations and players but I wish some people would use their obvious talents and take a coaching course who knows if they are successful they might have a vacancy to fill at Goodison when RM realises that a fair few supporters didn't want him here and will not be happy until he is plying his trade somewhere else - who knows we might do a swap with our former manager that should make them a little happier.

Jim Knightley
102 Posted 02/02/2014 at 22:28:27
I think our two defensive midfielders give two obvious benefits: they allow our full backs to attack to a greater extent than anyone in the division (bar City perhaps), and obviously strengthen our defense. If we drop one of the them, we damage our defensive capacity, and the license of our full backs to get forward.

I think the creation of chances must come from the attacking midfield players. I like Mirallas alot, but I think his best position is from the left. He has too often failed to create from the right hand side this season. Pienaar has a great relationship with Baines, and demonstrated his ability with the superb assist for Naismith on Saturday, but he too has been a little inconsistent. Barkley has brilliant potential...but he is naive and far too greedy. His runs are fantastic, and he causes all manner of problems, but a different player would create more chances for those around them.

I think that's where we have a weakness. Deulofeu gives us an extra, very important option, as does McGeady now. It will be interesting to see what happens in the attacking midfield positions over the next 3 months.

James Martin
103 Posted 02/02/2014 at 23:38:58
Patrick I used to make the same criticism of Moyes’ midfield selections. Carsley-Neville, Fellaini Rodwell, Neville Rodwell, not a forward pass between the lot of them. Our best football always come from a combination of one defensive one progressive in the deep lying two. Osman and Gibson played well last season whenever paired. Osman Carsley 07/08, Arteta-Neville worked well as well. I’ve rarely seen any top side score a lot of goals with two holding midfielders playing at once. McCarthy either needs to add more to his game or we need a bit of a reshuffle. We won’t concede many with those two (unless we’re playing Liverpool) but we won’t score a shed load either and will rely on midfield goals rather than striker ones. I completley get your point though that this is a side in its infancy and RM has done an incredible job to not only maintain the level we were at but to push us on further without any transition effects. This is just a scruple that I believe the side is lacking at the moment. Who knows we may steam roll everyone in front of us and breeze into fourth but I fear that we may see a couple of draws like the one Villa so nearly was due to not being incisive enough with possession and that for me comes down to the balance of the midfield two.
Harold Matthews
104 Posted 02/02/2014 at 23:42:54
Yes Jim. City fullbacks are encouraged to attack but, unlike us, they bomb the ball over quick before the opposition defence gets organised.
Mike Corcoran
106 Posted 03/02/2014 at 00:29:27
Ffs just give them a little time ...less than half a season for Barry and McCarthy so far.. Everyone wants instant fix. I'm just looking forward to the octopus Traore kicking on
Raymond Fox
107 Posted 03/02/2014 at 00:40:05
I'm with Jim 565 on this one, the onus is on Barkley or someone playing in Barkley's position to create the openings for the forwards.

Jim makes the very good point that having McCarthy and Barry together allows our full backs to advance up field more and know that were not leaving ourselves wide open for the opposition to counter attack.

Of course in a perfect world McCarthy and Barry would have wonderful creative skills as well, but I don't think those sort are very thick on the ground, even in world football!

Patrick Murphy
108 Posted 03/02/2014 at 01:06:44
I know where you're coming from James but Arsenal have scored 10 and Chelsea have scored 6 more than us while Spurs have scored 6 less than us Liverpool and Man City have world-class strikers hence the greater number of goals scored and they are the only two sides that have really scored a great many more goals than the rest of the teams in the Premier League. For a team with no top-class striker we are doing remarkably well. Now if we happen to buy or already have a true striker and continue to struggle for goals then your point then becomes more valid. Don't forget that a lot of people thought we would ship goals this season and I'm pretty sure that Roberto considered that might happen hence the safety tactic of having Barry and McCarthy - but the other reason they were paired together was to allow Barkley to develop, unfortunately he has missed a few games and has lost his rhythm.
Si Cooper
109 Posted 03/02/2014 at 02:20:24
Raymond (570) - creative contributions come in a variety of forms. Sometimes it is as simple as adding your presence to the right attacking opportunity and 'creating' an outlet for a simple pass or the space for another player to exploit. Both Barry and McCarthy have shown they can do this but it simply wasn't happening enough in the first half against a Villa side who weren't committing very much in attack.

I can give a few examples of what I saw as lack of awareness / urgency or a strange reluctance to take reasonable 'risks' in the first half.

On one particular occasion Barkley had possession left of centre mid way in the opposition half, and he headed further left towards Baines who was more advanced and closer to the touchline. Most of our attackers were further forward but either central or to the right, with the Villa defence and midfield in or around their own penalty area. A corridor about 15 yards wide from their area to our halfway line opened up inside of Barkley. McCarthy was stationary near the half way line about two yards from an isolated attacker, but had the two central defenders just behind him. There was zero threat from that attacker at that time and McCarthy could easily have taken it on himself to move into the acres of space in front of him. Barkley saw that Baines was pretty much hemmed in so checked and turned back inside but there was literally no one within twenty yards for him to pass to in that direction, so he checked back to the left touchline and played the ball to Baines who had subsequently strayed offside and the move came to nought. If McCarthy had simply moved twenty yards forward he would have really added to the threat, perhaps taking the ball moving at pace to their area (which he is good at) or drawing a player away from Barkley thus allowing him to drive in towards their area. Maybe this was a direct consequence of the pattern of the derby, but McCarthy seemed unnecessarily inhibited by perceived counter attacking threats on a number of occasions.

McCarthy, as usual, was excellent at getting back and intercepting the ball when they did threaten but, having then passed to a colleague, tended to continue his retreat towards our area and take up very neutral positions which neither offered a useful outlet for the player in possession nor occupied the attention of the nearest Villa players. I would have liked to see him quickly moving into the space behind their players to receive the ball directly or from a quick passing triangle, or at least drawing the Villa players quickly back to the half way line making it more likely we could quickly move the ball forward. Every now and then he could have easily retained possession himself and simply turned defence into a counter attack. He stuck to the safest option multiple times, sometimes ending up in the way of a sideways pass to a more open player and necessitating another backwards pass.

I also don't think he showed for the central ball from a defender as often as he could have, which Gareth Barry did do, and spent an undue amount of time strolling in no-mans land. When Barkley was tackled by Delph, it was at least in part because the lad felt the need to drop right back into our half to get possession of the ball and then drive it forward himself. With the two defensive midfielders and our defence clearly on top Barkley should never have had to come back into our own half, but the ball simply wasn't being moved through the centre anywhere near quickly enough.

This is being hypercritical because Barry and McCarthy did their bread and butter stuff very well indeed, but the psychology definitely wasn't right considering how the game panned out from the start and they passed up opportunities to do extra bits and pieces that are well within their abilities. In my opinion, this is what the manager was talking about after the game, and the positive movement was miles better in the second half.

On a related point, don't you think 70% possession and the fact that the likes of Osman and an unfit McGeady played (near enough) the whole game shows how easy the game was and why our defensive midfielders could possibly have shown more of their attacking tendencies?

Raymond Fox
110 Posted 03/02/2014 at 08:46:18
Si, good post, in fact there's a few very good posts in the thread.

Short reply from me Si, because I have to dash out.

The points you make about being too cautious in the first halve we can probably put down to a reaction to Tuesdays thrashing.

See you later.

Jim Knightley
111 Posted 03/02/2014 at 11:44:27
Si - 'On a related point, don't you think 70% possession and the fact that the likes of Osman and an unfit McGeady played (near enough) the whole game shows how easy the game was and why our defensive midfielders could possibly have shown more of their attacking tendencies?'

We had 70% possession because of the way we played...you can't simply state that because we had 70% possession, one of our dms should have gone forward more, because they are related factors. And I've no idea why Osman playing the whole match means the game was easy? That 70% possession also enabled our come back. It wasnt just simply a case of Naismith and Pienaar coming on, and now we had the tactics right, tearing through Villa at will. It was a case of wearing down Villa by dominating possession, and then bringing the right players on against a tiring team.

There is a reason the top clubs win games at the death, and it's because they dominate matches and wear down the resistance of opposing teams. We played against a Villa side in good form, with a great countering attack threat. We played them with multiple players missing, and after losing a derby by 4 goals...and we beat them. And it amazes me that some on here are complaining.

Brent Stephens
112 Posted 03/02/2014 at 12:11:15
Jim #618 " It was a case of wearing down Villa by dominating possession, and then bringing the right players on against a tiring team."

And that's just the way it was away at Villa this season, Jim. Eventually wore them down, and with a cameo performance or two from the subs.

Brian Harrison
113 Posted 03/02/2014 at 12:05:41
I think a lot of our first half performance was down to what happened on Tuesday night, we have been pretty solid defensively for most of the season. But on Tuesday they got in behind our back four so easily that I think both RM and certainly the players tried to overcompensate that happening against Villa. So McCarthy sat very deep all of the first half, and Barkley also sat deep which severely dented our attacking options.

Second half was completely different McCarthy played at least 10 yards further up the pitch Pienaar gave us more control and when Naismith come on we had someone who took up the positions that a striker should. Too often in the first half Kevin Mirallas wanted to drift out to the wing leaving nobody in the middle.
This was a massive result because if we had carried on playing the way we did in the first half chances are me might have ended up losing or drawing the game, but know we can put the nightmare of Tuesday behind us and the players can now put it down to a blip and not a formation problem.

Jim Knightley
114 Posted 03/02/2014 at 12:23:51
I agree about Mirallas Brian. He often made the wrong runs, and having Naismith there helped us. I'm a fan of Mirallas, but aside from a brilliant goal, he was very poor against Villa. But I suppose that is the mark of a top player; the game changing moment of quality even when performing badly.

Carl Peters
115 Posted 03/02/2014 at 12:32:26
I totally agree, Jim, a player like Mirallas can be having a mere for 89 mins, as Cloughie once said "It only takes a second to change a game." — how true was that on Saturday?

Thinking about the goal he scored, had that been Messi, we would have been getting told how many millions it had put on his value. If he puts a few more in like that this year, I for one will be eternally grateful.

Paul Kelly
116 Posted 04/02/2014 at 04:25:32
I’d just like to add well done to the lads and apologize to RM as I didn’t think we’d do it it after the midweek thumping. Really had my doubts but that result against Villa – superb.

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads

© ToffeeWeb