Alcaraz ruled out for Spurs game

, , 7 February, 111comments  |  Jump to most recent
Updated Antolin Alcaraz has suffered a new blow in his injury-plagued seasonat Everton and has been ruled out of this weekend's trip to Tottenham.

Alcaraz was rushed back from a three-game absence due to muscle fatigue to play in the Merseyside derby last month and after was absent again for the win over Aston Villa last Saturday, a premature report in The Express had claimed he was sidelined for another month.

Roberto Martinez said at his pre-match press conference that the Paraguayan international will be missing from the Spurs game but did not anticipate him being out much longer than that.

Alcaraz has made just four appearances since arriving at Everton on a free transfer in the summer having required a hernia operation at the start of the season.

Meanwhile, the manager was uncertain whether Lacina Traoré would be sufficiently fit to play any part in the vital game at White Hart Lane. The on-loan Monaco striker has recovered from a hamstring strain and is therefore "fully fit from a medical point of view," according to Martinez but is lacking match sharpness.

The same will go for Gerard Deulofeu who has recovered from a severe hamstring injury of his own but has only just returned from his rehabilitation in Barcelona.  



Reader Comments (111)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


James Elworthy
1 Posted 06/02/2014 at 09:28:59
So Alcaraz is now out another month with muscle fatigue. If he was a horse, he would of been put down.

How long of a contract did we give this guy as we are pouring wages down a drain here and would be better spending it on a young up-and-coming centre-back. This is a position we need to strengthen next season purely due to the age of our current pairing not their ability.

We have young Stones who will probably in time be a regular centre back but from what I have seen of Duffy he will be a regular at some club or other but I don't think he is Martinez's type.

Shane Corcoran
2 Posted 06/02/2014 at 09:38:06
Where'd you see that James?

Muscle fatigue, is that tired muscles?

James Elworthy
3 Posted 06/02/2014 at 09:42:21
It is in today's Daily Express and was on the Radio City 8am news.

I'm not sure what muscle fatigue is, I heard from someone that it is his muscle in his groin and it wasting away. However, Everton do not seem to elaborate with any more detail.

I can't see him lasting much longer, he will probably have to prematurely retire, as it sounds like an incurable problem.

Jimmy Sørheim
4 Posted 06/02/2014 at 09:45:07
Everton appear to have stopped elaborating altogether now, and just put these general terms that are too cryptic to understand.

Much better he started being straight about what injuries Alcaraz has, instead of this weak pissing about in general terms."muscle fatigue".

I have found that our medical department and physios stink this season. Probably because Moyes has picked the best away from there too.

David Ellis
5 Posted 06/02/2014 at 10:29:21
James Elworthy 191 - extraordinary extrapolation there. From muscle fatigue to career ending injury. Others have reported that this is a common by-product of his earlier injury he had in November. Yes its not good that he can't stay fit for long, but its all coonected to the original injury (and not a fresh injury). And there is no suggestion that it is career ending (or season ending).
Mike Allison
6 Posted 06/02/2014 at 15:29:18
Get rid. Can't afford passengers on our wage bill.
Paul Olsen
7 Posted 06/02/2014 at 15:34:12
Although looking solid for 3 of his 4 games for us, this is beginning to look more and more like a failed signing.

Alongside Koné, that's 2/3 Wigan signings failed. Jury still out on Robles.

James Elworthy
8 Posted 06/02/2014 at 15:45:33
McCarthy also came from Wigan and has been a resounding success.

Robles has made one mistake and looked solid v Stevenage in a trick encounter.

Koné has not failed – he had an injury recovered and got a worse one.

Alcaraz looked okay in his first couple of games, but if this injury is ongoing then maybe time to release him and look for a younger man.

Anthony Flack
9 Posted 06/02/2014 at 15:49:46
Duffy back or Heitinga back on loan..........
Linda Morrison
10 Posted 06/02/2014 at 15:49:30
James how could he be released as surely he has a contract? It is a shame as when he was with young Stones in defence I thought he did really well.

With regards to Kone his injury, although it has kept him out for the season, is less likely to be a "creaking gate" one that keeps coming back all the time.

I know he is over 30 but I have high hopes for him next year.

Tom Bowers
11 Posted 06/02/2014 at 15:50:18
Well I can think of 2 names to be moved on at the end of the season and Alcaraz is one.
Can't remember when Everton had so many crocks on the books. Gibson is another who seems a permanent crock.
Kone has been no help at all to the squad. Thank God for McCarthy.
James Elworthy
12 Posted 06/02/2014 at 15:59:23
I am not sure if Alcaraz got a one year or two year contract.
Hopefully it is a one year contract so he can be released. If not then we have another crock on the wages bill for a year.
It seems an injury that he cannot shake off.
Gibson is another player who cannot play 3 or 4 games on the trot without getting an injury and at Utd he was the same.
Also we seem to be playing a lot of midweek games since the Xmas break, cannot the schedulers give more midweek games early in the season as the holiday programme followed by FA Cup fixtures has taken its toll on our small squad.
Mike Hughes
13 Posted 06/02/2014 at 15:52:26
Muscle fatigue?

Back in the 80s I ran the Sheffield half marathon one morning then played a full 90 mins footy in the afternoon for the Sheffield Polytechnic Science Department team (+other stories).

In 2008 I ran the full Blackpool Marathon in 2h 58m in the morning then drove to the match, parked near The Mons, grabbed a bag of chips and scoffed them on the way while hobbling to GP and had to somehow make it up to my seat in the Top Balcony for our home match against Villa.

Tut! Kids these days.
Soft as shite with their skinny jeans, earrings, indoor toilets, extra soft bog roll and central heating.

What's the world coming to? They should bring back National Service.
In my day ...... during the war ...... when I was a lad ...... etc etc.

Kevin Rowlands
14 Posted 06/02/2014 at 16:11:18
At this point it seems obvious that we will never be able to rely on him, not buying the muscle fatigue excuse either, never heard of that before to be honest, shame really because he looked really good them first two games.
James Elworthy
15 Posted 06/02/2014 at 16:16:57
The Wiki definition to Muscle Fatigue ( I believe it is his groin were this occurs)
Muscle fatigue, or physical fatigue, is the decline in ability of a muscle to generate force. It can be a result of vigorous exercise but abnormal fatigue may be caused by barriers to or interference with the different stages of muscle contraction. There are two main causes of muscle fatigue. The limitations of a nerve's ability to generate a sustained signal and the reduced ability of calcium (Ca2+) to stimulate contraction.

There you have it as clear as mud.

Andy Mack
16 Posted 06/02/2014 at 16:23:00
Unfortunately, Gibbo and Alcaraz need contracts cancelling, paying these bloke every week to be crocked or almost crocked is silly for our club. Saha style pay as you play at best. Talented but not up to this league any longer having a lean squad is one thing. Move them both on if at all possible.
Linda Morrison
17 Posted 06/02/2014 at 16:29:09
Andy's right. I do not see why employment contracts are any different in football than in other areas of employment.You would hope especially when taking on Gibson with his history there would be some clauses in the contract regarding injury. Gibson's wages are being paid by his country as the injury was sustained in a friendly international.

After all if you are unable to work for months you can not do your job.
When I was a manager we went on a lot of ACAS training and the general rule is that if an employee is missing more than 70% of their allotted work time they are not doing their job.

Give them work targets to achieve in terms of attendance and follow a pattern of warnings
Of course it may be different with footballers due to the contact nature of the sport, but the rule applies to police officers and fire officers who face more arduous tasks than running around a football pitch

Michael O'Brien
18 Posted 06/02/2014 at 16:30:34
What a joke. Get rid. Look at the work some of the clubs did in this transfer window, fulham, Cardiff. To name a few and we are stuck with this load of bollocks, I know unrelated, but it's frustrating when those shit houses are getting good signings and we are challenging for top 4 bringing in a future keeper? When we have so many injuries. Like wtf... Rant over
Peter Laing
19 Posted 06/02/2014 at 16:42:03
With any of these injury prone players I would be adopting the pay as you play mentality. If Aclaraz is earning £20 grand per week for instance I'm sure that his wife and kids (if he has them) would'nt exactly starve on a 25% retainer whilst he recovers.
Denis Richardson
20 Posted 06/02/2014 at 16:54:00
What in the name of fook is 'muscle fatigue'? Only Everton can come up with a new unheard of spin for an injury so as to make it sound less bad. Fact is this guy is going to have missed most of the season come May.

Good news is that he came ona 'free' and most players are covered by injury insurance so hopefully we're not paying him a years wages for sitting in the treatment room. Although I dread to think what the insurance premiums are for him given his injury track record.

To be honest we may as well right him off as a proper squad member, just like Gibson, who also seems to have set up home in the treatment room.

Fingers crossed Distin and Jags can stay fit for the rest of the season with Stones giving them a rest once in a while. Am still a big fan of RM but I don't think Gibson or Alcaraz should feature in the club's long term plans. Both seemt to spend more time in the treatment room than on the pitch.

Linda Morrison
21 Posted 06/02/2014 at 16:59:51
I think Fulham and Cardiff were buying o try to prevent themselves going down.
I think that it must be difficult for clubs as the players all have a medical prior to joining.

Not sure what is covered but surely a player with a history of injuries should only get a short contract?
It is probably a legal minefield. As for play and get paid for each game I think you will only see that when a player has no club and is out of contract

Dave Roberts
22 Posted 06/02/2014 at 16:47:42
Jesus Linda when was the last time you knew an office worker who did in his cruciate ligaments while doing his job? Or a factory worker who suffered a double fracture of his leg in his efforts to secure a result for his employer? What kind of work targets or fucking warnings would you give to Oviedo who is now laid up with a double fracture of the leg he suffered in his services to the club? For God's sake, football is a contact sport in which injuries, some of which are far more serious than any 'normal' worker would ever suffer as a result of his/her employment. Football contracts have to take account of situations like this or we could be telling Oviedo next week, sorry but your not doing your job at the moment so fuck off.

I was a manager too once in local Government and it sounds like you are a manager too in some capacity or other, salivating at the prospect of inflicting additional misery on the sick and the injured. Jesus Christ what is the world coming too? I bet you vote Tory too and your pin-up in Boris.

FFS!

Dave Roberts
23 Posted 06/02/2014 at 17:08:49
Sorry about the typos but that made me fucking fume!
Brian Garside
24 Posted 06/02/2014 at 17:14:11
If he was injured why did Stones not play CH and Hibbo RB? I´m think we should be told!!!
Linda Morrison
25 Posted 06/02/2014 at 17:10:39
Well Dave I think you should have followed the thread. I was following on from other people who were discussing Gibson and Alcatraz. I did not mention any other player including Kone.
You are right football is a contact sport but in the 2 players discussed in this thread there was a long history of injuries. Some players are just like that which is why I think going in for Rodwell is a big mistake.

We have a small squad because we can't afford a big one so having players out puts extra pressure on the rest, some of whom return from injury not fully fit They are the ones I am thinking of trying not to inflict misery on..That was my reckoning rather than the fact we are paying their wages. All EPL clubs have insurance cover for that

As a card carrying member of the Labour Party your last comment made me laugh.

Denis Richardson
26 Posted 06/02/2014 at 17:13:54
Linda - you cannot compare sports conracts to a normal contract. Taking your logic would mean you may as well say that if a soldiar is injured in battle and in the hospital, 'he's not doing his job' and so should get no pay.

Its a contact sport, injuries are expected, hence clubs get insurance to ease the cost of wages for injured players...all those moaning about the wage cost of injured players seem to ignore this point (or don't know about it).

Dave Roberts
27 Posted 06/02/2014 at 17:18:54
If you're a card carrying member of the Labour Party, like me, then try and at least sound like one. Your post read more like something Eric Pickles would spout.
Raymond Fox
28 Posted 06/02/2014 at 17:00:01
Seems obvious to me that's its to do with the original groin injury, why the club don't just say so is silly.
Every one then knows what the situation is!
I have said a couple of times before that groin problems are one of the worst to shake off, so its not looking good.
Its a shame because I like Alcaraz he did well in a couple of games, especially when its seems he wasn't half right.

As far as Kone's concerned the manager cant see into the bloody future can he, at least I don't think so! You don't blame him for Oviado's broken leg as well, do you!

Have you had a look at the PL injury list its a mile long, these lads are playing on the edge a lot of the time, injuries are going to happen.

I think 1 or 2 of you just love to have a pop at Roberto every small chance you get.
Jimmy is 1.

Linda Morrison
29 Posted 06/02/2014 at 17:22:47
O.K Dave point taken. Although I doubt Eric Pickles could string thast many words together!

I think all the stuff about the injuries is just borne out of frustration of doing so well and then it all seemed to be going tits up again!

I doubt any club would really take a chance on a player if they thought they would be out injured. It's just a run of bad luck so let's hope we have had our share for this and next season!

Dick Brady
30 Posted 06/02/2014 at 17:17:31
I'm sorry but Alcaraz is a really bad signing by Roberto. He's played next a paltry number of games and when he has been fit he's been average to awful. Alcaraz was bloody awful the derby humiliation.

People will argue he was a free transfer but we have still been paying him a wage every week. If you guess Alcaraz is on £40,000 a week then times that by however many weeks (25? 26?) Alcaraz has been at Everton and you're looking at a significant amount of money.

My guess is Alcaraz has cost us close to one million pounds in wages. And what have we gotten in return? A couple of average games, a bloody awful derby performance, and plenty of injuries.

And at 31 years old, we can only expect the injuries to get worse for Alcaraz. Still, he's been a better signing than Kone. Our £6 million striker has not even scored a debut goal for Everton.

Roberto has been very hit-and-miss in the transfer market. That's my opinion anyway.

Mike Hughes
31 Posted 06/02/2014 at 17:26:40
Getting a bit political on here.
Is there a General Election due or something?
Jon Withey
32 Posted 06/02/2014 at 17:21:07
If you were a player offered two contracts, one that said you are covered for injury, one not....there is no way you'd risk not getting paid. You can't retrospectively change someone's contract. Everton should have insurance for this, although who would insure such a high risk ?

It is infuriating though. I'd expect all 4 of our long term injuries are on high wages. I used to think pistone was bad enough.

Wayne Smyth
33 Posted 06/02/2014 at 17:19:50
Linda, the idea of cancelling footballers contracts due to injury is bizarre in the extreme....unless its catered for in the contract. Clubs buy players knowing their injury record, they play them knowing they will get injured.

From reading this thread it sounds like he may have been brought back too soon for the Anfield game, which has caused a recurrence. Should he sue Everton for causing him harm by failure to take reasonable care in giving him time to recover properly? Of course not.

Equally a club cancelling a contract because of something they were at least partially responsible for, or because of something that can be expected to happen in the normal course of the job, is equally ridiculous.

As for Alcaraz himself, when he's played he's looked our best defender. Even at Anfield, when the whole team were awful, Alcaraz was least awful out of him and Jags. I do like how calm and composed he is on the ball. Hopefully with Jags, Distin and Stones available, he won't have to get rushed back prematurely.

Harold Matthews
34 Posted 06/02/2014 at 17:36:18
Shame we never got the chance to see this lad fully fit. At his best he was a serious player.

The Kone injury is a different story. The clout to his knee made me wince and we can only hope he makes a full recovery.

Steve Pugh
35 Posted 06/02/2014 at 17:54:20
I would like to point out that you cannot just get rid of an employee if they are prevented from doing their job due to a long term illness or injury. Especially if that injury is work related, like RSI. It is the duty of the employer to try and find alternative employment for said employee within the organisation. Only if no alternative can be found can can you start looking at a termination package, but these can end up costing more than just keeping the person.

Standard practice is to keep finding alternative employment that the employee won't accept until they choose to leave of their own accord, although even this has led to cases of constructive dismissal

Dan Brierley
36 Posted 06/02/2014 at 18:05:12
I fully agree he looks good on the ball Wayne. But the problem is, that he doesn't look like a very good defender which I think is probably a bit more important for a centre half.

And I am amazed that you think he looks our best defender, when before he partnered Jags against Liverpool, we had the joint best defence in the entire PL. The issue in that match was not only fitness, he did not seem to understand the system that Jags was playing. Alcaraz was constantly out of position leaving Jags to cover far too much space. Finally, he looks slower than Osman even when fit.

I think he was a bad signing based on all the above points, and a waste of wages. His fitness at his previous two clubs also speaks for itself.

Colin Glassar
37 Posted 06/02/2014 at 18:28:55
I like Alcaraz, I think he's a top player but, unfortunately, he's injury prone. Not only with us but with Wigan as well. So, as they say on Dragon's Den, I won't be investing this time around. Sorry Al.
Raymond Fox
38 Posted 06/02/2014 at 18:24:28
Dan, I think your out voted on Alcaraz's quality, I too thought he was better than Jag's and Stones in the derby, Baines didn't do much better either.
Our back 4 were taken out of game for at least 2 of the goals by quality though balls and well timed runs, I don't think Usain Bolt would have been fast enough!
Phil Walling
39 Posted 06/02/2014 at 18:47:15
Raymond, your defence of all things Roberto related deserves your anointing as the founder member of RIG. (Roberto is God).

Why can't you accept that like all of his ilk, he occasionally gets things wrong and lumbering us with some ex-Wigan 'no marks' is the one thing about him that is not 'a positive'!

OK, we all rate McCarthy but he did cost a great deal of money .The rest have turned out to be crap.

David Graves
40 Posted 06/02/2014 at 19:01:00
Steve normal work place legislation doesn't apply here - you don't have to find 'alternative employment' for a professional footballer! You can negotiate an early end to their contract or let the contract run out. Alternatively the club can encourage the player to retire through injury then both parties win due to insurance cover.
Tom R Owen
41 Posted 06/02/2014 at 18:56:36
Get rid - cancel contract
Linda Morrison
42 Posted 06/02/2014 at 19:11:36
Tom that may be an option for Alcatraz who is over 30 but I can't see Gibson wanting it
Steve Pugh
43 Posted 06/02/2014 at 19:11:15
David I was responding to Lindas claim that Alcaraz and Gibson should have their contracts terminated because that's what would happen in the real world. Which it isn't.
James Elworthy
44 Posted 06/02/2014 at 19:12:36
Robles is an improvement on Mucha as backup goalie.
Aidan Wade
46 Posted 06/02/2014 at 19:17:53
Glasscaraz
Phil Walling
47 Posted 06/02/2014 at 19:20:38
James that may be your opinion but , take it from me, Robles is 'a dodgy keeper'!
Patrick Murphy
48 Posted 06/02/2014 at 19:26:08
Alka seltzer is more like it - no wonder DM didn't want to talk about injured players. Anyway for the privilege of watching all of these crocks you can find out how much you will pay for next season as the OS has announced it's prices for next season. ST's go on sale from 22nd of this month and the last day of the early bird is mid to late April - just thought I'd let you all know.
James Elworthy
49 Posted 06/02/2014 at 19:25:27
I didn't say he was a great keeper, he may well be dodgy but Mucha was very dodgy and lacked height. Robles had a decent game v Stevenage and I can only recall one real error in his 4 appearances.

He had a great game also in the pre-season match v Real Betis and has something Moyes never achieved for us an FA Cup winners medal.

There are very few clubs who have a decent backup keeper, though a few may of been good in their prime Freidel, Sorensen and Schwarzter.

Brin Williams
50 Posted 06/02/2014 at 19:31:19
I'll tell you this, this muscle fatigue is not to be taken lightly.

I have been suffering from it for a few years now and it really gets the wife down,

I have total sympathy with Alka whatsisname it can get you down.

Not sure what the answer is tho - wife has told me I should stop drinking the bitter and that should cure my brewers droop.

Muscle fatigue my ass!

Oliver Molloy
51 Posted 06/02/2014 at 19:35:16
Linda, is that a fact that Ireland are paying Gibson's wages?
Phil Roberts
52 Posted 06/02/2014 at 19:35:41
I would like to add - that one of the reasons given for Wigan's relegation that Alcaraz was injured for most of the season and therefore they shipped goals.

He only started 8 league games last season and so far 3 league games this. The new Darren Anderton

Barry Thompson
53 Posted 06/02/2014 at 19:42:33
Allegedly it only takes half a pint of bitter to cause fatigue in Brin's muscle
Jim Bennings
54 Posted 06/02/2014 at 19:50:51
Neither Alcaraz or Gibson are likely to be regulars for Everton's first team in the future so I don't know why we bother getting worked up.

Alcaraz was signed on a two year contract, relatively short, as a back up defender but now Stones has emerged quicker than expected we are hardly desperate.

As for Gibson, its hard to see this lad ever being able to cope with the physical demands of the Premier League.
I loved the guy when he first came here but I cant see how his body can keep recovering from long term injuries.
The guy clearly has some problems that are persistently recurring and for somebody of Gibson's age thats worrying.

What I would like to find out is why we cannot get him fixed up.
There is little point in him starting the first few games of next season only to fall down with another three month thigh/knee injury again.

It needs looking at or either we need to find a replacement

Tom R Owen
55 Posted 06/02/2014 at 19:55:08
Linda
Surely if medical opinion is such that it will keep re occurring any player can have a contract cancelled and the insurance company pays out?
Robin Cannon
56 Posted 06/02/2014 at 19:59:02
I think that, assuming we sign Barry on a permanent deal in the close season, Gibson becomes a far more reasonable proposition to keep.

Reliant on him as a regular starter is obviously dangerous given his continued injury problems. But as the immediate backup to Barry/McCarthy then we can manage his fitness more effectively as well as providing more opportunities for midfield rotation.

The Alcaraz one was something of a risk; though it's really only last season that his injury issues came up. Before that he's been clear for near 30 games pretty much every season over the last decade. So it's not unreasonable to have concluded "well, he had a tough time last year, but he's a good player who I'd assume will have less fitness issues this season" when we were signing him.

Steven Telford
57 Posted 06/02/2014 at 20:10:00
The trains are cancelled due to......... you guessed it......... "Leaves on the tracks". And the experts who are looking into it, are perusing a theory that, it just may - just may - be a seasonally related issue.
Raymond Fox
58 Posted 06/02/2014 at 20:04:18
You make a fair point Phil.

I just happen to think that Roberto is a cert. to become a great manager, of course time will tell.
Whether it will be with us, again we will have to wait and see, I sincerely hope so.

I think its so obvious, that I'm surprised that
some people cant see it.
Of course he'll make mistakes, he'd be unique if he didn't.

Your criticising me for being so positive about him, while you it seems to me, irrationally the polar opposite, you manage to find fault with everything that he does.

Your in a very small minority Phil!

Wayne Smyth
59 Posted 06/02/2014 at 20:10:10
Dan you're not going to convince me on the quality of Alcaraz. Based on what I've seen he appears to be at worst a decent defender. If we were dismissing players on the basis of what happened at Anfield then we can get rid of our entire team that played that night.

He may yet turn out to be a complete dud, but even if he's not as good a "defender" as Jags in terms of the basics such as tackling, heading, positioning, he will still not concede a goal like the one at Anfield where Jags got his pass intercepted....and it doesn't matter if its conceded due to losing possession, or getting positioning wrong.

Infact for a team that passes the ball about, a defender who can't pass or stay calm and make the right choices is a big problem. I've also liked the way Alcaraz can bring the ball out of defence. Can't remember the match, but I think he brought the ball quite far into the opposition half. Not bad for a player in one of his first games.

I also don't accept he is slow; in the incident where jags lost the ball at anfield on the half way line, he was about as quick as Jags on the sprint back to the keeper, although neither was close enough to prevent the goal.

Oh and Phil, I think most of us stopped listening to your pearls of wisdom after the "everything from wigan is shit" and "Roberto will get us relegated" nuggets. I actually quite rate Robles. He's been ok when he's played for us. Not many keepers play without the occasional mistake, and even fewer young keepers. I actually thought Mucha was quite good too. Came in, played really well, then Moyes dropped him as soon as Howard was fit again, but at least Robles has time on his side and is cheap.

Steve Guy
60 Posted 06/02/2014 at 20:29:30
I'd sue the medic who passed him fit....clearly made of glass.
Paul Campbell
61 Posted 06/02/2014 at 20:37:06
I think that's where Rodwell could have come in handy if we'd have got him on loan as centre half. When he was with us, people were saying he could easily slot into defence... He couldn't be any worse than Alcaraz!!
Anthony Lamb
62 Posted 06/02/2014 at 19:16:20
Like much else regarding "professional" football today everything is "inflated" by the so-called profession. We have the spin that the demands of football are so intense, so demanding, that we cannot expect a 20 year old young man, whose only job in life is to be fit and play a game of football once a week (sometimes rarely twice a week) and to do so "without being in need of a rest". I have seen this quoted quite often recently regarding Lukaku.

Now we have the situation regarding Alcaraz and the situation regarding Gibson. When a player is about to join a club we hear that they are to have a medical etc. We are led to believe that this is a stringent, exhaustive exercise etc as the financial stakes are so high etc, and then as in this case, in a matter of days we have someone who apparently has a seriously debilitating ailment namely "muscle fatigue". Now I would think that muscles seem to be a significant element of an athlete's ability to do his job and as such should comprise a major element of the said medical. However, perhaps this condition develops quite suddenly and thus is undetectable at the medical. Be that as it may is still raises the question as to just how stringent these things actually are. A similar predicament applies to Gibson whose history shows that seemingly he is simply physically not up to the demands of a professional footballer and should be moved on asap.

It may well be the same with Alcaraz and so, obviously within the terms of employment law, the club should endeavour to move both these highly paid employees on as quickly as possible for as things stand at present it seems they are not "fit for purpose". After all, if a fireman suddenly shows a fear of heights or is left bereft at the sight of fire he would certainly be defined as 'unfit for the purpose for which he was employed" and moved elsewhere.

Robin Cannon
63 Posted 06/02/2014 at 20:48:27
@Anthony (337) - The tiredness thing is not spin. And I really wish people would stop going on about how it's somehow unbelievable.

The issue is not that they are exhausted in comparison to a regular person, but that for athletes at the peak of physical condition can see significant drop offs in performance based on over training; relative to other athletes of a similar level.

It's why peak condition athletes in all disciplines make sure to get significant rest periods, especially immediately prior to competition.

It's completely valid to suggest that a player who's just played three games in a week would benefit from a rest, and would see a significant increase in performance for having that rest.

Patrick Murphy
64 Posted 06/02/2014 at 20:52:30
I'm not a horse-racing expert but I think it is true to say that highly trained horses are suceptible to more inuries than those who don't train so hard. So it's not just a case of a bloke running around for 90 mins twice a week but a player being at peak fitness who will on occasion pick up injuries. Perhaps somebody who has more knowledge on this subject can enlighten us all.

Adrian Heath was out of the team for ages due to a bad injury. Andy Gray also had fitness problems as have a whole host of former Everton players. In 1963-64 one of the reasons that Everton failed to make a proper fist of retaining the title was due in no small part to a raft of injuries during the early part of the season. It is just the luck of the draw, sometimes you can go through a whole campaign without any major injury problems sometimes a club can suffer an insurmountable number of injuries. I don't know whether there is a website devoted to Injuries and which players for Premier League sides have missed a significant part of the season due to injury. But I bet there are more players unavailabe at other clubs then most of us think.

Robert Collins
65 Posted 06/02/2014 at 21:02:28
"Muscle Fatigue"

Is that a euphemism for "Old Age"?

Has it caught up with him quicker than he and the club thought it would?

I like him and think he's very good player, an asset when he does play.

It's sad if "Muscle Fatigue" really does mean "Old Age".

David Graves
66 Posted 06/02/2014 at 21:12:01
O.K. sorry Steve.
Wayne Smyth
67 Posted 06/02/2014 at 20:55:04
Robin, it annoys me too.

In football, like most professional sports you win or lose based on the smallest of margins. Clubs spend fortunes on nutrition, fitness facilities, recovery, data gathering and analysis not because they're looking for a way to spend the cash burning a hole in their pocket, but because they're working on getting every last ounce of performance from their players for the full 90 minutes.

When a player has lost that 5 or 10% they make mistakes. When 3 or 4 players lack that sharpness we end up with the result and performance at Anfield.

I think fitness and professionalism have moved on a great deal in the last 30 years since the money started coming into football and players started costing so much. Clubs have got serious about how they prepare players for games.

Spragg Johnson
68 Posted 06/02/2014 at 21:12:43
Hard to disagree that if and when Gibson, Alcaraz and Kone have their contracts reviewed then some kind of 'paid if you play' arrangement should be put in place. A cumulative total of ten matches per season from three highly paid players is hardly what a club with limited funds needs. Loans make more sense than crocks.
Jim Bennings
69 Posted 06/02/2014 at 21:21:52
I am not sure Kone falls into the crock category just yet.

He sustained a long term injury in October but last season played most games and was as fit as a fiddle unlike Alcaraz and Gibson who do have quite a disturbing recent past, much in the same way that Rodwell and James Vaughan had.

I don't know what the reason is because I am not physiotherapist nor doctor but I can see when something is staring me in the face and that is certain players suffer more injuries than others. Luis Suarez does not suffer the injuries Gibson suffers with for example.

I worry about Darron Gibson I really do, I am concerned that if this lad doesn't shake off these injuries that have dogged him over the last few years he could end up retired before he reaches 30.

The rumours that I heard about Gibson not being able to strike a ball with any power for fear of aggravating his injury are a major concern, I don't know how true those rumours were but if true then that surely cant be right on the lad's playing ability, you are only getting half a player if that's the case.

Kieran Fitzgerald
70 Posted 06/02/2014 at 21:29:21
I think that clubs can be their own worst enemies when it comes to treating injured players. I remember us giving Lescott pain killing injuries for his knee and then playing him. This made absolutely no sense to me at the time as it surely just going to make the problem worse in the long run.

With someone like Gibson, I wouldn't let him anywhere near the first eleven this season. Don't rush him back if we don't have to. Let him recover fully without the pressure of having to play games and be match fit. Bring him back for pre season a week or two early in June instead of July and then have him ready for August. He is still only in his mid twenties, give him a chance to heal fully and properly and we may yet get several good seasons out of him.

Dick Fearon
71 Posted 06/02/2014 at 21:00:04
It seems some will never learn, after four years of carrying a 40,000 pound per week alcoholic who in his own words was a drug using philandering sick note, a total phoney known as AvdM.

Up to the day his contract was finally up and we could get rid of the no good bastard there was lots of TW bleeding heart posters still making excuses for him. It was obviously a forlorn hope that we learned something from that debacle but obviously not.

We now have three sick notes on perpetual sick parade. I shudder to think how much wages per game they are costing. One of them injures himself just by striking a ball, another has a mysterious muscle fatigue, could it be caused by hauling his wage packet to the bank.

Due to his religious duties, the third was never fully fit from the start of the campaign. Yet once again these pages witness a re run of the same old sob stories.

Mike Hughes
72 Posted 06/02/2014 at 21:46:57
Exactly how did Kone get injured and what is the injury?
There are so many injuries at EFC that it's difficult to keep up.
Robin Cannon
73 Posted 06/02/2014 at 22:00:00
Kone had dislodged cartilage in his knee and needed to get an operation.

He's played in excess of 30 league games the last two seasons, so it's not like we were buying a constant crock in the first place.

Michael Polley
74 Posted 06/02/2014 at 22:09:06
Looks like the type of player who is always going to be prone to injuries. We will need to sort out cover during the summer.

I can see Alcaraz only making a handful of appearances even next season.

Shane Corcoran
75 Posted 06/02/2014 at 22:17:03
Dick, whatever about Gibson's previous injuries, the current one wasn't from kicking the ball.

I imagine Moyes thought Gibson worthy of the risk given the low price tag.

I'm not sure how Kone could be seen as on perpetual sick leave as he's only had one injury since he arrived.

Your point isn't unreasonable but it's buried in unnecessary drama.

Frankie Brooks
77 Posted 06/02/2014 at 22:26:41
Medicals for transfers are not that robust. The medic just highlights issues and the decision to sign rests mainly with the manager at the end of the day. Often the medic can advise whether they should be signed etc.

Gibson's current injury is an ACL tear which is a completely different kettle of fish to his previous ones.

Kobe as I understand it has had some form of joint cartilage surgery which is different from the usual meniscus surgery.

Dick Fearon
78 Posted 06/02/2014 at 22:28:04
Mike, Robin and Shane, it is possible that lack of a full pre season contributed toward Kone's injury, it certainly would not have helped. As for being a perpetual sick note what do you call his continuous injury treatment.

Gibson as with the afformentioned AvDM seems to have differing reasons for his injuries. I may have missed some of them but thigh strain due to kicking a ball was named as one of them.

Don't get me wrong, it was not my intention to castigate those players who quite possibly have legitimate reasons for their incapacity.
The AvdM experience still lingers and I am not nor ever will be completely sympathetic in such cases.

Kevin Rowlands
79 Posted 06/02/2014 at 23:21:20
This situation with Alcaraz and Gibson is the exact same reason we should steer well clear of Jack Rodwell, for whatever reason some pro's spend practically their whole career injured (see ickle Mikey Owen) Rodwell definitely falls into that category, no thanks.
Gaute Lie
80 Posted 06/02/2014 at 23:38:48
I thought Everton had some sort of medical insurance, that would pay parts of their salaries in case of injuroes like these. Or is it just in Football Manager?
Robin Cannon
81 Posted 06/02/2014 at 23:54:07
@Dick - In terms of his time here, yes; perpetual sick note.

I think the implication in a lot of posts was that we signed him as a perpetual sick note; and given his solid appearance record over the last couple of years, that wasn't the case. i.e. In this particularly situation, his long term injury is unfortunate, but not really based on the club carelessly signing a previously injury prone player.

Patrick Murphy
82 Posted 07/02/2014 at 00:18:49
This made me smile on the BBC ceefax gossip column. Arsene Wenger speaking about the failure to land ratboy last summer says 'The Gunners will not make another bit for the striker in the summer" obviously a mis-print or a Freudian slip?
Graham Mockford
83 Posted 06/02/2014 at 23:19:37
Mike Hughes

What years did you play for Sheffield Poly?

Anto Byrne
84 Posted 07/02/2014 at 03:32:37
We have a class defender on the books for the next few seasons. Put him in rehab with Koné, Gibson & Oviedo and next season it will be like four new signings.

Tony Hibbert is just coming back after almost a year on the sidelines... I don't hear any rumblings to get rid. I would like to see some more kids introduced in the last few games. I'm not sure why we have Vellios and Gueye burning a hole in the wages bill if they're not going to get on the pitch. Duffy looked more than capable when he was given a chance.

David Ellis
85 Posted 07/02/2014 at 05:14:58
I am constantly amazed by the blinkered knee jerk reaction of so many on here. Everton do not have a bad record of injuries. Look at the injury league tables on the web, we are doing fine. It's normal.

Alcaraz was not a sick note, nor was Kone. Alcaraz had a bad injury last season, and unfortunately another one at the beginning of this season after we bought him. Even then he played a vital role in the period when both our first choice CBs were injured. When fully fit he may well be first choice for a few years. Not a waste of money, at least not yet.

This talk of changing players contacts is so uncommercial. Once signed you cannot change it without the player's consent. If you try and hire all players on a pay as you play basis you won't attact good players. We expect loyalty from players, we should at least honour our contracts rather than yelling "get rid".

And the idea that political reds have a monopoly on compassion is also absurd.

Mike Hughes
86 Posted 07/02/2014 at 08:38:08
Robin #354 - thanks

Graham #379 - I was at Sheffield Poly 84-88 but it was a sandwich course so I was also away in London and Widnes on 6-month work assignments during that time. As stated, I played for the Science Dept team from time to time and not the official Polytechnic side.

Max Wilson
87 Posted 07/02/2014 at 09:24:38
Sorry to appear unsympathetic but I agree with Kev Rowland. You do get injury prone players and they are a financial drag upon their clubs. It is a hard physical game and I suspect their doctors advise them after a while that they are likely to pick up further problems if they continue. They always seem to continue unless it is really impossible. This must be partly due to thier remuneration on contract.
Graham Mockford
88 Posted 07/02/2014 at 09:51:45
Mike Hughes,

I think we played in the same side. We have may have even been in the same car on the trip from Sheffield to the Bayern Munich game at Goodison in 85.

James Elworthy
89 Posted 07/02/2014 at 10:15:39
I am wondering who is the biggest sick note of the past 10 or so years:

Darren Anderton
Chris Kirkland
Michael Owen
Kieron Dyer
Jack Rodwell
Glen Johnson
Daniel Agger

These are names that spring to my mind; I am sure there are many others. I think I will plump for Dyer as the worst.

Dick Fearon
90 Posted 07/02/2014 at 10:22:05
Surely our very own Andy van der Drunk would be up there with the best/worst of them. So too would Harry Kewell during his Liverpool career er' holiday.
James Elworthy
91 Posted 07/02/2014 at 10:34:26
Yes how could I have forgotten AvdM (easily I guess).

Harry Kewell yes a good one

James Elworthy
92 Posted 07/02/2014 at 10:35:25
Jamie Redknapp another one I just thougth of.

Sam Higgins
93 Posted 07/02/2014 at 10:33:17
Jonathan Woodgate.
Matt Traynor
94 Posted 07/02/2014 at 10:42:19
James, another candidate for Everton would surely be Slaven Bilic. Great start to his career, then a mysterious pelvic injury that ruled him out of an entire season (still collecting his massive wages) but he recovered in time to get his country to the World Cup Semi-Final in 1998 – ruling Laurent Blanc out of the final after a pathetic dive in the semi-final – only to return to us the following season and "break down".

West Ham really sold us some pups down the years!

James Elworthy
95 Posted 07/02/2014 at 10:49:02
Yes, Woodgate is a classic.

Bilic, that is true, was not a popular player at Goodison.

Changing sports: Andrew Flintoff — he was always injured, he can never do any of the challenges in League of Their Own.

Jim Harrison
96 Posted 07/02/2014 at 10:40:51
Owen Hargreaves.

Regarding the main gist of the thread, of the players mentioned, I think Alcaraz is the most worrying. Kone will only ever be a back-up striker, Gibson had been doing okay; perhaps now Barry is here he will be given a good chance to get fully fit.

The Rock seems to be in a bit of a rut though. He gets fit, then he gets injured, and not just re-occurrences of old injuries. I think he will prove handy as a low-cost back-up for a season or so, but the longer-term plan has to be getting in another young player to partner Stones.

Left-back is well covered when Oviedo gets back, Hibbert will need replacing soon enough but Coleman has years in him. Jags and particularly Distin are getting closer to the end of their careers than the beginning but still look steady, that leaves Alcaraz to fill the gaps, and he ain't getting younger.

Tony J Williams
98 Posted 07/02/2014 at 12:39:04
It's not as if we didn't have any warning. He just about made double figures last season and managed only 25 the year before.

The exact definition of a sick note: since the start of the 2011 season, he has managed 38 league games.

Strange purchase (part of the Wigan buy-off for us taking Martinez?)

Mike Hughes
99 Posted 07/02/2014 at 13:06:46
Graham #402

No, I came home and stayed at my parents' house in Walton for the Bayern Munich match. Small world though.

I bought my first house in Sheffield (Beighton) as my girlfriend / mates were there. I lived in some dodgy places as a student – a bedsit in Broomhall, an attic in Crookes and a shared house in Pitsmoor. The quality of the accommodation was terrible and I don't think they'd be accepted by today's standards.

I can't say I miss the place but I enjoyed my time there. Also, I was in the Sheffield University bar the night we won the ECWC as they had the match on a big screen. It was a great atmosphere and all the neutrals were cheering us on.

I did get to see the whole of our 5-0 win away to Sheffield Wednesday in the FA Cup. Many of the EFC fans only got in at half time when we were already 5 goals to the good as there were delays on the motorway.

Daniel Lawrence
100 Posted 07/02/2014 at 14:21:10
Regarding Gibson, I'm assuming that the Irish FA are picking up his salary as he was injured on International duty?
Karl Graham
102 Posted 07/02/2014 at 15:40:42
Alcaraz and Distin are both unfortunately unable to play two games in a week so we are either gonna have to promote Stones or Duffy to partner Jagielka or bring someone new in. If we bring someone new in he clearly doesn't rate Duffy and so I'd sell him and possibly move Alcaraz on as well.
Shane Corcoran
103 Posted 07/02/2014 at 15:54:19
Daniel, I'd assume you're wrong.
Phil Smith
104 Posted 07/02/2014 at 15:55:41
Surly Marco Negri should be in the 'Sick Note 11'. Remember him at Rangers? 1 season scoring 40+ goals and then...
Col Wills
105 Posted 07/02/2014 at 15:57:19
The Irish FA will be picking up Gibson's wages, Shane, I'm fairly sure of that.
Tom Bowers
106 Posted 07/02/2014 at 16:00:13
The best defender I ever saw who was plagued by injuries was Kevin Beattie. His constant injuries allowed a certain E Hughes to grab more England caps than he deserved at left back. RIP.
Eric Myles
107 Posted 07/02/2014 at 16:01:38
How can he be 'ruled out' if he was never considered a serious starter in the first place?
Harold Matthews
108 Posted 07/02/2014 at 16:38:16
This is beginning to sound like a teenage thread.
Karl Graham
109 Posted 07/02/2014 at 17:01:39
Danny Williamson was probably the worst sick note we've had although honourable mentions to Slaven Bilic, Terry Phelan, Duncan Ferguson, Alessandro Pistone and Gary Naysmith.
Linda Morrison
110 Posted 07/02/2014 at 17:00:34
Don't know on what basis Karl makes his assertion that Alcaraz and Distin cannot play two games in a week. Until his injury recently, Distin certainly has and as for Alcaraz, we don't know as he has been injured.

The Irish FA are picking up Gibson's wages as he was injured on International Duty, I remember reading it in the paper. I remember Paul McGrath, fantastic player but his knees were shot. He only played games as he could not risk injuries training as well. That was however some time ago and I doubt we would be able to do it now as the game is so much faster.

I think with the likes of Gibson and Alcaraz, the manager will have worked out a method to use their skills in a game without too much risk.

As for Koné, I fully expect him back firing goals next season without any long term effect from his injury. He was just unlucky. With our long term injuries back and some permanent signings, next year will be good.

I see as usual Lawro has predicted us to lose on Sunday. Nothing new there then.

.

Karl Graham
111 Posted 07/02/2014 at 17:28:14
The reason I say this is he had no problems until he played games in a short space and he picked up an injury. It happens to all older players look at Giggs they use him sparingly. Also when Dave Watson was coming towards the end of his career by his own admission he could only manage one game a week.
Linda Morrison
112 Posted 07/02/2014 at 17:32:39
True Karl but I think both players were sent back into the team before they were 100% fit and as you say older players can't get away with carrying a knock like the younger ones can.

Going off the current topic and I know it is a long time since I last saw Hibbert but has something happened to the colour of his hair?

Karl Graham
113 Posted 07/02/2014 at 17:38:27
I agree Alcaraz was sent back in too soon but he must have said he was ready as we could have Stones CB and Hibbert RB.

In what way were you thinking it was different? I thought there was less!

Andrew McGuffog
114 Posted 07/02/2014 at 17:43:51
Back in the 60s, Everton signed a real malingerer. Early in every season he would be sidelined with, of all things, blistered feet. Why the hell we persevered with a so-called footballer who was not able to wear football boots for weeks on end, I'll never understand. He should never have been bought, and should certainly have been chucked out of the club as soon as his pathetic problem became apparent.

His name was Alex Young.

Anthony Lamb
115 Posted 08/02/2014 at 20:07:15
Robin (338), thanks for the comments, however I remain convinced that in fact it is professional spin to trot out this tiredness excuse. I was not of course equating professional footballers with a regular person but simply against the standards of fitness one should expect from professional footballers in order to do their job which after all is simply to play football and not conduct eight hours brain surgery!
I am not sure what "significant rest periods we can actually grant pro footballers - or what "over-training" they do -have you seen some of the the weekly schedules of these guys? Of course if you play three games in a week it is likely to be far more demanding than playing one game - but is that not what being a professional footballer is all about enjoying as they do every added support facility that should be enabling them to do so (within reason). If we apply the criteria of three games meaning a follow-up rest period then does that not imply it applies to all of them? Problem! I also think we should not be sucked into the inflationary unjustified language surrounding much professional football hype eg "peak condition athletes" - I am not sure Grant Holt equates with Mo Farrow! Anyway thanks for the comments and let's hope our super-fit blues get a result at Tottenham!

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads