Everton prevail to knock out Swansea

, 16 February, 53comments  |  Jump to most recent
Everton 3 - 1 Swansea City
Everton booked passage to the quarter finals of the FA Cup for the third successive season but they had a couple of lapses from Swansea City to thank for turning the tie their way.

Lacina Traoré made his debut for the Blues and took less than four minutes to mark his first game with a goal, flicking home from close range following determined work from Sylvain Distin from a Leighton Baines free kick.

Swansea, who had spurned a gilt-edged chance to score even earlier when Vasquez was put clean through but he allowed himself to be forced wide by Joel Robles, never looked out of the tie while Everton were allowing them so much space and Garry Monk's side were level just 11 minutes later.

Taylor's cross from the left just eluded Distin and Jonathan de Guzman stole in front of Baines to power a header past Robles.

The home side remained the more dangerous of the two as the first half wore on, though, and Steven Pienaar almost capped a wonderful move with an equally good goal but his shot came off the woodwork.

Kevin Mirallas, meanwhile, should have done better with Seamus Coleman's precise cross but fired wide of the far post and also saw Gerhard Tremmel push away a 20-yard free kick.

Everton appeared curiously lacking in killer instinct in the second half and the increasing apprehension in the home crowd wasn't eased when Pienaar planted a free header wide of the back post off another well-placed Coleman centre.

A minute later, though, they were gifted a goal and the momentum from which to win the game. An ill-advised back-pass by Neil Taylor was pounced on by substitute Steven Naismith and the Scot slid the ball past the on-rushing 'keeper and inside the far post to notch his fourth goal in five games.

And the Scot was involved again seven minutes later when he was tripped by Ashley Richards in the visitors' area giving referee Kevin Friend no option but to award a penalty and Baines expertly converted to make it 3-1 and effectively put the game to bed.

Swansea's fire had been well and truly put out by this point and the fact that Naismith had to go off for the last few minutes with suspected concussion following a collision leaving Everton to finish the contest with 10 men proved academic.

The Blues were paired with Arsenal or Liverpool in the draw for the sixth round after the match, with a date at The Emirates confirmed when the Gunners beat the reds 2-1 in the later afternoon game in London.

Full Coverage: ToffeeWeb Match Reports



Reader Comments (53)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Brian Harrison
1 Posted 16/02/2014 at 19:47:38
Thankfully the FA Cup is all about the result and it doesn't matter how you get through, because in the first half our performance was pretty average. Yes Traore scored on his debut, but did little else although you could possibly make an excuse being his first game for a new club. Barkley cant use that excuse he again frustrates yes you can see he has potential but makes far too many errors and if he is to hope to be selected in future starting line ups then he needs to eradicate silly errors. But the most disappointing thing for me is his lack of effort when he loses possession, a few times today he lost the ball and made no attempt to win it back.

When RM made his substitutions there was a marked difference, the much maligned Naismith led the line well, pouncing on a bad back pass to score, then being brought down for a penalty for Baines to kill the tie. I hope he is able to start against Chelsea, as apart from Lukaku who is ineligible he is the only natural leader of the line. I also though Osman played well and links up well with Baines and Pienaar. We seem to be getting into a habit of starting games slowly are passing in the first half was pedestrian.

Declan Brown
2 Posted 16/02/2014 at 20:06:18
Well done, Naismith, he won us the game – a game we were poor and pedestrian in most of the time. Is it our fitness levels that are sagging now?

Anyways, again, well done, Naismith, I hope he's okay, but I nearly wet myself laughing when he said to Roberto on his way off "I don't know what I'm doing". ToffeeWeb would have a field day with that.

Glad we've got the Arsenal next, Liverpool would have destroyed us again if we played them like we played today. Our passing is too slow for the pace we have in the team.

Wayne Smyth
3 Posted 16/02/2014 at 20:02:53
Brian, for a forward player I think Barkley does enough to stay in the squad. You show me a forward player(20 year old or not) who doesn't give the ball away or plays the wrong ball, and I'll show you a player who gives nothing offensively to the team.

Don't forget this is his first season and he's still recovering from his toe injury and playing alongside a forward who is playing his first game for the club.

Would be great for him to work harder, but he's not alone in our squad in that respect.

Frank Duffy
4 Posted 16/02/2014 at 20:17:42
I agree, we looked slow and off the pace except for a few times. We need to go at teams and unsettle them. Today, Swansea did that in the first half but visibly tired as the game went on.

I thought Jack our Centre Back had a poor game, which had an effect on the players around him. Though we improved in the second half especially when Naismith came on – and, to top it, the Reds lost.

Not a bad day.

Jim Bennings
5 Posted 16/02/2014 at 20:08:34
I too hope Naismith starts at Chelsea.

I am aware we can make a case for him coming off the bench again and being a very good impact sub but away from home at a place like Chelsea you are looking for your striker to give John Terry and Gary Cahill a hard time and I am not so sure Traore is liable to fall into that category yet.

Martinez could be close to the truth when he says Traore will be a player for the last 9 games or so.
Naismith will battle for the ball and give the lad credit, he wins his fair share in the air too.

I was actually a bit disappointed that Traore, being the height he is, didnt win a few more headers, seemed a bit like Fellaini in that way, didnt ever get off the ground to jump, thats not going to cut it away to Chelsea when we will be looking to our lone front man to be big and strong and hold the ball up.

The Cup draw is a miserable one but we have to be positive and I am sure Martinez will be, he will be ramming home to the players positive thoughts I expect also.

We went to the Emirates before Christmas, four days after our Old Trafford victory and somehow you just knew that afternoon in London we would not leave empty handed, we were at the peak of our powers and riding the crest of a wave.

The reality at the moment is we are looking a tired team that no longer bosses possession like we did say two months ago, the opposition now seems to have worked out the secret, and that is harrying us high up the pitch, we look easy to stifle at the minute, although we managed to get the win today, think that mistake from their defender on Naismith’s goal really couldnt have come at a better time.

The substitutions worked well today but we cant be relying on subs to save us so often.
The start was poor at home to Villa, it was poor at Anfield and last week at Spurs when we did start well we didnt score, then it was also a poor display right throughout at the Hawthorns.

Results are all important but its not coincidence that with more slackening performances in the future, wins are going to be harder to achieve.

Another game next at Chelsea where we need to pick up a point at least but really, most fans eyes are going to be focused on the FA Cup now in three weeks time.

Could this finally be our year?

Mark Frere
6 Posted 16/02/2014 at 20:26:49
There were some really poor performances out there today. Mirallas needs to be taken to one side and told in no uncertain terms that football is a team game. The lad is blessed with immense ability but he needs to pass the ball at the end of one of his dazzling runs. Martinez is spoilt for choice as far as wingers are concerned, so if Mirallas is not willing to be a team player he should be dropped.

McCarthy really was lacklustre today, he was lethargic, didn't show for the ball and looked a shadow of the player we got used to seeing last year. Perhaps he's tired, I don't know, but if he can't offer that 'tiger' like ball retention then I'm afraid its pointless having him in the team.... he's never offered much creative wise.

We have definitely found Naismith's best position, he should be given a sustained run in the team as a striker. Lukaku was fading before he got injured and I was less than impressed by Traore. Naismith has earned his chance IMO.

Delighted with the result but disappointed with the display and the Quarter-Final draw.

Paul Thompson
7 Posted 16/02/2014 at 20:20:46
(With reference to the previous thread) some people can't see beyond their own preferences. The usual suspects bashed their usual targets (Pienaar, Osman etc). It seems unarguable that we played better when Naismith and Osman came on. That's not to say that they will always bet better choices to play, but they certainly were this time. Barkley was probably our biggest threat in the first half, but faded in the second, showing his usual weaknesses of poor decision-making and losing the ball in dangerous positions. Yes, I'll get the usual 'FFS he's only 20' comments, but I'm just describing how I thought he played, not his potential. There is a basic was/is confusion in a number of comments. If a poster says someone was poor, that is often taken to mean he is poor. I really like Barkley and think he will become a great player, but it's no accident how early Martinez often subs him.
Brian Harrison
8 Posted 16/02/2014 at 20:26:27
Wayne

I agree that young players often pick the wrong option, but you should at least learn from your mistakes. Barkley lost the ball in unnecessarily in midfield against Villa and they scored from his mistake. Then against Spurs a week later he loses the ball in his own half which results in Defoe clear through on goal.

Just to be clear the boy has bags of potential but at this moment that's all it is and he may need to be used more sparingly than at present. He isn't having much of an impact at present in games like he did at the start of the season. So obviously keep him in the squad but maybe its a little early to start him so often, and it doesnt matter how talented you are there is no excuse for not trying to win the ball back once you have lost it.

Paul Corbett
9 Posted 16/02/2014 at 20:51:20
Love this quote from Martinez on Naismith:

He said: "Steven took a knock and had delayed concussion. He felt fine initially and was then dizzy. He couldn't remember that he scored – so I told him he scored from 40 yards."

Sam Hoare
10 Posted 16/02/2014 at 20:44:32
We all want Barkley to become the cracking player that he could be but it is fair to say that recently he has not been at his best. Too often he gets the ball in good positions and does not do enough with it. His goals/assists for the season are testament to this. He has huge ability but needs to improve decision making in the final third if he is to deliver on his potential.
Colin Williams
11 Posted 16/02/2014 at 20:58:18
Sam,

"Barkley recently not been at his best" — does that apply to most of the team?

Julian Exshaw
12 Posted 16/02/2014 at 21:09:26
Forgive me if this has been mentioned before, but I really think we miss Oviedo. Is it just a coincidence that he featured in arguably our best football of the season before Christmas? This is not a criticism of Baines at all but Oviedo did really well for us when he played. I was not impressed with what I saw today but a win is a win. March on beloved Toffees....
Kunal Desai
13 Posted 16/02/2014 at 21:14:18
Personally I think the winners of the FA Cup will be The ones that make it through from this tie. I think it'll be tough to beat Arsenal at the Emirates but i'm confident of taking back to Goodison (they won't want an additional fixture to already increase fixture congestion) and beating them. I believe Gibson is a big loss, we are continually playing Barry and McCarthy and haven't got any other personnel to change it like for like sitting deep. Atleast once Gibson is back it may give Barry a much needed break.
Mark Frere
14 Posted 16/02/2014 at 21:20:20
So you don't think Man City have much of a chance then, Kunai?

Definitely agree with you regarding Gibson, he's been a massive miss and would've been excellent back-up and competition to Barry and McCarthy. His good range of passing has been sorely missed.

James Elworthy
15 Posted 16/02/2014 at 21:21:09
Good win without playing well.

Traore needs time to blend in and as does McGeady another acquisition from the Russian League which is also where former lacklustre players such as Bily and Jo came from.

We do miss Lukaku but Naismith is proving a great super sub and finisher, I like the way he calmly passes the ball into the net. As we get closer to a fully fit squad, we need our former injured players to find a bit of form too (ie, Barkley and Coleman).

Sam Hoare
16 Posted 16/02/2014 at 21:30:08
James I think Coleman has refound his form already. He put in some great crosses today and served up two cracking chances that Pienaar and Mirallas should have scored.
Wayne Smyth
17 Posted 16/02/2014 at 21:27:04
I'd agree Barkley isn't at his best, he does make mistakes, some of which give the opposition a chance to score. However he isn't alone in this respect.

Jags gave a loose 10 yard pass that allowed RS to score. Should he start the next game? Of course, because he's one of our best defenders. Jags and Distin normally give the ball away quite regularly. Howard is normally not far from a howler to gift the opposition something. Osman will often lose the ball to a strong challenge if started against fresh opposition.

Equally, Barkley will give the opposition chances, until he plays enough to get the experience to improve his decision making. Personally I'm entirely comfortable with that.

Its the only way for him to learn, to make mistakes and it will cost us points in the short term. In the long term, however, we will have an absolutely cracking player who is probably going to be world-class.

Unfortunately we're not in the position of a Chelsea to loan him out and let him make mistakes for another team, while a £20M experienced player takes his place, so he must learn with us and he must be playing to learn.

I'd agree completely about him needing to work back more too. Hopefully this will get added to his game as well, but given the talent he has, I'm more than happy to see him given every first team opportunity when fit.

Rob O'Brien
18 Posted 16/02/2014 at 21:39:44
Good win against a potential banana skin! Didn't play great but we got through to the next round. I'm glad we don't have to play Liverpool to be honest because we seem to shit ourselves against them lately! By the way, did anyone notice how nervous Jags looked today? Everytime he got the ball he was giving it back to Robles! He looked like he didn't want the ball near him!
Terry Downes
19 Posted 16/02/2014 at 21:42:16
Anyone else think McCarthy didn't look interested today? Quiet a few times, he made no attempt to chase back.
Andy Crooks
20 Posted 16/02/2014 at 21:38:22
I thought it was a tired performance which timely substitutions rescued from a complacent draw. We seem to have taken the hospital pass to a new level and some of the back passing was dreadful; the one Pienaar put over the cross bar was a collector's item.

Having said that, the over-elaboration of the defenders on the ball wasn't helped by the lack of movement ahead of them. We seem to lack a player who always finds space and takes the pressure off the back four.

Finally, I think the assault on Naismith warranted a red card.

Andrew Hawes
21 Posted 16/02/2014 at 21:37:35
A very strange game from us today! I was expecting us to destroy Swansea but it never happened. We are not the team that played before Christmas; our defence is a worry, especially with Roberto's past history with the defensive side of his teams (wide open at times again today). What has happened to Jagielka??

But hopefully it's the start of us pulling games and points out of the bag without playing so well!!

Well done boys... but we need to step up a few levels from now on!!!

Frank Duffy
22 Posted 16/02/2014 at 21:49:12
Andy I thought the same. Straight Red Card. We went down to 10 men while they had 11 men. Ridiculous.
Gerry Quinn
23 Posted 16/02/2014 at 21:51:01
Is it just me or does anyone else feel petrified when Jags or Distin get the ball? Those two put me so far on the edge of my seat, that I am moving behind my couch! Along with Howard (and Robles at times today) their decision making when closed down is slow and in most cases appears wrong. What is it that stops them hoofing it when it obviously can be the only option? No, let's piss around with it. Pienaar did it today as well - almost chipped Robles. I used to be a nervous wreck watching the previous Everton style, but now I am suffering from "defensive petrifaction"
Phil Sammon
24 Posted 16/02/2014 at 21:56:09
We were poor today and made hard work of a Swansea team who seemed ready to roll over.

I noticed Distin and Jags getting a lot of stick for the amount of sideways hospital balls they played to one-another today. They both dwelt at times and they did make poor decisions, but I think you really have to look at the midfield for not giving them enough options.

Some nugget in front of me was losing his rag every time Jags, Distin or McCarthy looked to pass to one-another. "Get fucking rid" was his catchphrase this afternoon. He also followed it up with "We're just gifting them possession". Now you can't have it both ways, you big blowfish (he looks like a blowfish in his puffed up North Face jacket) either we lump it like you say, or we try keep the football. The lads are trying to do the right thing, in my eyes, they just need to get better at it.

My one gripe is our reluctance to shoot. Even Barkley was hesitating around the 18 yard box. You don't get two goals for walking it in, I wish we'd take on more shots from just outside the box.

Nick Entwistle
25 Posted 16/02/2014 at 22:08:07
Gerry, Clark Carlisle made a good point in his co-commentary today that Roberto must include everyone in his philosophy. That you simply cannot say to some people, no no you can't play a certain way because you're not good enough.

Personally, if it needs hoofing out of necessity, hoof away.

Jamie Tulacz
26 Posted 16/02/2014 at 22:11:52
Gerry, definitely, especially Jags more than Distin, who seems to have a little more ability on the ball. This also seems to have had an adverse effect on their defensive game today, to make things even worse!

Having said that, I think that there has been a general gradual improvement of their passing game during the season (admittedly from a low base), so hopefully this is more of a rarity/one-off..

Jim Bennings
27 Posted 16/02/2014 at 22:02:41
Regarding our midfield.

Yes it has looked tired for the last six or seven games now but we have limited other options for central midfield, without meaning to sound negative here, as much as I would love to see Gibson back this season, there is little chance of him being anywhere near the real Darron Gibson again until next season now.
If he does play any part at the arse end of April/May then its practically Gibbo's pre-season, he is going to be so far off the pace.

Barry and McCarthy have both looked jaded lately and Barkley is clearly feeling his way back into things aswell as feeling discomfort from the toe.

The only other thing we can do is change the formation to 4-4-2 by giving Barry a breather maybe against West Ham..
Try this against the Hammers on March 1st.

Howard
Coleman
Distin
Jagielka
Baines
Mirallas
Barkley
McCarthy
McGeady
Traore
Naismith

The subs bench could include the likes of Pienaar, Barry, Osman, Deulofeu and Lukaku is he is meant to be back by then, but obviously not ready to start.

Its not like West Ham would come here and show much ambition anyway and even with 5 midfielders lately we have surrendered quite a lot of possession to teams who we wouldnt have hardly seen the ball two months ago.

Jim Bennings
28 Posted 16/02/2014 at 22:17:37
Point I am making is the 5 man midfield that includes two defensive players in Barry and McCarthy is fine against Arsenal away but at home to West Ham, Cardiff ect, do we always really need it?

We have a young dynamic central midfielder in Barkley and we are as someone says, spoilt for choice winger wise, and when Lukaku comes back we can either pair him with Traore, or with Naismith.

That way it will give Barry (or McCarthy, but more likely Barry) a breather for the 'bigger' games such as Arsenal away in the cup.

Its always good to keep fresh idea's and show a willingness to adapt to playing different teams that come and park the bus.

John Gilfoyle
29 Posted 16/02/2014 at 22:02:57
Surprised no one is a little alarmed at Traore's performance, I was expecting a lot more really, he made Crouch look like Zidane. Especially when he controlled it and it hit him in the face. I know people will say he isn't fit yet but he was absolutely laughable today. Lets hope he picks up.

Coleman is a superstar, I wonder what would happen if we moved him to RM as it's clear he's improved dramatically and looks so assured in possession and dangerous in the final third.

I'm also bemused as what McCarthy brings to the table, He goes backwards or sideways every time in possession and is basically useless. I see Barkley's getting some stick on here today but i'd take a player who tries to take a player on, play a killer pass and shoot rather than someone whose first thought i, "Shit, don't lose it, here you go, Distin, with a man closing you... not my fault if you lose it, my pass was successful."

Kunal Desai
30 Posted 16/02/2014 at 22:30:21
Mark — I think Man City will probably now make it to the final, I have a feeling it'll be like last season, they'll start as favourites but either Arsenal or ourselves will raise the game, we'll want it more, they could be involved in the title hunt and CL as well. I think Man City at home are a force; away from home and on neutral venue they are a different proposition.
Jamie Barlow
31 Posted 16/02/2014 at 22:32:20
John, I know you said people will comment on how unfit he is but it’s just that. He said in his interview that that was his first competitive minutes for 5 months.

I also think Barkley is just going through a bad patch and is lacking a bit of confidence at the moment. It happens to everyone but it’ll soon be back.

Paul Thompson
32 Posted 16/02/2014 at 22:35:54
Distin is more comfortable in the RM style than Jags, but a couple of times he hoofed it you could see that it was shouting for someone to show for a pass. McCarthy was particularly guilty of not doing this. He seems to have lost his zip, which, without he's not bringing that much to the team.

To be fair, he's not the only player looking jaded – the result of too many games with a small squad and injuries. As for Traore, he looked lost. In league games I think you'll see him coming off the bench while he adjusts. I have my doubts, but you've got to give him more time than half a game.

John Gilfoyle
33 Posted 16/02/2014 at 22:44:45
Jamie fair enough, five months is a long time, I thought it was a few weeks. He did have a bad first touch at times and went missing throughout.

Similar to Lukaku's recent performances, makes me wonder if our style of play starves the guy playing the lone role, we seem to pass a lot quite nicely between the back four and midfield but I don't think it clicks in the final third yet, Martinez sorts that piece of the jigsaw and we're a team.

Minik Hansen
34 Posted 16/02/2014 at 23:06:16
Good win, quarter final here we come! Play to our best and tell your ma we're going to Wembley twice. :)
Dave Street
35 Posted 16/02/2014 at 22:59:23
Terry Downes (#537). Fairly ridiculous comment to say that McCarthy didn't look interested. For any of his failings as footballer the lad gives it everything every time he sticks a shirt on for us so behave yourself.

Also how come any time teams or players play below par they are suddenly tired!! During the course of a season you have peaks and troughs. You just have to work through them.

Great to get to the quarters and roll on next Saturday against Chelsea, where we will go with no fear, win lose or draw.

Jamie Barlow
37 Posted 16/02/2014 at 23:03:35
You’re right John. Martinez also said that we’re a good team getting into the final third, it’s what we need to do in the final third that will make us a top team. Martinez is just two-thirds into his first Everton season. It’s only early days.
Brent Stephens
38 Posted 16/02/2014 at 23:07:17
Poor performance until the subs came on. Thanks, Nais – did it for us again.

Barks disappointing – let's put it down to his toe.

Jags, you frighten me at times.

Robles, practice your kicking!

Si Cooper
39 Posted 16/02/2014 at 23:35:14
I echo the sentiment that at times it is best just to hoof the ball upfield and hope for a fortunate bounce, if only to keep the opposition guessing. We only really looked comfortable today once Swansea abandonned their pressing game.

Initially, Swansea (like a fair few others recently) closed us down quickly in our own half forcing the centre backs into increasingly confined spaces and causing panic at times because a measured pass wasn't really on. Jags never seemed to recover his composure for the whole game though he wasn't the only one who was sloppy at times. The defensive midfielders didn't always make themselves available and at one stage Pienaar tried to find an outlet by crossing it over our own penalty area – that can't be what the manager is aiming for.

Pienaar wasted a lot of possession with far too many attempted back heels and plenty of dodgy passes, but he is important to our attacking efforts. Very harsh to call him for missing that headed opportunity considering it had taken a flick on at the near post.

Hard to judge Traore from today's showing. Not enough for him to run onto and too much at upper chest height with back to goal. Looked mobile at times and should improve with games.

Kevin Tully
40 Posted 17/02/2014 at 00:27:01
I think Robles will prove to be a far better 'keeper than Howard. He's quicker to come off his line, and he gets us going forward without hesitation. Howard is a decent shot-stopper, but the rest of his game is average.
Ernie Baywood
41 Posted 17/02/2014 at 06:29:01
Job done, and summed up quite neatly by the Independent...

"Martinez said that his player could not recall scoring or much of the match. The first was a pity, the second was something of a mercy."

Will be a different performace at the Emirates.

Patrick Murphy
42 Posted 17/02/2014 at 07:19:43
Cup football is built on results and nothing else - play well and lose and it means you're out and that is what happened to Everton in 1983 they beat Spurs the Cup-holders and then went to Old Trafford and battered United but lost to a late late goal.

The following season Everton beat Stoke, struggled to beat Gillingham over three games and beat Shrewsbury. In the sixth round Everton beat a poor Notts County team away before struggling to beat a good Southampton side in the Semi-Final. The only reason that most of those games are still remembered today is not because we played fantastic football but more because we lifted the trophy and that was the catalyst for our greatest period of success.

I don't care if we beat Arsenal on penalties at Goodison or win well at the Emirates, in the FA Cup the result is everything and while we are still in it we can win it.

I agree that in the league you need to play well in the majority of your games to be successful but in the cup the result is everything.

Anthony Flack
43 Posted 17/02/2014 at 07:23:44
Traore was horrible. Have to hope it is rustiness. Reminded me of a black Brett Angell. (PS thought carefully about that sentence and trust no one thinks it remotely racist..) I also heard some bloke imitating Souness "whose fucking brother did you say he was...)

I agree that Mccarthy and Barry looked tired. Barry in particular looked ponderous I said the same after the Spurs game and I am worried that there is something unsettling him post transfer windows?

Not worried about Barkley. Class act. Played poorly yet still got several good shots off which on another day could easily have gone in.

Anthony Flack
44 Posted 17/02/2014 at 07:23:44
Traore was horrible. Have to hope it is rustiness. Reminded me of a black Brett Angell. (PS thought carefully about that sentence and trust no one thinks it remotely racist..) I also heard some bloke imitating Souness "whose fucking brother did you say he was...)

I agree that Mccarthy and Barry looked tired. Barry in particular looked ponderous I said the same after the Spurs game and I am worried that there is something unsettling him post transfer windows?

Not worried about Barkley. Class act. Played poorly yet still got several good shots off which on another day could easily have gone in.

David Ellis
45 Posted 17/02/2014 at 08:23:39
I think Swansea dropped their high upfield pressing game because its impossible to maintain that for a full 90 minutes. They spent too much energy on it in the first half. One of the reasons why playing aganst tic tac is difficult
Jermaine Jennings
46 Posted 17/02/2014 at 07:44:05
The players are all jaded but our squad isn’t big enough for rotation. We know this so no point going on about it!!! Passing is slow and ponderous — how many times could we have shot or passed the ball forward when just outside the 18-yard box and instead goes back to our own 18-yard box?

Clearly Jagielka cannot pass and defend, it’s too much for him. I prefer it when he just concentrates on defending. instead he’s concentrating on passing, which is the right pass, which is why we are so poor at the back: indecision.

Anthony, you’re spot-on: Barry looked awful yesterday and he is just biding his time and then at the end of the season he’ll do one. McCarthy played too deep in the first half and he is much better further forward, like in the second half. We need legs alongside McCarthy because I think he’s really cautious alongside Barry because of Barry’s lack of pace so he feels inclined to sit alongside him, which is why he rarely gets forward.

Martinez has to get around the fact that teams when they come will press high... the gap between the defence and midfield was too big when our back four had the ball and it didn’t work.

As for Barkley, at home he needs to play deeper and learn the role more as we will get much more from him. Sometimes against the good teams we can’t cover for him when he goes missing as we get overrun in midfield, like yesterday. If he plays deeper, then we have more options in attack and it keeps the opposition guessing. Against the RS in the second half, when he dropped deeper, he ran the show and our midfield dominated theirs as it was unpredictable.

Ian Burns
47 Posted 17/02/2014 at 09:22:21
Anthony - 597 - "whose ..... brother did you say he was?" Brilliant, which summed up Traore's performance and one has to put it down to being 5 months out - we hope!

Performance as said so many times above was lethargic; centre backs are uncomfortable when pressed and the midfielders not helping out by providing options.

The next part of our development has to be to pass with pace and providing options quickly which will move the pressing opposition about creating space behind their pressing players.

RM's first season, we are getting there and I firmly RM will lead us into the promised land.

Dan McKie
48 Posted 17/02/2014 at 10:16:30
Something needs to be done about the centre of midfield. Barry is still doing okay, but looks his age at times, but McCarthy was shocking yesterday, but take off the tinted specs that a lot of people have with him and those performances are not that rare. All that gets said about him is 'tiger-like' or 'never stops running' and has people shouting for him to be Man of the Match because he has made the odd tackle here and there (often when he has lost the ball in the first place).

He constantly put the centre backs under pressure yesterday when he was coming for the ball and not having a clue what to do with it. This resulted in 4 or 5 passes between him and said centre back, with the opposition pressing closer and closer each time, leading to mistakes. For me, he is shirking the work and the responsibility right now.

Plus the fact that we don't need two water carriers on the pitch. I personally wouldn't mind seeing Pienaar played with Barry in the centre. He works hard enough and has ability with the ball to go with it. Our game is too focused on wide play all of the time. We need something to come centrally.

Jim Bennings
49 Posted 17/02/2014 at 12:27:40
Dan

Every club needs a McCarthy type midfielder, its not all about being stylish. Liverpool fans admit they are a better team when the unstylish Lucas plays. Roy Keane was not creative but he was Man Utd's lynchpin back in the day. How about our own super Lee Carsley? Arguably the most important cog to the team that finished 4th with limited resources.

I am well aware we paid a lot of money for McCarthy but that's the going rate these days for a player who is good at what he does. McCarthy is very good at what he does, it's not his fault that we don't have an Arteta or Fernandes type creative midfielder next to him.

Barry is also defensive but has been a steadying influence until his recent loss of form and Ross Barkley is meant to be the driving force going forward but he is nowhere near the finished article and, unlike Arteta, cannot really find that true creative spark; Ross is more about running with the ball.

I have made the call for a four-man midfield against West Ham at home in a few weeks time, I think that would be the perfect game to give Barry a breather and bring him back for the monumental clash with Arsenal the following weekend. I don't see why we need to play both Barry and McCarthy against West Ham at home who will come and look to defend.

Plus, if we all put our hand on heart, the league has gone now in terms of finishing 4th... and, if we don't win at Chelsea next week, even 5th is fading away rapidly.

We could try to make the formation switch and let McCarthy and Barkley get on with it just for one game and thrive using Mirallas and any one of Pienaar, Deulofeu or McGeady on the left wing. It's food for thought...

Dan McKie
50 Posted 17/02/2014 at 12:48:22
Jim, when we bought McCarthy for £13 million, I wasn't aware we were buying a player who is basically 'busy', whatever that means, but can do little with the ball. I remember seeing him makes runs through the centre of midfield for Wigan with some pundits even comparing him to a young Gerrard.

He is young, but experienced, quick and has a good engine. I want to see it used more. He has done it a couple of times and looks very comfortable when doing so, like setting up Lukaku against Southampton, and in the Liverpool home game early on.

That is the McCarthy I want to see, a long striding driving centre midfielder – not one like Lee Carsley, which I think even that is giving him too much credit; he's more like a slightly better Phil Neville.

Tony Draper
51 Posted 17/02/2014 at 21:05:26
McCarthy has put in some mighty shifts for us this season
Too many seem to have convenient/short memories

Second half of the season and ALL prem teams play tighter EVERY week, EVEN in the cup
WHY
Cos 50% of em are shitting themselves EVERY WEEK

Swansea mid field were on us to quieten us down and Macca AND Barry were continually harassed
BUT
We pressed too and
NAISMITH
The anticipation for the backpass goal was SPOT ON

Plenty here wouldnt give the lad credit if he wore the bloody rollover Euromillions numbers on his back

He guessed and guessed right, early and WASNT offside, his finish was just tidy and panic free

Maybe the monkeys NEED to GTF off his back
Dont think Robles would get stick if he was played as DM for a season after a 12 month injury would he ?

Good on ya Stevie, keep on keepin on !

Dan McKie
52 Posted 18/02/2014 at 10:11:23
Tony, if your memory is so good, then tell us of these might shifts that McCarthy has put in, and exactly what they involved. Was it 'running around' by any chance? Smacks of headless chicken to me.

As for Naismith, Martinez seems to have found a decent role for him. I'm not sure if he could pull off the same performances for 90 minutes against Chelsea defenders though, but after seeing Traore, I'd give him a chance.

(ps: It's difficult to be offside when their defender plays the ball through...)

Jim Bennings
53 Posted 18/02/2014 at 10:22:00
The mighty shifts McCarthy has put in.

Manchester United away
Arsenal away
Liverpool home
Chelsea home
Aston Villa home&away
Stoke home & away
Swansea away (his driving run earned the free kick for Barkley's winner)

McCarthy does a excellent job at what he does. He outshone our midfield at Goodison last season when they won 3-0 and he was outstanding in the Cup final when Wigan beat City.

He is one man; as I say, it's not his fault we don't have a real creative source next to him yet.

Matthew Williams
55 Posted 18/02/2014 at 16:19:52
I've been hoping for that exact formation too, Jim. We need only one defensive midfield player verses West Ham & others during the run in, let our attacking play dictate things in our final games of the season and see what happens, eh? We ain't finished with this league season just yet...

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads

© ToffeeWeb