ESA calls on Arsenal to honour Cup allocation guidelines

, 20 February, 45comments  |  Jump to most recent
The Everton FC Shareholders Association has publicly called on Arsenal to provide an away ticket allocation for next month's FA Cup quarter final that is in keeping with both the traditions of the competition and Football Association rules.

FA rules state that the visiting club for an FA Cup tie is entitled to claim up to 15% of the host stadium's capacity, the equivalent of 9,000 seats at The Emirates Stadium which is the total allocation offered to Coventry City in the Fourth Round.

After offering both Tottenham and Liverpool similarly reduced allocations in the Third and Fifth Rounds respectively, Arsenal have made just 5,186 tickets available for Everton and the ESA have asked "if Arsenal are acting in the cherished traditions of the FA Cup."

They have also questioned the rationale put forward by Arsenal's Safety Advisory Group for their decision — specifically concerns over "persistent standing" and the use of pyrotechnics and smoke bombs by visiting supporters — and why those fears do not apply to home fans or those from lower-division opposition.

The ESA asks:

  • If this tier of the stadium is considered safe for home fans why is it considered unsafe for selected away fans?
  • If this tier of the stadium is considered safe for Coventry City fans why is it not considered safe for Spurs, Liverpool and Everton Fans?
  • Does the upper tier above the away end have a corporate section in the middle?
  • Does the Emirates stadium stage concerts where people in the upper tier are allowed to consume alcohol and dance?
  • Is the occasional use of smoke bombs — of which the ESA completely disapproves — just a smokescreen for Arsenal to reduce the number of away fans from Premier League opposition?
  • Why is the large and modern Emirates Stadium — and its partner authorities — able to maintain a safety certificate when it is apparently unable to safely manage 15% of seats being taken up by visitors?
  • Will the Arsenal Safety Advisory Group be making public the detail that supports their decision?

The Everton FC Shareholders' Association calls upon Arsenal Football Club and its partner authorities to urgently reconsider their decision and to allocate the full allocation of 15% to Everton supporters.

Source: EFSCA



Reader Comments (45)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Patrick Murphy
2 Posted 20/02/2014 at 18:31:32
Probably won't get the reply that the letter deserves but at least the correct questions are being asked. Well done to the Everton Supporters Association.
John Crawley
3 Posted 20/02/2014 at 18:30:02
Absolute disgraceful behaviour by Arsenal. I would like the club to issue such a public complaint as well.
Patrick Murphy
4 Posted 20/02/2014 at 18:46:47
Sorry Everton Shareholders Association.
Paul Smith
5 Posted 20/02/2014 at 18:43:52
When we get them in the League at home just do the same to them and give them as few as tickets that we can.

Whilst we're on about crowds, I've always thought whatever we get charged at an away game we should charge their fans the same price when we come to Goodison. I'm fed up of paying over the odds then other teams coming here for cheap tickets.

Andy Meighan
6 Posted 20/02/2014 at 18:55:10
Hope they get humiliated in Munich the horrible bastards
Jay Doyle
7 Posted 20/02/2014 at 18:52:22
Hear Hear, but why couldn’t the club have asked there every relevant questions ?

No coincidence that Coventry ( no real threat to Arsenal) received the full allocation, whereas ourselves, Spurs and the shite (considerable threats) receive the reduced allocation.

Very convenient for the home team, but the FA should grow a pair and stop this blatant manipulation of their own guidelines.

Matthew Salem
8 Posted 20/02/2014 at 19:01:02
The last question is the best one. I'd love to hear an answer to it, although I doubt Arsenal Football Club will be forthcoming .
Declan Burke
9 Posted 20/02/2014 at 18:59:14
What else would you expect from a club whose manager is probably the most biased in the league. He moans about refereeing decisions that go against his team but when one of his players get away with a potential yellow/red card, "Unfortunatly, I didn't see it"

Come on Blues, let's stuff them!

Aman Kanji
10 Posted 20/02/2014 at 19:13:58
Good effort but it ain't gonna happen..
Doesn't matter anyway... Just sit with the Gooners. Won't be able to afford the butties though... Might have to just have a liquid lunch on the train...
Paul Holden
11 Posted 20/02/2014 at 19:53:40
Arsenal are a disgrace and I guarantee there will be 5,000-plus Blues mixed in with the home mob as a result!
Fran Grimes
12 Posted 20/02/2014 at 20:28:59
This is a disgrace, either there is a rule or there is a guideline, how can you give Coventry a full allocation but apply different guidelines for others, if it was say Chelsea would they give 2000, Man U 3000, if they reckon its a sell out give none, safety reasons prevail. I mean Coventry don’t have hooligans or burn fireworks, do they.

Arsenal appear to examine their needs first then apply the outcome to the away support. Coventry fans probably took up a full allocation because it was a chance to revisit a premiership ground, Arsenal fans weren’t arsed, so sell as many to aways as possible.

Bill K should lodge some kind of objection, its twisting the rules to suit their needs, I’m disappointed with Arsenal, as they are a club I used to admire- God bless Mickey Thomas, I used to say

Andy Cope
13 Posted 20/02/2014 at 20:32:40
The concern is that there would be persistent standing in the upper tier, which is where most of the additional tickets would have been allocated. Nobody is questioning that there is persistent standing in the lower tier but since we have never been allocated seating in the upper tier at The Emirates, the judgement that has been made can only be based on supposition and not evidence. Moreover, two weeks ago there were around 2000 blues in the Upper Tier at White Hart Lane and, for the most part, we all sat down! So the relevant evidence that did exist was ignored.

The question that the ESA might have asked was why Chelsea were allocated 9000 tickets earlier this season for the Carling Cup game. Coventry took 9000 last year but did not sell them all and had to pay for over 1000 unsold tickets. Consequently, although they were offered a similar allocation this year, they only took 5100 - the same as we have been offered. This means the Chelsea evidence is arguably more relevant to our case. Regardless, the fact that clubs have continued to be offered the larger allocation suggests the evidence from away fan behaviour to date has not been a problem.

The whole episode is a disgrace.

Simon Smith
14 Posted 20/02/2014 at 21:07:28
Mr
Mannering, Mr.Mannering, they don’t like it up them!!!
Here’s hoping that whatever allocation we do get that the fans get right behind the team and cheer them into the semi finals
Mike Owen
15 Posted 20/02/2014 at 21:24:19
It's worth adding that kick-off times in the previous three rounds at the Emirates stadium were much later in the day (Spurs, 5.15pm; Coventry, 7.45pm; Liverpool 4pm) than the 12.45pm for Everton.

So, if alcohol is considered to be an issue, it seems even more questionable to give us fewer than 5,200 tickets.

Coventry were offered 8,686 seats last month for a night game but in the end only took the lower tier

James Royston
16 Posted 20/02/2014 at 21:31:12
Everton FC should complain officially to both Arsenal & the F.A. Is the allocation a rule or just a recommendation ? if its a rule the F.A. MUST demand it is followed....In any case just how can there be a safety issue with virtually new stadium ????
Guy Hastings
17 Posted 20/02/2014 at 21:30:49
On the related matter of ticket allocation, from what I can gather, EFC are getting arsey about reimbursing Palace (and their supporters) for their allocated tickets for the postponed match. Hope that’s not the case. Distinct lack of class if it is.
Kevin Tully
18 Posted 20/02/2014 at 22:02:15
This is all about Arsenal not wanting away supporters directly above their corporate seats in the middle tier. Let's just hope we give them the same treatment if a replay comes back to Goodison - can't see it somehow.
Jamie Sweet
19 Posted 20/02/2014 at 22:01:08
If they don’t want their home fans to be out-sung and out-supported by my fellow Blues then they really should reduce our ticket allocation even further, because our 5,000 v their 50,000 is still no contest.
Patrick Murphy
20 Posted 20/02/2014 at 22:07:18
Guy I read a piece today that Tony Pulis and Palace were put up in a hotel found a place to train the following day and fed all at Everton FC's expense and Pulis had nothing but praise for the club, I don't know the rules for the reimbursement of ticket money for a postponed game and I would be surprised if Everton FC are getting 'Arsey' about it as you claim but have you any evidence?
Kris Boner
21 Posted 20/02/2014 at 22:47:43
Damn straight the ESA should say this.
Paul Holden
22 Posted 20/02/2014 at 22:51:01
I was in a box seat for the 1-1 draw - in the Arse end, and at lest 40 per cent of the seats around me were empty
Kevin Tully
23 Posted 20/02/2014 at 23:16:55
Talking of away games at Arsenal always reminds me of the Ken Loach play "The Golden Vision"

If you haven't seen it, it's now up on YouTube, a must watch for all Blues;


Link

Paul Ferry
24 Posted 21/02/2014 at 02:32:10
AH Kev - 218 - I watch it at least once a month. Essential, utterly essential for old lady culture, can just imagine Harold Matthews, Dick Fearon, and Ray Roche heading down sarf with the boys that day!

No more points for me to make here, it's all been said, and so well. Everton FC need to take the lead here and if the FA turn a blind eye then make sure to limit tickets for the twats if there is a replay, although to be honest when all is said and done, we're better fans, and the arse demand probably wont be there for a late evening roasting under the Old Lady lights

The Golden Vision;

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WcAmE5GxGd0

The opening seconds just break your heart.

Guy Hastings
25 Posted 21/02/2014 at 06:56:42
Hi, Patrick - just a whinge doing the rounds. Empires have fallen for less. Must admit our divided house is getting a bit arsey about news of the rearranged date.
Mike Green
26 Posted 21/02/2014 at 08:52:42
The Emirates has a lower tier capacity of 24,425, so plenty of room without the need to use an upper tier.

If they feel that the upper tier cannot be used, and are unable to utilise a lower tier that’s almost 2/3rds the size of our ground to accommodate the away support allocation, they should be banned from the competition – as much as they would be from top flight football if the ground was not all-seater.

Mike Green
27 Posted 21/02/2014 at 09:17:35
Alternatively, the FA should tell them to shut down the middle tier boxes for Cup ties if it doesn't sit well with them having away fans above and below – either that or allocate them to the away support.

Brian Waring
28 Posted 21/02/2014 at 10:15:32
So if we are entitled to 9,000 tickets, but only get 5,186 because of the concerns of Arsenal's Safety Advisory Group, does that mean there will be 3,814 empty seats???
Mike Gwyer
29 Posted 21/02/2014 at 11:01:01

Jamie Sweet #211.

The 2,500 blues that go to the Emirates for EPL games easily out-sing the Arsenal fans now – The Emirates with all their hospitality suites, expensive seats and shall we say "well-off fanbase" are not the same mob that went to Highbury.

With over 5,000 blues going to this game, I can assure you it will be a raucous away end. However, for blues intending to filter into the home sections, beware, the stewards will eject you as soon as it's obvious your not a Arse fan.

Richard Reeves
30 Posted 21/02/2014 at 11:00:14
A simple case of Arsenal being Arsenal (wankers).
It's obvious they are limiting tickets so they have an extra advantage in atmosphere but I'm not surprised to be honest. That club and particularly Winjer sit on there highground claiming they do things the right way yet don't.

Operating within their finances,spending small amounts on young players and developing them into world stars, keeping within a certain and lower wage structure to other clubs of similar finances,all of which is nonsense.

They may of had a stadium to pay for but it is the fan who has had to pay (the ticket prices are a disgrace), the young players that they buy are normally quite expensive and are known to just about every other club before 90% of them fail at Arsenal, Winjer never see's anything harmfull his own players do and contrary to what he claims hardly ever takes responsibility himself... Actually, after the defeat to the Red Shite, it was the first and only time I've heard Winjer say that he needs to take a look at himself or something to that extent, and as for this image that they try to create – one of a team trying to play beautiful attacking football but being kicked and bullied out of any silverware – it was only the other night that they had there 100th player sent off from under the Winjer era.

If there's any justice, we should give them a bloody good hiding.

Brian Hill
31 Posted 21/02/2014 at 14:22:29
Arsenal apparently cannot comment on the ESA questionnaire as they didn't see it.
Matt Traynor
32 Posted 21/02/2014 at 14:29:13
I’m afraid we were never getting 9000 tickets, and actually Arsenal have somewhat dug EFC out of a hole.

The problem is in the rules governing sale of away tickets. (I’m assuming the ticketing rules are the same as they are for the Premier League.)

Currently clubs have to provide a minimum number of tickets for away clubs on sale-or-return – the club only pays for the ticket it sells. Some away clubs have in the past returned a large portion of tickets which could otherwise have been resold to home fans. Therefore what happens now is any request for an amount above the minimum is granted on a consignment basis – that is, the club is on the hook for the full amount.

It puts clubs in a difficult position, but really in this day and age of electronic ticketing, ticket to mobile phones etc there’s no need. With a bit of prompt action by clubs, especially in notifying the home clubs if take-up will be poor, they should be able to satisfy away demand easily.

Sadly for a club like Everton, risking ~£100k losses on tickets just isn’t feasible – and nor should they be asked to take the risk. This is why, for example, we end up taking lower allocations like QPR (a) last season – when we could’ve sold far more. I guess Fulham’s "neutral" zone is their way of managing over-demand for away tickets (and for that reason alone I’d like to see them stay in the top flight!)

Kevin Naylor
33 Posted 21/02/2014 at 15:07:45
Matt I'm sorry but we would have sold the lot no problem and as for Arsenal getting EFC out of a hole please.
Kevin Tully
34 Posted 21/02/2014 at 15:17:49
Matt, I know season ticket holders who will miss out on a ticket because they haven't got enough away credits.
Matt Traynor
35 Posted 21/02/2014 at 15:26:43
Kevins, I have no doubt we would have as well, but for reasons that are obvious, the ticket office are risk-averse when it comes to it. Someone posted last season they’d asked QPR about the piss-poor allocation and was told Everton didn’t take up the increased offer...
Kevin Rowlands
36 Posted 21/02/2014 at 17:24:05
KT, thanks for that link, 1st time I'd ever seen that and loved it, absolutely laughing my arse off at the wedding at the end, great stuff.
Lee Gray
37 Posted 21/02/2014 at 18:12:17
Just refuse to give them ANY tickets for future games, if each club does that you force their hand, what's the point in having rules if clubs don't adhere to them, kick them out if that's what is required, that won't happen as they ARE part of Sky's elite!
Chris Leyland
38 Posted 21/02/2014 at 19:04:22
The capacity for away fans at league games at Goodison is up to 3,000.

So, I say for the league match at Goodison later on this year we say to them, for every thousand tickets upto 5,000 tickets you give us for the cup game we will give you 1 ticket per thousand in return but for every additional thousand tickets you give us above 5,000 we will give you a further 749 tickets for the league game at Goodison.

So, give us 9,000 tickets for the cup game and we give you 3,001 tickets for the league game but give us 5,000 cup tickets and we allocate you 5 tickets for the league game.

Kevin Rowlands
39 Posted 21/02/2014 at 19:24:13
The safety issue is laughable. There will probably be a lot more blues travelling down there than the allocation they’re providing in the hope of getting in somehow, therefore meaning that they will be ’mixing in’ with the Arsenal fans outside and inside the ground.

Surely that alone would make the possibility for trouble a lot higher, or in other words a lot less safe? Absolutely scandalous really.

Patrick Murphy
40 Posted 21/02/2014 at 20:14:54
There will be two neutral supporters at the game I wonder how they'll come by their tickets? But it is a nice story.
Pair Will Stick With Toffees
Andy Walker
41 Posted 21/02/2014 at 20:26:16
If they had just asked the last question (which covers the rest) it would have been so much more powerful without the 'chip on the shoulder' feeling. Just makes them look like argumentative scousers and they will simply close down. Naive I'm afraid but with good intentions. They need to wise up if they truly want to influence.
Patrick Murphy
42 Posted 21/02/2014 at 20:35:59
What I find reprehensible is that neither the clubs or the FA are responsible for this situation as they have abdicated their responsibility to a bunch of faceless, nameless people who it would seem are responsible to nobody in particular and therefore can wield power in any way they see fit.

This is not what I would expect in a democratic country and certainly goes against the sporting ethics that I was brought up with. This type of body seems to permeate every area of society and I don't find it particularly helpful or useful to the ordinary person.

Andy Walker
43 Posted 21/02/2014 at 20:46:27
Totally agree, Patrick, just wish we'd tried to lure them out of their holes rather than making them hide.
Jay Doyle
44 Posted 21/02/2014 at 21:54:28
Well said, Joe Anderson, I've met him, he's actually a sound bloke and a blue despite being a politician.
Karl Masters
45 Posted 21/02/2014 at 23:14:37
Why can’t they just give us 9,000 tickets in the lower tier?

With a replay more than possible, you would like to think our club will be prepared to even up the score with their ticket allocation... but, judging by the deafening silence emanating from Goodison Park so far on this matter, you already know it won’t happen. We will probably give them most of the Bullens Rd and let them dominate the TV microphones.

People’s Club, my arse.

Graham Mockford
46 Posted 22/02/2014 at 15:53:43
And in other news the Greek government have demanded the return of the Elgin Marbles.

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads

© ToffeeWeb