Tony Hibbert: deal or no deal

, 20 February, 27comments  |  Jump to most recent
Luke O'Farrell asks whether Everton should offer the veteran fullback a new deal or look for a longer-term backup to Seamus Coleman.

» Read the full article at ESPNFC



Reader Comments (27)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Nick Entwistle
1 Posted 20/02/2014 at 19:02:26
At his age, with Seamus offering so much more... Hibbo will probably make the decision himself.
Harold Matthews
2 Posted 20/02/2014 at 20:56:39
No brainer for me. A new deal.
Peter Conley
3 Posted 20/02/2014 at 21:06:35
Whilst Tony may not be the most gifted, no-one can doubt his passion. I would give him a new deal — 12 months??

Football is changing and Tony is amongst a dying breed: loves a tackle, hates losing, does not dive, moan at ref, etc etc. Deffo joining the coaching staff when the time is right. The news today that Dunc has been added to first team duties only backs this up.

Notice the shite are having guest appearances from ex players at the midden in Kirkby, not full=time though... must keep BT Sports happy with their drive.

Mark Frere
4 Posted 20/02/2014 at 21:16:30
Its time to move on from players like Tony Hibbert, modern day Fullbacks are expected to do much more than defend. Hibbert has been an excellent servant to this club and he seems like a truly decent lad, who has always gave 100% commitment but we have to move forward as a club.

I would like to see us sign a more like-for-like replacement for Coleman, we have two good modern day LBs.....the same needs to apply at RB.

Ian Bennett
5 Posted 20/02/2014 at 21:29:11
As a backup and positive influence on development players, I hope he stays. However, surely at his age he still wants to play regularly for a premiership or championship side.
Robin Cannon
6 Posted 20/02/2014 at 21:52:03
I'm totally supportive of a new one year deal for Hibbert. He's been a good servant to the club, and assuming he's overcome those injury issues, I'm perfectly comfortable with him being a back-up for Coleman, as well as a generally positive influence on the squad as a whole.
Craig Fletcher
7 Posted 21/02/2014 at 00:23:57
Agree with Robin and Harold. Money for new players can be better spent in other areas of the pitch rather than just a back-up RB to Seamus; especially when we also have John Stones who can deputize there also if required.

Hibbo has been a great servant for the club and in the brief times he has featured this season (i.e. FA Cup v Stevange) he still has looked more than capable. He's also a Blue from the old-school, so he'll be a fantastic influence on new players to the club and the younger lads.

Jim Harrison
8 Posted 21/02/2014 at 01:15:30
As stated above, Right back is a well covered spot. Keep him on and use them money where it is needed
Shane Corcoran
9 Posted 21/02/2014 at 09:35:36
Is he out of contract this summer?

I imagine RM will offer him a one year contract but whether he wants to sit on the bench is another matter.

I'd see him as cover for centre back too especially if we ultimately switch to a 3-4-3.

Trevor Lynes
10 Posted 21/02/2014 at 11:00:54
I really believe that Tony would be a decent stand-in for either McCarthy or Barry as defensive midfielder. Phil Neville managed to act in that role and I am sure that Hibbert could do that job now. Pace is not so important in midfield and Hibbert is experienced enough to be able to seamlessly slot into either slot. Lots of older footballers move further back or inside from fullback as they have the experience to be able to read the game better than promising youngsters.

When I see the likes of Cattermole and others in the role I reckon our Tony could do that job easily and enjoy his game more. He would not be worried about pace so much. Even Distin preferred not to play fullback and he is one of our faster players.

Tony is a very good tackler and he just needs to improve his distribution side and he could very well be in for a new career at defensive midfield.

Richard Reeves
11 Posted 21/02/2014 at 12:00:34
No deal!

On another note, Is Noel Edmonds still alive? He's starting to resemble a corpse that's had a bad makeover or reminds me of that Mr Potato Head toy where you add on the features.

David Ellis
13 Posted 21/02/2014 at 15:55:43
Trevor - I think that Tony "just needs to improve his distribution" to play the DM role is like saying my Mum just needs to run a bit quicker to make the 100m final in the Olympics. Masterful understatement. There's a reason why he did not make a career as a DM and that's it.
Wayne Smyth
15 Posted 21/02/2014 at 21:12:39
Trevor, I think you may be in a minority there. He can barely play right back anymore never mind switch to a position requiring distribution, technique and confidence on the ball.

A few years ago, Hibbert was a decent right back. He had a yard of pace which got him out of trouble. Now he's getting a bit too old to cope with the decent wingers that most teams have. I'd consider him for centre-half based on his displays there a few seasons ago, but it's probably something which would need trying to see if it was a one-off, or whether he can genuinely play there against current premiership strikers.

If I'm honest I'd probably keep him on for the reasons given, but not at the £40k / week he's probably on. Time to look for an alternative. Players like Oviedo offer so much more and there are no doubt quite a few young, modern full backs out there who can offer us proper competition for Seamus, never mind a backup.

Trevor Lynes
16 Posted 21/02/2014 at 21:30:56
Cheers Wayne and David but I think you may be wrong! Lots of older players do the defensive midfield role and if you look around the league you can list them. Tony is 100% and always works hard for the team. He may have lost a yard or two of pace but he is as fast as Barry.

He has bags of experience and I reckon he would be a decent sub. far better than the likes of Heitinga or Phil Neville. We are very sparse in that particular position as we do not have subs for either Barry or McCarthy unless maybe a fit Alcaraz could fill that role. We cannot rely on Gibson unfortunately.

As it stands, Barry and McCarthy have no competition and can play if they like!

Paul Johnson
17 Posted 21/02/2014 at 22:34:45
While home at the end of January, I was sat next to a guy at the Villa game who says he knows Tony's agent and, according to him, the club are not interested. Reckons he would sign for a 50% pay cut as well. Commendable in this day and age. I would sign him for 1 more year.
Peter Laing
19 Posted 21/02/2014 at 22:43:53
Non-subject: Martinez stated a couple of weeks ago that Hibbo is part of the furniture at the Club and, though his presence on the field has waned due to persistent injuries and the emergence of Coleman, that he still has a future at Everton. I would expect Tony to be signing a contract extension and taking up a coaching position in some capacity with the Club.
Paul Johnson
20 Posted 21/02/2014 at 22:48:46
Peter, I love the sentiment but we are striving to win the league and I'm not too sure that Tony is built that way. I could be wrong but we don't owe players from this era a great deal as they have secured their financial future.
Denis Richardson
21 Posted 21/02/2014 at 23:05:34
Lot of sentiment here for a good servant but let's be honest here, we're not a charity! The guy is not realistically going to get on the pitch for us again and he's definitely not a Martinez type player.

Time to wave goodbye in the summer, we have Coleman and Stones who can play that position so Hibbo would be 3rd choice at best.

We cannot be paying seven figure sums to third choice players with zero sell on value. Better to sign a younger hungrier player on a fee and see if they can develop instead.

Hibbo, Vellios and Gueye to go in the summer, probably frees about £4-5M a year in wages!

Ian Riley
22 Posted 21/02/2014 at 23:57:32
Sorry it's time to go!

In what other job would you give a contract £500,000 plus a year to play less than ten or five games a year? He could do a decent job in lower leagues, the pace of Premier League games is too much (sadly Osman struggles with more than 60 mins). The position demands so much more now: pace, passing and goals... he would struggle on all three.

A great servant to our club, whom have rewarded him over many years. He may take Duncan's role as coach next season at under 18s level or may carry on playing. When I saw him play at centre half a few times, I thought he done a decent job.

Whatever he decides, good luck to him, but no more contracts from EFC,

Best Wishes All

Anto Byrne
23 Posted 22/02/2014 at 00:23:07
After his long layoff with injury, he looked like a player reborn from the couple of runs he has. He has a lot of experience, is a solid defender and is a steadying influence on younger players. We don't need to discard him just yet and he still needs to score his first goal I think?
Si Cooper
24 Posted 22/02/2014 at 00:19:03
If we are looking at a potential third choice full back, is it worth investing in a newcomer at this point in time?

I don't know if we have a youngster in the junior teams who looks like they will make the grade in a year or so but, if we do, then I would give Hibbo the extension to cover the gap, especially as he can cover the centre of defence as well.

Other factors are his relative cheapness if he is willing to halve his wages (I don't think he is on a relatively high salary as it is) and whether he is a good influence in training as well, helping by showing a good example and passing on the benefit of his experience (a lot of good coaches weren't the most gifted players). If he is hoping for a coaching career, moving elsewhere for regular football isn't necessarily to his advantage.

Ultimately, this is the manager's call as he has a view of the 'whole picture' regarding what he needs in his squad for the next season. Probably too early for this speculation anyway as it could all change with injuries and transfer activity in the summer anyway.

Matt Traynor
25 Posted 22/02/2014 at 09:01:45
I think it's well known he's not a top earner at the club. (I hope his agent has other clients as well!)

I think Si makes a good point - if there's someone in the ranks who's not too far away, a one-year deal makes sense. Tony's had a good solid career, got his carp farm in France, and seems happy with his lot. It's not sentiment at all, but if he's finally over his injuries he's definitely worth a place in our small squad as he could, at a push, fill in anywhere across the back.

Brian Garside
26 Posted 22/02/2014 at 11:47:20
Must be kept. Back up to Coleman and then coaching the youngsters (if he tones down the accent). Keep the soul of the club blue etc etc........
Ralph Basnett
27 Posted 22/02/2014 at 16:09:21
No brainier, we are skins, he is past it, thank you and goodbye.

Fans should consider we give enough loyalty to be able to say move on, these players nowadays have good careers with excellent salaries and we should worry more about the future and not hold on to the past.

Thank you Hibbert, you were a good servant but Everton need to move your salary elsewhere!!!!

Roman Sidey
28 Posted 23/02/2014 at 13:06:14
Should have been culled in 2006. Was never going to be a player to get us back into the top four. Peter Conley, whilst I agree with your assessment of him as a dying breed of decent guys who play football, I think if his passion was so high, he would have pushed for a move a few years ago when he realised he was never going to be the first choice right back at the club.

If he gets a new contract at the club and it's in a playing capacity, it will show that all this talk of ambition this season is really just lip-service to the fans.

Colin Glassar
29 Posted 23/02/2014 at 14:08:55
Despite being a massive Hibbo fan, can we really afford to pay him a further contract out of pure loyalty to him? Let's be honest, Seamus is number one, then Stones. I'm sure there is probably a decent RB in the Ressies who could do a job as well.
So Hibbo, thanks for the service, and memories, but I think it's time for you to go fishing and enjoy your retirement.
Peter Lee
32 Posted 04/03/2014 at 22:26:06
Stones played right-backat Anfield. The result wasn’t down to him but his performance was abysmal. The only choice on the day in Coleman’s absence was TH.

Sounds like hindsight but said so before the game. Stones should have played centre-back instead of a nowhere-near fit Alcaraz.

Not a right-back for me so, until he proves otherwise, contract for TH. Nothing to do with gratitude/sentiment.


Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads

© ToffeeWeb