FA urged to “stand up for Everton”

, 25 February, 27comments  |  Jump to most recent
The Football Association are being urged to intervene in the ticketing controversy over Everton's allocation for next month's FA Cup Quarter Final at Arsenal.

Based on the recommendation of their Safety Advisory Group which cited safety concerns for their decision, Arsenal opted to make just 5,186 seats available to Everton's fans for the tie at The Emirates Stadium, well short of the 9,000 seats, or 15% of capacity, provided for in FA rules.

Now, both Merseyside-born Member of Parliament, Andy Burnham, and supporters group, The Blue Union, have joined Liverpool Major, Joe Anderson, in making separate calls for the FA to ensure that Arsenal honour the governing body's recommended allocation.

Mr Burnham, MP for Leigh, wrote to FA chairman Greg Dyke in a letter obtained by the Liverpool Echo in which he says: "The views of the Ground Safety Advisory Group are important and should not be ignored, but I fail to see how a club with years of experience handling big fixtures, in a purpose built stadium, cannot devise a solution to meet the ticketing rules.

"It is also worth saying that any Safety Advisory Group will be more influenced by the views of one club.

"In situations like this surely there is a role for the FA to broker a more independent view, fair to both sets of supporters?"

The Blue Union, meanwhile, in an open letter of their own to the FA, question the SAG's decision, describing it as "a flagrant disregard for the rules of the competition, and sets a dangerous precedent that could impact supporters in the future.

"Everton has a rich history in the FA Cup, something that Evertonians are immensely proud of. The ties, either home or away, are some of the most highly anticipated fixtures of the season... [T]he decision that the Safety Advisory Board has come to is at best poor treatment of the biggest stakeholders in the competition of one of the best supported Clubs in the country, and at worst an obvious attempt to give the home team a greater advantage."

Though Arsenal made the full 9,000 allocation available to Coventry City for a Fourth Round tie at The Emirates earlier in the season, they offered both Tottenham Hotspur and Liverpool significantly reduced allocations in the Third and Fifth Rounds respectively.

 

Reader Comments (27)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Ciaran Duff
1 Posted 25/02/2014 at 21:37:57
Good to see that we are not taking this lying down. I think it will be really important to have a big away support for this game. At this stage, it is looking like our biggest game of the season.
Kevin Tully
2 Posted 25/02/2014 at 21:52:16
Don’t forget Joe Anderson’s letter (Don’t know if this is elsewhere on the site?)

I am extremely concerned that Arsenal FC have taken a decision to dramatically reduce the away fans’ allocation for the FA Cup Quarter Final. I will declare my own interest on this matter immediately – I am an Everton season ticket holder, but as Mayor of Liverpool I will fight for fairness for people of this city under any circumstances. I am also concerned that the FA have been overwhelmingly silent in their response to the announcement.

I fail to understand how the FA can sanction a move contrary to its own rules, at a time when the FA Cup is struggling to preserve its reputation as a truly special and inclusive cup competition with a long and proud history. Surely what represents all of its finest traditions and the aura of the cup most is the atmosphere generated by highly partisan crowds which are boosted by the 15% regulation and which go some way to levelling the playing field for the away side.

I respect that the views of the Safety Advisory Group are critical in respect of stadium safety issues and cannot be ignored. I also absolutely condemn the use of flares or any other pyrotechnics at matches. I am not for one moment convinced however that the stadium management of a premier league football club, with years of experience of handling domestic and European cup fixtures cannot devise a solution to ensure that the FA’s 15% rule is maintained, especially in a modern, purpose built stadium such as the Emirates. I am aware that the stadium stages concerts where dancing and alcohol consumption are a regular feature in the upper tier, yet football supporters are treated so appallingly. This is deplorable given fans’ importance as a key stakeholder in the success of the game, a fact which the FA regularly appears to overlook.

Arsenal’s aggressive and draconian stance that any previous transgressions by a mindless few will result in 4000 fans being penalised is blanket discrimination and is the time for the FA to step in rather than absolve itself of any responsibility.

Surely the obvious solution, if the Safety Advisory Group are so concerned about the upper tier allocation, is to identify a block with seats in the lower tier of the stadium? It seems not just to me and the majority of Everton fans, but also to casual observers, that Arsenal are seeking to use this excuse and their obstinate refusal to co-operate, to reduce the away support and thereby gain a competitive footballing advantage, with the FA’s apparent endorsement. The decision to not reduce Coventry’s travelling support, yet to do so when Premier League opposition such as Liverpool, Tottenham and Everton comes to town only reinforces the suspicion that safety factors are not the only motive behind their decision.

By being weak-willed and failing to impose its own rules the FA are acting against all of its equalities obligations but also foolishly shooting themselves in the foot by conspiring to denigrate the very traditions and spirit that embodies the FA Cup.

I urge you to meet with the management of Arsenal FC as a matter of urgency to find a solution that ensures compliance with the FA regulation. Failure to show any leadership on this matter will only further the perception held by the majority of football fans that the FA is spectacularly out of touch with the needs of the modern supporter and has total disregard for the role that fans contribute to the game. It seems abundantly clear to me that if the FA can’t be bothered to uphold the spirit and respect the value of the FA Cup, then don’t cry if fans do the same.

I look forward to hearing from you.

Yours sincerely

Joe Anderson
Mayor of Liverpool


Mike Connolly
3 Posted 25/02/2014 at 22:01:30
If there is an issue with safety, Should Arsenal try and play this match at another venue Like the non leagues clubs use to in the Fa cup. Best solution I can think of is: Arsenal reduce their capacity to roughly 35,000 this would leave the allocation they gave us correct at 15% or near enough.

That would leave everybody happy, us and the safety officers. Apart from Arsenal who are not just happy with home advantage but want to steel the away fans ticket. It just goes to show you the desperation of Arsenal to get silverware.

Andy Griffiths
4 Posted 25/02/2014 at 23:35:57
I just read the letter on the Echo site, and something struck me. The rule from the FA website is:

"In all matches preceding the Semi-Finals, the Visiting Club shall have the right to claim up to 15% of all accommodation for which tickets are issued providing these tickets are in a fully segregated area, and subject to the following regulations...."

If I work what I think the maths are:

60,000 Seats in the stadium;
Tickets are being issued for 56,186 seats, as supposedly 3,814 seats are not safe for supporters;
Therefore Everton supporters are entitled to 15% of 56,186 or 8,427 seats, assuming that somewhere near that number can be supplied in a segregated area

The key piece is the text "15% of all accommodation for which tickets are issued" – not 15% of the total capacity of the ground.

The way I see it, the rules are designed so that home and away supporters both suffer from seats which for some reason can't be used for a game. Even if we accept the recommendations of the safety advisory team, I don't understand why the vastly reduced number?

Jamie Carroll
5 Posted 26/02/2014 at 00:18:55
Arsenal do not want to be outsung by Everton fans at this game.
Karl Masters
6 Posted 26/02/2014 at 00:24:10
There appears to be one missing voice of complaint here - the Club themselves! I am sure that the FA will say that it notes the comments of a Mayor and a fans’ group, but as EFC aren’t complaining they don’t feel it is necessary to act.

Deafening silence from Bill, Robert and co. and although they mentioned in the announcement of the allocation they had pressed for more it sounded more like a whimper than a roar.

Good on Joe and Everton fans for kicking up over this. Arsenal have behaved disgracefully and should not be allowed to get away without it being publicised at least.

James Byrne
7 Posted 26/02/2014 at 08:43:43
Well done to Joe Anderson for raising this issue; not just for the supporters of Everton but also Liverpool FC and the other hard working, dedicated supporters of football clubs around the country.

This is a truly dispicable tactic by this horrible football club to bend and break the rules that are quite clearly set out by the FA and are signed off on by all the clubs in the competition.

If the clowns at Arsenal / SAG have concerns regarding the away ticket allocation amount, then the whole stadium should be reduced to match the percentage that away club has been given by Arsenal.

The problem we have here is that we probably all know what the outcome will be when dealing with the FA and combined cronies in and around London. I’m sure the FA would "jump in" if the likes of Manu or Man City referred to this tactic of reduced ticket allocation for a London based Prem club.

One other area of complaint that might be / should be considered is the Emirates group themselves who are a primary stackeholder of Arsenal FC.

Jim Bennings
8 Posted 26/02/2014 at 09:42:29
Stay at home and watch it on the telly lads at least when we do our self destruct job in the second half you can throw the remote through the screen.

Mike Keating
9 Posted 26/02/2014 at 09:40:05
Those who know their history will not be surprised by the shenanigans of Woolwich Arsenal who moved north of the river to attract better crowds and bribed their way into the First Division following the First World War on a vote which saw them leapfrog Spurs and Barnsley.

http://www.spartacus.schoolnet.co.uk/ARSEnorrisH.htm

This is covered in more detail in David Conn's wonderful book The Beautiful Game – in search of the soul of football – which every fan of the game should read.

BTW, it is also worth looking into the role played by LFC in the vote which kept Chelsea up and sent Spurs down at the resumption of post war footie... No surprises there either.

Aman Kanji
10 Posted 26/02/2014 at 12:00:13
Well written "Joe Anderson"
About time someone stood up to the FA cronies... Hope we get a couple more thousand
Frank Duffy
11 Posted 26/02/2014 at 13:38:47
I agree the Club is too quiet. It needs to say something to both Arsenal and the FA. It should not leave it to the fans. It will never do it but it should refuse to play the game until it gets a satisfactory answer from the FA and/or Arsenal.

Matthew Williams
12 Posted 26/02/2014 at 15:04:26
We should not play the game! The Gooners, The FA & the rest should be well & truly fucked over on this, SOME CLUB needs to make a stand on this & all football injustices once & for all. The telly companies would be up in arms... but things would change & it would've been EVERTON FC who started it! Yet another first for our great club... time to stand up Billy lad!
James Royston
13 Posted 26/02/2014 at 15:46:56
We are all aware of the silence from the FA and for some strange reason Everton FC...

Question: Does anyone know how many tickets were allowed for this season’s Premier League fixtures for us and the other "big clubs"??? Were they in the same now apparently "dangerous & prohibited" area...???

Michael Kenrick
14 Posted 26/02/2014 at 15:58:14
James (#579), I’m not sure where you’ re going with this comparison but the allocations of away tickets for Premier League games are much lower – I think around 5% of stadium capacity, so less than the reduced number that Arsenal are allowing for the FA Cup Quarterfinal.

Matthew (#569), part of me feels the same way (although solving all injustices in one go? Probably never gonna happen!) — but I’m sure the sanctions against a refusal to appear for the game would be massive and possibly final. Massive fine... Thrown out of the competition for multiple seasons... maybe even points deduction or expulsion from the Premier League too, as this is run by the FA, not the Football League. Maybe Matt Traynor or another who studies the regs has the answer to this one?

James Royston
15 Posted 26/02/2014 at 16:21:42
I did not realise the Prem allocation was so low... Presume this must mean that the dangerous area is used by very safe & lily-white Arsenal fans on other occasions including the concerts...
Brian Wilkinson
16 Posted 26/02/2014 at 16:36:59
So am I assuming a flare can only be fired from an upper tier of a stand and no matter how hard you try, you will not get a flare to go off in a lower tier?

We all know this is just a smokescreen (no pun intended) and even so isn't that why stewards earn their money? — to search fans and any fans caught misbehaving get ejected from the ground.

If the FA do not act on this, it will further kill off the passion of the FA Cup.

Brent Stephens
17 Posted 26/02/2014 at 16:52:40
Andy #474 - very perceptive. If sound reasoning, I hope Everton are wise to this.
Matthew Williams
18 Posted 26/02/2014 at 17:11:12
Maybe your right, Michael, but we're way too nice as a club both on & off the pitch. I would rather take a shitload of sanctions than be shafted by all & sundry & maybe one day all involved with the great game of footy will thank us for being THE club who made a stand for doing the RIGHT thing!
Jimmy Kelly
19 Posted 26/02/2014 at 17:19:28
Andy, I see what you mean but that is actually where the problem lies. Arsenal will be selling tickets for those seats – but only to their own fans. They are not closing that section, just saying it can't be used by Evertonians.

The whole thing is a joke, if it's not safe to have Everton fans up there then fine, I accept that. What I don't accept is that those same fans could not be located on the lower tier. If Arsenal fans have to move and tickets have to be sold for less than they would usually be worth then tough - they should have thought of that before they built a stadium which could not comply with FA regulations.

Patrick Murphy
20 Posted 26/02/2014 at 17:37:05
Arsenal have played 10 FA Cup Ties at the Emirates in the past four seasons and the lowest official crowd recorded is 58,359, which is about 1600 below capacity - the highest FA Cup attendance recorded was for the visit of Blackburn last year when 60,070 people attended and for Liverpool's visit earlier this year 59,801 people attended. Something awry with the maths in my opinion as Arsenal don't seem to have lost out on revenue.
Patrick Murphy
21 Posted 26/02/2014 at 17:57:12
Ah well 5,000 tickets it is then!!!

The Football Association has outlined the process for deciding away ticket allocations at FA Cup with Budweiser ties.

A spokesman for the competition said: "FA Cup rules allow for an away allocation of up to 15% of the home stadium.

"However this is subject to the local Safety Advisory Group (SAG) agreeing to that ticket allocation number.

"The SAG is made up of services such as the local council, police, fire brigade and the club amongst others and issues the stadium’s health and safety certificate.

"In regards to the Arsenal v Everton Sixth Round tie at the Emirates on Saturday 8 March, the local SAG has chosen to allocate just under 9% to the Everton supporters.

"Although we appreciate the disappointment in the SAG not granting the full 15% allocation, it is nearly double the amount of tickets that Everton would have received for the Premier League fixture at the Emirates back in December.

"The FA does not have any input into the decision of the SAG and cannot change it as this is a matter of health and safety."

Jamie Barlow
22 Posted 26/02/2014 at 18:05:22
What has how many seats we received for the league game got to do with anything?

Who’s going to sit in the 3,814 seats that we don’t get? Arsenal fans who are going to sit still and clap politely if they score?

It’s all bollocks and the club should fight it but won’t. They’ll accept it and move on without making a fuss.

Jamie Tulacz
23 Posted 26/02/2014 at 18:32:28
Tit for tat it is then... Spineless idiots at the FA, I expected no better though!
Gerry Quinn
24 Posted 26/02/2014 at 18:37:18
I wanted us to win so much, but would be happy to settle for a draw and tell them ALL of our away end at Goodison is closed for "safety" reasons. The FA? Spineless, gutless and boring bunch of non-persona!
Frank Duffy
25 Posted 26/02/2014 at 18:41:31
Just a joke. Let the FA have to deal with EFC who say we will not play the game unless we get our full allocation of 15%. Someone has to make a stand. The game is just there for the SKY 4 and TV. I despair. Come on BK and RM stand up for the fans for once. You 2 will be ok to get into the game.
Darren Hind
26 Posted 26/02/2014 at 19:06:23
The Mayor of Liverpool hits nail squarely on the head (fair play to KT #454 for getting it up there, I hadnt seen it)

I have always had a respect for Arsenal FC. They always seem to do things with a bi of little class, but their conduct here ( and throughout this cup campagne) has been disgraceful.

The FA cup has broken many Evertonian hearts down the years, but we have never fallen out of love with it, no fanbase has supported or respected the competition more than us.

I remember knocking chelsea out at Stamford Bridge on penalties a few years back and to this day, I still believe the incredible backing we gave the players is what dragged them over the line. I didnt get to our replay at Sunderland a couple of years back, but I was told our boys drowned out 40,000 Mackems and we romped home. I've lost count of how many times we've turned up in our thousands down the years to roar our team on, So there 's one thing we can all be certain about, whether it is 5,6,7,8 or 9 thousand, the Evertonins lucky enough to get in will not let the rest of Evertonia down.

I hope RM will make all the players aware of how wronged we feel. Hopefully it will provide the extra little spur to knock the disrespectful fuckers out.

Mike Keating
27 Posted 26/02/2014 at 20:35:16
Okay – get on to Doc the Knob Savage this weekend on 606 and ask why the FA are so spineless.

I as asked a similar Q after the semi against the Shite as in why we were set up for a 12:30 KO at Wembley. Same Q and a few more regarding 'safety restrictions' at The Emirates.
Don't be surprised if the Man of Bronze talks a load of bollocks or (more likely) does not respond. My email and phone call got no response. If all ToffeeWebbers phone 606 on Saturday after the WHU game – what will they do?
COYB


Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads

© ToffeeWeb