Season › 2013-14 › News
Martinez concerned over potential use of video technology
The IFAB are set to convene in Switzerland this weekend to discuss potential rule changes, including the introduction of NFL-style video replays to resolve contentious decisions during matches.
While accepting of the recent introduction of goal line technology, Martinez is wary of adding another layer of technology-assisted decision making to football.
"I think goalline technology is a massive, massive help to referees and I think referees need as much help as they can get," the Spaniard says in the Liverpool Echo.
“But having replays for the fourth official, I don't think that goes with the nature of the game. I don't think the fourth official has got the perfect environment to do that.
“If you can imagine, it gets a bit chaotic in the technical area and on top of that you are giving the fourth official the opportunity to review the last action? Maybe we'd need an extra camera just to see the reactions in the technical area. That could be a different sport!”
With the number of controversial or erroneous decisions affecting the outcome of matches as high as ever, there is pressure from some quarters to give match officials more tools to eliminate costly mistakes but there is also concern that the character of the game could be altered by too many interruptions for video analysis.
Reader Comments (27)
Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer
2 Posted 28/02/2014 at 19:42:03
Cricket and Rugby have it and it could be argued that it has enhanced them as entertainment. I can understand that all levels of the game cannot have this technology in place but surely at the top level there is no excuse for not having it in place.
Goal-line technology may help on a couple of occasions a season, but at least once a week a dodgy decision is made in the Premier League alone - it may hold the game up but no longer than it takes for a goal celebration or a player feigning injury all that has to happen is the fourth official speaks directly to the referee and the referee can alter his decision accordingly.
Penalties and red cards are the obvious candidates for reviews. Offside would probably not be worth covering as it happens so often, nor yellow cards or run of the mill fouls.
3 Posted 28/02/2014 at 22:02:14
4 Posted 28/02/2014 at 23:35:32
People supporting technology are being sucked into their thinking by the big financial interests in the game. As such it's gone over a century without technology. Ignore the big business interests and let's just love it for what it is -- a sport. Deliberating over decisions will kill it.
5 Posted 01/03/2014 at 00:10:13
I can't imagine he would be opposed to more technology, provided he game wasn't slowed down too much, if it led to the right decisions; we lose more of these than we win.
6 Posted 01/03/2014 at 00:58:50
Football – tackle: I don't see how objective. Football – handball (which, for many commentators who just don't get it, means intentional hand to ball)... no thanks.
Even penalty decisions – a referee would practice "defensive refereeing" meaning giving a penalty each time (or not) and getting corrected each time.
Would be such & stop sport would ruin it.
I would agree if it would be having say 2 decisions you can appeal each half (be it penalty or sending off).
The problem is that almost every decision is subjective.
7 Posted 01/03/2014 at 04:33:08
As for disrupting the nature and flow of the game it would only take a couple of weeks of red carding the cheats to make them cut it out. Now they know they can get away with it with impunity but if they are 100% certain to be caught it will be stopped completely.
8 Posted 01/03/2014 at 04:06:40
It works well in other sports, let's sit back and take a look as if this came out in 1975 a random year pick and how our history may have changed,
The fourth official is taking another look at Hamiltons goal, over ruled its a goal and Everton will now face Man Utd in the 1977 fa cup final.
Controversy in the first all Merseyside milk cup final, after a review Alan Hanson has been red carded for a deliberate handball and Everton have a penalty.
Unbelievable in the dying seconds Don Hutchison scores the winning goal at Goodison after being disallowed the 4th official over ruled the first decision.
What an amazing comeback Everton are heading for the champs league after Duncon Fergusons initial goal was disallowed but after a review overturned and the goal given.
Dirk Kyote is joining Tony Hibbert for an early bath after a reckless two footed challange seen by the 4th official, he won't be alone as his colleague Carrigher joins him after pulling Lescott down in the box and a penalty to Everton.
A resounding 4-2 win for Everton against Newcastle, thankfully technology showed the Everton player was not offside for the initial first goal disallowed, and the ball had crossed the line for the second disallowed goal.
After the dominance against Spurs, Everton win a penalty after Coleman was brought down in the box, missed by the ref but not the 4th official.
Just a bit of banter but blimey how we could have done with technology 40 years ago.
9 Posted 01/03/2014 at 04:48:15
Any instances where their star players was out injured for a long period of time, I'm not talking two or three at a time, just one will do.
Every team had a player out at some point but it just never happens over the Park, Keegan, Dalglish, Rush, Gerrard, Suarez the list is endless but not one was out for a long period of time.
Not got enough space for our casualty list but the likes of Big Nev, Ratters, Snowy, Heath, Parkinson's, Bracewell, the list is endless.
I am beginning to think like the rest that they are from the dark side and made a bargain with the devil.
Either that or we moved some gypsies on in the seventies and one returned to pee in the four corners of Goodison Park.
I could handle some of the hard luck stories we've had if it evened out a little over the park but for all the past dodgy decisions we've had against them, I would take technology for sure, at least then it would give us a fairer crack of the whip, and hopefully the divers will be a thing of the past.
10 Posted 01/03/2014 at 09:29:32
I'm now convinced that the likes of Liverpool and Chelsea in particular actually have a section of their training programme dedicated to "gamesmanship / cheating" etc - the world famous Stevie G trailing leg technique? WTF is that all about and why have so many Ref's fallen for it over the years. How many fucking penalties have that shower of pricks had this season alone!
They both just seem to be so good at it and it works every time to kid referees. I also think that some of the Ref's fall for the antics a lot easier and the intro of further video technology can only help.
My only other concern would be the use of the 4th official doing the verification - this should be done by someone independent of the officials and done away from the technical area.
11 Posted 01/03/2014 at 09:50:58
Rugby and cricket are much more complex games, and replays make them even more interesting to watch (especially cricket if you love the science of the game) but it will utterly ruin football if you use replays for everything.
Referees get it right 9 times out of 10, and linesmen (yes that's what they're called because they run the line) get it right less but so what? If everything went to a replay then you'd have silent stadiums with bored supporters watching a load of drones wander around the pitch.
LEAVE THE GAME ALONE! It has more than enough silly rules as it is and it's those silly rules that make it interesting/controversial/worth talking about.
Arrrgh!!!
12 Posted 01/03/2014 at 10:01:05
(BTW I firmly believe that Nathan Blake fouled Southall in the build-up to that goal - but that wasn't seen either, so a case of 2 wrongs making a right!)
13 Posted 01/03/2014 at 10:00:18
I would also make the person in control of the technology to be in a sound proof box away from the hurly burly of the touchline, so he can not be harassed by opposing managers and players while making the decision.
14 Posted 01/03/2014 at 10:08:43
It certainly wouldn't break the game up because the decision could be made whilst Stevie G et al are haranguing the ref. I would agree with James that decisions should be made by a fifth official locked in a booth somewhere so he can't be influenced by people around him.
If this technology could only be used to determine sendings off, penalties and dodgy goals then it would improve the fairness of football no end. For example, if an offside is tight let play run on for a few minutes, if a goal is scored the offside can be reviewed and a decision made: onside goal stands; offside no goal restart with a goal kick.
15 Posted 01/03/2014 at 12:14:18
What would you have to talk about on here or with your mates, it or at work if everything was cut & dried? I dread the day it's taken out of human hands.
16 Posted 01/03/2014 at 17:44:21
17 Posted 01/03/2014 at 17:58:14
18 Posted 02/03/2014 at 00:27:14
Football was played for nigh on a century without even TV replay technology and games were full of reffing errors – but no-one cared (or for that matter even realised). And if are looking at how different outcomes would have been if reviews had existed in the past then we wouldn't have had the most glorious match in our history, the 66 FA Cup Final, since in the first half we were denied both a blatant penalty by Springett on Young and scored a perfectly good goal that was flagged offside. Without these decisions, we'd have cruised home against Wednesday.
20 Posted 02/03/2014 at 11:57:05
21 Posted 02/03/2014 at 17:43:43
22 Posted 02/03/2014 at 18:15:18
An ideal world would see the use of cards for simulation as they've written into their own rules being used as punishment. I won't hold my breath but if they want to clamour for technology then bring it on, fuck this "clever play" or "Spanish penalty" or whatever crap the red shite pundits want to call it each week.
23 Posted 02/03/2014 at 20:48:52
24 Posted 03/03/2014 at 08:49:20
In football the 4th official could make a decision within 15 seconds after two replay angles if it was obvious. Non-obvious 'dive or foul' decisions he just goes with the ref's decision.
The best sporting comparison is the last World Cup where (I think it was) Argentina scored an offside goal. You could see the linesman holding his flag up while he looked at the big screen replay, his face apologetic as he knew within seconds he'd called it wrong but wasn't allowed to change his mind.
The talk of how we shouldn't break what isn't broken, I'm sorry but big teams getting the advantage due to crowd pressure has had it broken for years. (If you look at the 'Hugh Dallas coin-throwing incident' in Scotland alone, it shows it.)
25 Posted 03/03/2014 at 09:33:03
The vast majority of contentious decisions are made when the ref has blown up, therefore, this need not cause a delay to the proceedings. However, if there is a decision where play continues the manager wants to appeal, he could use his 'strike' to do so to the fourth official during play and if upheld the game gets pulled back whatever the state of play at that time.
Even if a team is attacking, they would not have been doing so had the appealed decision been correctly applied so lose nothing by pulling the game back. If the decision was already correct, the game continues and ref is only informed of a lost strike for the appropriate manager.
Simples!
26 Posted 03/03/2014 at 09:28:06
Whilst I'm not necessarily in favour of it and I do see the talking points caused by refereeing decisions as being part of the spirit of the game, I think the march of similar technology in other sports is now making football look behind the times.
For me, the best way to do this is to follow the model seen in Tennis and Cricket of a limited number of 'challenges' afforded to each team, probably set this at a max of 2-3 per game.
I'd give this control to the manager who has the advantage of being next to the 4th official anyway and allow them to either press a button or alert the 4th official if they want to challenge a decision. If they get it wrong (as will be most appeals, then they lose an appeal, if they get it right they keep the same number – or equally you have 2-3 and when you've used them, they are used).
I think the ball would have to go dead for this to be used and if say the appeal was for a free kick not given, the play would continue until a natural break and then if correct the ball would have to be returned to the point where a free-kick would've been given.
The decisions could be:
> Fouls given/not given (latter is most problematic)
> Penalty appeals
> Yellow/Red cards
> Corners given/not given
I'd envisage the main use case to be relating to fouls and other controversial decisions in and around the box (a time at which the ball is often booted out of play or in the keeper's hands/back of the net anyway.
At the point of review, an AV box shows the 4th official / the ref / a dedicated TV official some slow motion replays of what's occurred (would need to keep the managers/players away from this so maybe something happening in a room off the pitch would be best) and a decision is provided within an agreed timeframe (say 2 minutes). You could even show the footage being reviewed on the big screen as they do with tech decisions in cricket/tennis and then announce the verdict. Play then continues appropriately.
If handled right then this could actually add a little extra strategy and stimulate further talking points (it wouldn't be every decision, only 5-6 big ones in a match), when do you use your appeals vs hold onto them? Which decisions were beyond the appeal system, etc?
Naturally there'll still be edge cases, when different people see different things on the video (issues such as intent in tackles or just interpretation of the rules means there will always be a grey area) and if it's inconclusive I'd say the ref's view wins. However, at least if 2 separate officials have ruled against an incident there's more chance you'll get the right decision and there'll be some release for frustration for managers/players and a few less howlers changing games.
27 Posted 04/03/2014 at 15:33:35
Talking points and contentious decisions are good for football. It's the common-man's game the world over and should be kept as such. Undermining refereeing decisions by over-ruling them? You might as well do away with the officials on the pitch entirely and just have a big fucking hooter go off when something happens.
I've never heard such a load of old rubbish in all my life.
28 Posted 05/03/2014 at 10:14:47
Just remind us all, who the hell do you actually support? It clearly isn’t one of the teams habitually on the receiving end of the majority of points-costing decisions.
Add Your Comments
In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.
Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.
1 Posted 28/02/2014 at 19:40:53
There are lessons to be learned I think from RFU and RFL that have worked in those sports.
Don't think Martinez is exactly disagreeing, but clearly there's a lot of interest in this. FIFA seem to have gone from zero tolerance towards a more sensible conversation....I think they had no option.
Personally, I think video replays, viewed by an appropriately located and qualified TMO, would add value.I for one do not think things balance out over the course of a season and feel refs need far more help (that's being diplomatic).