Season › 2013-14 › News
Lukaku makes the breakthrough to seal double over West Ham
Everton 1 - 0 West Ham United
Romelu Lukaku stepped off the substitutes' bench to score the decisive goal against West Ham for the second time this season, earning Everton a hard-fought but deserved victory at Goodison Park.With the Belgian striker just back from injury and suffering from a mild chest infection, Roberto Martinez selected the Steven Naismith to lead the line, preferred Gerard Deulofeu to Kevin Mirallas on the right and kept Ross Barkley on the bench as he continues his gradual return to fitness.
The Blues began with intensity and purpose and Naismith glanced a header wide from Leon Osman's flick-on and then forced a save from Adrian at the near post with a powerful effort from the angle.
The Hammers barely got a look-in in the first 20 minutes but, as has so often been the case this season, Everton were battling to turn their dominance into clear-cut chances. A half chance opened up for Deulofeu with 24 minutes gone but he fired wide and just before the break the Spaniard jinked his way past three defenders before whipping a shot narrowly wide.
Everton came out of the interval in enterprising mood and the second period was barely a minute old when Leighton Baines and Steven Pienaar combined superbly down the left and the England international's cut-back found the South African perfectly but he rolled his shot agonisingly off the face of the post.
Pienaar was presented with an almost identical chance by Gareth Barry five minutes later but this time he skied over.
That was followed by West Ham's only sustained period of pressure in the game but Martinez checked any momentum they might have been building by introducing Lukaku in place of Osman with an hour gone. The striker added a more powerful and pacey dimension in the final third as Everton fed off the home crowd's urgency to build some pressure as the game progressed.
Further genuine goalscoring chances remained at a premium, though, and when Sylvain Distin spurned one from a free kick with an awkward connection that bounced wide it looked as though the familiar failing of the final ball was going to let the Blues down again.
Everything came together superbly, though, with 10 minutes left when they once again built down the left flank, Baines's square pass found Lukaku lurking in space by the penalty spot and he stroked the ball home with a confident finish.
Barkley made a late cameo and crashed a shot narrowly wide as Everton finished the stronger and comfortably closed out the game to notch their first League win since a month ago, and three points that move them back into 6th place in the table.
Full coverage: ToffeeWeb Match Reports
Reader Comments (96)
Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer
2 Posted 01/03/2014 at 18:56:47
There were enough opportunities today for shots from 18-20 yards but no, they'd rather keep passing than shoot.
Delighted with the result and delighted with the play up to the box. Some excellent chasing down and movement.
Just hit the damn thing!
3 Posted 01/03/2014 at 18:49:07
Looks different but the end product not much different or exciting than the Moyes way.
4 Posted 01/03/2014 at 18:50:26
Martinez needs plenty of money to spend come summer....over to you,BK.
5 Posted 01/03/2014 at 18:53:02
I don't know how much we really learnt today other than we know we are never going to get many goals from this current midfield and that Lukaku is our only genuine true goal threat. The target for him now though is to sustain some serious consistency — and not just when he feels like it.
I disagree that Pienaar was awful today. I actually thought he was very busy today... at least when he got on the ball, there was some urgency; yes, his final ball/shot was at times poor but at least he was willing to have a go.
McCarthy was outstanding today and I reiterate that he is as good as any defensive midfielder in the League.
The major headache for Martinez is how does he get this team scoring more goals? Sometimes our approach play is fantastic but too often it has me tearing my hair out: we can at times be so bloody frustrating. It was a win though and probably given the scoring problems and West Ham being hard to beat, 1-0 was about all I expected really.
I know we are not the kind of team that is free scoring so any narrow wins will be gratefully appreciated.
Damn that Redshite... Ruined my day again, I am really getting concerned about these winning it now, I think they are probably two big wins against City and Chelsea at home from winning the bastard League. What a situation it could be when Manchester City visit Goodison for our last home match this season... We could be in a position where we are all wanting City to win here because I just cannot see this Redshite team falling away somehow.
6 Posted 01/03/2014 at 19:01:55
When we're in full flow, he is invariably the one making us tick and the trust that Baines has in him is what makes the partnership so effective.
7 Posted 01/03/2014 at 19:02:20
Stones for me did very well. A young lad, still learning but so advanced for his years. An important part of our young player development.
Nais again ran his bollocks off (how many pairs does he have?) and caused their defence some worry. Good team player.
Great to see Lukaku back on the score sheet.
A WHU fan said to his mate on the way out "I expected better atmosphere at Goodison but it was embarrassingly quiet". Let's hope for more atmosphere at Wembley!
8 Posted 01/03/2014 at 19:05:56
Tough game today and a brilliant 3 points; Lukaku took his goal well today.
James McCarthy — Man of the Match; truly outstanding.
9 Posted 01/03/2014 at 19:04:20
It's a fair point you make. I really believe now that the only way we can make a proper challenge next season is by investing in better top-draw players who are going to be able to kill teams off. That will take a hell of a lot of money... money that I am not certain we have in all honesty.
We can big up Barkley, Deulofeu, etc but we are going to need a lot of money; otherwise, like last season and probably this, you are going to be looking at pretty much the same.
I think Martinez could potentially try a different formation but he seems dead-set on this one where it dictates the ball but limits our scoring record because we tend to over-egg the passing play where it does little harm to the opponent.
Our hopes this season will pin on how Lukaku can perform between now and May and can he register 15 plus goals? Whatever we say, he is our only genuine potential regular goalscorer.
The aim for the remainder of the season has to be to better last season's win total and maybe better the clean sheet tally, plus better last season's FA Cup Quarter Final with a Semi-Final at least.
Let's see what happens next week...
10 Posted 01/03/2014 at 19:12:02
I don't think Roberto will dump either of them yet.
11 Posted 01/03/2014 at 19:12:52
More than anything though, I would love Everton go all the way, and do it not just for themselves, and the fans, but for Bryan Oviedo.
14 Posted 01/03/2014 at 19:51:29
15 Posted 01/03/2014 at 19:52:26
16 Posted 01/03/2014 at 19:51:59
17 Posted 01/03/2014 at 19:57:26
18 Posted 01/03/2014 at 20:13:20
As someone pointed out, you have to remember that both he and Osman are getting older and they will eventually be phased out over the next 12-18 months you’d think. For giving Pienaar stick, we need to realise that there are hardly a million better options on the bench.
I thought McGeady might have started today actually but perhaps he’s not yet where Martinez wants him, fitness wise, in fact we are possibly looking at next season with McGeady, and the same could be said of Deulofeu and Barkley who lack the consistency and still look very rough around the edges at times.
19 Posted 01/03/2014 at 20:07:06
Jim, I think Roberto sticks with the current formation because he hasn’t a viable option at the moment. I thought Gibson was going to be pivotal this season as a possession based gameplay is made for him and I wonder had he been fit if he and James would have been our CM with Barry filling in when needed. Barry has done well but the future of our CM surely has to be James and one other – not Barry.
Gibson is one possibility if he gets and stays fit, with Ross another if his play matures and he becomes a safer bet not to give away possession. That would then allow a Number 10 type player to go just behind the main striker, whoever he may be.
I see significant progress but our first team is still too old. Stones may well cement a place for next season but we cannot have a midfield comprising Barry, Ossie (smashing player though he still is) and Pienaar. Inject some youth in their place and watch the pace of our overall game improve!
20 Posted 01/03/2014 at 20:35:19
I agree with some points you make.
Martinez makes it sound like Gibson will still be a key member of the team when or if fit again.
I agree that Barry will not be the future; it’s a big ask for him to play every game this season and I believe it would have been between Barry and Gibson vying to play alongside McCarthy.
I think Barry is a better user of the ball than Gibson, that’s just my own opinion, but I still rate Gibbo highly – it’s just a shame he has always seemed dogged by injuries.
It’s a little hard to get too excited about his return until he can actually prove his body is capable of playing the same amount of games that Barry has played this season.
21 Posted 01/03/2014 at 20:32:26
22 Posted 01/03/2014 at 20:41:40
23 Posted 01/03/2014 at 20:48:05
What we need to ask is: What happens if he suffers another setback after that? I am praying for his fitness but just cannot stake much money on it happening. Could we ever see the goalscoring, long-range shooting expert version of Darron Gibson which we first thought we were getting when he signed from Man Utd? And which was backed up further by what looked like a typical Gibson goal on his home debut against Man City which we won 1-0 that night?
I just wonder really what happened along the way to that type of player... Is it just injuries that held him back, turning him into a more disciplined, defensive water carrier, or was it Moyes’s will to have him that way? Could Martinez convert him back to the Gibson that liked to get forward and shoot?
24 Posted 01/03/2014 at 20:45:41
Pienaar always wants the ball, rarely hides and his interplay with Baines is breathtaking at times, all it needed was a striker on the end today which thankfully came with Lukaku.
I don’t get the criticism of Pienaar, but thankfully, the man that matters, Martinez, obviously rates his contribution. Cracking player but sadly undervalued by some.
25 Posted 01/03/2014 at 21:06:31
We still find it difficult to play cute little forward passes, for players to run onto into scoring positions. You need the players to make those runs and I think that’s where were lacking at the moment. It’s definitely an area were we’ve room for plenty of improvement.
26 Posted 01/03/2014 at 21:32:57
27 Posted 01/03/2014 at 21:45:26
I thought we did well today against a team that made it very hard to find an opening. We managed to find a way to win — that’s what matters. West Ham have huge side, if no-one noticed, so pumping crosses in the box is not really a good tactic. They also fill the box when in defence which makes it easy to cut low crosses.
We need to give some credit to other team’s tactics. We won against a team that will frustrate a lot of teams, ask Chelsea. Good enough for me. 3 points and still a long way to go. COYB
28 Posted 01/03/2014 at 21:26:17
I didn’t see their game but saw the (shameful) recap of the goals afterwards, with Jamie Redknapp pointing out subtleties of play that ordinary folk may not have noticed (or which ordinary people could patently see was hugely outweighed by outrageous fortune).
Suarez may have made a good run but Sturridge spurned the opportunity to play him in and the ricochet off the defender to Suarez’s feet was a huge slice of luck. The second goal required three Southampton players to play as if they were back in the under-12s. The ’definite’ penalty only occurred because Suarez moved his leg sideways to make contact with the defender’s leg. (I accept attackers do not have to actively avoid contact, but initiating it is undoubtedly cheating.) I will be interested to see whether other commentators have a different perspective than the Sky lot today (including an embarrassingly personality devoid Theo Walcott).
I genuinely haven’t noticed much coverage on TV that I would categorise as overwhelmingly biased but I felt like putting my boot through the TV so nauseating was the love-in with Rogers: "You’re doing great. Keep it going."
29 Posted 01/03/2014 at 21:49:29
So, I guess it’s the FA Cup or nothing.
30 Posted 01/03/2014 at 21:50:59
However...to beat a well-drilled WHU who just won four on the bounce can’t be bad. Stones was excellent, I thought, as was McCarthy. Pienaar wasn’t terrible, he’s just a bit slower than he was. I said last week that the run-in might be quite good with our injured and unfit players coming back and let’s hope it continues that way. Shame that Liverpool also won but there’s no way they will catch Chelsea... is there?
31 Posted 01/03/2014 at 22:05:40
Certainly the TV obsession with them is stomach turning and why the TV stations are so keen to have ex RS players passing comment is beyond comprehension.
Almost without exception they are a bunch of smug,biased and bitter people who can’t give credit to anyone else.
I’m starting to get hung up myself just typing this!!
32 Posted 01/03/2014 at 22:18:46
33 Posted 01/03/2014 at 22:30:10
34 Posted 01/03/2014 at 22:07:11
Pienaar is also the player most responsible for our slow tempo, he always stands on the ball, waits and waits. There was one incident today that I was interested to see if it got mentioned on TW. Last season Fellaini got a shit load of abuse for turning his back on the ball against Wigan, Pienaar did exactly the same today but, for some reason, it’s okay for him.
35 Posted 01/03/2014 at 22:31:20
We have a lot to do but there could be a few twists yet.
36 Posted 01/03/2014 at 22:13:16
If you remember when he left for Tottenham, we were terrible: so predictable and flat, side-to-side then hoof, the ball was like a hot potato. As soon as he returned, the quality of football went up. Phil Neville commented that the level in training went up a notch, and we went on a great run in the league and got to Wembley.
If he had the missing ingredients mentioned above he wouldn’t have been signed for £2.5 million and played for us for so long.
38 Posted 01/03/2014 at 22:58:46
"We can’t control what they do or don’t do"
Well, we can’t now as we don’t play the rs this season.
However, we can start from 2014-15 by not bending over at their place and giving them 4 points a season.
2 points less (i.e. a draw home and away this season) and they’d be 5th tonight — not 2nd.
Let’s hope Brenda has a Rafa-style "FACT" list against Mourinho and they implode.
Worried.
39 Posted 01/03/2014 at 23:14:01
By the way, £100k fine for Pardew and a formal warning by NUFC.
Ha, ha, ha, ha, ha. Classless get. Anger management classes, I think.
40 Posted 01/03/2014 at 23:05:11
All players have weaknesses. If they did not they wouldn’t be playing for us. I think that Barkley will become a great player and hope it will be in central midfield where he could be better than any of them. I hope McCarthy will mature and increase the positive things he does, like those strong forward runs bring the ball out of defence, but I don’t thing he will replace what Osman and Pienaar have provided.
41 Posted 01/03/2014 at 23:17:20
We on the other hand have a chance of a cup and a day out parading it in Liverpool. I would love that. Just watched the Arse against Stoke... Jaysus, they don’t like it up ’em. If we are in their face from the off and play a high tempo game, we can do them. An FA Cup and finishing ahead of the miserable one will do me for Year One of the Roberto Revolution. COYB
43 Posted 01/03/2014 at 23:34:29
45 Posted 02/03/2014 at 03:08:57
Suarez will be gone in the summer, he’s the one that has got RS to where they are and not deadhead Rodgers. In fact, it’s fortunate in my opinion the dickhead let Carroll go.
Without Suarez and, whether we like it or not, Gerrard, they are not even average side — they are relegation material.
This a false dawn for them; next season, Roberto will succeed — he might still make it this year, it’s not over yet.
You read it first here on TW.
46 Posted 02/03/2014 at 03:30:15
Barkley’s early season form has deserted him but at least we know he has the talent and can be a match winner on his day. I think the game today was all about the final ball; you can run your socks off as much as you like but we have seen players like Andy Johnson and Beattie busting a gut and getting nowhere. Lukaku is a natural striker, quick strong and lethal given the service. Feed the Rom!!!!
47 Posted 02/03/2014 at 06:17:08
48 Posted 02/03/2014 at 09:27:16
Oh, and whilst we are at it, lets cancel out any points that could possibly be attributable to input from Gerrard.
How about including Sturridge in your suspension of truth - and then THEY really would be in the shit ! I knew JH was suffering dementia but never realised he had any interest in Merseyside affairs and was still such an imaginative thinker !
Keep it up, old boy, and you’ll be back on MOTD in no time!
49 Posted 02/03/2014 at 09:43:22
50 Posted 02/03/2014 at 09:51:34
51 Posted 02/03/2014 at 10:04:27
52 Posted 02/03/2014 at 10:17:51
Mirallas must've spilt Martinez's pint or something.
53 Posted 02/03/2014 at 10:31:15
We need a fully fit Barkley back.
I must say I thought Stones was NOT the man of the match - he’s still, understandably, quite shaky.
Given the size of our squad, I believe we still need Heitinga and Jelly - unless RM had made permanent replacements for them in January. We’ve lacked proper penetration up front now for 2-3 months, in my view.
Does anyone know what’s really wrong with Ross?; he ought to be playing or injured - but seems instead in some sort of no-man’s-land.
Unless Ross returns full of beans, I fear we’ll finish 6th or 7th. Naismith and Osman are not enough for CL qualification, not even close.
54 Posted 02/03/2014 at 10:37:52
55 Posted 02/03/2014 at 10:33:42
Having a striker like Lukaku upfront will obviously improve any team but it shouldn't be the defining factor between whether a team can score or not. Our team shouldn't fail to work as soon as there isn't a 20-million-pound striker up front because there won't be one next season. As we have seen with Lukaku as well, if you don't give these top strikers something to be interested in every game, they quickly become disilllusioned and float through games.
The creativity of the side has got to improve and you can't just lump it all on Pienaar and Osman. It has to start from the back. Stones was better on the ball yesterday at getting it into the midfielders than Jags has been all season. Jags always looks for Coleman. Distin meanwhile always looks for Baines who is again too slow in picking a ball forward, he too often plays inside or backwards.
McCarthy and Barry are then naturally too conservative in their passing. The attacking three midfielders are much like a backline in rugby constantly getting slow ball off their lumbering forward pack. if its slow and backwards then they can never get the ball on the run or with momentum. What back-lines want is quick ball, hard and flat to run onto. Our attacking midfield want quick ball, forward, ahead of them so they can run onto it. This transmits forward to Lukaku who wants the quick ball in behind the defenders for him to run onto.
At the moment, our attacking players are receiving the ball stationary, with their back to goal (which is why Pienaar may have to keep checking back all the time). Class attackers like Mirallas and Deulofeu are being shut out of games because they can't produce ridiculous magic every time from a standing start to beat two markers. Contrast this to Liverpool who even make players half as talented like Sterling, Henderson and Moses look great in attack because they get early balls on the run with only a few defenders to beat.
As good as Barry has been this season, I'd only keep him on as a squad player. McCarthy plays well as a holding mid but doesn't have the passing guile to play attacking mid. Have him as the anchor then have one of Gibson, Barkley, or the boss 15 mill creative mid the board will buy in the summer (ha!) next to him and lest get some quick ball forward to our attacking players. Then the great mystery of why top class players like Lukaku, Mirallas, Pienaar, and Deulofeu don't hit the net very often might finally get solved.
56 Posted 02/03/2014 at 10:45:51
57 Posted 02/03/2014 at 10:54:30
The fact that both Pienaar and Osman are so lightweight and can be out-muscled regularly puts more strain on the two holding midfielders, and when Barkley plays too, it results in lost possession. We were opened up too easily by a poor WH side, and if Lukaku had not popped in the late goal, these posts would have been a lot more damning.
58 Posted 02/03/2014 at 10:54:02
As for McGeady - he isn't fit yet but I think we have a good player there. He has lightening feet and has the ability to come inside, something Deulofeu seemingly refuses to do. I too was surprised that Mirallas never came on, particularly when we were chasing a goal. But how refreshing having 4 genuine threats to being off the bench.
Also I have to say Lukaku looked bang up for it. I sense he's back to where he was in the first third of the season. I hope so anyway.
60 Posted 02/03/2014 at 11:00:42
I think he is one of our best players but he has to learn to play for the team and not for personal glory and I suspect Roberto has dropped him partly for that reason and partly because Gerard will only get his form back with an extended run of starts- 15 minute cameos will not do this for him and as Anto# 294 rightly says,he came on stronger as the game progressed.
61 Posted 02/03/2014 at 11:04:54
The goal yesterday was a classic example: Pienaar to Baines... cross... goal.
One thing about him is he never goes hiding, we are hearing a lot of our lack of creativity yet when one of our players tries something and it doesn't come off he gets slated.
I think the biggest issue in our lack of goals is playing a formation that employs two defensive midfield players whose strengths are not creating chances. It has certainly increased our possession of the ball and actually made us a better team defensively. Strange considering Roberto is seen as an attacking manager.
One other encouraging note is the number of goals we score late on. I think that is 12 in the last 10 minutes of games.
62 Posted 02/03/2014 at 11:35:19
I thought yesterday was a good time to take Mirallas out as since the Villa game he has'nt really performed all that much.
Its hardly like he scores bags of goals from open play anyway so we were never going to miss that side.
Martinez probably thought yesterday was the perfect game to bring Deulofeu back into the fold and who can disagree?
How is he meant to get up to speed by playing the last 10 mins every week?
He needs more starts and whilst he will be on the bench next week, he should in my opinion start against Cardiff the following week.
63 Posted 02/03/2014 at 11:45:51
Phil,
Pienaar is a good player, but I don't think anyone can reasonably dispute his 'dawdling'... It loses us momentum.
I also don't think he's in our best XI.
64 Posted 02/03/2014 at 12:02:24
65 Posted 02/03/2014 at 12:06:37
A good result yesterday but the league has lost interest for me now as I can't imagine us breaching the gap. It's all about next weekend.
66 Posted 02/03/2014 at 12:00:28
I agree Mirallas has his faults in terms of team play but he's got 6 goals and 4 assists so far this season. Barkley needs to improve in this area as well but its his first season and he's still developing.
67 Posted 02/03/2014 at 12:34:45
How many has Pienaar laid on a plate for Baines to provide the assist?
Facts schmacts.
68 Posted 02/03/2014 at 12:38:04
You always trot out the same rubbish when someone mentions stats. They may not be perfect but they're better than just a simple opinion.
This season, Baines has one assist in the league. The one from yesterday's game.
69 Posted 02/03/2014 at 12:53:16
In that situation it's a case of somebody to unlock their defence. Different ways of doing that (one is to shoot on sight a bit more!). I didn't think Delboy had a great game yesterday but what I did like was the couple of occasions he got to the byeline and cut a fast ball across behind the defence. Just aching for somebody to get on the end of it.
70 Posted 02/03/2014 at 12:47:15
You see it as waiting for Baines; I see it as passing on responsibility. Pienaar might be involved somewhere in the build up but he's never the one putting the ball in the net or the one playing the final (most important) pass.
There's plenty of times when he's the player in the best position to cross but he won't. Pienaar hasn't crossed a ball in the last two games, it could be longer but I've only made a point of counting in the last two games.
71 Posted 02/03/2014 at 13:00:08
I can't recall ever saying anything like that regarding stats in the past.
Baines only one assist. Well he must be rubbish too then. Get rid.
Get Barkley out too, he's not got many assists. In fact this is easy. I don't know why I bother watching the games when I could just read the Opta site and learn all I need to know from there.
72 Posted 02/03/2014 at 12:59:17
I'd like to see more of McCarthy bringing it out and running at the heart of the defence; he has got it in him, let's hope that, in time, he will have the confidence to take the responsibility and get on the front foot more often. It is these little details that either result in quick penetrative assaults or meandering frustration.
73 Posted 02/03/2014 at 13:12:40
It was a frustrating game against a West Ham team that has conceded few goals all season and is on its best run in the top flight for nearly 9 years. It was always going to be a 1-0 or 2-0 win at best.
Let's just focus on giving a monumental performance next Saturday at Arsenal and pray that we can at the very least get them back up here for another crack at them in the replay.
Whenever I think of FA Cup Quarter-Finals televised live on ITV, I keep getting nightmares of Wigan last year, and then Middlesbrough away in 2002, both 3-0 down at half-time.
Please put in a big display, Blues.
74 Posted 02/03/2014 at 13:18:28
I saw it once today from Delboy, give and go and we created a scoring chance. Why???
75 Posted 02/03/2014 at 13:34:26
He seems to have everything: he's fairly quick, he's very good in the air, he reads the game well, the timing of his tackles is excellent, and above all else he is absolutely phenomenal on the ball, which, in the modern game is absolutely imperative, particularly when playing the style of football that we do. He's 19 and let's be honest, he pretty much dominated Andy Carroll the entire game.
Yes, he will make some mistakes and his positional play will obviously improve a lot in the future but for him to be at the level he currently is at the age of 19 is astounding. Would not surprise me one bit if he ended up playing for somebody like Bayern Munich or Barcelona in the future. (Let's hope he stays with us for most of his career though!)
He is the future of this great club along with Ross Barkley and other exciting young lads that we will have to bring through in order to compete with the rest.
76 Posted 02/03/2014 at 13:15:38
You've just given a great example of what I was saying! Instead of putting forth some kind of reasoned argument you've just created a load of straw men to shoot down.
I never said Baines was rubbish or we should get rid but he hasn't had a very good season so far. I suspect that is to do with the contract situation and now that is resolved I expect his level of performance to get back to where it was. The stats back up the fact that he hasn't had a great season to date.
I made the point that Barkley was a young player and was developing. However Pienaar has seen better days and has had a poor season so far. I still think he has a role as a squad player but he's not good enough to be in the first choice starting eleven if we want to get into the top 4.
77 Posted 02/03/2014 at 13:49:09
78 Posted 02/03/2014 at 13:11:12
Stats should be taken with a pinch of salt. Remember Nevilles pass completion rate? One of our best. Utterly useless player, though.
The number of assists by Baines is only a small part of the story. What about the opportunities he made but which weren't converted? Is that his fault they weren't assists?
In terms of assessing players, stats can only be a minor part of it.
79 Posted 02/03/2014 at 13:58:14
80 Posted 02/03/2014 at 13:43:59
Paul is quite right, he has developed the "throw your head to the heavens' gesture when a pass goes astray and stand there in dismay rather than immediately re-engage appropriately. Just watch his inability as a midfielder to track an opponent"s offensive runs and his challenging of opponents is often no more than standing some three or four yards away in a "jostling gesture". For a player with good ability to manipulate a football when in possession, his shooting ability is really on the whole atrocious – what would we say if a joiner we had hired could not actually hit a nail cleanly into a piece of wood?
Yes, he does at times "combine well with Baines" (which I think, however, is often overhyped); yes, he does have good ability to twist, turn etc; and yes, he can "link" well... but I simply find that the rarity of the incisive penalty-box pass, the often lamentable attempts on goal, in other words the often lack of personal, crucial end product from a supposedly key figure in the attacking creative midfield unit, makes Pienaar at present somewhat less than his advocates maintain.
81 Posted 02/03/2014 at 14:03:52
Lukaku is back at his best, suddenly we had a dangerous match changer to give the ball to. Before he made that great assist, Baines had played really well. Pienaar was doing his best too and got better in the second half. McCarthy played really well, Gareth too, although his foul could have got him sent off; he was lucky.
I expected little from Stones, but he made a solid contribution and looked more reliable; he increased my confidence in him by 100%. Great save from Tim. He's still looking like our first choice even though Roberto is playing Robles in the Cup. Did you notice Browning on the bench? Preferred to Garbutt.
Naismith did his best to keep up to seven defenders at a time occupied. I'm sorry though, I think he's nowhere near the quality of striker we need in this league. Quiet game from Seamus, he tried to come forward when he could. McGeady? Didn't do anything wrong. It's far too early to make any meaningful judgement isn't it?
Overall, we should be pleased with the guys as well as relieved. Onto next Saturday then!!!
82 Posted 02/03/2014 at 14:21:29
I can only conclude that these people have never played a competitive team sport (and I'm not including doubles at darts), and fail to be aware of contributions made by players. Either that or they were reading the paper while the game was going on.
Pienaar had a reasonable game. He drove forward whenever he could, linked well, and almost had a goal. As for gestures — so what! All players have their idiosyncrasies.
83 Posted 02/03/2014 at 14:26:41
Jagielka is a great defender, but his distribution is shocking. We will have to sign another centre-half soon, as Distin probably only has one more season in him at this level. We really have the makings of a fantastic young side; Barkley, Stones, McCarthy,Coleman and maybe even Lukaku!
84 Posted 02/03/2014 at 14:17:36
I totally agree; I have been saying this all season about his ability to just stay on his feet!
Don't get me wrong: Pienaar is one of my favourite players but this season I have never seen a player age so quickly.
When Martinez came in with his possession football, intricate triangles and one-twos, I thought Pienaar was a dream for this system... but the lad can't seem to find his team-mate with a sideways pass of 6 yards!
His partnership with Baines – in my opinion, once the best in the league – is now practically non-existent.
And yes, all this looking up to the heavens, blessing himself and 'god is great' business is all well and good when he's on top of his game but, at the moment, it doesn't cover the fact that we are carrying a passenger in the side.
I bought my son this season's shirt with 'Pienaar' on the back which is how much I normally enjoy him as a player.
85 Posted 02/03/2014 at 14:39:07
86 Posted 02/03/2014 at 14:47:28
I cannot fathom how some supporters cling onto the memory of a player and fail to see how they play now.
87 Posted 02/03/2014 at 15:33:41
We lose out so much because our players have been taught for too long to play fair and have respect for the ref, and don't dive or cheat. All the teams that win anything do it. The authorities and the media do nothing to stamp it out and encourage it.
Pienaar is a very good player for us. He always shows for the ball, he has no pace but he does have quick feet and either holds on to the ball, or gets us a free kick. He's adept at keeping the ball in very tight situations and his link-up play is generally top notch. Added to that is that he's probably one of the hardest working players we have.
Think I'm wrong? Remember when we sold him to Spurs? Moyes only realised after he was gone, how vital he was to how we play. Thats why we went back cap in hand, paid a heavy transfer fee and gave him the 10k / week extra he wanted to get parity with Arteta.
Osman is not at the same level and that is why he gets more flak than Pienaar.
88 Posted 02/03/2014 at 17:52:41
Or possibly you're a better judge of football than Roberto Martinez?
89 Posted 02/03/2014 at 18:00:20
90 Posted 02/03/2014 at 18:44:47
91 Posted 02/03/2014 at 20:03:57
Baines doesn't understand the overlap, he just runs forward every single time whether it's on or not. The amount of times I've seen Pienaar cover him and slow an attacker down for Baines to get back is too numerous to mention.
Contrast this with Mirallas who 5 times out of ten won't even be on his flank, the other 4 he won't bother to track back, and then the one he does and puts in a tackle everyone's applauding him for his work rate.
Pienaar, like any player, has his limitations. All I know is that, in the post-Arteta era, it was barely worth turning up if Pienaar wasn't playing. The alternatives of Bilyaletdinov or Gueye were atrocious. As soon as Pienaar returned, we got some fluency back into our game. Equally this season when he returned against Hull we immediately started playing better.
Undoubtedly he has to take a share of the blame for failing to create chances (although he has been near the top of our assists charts the last few seasons), but equally he has to take credit for our ability to dominate the ball. I keep hearing he's a bad passer yet his interplay with Baines is far more complex and difficult than McCarthy's or Barry's crab like shuffling from one side to another. I'll always applaud a player who fails when trying something rather than one who just goes safety first all the time.
92 Posted 03/03/2014 at 06:21:45
93 Posted 03/03/2014 at 06:38:42
94 Posted 03/03/2014 at 08:17:46
'... a completely errant full back ........ Baines doesn't understand the overlap.'
Fair do's for defending Pienaar but your opinion on Baines is quite frankly ridiculous.
95 Posted 03/03/2014 at 08:16:00
Good to see 6th place now qualifies for the Europa League. I know some people feel that we should aim for the Champions League or nothing but I think we should try and get back into the Europa league for at least the next 2 to 3 years (with some decent runs obviously!) to build our Uefa ranking coefficient back up. We are now tied with Stoke for 82nd place and will fall even further if we don't get into Europe this year. Wouldn't mind following a path similar to Atletico Madrid and I'm sure Roberto is looking to implement a similar model.
96 Posted 03/03/2014 at 08:50:47
We should have got a penalty when Pienaar was tripped in the box. I love Pienaar, great character, great professional who's had to deal with a lot in his life. True Gent, as a lot of EFC layers are to..
He as also unlucky with a cracking curler which came off the post. We couldn't make more of the rebound.
Geri NEEDS to PASS sooner – at times. As per Barkley – we don't want to beat the creativity out of them though. As per Shamus's statement, "We just need to keep winning and see where we end up." Fourth is gone, but fifth is a definite possibility.
RM has had a lot to injuries to deal with this season, and Traore's injury is NOT what he needed. The style of play is dictated by these injuries. Bryan Oviedo is our most crucial miss – he is the type of player Barkley and Geri should be looking to emulate.
Confident we can grab a win this Saturday. On the point... LOOKING FOR 2 SPARES? (rent@tsce.co.uk)
97 Posted 03/03/2014 at 09:14:37
What frustrates me about Roberto is I thought we would be getting a flexible attack-minded manager but we look like a one-trick pony who everyone has sussed out and theres no Plan B. What about trying different formations especially getting two up top by playing 3-5-2 or 4-4-2 just to shake things up?
98 Posted 03/03/2014 at 15:41:23
Martinez will not budge from our back seven, Howard included. Apart from the Anfield debacle when Distin was missing and Jags pushed the line up too high, we've been a pretty solid unit all season. Still only 23, McCarthy will continue to improve but his options to move further forward will always be dictated by whoever occupies the right wing spot. If it's Mirallis or Delboy, he'll be careful about committing himself, but if it's Naismith or McGeady he'll know they will cover. These days it's all about small details and that's one of them.
As for getting into the box. Like Barcelona, we'll continue to pass or dribble our way in a la Delboy. Man U hit 81 crosses the other day and they all came to nothing. Defences are very organised and Martinez sees dribbling as a way of opening things up. He reckons he got this idea from a guy named Bielsa.
Lukaku opens things up by just being on the pitch. It takes two men to mark him and players with the pace and awareness of Mirallis and Barkley will get more opportunities to score.
Much will depend on injuries. If we can keep a settled side for a number of weeks our performances will improve.
99 Posted 03/03/2014 at 17:24:20
Talking about dementia I think I mentioned Gerard. In my eyes the jury is still out on Sturridge, he has good season followed by a couple of bad ones and The rat boy is still making everything happen with his runs and positioning.
I believe Martinez has a better all round team. Perhaps your youthfulness indicates your knowledge of football. My be in another 30 years when it improves you will considered for MOTD.
100 Posted 03/03/2014 at 17:48:37
101 Posted 03/03/2014 at 18:23:20
Afraid I have too agree with your one trick pony remark. Basically the formation RM uses is defensive, it has to be to accommodate two holding midfielders.
Possession football is great but when your main threat up front is being contained you need midfield players who can run beyond HIM.
We don't, at this moment have enough firepower to worry the likes of Arsenal, so as far as our cup run goes I fear the worse.
102 Posted 03/03/2014 at 19:23:53
Add Your Comments
In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.
Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.
1 Posted 01/03/2014 at 18:35:10
I'd love to know how Roberto thinks we're progressing, and what he feels the squad needs in the summer.
Personally I'd dump Pienaar and Osman. Pienaar is just dreadful, truly awful.