Martinez effusive over Stones's future

, 6 March, 58comments  |  Jump to most recent

Roberto Martinez has been singing the praises of John Stones as he considers the young defender for Saturday's FA Cup tie at Arsenal in Phil Jagielka's expected absence through injury.

The Spaniard reiterated in his pre-match press conference today that his Captain is "very unlikely" to be fit enough to play in the quarter-final match-up which will again leave an opening in the line-up next to Sylvain Distin in the heart of the Blues' defence.

Stones made his fifth Premier League start of the season against West Ham last weekend and, along with Antolin Alcaraz, is in contention for the all-important trip to the Emirates. His manager feels the 19-year-old will up to the task if selected, saying that Stones is "as good as it gets at his age."

Martinez told evertontv: “I know how good he is and what a special footballer he is. He is going to have an incredible career.

“He is one of the most significant young players we have in the English game and I have seen him grow a lot in the last few months. He is someone who takes aspects of the game on board very quickly.

“He is a complete centre-half and in the modern game you need to be able to play from the back and have good distribution. John has that.

"On top of that, he is good in the air, very comfortable in one-v-one situations and he can defend within a unit. He is as good as it gets at his age.”

After giving supporters a glimpse of his confidence with his audacious penalty against Juventus in the International Champions Cup last summer, Stones has shown remarkably maturity and composure in the games in which he has played so far this season.

“John...has had two of the toughest tests you can have in the Barclays Premier League, playing against a striker like Andy Carroll, with his physicality and power in the air, and playing at the Britannia Stadium against Stoke," Martinez continued.

“Both challenges were answered with two outstanding performances and John has been working really well. That's what's important."

 

Reader Comments (58)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Dick Brady
1 Posted 06/03/2014 at 15:39:05
Stones has done great so far. Made a couple of mistakes but which young defender hasn’t? Stones looks the real deal and he should have a big future in front of him.

He’ll need to be on his game against Arsenal though if Jagielka remains injured. Lot of pressure on Stones but I’m hopeful he can handle it.

Brian Carey
2 Posted 06/03/2014 at 16:05:51
Did you hear that Wilshere is out for about 6 months. But Arsenal have lots more better midfielders than him.
Kevin Rowlands
3 Posted 06/03/2014 at 16:15:03
Have no problems with this, in fact it wouldn't surprise me at all if he's a regular starter next year, he's that good.
Sam Hoare
4 Posted 06/03/2014 at 16:13:17
I would say Arsenal at the emirates will present a much sterner test than donkey Carroll at Goodison.

There aren't many 19 yr olds good enough to start for Premiership clubs and it's very exciting that Stones is almost there. I reckon that it will be another year or two at least till he is ready to be a nailed on regular but if he gets the nod against Arse then I have faith that he won't let us down. Having said that I'd possibly pick Alcaraz if he's fit whose experience could be preferable in a huge cup game.

Al Reddish
5 Posted 06/03/2014 at 16:16:08
At least with Distin alongside him he has a chap that has experience and pace to get out of most situations. I really hope he gets the nod over Alcaraz.
Brian Harrison
6 Posted 06/03/2014 at 16:16:25
I think John Stones looks really classy at centre back, and he showed against Carrol last week that he can handle the physical battle as well. I guess with both Jags and Distin playing so well it has been hard to replace either.

I just wish RM wasnt in the press everyday praising one of our players, yes its nice to hear positive comments but just not everyday.

Dick Brady
7 Posted 06/03/2014 at 16:23:40
Alcaraz got destroyed by Liverpool (Stones did too but you could argue he was playing out of position). I’m not sure I would trust Alcaraz in another big game. I would probably pick Stones to play if Jagielka is injured.
Raymond Fox
8 Posted 06/03/2014 at 16:18:01
Sorry, but I'm not convinced he's ready to face Arsenal at the Emirates!

Nothing against the lad, and he will no doubt prove to be a good Premiership player in the future.

I notice that RM did put in the proviso for a 'nineteen year old' and conveniently didn't mention the rs. game!

If he starts the game, I hope I'm proved wrong, it could be RM doesn't have much choice anyway given that detailed news on Alcaraz seems to have dried up again!

Raymond Fox
9 Posted 06/03/2014 at 16:37:55
Dick, all our defenders where destroyed at Anfield.

Steven Telford
10 Posted 06/03/2014 at 16:32:47
I echo those concerns about Antolin Alcaraz.
While I am very happy with Roberto, the "Martinez-isation"of our defence is - IMHO - something to pause for breath on. I hope he gets it right, because some of those past Wigan score lines were pretty shacking.

Kevin Rowlands
11 Posted 06/03/2014 at 16:42:37
The difference between our defense at Anfield and on Saturday is Arsenal don't have Sturridge and the rat to trouble us, I think Distin and Stones will be able to 'manage' Giroud comfortably.

Btw Steven, what exactly is the "Martinization" of our defense, if you take out the Anfield derby (where we had injuries and players out of position) I would say the defense has been solid, our main problem this season has been scoring goals, not letting them in.

Raymond Fox
12 Posted 06/03/2014 at 16:51:40
Alcaraz has become the fall guy on here for the Anfield debacle, for me Jags and Stones were worse than Alcaraz, with Baines not much better, go back and watch the match again, that's if you can bear to!
Wayne Smyth
13 Posted 06/03/2014 at 16:57:02
Dick, I'm interested that you pick on Alcaraz out of our players for having a shocker against the RS. What in particular did he do that cause you to single him out?

The worst defensive mistake I remember in that game was when Jags gave a simple 5 yard pass straight to them near the halfway line causing us to concede a goal.

I don't actually remember any particular player being bad that night; many - including Alcaraz and Jags - were returning from injury and lacked match sharpness. Virtually the entire team played below par.

Linda Morrison
14 Posted 06/03/2014 at 17:09:39
Wayne is correct the Anfield fiasco was due to a number of factors, including Roberto gambling on playing people who were not fit and we copped for it.
All the players had a bad game, not just Alcaraz so it is unfair to single him out. I'm trying to think if there was anyone who performed to their best but can't.

Whoever plays with Disitn on Saturday will do their best. Arsenal, like Everton, have suffered due to injuries. Arsenal, like Everton, know the FA Cup is their chance of some silverware No one is giving us a chance and I think we will do better against Arsenal than a lower league team who we always struggle against

Harold Matthews
15 Posted 06/03/2014 at 16:52:03
Terrific prospect, despite continually turning his back when attempting to block a shot head-on. Didn't enjoy a good game against the fast Welsh U21 number 9 but I've seldom seen a centre back with such technical ability. Right now, circumstances are pushing him into the jungle a bit too early but he's getting the competitive experience he needs in order to progress. Hopefully, with Distin's guidance, he'll have a decent game against Arsenal. Wenger will be sure to aim his troops straight at him and it won't be easy. Fingers crossed he plays out of his skin.
Kevin Rowlands
16 Posted 06/03/2014 at 17:31:24
Just looked up our recent fixtures and Alcaraz hasn't even made the bench since the Anfield derby, is he even fit? I think he'd be more of a risk than Stones would, what's he played, 3 games all season?
James Stewart
17 Posted 06/03/2014 at 17:43:28
Stones is classy. Will be 1st choice centre back before long
Wayne Smyth
18 Posted 06/03/2014 at 18:19:17
Don't recall too many centre backs of his age playing in the top flight, never mind looking so calm and composed.

He has all the physical, mental and technical attributes to go straight to the top and I'd not be surprised to see him as a first choice England centre half in a couple of years.

Talking of young players with potential, I'd not mind having Schmeichel in goal for us next season. Out of contract at Leicester I think and he looked absolute quality last night....and having watched Nathan Redmond play for the U21's last night, I was hugely disappointed we didn't pick him up for £1.5M when he went to Norwich. Looks vastly underrated and very quick and direct.

Wayne Smyth
19 Posted 06/03/2014 at 18:24:48
Kevin, Alcaraz has not been fit. He had "muscle fatigue" after the anfield game, apparently because he'd played 3 times in a week having just come back from injury.

Should be available for selection at the moment. Happy to see Stones given the nod; he's probably not far off where Jags and Distin are and needs the pitch time to improve.

Phil Walling
20 Posted 06/03/2014 at 18:49:01
Stones has done okay when called on this season but certainly looked no better than Shane Duffy when he came in for a few games two years ago.

I wish this manager would let players get on with earning their spurs rather than setting them up to fail with his over the top praise for alright performances.

The expression 'all his geese are swans' comes to mind!

Mikey Waterman
21 Posted 06/03/2014 at 19:03:03
I've got complete and utter faith in the class act that is Johnny-boy Stones. Him and Distin seem to be quite a good, well balanced partnership. Plus, I know distribution isn't the top priority for a defender but Stones' distribution is on another level and genuinely makes a difference in our ability to bring the ball out of defence and use possession well.
James Elworthy
22 Posted 06/03/2014 at 19:30:30
Most defenders this season have been torn apart by Sturridge and the Sewer Rat including Arsenal's.
He looked good against both Cole and Carroll on Saturday and looks assured alongside Distin, he is certainly a far superior passer to Jags and a better player than the injury prone Alcaraz.
Noel Early
23 Posted 06/03/2014 at 19:53:42
People having a go at Martinez for praising a young player, words fail me. Bring back the days of moaning arse banging on about bringing a knife to a gunfight.
Graham Mockford
24 Posted 06/03/2014 at 19:51:52
Personally I think Stones is going to be a better player than Barkley.

I can see the player Stones is going to be, I'm not so sure about Ross. Stones has all the natural attributes to be a top class centre half. Pace, athleticism, good on the ball.

Whereas I'm still to be convinced about Ross. He obviously has something but will that develop into a fully formed central midfield player? For me he still needs to develop the key attribute that all great midfielders have which is vision. Yes he is athletic, shoots off either foot but I still don't see the awareness what is around him. And you can't coach vision.

Kevin Tully
25 Posted 06/03/2014 at 19:54:06
Steven 005 - You say; "While I am very happy with Roberto, the "Martinez-isation"of our defence is - IMHO - something to pause for breath."

Now, whilst Martinez undoubtedly has his faults, it's throwaway lines like this which are really starting to get on my nerves.

There are Two teams in the Premier League who have the joint best defensive record. One is Man City....

Andy Crooks
26 Posted 06/03/2014 at 20:10:31
Not often I agree with you, Phil, but that's a good point. Duffy deserved a run in the side and didn't get it. Last week he scored and was magnificent in an heroic result for Yeovil. So far Roberto has appeared disinclined to have favourites; I hope he sticks with that.

Duffy was behind in his development because of a life threatening injury. In my view, he's ready for the Premier League.

Kevin Rowlands
27 Posted 06/03/2014 at 20:11:26
Phil, if you think Stones is no better than Duffy why isn't he loaned out to a lower division club then? I think I'll trust RM on him and my own eyes, he is a far better player than Duffy and a huge prospect.

As for Barkley I agree with you Graham, he flatters to deceive, one game looks a world beater, next game looks bog average, hopefully the consistency will come as he matures, in fact at this point in their early stages of their careers I would say Stones is way ahead of both Barkley and Del boy.

Steven Telford
28 Posted 06/03/2014 at 20:11:59
Kevin, #007, I thought it pretty self-explanatory, but what I meant by the "Martinez-isation of our defence" is the gradual development of our defence by a man named Roberto Martinez.

My implicit point being, that he has made his stamp on our midfield (impressive), and on our forward line (work in progress), but the least touched part of the team is that of our defence which is very much OFMs – and credit were credit is due, its was our strongest department, whereas at Wigan it was his weakest department.

Tony Dove
29 Posted 06/03/2014 at 20:24:22
Barkley, for whatever reason, is going through a difficult patch. I still maintain he has fantastic potential. To say he has no vision is complete and utter nonsense. He can see a pass that is beyond virtually every other player in the Premier League.
Kevin Tully
30 Posted 06/03/2014 at 20:28:41
Fair enough Steven – It read as if we had an awful defensive record. I think the change has been either Barry or McCarthy dropping in to make a three when Coleman & Baines are getting forward.

I would like to see if more often though! Apologies if I misunderstood your post.

Darren Hind
31 Posted 06/03/2014 at 20:25:05
Alcaraz is a fantastic footballer and will hopefully stay fit long enough to prove himself a great asset to us... but if he was in a three way race with Johny Heitinga and Brian the snail, he would not get in my twist forecast.

I kinda agree with those who think Stones may not be ready for The Emirates; there's only one way to find out. I think I'd give him the nod anyway.

Tough call for Martinez.

Kevin Rowlands
32 Posted 06/03/2014 at 20:31:37
Tony, he might be able to see the pass but unfortunately very rarely makes that pass. Don't get me wrong, he has huge potential.... but 'a bull in a china shop' expression comes to mind a lot of the time when I've seen him play. He needs to make smarter decisions on the field, that's when he's going to start living up to his undoubted potential.
Kevin Rowlands
33 Posted 06/03/2014 at 20:36:20
Steven, I would think and hope that RM is smart enough to realize that you don't fix something that's not broken.
Raymond Fox
34 Posted 06/03/2014 at 20:24:31
I've no axe to grind about Stones, but I think we are getting carried away again aren't we about how good the lad is!

Ross was everyone's boy wonder not very long ago; now he's come back to earth again, chiefly because of his toe injury, and all of a sudden the doubters are appearing!

Both of them need much more time.

Wayne Smyth
35 Posted 06/03/2014 at 20:50:35
When people talk about Barkley not being the real deal, I think they are often confusing form and class.

Before his injury, he was playing consistently well.

After his injury, he was brought back too quickly due to injuries to our other players, and was then played with other players who also lacked match sharpness because of injury. None of our squad have played really well recently. When you look at one players contribution, you need to check how well the players around them are playing before you pass judgement.

He's not a world-beater yet... but he's only 20 in his first season of proper first-team football. I think Stones and Barkley will both prove to be top-quality players, probably among the best of their generation.

And I'll never complain about Barkley shooting (too much). Our players have been guilty for many years of passing the buck rather than taking the responsibility of having a go. Once he gets a couple, the floodgates will open.

Alan McGuffog
36 Posted 06/03/2014 at 20:58:36
I'm certain that I read on a TW thread a while back that Stones is viewed very highly by both the club and the powers that be at the FA... indeed he is viewed as a better long-term prospect than Ross Barkley.

That said, and I consider myself an advocate of football being played from the back, there are times when I wish he would just put his laces through the feckin thing. Mickey Lyons he ain't !

He will be the new Brian Labone.

Simon Hermansen
37 Posted 06/03/2014 at 21:28:33
A 19-year-old with the reputation Stones has got himself has got it for a reason and it refreshing to see such talent given his head in the PL rather than languishing in the reserves.

And no issue with Martinez bigging him up in the press, it's called giving a young lad a shot of confidence and belief before the biggest game of his career.

Paul Holmes
39 Posted 06/03/2014 at 22:05:13
I might get slated on here but I thought Heitinga would be a better alternative to Alcaraz and Stones. I know he’s gone but I would trust him more than the other two against Arsenal. We need a draw and get back to Goodison, but I fear the worst with one of the other two partnering Distin.
Ciaran Duff
40 Posted 06/03/2014 at 22:13:54
Alcaraz looks like a good footballer but obviously not got a lot of pace. I think that he was "let down" by Jags in the Derby. Saying that it seemed fairly obvious that Jags was not fully fit. Apart from giving the ball away to the Rat, there is no way that the normal Jags would be outrun by Ratboy (or most other players).
For the FA Cup game, assuming Jags will be out. Alcaraz is left sided, so it would be unusual to play him and Distin together.
Tom Bowers
41 Posted 06/03/2014 at 22:14:14
There has been a plethora of praise being handed out just recently for individuals within the club and I am not sure why unless it is to boost the team in readiness for the battle on Saturday. It would seem from what has been said that confidence is sky high and that all is well. We all certainly hope so and that the game on Saturday sees a re-emergence of the performance that grabbed a creditable draw last time they were there only this time better. With Delboy back and a fresher Barkley, the signs are that they may get a good result.

My gut feeling tells me that RM may again screw up and put us behind the eight ball by starting Osman. Whilst we survived against the Hammers, I doubt the Gunners will be as easy to compete with in midfield even without Wilshere. I hope I am wrong but Ossie should only be used off the bench, if necessary, as many others have already said.

Steven Telford
42 Posted 06/03/2014 at 22:31:02
Kevin, I am thinking more long term, and age wise, it's inevitable that he will have to tamper/develop it.
Colin Glassar
43 Posted 06/03/2014 at 22:49:05
I am Roberto's biggest fan but I think he sometimes goes a bit overboard with his public praise of our younger players. I think it can put a lot of pressure on some, eg, Barkley, whose form has dipped since his injury and over-use of hyperbole by Roberto. Just let them develop and progress quietly.
James Stewart
44 Posted 06/03/2014 at 23:09:09
Duffy is nowhere near the quality of Stones. Laughable suggestion.
Si Cooper
45 Posted 06/03/2014 at 22:55:40
Stones and Duffy on a par? Not from what I have seen. Duffy never had the pace or the assurance carrying the ball that Stones already displays, and I don't believe he has found those attributes during his spell with Yeovil.

Perspective is a weird thing. Can we really get a good read on the relative abilities of the likes of Duffy and Stones if they are not playing against the same opposition, or with the same team-mates? Saw some highlights of the Wales - Iceland game and Robson-Kanu looked brilliant at times. Maybe he is a late bloomer, but the fact that he has apparently struggled to make it at Reading makes it more likely the Icelandic defenders may not be top-class.

Similarly, a not-fully-fit Alcaraz can't catch a scampering Sewerat and is labelled a cart-horse by some. If he can overhaul Giroud, then he will do for Saturday.

Si Cooper
46 Posted 06/03/2014 at 23:18:58
Any player who gets giddy from a bit of praise from his manager does not have the temperament to succeed as a professional sportsman.

IMO, Martinez 'bigging up' his players cannot possibly have a negative effect on his players; rather than being weighed down by expectations they will at least know that their efforts are greatly appreciated by the man who leads them.

Chris Williamson
47 Posted 06/03/2014 at 23:28:23
Wayne... Last centre half that was this good at such a young age? Tony Adams. Not a bad aspiration. I hope he stays.
Kevin Tully
48 Posted 06/03/2014 at 23:14:18
Steven # 065 - as much a Jagielka & Distin are great defenders, they are not really they type of ball playing centre-half's Martinez prefers.

When Alcaraz had his first few games, you could notice how very comfortable he was with the ball at his feet, when for years it was one touch and hoof from our central defenders, even if they weren't pressed.

John Stones is going to be just the type of player Martinez wants at the back, but it will take two or three years before he will be ready to lead the line.

Some posters have made it clear they would rather see the ball being twatted out of defence, trying to win the knock downs in the final third. That's their choice, but we will be waiting another 19 years for a trophy going down that particular route if you ask me. We have to try and bridge the gap between us and the moneyed elite somehow, lumping it to Fellaini can be a leveller in some games against the big sides, but it will get us nowhere in the long run.

Mikey Waterman
49 Posted 06/03/2014 at 23:31:30
Duffy's distribution is where the serious questions lie. Defending long balls in the championship is one thing but playing under Martinez (and his passing philosophy) in the premiership is another thing entirely. Stones and Duffy are not comparable, I think Duffy may have a decent career but John Stones is on another level in terms of current quality as well as future potential, I am absolutely certain of that.
Mikey Waterman
50 Posted 06/03/2014 at 23:40:30
Kevin #079 - absolutely brilliant post - completely spot on. Playing out of defence is absolutely central to Martinez's philosophy and John Stones is the embodiment of that philosophy in my opinion. This lad could be one of the best English defenders of his generation, I truly believe that. I understand we don't want to be putting too much pressure on the lad but that doesn't change the fact that from what I have seen the boy is absurdly talented.
Darryl Ritchie
51 Posted 06/03/2014 at 23:44:28
Colin 067

When RM tells the press nothing but positives about our squad, he is in effect telling them nothing. What he tells the players and what he tells us, through the press, are probably two different things entirely. Sometimes I fear RM is just too nice of a person; maybe that's why they promoted Big Dunc. He can raise a bit hell in the locker room when it's needed.

Mick Davies
52 Posted 07/03/2014 at 00:32:25
I think Stones, Alcaraz or Duffy will be the future of our central defence, barring sales or incoming transfers. Duffy was receiving huge praise before his life-threatening injury, and it looks like he has a goal or two in his locker.
Andy Crooks
53 Posted 07/03/2014 at 01:43:28
Si and Mikey, as well as having a footballing defender do you not see the advantages in having a sleeves up out and out defender. Tony Adams and John Terry come to mind and I believe that Duffy will be as good as them. Also, I think that Roberto has an open enough mind to see that variety is good.

His interest in Traore confirms that.

If Stones replaces Distin then Duffy can replace Jagielka.

Darren Hind
54 Posted 07/03/2014 at 06:26:25
"He (Barkley) was brought back too quickly due to injury to our other players" . . . What ??? . . . .Which other players?

I don't care if Martinez only had 10 fit players to choose from, NOTHING can justify injecting a boy with painkiller knowing he could not get through the game without it. The fact is Martinez had several options, but this is the one he chose. Who knows what damage may have been done?

I don't get these attempts to excuse every error Martinez makes. The only saving grace in this whole sorry saga is that he himself has stood up and acknowledged it was a mistake, fair play to him. Perhaps his medical staff should do the same.

Martinez is still a relatively young manager, but he is razor sharp, He'll learn from this

Gary Reeves
55 Posted 07/03/2014 at 08:37:58
So Barkley’s brain (and his ability to make decisions on the pitch) has been hampered by an injury? Is that the general consensus on some of his recent performances?

Personally, I’m more concerned every time I watch him. Easily "mugged", stray passes, not spotting team-mates, not closing down opponents, schoolyard tackling... All my instincts are twitching at the moment, and I just hope they’re wrong.

Pat Waine
56 Posted 07/03/2014 at 09:50:40
Stones has done well and is progressing well since he got into the side; however, he is not the finished article by any means. In that position, you need to grow into it and it will take time. He could do with bulking up but that will come.

On Barkley he has not really progressed enough in my mind. He needs to learn the basics of spotting dangers as well as picking the pass. I think he chooses wrong options at times but hopefully he will learn. He reminds me of Alan Ball in ways that he makes himself available all the time and doesn't look worried about anything. Ball though didn't give the ball away very often. Alan Ball was the special one though.

Trevor Lynes
57 Posted 07/03/2014 at 20:25:12
The comment about playing with pain killers is laughable. Nearly every top player uses pain killers to help get him through games even with just small niggling injuries.
Fraser Auld
58 Posted 07/03/2014 at 20:31:52
Stones looked good against West Ham, one of his most convincing performances. He could become a very, very good player.

Think he will play tomorrow and it will be a big test for him, interesting to see how he gets on. His positioning is the biggest area he needs to improve on for me, when he's come up against pace and good movement he's looked like the novice he is...hopefully he has a big game tomorrow.

Wayne Smyth
59 Posted 07/03/2014 at 21:39:41
Gary, don't you notice players often come back from injury firing on all cylinders, immediately making all the right decisions, playing really well etc? Err, no, me neither.

Barkley will take time to get back full match sharpness and he will make mistakes and play worse than usual while he gets there.

Unlike many players he's playing the most difficult position. Creators do take risks, make mistakes and fail often. Being in his first season its all the more reason why he's going to struggle. Being in a side which has so many players with injuries will also hamper his performances.

Take a look at an equivalent young player; Wilshere, who is 2 years and 40 appearances ahead of where Barkley is. I'd say there isn't a lot between them. Barkley looks the better player even though he's 2 years younger.

The thing I like about Barkley apart from his surging runs, quick feet, powerful shot is the fact that he doesn't hide. He always wants the ball and he always tries to do something positive, even if things he's been trying have not worked. He never gets phased.

No-one knows if he'll become a great player, but I think its clear he certainly has all the attributes to do so. Having the fans get off his back and having a manager who has faith in him and gives him the time on the pitch can only help.


Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads

© ToffeeWeb