Martinez: Scoreline was harsh

, 8 March, 154comments  |  Jump to most recent
Roberto Martinez admitted after today's FA Cup defeat at Arsenal that the 4-1 defeat was hard to take given how hard his team had tried to win the tie and what he viewed as a soft penalty award for the Gunners' second goal.

The Blues were dumped out of the competition at the Quarter Final stage for the second season running, the victims of clinical finishing by Arsene Wenger's men after Mikel Arteta had put them 2-1 up from the spot after 67 minutes.

"It's hard to take but we lost a tie giving everything and trying to win," said Martinez.

"The scoreline at the end doesn't reflect what happened in the game. It shows what we have in the dressing room, trying to go forward right until the final whistle.

"We weren't happy with the first goal and we need to be much better with our defensive duties. But once we steadied ourselves after the first 20 minutes we were where we wanted to be.

"Unfortunately, we couldn't score that second goal to put the game in our favour."

Romelu Lukaku allowed an excellent chance on the counter-attack evaporate late in the first half at 1-1 and Ross Barkley swept another good chance over the bar early in the second, but once the Gunners had retaken the lead, they killed Everton off as they chased the game.

Martinez acknowledged that his side needed to take their chances but also felt the penalty award for Gareth Barry's challenge on Alex Oxlade-Chamberlain was harsh.

"I felt it was a situation where Gareth was fighting for the ball with Oxlade-Chamberlain," Martinez continued. "Of course there was contact but was there enough contact to give a penalty?

"They are difficult decisions and you need luck to be in your favour. Then, from our point of view, there was the chance before that.

"We wanted to make it an open game and have the opportunities to score the second goal. Nine out of 10 times Ross always hits the target from those positions."

Quotes sourced from Sky Sports



Reader Comments (154)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Matthew Salem
1 Posted 08/03/2014 at 16:41:48
We're out. Tits...
Barry Pearce
2 Posted 08/03/2014 at 16:50:03
The score might have been a bit harsh, but we were beaten by the better team on the day.

Please don't keep making excuses Roberto.

Tony Doran
4 Posted 08/03/2014 at 17:03:35
No bite in and around the box. Needed freshening up in January but instead went backwards. My gran is going on a free incase the board are interested.
Chris Leyland
5 Posted 08/03/2014 at 17:13:13
Roberto - you don’t have a plan B on the pitch and you don’t have a plan B on the post-match comments front either. Fact is we have lost the last 4 away games and apparently in each of them we have been unlucky and the score line hasn’t reflected the game. Those same 4 games where we have scored 2 goals and conceded 10.

The fact is you have been found out as being tactical inept. You have one system and one way of playing and it clearly doesn’t work against the better sides away from home. So why not come out and be honest for once instead of feeding is this relentless over-positive bollocks. Like you tactics it is becoming predictable

Geoff Evans
6 Posted 08/03/2014 at 17:10:21
What does it matter if the score was harsh, it wasn't a two-leg tie. Too many excuses and bullshit RM your team can't cut it and neither can you. Your all fur coat mate. It was a stroll for an under strength Arsenal whose standards are a lot higher.

Everton's best player would only be an Arsenal bench warmer.

Neil Steele
8 Posted 08/03/2014 at 17:23:49
Chris, Geoff...I assume you two are on some kind of poor WUM here? I mean, i'm saying that and affording you a bit of credit that surely nobody could seriously be so dense, could they?

The last 4 away games, that Chris refers to, have been Arsenal, Chelsea, Spurs and Liverpool. You've got to be some kind of fool to blame losing those games on the players and manager given the paucity of our resources.

Roberto's assessment, whilst (as is his way) perhaps overly positive, is a fair one; We did go out and play an open game, trying for the win instead of 'only' losing 1 or 2-0 and playing like a team of shithouses. The scoreline was very harsh, and the game was close.

You boys need to get a grip on reality. We never won these games under David Moyes, and more to the point we never even looked likely..or that we even intended to, at times.

The subs said everything that needs saying really. Arsenal introduce Olivier Giroud to win them the game... we bring on Leon Osman. The only realistic criticism you can throw at the manager is selecting Joel, who is clearly rubbish and an awful signing... but let's be honest: he didn't really impact the result, did he?

Linda Morrison
9 Posted 08/03/2014 at 17:28:59
Let's accept that we lost to the better team.

Our team was under too much pressure and because of this they did not play as they could until the first Arsenal goal went in.

I hope the players do not access this site. I'm not sure what people expect from the team, a team that has played with injuries to key players too many times as we do not have a squad.

The comments about the loan signings just putting themselves in the shop window may be true but if that was the case surely they would play better than they have.

Most people on this site go overboard for Gerard, but I am not convinced mainly as he never gets a game apart from the last 10 minutes or so. Maybe if he got a start he would show the talent everyone believes he has.

I think in many ways Roberto is in the same position as Moyes, but without all that lovely money, both have gone from less achieving clubs to clubs with fans that want not only good football but also trophies.

I think that it is only a matter of time before a Premier League club goes into administration, Liverpool were only a whisker away a few years ago.

We must hold steady and support our team. That is what Bluenoses do.

ps: If we have a scientist out there, can you see if you can clone Big Dunc!

Dick Brady
10 Posted 08/03/2014 at 17:37:44
"Nine out of 10 times Ross always hits the target from those positions."

Really Roberto??? Really? 9 out of 10 times???

That’s why Ross Barkley has scored just 4 goals all season is it??

Geoff Evans
11 Posted 08/03/2014 at 17:38:28
Neil 445

Glad to hear that your so pleased with mediocrity. You'll never be disappointed.

Ian Glassey
12 Posted 08/03/2014 at 17:48:39
It was a pen, end of.

Everyone back in the afternoons for shooting practise. Because they are crap.

Oh for Bob Latchford and Dave Thomas.

Steve Guy
13 Posted 08/03/2014 at 17:56:52
Barry gave Battenberg an easy decision to make and he was always going to take it!
Jimmy Sørheim
14 Posted 08/03/2014 at 17:53:47
Just spouting more spin to the gullable fans left who still buy into his bullshit talk.

It is all a fa&cidilla;ade to take the blame away from where it really lies.

It seems like no manager is wiling to take the responsibility for losing games anymore.

I am fed up with it; time to get some balls RM and fess up and tell it like it is.

Nobody is finding your spin cute anymore.

Paul Holmes
15 Posted 08/03/2014 at 18:16:51
We need pace upfront, the build up is too slow, and when we break on the counter our players are too slow to react resulting in the opposing team getting everybody back.

Pienaar is the worst culprit, always looking to go backwards and is scared to even try a shot. Do none of the players practice shooting and getting the ball into the 'BIG' thing called a goal? Mirallas has lost whatever he had to the point that he cannot pass to a teammate or get a shot on target.

David Holroyd
16 Posted 08/03/2014 at 18:22:20
No penetration in the final third. Mirallas, McGeady and the Spanish wonder who keeps loosing the ball are not consistent enough. Mirallas flatters to deceive in the big games. We missed Jagielka today; Stones played okay but Jags is still our best defender.
Ralph Basnett
17 Posted 08/03/2014 at 18:38:25
Would I give Barry another contract – no.

Would I risk a dodgy keeper for an important game – no.

would I take this small inadequate squad into Europe – no.

Maybe this is why I am not a Prem manager but I would at least not be singing their praises after they had their arses kicked. The score does not flatter to deceive as they looked like scoring every time they attacked and we bumbled a goal that we nearly embarrassed ourselves with by missing!!!!!!

We are not ready for Europe and cannot make a serious challenge to the big teams without investment and a bigger squad... which we will never have whilst Kenwright is at the helm!!!!!

Kevin Hudson
18 Posted 08/03/2014 at 18:25:28
In the same manner that we allegedly "controlled the game," at Chelsea two weeks ago, I'm not exactly sure what game Mr Positive was watching today, but we got battered; Arsenal had 3 times as many shots as we did, and racked up thirteen corners to our two.

We had a rabbit in goal who simply inspired their attackers, and we played with only fleeting conviction.

In short: Pea-shooters versus cannons.

I also thought Arteta was a bit of a shit for grabbing his badge when he scored.

7 away games against the teams above us, five of them ending in defeat. Ultimately, little progress.

Bottom line: Until Fathead steps aside and is replaced by someone with considerably bigger pockets, we will continue to tread water.

Cue Barkley's £30 million exit in the summer...and us "replacing him," with Eric Djemba-Djemba....

(On loan.)

Callum McNab
19 Posted 08/03/2014 at 18:45:15
He is getting to sound like a broken record, watched the same crap being spouted after every game for Wigan last year. Either tell bill the robber to back you with the money he has stashed or taxi for Martinez. But, after seeing him stating we had a good transfer window in January, I think it's going to be the same bullshit for another 11 yrs.
Mike Hughes
20 Posted 08/03/2014 at 18:47:05
I don’t want to knee-jerk after a poor outcome.
There are so many factors that contribute to our current predicament (finance, stadium, attracting top players, strategy, tactics, injuries, plan B and so on).

However, one RM post-match comment did irritate me.
It was along the lines of, "The score was not reflective of the game." It was – they scored 4, we scored 1. That’s all that counts.

And if anyone wants an argument about that I suggest you go and watch a more subjective pastime such as ice-skating instead of football.

Mark Tanton
21 Posted 08/03/2014 at 18:52:33
I certainly hope he's telling the lads something different behind closed doors. We cannot simply continue to claim the 'moral high ground' every week, insisting that we controlled the game and being very proud that we had more posession. Look what Liverpool did to us, now Arsenal have done it too.
Declan Brown
23 Posted 08/03/2014 at 18:57:59
The outcome was deserved, not sure for me if 4-1 was a true reflection of the game, 2-1 would have been more fair, but we never deserved to or even got near winning that game.

The lack of pace concerns me, the awful free kick and corner routines are atrocious, defending them we’re worse, the slow build up is killing us, the lack of creativity is worrying, the lack of goals is a big concern, the lack of opportunities is criminal, even more is depending on your full backs to create things, the lack of goals from our attacking front 4, well i’m running of negative things to put into this. Knowing when to keep possession and when to be direct is something we need to master.

One thing that vexes me, we play less games than other top 6 teams due to lack of European games / competition, so with playing once a week, how the hell do we always look knackered in the last 30 minutes of the game? Is there a fitness problem, is it too much ballwork and not enough fitness work, it’s the unfittest Everton team I can remember since Mike Walker’s days.

Roberto is a special sort, he’s so positive he could polish a turd and sell it for a huge profit, with Kenwrights tight wallet and what we saw today he may need that special skill in the summer.

Today was not a day for his special brand of happiness afterwards, he never ever criticises his players in public, but I’ll bet he laid into them afterwards.

When Robles was having a stinker, being a keeper myself, what I was looking for was to see an experienced player like Distin or Barry geeing him up and encouraging him, to me Robles had a bad one, but he was left there by his team-mates who should have been rallying around to settle his obvious nerves.

As for our new players and fans who don’t remember Mark "you know you don’t give last minute penalties against Liverpool" Clattenberg, that’s why we hate him, he was always going to give that penalty and I thought he was poor today, a small reason for the defeat but not a main factor for it. The blame lies solely on our players.

Just some of my observations!

Paul Ferry
24 Posted 08/03/2014 at 19:03:06
Agree 100 per cent Mark (501) that this 'we deserve more coz we boss possession' is wearing quite thin now and starting - that's all just starting - to have the appearance of self-legitimizing papering over the cracks. A decent and fair reaction to a brewing issue and a dire day Mark.

Geoff Evans (439), on the other hand, is in all respects beyond belief - not a name I know from on here and he might slip silently away into the kipper mist. Jaysus Geoff if you really believe what you write there - and it sounds like well quite frankly contempt - then you might as well take an old lady sabbatical until the next fella - Mick McCarthy or Warnock anyone? - slips into the hot seat.

On the brighter side of life: we have a decent run of games ahead of us, Spuds are 3-0 down, hang on 4-0 - Jaysus make sure you see the spuds shockers gifting Chelski three - and there's good reason to be a little cheery about the next couple of months, although, yes, slumped on the sofa, dazed, today is horrid.

Chris Leyland
25 Posted 08/03/2014 at 18:29:37
Neil - I’m not a wind up merchant but I am a pissed off Evertonian forced to endure another season of promise end in failure. Another false dawn. I don’t give a toss about the former manager’s record at these grounds either. Others clearly did as it was a stick to beat him with regularly but we have been told countless times on this very site that all of money was no excuse for his failures at these grounds and Martinez would make the difference. Guess what, he’s made fuck all difference in the end.

You might think it’s acceptable to not have a plan B on the pitch and to spout the same shite after every game littered with adjectives like phenomenal and special but I don’t when we have failed yet again.

Paul Holden
26 Posted 08/03/2014 at 19:25:03
We weren't good enough! Sunday League goals!
Dick Brady
27 Posted 08/03/2014 at 19:25:14
Kevin Hudson, which fools are going to pay £30 million for Ross Barkley?
Neil Pickering
28 Posted 08/03/2014 at 19:25:16
Over the past 2 months it has occurred to me that we are a similar side to Arsenal, but just without the brains!

Our manager can go on as much as he likes about being positive against the big teams, but the reality is that you get what you pay for. We have good players, there’s no doubt about that, but the majority are never top 4 quality, and when it comes to the big games they are still found wanting. I think until we give the manager at least £25M per year then we will always be nearly men.

All that being said, I getting a bit bored of Roberto giving it large about our players, especially the young ones, Stones, Barkley, etc. it puts too much pressure on them. They should just be left to develop without their gaffa spouting his bollocks.

In 12 months, we have gone from a dour, miserable bastard who doesn’t want to lose a game, to a guy who goes gung-ho in every game, with no Plan B or thought of consolidating. Only problem is he is doing it with players who aren’t good enough to play the way he really wants. Only Barca and maybe Arsenal themselves can do it. In the final third our lads don’t have the speed of thought those boys do,and the reason? Purely down to cash in my view.

John Moore
29 Posted 08/03/2014 at 19:11:20
I’ll just throw my two penneth worth in here...

Our defence has gone from rock solid last season and into the first half of this to looking like conceding from every opposition attack, so maybe Martinez’ defensive nous is just being realised now.

Add to this a unwillingness of anyone to risk losing possession by actually having a shot at goal in case it doesn’t go in, then I’m sensing disaster looming.

Dean Adams
30 Posted 08/03/2014 at 19:27:20
So if we listen to all this negativity, we will never achieve the step up. Bobby might be telling the world a very different story to what he tells the players.
Spurs were battered today, we win opur games in hand (Cardiff and Palace) and we are back in 5th. Not a bad first season really, seeing as most had us fighting relegation last summer.
Brent Stephens
31 Posted 08/03/2014 at 19:41:50
"Roberto Martinez admitted after today's FA Cup defeat at Arsenal that the 4-1 defeat was hard to take given how hard his team had tried to win the tie."

If that's what he said, then I think going away in the cup looking for the win at the Emirates is a strategic blunder. Get the draw and take them to GP under congested fixture conditions for them.

Gavin McGarvey
32 Posted 08/03/2014 at 19:14:02
Agree with Declan. Would have liked a bit more of a mea culpa from rm, as I don't think today was his best day in the office for him. I really think there are a lot of little things we could do to improve. Set pieces for example, rm may not like them, but it's madness not to be a bit smarter with them. Surely the aim, is to emulate some of the foreign teams who produce good football without spending big. Well, if we're going to do that then rm has to make every aspect of our game as good as it can be from fitness to free kicks.

I think he's a good manager, but the job at Everton is a lot harder now than it was when Moyes took over. Maybe if Moyes had won something, it wouldn't hurt so much each year when our season was over, though probably not. Anyway, I don't expect him to start slagging the players, but he must know how gutted we all are and that we are not fools. Had Arsenal not been so profligate it could have been worse. We were lucky to go in at half time all square.

Also although we do always try to push on and play positive football, rm is just as risk averse as dm. Do we ever put on an extra forward? GD always comes on late. We didn't exactly go at them all guns blazing. I can understand why he picked Robles, and whilst it wasn't a great decision, the players knew he was hardly going to be substituted so why not get behind him.

The penalty was very soft, in fact it was exactly the type of thing that winds me up about football these days, with its "winning penalties" commentators. The fact there's nothing wrong with looking for a trailing leg to limply fall over makes my blood boil. However we didn't lose because of the penalty, although it didn't help, we just didn't play well enough particularly in midfield.

I know money isn't everything in football, but we could really do with some to get in better players.

Brent Stephens
33 Posted 08/03/2014 at 19:52:45
Declan #510 "Roberto is a special sort, he's so positive he could polish a turd and sell it for a huge profit."

Dont give Bill ideas for commercial activities. Can you imagine them all piled up on the counter in Everton 1 and 2?

"Would you like a polished turd with your programme, sir?"

Patrick Murphy
34 Posted 08/03/2014 at 19:48:31
The problem with an optimist is that he refuses to believe that a fire has broken out even when all the fire engines have arrived and the flames are lapping about his feet, A pessimist on the other hand is persistently so worried about fire breaking out that he stores so much water to prevent a fire that he ends up flooding the gaffe. What would I give to have the bloke who realises the practicalities of any given situation and amends his thinking to prevent the fire without being over cautious,

FA Cup games 0-1 or 1-4 doesn't matter - you're out!!

Dean Adams
35 Posted 08/03/2014 at 19:54:47
I just guess that I am glad that we are not Spurs. They have spent a fortune and have had some batterings. They are no better off than us in the league and have some tough games coming up. Really, the only time to judge our season for me anyway, will be after 38 games. I will then see how many points we have gained in RMs first season and it will give me a good indicator as to where we stand going forward. At the moment I still think it looks like we have moved closer to those above, but lots of room left for improvement.
Kevin Tully
36 Posted 08/03/2014 at 19:57:40
We ran out of ideas in the last third, it was incredible to see Baines look clueless when he should have been trying to take on their right back - he seems to be lacking confidence for some unknown reason. I don't remember Robles punching like that the last time he played, wrong choice Roberto in a game of this magnitude. A very poor decision on his part.

Mirallas is not the player HE thinks he is, and although Ross will be a fantastic player soon enough, he has lacked sharpness since his injury. not enough bodies in the box when we got forward, too many players are not making runs into the areas we can hurt the opposition. That is something we need to address, or we will never win these big games.

Can someone explain why it takes 10 minutes to make a substitution? It's doing my fecking head in.

Lastly, Goodison is a non-League ground compared to the Emirates, we are so far behind these teams I fear we will be left behind for the foreseeable future.

Bill Gall
37 Posted 08/03/2014 at 20:15:32
Mr Martinez, when you have players who can put the ball in the net when given the opportunities there is nothing harsh in the scoreline. I am starting to believe that when Finch Farm was built they never put any goalposts up so players could take a shot at them to make the goalkeeper work.
Jimmy Hill
38 Posted 08/03/2014 at 20:23:01
4-1 flattered Arsenal; sure, they deserved in the end. The game was a lot closer than the score line suggests. Don't know what people are expecting of RM in his 1st year. I think we compete up until the last 10 mins.

I've enjoyed this season and can see us getting better. RM like Moyes can't win with many on this site. Miracles need money... until we have that then you have get used to the fact we might sneak a trophy or a European spot now and again. Harsh but true. No manager is going to change that fact.

Patrick Murphy
39 Posted 08/03/2014 at 20:37:49
Jimmy, I think most posters accept that nicking a trophy now and again is to be our fate but for the third season on the bounce we have limped out of the FA Cup in the latter stages. Arsenal away was always going to be a difficult ask but could we have done more as a team to turn the game in our favour? I think we could and should have done and that is what has caused the pain today.
Jimmy Hill
40 Posted 08/03/2014 at 20:49:49
Patrick, I don't think most posters do accept it by the nature of some of the posts. I also think that we were competitive today and had chances to win it. Unfortunately today our young players didn't convert for us, on another day they will. We want RM to bring young players through and give them every chance to develop so we have except the good with the bad.

At the moment we lack the ruthless streak that makes you winners. When was the last time we had 20-goal-a-season striker?

Patrick Murphy
41 Posted 08/03/2014 at 21:01:43
Jimmy we were not at all competitive Arsenal didn't have to worry at all for most of the game yes we had the odd chance but that will happen in most games; we didn't control the game today and we lacked ideas and creativity when we got forward and had Arsenal have been up for it in the first-half we would have lost the game a lot earlier. It was a poorer performance than those at Chelsea and Spurs and they weren't really Everton at their best either - so I maintain it was a limp exit from a competition which we should be fighting tooth and nail to win.
Neil Steele
42 Posted 08/03/2014 at 20:57:38
I don't know whether to laugh or worry reading sone of these posts, some of you seem to have absolutely no grasp on reality whatsoever.

Man of the match today was a £42m signing...they brought Olivier Giroud off the bench to kill the game, they rotate their defence and bring in Thomas Vermaelen!

For 70 minutes we were right in the game, and as we have seen so many times this season...on our day we can compete above our level. As all realistic people have said from the outset though, it is physically impossible for our squad to compete against the top 4 over a season...impossible.

We gave it a right good go today, we were profligate at times, unlucky at others, tired at others and just not good enough individually at others. After the football we have played this season though, the vast improvement we have seen in terms of the way in which we have won the games that we should be winning, you have to be some kind of idiot to be getting on at the players or manager.

I am not and will never accept mediocrity...but at least have the sense to direct your criticism at the right individuals. Zero investment has led to this situation, and that is down to one man, his lies and refusal to sell.

Patrick Murphy
43 Posted 08/03/2014 at 21:07:56
Neil - I agree with your reasoning about who is responsible as his ambition sets the tone for the whole club and like it or not the man's only ambition is to carry on regardless. He doesn't see a problem therefore Everton haven't got a problem. If we honestly believe that we can't compete with those clubs above us even in a knock-out competition then it really is time to call it a day.
Raymond Fox
44 Posted 08/03/2014 at 21:12:28
Neil excellent post, Patrick we did compete today, till the very clumsy/brainless penalty given away by Barry we had a chance, we were 2nd best but we were still in it.

What worries me more than todays result is the number of aging players that are going to have to be replaced.
Where's the money going to come from?

It probably means waving goodbye to a couple of our best players as usual!

Neil Steele
45 Posted 08/03/2014 at 21:32:24
Raymond, I've just read a brilliant write up from a guy called Luke O'Farrell on ESPN, google it and im sure you'll enjoy.

Essentially he makes the point that we've had a great season but reality has taken it's toll. Barry's tired challenge today was that of a 33-year-old long overdue a rest, but one we can't even consider giving him due to our wafer-thin squad and reliance on him as a key player. That incident really embodies the whole squad situation.

Jags injured... a teenager comes in. Only serious investment in the order of £150m + over 2/3 windows will even give us a chance of bridging the top 4 gap over a season.

Maybe we'd have won this one in October... in March though, no chance.

Peter Laing
46 Posted 08/03/2014 at 21:31:57
Fuck all will change at this great Club until the 'emperor has no clothes' of a Chairman does the right thing by us long-suffering Evertonians and fucks off up Goodison Road with market value and no more for the shares that he has garnered by hook or by crook.
Danny Broderick
47 Posted 08/03/2014 at 21:43:34
I don't think it was RM's finest hour today. I would have liked the subs to have been introduced earlier, & I would have brought Naismith on to add a goal threat. I would have started with Howard instead of Robles also.

However, if Moyes was still in charge, if we had gone down 2-1, we would have lost 2-1. Would that have been better? We went down fighting, trying to get back into it. We got badly exposed, but at least we had a go.

It will take RM a bit of time to get different players into the squad. For me, we need far more from our 3 attacking midfielders. The game seems to pass them by every week. We need far more creativity and goal threat. We have a good base with the defence and the centre mids. The creative 3 need to do a lot more...

But I would rather go down fighting and having a go, even if it means losing 4-1 occasionally, than meekly surrendering to keep the score 'respectable', like we saw regularly for 10 years previously.

Jackie Barry
48 Posted 08/03/2014 at 22:28:48
Agree Jimmy, while the result was poor our players tried their best, we were very much in the game until we gave away that soft penalty. Obviously people are upset, I was too but to be judging RM after 7-months is kind of poor and your giving ammunition to those that won't even give the guy 1-week never mind a full season.
Jackie Barry
49 Posted 08/03/2014 at 22:39:12
Oh and to say we were not competitive is one of the biggest pieces of BS I have ever seen posted on TW.
Phil Smith
50 Posted 08/03/2014 at 22:38:00
Well, well, well. What a difference a day makes. Fickle few on here, fellas. Barry should apologize to the team after that. For a player of his experience to give away a penalty like that – not the first time this season – was shocking.

What is more shocking are some of the knee-jerk reactions on this site. Yes, I was annoyed by the way we feel apart but get a grip lads. Let's see where we finish at the end of the season. 5th is still ours to take and that would be a pretty good return for Roberto's first season at the helm.

Carl Sanderson
51 Posted 08/03/2014 at 22:22:12
Some very perceptive, heart-felt posts there.

Martinez's relentless positivity started to grate a while ago for me: today's comments are sadly unsurprising. The challenge by Barry was a definite penalty; Everton matched them for 70 minutes and then they threw on Giroud; and the decision to play Robles was just dumb.

I don't rate Martinez, just as others didn't like Moyes. Ultimately, though, it won't matter who's in charge. We won't win anything with this Board in place.

Keith Pratt
52 Posted 08/03/2014 at 22:30:00
Just gutted by today because I really believed this was our year. However, I am far more optimistic that we can make real progress under Martinez, rather than the clueless miserable one.

Barry giving away a needless penalty is unforgivable for a player of his experience and beyond the control of any manager, but cost us the game at a stage when we looked very comfortable.

Although I am very pro RM I thought playing that clown of a keeper was wrong and I can't remember the last good game that Pienaar played. I am also baffled by the confidence he has in Stones, as he might well turn out to be decent, but at the moment he is a kid way out of his depth and after his Anfield nightmare, I didn't expect to see him again this season.

Anyway, that's it for another season as far as silverware goes, just hope we can have a good end to the season without assisting the red shite and without Pienaar, please, Roberto!!

Paul Smith
53 Posted 08/03/2014 at 22:45:32
"Competitive"...every time Arsenal came forward my heart was in my mouth and that's without all the corners they had.

Do you think their fans felt the same when we went forward ?

We we're always under pressure. Joel didn't help – god knows what it's done for his confidence.

It's really got to me this defeat.

Arghhh – it stinks being born an Evertonian at times.

Tony Dove
54 Posted 08/03/2014 at 22:52:15
We were well beaten and no excuses. However, I cannot believe that in our most important game since the semi-final against Liverpool and with an inexperienced centre-back playing his biggest match, the manager chooses to play the second-choice goalkeeper. Watching the ball come into our area in the first half was a nightmare.

Considering his recent problems, Ross was superb. McCarthy and Coleman in particular were very poor. Roberto needs to up his game or it will end in tears.

Steve Carse
55 Posted 08/03/2014 at 22:31:07
I must have been at a different game to most posters here. For over an hour the game could have gone either way. It was a penalty but what an unlucky bounce of the ball to have created the need for the challenge to be made. Such a bounce could easily have occurred at the other end to our advantage. And just prior to that we had missed the clearest cut chance of the game which if taken would have probably have at least afforded us a replay.

I do agree with some of the criticisms of Martinez however. His philosophy is that by passing the ball around we will eventually create chances. Unfortunately alongside his distaste for corners and crosses generally, he also appears to dissuade his players, having created the space, from then having speculative shots on goal. I lost count of the number of times we had clear views of the goal but steadfastly declined to have a pop (a failure of Arsenal's as well it should be said).

But he is also burdened by a the underperforming of a number of players since the turn of the year, notably Barkley and Mirallas who had previously proved to be matchwinners in tight matches. Mirallas in particular has been a let down. He's hardly a spirited fighter so when he also puts in a string of invisible or ineffective performances you've got to question his future at the club.

The biggest difference between the top teams and the likes of ourselves (and others like Spurs) is that they have far greater belief and conviction. In the final third our play is extremely poor. We get into great positions only to delay the final pass or put in a hopeful ball. And in defence, when the going gets tough we concede. Of course we're never going to have the resources to provide the quality to give us a shortcut to help improve on these fronts but surely out there somewhere, at a reasonable price, there is a leader who can bring more of a never say die attitude to our play.

Ross Kerry
56 Posted 08/03/2014 at 23:06:29
Paul Smith @636, I can think of at least 3 instances when Arsenal fans would definitely have thought "they're going to score". We did threaten, we did make chances but didn't convert.

They shaded the play and got the crucial break. Everton can walk away with heads held high, fine effort.

Paul Holmes
57 Posted 08/03/2014 at 23:11:37
We need to clear out the whole forward line: Mirallas, Lukaku, Pienaar, Osman, Naismith, Del boy... Why? Because there is not enough goals in them. They all need ten chances to score one goal.

We need to buy Burnley's front two: Danny Ings (24 goals this season) & Sam Vokes (18 goals this season) — total: 42 goals this season. These two can hit the target every time. They played Southampton in this seasons FA Cup and scored 3 away from home.

I personally would give Burnley all the above players + a couple of million for these two, who would in my opinion bring us closer to Liverpool of Suarez and Sturridge for goals.

Judge for yourself next season when Burnley play in the Premier League and these two outscore the whole 'toothless' Everton team.

Ross Kerry
58 Posted 08/03/2014 at 23:36:17
Nothing harsh about it, we spurned chances and they converted theirs.
Andy Meighan
59 Posted 08/03/2014 at 23:16:21
Martinez's shite is really starting to wear a bit thin now. That, once again, was another away game that we really never looked like remotely winning... and moaning about a blatant penalty is so feeble.

Arsenal looked like scoring every time they got in our box while we never troubled Fabianski at all. All this intricate little passing is getting us nowhere and I'm really starting to worry he's turning us into Wigan – his naïvety in letting teams pick us off is worrying, it really is.

I notice once again he hasn't apologised to the wonderful support that cowardly team of his got again. But why should he? He quite plainly doesn't give a fuck about the people getting up at all hours, spending all kinds of hard earned pay, while he's got media idiots telling him what a great job he's doing.

Another season of promise gone up in smoke... god. I fucking hate Everton, I really do.

Sean Kelly
60 Posted 08/03/2014 at 23:37:26
Time for change me thinks. Let's put the pressure on the board. This club needs direction and it's not getting it from this board. Small squads and squads lacking quality in depth will not win silverware. Billy and his mates have stitched us supporters and RM and the playing staff right up.

I ask the question if you worked for a money grabbing egotistical employer, as our squad do, would you be arsed if you saw fuck all investment? I wouldn't – I'd be looking for the door. So don't be surprised if you see a few players looking for the door in the summer... and Roberto shortly after them.

Jimmy Hill
61 Posted 08/03/2014 at 23:43:15
Patrick I guess that's what makes the game great, everyone sees it differently. I don't think Roberto is any less upset than we all are. Stating his thoughts on the game and that he felt, like many of us, that the score was not really a reflection on how close is was does not constitute him being over-optimistic, in my view of course.

That was a tough game for Arsenal; despite the score line, they will be glad they scraped through. We went for it the last 10, watch it again. I was proud that we had a go. Like 2-1, 4-1 what does it matter?

Colin Grierson
62 Posted 08/03/2014 at 23:51:23
Neil Steele - Couldn't have stated it any better. We have to support the manager and players we have. It wasn't RMs finest hour but Billy Bullshit is why we took Rock Paper Scissors to a gunfight today. It's fuckin annoying as fuck but it's down to one man and one man alone! All long suffering blues know how it is.

The players did their best and for some it's just not good enough. Robles was a joke though no blue was laughing. He was embarrassing. The rest can do it on their day but Arsenal were better than us. Arteta can fuck right off, though, the little fucker. I liked the cunt before today. Badge kissing wanker!

Jimmy Sørheim
63 Posted 09/03/2014 at 00:00:16
The problem is RM. He has himself told us that he slowly gave the players input on how to play so not to overburden them.

The problem is the way we play right now, in October or November he had not showed them everything he wanted to implement, but now we can clearly see a different side than that played in October.

The new style does not fit these players, they seem shellshocked and under a spell to do it the Martinez way and they simply can not do it the way he wants it.

If RM had chosen a longer time period to teach them then I think we would be better off right now; however, the truth is we are dire.

I am beginning to lose interest just because of the way we play. I really think many of the players are reverting into themselves and the smiles on their faces are all long gone. Lukaku for example looked happy when he first came here, but now he just looks downbeat. Baines is another one who has lost his fire under RM.

I think we are in deep trouble if RM does not mix things up or alter his approach. I now see how Wigan got relegated.

Frank Crewe
64 Posted 09/03/2014 at 00:32:04
Link

This is the YouTube link to Tim Sherwood's post match interview after Spurs 4-0 hammering by Chelsea. This could have been RM talking about Everton if he wasn't so annoyingly upbeat all the time.

A disappointed manager talking about his waste of space team. As he says. Spurs are miles away from the top four — and so are we.

Si Cooper
65 Posted 08/03/2014 at 23:42:29
Some people need to learn to read things properly.

RM hasn't said we bossed the game or anything like it; what he is pointing out is that we were in it for the majority of the game and the scoreline makes it look like Arsenal strolled it.

Arsenal were better, but because they played very well not because we were poor. The same cannot be said about Tottenham who we did outplay, and the Chelsea game was a lot closer as well though they probably did shade it. Why are people calling for us to abandon the style of play that saw us massively outplay Arsenal for a half in the league game and that got us three points at Old Trafford?

How many times this season has Ross Barkley missed the target when it has been laid on a plate for him 15 yards out and central? His goal tally has nothing to do with him not making the best of this sort of opportunity (which does not come often) but that he would expect to hit the target with. Generally he was a lot closer to his best today, which everyone apart from some ridiculously picky posters on here could see.

Disappointing for me today were Mirallas and Pienaar, who didn't do a lot wrong but hardly made any positive impact. How is McGeady attracting so much flak? He has hardly had a chance to make an impact and certainly hasn't disgraced himself when he has played even if there haven't been any 'wow' moments yet.

RM is wrong about the penalty and will no doubt realise that when he sees it again. Barry was unlucky to stumble after blocking Oxlade-Chamberlain's first attempt at a cross and his attempt to recover was ill-advised but probably more instinctive than thought out.

Giroud's first goal was annoying as no-one seemed interested in tracking Sagna's run and he wasn't closed down when he got the ball in the area, but it wasn't indicative of a general pattern of play.

Joel was poor in that he chose to punch on occasions when he should have caught the ball, but I don't agree that he spread panic amongst his defenders or that he was actually in any way culpable for any of their goals.

Overall, we were undermined by too many tired legs, inexperience and lack of match fitness for some key players, not by any lack of effort or tactical paucity.

Jim Harrison
66 Posted 09/03/2014 at 00:40:35
Do you actually pay any attention to post match comments? What should he say? "Shit, we lost."?

Patrick Murphy
67 Posted 09/03/2014 at 01:03:27
Jim - He should be aware of the fact that he is speaking for the club and to its supporters. He should just admit that, although his side tried their best, they weren't good enough on the day and accept defeat gracefully.

I saw Sherwood's interview and although it will in all probability back-fire for him it must be a devil of a job to motivate millionaires week-in & week-out. Premier League players are so out of touch with the realities of life they probably will, like Sherwood suggested, have forgotten all about their own performances by the time they reach the motorway.

Si Cooper
68 Posted 09/03/2014 at 01:11:33
Patrick - what possible relevance do Sherwood's comments have for our game today?

RM is actually mainly speaking for his team and training staff, and to the media. As a supporter I have no problem with what he said after the game apart from his take on the penalty.

It seems that only some Evertonians are taking him to task and most neutrals have agreed with his comments apart from the penalty incident. People are making out he is claiming we were the better team, when all he is actually saying is the game wasn't as one sided as the scoreline suggests, and we gave it a go when we were chasing the game rather than falling apart under pressure.

Patrick Murphy
69 Posted 09/03/2014 at 01:33:29
Si - Sherwood's comments may not have relevance to our game but they do show a difference in style. Sherwood was being perhaps naively honest and RM even if he thought the penalty was harsh cannot escape the fact it was another heavy defeat when going toe-to-toe with a big team on its own midden.

But here's the rub: did we really go toe-to-toe with them or did our players go through the motions? How many saves did their keeper make compared to how many ours made?

Whilst there is only a goal between two sides then you are always in the game, I thought we lacked belief and determination all over the park and Arsenal were the hungrier of the two teams.

It could have been worse... we could have been returning from across the park having lost the sixth round tie – perhaps there is a god.

Patrick Murphy
70 Posted 09/03/2014 at 01:54:25
When was the last time prior to the Emirates defeat did Everton lose four consecutive games on the road? Answer the start of the 2005-06 season starting with Villarreal (2-1), Fulham (1-0), Dinamo Bucharest (5-1), Arsenal (2-0), Man City (2-0) & Spurs (2-0) before we stopped the rot at Birmingham City (0-1). Let's hope we put this bad away run behind us and soon...
Si Cooper
71 Posted 09/03/2014 at 01:53:07
Patrick - fact remains that Sherwood's comments have no relevance and so have no bearing on what Martinez says at any time. My point is that people are saying Martinez has said something that he actually hasn't.

The scoreline may be one-sided but the game wasn't to the same degree and that means Martinez is correct in what he has said. I also completely disagree with your critical assessment of our team's play today. I may not be happy with some of the decision-making and some of the execution, but you are totally wrong to call into question the teams attitude or effort.

We very nearly went ahead in that game today and it would not have been outrageous at that stage if we did. Understandably tired legs, inexperience in key positions and a couple of pivotal players still coming back to full match fitness and form easily explains how we ultimately fell short to a top team that had none of that to hinder them today.

Si Cooper
72 Posted 09/03/2014 at 02:05:57
The relevance of those statistics without any context, Patrick? You would have to provide details of the players available and the manner of the defeats before they even start to have meaning.

As it stands it is a pointless comparison.

Patrick Murphy
73 Posted 09/03/2014 at 02:12:54
It is not a pointless comparison because the results, whether unfortunate or not, are the results and we haven't won away at a Premier League ground since we beat Swansea in December - 3 months ago. Can we see a pattern emerging?

I'm all for backing the team and the manager but should we really be upbeat and positive about our away form at this moment in time? Losing, like winning, becomes a habit and I don't want us to continue on the current run of form away from home. The evidence is there for all to see and surely the manager has had enough time to realise that something isn't working properly.

Transition season, I know... but that doesn't mean we should accept defeat at the drop of a hat. What the run tells you is that, as a club, in the past eight years, we haven't been used to losing away from home on such a regular basis.

Mick Davies
74 Posted 09/03/2014 at 01:54:56
Which manager's comments will boost their respective sides for the next game? Sherwood's, bringing them down, so they will resent him and his position, or Martinez's, who they will feel they have let him down and make an effort to repay his loyalty?
Si Cooper
75 Posted 09/03/2014 at 02:33:05
It is pointless because it is meaningless without context!

There is no pattern because you are attempting to liken two different squads, under two very different managers, playing different opposition at two different stages of a season.

You can't simply say "It looks the same to me, so it must be the same"!

Si Cooper
76 Posted 09/03/2014 at 02:39:12
Mick, it is funny how the manager whose expensively assembled players were humiliated by Chelsea is being held up as a paragon compared to the manager whose much cheaper team gave Chelsea much more to deal with the other week.

It is also ironic that the manager who is shifting all the blame onto his players is currently more popular on this site than our manager who should apparently be wringing his hands in abject apology for his part in our players being unable to overcome the favourites in our game.

Roger Sunde
77 Posted 09/03/2014 at 04:02:43
That people are disappointed we didn't beat Arsenal away — something we haven't done for nearly 20 years — means we're on the right track.
James Stewart
78 Posted 09/03/2014 at 05:06:17
Blatant penalty and one of the stupidest conceded from an Everton player. Unacceptable from a player with his experience. This a week after he escaped a deserved red card for a similar stupid foul.

All the talk from Mirallas and co before the match amounted to nothing. Nowhere near as good as a lot of them think they are.

Substitutions were really poor from RM too.

Colin Grierson
79 Posted 09/03/2014 at 06:52:11
RM can reasonably be pulled up for
A. His selection of Robles over Howard.
B. The lateness of his substitutions.
C. His comment regarding the penalty (he surely hadn't seen it on a monitor)
Apart from that I would expect him (publicly) to try to take positives from every game. If he wants to tear anyone a new arsehole then that is kept in the dressing room or all he'd get is resentment from the players. They'll watch the game and analyse it. The style of play won't win us every game but personally I think it's the way forward but we must remain patient. As Roger rightly says it is a measure of where we are that people are so disgruntled with a defeat at the Emirates.
As for the players, we'll I'm sure we could all point to every position and suggest players who would do better but that's what fantasy football leagues are all about. We can only support what is put in front of us and that's what we've been doing for years.
Why some posters say things like I hate Everton is purely down to frustration. We are a frustrating team to support! We always have been especially with that shower across the park doing so well it makes it all the worse.
Now I'm not saying this will happen BUT If at the start of the season you had been offered 5th in the Prem, a place in the Europa cup and to finish above Manure would you have taken it?!? Cos that is still a realistic target. COYB!
Sam Hoare
80 Posted 09/03/2014 at 07:49:30
It seems clear to me that something is not working in our approach at the moment. There are always moments that can change matches but I don't see how anyone can say we deserved anything different yesterday. Arsenal were far more effective with the ball and always looked likelier to create chances. As opposed to our last trip to the emirates when we legitimately deserved a draw at the least.

It is of course impossible to know exactly what has caused this downturn and people will offer explanations from Martinez tactics through to BKs chequebook. It doesn't really matter.

I hope and believe that Martinez was chosen as a manager with a view to the long term rather than short. This team is still mostly Moyes' and certainly we are at least a year or two off seeing the youngsters coached in Martinez' philosophy break through. If we end this season 6th and make Europa league it will mean we have transitioned with no loss of position which is an achievement of sorts though we all crave much better.

The real onus will be on BK and RM to see if this changed approach can reap rewards over the next 5 years and if we can show the moneyed elite that there is another way. It's a tall challenge and yesterday was but a dirty prologue to the real adventure. I'm hoping for much better times.

Amit Vithlani
82 Posted 09/03/2014 at 08:02:09
Sam 717 really good post. If we are taking the long term view then it is fool hardy to denigrate what the team has achieved this season bearing in mind the circumstances we have faced I.e. injuries to key players, players wanting to leave in a World Cup year etc.

That said the short termist assessments cant be ignored. There was a lack of guts after we went behind and if we are to achieve our potential Martinez needs to instill a fighting, scrapping mentality if things in a game go against us.

Derek Thomas
83 Posted 09/03/2014 at 07:54:24
We were still in it until the dafter than daft penno. They looked more likely to score than us, but we still looked as if we could.

Sad to say a smidgin of KITAP1, would not have gone amiss.

Yeah I know, but before people jump down my neck, we used to be 'fighters' now we are purely a 'Boxer'... we need to do both...but at the right time.

Roberto; we haven't the funds to buy our way to a Barcalona, nor the time to find Messi's or xavi's

You have to adapt... a little, get them ( and the 'them' of now will not be the 'them' of 2 years hence ) playing as much joined up stuff as you can afford and they can handle, but up the pace in the opposition half, oh and find a ' mongrel or 2 who can play a bit.

Not much of a wish list I know but it's all I got.

Graham Mockford
84 Posted 09/03/2014 at 09:03:20
Amit #721

I agree that it is important to take a long term view but out of interest what do you think the team has actually achieved this year? Are we looking like we are in any better position than when the manager joined?

Certainly results are more a less on a par, in fact they are strikingly similair. But what about the squad of players.

Our strike force cosists of one loanee who probably will leave, another loanee who won't play another game and a third who is also crocked.

Two loanees in midfield, one who will undoubtedly be off and another who you would have to question it's worth signing given his age.

We've also bought a centre half who can't get fit and a dodgy keeper. So where is the progress?

Neil Kudrycz
85 Posted 09/03/2014 at 09:26:33
Neil (586) Excellent post, Neil. I totally agree. Until we have serious investment on the pitch we will struggle during the season to freshen things up by being able to rotate the squad.
Danny Harris
90 Posted 09/03/2014 at 10:01:17
Aiden McGeady? This fella will go down as another bad signing this guy offers nothing in any game I’ve seen. He looks lazy, uninterested and talentless, please tell me he doesn’t receive high wages on a long contract.
Vinny Garstrokes
91 Posted 09/03/2014 at 09:47:58
Neil 586 and Neil 729 - I totally agree

My ownly qualm with RM about yesterdays game is that I probably would not have used Joel as when he was punching the ball instead of catching, I don't think it instilled our defence with a great deal of confidence. Last night I watched Chelski batter Spurs and Spurs spend 100+ million last summer. When we played them we were very unlucky not to come away with a point. But what it boils down to for me is this:

I really do not enjoy watching Everton on the telly or some dodgy asian link courtesy of some oppo on TW. I love going to the match and it is a massive part of my life. The lead up and post mortem of every game is everything. I usually manage a couple of away games each season. I like going to Villa particularly and Stoke. I used to go to Wigan, Bolton and Blackburn when they were in the premiership but don't venture too much further than that.. The simple fact is that if I was an Arsenal, Spurs or Chelsea fan, then I would not be able to afford to go due to the price of a season ticket. To get to the next level is going to require investment, new ground, galactico signing etc etc which would inevitably lead to investors needing to pass that on to us. I read recently that the Arse wanted to charge £108 for entry to one of their games. Of course I am passionate, ambitious and want us to win everything and slaughter those in our wake, but not at any cost.

Brin Williams
92 Posted 09/03/2014 at 10:03:07
Lots of comment about our performance and Roberto’s BUT not one word about our Public Enemy No.1 = Clattenburg.

Why? Because he had an excellent game.

Scott Jones
94 Posted 09/03/2014 at 09:46:16
Neil (586) I totally agree mate. spot on.

So many posters with knee-jerk reactions and lack of football knowledge!

The gaffer hasn't had 12 months yet FFS! Robles getting stick after playing 6 games for the club is very narrow-minded... Barry Horne springs to mind:12 months the lad got terrible stick, he eventually silenced the doubters (when he settled) by putting in some brilliant performances and becoming the first name on the team sheet.

This season was always going to be a "one-step back to move two-steps forward" season.

Phase 1 — Learning how to keep possession of the ball + the ball is not a (hot-potato);

Phase 2 —Learning how to play possession football and open up defences at our choosing (not achieved yet).

What Roberto is trying to do takes time and patience. Have faith and we will have a legacy that will ECHO THROUGH ETERNITY!

Paul Taylor
95 Posted 09/03/2014 at 10:25:54
Anyway, season now well and truly over. Must start planning for next season by giving some youngsters a chance and getting rid of the deadwood in the summer. But we do need decent attacking midfield players and a proven goal scorer as well. That needs investment.

Difficult times ahead...

David Holroyd
96 Posted 09/03/2014 at 11:57:41
The first ten minutes were a good indication about Robles: he never caught anything, always tried to punch, didn't look at all confident. We need to get rid – no knee-jerk reaction. Bad mistake by Martinez to play him.

We need to somehow get more players who can score goals in the side. 38 goals in 27 games tells it's own story. Pienaar is now like Osman – cannot last more than 60 mins – we need more players who can last the full game.

John Daley
97 Posted 09/03/2014 at 12:29:07
"Martinez's shite is really starting to wear a bit thin... I notice once again he hasn't apologised to the wonderful support... He quite plainly doesn't give a fuck about the people getting up at all hours, spending all kinds of hard earned pay...."

Oh, c'mon. Everyone's gutted but casting aspersions on his character is taking things a bit too far.

Firstly, what has he actually got to apologise for? The fact his team got beat? Well, it was one of three possible outcomes so it shouldn't have been totally fucking unexpected.

The fact they didn't give it a go? It's not like the team just meekly pulled their keks down, closed their eyes and helpfully pointed out that there's a bottle of lube in the bedside cabinet prior to being beasted. They fought to get a result, and tried to get at the Arsenal defence whenever they could. They just weren't ruthless enough to inflict any real damage when they had the chance.

With the exception of Robles, Martinez picked the team that the vast majority of Evertonians probably would have fielded themselves. He sent them out against one of the top four, on their own patch, to stand toe to toe, play their normal game and attack rather than simply stifle, stay back, get stuck in and hope for a draw. Which is something a lot of Evertonians have been screaming out for in the recent past, claiming it could only improve the probability of getting an away win against these sort of teams.

He chose to put his trust in the ability of young players like Stones, Barkley, Robles to step up to the plate, play without fear, and prove they can cut it at the top level. Once again, this is something his predecessor often faced criticism for not doing in previous seasons.

Yes, it all went tits up and backfired badly. The squad has clearly hit a brick wall and the swagger and defensive solidity shown in the first half of the season seems to have dissipated but the manager, his mindset and the style of play he's trying to implement hasn't changed. He's still doing the same things that served him so well, and had (almost) everyone swooning, up until a couple of months ago.

He doesn't need to come out and make an apology. He just need to come out fighting for the rest of the season and show he actually has the managerial ability to overcome a sharp downturn in momentum.

These past few months of adversity will have taught him a lot more about the players he currently has at his disposal than those months where things were going well. The final part of this season and the forthcoming transfer window should tell us a lot more about the man we now have in charge.

Andy Crooks
98 Posted 09/03/2014 at 12:32:15
Frank # 663 public condemnation of players doesn't work. Ask Phil Brown. His public humiliation of the Hull players was a gaff of Gerald Ratner proportions. Sherwood has made a huge error because he'll be gone long before his players.

Managers are obliged to speak to the press and inane ramblings are usually better than brutal honesty.

John Moore
99 Posted 09/03/2014 at 10:37:09
You win or lose games in midfield: dominate the middle and you invariably win the game. Our midfield consists of two players whose sole purpose is to stop the opposition playing.

Now I quite like McCarthy so I'd stick with him and by all accounts he used to weigh in with some goals in his early days so he should be encouraged to drive forward with purpose some more.

But to play two defensive midfielders, one being a 33-year-old with the pace of an underwater sprinter, is just asking for teams to attack us; every defence in the world can be got at, which is why we look like conceding from every opposition attack.

We need a playmaker who can drive at teams, hopefully Barkley can become that player, but he can't do it on his own with two passengers sitting behind

Get rid of Pienaar and break the bank for Adam Lallana.

Andy Walker
101 Posted 09/03/2014 at 13:14:53
Martinez could start by apologising for his own tactical ineptitude over the past couple of months. It is his 'roll the dice' attitude that has cost us against the Shite, Chelsea, Spurs and now Arsenal. Sure, we went for it – just like Wigan used to. So fucking what?

I watched the Arsenal v Wigan game near the end of last season at The Emirates when Wigan needed to win to stay up. Wigan played attacking football and took the lead... and then what? Knowing they needed to win, did they make any tactical switches to be less open and keep their lead? Of course not – the gambler that is Martinez kept attacking and they got caught wide open 4 times and lost 4-1 and were relegated.

The man clearly cannot set a team up to protect a lead and contain the opposition. His whole tactics revolve around retaining possession to stop the opposition having the ball and being able to attack his team. That works okay against lesser teams where we can dominate possession, but against good teams we can't dominate and we have looked frail without the ball all season.

It is so obvious yet the positive PR merchant that he is means he keeps everyone convinced he's doing a good job. He's a casino manager not a smart tactical thinker who can assess and recognise times when containment and keeping things tight are better tactics. I'd have loved a dour 0-0 yesterday but that was never going to happen under Martinez, but if it had we'd still be in the cup. Take your pick then: results or style over substance?

Frank Crewe
102 Posted 09/03/2014 at 12:41:32
I see my link to Tim Sherwood's interview generated some discussion. I put that link up to show at some point it becomes impossible to continually try to put a gloss on another losing performance against a top 4 side. Sherwood is Spurs to his bones yet he knows his beloved club is simply in the Premier League to be one of 16 punching bags that the top 4 get to knock around every season.

I use Spurs as an example quite a bit because they are a mirror image of Everton. A club with a big history but currently struggling to get out of the shadow of it's richer neighbours. They have exactly the same problems we do. An outdated stadium, lack of cash, and the burden of their illustrious history. They have only been in the top 4 twice in the last 23 years and we have been in the top 4 once in the same period.

Sherwood knows that to get into the top 4 you have to beat the top 4. Yet season after season both Spurs and Everton fail to do this. That's 24 points (or the majority of) we fail to secure. This failure puts us and the rest of the non-top 4 clubs at a massive disadvantage.

On top of this, if we get far enough in the cup competitions, eventually we will get drawn against a top 4 club, such as Arsenal, and we will get knocked out. So we can't even win a cup either.

As things stand we cannot hope to overcome the financial disadvantage so we need a new approach on the field. Sherwood complained that his team didn't have enough characters. Do Everton have enough leaders on the pitch? Maybe that's something we should be looking at. Buying players with the right attitude who understand that Everton are not just a stop along the way to a top 4 side.

Are our tactics correct? I think we play to slowly. Our counter attacks are pedestrian. Will there be no real change until we get rid of Moyes's men with their "a draw is a good result" attitude. Can we afford a manager who puts sentimentality above professionalism. Howard should have played yesterday, not Robles... So why was Robles on the pitch?

Now I don't have all the answers. In fact, I don't have any of them. But I do know that good league starts don't last. Injuries and suspensions, not to mention morale-sapping defeats against the top 4 clubs, take their toll on the players and us, the fans.

This season will soon be over and no doubt we will be among the "best of the rest" once again. For the foreseeable, this would appear to be the best we can hope for.

Neil Steele
103 Posted 09/03/2014 at 14:52:20
Andy 809, I think that's possibly the most juvenile and technically incorrect analysis of a manager's style that I've ever read. The first major flaw in your argument is your suggestion that tactics have cost us these games – as if to imply that we'd normally've won them under the ginger Mourinho, or that we should even be realistically expected to. It's utterly ridiculous, and completely undermines anything else that you might have to say.

Having read on though, to then suggest Martinez's style is counter-productive to containing or protecting a lead... again, what absolute tripe. Look at the West Ham away game this season as a prime example: we have a 3-2 lead to protect with 10 men and we never once looked in danger. Ditto Old Trafford. Ditto numerous other games this season where we've held a one-goal lead or a draw.

You must be thinking of the last manager if you associate Everton with meek surrender... the hoof merchant who's defenders were paralysed with fear and consistently treated the ball like a hot potato and hoisted it back to the opposition time after time.

Everton win and see out games now by completely controlling them, and in doing that you hugely mitigate the chances of 'bad luck' playing against you. The only thing we haven't been able to do, understandably so, is take that style and authority and manage to stamp it on the opposition in the forms of Chelsea, Arsenal, Man City, Liverpool or Spurs.

You put that down to tactical naivety of the manager... I'll stay here in the real world thanks. Get real Andy, that's the only advice I can give you. Put Ozil, Cazorla in our side yesterday instead of Mirallas and Pienaar and i've no doubt we win.

Let me know when you've found that spare £60M lying around so that we can buy them (we'll discuss wages later...).

Chris Leyland
104 Posted 09/03/2014 at 15:09:11
Neil Steele - we might as well all give up and go home then as it is just about money so why bother?

Andy did make some valid points but you dismiss them as 'juvenile' yet, in your own post, as evidence of Roberto's ability to hold onto a lead, you state:

"Look at the West Ham away game this season as a prime example... we have a 3-2 lead to protect with 10 men and we never once looked in danger."

That would actually be the game we trailed 2-1 in until West Ham had a player sent off to go down to 10 men? We then got to a 3-2 lead and had to play out all of 6 minutes to win. Hardly what I'd called a "prime example"!

Andy Walker
105 Posted 09/03/2014 at 15:06:41
Neil, you're making my argument for me. As you rightly point out, we haven't the same quality of players as the top sides so to attempt to take them on at their own game is suicidal. We therefore have to try and counter the opposition by setting our team up to contain their threats. Martinez sets his team up the same for every game regardless of the opposition; he shows no tactical awareness when it comes to opposition threats.

If you don't believe we could have got at least one draw out of those four matches by playing with better tactics then that's naïve. We played far too high up the pitch, got players too far ahead of the ball, effectively played with two at the back yesterday as either Barry or McCarthy were dropping back to cover our two centre-backs while Baines and Coleman invariably were ahead of the ball when we lost possession.

Please don't tell me you've never noticed. Wake up and trust what you see – not what our spin doctor of a manager spouts. Our form away from home second half of the season is appalling because of a lack of tactical ability to set up a team capable of getting results when we don't dominate possession. The opposing managers have sussed us out now (press hard, don't give them any time so we loose possession) and when we lose the ball, counter quickly as we will invariably have pushed on, be out of position and will be vulnerable to a counter-attack.

Neil Steele
106 Posted 09/03/2014 at 15:30:28
Andy, you seem to think that what you are saying is revolutionary or something... anyone with eyes can see what happened, but likewise I have seen equally futile efforts year after year when we have put 10 men behind the ball and kept kicking it back to them aimlessly for 70 minutes until finally the resistance breaks.

What you need to get your head around is that better is just better, sometimes it doesn't matter what your tactics are... the end result (ie, a loss) will be the same.

Maybe in years to come, the manager WILL switch his tactics somewhat in these games, but a big part of what he is trying to achieve now (as he is on record as stating) is removing our inferiority complex and instilling in the players a philosophy that allows them to go and play 'eye to eye' with top opposition, on their pitch.

We won at Old Trafford, we played brilliantly and drew at Emirates in the league – arguably our best performance of the season – and we were under no real pressure at all against Chelsea and lost only due to Howard's individual blunder.

So really, when you cut through all the hyperbole, you've only got Liverpool and this one where your point even stands up. The Derby was an inexcusable mess, so I'll grant you that... but this one, behave man. We were bang in the game until 70 minutes and conceded the last two spinning the dice to get back into a cup tie... and I'd certainly rather do that than have lost like a shithouse, as was the hallmark of David Moyes's sides. What was his phrase... "get out alive"?

I come back to the start again... sometimes you have to accept that, irrelevant of tactics, you are limited by your resources. In October we may have given them more of a game; in March, with a leg weary squad – never better evidenced than Barry's lazy leg, a 33-year-old desperate for a rest period – and a teenage centre-back filling in for our captain, I think what you saw is what you get.

What the manager and the team need is support, not sniping. This season has been our most consistent and convincing in many many years in terms of winning the games we would be expected to win; we have controlled them for the main part. All that people are crying about is a period in which, unfortunately, we have faced a number of the top sides consecutively, away from home, and knee-jerk frustration is overtaking reason and logic.

John Gilfoyle
107 Posted 09/03/2014 at 15:23:24
I think Pienaar and Mirallas are our weak links at the moment, our system allows Mirallas, Barkley and Pienaar to push forward and supply Lukaku with chances. Pienaar unfortunately is finished: far too slow and can only just about hold onto the ball and relies on Baines to make runs.

Mirallas for me has all the ability, pace, skill and sometimes a good shot; sadly for me, he doesn't have that footballing brain, when to release the ball, awareness of his teammates positions.. I don't think this can be taught. The amount of times he gives the ball away is shocking.

Lukaku had a good game and it's sad that he doesn't get more service as I think he could bag 30 goals, the guy doesn't miss many chances.

Andy Walker
108 Posted 09/03/2014 at 15:44:09
Oh please Neil, let's not go all virtuous – "What the team needs now is support, not sniping" – what a fucking twee statement. What the team needs now is a leader who gets the tactics right.

We did not look comfortable yesterday for 70 mins. Arsenal looked like they could score on each attack, it was only a mixture of last minute blocks, bad finishing and some saves by Robles (he was shite with crosses but he made a couple of decent saves) that kept the score close for so long. We didn't win our first corner until about an hour.

As for winning at Old Trafford, yes it was great but West Brom and Newcastle have won there too, it's not the benchmark it was. We played great first time at the Emirates as well but then, guess what? – a tactician in the form of Wenger worked us out and played a different game this time; tactics mate, tactics. We need a balance between pragmatism and flair and know how to change that balance for each match and during games. Moyes was too pragmatic at times, Martinez is too aggressive at times and the results are similar, so we stand still in terms of results.

I agree we are generally better to watch now; progress... but, as I said originally, yesterday was the last big game of our season and I wanted a result and didn't give a shit how we got it. We should have kept it tight but we didn't set up to do this and played into Wenger's hands – just as he no doubt thought we would.

Patrick Murphy
109 Posted 09/03/2014 at 16:05:12
Sheffield United or Hull City will be in Europa next season if Man City beat Wigan Athletic.

Man City v Arsenal
Hull City v Sheffield United.

If Arsenal do go on to win the trophy ,they will have done it the hard way, Spurs, Liverpool, us and possibly Man City.

Amit Vithlani
110 Posted 09/03/2014 at 15:57:51
Graham (#721), these would be my list of achievements so far this season

1. First win at OT in 20-odd years
2. Much better style of play
3. Emergence of Ross Barkley as a first team regular.
4. Going toe to toe with big guns
5. Still in with a shout of 5th which we will be if we win our two games in hand

All this achieved as Sam points out in a season of transition. Add to that an appalling streak of bad luck with injuries, the loss of our biggest goal threat from last season (Fellaini), and key players from last season showing their age (Pienaar, Jags) and I would say we are making progress.

Amit Vithlani
111 Posted 09/03/2014 at 15:57:51
Graham 721 these would be my list of achievements so far this season

1. First win at OT in 20 odd years
2. Much better style of play
3. Emergence of Ross Barkley as a first team regular.
4. Going toe to toe with big guns
5. Still in with a shout of 5th which we will be if we win our 2 games in hand

All this achieved as Sam points out in a season of transition. Add to that an appalling streak of bad luck with injuries, the loss of our biggest goal threat from last season (Felli), and key players from last season showing their age (Peanuts, Jags) and I would say we are making progress.

Neil Steele
112 Posted 09/03/2014 at 16:19:58
More of the same, Andy... soundbites with no basis in reality. You can keep saying 'tactics' all you want, tactics will only get you so far... and as I've repeatedly pointed out, playing the 'other' way has never served us any better over the last 11 years so your point rings completely hollow. Essentially, whinging for the sake of whinging.

Tactics aren't the difference between a £42m player finding the corner of the net with a first time shot on the run when we have the likes of Mirallas and Pienaar who couldn't finish their dinner...

Tactics isn't one side replacing a first choice centre-half with a nigh on 50 cap international player (Thomas Vermaelen)... whilst the other brings in a 19-year-old kid from Barnsley with less than a dozen top level domestic appearances to his name...

Tactics isn't Arsenal freshening things up by bringing on Tomas Rosicky and Olivier Giroud, when we could call on Leon Osman and Steven Naismith by comparison.

In any game, at any level, there are always things that the team who loses could have done differently, with hindsight, to have not lost in the manner they did. What you seem completely oblivious to though, despite the evidence of the last 11 years, is that – far more often than not – the better players will still find a way to win. Whether it be 1-0 or 4-2... whether from a free-flowing move or from a ricochet from the 15th shot from 20 yards... that is football: deal with it.

I repeat what I said way earlier in the thread: if you are looking to apportion blame... look to the boardroom and challenge the chairman to put up or sell up. Whilst we keep taking our pea shooter to a gunfight... nothing will change, as much as you or others like you continue to cry 'it's not fair'.

Si Cooper
113 Posted 09/03/2014 at 16:24:02
Can I register my vote for Andy Walker as our next manager!

Apparently, though it may be dour stuff, he can guarantee results.

A legend in his own mind. (Get rid of the ridiculous 'mad gambler' allusions as well - they really don't apply as far as most people are concerned).

Michael Kenrick
114 Posted 09/03/2014 at 16:44:13
Neil (#836) "in March, with a leg weary squad – never better evidenced than Barry's lazy leg, a 33-year-old desperate for a rest period"

I struggle with this one. They're professional footballers. It's their job to run around for 90 mins once or twice a week. God knows they have enough leg strength to walk around a golf course for their own pleasure and relaxation...

I'm sorry but I ain't buying it.

Neil Steele
115 Posted 09/03/2014 at 17:03:04
Michael, I fully understand and agree with the sentiment..it has always been a difficult, if not impossible, concept for us folk who actually work for a living to comprehend... that having been said, football science and statistics says beyond any doubt that there is something in it.

Barry has never been known for his mobility, but in recent weeks it has been visibly noticeable (for me anyway) that he looks even more sluggish than normal, like the trailer he's pulling is carrying some extra weight! This goes for many of our key players though... because of the size of our squad and over-reliance on the same core, none of them have been afforded the treatment that the top sides benefit from offering their players. I just can't accept, with all the evidence to hand nowadays, that it's not a valid factor... it has to be.

That chap Raymond Verheijen who is regularly pummeling Moyes on twitter has published a ream of stuff on rest and recovery periods, games in a season etc, and there is a direct statistical correlation between results and players getting adequate rest periods.

Andy Walker
116 Posted 09/03/2014 at 16:45:38
Neil 'sound bites with no basis in reality' ha ha can't you see the irony of that?

What I have written is an opinion backed up with an explanation with supporting evidence. As you say, tactics aren't anything to do with the quality of the players you have, exactly my point, you make it better than me, thanks. Instead tactics are what you use to counter the fact that you have less gifted players.

This isn't hindsight on my part, I have been making this same point on TW since the debacle that was Anfield, it's based on the reality of what's gone on on the pitch.

I still have no idea what you point is other than to attempt to undermine my own opinion. Exactly what is your view? You mention in hindsight, so you accept that things could have been done differently, but what exactly should we have done differently and why couldn't this have been planned in advance of KO? You accept that Martinez tactically got it wrong at Liverpool, so clearly tactics are important, we agree at least on this, but you think he got the tactics right for the other 3 away games? Don't see how you can reach such a conclusion.

Andy Walker
117 Posted 09/03/2014 at 17:17:54
So 857 have you actually read my posts?

'I agree we are generally better to watch now; progress... ' was my statement.

How does that tie in with 'this may be dour stuff'?

My opinion is clear, Martinez is an attack-minded aggressive manager but over the past few critical away games he has been found wanting tactically. Is that really so off the wall? Probably is to you, I guess, as it's not an intransigent black or white position. Martinez could be great if he can learn to adapt his tactics to the circumstances. There I go again, I'm just a nutter.

Neil Steele
118 Posted 09/03/2014 at 17:31:01
Andy, I think the fuse has finally blown mate! Your last post has me confused... you seem to be suggesting that an explanation of your opinion is evidence? No, evidence is facts... results that back up your opinion.

That's the black and white of the whole debate. I'm saying to you, you show me the evidence that playing a more direct style, or more containing tactics (both of which David Moyes did) would be more effective.

The simple irrefutable facts of 11 years worth of evidence in results says that playing the 'other' way is equally futile when it boils down to it.

You either accept that, as the fact that the results say it is, or you continue to state your own opinion – which, again as I said, has no basis in reality... just an opinion. I can say whatever I want, I can say that we'd beat Barcelona with Dario Grady in charge... it doesn't make it so, but how do you 'prove' me wrong? Beauty of the internet, if gives a voice to madness.

Si Cooper
119 Posted 09/03/2014 at 17:29:37
Andy, you stated earlier that you would have taken a 'dour 0-0' yesterday. Mypoint is, is that how you 'guarantee' it? You have zero evidence that your approach would have yielded the result you would have been happy with. I suppose that same approach to the game would have ensured a victory at Goodison?

Of course it is shades of grey, but your pontificating and casting aspersions on the manager's attitude suggests that you think you have all the answers.

Andy Walker
120 Posted 09/03/2014 at 17:37:02
Neil, I supported my opinion with evidence is the results and the reality of the way we set up against Liverpool and were way too open at the back. You clearly agreed with that in your 836 post. I just believe the same applied (ie the way we set up) to the other 3 games. It's an opinion and I have explained why I have it.

I don't know what your opinion is other than its the same as mine for the Liverpool game. All you seem to have done is criticise my opinion of the performance yesterday with no explanation as to why you disagree, other than harping back to Moyes all the time! he's gone now let's deal with what is happening now. A defeat like yesterday's should warrant some sort of constructive criticism shouldn't it? We never hear it from our manager who just treats us all like imbeciles with his positivity for positivities sake nonsense.

Andy Walker
121 Posted 09/03/2014 at 17:47:59
Si, I would have taken a dour 0-0 yesterday and that was my whole point it was a one off cup game with a Wembley semi at place, it didn't matter on this one specific occasion how we got through, the result was more important than the performance yesterday, which I wouldn't always say was true in the league.

I've never said I have all the answers and obviously don't. But I don't think it takes any great expertise to suggest that our tactics have been found wanting In these recent away games. When your team persistently ends up with its full backs way too far up the pitch at the same time something is wrong.

Si Cooper
122 Posted 09/03/2014 at 18:03:18
"When your team persistently ends up with its full backs way too far up the pitch at the same time something is wrong."

Andy, the only two games you can possibly apply that to are the Anfield derby ( a cobbled together team against an attack that has terrorised many defences this season) and yesterday's game AFTER they scored their second and we needed to score to get anything from the game.

You are inventing scenarios and outcomes of games played 'your way' to portray what is purely speculation as definitive, and then attacking the manager for what you THINK he has simply thrown away.

Chris Leyland
123 Posted 09/03/2014 at 18:09:13
Neil — I see Wigan no money and championship players have just gone to Man City and beaten one of the top two most expensively assembled squads in the world alongside Real Madrid's. Still, it's all about the money as you've pointed out isn't it?

Still at least we can be pleased that we've gone 'toe to toe' against Man City Away, Spurs away, Liverpool away, Chelsea away, Arsenal away twice and manged to get one draw and five defeats out of these games scoring a magnificent 3 goals whilst conceding 14.

Neil Steele
124 Posted 09/03/2014 at 18:13:49
Andy; "I supported my opinion with evidence is the results and the reality of the way we set up against Liverpool"

That isn't supporting your opinion with results, that is stating your opinion by criticising a result.

I am asking you to provide some evidence of a set of better results playing in the way that you suggest would have served us better..surely that can't be hard given that the previous manager played that way for 11 years?

The conclusion is simple... the results of the last 11 years conclusively discredit your theory. David Moyes played the cagey, containing football that you are telling us that we should have employed... and his record against the top 4 was utterly abysmal, as I'm sure you know.

So really, that's it. You can continue saying what you say, but the facts say that it's meaningless pony. As fort your ramblings about the Derby, you seem to have completely rehashed what I said. I agree that it was a bad performance. I don't conclude that the result would have been different however we had played though..the fact is, they are a lot, lot better than us this season.

Neil Steele
125 Posted 09/03/2014 at 18:20:00
Chris, well done..I wondered who the first dunce to come out with that one would be. You've walked straight into the massive irony that our manager, with his inflexible tactics that Andy is criticising here, beat them when it mattered last season and actually won the cup... so what is your point!???

Never at any point have I said that money will always win, clearly that is not the case; but nor is the game so flowery and idealistic that changing your tactics on a given day will overcome a vast quality gulf.

Wigan won because City turned up with an horrendous attitude and gave them a 2-0 lead... even after that, Wigan still relied on a few sizable bits of fortune! That win was all about spirit and belief, neither of which were missing from our performance yesterday. Unfortunately we faced a team properly motivated who came ready to compete from the off... as i'm sure City would have too had they drawn another Premier League side.

Good luck to Wigan, though...that's the magic of the cup, I couldn't be happier for them!

Raymond Fox
126 Posted 09/03/2014 at 18:22:41
Excellent post again Neil.

Anybody that thinks that money doesn't matter in football is deluding themselves. Just look at the top of the PL each season.

We've gone 20 years without a trophy, we'll go another 20 years if we continue to operate on a shoestring!

Jackie Barry
127 Posted 09/03/2014 at 18:36:53
Great post by Neil.
Jackie Barry
128 Posted 09/03/2014 at 18:41:39
I love the comments criticizing our manager for being optimistic, sounds you have all been taken in by the BK mediocrity wonder years. Geez would you please listen to yourselves, you sound pathetic, even if Martinez is being overly optimistic it's better than been a dour no hoping whinger. To achieve what we want we need the people at the top to be exactly that, it's precisely how people make that transition to the next level, by being optimistic. Obviously our owners are big stumbling block but at least we now have somebody at the top with the belief that this club can become great again. Given the time period our current manager has had I am not going to start calling for his head, I'm going to give him time and let him carry out his plan. For me Martinez has been a breath of fresh air as shown by the Christmas video released by the club, yeah it doesn't change our league position but it does show a change happening at the club, a mental change that is going to take time to come into full affect. Wigan had that belief installed into them by Martinez that they could beat anybody, something our lot have gradually had taken away from them over the years, this is going to take time it won't happen over night but I trust Martinez to get it right.
Bobby Thomas
129 Posted 09/03/2014 at 18:57:36
The phrase tactically inept needs banning from this site.

In future, anyone who uses it should be beheaded.

Geoff Evans
130 Posted 09/03/2014 at 18:38:33
Neil 915

''Wigan won because City turned up with an horrendous attitude and gave them a 2-0 lead''.

Thanks Neil for that precise and expert analysis.

Your obvious knowledge in all things football and beyond is truly outstanding. Please don't waste you valuable time replying to al those comments that dare to question or disagree with yours.

Kevin Tully
131 Posted 09/03/2014 at 19:30:18
Did anyone watch the Chelsea or Spurs games? Even the opposition managers said we never deserved to lose those games, but our own fans think we did. How very strange.
Geoff Evans
132 Posted 09/03/2014 at 19:38:12
Kevin

So why did we? Unlucky, bad refereeing, lack of money spent, BK, very strange

Colin Glassar
133 Posted 09/03/2014 at 19:46:56
I finally got round to watching (recorded) the game this afternoon. As Kevin Tully said, we didn't deserve to lose any of these games. But, until we start putting away our chances then we will continue to struggle.

I knew we would lose yesterday, I predicted a 2-1 loss, but the scoreline is a bit harsh.

Phil Walling
134 Posted 09/03/2014 at 18:59:54
Just hope that Martinez can motivate this lot enough to hold on to seventh place. Talk of anything better is just wishful thinking but it will be a real pisser if we can’t average a point a game to finish best of the rest.

At least the style we play seems to receive universal approval so I guess that’s a plus to take out of the season.

Paul Hewitt
135 Posted 09/03/2014 at 19:51:24
Martinez has been sussed out. Slow slow build up play, no-one willing to shoot. Predicable, pedestrian and boring.
Paul Smith
136 Posted 09/03/2014 at 19:54:24
Neil (#445), there's another reason to have a go at the manager's selection, why does he insist on two defensive midfielders, week-in & week-out, no matter what your talent is, it's extremely rare to see any player these days playing every single game. Even if one of them is playing poor (like McCarthy at Arsenal) he still won't take one off.

Your theory about money wont work every week either, Wigan have just beat Man City away and I'm sure City have more cash than them.

The simple fact is we fell short again and the Arsenal game was a sign of how short we are yet again. The manager is still picking the same trustees who more often than not fail to impress, we don't create enough and too many stalwarts are trusted before youth. Just because you become fond of the manager doesn't mean he's immune to mistakes, Moyes's army made that mistake and it set us back year after year. If you want to get real you have to highlight every problem.

I wanted Martinez long before 95% of blues but I learnt during Moyes's tenure to never protect a manager that would up and walk as soon as a bigger job comes up. If I think he's making mistakes, I'll say, without the thought of money or any other football drama.

Andy Walker
137 Posted 09/03/2014 at 19:45:50
Neil the defeatist, nothing we could have done, behind our control, it was inevitable (but only when Martinez is our manager mind).

I have never told you we should play like Moyes did, never said it. But you've no argument and have to make stuff up to support your prejudice (anti Moyes/pro Martinez at all costs). Get over Moyes he's gone, why are you obsessed by the man?

I am pro Martinez when it comes to attacking more but it needs to be pegged back on occasions – are you really incapable of seeing that, or at least acknowledge it's a legitimate observation?

The argument that you are using, ie, provide the evidence that playing more tightly would have got a result, is something from a primary school kid. Of course you can't evidence what would have happened if something had retrospectively been changed, you child. Sorry, 'retrospectively' means looking back in time. Based on the theory of philosopher Neil you can never criticise anything that's ever happened (unless you have a Tardis). Following your childish argument means that no-one could ever criticise Moyes for negativity then, as you could never prove what would have happened if he had been more positive.

"You've only got Liverpool and this one where your point even stands up" – your quote. So we do agree then that the defeat was down to bad tactics (my point you refer to). No rehash there, just quoted you word for word. Wish you'd been playing CB for Arsenal yesterday as we would have had 6 own goals, or wait a minute – I have no evidence to prove that.

Kevin Tully
138 Posted 09/03/2014 at 20:11:37
Geoff - go and find the two goals we conceded in those game and tell me they weren't easily preventable. In the context of 90 min's we deserved at least a draw. At least that's how I looked at those games.
Darren Hind
139 Posted 09/03/2014 at 20:21:07
So failing to prevent "preventable" goals no longer means you deserve to lose?

Fuck me, we've been unlucky this year...

Geoff Evans
140 Posted 09/03/2014 at 20:23:45
Kevin: respect what your saying, they were easily preventable, the problem is we failed to prevent them and because we didn't score ourselves, we came away with nowt.

If we are going to progress to the next level, the prevention of these goals and, to my mind, more importantly, scoring more at the other end, need addressing and soon.

Tony Abrahams
141 Posted 09/03/2014 at 16:49:15
Good discussion with the one thing sticking out — the fact that we are all desperate for Everton to succeed. It's now our longest period by far without winning a major honour and it looks to me that we're going to have to wait a good while longer for this long wait to end.

We can blame the manager for getting things wrong but the fact is Guardiola with Klopp working as his Number Two would genuinely struggle to get anymore out of this Everton. Moyes had good half seasons but never was his team consistent for the full ten months and until we get a much bigger squad neither will Martinez's.

I don't want to go down the same old road again but we have a chairman who, although an Everton fan, cannot love Everton as much as a lot of our supporters do. He has continually borrowed at ridiculous rates and when the council kind of bailed Everton out by buying Finch Farm and renting it back to the club at a vastly reduced rate, Elstone had the temerity to call it an innovative deal, honestly.

It's going to be an interesting summer because if we have made £15M this year on transfers and we are about to receive an extra £20M off BT, then we should be a club virtually debt free, which should enable a cheaper sale from a custodian who has genuinely got the clubs best interest at heart?

This is where the goalposts quickly move because the people who like Kenwright then start talking about him being a businessman and accept that this type of person usually sell for profit. People quite rightly talk about the Venkys and the Launderer but, while this particular fan is in charge of Everton, we are always going to be along way away from where we really wish to be.

Kevin Tully
142 Posted 09/03/2014 at 20:52:33
Change "preventable" for "three dickhead defenders turning their back on the ball and one shithouse goalie" if it makes you feel better, Darren. I personally don't like to describe our players in that manner though – but it's the truth.
Dan McKie
143 Posted 09/03/2014 at 21:44:24
4-1 might have been harsh, but 2-1 or 3-1 wouldn't, and we would have still been out. Every game we don't win is harsh on us according to Martinez.
Si Cooper
144 Posted 09/03/2014 at 23:19:05
Dan, Martinez actually said exactly what you just posted. The scoreline was a harsh reflection of the actual game.

Nowhere have I seen him say that we didn't deserve to lose or even to win, but it suits some people's agenda to make out that he has. He might be a little overly positive about our performances at times but it is hardly the crime some seem to think it is.

Sean Kelly
145 Posted 09/03/2014 at 23:31:38
What's harsh Roberto is that thousands of us spent the full day travelling and got a shite performance. No desire, no fight and no cutting edge. A poor performance by all involved including Roberto.

It's pay back time for two full months and more of mediocrity dished up to us beleaguered and broke fans.

Si Cooper
146 Posted 09/03/2014 at 23:34:24
Paul Smith (#969) - bit embarrassing to have to explain this to a fellow Evertonian, but the whole point of playing two defensive midfielders is to give the two full-backs the license to support the attacks.I would have thought that was obvious to anyone who has watched us this season.

A lot of people seem to think that using the likes of Baines, Oviedo and Coleman in this way is actually a pretty good thing to do. Do you disagree?

Si Cooper
147 Posted 09/03/2014 at 23:43:16
Andy Walker (#971) - you would probably be better with the ability to visit the parallel worlds that exist according to the multiverse theory rather than just a time machine if you want to avoid the fuss of laboriously having to change players and tactics to see the consequences.

You are right that is unfair to assume that certain results would have automatically gone our way if only OFM had approached the games with a more daring approach; problem is it is similarly unfair for you to do the same to Martinez.

The real distinction is that a lot of people wish Moyes had been more daring simply for the fact that we would have at least gone down fighting and /or the games may have been more entertaining rather than any real belief that the outcome would necessarily have been different.

The other thing to note is that years of one approach got us very little and that can be used as circumstantial evidence at least; we are still really waiting to see whether Martinez's approach will bear fruit as his management of Everton is in its infancy and there is not the same extensive list of failures to provide any sort of evidence.

Ian Tunstead
148 Posted 10/03/2014 at 00:14:58
Si, we still only need one defensive midfielder even when the full backs have more of a licence to get forward. It's a very negative and overly defensive approach.
Jackie Barry
149 Posted 10/03/2014 at 02:42:56
I watched more poor performances many times over during Moyes's reign but the amount of people who are turning on Martinez after 7-months is quite frankly sickening. I remember the 4-0, 4-1 thrashings at the hands of West Brom, the 5-1 embarrassment to Man City, or 4-0 to Bolton anyone? The 7-0 or 6-1 thrashings to Arsenal or the embarrassing 5-0 kicking from Benfica. Remember we have seen all this before so before you start laying into our manager remember the times it happened under our previous manager. Short term memories or what!
Eric Myles
150 Posted 10/03/2014 at 00:45:12
Jimmy #662 "The problem is the way we play right now, in October or November he had not showed them everything he wanted to implement, but now we can clearly see a different side than that played in October"

Back in October we were playing better and winning, so if now is the new improved version of our team it's a worry.

Tony Abrahams
152 Posted 10/03/2014 at 08:48:42
That's exactly the problem, Jackie (#040) but I don't think that it's short memories – I think it's long-term pain. We are desperate to see Everton win again... so, when we fail, all the old disappointments come flooding right back.

Arsenal away at a ground we have never won at, against a team that have qualified for the group stages of the Champions League since it began was never gona be easy and so it proved once again. Arsenal, a club that used to be our equal but the only similarity now being we play in the same league. They have built and paid for a ground in the most expensive part of the country because of two things: A) Champions League money and B), they had a plan.

People go on about getting bad owners but I think that will be impossible while our present chairman has a heartbeat! I have enjoyed part of the season and I wish Martinez well but how could anyone genuinely succeed under the present regime? As Phil Walling consistently tells us, 7th is where we will come, but for how long when you have clubs like Cardiff, Southampton and even Stoke City spending more money than the once mighty Everton?

Scott Jones
153 Posted 10/03/2014 at 08:34:22
Like has been said by a few sensible posters...the idea of 2 DF midfielders is four-fold:the full-backs push on,the 2 DF's sit deap,the No10 hovers on the edge of the area and the No 9 in the box....This philoshophy,in theory,widens the pitch so you don't get a cluster-fuck of bodies in the box limiting space to carve out clear-cut chances.

I like the way we are set-up,when it works its a thing of beauty.....the trouble is,some of our players are not up to it yet. the foundations are being built this season.

Given time,i am convinced RM will prove the doubters wrong.

Geoff Evans
154 Posted 10/03/2014 at 09:45:11
Scott 067

Which players do you think are up to it and which aren't?

Scott Jones
155 Posted 10/03/2014 at 10:07:08
Geoff 069

Kevin Mirallas has the ability but not the brains?

Leon Osman – no stamina... no strength.

Ross Barkley – poor decision-making at times. That will improve though given more experience. future star.

Steven Pienaar – age has caught up with him.

Gerard Deulofeu – poor decision making/workrate; needs time to settle... next year hopefully? He's going to be a gem of a player.

James McCarthy & Gareth Barry – need cover to give them the odd rest.

Romelu Lukaku – I feel sorry for the guy! The final ball to him has either not arrived or been poor. good player.

Aiden McGeady – will be a decent player for what he cost us. another for next season.

Steven Naismith – I like him as a squad man; not a first team player; honest pro.

Seamus Coleman – love the guy.

Geoff, I don't think we are miles away... just a little more experience and fine tuning needed.

Jimmy Kelly
156 Posted 10/03/2014 at 12:00:06
Jackie, it's not short memories at all.

I know this is difficult for some people to get their head around but I used to get annoyed with Moyes, and now I get annoyed with Martinez. It's amazing isn't it? Almost as if the club is more important to me than the manager. And talking to people at the game on Saturday, huge swathes of them felt the same way. We all feel that both Moyes and Martinez have faults and feel that as fans we have a right to point them out and complain about them.

I could not care less if Moyes, Martinez or Mourinho was in charge on Saturday, I was not happy with the way we played and I reserve the right to bloody well say so!

Geoff Evans
157 Posted 10/03/2014 at 12:35:37
Scott 75

Agreed with your analysis of players at our disposal. I think personally for what it's worth, that we lack pace and penetration from midfield and too much is being asked of young Berkley. The boy has great potential, but needs someone alongside who can share responsibilities. My fear is that because of small squad the boy isn't being nurtured the way he should be.

Mark Pendleton
158 Posted 10/03/2014 at 12:52:05
I love Roberto’s positivity, but there are times now when he’s really appearing to see things i’m not. I just hope he’s saying a different thing internally because some areas are abundantly clear...

1. Striker or no striker we’ve not been as creative pretty much since Xmas
2. We lack pace and movement, we’re too slow and predictable
3. We lack a plan B. Teams are happy to let us have possession, knowing we will struggle to break them down and they can just try to hit us on the counter-attack
4. Robles - aerial presence or just presence is non-existent, he cannot appear to catch a ball to save his life and his distribution is woeful
5. Unless i’m proven VERY wrong in the final few weeks of the season signing an injured Traore and then keeping him after his latest injury pointless
6. It’s all very well training with the ball as you use different muscles with than without the ball, but players spend more time running with it to get up with play. A coincidence given the number of hamstring injuries we’ve had?

I could go on really, there are just things that are not right at the moment. A big big summer coming up where these need to be addressed and I feel the league will be harder next season.

Jackie Barry
159 Posted 10/03/2014 at 13:13:24
Couldn't agree more Tony, the right words are certainly long term pain. The problem for me though is that too many of us seem all too happy with our current owners, like you said we expect miracles myself included when in reality it is never going to happen with the current setup. I'm at a loss and all I know is that I have felt the same frustrations many times since our current owners came on board. Blaming the manager though is not the answer and it never will be until we see a change in owners, the fans have the power, they just need to realise it.
Kevin Tully
160 Posted 10/03/2014 at 13:04:58
Mark - I would add that our one-touch football is non-existent. If you watch teams closely such as Bayern or Barca, those players do not take two or three touches before they get a pass off.

Whether we have the players to execute that type of football is another discussion entirely, but I am prepared to take some short term pain if we can pull it off in the long run.

If we end up looking upon this season as a learning curve, but still manage a respectable 6th/7th place finish, then surely that's been worth it?

If we carry on next season as we have since Christmas, then Martinez has to realise it's no use trying to instill a style that will never suit the players at his disposal.

Rodgers has changed the way Liverpool are set up since last season. They score the most basic of goals, playing the ball over the top of defences, maybe Roberto can look across the park for lessons. There is always the possibility Martinez intends to implement a mixture of the two styles, and we are only looking at the opening pages this season.

One thing's for sure, we need two permanent strikers next season, no matter how he intends to play.

Brian Harrison
161 Posted 10/03/2014 at 13:09:56
I just hope that behind closed doors at Finch Farm RM is less complimentary as I think that although they were in the game till the penalty, we seem to lack any passion in our play.
As many have commented our form since Xmas has really tailed off, now that could be down to injuries or too many games for a small squad and some members haven't the same energy levels they had prior to Xmas.

I know some will see this as heresy but I would suggest RM look across the park at the way Rodgers has his team playing, fast exciting attacking football. Also apart from missing the first 4 games due to the ban Suarez has played every minute of every game since and I don't see him running out of steam. They get the ball forward early to their quick front men to run onto, were we prefer to make possession more of a priority than attacking with pace which we do possess.

Paul Holmes
162 Posted 10/03/2014 at 14:28:34
What really gets to me and other people is the rubbish questions reporters ask Martinez on the EvertonTV website. During his press conferences, a 5-year-old could ask more meaningful questions. Some of these reporters work for local media so they don't all have to ask so basic and rubbish questions.


On ToffeeWeb, most of the posts are submitted by intelligent fans who have what these so-called reporters don't have and that is a 'brain'. Hopefully most of our fans will agree, and we can get more questions like the ones posted on here asked by better reporters!

Paul Holmes
163 Posted 10/03/2014 at 14:28:34
What really gets to me and other people is the rubbish questions reporters ask Martinez on the EvertonTV website. During his press conferences, a 5-year-old could ask more meaningful questions. Some of these reporters work for local media so they don't all have to ask so basic and rubbish questions.


On ToffeeWeb, most of the posts are submitted by intelligent fans who have what these so-called reporters don't have and that is a 'brain'. Hopefully most of our fans will agree, and we can get more questions like the ones posted on here asked by better reporters!

Tony Abrahams
164 Posted 10/03/2014 at 19:23:37
Think that might just be the problem Jackie, the fans. Just imagine the reaction across the park if hicks and Gillette sold mellwood for a pittance and then intended to lease it back paying nearly 80 million over the coarse of the next fifty years? That's just as long as someone else doesn't purchase it and put the rent up even more. Luckily for Everton the city council bought it and despite implementing government cuts across the board have actually reduced our rent.

It was a disgraceful buisness decision and yet the blue union have received a lot more criticism for allegedly tape-ing a meeting with our chairman than the everton board have ever received over this. Moyes done a great job when you consider our financial restraints and was very well paid to keep his mouth shut.

I know how Everton work he said in the summer when he tried to steal our main assets for a song? When we all know what the phoney sycophant should have really said is I KNOW HOW BILL KENWRIGHT REALLY WORKS!

Paul Smith
165 Posted 11/03/2014 at 21:32:30
Si (#026), I realise why Martinez thinks it's right to play two defensive midfielders. Of course it's good to see Coleman and Baines getting forward but they always did anyway so god knows what your point is. Baines has one assist this season – that's hardly ground breaking stuff, is it?

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads

© ToffeeWeb