Martínez and Mourinho: Compare and Contrast

In Sunday's Observer, Tim Lewis provides a fascinating comparison between José Mourinho and Roberto Martínez.

» Read the full article at The Observer



Reader Comments (13)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Brent Stephens
1 Posted 09/03/2014 at 12:21:55
Interesting article in today’s Observer, comparing Roberto and Mourinho.
It would be more accurate to say that Martinez is the romantic man in English football and Mourinho the most pragmatic.

Martinez curates teams that are often a pleasure to watch. "I will never ask a player to do something he’s not good at. I’ve got a way of playing", he accepts. "I’ll never give you the ball, I want to have most of the possession". His aim is a romantic one: he would like the clubs he manages to play like Barcelona at their peak.

If Martinez creates a world of football as we’d all like it to be, then Mourinho plays in the world as it is.

Interesting comments and comparisons.
Guy Hastings
2 Posted 10/03/2014 at 05:33:14
Nice piece! The closing line sums it all up: "If Martínez creates a world of football as we'd all like it to be, then Mourinho plays in the world as it is."

Michael Penley
3 Posted 10/03/2014 at 07:02:04
"School of Romance"

Could work. Not sure it will win us anything other than a few laughs from across the park though.

Thomas Lennon
5 Posted 10/03/2014 at 12:38:03
Some time ago I remember a discussion saying that it was more important to preserve the 'soul' of this football club than it was to win. If we see ourselves as a footballing club come what may then we seem to have the right manager.

For me this is a football club and football is more about winning than being attractive - which attracts more fans Mourinho's way or Martinez's way?

James Martin
6 Posted 10/03/2014 at 12:58:52
Thomas to answer your question, the Mourinho way. Any criticism of his football is purely subjective and usually from a jealous place. Arsenal’s football is not better than his, Liverpools football is not better than his, pur football is certainly not better than his. His football wins more than anyones in the prem so therefore it is the best because that is the only measure that matters. Goals scored, pretty triangles, flying full backs, all belong to the entertainment category unless they help you to win.

If we finish with more points than last season tgen our football has been better. If we finish with less then it hasnt this season. This is the only definitive measure of a sides football. Everything else is purely subjective. Barcelona brainwashed a lot of people into thinking tgeir way was the most beautiful, the only way to play football. Bayern demolished that with power. Winning is all that matters.

Harold Matthews
7 Posted 10/03/2014 at 14:32:57
We have one or two fairies who turn their back when attempting to block a shot. Mourinho would have them out the door like a shot. Big or small, all his players are fearless and anything less than 100% effort is not tolerated. McCarthy, Kone, Alcaraz and McGeady are a positive pointer to the type of character Martinez wishes to bring in but if he continues to select pansies because they are more comfortable on the ball than tougher guys on the bench, I will not be happy.
Geoff Evans
8 Posted 10/03/2014 at 19:00:06
Did he write this article off his own bat or did BK write it for him. There's a future Everton manager in there somewhere.
Iain Johnston
9 Posted 12/03/2014 at 09:20:51
Yeah Brent, the comparison the article made regarding Mata was interesting too... RM would build a team around him whereas Mourinho showed him the door as he felt his work rate and defensive capabilities aren't up to scratch.

It was a massive article which included Prozone and Opta and how some managers are picking their teams using these alone having listened to the clubs stattos which they are all now employing.

Trevor Lynes
10 Posted 12/03/2014 at 13:00:46
How can anyone truly compare these two very different personalities when Mourinho can spend buckets of dosh and Martinez is shopping at Poundland.

We would take anyone from Mourinho's squad who is not playing regularly including Ba, Mata when he was there etc etc. Lukaku would be third choice at best at Chelsea.

The song comes to mind... I who have nothing!!

No one knows what Martinez would accomplish if he had lots of money to build his idea of a top side.

Jim Harrison
11 Posted 12/03/2014 at 13:22:47
I suppose you could also look at what Bobby himself says. Not the exact quote, but something along the lines of "The pressure to win is greater than it is for me". So, Jose wins by any way he can, Bobby knows he ain't gonna win the league, so he might as well go out there and create entertaining football.

When you look at it, the last boss was a poor man's Mourinho. The new guy is a poor man's Guardiola. Neither had/has the resources to bring in the players to really make a difference, so they did/do what the can with what is available to them. Jose wouldn't win the league at Everton, neither would Pep.

Raymond Fox
12 Posted 14/03/2014 at 21:39:34
Trevor is spot on, how can you compare managers.

If we are racing 2 cars over a straight mile track, Martinez is behind the wheel of a Toyota Yaris, Mourinho is driving a Porsche.

Hardly a fair race is it!
I would suggest its far easier for Mourinho to look good than it is for Roberto.

Jim Lloyd
14 Posted 17/03/2014 at 18:23:41
A daft comparison, if the measure of the men is their relative success. As others have said, Martinez manages a team without anything remotely like the resources Mourinho has.

If Martinez could ever get us winning titles with the type of football that we played in the early sixties, that would do for me.

As it is, he will do well to get us into the Europa League, with the players we've got. That is not knocking those players, it is just logical that if he had sufficient funds to match any of the top four/5/6, we could then judge him.

Wionning isn't all, good football is all.

Tony Draper
15 Posted 18/03/2014 at 06:43:50
"If we are racing 2 cars over a straight mile track, Martinez is behind the wheel of a Toyota Yaris, Mourinho is driving a Porsche."

Car DM leaves the garage at 10:00 am and travels at an average speed of 7th place
Car RM departs the same garage several years later
Car RM wins a shiny silver cup
Discuss ?


Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads