Everton recall Lundstram from Yeovil

, 10 March, 24comments  |  Jump to most recent
John Lundstram is the latest player to be recalled from loan, with Everton electing to end early the young midfielder's spell with Yeovil Town.

Lundstram had been due to stay with the Glovers until the end of the season where teammate Shane Duffy has been spending the campaign but Roberto Martinez has decided to bring him back to Finch Farm.

This follows similar decisions to recall Matthew Kennedy and Matthew Pennington who have since been involved with the Blues' U21s side.  



Reader Comments (24)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Dick Brady
1 Posted 10/03/2014 at 18:23:19
Why wouldn’t Roberto just leave Kennedy, Pennington and Lundstram at the loan clubs?

Surely first team football in the lower leagues is more beneficial to a youngsters development than reserve team football at Everton?

Its not like Roberto has any intention for actually using Kennedy, Pennington or Lundstram in the first team.

Patrick Murphy
2 Posted 10/03/2014 at 18:26:03
Dick perhaps he wants to make the first team players feel the pressure and will threaten to use the youngsters if he thinks any of the first team are not contributing 100%.

He will not have been happy with Saturday's performance despite his philosophical public utterances. I can see a few players being dropped from the squad if they continue to under perform.

Either that or BK has just given RM the summer budget.

Ryan Johnson
3 Posted 10/03/2014 at 18:57:58
Lundstram was no longer a starter at Yeovil due to a large number of loanees coming in. Because of new league regulations only a certain amount of loanees can be selected for the match squad so Lundstram was being omitted from the match day squad alot. If he's not even getting on the bench then I fully agree with bringing him back to help out our under 21's squad where he is selected regularly.

At least now he can get accustomed to
Evertons new style of play under Martinez and be ready for next year should be qualify for Europe as a larger squad will be vital.
Dick Brady
4 Posted 10/03/2014 at 20:15:44
This guy is 20 years old now and if Lundstram is not good enough to get into a relegation struggling Championship side you have to wonder what use he will be to our Top 6 chasing Premier League side?

In fact, if he can’t make an impact at Yeovil, then should we not be asking what he’s doing at a Top 6 Premier League side in the first place?

Might sound a bit unfair but I always think once a player gets to 20/21, you can more or less tell if he’s got it. At least a top manager should be able to tell.

Why keep paying all these 20/21-year-olds thousands of pounds a week knowing full well they will never be good enough for the first team?

Patrick Murphy
5 Posted 10/03/2014 at 20:20:15
Dick, if they are as useless to us, as you say, what makes you think we can just get shut of them? They do have contracts even if they don't feature in the first team.

Every player that is signed for whatever fee is a gamble and you hope that you get the odd Coleman or Osman from the crop. If you consider that Barkley is worth at least £20m and Rodwell was sold for big money, you can see that it is a gamble worth taking.

We can't retain a squad of 30-35 players who are capable of first-team football – in fact, only a few clubs can; so we have to take the rough with the smooth.

Wayne Smyth
6 Posted 10/03/2014 at 20:45:10
Perhaps Martinez wants to take a closer look at him while he plots next seasons signings?

Perhaps its because he's not getting regular games at Yeovil?

Maybe personal reasons he's not settled down there?

Perhaps its one of a dozen reasons you or I don't know about, Dick.

In general terms, Osman was about 23 before he started to make our first team regularly if I remember rightly and it'll be cheaper to keep Lundstram for a few more years paying him a few k's per week or whatever players of his stature get, than get rid of him prematurely like we did with Baines, Callum McManaman etc and have a BIG fee to pay if we want to resign them.

Dick Fearon
7 Posted 10/03/2014 at 20:56:00
OFM was often criticised for releasing players who were approaching 20. At some time, some of them had been lauded as being future Everton stars. Off hand I cannot recall one of them going on to forge a career with another Pem club. Perhaps OFMs judgement was proved correct.

Lundstram and others on recall will be under Roberto's scrutiny where they will need to show that their loan deals have brought improvement and whether they deserve a renewed contract.

Sam Hoare
8 Posted 10/03/2014 at 21:29:00
Perhaps it's because Barry has been looking in need of a rest lately. With some winnable games at home coming up and not a great deal of pressure it might be a good time to give the fringe youngsters a taste of first team...
Mike Allison
9 Posted 10/03/2014 at 21:32:28
Their last game is the only recent one he hasn't been involved in, he's started most since the end of January and been a sub for the others.

I'd like to think this is to continue his development, he's had a taste of first team action and it may be that Roberto wants to work with him on a more regular basis now. You can't coach them if they're away at another club.

His loan spell has been a success, but his position is one we're extremely short of numbers in, with only really Barry and McCarthy able to call it their first choice position. Osman has played there effectively as well but Lundstram may get a chance between now and season's end. Not least because Barry will have to miss at least one game at home to Man City.

Trevor Lynes
10 Posted 10/03/2014 at 21:41:26
Martinez said that Alcaraz was fully recovered and available but he was not on the bench, even though it was weak. I would have thought that a player with his control and experience would have been the obvious choice to rotate with Gareth Barry. The position needs good distribution and being able to read a game rather than pace, so I'm sure that Alcaraz could do that job.
Jamie Crowley
11 Posted 10/03/2014 at 23:44:57
I read somewhere (yes I know...) that the average male athlete does not attain full physical potential until aged 24. Now I can't back up the claim at all but it does seem "reasonable" to me.

There seems to be, in England in particular, a ridiculous amount of pressure on very young men to "make the grade" or they are tossed on the trash heap of "almost men." It seems odd to me and I frankly can't understand it. These kids - and they are just that - really can't mature physically and mentally until they are near their mid-twenties, can they?

If the kid's 20 FFS let's give the boy some more time.

Here in the States in our "football" we draft kids out of college - usually 21 to 22 years old. Very few are starters in the NFL until they are 2-3 years in, putting them at 24-25 years of age. This seems much more reasonable to me...

20 year old kids getting pressure to make it or be gone seems silly to me to be honest.

Chris Jones
12 Posted 11/03/2014 at 00:05:19
Jamie #210: peak physical potential at 24 bollocks! I'm 51 and I'm still waiting
Kieran Kinsella
13 Posted 11/03/2014 at 01:25:06
Lundstram was pretty much a regular at Yeovil and got a good send off from their fans on Twitter.

It is silly to say "If he couldn't hack it there then why is he here" Dick. Firstly, he did make it at Yeovil but if you want to talk about bad loan spells then look no further than Ross Barkley who couldn't get a game in a lousy Leeds team. The same Ross is now in contention for a World Cup place.

Our primary concern as Everton fans is player development while Leeds, Yeovil, MK Dons and others taking our players on loan are more concerned with their own promotion chases, relegation battles. Many of us feel that John Stones will be a better player than say Tony Hibbert and yet we'd rather have seen Hibbert play in the Derby. Why? Because he is experienced and willing to get down and dirty while Stones is learning his trade.

By the same token, as we reach the business end of the season the likes of Yeovil may be reluctant to keep fielding youngsters and schooling other people's players and instead turn to some no-nonsense old pros who are maybe less skilled but also less error prone.

Kieran Fitzgerald
14 Posted 11/03/2014 at 08:34:06
Yeovil have given themselves a fighting chance of avoiding relegation after their last couple of results. I was hoping that Lundstrum would have been left there as the experience would have been good for him.

Now, he'll kick his heels in the reserves and may well go backwards in his development.

Phil Walling
15 Posted 11/03/2014 at 14:54:59
Perhaps Roberto wishes to ensure that these lads are developing ’in the Everton way’ and are not picking up bad habits like forward passing or shooting at goal.

More likely, he wants to take a final look at them before ’sending them down the road.’

Brian Hill
16 Posted 11/03/2014 at 15:27:05
Chris Jones, I am also 51 and it is good to know that I am not alone in believing that my peak years lie ahead, although I did have a pretty good spell between 37 and 41 when we had our three daughters. The future is ours!!

By the way, I know nothing about Lundstram.

David Waugh
17 Posted 11/03/2014 at 17:22:28
Dick Fearnon 194 - I always wanted to ask...... what is 'OFM' the acronym of in relation to David Moyes ?
Gaute Lie
18 Posted 11/03/2014 at 17:49:58
OFM= Our Former Manager
Dick Fearon
19 Posted 11/03/2014 at 23:03:14
Jamie @ 210, You say the average athlete does not reach his peak until his mid 20s. I do not have footballers age data to hand yet I would guess at least a third of PL players would fall into that category.

Taking into account that they would on average be earning somewhere in the region of 100 times the average working mans wage that is an awful lot of cash to pay average players.

I am not surprised nor in any way upset to see players older than 20 with average skills removed from the list. An annual culling of those average players would hopefully give room for others to show if they are above or below average.

Mike Allison
20 Posted 12/03/2014 at 15:39:25
"Perhaps Roberto wishes to ensure that these lads are developing 'in the Everton way' and are not picking up bad habits like forward passing or shooting at goal."

That made me chuckle.

Michael Kenrick
Editorial Team
21 Posted 13/03/2014 at 03:53:54
Some more on this story:

Yeovil Town manager Gary Johnson has explained the decision to allow Everton midfielder John Lundstram the opportunity to return to Goodison Park. The 20 year old cut his loan spell short after Saturday's game against Sheffield Wednesday, after he finished his time at Huish Park as an unused substitute on the last occasion he was named on a Glovers teamsheet.

Johnson confirmed to BBC Somerset yesterday that the lack of game time towards the end of Lundstram's Yeovil career was a factor in how things turned out, saying that in the end it was a mutual decision between both clubs and Lundstram himself to cut the deal short:

"It was a little bit mutual on everybody's part really. He wasn't going to get regular games. He was a bit worried about us having six loans, when we can only use five – and then us winning games (without him). Then (Ruben) Palazuelos put in a good performance (against Sheffield Wednesday) and we've got Joe Ralls there as well. So I think John felt that rather than sit on our bench or not be involved, that he'd rather go back and play in Everton Under-21s."

Lundstram had been on loan at Huish Park since late November, coming into a side that had been struggling somewhat in the lead-up to his debut against Watford at Vicarage Road. That was his first taste of Championship football, having played a successful part in Doncaster Rovers' League One promotion campaign last season. Overall, despite his time ending early, Johnson felt that it had been a good experience for both Yeovil and Lundstram:

"We thank him for his time here. He had sixteen games, which is a fair stint in the Championship. We gave him his Championship chance, and hopefully he has learned something, both physically and mentally. He came into a place where he's probably never been in this situation before where a club is fighting for their lives. Some people can handle that and some people can't."

Geoff Trenner
22 Posted 13/03/2014 at 13:37:41
Yeovil fans I've spoken to (they are my local team) were undecided on Lundstram. They say he showed touches of class but not that much better than what they already have.

Duffy, on the other hand, they REALLY rate. He's been MotM in pretty much every game he's played for The Glovers & they want to keep him.

Ray Roche
23 Posted 13/03/2014 at 14:13:58
Kieran Kinsella @225
"Ross Barkley who couldn't get a game in a lousy Leeds team"

Kieran, that's bollocks, mate. Below are some of the comments from Leeds fans after he left. Mainly from the Yorkshire Evening Post, he was also highly rated at Sheff Wed when he was there. My mate is a season ticket holder at Leeds (and not very happy!) and really rated Barkley, but as Leeds had that gobshite Warnock in charge he said that nothing surprised the fans at that time. There was also some in fighting between Warnock and the board and some felt that sending Barkley back was some sort of statement.

" Typical Warnock the most creative CENTRAL midfielder the clubs seen for years so stick him on the wing...genius maybe he couldn't kick it high enough!"

"Watched Barkley a few times this season, they say he,s the next Rooney,its strange Leeds have no place for him.Very Very talented."

"Barkley was class when he played. How Warnock could play Brown or Austin - both of whom are utterly hopeless - instead of him is mystifying"

"How a player like Barkley cannot be guaranteed games ahead of the likes of Brown and Norris is beyond belief."

Mike Allison
24 Posted 13/03/2014 at 16:18:32
Good info there Ray.

Geoff, what you say suggests confirmation of a prejudice I already have, which is that Lundstram may be more suited to a higher level, whereas Duffy is a Championship player who isn't going to make it at Everton. Other posters have commented on his use of the ball, which is poor, and wouldn't suit the way we currently play.


Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads

© ToffeeWeb