How computer analysts took over at Britain's top football clubs

, 10 March, 11comments  |  Jump to most recent
Roberto Martinez and Everton feature heavily in this look at the prevalence of statistical analysis and metrics in the modern game.
It is the psychology of a player that Martínez believes is the most crucial aspect of whether a player flourishes or wanes. And it is here that statistics or metrics are most restricted and unreliable.

» Read the full article at The Observer



Reader Comments (11)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Dick Fearon
1 Posted 10/03/2014 at 22:32:34
After ploughing my way through all that, I feel like having a good weep. What in hell's name is our beautiful game morphing into? Are we creating a robotical non-sport for geeks?

Are they gradually removing emotions and replacing them with emoticons? Take the heart and soul out of the game and it will perish.

Patrick Murphy
2 Posted 10/03/2014 at 23:00:14
I read it all as well, Dick; it was grim reading. The money people have taken a simple game with what used to be relatively simple rules and made it into a grotesque version of what used to be known as 'football'. A game where any group of kids could just get a ball and enjoy themselves; soon we won't be able to tell the difference between a computer simulation and the game itself.

I suppose a sport which generates so much money will inevitably lead to a load of hangers-on trying to make a few bob for themselves and it is what happens when corporations become involved: they don't love the game they love the money.

Anthony Lamb
3 Posted 10/03/2014 at 23:43:26
The article is very interesting. It alerts us to the fantastic resource that Everton have in having access to a data base giving them detailed information on 130,000 players in 130 countries. Now then.... out of all those 130,000 players in 130 countries Everton take on loan a young man by the name of... Traore.

There are systems able to analyse every facet of a players capabilities, application, technique etc and yet players such as Pienaar etc cannot hit a barn door from 12 yards after being involved in the professional game for God knows how long? Wonderful all this science and technology isn't it? Further examples of professional soccer, especially the Premier League, being a breeding ground and feeding trough for an extensive range of charlatans.

Dick Fearon
4 Posted 11/03/2014 at 23:29:28
In my 1980 badge course, computers were unheard of and we student coaches made extensive use of note pad paper. One segment of the course with two students per player we had to analyse their performance in a regular game. We were provided with fact sheets containing tick a boxes for the likes of short and long balls, attacking and defensive heading plus the usual mundane stuff.

It was disappointing there were no boxes for individual brilliance or initiative. in fact it became obvious that kind of stuff was frowned upon by those who controlled the course. Even in those days, conformity was smothering the English game. For every Tom Finney there were dozens, nay, hundreds of cloggers.

I kept Willi Meisels 'Football Revolution" under my pillow and that helped me remember there was much much more to our game than the garbage taught on those courses.

Eric Myles
5 Posted 12/03/2014 at 04:48:30
"Their players relentlessly practised throw-ins, corners and free-kicks – targeting "pomos" or positions of maximum opportunity – and scored around half their goals, far above the league average, from these set-pieces"

It would seem Martinez doesn't believe in the power of "pomos"

Dan Brierley
6 Posted 12/03/2014 at 23:37:57
Anthony Lamb, you nailed it. All these superb databases full of stats, and we end up with an injured player.
David Ellis
7 Posted 13/03/2014 at 02:08:35
Very interesting article. I did n't find it depressing at all. Intutition is just our way of making sense of the world based on our previous (narrow) experiences. Mathematics and analysis of specific statistics is another way of doing this. Both are flawed. But link them together and you will get closer to the truth.

I remember hearing the phrase "pomo" (position of maximum opportunity) back in the 80s as even then someone had worked out that a lot of goals came from set pieces. However recent stats I have seen show that in fact not many goals come from corners. So the Bolton routine from the mid 2000s no longer seems to work - I think because if you lose the ball to a Premier League team you won't get it back so quickly.

Anyway it is useful to know whether corners do in fact lead to a lot of goals or not - this is a matter of fact not intutition.

Derek Turner
8 Posted 13/03/2014 at 12:17:39
So you mean that all the donkeys Big Sam has bought over the years to avoid relegation at successive clubs were part of the plan? I thought he just hated football resulting from open play.

Andrew Ellams
9 Posted 13/03/2014 at 13:00:11
Too much information just muddies the water and makes it tougher to make a decision. Sport in general has become massively over complicated with advances in technology. You just need to look at the coach's room that they have in rugby that looks like something akin to a NASA control room or cricketers walking back to the pavilion to analyse how they got out on the laptop. It's madness and makes a mockery of the sporting greats who excelled for decades without any of this nonsense.
David Ellis
10 Posted 15/03/2014 at 07:52:18
Andrew
I appreciate your sentiments, but that's like saying France could invade Germany using cannons and horses because it worked for Napoleon. Those old greats would not win nowadays, no more than Napoleon would, regardless of their greatness. Times and techniques move on.

I remember Brian Clough defending criticism of his European Cup winning Forest side. He insisted they were the best club side ever, and the said "if people did not have stop watches they would still be saying that Roger Bannister was quicker than Seb Coe". It's hard to argue with that.

Robin Cannon
11 Posted 17/03/2014 at 22:22:10
So I want Martinez to have access to all of this, which he can combine with his intution to obtain players and build a plan which succeeds according to his philosophy.

The data is important, but it's how the data is used that's more important. Sam Allardyce used stats and metrics to create a team that was effective in achieving what he wanted it to achieve. And it was ugly. Valeriy Lobanovskyi used stats and metrics to create a team that was effective in achieving what he wanted to achieve. And it was attractive and groundbreaking.


Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads

© ToffeeWeb