Martinez on cup fallout and injuries

, 12 March, 65comments  |  Jump to most recent
Jagielka won't be rushed back

Roberto Martinez spoke to evertontv yesterday and discussed the mood at Finch Farm in the wake of the FA Cup disappointment at Arsenal last weekend and the condition of Phil Jagielka and Steven Pienaar.

The manager expressed how much hurt there was in the dressing room after the 4-1 defeat at the Emirates which ended Everton's involvement in the competition but he was heartened by the reaction which he feels proves how much the players care and wanted to progress.

"There are aspects that we need to learn from and make sure we carry on developing and learning from those experiences," the Spaniard said.

"Now we need to switch our concentration to the League. We've got 33 points to fight for... and it's an essential part of our season."

Looking ahead to Saturday's visit of Cardiff City, Martinez explained that he will be assessing Jagielka and Pienaar this week, as well as a couple of other players who picked up what he described as minor "knocks and bruises""

The captain has missed two matches with a hamstring strain and Martinez is keen not to rush him back and risk more serious damage, insisting that the club's medical staff will ensure that he is 100% fit before returning him to action.

"Phil is recovering well and now it's a case of assessing him day by day. He is the kind of player who at 90% will push himself forward to help the team but we need to make sure, with the number of matches we have ahead — 11 games in nine weeks is a very demanding period — that we protect him and make sure he isn't rushed back too early.

Pienaar, meanwhile, had to be withdrawn from the game at the Emirates with a knock of his own but Martinez was confident that his injury was nothing to be concerned about.

Quotes sourced from evertontv



Reader Comments (65)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Tony Smith
1 Posted 12/03/2014 at 07:48:29
Pienaar looks as though a break would do him a world of good. His play has bordered on the pedestrian recently, his body language is very poor and doesn’t look in a positive frame of mind at all.

Over the years he has been my favourite Everton player but age seems to be catching up with him and we don’t see those clever runs and interplays that have made him such a pleasure to watch.

Here’s hoping he finds his form as soon as possible as when playing well we are much a better team.

Anto Byrne
3 Posted 12/03/2014 at 08:17:26
He has been a very good player but now fails to deliver. I think Bryan Oviedo is a much better prospect going forward; he has pace and can score goals. Summer business should bring in at least 4 new faces.
Peter Murray
4 Posted 12/03/2014 at 08:48:47
We are currently 5 points off 5th place with 2 games in hand and winnable games coming up. Everything to play for.
Andrew Lawrenson
5 Posted 12/03/2014 at 09:11:51
I am a big fan of Roberto and I’ve been impressed with his first season with us. I feel that, once the end of the season as come, he must do a lot of hard work with tough decisions. He will have seen all the players both in matches and training and must’ve surely been making mental notes.

It is time for some of our seasoned professionals to be moved on: Osman, Pienaar, and Hibbert must be shown the door. The likes of Distin can only have one more season left... and with Lukaku, Deulofeu, Barry all to leave either at the end of this season or next, we are in trouble. Gibson is too injury-prone, Kone is older than the pillars holding the roof up at the Glwadys St, Alcaraz is injury-prone and, with some of the reserves obviously not up to standard, then what are we gonna do?

Out of the present squad, only Howard, Coleman, Jagielka, Baines, Stones, Oviedo, McGeady, Mirallas, McCarthy, and Barkley merit places in future squads so – unless we do have some real prospects in the Under-18s – we are up shit creek with not even a canoe never mind a paddle.

The other thing I wanna say is Roberto’s infectious positivity is now starting to wear a little thin with me; whenever I hear him speak, I know exactly what words he will be using. Next season is gonna be a real test for him and he will have my continued support and although he deserves a holiday like the rest of us I hope it is only a 3-night break in Tenerife before getting back to work and trying to take us to a higher level.

Patrick Murphy
6 Posted 12/03/2014 at 10:07:20
Is it true that our motto for next season will be "Nil Statistics Nisi Opta"?
Phil Walling
7 Posted 12/03/2014 at 10:03:27
My biggest fear continues to centre on the man’s desire to transform us into another Wigan. Many of his signings demonstrate this, none more so than those who appeared – or who haven’t yet appeared – in the January window.

Because Robles was a lucky Cup mascot up the road, Roberto tried to re-create the scenario here. How misguided he was is now a matter of history.

As for the football style, well it’s pretty but pretty ineffective against the big boys and it’s persistence at any price did see the Pie Eaters’ dream end in relegation. But it’s a ’filofosy’, you see!

Of course, all this sits well with our Chairman who continues to smile benignly because he’s only being asked to shell out sick pay for an increasing number of the playing staff!

Jimmy Hill
8 Posted 12/03/2014 at 10:23:42
God bless Bill Kenwright for bringing Roberto Martinez to our historical club and being a true custodian. We could have been playing in red, be called The Tigers or be a feeder club to Liverpool by now with the wrong very rich owner.

Martinez is one the best in the league great season: 5th as minimum; Spurs are going to blow out... Possible 4th ahead of Arsenal.

We’ll done, BK – keep doing what’s right for my beloved Blues.

Christine Foster
9 Posted 12/03/2014 at 10:36:10
Jimmy Hill, I don’t know which is the biggest joke, your name, your post or the fact it’s all a wind up... l’ll go for all three and congratulate you for your sarcasm..
David Ellis
10 Posted 12/03/2014 at 10:32:34
Jimmy Hill – obviously the Martinez optimism is still catching! I agree 5th is possible - but 7th is more likely. I would settle for 6th. 4th is almost certainly gone.

Phil Walling – and then at the other extreme we have good old Phil. I think we have to stick with the philosophy. I agree it has been ineffective against Spurs and Arsenal and Chelsea. We don’t look dangerous enough, the off the ball movement is either ponderous or ignored. But I think that can be fixed without changing the philosophy. Chopping and changing does not work without massive cash injections, and its not an option for us. We have to go through this transitional period and grit our teeth when it does not work out well.

I thought we would get a team that was naive and cavalier under Martinez, but despite recent disappointments this has still been an excellent transitional season and far better than I feared. Changing the philosophy (or changing managers) now would be a massive mistake in my view.

Jimmy Hill
11 Posted 12/03/2014 at 10:31:14
Phil Walling, how can you possibly say that? Robles didn’t cost us the game... I agree he looks a bit dodgy on the high ball. But his overall positioning was pretty good, although I’m not a fan keepers punching all the time.

As for the football being ineffective, we match most teams but yes, we have not been finishing. That’s not a problem of style but composure and experience.

In my eyes, and I believe like most Evertonians, our chairman is doing as well as he can with his limited resources. Are you not reading the news on some of the great foreign ownerships going on at the moment.

Me? I love Everton and the fans own the club; rich owners will walk way from the game one day. Everton will still be there, stronger than ever because we have an owner who is one of us.

Patrick Murphy
12 Posted 12/03/2014 at 10:37:47
Phil do you reside in the Wigan area? If you don’t perhaps you should think about moving there it is obviously a place you are obsessed with.

The manager expressed how much hurt there was in the dressing room after the 4-1 defeat at the Emirates which ended Everton’s involvement in the competition but he was heartened by the reaction which he feels proves how much the players care and wanted to progress.

Mucha
Coleman*
Heitinga
Distin*
Baines*
Mirallas* (79’ Barkley)*
Neville booked:39’ (46’ Anichebe)
Osman booked:40’*
Pienaar*
Fellaini booked:57’ (58’ Gibson booked:87’)
Jelavic
Subs not used
Springthorpe
Duffy
Hitzlsperger
Naismith*

Seven of the squad who took part at the Emirates also knew what it felt like to fall at this hurdle last season - It just shows that players don’t remember much about how they felt when they were knocked out last year as I didn’t see a real determination to put it right last Saturday.

Phil Walling
13 Posted 12/03/2014 at 10:48:18
’Seven of the squad who took part at the Emirates also knew what it felt like to fall at this hurdle last season’. And two who knew what it was like to triumph in that match didn’t exactly cover themselves with glory last Saturday, did they, Patrick?
Nigel Gregson
14 Posted 12/03/2014 at 11:05:02
Phil Walling - I suggest a read of the book ’the numbers game’ especially the section on Roberto’s time at Wigan and about what exactly he did and didn’t do there.
Phil Walling
15 Posted 12/03/2014 at 11:33:21
Nigel, I don’t need to read the book to know it ended in both triumph and disaster. Methinks we’ll wait a long time for the triumph here!
John Daley
16 Posted 12/03/2014 at 11:41:05
33 points left to play for with the team 22 points short of the 70 point target Martinez set at the start of the season. It’s doable, with a bit of luck, but it still wouldn’t be enough to creep into those Champions League places.

The red shite resurgence this season has caught everyone by surprise and, instead of spontaneously combusting as per usual, they’ve kept on churning out results. The consequence of their new-found consistency (and eternal supply of spawny bastardry) is that the points tally needed to take that fourth place has crept up in comparison to past seasons.

When the 70 point target was first mooted, some on here criticised Martinez for not being a realist. If he does actually go on to meet that target, only to finish fifth, will he be praised for our record Premier League points haul or criticised for failing to do even better and oust one of the top four in his first season?

George McKane
17 Posted 12/03/2014 at 11:57:15
Fascinating article in Sunday’s Observer Newspaper (Technology Supplement) on Football and technology. A great part of it on Martinez. Worth a read.

Underlined for me, in my opinion and that all everything is on TW, that we have a great Manager at the Club.

Time of course will tell.

Right now. although bitterly disappointed by the weekend result and some of recent games, I am still more than happy that we have Martinez and believe that his ideas,ideals and plans for our style of play will pay off.

Up The Blues.

Kevin Tully
18 Posted 12/03/2014 at 11:51:03
I know that result at Arsenal hurt, but I really don’t understand "that’s it, the season is over for me" malarkey.

We’ve got three huge games left at Goodison Park against Arsenal, Man City and Man Utd. We have a real fight on our hands to finish above Spurs & Utd. It would be a brilliant first season as JD says to surpass out best ever Premier League points total of 65, AND finish above Man Utd and a certain Mr Fellaini, who both left for ’bigger and better things.’

I want a Europa League place because there are no better away games than in the middle of Khazakgetthealeinastan (plus an excuse for 3 days off).

It’s also important we finish this season with a flourish, it will give our lads confidence in the new manager’s methods, especially if we can get to the magic 70 point mark. No more losses will mean what? Lost 5 in the League all season? Another record to aim for.

Come on now Blues – it’s all to play for!

Jimmy Kelly
19 Posted 12/03/2014 at 12:44:22
John, I certainly wouldn’t criticise him if we finished 5th, and certainly not if we got 22 out of the possible 33 points this season.

However, I’ve said numerous times on here that the number of points from season to season is totally irrelevant. There are different teams in the league every year, and other teams get better or worse. The only thing that matters is how far up the table your points get you this year.

In the last Olympic final Tyson Gay ran the 100m in 9.80 seconds. That would have been enough to win all but one of the previous Olympic finals, and would have taken silver in the other. Do you think that makes him feel any better about finishing fourth? I doubt it. He went there to beat his competitors and didn’t, the past would have no bearing on it.

Phil Walling
20 Posted 12/03/2014 at 13:30:37
I read the other day that Everton are the 10th best resourced club in the Premier. We shall undoubtedly finish 7th so just like his predecessor, Martinez will have done a good job. Nothing more.
Denis Richardson
21 Posted 12/03/2014 at 13:22:13
Again far too much crying in a dark corner going on here. Some people already bricking it for next season when there’s still 1/3 of this season to go. I really do wonder why some people on this site bother to support Everton in the first place – if you want a football club without any problems then support Real Madrid or Bayern instead.

We don’t have an ageing issue in the squad that is any different to pretty much every other team. Every year, players get older – shock horror! It’s the manager’s job to bring in fresh faces to replace old ones. People (including me) moaned for ages that there was far too much deadwood in the squad – Martinez in barely half a season has gotten rid of most of it, as well as signing FIVE new players. He’ll have the summer to carry on his rebuilding job, just give the guy a fucking break – did you expect him to sign 20 odd players in half a season? We will be just fine.

For those on the brink of slitting their wrists at the thought of our squad for next season, keep in mind that without even signing any new players, we already have Kone, Oviedo and Gibson to come back. Yes some loanees will go – but... we can still bring in new ones!

I am sure Martinez will sign at least another two or three permanent players in the summer, hopefully some Michu type unheard of player from the continent. In the meantime, why don’t we just concentrate on supporting the team for the remaining 11 (yes ELEVEN!) games of the season and leave next season to... next season.

Ian Burns
22 Posted 12/03/2014 at 14:04:55
Dennis - 428 - well said Dennis - agree 100%. Some of the posts on here are akin to crapping yourself over a dentist’s appointment in August when it is only March.

Let’s enjoy the rest of this season and get behind RM and the boys. Enjoy summer and come back with high hopes for next season.

Mark Andersson
23 Posted 12/03/2014 at 13:44:00
Once again, fascinating reading from all the above. I have to agree with the optimism. Liverpool where shite last year, and this season they have stepped up a notch. We can do the same. It’s going to be a great run in for all teams from the bottom to the top.

So just get behind OUR team and do what all good supporters do and SUPPORT. Happy days to all you blue fans all over the world.

Dan Parker
24 Posted 12/03/2014 at 14:11:29
We’ll never win anything until we have a sufficient squad to cover for a few injuries to key players and a couple of solid strikers...

Let’s face it, we’ll never be able to afford a world class striker while BK owns the club and that makes the difference. All the teams above us have more than one striker capable of a glut of goals, we don’t.

And belief..

(or Wigan’s cup tactics)

Jay Harris
25 Posted 12/03/2014 at 14:42:20
The league (unlike the cup) is a marathon not a sprint and over the season the better quality squads rise to the top.

I call them squads and not teams because in the current climate the top clubs could field two Premier League teams and still stay near the top.

Therein lies our biggest problem. While our best 11 is reasonably capable of competing with the top clubs, they cannot maintain it over a season and the deputies are not up to top level. We keep shopping at Paddies market while the top clubs shop at Harrods.

Good coaching and teamwork can make a small difference but not enough to be serious about winning things. The sooner we get Kenwright and his cronies out the sooner we can look to rebuild what was once a great club.

Scott Jones
26 Posted 12/03/2014 at 15:01:45

Denis Richardson
428

Good post mate....spot on!!

Steve Jones
28 Posted 12/03/2014 at 14:52:29
Jay

You’re missing the second half of your sentence at the end there: "Get Kenwright and his cronies out... and replace him with someone outrageously rich who will jump when the fanbase tell him to... the sooner we can look..." etc. Getting rid of Kenwright is only half the job and, in all likelihood, will be the easier half.

For the rest of it, well, I didn’t want Martinez in, I thought Pereira would give us more technically and more credibility in Europe to bring in players. I was wrong. Martinez is a fine manager and, to be honest, the very fact that we’re all bitterly disappointed about not going down to the Emirates and playing Arsenal off the park and getting all twitchy about missing out on the Champions League is the clearest testimony to that I can imagine. When would we have even dreamed of being able to do that over the last decade? .... Maybe the 08-09 season before Yakubu and Arteta got injured? Apart from that, when?

We’ve not seen anything of Kone really yet so maybe next year he has a blinder? Young McAleny is a definite prospect we’ll be pulling through. Garbutt is the same. Oviedo will be back and we might even get a few games out of Gibbo. Obviously Barry is being offered a deal and his comments, last I heard, haven’t been negative. We’ve still properly got to see what McGeady offers and Mirallas cant have another season as poor as this one... and we know when he’s on his game he’s a serious player. Maybe we get to play with another of the Barca kids when Deulofeu goes back as well... that’s just a good deal all round.

Realistically then, even with a third of the season left, we’ve got a lot to be positive about looking forward. If we can just pick up a solid 20-goal-a-season striker somewhere, I reckon we can really start to dream big...

John Daley
29 Posted 12/03/2014 at 15:26:12
Nope, I’m sure he was gutted. 

Imagine though, if you will, that this Billy Whiz’s previous best time was 9.93 seconds and so he employs a nifty new trainer with totally different coaching methods (say... a sweat-band sporting Jo Brand seductively stripping off her size fucking massives in front of him, spreading her tree trunks and offering him a closer look at ’Chewbacca’ yawning) who optimistically states her aim is to get his time to 9.80 seconds and the gobsmacked Mr Gay says he’d be absolutely delighted to get near that time but doubts he could actually do it.

The gutted Gay, although ultimately missing out on the medals, couldn’t really turn round after actually achieving the specified speed and say "You’ve let me down badly here... .Brand. Although I reached the target time I previously thought unattainable,  I’m absolutely livid that there were still 3 lanky streaks of piss who powered home in front of me. You’re taking the piss. Go get your bags and jog on... Actually Jo, I’ll go call you a taxi. One of those big six-seater ones. I don’t want you dropping dead half way down the street".

The only point I was trying to make was that when first mooted, it was widely accepted that getting close to that 70 point mark would be an excellent achievement by Martinez. Now, even if that target (which many thought fanciful) is reached,  there will still be those saying he’s useless, tactically naive, ’turning us into Wigan’ etc.

If he finishes with more Premier League points in his first season than his predecessor did in the previous eleven, then surely that still represents some sort of achievement. Any improvement, even a slight one, is not to be sniffed at when you consider he’s still in the early stages of implementing a totally different playing style and stamping his personality on the place.

Craig Walker
32 Posted 12/03/2014 at 15:50:52
Sometimes think we need a reality check as Evertonians. We seem to think that we've got a God-given right to win things. Like everyone else, I was absolutely gutted on Saturday and have been on a downer since the Anfield debacle. It seems that the closer we get to achieving something, the harder we get knocked back. However, who honestly relished the draw for the QF when it came out of the hat?

My first thought was "well, that's us out". We competed for 75 minutes and blew a couple of good situations. That, I'm afraid is the difference between winning and losing. We haven't played that well in 2014 if truth be told but normally we are hard to beat. Everyone tells me that Southampton have had a wonderful season playing some good stuff with England internationals. Is the same not true of us? Last time I looked we were way above them in the league. We lost one league game at Goodison in 2013 because of stupidity. Not long ago, we had the highest points total we had achieved in the same period since we last won the league. We're doing as well as the current league champions and their multi millions.

The reality is this. Until we find players who can deliver in the big games when it matters and not just quote empty platitudes in the press and then not turn up on the day then we will continue to be a good team that can beat anybody on their day but will never win anything. Those players tend to cost money that we don't have. If we had a £50 million strike force then I think we'd comfortably be in the top four this season.

I think if the RS were below us then we'd be a lot happier. I think that is what depresses me the most. I hate to say it but they've finally found some consistency and a potent attack and that is the difference.

Darryl Ritchie
33 Posted 12/03/2014 at 16:31:49
There are "glass half-full" ToffeeWebbers. There are "glass half-empty" ToffeeWebbers. And then there's a few that see the glass shattered.

Phil, is there anything about the current version of EFC that you actually like?

Patrick Murphy
34 Posted 12/03/2014 at 16:42:15
Evertonians don't think that their club has a god-given right to win things but the history of the club dictates that we should be in the mix on occasion. I don't mean winning the PL or anything daft, but we should be a club that is capable of making a sustained effort on the CL places even if it means missing out on it.

Too often in the recent past we have been the masters of our own misfortune, too often the players haven't rolled up their sleeves and given 100% effort. We know what the players are capable of but there is a mental block in some of their minds and it shows.

I have seen many Everton teams and a lot were far inferior to the group of players we have at our disposal at the moment, they fought tooth and nail to please the supporters and had some nearly moments along the way. I was 35 years old the last time Everton won a trophy that will be 20 years next season with only a single FA Cup final appearance to show for all the effort that the players and supporters have put in during that period.

One FA Cup final appearance is hardly the best our club should be doing even in this day and age, Evertonians are right to expect more from their club; Previous to the last couple of decades the only ground that Evertonians feared going to was Elland Road, now it's a litany of places we don't like travelling to as we don't expect to win.

This group of players if they were put their heart and soul into it are more than capable of winning all of the remaining league games - they won't though and will probably cock up on Saturday and again the following Saturday as they limp along and dream about their holidays.

Jimmy Kelly
35 Posted 12/03/2014 at 16:43:14
I agree with you John, as I say I certainly wouldn't be criticising Martinez for it, believe me I am and have long been a 'realist' - I think finishing 5th is an excellent achievement for us at this moment in time.

The point I was making is that while I think finishing 5th with less than points than year would be an achievement, finishing 7th with more wouldn't. That's because our competition is against the other 19th teams, not a previous incarnation of ourselves.

Just to be clear though, at the start of the season I'd have been relatively happy with 7th and I still would now.

Steve Pugh
36 Posted 12/03/2014 at 16:46:12
I have a question that I hope won't cause offence. I am wondering whether those people who are claiming season over, Martinez is useless, Everton are crap, my name is Phil Walling etc, are from generations of Evertonians or whether you are the first in your family to don the beautiful blue.

My Great Great Grandad played for the Toffees in 1902 and the families support goes back much further and to me this season is far from over, if I complained the way some people do my folks would rip me a new one.

We have no right to be at the top, nor to win a thing. Nil Satis Nisi Optimum applies to the fans as well as the players/management/coaches and board

Raymond Fox
38 Posted 12/03/2014 at 17:29:25
I have to agree Steve, too many fans on here have unrealistic expectations of the team. Take the Arsenal game, the Bookies who take an informed impartial view, bet 4/5 Arsenal 7/2 Everton 11/4 the draw.

We get beat and by the comments off some, anybody would think we were favourite to win the game! It was a bum draw; away to Arsenal was always going to be difficult, so it proved.

We will likely finish in the League where we usually do most seasons, which in itself deserves lots of credit, which by the way we do get off the media.

Unfortunately, I can''t see anything changing much in the near future though, the reason being our finances!
OFM couldn't win a trophy in all the time he was here and Roberto will find it just as difficult. We should give the most attention to the Cups, because they offer our best chance by far.

Kevin Tully
39 Posted 12/03/2014 at 18:12:03
Funnily enough, here is a predictor for the final League placings. I don't think it's too far off actually;

Link

Clive Lewis
40 Posted 12/03/2014 at 18:50:33
Yes, let's get behind them this season and look forward to next. Next season will be our year, when Kone and Gibson are back; we will be transformed. Actually, scrap that; let's look forward, fingers crossed, to next season and positive signings.
Phil Walling
41 Posted 12/03/2014 at 18:53:56
I totally agree that we have no right to win things. What I must learn is to accept that fact and be eternally grateful that we are eternally seventh.

Martinez is God. 100 times.

How’s that for penance?

Clive Lewis
42 Posted 12/03/2014 at 19:04:25
Kevin,

My top 7 prediction for what it's worth, yes I believe if Man Utd beat Liverpool this weekend, they will be 8 points behind 4th:

Man City
Chelsea
Arsenal
Man Utd
Liverpool
Everton
Spurs

Jimmy Hill
43 Posted 12/03/2014 at 18:49:28
Christine Foster perhaps some of us care about the club enough to realise that the wrong choice of owner can do real damage, ie, Hull, Cardiff and now Charlton. Most of their fans would rather their clubs stayed safe hands. Not everyone thinks BK is doing a bad job. It all about opinions. As for my name it wasn't my decision, but you make your own mind up.
Raymond Fox
44 Posted 12/03/2014 at 19:07:22
Phil, we all want to win trophies, but we need to show some common sense also. Be disappointed when we lose, okay but some fans totally over react.

Martinez is not perfect by a long way, and is open to criticism like all managers and players.

Let's face it though, he has hardly been a failure has he!

Eugene Ruane
45 Posted 12/03/2014 at 19:17:34
Phil Walling (404) - "My biggest fear continues to centre on the man's desire to transform us into another Wigan"

Not really sure who you think you're convincing - everything you post (absolutely definitely and without doubt) tells us your biggest fear is not being able to say 'I was right.'

Nick Entwistle
46 Posted 12/03/2014 at 19:34:49
Clive, I like the idea of Liverpool out of the top 4, but without winning this weekend, Man Utd won't get near.

However, ideal scenario, Liverpool claim 4th, yet Utd take the Champions Leak. Liverpool are then hoisted by their own petard.

Ian Burns
47 Posted 12/03/2014 at 19:38:38
Steve - 458 - you have captured the mood swing on this thread quite nicely. People are beginning to realise that we are actually SUPPORTERS who care and who believe we are making progress. We recognise the club's limitations and the reasons for that are for another time and another thread.

My grandfather; my father and myself are a generation of Evertonians and I saw my first game in the late 1950's which was a cup tie replay against Charlton Athletic which we won 4-2. If I may be nostalgic for one moment, I stood in the Boy's Pen and the game was played in thick fog. The next day the Daily Express headline was "The Greatest Game Never Seen".

Jimmy Kelly
48 Posted 12/03/2014 at 19:28:20
Raymond, I think whether or not Martinez has been a failure depends on what you expected of him.

For me, absolutely not. I'm not 100% happy by any means, but he's basically done what I expected of him. He's kept us competitive, we've had some good games and we've played some decent stuff.

Look back to the start of the season on here though, and you can see why some people are very disappointed.

There was a lot of talk of how the football would be revolutionary - it hasn't been.

We were told we would full of excitement and goals, we might lose some games badly but we'd hand out some thrashings too - not happened.

Our young players were all going to get chances and the old favourites would be axed - couldn't be further from the truth. Osmans played every game, hibberts getting a new contract, naismiths moved up the pecking order and vellios and Duffy are further away than they ever were. Only Barkley has really benefitted in that sense.

The fact is, our ills were never going to be fixed by a change of manager but many believed that could be the case.

Jon Cox
49 Posted 12/03/2014 at 19:24:36
Quite simple really.

If you instill a losing mentality over a period of ten years then a guy coming in is never going to change that way of thinking what-so-ever.

Our fortunes will only change overall when RM has his own squad with his mentality.

Of all the players we've had in the past 10-11 seasons I would have loved RM to have had his way of playing football instilled into those players.

I just reckon we should be patient with RM but let the guys upstairs know we're watching them.

What was the last total worth of these people 50-100-150 mill. Well if they don't want to invest their money in OUR club then my message to them is

Either shape up or ship out.

If you're not prepared to back one of the best young managers in Europe then

bugger off!

Ian Tunstead
50 Posted 12/03/2014 at 19:52:06
Jon, maybe its even more simple. Maybe the simple truth is we haven't had the money of the top sides to be able to bring in top quality players to compete with the sides above us. If you have to rely on loans and bargain basement signings its going to be a struggle for who ever is in charge.

So can we stop trying to blame every bad thing on everything or everyone other than Martinez while giving Martinez all the praise for every good thing that's going on? Perhaps the truth is somewhere in between.

Kevin Tully
51 Posted 12/03/2014 at 19:49:39
Jimmy 481 - Are you serious with this ;

"Our young players were all going to get chances and the old favourites would be axed - couldn't be further from the truth. Osmans played every game, hibberts getting a new contract, naismiths moved up the pecking order and vellios and Duffy are further away than they ever were. Only Barkley has really benefitted in that sense."

Shipped out - Jelavic, Heitinga, Anichebe, Fellaini.

Young players given a chance - Barkley, Stones, Oviedo, Deulofeu.

That's in the first 6 months. Osman was put on the bench until injuries took their toll. Vellios and Duffy just aren't up to the required standard I'm afraid, no Evertonians I know have been calling for them to start a game.

Let's see who we line up with in August eh? I think he's not afraid of shipping out anyone, so expect a few more of the old guard to be shown the door.

Mike Anson
52 Posted 12/03/2014 at 20:01:13
Nick 479, Second paragraph, love it. Absolutely spot-on!!!
Jimmy Kelly
53 Posted 12/03/2014 at 20:19:44
Totally serious Kevin.

Deulofeu clearly doesn't count, just as I wouldn't have counted someone like Fellaini when he was here at 20. Barkley I mentioned. Oviedo I wouldn't class as a youngster, he's 23, and given a chance? Really? He couldn't even get on the bench until baines got injured and was dropped as soon as baines was even close to fitness. Stones has played a bit true, but we have no evidence he wouldn't have played just as much under the manager who bought him.

Osman has played EVERY game. Read it Kevin. Check it if you want. You can fudge it all you want but you can't change the facts, he is clearly rated by the manager.

I used vellios and Duffy as they were the ones being asked for last year, I'm sure you can recall that from on here? The fact people haven't asked for them this year possibly shows a level of acceptance that they were wrong.

Kevin Tully
54 Posted 12/03/2014 at 20:42:03
Jimmy - Why doesn't Deulofeu count if we are talking about giving young players a chance? On Oviedo, he was being given a run in front of Baines wasn't he before he got injured?

Osman has been used as a sub 6 times this season Jim, and you can bet that would have been double figures if injuries hadn't decimated the squad.

Overall, we will see more changes, but you can't do it all in one season, and certainly not with all the injuries we've had to contend with.

Trevor Lynes
55 Posted 12/03/2014 at 20:43:03
Reading the above articles makes me feel my age. I was a fan before and during relegation with gates as low as 13,000 and I was a fan during the heady sixties with gates over 70,000. We won our trophies with level playing fields and without foreign players. No one cared about the Manchester clubs and only Arsenal and Spurs shone in London.

Now the Sky money has made our league little better than the SFA where only a rich few can really compete. However, I do not believe we are a club without money to support the manager.

Conn Prosser
56 Posted 12/03/2014 at 20:03:13
Some decent comments on here. I read teedub because I need to feel the reaction to my own Walling-esque musings.

Common sense prevails as usual, however, I do fear next season's progress if are shrinkydink squad we are saddled with Europa League games.

The suggested four new first team players should be enough to push us on, but how many extra new faces would we need with regular midweek ties as well?

I shall ruminate our possible squad additions and get back to you.

Ian Bennett
57 Posted 12/03/2014 at 21:01:24
The side lacks character. It's probably a hangover from Moyes, and time will tell if Martinez sorts it out, but a number of our squad can be labelled bottlers when the pressure bites.

Finding technical players will only take us so far, so here's hoping we find some Reid's, Southall's, and Ratters.

Andy Crooks
58 Posted 12/03/2014 at 21:11:00
Kevin, you post loads of common sense and then suggest that Duffy isn't up to the required standard. Am I the only one on this site who can see that Duffy is a talented centre half who can and will sooner or later provide the team with some steel and leadership|?

He has been superb at Yeovil and if we were buying a centre half and he wasn't on of our own surely we'd be looking at him.If Duffy doesn't start for us next season I swear I will be in league with Phil Walling.

Jimmy Kelly
59 Posted 12/03/2014 at 20:58:02
Kevin, in my opinion deulofeu doesn't count because he's been brought in on a short term loan by the manager, he's here for 1 year and therefore his age is irrelevant. By the same token I don't count lukaku. Nor, as I've already said, would I count the likes of Fellaini, arteta or McFadden who were all regulars under Moyes when aged between 20-22.

No actually, Oviedo wasnt getting a run in front of baines. Of the 4 league games played since baines returned he had played in 2 and missed out on the other 2. One of the 2 apprarances was also not in front of baines but out of position on the right.

So osman has been a sub 6 times? Right. Am I supposed to be proved wrong by that? We always have injuries, and that will always impact on the appearances by any player, but the fact is he started our first game of the season and when we were looking to turn things round on Saturday he was brought on. If you want to pretend that Martinez hands are tied then fine, to me it shows he's a good judge of player and knows osman is a useful player.

I don't disagree on changes, and this genuinely isn't a criticism of Martinez, more of all those people who insisted that it was so simple to make us a top 4 side and we were being held back by an idiot. Many of those same people seem to be defending the current manager by using things they would not accept as a defence of the old one.

Moyes or Martinez, makes no difference to me. If you've got a record signing of £15m and your top earner is on £75k, you ain't winning many trophies.

Peter Warren
60 Posted 12/03/2014 at 22:11:07
Jimmy – Dortmund don't seem to have done so bad.
Jimmy Kelly
61 Posted 12/03/2014 at 22:22:57
Nor do TNS or molde Peter, but none of them are competing against the sort of resources we are.
Ian Riley
62 Posted 12/03/2014 at 21:45:26
What do we expect?

The club sells players for over £40 million during the past year. We spend £25 million with loans. This summer will be the same again. Players coming back from injury will be like new signings. This is true but the manager may see the financial limitations that Mr Moyes faced. The manager may be given £20 million but I worry which players will be going. Barkley and Coleman are the assets the club has left to cash in.

The football we are playing is easy on the eye but sadly we lack a player to get the players going, a 'kick up the arse' character (a Joey Barton type). The manager can now assess over the next two months which players stay or go and players needed for next season.

The manager is right over Jagielka: rest him and let him go to the World Cup fit, fresh and injury-free. He deserves his chance this summer and we have nothing left to play for.

Paul Holden
63 Posted 12/03/2014 at 23:17:36
I've enjoyed most of our footie this season, mainly because it has been so different to what we've been used to, but let's face it, the season's over and 7th place would be a good finish.
Dan Brierley
65 Posted 12/03/2014 at 23:54:46
'I don't disagree on changes, and this genuinely isn't a criticism of Martinez, more of all those people who insisted that it was so simple to make us a top 4 side and we were being held back by an idiot. Many of those same people seem to be defending the current manager by using things they would not accept as a defence of the old one.'

Couldn't agree more.

Last season: Look at Wigan, you don't need money just a positive manager with a winners mindset

This season after getting Wigan's positive manager: it's not his fault, he clearly needs money to compete

What a phenomenal change of heart!

Mike Gaynes
67 Posted 13/03/2014 at 02:12:21
Kevin Tully (496), no, you're mistaken. Before Baines's injury, Oviedo was getting exactly the same number of minutes from Roberto as he had gotten from Moyes – almost none – and personally it was driving me crazy because I've always rated him very highly. Roberto didn't even give him a chance to really compete for Pienaar's spot. The same is true with Stones... he was getting very few minutes before the injuries clicked in. So while Roberto gets tremendous credit for many things this year, giving chances to Oviedo and Stones wouldn't be on the list... his hand was forced by injuries.

Andy (502), I'm with Kevin on this one. The Duffy I saw (and it was quite some time ago) was glacially slow. I hope he's improved, but being great for Yeovil doesn't make him fit for the top level, and evidently Roberto feels the same about him as Moyes did... rated him behind Stones and Heitinga and couldn't wait to loan him out. If he ever does show us "steel and leadership" I will happily congratulate you on your discerning vision... but I'm not expecting it.

John Daley
68 Posted 13/03/2014 at 03:50:26
"Last season: Look at Wigan, you don't need money just a positive manager with a winners mindset.

This season after getting Wigan's positive manager: it's not his fault, he clearly needs money to compete."

He also 'clearly' needs time Dan. The last guy had eleven years of trying whilst Martinez hasn't yet had one.

David Johnson
69 Posted 13/03/2014 at 03:49:03
I'm made up with Roberto although I'm bitterly disappointed with how the season has gone since Xmas and the lack of backing for a manager who had got us playing with a swagger and a verve that had been missing for over 20 years. People sometimes complain about the tippy tappy style but I'm made up with it and would much rather see the likes of Phil Jagielka or Hibbo attempt to play the ball to feet rather than hoof it up the field.

I suspect it will take a while for Roberto to really mould the squad in his own image, given that he is hamstrung by Bill Kenwright and the other useless bastards who sit alongside him, but he's actually got me looking forward to every match when I'd all but given up after years of turgid negativity.

The lack of depth in the squad is nothing short of criminal though and I don't expect anything to change so for that reason I expect Everton will both delight me and frustrate me in equal measure for the foreseeable future.

Sam Hoare
70 Posted 13/03/2014 at 06:54:33
We (and every club in the world) need more and better players. We have suffered this season mainly due to 2 things; not being able to adequately replace injured or tired players and lacking a top class creative forward.

We will likely never have enough money to buy the top class players which puts an onus on RM to either buy a diamond or two in the rough or start bringing through more youth players which he has said will start happening more in 2 years time.

In the meantime we have not regressed at all are on course for our biggest points tally in years. This summer will be a big one and I hope RM has had time to analyse needs and targets and push us forward another step.

Scott Jones
71 Posted 13/03/2014 at 10:16:01
Roberto said in pre-season that he didn't want to change the foundations of the first team to quickly, as this would have a negative effect. Roberto wants a gradual change; have a look at what he's got and tinker as needed.

Roberto will have gained an opinion on the senior players so far....those that show fear will be shown the door in TIME. AVB at Chelsea tried to be a "smart-arse" by dropping John Terry and Lampard etc. AVB made the same mistakes again at spurs and it totally ruined the harmony at these clubs.

The likes of Stones, Duffy, Oviedo etc will have to be patient as the gaffer gives the senior players the chance to prove to him they have what it takes. I believe we have a very astute manager who is prepared to build a team over 4/5 years... even if it means taking a bite out of a giant "shit-sandwich" in the first 2 seasons.

Our boss, given time, will be a winner; give him time and it will be us.

Richard Reeves
72 Posted 13/03/2014 at 13:07:48
This has been the best season since we reached 4th which was about ten years ago. Maybe or maybe not for league positioning (time will tell) but overall for entertainment and actually enjoying a season with hope, it has to be for me. That's in the manager's first season where I expected it to be very difficult to impose his play, so I was expecting a mid-table finish. If that had become the outcome, then I would've been content if I believed the future looked a bit more positive with a certain style of play and an intention to bring through the youth so, so far it's looking positive.

As I say, all in his first season, a positivity and style that took Moyes about ten years before showing a glimpse of, like the end of the 2011-12 season and the first half of the 2012-13 season — and even that was probably born out of the manager giving up after the display at Wembley and the players doing what they wanted.

When the manager's job was up, there were other candidates that I preferred at the time but, looking at it now, I wonder if they would've stuck around after working with the board for a short period of time? Martinez was the easy choice but now I think the right choice due to finances and his ideas of how to progress.

So far, it's been a fantastic season as far as I'm concerned, whatever the final league position. Martinez has done very little wrong so I can't understand some of the criticism at times. I'm sure there are people who are so bitter and wounded about the criticism for our previous manager that they feel the need to have a go at our current one or people who just prefer mindless, aggressive, basic and direct, passionate football.


Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads

© ToffeeWeb