Season › 2013-14 › News
Sheedy makes waves with criticism of Moyes
Sheedy worked under Moyes for almost seven years in the Everton Academy at Finch Farm and, after tweeting a sarcastic critique of Manchester United's tactics in their 3-0 home defeat to Liverpool, he added his opinion on what he feels was the former Blues boss's lack of attention to the club's younger players.
"All of you out there moyes (sic) was never interested in our youth team or players.
"In my 7 years moyes (sic) showed no intereset (sic) in our youth team."
The more accusatory tweets have since been removed by Sheedy who is new to the social media platform, having only joined within the last fortnight.
Quotes sourced from Twitter via Daily Mail
Reader Comments (175)
Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer
2 Posted 17/03/2014 at 09:25:12
3 Posted 17/03/2014 at 11:49:28
I know these Twatter accounts can be hacked, so I would take it with a pinch of salt for now, explosive if true though.
No doubt our Ed's will look into this. Should make for a good argument later.
4 Posted 17/03/2014 at 12:51:03
Interesting comment, no matter which way you look at it!
6 Posted 17/03/2014 at 13:01:05
7 Posted 17/03/2014 at 13:14:11
"You want to sign Ross Barkley? No problem Mr. Ferguson sir."
Fuck that, it's about time we got some pride back. Every player has their price, but I was over the moon that we stuck to our guns over Baines. A combination of extra TV money and £27m for Fellaini helped our cause, but at least we stood firm.
You heard what Moyes had to say about players if Fergie called, hopefully Martinez will not bend over so readily.
It's no use being the 'classiest' loser in professional sport.
8 Posted 17/03/2014 at 13:50:14
9 Posted 17/03/2014 at 13:59:05
The players that were good enough he played, some who weren't he still played, and other than Mustafi, no one slipped through the net.
As for Sheedy, as Kevin above says, it could be a hack job.
10 Posted 17/03/2014 at 14:01:47
The youth team prospects haven't been good enough, let's be perfectly honest. I know its anything to have a pop at Moyes these days but he gave enough of those kids a chance. None have gone onto great things apart from Rodwell (ish) who Moyes made a first-team regular. The best out of the academy is currently being kept out the starting 11 by Leon Osman.
Moyes has also given Januzaj a run in the Man Utd team. His mis-handling of youth players is in my eyes a pure myth (how might Gosling have fared differently if he'd listened?). There weren't enough good ones. If there were, Martinez would have them in the team. As it is, the only one who plays regularly is Barkley who was already featuring a fair bit last season and has, often, blown hot and cold form-wise this year.
11 Posted 17/03/2014 at 14:08:33
What a ridiculously sensitive overreaction. Why would it ever put his job under threat? He didn't say anything offensive or abusive, nor was it aimed at a colleague or anyone currently connected to the club.
12 Posted 17/03/2014 at 14:14:50
13 Posted 17/03/2014 at 14:13:47
Isn't it unprofessional to say that Everton should consider their players' futures and allow them to join Manchester Utd? Because... er, well... because Utd's manager thinks we should bend over and get shafted by the "bigger club"? Maybe Sheeds thought he was entitled to have a pop at Moyes because of the way Moyes treated him and the youth team during his tenure at Goodison.
We'll never know the answer to this sort of question unless players like Sheedy voice their concerns about the treatment they have been subjected to in the past. It's nowhere near as bad as the "small club" jibes, knife to a bunfight, and all the other patronising crap we've had to put up with.
14 Posted 17/03/2014 at 13:56:18
Apart from having an obligation to the club to conduct himself in an appropriate manner how does he enforce discipline on the same issue with the young players he is charged with developing.
15 Posted 17/03/2014 at 14:18:09
All Sheedy (or your sneaky Sheedy simulacra) said was that Moyes didn't bother much with the youth team and that he didn't like him. Neither of these comments are exactly revelatory and, indeed, were pretty much common knowledge by now anyway.
.
16 Posted 17/03/2014 at 14:29:31
Sheeds is one of the all-time Everton great players and he should have learned his lesson from that defeat at Anfield all those years ago - we won the league and that hurt the other crowd far more than his two-fingered gesture - albeit it was funny at the time.
17 Posted 17/03/2014 at 14:34:06
18 Posted 17/03/2014 at 14:20:55
So because some of the youngsters Moyes let go ended up playing in the lower leagues, that means they're not good enough for our bench?
It wasn't that long a go Norwich and Southampton were in League One, both won back to back promotions and a lot of their players proved they were good enough for the top flight.
There will be plenty of players in the lower leagues that could hold their own in the Premier League but will not get the chance to show it. There will also be plenty of Premier League players that would not stand out in League One. If Anichebe, one of Moyes's favourites had come through the ranks at a lower league club then I would be very surprised if he made it to the top flight.
19 Posted 17/03/2014 at 14:51:02
20 Posted 17/03/2014 at 14:48:19
21 Posted 17/03/2014 at 14:52:49
As expected from a young player there is a lot of naivety and inconsistency in his play, he needed his loan spell to give him confidence and experience. He was even dropped to the bench when at Leeds but has come back the better player for it in the same way Martinez hopes others like Duffy and Lundstram will. How many players would get in the Everton squad that we have let go? So what ever Sheedy says he was proven to be wrong.
22 Posted 17/03/2014 at 15:08:29
It's almost, I say almost, a tragedy watching this play out. He'll be gone in the summer, but it took him leaving before the players and back room staff started letting snippets of the truth out.
Moyes looks so much older now, dare I say it, he looks physically ill and totally fed up, deep inside him I bet he wants to leave the Utd job without looking like a washed up loser.
11 years we put up with him.
23 Posted 17/03/2014 at 15:13:58
28 Posted 17/03/2014 at 15:12:39
30 Posted 17/03/2014 at 15:15:05
So what if he's made it public? I back his every word.
Well said,Kevin.
31 Posted 17/03/2014 at 15:25:03
He's gone and we are all united (pun intended) in wishing his the worst in his new job with the Mancs.
Not really earth shattering news is it? We knew that he didn't really trust the youth, but then again neither really has Martinez.
Oviedo managed to get a game because of Baines's injury.
Stones gets a game because of that muscle fatigued waste of space
Osman is still getting picked over Barkley too.
The truth probably is that the youth team aren't as good as we really hope they will be.
All Martinez has done differently is get the majority of them out on loan.... so in a sense he must take notice.
Oh who gives a fuck, not really newsworthy.........but funny
32 Posted 17/03/2014 at 15:44:06
However, I too wish he had said this to a reporter instead of just firing on Twitter. Anything snapped off in 140 characters comes off as a cheap shot, no matter how credible the source.
33 Posted 17/03/2014 at 15:59:40
Payback time
34 Posted 17/03/2014 at 15:55:11
35 Posted 17/03/2014 at 14:32:30
36 Posted 17/03/2014 at 16:53:23
Sheeds, I salute you :-)
37 Posted 17/03/2014 at 17:19:05
38 Posted 17/03/2014 at 17:13:32
After OFM's last summer transfer window shenanigans, behaviour and words, I for one am happy to see it all go tits up for him; long may it last. I honestly believe if they don't get a good result in the CL this week, he may be gone.
39 Posted 17/03/2014 at 17:20:29
Maybe Sheedy felt that after yesterday's fiasco the rose-tinted glasses about OFM had completely gone and he could vent his feelings. You just get the feeling that, in those last few seasons under OFM, there were a lot of unhappy people at the club.
Having said all that, I bet Sheedy regrets it now...
40 Posted 17/03/2014 at 17:23:04
41 Posted 17/03/2014 at 17:31:14
42 Posted 17/03/2014 at 17:34:06
Now we know proper Evertonian's who worked with him never liked him. Now we know that, even with a Title-winning side, he will finish around 7th.
Now we know the best thing to happen to EFC in years was Alex Ferguson's insane decision to appoint Moyes his successor!
But still, people will claim he is an above-average manager with no evidence to back it up.
43 Posted 17/03/2014 at 17:39:14
On another note, I haven't seen it mentioned on here but Nev Southall called the ginger twat the most boring man in the world on his Twitter timeline. It certainly doesn't seem like two real Everton legends have a very high opinion of him; I'll take their word on it.
44 Posted 17/03/2014 at 17:45:38
Anyway, I don't think Moyes can complain too much considering the lack of respect that he's shown to Everton since he jumped ship, especially in the manner that he left.
45 Posted 17/03/2014 at 18:01:29
46 Posted 17/03/2014 at 18:09:52
I understand he paid no visits to the youth team matches, nor sought reports on the progress, or lack of it, of young players.
In contrast to that, our current manager makes a point of watching all the youth team games that he can, and I would guess by this, that he has raised the motivation of the youth team players and the coaches as well.
47 Posted 17/03/2014 at 18:22:15
Just because Osman gets the occasional game ahead of Barkley doesn't mean he doesn't trust youth. Barkley has come back from injury and has not exactly been firing on all cylinders recently, but has still probably played more in the first 4 or 5 games this season than in the sum total of Moyes reign.
Stones has been given quite a number of appearances, some when we had fit senior defenders like Heitinga available. Deulofeu has been given games. Robles has been given more time than most on here would like.
Oviedo I'm genuinely surprised about. Maybe he didn't show in training what we saw when he got into the team? I was genuinely surprised at the quality he showed when he was given a chance.
I can't say there are any other young players in our squad who deserve to be given a first team shot who have been denied.
Interesting view from Sheedy though; confirms what many of us suspected about Moyes and his very conservative nature.
48 Posted 17/03/2014 at 18:39:57
49 Posted 17/03/2014 at 18:28:41
Then went on to say he had never been near the young lads..
51 Posted 17/03/2014 at 19:05:24
An insight into the current levels of disharmony at Manchester United has been given by a fanzine report claiming manager David Moyes has lost the dressing room.
The latest edition of Red Issue claims that club legend Ryan Giggs recently skipped a coaches' meeting, later telling Phil Neville it was "pointless, as Moyes doesn't listen".
Giggs is also said to have stormed off the training ground after a recent two-hour defensive session.
And the fanzine also claims that Rio Ferdinand has fallen out with Moyes after growing tired of being asked to emulate the efforts of Everton centre-back Phil Jagielka.
The reports claim:
"Moyes did not like being asked 'how does what Jagielka would do have anything to do with how United do things?'"
Perhaps most interestingly of all, Red Issue claims that Sir Alex Ferguson is "considering" a comeback if his replacement Moyes is ousted.
52 Posted 17/03/2014 at 19:31:06
53 Posted 17/03/2014 at 20:02:31
54 Posted 17/03/2014 at 20:11:25
55 Posted 17/03/2014 at 19:40:22
On the other hand, I still think Stubbs should go in the Summer. His remarks on the Baines speculation disrupted the team and were therefore unforgiveable
Moyes consistently signed promising youngsters from elsewhere who mostly vanished. A few went on to play elsewhere - notably Ruddy. Rooney was completely different. A few of these players hovered around the first team. I guess most of us recognise Stones wouldn't have played so many games under Moyes.
It may go against the grain but I can't think of many ex Everton youngsters who've gone on to successful or even middling top level careers after being released. A number that Smith released or sold cheaply did (McCann, Dunne), yet not Moyes. Danny Fox was closest I can think of.
It will be very interesting to see how many of the current promising group make it. Stones and Barkley certainly, Garbutt possibly, but it is hard to tell with Lundstrom, Hope and Long. We can just hope a number do
56 Posted 17/03/2014 at 20:23:14
"Man Utd gonna sack tonight to David Moyes"
"Liverpool defeat became the end for David Moyes! Manchester United will announced that it be fired Scottish manager tomorrow morning."
http://www.nationalturk.com/en/manchester-united-0-liverpool-3-gonna-sack-david-Moyes-epl-exclusive-news-48428
57 Posted 17/03/2014 at 20:30:50
As far as Moyes is concerned, his future at Man Utd is looking very grim, what a total mess! I didn't think it possible earlier in the season for him to lose his job, but it's looking like it's going to take a minor miracle for him to regain any credibility now.
There's no sentiment in big business, I think he will have to go!
58 Posted 17/03/2014 at 20:53:32
Moyes was a con job who has been found out; how he hasn't been sacked yet is incredible. I hope he stays there for years.
What I find ironic is Martinez is under far more scrutiny (as he should be at such a historic club) than Moyes ever was while he was here. He had such an easy ride and thankfully he's gone.
59 Posted 17/03/2014 at 21:27:42
60 Posted 17/03/2014 at 21:44:46
61 Posted 17/03/2014 at 21:48:58
Celtic, or Aston Villa is his next stop.
But in my dream of dreams he goes to Liverpool.
62 Posted 17/03/2014 at 21:50:58
63 Posted 17/03/2014 at 21:52:29
64 Posted 17/03/2014 at 21:58:31
65 Posted 17/03/2014 at 22:05:55
67 Posted 17/03/2014 at 21:43:18
Michael Ball and Richard Dunne – £8 million I think.
Wayne Rooney – £27 million
Jack Rodwell – £12 million.
Nearly £60 million Everton made off five players and, if the rumours are true, this money has saved the club from administration at least once. This shows you how much of a football man Moyes really is. Surely if you are the manager of a top football club you would want every team playing the same way if only to make it easier for the players who climb up the ladder. I forgot to mention Vaughan and Anichebe and then shudder at the size of our debt and imagine how much worse it could have been.
The arrogance of Moyes was shown when he got the Man Utd job and he thought that he had really made it. You've only truly made it when you can put your medals on the table and you have got to be a winner to be able to do this. Maybe that's why Sheedy has said his piece because, whilst it does lack class, surely the same thing can be said about 'arl grey-haired Davey Moyes!
68 Posted 17/03/2014 at 22:08:36
After the initial few years and some astute signings and many duds the general tactics were always a sign of a defensive, dogged team that had eleven workhorses but when push came to shove he never had a plan 'B' once they conceded a goal.
This scenario was allowed to continue by BK far too long and after 5-6 seasons he should have been moved out.
Manure are a mess this season and there are players at Old Trafford who just don't seem too interested under Moyes.
I am not surprised at Sheedy's comments and one only has to look at the refreshing way the present Blues play since Moyes went. Yes, it's a work in process but it's taken RM less than a season to make a big difference.
69 Posted 17/03/2014 at 22:12:01
Please, Bill... consider it — and do one.
70 Posted 17/03/2014 at 22:18:10
When asked by the host of the evening as to how many times Moyes had been to watch the youth team under Sheedy, I think we were all surprised when he said in his seven years as Under-18s coach Moyes had been to watch them 3 times. He clarified this with the comment that he was not interested in the youth team.
In reply to Brian at #439, when asked who he thought should be our next manager, he said he wanted Dunc to get the job and went on to say how impressed he had been by him as a coach and his love for the club.
71 Posted 17/03/2014 at 22:28:29
And well said. I was astounded by the level of support he received from fans whilst at Goodison – especially the send-off he was given. I just hope he stays in his job long enough to return and get taught a real lesson.
72 Posted 17/03/2014 at 22:38:20
But throwing mud at an MUFC employee doesn't enhance either Everton or Sheeds, not one ounce.
Me? I do NOT even remotely fulfill a single one of the opening 4 sentences.
DM? Fullfilling his "density" at the "Theatre of Drear"
I wish to fuck he'd manage "the club previously known as Everton Athletic" as well..... lol.
73 Posted 17/03/2014 at 22:24:58
74 Posted 17/03/2014 at 23:05:58
When he left us, the club was a regular top half finisher and we'd qualified for the CL on one occasion.
So let's not think in black/white, Moyes/Martinez. Martinez was presented with a far easier job than the one Moyes found, purely because of Moyes's work – whatever we or Sheedy thinks of it now.
75 Posted 17/03/2014 at 23:18:23
76 Posted 17/03/2014 at 23:43:43
77 Posted 18/03/2014 at 00:15:02
A horrible thought, but more than possible with Carpetbaggers 'R' Us as our Board.
78 Posted 18/03/2014 at 00:19:24
This whole thing is a complete nonsense.
"All of you out there Moyes was never interested in our youth team or players"
Erm... Rooney came from the youth set up and broke the record to become the youngest ever player to score in the PL. Vaughan came from the youth set up and broke the record again. Rodwell was given the chance from the youth team and became the youngest player to play for Everton in Europe. Baxter was given the chance and became the youngest player to ever play for Everton. No doubt Barkley would have broke another record only for his horrific injury just as he was on the verge of breaking into the first team. I doubt there is a manager or team in the PL that has given more 16 and 17 year olds a chance in the last 12-13 years.
79 Posted 18/03/2014 at 00:15:02
A horrible thought, but more than possible with Carpetbaggers R Us as our Board.
80 Posted 18/03/2014 at 01:07:47
81 Posted 18/03/2014 at 00:52:09
When he left, I thought, "Great, an ex-Everton man can now stick it to Liverpool for many years to come." — How wrong was I??? Now we have to live with the fact that this ex-Everton man is a walking disaster.
The Sheedy debate: IMHO, why not? He is still a class above the rest and whether he regrets it later or not is immaterial.
82 Posted 18/03/2014 at 01:48:12
83 Posted 18/03/2014 at 00:44:41
But even then Under-18s are rarely good enough to jump straight to the Pemier League first team, the aformentioned Rooney and Royle being exceptional exceptions.
Ian #464 "Then went on to sat (sic) he had never been near the young lads" — so the song is not true then?
84 Posted 18/03/2014 at 06:48:36
Moyes never gave the young lads a fair go — 5-minute cameos don't count.
- Rodwell was ruined, he had all the ability in the world, and became nothing more than a passive crab.
- Barkley would not have featured as much if Moyes was still here.
- Seamus Coleman has come on in leaps and bounds since Moyes left also.
- What happened to John Ruddy?
- What about this Mustaphi kid?
- Also, the other highly rated centre half we got in on loan from a Portuguese team?
With good young players like George Green coming through, I'm glad Moyes has gone.
85 Posted 18/03/2014 at 07:14:40
Moyes has no excuses as regards how things have turned out at Man United – we all know his ultra cautious tactics and his use of subs. He has always been reactive and not proactive regarding when he brings on a sub.
As regards using young players – he would nearly always prefer to play an experienced player out of position than a younger player. Check your facts please: for David Moyes, read Gordon Lee Mark II – both of these guys saved us from relegation but then couldn't take us any further. Out of his depth at United? – he was out of his comfort zone when we qualified for Europe – as was Gordon Lee!!
Well done to Sheedy for saying what many seem too reluctant to recognise. Moyes's tactics were negative: no wins away at Arsenal, Chelsea, Liverpool and Man United in 11 years speaks for itself. He was shown up by Martinez in the Cup last season, when he failed to recognise that Neville (a player I admired by the way) was past it. In the end, that blinkered view by Moyes did neither the team or the player any good.
And as regards throwing mud – perhaps Kevin, like myself and many others, is a bit tired of the holier than thou attitude of the Moyes apologists. They seem to suggest/imply that Moyes is above all indeed any criticism. Yes, he was good for Everton (for a time) but Everton were good for him and maybe that should be recognised.
86 Posted 18/03/2014 at 07:43:02
Those of us longer in the tooth have seen a lot down the years, and don't so easily buy into the "we've no money so accept shit" mentality that seems to pervade all fans of a younger generation.
Moyes has a lot of positive attributes but he is yet to prove he has the winning mentality. In his defence, he probably stayed at Everton too long, and had stagnated (makes me wonder just how long was he "on a promise" for the job at Man Utd), but that's not our problem now. He's gone, and I hope never to return as some fear. (I too fear it, and given the apathy of the fans, you know half would welcome him back with open arms...)
87 Posted 18/03/2014 at 08:01:38
88 Posted 18/03/2014 at 08:29:47
Vaughan, Anichebe and Rodwell were all ready for first team appearances in some shape or form when they got them as they did not look completely lost.
I would say that all of these players were handed to Moyes by the youth coaches. By the number of remarks from youth team coaches that people have mentioned above, I doubt if Moyes went looking for them.
89 Posted 18/03/2014 at 08:03:28
I am uncomfortable with Kevin Sheedy taking to social media, as I like to think of EFC as a cut above the rest. Having said that, I would be less than honest if I didn't admit to enjoying the debate it has caused on this thread and some of the comments raised.
The Scot has gone and as he is no longer at EFC, I wish him neither good nor ill, other than he remains below us in the league - long reign the Spaniard.
90 Posted 18/03/2014 at 08:21:57
91 Posted 18/03/2014 at 09:19:00
92 Posted 18/03/2014 at 08:57:04
93 Posted 18/03/2014 at 09:27:18
"It makes you wonder how long he was on that promise" — I can tell you: it was from day he walked through our door, mate.
He was recommended to our board from a friend of SAF with the sole purpose of upsetting a young player and getting him out of our club. OFM was destined for Man Utd from the moment Rooney left in August 2004.
Mission accomplished for SAF and now they are both geting their just deserts
94 Posted 18/03/2014 at 09:30:39
95 Posted 18/03/2014 at 09:35:42
He said that Duncan Ferguson had been heavily influenced by his time in Spain and when he joined up with Sheedy he introduced some new ideas. These chimed with the way that Sheedy thought the game should be played and they have had the U18s playing a passing possession game for a while now.
When Martinez came, this obviously fitted in with his views of the game. He said that Martinez had been very supportive and taken a great deal of interest in the young lads and has introduced this way of playing throughout the whole club. Dennis Lawrence is playing a key role in this aspect.
96 Posted 18/03/2014 at 09:40:36
We all know the man is limited, we have known it for years but because the media thought he was working wonders with little old underdogs in the financial world, they all hyped the man up to be the next God.
We had become more aware of Moyess downfalls more than ever over his final 4 years at Everton.
He did a good job at steadying a ship that was sinking in 2002 and we thank him for that, but when Everton had progressed as a club, partly down to Moyes but also down to the fact that he had better players on the pitch towards the end of his tenure than the dross when he arrived, Moyes proved between 2009 and 2013 that he could not take our club over the line to achieve something.
He drove home a what we have, we hold mentality and that is something that Martinez is going to need to drag away from players like Baines, Jagielka, Distin, Pienaar, etc. In other words, too many of Moyess players are still here.
Manchester United are now seeing the same as what every Evertonian saw this past few years... A man limited in what he can offer and once these so-called miracles of turning water into wine are no longer required, Moyes has proven that, even with a massive transfer kitty and taking over the reigning Champions (regardless of what people say whether they were on their way down, bullshit they still won it), our former Messiah has shown that he still is clueless of what to do.
He brings in players and plays them out of position, he destroys strikers confidence. Its no coincidence that Manchester United won their opening game of the season 4-1 at Swansea but months down the line, under Moyess leadership, the club have become what we at Everton were under him.
Whatever people think of United and how they won the League last year, this season they have been knocked out of the Cups by Swansea City, Sunderland and all but Olympiakos... Now is anybody trying to tell me that would have been allowed to happen under Alex Ferguson with these players at his disposal??
Fuck, its hardly like he has got people like Kenwyne Jones there... [No disrespect, Kenwyne.]
97 Posted 18/03/2014 at 09:58:58
Some silly statements like a con man for 11 years – unless Im wrong we won every point we earned in the league!
Now Im not a Moyes fan and wanted him gone for years but he has often been credited by personally approaching youth players to join Everton – without Moyes, we wouldnt have George Green!
He was renowned for giving youth a bit of a go but ultimately most didnt prove to be better than what we had or he could source elsewhere – doesnt mean they were bad... Can anybody explain yet Gueye getting so many games? We of course have our fair share of diamonds.
So thats the upside but Ive always believed he didnt do enough. When he could give a kid a 20 minute run out it became injury time 3 minutes. He clearly didnt trust them.
Im also a believer that some of our kids havent made it because we suppressed their development. So by saying this kid or that kid isnt good enough when at a youth level they were incredible shows me we didnt know how to take them to the next level – and that is my biggest issue with Moyes. I still look out for Baxters results every week as the poster boy of this theory. Will he be a late bloomer held back all the years?
It doesnt appear to be changing yet with the first team but we are seeing more and more boys going out for exposure which is great! For me, that interest in getting the boys game time in the Championship was more important that an injury time run out in the prem... Moyes in this didnt seem too bothered.
So .. Good talent scout .. But not much more sums it up for me.
98 Posted 18/03/2014 at 10:25:50
I find a lot of people just move job if they have a terrible manager, but Sheedy has managed to stick in there for 7 years (for whatever reason) and now Moyes is gone hes let out the pent-up frustration. I cant blame him for that.
Will he have taught the kids to act the way hes acted? Possibly, but what that means is they will do what theyre told by the manager and stick in at Everton until they leave for £x million then slag Sheedy for making a success of them. Meanwhile Sheedy and we will not care.
Rooney - as has been said - is a freak, he cant included in the disection. It could be argued that due to lack of financial support and injuries to senior players, Moyes was forced to play the Gosling, Rodwell, Anchiebe, Coleman etc.
Dont get me wrong, Moyes saved us from obsurity - and maybe his win more than lose while playing ugly tactics wouldnt have worked with kids carrying them out - but I dont think he gave kids a good chance, and Sheedys untitled to shout his frustration at this also.
99 Posted 18/03/2014 at 10:28:19
I thank him for what he did for us. We were relegation battlers before his arrival and became a solid top six side. It did become increasingly apparent that he was unable to take us to the next level however. I mean last year we drew 15 games! Most of the games we should have won. If we could have turned 6 of those games into wins we would have been level on points with Chelsea in third!
DM got his chance to manage a club with greater resources and off he went. However his over cautious approach and reluctance to make substitutions is more apparent under the spotlight at United.
I was dubious about Rubbertoe at first. But his arrival and DMs departure has seen better, more adventurous football at Goodison. Highlighting further his tactical shortcomings.
Unless they go through against Olympiakos I reckon he will get his P45 before Manure get the chance to be thrashed by Manchester City (never mind though he would get a huge pay off for his 6 year contract, could go on holiday and then in a few months pop up as a tv pundit, do a book deal etc, etc...). So that limits my sympathy somewhat!
100 Posted 18/03/2014 at 11:27:25
101 Posted 18/03/2014 at 11:41:16
102 Posted 18/03/2014 at 11:58:52
However I dont think anyone at all could see the fall from grace of the Champions of last year.
DM to me looks like a man well out of his depth and stressed to death.
He was probably very flattered to be "The chosen one" and did not take a cool look at the prospect and he and MU are paying the price.
Sheedy was only putting on Twitter what he has been saying publicly for over 3 years now
If MU fail to make Europe I cant see DM being there next year.
103 Posted 18/03/2014 at 12:06:56
Cant see Moyes making the Goodison game never mind the end of the Season.
104 Posted 18/03/2014 at 12:15:02
105 Posted 18/03/2014 at 12:19:17
So was Frank Spencer but no one felt bad about laughing at his beret sporting buffoonery.
Actually, Moyes does look a little bit like a more meffy Michael Crawford and if you substitute the catchphrase of "oooh Fergieeee!" for "oooh Bettyyyy!", his escapades at Man Utd are rapidly turning into a more amusing, modern day version of Some Mothers Do Have Em.
Hopefully, hell leave a long running trail of chaos behind him like the loveable seventies simpleton.
106 Posted 18/03/2014 at 12:26:26
Unless the player is good enough, he doesnt get a chance.
The same with the other 90 odd teams.
Apart from Villa last season (which nearly got them relegated), what other manager has really utilised the youth squad?
Its all bullshit anyway, most of the "youth squad" were bought anyway. Not many come through anymore
107 Posted 18/03/2014 at 12:53:47
108 Posted 18/03/2014 at 13:11:13
Going off the comments from people involved at the club (not just Sheedy) Martinez is obviously being more attentive to that area of things and providing more interaction than they were previously accustomed to. Something as simple as showing his face now and again and offering some words of encouragement might be the sum of his greater involvement, but at least it serves to signal that theyre all striving towards the same goal instead of being set up as two different entities: first team....and every fucker else.
Moyes always came across as the more aloof type and his dour demeanour may simply have translated as disinterest, leaving a few people disgruntled and doubting the value DM actually placed on their work. Doesnt mean Moyes truly didnt give a toss about the youth team, more that he came across that way enough for it to have a detrimental effect on morale.
He may just have preferred to hole up with Steve Round and ruminate on revolutionary new coaching techniques, like shouting "run Kevin" at varying volume, speed and pitch to see which had the desired effect on performance, whilst leaving the academy staff to get on with it and shove a report on his desk if any particular kid was regularly catching their eye.
109 Posted 18/03/2014 at 12:59:38
I am not saying we cant have a right laugh at whats happening at Manure right now. What I mean by having a bit of sympathy for him comes from the fact that he is getting pelters from everywhere. At the end of the day he had the balls to take the job on after Ferguson. His time with us was effectively up, he went for it, but is being found wanting.
110 Posted 18/03/2014 at 13:24:20
111 Posted 18/03/2014 at 13:24:33
The guy is a tosser and a cunt of the highest order and I still get annoyed when I think that Kenshite let him run our club for over a decade. Hes an average manager at best whose main and only real gift is managing expectations down.
(Note him saying that Man Utd were underdogs for the last game - can you imagine any other Man Utd manager (let alone Fergie) saying that Man Utd were underdogs in a home game against Liverpool? Whether it was true or not, that was classic Moyes.)
The fact that he didnt give a shite about the youth players is old news and people saying that RM doesnt do much either on the youth front seem to have wiped this seasons appearances of Deulofeu, Barkley, Stones, Lukaku, Oviedo etc conveniently from their memory.
I just hope Man Utd dont sack the poor git too soon, every week hes there, the worse they get! ABSOLUTLEY LOVING IT.
Come on Olympiakos!
112 Posted 18/03/2014 at 13:27:38
I was glad to see the back of him, knew he would be out of his depth at OT but didnt think hed stink the gaff out this much.
113 Posted 18/03/2014 at 13:55:47
Critics are suggesting that its all spin and happy clapping from Martinez. Personally I just think hes a better manager and leader.
114 Posted 18/03/2014 at 14:10:43
All I can glean from this season is that Martinez has sent more out on loan. Nothing to say it was his decisions either.
I dont give a toss if he doesnt take interest, its for his staff to bring players to his attention. His focus should be on the first team only and if anyone outstanding is in the youth set up, then Sheeds and his staff should bring that player to Martinezs attention.
115 Posted 18/03/2014 at 13:30:07
As regards Barkley, it was only a matter of time before he got an extended run in the side. He had been long acknowledged as perhaps the most exciting young talent since Rooney and was on the Everton bench from the age of 16 before he had his injury which knocked his progression by about 2 years. He was clearly lacking match practice and confidence and needed to be slowly introduced.
You only have to look at how Osman, Jagielka, Baines and Coleman all became the managers favourites playing every game but only after spending a lot of time on the bench or on loan for the first season or two at the club.
"As regards using young players – he would nearly always prefer to play an experienced player out of position than a younger player."
What is the problem with this? Perhaps the experienced player played out of position was the better option than to play the youth player completely out of his depth who would only be good enough to play at lower league level. Martinez has also done the same.
While Sheedy digs the knife in with criticisms of tactics and comments saying that we now have a manager that plays to win, has he forgotten the humiliating defeat we suffered ourselves against the Shite quite recently, the worst defeat against them for many a year... has he forgotten that they also destroyed Arsenal even more convincingly quite recently?
Some people on here made every excuse under the sun when it was us getting a good pasting, saying it was because of bent refs and because of the quality and ruthlessness of Sturridge and Suarez, but those same excuses are not afforded to Man Utd. The same people who made excuses now use the opposite arguments and arent so keen to make the same apologist arguments.
Kieran (#555), so basically by your comments you sound like you are proving my point and showing that he did have an interest in the youth team if they were good enough. If they werent good enough, he wasnt interested. Makes perfect sense to me.
116 Posted 18/03/2014 at 14:20:41
Its what any effective leader would do. Thats what Martinez appears to be doing differently and people inside of the club have talked of it being a revolution.
117 Posted 18/03/2014 at 14:20:19
Given Sheedy has world class facilities delivered under Moyess tenure for him to do his job, perhaps he shouldnt be making waves and concentrate on delivering players worthy of attention. Theyve been thin on the ground.
118 Posted 18/03/2014 at 14:35:30
How Moyes ever got the Man Utd gig is a fucking mystery to me.
119 Posted 18/03/2014 at 14:56:06
When Martinez is able to put his influence on the youth teams, then those who can cope with his style of play will make it to the first team. At the moment we are less than a year in and those youth players need time to adapt.
If Moyes didnt take an interest in the youth teams then they will inevitably struggle to break through because you are allowing your coaches all to pick their own style and therefore they dont play the hoofball Moyes wanted.
The comments about lumping it up to Fellaini were just as damning. Sheeds has said what needed to be said. I hope Moyes is still at Utd when they come to Goodison and I hope Martinez can deliver the final nail in his coffin.
120 Posted 18/03/2014 at 14:52:17
Moyes dropped him for a half fit Leon Osman for the Sunderland away fixture - which we lost. Moyes even said in his post match interview that Leon wasnt really fit and perhaps it had been a mistake.
Moyes only played the youngsters when he had to because of injury or suspension. As soon as the experienced player was available the youngster was benched irrespective of how well they were playing.
Martinez has already put his faith in Ross Barkley, Jon Stones, Deulofeu and Lukaku. Ive seen interviews where he expresses his interest in the youth teams at Everton and how he hopes to get every team at the club playing the same way.
In my opinion I would have preferred Sheeds to have said what he did in a formal interview rather a tweet, but thats social media. I think if his account had been hacked, a press release would have been forthcoming from the club . . . .I still dont think it is particularly controversial though, just pointing out some facts as he saw them.
121 Posted 18/03/2014 at 15:38:04
If you like Moyes, don your helmet and defend him to the hilt.
If you dislike Moyes, don your helmet and criticise him to the hilt.
Feel free to twist the facts to suit your default like/dislike.
Yawn.....
In the meantime, EFC moves on. Why dont we?
122 Posted 18/03/2014 at 15:43:52
Very poor and I would guess that Martinez will pencil Sheedy out of his future plans.
123 Posted 18/03/2014 at 15:37:50
For what its worth, I assume Sheedy is right with what hes saying, but is it really news? First team manager in not that bothered about under 18s football shocker? Its nice if Roberto is dropping in on the youth team, Im sure its great for a young lad to believe he may be able to impress the big boss, but to be honest, thats why you employ coaches.
124 Posted 18/03/2014 at 15:47:17
If this next week goes badly for them he may be a gonna, its going to break Nick, Ian, Phil and Tonys heart.
125 Posted 18/03/2014 at 15:55:18
Fair point. Although I think that Roberto has stated that Ross is still suffering some discomfort in his foot after the injury and that he would try and ease him back in without risking further injury. Also I am not sure that young Ross was a clear man of the match v Asrenal in the Cup, although his break did lead to our goal and he always appears to be try - sometimes too hard?
126 Posted 18/03/2014 at 15:56:33
127 Posted 18/03/2014 at 16:04:06
Spot on.
I think it would more likely be Stubbs, after he blabbed to the press about Baines, who would be in danger of being written out of the master plan.
128 Posted 18/03/2014 at 16:06:17
I would say the only youth player brought through this season has been Stones. Barkley has of course got lots more time but started a handful of games towards end of last season and was in or about the first team.
Hopefully we will see more evidence of Robertos youth policy as time carries on but it seems a bit early to declare him a huge advancement on his predecessor so far from the evidence on the pitch in terms of bringing through players from the academy.
129 Posted 18/03/2014 at 16:21:10
Rodwell was already playing U21 football at that stage, anybody else?
Or maybe it was all Moyes fault.
130 Posted 18/03/2014 at 16:28:14
131 Posted 18/03/2014 at 16:30:26
One interesting point you raise though is that of the injury, as I know a few people have used that as an excuse if you like for Rosss poor performances and/or lack of game time recently.
If that is the case it is very, very, worrying. His injury kept him out of the team for just 3 weeks, and hes been back in the squad for 6 weeks. On that basis, it cant be a case of trying to get match fit, hell have never really lost match fitness in that time so that would be resolved with a quick run out. That suggests he is still struggling with the actual injury. If thats the case then somebody has got some serious questions to answer. Bringing somebody back from injury 6 weeks before theyre ready is not just rushing someone back, its gambling with their entire career.
132 Posted 18/03/2014 at 16:52:25
133 Posted 18/03/2014 at 17:19:10
For most people you probably can come back to work 5-6 weeks after a broken toe. But most of us do not have to run, twist and turn as the players in the EPL do.
Michael Owen is a prime example.
134 Posted 18/03/2014 at 17:21:48
There is not a club of significance anywhere whose supporters – okay a concession: a section of them – would not be interested in what an ex-player thinks of an ex-manager. None. And this is no run-of-the-mill ex-player. This is Lord Sheeds, in my opinion – and I started going the match in 76-77 – the greatest of players I have ever seen put on the beloved blue shirt.
Footie fans everywhere – a second concession, sections of them – are deeply interested in unravelling goings-on at their club; this is precisely why the debate about Moyes, slammed by some over the summer, was highly relevant to understanding our past, present, and future.
Me? I cant wait for another insight from an ex-player into our ex-gaffer.
Oh, and love the snide turning on it’s head stuff now knocking Sheeds for his apparent lacklustre approach to the youth set-up.
Nutty. Unfair. Inaccurate. But what the heck – it diverts attention away from ginger, the whole point in the first place.
135 Posted 18/03/2014 at 18:22:39
Fair point, but why did you then mention Liverpools result against Arsenal? Whats that got to do with Sheedy, Martinez or Moyes??? Its a post about everton isnt it nothin to do with Liverpool beating Arsenal surely. Very strange...
136 Posted 18/03/2014 at 18:53:17
I have always admired Sheeds as a player and then for going on to work in the youth set up but choosing to publicly put DM down now is like putting the boot in to a man who is already staggering.
I could understand Sheeds not going public when DM was manager as he would be concerned about his job, but he has had plenty of time to vent his spleen since DM left.
137 Posted 18/03/2014 at 19:01:13
138 Posted 18/03/2014 at 19:37:52
139 Posted 18/03/2014 at 19:41:47
What is happening at Old Trafford was predictable to an extent but it has disintegrated even more quickly than I imagined. It is like watching someone who thoroughly deserves a thrashing getting a more thorough thrashing than they deserve.
Finally, James Martin # 409 your reference to young players who gave their best for our club as " dross" is appalling and out of character.
140 Posted 18/03/2014 at 19:51:28
141 Posted 18/03/2014 at 20:13:01
142 Posted 18/03/2014 at 20:11:21
I know we are on first name terms and all but why is it snide to question Sheedys achievements in the job he is paid to do.
One player in seven years progressing from Academy to first team seems fairly poor to me.
143 Posted 18/03/2014 at 20:25:22
Gavin#617
Spot on.
Stubbs in a snake.
His cancer clause, his going public over Baines to Utd..
Why hes still in any job at the club amazes me.. Christ.. He even went odds on to get the managers job last year !
Imagine if that one came off !!
Sheedy, and others.. Have been saying this for a while, and as some other posters say here.. Why its suddenly news is odd.. I guess it just suits Utds current situation and fills and makes a headline.
Sheedy is one of the good guys.
144 Posted 18/03/2014 at 21:01:44
Perhaps we ought to have a dedicated thread to the much greater matter of the successes and failures of the academy over the last decade or so, discuss, of which this Moyes factor would be one (important) part in a much more intricate mosaic.
145 Posted 18/03/2014 at 21:12:20
146 Posted 18/03/2014 at 21:32:33
I know Stubbs told people he was well on for it just before our End of Season awards bash however.
Id replace Stubbs with Unsworth... All Day Long.
147 Posted 18/03/2014 at 22:30:04
Never liked him since his role as shop steward in the players revolt during the disastrous 2003-04 season, publicly advising Rooney to leave at the end of it, and the strong rumours he made a few quid for himself when Rooney was sold.
And before the stuff he was saying about Baines last Autumn.
Hes the enemy within... Get rid.
149 Posted 18/03/2014 at 22:53:00
Not sure Im smarter but what I do agree with is Moyes distrust of young players. The evidence is there for all to see.
Maybe my view of Sheedy is tainted. A great Everton player, part of the team I will always remember. But I have a friend who played with him (no name, no pack-drill) and he tells me he was a bit of a twat.
150 Posted 18/03/2014 at 22:43:04
He also refused to have television anywhere near Bellefield or Goodison. His reason being that other clubs might gain insight of his tactics.
To be fair to the man I personally know of him visiting a young players home to discuss with his parents how to correct the lads wayward ways.
As for Sheedys complaint I wonder what he might have said had the big boss been looking over his shoulder every minute of the day.
151 Posted 18/03/2014 at 22:57:34
Sheedy and Moyes clearly did not like each other much and whether Sheedys comments are accurate or whether it is a case of him giving vent to his feelings who knows and quite frankly who really cares? In his recent interview HK was very diplomatic when asked how he got on with Moyes and refused to have a dig at him and Sheedy should have been professional enough to keep his own counsel. It is a shame that Moyes has damaged his reputation with us by his statements and actions at Man Utd but this stuff is a bit undignified.
That said, it made a great read!!
152 Posted 18/03/2014 at 23:28:23
153 Posted 18/03/2014 at 23:10:24
Maybe Moyes wasnt interested in the youth team. I was critical of his caution with first team selection and substitutes but how many other Premier League managers really watch the youth team? Or do they just wait he hear glowing reports from a number of sources about players with potential to step up to the next level.
My last experience of watching the Under-18s was against Arsenal at the Emirates in the FA Youth Cup and none of our (or for that matter Arsenals) players really stood out as outstanding prospects. Our tactics were one-dimensional and predictable, Arsenals players were fitter, faster and stronger with better close ball control, although a bit too showboating and trying tricks rather than keeping it simple when required.
The reality is that most youth players dont now make the grade to step up to the first team (or even regular substitutions) and most players who are in a lower division dont get signed and get regular first team football at a Premier League club.
Even if we get a (raw) talented bunch of teenagers coming through the system I cant see the coaching and tactics of Sheedy or Stubbs developing many of them in to potential first team material. Dont get me wrong, I like having ex-players involved at all levels but we need coaches who have the vision to develop new tactics and systems that will progress the game forward and give us an edge on the moneyed clubs who can buy players from around the world and then send them out on loan to smaller clubs.
154 Posted 18/03/2014 at 23:51:03
Laughable stuff.
155 Posted 18/03/2014 at 23:56:25
"Sheedy-esque!" — I would snarl through gritted teeth.....
156 Posted 19/03/2014 at 01:12:30
Now, Dave Williams (#713) – "I remember him [Sheeds] as a very good player who disappeared in a lot of the big games (never performed even averagely in a Wembley game) – always struck me as someone who would follow the dollar rather than wear his heart on his sleeve for our club." – What unmitigated garbage!
Totally agree with Ste (#717) – its laughable. Went missing? Rotterdam, Luton semi, and many more? A nutty statement bordering on libelous... and yes, what a money-mad mercenary who stayed playing for the club for exactly now long, after many of the 84/87 teams walked, and who is hmmmmm let me think, plying his trade now where? Oh yes... The Old Lady. Like I say just about everyone of the aforementioned 84/87 teams.... The man who crossed Stanley Park because he is chasing the mighty dollar ............ Who mocked the Kop with his fingers while the cameras looked on .......... who played how many games for Everton?
An Everton legend.
157 Posted 19/03/2014 at 02:16:11
158 Posted 19/03/2014 at 02:43:38
159 Posted 19/03/2014 at 03:08:45
160 Posted 19/03/2014 at 05:09:00
We saw Duffy who had a few games and did very well under the guidance of Johhny Heitinga but was dropped for a game in which Tony Hibbert played instead. Made no difference: we still lost. What happened to Shane Duffy?
A couple of seasons back, McAleny was given a cameo at Arsenal and hit a sweet volley that skimmed the post. Never made the bench again.
We saw Junior thrown to the wolves at Leeds and never seen again. Im sure there are more examples. We either have a youth policy and Under-21 team that feeds the first team... or we dont bother.
161 Posted 19/03/2014 at 10:08:43
Constantly moaning about having no money yet ignoring the youth coming through. They only got a game when the seniors were injured, eg Rodwell who came in for Jags but, as soon as Jags was fit, Rodwell was dropped. Just one example.
Moyes controlled everything, even the Local Radio and Press; no criticism could be made of him or a news blackout was threatened.
To those who say Sheedy is now unprofessional, I say to you Moyes said many things that he did not do. Where is the Rooney Compensation money which Moyes won in a court case and promised to give to the Everton Former Players Foundation? It has never been paid to the Foundation.
Its time for those of you who supported him in everything to hear the other side of the story. If you dont like what is written then dont read it, its your choice.
162 Posted 19/03/2014 at 08:41:32
I still reckon Sheedy was out of order.
163 Posted 19/03/2014 at 12:02:42
Would have thought better of Sheeds but he does himself no favours with this outburst – even though it sounds absolutely on the button!
164 Posted 19/03/2014 at 12:30:09
165 Posted 19/03/2014 at 12:47:34
166 Posted 19/03/2014 at 14:50:31
It really is a game of divided opinions I guess!
167 Posted 19/03/2014 at 19:25:18
168 Posted 20/03/2014 at 00:47:30
The fact that OFM got involved in the recruitment of certain players isn't enough if he was apparently then oblivious to their progress until he desperately needed someone to fill a slot in the first team. The waters are further muddied by the fact that a member (or members) of the Moyes clan were employed as scouts by the club, as it may be that they benefitted financially if he made sure one of their suggested players was signed up (this is purely speculation; I am just saying you can't simply point out a few examples of OFM door-stepping and claim that shows he was involved enough without comprehensive details).
I dislike the way social media seems to prompt public exposition of personal views with scant regard to the wider ramifications, but if this stuff is already a pretty open secret then it seems that it is not worth any public disciplinary action by the club. If they feel it has set a bad example then everyone at the club should be given a gentle reminder of how the club would like them to behave.
I remember Sheeds as a very particular cog in the team; unlikely to do much tearing around and thunderous tackling, but generally reliable in the exceptional skills he brought to the team. Consequently there would inevitably be times when he was little more than a spectator (and that is always likely to be true of certain types of 'luxury' players), but it would be harsh to class that as 'going missing'.
169 Posted 20/03/2014 at 02:13:26
170 Posted 20/03/2014 at 02:31:41
171 Posted 20/03/2014 at 16:11:16
172 Posted 20/03/2014 at 16:36:05
173 Posted 20/03/2014 at 16:34:23
My intelligence and mind has nothing to do with me being fed up with a dull boring coach who had me nullified up at most matches.
Nor does intelligence or big or little mind have anything to do with me really liking Martinez and what he appears, in these early days, to be trying to do with our Club.
Now back to my current reading:
- Einstein decoding The Universe
- The Secret language of The Renaissance
- A Biography of Stefan Zweig
Can hardly wait for Saturday - The Dark House early, a few pints, the match, football talk in TDH late, our Everton Quiz.
Life - - isn't it wonderful.
Come On You Big Minded Blues.
174 Posted 20/03/2014 at 16:44:29
Die Frende am Denken.
Absolutely.
175 Posted 20/03/2014 at 16:47:14
176 Posted 20/03/2014 at 16:53:37
177 Posted 20/03/2014 at 17:03:26
Great stuff Brian and Patrick.
Now what about Roth's The AntiChrist. Mmmmmm.
I once wrote an article for a Theatre/Cultural Magazine years ago and opened with "Grotowski, Boal and Artuad, Everton's Central mid-field trio."
Also in a Radio Interview Im was asked about my love of Vincent Van Gogh and said he "nearly signed for Everton".
Good stuff and a bit of fun.
178 Posted 21/03/2014 at 01:37:36
Having suffered the slings and arrows for being one of the very first to criticize Moyes when he was the darling of the cognizant set among which of whom I now recognize are some of his most ardent admirers turned haters, I find it a little congruent to be accused as a supporter of the fallen messiah.
The difference between our points of view, I suggest, is that my criticism of the rotten bastard and his later nefarious dealings is totally impersonal and based on fact whereas much of this later stuff is mean spirited and unworthy of the Everton ethos.
179 Posted 21/03/2014 at 17:08:31
180 Posted 21/03/2014 at 20:00:05
181 Posted 21/03/2014 at 20:51:12
182 Posted 21/03/2014 at 21:21:17
I say that without a hint of sarcasm or... anything else.
A wonderful sentiment and choice of words (and I for one don't doubt your claim for a second).
183 Posted 21/03/2014 at 21:56:46
I guess it sounded a bit big-headed but it was just a response — but I never play myself as the fool. I am doing Van Gogh on his 161st birthday in Liverpool; have a look at my football FB Page, The Dark House Blues, for some photos/details.
I remember being on a Radio Merseyside phone-in about Moyes and I mentioned Aristotle — went down a treat.
All the best and remember to keep those cosmic grooves flowing.
184 Posted 24/03/2014 at 01:57:46
"The difference is apparent in the results – his team have won 52% of league games this season, compared with 42% under Moyes last year – and a sea change in attitude has occurred. If the Scot's priority was not to lose, the Spaniard's aim is invariably to win."
http://www.theguardian.com/football/2014/mar/23/Roberto-Martinez-everton-swansea-europe
Add Your Comments
In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.
Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.
1 Posted 17/03/2014 at 08:56:45