Off-key Blues hold off profligate Swansea

, 22 March, 33comments  |  Jump to most recent
Everton 3 - 2 Swansea City
Everton registered their eighth successive home win in all competitions and prolonged their historical dominance over Swansea City but it was an uncomfortably narrow victory in the final reckoning.

Thanks to a superb striker's goal by Romelu Lukaku and Ross Barkley's first in the League since December, the Blues put enough goals on the board to earn the three points and held off a late rally by the visitors who missed a couple of gilt-edged chances in the second half.

Swansea started brightly, enjoying plenty of possession but it was Everton who carved out the first clear-cut opening, Barkley slicing off his shin from a good position at the end of a good move involving Lukaku and Seamus Coleman.

Roberto Martinez's men were handed the platform they needed to assert some control over the game in the 19th minute, though, when John Stones' well-placed ball forward released Barkley into space and he sold Chico Flores with a dummy, prompting the defender to clumsily bring him down just inside the box.

Leighton Baines stepped up to take the resulting penalty and buried it confidently past Michel Vorm to make it 1-0.

Swansea were level 12 minutes later, though, with their best move of the half, Wayne Routledge clipping the ball over the home defence to Angel Rangel on the far side of the area and he picked out Bony who converted from close range.

It was more or less all Swansea from then until half time, with the Blues restricted to just one shot on target in the first 45 minutes, and Pablo Hernandez came within a couple of feet of putting the visitors ahead when his free kick took a heavy deflection off James McCarthy and flew wide of the far post.

Everton's best spell of the match came in the quarter of an hour after half time and, after Sylvain Distin had gone close to scoring a rare goal, they capitalised clinically by surging into a two-goal lead.

Their pressure told in the 53rd minute when Kevin Mirallas delivered a low cross into the perfect spot behind the Swansea defence and Lukaku was on hand to lunge forward and score his 12th of the season with his extended leg.

2-1 became 3-1 five minutes later when a corner whipped in from the Everton left eluded everyone but Barkley in front of goal and he stooped to head home.

Swansea responded purposefully, though, and Tim Howard was called into back-to-back saves to paw Bony's header away and then deny Pablo Hernandez's scuffed shot from the angle.

And when Bony put Rangel in the clear a few minutes later, the Catalan fullback wasted the opportunity and failed to punish similar profligacy by Mirallas at the other end by allowing Howard to close him down and make the save.

One more great save by Howard, leading by example with the Captain's armband, to stop shot Hernandez's effort and a block by Distin that sent Michu's shot over the crossbar preserved the two-goal cushion but Everton remained vulnerable and gave up a second goal two minutes into injury time. Ashley Williams got in front of Lukaku to head home a corner from the Swansea right but it would prove to be a mere consolation.

The win pushes the Blues into fifth place above Tottenham Hotspur who will once again have played a game more after their match tomorrow. The focus now moves to Tuesday's important trip to St James' Park to face erratic Newcastle United.

Full coverage: ToffeeWeb Match Reports



Reader Comments (33)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Kieran Fitzgerald
1 Posted 22/03/2014 at 21:28:21
It’s good that Spurs are playing a day later. It keeps the pressure on them. They are flakey at the moment and I fancy Southampton to get a result tomorrow.
Andy Meighan
2 Posted 22/03/2014 at 21:46:34
I never for one minute thought we’d lose that game. I thought the Toffees were always controlling...I just couldn’t see The Swans getting back into it.
Terry Murphy
3 Posted 22/03/2014 at 22:45:55
Only saw the game on the telly. Anyone know why Mirallas and Lukaku seemed to celebrate our second goal on their own?
Kevin Rowlands
4 Posted 22/03/2014 at 22:54:01
Terry, hopefully because they’re both gone next year.
Terry Murphy
5 Posted 22/03/2014 at 22:58:51
Stephen 460 — a 19-year-old steps in to cover for an England international player, looks mostly composed in possession and doesn’t look a total liability in defence and you can’t see the potential — ever thought of becoming a scout???
Brent Stephens
6 Posted 22/03/2014 at 23:01:12
Stephen #460 you thought Barks was ok today and of late? No way that I think he’s regained the form of earlier in the season before his injury.
Brent Stephens
7 Posted 22/03/2014 at 23:06:17
Stones is one for the future. A great talent in the making. A great buy.
Wayne Smyth
8 Posted 22/03/2014 at 23:15:48
Stones is a very good defender with the potential to be superb. Couple of dodgy moments, but let’s not forget that Jags, our best defender, is prone to giving away goals with bad passes etc.

What I like about Stones is that he has all the physical attributes to be a top defender, but crucially is mentally strong. Very composed in most situations and willing and able to bring the ball out from the back too.

All this at his age is quite remarkable given centre halves don’t normally start playing top flight football till they’re a few years older.

John Daley
9 Posted 22/03/2014 at 23:03:52
"Okay he’s very young but still I can’t see what all the fuss about. Never a top quality footballer."

Never? Like never ever? I’d say in four or five years he will be a central defender of the highest quality. At the moment he is still raw and doing his learning in the lions den. Part of that learning process is making the odd mistake, recognising what you did wrong in that instance and ensuring that, next time, you deal with it differently. It’s the whole point of ’gaining experience’.

He’s nineteen and playing in a position where the slightest slip or momentary lapse of concentration can lead to a goal-scoring chance for the opposition. Not many players his age are trusted to play centre-half in the Premier League, nor do many possess the composure or positional know how to not stick out like a sore thumb with a neon sign round their neck flashing ’fucking weak link’. Stones has performed admirably in the majority of games but is bound to have the odd nervy moment now and again. It’s to be expected. He’s only ’very young’.

I always find it bizarre how people call for young players to be thrown in and given the chance to sink or swim then prematurely berate them and get on their back for not being the finished article in the first flush of their footballing career.

Terry Murphy
10 Posted 23/03/2014 at 00:17:10
Stephen – You’re taking his age into account?

Okay, name some other 19-year-olds you think would do better in central defence.

Stephen Scofield
11 Posted 23/03/2014 at 00:54:27
I have to disagree; I think Stones has shown some great signs. He has been no more a liability than Barkely has this season and everyone is raving about him. The problem is, we are without our pacemaker, Jagielka, and it makes a massive difference.
Kevin Rowlands
12 Posted 23/03/2014 at 00:50:55
Stephen, Stones is top draw and may even be the next Everton and England captain. He’s 19 — give the lad a fucking break; he’s occasionally going to make mistakes. I hope you come back in about 2/3 years and see how stupid your posts are.
Anto Byrne
13 Posted 23/03/2014 at 05:16:07
Put Stones on the bench and bring back Tony Hibbert.

No, wait... play Barry back there instead.

Perhaps we can send Stones out on loan to get real experience in the lower divisions that will get him ready to play in the Prem.

Ralph Basnett
14 Posted 23/03/2014 at 08:35:55
Stephen, as you seem to be the only one who does not rate Stones, I think on this occasion, whilst we can all have our opinion, you have to now step down to the majority.

If he fails to make it, then come back and revel in the knowledge that you knew he was crap; until then, let it go, lad.

For those who are lucky to go the game, we all know we have been playing crap as a whole team and are struggling for form throughout.

Brent Stephens
15 Posted 23/03/2014 at 09:36:36
There’s maybe an interesting comparison between Barkley last season, and whether the Scottish Manager should have given him more time in the first XI (to gain experience there, make mistakes, develop etc), and Stones this season, and whether Roberto should be giving him time etc etc. What’s sauce for the goose, etc.

Not sure Stones gave away any goals yesterday. And all others on the pitch were making mistakes, all over the place. So, in that context, yesterday was part of his development, low-risk. And if he wasn’t good enough yesterday, neither were most of the others.

Jackie Barry
16 Posted 23/03/2014 at 12:50:16
Everyone – or should I say, most people – know that it takes time to develop into a great defender. The signs are there and he shows great potential.
Wayne Smyth
19 Posted 23/03/2014 at 14:09:01
Stephen, I think you’re onto a loser on this one.

You say Stones was shocking in our derby defeat. Failing to mention he was played out of position on the right. Failing to mention that a number of our players were coming back from injury. Failing to mention that of the goals they scored he was responsible for conceding none, unlike our other defenders like Jags. Failing to mention that all of our team were shit that night.

Stones needs to bulk out, and he will. He’s 6’-2", quick. His mental strength is shown in his confidence to bring the ball out and in small things like his pen against Juve or the way he tackles to win the ball and play it forward, rather than just tackle to give away a throw in. Most centre-halves his age would be doing everything 100% conservative to avoid fuck-ups, but he does a lot more than he needs.

What he’s missing is experience and he’ll be getting that playing alongside the more experienced players, especially when he makes mistakes. I’d agree it would be best to have him on loan rather than in our first team making errors but, unless you hadn’t noticed, we’re operating on a lot less cash than about 8 other teams in the league.

To finish higher up than 8th, we need to take risks, including developing our young players a bit closer to home than might be ideal.

Gabriel ONeill
20 Posted 23/03/2014 at 14:19:46
Stephen... you are perfectly entitled to your opinion and any assessment of the ability of a player is always going to be subjective but your arguments about Stones have left me almost speechless... The lad is 19 and playing his first season in the fastest, most physical league in the world and is more than holding his own.

He will make mistakes and he will make fans nervous on occasion but this is how a player (particularly a centre half) develops. We are out of the cups, unlikely to finish 4th and I think most of us would take or leave Europa qualification, so why not play him in the last quarter of the season and allow him to develop when we have little to lose? He will learn ten times more by playing in these games then a full season of playing in the Under-21s.

We can’t afford to splash cash on a ready-made world-class centre-half so developing youngsters is crucial for to our future and personally I take far more pride in watching a player come through the ranks – even with the inevitable mistakes – and go on to become a top player.

Making a judgement on the future of the player after a handful of games and stating he will ’never’ be a top player is unbelievably short-sighted and it is fans like you that leave me shaking my head in frustration... Remember, Gareth Bale took 24 games with Spurs before he even won a match... I guess you would have got rid of him after 6 games??

Max Murphy
21 Posted 23/03/2014 at 15:21:28
Bollox! Spurs get late winner.
Mike Powell
22 Posted 23/03/2014 at 15:51:50
Absolutely woeful performance; we were very lucky to win that game. If we keep playing like that, we are going to get another hiding of someone.

Martinez is pissing me off with all this pass pass pass pass and pass again. To win a game of football, you have to get players in their box and cross the ball in to them... simple! Not pass then pass and pass — have a fucking shot!!!!

Paul Andrews
23 Posted 23/03/2014 at 17:39:24
Mike Powell 598,

The style of football we are playing is a work in progress.
Martinez has totally changed the style in his first season.

Would you prefer the football style and lack of tactics of the last manager?

Mike Powell
24 Posted 23/03/2014 at 20:56:16
Paul Andrews, if you’re happy with the way we are playing then you’re easily pleased; it’s driving me and everyone I know up the wall. We have got to be the slowest team in the Prem when attacking. Yes, it’s his first season; if we don’t improve next season then I fear for us. How can you be happy at getting embarrassed at Anfield and Arsenal in the cup? Yesterday was woeful.
Matthew Salem
25 Posted 23/03/2014 at 21:42:12
I think Stones has potential and has shown quality for a boy his age. I do however fail to understand how Alcaraz is on the bench behind him, if he is fit again. Everybody on here calls him a sick note etc, which may be true, but Alcaraz is pure quality and very experienced and I want to see him play on Tuesday with Distin against the skunks.
Paul Andrews
26 Posted 24/03/2014 at 06:18:01
Mike Powell,

I believe we have the highest points total after 29 games since the Premiership started. If I am not mistaken, 61 points is our highest total under the previous manager, he will pass that total in his first season. The style he is playing now will remain; the difference next season is it will be quicker.

Stephen Sulliven,

Stones has started 7 league games.

Graham Mockford
27 Posted 24/03/2014 at 07:02:40
Paul Andrews,

How many points we have after 29 games doesn’t mean too much. Our best points tally under Moyes was 65 in 07-08, so given that our final nine games are relatively difficult your assumption we will beat this is up for question, unless our performances improve.

Saying that, points total is only one way of measuring progress. Squad quality, playing style, player development are equally as important.

Jason Chew
28 Posted 24/03/2014 at 07:48:01
Stones? Don’t see much of those in him. That’s twice in two games I see him back off so much from the opponent and has to recover with a ’fantastic tackle’. Truth is, he made Bony look world-class.

Is Bobby doing to him what DM did to Rodwell? Make a midfielder learn his trade at centre-back? I don’t really care who the manager is, defending to me will always be about hoofing the ball away from goal when in your own box when there is an opponent within 2 m of you.

If, however, he has been told very clearly by the manager NOT to hoof the ball away under any circumstances, then I lay the blame at the manager’s feet. (I am quite sure his coaches at Barnsley thought him the right stuff, or else DM wouldn’t have bought him in the first place.)

Gary Reeves
29 Posted 24/03/2014 at 07:58:59
I don’t like to post on negatives of individuals (particularly young ones) without an element of constructiveness. But I suppose that’s what these forums are for so here goes: Stones is not brave enough!

I watched him in the Under-21s before he made the first team, and I noticed it there too. Sometimes you’ve got to put your body on the line at centre-half. You’ve got to see each goal conceded as a stab to the heart, and I just don’t see that in him.

Hope I’m wrong, and he’s only young, but...

Chris Henderson
30 Posted 24/03/2014 at 09:32:39
Unbelievable, Jeff, the comments regarding Stones are as stated — UNBELIEVABLE.

The lad is 19 and already one of the best prospects around, already playing with confidence and ability... how people can come on here an slate him? He will always make mistakes as any player will do at some point; he will only get better and will become club and country captain at some point.

Again, he is 19, we all moaned Moyes wouldn’t trust the youngsters and now you are moaning when Martinez does!

We are still winning when we play bad (never happened before) and if we win our game in hand and beat the Arsenal, we are only 2 points off 4th... Terrible season, ain’t it, guys.

David Price
31 Posted 24/03/2014 at 10:37:30
I guess his inch-perfect pass to Ross to get the penalty was just a hoof as well.

This lad will be England’s centre-half at the Euros in two years. Quality and class.

Martinez debate already? 4 wins instead of 4 draws this season and we would have been in the title race. I think the boy has done okay in his first season.

Ray Roche
32 Posted 24/03/2014 at 13:37:52
David, I watched again on MotD and you can clearly see Stones look up before he hit that pass, yet the commentator said "He didn’t mean it". I was at the match and thought, despite a couple of lapses in concentration, that Stones had a decent game. He will be some player.
Norman Merrill
33 Posted 24/03/2014 at 13:42:03
We all our opinions on players & rightly so. I personally, think he has a great future, whether it be at Everton remains to be seen?

Knowing our finances, John will become a seasoned international, & whoever will offer a sum, that 24/7 will drool over, & then like Wayne before him, will be gone. Knowing our financial situation, the same will happen with Ross.

Gabriel O'Neill
34 Posted 24/03/2014 at 14:28:55
As an Evertonian, I have always prided myself that, as fans of this club, we are in some way different to the supporters of other clubs. We do not resort to short-term, knee-jerk reactions when things aren’t going well and we back our managers, even when they do make mistakes or make decisions we don’t always agree with.

We are not like the fans across the road who happily ignore a little racism, diving and biting as long as the player scores a few goals...

We are not like the Geordie fans and their ’hot bed’ of football, which seemed to get a hell of a lot cooler when they were down in the old Second Division with under 10,000 fans at home games...

And we are certainly not like the Chelsea or Man City fans who delude themselves that, once their particular billionaire gets bored/arrested they will be anything more than a mid-table club at best.

We are Everton fans who, as far back as I can remember, have not just supported the team through thick and thin but backed the players to the hilt and been a consistent and positive force for the club.

It therefore amazes and saddens me to read some of the comments on here that, when things are actually going well and we are playing a more cultured and expansive form of football – albeit a work in progress – that some of us persist in such soul-destroying negativity. I would swear reading some of the posts on here that we were rooted to the foot of the table, had a team full of players who lack both talent and desire and that we had just agreed to sell Barkley, Stones and Coleman for a handful of magic beans.

Debate and opinion are great and I would welcome more of it but when you find yourself trying to turn every positive into a negative you need to think back to the days when we were fighting relegation each season, were playing 8 defenders in home game in the hope of sneaking a point or God help me thinking Brett Angel was a professional footballer!!!

We are Everton fans... we are playing well... we do have money to spend in the Summer... we will be back in Europe... we do have great young players... we do have the best young manager in the country.... BE POSITIVE!!!!

Geoff Evans
36 Posted 25/03/2014 at 09:02:59
Ray, Same MotD that said Sturridge back heel to find Suarez in the box was telepathic when basically it was hopeful, where the fuck did the biased bastard think a striker who has scored 20-odd goals was going to be..??.

One of the drawbacks of watching MotD is that most of the panel are ex-shite who are there to boost their pension plans... so take their comments with a pinch of salt because to them there is only one team; to them, the Shite are either brill or unlucky depending on that week’s result.

I always watch it with the sound down.


Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads

© ToffeeWeb