Everton plan permanent memorial for the 96

, 26 March, 141comments  |  Jump to most recent
Everton have announced that plans are underway to erect a permanent Hillsborough memorial outside Goodison Park to coincide with the 25th anniversary of the tragedy next month.

The club's Head of Media and Communications, Mark Rowan, said: "Plans at this moment are in the early stages. But we have a commitment to unveil a memorial to coincide with the 25th anniversary of that tragic day.

"Evertonians and the Club have always stood shoulder-to-shoulder with the families of the Hillsborough victims during their long fight for justice and we feel it is fitting that our home should have a permanent tribute to the 96."  



Reader Comments (141)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Trevor Lynes
1 Posted 26/03/2014 at 18:42:24
Fantastic news!
Danny Broderick
2 Posted 26/03/2014 at 18:42:37
Fantastic initiative. We were all affected by Hillsborough, red and blue.
Brian Murray
4 Posted 26/03/2014 at 19:20:40
Once again our club shows why it is head and shoulders above any other football club in the world.
Alex Trevalyn
5 Posted 26/03/2014 at 19:26:22
Well said Brian,shows why we are a cut above..
Tony Sullivan
6 Posted 26/03/2014 at 19:59:11
Well done Everton.
Dennis Stevens
7 Posted 26/03/2014 at 20:05:15
I'm rather surprised - seems a bit odd, to be honest. I wonder what the response from both red and blue will be - it may not be universally appreciated.
Kevin Davies
8 Posted 26/03/2014 at 20:44:48
Perhaps its because I don't live anywhere near Liverpool, but I just don't get WHY ? For me something like a tasteful and discreet plaque on the existing memorial at Anfield would suffice.
Phil Sammon
9 Posted 26/03/2014 at 20:15:08
Do we not do enough to remember Hillsborough? I mean come on! It was a terrible tragedy and it should be remembered, but this non-stop mass outpouring of grief is just too much for me.

Tony Sullivan
10 Posted 26/03/2014 at 20:56:38
Phil Sammon, it's a memorial not a mass non stop out pouring of grief.
Peter Mills
11 Posted 26/03/2014 at 21:10:25
This is a rather strange announcement. "Plans at this moment are in the early stages" but there is less than a month until the anniversary.

Whatever form the memorial takes, I hope it makes reference to the fact that we were playing in the other semi-final that day. My over-riding feeling on the day on the way home from Villa, and ever since, was that "it could so easily have been us".

Brian Wilkinson
12 Posted 26/03/2014 at 22:09:31
People lost lives. It could so easily have been us had we played there instead of Villa Park.

I hate the red shite but I will never forget the errie silence on the way back from Birmingham, and that after an f a cup semi final win.

For those from afar away the city united in grief, there may not be any love lost when it comes to football but scousers have always stood toe to toe together even families divided down the middle.

96 yes 96 penned in with nowhere to go,children, women, men, I cannot even imagine how they suffered that day and thank my lucky stars I was at Villa Park.

Until justice is carried out I'm all for the families getting justice and the guilty charged.

We've done plenty in the past and this for me is another example just how much Everton will stand side by side and remember the 96.

We may hate them but a big injustice was done that day when the blame was passed onto the supporters, police changing statements, families of the dead not allowed to hold their loved ones but view them behing a glass window.

Time to put our differences to one side, the least those fans deserve is people of Merseyside remembering them, the memorial makes me proud to be an Evertonian.

Jimmy Kelly
13 Posted 26/03/2014 at 22:49:32
I've been best man at 2 weddings this year. Both of them are Liverpool fans. My brother in law's a red, my fiancée's mum too. Any of them could have died that day.

I may hate the club but I don't hate the people; we're not different breeds, we are friends and family and that should never be forgotten.

Phil Sammon
14 Posted 26/03/2014 at 23:01:44
It was a tragedy, like I said, and people who wish to commemorate it should do so.

But where does it end?

All kick-offs in every league game in the country will be put back seven minutes over the anniversary weekend as a mark of respect, Everton unveiling memorials 25 years on, I've even heard some saying that no fixtures should ever be played on 15th April as a mark of respect.

Why don't we unveil a banner at Goodison to mark the anniversary too? Why don't we sing You'll Never Walk Alone as a show of solidarity? Why don't we have JFT96 on our shirts next season?

A minute's silence before the game is poignant and respectful. Do we really have to be force-fed anymore?

Jimmy Hill
15 Posted 26/03/2014 at 23:12:49
For all the people who ask 'Why?' While Liverpool are our enemy on the football pitch, their supporters are our friends, brothers, sisters, cousins and football fans in our city. Our city would not be the same without these two great clubs. In times of strife, like families here, we stick together; same goes for the people in the city.

We are Everton and we are class and we do things right. Hope that explains.

Mark Boulle
16 Posted 26/03/2014 at 22:43:00
I'm not from Liverpool and was only 7 when this happened, so I accept I cannot comment regarding feelings in the City at the time. I do certainly believe that fans both red and blue would have united in a desperately difficult time.

I am, however, with Phil Sammon on this one. More for the endless NATIONAL banging on about Hillsborough than anything local to Liverpool. The BBC never shuts up about it, every single year the anniversary is marked with silences, featured on the news, MOTD etc, not to mention whatever endless, maudlin programme of memorials there will be for the 25th anniversary in a few weeks! Even New York doesn't mark the anniversary of, with respect, far greater tragedies (if these things can be scaled) such as 11th September every single year anymore! It's a cliche but true to say that time is a great healer, but if you never let go grief can never start to heal! Immediately following the end of the Franco dictatorship in Spain, a national 'pacto del olvido' (pact of forgetting) was adopted - forgetting and burying the pain (again, with respect, the actions of Franco's henchmen were a damn sight worse than those of the police at Hillsborough) was how they dealt with it, and it worked.

I, for one, am sick of hearing about Hillsborough, whatever the rights and wrongs of the police and the fans' actions that day. I do try, but fail, to put aside the Liverpool angle as well, in that we are made to put up with the never-ending Hillsborough talk but Heysel and the actions of their fans that day, which robbed EFC of our best ever chance to win the European Cup and perhaps changed our history for the worse forever more, is never mentioned.

I would actually support this planned memorial at Goodison, out of respect for the victims of a LOCAL tragedy. I am, however, convinced that the country as a whole just needs to let it go and get over it. I would like to end by apologising in advance if any readers who were affected by the disaster are offended by this honestly held point of view - as I say, not being a local and not knowing anyone who lost a friend or family member there makes it an easier view to which to subscribe.

Trevor Lynes
17 Posted 26/03/2014 at 23:24:11
It is not just because it was a dreadful tragedy. It is to illustrate the total injustice of the police and media at the time.

I am a blue through and through but I have never bought the SUN newspaper since that dreadful day.

There was real haste to punish the police over the upsetting of an MP not so long ago but it has taken well over 20 years for our city to receive justice due to corruption, cover ups and the government of the day.

As far as I am concerned it is a miscarriage of justice that should be forever in the public domain until justice is seen to be given to the friends and families of the deceased.

Kieran Riding
18 Posted 26/03/2014 at 23:33:01
It could well have been us.... That's not in doubt. We have acted with total class whenever it's been required.

Is there a need for such a permanent memorial at Goodison? In my opinion, no.

And I'm sure the first "What about Heysel?" comment left at this memorial will also make the news... And unnecessary national headlines.

Sam Morrison
19 Posted 26/03/2014 at 23:33:14
While I respect the opinions of those who have had enough of it - or their right to say so, anyway - I don't think it's about football, or Liverpool FC - it's about politics, spin, corruption, bullshit, and terrible tragedy. That stuff is worth remembering, and I'm glad it is spoken about every year.
John Daley
20 Posted 26/03/2014 at 23:43:40
"I just don't get WHY?"

Is that a serious question?

Hillsborough wasn't just a tragic event that shattered, and continues to this very day to impact upon, the lives of supporters of Liverpool football club. It impacted upon the entire city of Liverpool. Red and Blue.

It's about remembering the lives of family and friends, or just ordinary football fans like me and you, who went the game and never came back. As far as I'm aware the original proposal for a plaque/memorial came from an Everton supporter whose Liverpool supporting brother died that day. On the same day one brother went to watch EFC in a semi-final and lived, the second went to watch LFC in the other semi-final and did not. You may as well have tossed a fucking coin. He's not the only one with a similar tale to tell.

Even forgetting the family element and the effect on the local community, from a football perspective, Everton have been fatefully intertwined with Hillsborough from the very start. Both clubs were playing in semi-finals the day it happened. The first game Liverpool played after the events of Hillsborough was against Everton. The cup final that year was contested between the two clubs. Everton and it's supporters have continually aided the ongoing fight of the bereaved families to find out the truth of what occurred that fateful day.

I really don't see how anyone can struggle to fathom the reasoning behind it.

Dennis Stevens
21 Posted 26/03/2014 at 23:26:27
I understand the points being made and did already understand them. But none of that explains to me why Everton are doing this for the 25th anniversary, or at all for that matter. A memorial at Anfield is entirely to be expected. A memorial at a suitable location for the whole City is quite understandable. The shared grief and outrage, the support from Blues, both in terms of the club and also individual supporters, entirely consistent with the club we are.

I'm endeavouring to keep as open a mind about it as possible, seeing as we don't know any details as to the form of the memorial, but I do hope that, having made this commitment, they get it right. It would be tragic if a misjudgement on a matter as sensitive as this were to be a cause of any unnecessary discord where hitherto there has been unity. This announcement, coming as it does without any further information, is likely to perplex more than a few supporters, both Reds and Blues, at least until more details are forthcoming as to the nature of the proposed memorial.

Garry Corgan
22 Posted 27/03/2014 at 00:11:55
A lovely move. The scenes of Everton and Liverpool scarves tied in an unbroken chain across Stanley Park all those years ago were touching, as we're seeing all those Everton scarves at Anfield.

We've had a number of Liverpool fans invading the live Match Day forums recently but the number of blues who immediately turn to calling them "murderers" and making tasteless references to Hillsborough and Heysel is a disgrace. They really let themselves, this website and our club down. Great to see that the club itself has more class and sensitivity, as well as a true understanding that the 96 weren't just reds, but brothers, sisters, mothers and fathers of blues too.

Jimmy Sørheim
23 Posted 27/03/2014 at 01:38:04
I can understand the gesture, but it is not really for Everton fans is it.

Why not put up a new stadium until Goodison falls apart?

Nick Armitage
24 Posted 27/03/2014 at 01:41:04
Mark Boulle - you have no idea what that day did to the people of this city. I was young when it happened, but I will never forget it.

Our friends and family were treated worse than animals and then they had salt rubbed in their wounds for 24 years by pondlife in the police, media and government. It is one of the great wrongs of the last century, and I hope some see the inside of a prison cell for it.

JFT96.

Kopites are still gobshites though.

Julian Wait
25 Posted 27/03/2014 at 03:21:28
Two of my best mates were up in Yorkshire, one I’d known him and his little brother since I was able to kick a ball. I was at Villa with my brother and best mate.

If you weren’t at either ground, and didn’t know anyone affected (really?) then you really don’t and won’t ever understand. Indeed, I am sure for those at Villa like us, we can’t ever really understand what it was like to be up there instead of at Villa, we can just be thankful it wasn't us.

As it was, I didn’t find out until watching MOTD that night on Saturday, we’d gone straight out with old family friends in Brum for beers, the obligatory curry (and IIRC to see Chicken Shack play live); of course it was all before internet, cell phones and everything that provides instant information these days. We were a bit pi$$ed uo so we slept and then drove home early to be with our mates who’d returned shell-shocked from Yorkshire.

I learned today from one of the two lads that he couldn’t be in crowds for years after Hillsborough. We both left Merseyside within a year or two of ‘89, but we’ve stayed in touch and it’s a bond that will never break. I can’t believe I just found that out about him, but frankly I don’t think he talks about it much. Call it PTSD if you like, much like our fathers and grandfathers after the war, they didn't like to talk about it much, even to the end ….

As an aside, I had picked up another mate in So’ton, fresh off the train from Heysel, and I will never forget his face (he’d also gone to Rotterdam – with me - to support Everton even though he was a red through and through … imagine that?).

I am as blue as anyone, and come match day I want them all sent off and us to win by a mile. But these friends, red or blue, are family to me and I hold our friendships very dear. We’ve played footy together, been on the town together, and been through life together. A mark of respect and something to commemorate the event and to mark our role in the event - and all that followed - is appropriate under the circumstances, and if you want to be cynical, shows us and our glorious club in only the best possible violet-tinted spectacles, and is the best possible weapon against the “bitter blues” tag some like to throw around.

And for those that are concerned about “where will it end”, I understand that, and I think it shouldn't be more than is proper, and that it shouldn't be turned into a circus; that's just crass and attention seeking in itself and we shouldn't become the center of attention or make it about us or about Everton.

Would they do the same for us? I would like to think so, and if they wouldn't, well that just proves we're made of better stuff, doesn't it.

JFT96

Brian Wilkinson
26 Posted 27/03/2014 at 03:26:48
25 years ago, Everton suffered a grave tragedy, they were penned in and no way out, children women and men who were fellow Evertonians suffered until finally the fence was open.

Evertonians saw bodies being dragged out, some Everton fans tried in vein to revive people layed out, mums and dads at home not knowing if their son or daughter was safe, no mobile phones back in 89,

Travelling down to Hillsborough, looking of photos of the dead on a board, then having to identify through a glass window then be told sorry you can't go to your child you have to stay on this side.

You look around and see your fellow Evertonians doing everything possible.

Then you read the scum newspaper and reports of fans peeing on the dead and robbing their own supporters, how it was all the Evertons fans fault they were all passed up, high ranking police officers making police on duty change their statements to put the blame on the Everton fans.

Does it make you scream for Justice for your beloved Everton.

Well I was at Villa Park that day and will never forget nor should anyone until the truth comes out.

Some who are asking 'Why?' may be too young to remember the horror at the time but believe me, it was horrible, even more so that the supporters got the blame.

I hate them cause they are our rivals on the pitch, but I have mates who support them and others Everton, I have no problem Everton erecting a memorial.

Brian Wilkinson
27 Posted 27/03/2014 at 03:55:48
Julian 363, yes they would have done it for Everton, Rhys Jones having Z-Cars played at Anfield in his memory and not a single boo, only applause, shows why Merseyside supporters are the best in the world.
Peter Barry
29 Posted 27/03/2014 at 04:20:57
A 'Heysel' memorial would be more appropriate.
Harold Matthews
30 Posted 27/03/2014 at 04:06:44
For me, this is a fine idea. A framed photo of the little girl and boy holding hands sits on my mantlepiece.
Darren Hind
31 Posted 27/03/2014 at 06:00:28
John @350

Fantastic post

Matt Traynor
32 Posted 27/03/2014 at 06:40:34
Echo the points made by the excellent post from John Daley #350, and others.

I was 18 that day, and at the other semi final like a lot of others, when news began to filter through (from those with pocket radios). Coming back on the bus you'd think we'd had a hiding, but at least there were no unexpected empty seats on our coach.

Someone else pointed out above that the speed at which the Andrew Mitchell "plebgate" row was escalated and dealt with is shameful. Coppers facing jail for lying about what someone said. Think about that.

Then think about the litany of lies and deceit and cover up that have plagued this tragedy since the moment it began. Think about what the families are going through. I've not heard one person say it's about compo - a label so quickly attached to the city thanks to layabouts happy to go over a poorly maintained footpath.

A lot of this is about justice, and trying to make sure that similar families never have to go through the loss, and grief, compounded by a government-sanctioned cover up.

The only alternative it seems is an OxBridge education and a job as a fucking MP.

Steve Cotton
35 Posted 27/03/2014 at 07:57:50
Can't we put up a plaque commemorating all those that died in the Hillsborough AND Heysel tragedies? By mentioning both, we show respect to the people that died in both incidents, proving that we commemorate both tragedies.

Then at least one club on Merseyside will honour the Heysel dead.

Ian Burns
36 Posted 27/03/2014 at 08:32:20
Many years ago, I was invited to dinner by a business colleague and was sitting in his lounge talking and watching early Sky Sports television. If I recall properly, it was a Monday evening and Everton were playing Liverpool at Goodison Park. As the programme opened an hour before kick-off, the camera picked up two young boys, circa 12-13 years old sitting next to each other in an otherwise almost empty stadium, sharing/reading the Match Programme. One was dressed in blue kit and the other dressed in red kit.

My host was astonished that two opposing fans sat next to each other without a care in the world.

I was proud of my city that evening because although we are bitter rivals, whether or not we are blue or red, we are from Liverpool and collectively that means everything.

This memorial is the right thing to do - it is about the people of Liverpool - football is massively important but it comes second to family; friends and fellow scousers.

Well done EFC.

Phil Sammon
37 Posted 27/03/2014 at 08:47:49
Genuine question:

In the year of the 25th anniversary would you have liked to have seen JFT96 stitched onto our shirts and Z-Cars replaced with You'll Never Walk Alone at home games, as a show of solidarity?

Is there ever a point at which a line could be drawn whereby enough would be enough?

Craig Walker
38 Posted 27/03/2014 at 08:51:13
I think this is a good move. Everton have risen above the usual football tribalism and supported LFC and the Hillsborough victims for the quest for justice. Andy Burnham the Labour MP did a lot on their behalf and he is a blue through and through. Families on Merseyside have split allegiances and Everton's support of LFC has been exemplary.

The cynic in me thinks that sometimes LFC have used Hillsborough to promote their football club as being above the game. The images of scarves aloft and that dirge of a tune which TV broadcasters feel compelled to show EVERY game. The endless tributes etc. Gerrard donating £96k on the morning of the Anfield derby etc. etc.

Going a stage further, football likes to latch onto any national grief and try and show itself in a positive light. It seems there is a minute's silence or clapping for any event these days.

One thing that has always riled me about LFC though it how they seem to have airbrushed the Heysel tragedy out of their history. 39 people died that day. 600 were injured. We never see BBC programmes devoted to the memory of the people who went to a football match that night and never came home. I work with a lad who is a RS and was born after Heysel and Hillsborough. He knows all about the latter but nothing about the former.

Lenny Kingman
39 Posted 27/03/2014 at 09:02:57
What a marvellous way to kick off his Everton career. A good national headline grabber like this will satisfy any attention seeker. Here I am everybody.
Sam Morrison
40 Posted 27/03/2014 at 09:06:03
Phil, while playing devil's advocate you still fail to grasp that it's not about our local rivalry.
Kevin Davies
41 Posted 27/03/2014 at 08:46:49
John Daley, yes "I just don't get WHY?" is a serious question!

I am all for justice for the victims of a terrible tragedy and a disgraceful cover-up by the police and probably certain senior members of the government of the day... but I fail to see why a memorial at Goodison Park has any merit.

Surely it is the place of LFC to commemorate that tragic loss of life of their fans, and the place of LCC to put up some kind of memorial remembering the unity shown by the entire city (and probably every right-thinking football fan throughout the country and beyond). This could be positioned in a relevant place in the city, perhaps somewhere in Stanley Park.

Simon Lloyd
42 Posted 27/03/2014 at 09:08:26
I agree with Brian #333 and John #350.

Another reason to mark the anniversary at Goodison is what I believe it would mean to the families of the victims. If you remember the recent commemoration at Anfield when BK spoke (the Liverpool mum's speech) he received a standing ovation when he said that Everton stood side by side with Liverpool on the issue of Hillsborough. Whatever else might be said of BK he got that spot on.

When you are up against what appear to be unsurmountable odds, at a time when emotionally you must be at your lowest ebb, you need people to stand by you. Everton did it for the families. I am proud of that. We are only now getting to the end of the process where the full truth is coming out and so quite how the families are supposed to "let it go and get over it" (Mark #'342) I don't know.

For the record, I am not from Liverpool although my mum and her family are. I was at Villa park with my father and uncle who would both have been in their 60's back then. It could have happened to us.

Ray Roche
43 Posted 27/03/2014 at 09:27:26
I'm not against any such memorial but I AM a bit mystified as to why we have waited for 25 years to provide one. EFC and it's...our... supporters have shown a degree of solidarity towards the Red Side that is extraordinary in both it's genuine nature and the depth of the shared grief.

As has already been stated, we all know someone who has been touched by the tragedy and many were fellow scousers. But why now? After all this time? As a club and individually we've done as much as anyone to ease their grief and the "96" shirt and "He ain't heavy" were both Everton initiatives. I'm just a bit puzzled.

(It would be easy and understandable to slip Heysel into any such debate and it shows why we are a class above the other lot that we don't bang on about it as much as we could.) Maybe we should, before it's airbrushed from the rewritten history books.

Geoff Evans
44 Posted 27/03/2014 at 09:13:06
I've always loved Everton; my brother has always loved the Reds. We've been arguing with each other since we were kids about football and I'm glad to say we are still around to do so; because of events that day, some aren't.

Is life a game of football? No it's more important than that!

Phil Roberts
45 Posted 27/03/2014 at 10:12:41
And one for the 39 Juventus fans killed in 1985 was my first thought - and then I read Ray #391 and agree. It is being airbrushed from history, it certainly broke up the greatest team we had and most of whom were all in their early to mid-20s but we don't talk about it because we are Everton.

And just another thought. It really isn't justice for the 96. The 96 were crushed to death by large numbers of people being let into the ground by the police. For years, these large numbers have been blamed and the police were innocent. Now the truth has come out, these large numbers of fans have been exhonorated. So the justice is actually for them, not the 96 who lost their lives.

But on the other hand, the large numbers of unidentified (unidentified because of their numbers) fans would never have generated the passion and compassion that those who tragically lost their lives were able to do through the tireless campaigning of relatives, friends and supporters.

Tony Abrahams
46 Posted 27/03/2014 at 09:33:39
Mark 342, I think you have already been put in your place, but perhaps, when these families finally get justice, then maybe the healing process can begin. Mums and dads have gone to the grave without seeing justice done for their children, and you go on about greater tragedies?

Don't know why it's taken 25 years for Everton to make a permanent memorial but I also never understood why Everton never fought the European ban when Norwich City approached them.

This has caused so much bad blood in our city with us Evertonians blaming those bastards for getting us banned from Europe when we never even took it to a court of European law?

When it comes to football I hate Liverpool, but when it comes to Hillsborough, I often get a tear in my eye and I'm 44 now. God Bless the families who, after 25 years, are still waiting for Justice!

James Byrne
47 Posted 27/03/2014 at 10:22:40
I attended my dad's funeral yesterday and he came from a family mixed with Red and Blue; thank fuck Kenny was a blue – he made all of us at home Evertonians. My old man was an old-fashioned type and he had a lot of respect for the Reds; although I have to admit we're a little bit bitter this day and age. We were all born in this city and, even after my dad had travelled the globe a few times at sea, he wouldn't have settled anywhere else.

The memorial isn't just about football; it's about the unique people within this city and how we come together during difficult times. The memorial will also remind all football fans and tourists who come to this city that the Hillsborough tragedy was the biggest travesty of justice that this country has ever seen. Those mistakes cannot be repeated.

Ray Roche
48 Posted 27/03/2014 at 10:53:22
James, good post. Tony mentioned your dad's funeral yesterday. A number of blues on here sent their condolences. I hope all went as well as those sort of occasions can.
Richard Reeves
49 Posted 27/03/2014 at 10:40:23
I must be in the minority here but I don't like the idea of a permanent memorial outside Goodison Park. Ever since that terrible day, Everton have shown nothing but class and support towards Liverpool FC and their fans, this for me is something that should be outside Anfield or maybe the city centre with a message of unity from Evertonians to – errrmm... better be respectfull here – the Reds.
Ian Burns
50 Posted 27/03/2014 at 11:36:41
James 398 - thought about you yesterday, along with other blues on TW and I would also like to add my condolences along with thanks for a good post.
Paul Niklas
51 Posted 27/03/2014 at 11:46:40
This is good to see see, despite what we think of them as a team and a club.

I would like to see a bronze of the two kids used recently at the last recognition by the club. I would have it put right in the middle or somewhere in the Stanley Park, plus a copy at the ground, wherever that could be positioned.

Danny Broderick
52 Posted 27/03/2014 at 11:39:44
When the Sun posted that article, they tarred all people from Liverpool with the same brush. Thieves, pissing on the dead, drunks etc.

I have never forgot that. And even if it was only meant for the Liverpool fans, I couldn't accept that bollocks being written about people from the same city as me, when it has been proven to be rubbish. For anyone who needs to be educated on this (like Phil Sammon), go and read the Taylor report.

96 people can't die, and then no-one is accountable. Worse still is the smear campaign to say it was the fans fault – cheap shots like stealing from the dead, because we are all thieves from Liverpool, or so some people would have you believe. That smear needs removing. Justice is quite simply recording that the accident was caused by police incompetence. Nothing more, nothing less.

Andrew Ellams
54 Posted 27/03/2014 at 12:20:49
Firstly this is HUGE national news. A police force lied continuously and criminally to deflect blame for the deaths of 96 men, women and children. Also, not all of them from Liverpool so this does go beyond the city boundaries and often forgotten the emergency services from South Yorkshire who actually did do there jobs that day and maybe even stopped that number being more than 96.

Now onto the annual memorials etc., this is something that does happen in Liverpool more than in other cities perhaps, it's just how the people from this city are and in the UK only Glasgow has experienced something like this before and the divide up there is a whole different thing. A memorial at Goodison yes, but maybe a memorial on behalf of Everton FC at Anfield would be more appropriate. But when it comes to putting back kick offs and even talk of keeping 15th April off the football calendar, not for me. Minute's silence every year, even if it's just Everton and Liverpool, is respectful and enough.

For those of you mentioning Heysel memorials, way to sensitive politically and probably best to leave well alone.

Jimmy Kelly
55 Posted 27/03/2014 at 12:24:41
Mark, would you want to ’let it go’ if your child had been killed by gross negligence? If that gross negligence had then been covered up by the authorities? If the national media had portrayed YOU and your dead child as responsible for their death? If somebody tried to tell you your child was already dead at a time you knew for a fact they were not?

Would you just say ’ah well, things were done differently then, at least I’ve now got my really important local sports club to run so I’ll forget about it’?

It’s people like you who’ve made this journey hell Mark, people who believe what they’ve read in red top rags and think the dirty scousers just need to shut up and take it. Well it ain’t going to happen, and justice WILL be done.

Dave Lynch
56 Posted 27/03/2014 at 12:16:58
Hillsborough was tragic to say the least, as was the Ibrox disaster, Heysel and, closer to home, the Bradford fire disaster where people were watching fellow supporters being burnt alive.

I do support the justice campaign but the one thing that rattles my cage is LFC’s blatant use of this disaster to make sure the club remains within the limelight and the hangers on who have hardly been to a game over the past 20 odd years.

The manipulation of the FA around moving kick off times and minutes silence across the country also does not sit with me either; keep it in the city by all means and I will pay my respect as I see fit.

Why not have a designated day for "all" those who lost their lives because they went to a footy match ?

John Schrempft
57 Posted 27/03/2014 at 12:11:21
As a blues fan for more than 50 years and having sat through the Heysel tragedy with a Juventus fan, my question is whether there is a memorial plaque to the victims of that awful event at Anfield?

32 Italians, 4 Belgians, 2 Frenchmen and one from Northen Ireland were amongst those that died that night and 400 people were injured..

I’m all for showing solidarity to LFC by having a Hillsborough memorial at Goodison. After all, there was a travesty of justice and both sets of fans are Liverpudlians when all is said and done. On the other hand, to learn that some younger LFC fans know all about Hillsborough but not Heysel is food for thought......

Phil Sammon
58 Posted 27/03/2014 at 12:40:26
Jimmy Kelly

The reason the fight for justice ’has been hell’ is absolutely not because of people like Mark Boulle - let’s make that clear - and what an outrageous accusation to level at someone who is merely questioning the extent to which we commemorate an event.

That is exactly the kind of comment that winds me up about the whole Hillsborough affair. If you dare to even question anything you are immediately set upon as though it was you sending people to their deaths that day.

And yes, John, there is a plaque for Heysel at Anfield.

Gary Reeves
59 Posted 27/03/2014 at 12:13:20
Mark Boulle #408

Good point, well made, Sir! It also baffles me as to what the "end game" will be on this issue. That tragic day was the culmination of a thousand and one factors and the continuing apportioning(s) of blame will get nobody anywhere. What, for example, should a pitchside Policeman have done? They don’t carry angle grinders with metal blades – never have, never will!

Can anybody ever prove that people acted with wicked-minded, wilful negligence on that day? – probably not. Did people in authority panic in the aftermath? – well, yes, that’s been proven.

It is right that innocent people have been exonerated but there is a whole lot of context to understand football in 1989. I’ve been in frightening crushes at Leeds and Wembley, and I’ve had police dogs set on me at Boro and Oxford. Attitudes and infrastructures were different then and football supporters were seen as (and often were) thugs.

Whilst I can never imagine what it’s like to lose a loved one, at a football game, I do feel there is an element who hijack the Hillsborough tragedy for their own ends and I rather agree with others that it is not a part of Everton’s history. We make ourselves look like the obedient unquestioning little brother – and let’s not forget we were served up on a plate in the Final of ’89, like unwanted guests. They even turned the 2012 Semi-final at Wembley into a Remembrance before the game and that was just plain bad manners IMO.

Steven Goulding
60 Posted 27/03/2014 at 12:54:01
I’m genuinely amazed that anyone has a problem with this? It’s not like we are erecting a statue of Gerrard!?

As explained by the club it is inspired by the Evertonian who lost his brother, as the saying goes: ’Those that understand...need no explanation". My uncle was there but fortunately survived, we need things like this for perspective. Another classy move by the club, in my opinion

Robbie Muldoon
61 Posted 27/03/2014 at 12:51:49
Some quite ignorant posts on here; all you need to know about Hillsborough is that the authorities were to blame. Fuck the corrupt police, fuck the government of the day and respect our fellow football fans, scousers, and relatives who died going to watch a football match.

Two clubs, one city. It’s only right they have a memorial.

Ste Traverse
62 Posted 27/03/2014 at 12:52:08
Mark Boulle #342

Your post is an absolute fucking disgrace. You are an embarrassment to our great club and support.

I was at Villa Park that fateful day as a then 12-year-old and well remember the looks on peoples faces from Blues who obviously had family and friends at Hillsborough as reports coming in from the events in Sheffield and rumours of deaths and then the death toll mounting.

And what’s come out since is that it was a huge cover-up and justice wasn’t done. I for one won’t EVER be ’sick of hearing about Hillsborough’ like this prick Mark Boulle. It was a disaster for our whole City, not just for Liverpool FC, and the support LFC have got off EFC since that day has been nothing short of brilliant.

Patrick Murphy
63 Posted 27/03/2014 at 12:59:20
if Everton FC feel it is right for them to have a memorial then that’s fine by me; if they chose not to, that would also be fine by me.

I was at Villa Park that fateful tragic day and I was at the City ground on the day of the Bradford fire and both in different and similar ways were horrible events. The difference with the semi-final events has been the amount of time and effort that the families of the deceased have had to put in, in order to get justice – that has my full support and indeed it has brought to light many things within our society that we should all be aware of as fans and as members of the public and those responsible should be brought to book and punished accordingly.

Dave Lynch makes a good point regarding the delays in kick-off times, I don’t see why that should happen for one tragic event and not for other clubs who have also had their tragic events Bolton, Bradford etc.

Perhaps the 15th April should be designated as a national mourning day for all football related deaths and the FA should make it a day where no matches are played anywhere in the country at any level. That would give those who feel the need to grieve an opportunity to honour those who died and fans of other clubs wouldn’t feel guilty for concentrating on their own club’s fortunes in what are usually important matches due to the time of the year.

Jimmy Kelly
64 Posted 27/03/2014 at 13:02:57
Phil, there’s nothing outrageous about it.

The fact is people like that swallowed what they were told, they continually told people to move on, get over it etc. There was no groundswell of support for the families because too many people thought they were just moaning for moanings sake, they thought there was no way the police and authorities could be at fault.

I’m not saying it’s Mark’s fault that it happened, or that it’s his fault that it’s taken so long to get to the truth. But I am saying it’s attitudes like that that have made it hell for the people involved. They’ve known the truth all along and people like that have told them they’re wrong, they need to stop bleating and move on.It’s a LOCAL issue, rather than a national disgrace. Do you not think that would make life harder for them?

Chris Fennell
65 Posted 27/03/2014 at 13:17:24
I’ve signed up to ToffeeWeb specifically to comment on this post as I am afraid there are some people making comments that are embarrassing themselves. The memorial is a symbolic gesture of solidarity with Liverpool families who lost family and friends at a football match and then got screwed over by the police, the government, you name it for the best part of 25 years.

Complaining about the national coverage of Hillsborough or that Liverpool FC are using the tragedy as a way of staying in the limelight is a shameful opinion to have and very cynical. Ultimately, this memorial will not affect your matchday experience (for those fans who go to Goodison).

Declan Brown
66 Posted 27/03/2014 at 13:19:25
This is a very strongly emotive issue. For me Dave (413) and Craig (385) are good comments, I’m from Belfast, I signed the petition in the city when I was over at Goodison one year. I fully understand the impact it had on the families, my heart goes out to them, trying to come to terms with it all, ie, the truth when it came out.

But Stevie Me and his £96,000 donation to the charity right before the Goodison Derby? It’s charity Stevie, you’re not supposed to seek attention and glory-hunt in things like that.

A friend of mine, a Red, told me there was a scandal covered up at Anfield as the media turned a blind eye; as my friend put it, "We have the media over a barrel regarding Hillsborough and they’re scared to say a bad word about us so it never came out."

As for the Memorial at Goodison, if we do, then great, keep it classy and dignified. No glory hunting. I’m with the opinion that they have air-brushed Heysel out of their history, too conveniently forgotten in selective memories my opinion.

I hate their club but not the people I know associated with it (ie, my family members or friends who support them). So, for the memorial, if we do it, do it with class and dignity, don’t be banging on about it. Treat it with the respect it deserves.

Phil Sammon
68 Posted 27/03/2014 at 13:21:03
We’ll Jimmy, people in general will swallow what they are told. You only have to look at the transfer rumours section on this very site. Mark makes some points I agree with and some I don’t, I just don’t think some of the comments towards him are warranted.

My point throughout this thread is, where do you draw the line?

A plaque at Goodison...
All league kick-off’s delayed by 7 minutes on the anniversary weekend...
FA announce 96 seats to be left empty at an upcoming England game...
Family members invited into the Royal box to attend England game.

It just feels so horribly forced. It also feels like certain people, organisations and political parties will do their utmost to support the campaign just for the reflected benefit.

Respect should be paid, but eventually it becomes trite.

Gavin Ramejkis
69 Posted 27/03/2014 at 13:26:09
The cover up was very much symptomatic of Thatcher’s England in the day. That cunt had a hatred of the working classes and her mini army in blue got away with murder. The cover-up was atrocious and it’s scant relief for the families of those who died on that day to be proven right – that their relatives weren’t pissed up animals who deserved what they got – and those who could have been saved even when it happened but for the criminal negligence of the Police Officer in charge that day.

Hillsborough could have happened to anyone’s – fans not just theirs.

Sam Morrison
70 Posted 27/03/2014 at 13:39:13
Phil, where would you draw the line, personally? I think you and others on here have a problem purely because it’s Liverpool. And I find that disrespectful, that you can’t put your tribal allegiances to one side for something so monumental.

I think it’s equally disrespectful for various posters to keep bringing Heysel into the discussion. There is no question of balancing the scales here. You don’t equate one disaster with another and start saying "Therefore..." – That’s bollocks.

As for Stevie G and Liverpool "milking it" – exactly how picky do we want to get about how different clubs or people remember the loss? I understand the point about Gerrard making his donation public, but it’s pointlessly petty to get upset about it in light of the broader context. And isn’t it possible he wanted the publicity on behalf of the families of the 96, rather than himself?

Ray Roche
71 Posted 27/03/2014 at 13:40:53
Phil Sammon,

Phil, good post, some of the points you mention there are new to me, 96 seats left empty etc., and there DOES appear to be an orchestrated feel to everything about LFC these days, from the singing of that dirge pre-match, which the BBC feel obliged to show every MotD, to the points that you raise.

We are now all aware of the scandal that has followed the police corruption post Hillsborough and also the way the press manipulated events to force their opinion on everyone, but, corruption apart, no other club, even Manchester United and their Munich disaster (which our red friends see as fair game to crow about) have had such widespread support and coverage. It’s almost on par with Diana and Dodi.

My own personal view is that mourning loved ones is a private affair and is best left to those closest to the deceased. Nothing will bring the 96 fans back, I just hope that everyone concerned gets the correct decision when the courts have finished with their deliberations.

Dennis Stevens
72 Posted 27/03/2014 at 13:56:49
I can’t agree, Gavin. I’d say the cover-up is symptomatic of the police. Somebody mentioned the more recent ’plebgate’ business & it shows the police clearly still think the law doesn’t apply to themselves. They were quite happy to lie & make false statements to bring down a politician, so it’s no surprise what depths they’ll go to when dealing with the rest of us, as shown as a result if the ongoing JFT96 campaign.

Sadly, I’m sure there’s more to come yet &, even worse, I doubt we’ll ever really get to the bottom of it.

Paul Niklas
73 Posted 27/03/2014 at 13:49:27
Gavin, we all have sympathy for what happened and we all stand by the families completely for their loss and we always have. It does not mean we have to agree with every allegation or insinuation. I for one believe the blame lies across many people ranging from the FA in playing it there in the first place, the police for what boiled down to incompetence in the face of pressures from the fans on the day, who you cannot discount from some blame, no matter how big or small.

To deny the above is ignorant of the facts and and naive in the extreme.

Some Everton fans are very bitter about lots of things and their emotions are expressed without thinking about what they are really saying or the impact it has on the majority of pragmatic and sensible fans.

To bring Thatcher into the debate is bordering on the ridiculous but it typifies everything that was bad about how Liverpool as a city was in the 80s, blame everyone but ourselves and some like you continue to be of that type.

The bottom line is it happened; you can support the families or you do not have to but it will never go away. My only hope is that justice means we find the truth and those accountable for mistakes made are punished in a way that is fair. After all, none of it was a deliberate act – it was a catalogue of human error. My worry is that justice for some is a financial windfall which would ensure a lot of empathy will be lost.

Everton are doing the right thing and I applaud them.

Mark Boulle
74 Posted 27/03/2014 at 14:02:27
Phil #432, thank you. It is extraordinary that Jimmy, Ste and Paul Ferry in particular do not seem able to have a meaningful discussion on this without resorting to personally insulting me. I am neither a prick, nor a fucking disgrace, you just don’t like my views. That’s fine, I don’t like yours and we are all entitled to resent opinions with which we disagree.

In my view, if you can’t be civil in an argument and feel you have to insult the person whose view doesn’t accord with yours, you are already most of the way to losing that argument.

Kevin Tully
75 Posted 27/03/2014 at 14:09:37
Gavin R is spot on - Thatcher hated football with a passion usually reserved for our enemies. The cover-up had political influence and drunken fans were blamed for years. The establishment closed ranks from day one.

Don’t kid yourselves – it could so easily have been Blues fans that day.

Sam Morrison
76 Posted 27/03/2014 at 14:19:32
Mark (439) whilst I agree that the name-calling isn’t necessary, you maybe need to imagine how it appears when someone not from Liverpool (like you or I) comes into a discussion with what could be interpreted as a dismissive attitude.

You’re free to have your view, of course, but I’m afraid you don’t realise how insensitive you’re being. EFC is making a gesture towards not just another club, but the city as a whole. It’s a simple thing, trying to contribute toward the resolution of a very complicated and protracted matter. Implying we should all just shut up going on about it all the time – in my view – is not only insensitive but insensible.

Jimmy Kelly
77 Posted 27/03/2014 at 14:16:37
Mark, if I went on a forum for holocaust survivors or families of those killed on Bloody Sunday and said that people should ’get on with it’ ’stop banging on about it’ ’let it go’ and said that I was ’infuriated’ by the recognition of a campaigner then I’d feel I’d got away lightly if someone called me a prick.

You, on the other hand, have prattled on – despite a number of people mentioning that they have been personally affected by this tragedy – and have now tried to make yourself out to be the victim.

Paul Ferry
78 Posted 27/03/2014 at 14:09:54
I don’t get your stance here Phil that Mark Boule is ’merely questioning the extent to which we commemorate an event’ and the other fella something along the lines of a point well made.

NO! His posts are full of misconceptions and misunderstandings of a tragic event and he is not even aware that the inquiry we wanted all along is now going to happen. That is why to say "get over it, it’s 25 years ago" is I repeat a fucking disgrace. The last little swipe:

"But for those who think that further campaigning and inquiries will end with a handful of ageing, retired policeman being thrown in jail, I fear they are sadly deluded."

For someone who is not even aware of current developments, this is a ’sadly deluded’ and ill-informed statement. You know what, Mr Boule, getting justice really matters here on both sides of the park and banging up lying aged corrupt abusive disgusting coppers will at least be some recognition of the sub-human outrages that were perpetrated on Liverpool fans on that day.

Oh, and your two other highly significant points. "Why swear, Ferry?" — coz, Mr Boule, highly charged emotions often result in aforementioned verbal act. And what is your opinion or words to that effect. I think I made that clear; your misconceptions and misunderstandings are crass disgraceful.

Do I want this memorial? Read Harold Matthews above – 370 – deeply moving in few choice words that reflects what the vast majority of Evertonians – especially those who grew up in Liverpool – feel deep down.

Phil, sorry for getting my south and west mixed up and I know its a very meaningful error but one made forgive me in the heat of the moment.

Dennis Stevens
79 Posted 27/03/2014 at 14:29:50
Jimmy, I can’t believe you really just compared Hillsborough to the Holocaust – I suspect there are some who might find that offensive in itself.
Darryl Ritchie
80 Posted 27/03/2014 at 14:16:05
This was neither a LFC or an Everton tragedy. It was an event that affected the entire city.

The memorial should placed, not for moral or political reasons, but because it’s the right thing to do. Ninety six football fans from the city of Liverpool died needlessly.

That should be enough.

Phil Sammon
81 Posted 27/03/2014 at 14:36:06
And, this isn’t a Hillsborough forum is it? An all round very odd analogy there Jimmy.

No problem, Paul, I know it was an error typed in haste on your part. That is understandable.

What isn’t understandable is Everton ’fans’ chanting "murderers" at Leeds matches! But that is a whole other debate.

Jimmy Kelly
82 Posted 27/03/2014 at 14:42:07
Dennis, point scoring on the scale of a tragedy, very classy.

Phil, it’s a forum used by people who – like me – were directly affected by the tragedy and know people who have been actively involved in the justice campaign. It is incredibly insulting and insensitive to come on to such a forum and post the sort of garbage I have seen on here. You clearly don’t understand the way that this tragedy has affected people across this city and it’s something I genuinely hope you never have to experience.

I believe the majority of people on the site see this the same way I do and thankfully now so do the majority of the country. I’m going to stop replying now because it has genuinely upset me to see fellow Evertonians act in this way.

Gavin Ramejkis
83 Posted 27/03/2014 at 14:48:51
Dennis sorry if you misinterpreted me, I’ve known quite a few ex old bill and to the last man jack of them bending the rules was rife but they were given a free hand (and plenty of overtime to boot) in Thatcher’s reign that created a massive basis of corruption within it, Serious Crime Squads that should have been named Serious Criminal Squads, Special Patrol Group which should have been called Special Racist Group, strikers were targeted with military precision, the Stephen Lawrence case is just one of many many injustices yet to be unveiled.
Sam Morrison
84 Posted 27/03/2014 at 14:51:41
Phil - "This isn’t a Hillsborough forum"

Please re-read the original post.

Dennis Stevens
85 Posted 27/03/2014 at 14:51:21
Jimmy, I’m not point scoring - you made the comparison. I was merely expressing my surprise that you would do so. Others might be shocked or even outraged. But if it makes you feel better about what you’ve posted by criticising me for commenting on it, feel free. I think it’s rather obvious where the lack of class has been displayed.
Sam Morrison
86 Posted 27/03/2014 at 14:55:43
Dennis, you’re being silly. Jimmy made the comparison to try and explain something from a more objective point of view. It doesn’t mean he equates the tragedies equally, or hates the Jews. Stop looking for things to be affronted by.
John Daley
87 Posted 27/03/2014 at 14:55:31
"....the BBC gave some sort of unsung hero award to one of the campaigners. I was absolutely infuriated by that - it should have gone to somebody somewhere struggling against the odds to keep a vital community sports club open or something"

Why the fuck, besides a hatred of Liverpool FC, would that ’infuriate’ you? Someone who has lost a family member in such a senseless way shows the heart, resolve and sheer determination not to rest until the full facts regarding the circumstances of probably their darkest ever day are disclosed. Not just for themselves, or the memory of those they lost, but for every single person who found their lives similarly smashed asunder when someone they knew attended the wrong semi-final.

They’ve persevered in the face of public smear campaigns, blatant police corruption, political sleight of hand, and the inexorable passage of time. For 25 years now they’ve existed in a state of limbo, unable to (as you say) ’simply get over it’, because...well.... it’s not fucking over with at all. Not for them.

Yet, for you, such a person is less worthy of recognition than some quilt with a social conscience and plenty of spare time who simply organised a sponsored run to save a fucking scout hut or a club where fat kids can play ’crab soccer’ or something?

More than that, you don’t just disagree with it you find it ’infuriating’. Like it’s a....miscarriage of justice maybe? If I was you I’d take time to consider the meaning of that term and stop making a total tit of myself.

Mark Boulle
88 Posted 27/03/2014 at 14:49:18
Paul #443 - out of interest, what is the new inquiry that you and others say you’ve always wanted?

As I referred to in my last post, a major public inquiry concluded not that long ago - I forget whether it was 2012 or 2013, finding the police guilty of a cover up.

What more is there to say or inquire about? I understand your desire for a particular individual or individuals, rather than just a police force as a whole, to shoulder the blame here. You must, however, surely see that given the passage of time, lack of written records, subsequent deaths of some of the police involved on the day etc, it will be almost impossible to convict any one or several of anything at all now.

As for my other point about continued coverage of the disaster, altering kick off times, Gerrard’s very public donation and all the other stuff, there’s no sense in arguing further about that. The point is moot anyway, since the establishment appear to have decided that the commemorations will continue ad infinitum. That seems to me to be symptomatic of British society, whose ability to cope with and move on from tragic events ended with the death of Princess Diana.

Dennis Stevens
89 Posted 27/03/2014 at 14:55:31
I don’t think I mis-interpreted you, Gavin. You’re quite right about those criticisms of policing back in the day & sure, the 80’s was a good time to be in the filth, but a lot of that stuff was going on way back in the 70’s too & Thatchler only rose to PM in ’79. I’m certain that the police out of control at Hillsborough were in no doubt that they could blame it all on football hooligans, cover up their own incompetence, at best, & never be brought to book. In that sense, the JKFT98 campaign have done a great service not only to those directly affected, or even all football supporters, but all who are concerned about the rights of the individual & the power afforded instruments of the state - which should be everybody.
Paul Livesey
90 Posted 27/03/2014 at 14:04:30
I don’t leave that many comments on here, mainly because I’m a bit indecisive, but not this time.

I am absolutely flabbergasted that some fellow fans can be so insensitive by airing their negative thoughts on this subject. Surely they must realise how this could really upset some of our very own Evertonians who suffered on that dreadful day, and are still suffering. We should stand strong together and humbly support those that need it, not twist the knife. We are Everton remember.

Dennis Stevens
91 Posted 27/03/2014 at 15:06:50
Sam, I’m not affronted, just surprised. However, I do think it was an ill-judged comparison & others could be offended.
Simon Lloyd
92 Posted 27/03/2014 at 15:04:59
Ray #436, as you say "We are now all aware of the scandal that has followed the police corruption post Hillsborough and also the way the press manipulated events to force their opinion on everyone..."

The question, for me, is would we now all be aware of the scandal had Hillsborough just been quietly accepted. Isn’t it the widespread coverage that has helped the families keep matters in the public eye and forced the scandal to be brought to light?

John Audsley
93 Posted 27/03/2014 at 15:00:17
Its a good and touching thing to do

I was 13 back in 1989 and remember that day very clearly. My sister who is a red was 10 and remembers it too.

Living in Leeds Dad and myself woulf have gone to Hillsborough if the Everton game had been in Sheffield. Jo was only just getting into football back then and for some reason had a crush on Peter Beardsley........

No one should lose a loved one the way that so many people did that day.

25 years ago suddenly seems like yesterday but Ive got 2 blue boys and my sis has 2 red lads and we are close family apart from the football but that drives Mum nuts

Alot of people died that day and Families were destroyed. Im proud we are having a memorial

Its respectful and hurts no one

Sam Morrison
94 Posted 27/03/2014 at 15:09:54
Dennis, can you explain to me why the comparison was ill-judged? Who could possibly take offence from that?

Let’s assume you mean people who lost family or friends in the holocaust. Well, I don’t see how Jimmy saying it would be insensitive to tell them to "get over it" would offend them. They would agree.

And surely you don’t mean the families who lost loved ones at Hillsborough, as they were the very people Jimmy was trying to point out some posters were being insensitive about. Who is left? People who just don’t like comparisons generally?

John Gee
95 Posted 27/03/2014 at 14:57:56
I’m a scouser and I was 15 when the Hillsborough tragedy happened. I remember the grief and scarfs and certain people saying the FA cup should be given to LFC that year.

And they haven’t stopped banging on about it ever since. It’s exploited to galvanise support before every derby. It’s used as a vehicle to peddle the myth of what a great club they are. It is now being used as way for our head PR guy to ingratiate himself with the city. Whenever LFC want "it’s all about us" angle in the media, they play this card.

Scousers are far too ready to feel self pity and this is just the perfect opportunity to wallow.

It’s heart breaking for the families involved and their campaign deserves respect and support. But it’s THEIR campaign.

Also, the guys on here who are advocating moving on are right. The wound will never heal if the grieving process is prolonged.

Ian Burns
96 Posted 27/03/2014 at 15:03:48
I posted earlier on this site but reading some of the posts since, it has caused me considerable upset.

I was born in Liverpool and left for the first time as a young man of 21 and never returned due to living abroad for many years.

My heart and soul is in EFC having watched my first game in the late ’50’s but more importantly my heart and soul has always remained with the people of Liverpool be they blue or red, as I grew up with both.

96 fellow Liverpool people died that day and since that time they have suffered not only immense grief but horrendous injustice on a scale nobody could have imagined in our own country.

To read some of the posts on here, brought about by the excellent and further contribution of EFC and its supporters to put up a memorial to recognise 25 years, has shocked me.

I have always thought of EFC and its supports a cut above the rest and some of the unfortunate posts on here will never stop that belief - but I have to say to those who have raised issues and caused unnecessary debate - I am shocked and ashamed.

We are better than that; we are special; we are Liverpool people with a special history with two cathedrals; two football teams but one city and one people no matter where in the world we have spread ourselves.

I say it again, well done EFC, an excellent and further contribution and recognition of that terrible day.

Ray Roche
97 Posted 27/03/2014 at 15:14:04
Simon, I’m in complete agreement with you, it is to the families credit, and also those not directly affected, that they pursued what they rightly considered a cover up and brought to light that very scandal. I do, however, think that the CLUB, not the families or people of Liverpool like me and you (?) are in danger of milking what was a tragedy for those people and our city. Don’t forget,the widespread coverage was conducted by the very people who smeared decent Liverpool people in the aftermath of that tragedy and who only reacted to those untruths when the brown stuff hit the fan.
Like I said, now that the truth is out the families of the victims should be able to mourn in their own personal way and, yes, move on. That is my own view and that is how I would deal with things, were I so closely affected
Dennis Stevens
99 Posted 27/03/2014 at 15:31:30
Sam, I think you’re mischief making. Jimmy equated the 96 deaths at Hillsborough with the systematic extermination of approximately 6 milion Jews. Some might have thought twice about making such a comparison in case some might find it offensive. Obviously, you & Jimmy wouldn’t. It surprises me, but maybe you two are correct!
Paul Livesey
100 Posted 27/03/2014 at 15:33:43
I’ve just had my faith in Evertonians restored. Thought I would share this for anyone who needs it.

http://www.evertonfc.com/news/archive/2014/03/26/derek-is-second-we-go-the-game-winner

Sam Morrison
101 Posted 27/03/2014 at 15:47:48
That’s just it, though Dennis. He did not equate, and I do not ’make mischief’..

I’m surprised you’re genuinely sticking to this, but fine. The thread is actually about more important things than people possibly getting offended about something that was clearly intended to get a point across.

John Schrempft
102 Posted 27/03/2014 at 14:55:03
Mentioning Heysel is neither being disrespectful nor trying to balance one tragedy against another. The question about there being a plaque at Anfield has been answered.and I’m pleased to here there is one for what happened in Belgium.

ALL fans who died in accidents such as Heysel, Hillsborough, Ibrox and Bradford should be remembered on one occasion per year as they ALL have relations and friends who were severely affected by what occurred.

In all the above cases, human error was to blame. Clearly, the cover-up after Hillsboroough was a scandal and made an appalling situation even worse. Hopefully, those responsible will finally be brought to justice.

A Hillsborough plaque or memorial at Goodison is fine by me if EFC wish to do that.

I may not particularly like fans from other clubs but I do try to respect them. If they resort to violence or chant obscenites that cannot be condoned and should be suitably punished.

Equally, contributors to this forum( and their views) should also be respected and not be denigrated just because we don’t agree with what they say.

Andrew Hawes
103 Posted 27/03/2014 at 15:50:40
Is there any point putting up a "permanent " memorial?

After all, the daily search for funds and sites for our new stadium will mean we will be out of Goodison soon! Won’t it, Kenwright? Elstone??

May as well go and erect a memorial, it’s gestures like this that shows how much intention the club has of moving!

With regards the gesture, it shows what a great club we are!

Dennis Stevens
104 Posted 27/03/2014 at 16:29:27
Surprised that I’m genuinely sticking to thinking it was an inappropriate comparison, Sam? Why would I change my view? Just to agree with you? Now that would be ’being silly’.
David Jackson
105 Posted 27/03/2014 at 16:20:38
I think there are two seperate questions here - (1) Is it appropriate for EFC to have a Hillsborough memorial and (2) Is it appropriate for Hillsborough to continue to be commemorated outside of LFC ?

I would think most reasonable people would answer "yes" to question (1), as it shows class, solidarity, and that some things are more important than football.

Point (2) on the other hand, is less clear cut. Although the tragedy raised national issues, there has to be a point where the FA respects LFC (and any other club) commemorating it, but not force any other clubs to (ie by changing kick offs/match days etc). I would suggest that point be after this anniversary.

Sam Morrison
106 Posted 27/03/2014 at 16:39:25
OK Dennis if it helps clarify, I copy the relevant bit below.

The comparison (and it is a comparison; not an equation) was not between one tragedy and another. It was between Mark’s *reaction* to the memorial proposal and another, completely hypothetical *reaction* to an imaginary holocaust survival group. It’s not even a subtle difference. It’s a massive difference. Jimmy did not say "Hillsborough was as bad as the Holocaust". He said, in order to illuminate Mark and others as to their insensitivity, that:

"if I went on a forum for holocaust survivors or families of those killed on Bloody Sunday and said that people should ’get on with it’ ’stop banging on about it’ ’let it go’ and said that I was ’infuriated’ by the recognition of a campaigner then I’d feel I’d got away lightly if someone called me a prick."

Which is in no way ’equating’ the two, unless by ’equating’ you mean ’mentioning in the same paragraph’.

It’s a shame to get bogged down in semantics on a delicate thread such as this - but then it’s also a shame you and Mark felt the need to take Jimmy to task about the way he communicated something that affected him deeply.

If you still see it as ’inappropriate’ then let’s agree to disagree. We’re going in circles here.

Dennis Stevens
107 Posted 27/03/2014 at 17:06:15
Thanks Sam, but I understood it all the first time I read it, thought it inappropriate then & think it’s inappropriate now. I didn’t ’take Jimmy to task’, I expressed my surprise at what I felt was an inappropriate comment. If you feel it was appropriate that’s fine but I’m perplexed as to why you wish to labour the point considering you didn’t want ’to get bogged down in semantics’ then did exactly that.
Brian Denton
108 Posted 27/03/2014 at 17:24:23
As far as I am concerned we should bang on about injustices forever - it’s the best way (not guaranteed, alas) to ensure that they don’t happen again. And that goes for one victim or one million. People who have been complicit in wrongdoing should fear the consequences for the rest of their lives, whether they be bent cops, media child abusers, or concentration camp guards.
Geoff Evans
110 Posted 27/03/2014 at 17:52:10
Brian 491: Top thread. Stonewalling should never be allowed to get in the way of justice, unfortunately to my mind, some of the main players in the subsequent cover up are no longer with us and so have escaped earthly justice. Let’s hope there’s a higher one.
Colin Grierson
111 Posted 27/03/2014 at 18:40:14
If you are too young to remember or were unaffected by this tragedy then it won’t matter whether there is a memorial erected at GP or not. I am baffled by some of r comments on here. Most of my family are reds and both of my brothers were at Hillsborough. I hate. Liverpool Football club, however, I don’t hate the fans (although there are some...but then there are some blues too...) as we are all fans regardless of our allegiances.

If this proposed gesture by EFC upsets anyone in any way then you need to examine your humanity. Why not empathise with those whose lives changed that day 25 years ago and to whom this simple gesture by their greatest rivals may offer a moment of respite from grief you can only imagine.

For me, I am proud to be a member of a community that has people within it who have the tenacity to pursue the truth and justice against all the odds and for so long.
Proud to be a scouser. Proud to be a blue.

Jamie Crowley
112 Posted 27/03/2014 at 20:14:21
Wading into waters this American has no business in...

It seems to me, as an outsiders perspective and therefore I’d argue entirely objective, that this is solely a Liverpool Football Club issue.

I understand that many had family and friends involved in the tragedy. But is that not a personal issue and really not one for Everton Football Club to commemorate with a plaque / memorial outside Goodison? Everton did not play there that day - Liverpool did. It could have but Everton, but... it wasn’t.

I’d think that any statue, plaque, etc should be outside Anfield and not Goodison - despite the wider issue of police corruption that clearly affects many and not just one football club.

Everton have been exemplary and should be proud regarding their stance in standing in lock-step with their neighbors. But the commemoration of such events I believe should be left to LFC. if Everton wanted to be truly gracious (and they have been God knows) then pay for the plaque / memorial at Anfield and mention on it that Everton Football Club stood with their family, friends, and neighbors. Perhaps a line on the plaque saying, "two Clubs, one city, one family" or some such thing.

My only naive analogy is if Red Sox fans, attending a Yankee game (and there are many stead-fast friends who support one team or the other) perished in a horrible event and there was a memorial placed outside Fenway. My first reaction would be it should not be there as it was a Yankee game - it should be at Yankee Stadium.

Replace Red Sox with Everton (tough, I know...) and Yankees with LFC and I hope you can see where I’m coming from.

It’s intriguing to this man who’s adopted Everton and knows nothing admittedly of Liverpool sans the knowledge he’s gleaned off TW.... I pray I’ve not offended anyone.

Just trying to explain what may be seen as an objective, outsiders opinion.

Ste Traverse
113 Posted 27/03/2014 at 19:54:42
I really am amazed and saddened at some of the classless comments off a minority on here. It’s as if they can’t put their utter hatred of Liverpool FC to one side, even for this.

As Coin says #507, Proud to be a Scouser. Proud to be Blue.

Kieran Riding
114 Posted 27/03/2014 at 21:07:34
Ste.. 519.
I said in my earlier post I didn’t think it was necessary at Goodison, and I stick by that, it should be a City thing IMO.

I was at the other Semi myself. A teenager.
The luck of the balls coming out of the bag in the draw meant the blues were in Birmingham.. Not Sheffield.

Luck.

I can only call it as I remember personally ( not with the hindsight that some do.. )

The ’initial’ reaction.. And I mean initial here.. First opinion of breaking news of ’ trouble at Hillsborough ’ was one of " they’ve done it again ! "
Liverpool causing trouble at the game.

This was replaced VERY quickly once actual facts came through of what had happened.

The younger lads posting here, probably haven’t known life without Sky News 24/7 coverage.

Rumour and the press created doubt and anger.

I remember vividly queuing ( for what seemed like an eternity ) outside Anfield with my family to place my scarf on the pitch..
Christ.. So Many Flowers !
The full effect wasn’t yet known.. But it was a somber experience.

When it was footie time for Everton again.. I remember thinking how odd it was watching a game back at Goodison without the barriers !
( were we the first to pull them down ? )

There was a bit if a crush at Anfield in the Derby this year by the way..

Get to the ground early lads.

Colin Grierson
115 Posted 27/03/2014 at 21:31:34
Jamie 516 - I think your idea of paying for the memorial and having a statement on there is well intentioned but LFC have a memorial and an adendum would, I feel, be inappropriate.

Whether you are from New York or New Brighton we all have a cultural identity and Liverpool’s cultural identity can be defined by the way the family, friends and greater community stood against the disgraceful press representation of what was an avoidable tragedy. The people of Liverpool were misrepresented and accused of all kinds of heinous acts and left with a stigma of guilt.

Should my neighbour need my help or support I would not ask which team they show an allegiance, I would simply help if I could. Whether this gesture from EFC helps or not it is well intentioned and surely only good can come of it. Why anyone questions it’s validity or whether it is appropriate and whether an alternative is appropriate is, well, not what I would expect from a good neighbour.

Let’s leave the rivalry for the match day. Some things are more important than football.

Pete Gunby
116 Posted 27/03/2014 at 21:20:35
So we put up a plaque or a statue. Some will be moved, some will pause and reflect, some will contemplate. If it means nothing to you, then walk on and ignore it. If it offends or upsets you that our club would take such an action- seek counseling immediately.
Harold Matthews
117 Posted 27/03/2014 at 21:45:32
Jamie. As a big Red Sox fan I can see clearly where you’re coming from. I can also see that you are trying to understand things from an impossible viewpoint. People in England don’t understand Merseyside folk. Why should you? When John Lennon said we were foreigners in our own land he wasn’t kiddin’. I don’t know if its the heavy mixture of Irish and Welsh blood but we have a way of thinking and acting which does not always fit the norm. Sox and Yankees, Reds and Blues. They don’t come into it. It’s all about the kind of people we are up here. People born and bred outside this area are not expected to understand us and they never will.
Phill Shipy
118 Posted 27/03/2014 at 23:39:51
I’m a scouser born and bred, I was in the Holte End that fateful day too. as an aside, on the way out of Villa Park we, along with Derek Hatton who was making his presence known, were involved in some hairy moments with the sheer number of people exiting the ground en masse. This, of course, was common back then. I also remember the initial feeling, when the scoreboard announced ’game abandoned’ at Hillsborough, being one of ’oh they’re at it again’. The journey home from Birmingham is something that I’ll never ever forget, truly horrendous.

I was at Anfield early enough the next morning to tie my blue scarf on the goal post at the kop end, just an hour or so later the queue was around the ground. The ’story’ put out by the filth in the immediate aftermath was adopted and allowed to fester by more media outlets than just the s*n and, I believe, did untold damage to scousers and the City.

However, I feel uneasy about a memorial at GP. For a few reasons it just doesn’t sit easy with me, albeit I understand the sentiment behind it, totally. One other thing before I end what is my first post on TW, I’m disappointed to see people pilloried for holding an honest, if somewhat slightly naive, point of view. Sometimes educating is better than castigating.

Alan Blayney
119 Posted 28/03/2014 at 00:21:16
Phil Sammon, Mark Boulle, and any others who share their views, I can’t fathom why you would comment so insensitively. Hillsborough was a national disgrace that could have happened to any club, in fact it nearly happened on two separate occasions a few years earlier to Everton and another club if my memory serves me correctly. Would either of you want the book shut on it if any of your family was affected by it?

It is because of the tragedy that there has been no other similar incidents since. If Hillsborough had not have happened, some other similar tragedy at Hillsborough or at another UK ground would have occurred before now. Who knows where, when or who would have been affected. I pray to god you or anyone else is never caught up in something so tragic.

That there was a massive cover-up only made the tragedy even worse.

Karl Masters
120 Posted 28/03/2014 at 02:09:28
I was at Villa Park that day and have always said it could so easily have been us. I’m just thankful it wasn’t.

But that doesn’t stop me thinking the 96 Reds and their families still need our support as the truth is finally coming out (announced today that 13 police identified for prosecution) because this still isn’t over, is it? Not for those poor souls.

I don’t know what this memorial will be and of course I agree that it’s about 24 years late in arriving and therefore seems strange to some. However, we should never forget when attending any game of footie that we owe our much safer stadiums of today and no longer being treated as cattle (99.9% of the time anyway) to what sprang out of that awful day.

Football rivalry cannot supersede losing your life and the disgraceful police and media events that followed.

Jamie Crowley
121 Posted 28/03/2014 at 04:01:33
Colin and Harold -

I greatly appreciate your responses.

I believe Harold put it best while Colin illustrated it perfectly.

I view this through a prism that renders full comprehension impossible.

But your responses have helped me understand why that is - thank you.

Alan Williams
122 Posted 28/03/2014 at 08:33:41
Phil 549, I agree completely with your post; I feel the same way, my day was very similar to yours. We all feel for the families but people must understand that most football fans in those days acted in a terrible way and LFC had history as we did. The cover up was terrible but so was fans behaviour – just look at Heysel and the cover up from the LFC Chairman blaming Chelsea/London NF fans.

If I remember, then they had the audacity to walk around Goodison with collection boxes for the wrongly arrested "fans", asking for the scouse family to help their arrested souls, complete shamelessness and it’s this bit I don’t like about the two clubs pretending to be friends when the truth is at board level they have massive contempt for each other.

I would be more comfortable if the City made a monument for its people and left EFC to play a part in a collective memorial. I will stand next to them on Hillsborough but on everything else they are a bunch of self-pitying hypocrites. My mates always say: "Offended by everything, ashamed of nothing". Hillsborough apart, this sums up those urchins.

Paul Niklas
123 Posted 28/03/2014 at 10:05:04
Nice post, Ian Burns. If only your belief was the case, you obviously do not attend games anymore — the divide on derby day is more intense than it has ever been; the tangible hatred is there for all to see and feel.

Yes, we are one city with two teams but that’s about as far as it goes for some support. You only have to spend some time with some of our away fans to know how horrible at times some of our supporters are.

Dave Roberts
124 Posted 28/03/2014 at 10:30:10
I have no problem at all with Everton erecting a memorial to 96 supporters of Liverpool who died needlessly. I have no problem at all with annual ceremonies of remembrance. I have no problem with the culprits who caused the tragedy finally being held to account... in fact, it is long overdue and I welcome it. I have no problem with minute silences and delayed kick-offs.

What I do have a problem with is that other needless tragedy at Heysel being airbrushed from history. Thirty-nine people died that day as a direct consequence of the behaviour of many of our ’brothers and sisters’ from across the park. Where is the memorial to them? Where are the annual ceremonies of remembrance for those poor souls? Where is the 25-year hunt for those responsible for that tragedy? Where are the inquiries to dig out the truth of what happened that day?

Just because a majority of those who tragically died at Hillsborough were local, even our ’brothers and sisters’, does not mean in any sense that 39 Italians from 1,000 miles away do not deserve the same respect and, above all, should not be forgotten.

There have been many football tragedies, Ibrox, Bradford, Hillsborough and Heysel among them. All the dead arising from all of them and their families need justice.

David Lynn
125 Posted 28/03/2014 at 10:34:18
Just like Chris Fennell, I have registered to ToffeeWeb just for this single subject.

Mark, it is patently obvious you do not hail from Liverpool, as you have no understanding of the complex relationship between the two sets of fans.

I will not use terms such as hate to describe the other side of the park, in fact, I personally think it would be a big blow to the city if either of the two teams got into serious trouble. There perhaps lies the nub of my comment.

What happened that day and since was a grievous injury to the whole city and its people. Yes, we are divided by the colour of our teams; however, we are totally united in our beliefs and values and our love for our birthplace. It makes me extremely proud to see Evertonians at memorial events just as it did to see blue and white colours at the Anfield gates then and since.

I personally think our city has suffered many injustices and unfair decisions for many years going back to the ’50s; this was another of those, compounded by the attitude of some of the media and authorities.

Although I now live some hundred miles away and have done for many years, I am always a very proud scouser and will die that way.

I’m not even sure people like you have any concept of the relationship not just with the city but also as I said between the two sets of supporters. It also makes me wonder if you have a true understanding of what Everton are completely about.

Lastly, before you try and somehow use my not living in the city as a criticism of me. I have been a season ticket holder for 55 years and although not getting too many away matches, rarely miss a home one.

Colin Grierson
126 Posted 28/03/2014 at 13:04:26
Dave 626 -

Lots of friends and family where at Heysel and they ALL corroborated the same story to me. Liverpool flags hung on the hastily erected fence to segregate the supporters were set on fire by Juve fans. These fans were challenged by the owners of the flag who were then violently attacked in full view of the Liverpool fans who were just yards away and separated by a flimsy fence. The rest we saw unfold on TV and led to the tragic deaths of 39 innocent football fans.

I agree that there should have been an inquiry in to who was culpable for the organisation of this fixture and the segregation and subsequent policing of the match. I believe that many of those responsible for the violence were jailed for their part in this horrible event and justice (at least in part) was meted out.

The press once again went after the people of Merseyside following Heysel focusing on the violence shown by a minority. A week prior to this, I was in Rotterdam with tens of thousands of Scousers and there were was a solitary arrest for drunk and disorderly behaviour, not by a Scouser but by a Rapid Vienna fan! The point I am making is that people from the same community travelled to similar events and the outcomes couldn’t have been more different.

The question that springs to my mind is how would Everton fans have reacted to the scenario I was given by people who attended the Heysel stadium. Having attended many Everton games both home and away during that period, I feel the result would have been much the same. Hooliganism has all but disappeared from the British game but it was rife at the time of Heysel and those that ’enjoyed’ a fight with rival fans were present in every football ground in the league. Just like the Hillsborough disaster, it could have been us!

Alan Williams
127 Posted 28/03/2014 at 13:56:58
Colin 653, that’s the most stupid defence I have ever heard for Heysel: it could have been us so leave them be. The fact is, it wasn’t us – it was them and the vast majority of those fans arrested on the day and after were Liverpool fans, most season ticket holders. I’m afraid they have pushed this myth for so long that even locals believe it, you have been guilty of drinking their self-pity.

People’s (including Evertonians’) perceptions on Hillsborough were all wrong and we should support them unconditionally; but, on matters like Heysel, and the way they treated the Munich 58 survivors and family was disgraceful. Ask your LFC friends what their Chairman said after the events in 85, they tried to cover the facts with myths and lies, not dissimilar to what the British media did after Hillsborough, absolutely shocking I think it was Mr Robinson.

Colin Grierson
128 Posted 28/03/2014 at 16:44:06
Alan I offer no defence for those responsible for Heysel but give my views given the information available to me. What I’m saying is that had we been playing Juventus and those events unfolded do you really think ALL Evertonians would’ve stood by and just shouted STOP or do you think that some would’ve got physically involved and thus the same result would’ve ensued.

The way their chairman reacted and the statements from the club itself are nothing to do with what I am arguing. The abuse levelled at MUFC during that period concerning the Munich disaster is something that both sets of supporters were guilty of or did you not go the match then?

I took my brother to Old Trafford to watch Liverpool (weeks after we beat them 5-0 at GP) as he wasn’t allowed to go unless I went with him. I listened to the LFC fans sing their Munich songs while waiting on the station platform which was full of Mancs. One of those Mancs stabbed me. Luckily I wasn’t badly hurt and the lad was arrested and dealt with accordingly. But did he behave in that way because of the abuse from the LFC fans? No! he carried a knife just in case he came across a Scouser.

The likes of that lad were at every ground in the country back in the 80s and as we all know Kopites are not all from Liverpool. Many of those arrested after Heysel were not from the city of Liverpool but the city and it’s people were tainted by their acts. This thread had nothing to do with Heysel and I wasn’t the one to introduce it. The only similarities between Hillsborough and Heysel are innocent deaths and the wrongful denigration of the people of Liverpool. Whatever Robinson and his ilk said in the aftermath I think they should be held to account for but to judge everybody by the acts of a few is simply bigotry.

Alan Williams
129 Posted 28/03/2014 at 17:49:08
Colin, look at my post 595. I agree with you about fans’ behaviour, just ask many away fans that have been slashed at Everton, mainly coloured people which is disgusting but that was life in that 80’s watching football. I was there like you.

Ignorance is not a defence and just because "we" all acted that way doesn’t make it acceptable. LFC play this Scouse family when it suits them, always have and always will, it makes me cringe and its total bullshit. They are victims when it comes to Hillsborough and we will stand with them but on most other cases they are the perpetrator, but, no, we can’t talk about that because we are Scousers and one big happy family.

I have all my life been patronised by that lot and I can’t stand them when it comes to football chat but as people they are fine. But no different than any other fan and sharing a city as no relevance in my book. I agree life is more important and you should help your fellow man but I and many other fans would love LFC to accept their part in Heysel. Then we can all move on.

Colin Grierson
130 Posted 28/03/2014 at 18:41:24
Alan, I hate LFC for everything that they think they stand for and I agree that ’the club’ should stand up and be counted for the sins of their past. I won’t discuss football with many of my LFC mates as it’s a bit like religion in that we won’t and can’t agree. I’m right and they will always be wrong cos they believe they SHOULD be successful just like the Mancs. Their arrogance infuriates supporters across the land and does them no favours.

I had already read your post and agree to a certain extent about their part in Heysel and the accountability which at board level was not ever acknowledged. I reiterate that I make no excuses for what occurred at Heysel but the account I offer, I believe to be the truth. I remember my brothers arriving home and giving me their account like it was yesterday.

There are times though when we have to stand together as Scousers and refute the allegations levelled at us as a community. Like I said, only a week apart we travelled to the continent en masse as Scousers and I stand by my assertion that it could have been us. Maybe our board would have acted differently following the tragedy, I don’t know.

When it comes to Hillsborough, we agree. We will stand alongside them because it’s the right thing to do. I appreciate and understand your viewpoint on Heysel, I just don’t agree.

Peter Bell
131 Posted 28/03/2014 at 19:45:10
Colin, one year after Heysel, a delegation from Juventus were invited over to visit our City as a bridge-building exercise. The person from LCC who took them on the tour knew a friend of mine, and mentioned how the delegation had been given a tour of both our clubs. He commented that, based on the way they were treated, you would have thought that it was Everton who had been involved in Heysel — not the other team. That story has always stuck with me and history still shows how some people just don’t want to hear the word Heysel mentioned.
Tony Draper
132 Posted 28/03/2014 at 19:38:34
Burnden Park
Ibrox
Valley Parade

FFS This list MUST surely reduce any decent person to tears.

youtube.com/watch?v=TJ_vG4cHRKU

At Valley Parade, the heat from the fire was so intense that people who escaped the inferno by running onto the pitch still burst into flames!

Heysel Stadium
Hillsborough

ALL tragedies... TRAGEDIES

Human lives lost TOO MANY human lives lost. FUCKIN grow up and focus upon what REALLY matters.

No-one deserves to die just over a bloody game of footie. NO-ONE

Certainly not 14-year-old kids. Certainly not two teenage sisters!

Sarah Louise Hicks (19)
Victoria Jane Hicks (15)

I’m a true Blueblood. Any so called Evertonian who ever seeks to justify ANYTHING for some sad deranged line of reasoning... well you’re NOT a true blue

I’d HAPPILY see Everton go completely out of existence permanently if only Sarah Louise & Victoria Jane had survived that atrocity. Cos as much as Everton means to me... it’s not worth a single human life, let alone two sisters’ lives.

So a memorial at Goodison? Everton FC, Style & Dignity Since 1878 "......those who know...."

Colin Grierson
133 Posted 28/03/2014 at 20:15:11
Peter, It doesn’t matter what a delegation from Juve said or didn’t say really. I don’t really care what the LFC board did or didn’t say all those years ago. As Tony has stated, people died and they shouldn’t have. At Heysel, some of those guilty were held to account; at Hillsborough we await such justice.

This isn’t about point scoring or petty rivalry. There are plenty of things to take the piss out of the RS about but some things need to be left alone cos there’s no good in pursuing them.

The main reason some Blues pursue this is cos of the European ban. Those days are long gone and we shouldn’t be bitter about it. The way we react to such tragedies defines us as people. I agree with Tony: the thought of life without Everton Football Club is hard to imagine but the thought of life without loved ones is unbearable.

Phil Sammon
134 Posted 28/03/2014 at 21:01:38
Tony Draper

This isn’t about the value of human life. It’s about the value of a plaque.

Why don’t we have a 9/11 plaque at Goodison? Or are we only concerned about tragedies which affect our immediate family?

The people questioning a plaque are not callous souls, they just don’t understand why we are doing this when we already do so much.

Kevin Day
135 Posted 28/03/2014 at 21:22:15
I’ve sat reading the mixed posts, and been undecided about whether to add my tuppence worth, but here goes.

I’m not from Liverpool, but have visited many many times on match days, but I cannot and will not try and imagine how it affected the people of the City that day, I wouldn’t get close to how the hours ran down for those families not knowing if their loved ones were going to walk through the door that evening, and some of those wives, brothers, sister etc were Evertonians, waiting for their Liverpool-supporting loved ones to come home, safe. So for me, those who go to Goodison on match day who lost people that fateful day will see the memorial, and know that, no matter what the differences are on the pitch, their club remembers their loved ones. No matter what colour they wore. That’s what really matters.

Peter Laing
136 Posted 28/03/2014 at 22:12:50
Very nasty how a simple and poignant tribute from Everton FC in the form of a plaque honouring 96 supporters who never came home from a football match can denigrate into a pointless debate about Heysel etc. Shame on those who have spewed such cynicism and bile on these pages. COYB and JF96
John Daley
137 Posted 28/03/2014 at 22:22:06
"Why don’t we have a 9/11 plaque at Goodison? Or are we only concerned about tragedies which affect our immediate family?"

If you want to be blunt about it Phil, then yes.

What exactly is it you’re struggling to comprehend because you basically just answered your own question?

The fact is Everton, as a football club and massive part of the local community, are intrinsically linked to THIS particular disaster and the very people it directly affected.

What part of that is difficult to grasp?

Tony Dove
139 Posted 28/03/2014 at 22:28:04
Only just seen this news. I have strong views on Hillsborough to some extent governed by the behaviour of Liverpool fans at Wembley only three weeks later. It was of course the innocent supporters who lost their lives, ie, the ones who got to the game early.

Leaving all that aside it is totally inappropriate for Everton to be doing what is proposed. I would hate to see any plaque erected and even more for it to be abused at some point in the future.

Phil Sammon
140 Posted 28/03/2014 at 23:38:10
John Daley 746

Ok John, perhaps you will indulge me where others have refused.

If Everton had announced they would wear JFT96 on their shirts for this 25th anniversary season then would you have supported it?

What about if we raised a banner before each game?

What if we sang YNWA as a show of solidarity with our city rivals?

Just how far are people willing to go on this one? We already have silences. We already make very public statements of support. What are we going to do for the 30th anniversary? An even bigger plaque?

Ross Kerry
141 Posted 29/03/2014 at 10:59:05
Can't understand why anybody has a problem with this.
What does a plaque cost us? Who does it upset?

There are a fair number of us that lost a friend or family member that day and Everton, thankfully, has consistently recognised this. The plaque is a simple gesture that will mean something to some of us. If it doesn't mean anything to you, jog on and ignore it.

Simon Lloyd
142 Posted 29/03/2014 at 10:27:19
Tell you what Phil, let me indulge you.

Can things be taken too far? Well, of bloody course they can.

What then is taking things too far in the context of this thread? Well let's look at what prompted Everton's decision to make a memorial. Oh yes, they were approached by an Evertonian who lost his brother at Hillsborough. He asked. Why he asked now I can only guess at.

Maybe he feels now is the time given the extent of what we now know. Maybe it just felt right to him. Maybe his chances of being around to ask after another 25 years is slim. But he asked.

I don't think he has asked for too much. I think it would be pretty mean spirited to say no to him. I don't think a simple dignified plaque to the memory of his brother and fellow victims crosses the line.

If he asked every Evertonian to tattoo his/her backside with "Justice for the 96" then I would say that would be too far.

As for your specific examples, then it would depend on why we were doing it. If, for example, the Government were blocking the release of important information on Hillsborough, then yes, lets unveil a banner before every home game if it would help the campaign to do so. If unveiling a banner was done for just for the sake of it, then no, it would be too far.

Similarly for singing YNWA or putting a logo on the team shirts. If it is to say "look at us aren't we good" then I say the line would be crossed. If it would help the campaign then we probably stay the right side of the line.

Lenny Kingman
143 Posted 29/03/2014 at 11:46:41
#749 Tony

Hear hear sir.

John Daley
144 Posted 29/03/2014 at 13:20:13
Phil,

What would be the point?

You can pluck as many heightened, hypothetical alternatives out of the air as you want. It doesn't alter the fact that all we're actually talking about here is a plaque with a few words of remembrance written on it, not some engineered scenario or the first stage in an ever escalating series of events.

If any Evertonian wants to pause at the memorial and take the opportunity to pay respect to, or reminisce about, a fallen friend or family member, how on earth would that adversely effect someones experience of going the game?

If both Liverpool and Everton fans were to stop there briefly prior to the derby is it somehow going to sour the atmosphere? If anything it might serve to stifle some of the spite that's slowly crept it's way into the fixture over the past decade.

I simply don't see how such a gesture presents a problem and I certainly don't agree with your implication that it is a 'step too far'. If it means nothing to you then you can just stroll past and pay it no mind. It's not being forcibly rammed down your throat.

Dennis Stevens
145 Posted 29/03/2014 at 17:45:24
A few people have commented about a plaque being erected, I haven't seen anything officially stated this. Do we have any confirmation as to the form of this permanent memorial?
Paul Andrews
146 Posted 30/03/2014 at 11:56:39
The "Win it for the 96" campaign will start in the media next week.

Referee will be influenced in the City game played 2 days before the anniversary.

Simon Jones
147 Posted 01/04/2014 at 09:20:18
If Everton had played at Hillsborough instead of Villa Park on that day, then it might have been 96 dead Blues, the lies would have been about Everton fans, the cover-up would have been about Everton fans, the years of hurt would have been about Everton fans. It would be Everton fans lobbying the authorities to re-open inquiries, it would be Everton fans finally getting a chance to hear the whole truth 25 years later.

That is why I remember 96 ordinary football supporters, because it could have easily been my club that day and why I think the time is right for Everton to have a permanent memorial.

Andy Callan
148 Posted 02/04/2014 at 20:12:12
Where does this end....?!?!?!?!

Where is the memorial for Hysel, Munich, Bradford or Celtic?

People seem to forget those for some reason....

While I agree that Hillsborough was a tragedy and those killed were the innocent ones, but I think we should let that shower get on with it and leave well alone.

Phil Sammon
149 Posted 03/04/2014 at 23:40:34
So the inquest is underway...again.

Why on earth have the first days been spent poring over the life stories of the individuals sadly lost? This is an inquest, not a commemoration. This is what drives me mad about the whole thing. BBC headline: 'Disaster Robbed Children Of Fathers'...as though this is some sort of revelation. Can they please just get to the bloody facts rather than trying to pull on the already stretched heart-strings.

John Schrempft
150 Posted 04/04/2014 at 10:54:49
Agree 100% with #693 and #885.

The debate about Heysel is NOT pointless. That was just as much a tragedy as Hillsborough, so why no memorial to the Italian fans?

Heysel ensured that all English "fans" were tarred with the same brush and their reputation was made even worse. Hence the ban on ALL English clubs to play in Europe for 5 years,

LFC, with their dominance in the media, will milk Hillsborough
for every last drop of sympathy from the rest of us (which they've started to do at the inquest), while conveniently choosing to forget what happened in Belgium. By all means have a memorial... but also for the other tragedies too.

A couple of days ago, after the PSG v Chelsea match, so-called Chelsea "fans" went on the rampage in the St Denis district of Paris causing considerable damage. No mention of that on the BBC though. When will the idiotic minority of so-called fans from the British Isles EVER learn?


Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads

© ToffeeWeb