Barton says Rooney has not improved

, 3 April, 44comments  |  Jump to most recent
Wayne Rooney has not improved as a player since leaving Everton for Manchester United 10 years ago, according to Joey Barton.

Barton posted on Twitter: “I would have to argue that he has not been better since he broke on the scene at Everton. For me that’s when he stopped developing or just afterwards.

“As I say, he is a top player. My favourite of the current bunch. Love watching him. Old school.”

» Read the full article at Football News Direct



Reader Comments (44)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Brian Williams
1 Posted 03/04/2014 at 16:17:41
I tend to agree to a certain extent.
Shane Corcoran
2 Posted 03/04/2014 at 16:22:18
Why is this lad's opinions deemed worthy of media attention.

I think he has progressed, so that's one each.

Richard Reeves
3 Posted 03/04/2014 at 16:53:49
At Everton he was able to dribble past players with close ball control. He always had a good shot on him and with his build he was never going to loose his strength but I thought he was going to go on to be a Best/Gazza type of player so I agree more with Brian.
Peter Bell
4 Posted 03/04/2014 at 17:11:49
Wayne Rooney played his best ever football when he first came on the scene at Everton. Everything was totally spontaneous and it was excitement not knowing what he would do next. He has now been coached into a typical English footballer, running himself into the ground, with no definitive position and often looking tired. He does not get you off your seat any more.
Patrick Murphy
5 Posted 03/04/2014 at 17:26:24
His goalscoring record tends to undermine Joey's opinion - he may not have matched the all-time great European players but he is right up there with.the best of them. People often say that the Kings Dock was BK's greatest error but losing Wayne has to be one of the biggest errors in the history of Everton FC.

I know his agent was a greedy so and so and the club wasn't in the right state to be able to keep him - but the club would have qualified for Europe more often if he had have stayed and we would probably have had a bit of silverware in the cupboard if we could have kept him.

That myth about DM not getting along with Wayne doesn't seem to ring true as recently the lad has pulled his guts out to keep his boss in a job - obviously the ridiculous wages help.

But Wayne is in my opinion one of the best ever English players and although he could maybe have been better there are not many who are fit to lace his boots.

Michael Winstanley
6 Posted 03/04/2014 at 17:34:50
Ronaldo or Rooney?

Not difficult is it.

Tony Doran
7 Posted 03/04/2014 at 17:33:38
Over all he is nowhere near the same player. There is certain things he can do better which only come with age and maturity like heading and knowing when to pass. But there's part of the problem, all his natural instinct and directiveness has been coached out of him. In another league that wasn't marketed like the EPL he wouldn't be getting any attention like he does, certainly not on £300K a week. He was streets above Ronaldo and Bale as a youngster but look how they have blossomed. Possibly only Messi has always been better. He used to play street togger, now he's a team player.
Peter Bell
8 Posted 03/04/2014 at 17:43:01
Patrick, OFM was put in place to deliberately fall out with the kid and unsettle him. Who recommendedOFM to our board, yes, our former manager, who is best friends with who, yes, SAF, who was after WR since he was a kid.
Peter Bell
9 Posted 03/04/2014 at 17:46:59
And OFM was given his dream job ten years later as promised and is doing well by all accounts
Harold Matthews
10 Posted 03/04/2014 at 17:54:28
Moyes takes over a thread again.
Patrick Murphy
11 Posted 03/04/2014 at 18:02:01
Harold I think is only right to point out the shenanigans that surrounded Wayne Rooney' departure to Old Trafford and whether or not David Moyes was directly or indirectly responsible for it is obviously open to question' some think that the Glasgow football mafia played a huge part and whatever and whoever was involved Everton FC was ripped off good style - and we lost a player who we will never see the likes of again and for the fans that is the shame of it.

Mike Gaynes
12 Posted 03/04/2014 at 18:07:00
Joey.

Barton.

Not many players whose opinions would be less worthy of discussion.

Wayne Smyth
13 Posted 03/04/2014 at 18:05:36
Barton's opinion is probably quite close to the truth, whatever you think of the man himself. When people start criticising the messenger you know there is truth there.

Rooney hasn't fulfilled his potential compared to his peers. If you had a choice of any 10 strikers in the world today, he'd be lucky to get a spot, and I agree with Peter Bell that it is largely to do with how he's been played by Utd over the years probably combined with a poor professional attitude.

And I don't think the club made a mistake in selling him. Not only did he not want to play for us, but the money he brought in was used to buy players like Arteta and improve the squad.

Selling your outstanding talent to buy 3-4 is generally not a bad thing when those 3-4 improve the squad more than the 1 you let go, so it tends to depend on how low a base you're starting from in terms of squad depth and quality.

Graham Mockford
14 Posted 03/04/2014 at 18:33:07
I agree with Barton's sentiment. At 18 during Euro 2004 he looked like he had the potential to be one of the very best ever.

As it turns out he's only become one of the best English players of his generation. For some that makes him as a failure but that is more about the expectation rather than his actual achievements.

He will end up as England's top ever goalscorer, Man Utd's top ever goalscorer and a trophy cabinet that very few will ever be able to compare to.

My old feller always used to say to me when we argue who was the best player between us, 'show me your medal son', in reference to winning the Liverpool Sunday amateur league title.

The record books very rarely lie over a career.

As for Barton I have to admit a sneaking regard. Yes he was a fuckwit for many years, and he's never that far away from another meltdown but reading his stuff he can be remarkably insightful, is actually quite self aware and in this age of PR bollocks and inane 'take each game as it comes' drivel is always prepared to say what he thinks which is actually quite refreshing.

Bobby Thomas
15 Posted 03/04/2014 at 19:08:57
Regarding Rooney, absurd to say he hasnt progressed, he developed into a top European footballer, although for me hes levelled out since about 2010 ish, round about the season he knocked in 34 by March playing main striker.

Before that he would have to play second fiddle to Ronaldo at United, and theres no shame in that.

However I think he got coached into much more of a team player at United and the edges got knocked off him. Now that hes to happen to every player, they have to play to the team ethic as Mourinho has did with Joe Cole and now Hazard, very individual players who he has disciplined into the structure of the team.

With Rooney though he came through as a dribbling, swaggering player & those traits went. He rarely if ever beats anyone now, been that way for years and the burst seems to have gone out of his game. Plus he never developed the left hand side of his game in terms of running at people or shooting. It would have helped his unpredictability as hes virtually all right foot and checks inside all the time.

Hes 28, has a lot of miles on the clock and will only get deeper now. Im not expecting big things in the world cup. Long season, were not great shakes and I think hes had his peak years.

Dont get me wrong he turned into a brilliant player and his goals, assists his passing is/was all there. He just didnt turn into quite what I thought he would be. He isn't worth the contract but they almost had to the way things are there at the minute.

From a footballing point of view he should have moved to Chelsea, it would have been a chance to progress and I think hes stopped progressing, he'd have improved there.

Colin Glassar
16 Posted 03/04/2014 at 19:30:12
By now, he should be one of the best top five players in the world. He’s good but he might just make my top 20 right now.
Chris Corn
17 Posted 03/04/2014 at 20:19:40
The bottom line is he has a full set of club medals and is the 3rd highest goal scorer in Utd's history, therefore he is a Utd legend and one of the best footballers this country has produced. Not a bad legacy really.

I remember people saying all this" he's not as good as we thought he'd be" about Ryan Giggs about 10-12 yrs ago.

I'm just glad I got to see Rooney in a blue shirt and I'd have him back tomorrow.

Joey Barton's opinion is neither here nor there and his legacy is a faux accent, a jail sentence and stubbing cigars out on young kids eyes. Says it all really.

Roger Helm
18 Posted 03/04/2014 at 20:36:40
Rooney is the type of player who matures physically very early - at 14 or 15 he was built like a man (I heard he could have played in our first team at that age were it not for some law prohibiting boys playing with adults - don't quote me on that). So to maintain his career so long is an achievement, and it is no wonder he is not as explosive as he was then. Considering his talent and the state of our club back then, I think he had to leave. A footballer's career is about caps, money and medals, so it was a no-brainer to go to Old Trafford.
Jackie Barry
19 Posted 03/04/2014 at 20:44:25
He progressed in terms of winning things but I do not find him as exciting, for me he became somewhat tamed after he moved to United. Still he made the decision and that is that.
David Hallwood
20 Posted 03/04/2014 at 20:36:59
I'd have him back tomorrow Chris (#853) but that's not the point of Le Zoey Bar-ton's tweet. The fact is that Rooney although a very fine player hasn't turned into a Shearer let alone Maradonna/Ronaldo/Messi et al.

Would Rooney be in the world XI?-erm no, well how about the 2nd XI-no again, the 3rd? or 4th? possibly get into the 5th or 6th team, which to my mind is a great pity and as someone that had the privilege to see Rooney in a blue shirt and didn't blame him for leaving the club to further his career (because we were in a mess) I'm not bitter and twisted as some Evertonians are.

Chris Corn
21 Posted 03/04/2014 at 20:51:40
David, I'm sure there's no shame in not getting picked for your fantasy World 11 competition. However I am confident if you asked around the top pro's and managers when picking these teams, Rooney's name would be up there somewhere.

As for comparisons with Shearer, I will quote Graham Mockford and say 'show us your medals'. I take it you weren't watching that goal he scored against West Ham?

Having said that, it's a game of opinions and that is why we post on forums and they are multi-millionaires.

Peter Bell
23 Posted 03/04/2014 at 21:31:05
Chris, Phil Neville also has the full set of medals, and he ain't no Alan Shearer either. There has been some dross at Man Utd who were lucky to be there when all the medals were given out, the Nevilles being prime examples.
Winning medals doesn't make you a great player. Smicer won the CL with the RS which says it all.
Mark Frere
24 Posted 03/04/2014 at 21:31:13
Wayne (827)

The problem was, we sold Rooney for way less than he was actually worth. And initially, we signed some appalling players with the money:

James Beattie
Per Krøldrup
Simon Davies
Andy van der Meyde

Add the fact we sold Gravesen 6 months later... it's fair to say, we fucked up big time!

Shane Corcoran
25 Posted 03/04/2014 at 21:39:44
Peter Bell, there are a lot of OFMs in your posts.

What is it you're saying?

James Stewart
27 Posted 03/04/2014 at 21:48:38
Let's not forget Barton said he was the best English midfielder around not so long ago. Rooney is top class end of story. He is odds on to be their all time leading goalscorer for Christ's sake. No mean feat. Shame he came up when he did as we didn't have a team to match him. Now it's different...
Raymond Fox
28 Posted 03/04/2014 at 22:00:14
Let's put it this way, Man Utd aren't paying him £300k a week for nothing.

What you get with Rooney is a player that gives 100% for the team, maybe too much for his own good.

He has been for a long while and still is England's best player.

Alex Trevalyn
29 Posted 03/04/2014 at 22:43:08
He was like a delicate bull in a china shop.. If that makes sense..
Tom Dodds
32 Posted 03/04/2014 at 23:51:50
George Best was the difference between brilliance and genius.
Rooney going to United was a reversal of that equation.
Nick Entwistle
33 Posted 04/04/2014 at 00:23:37
Barton is a strange one. I think he's been eying a media role after his playing days for years. All the tweetering of philosophy... which I could do, just give me five seconds on google... and a tweeter account... and when you watch him with this interview, I think he's got a Bob Dillon t-shirt on in front of a copy of a Renoir. At least I think it's a Renoir. What's he trying to prove?
Patrick Murphy
34 Posted 04/04/2014 at 00:42:20
Did you mean this Bob Dillon Nick? "The latest from Bob Dillon (@ideaguy42). Learner, Leader, Dreamer, Pursuer of Happiness, Arsenal Fan, Dad. Saint Louis Missouri" or did you mean the Bob Dylan
David Hallwood
35 Posted 04/04/2014 at 00:40:33
Chris Corn(#861) It wasn't my fantasy team Rooney wasn't in, it was the FIFA team of the year that's chosen by over 5,000 pro footballers. The team was:

Manuel Neuer,

Dani Alves, Thiago Silva, Sergio Ramos, Philipp Lahm,

Franck Ribery, Xavi Hernandez, Andres Iniesta,

Lionel Messi, Zlatan Ibrahimovic, Cristiano Ronaldo

Not a Rooney or a Brit in sight.

Patrick Murphy
36 Posted 04/04/2014 at 00:45:20
Tom #887 That's because Wayne sold his soul to the Devils.
Steven Telford
37 Posted 04/04/2014 at 00:47:49
Maybe I'm dreaming, but I would love to feel its true that scoring for united never gave him the same joy as what he got from scoring for us.

What might have been..................

Phil Bellis
38 Posted 04/04/2014 at 01:26:00
When I first saw Rooney at 15, I thought he was going to be a Cruyff, Eusebio, Maradona, Zidane; even – Jesus wept – a Pele
Whatever the grassy knoll theories are, the bottom line is he was one of us and left to be a big fish in a big pond.

He ended up, at various times, instead of the best player in the world, the best or second best player in Manchester.

What a waste: great player, possible Everton post-war legend, chose (or Stetfordised) to give it up and become a Manc mercenary.

Never to be welcomed into the Gwladys St Hall of Fame – certainly doesn't give a toss.

Paul Holmes
39 Posted 04/04/2014 at 02:44:00
Rooney was the best he has ever been when he played for us (mostly on the bench under Dour Davy), and for England in the Euros. He terrorised teams in the Euros, especially France, and was doing the same against Portugal until their defender stood on his foot (on purpose) and broke his metatarsal.

He was the leading goalscorer in the tournament until then and he frightened the life out of the opposition. He was a one-man forward line (like Suarez is now), he had pace power and could score. Now, he is just a team player and his individuality has gone, unlike Suarez and Ronaldo.

Jim Harrison
40 Posted 04/04/2014 at 03:05:11
I think its kind of a fair point. He used to electrify games, now he puts in good performances and scores fairly consistently, but rarely hits top top level like Bale, Ronaldo or Messi. Years back he hit one of the best goals I have seen, against Newcastle, he was arguing with the ref, ref jogs off, ball bounces towards Rooney, Rooney runs up and hammers it on the volley from fully 25 yards. And swaggered off.
Anto Byrne
41 Posted 04/04/2014 at 08:16:26
Barton aint fit to lace his boots.
Tony Abrahams
42 Posted 04/04/2014 at 09:00:23
I still remember a 17-year-old Rooney's performance against Bolton and regard it as the finest outfield performance I have ever seen off an Everton player. He used to want to take them on by himself until he went to Man Utd, where it was all about the team. I think that's what Barton was maybe alluding to.

Rooney, whilst undoubtedly a great player, lost a lot of his individuality when he left Everton and therefore never became the great most of us thought that he could become. Nothing wrong with coaching, as some people have said, but maybe the coaching in England is just too methodical and Rooney has maybe sacrificed too much of his individual brilliance for the team?

Ian Tunstead
43 Posted 04/04/2014 at 09:10:13
The day Rooney left Everton was the day his progression stalled and then slowly regressed. He was brilliant at Everton, I have never seen anything like him. I have seen clips of Pele and Maradona when they were young but, for me, Rooney was the best 16/17-year-old there has ever been.

Everton were an awful team when we had him, so he was always going to struggle to score goals for us but, when put in a team of quality players with England, he was an even bigger star and was head and shoulders above everyone on the field, including the opposition, even pirouetting around the likes of Zidane and brushing aside the likes of Lilian Thuram, Veira and Makelele. He hardly ever dominates when he plays for England now.

His last Everton-standard performance was his debut for Man Utd in the Champions League when he scored a hat-trick, it has been down hill ever since... but he just has better players around him, which is why he scores more goals. He should be up there with Messi, Ronaldo, Pele and Maradona; instead, he's in the bracket of Lampard, Shearer and maybe one day Charlton.

For me he sold out and lost his hunger, fight and desire, his heart is no longer in the game because it doesn't mean as much to him. When you chose money over what you love, I think you lose that bit of magic.

Paul Kelly
44 Posted 04/04/2014 at 17:46:27
All I’ll say is £26m was a fucking disgrace. TGT and Bullshitter Bill should’ve walked and never looked back. The same will happen with Barkley if he has a good World Cup.
Ian McDowell
45 Posted 04/04/2014 at 18:16:52
Tony 931, Spot on I was there that day what a performance.
Andy Meighan
46 Posted 04/04/2014 at 21:33:13
Bobby (#843), why would anyone move to Chelsea from a footballing point of view? Chelsea are absolutely shite to watch and – as my old grandad said – if they were playing in my garden, I’d close the blinds.

He’s right: Rooney is a fantastic talent and he’s aided by the amount of years he’s been a full England international. That lad was and still is one of the greatest talents I’ve ever witnessed and will continue to be so. Don’t forget where he came from.

Phil Bellis
47 Posted 05/04/2014 at 01:09:29
Anto Byrne (920) That's not the point

Ian Tunstead (932) Absolute bollocks! - you can't have seen enough clips of young Pele
(ToffeeWeb protocol disclaimer: you are fully entitled to you ill-informed opinion, though)

Ian Tunstead
48 Posted 05/04/2014 at 02:36:33
Phil, I take it you've seen enough clips to know it's absolute bollocks? Or where you there to witness every performance of a 17-year-old Pele live?

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads

© ToffeeWeb