Martin Samuel says he's not anti-Everton

, 10 April, 99comments  |  Jump to most recent
Martin Samuel tries to set the record straight regarding his bandwagon campaign against the loan system, which he makes clear is not against Everton: "People thinking I had a pop at their club. Everybody. So, for the last time: I like Everton, I want Everton to do well. I don't like the loan system. I think we would be better off without it. Oh, what the hell.

» Read the full article at Daily Mail



Reader Comments (99)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Nicholas Page
1 Posted 10/04/2014 at 11:34:23
Martinez has also commented on the loan system today and especially on that massive snide Wenger.
Conn Prosser
2 Posted 10/04/2014 at 13:20:58
Nick Page (186), I know this is not a forum for loan system debate, but what a knob Martin Samuel is? I just don't see how us loaning players or selling our players at usually really high values to rich clubs is of detriment.

There's cash at the top and it trickles down. Very Thatcherite I know but Everton get to play great players because there is millions in the league in general. Happy days.

Tony J Williams
3 Posted 10/04/2014 at 13:56:06
I have read his follow up article where he responds to various responses.

Of course being the gobshite journo he has picked the best ones to reiterate his points.

Seems to have left out the ones that bring his attention to the other teams amount of loanees and asking why he is concentrating on Everton.

The bellend also uses an article from 2003 to say and suggest he has been campaigning against the loan system for over 10 years........ why wait for 11 years to bring out another article.

Effing bellend!

Jamie Yates
4 Posted 10/04/2014 at 15:11:49
I think Kenwright should sue the fat blert for libel.
Alex Bonnar
5 Posted 10/04/2014 at 15:11:01
One thing I would amend in the loan system is to stop loaning clubs from forbidding their player to play against them. If you are a lonee, you should be able to be used in any way and in any game — including against the loaning club. If you cannot, then that is unfair to all the other clubs.
Tim Locke
6 Posted 10/04/2014 at 15:33:21
Alex - its not the clubs who prevent it, it is the system itself. So used to be you couldn't loan to same division, but that was lifted, but you can't play against your parent club. I would presume just in case you tried to cheat.

Tony - spot on chap, if Martin wanted to follow up, he should have done it last year when Watford hard half of Italy on loan to them. The bottom line is no rules have been broken, a fair number of clubs have benefited from the loan system over the years, not just English ones, and it allows money to flow within the game.

If you stopped loans then one of two things would happen, rich clubs would buy and keep players, which would slow player development down. Big clubs wouldn't buy plays, this would reduce demand, which means lower league clubs wouldn't get as much money for players which would be more could go under. The loan system allows bigger clubs to buy good players, loan them out, such as Del Boy, watch them develop, if they look good get them back, such as Barkley, if they don't look up to speck then they can be sold. The club will normally recover it's outlay, and wages, so it is a risk(ish) free way of player development.

People may not like it, but I would like to see the solution and if people think rich clubs wouldn't buy good players, just in case, then they are being naive, just look at Man City and Tottenham, they have countless numbers of bench warmers and that is with the loan system in place.

Brian Harrison
7 Posted 10/04/2014 at 15:52:54
Although we have done brilliantly out of the loan system this year, I personally don't think it is right. Let's state that we haven't broken any rules and along with a lot of clubs in the Premier League have used the loan system, just seems as RM has been the best at using this system.

A system that allows Chelsea to buy and then loan out 24 players is just wrong; they are abusing the system they have decided that these players aren't ready for the Chelsea squad so hire them out till they are ready. So, although they have to find the money to buy these players, by and large their wages are paid by the club loaning the player.

The other abuse is when Darren Ferguson was allowed to loan players from Man Utd, to help them gain a false position in the league.

Carl Sanderson
8 Posted 10/04/2014 at 16:29:58
Martin Samuel likes Everton. He wants us to do well. Thank goodness for that. I was beginning to worry, there.
Fran Mitchell
9 Posted 10/04/2014 at 16:22:00
The loan system is a crock of shit.

Take away the loan system:

If Deulofeu stayed at Barca, he’d never play so he’d leave, and due to his age would not cost a fortune. But with loan system, Barça can loan til he’s good enough, then either sell him for a massive fee or reap rewards of loan clubs coaching and development. Loanee clubs are back to square one.

Lukaku signs for £17 million, Chelsea know they can loan him til they need him and his value won’t drop, in fact Chelsea can loan him and the loan fees may eventually cover the transfer fee. Otherwise, Lukaku may stay at his club in Belgium and help them in Europe or sign for a mid-level team who will play him straight away, maybe they can push for Europe or make a profit when they sell him.

Barry is on a massive wage, but Man City know they can loan him so no probs signing another defensive midfielder (or 5).

Look around the place, top clubs have players who they otherwise wouldn’t if the loan system wasn’t in place. Meaning smaller clubs don’t have players they otherwise would.

I’d call for an end to the loan system with a maximum squad number, something like 25 or 26 players (on professional contracts). This way, a club can’t stockpile youth players from smaller clubs, (including us... lads like Garbutt, Lundstram etc could all be regular starters at lower league clubs and maybe get the move; as it is, they’re in no man’s land).

It could also help reduce wages and agents’ power.

Michael Kenrick
10 Posted 10/04/2014 at 16:42:26
Fran, I think you're spot-on.

And isn't that what Samuel is saying? It's an interesting object lesson in 'confirmation bias' that, (apparently) because he's fat and writing in the Daily Mail, he can't possibly be saying anything meaningful, and that by bringing it up at all, he is being 'anti-Everton'.

Didn't the FA bring in rules a couple of years back, limiting Premier League squads to 25 players, of whom seven or eight must be 'homegrown'? There seems to be no reference ever made to those rules.

Michael Penley
11 Posted 10/04/2014 at 16:33:31
If loans are artificially skewing the table, then why not $37m purchases? Buying a player is just an extended loan anyway. No club really "owns" a player these days, and the only loyalty is to the highest paycheck. So why give a toss about Martin's notions of what constitutes valid property?

Player ownership isn't the issue anyway. I say bring back the focus to the teams, not the players. What we should do is end all in-season transfers and then judge clubs on what really matters – their season performance with a settled and fixed squad of players. A fluctuating pool of mercenaries-for-hire isn't really a team anyway, and it's far more entertaining to watch a squad whose integrity, passion and team spirit wins them titles over their rich rivals who thought they could buy success (Spurs $100m anyone?).

Lukaku, Barry and Deulofeu are all part of the Everton 13-14 team and that's all that matters. Where they were before and where they will be after doesn't mean a thing.

Tony J Williams
12 Posted 10/04/2014 at 17:08:11
Michael, he may well have a point but as already asked, why wait until this year to reinstate his 11-year crusade against loans?

He has specifically chose us to use as an example, of course we are going to get our backs up and let him have it. Any valid points are lost by the tone of his piece and his response article was just as bad. Using selected comments and then trying to sound all superior in responding to them.

Patrick Murphy
13 Posted 10/04/2014 at 17:21:12
Jamie #209 I think you are right - fancy Samuel using Rich owner and Bill Kenwright in the same sentence - get the lawyers in Billy.
Steavey Buckley
14 Posted 10/04/2014 at 17:22:41
The loan system masks the underlining problem of finding inexpensive and very talented young players. Who could be found if Everton focus more on European young talented players, than home grown. And I will be very interested to find out at end of the season what young home grown players are released.
Fran Mitchell
15 Posted 10/04/2014 at 17:28:21
#222 " Buying a player is just an extended loan anyway. No club really "owns" a player these days, and the only loyalty is to the highest paycheck. So why give a toss about Martin’s notions of what constitutes valid property?"

Not when you look at the club in business terms. For example, most clubs live with debt, this is normal. However, Everton can’t extent our debt, the banks will not loan us money so our scope in the transfer market, stadium development etc is solely limited to our income (transfers and Sky). This also results in myopic decisions such as the sale of finch farm.

Big clubs however can loan as much as they want, as they have young, saleable assets to guarantee the loan.

So yes, it ain’t Martin’s notion of valid property that matters, that is true, but the banks’ notion of valid property does matter.

Craig Whitham
16 Posted 10/04/2014 at 17:20:45
I actually find his follow-up more odious than his original article. His retorts by citing points he omitted in his original article (i.e. player stockpiling) is just a cheap way to try and argue against people who for obvious reasons, didn't feature them in their responses. As with others, it's the timing that made it such an obvious attempt to bait us. We put out virtually the identical team when Arsenal knocked us out of the FA Cup, but evidently our loans weren't worth mentioning then.

This comment from Samuels basically sums him up...

I didn't actually use the word 'sham' anywhere in the column, and certainly not about Everton.

The heading of the article is: Everton fairytale has us hooked - shame it's built on £50m loan sham of Lukaku, Barry and Deulofeu (so Wenger's right to moan).

Mike Benjamin
17 Posted 10/04/2014 at 17:49:52
I think the only reason it is being raised so forceably now is because we are threatening to gate crash the top 4, in particular Arsenal.
James Stewart
18 Posted 10/04/2014 at 17:49:21
It's funny how it's only Everton who are seemingly benefiting from the loan system. What other way is a club without a sugar daddy supposed to operate? Not Martinez's fault he can loan better players than most. Sour grapes. The best players at most of the bottom teams in the EPLare loans.
Raymond Fox
19 Posted 10/04/2014 at 17:30:05
I think it's fair to say that we all recognise that the PL is not a fair competition. How can it be, when a few clubs have a team of players that have cost 10-20 times more than your average PL team!

From our point of view, loans are manna from heaven as far as increasing the quality of our team is concerned. They're only a short-term fix though, and I agree with the point that they can be seen as depriving our own young players from gaining experience.

Wenger was the one that started the loan debate; Samuel being a journalist was duty bound to pounce on the subject.

I don't believe he meant any malice with the article; he did go out of his way to praise all concerned at our club, while stating he has always been against the loan system.

Ray Roche
20 Posted 10/04/2014 at 18:13:20
I didn't think Samuels was or is anti-Everton. He makes some good points one of which is that the success Martinez has made of the loan system magnifies the effect. Like Samuels says, no-one would take much notice if it weren't working so well for us. It wouldn't matter which club had loaned the players, if they were using it as well as us then people are bound to take notice.

The loan system is flawed. A wage cap would work better, players would be more inclined to stay at a club where they were happy and help that club to success rather than be coerced into moving for more money for himself and, more likely, his agent.

Lyndon Lloyd
21 Posted 10/04/2014 at 18:28:03
The thrust of Samuel's original piece may have been valid but it was the judgemental and, frankly, infuriating dismissal of everything Martinez and Everton have achieved this season as "a sham" and attributing all of it to the success of three loan players. (Notice that he didn't mention Lacina Traore at all.)

He could have gone about it in a far less sensationalist and inflammatory manner (I know, it's the Mail – he's paid to be controversial) if he'd just tackled the issue in more objective terms. His sub-heading was that Wenger is right to moan when he could have signed all three players (he'd probably have had to buy Lukaku, rather than loan him) if he'd had the foresight.

John Crawley
22 Posted 10/04/2014 at 18:20:13
Michael (#221), I think Samuel's overall view on the loan system is correct. Who then are the real beneficiaries of it? Basically the big clubs such as Chelsea and Manchester City. That's were the main focus of his article should lie and to me its cowardly journalism to make Everton the main focus of your article. By all means go after the loan system, Mr Samuels, but have the courage of your convictions and focus on the likes of Chelsea and Man City who are the main problem here. Here for example are a list of players that Chelsea currently have on loan:-

JHON PIREZ
A tall, right-footed striker with good stamina, Jhon has recovered from a serious knee injury that kept him out for 10 months...

PATRICK BAMFORD
Patrick Bamford is an English striker currently in his first full season at the club.

STIPE PERICA
Stipe signed for Chelsea in August 2013, moving from NK Zadar in his native Croatia.

PATRICK VAN AANHOLT
Patrick van Aanholt is a Dutch left-back currently on-loan at Vitesse Arnhem.

LUCAS PIAZON
Lucas Piazon is a versatile Brazilian attacker...

RYAN BERTRAND
Born 5/8/89 in Southwark, London. Ryan is a fast, attacking left-back, converted from a winger...

GAËL KAKUTA
Gael Kakuta is a left-sided attacker currently on-loan at Vitesse Arnhem.

SAM HUTCHINSON
Sam Hutchinson is a defender who has been with Chelsea since the age of seven...

MARKO MARIN
Marko Marin's transfer from Werder Bremen was agreed in April 2012

JOSH MCEACHRAN
Josh McEachran is a technically-gifted midfielder, he is currently on-loan at Wigan Athletic.

ROMELU LUKAKU
Romelu Lukaku is a powerful striker who joined Chelsea from Anderlecht in August 2011.

VICTOR MOSES
Victor Moses signed from Wigan Athletic on 24 August 2012.

ORIOL ROMEU

KURT ZOUMA
Kurt Zouma signed from St. Etienne on the final day of the January 2013 transfer window...

CHRISTIAN ATSU
The transfer of Christian Atsu from FC Porto was completed on 1 September 2013.

MATEJ DELAC
Matej Delac was signed from Inter Zapresic in Croatia...

THORGAN HAZARD
Thorgan Hazard, younger brother of Eden, is an attacking midfielder who has represented Belgium at international level.

THIBAUT COURTOIS
Thibaut Courtois is a Belgian goalkeeper who has spent two seasons on loan spell at Atletico Madrid...

TODD KANE
Todd Kane is a very quick right-back, comfortable on the ball and tenacious in the tackle...

BILLY CLIFFORD
Billy Clifford can operate in a wide range of positions, but more often than not plays in midfield.

WALLACE
Wallace signed for Chelsea in the January 2013 transfer window, and was immediately loaned back to former club Fluminense until the end of the season.

KENNETH OMERUO
A tall, quick centre-back or right-back, Kenneth is a Nigerian international who has played for his country since Under-17s...

NATHANIEL CHALOBAH
Nathaniel Chalobah is equally adept playing in midfield or defence...

BERTRAND TRAORE
Bertrand Traore completed his move to Chelsea on 1 January 2014 following a successful trial spell with the Blues...

GEORGE SAVILLE
George Saville is a tough-tackling midfielder who was part of the first team squad for the 2012 pre-season tour of America.

ULISES DAVILA
Ulises Davila can play either as an attacking midfielder or a forward, he is currently on-loan at Cordoba in Spain.

MILAN LALKOVIC
Milan Lalkovic was born in Slovakia and can play either as a wide attacker or a central striker.

CRISTIAN CUEVAS
Cristian Cuevas joined from Chilean club O'Higgins in July 2013.

Eugene Ruane
23 Posted 10/04/2014 at 17:29:46
Not in the least interested in his arguments on loans.

The article and all his self-righteous, outraged huff-and-puff pieces along the lines - 'Loans, they really are appalling!' - are imo a murky the waters distraction.

The fat bell is interested in fair?

Fine, maybe he can show us his many campaigning pieces along the lines "The PL is a completely unfair and ultimately pointless competition if a few teams can outspend the rest by hundreds of millions" or "Chelsea/City bought their titles, they have nothing to celebrate" or "Financial inequality in the PL is a disgrace"

Didn't think so.

So fuck Mr moral outrage - he ignores the money that Chelsea/City etc throw at trophies and instead 'campaigns' against sides doing what they can (within the rules) to bridge the ludicrous unfair financial gap.

So fuck him (nb: and fuck the hate-filled, hateful, venal arse-wipe of a rag he works for).

Gerry Quinn
24 Posted 10/04/2014 at 19:11:41
Eugene, don't you like him then? Don't hold back - say what you mean, man
Jay Harris
25 Posted 10/04/2014 at 19:16:46
All this outrage has only come about because the Blues are starting to embarass the so called big clubs.

My opinion for what it is worth is that no club should be able to loan players to another club in the same division thus avoiding any claims of manipulation of the league.

Michael Edwards
26 Posted 10/04/2014 at 19:46:42
Is it coincidence that this is now being raised when we are now a threat to Arsenal's CL qualification?
Ian Dickson
27 Posted 10/04/2014 at 19:49:21
Spot on John Crawley, I do reckon Samuel believes what he is writing - but he should be attacking Chelsea and City instead of Everton. There are other journos out there, should we claim a CL place, really be up in arms and this will make for very interesting reading!! Bring it on!!!
Carl Sanderson
28 Posted 10/04/2014 at 20:11:36
Craig 230:

To be absolutely fair to the fat twat, the headline itself was almost certainly written by someone other than Samuel.

Gavin Ramejkis
29 Posted 10/04/2014 at 20:19:09
Quite amused by that arsehole Samuel coming out with the responses, each and every last one of them as worthless as the original article. Don't forget this is the same gobshite that had Baines sold to Man U as a done deal for £15m and his countless others selling other members of our team to Gollum so his claims of not being anti Everton are as shite as the responses.

Fuck them all and lets hope Martinez and the players can just quietly get on with it and worry about winning as many of our remaining games as we can.

Tim Locke
30 Posted 10/04/2014 at 20:08:25
Fran I am not sure I follow the logic of the argument that if you couldn't loan players out then clubs wouldn't stock pile. You argue that players wouldn't go to a club because they wouldn't play? So Del Boy wouldn't stay at Barca etc.

So let's say we scrap the loan system no club can loan out any player. We say clubs have to delacre a squd at the start of the season of 25-30 players and they can be selected. Everyone else is out in the cold.

So this will not prevent clubs buying players, it will not prevent them stock pilling them. So the argument then is why would you go to a club when you won't start?

So let's consider and example, I am 16, I am picked up by a local scout and asked to sign for Barca, why wouldn't I, I think I am good and this approach has only confirmed it. So I sign and go through their youth system. If then bara kept paying me why would I ever leave? No one would ever see me play if I didn't make the squad so I sit there, well paid but on the fringe.

If you consider a good player lets say Rodwell and a team like Man city come in for you. You think more money, better opportunity etc. it wouldn't cross your mind you wouldn't make their squad. So you leave and sit it out on the side, people forget about you, you lose sharpness and you never make the squad. Why would you leave? You get paid? You get to play football each week?

The bottom line is clubs want to win things, so they buy the best they can afford, does it matter if a player does not work out? Not really, in fact just removing a good player from your competitors might be a bigger blow than playing them yourself. Make other teams weak.

This is then combined with players thinking they are better then they are, so move thinking they will cut the mustard, and money. Ego and money make the world go round. So players will say they want first team football, but like Jonny at West Ham, they would rather sit on a bench or stand than play at a poor club and get pay less.

Get rid of the loan system and you destroy any chance of small (in money terms) clubs achieving anything substantial.

Colin Glassar
31 Posted 10/04/2014 at 20:36:18
Why doesn’t he mention Mascherano and Tevez who kept WHU in the Premier League illegally? Double standards Mr. Blobby?
Trevor Lynes
32 Posted 10/04/2014 at 20:24:20
The media throughout my time has always been heavily biased towards Manchester and London clubs because that is where it is based. Henry Rose always played down Everton and even Liverpool achievements and lauded the Busby babes even when we stuffed em at Old Trafford before the tragedy.

When these clubs buy all and sundry then sit them on the bench or put them in the reserves it is a way of stopping other clubs from using them.Surely that should be looked at before moaning about the loan system.Everton and Southampton are two teams who are producing youngsters who will be the future of our national side without spending obscene amounts of money on ready made stars.Surely the example we and others are setting must suit the FA supposed limits on using high money players from abroad.

It is precisely teams like ourselves who are regularly playing youngsters who would not get a game if they were owned by the 'big' 4 or 5 clubs, who should draw praise not brickbats from the media.

How can young players be developed if not by using the loan system.

IMO Everton are the best team in the league as they are pushing for Europe and winding up the money bag clubs without spending a fraction of what they spend on just two or three players.Man UTD will BUY their way out of trouble and will be back in Europe in the near future.Give Moyes the same money as he had at Everton and see how long that will take.It is very sour grapes from a fretting media who desperately want Man Utd to be cock of the walk and they cannot take us being ahead of them !! HaHaHa.

Adam Baig
33 Posted 10/04/2014 at 20:44:51
Eugene 244. Perfect summation.....
Steven Telford
34 Posted 10/04/2014 at 21:49:33
To consider that the team with the lowest net spend of all EPL teams has somehow circumvented (what the real meaning of) financial fair play is - is more than a touch ironic.
And if you add up the prospective vale of our loan players, its not even that much, just Lukaku at 20-odd million. Barry's age holds down his value, and Deufoleu, give his limited experience, would be around 8-10 million max.

WTF is financial fair play to Chelski and Man city, there the ones that take the piss.

Fran Mitchell
35 Posted 10/04/2014 at 22:10:43
Tim Locke: Can’t say I agree...Baxter left Everton to get first team footy, i’m sure there are many more who have. If Deulofeu was sat in Barca reserves at the moment and had no chance to play for them, I’d reckon he’d go cause he seems a lad who likes playing football.

Besides, what I propose is that a club has 25-30 players on full time contracts, no more. There can be a loophole for injury crises’ and the like, but beyond that, a strictly limited squad.

Therefore the talent has to spread out, other leagues like Scotland, France, Poland etc also improve the quality. Look at that list of players at Chelsea out on loan, couldn’t they do well at another club full time, staying for 2-3 years with 1 manager and learning from the same professionals, rather than a month at Oldham, then 2 at Shrewsbury, then 2 at Preston, then 1 at Bury etc etc etc.

Patrick Murphy
36 Posted 10/04/2014 at 22:29:26
Steven but it's not just Chelski and City is it? - how much have our neighbours, United and Spurs spent? Arsenal have still spent a fortune - not as much as the other four or five but significant sums nevertheless. It amuses me how United and Liverpool are somehow not seen as part of the problem when these type of discussions take place.
Robbie Muldoon
37 Posted 10/04/2014 at 22:39:20
The established order is feeling threatened. Get in there you Blue Boys!!!!
Derek Thomas
38 Posted 10/04/2014 at 23:23:51
We're double victims of our own relative success.

1) The Pavlovian responses of a large sections of the rs / sky media who leap in at the drop of a hat ( even if they have to use spellcheck on hat ) to spout the party line and reinforce the status quo may filter through to the powers that be, don't be surprised if the rules are 'amended '

2) the main beneficiaries, City and Chelsea ( to be honest said that was half the point of loaning out Lukaku ) have reap said benefit...but not as much as we did, which means we will be getting jack from them next season as we are starting to pose a problem they would rather do without.

It is to be hoped that Bobby is keeping one step ahead of them.

Some one some where will ( I hope ) be rueing the synergy of the whole loan / Martinez / Everton thing.

And ruminating along the lines of...'All we have done is awakened a sleeping giant and filled him with a terrible resolve'

Serves em right.

Mike Hughes
39 Posted 10/04/2014 at 23:49:46
Never heard of Martin Samuel. That's because he writes for the Daily Mail (or the Curtain-Twitcher's Daily). The only time I ever read it was on a flight somewhere when it was given away free.

Some years ago, one article outraged me so much that I sent them an "Angry From Wirral" email to the columnist Charles Sale (another fat, public school boy). It was a snide joke about LFC touring South Africa and completing a tour of Robben Island - the snide comment being a stereotypical one and a play on the word "Robben".

Now I hate LFC with a vengeance but the scumbag DM won't be read by me even if it's free. (OK, I know I've used quite a bit of stereotyping myself here but the DM can shove it.) It seems you can't say anything against any "group" these days due to political correctness but "Scousers" (I hate the word) are fair game.

I have the DM in the same category as Talk Sport. Utter shite.

Steve Ferns
40 Posted 11/04/2014 at 00:00:57
Please do not make the mistake everyone seems to have done with this article. Yes, it is in the Daily Mail, and appears to be bashing Everton, but actually read what's written.

I've read above, what about Watford three times. He wrote about Watford, there's a link to it. He's been consistent since 2003.

He's correct the piece is not anti-Everton, it's anti-loans. I think his arguments might not be entirely correct, but I think they have merit to them.

If we did away with the loan system then transfer fees would tumble and teams would have less players, meaning that we could afford these players that we are forced to loan.

The thing that he's not mentioned is the fees paid by Everton. We've paid at the very least a significant proportion of Barry's wages for the season. We've paid Chelsea somewhere between £2-3m just for the loan of Lukaku and then on top of that we have to pay his wages in full. I'm not sure about Traore, but I'd expect it's similar. Deulofeu is on some kind of pay-as-you-don't-play deal, a reverse of the norm. But everyone's quiet on this. The true cost of loans never seems to be discussed.

Harold Matthews
41 Posted 10/04/2014 at 22:27:08
Anything that helps us compete with the money mob is ok with me, and the greeneyed complaints of Samuel, Wenger and co heighten the pleasure.

What none of these guys appreciate is the foresight and man management skills of Roberto Martinez. How he quietly nursed Delboy along, with a view to using him to the full later on. How he saw Barry as the perfect experienced midfield tutor and partner for young McCarthy. How he swopped Anichebe for Lukaku, eased out Jelavic and played Naismith in his best position.

Of course, the most difficult task with loan players is getting them to give everything for the shirt when their minds might be lingering elsewhere. This, as we all know, is where Martinez excels. Unlike Moses across the park and and others in a similar position, our loanees are treated like VIPs right from the start. He even gave Delboy the prized number 10 shirt.

All we need now is for Traore to reappear with dynamite in his boots. Now that would be really something.

Gerry Quinn
42 Posted 11/04/2014 at 00:19:53
Cop this loan deal issue..........Atletico must pay Chelsea £5m if they want Thibaut Courtois to play against the Blues

http://www.dailystar.co.uk/sport/football/373835/Atletico-must-pay-Chelsea-5m-if-they-want-Thibaut-Courtois-to-play-against-the-Blues

Gerry Quinn
43 Posted 11/04/2014 at 00:20:46
Yes, I know it's only the Daily Star, but the headline popped up on News Now Everton website
Eugene McLoughlin
44 Posted 11/04/2014 at 01:08:15
I remember when Christophe Dugarry was on loan to Birmingham City... he was very influential in keeping them up that year so his argument about lukaku on loan to West Brom doesn't hold up the fat fuck of a snide journalist! !!!
Eric Myles
45 Posted 11/04/2014 at 01:30:43
Alex 210, so say we are playing Chelsea in the last game of the season and the winner takes the title, or the Cup Final whatever you prefer, and our loanee from Chelsea scores 2 own goals and they win?

Is that fair?

Jim Harrison
46 Posted 11/04/2014 at 02:28:51
I read his original article and the follow up. Essentially what he is saying is correct. The reason it focuses on Everton is because at the moment we are at the extreme end of the issue, potentially getting into the worlds most lucrative competition with a squad strongly supported by loans. He also highlights the issues of monied clubs hoarding players

The main issue I have with him is not his opinions on the loans system, its his inflated opinion of his own self worth. His responses to comments made by the public boarder on contemptuous

Matt Traynor
47 Posted 11/04/2014 at 04:12:29
Jamie Yates #209 "I think Kenwright should sue the fat blert for libel."

On what basis? Oh, he described him as a rich fan in the first article who'd put everything into the club...

Any lawyers on here? Can we get a kickstarter legal fund going?

Jackie Barry
48 Posted 11/04/2014 at 04:25:51
What he is saying may be correct my problem is the way he goes on you would think he has been writing about the issue for 10 or more years continuously! Oh wait he does, only problem is that he hasn't! The truth is he wouldn't be writing about the issue if it wasn't Everton. He got a backlash and then tried to make himself look like some kind of Everton fan, which he isn't, and interviewing BK back in goodness knows when does no make them friends.
David Ellis
49 Posted 11/04/2014 at 05:42:17
Mike Hughes 293 - you bemoan people taking pot shots at "scousers" but you yourself take a pot shot at "public school boys". Just like scousers there are good and bad uns amongst public school boys.
Peter Barry
50 Posted 11/04/2014 at 05:53:24
So Martin Samuel says his article was not anti Everton well thank God for that because the title of the article and the contents of the article most certainly were anti Everton and no amount of journalistic double speak and bullshit can change that.
Peter Warren
51 Posted 10/04/2014 at 22:57:40
Didn't read the article fully but wonder if he moaned about Liverpool loaning Moses and how has helped them be top of the league?

Wasn't Tevez from his beloved West Ham loaned too or was it more murky than that (even when at ManU) with nobody owning him but his agent? Is that mentioned?

What I did read is that our 3 main loan players would have cost £60m - what a load of bullshit - perhaps (& I still don't think so) now but no way at the beginning of the season. Fool

Matt Traynor
52 Posted 11/04/2014 at 06:37:13
David #307, and he says he lives/lived on the Wirral! Pffft...

(Backs out of the room slowly...)

Chris Matheson
53 Posted 11/04/2014 at 10:41:29
I didn't see Mr Samuel mention the fact that not one of the Arsenal starting 11 was British. A far bigger scandal than any number of loans.

I didn't see any mention of the problems with the massive and ever increasing financial disparities between the rich clubs and the rest. Nor a condemnation of the Champions League system that maintain this cartel.

There was no analysis of WHY Everton need to loan players rather than buying them. Just the usual media luvvy tripe about Bill Kenwright that sidesteps the real issues of gross mismanagement at the club.

As others here have said, there is an agenda to maintain the status quo. Note all the talk that "Arsenal have not won a trophy for nine years" - we are double that but no talk of our failings; note the the talk that "Arsenal have qualified for the Champions League for the last 16 years" as though the thought they might not do so this year is a bigger story than Everton actually getting there.

It will be good for football for Man Utd and Arsenal not to qualify. Sadly both may yet get in to the Europa League even if we do get 4th.

Mike Hughes
54 Posted 11/04/2014 at 11:00:06
David #307 - I did admit to using stereotyping before you highlighted it in your post. There is a bit of a difference, though, in audience / readership / impact. My broader point was against the stereotyping against "Scousers" by a specific public school boy (not all) just to even things up. Then again, it's hardly evening things up when the Daily Mail has a readership of several hundred thousand, is it?

Matt #313 - yes, I live on Wirral, Merseyside. Your point? The suggestion in your post seems to be that by living here I'm exceptionally wealthy as is everyone who lives here. You are, of course, correct. Just ask my servants if you can get past the security gates. (Well done for taking small-mindedness to new levels... :) )

Brian Denton
55 Posted 11/04/2014 at 11:52:55
I live on the Wirral but was born and brought up in Kirkby. Not sure where that leaves me!
Ian Burns
56 Posted 11/04/2014 at 11:36:33
When I was poor I used to wipe my arse on the Daily Mail and still would if I couldn't afford toilet paper.

Peter Scudamore summed it up perfectly when he said the unfortunate season Man Utd are having is damaging the brand.

This story is no different - Everton are damaging the brand, so they pick on the loan system to complain about it. How dare Everton gatecrash the beloved brand called the Premier League.

It is the word "loan" which is causing the confusion and argument. We are in fact "leasing" these players because we are making a payment for their services, it is not as though we are getting them for free. However, "loan" or "lease" it is all the same thing but the answer lies in the financial arrangement between the clubs and rules should be set by UEFA for such transactions.

I don't pretend to have the answer but if EFC purchased Lakuku for say £6m, Chelsea would have the right to buy him back for £3m at the end of the period. If they don't take up the option, the player belongs to EFC. At least there is a transparent transfer system in place; a financial commitment making the word "loan" redundant.

There also needs to be a limit to the number of players any single club can have on its pay roll, this would help.

Only my thoughts.

Mike Hughes
57 Posted 11/04/2014 at 12:06:20
Brian #348- I live on the Wirral but was born in Walton and brought up in Bootle and Walton. According to Matt Traynor that now puts us firmly in the fox-hunting, tweed-wearing toff(ee) section. Beyond stupidity.

(Anyway, just off to check on things in the wine cellar ..... :))

Paul Tran
58 Posted 11/04/2014 at 13:16:43
Blimey, this thread is turning into a Crosby exiles reunion! Is this the right time to say that I'm ex-Manor High? Always remember chasing the St Mary's boys all the way to Hall Road Station.
Harold Matthews
59 Posted 11/04/2014 at 12:14:00
Yes Ian. I think we're all with you on the stockpiling issue. Unfortunately, it would be difficult to know where to draw the line. At one time this season we had practically the whole U21 side out on loan. Youngsters come and go but few make the top grade. It happens everywhere, including the lower leagues.
Jackie Barry
60 Posted 11/04/2014 at 13:46:33
And if you needed further proof of the Mail's agenda they have written another article today about our league position without loan signings. They are an absolute disgrace as far as I am concerned.
Gerry Quinn
62 Posted 11/04/2014 at 14:05:02
Bet you never caught me Paul (#359)!
James Stewart
63 Posted 11/04/2014 at 14:08:07
Quite right @338 I think that is a pretty disgusting stat to have on your cv. For a club of their size and resources to not have one British player in the entire team is wrong.
Ian Burns
64 Posted 11/04/2014 at 14:05:49
Harold 362. Yes, I agree it is difficult to know where to draw the line but a line must be drawn at some point on numbers, to bring the system back under control.

On the point of loans affecting our own your players, a system of purchase and buy back should be in place for all movements between the clubs, especially in the two top divisions. I suppose a loan system for players under a certain age could be utilised for the bottom 2 divisions so young players gain experience without causing alarm.

I am just throwing ideas into the wind because this article by Martin Samuel is so self-serving it makes my blood boil as did the comment by Scudamore about his precious brand!

Si Cooper
65 Posted 11/04/2014 at 14:13:07
This type of article needs to be published close season and not be reliant on the relative success of one club if it is intended to be genuine campaigning journalism, and not merely seeking to take advantage of simmering resentment and prejudice.

The timing (and perjorative headline) of the article cannot fail to smear Martinez's achievement this season in the eyes of many football followers (or worse, casual observers).

James Barr
66 Posted 11/04/2014 at 14:26:51
Got to say here that, although everyone is right about the tone of the piece, his argument would hurt the money teams more than us. If the loan system were outlawed and squads were limited to 25-30 players, people like Lukaku, Deulofeu, and Barry would have to find a place to go permanently. If anything, his argument, long term, actually helps us. Unfortunately for the author, the timing of the piece totally undermines his argument.
David Chait
67 Posted 11/04/2014 at 14:37:02
I'm jumping to the comments after reading Michael 221. EXACTLY. This was my point with the original article. Half jump on the headline when in fact he was complaining about stockpiling. I made the point that this inflates prices making it unaffordable for us to buy, which I notice the latest article says too.

Flip we can jump on that defensive victim horse as well as the rest of them.

I have tried to think of how this can be avoided. Very tough but here are some thoughts:

(1) basically no players should be allowed out on loan older than 21. So we can't get Barry but Man City would also be stuck with him and would have to delay buying his replacement for a year. Fair.

(2) No players under the age of 21 allowed out on loan unless they have been with the club for a certain number of years, say 5.

This means you can't buy a Lukaku and then just send him out. The loaned-out players need time on loan to develop but by being part of the club academy for a lengthy period shows the club has invested in that development and is not just leaving it to everyone else while they rake in the long term benefit eg Lukaku.

I actually think this might just work.

John Ford
68 Posted 11/04/2014 at 14:52:51
Can we not just give what money we have to the rich clubs, then wander into Stanley Park and bend over?
Colin Grierson
69 Posted 11/04/2014 at 15:36:29
Martin Samuel is a bell end of the highest order! When he walks into a room he thinks he is the cleverest and most important person there! I can't believe I've just wasted some keystrokes on him! Knob cheese!
Peter Laing
70 Posted 11/04/2014 at 16:24:29
Keystrokes Colin, more like vinegar strokes for Samuel he's that much of a wanker. Once had the misfortune of watching him on the Sunday supplement on Sky sports talking shite and looking like Dennis Roussos when he was trying to perfect the Georgie Best look.
Steve Pugh
71 Posted 11/04/2014 at 15:53:28
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/sport/football/article-2416860/Chelseas-Dutch-enclave-shows-transfer-market-like-cattle-market--Martin-Samuel.html

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/sport/article-2208564/Watford-snapshot-thats-wrong-modern-football-Martin-Samuel.html

Both articles by Martin Samuels, both criticising the loan system, both written within then last few years and neither about Everton.

Get your facts right before you slag the man off. His argument is that without the loan system Chelsea, City et al probably wouldn't buy all of these players because they couldn't loan them out, so the cost of buying players, and paying their wages, would be lower so a club like Everton could actually buy players like Lukaku and Barry rather than loan them. Makes a lot of sense if you ask me. Also reduces the chances of someone like Ross going to a Chelsea type club because he might end up in the reserves.

Jamie Tulacz
72 Posted 11/04/2014 at 20:50:35
Slight problem with the article's rationale (aside from the headline which clearly does slag us off and misrepresents the article which follows) is that it's not really the loan system that's distorting/inflating the market, it's the fact that a few clubs have multi-billionaire owners and can therefore afford to spend masses of money and not worry too much, whereas for most that's not possible.

I'm all set for Financial Fair Play to be an absolute farce as well, which further skews the system through dodgy accounting practices and FIFA's ham-fistedness and preferential treatment of the big clubs...

Paul Andrews
73 Posted 11/04/2014 at 22:10:58
Read the article and follow up earlier.

Mr Samuel is full of his own self importance.
Have a look at the Q and A section.

Comebacks to anyone who disagrees with him such as "would you like me to spell it out? In crayon if that is easier for you."

Sums the idiot and his condescending attitude up perfectly.

Eugene Ruane
74 Posted 11/04/2014 at 21:30:37
Steve Pugh (394) - "Get your facts right before you slag the man off. His argument is that without the loan system Chelsea, City et al probably wouldn't buy all of these players because they couldn't loan them out, so the cost of buying players, and paying their wages, would be lower so a club like Everton could actually buy players like Lukaku and Barry rather than loan them. Makes a lot of sense if you ask me. Also reduces the chances of someone like Ross going to a Chelsea type club because he might end up in the reserves"

I don't give a flying fuck what his 'argument' is, or for that matter what (re loans) you think 'makes a lot of sense.'

Any writer who GENUINELY gave a shit about 'fair' would see loans as simply a side-issue related to the REAL problem – the outrageous financial disparity between clubs in the PL – and would devote their campaigning to this.

It is an indisputable fact that every season, most of the teams in the league, including Everton, start at a FUCKING MASSIVE disadvantage to the teams that can buy players for £30/40/50 mill (and pay them £200,000k a week) and yet 'journalists' like Bluto say... absolutely fuck-all.

And because they say fuck all (no doubt to keep their freebies and perks) their opinions aren't worth a wank.

Arguing about the rights and wrongs of loans is imo absolutely being drawn into the kind of debate that suits this fat bar-room know-all, because it it avoids the REAL problem.

Martin Samuel is a lazy shit-house who (nb: like every other football writer in Britain) keeps quiet about the real and constant unfairness of the PL and instead manufactures shite like the above to deflect and to wind up supporters.

The loans argument to me is like someone going into hospital with some horrible disease and instead of the doctors concentrating on a cure, they stand around fighting over whether the sheets on the patient's bed should be nylon or a cotton-polyester mix.

Steve Pugh
75 Posted 11/04/2014 at 22:29:05
Eugene, so you totally agree with his article slating Chelasea for stockpiling young talent then.
Eugene Ruane
76 Posted 11/04/2014 at 22:35:35
Steve (441) - I couldn't be clearer

I see all arguments by journalists about fairness as deflection and bullshit as long as they continue ignoring the MOST unfair issue.

If the PL were constantly pressured by Samuel and his ilk to make the league fair, he/they would have my support.

But they're not pressured AT ALL.

Instead Samuels and his shit-house chums look for the smaller side issues (loans, bad refereeing, mind games, respect, bollocks blah blah).

Then they get all 'outraged' about the agenda they have set and... off we go for another season that will see title fought for by the sides who can massively outspend the rest.

(Not asking you to agree but what I'm saying is not complicated).

Si Cooper
78 Posted 11/04/2014 at 23:26:31
The timing of this article, the snidey headline, and the follow-up article with a 'corrected' league table make this poor journalism. Any casual observer will undoubtedly take away the sense that Everton are unfairly prospering from the current situation.

Tinkering with the loan system will not solve the problem which is caused by disproportionately wealthy clubs (far more so than when Everton were part of the big five) and greedy / stupid / badly advised players.

Until the whole situation is remedied then clubs like Everton should simply be applauded for redressing the balance somewhat, rather than having the way they have played the system held up for the sort of suggestive scrutiny and comment that Martin Samuel has indulged in (in spite of his pleading that he admires us).

This sort of article should have been left to the close season and talked about clubs in the most general of terms.

John Crawley
79 Posted 12/04/2014 at 00:06:00
I said earlier that it was cowardly journalism by Samuels and Eugene 445 has nailed it with his observation "Instead Samuels and his shit-house chums look for the smaller side issues."

And if you want some more proof of that here is Samuels in his own words:

"My personal belief is that the loan system is unnecessary and leads to stockpiling which advantages the elite clubs. I know, however, that the loan system is here to stay so it is pointless flogging that dead horse.

Financial fair play, another bad idea in its present form, is also not going away so instead of railing against it all the time, I now try to think up modifications or solutions to its obvious flaws."

Phil Sammon
80 Posted 12/04/2014 at 00:38:51
What I love about this site is how a so-called professional's article is dissected and pulled to pieces by folks in their dinner break. The sad thing is that 99% of the country see articles like Samuel's and probably agree with him due to the mass Sky 4 brainwashing programme.
Kevin Tully
81 Posted 12/04/2014 at 00:44:32
Can one of our friends from the US explain how they keep their version of football (or other sports) so competitive over there? I know they have have the draft system, but do they keep wages, squad numbers, youth players etc to set numbers?
Mike Hughes
82 Posted 12/04/2014 at 00:22:04
These media people - newspapers, TV and radio pundits - are all on the Premier League gravy train. They won't bite the hand that feeds them so they suck up as much as possible. I don't know anything about the "journo" who is the subject of this article but others are the same.

Alan Green probably can't stuff complimentary pies into his face (and possibly up his arse suppository-style) fast enough. Ditto the LFC pundit mafia and their "I scratch my back etc" everlasting career-fest.

Horse-faced, coke head Fowler has made so many PR gaffes (showing his arse to Le Saux in a moronic anti-gay stance based on Le Saux being a Guardian reader; naming his biography "God" when "Twat" would have been nearer the mark; having to apologise to women live on air for a derogatory comment) it can only be the Old Boys' Network keeping him going.

The Insipid Twins - Lawrensen and Hansen - revel in money-for- old-rope shite. Then little brother Owen comes along sucking on the teet. Oh and let's be multi-cultural by including our old buddy Dietmar Hamman. Then John "One Trick Pony" Barnes pops up from time to time as endearing and welcome as a dose of the shits.

Does anyone seriously think these toadies are going to rock the boat? They are so far up their own arses they probably believe they are regarded as national treasures. Mind you, listening to the phone-ins and the sycophantic comments ("you're doing a fantastic job, Alan" as if he's just administered CPR or something similar) makes me think the public are just as bad by lapping it up.

Anyway, I'm off to bed. And as for about the past 4 or 5 years, I won't be buying a newspaper any time soon - particularly the Daily Mail.

"Angry Of Wirral"

Jackie Barry
83 Posted 11/04/2014 at 14:30:34
Very funny, the Mail has taken one heck of a beating for their last article! People are really turning on them! LOL!
Kevin Tully
84 Posted 12/04/2014 at 01:01:21
Mike, can you imagine if someone took a few weeks out to compile an exhaustive list of ex-redshite, or redshite supporting pundits, jounrno's, editors etc in all media at home and abroad?

A scary thought indeed.

Mike Gaynes
85 Posted 12/04/2014 at 01:05:19
Kevin (458)... the US sports all have salary caps, usually total limits on what clubs can spend on salaries in a given year. Exceeding those caps triggers a punitive "luxury tax" that most owners don't want to pay. Somebody correct me if I'm wrong, but I believe top-level rugby in England has a salary cap.

The problem with projecting the idea onto the BPL or the European leagues is that the US salary caps were usually implemented amidst brutal labor battles between the players and the owners, often at the cost of lengthy strikes and lockouts. Hard to imagine the English league shutting down for half a season over the issue.

Kevin Tully
86 Posted 12/04/2014 at 01:14:27
Cheers Mike - it's great to see different teams contest the Super Bowl each season, is that down more to the draft system or the salary cap?
Raymond Fox
87 Posted 12/04/2014 at 00:58:09
Everyone knows that PL is not 'fair', at least everyone with half a brain knows.

The 'money clubs' are not shy about the advantage they have each season over the less rich clubs, so I wouldn't be getting too upset about this article.

Everton are the only ones to seriously challenge the status quo each season, and we should be extremely proud of the fact.

Mike Gaynes
88 Posted 12/04/2014 at 01:13:02
And to answer the second half of your question, all leagues have squad limits. In the NBA, if you don't have a roster slot for a player, you have to release him. Same in the NFL, although they are allowed to maintain limited "practice squads" for extra players. Baseball is the only major sport where you can stockpile young prospects and keep them in the minor leagues, but contracts are limited in such a way that after a few years you have to expose your minor leaguers to being drafted away by other teams.

The draft system varies in effectiveness by sport and team. Some organizations suck so bad they get top draft choices year after year and never get any better, and only in one sport -- basketball -- can a single draft choice, like a Michael Jordan, turn a franchise around completely.

Mike Gaynes
89 Posted 12/04/2014 at 01:20:43
Kevin (465), you could ignite an all-night debate in the bar on that topic and never get an answer. Likely it's both. Certainly the World Series and the Stanley Cup hockey finals always have different teams as well, and the days of the dynasty -- like the old New York Yankees -- are definitely gone forever.

Except perhaps in basketball, where as I say one player can make a huge difference. Like LeBron.

Phil Sammon
90 Posted 12/04/2014 at 01:27:41
The problem with the draft system, as I see it (from England), is that it rewards the worst teams with the best players. Could there be a situation at the end of a season where a team that cannot possibly achieve anything is actually better off throwing a few games just so they get first pick in the draft?

It also doesn't allow teams to build for the future. There's something special about a team developing a player from 10 years old and him eventually playing for the first team.

Kevin Tully
91 Posted 12/04/2014 at 01:26:26
Mike - another problem we would find trying to impose an American style draft system in football is the truly global nature of the game these days. Where most prospects are primarily scouted through your college system, clubs are sending scouts to Africa, or their academies have players from around 8 years of age. Maybe these academies are causing more of a problem than any other aspect if we think about it.
Kevin Tully
92 Posted 12/04/2014 at 01:40:18
Posted that before I read your post Phil. I think these academies may be doing more harm than good - if all clubs were forced to recruit from an excellent college type structure, maybe that would help every club instead of the stockpiling of talent by rich clubs we are witnessing?
Mike Gaynes
93 Posted 12/04/2014 at 01:36:32
Phil (469), teams "tanking" for better draft position has been known to happen, and fans always speculate on it, but professional pride usually takes precedence, plus players and coaches are playing for their own jobs and can be dumped for poor performance.

Also in the NBA, where one player can mean the world, they have a lottery for the top draft positions among the worst teams. So tanking doesn't really pay off that well and teams play to win. This year my team, the Chicago Bulls, lost their superstar to injury, and promptly traded their second-best player for nothing, triggering speculation that management was trying to fall into the draft lottery. Instead they actually improved and are now well into the top half of the league.

Regarding a player being developed from childhood to play for the first team, I know it's still common in South America... but in England, how often does it happen in today's world? How many current BPL players were groomed from childhood by their current teams?

Mike Gaynes
94 Posted 12/04/2014 at 01:48:54
Kevin (470), bang on target with your comment about the international issue. Bringing so many different nations and leagues in line with salary cap regulations would be impossible.

Not sure about the academy issue, however. American baseball teams run academies in the Dominican Republic (a veritable factory of young talent) and other Latin American nations, and compete for the signatures of teenaged prospects just like the big footy teams. It doesn't seem to do any harm to either the players or the leagues.

Chris Wilson
95 Posted 12/04/2014 at 01:51:02
A salary cap would generate some very interesting ideas. We would probably see more player-for-player swap deals rather than out and out purchases in order for teams to stay cap-compliant. There would be a huge increase in free-agents or Bosmans, which could go a long way towards leveling the playing field if you have the cap space to sign 3 or 4 good to great players. I'm not sure a draft would work within a league where a system of promotion and relegation exists. Would a draft be league-wide or only PL teams? Would relegated teams be involved or just established PL and promoted teams? Would it be British and Irish players exclusively for a draft, or could it be a world-wide selection process with players from North and South America, Asia, etc involved?

Unfortunately, Mr Scudamore revealed in his Man Utd comments that something like this would not happen. American sports love the parity. In the NFL, barring 3 or 4 teams; almost every fan base thinks they have a chance to go far in the playoffs. The FA is too concerned about their brand. Roster and salary restrictions could hamper English teams in the Champions League, and could conceivably create a nightmare scenario where Hull City and Stoke City are competing for the Championship on the last day. Would you REALLY tune in to watch that? If it hurts their pocket-book, it will not happen. Would be interesting though.

Tim Locke
96 Posted 12/04/2014 at 10:40:18
Fran - limit the number of players a club can have? You can't be serious? That is never a viable solution. Why stop there why not limit the size of stadium, the number of fans a club can have?

Limiting the number of players a club can hold professional contracts for is like saying to Tesco you are too big you can only have 2000 employees. So can how do you stop clubs stock pilling players?

You mention Baxter, that is a classic example of why the loan system would be good. Player things he is better than the club, leaves at the end of his contract and then spends months trying to get signed again, who signs him a club which he most likely would have been loaned to anyway! So now a small club has a player who they have a contract to pay, who may or may not perform for them and they still have to pay him. So higher risk of going bankrupt etc.

Tim Locke
97 Posted 12/04/2014 at 10:49:57
As an aside. First let's be clear about the loan system there are three systems one is form player development the other for player sales.

So player development, so Barkley, we had no intention of selling Barkley to Sheffield Wed, but we wanted him to experience competitive football. So Sheffield get the benefit of a player they could never attract, we get the benefit if the player growing. Sheffield might even get promotion or a decent cup run out if it, look at Crystal Place last year retaining Zaha. We as a club have benefited of this type of loan with Del Boy. I see nothing wrong with this, it means good players can help poorer teams, and it does not mean players can't end up staying, who is to say Del Boy wouldn't make the move over.

The second type of loan is what you might call a temp to perm role. This is typically a player who doesn't, for whatever reason, make it at his current club. So Barry, they are a good player but just not working out. Another club then has a chance to loan that player and see if they fit in, some players work better at some clubs, this is excellent. Both clubs benefit, the parent club has a reduced wage bill and the loaning club has a chance to review the player before buying with no real risk. Artea would be a good example of where this worked. I see nothing wrong with this, players and clubs both benefit and it can mean clubs have a low risk way of giving depth to their squad.

The third load would be best described as a fitness or friendship loan. So we have seen players from the USA come out of season to the prem, to keep up fitness, improve skills or because they have a history there. Out of the loan systems this would seem the most controversial. The player is not going to leave their parent club, has a high risk of getting injured and the people who normally benefit are those gaining the players. Although you could argue it is similar to the first type, I would argue it is not as this is additional football, and not needed by the player to gain first team football.

I personally don't see anything wrong with the loan system, it works well. As I have said about clubs will keep stock pilling players, if you have money then it is worth spending it to prevent others as much as create opportunity for yourself.

Peter Barry
100 Posted 14/04/2014 at 04:52:39
Martin Samuel is a 'meejah' whore and gobshite just like all those other 'meejah' gobshites who licked TGT's ass. They are now trying to change the goalposts because TGT has been revealed to be what many of us on TW knew he was a tactically inept, defensive one trick pony and a disrespectful liar and cheat to boot. Hence the pundits and other attacks on Everton disguised as criticism of the 'Loan' System. A system which EVERY club has access to but which Roberto has proved himself master of and that what gets right up their noses.
Brian Denton
101 Posted 14/04/2014 at 08:08:07
Tim Locke (513) if we continue to adopt the purely market-driven approach to football then what you will get is market outcomes ie bigger businesses getting ALL (not most of) the best players, providing high barriers to entry to competitors, forming cartels etc etc.

It is only because in the past we had 'artificial' barriers to the football free market (such as no freedom of contract, a 'gentleman's agreement' between BBC and ITV not to push competition for TV rights too far etc etc) that we had a diversity of successful clubs prior to the formation of the EPL. If we want to get that diversity back then the ONLY way is to dilute the free market by such things as squad limits and wage caps.

Anto Byrne
102 Posted 14/04/2014 at 10:28:22
Gee, we took a punt on Barry who at 33+ something and nearing the end of his playing days on a loan deal. That's good business because he could have been an absolute flop. Then we loaned a couple of kids, one who has never played in the Prem and another who was an impact sub at WBA. Fortunately, we got rid of Fellaini and got McCarthy, also great business. We also got cash for Big Vic and Jelavic, putting something like £25M in the bank.

At the beginning of the loan deals, these players would not have been worth £50M – not even to Wenger. Let's put a realistic number on them: say £20M at the start... but now, with a season at Everton, they are now collectively worth £50M+. Oh the benefit of hindsight and the astute managerial prowess that is Martinez.

If they decide to cancel the loan system, then they will just put them out on a buy-back agreement where theoretically no money will change hands. I hope we can secure the young Spanish whizz kid for another season and in the Champions League as well.

A couple of further additions in the summer to add a bit of creativity to the midfield with a playmaker and some cover for Coleman. It may well be time to move some players on. All will be revealed in the next episode of Martinez Street Blues.

Anto Byrne
103 Posted 14/04/2014 at 12:57:31
As we threaten the establishment of the top 4/5 money teams, I am thinking that we will be thwarted by the FA and another "Collina" outrage in the form of a Mariner or Clattenberg.

Last night, watching Man City and the RS, there were real claims for penalties and the Skrtel punch clearly using his arm to make the clearance has to take the biscuit. Then what about the wrestling and physical impediment, the City player was in a bear hug in the 6-yard box. Again play waived on.

I just thought there can’t be a shite game on without the usual penalty award. Of course, they had Clattenburg who tried to redeem himself with a straight red card at the end. It wasn’t two-footed, just a bit rash and, given what was on the line, a reasonable yellow-card challenge.


Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads

© ToffeeWeb