Why the Carping At Martinez's Success?

, 11 April, 10comments  |  Jump to most recent
A more balanced piece of commentary by Sarah Winterburn at the Football365 website asks: "Why does praise for Robero Martinez have to come with caveats about David Moyes's defence or the loan system? Is it just because he's proved us all wrong? Perhaps..."
[W]hile Everton supporters can revel in glory unexpected, some of those who are paid to know about football bitterly disparage their success simply because they did not know. It defies logic that a manager could so completely change a team's philosophy (in terms of both style and ambition) in such a short space of time. It defies logic so the aggrieved look for loopholes.

Some say he has merely built on Moyes's foundations of a solid defence as if that was a criticism, as if keeping the impressive elements of a team and making improvements elsewhere dilutes his impact; the same people don't stop to wonder why Moyes never attempted to make those same improvements himself if it was so damned easy.

Some say that borrowing players is somehow a shortcut, a cheat. They ask where Everton would be without the goals of Romelu Lukaku and the experience of Gareth Barry, as if they are the only ones to exploit a system that is available to every club, as if it takes no skill whatsoever to source, persuade and integrate a loan signing.

» Read the full article at Football365



Reader Comments (10)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Steve Guy
1 Posted 11/04/2014 at 16:46:58
Please forward this article to Samuels and all ex RS BBC pundits. I imagine part of the Team's success in recent games is that RM simply pins all the criticisms up on the dressing room wall and then challenges the lads to keep throwing it back in their detractors' faces.
Si Cooper
2 Posted 11/04/2014 at 20:00:05
The main problem with Samuel's article (apart from the timing and insulting headline) is that in his 'better' scenario Everton are reliant on home-grown and cheap alternatives for the loanees we have had this season.

Surely the whole point of his moral crusade is to release the stockpiled players and thus make players of that calibre affordable for the less well off clubs. We would still be reliant on an innovative and inspirational manager to attract the best of what is available in either 'reality'.

Questioning the success of Everton is not the same as exposing the inequities of the current system; you can easily (and rightly) do the latter without reference to any one team's supposed over-achievement.

Harold Matthews
3 Posted 11/04/2014 at 21:14:06
Wonderful article. This lady certainly knows the time of day. Unlike the bitter professional pundits who continue to show a very low level of intelligence.
Jamie Carroll
5 Posted 11/04/2014 at 23:19:48
A lot of pundits are now left with egg on their face with regards their worship of Moyes at Everton, they are now faced with either criticising Moyes at Man Utd or looking for other reasons why Everton have improved this season and are not struggling like they "predicted".
Paul Tran
6 Posted 12/04/2014 at 10:36:07
Last summer, the 'experts', who had staked their reputation on Moyes being a genius only handicapped by 'lack of money', almost to a man predicted that we would languish in the bottom half of the league.

This worked well for us, as this underestimation spread to the 'big' clubs who let us take Lukaku and Barry on loan.

Some journalists have spent much of this season making excuses for Moyes and are now actually writing what they are seeing Their frustration has spread to looking for reasons to crab what Martinez has done so far.

Big deal. We know he has taken a workmanlike, inconsistent team, made the defence stronger, done the 'impossible' by allowing professional footballers to pass the ball, given us shape, method, attacking options and results. And all on a profit, in his first season.

I hope the journalists keep crabbing him. It might be our best hope of keeping him here!

Tommy Coleman
7 Posted 12/04/2014 at 10:59:26
"It defies logic that a manager could so completely change a team's philosophy (in terms of both style and ambition) in such a short space of time. It defies logic so the aggrieved look for loopholes."

Phil W? Nick E?

Ernie Baywood
8 Posted 13/04/2014 at 02:47:09
I believe Samuel is now penning a piece complaining about the Sunderland win as the winning goal came from a player that we don't own.
Rob Halligan
9 Posted 13/04/2014 at 13:19:44
Well as the song goes:

"Roberto's got a dream
To build a football team
Got no money so signs his players on loan.
We build from the back
We're strong in attack
The school of science is on its way back.
Nar nar nar. Nar nar nar"

So shove that up your arse Samuels!!!!

Anto Byrne
10 Posted 13/04/2014 at 19:16:08
For eleven-odd seasons, we watched as our former manager created all sorts of milestones. Top 6 finishes, FA Cup Final and Semi-Final appearances. Champions League and Europa League football.

All this on absolutely no money other than a bit to fund the likes of Yakubu and Fellaini (£25M). In eleven seasons, we had this wonderful record of not getting 3 points at any of the big name clubs referred to as the Sky $4. Taking a team to Anfield and not registering a single shot on goal in the whole 94 minutes is almost inevitable.

Then, lo and behold, Man Utd snaffle our manager for zero compensation. He makes a derisory offer for Baines and the Big Fella that gets knocked back until Deadline Day when the Big Wig leaves.

Dennis Ng
11 Posted 13/04/2014 at 21:57:10
It is a nice piece proposing the right counter arguments to those haters in media trying to make their favorite Sky 4 team look better. Frankly, I've not heard much dig from non Sky 4 media or fans, in fact with some milder dark side fans providing encouragement. The main media we're used to reading are so filled with these clowns that they are able to make it seem like everyone is against us.

As many along with the article said, they definitely hate to be proven wrong. Perhaps they are trying to find reasons/excuses on why they are wrong. Perhaps they are fighting to keep their jobs, spewing nonsense that will only mean illogical direction for their teams. Perhaps they shouldn't be in their jobs to begin with? Perhaps all we need is that these media outlets overhaul their "brain" trust.


Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads

© ToffeeWeb