Howard: Treatment of Moyes was unfair

, 21 April, 74comments  |  Jump to most recent
Tim Howard has come to the defence of David Moyes after the former Everton manager was barracked by joyous Everton fans during Sunday's victory over Manchester United at Goodison Park.

Moyes's emergence from the tunnel prior to the match was met with boos from some Evertonians in response to the manner of his pursuit of Marouane Fellaini and Leighton Baines last summer and was the subject of mocking chants – presciently, they included an obligatory rendition of "sacked in the morning" – by the end as Everton ran out convincing 2-0 victors.

Howard, who was signed by Moyes in 2006, has labeled the treatment of his former manager as "unfair", though, citing the stability that the Scot brought to Goodison and his own experiences playing under him for seven years.

“That is unfair on him,” Howard said. “We have brilliant fans, but it's unfair. He was the second coming, the messiah 12 months ago, and I don't think as Evertonians we should ever forget that.

“He wouldn't want me feeling sorry for him. I love David Moyes. I think he is a brilliant manager. He was [a brilliant manager] here for us and I will be forever grateful.”

The American was pleased with the Blues' win, though, saying: “It was a good performance, another performance like the one against Arsenal. We got the goals and the clean sheet and we played it well from the back. I thought we did well.

“We had to absorb their pressure. They had a lot of possession. They have a lot of talented players. They over loaded the middle of the pitch and made it tough to get the ball off them but we were resilient and we adapted. We hit them on the counter. That is what the game called for.”

Quotes sourced from ESPN FC



Reader Comments (74)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


John Keating
1 Posted 21/04/2014 at 15:45:41
No sympathy from me at all. Howard should keep his trap shut !
Patrick Murphy
2 Posted 21/04/2014 at 15:49:36
Agreed John, seeing as Tim has just signed an extension to his contract his loyalty is to Everton FC and its supporters and not to his former boss; However, he is entitled to his own opinion.
Wayne Smyth
3 Posted 21/04/2014 at 15:50:37
As an aside, anyone think Coleman would make a better captain than Howard?

The guy is non-stop, all action, superb commitment from first minute to last. He is also one of our most gifted players in terms of ability. He does give the other players a rollocking too sometimes.

He may not have the footballing background, but his overall contribution is one that any of our players should look up to. I think to be a captain you need to have ability and your work-ethic needs to be top drawer. Someone who keeps going in all circumstances to set the standard. I think Coleman fits the bill perfectly.

John Keating
4 Posted 21/04/2014 at 15:57:30
Patrick I agree that Howard is entitled to his opinion but he has the luxury of mouthing off to the press/media which we don’t.

If he is such a brilliant passionate Evertonian why didn’t he further mention that he could understand some supporters being pissed off at Moyes for all the lies he gave us from the start of last season, never mind from Christmas on.

And the crap regarding Baines and Fellaini – short memory from the Lescott saga !

Yes let Tim Howard have his opinion but let him not try to rewrite history.

Steve Brown
5 Posted 21/04/2014 at 16:16:05
So John 026, basically you’re saying Howad can have his own opinion as long as it doesn’t upset you or clash with how you see the past?
Steve Brown
6 Posted 21/04/2014 at 16:19:53
It’s a free country, Howard can say what he likes.
Darryl Ritchie
7 Posted 21/04/2014 at 16:32:50
The way Timmy, and the players, see the sport, and the way we, the fans, do, is completely different. For them it’s a business, a paycheque. For us it’s a religion.
Phil Sammon
8 Posted 21/04/2014 at 16:25:52
If I had my way Tim Howard would be booed from now on. What a completely stupid comment from the man.

This was never about forgetting what Moyes did for us. We gave him the benefit of the doubt with regards to his contract stalling and the deal with Man Utd. We applauded and thanked him for his services at his final home game. We also paid the man a fortune...so I think we held up our end of the bargain, Tim.

If Moyes had have come back this year as Man Utd manager without the Baines/Fellaini saga then he would have been applauded again. I even believe he could have signed Fellaini AND Baines AND still have been afforded a grand reception had he gone about it in the right and proper way. All this crap about ’Everton don’t sell cheap’ then 12 months later he’s low-balling us and telling our new boss how he should run the club. It was disgraceful and he deserves every bit of abuse he gets.

If we had a reserve goalkeeper who could catch a football then I’d advocate putting him in.

Ray Roche
9 Posted 21/04/2014 at 16:47:05
Phil, booing Howard? As ridiculous as anything I’ve read on these pages. You’re not young Ross in a wig are you? (Not Barkley, Edwards.)
Phil Sammon
10 Posted 21/04/2014 at 16:55:37
Ray 048

Ha, no I’m not. I’m not serious about booing him either. I just think he’s talking crap.

Robin Cannon
11 Posted 21/04/2014 at 17:15:35
I think "Tim Howard has come out with a passionate defence..." isn’t really accurate. I doubt very much he just called up the press out of the blue.

It’s just a player trying to be diplomatic when he’s being quizzed on something he probably doesn’t want to answer.

Si Mar
12 Posted 21/04/2014 at 17:19:43
Why would you want to boo Tim Howard!!

He’s been our most consistent keeper since Martyn and in my opinion has been a great buy.

He expressed an opinion and that was all, Moyes was an excellent manager for us and I agree he let himself down with Baines/Fellaini etc but who got the better deal in the end, we end up with a better manager, Baines on a new long term deal and £27.5 million for a player who is a squad member at UTD and by all accounts (5.20pm on Monday) Moyes is getting sacked imminently!!!!

Lets move on and win our last 3 games, COYB!

James Martin
13 Posted 21/04/2014 at 17:22:14
I think the whole affair just makes us look small time and I think that is half of what Howard is getting at. Despite media twisting no Everton player has come out and said anything bad about Moyes. They all still like him and recognise what he did here. They all like Martinez too and are recognising that he is taking us forward. The fans have grasped the second part, why can’t we be dignified about the first.

Yesterday should have about this Everton team hunting down champions league football. Instead it seemed to be about getting one over Moyes. To other fans we just looked fickle and small time. There would have been nothing wrong with greeting him like any other manager at the beginning of the game and then sending him home packing after we won

Chris Stubbs
15 Posted 21/04/2014 at 17:13:09
I have no sympathy for Moyes. It looks like he is going to be sacked anyway. What gets me annoyed is the noise made about the number of our current players (Howard included) who were signed by Moyes and the fact that Martinez is benefitting from the Moyes legacy. It is true that Martinez inherited a good group of players, but he has added to it most effectively and has nurtured the raw talents of Barkley, Stones and Coleman.

Moyes inherited a title winning squad and seems to have alienated the players. This reminds me of when Brian Clough did the same when he became Leeds manager after Don Revie.

Cloughie bounced back after that. Moyes may find it difficult to do the same.

Mike Oates
16 Posted 21/04/2014 at 17:28:04
Hey lets grow up and move on. Moyes did a lot for this club and after 14-15 years of going nowhere he got us going again. He moved on to another club which at the time was light years ahead of us in all areas, board, finances, on the field success etc. He made a stupid low ball offer (maybe it was new CEO Woodward trying to prove a point ?) which we rightly said was derisory. End of, Martinez has come in and has demonstrated that there is another way and it looks like the UTD job is too big for Moyes . But anyone would think he has slated Everton repeatedly but he hasn’t. Grow up its a game of amateur spectators and professional players and management trying to do what’s right for them.
Tony J Williams
17 Posted 21/04/2014 at 17:36:02
Moyes probably saved his career so why wouldn’t he defend him?

Howard isn’t a fan like us and doesn’t have the illogical madness that comes with being an Evertonian, so he sees Moyes as an ex boss that did the best by him.

Not arsed either way, he is the past, we look forward...with Ross in attack, the school of science is on it’s way back

Gary Leonard
18 Posted 21/04/2014 at 17:36:14
This is my take on this story. Firstly, let’s not criticise Tim. He has been great this year. I agree that the players have a different perspective to the fans. I think that what needs to be borne in mind is that the fans feel betrayed by Moyes. The betrayal started with his prevarication over the renewal of his contract throughout the 2012-13 season, which seemed to unsettle the players. It later transpired that he had been negotiating with Man Utd over the manager’s job since December 2012. Then he started working for Man Utd, including apparently persuading Rooney to stay, even though he was till contracted to Everton. He then left, taking most of his backroom team with him and, despite a supposed ’gentleman’s agreement’ with Bill Kenwright not to poach any Everton players, he tried to buy Fellaini and Baines on the cheap (a ploy that backfired!). He did a great job for Everton while he was with us, but this is why we resent him now and why doing the double over Man Utd this season has been so satisfying. And Roberto has been an even greater replacement. I confess that I was hoping that Duncan would be appointed manager. This year has exceeded all expectations. And - to be fair to Moyes, Utd’s team had been run down over the last few years and I think that the Glazers were hoping that Moyes would rebuild it on the cheap.
Ray Roche
19 Posted 21/04/2014 at 17:41:49
Phil Sammon @050

Fair enough Ross, sorry, Phil, but if you think HE’S talking crap spend a day on here...

Dave Williams
20 Posted 21/04/2014 at 17:41:05
I don’t blame Moyes if he negotiated behind our backs for the MU job. It is a cut throat business with very little loyalty either way as he will most likely realise soon when he gets the sack!
He was very foolish in what he said about Fellaini and Baines and how we should sell to further their careers but how stupid does he look now having been screwed for £27.5m for Fellaini who is looking a total waste of money and it may be that deal which contributes to his demise - how ironic!
Ultimately it is a game of boos and cheers,heroes and villains and I am sure Moyes doesn’t lose any sleep over it. Tim should however butt out and leave the boo boys to it if that’s what they want to do. Tim should concern himself with what happens at Goodison Park and let Moyes look after himself. I will be forever grateful for the marvellous job he did for our club and also for him leaving when he did as Roberto has moved us on in a way that DM never could.
Jay Harris
21 Posted 21/04/2014 at 17:45:27
Gary
totally agree but just to add Moyes also seriously undermined EFC when he stated that "we should let Baines and Fellaini go to a bigger club to further their careers".

That was a disgraceful swipe at a club and supporters that had supported him through thick and thin and followed on from his own stance regarding Lescott.

Thankfully that has now come back to haunt him and I for one am gratified for it.

I fully understand Tim Howard’s stance in not wanting the man kicked when he is down and that loyalty should be commended but as supporters we should have expected much better from Moyes due to the adulation and support he enjoyed before he jumped ship.

Mark Dunford
22 Posted 21/04/2014 at 17:36:24
Agree with Mike (64). Judging by the many reports, it looks like Moyes has been sacked today. I can’t help but feel sorry for him as he was a good servant to Everton (sorry, but I find it hard to gloat) and I guess this is really what Howard is expressing - it seems a natural reaction from Howard given that Moyes rescued his career and did a lot for many of the players at Goodison now (from Osman through to Stones). I guess it was probably rumoured yesterday so Howard may have had an inkling before the media put the story in full flow.

Moyes had a dreadful inheritance, but he appeared overwhelmed by it all the same, their team is now poorer than it should be and dreadfully ill balanced (too many number 10s, no decent midfield and poor defence - this wasn’t a problem for him at Goodison and most of the bad players were there when he arrived). It was the failure in the transfer market in Summer and Jan that did for him - two marquee signings and nothing to rebalance the team. On the plus side, the goalie is better than he was last year!

Moyes needlessly lost friends through his ill thought out pursuit of Baines (who must be a mightily relieved man - he only needs to look at Fellaini or Buttner to see what might have been). A rather sad end to Moyes career (assuming it is true!).

John Daley
23 Posted 21/04/2014 at 17:53:48
"He was the second coming, the messiah 12 months ago"

Shit! Howard must have been in such a dark place this time last year if he spent all his spare time scouring the internet for tips on farcical fucking facial hair and studying the posts of our very own Nick Entwistle.

Wonder what other shameful bollocks lies hidden within his browsing history?

As for the reception Moyes was given being ’unfair’? I thought he actually got off lightly yesterday.

Kevin Tully
24 Posted 21/04/2014 at 17:44:03
Sometimes OFM’s tenure at Everton is glossed over like he lifted numerous trophies, or took us from the lower tiers to the P.L. glory days.

His dampening of expectations at every chance clearly worked a treat, look at these boards for proof of that. He took us to the top 8 on a regular basis after being backed with all of the available revenues. He won fuck all and we made him one the highest paid managers in world football.

I look at at this way - we could have done worse than Moyes, but we we could have done a whole lot better. You only have to read that piece by Ian Ross who says he turned down some amazing players who wanted to come to our club.

So when he says players should leave Everton to further their careers, I feel he is either thick as fuck, or he never really felt anything for this club. Whatever the answer is - he is not welcome anymore, so button it Tim.

James Stewart
25 Posted 21/04/2014 at 17:57:07
Agree with the above Howard should keep his beak shut and stop patronising his own fans. They can make up their own mind who to boo thanks
Jay Harris
26 Posted 21/04/2014 at 17:56:04
Mark,
he will walk away with at least 5 million which is more than any compensation EFC got for him being poached.

The last 12 months of his reign at GP were in total contrast to the man who was dignified and principled prior to his clandestine meetings with Ferguson.

John Daley
27 Posted 21/04/2014 at 17:59:14
"Moyes had a dreadful inheritance"

I love the way this fallacy is suddenly taken as fact. I’m sure most managers would cut their right arm off to inherit a team that ran away with the league title mere months before along with a big blank chequebook.

Karl Masters
29 Posted 21/04/2014 at 18:14:12
Do you have a link to that Ian Ross story, Kevin? I’d be fascinated to read it. Most people leaving Everton under a but of a cloud seem to attain instant muteness, due no doubt to a BK confidentiality clause payoff.
Tony Cheek
30 Posted 21/04/2014 at 18:22:19
I was never a Moyes fan, but was a bit disappointed that he got an earful on sunday. What we should have done was made him realize he left the best club in England by giving him a warm welcome. Now that would really have pissed him off!
Patrick Murphy
31 Posted 21/04/2014 at 18:28:49
Tony I think he got off relatively lightly yesterday - he had his good send off twelve months ago - and it could have been a lot worse, I’m glad it didn’t go over the top, but the man betrayed his former club with his silly utterances about doing what is right for the player rather than what is right for the club, If I had have been his new employer that utterance alone would have sounded alarm bells regardless of results. When somebody relies on their integrity and honesty and then trades it because he believes his own press they deserve everything that comes their way. I always believed that David Moyes was a different type of person to the usual football manager but he proved me wrong.
Trevor Lynes
32 Posted 21/04/2014 at 18:39:53
Gloating over a win or about another’s misfortune is dreadful and I have been an Evertonian since 1948 and still cannot stand it.

Moyes did a great rescue job at goodison and now Roberto has taken the players he left and added class recruits. He has left Moyes best legacy (the defence) intact and improved the midfield and front men by buying and loaning good players that have improved the overall squad. He has brought on the likes of Barkley and Stones possibly quicker than Moyes would have done. These changes have been brilliant but if they had not come off the same moaners on this site would have been after Martinez head.

Anthony Burke
33 Posted 21/04/2014 at 18:50:02
Moyes saved us from probably the dreaded drop he made Everton what they are today. Roberto has added a bit more spice tho I understand why fans are angry over the baines/Fellaini fiasco but some fans have very short memories. COYB!
Darren Hind
34 Posted 21/04/2014 at 18:53:14
John

Did he get off lightly? Maybe, it was nowhere near as bad as I thought it would be.

Having read some of the comments on this and other websites I thought he would be properly slaughtered.

I don’t think it was a sign of forgiveness. I put it down to the overwhelming majority being more interested in Everton than worrying about what’s happening in Manchester.

Peter Jamieson
35 Posted 21/04/2014 at 19:23:42
Martinez said it right in his post match interview on Sky.

He said Moyes got his standing ovation and thanks from the Everton fans at the end of last season.

Yesterday he came to Goodison as the Man Utd manager and got treated as such.

Are Everton fans expected to kiss his arse until the end of time?

Dave Roberts
36 Posted 21/04/2014 at 19:15:42
I didn’t barrack Moyes yesterday, even if it’s only because I’m too bloody old for that kind of thing! But I have lost most of the respect I had for him. Funnily enough, not so much as a result of the Baines/Fellaini saga because after all he shot himself in the foot there and ended up buying the inferior one of the two for more than he initially offered for both of them and made himself look like a right twat. That was punishment enough!

No, for me it was when it finally transpired that he knew as early as Christmas that he was going to United, stalled on his contract, lied to us, strung us along with his contention that he would see how things went, presumably lied to his best mate Bill too and cost us a few bob in compensation. Neither did he object to the fact that Manure decided to announce he was going there before the season ended when we were trying to qualify for Europe seemingly not concerned at the disruption that might cause the team. Nevertheless he was given a good and affectionate send off about which, knowing what he knew then and we didn’t, did not seem to embarrass him at all. It made me remember all the banners ’In Moyes we trust’ and the fact that in the end we shouldn’t have trusted him at all.

I also remember him saying he had moved on to better things at Manchester United. Well, after that game yesterday who has really moved on to better things? We have.

Jamie Barlow
37 Posted 21/04/2014 at 19:37:21
He definitely got off lightly yesterday. Even The Grim Reaper got chucked out didn’t he?
Paul Washington
38 Posted 21/04/2014 at 19:27:54
Does anybody remember Moyes stating during the Pienaar transfer saga that "certain clubs suit certain players " Well I suppose that could be used for managers too. I don’t blame Moyes for going or indeed trying for players from us, that’s footy. He got his send-off from us then sniped from afar with his comments, "when we played here [OT] with Everton our motto was to get out alive "and " I never had the tools to win at Anfield before " this despite us seeing the worst Liverpool team most of us have witnessed.

He got off lightly yesterday and I am glad it didn’t turn into a hatefest. He has shown little respect for us and it looks like he has been bitten on the arse with the news of his impending sacking. I have no sympathy despite Tim Howards views.
Ed Fitzgerald
39 Posted 21/04/2014 at 19:32:30
Mike Oates 064

You need a history lesson in the 14-15 years that preceded An Everton manager who inherited a team far worse than Moyes did and actually won something! I think we had less than 10 points was it 3? in November when Royle took over.

Moyes was masterful in one way, convincing everyone how we couldn’t achieve more whilst picking up a kings ransom for it. In one season Martinez has brought something vital back to the club, attacking football, that is something Moyes never understood about Evertonians. Howard is entitled to his opinion and so are we, we will be here long after he has gone and we pay for the privilege.

John Daley
40 Posted 21/04/2014 at 19:51:50
Darren,

I thought he would be getting stick for the majority of the game but, apart from the boos when he walked out and a few renditions of ’stuck with Moyes’, I never noted much goading going on. Certainly nothing too vitriolic. It seemed like people were more amused by his current plight than anything.

There was a small crowd awaiting the arrival of the United bus (i presume to have a pop) when I was heading past on the way to the Spellow, but I don’t know what scenes the Scots boggly, Doc Brown from Back to the Future eyes surveyed when he stepped out on to the street as I didn’t stick around to find out.

Andy Crooks
41 Posted 21/04/2014 at 19:57:13
Tim Howard is hired hand, not an Evertonian. His thoughts on this man who signed him are neither here nor there.
Dave Roberts
42 Posted 21/04/2014 at 19:49:06
It really does annoy me when people talk about the Moyes legacy and Martinez merely reaping the benefit. Moyes did a great job in steadying the ship and getting us out of the annual relegation battles but if he was still here now does anybody think.....

1. Stones would be a first team regular and demonstrating the fact that he is (for my money) the best prospect as a ball playing central defender I've seen in years.

2. Barkley would have moved off the permanent seat he had on the bench to become a likely visitor to Brazil with England.

3. Naismith would have moved in from the wing where Moyes always had him (where he was a waste of space) and into a striker roll where he has been quite impressive and a regular game winner.

4. That Coleman would become the automatic choice at right back.

5. That Phil Neville would still be here.

6. That Phil Jagielka was seen raiding up the wing at Old Trafford a few months ago and does punt the ball upfield a lot less nowadays.

7. That we would actually employ a player like Delofeu.

8. That we now expect rather then hope to see decent footy being played.

It's not as simple as what you have, it's how you use what you have and that is the difference between Moyes and Martinez.

Colin Grierson
43 Posted 21/04/2014 at 20:04:36
Who is Tim Howard to say how Moyes should be treated? I've seen many players and managers come and go. The vast majority of them are welcomed back warmly and treated with the respect that they earned and deserve.
There will always be those that are not welcome back. McMahon et al and now Moyes has joined there ranks. What he did for the club and how 'great' he was is a matter of debate and everyone deserves their opinion. However, Moyes shat all over us and disrespected us. He listened to the biased media too much and had us down as also rans for all his time with us. Look at us now!
Howard should button it. We pay, he gets paid ( by us!). We boo (if we like) he makes saves (if he can) and when he finally leaves the club we welcome him back if he shows the club the respect it deserves. If not he's not welcome. Simple.
Drew Shortis
44 Posted 21/04/2014 at 20:18:27
I think his comments are perfectly understandable. Tim Howard knew Moyes on a personal level and worked with him for many years. I can understand how it could be difficult for Tim to listen to abuse for a man he obviously respects. As others have pointed out us fans see things differently to most players.

Personally I have no beef with Moyes. I thought it was about time for a change and we have ended up with a much better manager. The Baines business was a bit shady but he did give us a laugh by paying over the odds for Fellaini. My big concern is that United will replace him with someone more suited to the role and our six points against United won't be guaranteed next year!

Scott Fisher
45 Posted 21/04/2014 at 20:38:07
Fair play to Tim. Although things have moved on greatly with the re-opening of "the school of science" with Martinez, Moyes overachieved with no resources for years and we shouldn’t forget it, although I admit it was painful to watch at times.

Martinez has built on the Moyes solid defence with some real flair up the pitch. I just hope his defensive signings will improve from Alcaraz who looks very poor from his bit part appearances. Hopefully Distin’s hamstring will not keep him out for the remainder of the season.

Mark Dunford
46 Posted 21/04/2014 at 20:42:02
Agree with Jay - Moyes will never be impoverished, but is unlikely to work at this level again - unless Celtic come knocking and that is scarcely on the same stage. It doesn't mean Howard's comments aren't understandable and Andy (163) is being unreasonably harsh on a player who has been our most reliable goalkeeper since Southall (Martyn was only there for a short while though was great). Howard's career was rescued by Moyes and he has since served Everon really well. He is entitled to his opinion and there is no reason why he shoudn't be allowed to raise his voice. Just like - say - Colin (177) who clearly thinks Howard has somehow lost the right to speak his mind
Colin Glassar
47 Posted 21/04/2014 at 20:55:54
TimHow is entitled to his views but, so are the fans.
Sean Kelly
48 Posted 21/04/2014 at 20:42:10
Dave Roberts 168 you are spot on mate and to emphasise you point about how to use your resources look at how he has used those resources at Man Utd. That's a squad that won the title by 11 points last year and he has managed them for 57 games and he had 57 different teams on the pitch. He is and was one-dimensional no Plan B or C and tried to get the Man Utd players to play HIS Everton way. He alienated players here and had done the same at Man Utd.

Roberto on the other hand has used the resources he has brilliantly. They for the most part were here under Moyes but have embraced Robertos philosophy. Established players that Moyes brought here have flourished this season under Roberto.

Keith Young
49 Posted 21/04/2014 at 20:40:37
Trevor#114 we have one thing in common,I have supported Everton since 1948 but I can't agree with you in complaining that if RM changes had not come off "the moaners would have been after his head". In those circumstances (like Tony Marsh endured for years) they are entitled and required to complain. The behaviour of OFM brought out his own kind in our supporters with their boos whereas many thousands kept a decent silence.

This thread was caused by Howard's "unfair" prodding using the media unavailable to affronted Everton supporters. Dave Roberts' #146 explains it all clearly and with dignity but he has no chance repeating that in the same media Howard used from his position as a paid employee of Everton.

Mike Gaynes
50 Posted 21/04/2014 at 21:01:39
"I love David Moyes. I think he is a brilliant manager. He was [a brilliant manager] here for us and I will be forever grateful."

Howard would be a complete ass to feel, or say, anything different. Moyes gave him a second chance after his failure at Man Utd, a failure made harder to handle by his illness and by his failure to beat out Friedel for the USA #1. Moyes gave Howard his faith and helped him restore his self-confidence, and never once wavered in his support. And Howard repaid him with years of fine service.

If he loves the man — and is concerned for his subsequent misfortunes — I'd say it speaks to Howard's good character and appropriate gratitude, not to any disloyalty to Everton.

Tony Draper
51 Posted 21/04/2014 at 20:59:45
I understand Time Howard's comments and I disagree with them. DM did the job he was employed to do and was delighted to accept it when he was appointed. He was paid handsomely for his services, yet, when the opportunity to WIN a trophy came along, he failed to step up a gear and really go for it.

For me, DM had begun besmirching his own reputation 18 months to 2 years before he departed. It is NO coincidence that DM began stalling on signing his new contract from the time that SAF was aware of his health problems.

SAF has said subsequently that he'd decided to retire should he be advised of a deterioration. And I believe that SAF was all set to retire until Man City ruined the party with the last kick of the season.

During that time, DM continually lied about signing a new contract... the giveaway was that the reason kept shifting. DM had begun to believe his own bullshit.

He's a decent manager, possibly even a good one, but he's not great or exceptional. He will get decent work, many Premier League clubs will see him as just what they need
reliable

I think he's dull, boring, unimaginative and a two faced cunt. I didn't always think that... But I do now, and I always will.

James Royston
52 Posted 21/04/2014 at 21:28:16
Most of the comments are understandable. But if Howard is so cut up about things perhaps he should rip up the contract he has just signed. Moyes will probably end up at Celtic perhaps Tim may want to go there then he would really experience what bitterness can be...We could try to buy Marshall from Cardiff... Goodbye Mr Moyes and Mr Howard if he feels Evertonians are unfair....
Anthony Burke
53 Posted 21/04/2014 at 21:46:53
I would love Champions League. I pray we get it but just found out the winners of the Europa league next season get Champions League qualification. Was hoping we would play the kids till I found this out.
Steven Telford
54 Posted 21/04/2014 at 21:43:57
Indeed, he was treated VERY well - fair is fair - most of us tipped our hats, and said thanks, and then he in turn spat that gratitude and fairness back in our face.

Regarding Baines and Fellaini: [let them go] "do what's right by the players" That statement above all else ranks up there as being one of his lowest statements to us.

What Howard is missing is that, ours is a "reaction", his was the "action". Moyes brought this acrimony entirely upon himself.

Jack Cross
55 Posted 21/04/2014 at 21:49:15
Well he brought stability here but nothing else. If he had won several trophies with us, well, we could have looked back and cheered or even thanked him, but he didn't. The day he left, he was history to me.

Man Utd can sack him, keep him, he can win things or not. He's their problem now, not ours. He wanted success at a bigger club and didn't care where that left us.

It's simple: he was'nt ready, but his arrogance thought he was. All his CV will read is 'failure'. Because that's what he is — a failure.

Jack Cross
56 Posted 21/04/2014 at 22:22:51
Has for Howard's comments on the fans booing Moyse, well he would have to stand by the man who bought him, surely.

You could look at it another way, I mean Howard as showed loyalty towards Moyes and felt he should stick up for him. I'd say that's a plus in Howard's favour. Out of his sight, but not out of his mind.

Let's be truthful, players forget so easy in this multi-million pound game. So good on you, Tim, for saying what you think and not for saying what the fans would want you to say.

Sam Hoare
57 Posted 21/04/2014 at 22:31:43
Jack, I wouldn't underrate stability. There is no doubt in my mind that Moyes did a very good job as Everton manager and laid the foundations that Roberto has built so successfully on. Yes he had his flaws (noticeably in the cups) but he turned us from relegation flirters into a solid top 7 club and all with considerably less backing then many of the clubs around us. Whatever happens I believe he deserves some appreciation for that. Having said that the moment he left I could not really have cared less and my only feeling if he was to be fired is a slight concern that Man U will be much better next season.
Eugene Ruane
58 Posted 21/04/2014 at 22:12:24
Before the coach arrived, the stewards appeared to be making a bigger deal than usual (for the arrival of the opposition's bus).

You had to walk around a line of them and stay on the pavement as you past 'The People's Pub'.

There was a bigger crowd in that area than usual although nothing in the least threatening.

As the coach pulled in and Utd got off, there was a pause then 'boooooo' but looking at the faces most were grinning and laughing.

Then a kid (or someone with a very high-pitched voice) screamed 'fuck off Moyes you ginger bell-end'.

A line like that, shouted by child, should probably make me feel sad or..depressed or...something.

Instead I laughed and thought 'I hope you heard that.....you ginger bell-end.'

Scott Williams
59 Posted 21/04/2014 at 23:00:24
Think the bottom line is that he would have got a good reception if he didn’t try and ruin a team he started putting together as soon as he had "better prospects." If he didn’t try and rip us off in the summer, he would have been a lot more welcome at Fortress Goodison!
Ste Traverse
60 Posted 21/04/2014 at 22:35:01
Can't agree with Tim here.

As far back as I can remember, as long as you give your all while at our club, leave on good terms and don't publicly slag us off or belittle us, you will always be welcomed back whenever you return to Goodison.

Moyes got shit. That says it all.

Also phoney Phil Neville was getting it off the Street End on Sunday too. Surely his 'Everton are buckling under the pressure' comment on Friday had something to do with it.

Mike Price
61 Posted 21/04/2014 at 23:21:05
Players are never honest about managers until they retire. There's always the possibility they may be affected professionally. Personally, I don't rate Howard; he's average at best, rarely steals a game for us, and has a penchant for diving backwards over the goal line so, even if he stops it, it's in.

Moyes brought it on himself, he acquired an arrogant, "better than you" attitude that is completely unjustified. He did a decent job for a couple of years and anyone with a footballing brain could see he was a limited PE teacher and outdated manager. How he got away with lowering expectations and making Evertonians grateful for barely achieving them, is still a mystery to me... talk about the Emperor's invisible clothes.

Tim Howard is an employee – not a supporter... sorry, Tim, but we know better than you!

Ross Edwards
62 Posted 21/04/2014 at 23:32:48
It wasn't unfair at all. Fully deserved in my view.
David Cornmell
63 Posted 21/04/2014 at 23:15:22
He never got us; never attempted to get us.

Everton is, was and always will be a special club. Read the quotes from Ball, Labby, Hickson, Young et al. Being a Blue is like being in a family. Once you're in, you're in for life. Moyes was never in.

One of the things I love about Bobby is he often references our history. I bet he knows the exchange rate between Evertonians and Kopites. If you know your history...I bet Bobby does.

Moyes is a strange one, a bit like Lineker in that he came here and had success but never became one of us. Unlike Lineker he had a fucken long time to do so...but still didn't.

About ninety percent of us knew that going to ManUre was never going to end well for him, but at least he backed himself and gave it a shot. He's got a shitload of cash to console him, and I suppose he'll find a gig somewhere where he can try again.

Hopefully for him he finds a club he belongs at, because it wasn't here and it wasn't at Man Utd either.

John Keating
64 Posted 21/04/2014 at 23:50:54
Steve 032, 034. Steve if you read my post I say that Howard is entitled to his views. However, I also say that he has access to the media and his words imply that WE supporters should not have an opinion. The only way we can voice our opinion in this case was to boo Moyes which I believe we have the right to do if we so wish.

Those supporters who feel different either say nothing or applaud – it's up to them. If Howard was balanced in his interview he should have at least acknowledged that there are some supporters pissed off with Moyes and that we have the right to voice our opinion.

Finally I don't think the "past" is how I see it. I think you will find the reason I and others are pissed off with Moyes is in the public domain and on record. Not my interpretation but fact.

Mark Andersson
65 Posted 22/04/2014 at 02:02:44
After reading all the post above. Two stand out (Dave Roberts & John Keating). I live in Australia and was surprised that the boo boys where not as vocal as I was expecting.

I think DM is now facing his Karmic debt. IF he had embraced the Everton family as John Keating rightly points out and became one of us, he would have never have left the way he did. He alienated himelf further over the Baines / Fellaini saga.

As a life-long blues fan, I was glad to see the back of him. He was paid well to do a job, which he did well (well for his standards). Tim Howard should have simply said the fans have a right to voice their opinion and so does Tim Howard.

It's time to move on, as we are... and, by the looks of it, so is DM. We had the last laugh and that's all that counts.

Alex Higgins
66 Posted 22/04/2014 at 03:21:25
Has anyone in the Media, apart from BBC McMulty, stated the real reason that Everton supporters are down on Moyes? It seems that the Media believes we should be grateful, and that seems to include our present players.

Neville Southall is the only past player to my knowledge to voice the real issues that have resulted in the falling out with our former manager. Any club's supporters would be angry by implying that their club wasn't good enough for their players. Moyes must have known this after spending 11 years of his life with Everton, yet he still went ahead and made these statements. I wish the Media would concentrate on this instead of seeing us as bitter ungrateful supporters.

Anto Byrne
67 Posted 22/04/2014 at 05:18:17
Sheedy had a pop as well. Everton could never live with Man Utd, they played at a different level. The School of Science is now open and they can't live with Everton now. Why is that?
Colin Grierson
68 Posted 22/04/2014 at 07:42:07
Mark 187 - Everyone is entitled to their opinion mate, Tim Howard included. I think you missed my point. I personally won't boo anyone but that is my stance as a paying customer. I stated on here on several threads that I would prefer it if the fans got behind Martinez rather than booed Moyes.
I can understand Howard's comments but we are being misrepresented in the media enough as it is. His opinion doesn't have to mirror that of the fans but when it regards an emotive situation such as this I feel he should keep his own counsel.
Moyes treated us appallingly after he left, burning bridges, probably in order to ingratiate himself to the Mancs. Well it looks like it has backfired on him.
I don't feel sorry for a man who we paid SO well, who moved on to one of the most prestigious appointments in the game and who will get more from 'tending his garden' than I'll earn in a lifetime. Tim Howard doesn't understand that does he. His mate took a bit of stick for his ill judged behaviour. I reckon he's being reasonably compensated for any hurt he felt.
Darren Alexander
71 Posted 22/04/2014 at 10:53:07
I've found that most who aren't Everton fans simply think we've all been very bitter because Moyes dared to move on - far from the truth, and witness the warm send-off he was given at Goodison less than a year ago.

I think we all would have continued to wish him well (to an extent), but he found a very quick route to burn his bridges with us in the dismissive way he spoke about us - including, but not limited to, the Baines/Fellaini saga. There was no need for such a lack of class. Quite rightfully, most of us turned on him. And given the events from Sunday to now, any right-thinking Toffee would need to have a heart of stone to not laugh.

I think we were very kind to him - too kind, to be honest, as let's not forget how all his messing around last season (failing to sign a contract when he was cooking up something else) had a very unsettling effect on the team, and I think we really underachieved as a result of this.

And, as others have pointed out, it's one thing finding/signing players, and quite another to manage and use them properly - the performances of the young players and the 'real' Naismith that we now see are all ample proof of this.

Paul Tran
72 Posted 22/04/2014 at 13:27:49
Best thing about our 'treatment' of Moyes on Sunday was the 'Moysie, Moysie give us a wave' chant. As the Times said; he was transformed from a figure of hate to a figure of fun. Plus the way Roberto talked with dignity about a man who had tried and failed to play mind games with him.

Now that most people must have realised that Moyes is a one-trick pony busted flush and that our 'rubbish' manager is actually rather good, let's stick with how well we're doing and what we're going to do in the future.

Phil Roberts
73 Posted 22/04/2014 at 17:35:26
"What really is annoying is low-balling over Baines and Fellaini". "He has a short memory over the Lescott Saga"

Can someone please explain to me why as the manager of Manchester United he should come back with an inflated fee to get the players from his former club? All Moyes was doing was the best thing for the club where he worked. Sentiment is fine, but it was sentiment which would have cost £20m-£30m. Great for his previous employers - lousy for his current (at the time) ones.

I am a Moyes fan. I liked that the qualities that United said he had was honesty and integrity. And don't give me any rubbish about him stalling and negotiating at the end of last season. What did you want him to do? Oh yes, I'll be leaving at the end of the season in 3 months time but let me carry on until then. Or should he have said No, Sir Alex, I'll have to wait until after the season is over to say yes. And I can't even say what I will say until then because of Everton. How long would United have waited before looking elsewhere? End Feb, end March - but for sure end of job offer.

March and April are now happy times in our house. Before Moyes arrived my wife dreaded the weekends as I was a nervous wreck. Would we lose again and are we out of the relegation places? He turned this club around and we should never forget that. He took over when we were 15th, one point clear of relegation with 9 games to go. When he left we were locked in to the top 7 clubs in the country.

He has failed at United - they will end up with about 68-70 points. Usually that is enough for 4th. The league has split into 3. The top 7, the middle 3 and the bottom 10. We are not in the top 7, we were in the bottom 10.

I would rather be a pauper in the house of the King than a King in the house of a pauper.

Si Cooper
74 Posted 22/04/2014 at 18:26:00
Phil Roberts - there is a world of difference between offering a reasonable amount for a player and offering a very low amount (according to most reasonable valuations) and then using the argument that our club was being unfair to the targeted players by not allowing them to move on to 'further their careers'.

He could have signed an extension to his contract with us even knowing he was likely to be offered the United job. That way we could have extracted a reasonable amount of compensation. Instead we ended up with nothing because Moyes preferred to make himself as attractive to United as possible and thereby feather his own nest.

If all that is acceptable to you then you are indeed a 'Moyes man' ; personally, I am an Evertonian and have greater ambitions for our club than just being a small fish in a large pond.

John Daley
75 Posted 22/04/2014 at 18:57:06
"Can someone please explain to me why as the manager of Manchester United he should come back with an inflated fee to get the players from his former club?"

Why? That's not what people are saying he should have done is it?What they expected from their former manager was a fair bid, somewhere within the region of the two players market value, rather than a derisory piss take of a bid that came across like he was begrudgingly flinging a bit of loose slummy at an old dosser in a doorway.

If you don't think that's a big enough bit of cheeky bastardry then throw in that he was supposed to have given verbal assurances to Kenwright that he wouldn't try to buy anyone from the club and the fact that the initial bid for Baines was made when he was still technically the Everton manager.

"I am a Moyes fan. I liked that the qualities that United said he had was honesty and integrity"

The very qualities that were conspicuously absent in his attitude towards, and treatment of, his former club.

"What did you want him to do? Oh yes, I'll be leaving at the end of the season in 3 months time but let me carry on until then. Or should he have said No, Sir Alex, I'll have to wait until after the season is over to say yes"

Either of those would have done. Both are preferable to bullshitting about waiting until the Jan window is out the way, waiting to see what funds are available for the summer, waiting to see where we finish etc.

"The league has split into 3. The top 7, the middle 3 and the bottom 10. We are not in the top 7"

'Please, pay no attention to the man behind the curtain. He isn't really there. I am the great and powerful Oz!'

Brent Stephens
76 Posted 22/04/2014 at 19:01:11
Never trust what a manager says, John?!
Colin Grierson
77 Posted 22/04/2014 at 22:05:55
Phil 577 - in the end Moyes showed us no integrity or honesty. Therefore he pays for that every time he visits GP. Luckily for him it was only the once! He got what he deserved. Ginger bell-end.
Phil Roberts
78 Posted 23/04/2014 at 13:07:10
"The league has split into 3. The top 7, the middle 3 and the bottom 10. We are not in the top 7. we were in the bottom 10.

Apologies - I meant to say

"The league has split into 3. The top 7, the middle 3 and the bottom 10. We are in the top 7. we were in the bottom 10."

Whole heap of difference and that is what Moyes did for this club.
I just had a check. The year he came, Derby, Leicester and Ipswich went down. One has never been back, the other 2, once and for one season each time. It could have been us.


Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads

© ToffeeWeb