Moyes sacked after just 10 months

, 22 April, 245comments  |  Jump to most recent

The Grim Reaper, planted at the United game on Sunday as a stunt by Paddy Power, taunts David Moyes from the stands at Goodison Park
David Moyes, the former Everton manager, who made the move to "better things" at Old Trafford last May has been unceremoniously dismissed from his post as manager of Manchester United after just 10 months in the job.

He leaves along with some of the backroom staff (Steve Round, & Jimmy Lumsden) he took with him from Everton on the heels of an ignominious defeat at Goodison Park, where his replacement, Roberto Martinez, masterminded a convincing 2-0 win for the Blues.

Media outlets were clearly briefed of the 50-year-old's impending dismissal yesterday but confirmation of the move didn't come the Manchester club until this morning. Moyes leaves Old Trafford having presided over Man Utd's worst points tally in the Premier League era and the former Champions look likely to miss out on a place in Europe as well.

Moyes left Goodison Park with a hero's send-off last May but the relationship with Everton soured with his pursuit of Leighton Baines and Marouane Fellaini and a pair of derisory bids for the two players that were summarily rejected. The Scot's assertion that Everton should let the players go "to further their careers" did not go down well with Blues' fans and he returned to his old stomping ground on Sunday to a muted but audible jeers before the match ended with chants of "sacked in the morning" from home fans.  



Reader Comments (245)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Paul Tran
1 Posted 22/04/2014 at 10:25:34
Part of the problem with Moyes was that when he was here, the management fawned all over him, so it appears he was never challenged. Plus the majority of the support was up his arse, falling for the line that we couldn't get any better than him and his methods. He had no reason to doubt himself, then he turned up at a club where the management and supported demanded results, success and high standards.

After a good few years here, he had the opportunity to raise his game and ambitions, but he still talked as if we were still the club he joined, rather than club he had built up. Every time he raised expectations, he failed to deliver. He couldn't take us further forward, so he wasn't going to do it there. Quite telling that he only looked at home when they were the underdogs against Bayern.

What a lucky break we got when Ferguson took him off us! Thanks Alex!

Trevor Thompson
2 Posted 22/04/2014 at 10:49:11
I never rated Moyes when he was with us. I always thought he was way too negative (maybe being a defender was the reason) and focused too much on the opposition obsessively that it stopped our players focusing on their game.

I could never understand what the media (and my friends) saw in Moyes. Maybe because we had very little money and had the odd decent season or two. He was a bottle merchant when it came to playing the big teams, the Liverpool FA Cup semi final a few years back was when I finally lost faith in him completely.

Man United were fools to have him take over. He had never won anything with us in 11 years how the hell does that make him a good choice for one of the biggest teams in the world?

His parting shots at our players being held back by not joining him made me lose all respect for him.

Rick Tarleton
3 Posted 22/04/2014 at 11:43:04
For years, the media kept telling us how good Moyes was. It was obvious to Evertonians he was limited, a negative mindset, and a constant desire not to risk anything. Young players saw the first team then had to wait and wait, this year he did the same with Januzaj.

Now, the media tells us Moyes was always the wrong choice and he is negative and inadequate. Going to Manchester United didn't make him that way, that was his philosophy.

I'll never forgive him for the cup semi-final against Liverpool, we took the lead, and we're palpably the better team; what did Moyes do? He pulled Cahill back in to the midfield and hoped to hold on to a one goal lead for and hour. That mindset was unchangeable and it was obvious to all, yet journalists kept telling us we had a great manager.

Now suddenly they've discovered the truth. Letters and articles on ToffeWeb, including my own could have told them that eight years ago.

Kevin Elliott
4 Posted 22/04/2014 at 11:14:51
I reckon that he will go to West Brom and his first bit of business will be to secure big Vic's services with a five-year extension to his contract and a 50% pay rise.

Apparently Round has already applied for another job at the Merseyrail Community Stadium as chief ball boy.

James Flynn
5 Posted 22/04/2014 at 11:05:50
Having Ferguson stifled the Glazer’s management-personnel revolving door instincts they’re known for over here. Good to see them defaulting to the hiring/firing policies they use with their NFL Tampa Bay Bucs. Which mean one less team for EFC to worry about challenging for the CL. Assuming the Glazers don’t sell up any time soon, for the foreseeable future at that.

It’s Henry running the RS I worry about. He knows what he’s doing. Not the Fergie-less Glazers.

Tony Draper
6 Posted 22/04/2014 at 11:54:59
Rick @435

Moyes was OVERJOYED when he joined "The People's Club" (NOT in fact his words but actually those of Graeme Sounness).

In his early days, he did just what we needed: solidified us and removed our membership of "The Trapdoor Club". His second phase was encouraging and had us beginning to think bigger and brighter... It NEVER happened!

And his third phase confirmed this repeatedly: He bottled EVERY important game.

This talk that he changed at Man Utd? He didn't, he'd already been in decline... BUT the most important factor is: Roberto Martinez has arrived!

And "The School of Science" has reopened!!!

Jamie Carroll
7 Posted 22/04/2014 at 12:04:41
No worries on Martinez being approached for the Manchester United job, as one of the first requirements of a new manager will be Champions League experience.
Rick Tarleton
9 Posted 22/04/2014 at 12:22:45
Tony, I've no doubt Moyes was overjoyed, it was a great opportunity after Preston and he was an improvement on the Smith era. And I agree, like Pulis, he's great at setting teams up not to lose, but it was manifest from early days that he was not going to return Everton to its glory days.

Martinez may have faults, but he tries to win and his teams play with that philosophy in mind. Moyes felt losing one-nil to the better teams was a kind of triumph.

Kev Thomas
10 Posted 22/04/2014 at 12:43:47
You know what really gets my goat though (and is even making me feel a tiny weeny bit sorry for Moyes)?

Loads of shithouse 'journalists' who, after bigging him up for 11 years with us and all through last summer, are now all like- "Oh no! He we always the wrong man for the job! That's what we said. We told you he was rubbish and shouldn't be appointed."

A quick check on the Google timeline/trends reveals this to be more of the patented bullshit you'd expect from hacks, but never mind, if you're daft enough to buy a 'newspaper' (and tbh, I think most should get a visit from trading standards) then you get what you pay for...

Ste Traverse
11 Posted 22/04/2014 at 12:25:00
I just made up the final nail in the coffin of David Moyes was at Goodison Park.

How VERY poignant.

David Nicholls
12 Posted 22/04/2014 at 13:06:53
I can't bring myself to have a laugh at Moyes expense. He will always have my respect for resurrecting our fortunes. Seriously were were a laughing stock in 2002.

However, I feel I need to hold my hand up and say I was so very wrong. I defended Moyes countless times on this site. I honestly felt that despite some of his obvious faults, given the necessary funds he would have taken us to the next level and his move to Man Utd would only prove me correct. His performance for Man Utd coupled with our re-invention under Roberto certainly supports the view that he had taken us as far as he could. I fell into the trap of thinking when Moyes departed it would only get worse when it has got much better.

Many people on this site called it correct a number of years ago, fair play to you all.

Peter Morris
13 Posted 22/04/2014 at 13:18:24
The media frenzy is now getting into full pelt, with the hacks getting lathered about who they will ’pick’ next. What is this? The spoilt little child doesn’t like the sweetie so spits it out and demands another flavour? Uniquely, all the media ever want for Man Utd, unlike any other club, is what is best for Man Utd... end of. Hence Roberto’s name creeping into chatter in some quarters.

No-one will ever convince me that Moyes going to United wasn’t a set-up between him and old red nose (cutting us out of much needed compensation) and Moyes’s stringing along of little Everton over his contract (and his assertion that we shouldn’t "stand in Bainesy’s way"!) is largely behind the antipathy now directed toward him by our supporters who were generous enough to give him such a wonderful send off less than a year ago.

He and those money grubbing plasticos in Salford Docks deserved each other. Pity really, as I was looking forward to several years of frustrating failure, so now will have to live in hope that the next guy is just as useless.

Chris Leyland
14 Posted 22/04/2014 at 13:08:36
The limitations of Moyes, which were hidden to the outside world but which many Evertonians have been talking about for a few years, have been well and truly laid bare at Man Utd.

When all is said and done, it is difficult to feel any sympathy for a man who always portrayed himself as principled but who seemed to sell-out those principles with his comments and actions towards Everton when he became Man U manager.

For me, one thing is inarguable, he left us in a better state than when he joined us in terms of our position in the league and the strength of our playing squad. I don't think that even the likes of Peter Barry could dispute this.

Having stabilized us and moved us to being amongst the 'best of the rest' team, his own self-imposed glass-ceiling mentality is what prevented us from moving forward. His innate negativity and constant down-playing of expectations. I will hold my hands up and say I fell for it for a while but Martinez is the polar opposite and convinced me otherwise. It took me until the 3-3 Derby to be a convert when I appreciated what Roberto's philosophy was all about. I posted on here at the time that "I'm in" my only regret was that it took me so long.

Whilst we may well ultimately end up 5th this year and therefore the 'best of the rest' the belief that we can actually achieve more and that we can compete with the so-called 'bigger teams' is there. It is there for the players who can play with a freedom and a confidence not there under the previous regime and it is there amongst the fans (taking account of our natural Evertonian selves which is still to expect to be let down deep inside ourselves).

We are Everton, the 4th most successful team in English History. The team who has played more top flight games then anyone else.The school of science.

Duncan McDine
15 Posted 22/04/2014 at 13:28:24
I'm not surprised about him getting the boot... it baffled me in the first place why he got the Utd job in the first place.

The pundits always refered to the 'miracles' Moyes pulled off by keeping little Everton in the top half... when in reality the Everton wage bill was consistently 7th or 8th highest in the PL. We at Everton were much more realistic about the job he did at our club (and he did a good job, no more no less).

Jackie Barry
16 Posted 22/04/2014 at 13:43:46
I agree Chris but all too many of our fans never saw those limitations either. They had fallen for the BS spread around the club by Moyes, BK and his cronies about how we were doing great and this is where a club like Everton should be.

We have now, I hope all seen the light and our expectations have been heightened. My fear is that BK might even consider bringing Moyes back should RM be poached in the future; if he did, I hope he would see a backlash like no other from the fans.

Patrick Murphy
17 Posted 22/04/2014 at 13:45:50
Duncan, according to some business guru on the BBC "Moyes was the cheap option and when you buy cheap you always take a risk" and the female interviewer said that "United are unlikely to choose an inexperienced manager like David Moyes next time around."

Now forgive me if I'm wrong but wasn't David Moyes manager of Everton in the Premier League for ELEVEN years – hardly inexperienced is he?

Thomas Lennon
18 Posted 22/04/2014 at 13:57:10
I was one of those who feared for the future when Moyes left, thought he would do well at Man Utd.

For the first – well, Martinez, has indisputably done well and there are few fears left there, a great appointment.

Moyes was undone at Man Utd by the players when he was supposed to be creating a new dynasty. It seems you can't lower expectations and get away with it – however the players are now running that team (literally) which is the precise opposite of what Ferguson wanted.

The new manager will have to be agreed with senior players – just like Chelsea & Man City before them. It hasn't worked at those two clubs too well this year so an interesting future lies ahead at Man Utd.

Will the board stand up to them? I think they will want to put this rebellion down quickly. I can see them looking to Anfield for their next manager.

Kunal Desai
19 Posted 22/04/2014 at 14:12:44
Maybe all the idiot jouno's and the brainless media will now change their take on Moyes and say that not only did he fail at Man Utd – he also FAILED at Everton.

He never won anything at a big club for 11 years so the writing should have been on the wall before he was appointed Man Utd manager. Of course none of these fools will swallow their pride and admit it.

It would be nice if we'd got a bit of recognition from the fact that perhaps those aside from supporting this club see Moyes as a failure at Everton now.

James Marshall
20 Posted 22/04/2014 at 14:10:51
On a human level I feel sorry for Moyes - being sacked isn't a nice thing and to have it happen so soon after his appointment, and so publicly I don't wish on anyone.

Having said that, he was on a hiding to nothing taking the job as nobody really expected him to work wonders in the first season post-SAF. At this point in time it was always going to be a slightly poisoned chalice, but he basically failed to deliver his remit, which would surely have been (minimum) a 4th placed finish, and possibly a cup.

He failed to deliver, handled the media badly, portrayed himself and the team/club negatively so only really has himself to blame.

I'm not one bit surprised they've fired him now, given that they will now have time to find a replacement well before next season. The issue they have is who's really available? Klopp? Why would he leave Dortmund? Simeone? Barely a word of English and why would he leave Atletico? Martinez? Why would he leave Everton? Guardiola? Hahahaha. I think that really leaves them with van Gaal as the man to take it. They missed the boat by not getting SAF to leave a year earlier and getting Mourinho in so they've shot themselves in the foot big time, IMO.

As for Moyes? I have a feeling he might take a year off now, given his 11 years with us and now this debacle.

Anthony Jones
21 Posted 22/04/2014 at 14:12:51
Today is a day to remember for many of us Evertonians!

The patronising pro-establishment media have totally about-faced on their opinion of The Chosen One.

Fellaini may never play for United again, to his father's amazement.

Phil Neville might stay off Twitter for more than 12 hours.

If we could sneak the top 4, five years of waiting for Moyes to move on will be a distant memory.

What a season this could be!

Harold Matthews
22 Posted 22/04/2014 at 14:25:39
He probably lost the dressing room a while back. Using a Jagielka video as a coaching aid for their medal winning centre backs would not have gone down too well. Maybe we can now enjoy ToffeeWeb without his name being mentioned on every thread.
Trevor Lynes
23 Posted 22/04/2014 at 14:25:53
He had probably the safest job in the Premier League at Everton and was very probably tempted by his good old pal Ferguson who was obviously pushing for him to go to Man Utd. Old Alex left while the going was good; even though Manchester United won the league, it was apparent that the old playing style was waning and some of the stars were coming to the end of their days. Like Rooney before him, he was weaned away by tapping up tactics long before he left.

Possibly thinking he had taken us as far as he could and believing the plaudits that came his way he was convinced he was stepping up in his career. I don't blame him for leaving but I also do not feel sorry for him either. I do not like Man Utd as a club because for so many years they have been the media darlings and all their past woes at not winning titles have been glossed over or ignored.

They dare to say that Alex Ferguson is the greatest ever manager when past managers of other clubs have established fine teams without spending billions or using foreign players. Teams like Chelsea and Man City were a laughing stock when the playing fields were equal and Man Utd were mostly amongst the also-rans.

I just hope that they do not bounce back too soon as if it just a matter of throwing billions of pounds at buying everyone and sundry then the league itself is devalued. Moyes did a good job for us and left a decent squad which has been added to and polished by Roberto. The King is dead, long live the King!

Sharabi Singh
24 Posted 22/04/2014 at 14:38:39
If only he had done things completely differently when leaving us I may have some sympathy for him. After all he did steady the ship and guide continually away from the falls off the bottom half. I'm happy we got to hammer the last nail in his coffin.
Ian Burns
25 Posted 22/04/2014 at 14:45:43
Like every Evertonian (and of course the world of football), I have been following this story for the past 24/48 hours. I have read every single post on TW and I would be less than honest if I didn't admit to being quietly pleased at this man's demise, if for no other reason than his attitude towards this wonderful club since he left for "greener pastures" (my arse as a well known comedian might say!).

I wasn't actually going to comment because all that needed to be said has been said here on TW.

However, I read Michael Kenrick's report with a growing smile as I worked my way through it, as I realised Michael thoroughly enjoyed writing this piece and I wouldn't be surprised if he framed it and hung it in his toilet!

Anthony Lewis
26 Posted 22/04/2014 at 14:43:30
I genuinely feel sorry for Moyes, I never thought I would say that, but there you go.
He gave us some decent years and certainly gave us back some respectability, even if it was constantly played down by himself, the media and Phil "Manchester" Neville.
But it's blatantly obvious now that it was Moyes holding us back and not, as he would try to make us believe, us holding him back.
He just isn't that brilliant manager he thought he was. He had a certain way of doing things that is probably good enough to keep a team in the top 10, but outside of the top 5. A slightly better version than Pulis.
Shane Corcoran
27 Posted 22/04/2014 at 14:46:30
Trevor Lynes, I think I remember United winning the double with a bunch of kids. Who are these managers that are better than Ferguson?
Also, can someone explain the "Everton being done out of compensation" part to a simpleton like me?
Moyes's contract was up at the end of last season so if he left earlier and we got compensation then surely we'd have had to spend that on the wages of the newly appointed manager? Am I missing something apart from possibly paying the new guy less for the short period we're speaking of?
James Martin
28 Posted 22/04/2014 at 14:34:17
I honestly think that the success or failure of any managerial appointment is down to a combination of players and owners expectations.

Let's take Liverpool for example, its 2008 they've just played in the EC final then Rafa leaves (hypothetically). They immediately appoint Rodgers who has a disastrous first window, buys all his own players at inflated prices and finishes with no European football. Had this series of events occured he would have been fired. The players believed they were euro champs and the owners would be expecting a title tilt. Instead Hodgson took this brunt, dampened expectations and then Dalglish also took a bit of this. It took 2 seasons for Liverpools players and owners to suddenly think 'maybe we're not entitled to success'. The players, humbled and now finally looking at themselves could now contemplate listening to a rookie like Rodgers. The owners, starved of european football can now bear the thought of allowing a man a year to rebuild. Rodgers still performs to a sackable level first season, but given the context this is now ok. They then win the title in their second season. Given a different time perod Liverpool could have fired a title winning manager for falling below expectations.

This is not saying Moyes would have done the same, of course not, just how timing plays a crucial role.

Now the new Spurs boss will come in and top 4 will be a huge achievement for him, the same achievement that got Redknapp and Villas Boas fired. Sherwood has effectively performed the Hodgson/Moyes role.

If Martinez had arrived in 2002 would we have stayed up that season? Could he have got us established in the top 7 in a way he couldnt with Wigan? We may have cast him aside not knowing that for 2014 Everton he is the perfect manager.

Thats why are playing staff deserve so much praise. Like United's or Liverpool's under Hodgson it wouldhave been so easy to consider themselves too big for Martinez from Wigan. Instead they humbled themselves to take everything in and give everything for the new manager. It didnt take us having to fire two managers for the players to realise they werent right and that they do need the help of a manager.

Craig Walker
29 Posted 22/04/2014 at 14:53:33
I liked Moyes during his tenure until the FA Cup semi-final capitulation against the RS. I thought we had the better team than them and after going a goal up we should have reached another cup final. His KITAP1 philosophy kicked in yet again and that was the end for me. When Wigan played us off the park the following season I wanted Martinez as manager. I got derided by some mates for voicing this opinion - "but he got Wigan relegated".

My feelings for Moyes rapidly declined with his quotes about "the will to win even in training" at Old Trafford and the insulting bid he made. This summer we got a manager who set a 70 point target instead of a 40 point threshold and a change in the whole ethos of the club. This has been one of the best seasons since the mid 80s. Just unfortunate that it has coincided with the RS getting results and playing well.

I can see Moyes going to Newcastle or Villa and doing a decent job but he must reflect back on what he had this time last year and wonder where it all went wrong. The grass isn't always greener. The double whammy is that a more flambouyant manager has proved that his self diagnosed glass ceiling for plucky old Everton doesn't actually exist when you are prepared to take risks and play a more possession based style of football.

Ross Edwards
30 Posted 22/04/2014 at 14:41:41
As I expected. Totally out of his depth. Not good enough or tactically aware to manage a club like Man Utd. The fact that he was tactically outclassed by players he knew for over 5 years sums him up.

He lost the support of the board and lost the dressing room. A dead man walking for over two months.

He disrespected us completely, not even having the decency to praise us for our performance on Sunday. I have no sympathy for the man. Mid table manager, clearly not good enough for a top club.

The pundits and others who thought that we'd collapse from within afer "the Moyesiah" bounced out in royal triumph have been proved wrong. Humble pie all round methinks.

Anyway, enough of that ginger miser, and on with our Spanish Maestro Roberto...

Ray Said
31 Posted 22/04/2014 at 15:00:26
The only similarities between Moyes and Ferguson are the accent and they both stand to have a slash-although Man Utd fans now query that one.
Shane Corcoran
32 Posted 22/04/2014 at 15:02:30
I don't think anyone was comparing the two Ray.
Bill Gall
33 Posted 22/04/2014 at 14:32:52
I am sorry to hear about David Moyes being sacked as it also means a number of the back room staff are being sacked as well who were only doing what he told them to do..

Regardless of my personal feelings about the man and his actions after he left Everton I do not think the board or SAF looked at his lack of experience in Europe or handling the type of players in an aging squad or the problems in rebuilding the team, and still expected him to qualify in the top four.

Football is a cruel business that, in today's environment, the only thing that matters is winning and at a club the size and previous successes of Man Utd there is no room for rebuilding without winning.

People are sacked in all businesses every day some deserve it and some don't but the bottom line is: in football there is an awful lot of people outside of the organisation who can influence the board.

Richard Lyons
34 Posted 22/04/2014 at 14:46:27
Shame - I think Man Utd deserve at least another season of the mediocrity that Moyes would have continued to deliver. The worry is that a new manager like van Girl will be able attract many more talented players than Moyes would have been able to, and that will push up prices all round.

While Moyes was good for us, and worked wonders at first, everything stood still in the last few years. And I think the best thing of all he did for us was to pay us £27.5 million for a crap player like Fellaini! The last time I saw him play, he reminded me of Pip Neville: completely incapable of passing the ball forward.

I wonder where we'll see Moyes next... Spurs? :-)

Jack Holmes
35 Posted 22/04/2014 at 15:09:15
"If anybody wanted to leave [Everton], they'd be poorer for it. Most people that have left here, it's not tended to work out for them." David Moyes, 2012.
Ray Robinson
36 Posted 22/04/2014 at 15:06:44
I was one who thought that things had become stale under Moyes and wanted a change. He was ultimately always too negative minded for my liking and blotted his copybook big style in the close season after leaving. However, I refuse to rejoice in his demise. We shouldn't forget what he did for us. We're supposed to be a club with a touch of old-fashioned class.
Plato Stavrinos
37 Posted 22/04/2014 at 15:09:28
At least we don't have to see him in a suit now :-)
Brian Waring
38 Posted 22/04/2014 at 15:10:06
Richard, just don't see him as a fit for Spurs. Could see Newcastle if they fucked Pardew off, the only problem is they were up in arms over the type of football under Allardyce, would they be happy with more of the same under Moyes.
Brian Waring
39 Posted 22/04/2014 at 15:16:59
Ray we are a club with class, but the classless way Moyes left and all the shite afterwards, he deserves everything he gets.

As of this morning, Moyes's reputation is in pieces.

Brent Stephens
40 Posted 22/04/2014 at 15:14:20
As Harold #487 says, "Maybe we can now enjoy ToffeeWeb without his name being mentioned on every thread." Here, here to that, Harold. Though my guess is that some still won't be able to let go. OCD.

DM - get back on the horse as soon as you can and ply your trade.

My satisfaction is that this has happened to United.

Brian Waring
41 Posted 22/04/2014 at 15:27:24
Like this
pic.twitter.com/tCcv37IXcP
Vinny Garstrokes
42 Posted 22/04/2014 at 15:04:16
I am also in the minority who feel sorry for Moyes. He obviously has to take responsibility for his actions and I am sure will spend a fair bit of time reflecting prior to picking up a prime pundit spot for the World Cup.

For my twopenneth, I think one of his greatest mistakes was appointing Steve Round when Alan Irvine went off to Preston 3 years or so ago. The defensive mindset was then well and truly entrenched in our club and DM became a big-game bottler. Not a trait that was going to easily transfer to OT.

That team knew how much a win at Goodison would have meant to OFM and they never even bothered turning up – that is what spoke volumes to me. Of his staff, it was accepted by us. I think Chris Woods has done really well as De Gea has come on leaps and bounds this season and if Man Utd had any sense they should keep him on the staff. I am also prepared to forgive DM for his outbursts with the media about standing in players way etc etc. He was quite clearly completely out of his depth and did not allow the David Moyes pre-2010 to turn up at Old Trafford and tried to talk the talk expected of an office of one of the biggest clubs in the world which I believe did not portray him in a true light. COYB

Simon Smith
43 Posted 22/04/2014 at 15:26:25
Congratulations Agent Moyes. Job well done!, your next task if you care to accept it is to get a job within the ranks of Anfield.......
This message will self destruct in 10...9...8...7....
Michael Kenrick
44 Posted 22/04/2014 at 15:23:49
Yes, Ian, some pleasure in seeing the charmless charlatan finally brought down to earth with a bang. I'd better print it off before Lyndon has a fit.

But I have to say, any joy is tinged with sadness: I would have much preferred he had stayed at Man Utd and carried on the great work he had started this season. Nothing could have been better than returning the Champions to the mid-table obscurity he had us believing was our lot in life.

"Magnificent 7th"? For me, I think that said it all.

Sadly, they will probably get someone in who is actually a good manager now and that prospect gives me no pleasure at all.

Terry McLavey
45 Posted 22/04/2014 at 15:18:07
I would have like to seen him stay and have them fight off relegation next season! But there you go...

As for feeling sorry for him being sacked? It's not quite like one of us being sacked, leaving your ex-place of work with your stuff in two carrier bags wondering how you pay your bills? I think the figure of compensation for him is in the region of £5 mill!! (and no that hasn't happened to me I just have a vivid imagination!) So bill-paying certainly won't be a problem! Or holidays for that matter!

Kevin Rowlands
46 Posted 22/04/2014 at 15:21:14
Dave #456, hats off to you sir for having the balls to come on here and admit you were wrong, there are a few others on here who should follow suite.

David Moyes — total fraud, he didn't even last one fucking season in his dream job. Completely found out, no sympathy whatsoever from me.

David Price
47 Posted 22/04/2014 at 15:26:32
The delight is in the fall of Man Utd. Moyes is no longer the enemy, let his name rest in pieces!!
Phil Bellis
48 Posted 22/04/2014 at 15:36:25
Mr Vinegar (512)

Strange that Woods' presence should be seen as the reason for De Gea's improvement... I see his absence as the reason for Howard's improvement

Paul Ferry
49 Posted 22/04/2014 at 15:19:22
There is a lot to be learned from the last 12 months of the life of David William Moyes and I suspect that right now he is going through an agony of introspection and reflection.

I never thought that he would be a success in his last job – remember the lads and lasses on here saying as some sort of vindication of his last years here, lampooning and lambasting others who never thought he would get such a big job, and remember too many of the same voices urging us to tread carefully about dumping Moyes because we never know who we might get next!

Well! Who was on the right side of good judgment in that one! Moyes today – and let's not forget that he's one proud and stubborn geezer – is humiliated and a laughing stock for many while our Bobby is being lauded as one of the very best 40-ish gaffers across Europe.

He never looked comfy. The sour and dour personality is simply not attractive, energizing, reassuring, or encouraging. He was always out of his depth and quite frankly the club could not trust him with a bumper window kitty and activated the 4th place clause.

Regrets? I've got so many: should I have left Everton? ... why did I treat Everton the way I did after I left them acting as the big boy in the 'biggest club in the world'? ... why did I leave the safest job in football? ... why did I pick 51 different line-ups in 51 different matches? ... why did I buy Fellaini? ... why did I clear out the backroom staff and bring in hieroglyphics and the boys? ... why did I ever think that I would be able to compete with the very best in Europe? ... why was I not able to take Everton to the level and quality that the former Wigan relegated manager has in only one season? ... and so on and so on.

It was clear to me that on Sunday and at other times that the a significant number of Man Utd players were no longer behind their gaffer. It will be interesting to hear what some of them say in months to come!

Anyone else think that there might be a new spring in Rooney's step this bright day!

Funny but part of me is smirking at Hieroglyphics more than Moyes and silly I'm-going-to-have-a-heart-attack-any-minute-now-chubby-Lumsy who dashed for the door as soon as ginger called but then again Martinez would have got rid I suppose.

Yep, I do feel a warm glow of I suppose smug satisfaction in Moyes's P-45 but that it tempered to some extent by a basic human empathy for the suffering of others and in this case what humiliating suffering!

Moyes will not now get another top top top job. His perch is down the league somewhere in Walling-world 7ish (come back Phil!) He will not land the Spurs job - not after the total screw-up of taking a Chelski reject.

And that's what Moyes is now: a reject... twelve months after he rejected us. He will have to look down the league. Wonder where Moyes and his REO Speedwagon and Styx box-sets will end up next? My hunch is Villa (if Lerner packs his money bags), Newcastle (Pardew must go), or coming up on the rails Leeds who will want a new fella in the hot seat now that the dodgy Italian has taken over – not really a Moyes sort of chairman but there are not too many Kenwright's out there as you will find out in the years ahead.

Anyone fancy a 10 million fire-sale big for Felli? Not me! But Hernandez and Welbeck would be nice.

Christopher Kelly
50 Posted 22/04/2014 at 15:08:45
After stabilizing the ship, and getting the plaudits he deserved, after about the 5th or 6th season, things certainly became stale for me and us as fans. We became bored as the 6ths, 7ths and 8ths rolled in every season.

That's where I became jaded with him, his tactics and I soon had this feeling that there is a wink-wink deal with Moyes: Keep us on the PL gravy train and we'll give you just enough £££ to stay in the top half... The fans will be placated, Moyes will be fed (£5m annually; the TOP paid manager in the game WTF?) and they the Board can remain somewhat blameless as TV money triples.

I was scared shitless. Am I going to blink and in another 10 years, still have this mid-table mickey at the helm? The owners don't seem to mind? it was literally SCARY to me.

All I can say is thank goodness for SAF as his and Moyes's ego is the only thing that finally brought RM and any hope into town after all of these years. Then when Moyes did a Men In Black and forgot about the past 12 years in the span of a month, he really was believing his own hype and couldn't imagine working for a "not top 4" club again. It couldn't have been scripted any other way.

For us to feel bad for this man after what he did to us would be the same kind of softness and need I say "little club" mentality that has plagued us for over 20 years. Get shit on and then feel empathy for the shitter?? HAHA sorry, not I. I want to win.

The difference in class was demonstrated last week when the Red Devils came into town. RM called for calm, politeness and respect, whereas Moyes backhandedly saluted RM's work by saying he's building off of the bricks that he laid in seasons past. He's of course right to a point but how disrespectful as deep down he knows he could only muster a top 6 finish from the lot and not in a million years be able to convince, Barca, Chelsea and Man City to loan out their stars!

In life people always get sussed out. I had told everyone that would listen that Moyes would be out by season's end. I was worried a few weeks ago as their results seemed to be turning. But at this point I know what he is, and that is a mid-table manager in the Pardew, Steve Bruce mold. That's what he is and that's where he'll end up.

Ian Burns
51 Posted 22/04/2014 at 15:42:57
Michael, I could see the pleasure it gave you - but don't worry, the new manager will be Louis Van Gaal - at least I hope it is - the most overrated manager in Europe (or at least the second most overrated!!).

Sean Kelly
52 Posted 22/04/2014 at 15:58:20
Message for the failed ginger one..."Last chance to beat early bird window for season tickets". Here's your chance to come and see how football is supposed to be played and, knowing you're a tight git, it's your chance to save a few quid.

Kevin Tully
53 Posted 22/04/2014 at 15:43:18
There wasn't one sports hack in the entire country (except a couple of F365 writers) who questioned his appointment last summer. It seemed every one was briefed to say what an excellent choice Fergie had made. Oh how they have changeed their tune this morning - it seems they knew all along he was the wrong choice!

Meanwhile, over at ToffeeWeb there were many of us who sat open-mouthed on hearing the news he had been given the Utd gig on a silver platter. A title winning machine, with a free reign to spend like a drunken sailor. Had they sat through a full match at Goodison for a few consecutive games? Surely the world of football knew he had limitations? Fergie must have thought that a corporate monster like Utd would carry him along and make him a serial trophy winner in his image.

Well Fergie, you badly misjudged that one me arl cock - you should have read EXACTLY what many of realised years ago. He was a percentage man who got lucky. A one dimensional manager, who relied as much on the hoof to Fellaini as he did on Baines & Pienaar. They were his only two tricks - I could have told you that.

If the 81 crosses vs Fulham (when they had a 6' 7" centre half ) didn't make you cringe, I'm sure telling everyone Liverpool were favourites at Old Trafford did.

Good riddance.

Phil Bellis
54 Posted 22/04/2014 at 16:12:05
David Price (521)

Yep...gone and forgotten
End of an error

Kev Thomas
55 Posted 22/04/2014 at 16:01:15
We can take advantage of this- If we could only tempt Steve Round and his "amazing bumper book of set-plays for boys" back (written with the help of the iggulden brothers I believe)
Craig Whitham
56 Posted 22/04/2014 at 16:15:38
Kevin #529 It's well known that one of the essential criteria for being a sports hack is a degree in Hindsight!
Scott Goin
57 Posted 22/04/2014 at 16:15:20
Without instant success at United, it was clear to me that Moyes was always going to be the rebound girlfriend. United just got through with a very long-term and successful relationship and obviously were still hung up on Sir Alex. It was too soon for them to give their love to another manager.

Moyes certainly made mistakes but there were a lot of things that attributed to Man Utd's poor season. I'm sure he'll move on to someplace like Newcastle and proceed to get them into top 8 for the next 5 years. That's kind of his niche.

John Keating
58 Posted 22/04/2014 at 16:18:56
Do I feel sorry for a 50 odd year old losing his job ? Dead right I do, because the poor bugger, at that age, will probably never work again in this day and age.
He'll have to soldier on until his shite state pension comes around.
Do I feel sorry for a 50 odd year old manager losing his job ?
Dead right I don't !!
The money the two faced bastard got from us over the 11 years. The 4 million he got this season and the 4 million pay off.
He'll be back working somewhere next season that's for sure.
Back stabbing bastard deserves everything he gets.
Paul Andrews
59 Posted 22/04/2014 at 16:38:43
Found out as a tactically naive manager.

Found out as a PE teacher when dealing with grown men.

Found out as a frightened manager,obsessed with stopping the opposition at the expense of attacking football.

Found out indeed

Joseph Foster
60 Posted 22/04/2014 at 16:41:05
Sky news reporting that Giggs is "taking care of affairs" you couldn't make it up
Richard Reeves
63 Posted 22/04/2014 at 16:14:22
Listening to the radio last night and heard some interesting stories or rumours about Moyes from Mike Parry of Talksport.

Apparently on the Man Utd pre-season tour of Australia, Moyes took the Squad for a walk along a beach where previously he had taken the Everton squad. When he did it with Everton, there were quite a few fans wanting autographs, particularly Cahill's, but with Man Utd the squad was mobbed. Moyes found it all too difficult to deal with and was found in a local restaurant leaving the players to deal with it all. At this early stage the players had already felt he was out of his depth and couldn't handle the expectation that goes with being the manager.

Another rumour was when showing Man Utd defenders how to defend, he used a video of Jagielka at Everton which infuriated the older players like Ferdinand and Vidic.

This one had me laughing a little: During a home game, Phil Neville jumped of his seat to give Giggs a rollocking about how and where he should play... to which an argument erupted at the end of the match with Giggs telling Neville how he's won all these medals and that it was Neville who left the club because of a lack of ability and can't really play football. But it was Moyes who received most of Giggs's anger, accusing him of allowing the situation to happen in the first place.

Darryl Ritchie
64 Posted 22/04/2014 at 16:35:17
The funny thing thing is, with Moyes being sacked at ManUtd, his time at Everton has finally come to an end. Everyone have one last go, pro or con, and let it go.

Time for Moysey to become an entry in the Everton dictionary. He's become irrelevant.

Ray Said
65 Posted 22/04/2014 at 16:48:00
Giggs quoted as saying 'David Moyes has been like a brother to me'.
Steavey Buckley
66 Posted 22/04/2014 at 16:51:09
Moyes no nonsense style of football combined with hard work and consistency won't even be accepted by the Everton faithful anymore, so won't be welcomed back here as manager again. Everton have gone Latin with consistency and hard work combined with flair, imagination and lots of skill on the ball.
Linda Morrison
67 Posted 22/04/2014 at 16:47:06
I'm also in the minority that feel sorry for the way Moyes was treated by the club. It was the cowards way out to let it slip yesterday and then not even have the decency to speak to the man direct sacked by text or tweet not sure which one.

having said that if you go off and swim with sharks you risk getting eaten by them as he was.

The players as far as I am concerned need to leave the playground behind and act like the adults- very well paid- they are supposed to be.

Group bullies and sulks as has happened to others. AVB etc. All managers in whatever field come in and change things. Unless you as an employee are being victimised you do your job and get on with it. The players all thought they were better than him maybe some of them are, but he was given the job and he should have been allowed to get on with it.
I would like anyone on this site to explain to me how with a debt of at least £400 million can have a transfer chest of over £200 million!

Albert Perkins
68 Posted 22/04/2014 at 17:02:50
Game of thrones.

You either win and become king, or lose your head.
Well, your job, but it might feel like he has lost his head.

Brian Waring
69 Posted 22/04/2014 at 17:00:06
Ray, it's funny Giggs saying that. My other half's brother is a Manc season ticket holder.He said reports from the training ground were that Giggs thought Moyes was a joke, eventually calling Moyes a clown because he sent the strikers to do 2 hours of defensive work.
Richard Dodd
70 Posted 22/04/2014 at 16:54:56
So, so many ungrateful Evertonians seeking to re-write history. Moyes was a very good manager here whilst so many of his peers at richer clubs were found wanting.

It is difficult to identify any of these who would have done such a god job of stabilising Everton and setting it up for Martinez to 'take on'.

It has become a popular pastime for people to deride his achievements and it will be interesting to see if his much vaunted successor can actually IMPROVE on his regular top six finishes over time.

Brian Waring
71 Posted 22/04/2014 at 17:04:40
Linda, Man U did lack class they way they dealt with it, but for me it's karma because of the classless way Moyes went, and then all the shit he came out with afterwards.

Ray Roche
72 Posted 22/04/2014 at 17:12:51
Ray Said @548

"Giggs quoted as saying 'David Moyes has been like a brother to me'"

Are you inferring that Giggs was boning Moyes Missus?

Ian Burns
73 Posted 22/04/2014 at 17:07:31
Linda - it is all down to market value and the company's record on paying off its interest payments on time. If they are paying off their interest along with capital debt and the stock market (New York) is providing stock value at a level their banks are happy with; then their ability to borrow more funds against that said valuation rises.
Kevin Rowlands
74 Posted 22/04/2014 at 17:13:55
Linda, besides the classless way he left Everton I think there is also about 5 million other reasons not to feel sorry for him if the figures being thrown around are right.
Brian Denton
75 Posted 22/04/2014 at 17:22:06
But let's face it, Man U coming was probably the only way we (or rather Bill and the board) were ever going to get rid of him. Trebles all round, so to speak.
Linda Morrison
76 Posted 22/04/2014 at 17:18:56
Kevin it's £10 million he is going to get not £5 million.

I think that Mu are going to get a very good lesson in reality check when they find how hard it will be to get a new man in.The Klopp fella has already said no

It's a shame that Kevin and probably Distin will miss the rest of the season, I think we are going to get into top 4 though even without them

Ben Dyke
77 Posted 22/04/2014 at 17:14:36
"Sky news reporting that Giggs is "taking care of affairs" you couldn't make it up"

Haha! Brilliant! As long as Giggs doesnt have to advise the players about off-field stuff then he'll do fine. The players will obviously look up to him and now go out and 'emulate' him by having affairs with their own brothers wives!

Tony McNulty
78 Posted 22/04/2014 at 17:18:29
I loved the thank you from the Manure.

His three qualities were listed as "hard work, honesty and integrity."

Anyone ever had a similar reference on a potential employee? I think we all know what these sorts of assessments really mean.

They should perhaps have added, "good to his mother", and "warm with a pulse."

Kevin Day
79 Posted 22/04/2014 at 17:06:05
Living in the Midlands, I've said to a few Villa fans today at work that I'd stick a tenner on Moyes landing at at Villa park, every answer was a resounding "NO THANKS".

I returned with you wouldn't of said that 12 months ago.

Their answer was pretty much; "yeah, but we can all see for ourselves how negative his tactics are, we already have that with Lambert".

I guess Moyes needs to go to the championship and reinvent himself.

Si Cooper
80 Posted 22/04/2014 at 16:59:52
I actually feel slightly insulted that the defeat on Sunday appears to have been the final straw for a lot of observers. You don't know a lot about football if you hadn't already realised that United would be very lucky indeed to finish much above 7th, and that Everton have consistently produced the better performances, this season.

I have been very surprised with OFM's failure to address the obvious defensive deficiencies in the squad he inherited. It is as though his famed defensive sensibilities have gone awry and he has all but forgotten (or dismissed) what made him so useful to Everton (as we were when he took over).

Too many changes to the back-room staff; not enough to the playing staff. Evidence that he believed that his influence (supported by trusted lieutenants) was sufficient to get the best out of any player?

Max Wilson
81 Posted 22/04/2014 at 17:05:26
A lot of us gradually became frustrated with our lack of progress under DM but lets not forget he did restore our pride in ourselves and signed some useful players. 60% of us were worried about RM but have now learned to trust him.DM made himself hated by Toffees when he was trying to nick our players. DM's lack of success at the top level is his weakness and when he began to struggle with a team that needed totally rebuilding , his previous record or lack of it, gradually lost him support with management and fans-no-one trusted him to deliver (altho here and there he got some good results out of the jaded team he inherited).Should we feel sorry for him, is it unfair to be pleased he's had the sack? No.He was the wrong choice for United and he came back to us and bit the hands that
had fed him.
Drew Shortis
82 Posted 22/04/2014 at 17:34:02
Moyes will be back at some point (not here, god forbid!) with a mid table team like West Ham or Stoke and I have no doubt he will do a good job turning them into a competitive outfit looking at top half finishes and stability. The Man United job was just too big for him and, as Martinez has already proved, so is the Everton job. The glass ceiling he battled against seems to be one in his own mind. I don't hold a grudge against the man as he did good things for our club and I wish him well for the future. I'm just happy we now have a manager who's ambition matches the fans!
David Denby
83 Posted 22/04/2014 at 17:42:38
Think it's worth a tenner on him ending up at Newcastle in the summer, think they're made for eachother. Can't see Mike Ashley giving Round a colour printer though, he might have to go back to crayons for his Set Play brochure!
Mike Gaynes
84 Posted 22/04/2014 at 17:20:36
Darryl Ritchie (547), best post of the day. Maybe the initials OFM will never be used here again, and it's overdue.

I was a big Moyes supporter when he was here.. recognized his limitations but thought he did a good job overall, and better than most. I also thought Moyes would ultimately fail at ManU, that the job was too big for him, but I admit to being stunned that he didn't even make it through his first season. As for feeling sorry for him, no, he took a chance that any manager would dream of and got very wealthy in the process, and he will manage again in the Prem, so no sympathy necessary. He'll be fine.

I do not, however, share the anger at his post-Everton behavior or the glee at his ManU demise. I was just never emotionally involved in Moyes' departure... I actually got to Darryl's point immediately and considered him irrelevant from the moment he left. And I found the "derisory" Baines/Fellaini bids entertaining, not infuriating, especially when it backfired on him so badly and we got a truly ridiculous transfer fee for Fellaini alone. We will benefit from that blunder for years to come, and I don't slate Moyes for that, I thank him cheerfully.

And as for ManU acting classlessly, that's been going on for decades, which is why I've always reveled in their too-infrequent failures. I feel about them the way most of you feel about the RS... if the Taliban had a team, I'd root for them against ManU. So for whatever damage he has done to the ManU "brand".... thank you again, Mr. Moyes.

Patrick Murphy
86 Posted 22/04/2014 at 17:56:03
It's ironic that DM got the boot from Old Trafford on the second anniversary of possibly his best day at the venue when Everton managed a 4-4 draw which probably cost United the title. It shows how much the Everton squad has changed since 22 April 2012
Howard; Hibbert, Heitinga,Jagielka, Distin(Cahill);Neville,Gibson, Osman(McFadden),Pienaar;Fellaini,Jelavic
Substitutes Muchal,Cahill,Barkley,Stracqualursi,McFadden,Gueye,Anichebe

With only 9 of that squad remaining at Goodison today.

Jack Plant
87 Posted 22/04/2014 at 17:59:56
Don’t Worry David!,
Now you’ve got the sack,
Don’t worry David!
We will take you back,
Don’t worry David,
We’ve got a job for youuuu,

Don’t worry David!
You can sweep the halls,
Don’t worry David!
And even carry the balls,
Don’t worry David!
And polish Martinez’ Shoooes

Ian Hams
89 Posted 22/04/2014 at 17:23:32
The board at Old Trafford new exactly what they were doing, no one was going to fill Fergies boots, it was mission impossible.

What they did was to go for the plausible fall guy, that was Moyes. No chance of success what so ever, but he never saw it coming believing his own hype.

The next boss there will now have an infinitely easier job, that is to rebuild Moyes's destruction as opposed to continuing Fergies legacy. Hence they will be able to get the big name manager who would most probably have ran a mile seeing what was clear to all.

All that being said do I feel sorry for him? No. As has been said by many he has handled him with a distinct lack of class towards his old club. Cue a job mid way through next season at who ever are the premiership struggler's at that time, and at that he will do well for that is his level.

Paul Andrews
90 Posted 22/04/2014 at 18:21:30
Richard Dodd,

11 years is a long long time to stabilise us.

His regular top 6 finishes are in reality an average of 7th by the way.

Brian Hill
91 Posted 22/04/2014 at 17:48:09
I disagree with the notion that Moyes became irrelevant immediately upon his departure. This standard has not been applied to any other Everton manager. Every Everton manager has had an influence upon the Club, if not, why was he here?

Every ex-manager from Carey onwards gets regular or occasional mentions, even the most derided. The difference with Moyes, and the major reason why he can never be consigned to a footnote in our history, is that no other manager to my knowledge, ever tried to reduce Everton Football Club to the status of also-rans, as Moyes did with almost every miserable comment that came from his mouth.

Harold Matthews
92 Posted 22/04/2014 at 18:28:23
Linda. Someone reckons there is a clause in his contract which limits his compo to one years pay if United don't make the Champions League.
Keith Glazzard
93 Posted 22/04/2014 at 18:22:57
They say that everything happens for a reason, and as far as we're concerned we got Roberto and some wonderful football as a result. So be it.
Wayne Smyth
94 Posted 22/04/2014 at 18:26:26
Si(569) that was my immediate reaction too, but apparently they only have to compensate him 1 years cash if they didn't qualify for the CL. I think sunday probably made it mathematically impossible and hence was the time they would do it. I've read somewhere they basically made their mind up around Feb that they were getting rid.

Richard Dodd, rewriting history about Moyes is something you're guilty of too. Saying he did really well for us, or was crap is far too general to represent the job he did over the 11 years.

You could quite reasonably divide Moyes era into two; the first 6 and last 5 years. For the first 6 he was superb. He made some top notch signings, turned around the playing squad, turned us from avoiding relegation to challenging and qualifying for europe.

Although he continued to some sign good players, such as Coleman and Mirallas, he definitely hit a glass ceiling. I heard some lazy hack on radio today saying basically that he was good enough for us, but not for the Manc's. Truth was, he had no clue how to move us on from where we were. The glass ceiling was hit many years ago, as many of us were complaining about. He lacked a winning mentality, had a mistrust of youth and a penchant for playing players out of position.

He would carp on about wanting cash to compete, when we all know we can't compete financially with the other 6 or 7 teams chasing European football. I'm thankful we have a manager now who has found different ways to help us bridge that gap. I think Martinez would've done a superb job at Everton no matter when he took over.

Mike Berry
95 Posted 22/04/2014 at 18:45:15
Lay off Moyes. He did a great job at the Mancs. Now send him to Liverpool?
Kevin Tully
96 Posted 22/04/2014 at 18:42:08
Brian # 587 - You don't have to be a genius to work out why some don't want to discuss Moyes, or his tenure and subsequent failure at the reigning Champions. Some say they are bored of it, or it's irrelevant to our current situation. That couldn't be further from the truth.

If you had just been conned or scammed for a number of years, would you want to talk about it?

Ste Traverse
97 Posted 22/04/2014 at 18:17:12
With 'them' looking like they'll be winning the Prem, I think United missed a trick by announcing this now rather than the sad day the RS clinch it.

Their reaction would be hilarious at being knocked completely off the backpages!

Brian Hill
98 Posted 22/04/2014 at 18:40:29
May I add, although not an original observation in any way, that the media, other fans, man in the street perception of us as plucky, over-achieving, doing well with what we have, lucky to have him idea was invented and promoted by Moyes with the gurning approval of Kenwright.

Pressure on Kenwright now, he has seen what is possible.

Jimmy Sørheim
99 Posted 22/04/2014 at 18:39:46
I was a anti-Moyes guy after the Drenthe situation, and before that when it came to his misuse of youngsters.

I never had faith in him that he could take us further.

I was right. I love it.

But I do feel he was misused by Fergie just to get Rooney signed up on a long term deal. It worked out that way too.

Moyes looks tired and worn out and he should take a few years off to charge himself.

Other then that I do not rate him and hope I never see him again.

Colin Glassar
100 Posted 22/04/2014 at 18:52:48
Good point Ste. Can you imagine the Monday papers covered with, "Moyes sacked" and on page 18, "rs win league"?
Gavin Ramejkis
101 Posted 22/04/2014 at 19:03:46
ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha

Now the Gollum bubble is well and truly burst, two jobbing, self serving, miserable bastard

Frank Duffy
102 Posted 22/04/2014 at 19:03:58
What did it for me was the Spurs game a few years ago. We were down 2 1 with a few minutes to go and Moyes took off a Forward and brought on Hibbett..The booing was intense.

That about summed up the man. The semi cup against Liverpool was another example. At least with Marty its a pleasure to watch the Blues.

Paul Andrews
103 Posted 22/04/2014 at 19:11:24
Gavin,

Can I read into your post you have very little sympathy for said Ginger Mingebag ?

Harold Matthews
104 Posted 22/04/2014 at 18:59:50
Moyes is getting hammered but, unfortunately, so are we. The adjectives people are using to describe his past management level are pretty sickening.
Barry Johnson
105 Posted 22/04/2014 at 19:02:28
I have absolutely no sympathy for Moyes. He did give us stability in those early years, but then got caught up in the media hype that he was a great manager, keeping an underfunded club in the top ten of the premier league.

In his later years at the club, he knew his job was safe and therefore didn't need to achieve much. In fact, achieving anything would have set a precedent for success which would have meant pressure to perform better every season.

Basically, Moyes was a loser, happy to coast along on his enormous salary, never under pressure to achieve.

The media had hyped him up so much that he seemed like a natural successor to Old Whisky Nose. Even Moyes himself fell for the media hype.

Over the last 12 years, Moyes has earnt somewhere in the region of £30,000,000. Now I'm supposed to feel sorry for him?

I Hope the guy rots in the lower leagues for the rest of his career and his armpits become infested with the fleas of a thousand camels.

Dennis Stevens
106 Posted 22/04/2014 at 19:14:02
Are MUFC not in line to finish 7th this season?
Wasn't that his average finish with Everton?
What did they think they were buying?
Sam Hoare
108 Posted 22/04/2014 at 19:15:03
I can't say I feel sorry for him but I really don't think he deserves quite as much gleeful mocking as he's getting on here. Anyone would think he was caught defecating on an Everton flag! (Cue someone ridiculously claiming what he did was worse)

We have come out of the whole thing a lot better than he has and that will do for me.

Jack Cross
110 Posted 22/04/2014 at 19:14:47
Brian Hill. I don't think it's as much about what Moyse did while at Everton, more about how he treated us on leaving and how he went about it. Must have known he was leaving at least the season before. Hence signing no new contract. He was sorting his own future at Man u out while still getting paid by us. Not giving our future a thought. And as for him still managing us (joke) when all in sundry new he was to be Man u next manager, it was all done and dustered. We were a laughing stock. And it showed what a spineless tosser Bill Kenright is. Moyse, stabilised us, then shafted us. Simple as that.
Colin Glassar
111 Posted 22/04/2014 at 19:27:06
I said, pre-season, that ginger would get the boot by Xmas. I was wrong by a few months but I knew he would blow it. His football philosophy is the antithesis of what most manc fans want to watch.
Patrick Murphy
112 Posted 22/04/2014 at 19:29:19
Harold I completely agree with you regards how Everton are coming out of this story - pretty woeful. if Everton had have sacked Moyes after the Semi-Final defeat to Liverpool at Wembley in the same way as Man U have just got rid of Moyes we would have been hammered by the press.

The press are now starting to sound as if Moyes joined Man U from a lower league club who then had the audacity to beat them home and away and have no right to do so at any time.

It won't be long before Everton will be getting the blame for every ill in the English game when in point of fact it is the likes of Man U Liverpool, City and Chelsea who are the real enemies of the game in this country

The quicker the four of them teams piss off to a European super league the better and we can once more enjoy the sport for what it is a distracting past-time and not a commercial enterprise with a football club bolted onto it.

Paul Washington
113 Posted 22/04/2014 at 19:12:40
Was the job too big for him ?
Yes for 11 years!
Jack Cross
114 Posted 22/04/2014 at 19:33:41
Colin. Would you let him spend 2oomil of your money? Not in a million years. He'll probably end up at Newcastle and do similar there as he did for us and no more. But one thing you can guarantee they won't win anything either. And if you call that success, he can have it.

Just listening to Jose Morinio, Said he felt sorry for Moyse, but no further comment. But I think reading his face, it said the job was too big for him and he should have got it, Maybe he should have.

Patrick Murphy
115 Posted 22/04/2014 at 19:50:26
Jack - I wouldn't rule the special one out of the running for the Man U job. Chelsea's owner is person non-grata in the current political environment and without Roman's millions Chelsea would struggle.
Dennis Ng
116 Posted 22/04/2014 at 19:41:06
This should have been old news but it wasn't probably due to the math of UCL elimination mentioned above. Given the performance through the Jan transfer window, why would a team logically give a man, who has not delivered, (granted, its only rumored) $200M to spend in the summer transfer season? Roman is not even half as patient. I definitely concur about them doing so now only to avoid contractual disputes.

As for sympathy, that went out the window after his posturing to get Baines. Credit to him for stabilizing the team but I've not heard of many managers who would go sniping his old team that he had "succeeded" with, however trophyless they are for the past 10 years.

Sean Kelly
118 Posted 22/04/2014 at 19:45:22
Colon. "His football philosophy is the antithesis of what most manc fans want to watch." You are only partially right. It's the antithesis of all proper football fans. The only thing is Billy indulged him and we were forced to forget about proper football for eleven years. Thank god we got Roberto.

He did steady the ship but that's such a long time ago. His biggest failing is his philosophy is so outdated and his tactics belong in the conference league. Fuck you Man U for getting rid of him so early. I was looking forward to next season and him blowing the money on new signings and playing them out of position.

Dennis Ng
119 Posted 22/04/2014 at 19:53:27
Currently Van Gaal looks to be the frontrunner. My gut tells me they will try to get Simeone. I dread Simeone on their side more.
Ian Burns
120 Posted 22/04/2014 at 19:56:37
Patrick 629 - I think you will find that Abramovich's billions are now London based.

I hope van Gaal gets the job - despite his success, I don't rate him - you will see what I mean when the media start to interview him.

The most heartbreaking side issue to all of this is I am reading, is that the jump from Everton to Man Utd was too big a leap for Moyes. I have said many times on this site I have supported EFC since the late '50's and in my heart EFC is still a big club (John Moores and all that), - though I'm not stupid enough not to recognise this is no longer the case compared to Man Utd. Nevertheless, I hate it each time I see somebody say it in the press and this inevitable sacking has given them plenty of opportunity to rub it in.

Ah well, I'll go back to my nostalgic dreamland and drink me gin.

Brian Denton
121 Posted 22/04/2014 at 20:10:55
Ian, don't apologise for still thinking of Everton as a big club. We are and we always will be.
Darren Hind
122 Posted 22/04/2014 at 20:00:17
Our ex manager sacked ?

Oh dear, how sad, never mind,

Never quite got why some people were so facinated and would follow his every move as Man U manager. . .I had trouble paying attention when he was here, he was boring as fuck.

I hope he stays out of the game for good, The thought of getting daily updates on what the Geordies or the Baggies are saying about him . . . .

Si Cooper
125 Posted 22/04/2014 at 20:35:16
Ian (#637) - ignore the musings of the ignorant masses.

Moyes's problem was that he inherited a squad that did not suit the way he prefers to play. Either he did not realise it or he thought he could get the players to play his way and so did not do enough to bring in players who he could really utilise (though we don't know exactly how much he dithered and how much he was actively restrained by people like Woodward).

People really underestimate how much the player - coach interaction contributes to producing an effective team / squad, and seem to regard them as more interchangeable than they actually are. The size of the club that surrounds them (and the wages paid to all parties) are immaterial in comparison.

It seems that even an elder statesman like SAF can have this blind-spot, having mis-identified superficial personal similarities as evidence that Moyes had the 'right-stuff' to step into his shoes.

Mike Gaynes
127 Posted 22/04/2014 at 21:15:17
Ian, agree with Si... don't let it break your heart. When they write that Moyes wasn't equipped for this job, it's not a slam at Everton's status. The job was too big because Moyes didn't know how to handle a large transfer budget, didn't know how to man-manage a veteran champion team, couldn't win in Europe and couldn't handle the pressure of living in the shadow of a legend. All things he had never dealt with at Everton and never had the chance to learn.

And Si, good point about this being SAF's failure as well... a huge misjudgement on his part. That red face should be REALLY red now. Which gives me more satisfaction than Moyes' failure.

Daniel Joseph
128 Posted 22/04/2014 at 21:54:48
Dennis Stevens (613)

They didn’t buy anything, they got him on a free. And THAT, is the reason this palaver is so satisfying. He can now pee off to his beloved kraut football and good riddance.

David Smith
130 Posted 22/04/2014 at 22:05:39
Can I just ask a question, I've never known what 'ofm' stands for, could someone enlighten me.
Barry Johnson
131 Posted 22/04/2014 at 22:08:22
OFM = Our Former Manager
Raymond Fox
132 Posted 22/04/2014 at 21:39:18
If SAF thought that Moye's was the correct choice as Utd's new manager, strangely it does not say much for his judgement.

Moye's looked the wrong personality, with an obvious tendency towards defensive football, just what you don't want as an Utd manager, it doesn't reflect well on Ferguson.
Talk about an almighty 'balls up' by a club worth fortunes on the stock market!

To follow Ferguson it should have been one of the worlds top 'name' managers.

Peter Cummings
134 Posted 22/04/2014 at 22:03:06
After a lengthy layoff I would like to contribute to the Moyes debate, Having read the numerous comments one thing has surprised me, namely the fact that DM has been given little credit for the benefits he brought to us.

Tim Cahill, Jags, Seamus Coleman, Leighton Baines, Steve Naismith, Joleon Lescott, and who can forget Landon Donovan. So credit is more than due for these signings, guys.

David Smith
135 Posted 22/04/2014 at 22:11:39
Ah, thanks. Thought it might have stood for something more offensive.
Lewis Barclay
136 Posted 22/04/2014 at 22:30:26
Moyes seems to spark more people into posting on TW than anything else, including our current manager and players.

Might we move on, please?

Graham Mockford
137 Posted 22/04/2014 at 22:36:28
David #676

Now of course OFM squared.

There are some who really disliked him, reading the schadenfreude on here shows you that. The majority of Evertonians were grateful for the things he did achieve hence the reception he got at his final game last season.

However his subsequent lack of respect for the club dented that appreciation and there was clearly a different atmosphere last Sunday.

The truth to my mind is somewhere in between. He stabilised the club, he bought some very good players at knockdown prices. The team of 2008 was despite a bit of history rewriting a damned good footballing side but ultimately he hit his own personal glass ceiling because of his naturally cautious nature and natural distrust of the unproven.

So no real sympathy for him, he can either spend his time counting his money or I'm sure a mid table PL side will come knocking.

Mike Gaynes
138 Posted 22/04/2014 at 23:06:31
Yes, Lewis!

All OCM now.

No more OFM.

Si Cooper
139 Posted 22/04/2014 at 23:02:18
Graham, why OFM squared? His status at United has no bearing on his relationship to our club. He remains OFM until he has a second stint and leaves again (not that I am in favour of that but with BK in charge can we rule it out?).

Lewis, this is a huge news story that reflects directly on our club because of the general assessment that he was a success for us and an abject failure for them. It is relevant and worthy of comment.

Christopher Kelly
140 Posted 22/04/2014 at 23:14:51
I'm not sure if anyone has said this above but I think Moyes will end up in Germany next.
Tommy Coleman
141 Posted 22/04/2014 at 22:55:54
It was a huge error of judgment by Fergie. I thought he'd last 2 years before getting sacked though. I actually wanted him to stay on and blow £150m on players they didn't need, I guess you can't have everything.

Man Utd will struggle to recover from the touch of Moyes, at least 2-3 years. Jurgen Klopp says his brother, Klippety, is willing to replace Moyes.

Kevin Rowlands
142 Posted 22/04/2014 at 23:11:49
Peter #686, he was given plenty of credit when he left and a send off at Goodison fit for a legend. It was HIS subsequent actions and words towards our club after he left, plus the fact that it also came out that he had known about the Utd position for months whilst stringing us along over a new contract that has caused all the bad feeling.

He created the situation himself and for most of us undone any credit for his good work, what goes around comes around as they say.

Dick Fearon
143 Posted 22/04/2014 at 23:35:28
I wonder if big hair has told his interfering dad to keep his frigging trap shut.
Lakovos Lasonidis
144 Posted 22/04/2014 at 23:32:30
God is having a laugh...
Eugene Ruane
145 Posted 22/04/2014 at 22:56:38
Moyes sits at home staring blankly at the TV as pundit after pundit appears on screen to put the boot in.

Morag enters with his favourite, mince and tatties: "Ach Davey, ye canae just sit there fer the rest 'o yer life starin' at that goggle-box. Here, get this doon yer neck"

Moyes: 'I've telt ye Morag, am no hungry, will ye no listen woman?"

Morag: "I'll no hungry YOU in a minute David Moyes, you eat yer dinner and then me an you are gonnae talk"

Wee Sandy enters.

Sandy: "So...are we gonnae be puir the noo?"

Morag: "GET OOT BOY! Dae yer hamework or whitever it is ye have tae dae"

Moyes: "Dae whit yer mother tells ye son and no, we're not goin' tae be puir...as lang as we don't go mad"

Sandy leaves

Morag: "Noo you listen tae me, am sick o' this lang face and miserable carry-oan. So you lost a job, so whit? We move oan, that's whit we dae. Naebody died, we have oor health and oor family and am no gonnae watch you feelin sorry fer yersel for the next three month - got it?"

Moyes: "But, whit am a gonnae..dae"

Morag: "Here's whit WE'RE gonnae dae, we're gonnae go on the holiday of a lifetime, we're gonnae travel, we're gonnae spend money, eat in the finest restaurants, fer once we're gonnae live a little"

Moyes: "You know whit, yer right, nae...yer ABSOLUTELY fucking right. I've been doo-er Davey the presbyterian fer tae lang. Serious, responsible, the man in charge, the man under pressure - well...fuck it! Noo it's time tae 'seize the day', time tae grab a bit o' the auld la dolce vita"

Morag: "You..you MEAN it!?"

Moyes: "Ah dae indeed woman, ave NEVER been mair serious in ma life. We're gonnae show them, we're gonnae show them all. We'll make Beyonce and that singer feller she's married tae, look like a couple o' rustic yokels"

Morag (smiling) "Och Davey, that's wonderful, I'll grab some brochures next time I'm oot!"

They hug.

.

.

.

.

Two weeks later.

Open in a church-yard in Peebles.

It's raining.

Colin Glassar
146 Posted 22/04/2014 at 23:48:46
Is this a new thread? The latest news is ginger might sue united to recover his one and only true love........ His cheque.
David Cornmell
147 Posted 22/04/2014 at 23:49:03
Eugene - you've done it again.
Genius.
Anthony Burke
148 Posted 22/04/2014 at 23:41:04
Moyes transformed our club from relegation material to European material. People have short memories. He was wrongly sacked in my opinion, he should have had at least 2 years to prove himself. He could do a good job at Spurs if not maybe a Dutch or German side .
Graham Mockford
149 Posted 23/04/2014 at 00:14:01
Peter Cummings #686

Add to that list Distin, Howard, Stones, Mirallas, Fellaini, Pienaar, Arteta and Oviedo.

His greatest strength as a manager was unearthing decent quality PL players at a good price.However they are not the qualities required for a team with aspirations of winning titles where you have to buy the best and have the gravitas and respect to lead them which is a total different ball game and in the 10 months he had, he did not seem capable of doing so.

My mam used to come home from Aldi with some cracking bargains but put her in Waitrose and she wouldn't know her moules marinere from her merguez cassoulet.

Kevin Rowlands
150 Posted 23/04/2014 at 00:22:17
Anthony #752, he also won fuck all in eleven years, bottled it in nearly every big game we ever played in, was 0 wins 44 losses at Anfield, Stamford Bridge, Old Trafford and Highbury/Emirates in the league, if you want to go back and discuss his tenure with us then please include the bad as well as the good.

Also you may think he was wrongly sacked, but I guarantee you a huge percentage of Utd fans and players would disagree with you.

Dick Fearon
151 Posted 23/04/2014 at 00:20:08
Amazing how every smart arse media pundit has suddenly discovered that their ginger poster boy, winner of lord knows how many managerial accolades yet his team not once winning any silverware is another King Coracalus.
Kevin Rowlands
152 Posted 23/04/2014 at 00:41:29
I stand corrected: it was 0 wins in 44 tries over 11 years at said grounds above.
Patrick Murphy
153 Posted 23/04/2014 at 00:38:13
According to the Mail - SAF is said to have been one of a group of directors who sealed the fate of DM at a secret meeting on Sunday night. Some bloke, that SAF... one minute, your best friend, and then helps to stab you in the back! Mind you, I thought he had already upped sticks and was off to the States for a teaching role.

I saw on the TV a little while back....I think it may have been the CL game at OT v Olympiacos(?) and SAF was in the stand deep in conversation with somebody and, from what I could lip-read, it looked like SAF was complaining that DM was all set to get rid of Giggs from the club. Another fine upstanding citizen, that Mr Giggs... like a brother to all his team-mates.

I was never that fond of MUFC in the first place but I hope they never get the right guy in and remain in the CL wilderness for a few more years. But at least they gave us a few bob for MF and forced BK to say Tara to DM.

Dick, only Roy Keane, who I like and respect, had the decency to say that the players at Man Utd had let DM down and that they should be ashamed of themselves. Media people you couldn't trust them to tell you the correct time even when they're staring at Big Ben.

Si Cooper
154 Posted 23/04/2014 at 00:57:45
Not sure how you could ever guarantee someone 2 years to prove themselves, but I expected him to get another transfer window and half a season to see if he could make some progress.

I still find the timing a little confusing considering it seems unlikely they will appoint anybody who will be in place and talking to targets before the World Cup.

Maybe the hierarchy weren't impressed by his list of prospective targets (which I assume would be due around this time) and perhaps as mystified as the rest of us by his fairly positive review of the game on Sunday?

Karl Masters
155 Posted 23/04/2014 at 01:10:26
Two years to the day since that 4-4 at Old Trafford. I wonder if anybody would have predicted that evening how it was gong to play out over the following two years?
Bob Parrington
156 Posted 23/04/2014 at 01:01:14
Another sad milestone in the EPL. Everybody has the right to gloat on this one but, to me, it is another bad example of the current state of moneyed football that the guy has not been given a longer period to sort out the mess at Manure.

On departing Everton he had left a club in a far better position than when he joined and it was noticeable vs Manure that 8 of our starting 11 were Moyes charges.

Now, don't get me wrong. I was glad to see him leave and RM has taken the negativity of DM's tactics away, replacing it with positive outlook, self expression on the pitch for the players and greater all round tactical nouse.

I just don't like to see the gloating! We're a better club than this with better supporters than any, with a strong, proud history.

Si Cooper
157 Posted 23/04/2014 at 01:13:23
Roy Keane is an obvious self-motivator and evidently has little regard for others who lack this quality.

It might explain why he hasn't made a successful transition into management despite being an outstanding leader on the pitch.

Peter Z Jones
158 Posted 22/04/2014 at 19:19:21
On behalf of all the former MOB members, we told you so.
Kevin Rowlands
159 Posted 23/04/2014 at 01:17:51
Bob, I would argue with you that it is not gloating, it's just simply satisfaction at seeing him getting his comeuppance for the lies and uncalled-for behavior and attitude to people that had been loyal and supporting to him for eleven years through good and bad.

The Mancs have treated him like a leper the last few months; he needs to think about that.

Keith Simmonds
160 Posted 23/04/2014 at 01:16:55
I don't think there is any proof that we have a better manager than Moyes right now. Martinez hasn't yet achieved anything remember (whereas Moyes made the Everton job attractive to someone ambitious like Martinez who had turned down other big clubs already to appear loyal to Wigan). We are only challenging for 4th due to Spurs falling apart and of course the demise of United. I am not sure we are any better off than before and the football is at times less effective. We played good passing football at times under Moyes so it isn't as if its a totally new concept. Chances are if we still had Moyes we would be in this current position.

Moyes has been badly treated. He should have been given another season at least. Also I don't get this idea about him being unsuitable to be given a war chest of £150m. Moyes strength has always been finding gems of players and making them better that cost a lot less. Players who wealthier clubs than us either covet or have already nicked. Moyes might not have picked them up quite so cheaply as United pay a premium on any signings they make usually but he could have done the same at United in finding the likes of Coleman, Oviedo (the 2 best fullbacks in the league) , Stones not to mention those who we have had longer like Baines, Jags. All those 5 players could easily be playing Champions League for any of the current top 4 sides. Fellaini and Mata are disasters according to some, yet both last season were probably amongst the best in their positions and loved by the fans of the clubs they left. He wouldnt have had to sign them if his chief exec had landed the players they had targeted.

Let's not forget also that Moyes tried to sign Lukaku on loan himself 2 or 3 seasons ago but there was a rule about him not being able to play for more than 2 clubs within 12 months. So the astuteness now being attributed to Martinez is slightly misplaced. Martinez's best signing so far is McCarthy who wasn't cheap so we got what we paid for. I hope we can keep Barry but won't be too fussed if he goes elsewhere. The rest are rubbish and havent raised the standard of the squad at all. Deleoufeu will most probably go back to Barca. He's Martinez's equivalent of Donovan 1st time he came. Was effective for a short period. Crap on the second run.

I don't expect us to get the 4th spot this season and fully expect us to be back down to 6th or 7th next season. Those clubs above and around us will be able to spend big and move their squads forward while we are being linked with Tom Cleverly and £25m Lukaku who is a middling striker (can do a lot better for that sort of money). Ah well at least we will have Kone back next season eh?

The whole Moyes thing this past couple of days and the reactions of journos (but more importantly some of our fans who have been as classless as those hacks enjoying Moyes demise) has put me off football. When share prices go up cos a man loses his job while all around find it so hilarious, you've got to ask yourself why you bother with it all. Well I do anyway.

Harold Matthews
161 Posted 23/04/2014 at 01:51:17
Yeah. They reckon Fergie and the Board decided to sack him 2 or 3 months ago. Waiting till he failed to qualify for the Champions League has saved them a mighty sum.
Keith Simmonds
162 Posted 23/04/2014 at 01:59:35
Should also add that if Moyes gets another Premier League side to manage, chances are that's yet another club who will be pushing us back. Think some people tend not to see the bigger picture just like the United board. Just cos the RS are top, you can't see them staying there for long even if they manage to hang in and win the league this season.

They have the fortune of a fit and ban-free Suarez at the top of his game playing for a move to Real if he is lucky. United potentially are going down the Chelsea route now by bringing in high profile names, rather than getting someone to build a new dynasty for them. Where do we fit into this? We don't. We will be pushing the boundaries just as far as DM was able to all these years. But no further than that.

We will still lose the odd player to a wealthier club. Nothing will really change. And that is only guaranteed with Martinez at the helm. We can only hope he stays as long as Moyes; otherwise we will go backwards and end up like Villa who used to be where we are now.

Or Bill finds a buyer and we really sell our souls once and for all.

John Daley
163 Posted 23/04/2014 at 02:39:38
"SAF was in the stand deep in conversation with somebdoy and from what I could lip-read it looked like SAF was complaining that DM was all set to get rid of Giggs from the club"

Fuck offffffffffff. How long did the camera linger on him like? I think your inner Hyacinth Bucket is getting the better of your Harry Palmer there Patrick.

Anyway, maybe your lip-reading skills are a bit rusty and the Red Skull was simply speculating whose wife was currently 'gerrinit oafa Giggsy'?

Kevin Rowlands
164 Posted 23/04/2014 at 02:56:03
Keith #757, take a look at your absurd post and look at the very first sentence, then after you have done that do a little bit of research and have a look at the number of points we have today with three games left versus the total number of points we had under any season Moyes was in charge, enough said!
Christopher Kelly
165 Posted 23/04/2014 at 02:58:51
Keith, what are you on about? How negative are you, bro? I almost feel bad for you as you're not understanding how fortunate we are to have RM as our coach.

To go on a rant about how Martinez isn't as good a manager when he's already amassed more points, has a warmer, more optimistic approach and not to mention, easier on the eye is all I need to know. When there is one match a week, I like knowing that we will go the earth's end for a victory vs nicking a goal and hoping for a draw against those teams "so far above us"...

nd FYI — Spurs are a wreck and Man Utd has major, major problems financially. Van Gaal is not the answer.

Keith Simmonds
166 Posted 23/04/2014 at 03:21:18
Kevin

You are basing Martinez is a better manager on one uncomplete season. We beat and drew v Arsenal and beat United twice. That is the difference, 10 points. If we manage this season after season you can draw conclusions. I will happily admit he is doing better if he manages it on a regular basis. I would say the Arsenal win is the most significant of them all.

John Daley
167 Posted 23/04/2014 at 03:38:31
"I am not sure we are any better off than before and the football is at times less effective"

Not watched many games this season then Keith?

" I don't think there is any proof that we have a better manager than Moyes right now. Martinez hasn't yet achieved anything remember (whereas Moyes made the Everton job attractive..)"

Got more points in his first season than Moyes ever managed in eleven. Won at Old Trafford at his first attempt after Moyes failed miserably to do so for over a decade. Players coming out and saying they prefer life under Martinez. Club staff not scared to sneeze in the hallway. Attendances up. Season ticket sales up. Most enjoyable season since the mid eighties. A much needed sense of belief about the place again allied with the shedding of the whole plucky little 'peoples club' mentality. It may not be conclusive 'proof' but it's evidence enough for me.

"Moyes tried to sign Lukaku on loan himself 2 or 3 seasons ago but there was a rule about him not being able to play for more than 2 clubs within 12 months. So the astuteness now being attributed to Martinez is slightly misplaced"

When exactly did Moyes try for him only to be foiled by red tape? When he was at Anderlecht? He was their star player and there was no chance of them sending him out on loan. When he first joined Chelsea? There was only Stoke reported to have seen a proposed loan move scuppered at that stage. The season after when he went to West Brom? Fulham was the only other team he nearly joined back then.

Keith Simmonds
168 Posted 23/04/2014 at 03:46:23
"Got more points in his first season than Moyes ever managed in eleven. Won at Old Trafford at his first attempt after Moyes failed miserably to do so for over a decade. Players coming out and saying they prefer life under Martinez. Club staff not scared to sneeze in the hallway. Attendances up. Season ticket sales up. Most enjoyable season since the mid eighties. A much needed sense of belief about the place again allied with the shedding of the whole plucky little 'peoples club' mentality. It may not be conclusive 'proof' but it's evidence enough for me."

And there's no cost of living crisis either. Wages are outstripping inflation. Sounds like Tory central office wrote all that! Thats one difference with Martinez. He can do the PR better. People seem to buy his schtick.

Some things are different sure. We give away possession less often. Thats a positive. Seem to draw a lot more these days. Score goals late on more often. I will wait to see how it pans out over a couple of seasons or three before I join in and proclaim Martinez as the better manager.

Matt Traynor
169 Posted 23/04/2014 at 03:57:32
Phil, is that you?
Christopher Kelly
170 Posted 23/04/2014 at 04:01:57
Hahahahaha — I was thinking the same thing, Matt.
Keith Simmonds
171 Posted 23/04/2014 at 03:55:50
And re: Lukaku. We did try to get him. The rumours were there. I doubt I am the only one who remembers this. If you don't remember it fair enough, but it definitely got reported. It was the first season at Chelsea (2011-12 season), during the January transfer window when he hadn't been getting any games. He had played a couple of games for Anderlecht and a couple for Chelsea so he couldn't join another club at that point. I believe we went in again at start of the following season when he ended up at West Brom. Was just rumour at time.
James Wong
172 Posted 23/04/2014 at 04:01:25
Keith - "Also I don't get this idea about him being unsuitable to be given a war chest of £150m. Moyes strength has always been finding gems of players and making them better that cost a lot less."

Thats exactly why I don't really trust Moyes with 150m either. His best buys have always been between 1-5m. Above that its been Fellaini, Yakubu, Johnson, Bily
and Beattie. He paid 60m pounds for Fellaini and juan mata. Fellaini he overpaid by about 10m and Juan Mata he already had decent attacking options. He really should have gone for a centre back, or a full back or a decent defensive midfielder.

Paul Ferry
173 Posted 23/04/2014 at 04:11:16
Good grief, Keith Simmonds - 757 - speechless ... one thing 'Seem to draw a lot more these days' - erm check back to 12 months ago, and this is just one of an unbelievable sequences of mistakes, misconceptions, and misrepresentations, but my friend we need you, we do. Phil has left us. Doddy bounced back for a day to say what he felt on the day that HE got the sack. We need you. Keep posting.
Paul Kernot
174 Posted 23/04/2014 at 04:51:41
There's a guy works down the chip shop swears he's Alex

Just like you swore to me you were good for the blues

There's a guy works down the chip shop swears he's Alex

But he's a liar and I'm not sure about you

Eric Myles
175 Posted 23/04/2014 at 05:22:25
"Seem to draw a lot more these days"

Not true Keith #772. Last season we drew 15 games, so far this season only 9.

Last season we won 16 games, so far this season 20

Losses are 7 vs 5.

Phil Hendren
177 Posted 23/04/2014 at 06:55:00
Never posted before but have to say that I was sucked in by OFM’s alleged quality for many years. I was gutted at first when he went and was sceptical about Martinez.

That scepticism was gone by November as too was the myth I had believed about OFM. It suddenly became apparent that Moyes had turned Utd into Everton and RM had turned Everton into Utd.

Don’t get me wrong, when Moyes turned up at Goodison he saved us and for that alone I’m grateful but as someone said above, having a manager that sets the starting target as 40 points compared to one who sets a target of 70 is a game changer.

As a blue for 30 years I’ve not been this excited about Everton since the 80s.

Tony Draper
178 Posted 23/04/2014 at 07:57:55
I really do want to clarify a point regarding dm

The reason that he failed at mufc, was the same reason that in eleven years, he won FUCK ALL for Everton, and that is because

dm is a dull, unimaginative, bottling, football, dinosaur and a two faced c**t

Phil Hendren
179 Posted 23/04/2014 at 08:14:57
@Keith .. wow.. just wow. Whatever you’re smoking I want some. Look, I can fully appreciate the argument that RM has not completed a full season yet so it would be sensible to not pass total judgement until another season has completed and we can all see if it was "beginners luck".

However, there can be no denying that there is a demonstrable difference between us now and us for the last 11 years. It’s not just the positive attitude in the media that RM has but the strikingly obvious difference on the pitch. The team is playing football in a completely different way and that’s obviously down to the manager.

You only have to watch Man Utd over the past 10 months and it becomes even more obvious. They look like we used to look. Every single football fan I know has made this same observation, and I’m talking about fans of Chelsea, RS, Man Utd, Arsenal etc. To suggest that it’s still much the same I can only presume requires immense amounts of narcotics.

John Daley
180 Posted 23/04/2014 at 08:07:00
"Sounds like Tory central office wrote all that"

Says the guy who follows up with this whopper:

""And re: Lukaku. We did try to get him. The rumours were there. I doubt I am the only one who remembers this. If you don't remember it fair enough, but it definitely got reported"

Rumour constitutes fact now for the guy who earlier requested 'proof'? I'll be getting shot in the chest by Rollo Tomassi next. "Just the facts Jack. Just the facts".

Stuart Gray
181 Posted 23/04/2014 at 08:41:32
I, for one, would like to thank David Moyes for the time he spent at Old Trafford. It's been way more entertaining than the 11 years he had at Goodison.
Craig Walker
182 Posted 23/04/2014 at 09:11:26
Apparently David Moyes has wasted no time getting down to business in his new role working for Sky: he installs his first dish on Monday.
Eugene Ruane
183 Posted 23/04/2014 at 09:07:04
"Fulworth Blenkinson!"

Too posh.

"Reg Twonk"

Hmmm..nope.

"Shadwell Mington!"

Um..too..'mad'

"Kenny Kote"

Fucking think man, think!

"Keith Simmington"

Better.

"Keith....sssimo..nds....Kieth Siimmonds..KIETH SIMMONDS!"

That'll do!

"Ahem, Kieth Simmonds here and definitely not Phil Walling (who I've never heard of anyway) and I think..."

Colin Glassar
184 Posted 23/04/2014 at 09:29:35
Tony Draper, that would make a fantastic obituary. I wonder if The Times would publish it though?
Jamie Carroll
185 Posted 23/04/2014 at 09:26:06
Keith, oh dear, your letters... Where do I begin?

Everton are on course for a record points tally under Martinez and if likely hadn’t been injured in February, would have picked up points against Spurs and Chelsea that their play deserved. Only for Liverpool’s unexpected title charge, Everton would probably be in the top four by now. Martinez is doing everything Moyes didn’t/couldn’t do, like the substitutions coming early in the games — remember being 2-0 down against West Ham at Upton Park and winning 3-2? Wouldn’t have happened under Moyes. The style of playing is also a pleasure to watch, and the attendances have improved under Martinez.

Phil Bellis
186 Posted 23/04/2014 at 09:19:28
Keith Simmonds (757)
Hmmmm
New poster?
Curious
Chris Morris
187 Posted 23/04/2014 at 09:50:26
Eugene,

Brilliant

Kevin Tully
188 Posted 23/04/2014 at 09:58:08
Apparently, they took the piss out of him from the first day to the last - Moyes I mean, not Phil W.
Colin Glassar
189 Posted 23/04/2014 at 09:54:38
Keith, as the song goes, " Are you Walling? Are you Walling? Are you Walling in disguise? Aaaaare you Walling in disguise?
Brian Waring
190 Posted 23/04/2014 at 10:13:20
"Moyes made the Everton job attractive to someone ambitious like Martinez"

No he never Keith, the reason why Martinez took the job is because we're
fucking EVERTON F.C!!!!!!!!

Liam Young
191 Posted 23/04/2014 at 10:36:19
The truth is, Moyes though did a good job at Everton, and did take us forward, could only take us so far. I respect him for what he did at Everton, BUT, Martinez has brought in an optimism and energy we haven’t seen for a long time at Goodison. I remember coming to this site under Moyes, and everyone focused purely on money, and that came to a loggerheads with our chairman over takeovers. Funny how all that gets talked about less now, huh?

Football philosophy is always the most important aspect of a football club; money can help, but it can also ruin you and destroy your integrity, Look at Manchester United: the team and players never from day one supported Moyes, and even though he is a negative manager, it was the negativity around the club that ultimately destroyed his time there. And I actually feel sorry for him for that, you see, at Everton, we have a mutual respect, and pride in our club – maybe not having as much money helps that!

But we are Everton FC; anyone will tell you, after you leave this amazing club, the only way is down. Everton are a big club over the entire history of English football; Manchester United are mostly big for the last 25 years of Ferguson’s success. Our passion runs deeper, stronger, and our sense of pride will always be stronger than anybody else’s. Martinez gets this, and his footballing knowledge combined with Kenwright’s passion for all things blue, is taking us forward.

Some people will get angry by that, but if we had a chairman with no soul for the club, like the Glazer family, trust me, our club would not have the integrity it has today.

I am proud of our achievements this season, and know that we will keep getting better under the current set up. Thank you for your 11 years, Moyes, but thank you Kenwright for bringing in a manager to take us to the next level again.

COYB!!!!!!!!!

Peter Morris
192 Posted 23/04/2014 at 11:14:28
Shane(493) my point about compensation, I think. My point being that Moyes in my view held off signing a new contract with us because I suspect he had a nod and a wink 'understanding' with red nose as to what was subsequently going to happen. If he had signed up again with us say in Christmas 2012, as is customary between like minded parties as contracts run down, then should Man Utd.,or indeed anyone else from the Sky 4 come calling, then Everton would be due some sizeable compensation(like that we paid Wigan for example). I am fully aware that we were not due it the way things ultimately panned out.
Robert Elliott
193 Posted 23/04/2014 at 11:34:19
Poor old Davey. Hard to imagine a more humiliating demise for him at OT than the one he's just had. And to think it all came to an end at Goodison!! Talk about insult to injury! From what's being said, it appears as if the United squad weren't having him from day one.

Any United fan thinking removing DM will solve all their problems overnight could be in for a shock though. I would say the problems there run deeper than just the appointment of a manager who wasn't good enough for the job. Some of them seem to have serious delusions about how good they really are. Ferguson was clearly a managerial genius who made them look good at the end, winning the league by 11 points in 2012/13 with that squad was probably his best achievement in 27 years. Not that I care too much, only from the point of view of hoping their struggles continue for a good while to come from a competitive point of view.

As for Moyes, this will be hard to come back from. I imagine he will get another shot somewhere, perhaps at a Villa, West Ham or Newcastle. However, his shot at the big time has probably gone for good though. His limitations have been fully exposed, both by the terrible job he's done at Utd, and the job Martinez is doing with pretty much the same squad of players at Everton. Anyone who doesn't think RM has already proved to be a better option for us than Moyes could ever be is totally lost on me.

Chris James
194 Posted 23/04/2014 at 08:30:26
I think Moyes lost the plot this year and let all the attention go to his head (although to a point I think this is understandable - very few people in any line of work can keep their head when faced with relentless fawning praise - see exhibit A: Hollywood). Also, as part of the process to try and live up to Ferguson's arrogance and be seen as a worthy Utd manager, he made some ill advised statements that quite rightly caused ire and made him look classless and ungrateful.

However, despite all of this I do feel sorry for the man who has been built up beyond his capabilities and then ripped apart by the media, the club (who's behaviour over the last 48 hours has been utterly vile) and the Utd players (who basically seem to have decided not to back the new boss in a Clough/Revie manner) - the only group who seem to have shown some dignity and class in this whole affair are the majority of match-going Utd fans, who actually backed the guy through tough times and even turned away from stupid stunts like the plane.

I am also not short-sighted enough to remember what he did for our club over his tenure, for instance:
i) Restored some stability after years when we'd become a joke and spent more time toying with relegation than challenging for honours.
ii) Instilled some pride and respect to the fans with the people's club concept and finishing above Liverpool several times (including last 2 years in a row)
iii) Had us challenging for Europe on a number of occasions and actually got us into the Champions League and a handful of Europa trips
iv) Steadily improved the team on a flat/negative transfer spend bringing in players who'd be real stars (in short and long term) Cahill, Arteta, Pienaar, Yobo, Campbell, Yak, etc
v) Has acquired many of the key players that have shone under Martinez (Howard, Coleman, Baines, Jags, Distin, Stones, Oviedo, Pienaar, Mirallas, Naismith!!)
vi) Helped in the main to get a decent value for the players that did go out (Lescott, Rodwell, Johnson, Rooney, Fellaini)
vii) Did give young players a chance (albeit not enough of one) - Rooney, Coleman, Barkley, Baxter, McAlney
viii) Created a genuine team spirit by avoiding signing/clamping down on big time charlies and fostering a togetherness
ix) Made us very hard to beat with a hard-working team defensive approach (may have frustrated but is what's allowing Martinez to be more cavalier)
x) Started the attacking wing-play and began to be more attack-minded (Although it was very slow, tentative and light years off Martinez, in the last season and a half - with Mirallas and Jelly on board, Pienaar back and Coleman regular - we did actually play some nice stuff, not always KITAP1)
xi) Raised our expectations (a mixed blessing for him), but I for one remember years of worrying about last few matches and thinking 40 points was a genuine success. Contrast that with the expectation of top 7/8 and hope of European place and a cup run. He did get us to a number of semis and 1 ill-fated final!.

Before I get shouted down, I do fully appreciate the man's limitations - that his initially essential defensive tactics didn't mature quickly enough, that he was always looking to protect rather than build and didn't instil enough confidence vs the big boys - I also believe his tenure had reached it's (and his) limits and that his departure was best all round (not that I or many believed that in the summer). However, no matter what he said afterwards or didn't achieve, I think we need to respect that on several levels Moyes was exactly what was needed for our club in difficult times and he definitely pushed us forward against the odds (and budgets).

It looks to all the world like Martinez is exactly what we need now and I'm loving the new boss and wouldn't change him for anyone (including Mourninho and Gaurdiola - love to see them try to function on our bank balance!)
The King is dead, long live the King!

Above all things though, we must remember that Everton is a club about heritage, tradition and history. We have achieved much, we have led the world at times and it might just be that we're heading up there again. But everyone who's been part of the story is important and regardless of what they do next or say next, we need to remember them with respect and dignity. That's what makes this club so much better than all the billionaire's play things that are ruling the roost and why we'll still be here long after the sheikhs and oligarchs have grown board.
Because we are Everton and we are born, not manufactured.

Gavin Ramejkis
195 Posted 23/04/2014 at 10:17:40
An amusing thread with the added bonus of charlatan Walter Mitty appearances and desperate adulation for "the sacked one" and the humour only ToffeeWeb can bring in spades.
Stuart Gray
196 Posted 23/04/2014 at 12:26:08
I agree Chris 858. Moyes was what we needed at the time, but stayed on for too long with too much control and overall power.

I think the biggest problem he has is that he lowered expectations such that we forgot who we were and I think that was found out at a club who has had success for the last 20 years.

Tony Draper
197 Posted 23/04/2014 at 12:32:15
Banner now reads

"The chosen Gone"

Ian Burns
198 Posted 23/04/2014 at 12:51:44
Gavin 870 - I have to agree there has been a great deal of the usual TW humour on this thread but I have to say none more so than Tommy Coleman's (707) comment about Jurgen Klopp not being interested in the job but his brother Klippety was! Brilliant!
Tommy Coleman
199 Posted 23/04/2014 at 12:57:57
Keith Simmonds - ha ha.

One of most moronic posts in the history of TW.

Good wind up though.

Ian Burns - Cheers!

Chris Morris
200 Posted 23/04/2014 at 13:19:03
Ball to him. He made his bed and now he's got to lie in it.

No sympathy here especially after the way he turned once he'd left. We've moved on to a better place since his departure.

Mark Andersson
201 Posted 23/04/2014 at 13:20:12
Thanks everyone for posting what has been a fascinating read, some insightful debates some very humorous remarks that actually had me laughing out loud.

Shame David Moyes burnt his bridges the way he did. A lesson to us all no matter what walk of life where in, never screw over the people who once respected you.

Only time will tell if Roberto is our new savior; I for one like what I see so far, but I remember feeling like that after a few seasons under DM. The most important thing on this thread is life is not the same without Phil Walling... was Phil, DM in disguise??? I nicked named him "Still Moaning"

I look forward to reading more posts on this matter, then hay let’s put it to bed and move on.

Phil Bellis
202 Posted 23/04/2014 at 13:16:36
Chris James (858)

List of achievements compared to the years prior duly noted but you obviously, understanding heritage etc, know he presided over some of the all-time lows in Everton's history

As Stuart Gray (872) hints, he engendered in a new generation of football fans, including, sadly, many Blues, the belief and acceptance that we are lucky to be "plucky liitle Everton"

Tom Bowers
203 Posted 23/04/2014 at 13:34:23
Why sympathize with Moyes? He’s laughing all the way to the bank!!
Steve Bell
204 Posted 23/04/2014 at 14:13:40
Apart from the appalling humiliation, DM must be experiencing an absolute sense of betrayal, if as reported SAF was involved in the decision to sack him. Quite ironic, what you give out to the world you get back by the bucketful, or to put it simply...

Be kind to the people you meet on the way up, 'cos sure as hell you will meet the same people on your way down.

Patrick Murphy
205 Posted 23/04/2014 at 14:36:52
BBC are reporting that David Moyes in his first statement since he lost his job as saying "To have been appointed as manager of Manchester United was and remains something of which I will always be incredibly proud, I remain grateful to Sir Alex for believing in my ability and giving me the chance to manage United."

I wonder if Sir Alex took DM because he thought it would harm Everton FC far more than it has? He did say he found Goodison one of the more difficult grounds to visit.

Steavey Buckley
206 Posted 23/04/2014 at 14:40:47
In hindsight, the Manu job as manager for Moyes was a poison chalice with Moyes record of not achieving a single piece of silverware in all his years at Goodison and his known record of dithering in the transfer market, which prevented Everton from finishing 4th last season. This record was repeated at Manu. But more than that, the next manager of Manu will not have to follow in the footsteps of the record of SAF, but that of Moyes.
Chris Leyland
207 Posted 23/04/2014 at 14:47:44
I've just read this statement from the League Manager's Association and it literally made me spit my coffee out.....

"Throughout his time at United, David, as he always does, has conducted himself with integrity and professionalism, values that he believes in..."

Nigel Gregson
208 Posted 23/04/2014 at 15:16:25
I won't jump into the “I told you so” bandwagon – because honestly, I didn't. I genuinely feared for us when he left. I had respected what he had done for us. When I first grew to follow football in the early 2000s, it was actually Ginger who drew me to Everton. Back then, the hope was real. He was a sincere, honest, humble straightforward manager, and our backs were truly against the wall.

I believed that he could take us to the next level, albeit slowly - one decent buy a season at a time. And for a while he did. Back then, Tony Marsh used to wind me up. (Admit it fellas, I was not alone.)

Where it started falling apart for me was the sale of Pienaar... then Arteta... and then of Rodwell. The few bright lights that we had here were gone. But, then again, last season, we did start to play some of the best football in a long long time (even old Tony was impressed, and he admitted to it on these very forums). I felt that Ginger had turned a corner and that he will finally be taking us places.

And then he left. And believe me, I was scared. It felt like a parent was abandoning me. But, as further details emerged, the fear evaporated and was replaced with rage. Respect went to the recycling bin.

It was clear as day. Ginger had behaved like any other slimy corporate ladder climber. You know those assholes in the real world, who get ahead because they cosy up to the big guy. The sort who have sneaky coffee session orgies of back scratching: [in indecipherable Scottish] “Hey Sir Alex, how's that lad Wayne Rooney working out for ya?"

"Brilliant Davie – you trained him up real well for us."

"May I have that reject goalkeeper of yours, sir... I promise I won't play him this season against ya?"

"What, you don't rate Phil Neville? Ok - I'll take him thanks!!!"

"Sir, May I have some more? How about that Darron fella who seems to be only fit 10% of the time?”

The sort who create a façade of competence around themselves: “Look at me, I'm doing such a champagne job with poor old Everton – the perennial underdog overachiever. Where would they be without me? Relegated I bet. I do this for two more years and I will probably deserve a statue across Goodison.” Knobs in the media sold it. Knobs like me bought it.

Of course, he had been planning this all along. He never truly had any plans to take us places. Fuck no - Everton was his stepping stone for the real job. Everton was just this abused old wife that he could beat up whenever he felt like and she'd still serve him dinner and do his chores, because she was afraid that she might not do any better than the handsome Scot with sharp features and abnormally big eyes. This, while he shagging and planning to settle down with the rich and hot younger neighbour.

Thank god football is not any other corporate job. Thank god, in football, merit and performances alone determine your fate. Charlatans like ginger ultimately get found out. The scheming tricks about managing expectations that worked here, didn't quite work over there. Unfortunately, that rich hot neighbour, the dream girl, is also a heartless slut who'll kick you out the moment she realised that your little noodle doesn't work as she expected it to (she's seen a lot better).

So why am I venting tonight instead of checking out news articles about us buying Cleverley and keeping Lacina for another year? It's because I'm sick and tired of people still suggesting that he deserves respect here and that they feel sorry for him. Forget sorry. He schemed his way to the dream – not on merit but on nepotism. For being the worst United manager in decades, that tortured soul will earn 5 million pounds.

This man didn't give us pride. By making us feel second tier for so long, he actually took away the pride. We had a whole generation (including yours truly) , who genuinely felt that without hundreds of millions of pounds, Everton won't get much further.

But now we know better.

In the words of our new leader – “In Football – you move on so quickly ….”

COYB

Paul Tran
209 Posted 23/04/2014 at 15:25:42
Mr Dodd: I am one of many who regularly dared to criticise the genius while he was here, so please don't accuse us all of 'rewriting history'.

History tells us that Moyes joined an unambitious club at lower mid-table and took it to the top seven. He then ignored his good work and kept us there, pretending that we were in the position we were when he took over. He spent his last three years offering nothing new, nothing different, no promise of what was coming next.

Within months of Martinez joining, the team had shape, players were bought for specific purposes, the players were passing and keeping the ball comfortably and we had a variety of attacking options.

As I have said before, if you gave most managers 10 years in a job with a club our size, give them the chance to break the transfer record regularly, put them under no pressure to win trophies, allow them to play functional, safety-first football and con the fans into thinking they would never get anything better, I think most of these managers would have done a similar job than Moyes.

At most clubs, he would have been sacked for non-achievement, but our 'directors' are unambitious people ,unwilling to put money into the club, so a steady, unambitious manager suited them fine.

He joined a club where success is a pre-requisite, with players who probably saw through him the minute he and his entourage came through the door, where you do not bumble along unquestioned. They had a good look at what he is actually like and fired him.

I'm grateful for his first few years at the club. His last few years here and his 10 months at United found him out. He did provide a foundation for a better manager to build on - it's just a pity we had to wait so long for that to come.

I consistently criticised Moyes because I believed he and we could have done even better. It became clear to me that he couldn't do any more. It's now clear to me that we definitely can.

Andrew Ellams
211 Posted 23/04/2014 at 16:12:49
Richard Dodd, surely you can see the irony in your comment about other managers at richer clubs being found wanting.
Si Cooper
212 Posted 23/04/2014 at 16:46:25
The modicum of sympathy I felt for the man following his unnecessarily brutal axing has evaporated in light of his arse-kissing acceptance of his dismissal.

Either he genuinely holds the odious Manure regime and their fans in higher regard than those who treated him in exemplary fashion whilst he was at EFC, or he is simply trying to maximise his pay-off. Utterly contemptible.

Jason Broome
213 Posted 23/04/2014 at 12:25:44
A lot of anger and its easy to see why. 12 years in the Premiership and all he has to show for it is wages.

Hated, despised and mocked by almost all in the game. Reputation near destroyed. Had he signed his contract with us last year this timeline wouldn't exist.

But in all of this I'm with Tim Howard. If Martinez polished a diamond it was Moyes who dug the coal!

When he was here he was a Blue. He bought our current team with the hope, desire and belief that he could bring success to us. He brought infrastructure, stability, Europe and pride where none existed after the 'dogs of war' bullshit. So I for one won't be hating.

His head was turned, simple. Man Utd tapped him up and his Hubris turned him into a Prick. He wanted a Wife and a mistress and now he has neither. That 'one more game' mentality has shown him that loyalty was the only thing worth fighting for.

Paul Holden
214 Posted 23/04/2014 at 17:04:29
Sorry lads, I'm not going to slag him - whether you agreed with his style or play or not, he gave his all for EFC and we all seem to have forgotten that fact
Paul Andrews
215 Posted 23/04/2014 at 17:10:17
For a return of £75,000 per week so he should Paul.
Raymond Fox
216 Posted 23/04/2014 at 16:15:32
Can we just forget the guy from now on, for crying out loud.
Ok, yes this thread is about him, but when its run its course, will all his ex. lovers give it a rest.

How do you think Martinez would have fared if he, instead of Moye's, had become Utd manager.
Why, a bleeding lot better I would wager.
Just imagine Martinez with £100m+ to spend, he would have waltzed into a top 4 place.

As for feeling sorry for Moye's is concerned, he is wallowing in money, with a life style that 99% of us can only dream of, and people are feeling sorry for him, give over.

He was exceedingly well paid for being our manager, he didn't GIVE us anything.

Phil Bellis
217 Posted 23/04/2014 at 17:38:08
Jason

I was proud as hell of the Dogs of War in the 95 semi

Also, grateful to Man Utd for breaking up out stale marriage with Moyes

Frank Crewe
218 Posted 23/04/2014 at 16:54:35
Moyes is not a charlatan. He was simply inadequate for the demands of the job he took on. He's not the only one though. The premier league is full of Moyes clones. Hughes, Allardyce, Lambert, Pardew, Bruce, Redknapp. Sherwood, and the current flavour of the month Tony Pulis. Then there is the recent sackings, O'Neill, Houghton, Clarke. If any of these guys had got the Manure job the result would have been exactly the same.

They have managed club after club with varying degrees of success but never over an extended period and eventually failure sets in and they get the sack only to roll up at another club and start the whole process off again. Mediocrity is ingrained in their bones. Every season they start off with one aim, mid table SAFETY. If they can keep an average side away from the drop zone they are lauded as "doing a great job" Pulis is getting it now. So is Steve Bruce even though Hull are 14th with a miserable 36 points. They made it to the cup final so he's a "good" manager. (Notice he's not in the Running for the Manure job. Once bitten twice shy.)

I think one of the reasons the top 4 has remained the top 4 for so long is ambitionless managers like these have hung around the premier league almost since it started giving the top 4 a free ride. Never attempting anything that might threaten the status quo. They have given themselves a self imposed glass ceiling that they didn't have the ambition or know how to break through. They are comfortable with their lot

Maybe Rodgers, Martinez, Potchettino will encourage other clubs to stop playing safe. To stop employing these plodders and go for something new and give the richer clubs a run for their money. If they don't and continue to believe that if they haven't got a billionaire chucking money at them then it's mid table also ran forever.

Will Sutton
219 Posted 23/04/2014 at 18:08:26
I absolutely agree that Martinez can take us places that Moyes could not. But I also agree with Tim Howard about the solid foundation Moyes built over a decade. Roberto can now add flair and creativity on that foundation but it's ungracious of Evertonians to rubbish Moyes' achievements. We're better than that!
Keith Young
220 Posted 23/04/2014 at 18:08:14
This has been a long thread about our Club and OFM. The bad news is when I come on with a fantastic original thought ( if it gets past MK) it invariably means the thread stops right there.That's the good news if we now close the case on OFM. After all we have won hands down!!
Paul Smith
221 Posted 23/04/2014 at 18:17:43
It's great to see so many onTW know their football! Total vindication in regards to the merits of OFM. Case closed. The EX that spurned us, is fu@cked.
Darryl Ritchie
222 Posted 23/04/2014 at 18:56:40
Frank@958

Every manager you have an issue with is British...just saying.

Peter Bell
223 Posted 23/04/2014 at 19:22:09
I often shake my head when people mention things about great service.
Someone once said to me
" That Cahills been a great servant to you"
My Reply
" What, eight years"
I know people who have lost jobs after 20-25 years who never earned the sort of money and payouts these people get
Johnny Rainford
224 Posted 23/04/2014 at 19:25:18
History repeating itself...?

Unfortunately for Moyes, Forest have just signed a new manager so he won't be going there.

As for the Damned United... Be nice if they "do a leeds" and spiral into terminal decline on the back of this....

(actually, apologies. I shouldnt even think about comparing Moyes with the legend that was Cloughie....)

Ian Bennett
225 Posted 23/04/2014 at 20:05:36
Old Soccer Saturday proverb say:-

"Be nice to people on your way up because you meet them on your way down".

Pull up a seat Moysey.

Jeff Hogan
226 Posted 23/04/2014 at 20:50:46
Keith Simmonds: it's a shame you didn't find the forum a little earlier there was another chap who shared an uncannily similar viewpoint to yourself who unfortunately recently stopped posting. I'm sure you and (the much missed) Phil Walling would have really hit it off.

To be fair he had been on a bit of a 'damage limitation exercise' of late after being repeatedly proved wrong by the team's results this season. But I think you have managed to say a lot of things he would really liked to have said if his credibility hadn't suffered so much.

Nick Armitage
227 Posted 23/04/2014 at 21:02:51
Sour Alex Ferguson employed Walter Smith after doing a great job at Everton so we all knew how much of a shit judge of managers he was.

I sussed Moyes out in 2005, and the fact that some of the greatest minds in football rated him, shows what a vacuum of insight and intellect there is in the game.

I am thrilled he has been found out and I am thrilled it has cost United near on £50m in salaries and a shite signing in doing so. Fuck the pair of them. Moyes is a twat and United are a shower of twats. Shame they didn't get much better acquainted, they deserved each other.

Andy Crooks
228 Posted 23/04/2014 at 21:18:03
This thread contains two of the best comments I've read on here for some time. Eugene # 716 is up there with his best. However, Jimmy Sorheim's # 598 is equally superb, where he reveals how his attitude changed after what he refers as the "Drenthe situation"'

I know what you mean, Jimmy, I have had similar misgivings over the "Duffy situation".

Ian Bennett
229 Posted 23/04/2014 at 21:21:20
Martinez and Jose owe him a pint. His outlay on Fellaini and Mata is truly mind boggling.

£27.5m transfer fee, 5 year contact
£37m transfer fee, 4 year contract.
If you assume £125k p/week = £59m

= £123m+ on players that make no difference.

Paul Dark
230 Posted 23/04/2014 at 21:48:28
Nick, 023 - good call.

Man U are the most undignified cheats in world football, and it is an indictment of this country that the likes of Alex Ferguson are (still) supported by the sub-mediocre media and political Establishment.

In my view, he cheated his way to success.

Moyes (not a cheat at least) and Utd do, indeed, deserve each other.

Ian Bennett
231 Posted 23/04/2014 at 21:48:33
Andy, they are both legendary posts. Jimmy's is clearly a spoof character. Nobody can be this funny for so long, and be serious. Clearly a ringer.
David Cornmell
232 Posted 23/04/2014 at 21:57:36
For Roundy and Pip - and Walling, Doddy and any others in the bunker -


At least he tried.

Ross Edwards
233 Posted 23/04/2014 at 22:02:28
Apparently United are giving SAF a say in Moyes's replacement.
Kevin Rowlands
234 Posted 23/04/2014 at 22:04:33
Si #940, great post, couldn't have put it better myself. As for the ginger twat although I have no sympathy whatsoever after reading the bbc headline this morning about Giggs, P Neville, Butt and Scholes taking training, add in that snake Ferdinand and I couldn't help thinking the inmates are running the asylum, that place is pure poison. Seriously has anyone ever seen any of this gang being interviewed, if brains were made of chocolate you wouldn't have enough chocolate to fill a fucking smartie with that bunch.

Any new manager going in there would be insane not to insist that all of them backstabbing twats were removed from anything to do with the 1st team. The nice part of all this mayhem that's gone on there is that the Glazers have nowhere near the amount of money to throw around like City or Chelsea, this is not going to be a quick fix and the problems are going to continue, long may it last!

Colin Glassar
235 Posted 23/04/2014 at 22:17:03
Ross, then it will be either Alec McLeish or Paul Lambert. Fergie loves a jock.
Ross Edwards
236 Posted 23/04/2014 at 22:25:44
It probably will be Colin. He made a huge error, now he has a chance to embarrass himself even more and sink Man Utd further.

Still, the more they decline the more entertainment we get as a result..

Kevin Tully
237 Posted 23/04/2014 at 22:23:57
BBC News just said ginge is 'livid' and no compensation package has yet been agreed with Man Utd.

Loves the smell of the green does wee Davie.

Colin Glassar
238 Posted 23/04/2014 at 22:30:17
Fergie, IMO, didn’t recommend a top notch manager like Mourinho or Ancellotti as he doesn’t want any Man U manager to overshadow him. He’s quite happy pulling the strings in the background. Hence my surprise if they name Van Gaal the new manager. Van Gaal won’t take any shit from Fergie.
Nigel Gregson
239 Posted 23/04/2014 at 22:35:42
@KevinRowlands my thoughts exactly. There is something rotten to the core at that place, which Fergie being an all encompassing figurehead could hide. Moyes would have likely used the big broom and actually cleared out some of the nastier pieces of work in there. But the players got him first. Good luck to Van Gaal or whoever they find.
Graham Mockford
240 Posted 23/04/2014 at 22:45:25
Sooner or later Moyes will disappear from discussion from this site.

However Jimmy's obsession with Royston is forever. I'd love to see his search history as I suspect 'Drenthe underpants images' figures large.

Ross Edwards
241 Posted 23/04/2014 at 22:42:46
Let's go through the candidates:

Klopp: He ruled himself out yesterday

Bobby: No chance of him going to a mid table side :)
Pep: Won't go after 1 season

Ancelotti: The only way he's leaving Real this summer is if they sack him

Pochettino: Quite possibly. He could leave Southampton. A young manager could appeal to the Glazers and he is one of the best managers in the league.

Simeone: Doesn't speak much English and other clubs will no doubt be targeted by other European clubs

Van Gaal: Very likely.

Steve Bell
242 Posted 23/04/2014 at 23:28:33
On a lighter note maybe the recommendation by SAF of DM has all the makings of a conspiracy theory. Why recommend DM, after all 11 years without a trophy etc etc ? Was DM set up to be the fall guy all along.

His ego massaged by the constant whispers in his ear by SAF and the media. Everyone knew he could not emulate what had gone before therefore what was the motive of SAF? To look continue his invincible legacy or destroy his 'friend'. Intriguing what?

Patrick Murphy
243 Posted 23/04/2014 at 23:44:14
Some of the stuff written in the Daily Mail is astonishing and reprehensible from the playing staff who it seems took every opportunity to belittle David Moyes and his assistants — apparently the players referred to one coach as Fuck-off [name inserted] every time he opened his mouth.

It really is grim reading and if that's the type of characters that win medals and trophies then I'm glad that Everton have been without Silverware in the last few years. I hope the bastards get relegated next season as they don't deserve to earn the vast sums of money and live the fantastic lifestyles that they enjoy. No doubt that Moyes made some serious errors of judgement but how could any person be expected to produce the goods in that sort of environment?

Peter Bell
244 Posted 23/04/2014 at 23:49:46
Nick Artitage @023 Alex Ferguson was not a knob for giving Walter Smith a coaching job for 6 months after he left Everton. He knew full well that he was respected by the parents of WR and used him to convince the best young player inthis country to join Man U.
Eugene Ruane
245 Posted 24/04/2014 at 00:16:43
Patrick ~ (077) - "...apparently the players referred to one coach as Fuck-off [name inserted] every time he opened his mouth."

Some things that come out of our mouths are natural given the (right) circumstances.

If you're drowning you don't THINK 'shall I shout 'help'?' you just shout it.

Same if you see something about to hit someone, you don't ponder whether to tell them or not, the words 'LOOK OUT!' just come naturally.

I'm guessing training sessions at Utd were the same.

My guess is if Phil Neville was telling Rooney how to play football, the words 'Fuck off Neville' would come out naturally.

Bob Parrington
246 Posted 24/04/2014 at 00:14:47
Keith Simmonds - well done for standing your ground against the onslaught!! Great thing about TW is the variety of opinion and the fact that you can express your view and, at worst, only be hung from the gallows in a "virtual reality" sense.

Certainly, I accept that it is early days for Martinez but IMO his whole style is country miles in advance of OFM. OFM did a good job bringing us from the brink of relegation to a "relatively" successful position but IMO he should have moved on a little sooner than he did or brought in a coach who understands that not all players are programmable machines without imaginations. RM allows, rather encourages players who have them to use their natural skills and this creates a massive point of difference. As a fan base, we get the opportunity to be really excited because our team is then playing the kind of football we want to watch.

Chris James #858
"Because we are Everton and we are born, not manufactured." ----- Well put!

Zack Yusof
248 Posted 24/04/2014 at 05:26:45
A great read this thread so a big thanks to all that contributed to it. Some of the comments on here actually made me laugh out out here at work while others were full of good logic and common sense. I expected even more bile to be honest!

And then there was Keith Simmonds' post. Inaccurate, misguided and seemingly devoid of reality as it was, I was totally hooked to it and salute Mr Simmonds on his commendable but deranged attempt to defend OFM on his darkest day. Like others have said, it's the variety of opinions that keeps things interesting on here. So keep it coming Keith, no matter how crazy or deluded your opinion. Phil Walling, Richard Dodd et al... you guys too!

As for OFM, I choose not to stick the boot in as it's no fun kicking a man when he's down and all that. He acted like a dick in the summer with the Fellaini / Baines nonsense bid and some of his comments regarding us but I put that down to his incompetence at handling the media, something OFM has never excelled at. While he frustrated me to fuck more often then not with his team selection and negative tactics, my stance is that he did an OK job in stabilizing us and making us a regular top 10 Premiership side during his tenure. Nothing disastrous but nothing spectacular either and certainly not deserving of a big gig like the MU job. He wasn't a bad guy, just very dull and conservative.

I don't think many would disagree that things are just so much better with Roberto at the helm on and off the pitch - no comparison really! In fact I hadn't had this much supporting and watching the team since the 80's glory days. But to say that Moyes did nothing good for us during his 11 years would be wrong. Having said that, I couldn't be happier that he's no longer our manager!

Zack Yusof
249 Posted 24/04/2014 at 05:50:02
" this much FUN supporting and watching the team..." I meant to write. Sorry for the typo!
Chad Schofield
250 Posted 24/04/2014 at 06:40:12
Just read through the entire thread but special mention to Eugene's bleak script Keith Simmonds' bizarre 'leave Moysie ALONE!' post... wow, I don't want anything you're smoking, Keith - that's some toxic shit.
Matt Traynor
251 Posted 24/04/2014 at 07:06:24
Peter #079, not doubting what you say, but the story I'd been told was it started with the change of Agents, and it was actually Dalglish (shareholder of Pro-Active as was) who persuaded Rooney's parents to ditch the current agent and sign with Stretford.

Then again, thinking about it, they probably planted several seeds.

Norman Merrill
252 Posted 23/04/2014 at 18:50:38
Without joining the ranks of the for & against vote, my lasting memory of David Moyes, was standing on the touch line at Goodison during & after, being beaten by an Everton team playing with far more flair, than any of the sides he produced.
Peter Bell
253 Posted 24/04/2014 at 08:30:11
Matt@128, agree about the Agent story, but did you also know what WS did with his severance package from our club. He invested the majority of it in shares with Strefords sports company, so they were all in on it.
Malcolm Joyner
254 Posted 24/04/2014 at 08:39:18
The national press have conveniently forgotten that not only was SAF responsible for taking OFM to Old Trafford, his fall-out with the Irish shareholders led directly to the take-over by the Glazers. Thus saddling his club with about £1B debt.

Great football manager he may be, but as a totally unprincipled shit has few peers. Just glad that I was born to support a proper football club and not 'a corporation'.

John Keating
255 Posted 24/04/2014 at 08:52:59
After reading Jimmys 598 I am now totally convinced he is not acting alone.
To continue to come out with so many class posts over such an extended period he has to be employing a team of scriptwriters !
If he is I hope he doesn't misuse them, in public at least !
Charles Brewer
257 Posted 24/04/2014 at 12:21:38
I have just seen Robert Martinez on the BBC lunchtime news talking about David Moyes.

What a paragon of manners, respect and decency! I just hope no-one sends him to Syria to sort stuff out, still, he'd probably be back on the next plane.

I regarded David Moyes during his time at Everton as a very decent man, condemning diving and cheating, and probably failing to do as well as he might because he didn't employ these tactics.

Foolishly, I think he went against his own principles this time last year and during the summer, and we saw a certain weakness which disappointed those of us who expected better behaviour. He fell below his own standards.

I find it interesting that those who know considerably more than I do (such as Roy Keane and Martinez) have found much more fault on the side of the players than of the manager. We all know that the Manchester United dressing room has been a snakepit for years - Ferguson effectively firing players who were conspiring against him, and managing to repress others who would have caused trouble but were too dim or weak to carry it through. Moyes did not have the authority or thuggery to maintain his position.

I had hoped that Moyes' influence at Manchester United might have been a good thing and that the likes of Saurez, Gerrard and so on would have been more properly controlled by referees. Sadly this is not going to happen.

Overall, I wish Moyes well, and like Martinez think he won't be out of work for long. And as for the cash? Well I'm sure that he won't be hard up, but he will certainly feel the failure very deeply.

Peter Morris
259 Posted 24/04/2014 at 15:53:28
Not a massive news day on the Man Utd front today...only a two page spread devoted into today's Daily Mail. However, a new bombshell may be just about to explode. 'Reliable Sources' can reveal that both beans on toast and ham,egg and chips have been removed from the daily specials at the Carrington nerve centre, a move certain to send shock waves around the world of football. Rio Ferdinand will no doubt be sharing his deep perspectives with an expectant world on Twitter any moment soon. Reporters have moved from the anti-fracking demo at nearby Barton Moss, and will update us as soon as an official comment comes out of the club.
Stu Smith
260 Posted 24/04/2014 at 20:37:37
Moyes was on a hiding to nothing. I have a work colleague whose brother worked very high up and man ure and ended up quitting because the glazers werent looking to the future. He said years ago that when Fergie left Man u would endure a difficult time in transformation
Mark Lavery
261 Posted 24/04/2014 at 21:22:40
I was a Moyes fan, but now accept that he had his limitations. I suppose we accepted those limitations for so long as he the one thing he did do, was give us back our self respect. For so long we drifted and flirted with oblivion and he stopped that (after a few rough years) and gave us hope again. That we can't forget and we do owe him our respect at least - no matter how hurt we were by his subsequent betrayal.
Justin Hart
262 Posted 25/04/2014 at 21:49:22
Are we now going to refer to OFM as TFM... ie, Their Former Manager?
Brian Wilkinson
263 Posted 25/04/2014 at 23:10:29
So not only OFM but Pienar, Lescott, Rodwell and Fellaini all thought the grass was greener elsewhere...

One things for sure: we will always be Everton and, for every player or manager we lose, we somehow seem to bounce back and that's what being an Evertonian is, no player or personal is bigger than the club.


Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads

© ToffeeWeb