How Moyes’s Failure Puts Roberto Martinez’s Everton Season Into Perspective

, 23 April, 11comments  |  Jump to most recent

Contrasting the experiences of the two managers in succeeding long-term tenures at their respective new clubs.

The contrast in the fortunes of both managers since taking up their respective roles is perhaps best illustrated by the Toffees’ 12-point lead over the Red Devils in the Premier League table.

But the gap between the two manager’s manifested itself as something more much more tangible in Everton’s 2-0 win over United at Goodison Park on Easter Sunday, a game that’d prove to be Moyes’ last in the Red Devils hot-seat.

The men in blue played with a clear ideal, with positive intent and with a desire that has been unshakably pertinent throughout the season. United by contrast, operated in a casual, intrepid manner, passing the ball aimlessly and waiting for Wayne Rooney, Juan Mata or Shinji Kagawa to conjure something, out of hope more than expectation.

» Read the full article at World Soccer Talk



Reader Comments (11)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Harold Matthews
1 Posted 24/04/2014 at 02:13:17
I'm a Martinez fan but after reading some of the stuff coming out of Old Trafford I think it's unfair to compare him with OFM. The old groaner made the mistake of taking his mates with him but he was never wanted, never respected and didn't stand a chance. The wrong man in the wrong job at the wrong time. Martinez is the right man in the right job at the right time. Says it all.
Mike Gaynes
2 Posted 24/04/2014 at 16:27:53
Right on the mark, Harold. As usual.
Brian Harrison
3 Posted 24/04/2014 at 16:43:20
While there is no doubting that RM has had a magnificent start to his managerial career at Everton, I think just like players it is best to judge over a period of time and not just one season. Lets face it whoever took over from Ferguson was going to struggle, just like when Busby retired they went through a number of managers who all failed.

Probably the only guy who could have taken over from Ferguson and would have automatically earn the respect of the players was Mourhino. I think probably some of their players thought we have won titles and cups yet you have won nothing so don't try and tell me what to do. I think there were players there that were not prepared to give him a chance because of his record. Whereas all the players at Everton were not prima donors and were prepared to listen and try RMs style of play.

Frank Crewe
4 Posted 24/04/2014 at 17:19:51
It should be pointed out that Steve Clarke took West Brom to 5th and the next season got the sack.

A couple of seasons ago Pardew took Newcastle to 5th and the next season almost got relegated and would also be sacked now if they could afford to bin him.

RM has had a very good 1st season. But it is only one season. Can he repeat it, or improve on it, in future seasons? Who knows, only time will tell.

Maybe it is easier to coach players who are used to defensive play to be more attacking than it is to coach players who are used to attacking play to be more defensive.

Bill Griffiths
5 Posted 24/04/2014 at 17:42:05
When RM was appointed I personally thought that he wouldn’t be up to the job but was prepared to give him a chance and thought initially we would maybe slip a few places down the league first season and that it would probably take a season and a half to two0 seasons before we would see any tangible benefits etc.

I can’t believe the impact he’s made straight away and I am now totally convinced that he will make a success of it. As Harold said Right Man, Right Job, Right Time.

However it would not surprise me if there were to be a slight dip next season but am confident that another 2 to 3 seasons time we will be capable of finishing top four or even as Champions.

Ross Edwards
6 Posted 24/04/2014 at 18:19:01
His first season had been excellent. However depending on whether we'll be in the Europa League and who he signs, expect us to slip a little to 7th or 8th next season.

I'm not being a Nicky Negative trying to dampen expectations, but I am predicting a lower finish next season, but as I say that depends on who Bobby signs and whether we get Champions League football or Europa.

Mike Gaynes
7 Posted 24/04/2014 at 18:45:56
I'm a bit less cautious than Ross... obviously much depends on who he signs, but given a full summer I'm convinced he will again work the loan system like a symphony conductor and bring in what we need to compete in both the Prem and the Europa. Plus we get Oviedo, Kone and Gibson back.
Ross Edwards
8 Posted 24/04/2014 at 18:55:09
I do expect a little slip in league position next year, but I would like us to get Deulofeu for a second season, as is being reported. Get Wilfried Bony in if we can’t get Lukaku, and maybe if we get 4th and Pochettino leaves, we could maybe try for Adam Lallana, who I like a lot. He’d definitely excel in a Martinez team.
Jack Cross
9 Posted 25/04/2014 at 00:25:58
Yes Deulofeu good news. As Roberto, wasn't my first choice but doing well, as you say lets see in next couple of seasons if it's still all rosy. Hopefully it will be. Loan deals are ok short term but you can't build a team around loans every season. How can you make plans on next step? A perm striker that's what we need. Bony hopefully. About 14 mil I reckon.
Harold Matthews
10 Posted 25/04/2014 at 07:35:07
Jack. Lukaku and Bony are both being touted at £20m+. Everyone wants a guaranteed goalscorer. They don't come cheap. Dave Whelan reckons that if you find one available at a reasonable price, you have to keep your mouth shut or he will be pinched from under your nose.
Paul Roberts
11 Posted 25/04/2014 at 08:05:57
Ross and Mike,

I used to protect myself from the pain of EFC failure by preemptive pessimism. I feel your doubt! But...2 more wins this season and we would have still been involved not only in the CL shake-up but also the "Race for the Title". At no point this season have I felt like we were "over-performing" (I've never quite understood that expression. If you can play at a certain level once, you can play at that level every time.). IF (that was a big 'if' by the way) we can keep hold of our best players and get 2 or 3 new ones in , loans or otherwise, then I genuinely believe that we should have big ambitions for next season. Who would have predicted this time last year that the RS would be champions elect? COYB.


Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads

© ToffeeWeb