Elstone to provide stadium update at AGM

, 24 April, 150comments  |  Jump to most recent
Everton will provide shareholders an update on a proposed new stadium development at next Tuesday's Annual General Meeting, the Everton Shareholders Association have announced.

With the club continuing to rule out redevelopment of Goodison Park as a viable option, CEO Roberto Elstone has been working on new plans to relocate Everton to a new site within the boundaries of Liverpool and will provide details at the meeting at the Liverpool Philharmonic Hall.

Chairman Bill Kenwright is believed to favour a site on nearby Walton Hall Park and there has been a flurry of rumours over the past week that that is the location of a proposal for a new 54,000-seat Everton stadium.

An excerpt from the ESA announcement reads:

Mr Elstone intends to cover the new stadium opportunity at the forthcoming General Meeting. Pretty much everything that can be said will be presented on the evening when Mr Elstone will update Shareholders with the current status of the search for a new stadium and happily take questions on the subject.

Depending on how concrete the proposals from Mr Elstone are, this will be the first tangible sign of progress towards a new ground for the Blues since the failure of the controversial Destination Kirkby initiative four years ago.

According to the ESA, the new development "will not be a rehash" of the Kirkby design.

 

Reader Comments (150)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Keith Simmonds
1 Posted 24/04/2014 at 19:57:51
Is there really such commercial demand that they need more corporate seating/facilities. The current ground isn't always sold out. Sort out the football. All that money on Finch Farm and where's the talent? Barkleys is what we need more of not expensive matchday packages.
Eugene Ruane
2 Posted 24/04/2014 at 20:08:13
Phil Walling (314) - Agree.
Kevin Day
3 Posted 24/04/2014 at 20:09:39
To be fair Keith, gates this season have rose significantly, with last 6 games being total sell outs, if this upward spiral continues, and with the possibility of CL football I see 54000 as adequate.
Keith Simmonds
4 Posted 24/04/2014 at 20:13:44
I’d be looking at season ticket sales increases year on year for at least 3 to 4 seasons and decent increases at that.

If you had a restaurant that was 80% full all the time, you wouldn’t say "we need more tables". You would make sure the food was a consistent standard so people keep coming back and eventually things snowball. In other words, we need to be in 5th or 4th for a few seasons and that should give you good reason to expand.

I think the brand of football being played will be a draw but only alongside some measure of modern-day success.

James Smith
5 Posted 24/04/2014 at 20:20:56
We need to move on but it will be a shame leaving Goodison. Also I know its unlikely but if this was to go ahead what would happen to Goodison Park?
Kevin Day
6 Posted 24/04/2014 at 20:31:46
James,

If the board had any sense they would redevelop the ground for housing/ retail park and collect the rent.

Duncan McDine
7 Posted 24/04/2014 at 20:35:45
Why do I feel completely disinterested in talk of a new stadium?... Could it be the fact that nothing will actually come of it?
Charlie Fath
8 Posted 24/04/2014 at 20:43:42
In response to 314 'Do we need more corporate/seating?' the answer is a big YES. Our challengers for 4th, Arsenal take just about double our receipts every home game, that's an incredible amount over the season. Its not just because they have more seats but the Emirates has extensive corporate facilities and is a common place for conferences etc.

We'll never compete with salaries with next to no corporate and 38,000 seats. Success on and off the pitch go hand in hand nowadays. If we want to keep Barkley and Stones then we have to be able to pay big big wages.

Colin Glassar
9 Posted 24/04/2014 at 21:14:39
Keith, you are pure comedy gold.
Jay Harris
10 Posted 24/04/2014 at 21:12:00
I would love to redevelop GP and feel that that would be the most cost effective option but I suppose when you take naming rights, corporate hospitality and increased gate prices into account there would probably be more potential revenue in a new stadium.

Wonder how this fits in with the new financial fair play regulations?

Patrick Murphy
11 Posted 24/04/2014 at 21:16:23
Keith is right - what are we thinking of spending money on stadiums and improving facilities anyone would think this is the 21st Century for God's sake. St. Luke's is more than adequate for pre-match tea and a biscuits and we could rip the seats from the lower Bullens and Lower Gwladys and put some buffet tables and a few deck chairs in their - reduce the capacity to around 30,000 and charge £50 a seat to raise money. Keith are you any relation to Mr Bill Kenwright?
Karl Jones
12 Posted 24/04/2014 at 21:11:24
Not this again. No doubt yet another controversial vote. Years and money wasted on plans for something that will never happen, unless some rich benefactor buys Everton, which also will never happen. It will be interesting to see how they propose to finance it though.
Brian Harrison
13 Posted 24/04/2014 at 21:11:42
I would imagine that Elstone will say that the club and the City council have had detailed talks and have identified an area that they would like to develop for a new ground. Maybe the council have suggested that they will not hold up any planning permission that may be needed.

But and its a big but where will we get the funds to build a new ground as well as giving RM money to buy players. I would imagine we will be told that to pursue this agenda we will be actively looking for new investors to make it happen. I hope I am wrong and we are told where we will be building the new stadium and how it will be paid for, but somehow I don't think that will be the outcome of the AGM.

Dan McKie
14 Posted 24/04/2014 at 21:17:35
I really hope we hear that there has been some real progress, not just, we've found a site, we have a design....we just don't have the cash!
Colin Glassar
15 Posted 24/04/2014 at 21:22:13
Pardon my ignorance but, what happened to Stanley Park? Why can’t we build there?
Dennis Stevens
16 Posted 24/04/2014 at 21:23:31
Deja vu all over again!
Patrick Murphy
18 Posted 24/04/2014 at 21:37:40
Come on folks! We all know it's going to be that Lego guy who is trying to build every stadium in the PL? out of Lego and Mr Suntan is going to introduce him as a visionary and independent member of the board.
Darryl Ritchie
19 Posted 24/04/2014 at 21:46:40
This issue has been thrashed to death. Any and all speculation is premature.... until after the meeting. Then let's have at it!
David Waugh
20 Posted 24/04/2014 at 22:17:56
We badly need this. Goodison, whilst a great atmosphere is long past its sell by date. Supply creates its own demand and more people would attend games knowing they'd not be sitting behind stanchions, etc. A new stadium brings kudos too, especially with the right corporate facilities. All this equals cash. If we stand still then don't be surprised if others overtake.
Ste Traverse
21 Posted 24/04/2014 at 22:33:57
Given their well known past failings, does ANYONE have any faith this muppet crew running our club delivering this time around?
Paul David
22 Posted 24/04/2014 at 22:38:30
It's Walton Hall Park. A stadium, hotel, bars and restaurants will all be built.
Shane Corcoran
23 Posted 24/04/2014 at 22:53:07
Dennis, have you experience Deja vu before then?
Dennis Stevens
24 Posted 24/04/2014 at 22:56:13
Yes Shane, but also : jamais vu ...... it's mixed up world!
Mike Goodwin
25 Posted 24/04/2014 at 22:38:54
Why are we sleepwalking towards a second-rate stadium, 800 yards away from our spiritual home and ditching 122 years of tradition – Dixie Dean, Dave Hickson, Alex Young, Duncan Ferguson, Goodison Park? You may ask how I know it will be second-rate. Where are we going to get the money to build anything to rival a re-vamped Anfield?

For some reason, there does not seem to be the will, within the Everton hierarchy, to rebuild Goodison Park. I'm sure if you asked the fans, 95% or more would prefer to stay at Goodison, were it at all possible, yet time and again, this notion is dismissed by the Everton board. Why?

At every step of the way, Liverpool seem to be facilitated by the city council. You want a new ground? How about a location in Stanley Park, 200 yards away from Anfield? No, you've decided to stay at Anfield. Okay, how about we re-generate the whole area with Anfield as the centre piece, so that you retain all that history and everything that goes with it, encased in a super modern stadium.

If they don't wan't Stanley Park, why can't we have it? Or more specifically, as we proposed a while back, just an encroachment of about 20 yards at the northern end, and re-route Walton Lane accordingly. Joe Anderson has said that the city council are looking at ways to help Everton in the same way as they helped Liverpool, but the club seems intent on moving away, without exploring other possibilities. Why?

Other posters have pointed out that Goodison Park is way past its sell-buy date. This doesn't necessarily mean we have to move away. I don't have the answers, but I know that I will be desperately disappointed, the day we move from Goodison Park.

Carl Sanderson
26 Posted 24/04/2014 at 22:55:23
Ste 390,

I for one have no faith on this Board to carry through a project with this level of ambition and complexity. The King's Dock fiasco revealed them to be utter amateurs. And as for Kirkby...

Kevin Day
27 Posted 24/04/2014 at 22:56:01
The thing with redeveloping it actually costs 50% more on average than building from new, the BRE reports (Building Research Establishment) have numerous technical research reports that prove this fact time and again. To redevelop you have to actually take apart the building fabric, and reinstate with new. To develop a new build, you have green/ brown field site and a blank canvas, you build your stadium with out having to dismantle which halves construction time.
Anthony Jones
29 Posted 24/04/2014 at 23:33:04
We do not need and will not benefit from Kirkby mkII. The current owners, who between them are unwilling to lend the club cash for even just the half time oranges need to accept an offer for the club that does not make them substantially wealthier than they were when they bought in. This would allow new owners to take a leading stake in a new stadium development. And still Bill spouts his righteous nonsense about the club coming first.
James Martin
31 Posted 24/04/2014 at 23:52:57
I know its all rumours but I really feel we could strike a decisive blow against our city rivals by building a new stadium somewhere in the city centre. If it was near the docks, every picture of the waterfront would have our stadium in it, every tourist from a cruise boat would see our name, every hotel resident would hear our stadium roaring at night. All of this whilst Liverpool remained stuck at Anfield.

This all sounds far too beneficial for us and detrimental to them... so tin pot stadium in some park that’s miles away is probably the order of the day, knowing Everton.

Dennis Stevens
32 Posted 24/04/2014 at 23:55:43
The reason the Board want DK Mk II is the same reason they wanted DK Mk I - & it’s nothing to do with Everton getting a new ground, or even leaving Goodison Park. They think that once they show some flashy pics & get planning permission the value of the club will soar & some numpty will give them a 400%, or so, profit. However, I think the flaw in their cunning plan may be that people as rich as that don’t get & stay that way by being really, really stupid.
Dennis Stevens
33 Posted 25/04/2014 at 00:03:42
Our only hope is that rs complete their stadium redevelopment & then Liverpool host the Commonwealth Games & Everton move into the new stadium built specially for the occasion.
Jamie Crowley
34 Posted 24/04/2014 at 23:59:20
Not being from Liverpool I just Google mapped Walton Hall Park. It seems to be a stone’s throw from Stanley Park.

The loudest argument re Kirkby seemed to be the location - outside the city. So, if this new location is so close to the current one and we could have a new stadium with much, much needed corporate boxes and increased seating, what’s the problem?

I don’t say that in a smart-ass fashion. As an outsider I’m asking quite literally what are the cons if this were to occur? It seems a no-brainer if we can afford it. Someone enlighten the dumb American please.

Of course I’ve very little confidence it will actually happen...

Dennis Stevens
35 Posted 25/04/2014 at 00:17:45
Jamie, we can’t afford it & the city boundary wasn’t the biggest issue by far.
Steavey Buckley
36 Posted 25/04/2014 at 00:24:34
If someone else’s money builds the stadium then leases it to Everton, that would make financial sense. But to go into massive debts to build a new stadium with the much needed money that’s needed (always) to be spent on players and their salaries, makes no financial sense.
Tim Locke
37 Posted 25/04/2014 at 00:24:04
Mike - spot on we should be looking at two option, expand the current ground, not sure where you get those figures from Kevin? Or move to the park.

Seems short sighted to go to 54,000; this would be the quickest way to become the very poor relations. You need a 70,000 plus.

As for people saying we need them queuing round the block before we expand that’s rubbish. Resturant and football stadium are very different, silly comparison.

The idea of having a 70,000 plus ground would be, sell more corporate seats, this gets money into the club and makes us better for investment, so shirt sponsors, boards etc. Sell more season tickets, prices could remain low and the club would make more money. More children’s tickets at low prices, get the kids hocked and cash in later in life.

So higher supply, I.e. More seats, lower prices, more people attend, demand increases. As demand goes up, prices will go up and the club will grow, more money, better players, better players better football, higher demand so it keeps going. You need a big stadium to get this process working.

Keith Simmonds
38 Posted 25/04/2014 at 01:07:07
Need to find a better model than pursuing this idea of making a bigger ground in order to piss it up the wall in higher wages.

The TV money on its own should be more than enough to run a club on. Should be churning out technically proficient players who play the same system from age of 11 or 12 till they make the senior squad like the germans do. And then stop signing players or giving in to wage demands. Sign up on pro terms at 18 on 7 year contracts. Wage capped at no more than £40k but only for the very best players with £20m buyout on every player. Let them go if they want but there will be someone else with same skills to do same job thrown into the deep end. All you need do is avoid relegation. Sometimes you will get lucky and get a great group of players and hit those dizzy heights of 5th or 4th.

Its madness saying "give Baines/Stones/Coleman" an extra £20k a week" and expecting to somehow be entitled to progress up the league. We are paying Lukaku and Barry’s wages arent we? In full. Theyre both on about £100k a week. Its insane. We cannot afford it and its frankly appalling that no one is trying to do things differently.

Eric Myles
39 Posted 25/04/2014 at 01:36:39
"we need to be in 5th or 4th for a few seasons and that should give you good reason to expand"

Problem is Keith #324, it’s too late then, you’ve lost all that potential revenue for the 3 or 4 good seasons you’ve had and by the time you’ve built the stadium your great new manager has been poached any you’re back to 7thish.

Mark Taylor
40 Posted 25/04/2014 at 01:35:32
I posted this elsewhere but I just don’t think new build stadiums stacks up financially nowadays, especially if you are barely selling out your current capacity of 40k.

It’s possible if you do a Man City or (maybe) a West Ham and move into something that someone else has built and funded. Failing that, it can work if your current ground is in serious real estate territory (Arsenal and maybe Chelsea in the future). Otherwise it’s one hell of a risk.

The biggest need is to add corporate facilities. These are currently at Championship level at best and their shortcomings are very probably holding us back from getting in big name sponsors. The current set is seriously uninspiring for a club reaching 4th or 5th in the world’s biggest league. I mean seriously, Crabbies? Stubhub, Sodexo and even Nike are suppliers, not really sponsors. Chang would be a good regional sponsor but not the main club sponsor. If we can’t do better than this, our prospects are limited but I would have thought that for a lot less money, we could extent the corporate facilities at GP.

I think the two biggest revenue drivers for clubs in the future won’t be ticket sales, but global TV right and sponsors. We could do with learning from Man U’s segmentation model on the latter.

Eric Myles
41 Posted 25/04/2014 at 01:52:00
Jay #344, not a problem if the redevelopment includes corpoate facilities, increased seat prices and what’s to stop a namings rights? Newcastle never moved but have changed the name of their ground.

The naming rights could even be for the individual stands rather than the ground as a whole.

Mike Jones
42 Posted 25/04/2014 at 05:28:12
We don’t need to move. We don’t need more Exec boxes. We have some of the very best exec boxes in the league (great sightlines, the closest boxes to the pitch in the league!) and we struggle to sell them. (Ask our commercial department for availability....you would be surprised.)

Also, if we had 60’000 seats we could end up with LESS season ticket holders as people could pick and choose what games they go to knowing they would get a decent seat regardless.

Knock down the Park End (Massive missed opportunity 1st time round) and rebuild up to around 45/48000 as phase one.

Thomas Lennon
43 Posted 25/04/2014 at 07:17:28
Here comes the same old arguments from the stay- here crew. Where we are is tiny. Compare it with any top 6 club on Google maps, it looks like a strangely shaped hemmed in matchbox, I was shocked when I did this.

GP holds us back. Tiny space limits top class facilities. Limits retail opportunities and has 5000 seats with crap views. Those that we have are as good as we can get them and we get the best prices we can.

There is no room to expand, it would cost quite a few people their homes if we tried to. And for what you get it is expensive.

Move up the road. Accept we are finally able to improve financially. Arsenal make 3_4 times we do every match they play. Don’t expect to beat them regularly.

Kevin Day
46 Posted 25/04/2014 at 08:38:43
Tim Locke;

I’m not trying to be a smart arse, but refurbishment does cost more than a new build, the biggest turn over from the construction industry is from refurbishment, due to the fact it costs a lot more, you ask where do I get my figures; well, I have 20 years experience in the construction, and a BSc in Building Surveying, and I use the BRE and BCIS on a daily basis.

Joe Bibb
47 Posted 25/04/2014 at 08:44:19
Sainsbury’s & Walton Hall Park that’s the plan.
Craig Walker
48 Posted 25/04/2014 at 09:00:59
I think we should follow the RS’s lead on this one and redevelop Goodison a stand at a time, starting at the Park End.
Tony I'Anson
49 Posted 25/04/2014 at 08:53:47
The EFCSA announcement says Robert is happy to take questions on the subject, so assuming some shareholders are reading this, why not post questions here to ask on the night?
Steve Carter
51 Posted 25/04/2014 at 09:06:32
To say we fucked up big time with Kings Dock is, of course, an understatement. However, to either redevelop Goodison or build in Walton (or any other nowhere land place) would be an even greater balls up. FFS what Everton do next will define us for every toffeewebber’s lifetime. So, we build a cheap stadium in Walton a stone’s throw from the better stadium build by our "world brand" neighbours. Good one. Whoever thinks that or redevelop Goodison, go skol a slimy pint in the Winslow and give yourself an uppercut. We have the build in the city centre. Some posters say we can’t afford to. Mates, we can’t afford not to.
Iain Johnston
53 Posted 25/04/2014 at 10:25:09
Does anyone know what is being built on the brown field site on Aintree lane? The area was once school playing fields... Quite close to the golf course that a certain Mr Johnson had his eye on.
Paul Mackie
54 Posted 25/04/2014 at 10:33:25
I couldn’t agree more with some posters in this thread. We need to build big or not at all. A 70,000 seater stadium with the cheapest ticket prices in the country. Football used to be affordable, Everton could do that again. Imagine growing up in the city knowing you could either go watch the RS sat next to a bunch of Norwegians for £60 a ticket or paying half that to see a match with a real atmosphere.
Kevin Gillen
55 Posted 25/04/2014 at 10:33:52
I found an old programme last week, England v Northern Ireland at Goodison. I’m sorry but the stadium is like a 70’s theme park now and I’m always shocked that the ground gets a new safety certificate. I’ve had some fantastic days there but it’s time to move on. When I go to Old Trafford I’m amazed at the space around the ground. We have been left so far behind Arsenal and United. Liverpool and Chelsea are still hampered by their grounds (Liverpool could probably sell their ground out twice in the next few games - there is a huge opportunity cost to not developing a new ground). Tottenham are about to relocate. There is a huge dormant Everton fanbase that a bit of success on the pitch will ignite. I’m not convinced this board can deliver a viable new stadium plan mind. The King’s Dock was a massive missed opportunity and Kirkby a fiasco.
Nick Entwistle
56 Posted 25/04/2014 at 10:40:35
Would love to see Goodison redeveloped. A modern take on the main stand’s design wrapped around three sides, and use the space behind the Park End for something like Dortmund have... only bigger.

What I couldn’t abide is some soulless bowl that is more about corporate sight lines than the proper fan. Fortunately we don’t have much of the former!

For every match I’d also have St Roberto enter the ground directly from St Luke’s carried aloft by alter boys in a show of smoke and lasers.

Eric Myles
57 Posted 25/04/2014 at 10:46:01
Thomas #460, redevelopment gets rid of those limitations you list.
Jonathan McMahon
58 Posted 25/04/2014 at 11:17:05
What we have to bear in mind here is, yes we need to concentrate on the football side, but ultimately we have been a top 7 side for around 10 years so, to make that next step, we need to have a bigger ground to attract better players and also to produce more income.

We are not going to get outside investment without a new stadium in place. Think of what has happened to Man City? If we had a new ground at that point, rumour has it we were first choice.

Thomas Lennon
59 Posted 25/04/2014 at 11:59:01
Eric#520, redevelopment would if we were allowed to expand our footprint radically - we are all familiar with leveling the school, small business and about 60 houses was it (?) giving us all the land we need. But those are peoples homes, not boarded up properties.

The only possibility on our present footprint is to build upwards - thus building in years of inferior space compared with our competitors. We have to think BEST standard not crowbar a ’fixit’ solution into a much loved but unsuitable ground for a team wanting to be at the top of our league. BU once published a sort of ’entertainment block’ built on the school site thet we are told we can have. It is a nice idea but makes us look extremely second class.

Liverpool are about to build in inferiority with a far smaller capacity than originally suggested, I wonder why? Cost? Room? Perhaps they can sell at higher ticket prices but we demonstrably can’t. We need lots of seats - right now we could probably fill 50 - 60 000 @ £30-40.

Back in the 70’s ManU thought big, 1990’s Arsenal thought big, 2000’s MCity thought big. We need to think big to compete. Dont imagine that Roberto can keep us up there year on year - just look at how the loss of big players hurt our ambitions Jan/Feb and compare with City or Chelsea when they lose a big player.

It isn’t just about seats or corporates but the room to efficiently serve those areas and make paying £150 a seat for corporate entertainment worth paying.
Moving also gives us our best chance of building a stadium to be proud of. The cost savings will allow better quality built in.

Peter Morris
60 Posted 25/04/2014 at 12:07:00
Without a) a major ’enabling ’ project, as with the Commonwealth Games for Man City, or London Olympics from which West Ham will benefit, or alternatively b)a very rich new owner(not likely either), then I can see no prospect of Everton being able to fund a stadium that would be ’fitting’ and in keeping this club’s status. Do we want to end up in a Reebok Stadium, a St Mary’s or a Ricoh Arena? God help us NO! Aston Villa did a good job overlaying Corporate facilities onto Villa Park and I for one would want to see the case for this NOT being done at Goodison FULLY justified in detail by this Board, and not just dismissed out of hand as being impractical. If we can’t afford to build a new stadium that will transfer Goodison’s unique, tribal atmosphere to a new site, as well as delivering all of the necessary corporate stuff, then I think we sit tight until we achieve sufficient success on the field to enable us to do so. I think Roberto’s ’build from within’ strategy so far has offered enough encouragement to believe that we can do this in time.
Ron Sear
61 Posted 25/04/2014 at 12:51:22
Perfect site. Halfway between Norris Green and Walton Prison. No shops, pubs or facilities and a known destination for a certain type of tourist. If ever Millwall make it back into the Premier League, they will feel completely at home.
Colin Malone
62 Posted 25/04/2014 at 12:41:28
Great news. My concern is the actual build of the stadium. Ok, it will be a massive plus not waiting 30 minutes for a pie and a drink, as in the Etihad, stadium of light and the Emirates, but they have lost their twelfth man, hence why Man Utd and the Shite have decided to build on their stadiums. I’m not in favour of these bowl shape stadiums.
Gary Cargill
63 Posted 25/04/2014 at 13:39:27
Let us hope the club understands, as we do, just how important it is to build a stadium with atmosphere in mind. I read somewhere Elstone saying something about the new ground having the biggest, most atmospheric home end in football. If that is the case, it would have to give Borussia Dortmund’s Yellow Wall a run for its money, and if so, BRING IT ON.

Talk is cheap, though, Mr Elstone, Mark Twain sums our board up best when he said... "Action speaks louder than words but not nearly as often." I will believe it when I’m sitting in it and can hear the faithful roar.

Andrew Sell
64 Posted 25/04/2014 at 13:56:11
I disagree with the notion that the location was not the biggest problem last time. Yes, the Kirkby stadium was very poor in my opinion but the Board would have got away with it if it wasn’t for the poor location and little compliance with planning policies.

Don’t forget, all those planning rules have now been watered down/abolished and this new location that Kenwright would love (rumoured to be Walton Hall Park) is a stone’s throw from Goodison in Walton and would be acceptable to at least 90% of our supporters.

Tim Locke
65 Posted 25/04/2014 at 14:40:42
Kevin - how come when you look at costs development comes up higher. RS spending £270m expanding stadium, Ars spent nearly £500m building theirs?

The benefit of expanding the current group would be:

History - although more a nice to have than a major benefit think history of a club stands for a lot.

Cost - As outlined above half the price, although happy to be proved wrong on this.

Quicker - You can develop part at a time while keeping the existing stadium open.

If the RS are going for 58,000 we should match or exceed that, I would like to see 70-80,000. Good spread of ticket prices and encouraging young people in

Ian Burns
66 Posted 25/04/2014 at 13:13:08
What a fascinating spread of opinions. I find this a really difficult subject because I have never really recovered from the wonderful opportunity the King’s Dock provided.

However, I feel the need to say something on the subject, although second to what happens on the field of play, this is the most important of subjects for the EFC family.

Kevin Day (401 and 474) brings up an extremely interesting point on cost and given EFC are going to have to fund it out of revenue, this point carries a lot of weight.

All the talk of a 70,000 seater stadium is in my opinion a non-starter unless a stadium can be so designed it can be expanded. The Etihad only holds 47 to 48,000 I believe.

Seeing the comment by James Martin 421 provides the sort of marketing opportunity from which we seem not to be able to take advantage - so the point made by Geoffrey Feeney 483 has some merit I believe with regards to the soon to be redeveloped Northern Docks. This is a question that needs to be asked at the AGM.

Whatever happens, I pray this latest announcement has some merit and if it goes to design, I agree with those who say we do not want a stadium lacking in soul - we need to transfer the GP feel!!!

Dennis Stevens
67 Posted 25/04/2014 at 14:54:45
Kevin Day #474 " ... refurbishment does cost more than a new build ... " - & yet rs turned their back on the new build, at a late stage, due to cost, apparently.
Carl Sanderson
68 Posted 25/04/2014 at 15:01:05
Ian 580,

"... I have never really recovered from the wonderful opportunity the King’s Dock provided."

Me neither. You’d need to ply me with a lot of Bombay Sapphire before I would believe that Kenwright won’t screw up any future opportunity.

Richard Reeves
69 Posted 25/04/2014 at 13:42:59
Mike Goodwin (#399), I could not agree more.

Looking at the footprint of both Goodison Park and Anfield, I would have to say there are more difficulties redeveloping Anfield as there are more residential houses keeping the ground hemmed in, yet they have managed to negotiate with house owners and will soon be expanding to something that looks a little like Old Trafford.

Surely the Council would help Everton in relocating the school which would leave the lorry depot and some residential houses to buy. I would’ve thought a good offer for the Lorry depot would have them move which would just leave the owners of the houses that you would have to negotiate on. Buying the residential houses would take time as not everyone would want to move but, as has been proven over the park, it is possible and we wouldn’t even need to buy them straight away as there is the whole of the Park End that can be redeveloped into a huge stand.

Personally, I would want Everton to start from scratch at the Park End or, if possible, add to it with a three-tier stand separated by a row of boxes in-between each tier. While the club are filling those seats, they could be buying houses with the plan to continue the triple-decker stand linking it up in stages so that eventually it either wraps around to the Gwladys Street End by the church or, as it could hold so many supporters, finish at the corner of Bullens and Gwladys, leaving the job of refurbishing the Gwladys Street End and removing pillars.

The capacity that the Park End could hold would mean that a continual building of this triple-decker stand could be done in segments like every 5 years or so. The board obviously are looking for another area so that other companies help foot the bill which inturn means the board will get a much bigger return on their next to nothing investment.

I hate it that we are told this is what is going to happen and that we have no choice; there should be choices. Without us fans there is no club or no board so we must be heard. There may be a few sites that people could give their opinion on but, as I’ve said before, it WILL be Walton Park as there will probably be a supermarket tied in with the whole development.

And, as I’ve said before, it WILL be as cheap as the Kirkby project, only different in design... but, if we have no choice but to move from Goodison Park, then it has to be a spectacular site near the City centre, on the docks as James Martin (#421) says.

I also agree with others who say we should be building a 70,000 seat stadium. If we are to compete with the RS for new fans, we could be offering cheap tickets for the kids, making the whole matchday experience more affordable for families. Most games I reckon could bring in 50-55,000 with the big or important games being a possible sell out but seeing as the whole league is getting stronger and there are more teams closing the gap those sell outs could happen more often.

Jackie Barry
70 Posted 25/04/2014 at 15:00:47
Why do I have the feeling that this is going to become the reason as to why Martinez is not going to have any money to spend? But in a few months time after the transfer window we will no longer be hearing anything about it.
Mike Allison
71 Posted 25/04/2014 at 15:27:31
I’ve skipped to the end a bit on this one so apologies if this point has been made.

I’d like to respond to the first few posters particularly Keith at 324.

Using your analogy Keith, let’s say we have a restaurant that is 80% full. We decide we have made the food a good consistent quality and that it is reasonable to expect people to come back. In fact we now believe with our growing reputation and new chef we will soon be 100% full and turning business away and losing money we would have made had we got more space and been able to offer more tables. Wouldn’t it make sense now to plan for the future, rather than do nothing, and when it happens realise we don’t have the facilities to cope with the progress we’ve made?

We need to balance the now with the future, something that working on a new stadium is doing. The team is doing well, they are very close to Champions League qualification and there are a lot of young players with a good medium term future at the club.

Incidentally, occasionally I allow myself to dream, what if all the money we haven’t been spending is saved up in a big bank account somewhere ready to build a beautiful new characterful stadium?

Mike Allison
72 Posted 25/04/2014 at 15:42:21
Okay I’ve got through most of the posts now, and there are two main issues that I want to talk about here.

Firstly, I want to stay at Goodison Park, and I think it is viable, it just needs some creative solutions that would leave us with a unique and idiosyncratic stadium rather than the off-the-rack shite that Kirby threatened to be. The Park End and the corners could be redeveloped first. The Park End could be twice its current size (including proper corporate facilities) and, crucially, nearer to Stanley Park. The pitch can then move a crucial 10/15 yards, meaning when the Gwladys is redeveloped, it doesn’t need to go back so far. The Bullens Road and Gwladys Street half of the ground could then be rebuilt.

However, there is definitely a part of me that thinks we should go totally outside the box. Maybe we have to move and my dream of developing Goodison in a unique and innovative way wouldn’t work. Well if we were to do that then a bigger stadium, let’s say 70,000 would be right.

The tickets would indeed be cheap, but crucially, the facilities would be good, the beer tasty and the food a joy to eat. Being in the stadium spending money for two hours before the game would be normal and enjoyable and all that money would be going into the clubs coffers. Maybe reserve or injured players would be doing meet and greets for the kids, fan zones (indoor and heated, not in tents!) would be fun to be in rather than just some wazzock with a microphone turned up too loud.

Local bands could play on the pitch before the game, other tie-ins could be introduced. You know, properly good ideas that would make the match going experience truly enjoyable, not just getting some fat kid or a bloke in a suit to take a penalty (and no, don’t worry, I’m NOT talking about cheerleaders).

I know 70,000 wouldn’t turn up every week, and empty seats kill atmosphere, but you could close the very top sections, make them set up for occasional use and use noise design to make sure crowd noise and atmosphere weren’t lost.

Oh, and it would have a tower in one corner (like the badge and the current club shop) and be designed like a church in another. In fact, the whole design would be based on replicating Goodison Park so that it felt familiar to any blue who went in.

Ian Burns
73 Posted 25/04/2014 at 15:58:46
Carl - 583 - you are probably right Carl with regards to having confidence in the Board to deliver - I still cry into my Bombay Sapphire every time I think of King’s Dock and the remarkable marketing opportunity we missed a la James Martin’s post - 421.

Kevin Tully
74 Posted 25/04/2014 at 16:31:02
Absolutely no chance our board will even consider redeveloping G.P. - who would fund it?

The only way forward for those in charge is for someone else to pay, including the council and maybe a supermarket chain. Beggars cannot be choosers has never been more apt!

Eric Myles
75 Posted 25/04/2014 at 17:03:50
Thomas #539, we could increase the capacity of Goodison to 55,000 without expanding the existing footprint.

Jonathan #525, that wasn’t rumour, that was bullshit from Bill. Look how much the Mansours are spending on City training facility and ground.

Ray Roche
76 Posted 25/04/2014 at 16:39:54
Tim Locke @432

Tim, just a point for you and all the other posts that think a 70000 seat stadium should be what we should be looking at, in our entire history we have only managed 70k plus on about 7-10 occasions, even when we had our highest AVERAGE attendance in the 62-63 season we managed 70k plus once and that was the first Derby match after the RS were promoted. As others have noted, nothing kills an atmosphere like empty seats. Fair play to Mike Allison, he has also noted that the top tiers could be closed off so that the rest of the stadium would appear full for the vast majority of matches when their would be our usual 40k (at best) in situ, something I mentioned on a previous thread. The likelihood of sitting in a half empty stadium fills me with dread. Those old enough to remember an average 20k plus with one season of 19288 will recall just how soul destroying that is. Actually, you don’t need to be that old. Why? Because it was in our Glory days in the 1980’s. In fact, from 1979-1980 to 1989-1990 we managed an average of less than 30k in eight separate seasons.
To imagine us suddenly getting an extra 30k EVERY week is living in cloud cuckoo land.

Richard Nelson
77 Posted 25/04/2014 at 16:29:54
I would hate to see EFC leave Goodison, 122 years, Dean,Young, Ball,Labone etc., so what does any one think about the following proposals, are they feasible ?

What would it cost to move the Park End back 10 metres and build a 5,000 seater upper tier ? (Newcastle have done it)

What would it cost to move the Lower Gladwys forward 10 metres in preparation for a new Upper Gladwys in the future ?

What would it cost to demolish the hospitality boxes under the Main Stand and return with seating ?

What would it cost to develop 60 2 tier hospitality boxes under the Upper Bullens ?

What would it cost to push the Upper Bullens out 5 metres over the pavement and road ? ( Villa have done it)

Does it matter if the Goodison looks unbalanced for a few years if it buys time ?

Surely a 47,000 capacity will keep the club going for a while!?

Gavin Ramejkis
78 Posted 25/04/2014 at 17:50:27
Its the magical time of the year when Jackanory Kenshite rolls out something to please the seals. This will go nowhere, more piss and wind, pissed away millions on consultancy, pretty plans, poncey artists impressions etc.

Cutting right to the chase, if the current incumbents have proven anything beyond a shadow of a doubt is that not one of them puts their own hands in their pockets for anything to do with the club. A new stadium or even redeveloped Goodison simply isn’t going to happen on their clock, roll up roll up the begging bowl for some other sucker to fund it - Desperation Kirkby shows what that brings out someone looking to use us as the sucker for their con not ours.

In cloud cuckoo land of lets go and get a 70 or 80 or however many thousand seater new stadium there is a screaming elephant in the room - who is going to pay for it? Even a Barr concrete shithole of pure breeze blocks that looks like some lego abortion would cost serious dough which would be transferred onto the club meaning what little we make from the piss poorly ran business (which also won’t change overnight) will be spunked on paying the build costs for at least the next 30 years or more, probably a lot longer. Don’t forget this is a business that uses payday loans from the BVI not some shrewd money spinner.

I wouldn’t trust the current incumbents with any meaningful project or build or sudden discovery of business acumen, their track record stinks. Expect this to fizzle away quickly until Black Bill needs his ego stroking again next year.

Thomas Lennon
79 Posted 25/04/2014 at 18:27:18
Lots of old ground being covered here so I might as well add

Those criticising the apparent cheap nature of a future stadium - have you ever stopped to look at what Goodison Park is made of? There is an awful lot of corrugated iron for a start - not that expensive if you want that on your new stadium? Concrete blocks, old brick.

We miss many a carbuncle on the face of those we love.

Lee Gray
80 Posted 25/04/2014 at 18:52:17
We have to move forward and if Arsenal can fill 60,000 with limited success we can if we get Champions League football on a regular basis.
Malcolm Joyner
81 Posted 25/04/2014 at 18:33:37
I suspect this subject has only raised its head again on the coat tails of the Anfield plans.

Whatever scheme emerges, it will split Evertonians’ views just as DK did.......and it will never happen, anyway.

Don’t give it dignity by arguing about it !

Eugene Ruane
82 Posted 25/04/2014 at 19:02:11
Regular Champions League, Everton in a new (full?) sixty thousand seater stadium, a SEVENTY thousand seater stadium (!?), a city centre location..

Talk about wishful thinking - what in EARTH are people on?

Seriously, how many times do you need a kick in the bollocks before you start to think of cupping your hand in front of your ball-bag to protect yourself?

I have NO idea what Elstone is going to say, or what is in the pipe-line, but whatever it is, anything other than re-developing Goodison and I’m fucking terrified.

Brian Wilkinson
83 Posted 25/04/2014 at 19:08:52
Uncle Bill is looking to cash in his green shield stamps and trade in for some bricks and mortar, along with a new kettle and a push and go lawn mower for the groundsman.

He’s then going to get Nick Knowles and his crew from diy sos on the job, he will give Nick a sob story of how he stood in the boys pen with his arse hanging out of his kecks and how a Community badly need a new stadium.

Season ticket deadline will pass and the sound of Big Ben chiming with yet another transfer deadline passed and uncle Bill then stating we tried, we really tried for the new ground but met with too many hurdles.

The supporters can take it from me I will ensure Roberto will have the funds for the January window, besides its World Cup year prices are over inflated so best we wait til January hey lads.

Heard it all before Bill, for once just be open and honest with the fans and cut out the bullshit.

Andrew Hawes
84 Posted 25/04/2014 at 19:31:11
I don’t think we should be thinking about the capacity, corporate or even position of this new stadium. Just the fact that once we are in a 50-60,000 seater stadium then the business billionaires will start to circle, just as they have done at Man City and various other clubs.

Any rich wannabe owner could not fail to be impressed with the team, manager, fans, history etc... but, as we all know, to get someone in with the kind of money to complete £20-30M transfers, then we have to be sitting in a home fit for purpose!!

Raymond Fox
85 Posted 25/04/2014 at 19:21:46
What we need is a winning team.
Do we need a new stadium, it would nice, but who the hells going to pay for it?
We don’t desperately need a stadium , our priority is a winning team, we need to win something, then we may attract someone with the money to invest in a new goodison.

We need to speculate to accumulate and back our manager, that means giving him a substantial transfer kitty.

Will this happen, file it under unlikely!

Ray Roche
86 Posted 25/04/2014 at 20:02:16
Raymond, "but who the hells going to pay for it?"...who the hell’s going to populate it more like!
Ian Bennett
87 Posted 25/04/2014 at 20:20:37
Unless Bill has put the a Arteta money on a super Yankee I wouldn’t get too carried away. I’ll believe it when I am sat in it, paying £10 a pie.

Until then it will be cheap pies, big queues for a piss and the smell of ammonia emanating from the Bullens Road stand on a wet day. National Trust, Goodison Park.

Bobby Thomas
88 Posted 25/04/2014 at 20:27:19
We are pretty much filling the ground now, even with an absurd number of restricted views.

We havent won a trophy for 19 years ffs. There is a load of latent Everton support out there.

Considering how often the fanbase has been slapped in the face over the past 20 years I think support has held well.

The new stadium effect is well documented. Get momentum on and off the pitch we would fill 50,000, these are the boom years of football.

The club is being held back, its on a leash and if we can harness our potential we can go places.

Eugene Ruane
89 Posted 25/04/2014 at 20:38:50
Bobby Thomas - "The new stadium effect is well documented. Get momentum on and off the pitch we would fill 50,000, these are the boom years of football"

Do you have reference to these documents?

The reason I ask..

http://i.dailymail.co.uk/i/pix/2013/09/18/article-2424513-16C58F7A000005DC-234_634x408.jpg

Alan Rodgers
90 Posted 25/04/2014 at 20:40:30
Well said Bobby Thomas. It’s been difficult to buy 3 seats together this season and will be worse next season ,CL or not. If we could only get rid of restricted views we could easily fill a 50,000 stadium .
Kevin Tully
91 Posted 25/04/2014 at 20:54:06
Parents everywhere are always looking for somewhere to take their kids for a day out. Make football on Merseyside affordable enough and I’ve no doubt we could reach out to maybe 15 - 20,000 extra fans per fortnight?

The red side are already pricing more and more people out of attending games, whereas we are doing season tickets for £99.00 for kids, a great initiative. As they grow up to be adults, they will come back as long as football is popular. Plenty of scope for 60,000 if we can bring some success IMO.

James Martin
92 Posted 25/04/2014 at 20:54:53
I know this will be laughed at, but why don’t we just build a bigger stadium than what Anfield will be after the redevelopment. It is a test of the board’s aspiration they should build a 70,000 seater and try and fill it rather than building a 50,000 seater. Why should we operate under the assumption that Liverpool will always have more fans than us?

It irks me all the time that Anfield is bigger than Goodison, that it is considered for world cup games whereas Goodison wouldn’t be. Its the biggest outward expression of our inferiority in comparison to them. Two stadiums right across the park from each other but one is bigger than the other - naturally any new stadiums would reflect this? The same way Everton can have a good season but Liverpool’s always have to be better. For once can we go back to when we used to be the pioneers who did things first and everyone copied us. Why do they need a bigger stadium than us - that is just admitting that we expect them to be successful long term whereas we are hedging our bets with 50,000

First club in Merseyside to go over 70,000 seats - suck on that RS. Biggest stadium in Merseyside, best team in Merseyside - someone at Everton other than Roberto has to start thinking big one of these days and then we might actually go somewhere.

Ross Edwards
93 Posted 25/04/2014 at 21:38:01
Do we have the money to build a 70,000 seater stadium James?

Even City are only thinking of 60,000 for their expansion of the Etihad.

Sean Kelly
94 Posted 25/04/2014 at 21:40:13
I think Malcolm 637 has it right. We can’t afford it and it won’t happen on Billy’s watch. Just remember what Distin tweeted a few weeks ago saying we can’t afford to replace him and he’s all we can afford. If that’s right and from the inside how in fuck’s name can we even dream about a new stadium?

Let’s face it, folks, we are already borrowed up to our nuts and, unless you or I win the Euromillions money it ain’t gonna happen. Billy and the board are masters at spin. A couple of fancy drawings and an aspiration will satisfy the Billy Clappers but not the rest of us.

Keith Simmonds
95 Posted 25/04/2014 at 21:40:29
James, if we want to be pioneers, we could start by not doing what everyone else is doing. Rather than being the other club from Liverpool, we should be the Premier League team that has a squad of 100% EFC academy graduates.

All the money saved spent on redevelopment of GP and lower ticket prices for all. TV money is probably going to be around £80-90m all told. Debt should be a distant memory. We should be able to afford to close one stand at a time to do it up.

Alan McGuffog
96 Posted 25/04/2014 at 21:44:05
Bobby Thomas... totally agree. Remember the dark days of the early 1980s when we were " attracting" crowds in the low teens of thousands. The reds were on a high and myself and many more saw it as the end of any real support for the club. Why would any youngster choose us rather than them?

But time proved us wrong... there will always be immense support for the blue cause – if for no other reason than we are an alternative to them.

Kevin, affordability will be the key. Couple of deluded Reds I know genuinely feel that, when the capacity of Grey Skull goes up by one-third, then the admission prices will fall accordingly. They haven’t quite grasped the concept that their owners are in it to make money – not subsidise a day out for the denizens of L5.

An intelligent and sympathetic pricing system WILL ensure crowds of over 50k for most games. Not that it’s ever gonna happen like.

Bobby Thomas
97 Posted 25/04/2014 at 21:13:31
Eugene 670

A picture of empty seats at Boro. Well done.

The main point I suppose is for any club to have good gates and progress you need progress on and off the pitch, you need to drive the cub forward.

Middlesborough get crap gates because they are shit.

I would have no way of knowing how to direct you to this PDF thing ive found, technophobe. However, here is a list of some clubs, the attendances in the last 3 years at the old stadium and the first 3 years in the new:

Sunderland: Old: 15,700; 17,504; 20,847. New: 34,337; 38,475; 41,375.

Reading: Old: 8,917; 9,165; 9,676. New: 11,262; 8,985; 12,647.

Southampton: Old: 15,133; 15,132; 15,115. New: 30,633; 30680; 31,699.

Swansea: Old: 5,160; 6,850; 8,458. New: 14,112; 12,720; 13,520.

Now, how you progress your club is key. But have a look, the new stadium affect, short term is proven. After that, its just one element of how you progress the club.

Also, Goodison has one of the lower % take up of capacity seating in the Prem, about 96% I think, as the ground actively discourages people from showing due to the obstructed views.

Get the club rolling and we can take off. The latent potential of the club is huge. Or do you think it isn’t?

Bobby Thomas
98 Posted 25/04/2014 at 22:00:34
Oh, and I actually forgot:

Middlesborough: Old: 16,724; 10,400; 18,710. New: 29,257; 29,871; 29,997.

By the way I am not a 100% advocate of a stadium move, I think a plan for aggressive redevelopment would energise our fanbase as well. But it seems thats a no go for the board.

My main point is, you have to give your fanbase something to hold onto. Show you mean business and progress your club.

Club showing vision with a stadium move that people can get behind and a team having a proper go at the top 4? We can add 10k on the gate no problem. But it needs to be in harmony.

Shit team equals shit gates as your picture shows Eugene. Thats the only relevance it has.

James Martin
99 Posted 25/04/2014 at 22:02:40
I don’t know if we do Ross, we probably don’t have the money for a 50,000 seater stadium. Just seems stupid when you’re spending a load of money anyway only to put in 10k extra seats. I don’t mind if it comes with an option for future expansion to a greater capacity but I think this is a great opportunity for us to set our stall out for the type of club we want to be.

Largest stadium in Liverpool, in the city centre screams of a club ready for success.

50k seater Sainsbury’s drome in Walton hall park being overshadowed by Liverpool’s revamped spiritual home nearby just reeks of ’always in their shadow’. We’ll get accused of being a soulless pit in comparison to their magical European nights.

We could blow them out of the water and off the city map if we put a marker down for the future of the club in a prime location. Their staying at Anfield could turn out to be a fatal mistake in the long term but only if we capitalise on it. If we just retreat even further into a park accepting our ’little brother’ status then the status quo remains.

Ross Edwards
100 Posted 25/04/2014 at 22:13:14
I know what you mean though James. I’m fed up of the club being seen as inferior to others like City and Chelsea because they have more money than us.

We have more League titles than both of them put together, but as some fans in the country think football began in 1992, people think we are just a small mid table club that was ’saved by David Moyes’.

Mike Allison
101 Posted 25/04/2014 at 22:22:09
Middlesbrough also moved from the town centre in walking distance of everyone’s house, pub and working men’s club to an industrial site miles from anywhere, and raised ticket prices.
Eugene Ruane
102 Posted 25/04/2014 at 22:55:50
Bobby - "Shit team equals shit gates as your picture shows Eugene. Thats the only relevance it has"

Far too simplistic in my view.

One question I would ask is WHY are they a shit team?

Well I’m sure there’s loads of reasons (and I don’t know anything for sure) but imo it’s possible (even likely) that instead of putting what money they had into players, trying to get success, sustaining success, then using that success to fund a new ground, they put the horse before the cart, tried to be bertie big-bollocks (with a new ground) and look to have paid a high price.

Result, a shit team in a shit league...but with a ’new’ 35,000 seater stadium, currently getting about 15,000.

(nb: and unlike us, they had someone there in charge who DID put his hand in his pocket)

Same goes for Bolton and Coventry imo, horse before the cart.

As for the first three seasons in the new grounds, well great but...what’s to say it will last and what happens when it doesn’t?

Sunderland’s present average is (like them) heading downwards and will undoubtedly drop further in the championship.

Sorry but there is some incredible wishful-thinking on this thread, in fact a lot of it is pure fantasy imo.

Seventy thousand seater stadium ffs!?

(not 50, not 60....70!!).

Ok I’ll hold my hands up and admit that most of the above is simply opinion.

I’ll also admit I know less about finance than anyone, but I KNOW the following two things.

1) We have a board who will NOT spend their money.

2) New grounds cost fucking millions (nb: and really well-designed, none-shitty new grounds cost millions AND millions).

When talking about new grounds, that should be everyone’s starting point.

I mean how with BK and his mingebag dog-in-the-manger board, do we get a new ground and put together a side that can get and sustain success?

Anyone?

Sue Brown
103 Posted 25/04/2014 at 22:46:57
First time posting on here, but I do feel passionately about redeveloping Goodison and not moving to a soul-less bowl of a stadium.It’s not just our history over the last 122years, it’s the atmosphere, and...well...everything that is L4.

I do agree with a lot of the posts here that we need to invest for the future but does that have to be away from this Grand old Lady? I smile when the games are on TV because it’s rare that the special atmosphere of Goodison isn’t mentioned.

Looking at an ariel photo of the ground, my uncle once said if you could just move the ground a few degrees round towards the park away from Goodison Road you would have all the land you needed to extend and redevelop? Done in stages the cost is staggered which certainly suits our budgeting.

I have to agree with Alex Young when he said "Goodison Park is a magical place..there is something that makes the back of your neck tingle even when the place is empty"

Brent Stephens
104 Posted 26/04/2014 at 00:11:50
Welcome to TW, Sue. Sometimes it’s the emotion in a post which is more important than the content. I think your view about GP is a valid one. But I can just feel your emotional attachment to all things Everton in your post. Welcome on board.
Steavey Buckley
105 Posted 26/04/2014 at 01:31:42
What will keep Roberto at Everton for years to come, is that Everton are moving forward with him at the helm. That means that 2 things have to happen, the first team squad and academy improves, year by year; and Everton must either develop GP or build another stadium somewhere else.
Tony Draper
106 Posted 26/04/2014 at 06:15:34
Elstone says that there are proposals for a new ground

Personally, I have "proposals" for a threesome with Angelina Jolie & Charlize Theron

Of the two, mine (I believe) hasa considerably higher mathematical probability of "coming off"

Kevin Day
107 Posted 26/04/2014 at 07:52:23
You provided an answer to you own arguements there Tim Locke, the RS are spending 270 million on expanding one stand, from the pictures I’ve seen, Arsenal spent £500 on a brand new state of the art stadium.
John Crawley
108 Posted 26/04/2014 at 08:30:10
Kevin 740, where on earth did you get the figure of £270 million from? There’s been lots of articles in the press about the cost of Liverpool’s redevelopment and its nothing like £270 million. Its going to cost them £150 million to redevelop the ground and increase capacity to 60,000. They are looking to do it in a couple of phases. They are doing this because they can’t afford to develop a new ground.

I’m with Eugene on this, developing a new ground makes no sense, the sensible way forward is to do what Liverpool are doing which is a phased redevelopment. If we have a new ground we will lose our tradition and that magic that is Goodison.

Mike Green
109 Posted 26/04/2014 at 08:42:09
If you look at the "top" clubs (Arsenal, Chelsea, Man Utd, City, LFC, Spurs etc) they all have owners, in different shapes and forms who have backed, or are backing their clubs in the transfer market, or new grounds, or redevelopment. Even Newcastle fall into this.

Then there are the rest, and we for me, fall somewhere between the two. Great club, great potential, up fighting with the big boys thanks to good management on the pitch but in need of owners capable of taking us to the next step. Our current owners are not those people.

I don’t believe that type are going to touch us with Goodison in the state it’s in at the moment. So we need to extensively redevelop it, or move.

I’m with James Martin, if we move we need to build something spectacular. If we do that with Roberto’s help we’ll have a top 4 challenging side playing in a blue riband stadium for one of the games most historic clubs in the headland of world football. We would have a buyer - and a big buyer - within a year. They are out there.

The challenge for the current owners is to think big, act big, find the money (and don’t tell me the current lot and their pals couldn’t do it if the will was there - exactly as should have been done with Kings Dock), build the ground, sell up to get their desired profit and move on.

They can only achieve this if they get this right - New World Class Ground first - World Class Owners second - World Class Team third.

(imo...)

Mike Allison
110 Posted 26/04/2014 at 09:04:50
Eugene I’ll hold my hand up and say my posts are 100% wishful thinking, I don’t really see what other point this thread can have.

I’ve outlined what I wish would happen for Everton in the future. I think that should be the way you go about planning for the future, first identify what you want, then work out how to get it.

Either way, a top quality phased re-development of Goodison or a new massive stadium with loads of character and a distinctive design that evokes Goodison Park constitutes wishful thinking at this point, but I will be gutted with anything else.

Brin Williams
111 Posted 26/04/2014 at 09:12:25
Eugene, Having read most of the posts on this thread I am not sure what exactly you are advocating as a future football stadium for EFC.

You tell us what you don’t think will work - disagree with most suggestions put forward but can you please explain to a non-Merseyside resident exactly

1 Where the new stadium should be
2 What capacity it should be
3 If GP how is that to be developed
4 Are there any alternatives

No trying to catch you out just trying to get into your positive mindset as most of your previous posts has been about ’negativity’ and disagreeing with posters’ points of view.

Kieran Fitzgerald
112 Posted 26/04/2014 at 09:26:27
Why do people assume that we would get a commonwealth games stadium handed to us if there was ever one built. From a commercial point of view the RS would have a far better bid as they would be better able to fill the ground and make full use of any corporate facilities. Our amateurish Board would only make a fuck up of it anyway.

Ray Roche
113 Posted 26/04/2014 at 09:11:49
Bobby Thomas,
"Shit team equals shit gates" is really what it all boils down to. OK, we are getting decent gates at the moment and some are getting carried away ( in my opinion) in calling for a 70k stadium, but if we can afford investment in the team, that should come first. I mentioned earlier @616 that even in our successful 1980’s we didn’t have gates as good as we are getting now because, again, in my opinion, interest waned due to some of the poor performances in the 1970’s and this despite a 3rd and 4th finish under Lee. Football is a more saleable commodity now and it would be great to see Goodison redeveloped, which would be my option, but a successful team playing Champions League football regularly would give us the money to attain those aspirations AND ensure we had a chance of filling more seats.
Ray Roche
114 Posted 26/04/2014 at 09:41:55
Brin Williams @759

Over recent seasons there have been a number of articles, some in great detail, regarding HOW Goodison could be redeveloped. Enter "Goodison Park redevelopment plans" into Google and you can see them there. Tom Hughes did some excellent proposals as did the KEIOC.

Kevin Day
116 Posted 26/04/2014 at 10:05:25
John I was stating figures from a previous poster, I should given them citation maybe.
Mike Allison
117 Posted 26/04/2014 at 10:24:00
Weren’t low attendances in the 80s a result of apalling conditions and frequent violence or is this too simplistic?
Eugene Ruane
118 Posted 26/04/2014 at 09:57:07
Brin - "No trying to catch you out just trying to get into your positive mindset as most of your previous posts has been about ’negativity’ and disagreeing with posters’ points of view"

You say it’s about negativity, I say it’s about being realistic.

I’ve read fantasy stuff about what people would love to see happen, without any sensible suggestions of HOW these fantasies could become reality

You ask what, for me, is a key question..

"Eugene, Having read most of the posts on this thread I am not sure what exactly you are advocating as a future football stadium for EFC"

Well right now (nb: right now) I’m advocating...nothing.

Literally nothing, as in in no new stadium.

And why?

Because right this minute (for reasons I’ve explained), that is the only REALISTIC choice (a choice the facts forces me to make)

Depressing, frustrating, annoying, extremely worrying but... realistic.

And it is (again for reasons I’ve explained) wishful thinking to assume otherwise.

"Yes but there has to be something new at SOME stage in the future"

True, but the future can be the few seconds that will arrive after you’ve read this post, or 100 years from now and my belief (nb: with the present board in place) is that any 70,000-seater super stadium in the city centre (or wherever) hosting Everton in regular CL games will be closer to the latter.

Look, I accept that after smiling Bob has delivered his stadium update at the AGM, I could look way off the mark.

If we hear "We have a Japanese billionaire investor who is an Evertonian and is going to build a 60,000 seater stadium in the centre of Liverpool" I will be more than happy to admit "well I never saw THAT coming"

However, with what we know RIGHT THIS minute, my answer to your question ’what are you advocating’ has to be ’fuck-all’

Negative?

If you like but some things just...are.

Mike Goodwin
119 Posted 26/04/2014 at 12:03:36
Nothing to do with the new stadium debate, but does anyone remember in the 50s and 60s, when Everton DID have a 70,000 stadium and Liverpool DID have a 60,000 stadium?

Obviously, of course, this was before all-seater stadiums and more stringent safety rules were introduced, but in those days, they were the respective capacities of the 2 grounds, regardless of being hemmed in by streets of terraced housing.

Brin Williams
120 Posted 26/04/2014 at 21:18:32
Eugene,

At the mo you say ’do nothing’ about the new stadium - which is what will probably happen anyway - in the short term.

Chris Owens
121 Posted 26/04/2014 at 22:43:19
I wouldn’t expect much detail about a new stadium from next Tuesday’s AGM. I don’t know what these things cost, but if a suitable site has been found, then maybe the club is just trying to get an outline plan for a new stadium in place, with the relevant planning permission? This could be a vital first step in attracting a buyer for the club.

Clearly, we don’t have the money to build a stadium, but if we can remove some of the planning obstacles, then a potential buyer will have a better idea how much investment will be required.

Andy Crooks
122 Posted 27/04/2014 at 12:25:34
Is there someone out there who is going to give Bill the money for a 70, 000 seater stadium? I cannot believe how this subject makes normally rational posters go along with this insane delusion.

We cannot sustain premier league football AND build a new super stadium. Nor will we ever fill 70,000 seats. This is madness.

John Raftery
123 Posted 27/04/2014 at 18:19:20
My guess is that nothing precise will be revealed on Tuesday about funding options other than that a new stadium will not be part of a retail led development. The City Council made it very clear during the Kirkby Inquiry they will not sign up to any development which would compete with Liverpool One. The finance would therefore have to come from another form of development coupled with a public sector grant leaving the club to fund its share through naming rights and a long term rental agreement. The North Docks looks a favourite location to me.
Colin Glassar
124 Posted 27/04/2014 at 18:57:11
Mike Goodwin, and they were both filled to capacity on game days. But it was only about two bob to get in.
Rich Nelson
125 Posted 27/04/2014 at 19:43:10
Evertonians... stay at Goodison.... build a 6,000 capacity second tier at the Park End... £40/50 million. No disruption... job done in the Summer, What could be simpler?
Peter Lee
126 Posted 28/04/2014 at 00:01:05
Colin,

Neither ground was filled to capacity as you suggest. If I recall accurately, we needed to have an average gate of just over 47,600 to have a million fans at home games in a season, which we achieved just once. Capacity 63,000, do the maths.

Whilst I am on, can we nail this canard about Everton being favoured by the sheik over MCFC? The City purchase was all about raising the profile of the then newish Etihad airline. Without access to enough landing slots in the south-east they determined to make Manchester their base. John Lennon was never a consideration and neither were Everton.

In the same vein, there are only 4 big money prizes in the PL.There are currently 5 teams being bank-rolled big by foreign "investors". One misses out every season. Why would anyone want to join that club of five, make it six and thereby ensure that the cost of success will escalate as a result and that the chance of finishing in the top 4 becomes less?

Tom Hughes
127 Posted 28/04/2014 at 08:48:38
There is no way that adding 10-15,000 capacity to Goodison need cost more than building a whole new stadium of 50-60k elsewhere. That is mathematical nonsense. Even a bog standard flat-pack new bowl stadium will be approx £100m... excluding land and infrastructure costs. With something more inkeeping double or even tripple that. There are multiple possibilities on the current site. For example: Building a new 10k upper tier for the Bullens, with the first 6k built behind the existing stand and the rest added after demolition of the old upper tier. The lower tier could then be reprofiled adding a further 2000 new seats and say 30-40 boxes. New capacity 48,000. Cost: approx £25-30m. At a later date if demand increases.... Extend this tier around corner into an enlarged Park end increasing capacity by a further 6k for approx £12-16m. Seek some enabling funding via hotel and regeneration joint venture schemes on the Park end and Bullens road sides. Perhaps incorporating a new school and residential development to help release funding. Preserving history, intimacy, and intensity of the existing stadium with proper overhanging upper tiers..... with tried and tested transport infrastructure and millions of man-hrs of Evertonian memories built in.

I’m not against moving per se. I even voted for it once. But..... when I walk to the ground, I’m walking in the footsteps of my dad, grandad and great grandad.... that small bonding factor is never lost on me, and I’m very reluctant to sell it for cheap non-descript flat-pack blandness elsewhere. Something genuinely inspiring, on a great central site with masses of public transport already in place, then I will vote to walk in my ancestors’ footsteps for the last time. Anything less has little currency for me.

Anthony Fielding
128 Posted 28/04/2014 at 17:20:37
Goodison Park, as much as I love it, is a dump; the facilities are shocking. I’ve had season tickets in the Main Stand, Upper Bullens and Park End... the Park End is bland but at least has okay facilities; the Main Stand and Upper Bullens are terrible. I would not spend any time there before the game or leave my seat at half-time to buy a drink or snack simply because it’s so damp, dark and just plain uninviting.

No additional tier on the Park End is going to fix this, except for in a new stand. If a new build on the same site would be possible, then of course most Everton fans would want this, but anyone who is a regular at Goodison will know it’s just not possible to do that without aqcuiring the land around the stadium, which obviously isn’t that straight-forward otherwise we would have by now.

I’m not opposed to moving to a new site as long as the design is good; the Kings Waterfront would have been amazing. New memories can be made, old memories will live forever — no matter where we play.

Peter Lee
129 Posted 28/04/2014 at 22:55:01
Tom, I can’t see that your figures stack up. the obvious comparison is the set of proposals that LFC are working up. They are talking £100m + for a similar number of seats to what you are suggesting eventually.
Tom Hughes
130 Posted 29/04/2014 at 09:18:04
Peter....

Firstly, the Liverpool cost is essentially for 2 very high spec whole new stands, which while only producing a net capacity increase of 14k actually amounts to upto 20k new seats if the whole Anfield Rd end is replaced.

Secondly this includes a depth and volume of construction not required to replace a much lower upper tier on the Bullens without the multiple levels of lounge and concourse space. There is no real overlapping of tiers proposed in the Anfield design meaning there is significantly greater roof costs. In otherwords our solution is much simpler and therefore cheaper.

If you want current cost comparisons check out the cost of Cardiff’s new upper tier.... built in situ £12m for 5k new seats.... or all of Wolves existing and planned new stands. Yes, you can pay £7k per seat for very high stands with large expensive roof structures and several floors of executive accommodation.... but you can also pay just £1k per seat for simple lower tiers. There lots of other examples of similarly costed redevelopments. Included those carried out for an expansion of the Park end stand.

Suffice to say LFC have concluded that this option is significantly cheaper than building 60k from scratch..... and certainly not to the same spec they are proposing now.

Ray Roche
131 Posted 29/04/2014 at 12:40:39
Peter Lee: "we needed to have an average gate of just over 47,600 to have a million fans at home games in a season, which we achieved just once."

In 1962-63 we averaged 51,460, in 1963-64, 49,401 and 1969-70, 49,531 meaning we had over 1M fans in each of those seasons. We had over 900k in 12 seasons.

Andrew Ellams
132 Posted 29/04/2014 at 13:05:47
We actually need an average of 52,631 over 19 league games to reach the million mark. Peter’s number are over 21 games which I suppose could happen with cup draws etc.

We are playing in a two-team city so share our support and as yet don’t have the pull on international tourist fans that other clubs have. 50-55,000 should suffice and if we knock 20% off current ticket prices will probably pull more in and still make more and hopefully gain from improved commercial boxes too.

Tom Hughes
133 Posted 29/04/2014 at 13:31:21
Anthony,
Saying that we would’ve done something by now is a bit like wishful thinking given the missed opportunities to date. If we had taken a board member’s offer we would be in the Kings Dock now....

Only a relatively small footprint expansion is required to expand this side completely, and the Park end also has sufficient space already to achieve any size stand. It can also be achieved without loss of capacity. This has been the preferred strategy for the vast majority of football clubs for good reason. Many with similar or worse confinement than GP. Yes, the facilities beneath the existing stands are predominantly cramped.... but this needn’t be the case in an expanded format. It should also be remembered that despite its obvious misgivings the views in the majority of the likes of the upper tiers at GP are as good if not better than most elsewhere. GP has easily the shortest viewing distances of all equivalent sized stadia with the highest variety of viewing angles. Not bad for a "dump". The obstructed views problem and capacity/facility requirements can be addressed.... as they have been everywhere else.

Brian Wilkinson
134 Posted 29/04/2014 at 15:27:01
We cannot even afford Finch Farm! On that basis, who is going to stump up the Majority of the money.

We have the Arteta, Anichebe, Jelavic money, a big percentage of the Fellaini money as Bill stated McCarthy was bought regardless of the Fellaini sale.

Put to that the TV money and we should be looking at a decent transfer kitty, yet we are led to believe its just over the £20 million mark.

Even without the sale of players and tv money, you would expect a premiership team to have a budget of around £20 million on team building.

So if we are struggling to provide major transfer funds, I just do not see how the hell we can even afford to pay part costs for a new stadium, even after the sale of Goodison Park.

I have to agree that it’s in our board’s interest to have a new ground; once that happens, they know they have a lovely nestegg to sell on for a very big profit.

The board are hell-bent on moving away from Goodison Park, somewhere where there’s land alongside to build shops, apartments... rebuilding Goodison kills off any chance of building anything around Goodison Park.

That’s my opinion why Goodison will never be redeveloped.

Someone stated it will cost more than that to build a new stadium, so what if staying at Goodison is an option? It has to be taken seriously; it has over a hundred years of history and if it is possible to redevelop Goodison then I would rather that option given a choice.

Eric Myles
135 Posted 29/04/2014 at 16:27:54
Trouble is Brian #166, our board won’t provide the investment to redevelop Goodison Park, and so make the Club more attractive to buyers.

They want someone else to invest their money into a new stadium to increase the asset value of the Club and so attract a buyer.

Trouble is, there’s not too many mugs around to do that... not even Tesco.

Anthony Fielding
136 Posted 29/04/2014 at 18:43:13
Tom, the only part of the ground where there is an abundance of surrounding space for us to develop on is the Park End, which, fair enough, could be pushed back to allow more space for a new Gwladys Street end and what then would have to be an entirely new Park End, but more than a relatively small footprint expansion would be required to vastly improve the Main Stand and the Bullens Road stand.

And yes the view from the upper tiers are great and close to the pitch, but this is at a cost of the views from most of the seats in the lower tiers, especially the Lower Bullens.

Paul Holden
137 Posted 29/04/2014 at 19:03:49
New stadium - the industrial land near old sugar warehouses on the bank of the Royal Blue Mersey - imagine it all lit up at night, blue and white, as cruise liners came into dock - one of the most iconic stadiums in the world! But do Everton have the vision (and the cash)?
Darren Hind
138 Posted 29/04/2014 at 20:03:53
Tom Hughes

You’ve certainly convinced me. . . So what am I missing?

If ever a board was going to take a cheaper and more popular route to making the club more valuable I would have put money on it being this one.

Probably a dumb question, but can somebody explain to me why the idea of increasing capacity at the old Lady has been dismissed out of hand ?

Tom Hughes
139 Posted 30/04/2014 at 01:11:44
Darren,
I bet they can’t !
Jackie Barry
140 Posted 30/04/2014 at 01:22:42
I smell BS, and think this is all part of an excuse for their being no money to spend in the summer. This is how much faith I have in our owners, we will have our expectations built up after a great season under a fantastic manager, only for it to crumble over the summer.
Tom Hughes
141 Posted 30/04/2014 at 08:52:31
Anthony,
The Bullens road is abutted by just 2 streets and a school. By just bridging the road, and the space occupied by the end houses, enough space would be released to replace the whole upper Bullens tier with a new 10,000 seater upper stand with boxes. With lower tier also extended and now completely unobstructed. Incidentally, the houses surrounding GP are the cheapest houses surrounding any stadium in the country..... and if a residential/commercial or regeneration scheme was built in parallel to the stand development there may be other funding opportunities to exploit. The lower Gwladys St has less supporting columns and thus less obstructions a new goal post truss supported roof would eliminate all obstructed views in the upper tier. Similarly the mainstand could have its two front columns removed making the entire top balcony unobstructed and the whole front section of the mainstand column free. In otherwords the obstructed views can be reduced dramatically, with capacity and quality increased and enhanced significantly. All of this combined can never cost as much in construction terms as a whole new stadium elsewhere..... and god knows how much a characterless flat pack may cost us in terms of the loss of historic value of what GP represents, and change of perception.
Dennis Stevens
142 Posted 30/04/2014 at 09:49:58
Darren, I think the cheaper option the Board is hoping to take is to not build a stadium at all. I believe they only intend to get to the stage of having the ’project’ approved in the hope that this will enable them to realise the ridiculously high price they wish to sell at. However, I don’t think most billionaires get that way by being that stupid with their money.
Anthony Fielding
143 Posted 30/04/2014 at 20:47:42
Tom, Ok, let’s say you could build a new Bullens by acquiring a few houses and the school etc, it still does not address the Main Stand. That would need the Bullens Road shifting far further than you suggest to replace that stand, especially to replace it with a stand of similar capacity but with better facilities, no obstructed views and more space on the concourse.

And it also seems you’re suggesting keeping the Gwladys Street stand, along with the obstructed views on the bottom tier!? In fact it seems what you’re suggesting indeed is just a patch up job on the Old Lady just for the purpose of increasing the number of seats. I think the purpose of this is to build something that’s going to be fit for the future, something to take us through the next 60 to 100 years, not just sticking a few band aids over the cracks of an ageing building.

I’d love to stay at Goodison, but not if that means we have to just make do with whatever fits on the site.

Tom Hughes
144 Posted 30/04/2014 at 22:52:09
Anthony,
I’m simply suggesting a scheme that could realise more or at least as many unobstructed seats as just 50k new seats in a basic bowl on WHP, and for a fraction of the cost. Perhaps preserving one example of an historic Lietch stand (as at Ibrox) at least in the short to medium term. As regards the longer term ( if you are talking 60yrs fwd) the upper Gwladys could be replaced if required. Similarly, a new exec tier could be suspended beneath the top balcony to greatly reduce the obstructed seats behind the supporting columns as shown in scale drawings on the KEIOC site. All cheaper solutions than building complete new stands of similar capacity. Hardly sticky plaster when you consider the benefits of preserving or enhancing a world famous stadium on the site of the world’s first purpose built football stadium. Not to mention the tried and tested infrastructure that may incur an additional cost elsewhere.
Anthony Fielding
145 Posted 01/05/2014 at 07:31:17
Tom........

What you’re suggesting just does not sound befitting of what was once the grandest stadium in the land. Goodison Park was once the greatest and most pioneering football stadium certainly in this country, if not the world. Sadly, it is now slowly becoming a relic. Squeezing a few new cramped stands on the existing site is not going to do the Old Lady justice, especially as you seem to be suggesting we can do it on the cheap in earlier posts.

Tom Hughes
146 Posted 01/05/2014 at 16:16:19
Anthony.... I never said it would be on the cheap at all...... I said it could be cheaper to produce a net increase of just 10,000 seats at Goodison than say 50,000 very cheap new seats at a non-descript site elsewhere. Infact you could spend twice as much per seat at GP, creating real quality elevated views, and still have change from what a whole new stadium might cost..... which is why the vast majority of football clubs have chosen redevelopment ahead of relocation. Many now with better quality than the new-builds we have seen. Incidentally, Goodison became the great stadium it was BECAUSE of the confinement forcing our owners to innovate and adopt double-decker formats on all sides. Of course we could simply go to a wide open park and build a cheap bowl, will that be befitting of our history? Goodison can be great again, and combine modernity and tradition to create something unique.
Anthony Fielding
147 Posted 01/05/2014 at 19:35:30
Tom.....

Producing a net 10k increase in seats like you’re suggesting does not improve the facilities etc for the fans in the rest of the ground does it? I’m not debating what a new ground would be like and whether it will retain the atmosphere etc of Goodison, that’s a whole different matter. What I am saying is the whole ground needs rebuilding to improve the facilities for everyone, not just those in one stand or the corporate fans, and to do that simply bridging over Bullens Road just won’t do it.

Tom Hughes
148 Posted 01/05/2014 at 21:14:28
Anthony.....

I suggested a series of things that will improve things quite dramatically in all of the stands. I have visited practically every ground in the UK... I’m not sure what you think many of these newer stands do that cannot be achieved at GP.... and I certainly cannot see how it merits hundreds of millions up front to achieve what some of them do.

Adding a whole new upper Bullens and upper Park End will massively transform GP. Bringing three sides upto the height of the Goodison Rd side. Increasing concourse areas several fold and new lounge spaces etc.

The design for Kirkby for instance was compared directly to modifications I propose.... and it was shown that viewing performance was for the most part superior at GP than at Kirkby... where massive viewing distances saw fans in the upper tier upto £24m further from the pitch for equivalent rows in GP.

Far from being piecemeal.... most of the world’s greatest stadia have evolved precisely in this manner. There is no reason why GP cannot be the same..... and potentially for a fraction of the cost of building 4 whole new bog standard structures elsewhere.

Anthony Fielding
149 Posted 01/05/2014 at 21:43:19
Tom...

I just don’t see how it can be done, I’m a regular at Goodison, I’ve sat in every stand, had a season ticket in the Main Stand, Park End and Upper Bullens, I’ve walked around the stadium hundreds of times... where exactly is the room to increase the capacity?

I’ve just looked at the stadium on Google Earth and came across a page on the official site from Destination Kirkby days when they superimposed other stadium footprints onto our current footprint and even the Reebok stadium doesn’t fit on out current footprint.

Like I say, I’m not opposed to staying and improving Goodison, but I don’t want a patch-up job.

Thomas Lennon
150 Posted 01/05/2014 at 21:54:50
Tom, This part tells me what I need to know:

Firstly, the Liverpool cost is essentially for 2 very high spec whole new stands, which while only producing a net capacity increase of 14k actually amounts to upto 20k new seats if the whole Anfield Rd end is replaced.

Secondly this includes a depth and volume of construction not required to replace a much lower upper tier on the Bullens without the multiple levels of lounge and concourse space. There is no real overlapping of tiers proposed in the Anfield design meaning there is significantly greater roof costs. In otherwords our solution is much simpler and therefore cheaper

Your are proposing building a far smaller (simpler) construction with no improvement in concourse & lounge space for a cut price in order to add cheaper seats - why do we want to make our ’new’ stadium inferior to Anfield? Wasn’t Kirkby a cheap insult? Why do modern stadia not overlap tiers?

Tom Hughes
151 Posted 01/05/2014 at 22:34:37
Thomas..... I am not advocating a cheap and nasty option at all. Liverpool are building behind the existing mainstand which is almost twice as deep as the Bullens. They are also building over 7 floors of accommodation on that side..... including a whole executive tier sandwiched between 2 levels of boxes. I am proposing a stand that will be approx 3/4 the size of the LFC proposal in terms of capacity. With better or equivalent concourse area per fan than anything proposed there. LFC will still have some of the crampest concourses and legroom provision in the lower tier and on the kemlin Rd side. There are similar lower quality areas in most stadia.

Many modern stadia do have overlapping tiers.... Chelsea have them on all four sides for instance. LFC haven’t been able to do this easily because the existing stand is too steep and there was a requirement to fit two rows of boxes and an exec tier.... this usually needs a much shallower lower tier as at the Emirates or Etihad.... where again there are also overlapping tiers bringing people closer to the pitch. The lower Bullens is shallow enough to achieve this as the stand geometry was built to accommodate an overlapping upper tier. Instead of an 18 row upper stand it could be expanded to double that amount with a row of boxes suspended beneath. These stands (several versions) have been drawn up using full site plans and sightline modelling, and don’t require a massive land grab to achieve them.

Tom Hughes
152 Posted 02/05/2014 at 08:27:11
Anthony, somehow I missed your post last night. The Reebok has no overlapping tiers.... the upper tiers are simply stepped up above the boxes. There is also very generous legroom throughout at the Reebok, which is very affordable when you’re only aiming for less than 30k seats. The result is that the Reebok has a bigger footprint than GP.... thus illustrating the benefit and indeed necessity of overlapping tiers in medium to large stadia to minimise viewing distances this can be crippling in large single tier stands (St James’ Park for instance). A better comparison might have been Stamford bridge, the North stand at Highbury, many European stadia or some of the early or latest generation baseball stadia in the US...... or even our Top Balcony where the fans are over 25 m closer to the action than those in the top tier at St James’ Park.

As regards GP, just a 15-20 m land grab on the Bullens and park stands will readily create enough space for additional capacity, and supporting amenities to match anything proposed elsewhere (ie 50-54k). This wouldn’t be a patch up.... it would be a transformation. Whereas the same or significantly greater budget, spent at a new suburban site, might well be very basic and characterless giving very few of the superior but more expensive to construct elevated views that GP can have.

Of course if the new site comes with a high yield enabler, and/or other great investment.... then perhaps it will be of a higher standard than a basic bowl with one larger stand. If it is more central site with high-density high-value developments around it this might be possible. In a suburban Park this is far less likely.

If the strategy is to package the club to maximise profit in a sale to a rich investor..... then we should also be seeking to maximise the benefit to the club by creating real quality and not a cheap off-the-shelf design, as was the case with DK.

Anthony Fielding
153 Posted 03/05/2014 at 11:18:13
Tom....

I really don’t think just a 15-20 m land grab would be sufficient at all. Yes, we might be able to throw a few new stands up in place of the cramped ones we have now, but it’s going to be just a patch-up job, a "make do with what we’ve got" kind of thing. You can’t polish a turd!

I don’t know what any new stadium in a different location would be like; Kirkby was bland at best... Kings Dock was the kind of thing we should be aiming for. I’m not sure if the club could deliver that kind of thing... that remains to be seen. But I just don’t think that can be done on our footprint, not even with a 20 m land grab like you suggest. To be honest, I’m starting to think that nothing will ever happen at all!

Tom Hughes
154 Posted 04/05/2014 at 07:20:08
Anthony, 15-20 metres would release enough space to put a completely new upper tier and boxes on the Bullens Road side, eradicating all obstructed views on that side. There are probably images of this transformation archived on here somewhere. It is precisely what LFC and numerous other clubs have/are doing.

It is what happened at the Bernabeu, Nou Camp and San Siro..... are those turds sufficiently polished? The point is, it is often the most prudent way forward..... but perhaps not the sexiest way to package a sale, if that’s the club’s intention.

I’m not against moving..... but I am against moving for the sake of it or to maximise profit for the seller. If the stadium design is not innovative and on a site with massive public transport capacity..... then we should enhance what we have in affordable phases. It is certainly not a "turd"... and it could be unique in character.

Anthony Fielding
155 Posted 04/05/2014 at 17:34:04
Tom...

Like I say, maybe we could build a new search Bullens Road Stand with such a land grab, but what about the rest of the ground? What about the Main Stand? Do we land grab in the other direction 10-20 years down the line to improve that??

What about the Gwladys Street End?? The facilities and space are appalling in all sides of the ground except the Park End stand, which is mediocre at best. It’s not just about increasing capacity, it’s about improving the matchday experience of a new generation of fans.

Tom Hughes
156 Posted 05/05/2014 at 08:06:59
Anthony....
I've visited nearly every ground in the uk. Yes some of the concourse areas are tight in GP, but they are in many modern stands too. LFC are building their new stand above a stand who's core structure was built in 1906. The concourse areas are like rabbit warrens compared to GPs. Some of this may remain too.... but this will then be offset by the increase in attraction of the new areas enabling a broader price structure. The tighter concourse areas will still remain elsewhere in the new Anfield.

As regards the specifics of each of our stands.... I don't think they fare too badly with most to be honest, and in some ways they are better. Many modern stadia are simple C-value-led designs. Yes, good clear views of the pitch but often large viewing distances and shallower viewing angles in comparison to GP. The upper tiers at GP are better for viewing than at many of the new stadia. For instance: The Top Balcony offers better viewing than anything of a similar height elsewhere. The upper Bullens and upper Gwladys is closer than the uber-expensive middle tier at the Emirates....

The mainstand, with the 2 roof support columns removed, would instantly eradicate all obstructed views in the top balcony, and many in the mainstand itself. An exec tier beneath the mainstand would add much needed and far superior boxes and remove some of the worse obstructed seats in the mainstand... (this is drawn to scale on the KEIOC site). ie.... there is no need for a land grab on this side. Although the road could be bridged for mainstand concourse expansion if necessary.

The Park end..... quite simply: you can do anything at this end. Cardiff are currently adding a second tier to their existing stand, and we could readily do similar and increase facilities beneath substantially.... including lounges and new general concourses.... all with a hotel or other commercial enabler to part fund it. No land grab required.... as we already own the surrounding land.

The Gwladys street is what it is.... a classic 1930's stand. Some clubs would preserve these for what they are...... warts and all. One of the last remaining Leitch stands. The centre court at Wimbledon has been preserved and enhanced similarly.... because of its intrinsic historic value. The lower concourse area is adequate if not spectacular. The upper is cramped but this could be greatly eleviated by a new corner area if the Bullens was expanded. Furthermore, in the medium to long term future, if demand dictated then the upper tier could be replaced or enlarged in a similar fashion to that proposed for the Bullens. There are only 23 houses facing it with a gross value of probably less than £1.5m. The club may already own some of them. In the short term the roof support columns could be removed to eradicate all upper tier obstructions.

All of these quite simple and cheap modifications can be achieved in phases, to eleviate costs and will greatly transform the appearance, and performance of the ground. Obstructed views would fall by 90% or more and new high value capacity created on all sides..... All possibly for less than half the cost of a whole new ground elsewhere..... with none of the risks associated with moving.... ie large initial costs; change of perception or loss of identity/tradition/character; transport and infrastructure issues and costs. All of which is why the vast majority choose to redevelop.

Our desperation for an enabling partner, or a shiny whole new project to help facilitate a high profit sale for the current owners shouldn't cloud that basic principle. GP can be a relatively cheap and high quality solution. Moving is rarely cheap and often as a result low in quality.

Anthony Fielding
157 Posted 05/05/2014 at 10:26:16
Tom
I have read your letter to the club on the KEIOC website, I have seen your designs etc, in which you state clearly that the Bullens Road and Gwladys Street stands need replacing. Then you go on to state that the pitch needs pushing back in the direction of the Park End and that a new two-tier Park End Stand to be built.

Also with modifications to the Main Stand, although I'm not sure how that would work with the current shape of the stand due to Goodison Road!? So sounds like basically a whole new build, in a similar design, squeezed on the existing site!?

Still not convinced that this could be done with just a 15-20 m land grab. Still just sounds like we will just be building what the space allows to be honest.

And one thing for sure is that if it was viable and cheaper than a new build on a different location, then the board would be all over it!?

Tom Hughes
158 Posted 05/05/2014 at 14:34:24
Anthony,

That letter predates the Kirkby proposals. It is just one of a series of studies and letters looking at different approaches. From replacing one, two, three or even all stands.

The design studies took place over several years (early 90s to approx 2007). All would be valid approaches in resolving the obvious issues. They all came with scale drawings, and some with 3D renderings, all using actual site plans and are illustrated on various sites.

As regards the one shown, this was a "three new stand" strategy with the Main Stand staying. None require a land grab on more than two sides..... and that one only required the Bullens Road itself and the end terraces only. The approach I have spoken about here involves the addition of two new upper tiers and the reprofiling of an existing lower tier.

As regards the Board being all over something.... it should be remembered that they failed to deliver the Kings Dock when it was offered on a plate by one of its own members.... in fact, the same Board have delivered the least infrastructural changes of almost any Board in the entire league.

Until (and including) very recently, the club have been insistent that any scheme would still follow a retail-led model.... despite the fact that this has long since been shown to be unviable. It now accepts that. Similarly when it suited the LFC board, the Anfield redevelopment was said to be a complete non-starter.... they have completely changed their tune now. Why? Because of cost.

In construction terms, it will always cost more to build 50-55k new seats than it will to build 10-20k unless massive enabling can be secured elsewhere. If it's WHP, the entire park probably couldn't yield sufficient enabling to build one stand.... Let's face it, the whole Kirkby project couldn't and that had a massive retail element. So, in other words, saying the club — who have achieved the least in this regard — would be all over anything, is probably nearer to blind optimism.


Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads

© ToffeeWeb