Blues can't recover from self-inflicted wounds

, 26 April, 70comments  |  Jump to most recent
Southampton 2 - 0 Everton
Everton's Champions League hopes took a potentially fatal blow at the St Mary's Stadium as two first-half own goals, one from Antolin Alcaraz and another from Seamus Coleman, left them with a mountain they never looked likely to conquer over the final hour of the game.

Needing to win to maintain the pressure on Arsenal in the chase for a top-four finish, the Blues got off to the worst possible start when Antolin Alcaraz headed Rickie Lambert's cross into his own net with just 53 seconds on the clock.

And things got worse for an Everton side already facing a difficult task against a well-organised and energetic Southampton side when Nathaniel Clyne's cross eluded both Alcaraz and John Stones and Coleman could only steer an emergency header back across goal and past the stranded Tim Howard.

Shorn of the injured Kevin Mirallas, Roberto Martinez had deployed Gerard Deulofeu on the left side of a front three that included Lukaku and Steven Naismith but the Spaniard struggled to make an impact, although he was central to Everton's best moments of the first half.

He bounced a shot from distance that was safely gathered by Boruc, drew a foul from Clyne from which Gareth Barry should have had a penalty as Jack Cork clearly tugged him back by the shirt, and served up a decent cross for Lukaku but the Belgian couldn't get over the ball and his header flew over.

Martinez made a first change at half time when he withdrew Ross Barkley in favour of Leon Osman but it was Naismith and Deulofeu who looked to have combined to carve out the Blues' best chance of the contest thus far. Unfortunately, an erroneous offside call on the Spanish forward pulled back play with Deulofeu set to bear down in a one-on-one confrontation with Boruc.

And there would be further outrage from Everton players and supporters alike when first Osman and then James McCarthy were denied penalties — indeed, the former was booked for diving despite being clearly caught late by Dejan Lovren.

Unfortunately, Southampton made life as difficult for Everton as possible and almost extended their lead when Lambert clipped the post with a low shot and substitute James Ward-Prowse forced a late parried save from Howard.

In between, Aiden McGeady's wicked cross had picked Lukaku out perfectly but he headed straight at the 'keeper from point-blank range, spurning perhaps Everton's best chance of a frustrating game.

The defeat leads the Blues needing Arsenal to collapse at home against struggling Newcastle on Monday evening for them to have any hope of finishing in the Champions League places. A win for the Gunners would put them four points clear with two games to play.

Full coverage: ToffeeWeb Match Reports



Reader Comments (70)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Timothy Blanshard
1 Posted 26/04/2014 at 16:51:08
One of the worst games of the season, no one stood out for any good reasons, note to Ross B, we all know you like the big games but you need to show your worth even in the so called "smaller games". Does the champions league count as playig in big games because you can kiss it goodbye as from today.
I should know better, 40+ years a supporter and my team still manages to do my effing head in.
Steavey Buckley
2 Posted 26/04/2014 at 16:51:05
Deufoleu should have been allowed to take a more central role and McGeady brought on in his place when Everton went down 2:0, because Lukaku was having a stinker and it was left to Naismith to take the attack to the opposition.

But there is no doubt, the opening own goal had a bad effect on Everton's game plan, to hold Southampton and hit them on the break. Because Southampton offered little as an attacking threat with the lumbering Lambert as their main attacking option. Yet, he hopes to go to the World cup with England. If he is England quality, England will be arriving home before the post cards are sent from Brazil.

Matt Traynor
4 Posted 26/04/2014 at 17:26:53
Baines picked up a "knee and thigh injury" apparently as well. Gets better doesn't it?
Paul Dark
5 Posted 26/04/2014 at 17:27:55
Both teams were poor; we won on points.

Alcaraz and McGeady are poor signings, in my view if our ambitions are high. We could finish sixth at this rate.

Patrick Murphy
7 Posted 26/04/2014 at 17:28:08
Roberto a genius one week because we won and this week a one-trick pony because we lost. If we screw up at home to Man City, it will be the end of any hopes of European football so I'm sorry we have to go for the win. We'll get nothing at Hull as they'll want to leave their fans on a high in their final home game prior to Wembley.

We may well end up in magnificent 7th spot but it has been a far better ride for most of the time... however, our lack of spending power is crippling us in the more demanding parts of the season and you would have thought that 8 wins out 10 would have been enough but whatever Everton do it always falls short one way or another.

Never mind... come August, Roberto can take over at Barca and we can re-appoint David Moyes who will swap Barkley for Fellaini – now that would be better wouldn't it?

Mark Griffiths
9 Posted 26/04/2014 at 17:40:15
Paul 5 - At this rate we could finish 7th! To be honest, take out the Arsenal and Man Utd games and we have been off the boil for a few games now.
Kieran Kinsella
10 Posted 26/04/2014 at 17:42:11
Get a grip. Today we were without our central defensive pairing of Distin and Jags, we were without 2 of the 3 strikers we have (Traore and Kone) without regular midfielder Pienaar and the guy who could have filled in for him or indeed for Baines when he went off -- Oviedo. We could have rested the tired looking Barry if he were fit too. Point being, Arsenal apparently went into freefall for 3 months because Aaron Ramsey was injured. Well we had a weaker squad to begin with and have had no end of injuries to key players. Additionally, Soton are actually a good team. They also play the way we play but like Liverpool they've been doing it longer than us so at this point they're more proficient than us. As far as Barkley goes -- let's not turn him into the next Osman by slagging him off any time he has a sub par game. That's the mentality that drives people like Moyes to play it safe with average water carriers like Carsley rather than giving a chance to people who may, may, may just turn into something special.
Drew Shortis
11 Posted 26/04/2014 at 17:28:40
Regarding the Europa League. I agree that it is somewhat of a booby prize, especially monetarily, but it does have its advantages too:

- It will help attract a higher (perhaps not the highest) calibre of player than if we offered no European football. I wonder if Swansea would have been as attractive a proposition to Bony without European football on offer. I know the Premier League is a massive draw, but a lot of the European clubs we will be looking to buy players from will be able to offer their players European football if they stay!

- We will earn extra income from it, even if it isn't at the same level as the Champions League.

- It will give us valuable experience in Europe which will help us when we make it into the Champions League. Remember what happened against Villareal!

- Its another competition to try and win!

I think we would be a stronger team now if we had been playing in the Europa League over the past few years instead of narrowly missing out. When we were qualifying under Moyes we had some interesting nights against the likes of Fiorentina and Standard Liege. We are poorer for missing out on these games. OK playing the likes of BATE isn't what everyone dreams of, but it would be a good chance to give some of the youngsters a chance. We were progressing as a club, but I feel like we went backwards over the past few years due to some misfortune with the FA Cup runners up getting our spot.

Martinez has already indicated he has money to spend strengthening the squad and that he acknowledges that Europe will demand a bigger squad. To do this I think we will have to forget about signing Lukaku and look for quality players at a lower cost. Quantity over quality is not a good plan, but I think we could get several decent young prospects in for the money we would have to fork out for Romelu. This would also help us to avoid the inevitable squad depletion due to injury and would allow us to rotate tired players more often.

I know this has been a disappointing way to end the season after coming so close, but the fact that we are so close shows we have improved and will continue to get better. Not the terrible transitional period that many predicted!

Harold Matthews
12 Posted 26/04/2014 at 17:16:28
Howard did OK. McGeady also but had no-one with him. The rest were all well below par and looked to have had enough for the season. Saints passed the ball around for the last 15 minutes but their attack was mediocre. That said, their defence was pretty solid and their midfield, led by Wanyama, brushed our little guys aside.

Klyne and Shaw wrapped up our wingers and fullbacks, leaving our two centre backs to flap like fish out of water. Both good on the ball, Alcaraz is slow and rusty, while Stones is very unsure, fails to close down and still turns his back. A bad day at the office. As for winning the Europa League. Gueye has more chance of winning Le Ballon D'or.

Drew Shortis
13 Posted 26/04/2014 at 17:50:21
@Paul Dark 5

I'm not sure why so many are keen to write off McGeady. He is still settling into the team and into the Premier League. To me he looks like a decent winger who can beat his man and put in a good cross. Today the whole team played badly! Martinez has been after Aiden for a long time and I have faith that he will become a vital part of our team.
Dennis Ng
14 Posted 26/04/2014 at 17:58:51
Well said Harold, wished they had a like button. Bad day in office. Disappointing result but nothing to go nuts about.
Denis Richardson
15 Posted 26/04/2014 at 18:00:51
Well, am not going to waste many words on that crock of shite. Really really surprised and disappointed that we could play that badly when so much was riding on the game – 30-odd years of supporting this club and I still let myself fall for it.

Cannot really think of any player that played well, after the own goal things just went from bad to worse. We'd have struggled to beat a league one side playing like that!

4th is 100% gone now – let's not even bother dreaming here, Arsenal are not going to lose two out of their next 3 games – as well as us win both of ours. After being so close to 4th its now not out of the question that we could finish 7th! Both Spurs and Man Utd have relatively easy games left, if we don't manage one win against City or Hull, it's seventhsville again.

Depressed – those dropped 5 points against Palace are going to come home to roost at the end of the season.

For the record, I want Europa League next year; I read somewhere someone saying most fans don't want it, which I find extremely hard to believe, especially as the winner next year also gets a CL place. Let's at least make sure we hang onto 5th if we can.

Paul Dark
16 Posted 26/04/2014 at 18:20:21
Drew - you could be right about McGeady. He hasn't impressed me so far. He can beat a man... sometimes. His passing is average at best and he isn't a great tackler or coverer, in my view. Still, it's early days, I suppose. A full pre-season might revitalize him.

We missed Mirallas badly, and Pienaar would have added energy. We looked better after Osman came on – which is remarkable in itself.

Southampton were by no means 'superior' (Pochettino); we were (possibly just) the better side (of two in a poor game).

Stones and Alcaraz will concede against Citeh, possibly badly. Let's hope Jags is back (for Alcaraz).

Paul Ferry
17 Posted 26/04/2014 at 18:22:50
Good grief - 7, 9, & 15 - 7ish! And the remarks about McGeady are quite frankly silly; for a fair while in that 2nd half he looked by far the one who bothered and cared the most, and there's plenty more than that to be said on his behalf! 7ish! Phil Walling – who now by the way has reinvented himself as Keith Simmonds since his self-imposed exile – might be the best soothsayer of all of us!
Steavey Buckley
18 Posted 26/04/2014 at 18:15:35
The FA Cup is far more respected than the Europa League, but took it's toll already on a fragile squad. In the 3rd round, Barkley was injured with a broken toe and has not been the same player since; then Oviedo broke his ankle, and how much he is been missed; then Pienaar damaged his knee ligaments against Arsenal in quarterfinals, and Baines has definitely missed him, because his performances have been well under par ever since.

In the Europa League, there are endless teams with endless matches, some teams many would have not heard of, with their poor pitches, played well away from the UK, and it's back again with unknown fit players to play teams on a Sunday waiting to cash in on any fatigue, whether mental or physical.

No thanks. It's top 4 or bust. Just ask Swansea and their previous sacked manager about the Europa League.

David Harrison
19 Posted 26/04/2014 at 18:34:37
Europa league. It's like a huge bunker just in front of the CL green or the snakes head on square 99. A few good trips for the fans but a massive obstacle for the club to get over
Barry Stevens
20 Posted 26/04/2014 at 18:42:48
Disappointed but to be in with a shout of Champions League with 3 games to go is not a bad thing. Was worried about Alcaraz and proved to be for good reason. Mofo looks like Chico from X Factor and played like him today.

I for one will look forward to Europa. It's a competition we can win, and a chance to follow the boys abroad.

Patrick Murphy
21 Posted 26/04/2014 at 18:56:11
I'm not advocating this but does a club have to take up its place in Europa or does it have the power to decline?
Tony Doran
22 Posted 26/04/2014 at 19:18:27
Now will people finally see that Delboy and Lukaku are rubbish? Never convinced about either despite the odd bit of quality. Alcaraz is always a headed own goal away from a headed own goal. Still very upbeat about the future but frustrated about the players who need packing off.
Alex Jones
23 Posted 26/04/2014 at 19:22:15
Unfortunately our game plan relies on attacking down the flanks with our wingers and fullbacks and if these are nullified, for whatever reason as they were today, we are nowhere near as effective.

Ideally in that situation we'd take off one of Barry or McCarthy and pull the fullbacks back a bit and try and work up through the middle a bit more. Martinez doesn't seem to agree, however, and so just swaps like for like and we end up doing no better. He can line up a team well and, if the game plan goes well, we look fantastic... but, as soon as it doesn't, he doesn't have a clue how to change it.

Why take off Barkley for Osman? It was a pointless change. He'd have been far better taking off Barry for Osman and leaving us two creative mids in the centre rather than only ever having one stuck up top.

Deufoleu is a waste of space this season imo, he's been given a lot of game time and has not improved a bit. He makes exactly the same errors now as he did in his first game. He occasionally does something good but he did that at the start and the rest of the game he's woeful. If he's going to stay next year then, to a degree, it makes sense to persevere but if not then who cares how good he'll be in 5 years time? Right now, he's a hindrance.

For me, we really need some creative mids to come on for our two defensive grocks when the game plan fails as we need the ability to adapt and challenge our opposition when they take control.

Lee Gorre
25 Posted 26/04/2014 at 19:36:11
A bad day, but in terms of the Europa League and where we finish we need 3 points max to finish 5th and 1 point for 6th. Both places qualify for Europe.
Tahir Abdullah
26 Posted 26/04/2014 at 19:40:12
Osman for Barkley was a no-brainer as the latter stank up St Mary's in that first half; a worse performance from Barkley this season, I can't recall. I though McGeady did quite well in parts; his crossing seems superior to that of Baines at the moment.
Kevin Rowlands
28 Posted 26/04/2014 at 19:38:47
I seriously hope we are not considering Lukaku this summer, except for the odd game he has flattered to deceive, just not good enough. As for the Spanish wonder boy can anyone honestly say he's going to be a superstar? he's woeful, I for one wouldn't miss either if they are not here next season. Today was horrible!
Patrick Murphy
29 Posted 26/04/2014 at 19:43:54
Just looked at the fixtures for Man Utd and Spurs. United have Sunderland and Hull City at OT and travel to St Mary's in their last fixture. Spurs have West Ham at Upton Park and Aston Villa at WHL in their final game. It's ridiculous but both United and Spurs who according to the media have had disastrous seasons yet even at this late stage, both of them could finish above us.

Get out of town Kenwright - I'm getting sick of this!!

Brent Stephens
32 Posted 26/04/2014 at 19:48:22
Tahir #26 - agree on both points.
Dick Brady
34 Posted 26/04/2014 at 19:53:12
I wouldn’t say Lukaku is rubbish but I certainly wouldn’t consider paying £30 million for him. Lukaku seems to think he needs a Champion’s League side next season but I personally think he’s deluded. He would be lucky to sign for Everton permanently and if I was Roberto I wouldn’t big a penny over £15 million.

The jury is most definitely out on McGeady. Really don’t know what to make of him but I’m willinging to be patient and see how he does after a decent pre-season.

Deufoleu is as frustrating as he is exciting. He’s got bags of potential and I’d love Everton to sign him permanently because I think Roberto could develop him into a world class talent given time. But I fear during his short spell at Everton we’ll see more of the frustrating side than the exciting side.

Patrick Murphy
36 Posted 26/04/2014 at 20:00:22
Kenwright should have given more money in January but he only sanctioned McGeady and a loan move for Traore which was a fop for the fans. Notice that the Early Bird has closed once more and the team put in a performance of that standard - perhaps unrelated but perhaps not.

I also note that the Daily Mirror had a story of a fall-out between some local 'gangster' and Ross Barkley just the first shot in the end of season 'Barkley goes to whichever club' - probably United propaganda. I'm sick to death of Bill Kenwright and his cronies holding the club back and regardless of how much hope we may or may not have their agenda is not what it should be for Everton FC. I wonder what crap Elstone will give the shareholders next week.

Paul Jones
37 Posted 26/04/2014 at 20:00:48
To mark the passing of a ToffeeWeb stalwart this week (initials PW - gone but not forgotten), Roberto asked his team to defend like Wigan and to go all out for 7th place.
Fortunately, normal service will be resumed next week.
Patrick Murphy
39 Posted 26/04/2014 at 20:05:58
Obviously any team can lose anywhere at any time but I'm getting a little bit fed-up of these under-par performances which often come following a good result such as Arsenal or United, it's not unacceptable to lose it is unacceptable to lose without really trying.
Colin Malone
40 Posted 26/04/2014 at 19:53:48
I remember a certain young Paul Gascoigne, who missed a sitter, in front of the Gwladys street end, but we could all see CLASS. He went on to prove it.

I see a young Ross Barkley who a blind man can see, he is CLASS, and a long way from he's peak. Enough said.

Raymond Fox
42 Posted 26/04/2014 at 19:47:14
Well done chaps, a largely mature reaction to the defeat.
Could have been better, we should have had 1 definite penalty, but we were not good enough on the day.

It goes to show that we need strengthening in some areas, we are not quite top 4 class yet You learn more from defeats than wins, and in midfield we certainly need a ball playing class player.

I thought we would just fall short of the Champions League qualification, we have/had much the more difficult run in than Arsenal.

I'm confident that we will be seriously challenging for the CL places again next year when Roberto, will have more of his own team in place.

David Waugh
46 Posted 26/04/2014 at 20:20:50
Luck and the referee went against us today. However, we also lacked the tenacity to do anything about it when it mattered. I want to see a bit more grit from the side in these situations. I'd also like to see some clear, on field leadership from the captain.
Ray Brown
47 Posted 26/04/2014 at 20:05:30
I've enjoyed this season. it was perhaps the first three games that may have kept it from being a remarkable one. My age blessed me with Alan Ball. Friday held a memory for me. I think it's exciting being an Everton fan in these times. Shit still happens though.
Alex Jones
48 Posted 26/04/2014 at 20:19:38
I don't get the whole "this is just a knee jerk reaction" argument? Well yes of course it is, how could it be anything but? Any analysis of the game we just watched is going to be a knee jerk one, that's as it should be whether it's full of praise for a good result, or critical of a bad one.
Jim Knightley
49 Posted 26/04/2014 at 20:19:05
Barkley has big potential...but he is far too inconsistent. Does anyone think his goals and assist ratio are acceptable, given how many runs and shots he has? He does not deserve the accolades he has received so far...he can deserve them in time, but I think he is only being hyped up in this way because he is English. Also, the Barkley to United rumours are madness...and it's not United Propoganda. United have a major problem in their team: Second striker/AMC. They have Rooney, Kagawa and Mata all vying for a position behind RVP (and both Mata and Kagawa are natural AMC's imo). Why on earth would they want Barkley too? He is less accomplished than any of them. Barkley will be safe this season. I'd be alot more worried about Coleman.

It was disappointing today, but had a sense of inevitability about it. Martinez, save for resting players in the Capital One Cup (if it's still called that?), has made one more major mistake: Letting Heitinga go and not bringing in CB cover in January. Stones, although he has certainly improved, and looks a top prospect, is mistake-prone, and we are fortunate that we've generally got away with his slips. But he is young and learning. Alcaraz on the other hand, does not look good enough, and has persistent injury problems. I think the Stones and Alcaraz cb pairing will cause problems, and I think the loss of Mirallas is massive, as he has been extremely effective in the second half of the season in particular.

But, I think we left too much to do with top four anyway. Arsenal fixtures were too easy, and ours to hard. We've had a great season whatever, and we just need to make sure we secure Europa league football now imo. I don't see us as capable of breaching the top four, and regular Europa league football would improve our co-efficient in readiness for potential CL football at a latter date, whilst offering a potential for silverware and CL qualification. This has been a great season, and whatever happens, I think most of us will agree that the transition from Moyes to Martinez has been a successful one, and that we have much to look forward to in the future, especially from the young players who have emerged/continued to emerge this season (Coleman, Stones, Oviedo, Barkley and McCarthy).

And Kieran: one point about Arsenal. They didn't go into freefall just because Ramsey got injured. They lost Walcott as well. And Oxlade for most of the season, and Ozil more recently along with Wilshere for large parts of the season. Unfortunately for us, future top four hopes rely on us finishing above an Arsenal team who now ostensibly have money, a Liverpool team who always have more money than us and finally have a team to match, and the deep pockets and star filled squads of City and Chelski. Then there's United. Unless fairplay rules bite (And comments this week suggest nothing much will change), I think UEFA cup might be our best chance for CL football until a buyer comes in.

Bill Gall
50 Posted 26/04/2014 at 20:01:04
Do some supporters really want Everton to loose their last 2 games so they finish 7th? Am I mistaken that you really get more money finishing in 7th than in 5th. Do you not recieve extra for qualifying in Europe.?

Regardless what position we finish how mutch of a transfer kitty do you thinkMartinez will be given by B.K. and his board going on past experiences.

This season was suposed to be a transition period with a new manager with a new philosophy that became a lot more successful that most people expected and I for one are thankful for what the future of the club looks like.

People that are looking for excuses should look no further than the beginning of January when the time was to strengthen the team and to quote Lyndon Lloyd (it is over to you Mr Chairman) and we all are aware of what happened in that transfer window.

In qualifying even for the Europa competition unless you are drawn against one or two of the better teams this gives the club a fast track to give some younger and fringe players more experience, than sitting on the bench and coming on for 5 min at the end of a game.

Looking at the league table the problem this season was the number of drawn games we had at the start of the season that could be attributed to Mr Martinez not wanting to change the system in place to quickly and maintaining the defense as per previous seasons until they got used to the type of play he wanted.

Yes I am more than upset with some of the performances this year but overall I am very happy how the season has gone and am looking foreward to next season to see how Mr Martinez can improve the team from the standard he is startedto set this season. Remember the teams above and below Everton have all recieved a lot of financial backing compared to Everton.

John Brennan
51 Posted 26/04/2014 at 21:05:03
I would say cheerio to Barry. Too slow, nearly always picks up a yellow.
I would keep Deolefeou, and let Lukaku go.
Who would I bring in? Not my decision, up to you, Roberto!!
Sam Hoare
52 Posted 26/04/2014 at 21:16:13
Barry looked knackered today. McCarthy was lacking a little of his usual bite too. Definitely need 3 fit CMs next season as relying purely on 2 is impractical.

Ste Traverse
53 Posted 26/04/2014 at 21:12:43
No way will I be one of the lot sneering at the Europa League. Why do these fans think this club is somehow above the competition?

What do they want us to do? Down sticks for the rest of the season and make sure we finish 7th? Then these fans will be moaning about us losing games.

Possibly the best away day experience I've had with the Blues was in Germany, Nuremberg away in 2007, I would love more of these trips.

Of course I'd rather be in the CL. But these's no chance will I look down my nose at the lesser European competition.

Dick Brady
54 Posted 26/04/2014 at 21:40:45
It’s a thin line isn’t it. We finished 6th last season. Will Martinez better it and finish 5th this year or will we lose a little ground and end up 7th?

It’s all very exciting and all still to play for.

Peter Jones
55 Posted 26/04/2014 at 21:42:08
I should like to know how those criticising todays's performance would improve it. What did we lack today? Was it defensive solidity? Midfield control? Forward incisiveness? Or all three? Or a combination thereof? I should think that two eminently avoidable (imo) ogs left a big mountain. Did RM rebuild to climb it? Or did he re-arrange to little effect? How far was RM to blame for poor performance? Or was it purely down to players? Or maybe the injuries? What is forum consenus?
Colin Williams
56 Posted 26/04/2014 at 21:55:15
The only area we were poor today is the final third, we were shocking! Lukaku was dire! I was a bit surprised McGeady didn't have more playing time.

Denis Richardson
57 Posted 26/04/2014 at 21:49:47
Peter 55, the early own goal obviously blew the game plan out the window and would undoubtedly have knocked the players back. The disappointing thing for me was that we were run over in midfield for pretty much the whole game. Clyne and Shaw snuffed out our flanks and we had no answer down the middle at all, Barkely really had a poor game – I can barely remember him doing anything – and Naismith will try all day long but is not a creative AMC.

We basically had no Plan B, or at least the Plan B didn't really work once Plan A went out the window. In saying that, we improved a bit in the second half with Osman giving us a bit more in the middle than Ross and on another day should have had a penalty when Lovren clearly brought down Osman and also Delboy should have had a clear run at goal instead of incorrectly being called offside. Had either of these two happened and we'd gotten a goal back, we may have ended up getting back in it.

But after gifting a team two goals away from home, it was always going to be a really tough ask. The OG after 53 seconds killed it for us imo, after that Southhampton could hit us on the counter and our confidence was shot.

John Hughes
58 Posted 26/04/2014 at 22:23:39
Ste (53) I don't think people are sneering at the Europa competition. The fact is that, with our resources and overall quality within the squad, it potentially could take us back a few steps. As has been alluded to somewhere here, ask Swansea about their experience.
Jay Woods
59 Posted 26/04/2014 at 22:48:29
I would really prefer us to just finish 7th now so that we avoid the dangers of being streched and distracted with that Europa League non-entity in next year's hopeful assault on 4th spot. I know this isn't very Evertonian-esque, but we should roll over for City if Chelsea reserves can do the unthinkable and win at Anfield.
Drew Shortis
60 Posted 26/04/2014 at 22:59:48
John Hughes (#0580

My memories are a bit hazy now, but I seem to recall we coped OK with a small squad the last few times we were in the Europa League and didn't suffer the catastrophic loss of form some other teams have in the past few years. I remember us playing a load of kids against BATE Borisov, but I think we had already won the group by that stage.

Martinez has acknowledged that we need a larger squad to cope with the additional demands of Europe. Yes, there are extra matches in far flung corners of Europe, and yes the money is not as good as the Champions League, but it is extra money. Additionally we stand a better chance of qualifying from the group and getting some of the bigger prizes, the biggest being qualification for the following seasons Champions League, so we would have two potential routes into that elite competition!

Here is a breakdown of the payouts:

Similar to the Uefa Champions League, the prize money received by the clubs is divided into fixed payments based on participation and results, and variable amounts that depend of the value of their TV market.

A group stage participation in the Europa League awards a base fee of €1.3 million. A victory in the group pays €200k and a draw €100k. Also, each group winner earns €400k and each runner-up €200k. Reaching the knock-out stage triggers additional bonuses: €200k or the round of 32, €350k for the round of 16, €450k for the quarter-finals and €1M for the semi-finals. The losing finalists receive €2.5M and the champions get €5M.

By my calculations that means the winner (if they were to win all their group games) would net €9.5M and qualify for the following seasons Champions League. Not too shabby.

For the Champions League, the prize money is obviously higher:

As of 2012–13, Uefa awards €2.1M to each team in the play-off round. For reaching the group stage, Uefa awards a base fee of €8.6M. A win in the group is awarded &#euro;1 million and a draw is worth &#euro;500,000. In addition, Uefa pays teams reaching the first knockout round €3.5M, each quarter-finalist €3.9M, €4.9 M for each semi-finalist, €6.5M for the runners-up and €10.5M for the winners.

My calculations may be off here, but if a team were to win two and draw two in the group stages and then go out in the round of 16, they would earn €17.2M.

All of that is hypothetical of course, but it does show that the financial benefits winning the Europa League are not a million miles away from a moderately successful run in the Champions League. Also the TV revenue is not taken into consideration here for either competition. It's obvious which competition we need to get into, but I wouldn't write off the Europa League as a complete waste of time!

Drew Shortis
61 Posted 26/04/2014 at 23:26:46
Bill Gall (#050):

I believe 5th pays out £12m and 7th pays £10.5m. The difference would pay for another Aiden McGeady or 25 Seamus Colemans.... ;)

Anto Byrne
63 Posted 26/04/2014 at 23:33:02
The own goals didn't help... but shit happens. The ref and linesman got two very important calls wrong that could have changed the outcome. Let's regroup for City and Hull.

We need a point for 5th and the Europa offers a way into the Champions League so it's been a very good season. We have Barkley and Stones with lots of game time. We can pray for a miracle and see Arsenal drop points in their remaining games. Let's all be positive and do a Martinez not a Moyes.

Bill Gall
64 Posted 27/04/2014 at 01:09:34
Drew #61

I will take 25 Seamus Colemans.

Brian Wilkinson
65 Posted 27/04/2014 at 01:24:45
What is going on with our injuries, ok we all say the reds are blessed with the devil with lack of injuries.

If you look at their team week in week out there's not much rotation yet they suffer few injuries.

So maybe we need to look into why we get so many inuries year after year, what are our neighbours doing right and Everton so wrong in regards to injuries.

We can call it bad luck, but is it, year after year it's the same players out for weeks, I may be wrong but I will have a guess and say our neighbours have played fewer players than we have so maybe it is down to our training methods.

It's time this is looked into more closely for the coming season.

Patrick Murphy
66 Posted 27/04/2014 at 01:58:55
Brian – I don't think it down to training methods alone but rather a culmination of season after season the same players are used in a high percentage of games for the Blues so it is a cumulative effect rather than anything else. Although perhaps the style of football doesn't help as there are different muscles in use more regularly playing football with the ball rather than lumping and chasing the ball every week.

Also, we don't get the same level of protection from the officials as the there have been many occasions in the last few weeks where the referees have allowed play to continue despite some heavy challenges from the opposition.

Conn Prosser
67 Posted 27/04/2014 at 03:01:50
Yep, disappointing. I'm not going to berate the players or manager for this, after everything else they have brought us this season. All this stuff about chokers, bottlers, not turning up for the 'big' games, not turning up for the 'smaller' games – I don't buy it.

There is no obvious pattern, other than the BT Sport curse. It's the crunch end of the season and we're still in with a shout for CL despite a host of injuries.

I don't think we've handed 4th to Arsenal yet. We'll beat City, I can see them slip up, and we'll hand 4th to Arsenal by ballsing it up at Hull.

Peter Barry
68 Posted 27/04/2014 at 03:49:34
I have a sinking feeling after watching the Southampton debacle that Arsenal will not trip up any more and with Man Utd resurgent after ridding themselves of the turgid, useless, tactically inept millstone that was TGT, and with Spurs also picking up points too, that Everton – far from finishing 4th – could end up 7th on goal difference from Man Utd.
Peter Barry
69 Posted 27/04/2014 at 03:55:55
It also appears that Barkley's head has gone if this is down to the 'gangster' threats then Everton and the Liverpool Police need to step up and close this scumbag down.
Tahir Abdullah
70 Posted 27/04/2014 at 04:57:44
Drew @60; nice contribution!
Darryl Ritchie
71 Posted 27/04/2014 at 05:42:10
I finally got a chance to watch the game. A few observations.

The first goal. If Alcaraz hadn't tried to head clear, Soton would have probably scored as there was a player unmarked right in front of Tim.

The second goal. Just plain bad luck. Seamus expected a touch from Stones. The most surprised man on the pitch was Coleman.

There wasn't going to be a penalty awarded in this game. For either team. This ref had an agenda before the start.

Soton is a quality side.

The Blues put in the effort. What we didn't get was a lucky bounce here or there. That bit of magic, that we have come to expect, didn't happen!

The lads looked a bit frustrated in the second. Too many missed passes and too long on the ball, which allowed them to close us down in possession far to often. Maybe the season is catching up to us.

I have no idea what Roberto can do to get the squad " up " for Man City, but he better have some, because if we play the same way, it won't be pretty.

Norman Merrill
72 Posted 27/04/2014 at 01:47:25
We should not forget, that this close season is very short for many players, with the World Cup??
Regardless of how far certain countries get, players still pick up knocks
With our paper thin squad, & If & When our long term injured re-appear, we will have to contend with the Europa league, which starts early, so Roberto will really have to bring in some new faces, rather quick.
Jason Heng
73 Posted 27/04/2014 at 06:30:31
Simply no leader in the pack. Distin, Jags were missing. Baines left out on the side. Only sort of action figure was Naismith. Could we buy a captain personality somewhere?
Tony Farrell
74 Posted 27/04/2014 at 06:20:25
Understandably there’s a lot of disgruntled fans offering their disappointments on here today; and rightly so. Bob bangs on about the points tally we have achieved bettering that of seasons gone — does he think that’s enough?

Being a blue for many years, I’ve been fortunate to see brilliant sides, eg, the mid-eighties. I feel sorry for the younger generation of blues who have yet to see such achievements. Under El Bob, I really think this man can bring those glory days back to Goodison Park. But yesterday was embarrassing; with so much at stake, we play like a gang of schoolgirls. I felt for the true fans down there, having spent a fortune to get there, to be treated to a gutless performance like that. The players should be made to give those fans there money back.

4th is beyond us now; let’s not let 5th go – beat Man City next week and finish 5th by our doing. It’s been a good season – let’s finish with a bang and put this and the Palace debacle behind us.

Kieran Fitzgerald
75 Posted 27/04/2014 at 06:57:59
A squad has a registered twenty five players. Why can we not cope with the Europa League when we can just rotate players. Play our best eleven for the league and give the younger players and back up players for each position game time in the Europa League.

How else are Garbutt, Duffy, Oviedo, Lundstrum, Green, Kone, Traore and others going to get proper competitive game time next season if they are promoted to the senior squad?

If we don't get a large enough transfer kitty to buy three or four quality senior players next season, without having to sell a top player, then we are going to have to promote these players to the senior squad. I for one can't see the Board giving Martinez twenty million plus for transfers.

Also, it will help our profile and more importantly our co-efficient for further European qualification.

Matt Traynor
76 Posted 27/04/2014 at 07:27:32
Drew #60, good analysis, and as you point out, that doesn't include TV money which is based on the domestic market valuation it is sold in. BT Sport have paid a whacking amount for the next round (which I can't remember if it starts next season or the season after - think it's the latter).

When Man U lost to Barca in the final of the CL a few years ago, Man U actually earned more than Barca did purely due to TV money. (Which is really all the Glazers would've cared about).

Helen Mallon
81 Posted 27/04/2014 at 16:13:48
I just hope we put out a weakened side next week, if we can't get 4th, so the Shite can't win it.
Gergő Ács
82 Posted 27/04/2014 at 16:38:55
Alcaraz is utter shite, not good for us at all (not because of his own goal)
Mark Wilson
83 Posted 27/04/2014 at 16:37:04
Quite a surprising response from TW to what I described on Twitter as one of the worst performances I've seen for many a season. I got jumped on by one follower for this, mainly because he'd seen lots worse apparently and it all got a bit silly as the players continued to do their best to prove me right. It's all opinion of course. You can read it here or elsewhere that at the start of the season "we would have grabbed 5th and cheered to the rafters" etc. Well maybe so but the reality is this.....we were incredibly close to CL qualification and it was in our own hands. We may now have thrown it away now and if so I'm gutted. Particularly as this pathetic display at Southampton was just that, utterly pathetic. No tempo, no guile, no grip in midfield at any time in the game and of course some rank bad defending.

Cue the screams from the RM is God brigade, or the "how dare you knee jerk" club and of course the "plucky little EFC we punch above our weight" Association.

Here's the thing. I'm made up RM is our mgr, he's got style and really is a hugely likeable chap who represents us brilliantly. He has some impressive ideas and is an innovator. If he gets backed financially we will do well. But he's not God and gets things wrong. Mostly right this campaign but there have been a handful of real clangers and that has cost us.

The players have for the most part done really well and provided us with some cracking wins, exciting, passionate, skilfully delivered and almost giving truth to the new chant about the school of science returning. Love it. And then there's a day like Southampton or Arse in the cup of the RS away or Palace though the latter wasn't that bad.

All I'm after knee jerk wise is for us to go into a couple of must win games and, er, win. No hard luck stories, no let down, great performances, and, crazy I know, an outcome that lives up to expectation. Why is that so much to hope for, so unrealistic ? So maybe Arse can lose all three of their remaining games and we win both ours. Childish hope at age 57. But there it is, that's how I feel after an utterly shite performance against an average team and another bloody huge let down.

John Flood
84 Posted 27/04/2014 at 17:30:26
Lots of nonsense on here about the Europa League, saying it has twice as many games as the Champions League. I’ve checked the Uefa web page and it doesn’t. If we were to end up 5th we’d have a 2-leg qualifier, before a group stage where we’d play 3 teams home and away, then the knock-out rounds of last 32, last 16, quarter-finals, semi-finals then final. The only additional round to the CL is the last 32 round, but if we were to end up 5th and Arsenal were to win the FA Cup then we’d go straight into the group stage meaning there’d be exactly the same number of potential games as the CL.

It is true that if we ended up 6th we’d have two qualifiers before the group stage, but again that would be reduced to one if Arsenal won the cup.

The Europa League is important to us as we need to increase our Uefa coefficient score. Believe it or not, but at the moment it is the same as Stoke City’s, meaning if we were to make CL we’d end up in the unseeded pot and get a really difficult qualifier like last time. When Arsenal, Chelsea & Tottenham ended up 4th they were always seeded as they had a good Uefa coefficients, meaning they had a far easier draw in the qualifier.

The other reason the Europa League is important is that we need a European profile and the experience will be a massive plus if we were to make the CL, plus we as fans need a European tour – it seems ages ago since we played Sporting Lisbon when we were last in Europe in 2010.

Mike Childs
85 Posted 27/04/2014 at 17:52:12
Tough to be an Everton fan but I wouldn’t want to root for any other club. Great points one and all. Thanks for the lesson as I’m just a baby as a fan since 2010.
Jack Cross
86 Posted 27/04/2014 at 21:11:25
Why didn't he play Hibbert yesterday he's reliable. Doesn't look like he'll get another game under Martinez. Alcaraz done ok against Man u but they were shite. Surely he don't think he better than Hibbert?
John Malone
87 Posted 27/04/2014 at 20:44:52
Steven Gerrard Ahahahahahahaha! That has cheered me right up, couldn't have happened to nicer bloke.

If Arsenal win tomorrow which they will, I'll kick the ball in the net meself for Man City next Saturday.

If we've blown our top four hopes which it looks like we have the last thing I want is for them to win the Prem. Perfect scenario, Arsenal lose to Newcastle, Liverpool lose at Palace; we draw with Man City, beat Hull City and the Arse do no more than draw at Norwich.

It's never happening like, but wouldn't it be nice for just once for us to take all the glory.

Paul Kernot
88 Posted 27/04/2014 at 22:27:35
I was unsure which side I was on in the debate on whether the Europa League will be damaging or helpful until I just watched the entire Liverpool v Chelsea game. Strange that that's how my mind was made up... but here are the two things I'm now convinced about:

1) Mourinho did a perfect job on Liverpool today. Where have we seen that so many times before? In his absolute mastery in getting a result from difficult away games in Europe. Could we use some of that experience? No doubt.

2) Yes, we have a slightly weak squad right now... but qualifying for CL would have meant we would absolutely HAVE TO have strengthened in summer to prepare for it.

In the Europa League, we'll still have to do that, either with good new players, or bringing on the youngsters, or both. Either way, Roberto is the right man and I'm looking forward to next season.

Steavey Buckley
89 Posted 28/04/2014 at 17:15:43
The simple truth, Everton could not give 2 stupid own goals away and expect to win against Southampton on Saturday. Although not helped by poor decisions by the referee and his assistant, who denied 2 stonewall penalties and wrongly claiming Deufoleu was offside when he was on side, when he was bearing down on the Southampton goal. And not to forget Lukaku's missed 2 headed opportunities.

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads

© ToffeeWeb